shs2015 3web izrez

28
S H S tudia istorica lovenica ^asopis za humanisti~ne in dru`boslovne {tudije Humanities and Social Studies Review 3 2015

Upload: i-resitvenet

Post on 30-Jul-2016

245 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

DESCRIPTION

http://shs.zgodovinsko-drustvo-kovacic.si/sites/default/files/SHS2015-3web_izrez.pdf

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS le

tnik

15

(201

5), {t

. 3

Stu

dia

His

tori

ca S

love

nic

a

tudiaistoricalovenica

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

^asopis za humanisti~ne in dru`boslovne {tudijeH u m a n i t i e s a n d S o c i a l S t u d i e s R e v i e w

32015

Fotografija na naslovnici /Photography on the cover:

Prof. dr. Andrej Vovko (1947-2015)

Professor Andrej Vovko, Ph. D. (1947-2015)

JANJA ŽMAVC: "Post autem auditis oratoribus Graecis...": Some Notes on Intercultural Perspective of Classical Rhetoric

MATJAŽ RAVBAR: Maistrova eskadrilja : letalci v Mariboru v letih 1918 in 1919

GREGOR PIVEC: Sanitetna služba Maistrove vojske

ALENKA KORON: Tematizacije vélike vojne pri Jušu Kozaku

JOŽICA ČEH STEGER: Stanko Majcen in vélika vojna

KATJA MIHURKO PONIŽ: Prva svetovna vojna v delih slovenskih književnic

BRANISLAVA VIČAR: Vloga vojaka v spomenikih prve svetovne vojne: ideološka reprezentacija vojne v tridimenzionalnih objektih

MATEJA MATJAŠIČ FRIŠ: Izvrševanje "poslednje volje" dr. Pavla Turnerja

URŠKA LAMPE: Od prve svetovne vojne do Konvencije o ravnanju z vojnimi ujetniki (1929)

VINKO SKITEK: Nemška poštna služba v Mežiški dolini med drugo svetovno vojno

TOMAŽ IVEŠIĆ: "Compared to Him the Prisoners are Innocent People'': The Fall of Milovan Djilas (1948–1954)

ANDREJ STOPAR: New Relations in the Crumbling Times: Emerging Slovenia's Independence in Russian Diplomatic Sources (1990–1992)

Page 2: Shs2015 3web izrez
Page 3: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za humanistične in družboslovne študijeHumanities and Social Studies Review

letnik 15 (2015), št. 3

ZRI DR. FRANCA KOVAČIČA V MARIBORU

MARIBOR 2015

Page 4: Shs2015 3web izrez

Izdajatelj / Published byZGODOVINSKO DRUŠTVO DR. FRANCA KOVAČIČA V MARIBORU/

HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF DR. FRANC KOVAČIČ IN MARIBORhttp://www.zgodovinsko-drustvo-kovacic.siZRI DR. FRANCA KOVAČIČA V MARIBORU/

ZRI DR. FRANC KOVAČIČ IN MARIBOR

Uredniški odbor / Editorial Boarddr. Ivo Banac (ZDA / USA), dr. Rajko Bratuž, dr. Neven Budak (Hrvaška / Croatia),

dr. Jožica Čeh Steger, dr. Darko Darovec, dr. Darko Friš, dr. Stane Granda, dr. Andrej Hozjan, dr. Tomaž Kladnik, dr. Mateja Matjašič Friš, dr. Aleš Maver, dr. Jože Mlinarič, dr. Jurij Perovšek,

dr. Jože Pirjevec (Italija / Italy), dr. Dragan Potočnik, dr. Tone Ravnikar, dr. Imre Szilágyi (Madžarska / Hungary), dr. Peter Štih, dr. Andrej Vovko †,

dr. Marija Wakounig (Avstrija / Austria), dr. Zinka Zorko

Odgovorni urednik / Responsible Editordr. Darko Friš

Zgodovinsko društvo dr. Franca KovačičaKoroška cesta 160, SI – 2000 Maribor, Slovenija

telefon / Phone: 00386 2 229 36 58fax / Fax: 00386 2 229 36 25

e-pošta / e-mail: [email protected]

Glavni urednik / Chief Editordr. Mateja Matjašič Friš

Članki so recenzirani. Za znanstveno vsebino prispevkov so odgovorni avtorji. Ponatis člankov je mogoč samo z dovoljenjem uredništva in navedbo vira.

The articles have been reviewed. The authors are solely responsible for the content of their articles.No part of this publication may be reproduced without the publisher's prior consent and a full

mention of the source.

Žiro račun / Bank Account: Nova KBM d.d. SI 56041730001421147Prevajanje / Translation: David Hazemali, Uroš Turnšek, Rok GorjupLektoriranje / Language-editing dr. Ines VoršičOblikovanje naslovnice / Cover Design: Knjižni studio d.o.o.Oblikovanje in računalniški prelom /Design and Computer Typesetting: Knjižni studio d.o.o.Tisk / Printed by: Itagraf d.o.o.

http: //shs.zgodovinsko-drustvo-kovacic.si

Izvlečke prispevkov v tem časopisu objavljata 'Historical – Abstracts' in 'America: History and Life'.

Časopis je uvrščen v 'Ulrich's Periodicals Directory', evropsko humanistično bazo ERIH in mednarodno bibliografsko bazo Scopus (H).

Abstracts of this review are included in 'Historical – Abstracts' and 'America: History and Life'.

This review is included in 'Ulrich's Periodicals Directory', european humanistic database ERIH and international database Scopus (H).

Studia historica Slovenica, Časopis za humanistične in družboslovne študije,je vpisan v razvid medijev, ki ga vodi Ministrstvo za kulturo RS, pod zaporedno številko 487.

Izdajo časopisa sta omogočila Agencija za raziskovalno dejavnost RS in Mestna občina Maribor.Co-financed by the Slovenian Research Agency and City of Maribor.

Studia Historica Slovenica ISNN 1580-8122 Časopis za humanistične in družboslovne študije / Humanities and Social Studies Review

Page 5: Shs2015 3web izrez
Page 6: Shs2015 3web izrez
Page 7: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenicaKa za lo / Con tents

V spomin/ In Memoriam

MATEJA MATJAŠIČ FRIŠ, DARKO FRIŠ, MARTIN GRUM: V spomin – prof. dr. Andrej Vovko (1947–2015) ......................................................479

STANE GRANDA: In Memoriam – prof. dr. Andrej Vovko (1947–2015) .......485

Član ki in raz pra ve / Pa pers and Es says

JANJA ŽMAVC: "Post autem auditis oratoribus Graecis...": Some Notes on Intercultural Perspective of Classical Rhetoric .....................................491

"Post autem auditis oratoribus graecis...": nekaj opomb k medkulturnem vidiku klasične retorike

MATJAŽ RAVBAR: Maistrova eskadrilja : letalci v Mariboru v letih 1918 in 1919 .......................................................................................511

Maister Squadron : Pilots in Maribor between 1918 and 1919

GREGOR PIVEC: Sanitetna služba Maistrove vojske .........................................533Sanitary Services of the General Maister's Army

ALENKA KORON: Tematizacije vélike vojne pri Jušu Kozaku ......................549Representations of the Great War in Juš Kozak

JOŽICA ČEH STEGER: Stanko Majcen in vélika vojna .....................................565Stanko Majcen and the Great War

KATJA MIHURKO PONIŽ: "Prva svetovna vojna v delih slovenskih književnic ..................................................................................577

The Great War in the Works of Slovenian Female Writers

BRANISLAVA VIČAR: "Vloga vojaka v spomenikih prve svetovne vojne: ideološka reprezentacija vojne v tridimenzionalnih objektih ...............595The Role of a Soldier in First World War Monuments: Ideological Representation of the War in Three-Dimensional Objects

Page 8: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

MATEJA MATJAŠIČ FRIŠ: Izvrševanje "poslednje volje" dr. Pavla Turnerja ..........................................................................................621 Enforcing the "Last Will" of Dr. Pavel Turner

URŠKA LAMPE: Od prve svetovne vojne do Konvencije o ravnanju z vojnimi ujetniki (1929) ..........................................................649 From the First World War to the Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War (1929)

VINKO SKITEK: Nemška poštna služba v Mežiški dolini med drugo svetovno vojno ............................................................................... 661 German Postal Service in the Meža Valley during the Second World War

TOMAŽ IVEŠIĆ: ''Compared to Him the Prisoners are Innocent People'': The Fall of Milovan Djilas (1948–1954) .................................................. 677

''V primerjavi z njim so zaporniki nedolžni ljudje'': padec Milovana Đilasa (1948–1954)

ANDREJ STOPAR: New Relations in the Crumbling Times: Emerging Slovenia's Independence in Russian Diplomatic Sources (1990–1992) .............................................................................................. 709 Novi odnosi v razpadajočem času: vzpostavljanje slovenske osamosvojitve v ruskih diplomatskih virih (1990–1992)

Avtorski izvlečki / Authors' Abstracts ................... 751

Uredniška navodila avtorjem / Editor's Instructions to Authors ................................ 759

Studia Historica Slovenica / letnik / year 15 (2015) ................................................ 765

Page 9: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

Page 10: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenicaAvtorski izvlečki /Author's Abstracts

Page 11: Shs2015 3web izrez
Page 12: Shs2015 3web izrez

753

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

UDK 808.5(37/38):316.722Avtor: ŽMAVC JanjaDr., izredna profesorica, višja znanstvena sodelavkaPedagoški inštitut LjubljanaGerbičeva 62, SI – 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenija

Naslov: "POST AUTEM AUDITIS ORATORIBUS GRAECIS...": NEKAJ OPOMB K MEDKULTURNEM VIDIKU KLASIČNE RETORIKE

Studia Historica Slovenica Časopis za humanistične in družboslovne študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, letnik 15 (2015), št. 3, str. 491–510, 35 cit., 3 slike

Kategorija: 1.01 Izvirni znanstveni članekJezik: angleški (izvleček angleški in slovenski, povzetek slovenski)

Ključne besede: klasična retorika, stari Grki, Rimljani, medkulturna komunikacija

Izvleček: V prispevku obravnavamo grško-rimsko (tj. klasično) retoriko z vidika medkulturne komunikacije. Izhajajoč iz pojmovanja retorike kot sredstva interakcije med starogrško in rimsko kulturo, osvetljujemo ne-katere njene teoretske in družbeno-kulturne značilnosti in jo opredeljujemo kot: a) že v antiki uveljavljeno teoretsko disciplino javnega prepričevanja in b) kot povezujoč družbeno-kulturni element, ki je kot razvi-jajoča se disciplina spodbujal in do določene mere celo ustvarjal pogoje za medkulturne stike med starimi Grki in Rimljani. Za prikaz povezave med retoriko kot disciplino in retoriko kot med- oziroma čez-kulturnim pojavom, orisujemo tako značilnosti javnega nastopanja v stari Grčiji in Rimu kakor tudi nekatere “retorične" stike med obema kulturama.

UDC 355.354(497.4Maribor)"1918/1919"94(497.4Maribor)"1918/1919"

Author: RAVBAR MatjažM.D., curatorMilitary Museum of Slovenian Armed ForcesEngelsova ulica 15, SI – 2000 Maribor, Slovenia

Title: MAISTER SQUADRON : PILOTS IN MARIBOR BETWEEN 1918 AND 1919

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 511–532, 59 notes, 4 pictures

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Key words: fights for the northern border, aviation, Maribor, Maister squadron, pilots, national aviation, 1918–1919

Abstract: The term “Maister squadron" stands for the aviation unit that, in the key moments of the years 1918 and 1919, offered air support to general Maister in Maribor and above Carinthia, Styria and Prekmurje. The unit’s establishment started in November 1918 and was operative throughout the period of fighting for the northern border. The unit never carried this title and never operated as an independent unit. The men of the Maister squadron were part of the collapsed Austro-Hungarian monarchy aviation. The number of men was constantly changing; about 60 men were a part of the unit: 1 spotter, 7 pilots, 2 machine gunners, and 52 soldiers. After the fight for the northern border had ended, and the agreement of a peaceful solution for the northern border had been reached, the reason for its existence was gone. The squadron had disbanded on Oc-tober 6, 1919, and the men, along with aviation material, were sent to Zagreb. Although it never had a unified name, the aviation unit in Maribor partook in the fighting for the northern border, as its pilots carried out 74 combat flights without casualties and with the loss of only one plane.

Page 13: Shs2015 3web izrez

754

UDC 356.3:61-051(497.4Maribor)"1918"

Author: PIVEC GregorPh.D., assistant professor, prim., director University Medical Centre MariborLjubljanska ulica 5, SI – 2000 Maribor, Slovenia

Title: SANITARY SERVICES OF THE GENERAL MAISTER'S ARMY

Časopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 533–548, 29 notes, 7 pictures

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Key words: end of First World War, military and political situation, General Rudolf Maister, sanitary service of Maister's fighters, sanitary supply of military transports, military hospitals, organization of sanitary services, battles in Carinthia Abstract: Based on accessible resources, the author discusses the formation of the Austrian army within the 3rd Army corps (Graz), i.e. units with soldiers of Slovene nationality. He also describes the broader political and military situation at the end of the First World War. The so-called Maister's Army, which initially included volunteers from the former units of the Austrian army, established its own structure-specific sanitary services. The services functioned on similar principles as all sanitary services of the then armies, partially relying on military and partially on civil healthcare institutions. Special emphasis was placed on the problem of military transport at the end of the war. Due to non-discipline of soldiers leading to numerous injuries, including the severe railway accident near Hajdina, the military transports were particularly challenging. In the end the au-thor describes in brief the sanitary supply of Maister's fighters in battles across Carinthia.

UDC 821.163.6.09Kozak J.Author: KORON AlenkaPh.D., independent humanities specialistZRC SAZU, Institute of Slovenian Literature and Literary StudiesNovi trg 2, SI – 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia

Title: REPRESENTATIONS OF THE GREAT WAR IN JUŠ KOZAK

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 549–564, 35 notes, 1 picture

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Keywords: the Great War, Austria-Hungary, autobiographical, Pavliha Chronicle

Abstract: The place and role of Juš Kozak (1892–1964) – writer, critic and editor – in Slovenian literature and culture are relatively well known. His opus also received a rounded text-critical presentation with the publica-tion of thirteen volumes of his collected works. While the autobiographical Celica, the tale of imprisonment, and the narrative-essayist collection Maske from the writer’s mature period are considered his best works, the texts, which depict the experience of the Great War, however, have not received such flattering judgments. The article deals with precisely these texts, written over the course of all three periods of Kozak’s literary cre-ation. The author is interested in the reasons for their more rigorous assessment. The author tries to shed light on their meaning and find out how they are becoming a part of Slovenian cultural memory.

Page 14: Shs2015 3web izrez

755

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

UDC 821.163.6.09Majcen S.:94(4) “1914/1918" Author: ČEH STEGER JožicaPh.D., full professorUniversity of Maribor, Faculty of Arts, Department for Slavic Languages and Literatures Koroška 160, SI – 2000 Maribor, Slovenia

Title: STANKO MAJCEN AND THE GREAT WAR

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 565–576, 22 notes, 2 pictures

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Key words: the Great War, Stanko Majcen, short stories, drama, war theme

Abstract: This paper presents Majcen’s reflection on the Great War and how it is echoed in his narrative and dramatic opus. Compared with the letter Književnik v vojski permeated with the author’s initial enthusiasm for war, which was supposed to bring moral purification of man and society, such feelings no longer exist in his lit-erary short stories, as well as in his dramatic, war themed, texts. From these works, we discern the author’s con-demnation of the war slaughter, compassion for suffering people, especially war refugees, but also for animals.

UDC 821.163.6.09:94(4)"1914/1918" Author: MIHURKO PONIŽ KatjaPh.D., Associated Professor and researcherUniversity of Nova Gorica, School of HumanitiesVipavska 13, SI – 5000 Nova Gorica, Slovenia

Title: THE GREAT WAR IN THE WORKS OF SLOVENIAN FEMALE WRITERS

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 577–594, 38 notes, 5 pictures

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Keywords: the Great War, Manica Koman, Vida Jeraj, Ilka Vašte, Marija Kmet, Zofka Kveder

Abstract: In Slovenian literature, many literary works were thematically linked to the Great War. Only a few of these works were created by female writers, despite the fact that women also experienced the horrors of the Great War. The majority wrote their works in time of war; it presented a turning point in women’s lives, as they became more active than ever. However, after the war, many women withdrew from public life into privacy; even the writers rarely included the memory of the Great War in their texts. This can be explained by the fact that their experience of war was different. As a result, the genre of war literature, as developed by male writers, was not as appealing to them. Therefore, they had to find their own perspective, which only a few had managed to achieve. The ones who did are presented in this article, namely: Manica Koman (1880–1961), Vida Jeraj (1875–1932), Zofka Kveder (1878–1926), Marija Kmet (1891–1974), and Ilka Vašte (1891–1967).

Page 15: Shs2015 3web izrez

756

UDC [930.2:81’22]:725.945Author: VIČAR BranislavaPh.D., assistant professorUniversity of Maribor, Faculty of Arts, Department for Slavic Languages and Literatures Koroška 160, SI – 2000 Maribor, Slovenia

Title: THE ROLE OF A SOLDIER IN FIRST WORLD WAR MONUMENTS: IDEOLOGICAL REPRESENTATION OF THE WAR IN THREE-DIMENSIONAL OBJECTS

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 595–620, 71 notes, 8 pictures

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Key words: three-dimensional social semiotics, multimodal analysis, art and memory, representation of war, war monuments, First World War, imperialism

Abstract: The paper brings a semiotic and multimodal analysis of the seven figural monuments of the First World War, which were placed on Slovenian soil in 1920s and 1930s. The analysis shows that visual and mate-rial semiotic choices contribute to the re-contextualization of the war: the reasons for the colonial war are being substituted by the idea of national homogenization; collective national identification is based on the construct of the victim. Victim discourse is a characteristic of the soldiers’ form as well as commemorative narrative. Explicit pacifist undertone is the expression of a specific response to the social and political realities associated with the consequences of war for the majority of the Slovenian population. Unquestionable status of a soldier in the service of the Austro-Hungarian imperialism, which has constituted the foundation of the struggle between the capitalist great powers for global domination, integrates the memory of the First World War in the horizon of capitalist imperialism.

UDC 929Turner P.:347.67Author: MATJAŠIČ FRIŠ MatejaPh. D., research assistantUKC Maribor, Medical research departmentLjubljanska 5, SI – 2000 Maribor, Slovenia

Title: ENFORCING THE "LAST WILL" OF DR. PAVEL TURNER

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 621–648, 83 notes, 1 picture

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Keywords: Pavel Turner (1842–1924), last testament, legacy, Franc Firbas, Turner Institution, University of Lju-bljana

Abstract: On September 25, 1924, Pavel Turner died in his home in Krčevina near Maribor. Turner was not only a Doctor of Laws and an expert on global economies, but also a great educator, writer, passionate encourager of Slovenian national development, great cosmopolitan and a well-known philanthropist and patron. In his last testament, which he wrote only a month before his death, he left the majority of his assets to an institution (foundation) dedicated to scholarships, or as he himself had written: "to the improvement of professional and worldly education of accomplished Slovenian jurists and philosophers". Basing on archival sources, the author presents the course and the complications of the enforcement of his "last will".

Page 16: Shs2015 3web izrez

757

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

UDC 94(4)"1914/1918":341.341 341.33"1929":341.328Author: LAMPE UrškaB.D. in history, young researcherInstitute of Nova revija for HumanitiesGospodinjska ulica 8, SI − 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia

Title: FROM THE FIRST WORLD WAR TO THE CONVENTION RELATIVE TO THE TREATMENT OF PRISONERS OF WAR (1929)

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 649–660, 37 notes, 1 picture

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Keywords: First World War, prisoners of war, international humanitarian law and the Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War (1929), the International Committee of the Red Cross

Abstract: There are few legal and historical debates on the impact of the First World War on the development of international humanitarian law regarding the protection of prisoners of war. This paper offers a brief analy-sis of the problems of war captivity during the First World War, with emphasis on how the war influenced the development of the legal protection of prisoners of war. It also provides an emphasis on how the experience of war is reflected in individual articles of the Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War from 1929. The author argues that the Convention can be seen as a direct legacy of the First World War.

UDC 94(497.413)"1941/1945":656.254.5Author: SKITEK VinkoB.A. in historyVrhe 28a, SI – 2380 Slovenj Gradec, Slovenia

Title: GERMAN POSTAL SERVICE IN THE MEŽA VALLEY DURING THE SECOND WORLD WAR

Studia Historica SlovenicaČasopis za družboslovne in humanistične študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, 15 (2015), No. 3, pp. 661–676, 37 notes, 4 pictures

Category: 1.01 Original scientific paperLanguage: Original in Slovene (Abstract in Slovene and English, Summary in English)

Keywords: German occupation, postal service, Slovenia 1941–1945, the Meža valley, telegraph service

Abstract: In the paper, the author discusses the problem of the German postal service on the territory occupied by the Germans during the Second World War with a special emphasis on the Meža valley. He uses the pre-existing work in the field as well as archival documents form the German state archives as his primary source. The postal service was, second only to transportation, a system of primary importance for the Nazi Germany and had a joint ministry with the transportation sector. In his discussion, the author also touches the subject of the seizing the postal and telegraph offices by the Germans in the occupied Yugoslav territory. He explains the organization of the German postal and telegraph service in the occupied territory and their services. A part of the paper is also dedicated to the problem of postal employees during the Second World War.

Page 17: Shs2015 3web izrez

UDK 94(497.1)"1948/1954":929Djilas M.Avtor: IVEŠIĆ TomažMagistrski študent primerjalne zgodovine Central European UniversityNádor ut. 9, H – 1051 Budimpešta, Madžarska

Naslov: "V PRIMERJAVI Z NJIM SO ZAPORNIKI NEDOLŽNI LJUDJE’!: PADEC MILOVANA ĐILASA (1948–1954)

Studia Historica Slovenica Časopis za humanistične in družboslovne študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, letnik 15 (2015), št. 3, str. 677–708, 140 cit., 3 slike

Kategorija: 1.01 Izvirni znanstveni članekJezik: angleški (izvleček angleški in slovenski, povzetek slovenski)

Ključne besede: Milovan Đjilas, Edvard Kardelj, Josip Broz Tito, Aleksandar Ranković, Zveza komunistov Jugo-slavije, demokratizacija

Izvleček: Avtor v članku razpravlja o vzrokih, ki so pripeljali k preoblikovanja Milovana Đilasa od enega ključ-nih partijskih ideologov do prvega in najpomembnejšega jugoslovanskega disidenta. Đilasove dejavnosti od 1948 do 1953 kažejo, da je do temeljnega razkoraka prišlo zaradi njegovega resničnega in nepopravljivega preloma s Sovjetsko zvezo. Tega preloma ni ublažila, pač pa ga je samo še okrepila Stalinova smrt. Prikazani so tudi odnosi med najpomembnejšimi člani Zveze komunistov Jugoslavije (ZKJ), njihovi osebni razlogi za Đila-sov padec, ideološka razhajanja in odstopanja od pisanih in nepisanih pravil. Đilasova zgodba, ki je analizirana v prispevku, kaže da je ZKJ v svojem bistvu in modusu operandi še vedno ostala stalinistična stranka, kljub številnim dobro zvenečim frazam.

UDK 94(497.4)"1990/1992" 327(470+571:497.1)"1990/1992"Avtor: STOPAR AndrejDipl. zgodovinar in prof. primerjalne književnosti, vodja uredništvaRTV Slovenija Tavčarjeva 17, SI – 1550 Ljubljana, Slovenija

Naslov: NOVI ODNOSI V RAZPADAJOČEM ČASU: VZPOSTAVLJANJE SLOVENSKE OSAMOSVOJITVE V RUSKIH DIPLOMATSKIH VIRIH (1990–1992)

Studia Historica Slovenica Časopis za humanistične in družboslovne študije / Humanities and Social Studies ReviewMaribor, letnik 15 (2015), št. 3, str. 709–750, 104 cit., 5 slik

Kategorija: 1.01 Izvirni znanstveni članekJezik: angleški (izvleček angleški in slovenski, povzetek slovenski)

Ključne besede: Sovjetska zveza, Jugoslavija, Slovenija, diplomatski odnosi, razpad socialističnih federacij

Izvleček: Članek tematizira pogled Sovjetske zveze oz. njene naslednice Ruske federacije na razpad SFR Ju-goslavije in v tem kontekstu osamosvajanje Slovenije. Z analizo diplomatskega gradiva sovjetskega velepo-slaništva v Beogradu in generalnega konzulata v Zagrebu oriše, kako so diplomati spremljali dezintegracijske procese v SFRJ, in ga dopolnjuje z uradnimi izjavami in komentarji akademskih krogov. Poglavitna spoznanja so: sovjetska zunanja politika je dosledno podpirala celovitost SFRJ in je nasprotovala osamosvajanju republik. Priznanje novih držav leta 1992 je bilo posledica kratkega obdobja prozahodnega koncepta ruske zunanje politike in notranjepolitičnega merjenja moči med predsednikom Borisom Jelcinom in opozicijo, sestavljeno iz komunističnih in nacionalističnih sil.

Page 18: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

Uredniška navodila avtorjem /Editor's Instructions to Authors

Page 19: Shs2015 3web izrez
Page 20: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

Uredniška navodila avtorjem1. Stu dia hi sto ri ca Slo ve ni ca (SHS) je znans tve na pe rio dič na pub li-

ka ci ja, ki jo iz da ja Zgo do vin sko društvo dr. Fran ca Ko va či ča, Ko roš ka ce sta 160, Ma ri bor. Re vi ja ob jav lja član ke s po droč ja zgo do vi ne in os ta-lih hu ma ni stič nih in druž bo slov nih ved, ki me ji jo na zgo do vin sko zna-nost.

2. Re vi ja Stu dia hi sto ri ca Slo ve ni ca iz ha ja v treh šte vil kah let no. V dveh šte vil kah ob jav lja pris pev ke v slo ven skem je zi ku – s pov zet kom (sum-mary) v an gleš kem, nemš kem, ita li jan skem, fran co skem ali ru skem je zi ku in iz vleč kom (ab stract) v an gleš kem je zi ku. Ena šte vil ka je tu je-je zič na in je na me nje na ob ja vam pris pev kov do ma čih in tu jih av tor jev v enem od sve tov nih je zi kov – s pov zet kom (sum mary) v slo ven skem je zi ku in iz vleč kom (ab stract) v slo ven skem je zi ku.

3. Pris pe vek, od dan ali po slan ured niš tvu, lah ko ob se ga do 30 eno-stran sko tip ka nih stra ni s po 30 vr sti ca mi na stran (52.750 zna-kov). Pris pe vek mora biti od dan na di ske ti (pra vi lo ma z ure je val ni kom Word for Win dows) in v iz ti ska ni ob li ki. Sli kov ni ma te rial v ob li ki la ser ske ko pi je ali v elek tron ski ob li ki (PDF ali TIF for mat) mora biti oprem ljen s pod na pi som in na ved bo vira.

4. Av tor mora na ve sti na sled nje po dat ke: ime in prii mek, aka dem ski na slov, de lov no me sto, us ta no vo za po sli tve, njen na slov in mo re bit ni na slov elek tron ske po šte (e-mail).

5. Od da ni pris pe vek mora biti oprem ljen: s pov zet kom (30-45 vr stic), iz vleč kom (6-10 vr stic) in ključ ni mi be se da mi.

Iz vle ček mora biti ra zum ljiv sam po sebi brez bra nja ce lot ne ga be se di-la član ka. Pri pi sa nju se upo rab lja jo celi stav ki, izo gi ba ti se je tre ba slab-še zna nim kra ti cam in okraj ša vam. Iz vle ček mora vse bo va ti av tor jev pri mar ni na men ozi ro ma do seg član ka, raz log, za kaj je bil na pi san, ter opis teh ni ke ra zi sko val ne ga pri sto pa (os nov na me to do loš ka na če la).

Ključ ne be se de mo ra jo odra ža ti vse bi no pris pev ka in biti pri mer ne za kla si fi ka ci jo (UDK).

Pov ze tek mora pred sta vi ti na men pris pev ka, glav ne zna čil no sti in me to do lo gi jo ra zi sko val ne ga dela ter naj po mem bnej še re zul ta te in skle pe.

6. Be se di lo pris pev ka mora biti pre gled no in ra zum lji vo struk tu ri ra-no (na slo vi po gla vij, pod po gla vij), tako da je mo go če raz bra ti na men, me to do dela, re zul ta te in skle pe.

Page 21: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

7. Opom be mo ra jo biti pi sa ne enot no kot sprot ne opom be pod čr to. So vse bin ske (av tor jev ko men tar) in bib lio graf ske (na ved ba vira, upo-rab lje ne – ci ti ra ne li te ra tu re).

Bib lio graf ska opom ba mora ob prvi na ved bi vse bo va ti ce lo ten na slov oz. na ha ja liš če: ime in prii mek av tor ja, na slov dela (ko gre za ob ja vo v re vi ji ali zbor ni ku na slov le-tega), kraj in leto izi da, stra ni (pri mer – mo no gra fi ja: Jo že Mli na rič, Stu de niš ki do mi ni kan ski sa mo-stan : ok. 1245–1782 (Ce lje, 2005), str. …; pri mer – re vi ja: Dar ko Friš, "Ba no vin ska kon fe ren ca Ju go slo van ske na cio nal ne stran ke leta 1937 v Ljub lja ni", Zgo do vin ski ča so pis 59, št. 1–2 (2005): str. …; pri mer – ča snik: (av tor), "Vo li tve v ma ri bor ski mest ni za stop", Slo ven ski gos po dar, 27. no vem ber 1873, št. 48, str. …; pri mer – zbornik: Va si lij Me lik, "Vpra ša nje re gij v na ši pre te klo sti", v: Re gio nal ni vi di ki slo ven ske zgo do vi ne : zbor-nik re fe ra tov XXXI. zbo ro va nja slo ven skih zgo do vi nar jev, ur. Peter [tih in Bojan Bal ko vec (Ljub lja na, 2004), str. …), nato pa se upo rab lja smi sel-na okraj ša va (da lje: Mli na rič, Stu de niš ki do mi ni kan ski sa mo stan, str. …).

Pri na va ja nju ar hiv skih vi rov je tre ba na ve sti: ar hiv (ob prvi na ved bi ce lot no ime, v pri me ru, da ga upo rab lja mo več krat, je tre ba na ve sti okraj ša vo v ok le pa ju), ime fon da ali zbir ke (sig na tu ro, če jo ima), šte vil-ko fas ci kla (škat le) in ar hiv ske eno te ter na slov na va ja ne ga do ku men ta (pri mer: Po kra jin ski ar hiv Ma ri bor (PAM), fond Pa vel Tur ner, škat la 7, pi smo Da vo ri na Tr ste nja ka Pa vlu Tur ner ju iz Sta re ga Trga, 7. ju ni ja 1889.)

8. Pris pev ki so re cen zi ra ni; re cen zi je so ano nim ne. Na os no vi po zi tiv ne-ga mne nja re cen zen tov je čla nek uvrš čen v ob ja vo.

9. Za znans tve no vse bi no pris pev ka in toč nost po dat kov od go var ja av tor.

10. Ured niš tvo pre je te pris pev ke lek to ri ra, av tor lek tu ro pre gle da in jo av to ri zi ra. Ured niš tvo po sre du je av tor ju prvo ko rek tu ro pris pev ka, ki jo mora vr ni ti ured niš tvo v roku treh dni; šir je nje ob se ga be se di la ob ko rek tu rah ni do vo lje no. Pri ko rek tu rah je tre ba upo rab lja ti ko rek tur na zna me nja, na ve de na v Slo ven ski pra vo pis (1962), Slo ven ski pra vo pis 1. Pra vi la (1990). Dru go ko rek tu ro opra vi ured niš tvo.

11. Do dat na po ja sni la lah ko av tor ji do bi jo na ured niš tvu.

Ured niš tvo SHS

Page 22: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

Editor's Instructions to Authors1. Stu dia hi sto ri ca Slo ve ni ca (SHS) is a pe rio di cal scien ti fic pub li ca tion

pub lis hed by the Hi sto ri cal as so cia tion of Franc Ko va čič Ph D, Ko roš-ka ce sta 160, Ma ri bor. The pub li ca tion pub lis hes hi sto ri cal ar tic les and ot her hu ma ni stic and so cio lo gi cal ar tic les that ad join hi sto ri cal scien ce.

2. Stu dia hi sto ri ca Slo ve ni ca is is sued in three vo lu mes a year. The first two vo lu mes pub lish ar tic les in Slo ve ne lan gua ge – with sum ma ries in En glish, Ger man, Ita lian, French or Rus sian lan gua ge and ab stracts in En glish. The third vo lu me is a fo reign lan gua ge vo lu me, which is in ten ded for pub lis hing ar tic les writ ten by lo cal and fo reign aut hors in one of the world lan gua ges – with sum ma ries and ab stracts in Slo ve ne lan gua ge.

3. An ar tic le, de li ve red or sent to the edi to rial board, can com pri se of at most 30 one-si ded typed pa ges with 30 li nes per page (52,750 print signs). It has to be de li ve red on a com pu ter di sket te (edi ted in Word for Win dows) and in a prin ted form. Ima ge ma te rial in the form of a la ser print or in elec tron form (PDF or TIF for mat) must be equip-ped with sub tit les and the sour ce quo ta tion.

4. The aut hor must sub mit fol lo wing data: name and sur na me, aca de mic tit le, oc cu pa tion, in sti tu tion of oc cu pa tion, its ad dress and e-mail.

5. De li ve red ar tic le must be equip ped with: a sum mary (30-45 li nes), an ab stract (6-10 li nes) and key words.

Sum mary must be un der stan dab le by it self, wit hout rea ding the ar tic-le as a who le. In wri ting who le sen ten ces must be used, less known ab bre via tions and shor te nings should be avoi ded. Sum mary must con-tain the aut hor's pri mary goal and the pur po se of the ar tic le, the rea son why it was writ ten and the des crip tion of re search tech ni ques (pri mary met ho do lo gi cal prin ci ples).

Key words must ref lect the con tent of the ar tic le and must be ade qua-te to clas si fi ca tion (UDK).

The ab stract must pre sent the pur po se of the ar tic le, its main cha-rac te ri stics and the met ho do logy of re search work as well as the most sig ni fi cant re sults and conc lu sions.

Page 23: Shs2015 3web izrez

6. The text of the ar tic le must be clear and in tel li gibly struc tu red (chap-ter tit les, sub-chap ters) for the pur po se of clear re cog ni tion of ar tic le's aim, work met hods, re sults and conc lu sions.

7. No tes must be uni quely for med as foot no tes, which can be con tex tual (aut hor's com ment) and bib lio grap hi cal (sour ce quo ta tion, quo ted li te-ra tu re).

On first quo ta tion, a bib lio grap hi cal foot no te must con tain an en ti-re tit le or lo ca tion: aut hor's name and sur na me, tit le (re view or mis cel-lany tit le when pub lis hed in it), pla ce and date of is sue, pa ges (exam ple – mo no graph: Jo že Mli na rič, Stu de niš ki do mi ni kan ski sa mo stan: ok. 1245–1782 (Ce lje, 2005), p…; exam ple – re view: Dar ko Friš, "Ba no-vin ska kon fe ren ca Ju go slo van ske na cio nal ne stran ke leta 1937 v Ljub-lja ni", Zgo do vin ski ča so pis 59, No. 1–2 (2005): p. …; exam ple – pa per: (aut hor), "Vo li tve v ma ri bor ski mest ni za stop", Slo ven ski gos po dar, 27. no vem ber 1873, No. 48, p. …; pri mer – mis cel lany: Va si lij Me lik, "Vpra-ša nje re gij v na ši pre te klo sti", in: Re gio nal ni vi di ki slo ven ske zgo do vi ne: zbor nik re fe ra tov XXXI. zbo ro va nja slo ven skih zgo do vi nar jev, ed. Peter [tih and Bojan Bal ko vec (Ljub lja na, 2004), p. …). On fol lo wing quo ta-tions lo gi cal shor te nings are used (Mli na rič, Stu de niš ki do mi ni kan ski sa mo stan, p. …).

Whi le quo ting arc hi val sour ces, the arc hi ve must be sta ted: arc hi ve (who le name on first quo ta tion, on fol lo wing quo ta tions use a shor te-ning in brac kets), name of fond or col lec tion (sig na tu re, if gi ven), num-ber of fas cic le (box) and arc hi val unit, ad dress of quo ted do cu ment (exam ple: Po kra jin ski ar hiv Ma ri bor (PAM), fond Pa vel Tur ner, box 7, let ter Da vo ri na Tr ste nja ka to Pa vel Tur ner from Sta ri Trg, 7. June 1889.)

8. Ar tic les are re vie wed; re views are anony mous. An ar tic le is pla ced for pub lis hing on the ba sis of re vie wer's po si ti ve view.

9. Aut hor is res pon sib le for ar tic le's scien ti fic con tent and ac cu racy of data.

10. The edi to rial board ar ran ges the lec tu res hip, which is re vie wed and aut ho ri zed by the aut hor. Edi to rial board sends the first cor rec tion to the aut hor, who has to re turn it in three days; en lar ge ment of text whi le cor rec ting is not per mit ted. Whi le cor rec ting cor rec ti ve signs, as sta ted in the ort ho graphy, must be used. The edi to rial board per forms the se cond cor rec tion.

11. Ad di tio nal ex pla na tions are avai lab le at the edi to rial board.

Ed to rial board of SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

SHS

Page 24: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenicaStudia Historica Slovenica, letnik 15 (2015)

Ka za lo / Con tents

V spomin/ In Memoriam

MATEJA MATJAŠIČ FRIŠ, DARKO FRIŠ, MARTIN GRUM: V spomin – prof. dr. Andrej Vovko (1947–2015) ......................................................479

STANE GRANDA: In Memoriam – prof. dr. Andrej Vovko (1947–2015) .......479

Član ki in raz pra ve / Pa pers and Es says

MATJAŽ KLEMENČIČ: Slovene National Homes in the U.S.A. ........................... 29 Slovenski narodni domovi v ZDA

MARUŠA VERBIČ KOPRIVŠEK: History of Slovenian Home in Denver, Colorado – Political Diversity as an Exception .......................................... 55

Zgodovina Slovenskega doma v Denverju, Kolorado – politična raznolikost kot izjema

ADAM WALASZEK: Polish National Alliance in America in the Years 1895–1896 and the Foundation of the PNA Home in Chicago ..............71

Poljska narodna zveza v Ameriki v letih 1895–1896 in izgradnja doma PNA v Chicagu

JERNEJ ZUPANČIČ: Spatial Structure of Slovene Ethnic Settlements in the USA. The Role and Sense of Spatiality among Diaspora Members .....87

Prostorska struktura slovenskih etničnih naselbin v ZDA. Vloga in pomen prostorskosti med člani slovenske diaspore

Page 25: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

BOGDAN KOLAR: Slovenian Members of Religious Orders and Communities in the United States as a Link between the Catholic Community in Slovenia and in the United States .....................105 Slovenski člani redovnih skupnosti v Združenih državah kot vez med katoliško skupnostjo v Sloveniji in v Združenih državah

IRENA MARKOVIĆ: Baraga's and Pirc's Missionary Letters as a Source for Knowledge of the United States of America and Indians in Slovenia ....127Baragova in Pirčeva misijonska pisma kot vir za poznavanje Združenih držav Amerike in Indijancev na slovenskem etničnem ozemlju

MARTIN ŠÁMAL: Correspondence of Vojta Náprstek from Milwaukee (1848–1858) ................................................................................................149 Korespondenca Vojte Náprsteka iz Milwaukeeja (1848–1858)

MIHA ZOBEC: Familial Networks of Exchange, Support and Solidarity as Expressed through Personal Correspondence .................................... 169

Družinska mreža izmenjave, podpore in solidarnosti, kot se je izražala v osebni korespondenci

MIRJAM MILHARČIČ HLADNIK: Children as Correspondents in the Epistolary Practices of Migrant Families ....................................... 185

Otroci kot korespondenti v epistolarnih praksah migrantskih družin

ALEKSEJ KALC: "In This Way We Can Feel Closer": Audio Letters between Australia and Trieste/Trst .......................................................... 201

"Na ta način se počutimo bliže": zvočna pisma med Avstralijo in Trstom

REBEKA MESARIĆ ŽABČIĆ: Image of Croatia through the Eyes of Croatian Immigrants in USA ................................................................. 221 Podoba Hrvaške skozi videnje hrvaških priseljencev v ZDA

GREGOR ANTOLIČIČ: Bog Ohrani, Bog obvari Nam Cesarja, Avstrijo! Izbruh prve svetovne vojne v habsburški monarhiji ................................ 259

Gott erhalte, Gott beschütze unsern Kaiser, unser Land! Der Ausbruch des Ersten Weltkriges in der Habsburger Monarchie

JURIJ PEROVŠEK: Slovenci in habsburški vladar v vojnih letih 1914–1918 ...................................................................................................281

Slovenes and the Habsburg Ruler in the War Years 1914–1918

Page 26: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

GREGOR JENUŠ: Slovenci in velika vojna (1914–1918). Slovenska razdvojenost med zvestobo cesarju in željo po narodni avtonomiji .....301

Slovenes and the Great War (1914–1918). Slovenian Division between Loyalty to the Emperor and a Wish for National Autonomy

TAMARA GRIESSER-PEČAR: Mirovna pobuda cesarja Karla I: Misija Sixtus ...321Die Friedensinitiative Kaiser Karls I.: Die Mission Sixtus

BOŽO REPE: "Osvobajate nas, hkrati pa nas režete na koščke". Odnos velikih sil do Slovencev med prvo svetovno vojno in ob njenem koncu ....................................................................................337 "You are freeing us, but at the same time cutting us into pieces." The Attitude of Major Powers towards Slovenes during the Great War and at its End

MARKO ŠTEPEC: "Kot teleta smo bili": izkušnja in spomin na Galicijo ........357"We were like Calves": the Experience and Memory of Galicia

BLAŽ TORKAR: Odmevi dardanelske krize v slovenskem časopisju ...............377 The Response of Slovenian Newspapers to the Dardanelles Crisis

SANDI VOLK: Prva svetovna vojna v Trstu v poročanju dnevnika Edinost skozi prizmo tržaškega narodnega doma ................................. 393

Reports on the Great War in the Trieste Daily Newspaper Edinost from the Trieste National Hall Perspective

PIERO PURINI: Demografske in etnične spremembe Trsta in Primorske v prvi svetovni vojni ................................................................. 421

Demographic and Ethnic Changes of Trieste and the Coastal Region (Primoska) in the First World War

DARJA KEREC: Odzivi na vstop Italije v vojno v prekmurskem katoliškem tisku (s posebnim ozirom na Kleklov Marijin list in Koledar) ............... 441

Reactions to the Entry of Italy into the War in the Catholic Press of Prekmurje (especially Klekl’s Marijin list and Koledar)

JANJA ŽMAVC: "Post autem auditis oratoribus Graecis...": Some Notes on Intercultural Perspective of Classical Rhetoric ..........................................491 "Post autem auditis oratoribus graecis...": nekaj opomb k medkulturnem vidiku klasične retorike

Page 27: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

MATJAŽ RAVBAR: Maistrova eskadrilja : letalci v Mariboru v letih 1918 in 1919 .......................................................................................511

Maister Squadron : Pilots in Maribor between 1918 and 1919

GREGOR PIVEC: Sanitetna služba Maistrove vojske .........................................533Sanitary Services of the General Maister's Army

ALENKA KORON: Tematizacije vélike vojne pri Jušu Kozaku ......................549Representations of the Great War in Juš Kozak

JOŽICA ČEH STEGER: Stanko Majcen in vélika vojna .....................................565Stanko Majcen and the Great War

KATJA MIHURKO PONIŽ: "Prva svetovna vojna v delih slovenskih književnic ..................................................................................577

The Great War in the Works of Slovenian Female Writers

BRANISLAVA VIČAR: "Vloga vojaka v spomenikih prve svetovne vojne: ideološka reprezentacija vojne v tridimenzionalnih objektih ...............595The Role of a Soldier in First World War Monuments: Ideological Representation of the War in Three-Dimensional Objects

MATEJA MATJAŠIČ FRIŠ: Izvrševanje "poslednje volje" dr. Pavla Turnerja ..........................................................................................621 Enforcing the "Last Will" of Dr. Pavel Turner

URŠKA LAMPE: Od prve svetovne vojne do Konvencije o ravnanju z vojnimi ujetniki (1929) ..........................................................649 From the First World War to the Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War (1929)

VINKO SKITEK: Nemška poštna služba v Mežiški dolini med drugo svetovno vojno ............................................................................... 661 German Postal Service in the Meža Valley during the Second World War

TOMAŽ IVEŠIĆ: ''Compared to Him the Prisoners are Innocent People'': The Fall of Milovan Djilas (1948–1954) .................................................. 677

''V primerjavi z njim so zaporniki nedolžni ljudje'': padec Milovana Đilasa (1948–1954)

Page 28: Shs2015 3web izrez

SHS

tudiaistoricalovenica

ANDREJ STOPAR: New Relations in the Crumbling Times: Emerging Slovenia's Independence in Russian Diplomatic Sources

(1990–1992) .............................................................................................. 709 Novi odnosi v razpadajočem času: vzpostavljanje slovenske osamosvojitve v ruskih diplomatskih virih (1990–1992)

Avtorski izvlečki / Authors' Abstracts

Uredniška navodila avtorjem / Editor's Instructions to Authors