sig eportolio-ple event 2015 zurich– 20.11presenters: nadia spang bovey – unil patrick roth –...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE
SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11.2015
![Page 2: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
THE TEACHER’S GOAL
Offering an environment where students can produce deep reflections on their learning
Teacher’s contribution: • Clear instructions • Good and intensive support • Basic metacognitive skills training • A simple tool
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
A critical factor: building on student’s maturity (or lack of…)
INITIAL EXAMPLE
2
![Page 3: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
LEARNING SITUATION
Advanced Human Computer Interaction (HCI) • Goal: advanced concepts on HCI and research process • Students activity: to realize a research in HCI (SOTA, users
testing, data analysis, etc.) • Assessment: research report, presentation, learning portfolio
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
INITIAL EXAMPLE
3
![Page 4: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
REFLEXIVE PORTFOLIO
Advanced HCI: learning portfolio • Goal: reflection on their research (process, tasks) and the skills
being developed • Learning platform: ePortfolio Mahara • Support: teacher, documents
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
INITIAL EXAMPLE
4
![Page 5: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
SAMPLE RESULT
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS 5
![Page 6: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
ANALYSIS
Problems • Shallow reflection • Difficulties to understand the ePortfolio process • Blank page syndrom • Usability problem of the learning platform
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
INITIAL EXAMPLE
6
![Page 7: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
INTERMEZZO
Teacher’s expectations are unfulfilled. WHAT TO DO NEXT ?
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Abandon altogether
Change students!
Pat teacher’s shoulder… Give students workshops
More written explanations?
Make a video
7
![Page 8: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
A WELL-KNOWN APPROACH…
Portfolios widely used for decades in some fields: - artistic practice
- nursing
- education
- …
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Typical outcomes - Showcasing and providing evidence
of skills and competences
- Showing ability to reflect upon situations as a professional
- Artist’s statement
… only to be enhanced by new technologies
8
![Page 9: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
PRODUCT AND PROCESSES
Meta-cognition - Identify strengths and
weaknesses - Self-evaluate progress
and learning - Identify reinforcement
strategies - Set priorities and goals
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Acquisitions - Identify and formulate skills
and competences
- Provide evidence
- Articulate practices to theoretical knowledge
- Make links between knowledge domains
+
9
![Page 10: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
MULTIPLE EVALUATION APPROACHES…
Evaluation needs to be aligned with the expectations. No self-imposing option:
• Teacher-student Interview (individual, small group) • Peer-review (individual, tandem, small group) • Written comments • Rubrik • Content analysis (manual, qualitative coding software) • Oral presentation
• … or any combination of them!
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
… depending on goals and possibilities
10
![Page 11: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
MULTI-DIMENSIONAL EVALUATION
Suitable for analysis of: - Performance related to task
- Deep learning evidence
- Reflexive thinking ability
- Meta-cognition and diagnostic
- Communicative competences
- Program expectations and coherence
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
PURPOSE MUST BE CLEARLY DEFINED
11
![Page 12: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
SUCCESS FACTORS…
The portfolio itself, as well as all steps in the process, can be evaluated. However, to be successful, the approach needs that:
1. … the evaluator knows what is actually expected from the student
2. … the use of an adequately designed evaluation methodology
3. … the student gets tasks calibrated to show evidence of competence
4. … the student knows the evaluation criteria and indicators of success
5. … both students and evaluators understand the required practicalities of building a portfolio (and the related software if provided)
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
… to the desired outcome
12
![Page 13: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Define a key
activity
Reflect on the activity
List of tasks
Context • Lecture • Internship • Continuing
education • Autonomy
Overview • Activities • Skills
Task analysis Activity analysis
13
![Page 14: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Define a key
activity
Reflect on the activity
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
List of tasks
Context • Lecture • Internship • Continuing
education • Autonomy
Overview • Activities • Skills
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Task analysis Activity analysis
14
![Page 15: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Reflect on the activity
Context • Lecture • Internship • Continuing
education • Autonomy
Overview • Activities • Skills
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
List of tasks
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Task analysis Activity analysis
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
List of tasks
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Describe your task and your
interest
Evaluate the competence +
evidence Reflect on the
task
Task analysis
Define a key
activity
Define a key
activity
Reflect on the activity
Activity analysis
15
![Page 16: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
DEFINE YOUR CONTEXT
16
![Page 17: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
DEFINE THE ACTIVITY
17
![Page 18: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
DEFINE THE TASK
18
![Page 19: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
DESCRIBE YOUR TASK
19
![Page 20: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
LIST THE COMPETENCES AND EVIDENCES
20
![Page 21: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
REFLECT ON THE TASK
21
![Page 22: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
REFLECT ON THE ACTIVITY
22
![Page 23: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS 23
AN INTEGRATED INTERFACE
![Page 24: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
SKILLS OVERVIEW
24
![Page 25: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
ACTIVITIES OVERVIEW
25
![Page 26: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
SELFPAD THINKING PROCESS
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
Reflect on the activity
Context • Lecture • Internship • Continuing
education • Autonomy
Overview • Activities • Skills
Describe your task and your interest
Evaluate the
competence +
evidence
Reflect on the task
List of tasks
Describe your task and your interest
Evaluate the
competence +
evidence
Reflect on the task
Describe your task and your interest
Evaluate the competence + evidence
Reflect on the task
Task analysis Activity analysis
Describe your task and your interest
Evaluate the
competence +
evidence
Reflect on the task
List of tasks
Describe your task and your interest
Evaluate the
competence +
evidence
Reflect on the task
Describe your task and your interest
Evaluate the competence + evidence
Reflect on the task
Task analysis
Define a key
activity
Define a key
activity
Reflect on the activity
Activity analysis
ePortfolio
26
![Page 27: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS 27
![Page 28: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS 28
![Page 29: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
ANY QUESTIONS ?
COMMENTS WELCOME !
29
![Page 30: SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich– 20.11Presenters: Nadia Spang Bovey – UNIL Patrick Roth – UNIGE Partner: Laurence Gagnière - UNIDISTANCE SIG ePortolio-PLE Event 2015 Zurich–](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050414/5f8a7d5c45f6462cc96112e7/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
SELFPAD - SUPPORTING THE REFLEXIVE PROCESS
30
Scenarios contributors « Autonomy » Patrick Roth, Unige Céline Restrepo Zea, Unil Laura De Santis, Unil
« Course » Gilles Merminod, Unil Nadia Spang Bovey, Unil Sandra Berney, Unige
« Internship » Laurence Gagnière, UniDistance Emmanuel Fernandes, Unil Jean-Michel Jullien , UniDistance
« Continuing education » Catherine El-Bez, Unil Sandra Berney, Unige
Contact and access
Funding Université de Lausanne