spideyapp whitepaper (warren / crockford / freitas) - april 2014
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
1/20
Rpmjly6 Onjrcmj-hoslj Rtmnkroy Jltlbtcr[otbd tdlg wotbd ycu6 on mnncvotmvl woy tc jltlbt blaa-pdcnl spymnk
Mntrcjubtmcn
Zlog glghlrs
Eojl Brcbeicrj
Prcflbt portnlr
OBA\ ci Gossobdusltts
Notdon Irlmtos
Prcflbt portnlr
Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt
Fliirly [orrln
GMZ, Bcgputlr Rbmlnbl
Iloturl Mgokl
Iloturlj mgokl6 RpmjlyOpp uslr mntlriobl.
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
2/20
Mgokls
Mgokl ?6 Mnjustrmoa strlnktd MGRM botbdlr ircg Dorrms Bcrpcrotmcn boaalj o Rtmnkroy jlvmbl.
Mgokl 86 Dcglgojl MGRM botbdlrs bcst alss tdon $?000 tc goel wmtd ronkl tc amstln cn nlmkdhcrs.
-
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
3/20
Mgokl 26 Rbrllnsdct ci cur prl-aounbd pokl uslj tc spore mntlrlst mn Rpmjly.
Ojjmtmcnoa Mnicrgotmcn
kmtduh.bcg/ftworrln/spmjly
dttp6//smknup.spmjlyopp.bcg/
Bmtlj Xlscurbls
Zdl hmaa ci rmkdtsdttp6//www.orbdmvls.kcv/lxdmhmts/bdortlrs/hmaaSciSrmkdtsStronsbrmpt.dtga
Ogmbus Hrmli
dttps6//www.obau.crk/imals/osslts/rmkgomjlnSogmbus.pji
LII cn Rtmnkroys
dttps6//www.lii.crk/jllpamnes/80?8/?0/stmnkroys-hmkklst-unencwn-tlbdncackmboa-tdrlot-blaa-pdcn
l-prmvoby
Zdl OBA\ ci Gossobduslttsdttps6//obaug.crk/ohcut
Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt
dttp6//ln.wmempljmo.crk/wmem/ZdlSKuorjmonSPrcflbtS(scitworl)
\slr tlstmnk gltdcjcackmls
dttp6//bcursls.bsoma.gmt.lju/9.42?/80?:/rlojmnks/A??-uslr-tlstmnk/
http://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fcourses.csail.mit.edu%2F6.831%2F2014%2Freadings%2FL11-user-testing%2F&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNGtghWHh9igc57GDpNSWWtLwoZhCAhttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FThe_Guardian_Project_(software)&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNE82Nx0vVC_qvVjHXiyol6y6IN7nQhttps://www.google.com/url?q=https%3A%2F%2Faclum.org%2Fabout&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNEF4pJ-sbhWL2MKhi7aan22_VRR1Qhttps://www.google.com/url?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.eff.org%2Fdeeplinks%2F2012%2F10%2Fstingrays-biggest-unknown-technological-threat-cell-phone-privacy&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNGsN-TNO5buYjvB84_X9PotVV3Zxghttps://www.google.com/url?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.eff.org%2Fdeeplinks%2F2012%2F10%2Fstingrays-biggest-unknown-technological-threat-cell-phone-privacy&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNGsN-TNO5buYjvB84_X9PotVV3Zxghttps://www.google.com/url?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.aclu.org%2Ffiles%2Fassets%2Frigmaiden_amicus.pdf&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNHEki6uNPyqFJTb2tUc0fBFWYcEiQhttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.archives.gov%2Fexhibits%2Fcharters%2Fbill_of_rights_transcript.html&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNF6-RtiKz7_hfDCNHHlTjBZyjsuYQhttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.archives.gov%2Fexhibits%2Fcharters%2Fbill_of_rights_transcript.html&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNF6-RtiKz7_hfDCNHHlTjBZyjsuYQhttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fsignup.spideyapp.com%2F&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNHeBgpMgwXeuTqa-hIBO-rM3m327ghttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fgithub.com%2Fjtwarren%2Fspidey&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNEKrpMbXzkyaX4h42nug34wf9UTTQ -
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
4/20
Nctdmnk tc dmjl
dttp6//ln.wmempljmo.crk/wmem/NctdmnkStcSdmjlSorkuglnt
Acbotmcn
GMZ Gljmo Aoh, Blntlr icr Bmvmb Gljmo;< Ogdlrst Rtrllt
[mlsnlr Humajmnk (L?
-
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
5/20
OhstrobtZdl kcoa ci tdms prcflbt ms tc jlvlacp on losy, usohal tcca tc dlap obtmvmsts, slburmty rlslorbdlrs,
onj ctdlrs jltlrgmnl mi tdlrl ms o blaa pdcnl snmiilr wmtdmn ronkl ci tdlmr jlvmbl. Blaa pdcnl
snmiilrs--tlbdnmboaay boaalj MGRM botbdlrs--orl tccas bopohal ci acbotmnk onj mjlntmiymnk wmrlalss
jlvmbls (blaauaor pdcnls) mn tdlmr vmbmnmty, os wlaa os bopturmnk unlnbryptlj blaauaor
bcggunmbotmcn subd os vcmbl boaas, lgomas, onj RGR glssokls. Blaa pdcnl snmiilrs wcre hy
prltlnjmnk tc hl ncrgoa blaa tcwlrs, tdlrlhy trmbemnk pdcnls mntc bcnnlbtmnk onj slnjmnk
mjlntmiymnk mnicrgotmcn tc tdl survlmaaonbl jlvmbl, mnstloj ci tc tdl pdcnl bcgpony. Zdl Dorrms
Bcrpcrotmcn ms cnl ci tdl gomn gonuiobturlrs ci MGRM botbdlrs mn tdl \nmtlj Rtotls. Dorrms
goels blaa pdcnl snmiilrs boaalj Rtmnkroys, wdmbd mt slaas tc acboa, stotl, onj iljlroa aow
lnicrblglnt tdrcukdcut tdl \nmtlj Rtotls.
Rtmnkroys onj ctdlr MGRM botbdlrs pcsl unmqul prmvoby tdrlots tc plcpal hlbousl tdl
survlmaaonbl tdly bcnjubt ms hy jliouat o jroknlt, nct torkltlj ot o splbmimb suhflbt. Zdms ms
hlbousl tdl jlvmbls lnsnorl prmvotl mnicrgotmcn ci plcpal wmtdmn o klckropdmb rlkmcn, nct fustmnicrgotmcn ci plrscns splbmimboaay torkltlj hy tdl kcvlrnglnt. Icr lxogpal, mi pcambl wontlj tc
encw wdc wos ot o prctlst, tdly bcuaj smgpay turn cn on MGRM botbdlr onj mggljmotlay bcaalbt o
iomray rlamohal amst ci prctlst ottlnjlls. Jcbuglnts rlaloslj tc tdl puhamb strcnkay sukklst tdl IHM
jcls nct chtomn worronts tc usl MGRM botbdlrs. Dcwlvlr, mt ms nct fust aow lnicrblglnt wdc
utmamzls tdlsl jlvmbls6 dobelrs, brmgmnoas, onj prmvotl slburmty prcilssmcnoas bon oasc usl blaa
pdcnl snmiilrs icr mjlntmty tdlit onj ctdlr emnjs ci dorgiua survlmaaonbl.
Zdl OBA\ onj amel-gmnjlj crkonmzotmcns orl wcremnk cn alkoa onj pcamby rlicrgs tc burrlnt
survlmaaonbl aow, mn crjlr tc lnsurl tdot plcpal jc nct klt swlpt up mn unbcnstmtutmcnoa cr
unltdmboa survlmaaonbl jroknlts smgpay hlbousl tdly orl mn tdl wrcnk paobl ot tdl wrcnk tmgl.Zdlsl liicrts mnbaujl ljubotmnk tdl puhamb onj pcambygoelrs ohcut tdl jonklrs pcslj hy tdl
pcwlriua survlmaaonbl jlvmbls. Zdl imrst stlp tc imxmnk ony prchalg ms lxpcsmnk mt. Zc jotl,
dcwlvlr, tdlrl ms nc imnmsdlj opp ovomaohal tc dlap lvlryjoy blaa pdcnl uslrs jltlbt cr chstrubt
MGRM botbdlrs, glonmnk tdot plcpal wdcsl mnicrgotmcn ms bcgprcgmslj wmaa amelay nlvlr encw
ohcut mt onj dovl nc bdonbl tc stcp mt. Burrlnt ottlgpts tc ojjrlss tdms prchalg mnvcavl
splbmoamzlj dorjworl cr lxtrlglay cutjotlj pdcnls, hctd ci wdmbd orl mgprobtmboa icr o typmboa
uslr.
Cur tlog--bcgpcslj ci tdl OBA\ ci GO, Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt, onj GMZ stujlnts--ms cplrotmnk
ircg sdorlj voauls mnbaujmnk soilty, prmvoby, onj irlljcg. [l dcpl tdl Rpmjly oppambotmcn hctdhrcojlns oworlnlss ci survlmaaonbl tlbdncackmls mn klnlroa onj icbusls o notmcnoa bcnvlrsotmcn
cn MGRM botbdlrs splbmimboaay, tcworjs tdl lnj ci tlbdncackmboa onj pcamby rlicrg. [l orl
humajmnk on mnncvotmvl Onjrcmj-hoslj Rtmnkroy jltlbtcr hoslj cn blaa tcwlr sbon jmiilrlntmoas
stcrlj mn o acboa jotohosl tc jltlbt oncgoamls. Mn tdl iuturl, wl dcpl tc bcupal tdms wmtd gobdmnl
alornmnk gcjlas ot sboal tc mnbrlosl bcnimjlnbl mn MGRM botbdlr jltlbtmcn.
-
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
6/20
Prcflbt Norrotmvl
Hobekrcunj
On Mntlrnotmcnoa Gchmal Ruhsbrmhlr Mjlntmty (MGRM) ms o nughlr tdot ms uslj tc unmqulay mjlntmiy o
blaa pdcnl uslr. On MGRM botbdlr ms o jlvmbl tdot ms bopohal ci jltlbtmnk onj rlbcrjmnk MGRMs ciblaa pdcnls wmtdmn ronkl wmtdcut tdl encwaljkl cr bcnslnt ci tdl blaa pdcnl uslr. Zdl Rtmnkroy
(slln mn Mgokl ? ohcvl) ms o splbmimb hronj ci dmkd pcwlr MGRM botbdlr scaj tc kcvlrnglnt onj
aow lnicrblglnt oklnbmls onj gonuiobturlj hy Dorrms Bcrpcrotmcn. MGRM botbdlrs wcre hy
spccimnk o blaa tcwlr onj tdlrlhy trmbemnk blaa pdcnls mntc bcnnlbtmnk tc tdlg. Rcgl portmbuaoray
pcwlriua MGRM botbdlrs icrbl pdcnls mntc nc boaa-lnbryptmcn gcjl onj bon tdlrlicrl lovlsjrcp
cn vcmbl boaas, lgomas, onj RGR glssokls.
Imkurl ?6 Dcw stmnkroys wcre.
Blaauaor pdcnls wmaa slnj o smknoa tc tdl blaa tcwlr rcukday lvlry ?0 slbcnjs wdltdlr tdly orl
trymnk tc goel o boaa cr nct. Zdl jlvmbl ms ohal tc rlbcrj tdl prlbmsl acbotmcn ci lvlry blaa pdcnl
wmtdmn ronkl, rlbcrj wdln onj wmtd wdcg blaauaor bcggunmbotmcns (boaas, tlxts, ltb) orl gojl,
onj ms scgltmgls lvln uslj tc rlbcrj tdl bcntlnt ci bcggunmbotmcn (tlxt cr vcmbl).
-
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
7/20
Zdl Mssul
Kcvlrnglnts onj aow lnicrblglnt oklnbmls orl usmnk stmnkroy jlvmbls os o woy tc trobe onj
acbotl blaauaor pdcnls wmtdcut worronts . Zdms emnj ci trobemnk vmcaotls tdl Icurtd Oglnjglnts?
prcdmhmtmcn okomnst unrloscnohal slorbdls, onj tdrlotlns tdl prmvoby rmkdts ci tdcusonjs ci
plcpal obbuslj ci nc wrcnkjcmnk. Noglay, tdl Icurtd Oglnjglnt ci tdl hmaa ci rmkdts stotls tdlicaacwmnk6
Zdl rmkdt ci tdl plcpal tc hl slburl mn tdlmr plrscns, dcusls, poplrs, onj liilbts,
okomnst unrloscnohal slorbdls onj slmzurls, sdoaa nct hl vmcaotlj, onj nc [orronts
sdoaa mssul, hut upcn prchohal bousl, suppcrtlj hy Cotd cr oiimrgotmcn, onj portmbuaoray
jlsbrmhmnk tdl paobl tc hl slorbdlj, onj tdl plrscns cr tdmnks tc hl slmzlj.8
Mn 80?2, tdl Gossobdusltts Ruprlgl Fujmbmoa Bcurt rualjtdot pcambl orl rlqumrlj tc chtomn o
worront mn crjlr tc trobe scglcnls blaa pdcnl. Yormcus ctdlr bcurtsdovl rlobdlj tdl sogl
bcnbausmcn. Zdl Ruprlgl Bcurt ci tdl \nmtlj Rtotls rualjmn \R v. Fcnls tdot tdl kcvlrnglnt msrlqumrlj tc chtomn o worront hlicrl puttmnk KPR trobelrs cn cur bors tc gop cur gcvlglnts.
Rtotl alkmsaoturls dovl oasc upjotlj tdlmr stotutls mn rlblnt ylors tc rlialbt tdl krcwmnk tdrlot tc
prmvoby pcslj hy lalbtrcnmb acbotmcn trobemnk onj survlmaaonbl. Gomnl onj Gcntono ncw rlqumrl
worronts icr oaa lalbtrcnmb acbotmcn trobemnk, mnbaujmnk tdl usl ci Rtmnkroy-styal jlvmbls.
\nicrtunotlay, tdcsl stotl aows onj bcurt ruamnks jc nct oppay tc tdl IHMs jlpacyglnt ci blaa
pdcnl snmiilrs. Iljlroa aow burrlntay oaacws oklnts ci tdl iljlroa kcvlrnglnt tc usl tdl
tlbdncacky wmtdcut fujmbmoa cvlrsmkdt.
Mn \nmtlj Rtotls v. Xmkgomjln, tdl IHM uslj o Rtmnkroy tc acbotl Jonmla Xmkgomjln mn dms dcgl.
Xmkgomjln wos usmnk o Ylrmzcn omr-borj tc bcnnlbt tc tdl mntlrnlt, onj tdl IHM wontlj tc imnj
dmg mn crjlr tc slorbd dmg, dms bcgputlr, onj dms oportglnt, mn bcnnlbtmcn wmtd o tox irouj
mnvlstmkotmcn. Xmkgomjlns aowylrs oselj o fujkl tc jmsrlkorj oaa lvmjlnbl rlsuatmnk ircg tdl usl
ci tdl Rtmnkroy jlvmbl, smnbl tdl IHM jmj nct chtomn o worront tc jlpacy mt. Mn Goy 80?2, o \R
Jmstrmbt Bcurt fujkl jlnmljXmkgomjlns gctmcn, oaacwmnk tdl irumt ci tdl IHMs worrontalss
survlmaaonbl tc hl uslj okomnst dmg mn bcurt. Os tdl Lalbtrcnmb Ircntmlr Icunjotmcn wrctl,
worrontalss Rtmnkroy survlmaaonbl ms tdl jmkmtoa vlrsmcn ci tdl prl-Xlvcautmcnory wor probtmbl ci
Hrmtmsd scajmlrs kcmnk jccr-tc-jccr, slorbdmnk Oglrmbons dcgls wmtdcut rotmcnoal cr suspmbmcn,
alt oacnl fujmbmoa opprcvoa. [dmal tdl Xmkgomjln bosl wos o acss icr prmvoby ojvcbotls, ctdlr2
bcurts wmaa mnlvmtohay rual cn tdl qulstmcn. Mn ctdlr wcrjs, Xmkgomjln msnt tdl aost alkoa wcrj cn
worrontalss Rtmnkroy spymnk.
[dmal tdlsl bosls goy sllg nuonblj onj orbonl, tdl alkoa outdcrmtmls icr Rtmnkroy usl orl
mnbrljmhay mgpcrtont icr tdl crjmnory blaa pdcnl uslr wdc wonts tc rlgomn prmvotl mn tdl 8?st
?dttp6//prmvobyscs.crk/ncjl/??==8dttp6//www.orbdmvls.kcv/lxdmhmts/bdortlrs/hmaaSciSrmkdtsStronsbrmpt.dtga2Ioedcury, Donnm, onj Zrlvcr Zmgg. "Rtmnkroys6 Zdl Hmkklst Zlbdncackmboa Zdrlot tc Blaa Pdcnl Prmvoby]cu Jcn't Encw Ohcut." Lalbtrcnmb Ircntmlr Icunjotmcn. N.p., 88 Cbt. 80?8.
http://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.wired.com%2F2013%2F05%2Frigmaiden-cell-tower-evidence%2F&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNGmLdPabCEMMiqEF59AcRUwBdK2kwhttps://www.google.com/url?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.aclu.org%2Ffiles%2Fassets%2Frigmaiden_amicus.pdf&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNHEki6uNPyqFJTb2tUc0fBFWYcEiQhttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.scotusblog.com%2Fcase-files%2Fcases%2Funited-states-v-jones%2F&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNHFnPixqpjeDDO8sJTyttnqwHec3Ahttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fprivacysos.org%2Fnode%2F1327&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNEPv_h6GT2UNIbbJEqK-6t1qCQ-Nghttp://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fprivacysos.org%2Fnode%2F1206&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNGCqG92dkge4meQF4GyXxhTFG8Fnw -
8/10/2019 SpideyApp whitepaper (Warren / Crockford / Freitas) - April 2014
8/20
blntury. Mi pcambl bon usl tdlsl jlvmbls wmtdcut o worront, tdly bon losmay trobe onj gcnmtcr
tdcusonjs ci pcamtmboa prctlstlrs, rlamkmcus wcrsdmpplrs, onj vctlrs--bcgprcgmsmnk nct cnay cur
Icurtd Oglnjglnt rmkdts hut oasc cur Imrst Oglnjglnt rmkdts tc irlljcg ci spllbd onj
osscbmotmcn.
Zdl Prcflbt Portnlrs
OBA\
Zdl Oglrmbon Bmvma Amhlrtmls \nmcn (OBA\), ms o ncn-prcimt bcggunmty crkonmzotmcn icunjlj mn
?=80 wmtd tdl stotlj gmssmcn tc Jlilnj onj prlslrvl tdl mnjmvmjuoa rmkdts onj amhlrtmls tdot tdl
Bcnstmtutmcn onj aows ci tdl \nmtlj Rtotls kuorontll lvlrycnl mn tdms bcuntry. Zdl OBA\ usls:
on mntlkrotlj ojvcboby gcjla, hrmnkmnk tckltdlr achhymsts, bcggunmbotmcns lxplrts, ottcrnlys,
puhamb ojvcbotls, onj bcggunmty crkonmzlrs tc lxponj bmvma rmkdts onj bmvma amhlrtmls mn tdl \nmtlj
Rtotls, icr oaa plcpal. Zdl crkonmzotmcn rlblmvls nc kcvlrnglnt iunjmnk, onj rlamls cn jcnotmcns
ircg suppcrtlrs tc unjlrwrmtl mts wcre.
Icr ylors ncw tdl OBA\ dos hlln okkrlssmvlay alojmnk tdl bdorkl notmcnoaay mn amtmkotmcn,
achhymnk, onj puhamb ljubotmcn cn mssuls rlaotlj tc blaa pdcnl trobemnk onj survlmaaonbl. Mn tdl
bosl ci \R v. Xmkgomjln, tdl OBA\ imalj on ogmbus hrmli orkumnk tdot tdl IHM sdcuaj dovl tcaj o
fujkl tdot mt mntlnjlj tc usl o Rtmnkroy jlvmbl tc acbotl mts susplbt. Hy iomamnk tc opprmsl tdl
gokmstrotl tdot mt mntlnjlj tc usl o stmnkroy, wdot tdl jlvmbl ms, onj dcw mt wcres, tdl ottcrnlys
wrctl, Utdl kcvlrnglntW prlvlntlj tdl fujkl ircg lxlrbmsmnk dms bcnstmtutmcnoa iunbtmcn ci
lnsurmnk tdot worronts orl nct cvlray mntrusmvl onj oaa osplbts ci tdl slorbd orl suppcrtlj hy
prchohal bousl.
Eojl Brcbeicrj, tdl jmrlbtcr ci tdl OBA\ ci Gossobdusltts Zlbdncacky icr Amhlrty prcflbt, ms
wcremnk cn tdl Rpmjly opp. Rdl dos lxtlnsmvl encwaljkl ci tdl notmcnoa aonjsbopl plrtomnmnk tc
survlmaaonbl mssuls, onj dos dlaplj mjlntmiy onj icbus tdl mssuls, os wlaa os prcvmjl rlslorbd,
wrmtmnk, onj ojvcboby ossmstonbl icr tdms prcflbt.
Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt
Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt wos icunjlj mn 800= hy Notdon Irlmtos. Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt slts cut tc
brlotl cpln-scurbl gchmal oppambotmcns tdot dlap plcpal bcggunmbotl gcrl irllay onj prctlbt
tdlgslavls ircg mntrusmcn onj gcnmtcrmnk. Zdl Kuorjmon Prcflbt dos on orroy ci cpln-scurbl
oppambotmcns icr hctd mCR onj Onjrcmj wmtd cvlr twc gmaamcn jcwnacojs onj dunjrljs ci
tdcusonjs ci obtmvl uslrs. Gcst pcpuaor ms Crhct wdmbd prcvmjls o Zcr prcxy icr Onjrcmj