ANALYSIS OF IMPACT OF TARGETED OPERATION

IN KARACHI

FROM 5-9-2013 TO 28-12-2014

SEQUENCEA

Heinous offences (Comparative 2013-2014)

Heinous offences (Comparative after and before Operation)

B Killing

C Target Killing

D Arrest of Murderers

E Month wise Killing

F Month wise target killing

G Kidnapping for Ransom

H Extortion

I Robberies/Vehicle theft & Snatched

J Status of arrested accused

K Performance in ATC

L Cases Challaned

M Conviction during operation

N Police Performance

O Police Shaheed

P Police Strength in Karachi

Q Crime Control Strategies

R Way Forward

HEINOUS OFFENCES 2013-2014A

Killings(Persons)

Target Killing (Persons)

Bomb Blast /

Terrorism

Kid. for

Ransom

Extortion Dacoity /Robberies

Street Robberies

Mobile Phone

snatching

4 Wheelers Theft /

Snatched

2 Wheelers Theft /

Snatched

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

1816

917

26 98 434

982

1539

1826

3

3615

2142

1

2769

1814

41 116

537

1131

1772

9757

4094

2116

3

1-1-14 to 28-12-14

1-1-13 to 28-12-13

KillingsTarget Killing

Bomb Kid. Dacoity / Street Mobile 4 Wheelers2

Wheelers(Persons) (Persons) Blast / for Robberies Robberies Phone Theft / Theft /

Terrorism Ransom snatching Snatched Snatched

1-1-14 to 28-12-14

1816 917 26 98 434 982 1539 18263 3615 21421

2014 Per Day Avg

5.19 2.62 0.07 0.28 1.24 2.81 4.40 52.18 10.33 61.20

1-1-13 to 28-12-13

2769 1814 41 116 537 1131 1772 9757 4094 21163

2013 Per Day Avg

7.91 5.18 0.12 0.33 1.53 3.23 5.06 27.88 11.70 60.47

Difference -953 -897 -15 -18 -103 -149 -233 8506 -479 258

Diff: Per day Avg

-2.72 -2.56 -0.04 -0.05 -0.29 -0.43 -0.67 24.30 -1.37 0.74

PERIOD Extortion

HEINOUS OFFENCESDURING OPERATION

A

Killings Target Killing Bomb Blast /

Terrorism

Kid. for

Ransom

Extortion Dacoity /Robberies

Street Robberies

Mobile Phone

snatching

4 Wheelers

Theft / Snatched

2 Wheelers

Theft / Snatched

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

2404

1194

43 132

1343

1337

2165

2212

5

4902

2897

7

3752

2824

41 129

1389

1572

2399 12

160

5617

2678

2

During Operation

480 days before Operation

Killings Kid. Dacoity / Street Mobile 4 Wheelers2

Wheelers(Persons) for Robberies Robberies Phone Theft / Theft /

Ransom snatching Snatched Snatched

During Operation 5-9-13 to 28-

12-14

2404 1194 43 132 1343 1337 2165 22125 4902 28977

Avv per Day During

Operation 5.14 2.55 0.09 0.28 2.87 2.86 4.63 47.28 10.47 61.92

480 days before

Operation 3752 2824 41 129 1389 1572 2399 12160 5617 26782

Avv per Day Before

Operation8.02 6.03 0.09 0.28 2.97 3.36 5.13 25.98 12.00 57.23

Difference -1348 -1630 2 3 -46 -235 -234 9965 -715 2195

Diff: Per day -2.88 -3.48 0.00 0.01 -0.10 -0.50 -0.50 21.29 -1.53 4.69

KillingsTarget Killing

(persons)

Bomb Blast / Terrorism

Extortion

KILLING

During Operations Period From 5-9-13 to 28-12-14 2404

480 days before Operation From 13-05-12 to 4-9-13 3752

Decrease by 1348 persons in Killing incidents 296 accused involved in killings arrested 956 accused of fresh murder cases 72 Proclaimed Offenders of murder cases 343 Absconders of murder cases Interrogation led to detection 1117 murder cases

B

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000

3752

2404

Series1

TARGET KILLING

During Operations Period From 5-9-13 to 28-12-14 1194

480 days before Operation From 13-05-12 to 4-9-13 2824

There is a decreased by 1630 Persons in target killings During operation 296 accused involved in target killings are

arrested After completing investigation charge sheet against them

submitted in the court No one is granted bail by the court

C

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

2824

1194

Series1

ARREST OF MURDERERS DURING OPERATION

 Year Fresh Arrests Pos Abs TOTAL

Fresh Arrests challaned in Murder cases of the

year

YEAR CASES1990   2   2

1994     1 1

1995 1 1 3 5 1995 1

1996 1     1 1996  

1997 1     1 1997 1

1998 1   1 2 1998 1

1999   1   1 1999 1

2000     1 1 2000 1

2002 1 1 1 3 2002 3

2003   1 1 2 2003 2

2004 1 1 3 5 2004 5

2005 1 2 4 7 2005 4

2006     1 1 2006 1

2007 2 1 5 8 2007 10

2008 16 1 6 23 2008 25

2009 7 6 15 28 2009 18

2010 25 6 28 59 2010 54

2011 36 12 39 87 2011 71

2012 63 20 50 133 2012 115

2013 344 14 144 502 2013 487

2014 456 3 40 499 2014 317

TOTAL 956 72 343 1371 TOTAL 1117

D

Out of 956 murderers, 296 murderers involved in target killing cases

MONTH WISE KILLING

Monthly

Killing

Jan13

Feb13

Mar

13

Apr

13

May

13

Jun13

Jul13

Aug13

Sep13

Oct

13

Nov

13

Dec

13

Jan14

Feb14

Mar14

Apr

14

May

14

Jun14

Jul-14

Aug-14

Sept-14

Oct-143.7

Nov-143.5

Dec-143.0

276

261

318

241

252

259

246

289

153

152

164

160

197

187

169

159

164

186148152146115108

85

Per day

Average

8.99.310.3

8.08.18.67.99.35.14.95.55.26.46.75.55.35.3 6.2 4.8 4.9 4.9 3.7 3.4 3.0

E

Jan138.9

Feb139.3

Mar13

10.3

Apr136.0

May138.1

Jun138.6

Jul137.9

Aug139.3

Sep135.1

Oct134.9

Nov135.5

Dec135.2

Jan146.4

Feb146.7

Mar145.5

Apr145.3

May145.3

Jun 14 6.2

Jul 144.8

Aug 144.9

Sept-144.9

Oct-143.7

Nov-143.6

Dec-143.0

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

276

261

318

241

252

259

246 28

915

315

216

416

0 197

187

169

159

164 18

614

815

214

611

510

885

Per Day Avg

MONTH WISE KILLING 2013-2014

E

YEAR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC TOTAL

2013 276 261 318 241 252 259 246 289 153 152 164 160 2771

2014 197 187 169 159 163 186 148 152 146 115 108 85 1816

DIFF -79 -74 -149 -82 -89 -73 -98 -137 -7 -37 -56 -75 -955

JAN FEB MAR APRIL MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC0

50

100

150

200

250

300

35027

6

261

318

241

252

259

246 28

9

153

152

164

16019

7

187

169

159

164 18

6

148

152

146

115

108

85

20132014

MONTH WISE TARGET KILLINGF

Monthly target Killing

Jan-13

Feb -13

Mar -13

Apr-13

May-13

Jun-13

Jul-13

Aug-13

Sep-13

Oct-13

Nov-13

Dec-13

Jan-14

Feb-14

Mar

14Apr 14

May

14Jun 14

Jul 14

Aug-14

Sept-14

Oct-14

Nov-14

Dec-142.0

186

174

176

158

180

195

188

244

119 77 56 61 87 68 49 44 49 12

1 96 106

102 73 67 55

Per day Average 6.0 6.2 5.7 5.3 5.8 6.5 6.1 7.9 4.0 2.5 1.9 2.0 2.8 2.4 1.6 1.5 1.6 4.0 3.1 3.4 3.4 2.4 2.3 2.0

Jan136.0

Feb13 6.2

Mar13 5.7

Apr135.3

May135.8

Jun136.5

Jul136.1

Aug137.9

Sep134.0

Oct132.5

Nov131.9

Dec132.0

Jan142.8

Feb142.4

Mar141.6

Apr141.5

May141.6

Jun 144.0

Jul 143.2

Aug 143.4

Sept-143.5

Oct-142.4

Nov-142.2

Dec-142.0

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

186

174

176

158 18

0 195

188

244

119

7756 61

8768

49 44 4912

196 10

6

102

73 67 55

Per Day Avg

MONTH WISE TARGET KILLING 2013-2014

F

JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC TOTAL

2013 186 174 176 158 180 195 188 244 119 77 56 61 1814

2014 87 68 49 44 49 121 96 106 102 73 67 55 917

DIFF -99 -106-127-114-131 -74 -92 -138 -17 -4 11 -6 -897

JAN FEB MAR APRIL MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC0

50

100

150

200

250

300

186

174

176

158 18

0 195

188

244

119

77

56 61

87

68

49 44 49

121

96 106

102

73 67 55

20132014

KIDNAPPING FOR RANSOM

2011 2012 2013 2014Persons Kidnapped 99 110 79 117Cases Registered 76 108 72 90

Kidnapees Recovered/Returned 94 105 73 104

Kidnapees Killed 2 4 3 8

Kidnappers Arrested 105 79 75 81

Kidnappers Killed 10 11 26 20Cases Detected 39 46 33 41Kidnapees Outstanding 3 1 3 05

EXTORTION

PERIODFIR/

Complaints Received

EXTORTIONISTS

Fresh Arrest

POs / Abs. Killed TOTAL

During Operations Period (5 Sept-13 to 28-Dec-14) 1343 400 66 7 473

480 days Before operation(13 May-12 to 4 Sept-13) 1389 198 33 2 233

H

ROBBERIES & VEHICLES THEFT/SNATCHED

During Operation 2134 accused involved in robberies arrested

Heads

480 days During

Operation 5-9-13 to 28-12-14

480 days before

operation 04-09-13 to

13-05-12

Diff

Dacoity/Robberies 1337 1572 -235

Street Robberies 2165 2399 -234

Mobile Phone snatching 22125 12160 9965

4 Wheelers Theft/Snatched 4902 5617 -715

2 Wheelers Theft/Snatched 28977 26782 2195

I

ROBBERIES & VEHICLES THEFT/SNATCHED 2014-2013

Heads1-1-2014

to 28-12-2014

1-1-2013 to

28-12-2013Diff

Dacoity/Robberies 982 1131 -149

Street Robberies 1539 1772 -233

Mobile Phone snatching 18263 9757 8506

4 Wheelers Theft/Snatched 3615 4094 -479

2 Wheelers Theft/Snatched 21421 21163 258

I

STATUS OF ACCUSED ARRESTED IN HEINOUS CRIME DURING OPERATION

J

Heads ARRESTEDUNDER POLICE

CUSTODYBAILED

OUT IN JAIL

Murders 660 17 75 568Target Killing 296 10 0 286Explosive Act 455 1 2 452Kid. for Ransom 129 0 0 129Extortion 400 2 29 369Dacoities / Robberies 2134 15 583 1536Arms Ord. 8523 14 3327 5182Narcotics Ord. 6890 14 3850 3026

TOTAL 19487 73 7866 11548

PERFORMANCE IN ANTI TERRORISM COURTS DURING OPERATION

K

INSTITUTIONATC-I 367ATC-II 696ATC-III 477ATC-IV 158ATC-V 188ATC-VI 170ATC-VII 171ATC-VIII 170ATC-IX 174

TOTAL 2571

CONVICTIONATC-I 35ATC-II 57ATC-III 6ATC-IV 26ATC-V 45ATC-VI 0ATC-VII 0ATC-VIII 4ATC-IX 6

TOTAL 179

ALL CASES DURING OPERATION CHALLANED

Head of CrimeCases

ChallanedAccused

Challaned

Murder 515 631

Target Killing 199 255

Explosive Act 138 142

Kidnapping for Ransom 77 123

extortion 226 296

Dacoity/Robbery 890 1057

Street Crime 799 995

Arms Ordinance 8303 8040

Narcotic Ordinance 4881 5777

Other Crimes 7694 12253

TOTAL 23722 29569

L

CONVICTION OF CASES AND PERSONS FROM 5-9-2013 TODATE

M

HEADS Cases PersonsMurder 42 9Kid. For Ransom 17 19Extortion 25 10Explosive 8 1Robbery 50 23Encounter 30 14Arms 241 96Hurts 11 12Theft 13 8Vehicle theft/snatched 58 1Rioting 31 44Narcotic 557 530Gambling 96 436Other Local & Spl. Law 25 22Misc 250 376

TOTAL 1454 1601

POLICE PERFORMANCE

ARRESTS MADE IN HEINOUS OFFENCES

480 days During Operation From 05-9-2013

to 28-12-2014

480 days Before Operation

From 04-9-2013 to

13-05-2012 DIFFERENCE

Encounter Held 2319 1532 787Criminal Killed 708 156 552Murders 1371 1179 192Terrorism Act 455 126 329Kidnapping for Ransom 95 109 -14Extortion 450 233 217Dacoities / Robberies 2134 1352 782Arms Ord. 8523 7971 552Narcotics Ord. 6890 4238 2652

TOTAL 19918 15208 4710

N

ARRESTS OF

480 days During Operation

From 05-9-2013 to 28-12-2014

480 days Before Operation From 04-9-2013 to

13-05-2012 DIFFERENCE

P.Os. 583 607 -24

Absconder 7820 7078 742

Arrest made in Petty Crime 13881 10692 3189

Total 22284 18377 3907

POLICE PERFORMANCE N

RECOVERIES OF ILLICIT ARMS

AND EXPLOSIVE

480 days During

Operation From 05-9-2013

to 28-12-2014

480 days Before

Operation From 04-9-2013

to 13-05-2012

DIFFERENCE

LMG 4 3 1

K.Kove / SMG 231 147 84

Pistols/Revolvers/Mousers 10060 7600 2460

Rifles 174 192 -18

Short guns / Repeaters 162 152 10

Bomb Hand grenades 843 160 683

TOTAL 11474 8254 3220

POLICE PERFORMANCEN

MONTHPOLICE SHAHEED 2013 POLICE SHAHEED 2014

DSP Insp. SI ASI HC PC TOTAL SSP DSP Insp. SI ASI HC PC TOTAL

Jan 1 1 1 1 3 8 15 1   1 3 4 4 11 24

Feb       2 3 6 11       3   1 15 19

Mar     4 2 1 13 20     1   1 2 1 5

Apr   1 1 3 3 8 16     1 4   1 3 9

May       2 3 3 8       1   1 7 9

Jun     2 1 6 14 23       1 3 7 11 22

Jul     1 2 4 7 14       2 5 2 6 15

Aug 1   3 3 4 6 17     1 1 3 3 6 14

Sep     1 1 2 11 15       2 1 1 5 9

Oct   1 2 1 2 6 12     1 1 2   2 6

Nov     2     8 10         2 3 3 8

Dec   2 1   2 5 10            1 2  3

TOTAL 2 5 18 18 33 95 171 1 0 5 18 21 26 72 143

POLICE SHAHEEDO

POLICE STRENGTH

HEAD SANCTIONED POSTED / WORKING VACANCIES Pay Drawn

VACANCIES AS PER

PAYROLL

Addl: IGP 1 1 0 1 0DIGP 5 5 0 5 0SP / ADIGP 45 44 -1 44 1DSP/PDSP 81 85 4 76 5Inspector/PI 700 430 -270 550 150Sub-Insp./PSI 1876 2182 306 1955 -79ASI 3307 3030 -277 2997 310HC 4551 3590 -961 4104 447PC 20495 17137 -3358 19310 1185

TOTAL 31061 26504 -4557 29042 2019

P

POLICE STRENGTH

UNIT POSTED STRENGTH

% OF STRENGTH

Force deployed at P.S and H. Qtrs. & Investigation Unit to maintain Law & Order

East Zone 6277

66.56%

West Zone 5192South Zone 5186CIA 988

TOTAL 17643

Security Units

Security-I & II 5842

30.45%

CM House Security 187Governor House Security 119Court police 471Foreign Security Cell 758Muhafiz & Madadgar-15 551Anti Encroachment cell 129Private Security Co. cell 13

TOTAL 8070Miscellaneous Staff (Shaheed/Recruits) 479

 Range Office 312TOTAL POSTED STRENGTH 26504

P

POLICE STRENGTHCITY POPULATION

(IN MILLION)POLICE

STRENGTHPOLICE POPULATION

RATIO

LONDON 7.4 48661 1:152

DEHLI 16.7 57500 1:291

NEW YORK 8.2 34500 1:237

LAHORE 10.9 32600 1:337

KARACHI 22.0 26504 1:830

ACTUAL ACTIVE POLICE POPULATION RATIO IN KARACHI CITY IS

Out of 26504, 8707 are deployed for security purpose and 3102 personnelare separated for investigation of cases

Only 17797 personnel are availableto maintain Law and order and guard the lives and properties of 22 Million peoples of Karachi City

17797 personnel are being deployed in two shift of 12-12 hours

1:830One personnel available for 830

inhabitants

According to Police Rules Chapter-2 total strength of police for watch and ward should not ordinarily exceed one constable to every 450 inhabitants.

P

KIDNAPPING FOR RANSOM

PERIOD Cases Reg.

Persons Kidnap-

pedAccused Arrested

Accused Killed

Cases Det.

Persons Out-

standing

During Operations Period

(5 Sep-13 to 09 Oct-14)

108 99 95 13 35 9

400 days Before operation

(01 Aug-12 to 4 Sep-13)

116 86 45 23 20 0

G

Source: www.wikipedia.org28

S. NO.

CITYMURDER PER

100,000 POPULATION

1. CAPE TOWN 62 murders

2. NEW ORLEANS 57 murders

3. WASHINGTON D.C. 21.9 murders

4. MEXICO CITY 14 murders

5. KARACHI 10.14 murders

INTERNATIONAL CITIES MURDER RATE

S. NO.

CITY POPULATION

MURDER CASES

REGISTERED DURING 2012

MURDER CASES PER

100,000 POPULATION

1. Jhang 387418 158 40.78

2. Gujrat 738558 195 26.40

3. Okara 1887915 260 13.77

4. Karachi 22000000 2067 9.31

5. Sheikupura 3000000 310 10.33

6. Rawalpindi 3252132 277 8.52

7. Bajawalnagar 2600000 159 6.12

8. Lahore 11000000 631 5.74

9. Multan 3500000 166 4.74

10 Rahim Yar Khan 4800000 164 3.42

MURDER RATE OF PAKISTANI CITIES

29