sobisch: interpreting tantras (jiabs_32 2009)

Upload: achi1143

Post on 16-Oct-2015

30 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

A Tibetan debate on the numbers ofadepts admissible to tantric consecration

TRANSCRIPT

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    1/25

    !"#$%!&'()*+ &- ./0 ").0()*.1&)*+

    #22&31*.1&) &- $'44/12. %.'4102

    5&+'60 78 9'6:0( ; ?8=;=@

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    2/25

    !"#$%!&'()*+ &- ./0 ").0()*.1&)*+

    #22&31*.1&) &- $'44/12. %.'4102

    5&+'60 78 9'6:0( ; ?8=;=@

    !"#$%&'#()

    !"!$%$& '()!*)+,-.

    !" $%$&'()$* !"#+( ,()"-(" ./0 123245 6766 8 660 +2-(9::7; / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 0

    *'$#+,()

    1$234 5/ ,-))

    ?&$% &@4%'A)5(&"4 &" $25% 4=%%B $&"C4 / / / 66

    '7&83&9 -:;-.!3"&')"D%* %B(45%$&-&3E )"F 4&5%'(&-&3E 8 G)'5 ! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ?@

    AB$&834 >5..-;;

    H)5("3 -%55%'4 (" 5=%

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    3/25

    =L&93&94K

    -#"($&. )+01,&)$#+#)2 #. $0( 33$0&.4 35$0+(.$%'#()

    =L&9B7MN97L&4 9L $ O$&3J $9 9D3 P'9D=L&QB344 LR 9D3 *&93B&$97L&$J544L87$97L& LR ,NFFD749 N349 3F79LB4V W$48$J3 !NQL& $&F X3Y7& 'L43

    W$48$J3 !">()$&F X3Y7& '(

    *)&

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    4/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$45 ;7M39$& F3M$93 L& 9D3 &N2M3B4 LR $F3O94

    $F27447MJ3 9L 9$&9B78 8L&438B$97L&

    1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    5/25

    K6\ 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    6/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 K60

    G3 $JB3$F% B3$J7[3 4L23 LR 9D3 93&47L&4 9D$9 3e749 G79D7& 9D3

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    7/25

    K6 1$&I"JB78D LIB$24IO$ MB3$9H$493B4 LR 9D3

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    8/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 K6Z

    54 74 G3JJ `&LG&S 9D3 D)'E(9$&9B$ 8J$44 74S $88LBF7&Q 9L 9D3 2L49G7F3I4OB3$F 8J$447"8$97L& 4%4932 LR 9D3 J$93B 9B$&4J$97L& O3B7LFS 9D3438L&F JLG349 LR 9D3 RLNB 9$&9B$ 8J$4434/9hD% 74 9D3 OB$89783 LRM349LG7&Q 9$&9B78 8L&438B$97L& L& $&% OL447MJ3 &N2M3B LR F7487IOJ34 O3B27993F 7& 9D3 D)'E(9$&9B$4p *& D74 4X&$ 342$ '")$ @4=)FaRLJ/ @UBbS 9D3 8L223&9$9LB >LIB$24IO$ M

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    9/25

    K6C 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    10/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 K6@

    LB >LIB$24IO$S 9D74 BNJ3 L&J% $OOJ734 9L 9$&9B$4 LR 9D3 D)'E(8J$44SMN9 &L9 9L 9D3 aJLG3Bb C'(E(LB 9D3 aD7QD3Bb E&3)/ ;D3 BNJ3 LR 9D3?($("E)A(F=(32=E)5)"5')S DLG3Y3BS GD78D 74 iNL93F 7& 9D3 4X&$342$ ')@ F@E%S 74 $88LBF7&Q 9L 9D3

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    11/25

    KKU 1$&I"JB78D 7Y3& 9D3 RB3iN3&8% G79D GD78D 9D3 9$&9B$ 74iNL93F 7& ;7M39$& 4LNB834 $&F 9D3 72OLB9$&83 9D$9 74 $99$8D3F 9L 79S$ F39$7J3F 49NF% LR 9D74 93e9 GLNJF 83B9$7&J% M3 G$BB$&93F/ (R 8L&I47F3B$MJ3 7&93B349 7& LNB 8L&93e9S DLG3Y3BS 74

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    12/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 KK6

    79 74 9$`3& RLB QB$&93F M% LIB$24IO$ 9D$9 9D74 9$&9B$f4B349B7897L&4 8L&83B&7&Q 9D3 &N2M3B4 LR F7487OJ34 $F27993F 9L 9D3B79N$J LR 9$&9B78 8L&438B$97L& 4DLNJF M3 $OOJ73F 9L 9$&9B$4 &J &5=%'D-)44%4/ ,% 23B3J% iNL97&Q 9D74 Y3B% MB73R $&F 7&F33F 8B%O978 O$4I4$Q3 T 3Y3& G79D LIB$24IO$f4 8B3$97Y3 7&93BOB39$97L&

    T 9D3 FLNM94 GD39D3B B79N$J4 RBL2 $ C'(E(9$&9B$ $B3 $OOJ78$MJ3 9LL9D3B 9$&9B$ 8J$4434 FL &L9 4332 9L D$Y3 M33& 4LJY3F/ 5&F RNB9D3BI2LB3S 7R

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    13/25

    KKK 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    14/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 KK?

    $ J$BQ3B &N2M3B LR F7487OJ34 lRLB 9$&9B78 8L&438B$97L&m/

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    15/25

    KK\ 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    16/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 KK0

    ALB 9D3 4$`3 LR D74 $BQN23&9S 3Z2"3bkk4-&@ $) '% '% ")4@C23 aW> F323b45%kk34)"3 35&' 4"3) $) @Z=(" @E)4 -) aW> ")4bkk/ 18

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    17/25

    KK^ 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    18/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 KKZ

    $FZ)F B) F% "(k'")$ 4")"3 $"3&" @E)"3 ")4 342"34 B) -5)'k@E)"3D=2@ CE( 4%$4 CE( '3E2' f3E2' @)f( F3&4 B) C=E)F B)' D)" -) F3&"34")4 3')"34 "3%4 $) $FZ)F B) a_b

    ;D74 8L&83B&4 9D3

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    19/25

    KKC 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    20/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 KK@

    9D3B3 9D3 4`7JJ3F 2$493B B3J734 L& 9D3 B79N$J9D$9 G$4 9$NQD9 7& 9D3 ?($("E)I9$&9B$a4pb/

    588LBF7&Q 9L LIB$24IO$V cJ$8`4 8J$BI79%dbS 9D3 B79N$J LR 9D3 ?($("E)I9$&9B$a4pb 74 9L M3 $OOJ73F/ .7QIfF[7&=DL4I`%7IQB$Q4IO$ &LG OL7&94 LN9 9D$9 c&LG$F$%4 2$`7&Q 8LN&94lLR F7487OJ34m 398/ $OO3$B4 7& %LNB l7/3/ 9D3

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    21/25

    K?U 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    22/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 K?6

    9L QBLNO4 LR F7487OJ34 G79D 2LB3 9D$& 9G3&9%I"Y3 O$B9787O$&94S 9D74GLNJF 23$& a7& N&74L& G79D '7MD+978$&FB$pb289D$9 9D3 JLG3B 4%493274 O3B837Y3F $4 4L239D7&Q 9D$9 74 2LB3 B7Q7FS GD7J3 9D3 D7QD3B 4%4I932 74 2LB3 J3&73&9/ ,N9 9D74 74 &L9 9D3 $9979NF3 LR 9D3 f,B7IQN&QIO$4/*& R$89S $ 8J3$B 49$9323&9 9L 9D$9 3&F 8$& M3 RLN&F a7& 9D3 8L&93e9LR 9D3 9DB33 YLG FL89B7&3b 7& 9D3 FY&"34 3D(3a5FF3&FN2 6?k6\bV29

    l(9D3B4m DLJF 9D$9 9D3 9DB33 YLG4 $B3 $483&F7&QJ% 2LB3 J3&73&9 lGD7J3f17QIB93&I2QL&IOLm 2$7&9$7&3F 9D$9 9D3 9DB33 YLG4 $B3 $483&F7&QJ%2LB3 B7Q7F/

    4F&$ B) 342$ 3&"3 ")4 3&"3 F2 E)"34 42 f3'& @)' fF&Fk 4F&$ B)342$ 3&"3 ")4 3&"3 F2 F&3 52 f3'& @)' @Z=%F F&k

    588LBF7&Q 9L 9D74 Y73GS GD78D 74 4$7F 9L D$Y3 M33& 7&9BLFN83F 7&;7M39 M% 597($S30 9D3 B'(5($&C+)$M$&FL&4 9D3 8L$B43 23&9$J $RI!7897L&4 a"E&" $&"34 B) ')34 B)b G79D 9D3 D3JO LR $ 42$JJ &N2M3Ba3')"34 "E2"3b LR BNJ34 9D$9 $B3 QN$BF3F 9DBLNQD LBF7&$B% a5=) $)-

    28 *& D74 L( D=&4S X$B2$ =D$Q4I23F a6^6?T6^ZCb 4$%4 9D$9 '7MD+97I8$&FB$f4 OL4797L& G$4 OB$89783F M% 9D3 MX$fIMBQ%NFIO$4 a8797&Q 9D3 f,B7IQN&QIO$ f17QIB93&I2QL&IOL $4 $& 3e83O97L&b/ *& D74 GLBF4S c9D3 MX$fI

    MBQ%NFIO$4 OBL833F $ M79 J3&73&9 G79D 9D3 BNJ34 LR 9D3 Y7&$%$/d !3 8L&9B$4949D74 G79D 9D3 49$9323&9 RBL2 9D3 $FF3&FN2 LR 9D3 FY&"34 3D(3S RLB GD78D433 M3JLG/ ALB 9D3L( D=&4S 433 '

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    23/25

    K?K 1$&I"JB78D

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    24/25

    *&93BOB397&Q 9D3 9$&9B$4 K??

    D7QD3BS MN9 B$9D3B 9B73F 9L OB343BY3 3J323&94 LR 9D3 OB$89783 LR $ JLGI3B 9$&9B$ L& $ D7QD3B J3Y3J $&F 9D3 f,B7IQN&QIO$4f $72 RLB $8D73Y7&Q9D3 4$23 B34NJ94 a7/3/ 9$&9B78 8L&438B$97L&bS MN9 RLB $ Y$493B QBLNOLR O$B9787O$&94 9DBLNQD $ Y$493B 2L97Y$97L&S OB34NOOL47&Q $ QB3$93BiN$J7"8$97L& LR 9D3 QNBN GDL M349LG4 9D3 D7QD3B 9$&9B78 8L&438B$I97L&4S $4 9D74 74 $ 2LB3 F7*8NJ9 OB$89783 9D$& 9D3 O3BRLB2$&83 LR $9$&9B78 8L&438B$97L& L& 9D3 JLG3B J3Y3J/ * DLO3 9D$9 RN9NB3 B343$B8D7&9L 9D74 $&F B3J$93F 2$93B7$J G7JJ 4DLG GD39D3B 4N8D N&F3BJ%7&Q9B3&F4 $&F F74OL4797L&4 $B3 7&F33F 7F3&97"$MJ3 7& 9D3 $OOBL$8D34 9L

    9$&9B78 OB$89783 LR LJF KUUZ T 1L&$9D$& >LJFV ?)CE) G),-(5) &"R2FF=(45 ?D=&-)'4=(B (" N$B748L $&F*&QB7F H8:3LF a9BJ4/bS *9D$8$V

  • 5/26/2018 Sobisch: Interpreting Tantras (JIABS_32 2009)

    25/25

    K?\ 1$&I"JB78D