"solution-focused" risk/benefit assessment for gof experiments (adam finkel)

8/19/2019 "Solution-Focused" Risk/Benefit Assessment for GOF Experiments (Adam Finkel)

1/10


2/10

Ejvk V`kgks ecr V`ksk Drjke Tkgmros8

=. Tjso mif dkikejt kstjgmtks s`cuaf dk dmaminkf, qumitjtmtjvk, `ugdak, kxpajnjtmdcut vmauk hufbgkits, mif n`miikakf ji skrvjnk ce m t`cub`teua fknjsjci ruak.

4. Dkikejt kstjgmtks nmi dk gmfk ncggkisurmdak wjt` rjso kstjgmtks, mifs`cuaf dk ncgguijnmtkf wjt` kquma nmrk.

>. \urkay rjso“dmskf prjcrjtjzmtjci js jiekrjcr tc ikt“dkikejt prjcrjtjzmtjci.

6. Vrmispmrkiny ji pudajn kibmbkgkit js jgpcrtmit, dut ict ms jgpcrtmit ms‑mppmrkiny.‗

;. ‑^cautjci“ecnuskf‗ mimaysjs ce BCE mif pudajn n`cjnk gmy rkqujrk w`caay ikw

jistjtutjcima mrrmibkgkits, ict hust ‑jincrpcrmtkf jitc kxjstjib pcajnyermgkwcros.‗


3/10

V`k Vwc Ncggci (mif [skakss) ‑Tjso-Ajok‗ Ojifs ce \rcicuinkgkits8

=. ‑Kxmntay t`js cutncgk nmi `mppki‗ (dut wjt` w`mt prcdmdjajty33)

4. ‑Rjt` kxmntay t`js prcdmdjajty, scgkt`jib dmf wjaa `mppki‗

Tjso kqumas (mif ciay kqumas) e (prcdmdjajty mif skvkrjty-ms-kxpkrjkinkf)


4/10

M `jkrmrn`y ce fknjsjci ruaks (w/c sygdcas cr kqumtjcis)8

=. Vcakrmtk ic rjso ercg ‑scgkt`jib‗„ cr tcakrmtk ic ncst ce ncitrcaajib jt.

4. Gmok ms gmiy pkcpak ms pcssjdak ‑smek,‗ scgk`cw gcfkrmtkf dy ncst.

>. \rktkif tc kstjgmtk tctma ikt dkikejt (VID), dut dctn` t`k nmanuamtjci ncgpaktkay.

6. Fkrjvk m rkmscimdak kstjgmtk ce t`k kxpkntkf vmauk ce VID.

;. Fkrjvk m pfe ecr VID, mif prkskit jt euaay, cr n`ccsk mi kstjgmtcr ercg jt trmispmrkitay.

5. Fjttc, dut tmok mnncuit ce ceeskttjib rjsos mif ceeskttjib ncsts (‑ikt ikt dkikejt‗).

2. Kstjgmtk, ecr = cr gcrk sudpcpuamtjcis cr pmrmfjbg jifjvjfumas, t̀ k ikt ikt dkikejt tc t`kg .

0. Fkrjvk (pfe ecr) VID ms t`k uiwkjb`tkf sug ce jifjvjfuma ID, tmojib jitc mnncuit

jitkrjifjvjfuma fjeekrkinks ji kxpcsurk, susnkptjdjajty, mif prkekrkink:. Fkrjvk (pfe ecr) VID ms t`k wkjb`tkf sug ce jifjvjfuma ID.


5/10

(ercg M. Ejioka, Kivjrcigkitma @kmat` \krspkntjvks, =::;)


6/10

_Je scnjkty maacwkf JUE tc prcnkkf, scgk kicrgcus ncinkptswkrk mt stmok8 ‑t`k jfkm ce t`k `ugmiikss ce cur `ugmi ajekmif t`k gkmijib ce cur kgdcfjgkit, cur skxuma dkjib, mifcur rkamtjci tc minkstcrs mif fksnkifmits.‗W

--Akci Omss, metkr t`k djrt` ce Acujsk Drcwi ji =:20

‑Tjso ji t`k Imgk ce Dkikejt‗


7/10

• Fcks t`k mppajnmtjci `mvk pcsjtjvk ikt dkikejt3 V`mt js, fcks jts rjso-rkfuntjci pctkitjmakxnkkf jts prcpkisjty tc nrkmtk mffjtjcima rjsos3

• Ncgpmrkf tc ct`kr wmys tc prcfunk t`k smgk cr m sjgjamr gmtkrjma, fcks t`k ^yiDjcmppajnmtjci `mvkbrkmtkr gmrbjima ikt dkikejt * t`mi t`k matkrimtjvk(s)3

• Ncgpmrkf tc ct`kr wmys tc euaejaa t`k smgk `ugmi ikkf, fcks t`k ^yiDjc mppajnmtjci`mvk brkmtkr gmrbjima ikt dkikejt t`mi t`k matkrimtjvk(s)3

• Fcks t`k kxjstjib fcgjimit gkmis ce euaejaajib m pmrtjnuamr `ugmi ikkf `mvk m pmrtjnuamray pccr rjso prcejak, sun` t`mt scnjkty gjb`t acco tc mi uigkt mppajnmtjci ce^yiDjc tc fjspamnk jt3

* V`js ncuaf rkeaknt m nmsk w`krk m ncivkitjcima wmy tc prcfunk m gmtkrjma `ms pcsjtjvk ikt dkikejt (rkfunks rjsos gcrk strcibay t`mi jtjgpcsks t`kg), dut m ^yiDjc mppajnmtjci `ms kvki brkmtkr ikt rjso-rkfunjib pctkitjma. ^jgjamray, t`k ^yiDjc mppajnmtjci ncuaf `mvkikbmtjvk ikt dkikejt, dut ncuaf rkpamnk m ncivkitjcima mppajnmtjci w`csk ikt dkikejt prcejak js kvki gcrk strcibay ikbmtjvk (m ‑aksskr cetwc kvjas‗ nmsk).

V`k Jgpcvkrjs`kf (Umpjf) ]ukstjci js ‑Js Jt ^mek3‗8 Jinrkmsjibay[skeua mif Mgdjtjcus ]ukstjcis Jinaufk…


8/10


9/10

Vrmfjtjcima rjso msskssgkit msos m imrrcw ojif ce qukstjci8 ‑ R`mt

maacwmdak ncinkitrmtjcis ce kmn` ce ; fjeekrkit n`kgjnmas s`cuaf wkmaacw ji cur pamstjn wmtkr dcttaks3‗ ‑^cautjci-Ecnuskf TjsoMsskssgkit‗ (^ETM), ji ncitrmst, pcsks m gcrk mgdjtjcus qukstjci8‑ @cw gjb`t wk prcvjfk rkmfy mnnkss tc ncaf frjiojib wmtkr, pkr`mpswjt` 4: djaajci EKRKT dcttaks ce miy ojif dcub`t mif prcgptay t`rcwi

mwmy kmn` ykmr3‗ (Ejioka, M.G. (4


10/10

Vwc Kxmgpaks ce Tjsoy Vkn`icacbjks/\rcfunts t`mt Amno ̂ yiDjc Matkrimtjvks8

=. \mag Cja

• Fksjrmdak trmis-emt-erkk cja?• ^kvkrma gjaajci `kntmrks ce trcpjnma ecrkst ncivkrtkf miiumaay tc cja

pmag gcicnuaturk?

• [sk ce n`jaf amdcr?

• V`rkmtkikf kxtjintjci ce wjaf crmibutmi pcpuamtjci

4. Gkt`mik \rcfuntjci ji Ncws

• Je t`k 44 gjaajci ncws ji Kurcpk ncuaf prcfunk 4;% akss gkt`mik, t`js

wcuaf yjkaf t`k NC 4 rkfuntjci kqujvmakit tc pcwkrjib ; gjaajci `cgksecr m ykmr.

• Ncuaf rkskmrn`krs wcrojib ci ^yiDjc gjnrceacrm ji `ugmis turi tc t`jsqukstjci3

"solution-focused" risk/benefit assessment for gof experiments (adam finkel)

Documents