split-dollar life insurance chapter 42 employee benefit & retirement planning copyright 2009,...
TRANSCRIPT
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 1
An arrangement to share costs and benefits of a life insurance policy
– typically between employer and employee, but can be used by others
– can split premiums, death benefits and/or cash value, dividends, or ownership
What is it?
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 2
When employer wants:
1. To provide executive with low cost and low outlay life insurance benefit
2. An alternative to insurance-financed nonqualified deferred compensation plan for providing pre-retirement death benefit
When is it indicated?
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 3
When employer wants:
3. To provide exclusive executive fringe benefit
4. To establish market for stock• facilitate cross-purchase buy-sell
• enable non-stockholding employee to effect a one-way stock purchase at death of existing shareholder
What is it indicated?
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 4
1. Executive can use employer funds to receive current benefit with minimal tax cost
2. Employer’s outlay fully secured
3. Can customize plan to meet specific objectives
Advantages
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 5
1. No tax deduction for employer’s share of premium payments
2. Employee pays income tax each year on current cost of life insurance protection under plan
3. 10 - 20 years before policy cash values are sufficient to maximize plan benefits
4. Must terminate plan when employee near age 65
5. Unfavorable tax treatment under new regulations
Disadvantages
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 6
4 major categories1. Classic or standard split dollar plan2. Level premium plan3. Employer pay all4. Offset plan
Design Features: Premium Cost Split
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 7
Purpose – reimburse employer for share of premium outlay when employee dies or terminates plan
Design Features: Cash Value and Death Proceeds Split
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 8
Commonly used cash value / death proceeds splitarrangements:
– employer share is GREATER of:
(1) aggregate premiums it has paid
OR
(2) policy cash value
Design Features: Cash Value and Death Proceeds Split
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 9
Commonly used cash value / death proceeds splitarrangements:
– employer can only recover up to amount of aggregate premiums paid
OR– employer entitled to entire cash value
Design Features: Cash Value and Death Proceeds Split
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 10
Endorsement method– Employer owns policy– Employer responsible for premium payment– Employer receives death benefit = premiums paid
Design Features: Policy Ownership
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 11
Endorsement method advantages1. Employer has greater control over policy
2. Simple installation and administration
3. Avoid formal arrangement that might be deemed a loan for tax and legal purposes
4. Can use existing key employee policy without ownership change
Design Features: Policy Ownership
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 12
Collateral Assignment– Employee or 3rd party is policy owner– Employee or 3rd party responsible for premium payment– Employer makes interest free loans = premium– Policy assigned as collateral to employer– Employer recovers aggregate premium payments from
policy proceeds as collateral assignee at death of employee
– Employee’s beneficiary gets remaining benefits
Design Features: Policy Ownership
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 13
Collateral assignment advantages– Better protection for employee and employee’s
beneficiary– Easier to implement using existing policies owned by
employee
Design Features: Policy Ownership
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 14
1. Before September 18, 2003
– Employer could not deduct any part of premium payment
– Lacking clear rules, practitioners took position that either• no tax liability for increases in employee’s share of cash valueor• taxable only when plan terminated and policy ‘rolled
out’ to employee
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 15
2. After September 18, 2003
Split dollar life insurance defined as
“any arrangement between an owner and a non-owner of a life insurance contract”
that also satisfies the following three criteria:
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 16
3 Criteria for Defining Split Dollar Life Insurance: 1. Either party pays all or a portion of the premiums,
including a payment by means of a loan secured by the life insurance contract.
2. One of the parties can recover a portion of the premiums paid from the contract (or payment is secured by the contract).
3. The arrangement is not part of a Section 79 group-term life insurance plan unless the plan provides permanent benefits.
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 17
• Two mutually exclusive regimes for taxing split dollar life insurance
– economic benefit regime– loan regime
• Must ascertain owner of policy to determine which regime applies
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 18
Ownership rules– Named policy owner generally treated as such under
regulations– If two or more owners all have incidents of ownership with
respect to an undivided interest in the contract, each treated as owner of separate contract
– If two or more owners and not all have incidents of ownership, first named owner considered owner for purposes of regulations
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 19
Economic benefit treatment
Employee must count value of life insurance or other benefit provided under a split dollar plan as additional taxable income
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 20
Rollout (transfer of contract)– Transfer of contract to non-owner generates income for
non-owner equal to fair market value of contract less various sums paid by non-owner to transferor or taken as income by the non-owner
– If contract subject to substantial risk of forfeiture, employee can delay tax to sometime after the rollout
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 21
Loan treatment– Default treatment of plans that do not meet economic
benefit regime requirements– Generally, loan amount is deemed taxable income to
recipient (usually employee), specific details governed by tax law and loan characteristics such as interest rates or date loan payable
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 22
Effective date• Split Dollar regulations apply to arrangements
entered into after 9/17/2003 and arrangements materially modified after 9/17/2003.
• “Materially modified” is not defined, but a list is provided to show what is not a material modification.
• 1035 exchanges are not on that list.
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 23
3. Split dollar life insurance death benefits income tax free
– employer’s share– employee’s beneficiaries share– note: some transfers of insurance policies are exempt
from transfer for value rules, some are not
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 24
4. Incidents of ownership affect estate tax liability– if employee had no incidents of ownership, death benefit
excluded from employee’s estate for estate tax purposes unless policy proceeds payable to estate
– if employee is controlling shareholder, corporation’s incidents of ownership in policy will be attributed to controlling shareholder, death proceeds included in employee estate
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 25
5. May be federal gift taxes to pay if someone other than employee owns insurance policy used in split dollar plan
Tax Implications
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 26
Split dollar plans are ‘welfare benefit’ plans under ERISA
– must have written document, “named fiduciary,” and formal claims procedure
– can escape ERISA reporting and disclosure if is ‘insured’ plan maintained for ‘a select group of management or highly compensated employees’
– if cover more than select group, must provide SPD
ERISA Requirements
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 27
1. Split dollar plans are best suited for executives in their late 50’s and early 60’s.
2. In most split dollar plans, the employer’s outlay is fully secured at all times.
3. The employer receives a tax deduction for its share of premium payments under a split dollar plan.
True or False?
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 28
4. Under the classic or standard split dollar plan, the employer and employee split the cost of the life insurance premium equally.
5. An employee who terminates employment before a split dollar plan matures can be held personally responsible for reimbursing employer for aggregate premiums paid.
6. The employee owns the policy under the endorsement method of policy ownership.
True or False?
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 29
7. Recently, significant changes have occurred in the tax laws governing split dollar life insurance.
8. Split dollar plans are exempt from ERISA regulations.
True or False?
Split-Dollar Life Insurance Chapter 42Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning
Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company 30
Is a split dollar arrangement a useful compensation technique for a partner, proprietor, or shareholder employee of an S corporation?
Discussion Question