slides crossing borders in search of health, welfare, and safety al
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Crossingbordersinsearchofhealth,welfare,andsafety
MarketDesignPerspectivesonInequalityHCEO,Chicago,August2016
AlRothStanfordUniversity
1
(Kidneyfailure, Surrogacy,andRefugeequalification)
![Page 2: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Healthinequality
• Kidneyfailure
2
![Page 3: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
U.S.Incidentcounts(newpatients)&
adjustedratesofESRD,by
raceFigure1.5(Volume2)
Incident ESRDpatients.Adj:age/gender;ref:2005ESRDpatients.USRDS2012ADR 3
![Page 4: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
KidneysTransplantedpermillionpopulationU.S.A.
Nigeria,Phillippines (GlobalObservatoryonDonation&Transplantation)
Nigeria
Philippines
4
![Page 5: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Patientsreceivingrenalreplacementtherapy(dialysis)in2010(estimate)
LiyanageT,NinomiyaT,JhaV,etal.Worldwideaccesstotreatmentforend-stagekidneydisease:asystematicreview.Lancet2015;385:1975-82.
![Page 6: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Elsewhere,2-7millionpeopledieeveryyearworldwideduetoinabilitytopay
foreitherdialysisorkidneytransplantation
IntheU.S.,100,000peopleareonthedeceaseddonorwaitinglist,butweonlyhave12,000deceaseddonortransplants
peryear
![Page 7: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Papers• GlobalKidneyExchange,MichaelA.Rees,TyB.Dunn,ChristianS.Kuhr,ChristopherL.Marsh,JeffreyRogers,SusanE.Rees,AlejandraCicero,LaurieJ.Reece,AlvinE.Roth,ObiEkwenna,DavidE.Fumo,KimberlyD.Krawiec,JonathanE.Kopke,Samay Jain,MiguelTanandSiegfredo R.Paloyo,submitted.
• “FinancingTransplantCostsofthePoor:GlobalKidneyExchange,” AfshinNikzad,MohammadAkbarpour,MichaelRees,andAlvinE.Roth,workingpaper,2016
7
![Page 8: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Kidneyexchange—U.S.background• Manymorepeopleneedkidneytransplantsthanthereareavailableorgans.
• ThewaitinglistintheUShasabout100,000people– Thewaitcanbeyears,andmanydiewhilewaiting(4,448in2015,withanother4,377removedfromwaitinglistas“toosicktotransplant”).
– In2015wehad12,250 transplantsfromdeceaseddonors
• Transplantableorganscanalsocomefromlivingdonors.– In2015wehad5,628transplantsfromlivingdonors
• Sometimesdonorsareincompatiblewiththeirintendedrecipient.
• Thisopensthepossibilityofexchange .
![Page 9: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Simple two-pair kidney exchange
Donor1Bloodtype
A
Recipient1
BloodtypeB
Recipient2
BloodtypeA
Donor2Bloodtype
B9
![Page 10: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Noticethatnomoneychangeshands…
• Kidneyexchangeisan“inkind”exchange
• Section301,NationalOrganTransplantAct
(NOTA),42U.S.C.274e1984: “itshallbe
unlawfulforanypersontoknowingly
acquire,receiveorotherwisetransferany
humanorganforvaluableconsiderationfor
useinhumantransplantation”.10
![Page 11: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
2-wayexchangeinvolves4simultaneoussurgeries
11
![Page 12: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Chains initiated by non-directed (altruistic) donors
Non-directeddonationbeforekidneyexchangewasintroduced
Waitlist
Non-directeddonor
12
![Page 13: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Chains initiated by non-directed (altruistic) donors
Non-directeddonationbeforekidneyexchangewasintroduced
Non-directeddonationafterkidneyexchangewasintroduced
Waitlist
Non-directeddonor
R1 D1
D2R2
Waitlist
Non-directeddonor
13
![Page 14: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
![Page 15: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
O O A A B A A A A A
1Jul 2007
AZ
2Jul 2007
OH
3Sep 2007
OH
4Sep 2007
OH
5Feb 2008
MD
6Feb 2008
MD
7Feb 2008
MD
8Feb 2008
NC
9Mar 2008
MD
10Mar 2008
OH
62%CaucWife
Husband
0%Cauc
DaughterMother
23%Cauc
MotherDaughter
0%Cauc
BrotherSister
82%Cauc
HusbandWife
78%HispanicDaughter
Father
64%CaucWife
Husband
100%Cauc
BrotherBrother
46%AA
MotherDaughter
3%CaucFriendFriend
Transplant Date:Recipient's State:
Recipient's PRA:Recipient's Ethnicity:
Recipient-to-DonorRelationship:
1 The initiating donor was an unpaired altruistic donor from Michigan.2 The recipient of Transplant 6 required desensitization to HLA DSA by T and B cell flow cytometry.3 The recipient of Transplant 9 required desensitization to blood group (AHG titer of 1:8).
Recipient's Sexand ABO type:
Donor's Sexand ABO type: AO AO B A A A AB A AB1
2 3
![Page 16: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
KPD and NDD Transplants in U.S.
![Page 17: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
KPD and NDD as % of LD in the United States
![Page 18: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Kidney exchange outside the U.S.
• Wednesday,August3,2016FirstkidneyexchangeinNepal• March7,2016FirstpairedkidneyexchangetransplantdoneinSingapore• Friday,July24,2015KidneyexchangeinTurkey (1st exchangesthere)• April10,2015Afirstnon-directeddonorkidneyexchangechaininItaly• March30,2015AfirstkidneyexchangeinArgentina• March5,2015FirstkidneyexchangeinPoland• Friday,November7,2014KidneyexchangeinSpain:nowmorethan100transplants• June7,2014KidneyexchangeinFrance• December19,2013KidneyexchangeinVienna• August19,2013TenkidneyexchangetransplantsonWorldKidneyDayinAhmedabad,India• July28,2013FirstKidneyExchangeinPortugal:• July23,2013KidneyexchangechaininIndia• June6,2013KidneyexchangebetweenJewishandArabfamiliesinIsrael• December26,2012KidneyexchangeinCanada• December1,2012KidneyexchangeinIndia• June1,2012MikeReesandGreece:anintercontinentalkidneyexchange• March27,2012KidneyexchangeinBritain• February5,2012KidneyexchangeinAustralia,2011• April29,2011FirstkidneyexchangeinSpain• December8,2010NationalkidneyexchangeinCanada• August3,2010KidneyExchangeinSouthKorea• Tuesday,August3,2010KidneyExchangeinSouthKorea• Friday,July30,2010KidneytransplantationadvicefromtheNetherlands• March9,2010KidneyexchangenewsfromBritain (1st 3-waythere)• January27,2010TheAustralianpairedKidneyeXchange (AKX)goeslive• June25,2009KidneyexchangeinCanada (1st exchangethere)• February27,2009KidneyExchangeinAustralia (inWesternAustralia) 18
![Page 19: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Globalkidneyexchange:apossibilityofmutualaid
DevelopingWorld
UnitedStates
Transplantsunavailable 19
Two-wayexchange
![Page 20: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Firstglobalkidneyexchange,withapairfromthePhilippines—January2015,
AllianceforPairedDonation(Reesetal.)
JoseMamaril receivedakidney fromanon-directedAmericandonor inGeorgia.Hiswife,Kristine,donatedoneofherkidneystoanAmericanrecipientinMinnesota,whosedonorcontinued thechainbydonating toapatientinSeattle.THEBLADE/JETTAFRASER 20
•
Jose Kristine
D2R2
…
Non-directeddonor
![Page 21: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Thechaintodate
![Page 22: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Safelyhome…
• $50,000escrowfundforpost-surgicalcare
22
![Page 23: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
GlobalKidneyExchange
23
TheGKEproposalis“self-financing”.• Backoftheenvelopecalculation:– costofhemodialysis≈$90,000peryear– averagetimeunderdialysis≈5years– costoftransplant≈$120,000persurgery(plus$20,000inmaintenancetherapycostsperpatientperyear)
• Butinsteadystate,waitingtimedecreases.Sodialysiscostswillgodown…howlongwillGKEremainselffinancing?
![Page 24: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
GKEremainsselffinancingevenwhenitbecomeswidespread.
24
Intuition:• Somedomesticpairsimmediatelyfindamatch• Someotherdonotfindamatchuponarrival.– Theyincreasetheaveragewaitingcost
• Internationalpairsgetmatchedtothosethelattertypeofdomesticpairs
• Soeveniftheaveragedialysiscostislessthanthesurgerycosts,GKEcanstillbeself-financingbecauseitmatchesdomesticpatientswithhigher-than-averagedialysiscosts.
![Page 25: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Themedicallogisticsmaynotbethehardpart
25
![Page 26: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Financialflows• Savings:–Medicare—complexlegislative/bureaucratic– Privateinsurers(33months)
• Costs:– Surgeries—transplantcenters– Postsurgicaltreatmentinhomecountries– Infrastructuredevelopmentinhomecountries
• USAID?--SameFederalbudget,butnochangeneededinMedicare
• Allowinsurancecompaniestonominatepatients?26
![Page 27: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Repugnanceconstraints
• Livingdonors–Frompoorcountries
• Asafirstreaction,manypeoplearegoingtoconflateglobalkidneyexchangewithbuyingkidneys(whichisillegaleverywhereexceptIran—a‘repugnanttransaction’)
27
![Page 28: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Repugnance• 1.“theplanisreallynotabouttheinternationalrecipient(nor…abouttheinternationaldonor),butonlyaboutgettingorgansforUScitizens.Soitisexploitative."
• 2.“Letssolveproblemsathomefirst…We shouldencourageprogramsthatallowAmericanstohelpAmericans."
• 3.“Thereisanexploitationofasocialcondition(beingdestituteinaforeigncountry)thatkidneytransplantationshouldnotbetheremedyofresolvingsocialinequities."
28
![Page 29: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
• RepugnanceConcerns:– Inadequatepost-surgicalcare• Escrowfundsforimmunosuppressivedrugsandpostsurgicalcare(inPhilippines)• Basicinfrastructure(inNigeria)—USAID?
– Inappropriate/illegal/unethicaldonorsolicitation(howcanweensurethatforeigndonorsaren’tsellingtheirkidney?)• Familyrequirement?• Fornon-directeddonorstoo?
29
![Page 30: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Fertilitytourism
• Theurgetohavekidsisstrong.
• Somefertilityservicesarerepugnantinsomeplacesbutnotinothers.
• non-bordercrossing:wombtransplants(WombtransplantsinSweden(wheresurrogacyisillegal)
30
![Page 31: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
GermanSurrogacyLawSurrogacycontractsinwhichawomandeclaresherreadinesstoundergoartificialornaturalinseminationortohaveanembryo,whichisnothers,transferredtoherortocarryababyotherwisetothefulltermareviewedasunethicalandthereforetreatedasvoidinGermany.PursuanttotheEmbryoProtectionActandtheAdoptionPlacementAct,theactivitiesperformedbythosearrangingsurrogatemothersandbyphysiciansinconnectionwithsurrogacyarepunishableoffences.UnderGermanlaw,thewomanwhocommissionsachildinsuchaway(commissioningmother)isnotthemotherofthechild.Themotherofthechildisthewomanwhogavebirthtohim/her,thatis,thesurrogatemotherandnotthecommissioningmother.…Forthisreason,Germanauthoritiescannotrecognizethematernityofacommissioningmotherevenifaforeignbirthcertificateconfirmsherastheostensiblemother.FederalForeignOffice:http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Infoservice/FAQ/GermanFamilyLaw/Leihmutterschaft.html?nn=479790
![Page 32: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
SurrogatechilddeniedGermanpassport09May2011
By Nisha Satkunarajah AppearedinBioNews 606Achildborntoa surrogatemotherinIndiahasbeenrefusedaGermanpassportdespitethecommissioningGermanparentsbeingnamedonthebirthcertificate.TheGermancouplemadetheapplicationtotheGermanEmbassyinIndiabutapassportwasrefusedaftertheembassysaidithaddoubtsoverthechild'sGermancitizenship.Theplaceofbirthonthechild'sbirthcertificatewasstatedasanagencywhichspecialises insurrogacy.AcourtinBerlinruledtheembassywasentitledtorefusetheapplication.…'ThephenomenoniswidespreadinIndiawheremanychildlessGermansgotofulfil theirwishtohavebabies',aspokesmanforthecourtsaid.'TheythinkitispossiblewithoutanyproblemstotakethechildtoGermany.Butthat'snotthecase'.
![Page 33: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Canada:AssistedHumanReproductionAct (2004)
• Paymentforsurrogacy:6. (1) Nopersonshallpayconsiderationtoafemalepersontobeasurrogatemother,offertopaysuchconsiderationoradvertisethatitwillbepaid.
• Actingasintermediary:(2) Nopersonshallacceptconsiderationforarrangingfortheservicesofasurrogatemother,offertomakesuchanarrangementforconsiderationoradvertisethearrangingofsuchservices.
• Surrogatemother—minimumage:(4) Nopersonshallcounselorinduceafemalepersontobecomeasurrogatemother,orperformanymedicalproceduretoassistafemalepersontobecomeasurrogatemother,knowingorhavingreasontobelievethatthefemalepersonisunder21yearsofage.
33
![Page 34: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Surrogacy• marketdesign/ruleoflaw"Blackmarket"surrogacyinEngland,andsubsequentlegalcomplications
• Ruleoflawisaworkinprogresshttp://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/28/us/surrogacy-agency-planet-hospital-delivered-heartache.html
• Californialaw:escrowaccounts:http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=fam&group=07001-08000&file=7960-7962
• Indiaisattractivetosomeforothercontractingcapabilities—e.g.supervisionofthesurrogate’sbehaviorregardingnutrition,sleep,exercise(nottomentiondrinkinganddrugs) 34
![Page 35: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Migrationbyrefugeesandothers:• Steps:Qualification(forrefugeestatus,etc.),Determination
ofcountryofasylum,settlementinthatcountry.• Settlement:AlexandWill--settlingrefugeeswhohave
alreadybeengrantedasylumsomewherehassomestrongsimilaritieswith—anddifferencesfrom--schoolchoice.TommyAnderssonandLarsEhlers:matchingrefugeestohousing/landlords.
• Determinationofcountry:thathassomeelementsthatresembleschoolchoice(refugeepreferenceswillbeinformative)butalsohasamuchbiggerpoliticalelementinvolvingcountryquotas—HillelandJesúsFernández-HuertasMoraga haveinterestingideasonchoosingcountrycapacities.
• Butqualifyingforrefugeestatusisadifferentkindofproblem,moreakintopoliceinvestigation,sincetherearesomekindsofinformation(e.g.foreignfighter)thatitmayneverbesafeforapplicantstoadmit…andthisispotentiallyafirstorderproblem,nowthatsecurityissuchahighprofilepoliticalissuewithfar-reachingconsequences
35
![Page 36: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Brexit:AntiEU/anti-immigrantposters
36
![Page 37: Slides Crossing Borders in Search of Health, Welfare, and Safety Al](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022051319/58a2e61d1a28ab2e458b8572/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Designingproceduresforelicitingandverifyinginformation
• Dominantstrategymechanisms—powerfulbutrare.– “DoyouspeakEnglish?”– DoyouspeakBulgarian?– Didyoucarryagun?
• Policestyleinvestigationsaregoingtobeeasierformigrantswhoarepartofanaccessiblenetwork
37