$shm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

20
1N*0!5eLNHg;,dHkS\N6Xt l~gXgX! mg8=&fJ -hJXl6-h79F‘JXO ,95Y $sHm@/7gs =.D=-HHg;,dN,X \FGO1N*#NNHg;,dNfGb=.D=-rjKHj"=.D =GJ$h&JcrINh&Knk3H,G-k+H$&3HrRp7?$# CKhje2kNO=.D=GJ$h&J !5eLN0QA,dG"=N= [KO5$:,.5/6XtNg-$h&JkS\Nda~_rxQ9k#^ ?" !5KD$FNkLrb!5KH%9k}!KD$FbRp9k#\F O NkLNRpG"k# \FG7&NO1N*#NNHg;*J,dKD$FN-AG"kNG" ^:1N*#NNjArRYF*/# jA 1N*#N 1N*#N HO fN-BDN1NN8gG" JiP N9YFNLb NWGG"k# JiP" O H N>}NLG"k# H$&sDNror~?9bNN3HG"k# ?@7"33GOu8g O$UN1NN !5NLHM(F$kN G"suJ1N*#NO,: rWGK}D3HKmU7F*/#3NjAN fGV1NWr9YFVL?LNWKV-9(?bN,?LN*#NG"k# 1N*#NNWGNfG" !5NbNO:@ " !5NbNO U "=7F"q^X8GKgJbNOU!;CH HFPlF$ k#^?"U!;CHN!5NGgNbN,1N*#NN!5G"k#1N* #NG9YFNU!;CHN!5,y7$h&JbNOc G"kH$ olk#\FGOp\*K3NcJ1N*#NrP]H9k# 1N*#N KP7F r Nv?X*B= H$&#CK ,?MN H1jG"k~" O N0QA, d HFPlk#

Upload: others

Post on 15-Nov-2021

13 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

1N*0!5eLNHg;,dHkS\N6Xt

l~gXgX! mg8=&fJ

-hJXl6 -h79F‘JXO

,95Y�������������� ����������� �����

�$sHm@/7gs�

=.D=-HHg;,dN,X

\FGO1N*#NNHg;,dNfGb=.D=-rj‘KHj"=.D

=GJ$h&JcrINh&Knk3H,G-k+H$&3HrRp7?$#

CKhje2kNO=.D=GJ$h&J � !5eLN0QA,dG"=N=

[KO5$:,.5/6XtNg-$h&JkS\Nda~_rxQ9k#^

?" � !5KD$FNkLrb!5KH%9k}!KD$FbRp9k#\F

O ������! #"%$��'&)(+*-,/.��10324$���06587:9 NkLNRpG"k#

\FG7&NO1N*#NNHg;*J,dKD$FN-AG"kNG"

^:1N*#NNjArRYF*/#

jA ;=<>;=<4? 1N*#N @1N*#N ?>A'0324B�C30D.E03,/CF.E$�24B�C3�HG�@JI HO KML fN-BDN1NN8gG"

NPORQ I JiPON9YFNLb I NWGG"k#

NPO�S�TUQ I JiP"OWVUT

OOH

TN>}NLG"k#

H$&sDNror~?9bNN3HG"k#

?@7"33GOu8g X O$UN1NN Y[Z !5NLHM(F$kN

G"suJ1N*#NO,: X rWGK}D3HKmU7F*/#3NjAN

fGV1NWr9YFVL?LNWKV-9(?bN,?LN*#NG"k#

1N*#NNWGNfG" \ !5NbNO:@ ?^])�E�`_a�bG�@ " Z !5NbNO

U ?>�!c�&��d@ "=7F"q^X8GKgJbNOU!;CH ?^e>,/.E�b_H@ HFPlF$

k#^?"U!;CHN!5NGgNbN,1N*#NN!5G"k#1N*

#NG9YFNU!;CHN!5,y7$h&JbNOc ?>B�f1���g@ G"kH$

olk#\FGOp\*K3NcJ1N*#NrP]H9k#

1N*#N I KP7F hiIjhFkmlonqpdr O r I Nv?X*B= ?s&��E$�24�!_���0D.t���Hu,/C30Dvd,:_�03$� w@ H$&#CK h IUh ,?MN x H1jG"k~" I O x N0QA,

d ?s_���03,/ �&�f�C3,:_a0D$� w@ HFPlk#

Z

Page 2: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

5F"3NFGgKM(?$NO!N=.D=-H$&50G"k#

jA ;=<�� <4? =.D=- @?s0^@ 1N ? � !51NH=N9YFNL+iJk1N*#N @ O=.D=

?>.!$� �A'_���f�.b_a0D"�C3�d@ G"kHjA9k#

?>030 @ sDN�!5N1N*#N I�� H I�� ,&K=.D=G"5iK I�� V I��

,� Y�Z !5G=.D=G"k~" I� k I��� I � O=.D=G"kHj

A9k#

CK=.D=J1N*#NOcG"k3H,J1KN+ailk#

3N50O * $#.b�1A'_a�!�g5 Z��:9 KhCFGiKj0=5l?bNG"k,"1M

NM(}ObCHE$Hg;H]m8<K*1k ��� eN&eLN=.!Nf

Kb+ilk ?s���8&��������!�E2W,/ F5�����9 @ #3N=.D=-H$&50O1N*#Nr

Hg;*JroG,d9k3H,G-k+I&+"H$&50G"j"3No

N50rm8FVHg;,dW ?s.E$�2 "�03 =,�_a$��'0 ,/C c��!.E$�24B%$/A�0D_�03$� B��'$�Bw�E�'_��1@ HF

sG$k#

=.D=-NraH7FOsLj"j"lDO7’iVkH$&50NH

%H$&+}"b&lDOHg;*K=.G-k � $����! u! ,/.d,/f1C ,"� 1N*#

NN5V/i9H$&+}G"k#

#%$!#=.D=- &�' 7’iSjF#<"L?LN

7’iVkH$&50O ( 03 1&w5 Z!9 Kb+ilkh&KE/OHg;H]m

8<K*$F=N-A,@8ilF-?50G"k,"=N5iK0KO) .���C+*,-,�0 N Z�./��� /NL?LNN&fNfGL?LNN-&NJ9?LN*#

N,~?9-AH7F ? Z@4-G @ >j5lF*j"3NvBrZ@7J

*7? ( ��f�&�&/�EA�A'�E��( ,/ �0 50�:9 *hS=lrxQ7FVeBj}WrZ@7?

.� f1C3C3�! F5 Z1��9 G=NEW-,-/’15lkKjj"=_GOL?LNN&

fObHhj">gx8gd1N*#NlLNHg;=$dH]m8<r@8

keGEWJD<kNlDHJCF$k#J\7$XJKD$FO (32"*$/�� ��!�g5 �:9d ��03�!&�C3�!�g5����:9 JIr2H5l?$#K

5F"3N7’iVkH$&50G"k,"B]O?LN*#Nd5’;

k#NKD$FjA9k3H,G- ?s���8&����4(32"*$��� 1�E�g5���9 @ "5iKOcGJ$#

NKD$FbjA7FD@rJailF$kNG"k, ?5(32"*$/�� ��!�a(76 ,:.���Ag598����9^@ "33GOcJ1N*#NKC=7?lgNjAGRp9k#

jA ;=<�: <4? 7’iSjF#< @�!5NcJ1N*#N I NU!;CHr ; � S ;<� S>=>="=!S ;<? H$&gKBY"F@4A � KD$F ?B;C�3�ED"D�D-�F;HGJIK�'@ V ;�G , � Y�Z !5G7’iVkKJCF$k

h&KG-kH-" I O7’iVk ?>A��1�EC3C3,/"�CD�g@ G"kH$&#

3NU!;CHNBY}r7’js0 ?sA����!C3C30D �&#@ H$&#

Page 3: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

? 1N ? U!;CH,lD @ NlgO+0*KjAr~?7F$kNG7’iV

kG"j"CK Y[Z !5N1N*#N ��X�� O7’iVkG"k#3N7’iS

jF#<NjAO!5KX7FF"*KJCF*j" Y Z !5N1N*#N

��X�� ,7’iVkG"k3H,F"NP/@KJk# @3NjAr/aF_kH"jAfNF

@KP7F ?5; � � D"D�D � ;HG IK�'@ H$&

t,,IN@KD$FbjANror~?93HK$U/G"m&#3lKe

\7FhjF"-r/49kAG!Nh&Kq-9(k3H,G-k#

jA ;=<��F<4? F"*J7’iSjF#<NjA @?s0^@ 1NO7’iVkG"kHjA9k#

?>030 @ �!5N1N*#N I � H �

!5N1N I � KP7F"b7 I � ,7’i

VkG"j"+D" I � V I � , � YmZ !5G7’iVkG"C?i"

I� k I � � I � O7’iVkG"kHjA9k#

3l,eNbHNjAHyAG"k3HOJ1KN+ailk#

3&7FF"*Kq-9(F_kH"iaKRp7?=.D=-NjA

Z�� � HsoKwF$k3HK$U/#B]"jA Z�� � K*$F I� r1NK)B

9lP=N^^7’iVkNjAKJCF7^&NG"k#9JoA"

7’iVk k�� =.D=

H$&3HKJCF$kNG"k#

5iKL?LNHNX"r_F*/H"->J ( �'f�&�&�A'A��E��(� �,/ �0 Nj}O

!Nh&JbNG"k#

j} ;=<�� <4?5( �'f�&�&��!A�A��!�a(� �,/ 10 50�:9^@L?LNN-&rJ9#N ? D^j"L?LNN4NJ0NLNJ9#N @ O7’iVkG"k#

3N@@OV7’iVkWH$&50r?LN*#NKD$FjA7F.

j)DNG"k,"33GO1N*JlgKD$F7+7’iVkH$&50

rRp7F$J$NG"L?LNb1N*JbNKBj7F*/#kI!Nh

&JX8,"k3HKJC?#

1N*L?LNN-& k� 7’iVk k� =.D= �#%$�

=.D=- &�' ������������� �������! "��#$��� ' 'l} � $����! u! ,/.d,/f1C ,"� H$&50HNX8N}b+F_h&#

� $��1�E u� �,/.d,:f�C ,"� J1N*#NH$&50O) _�,/ 1C3� ��5�����9 N1N*eLKD

$FNVeBj}WNZ@K<r/7"7’iVkH$&501M">gx

8gd1N*#NN&fKg+;J$EWJ50NlDG"k#3lOI&

$&50G"k+H$&H"1N*#N I KP7FN % eN) _�,/ �CD� �)u"& �E0DA� ��!�

Page 4: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

D % r H$&bN,jA5l"3N % r , � $/���E u� �,/.E,/f�C ,"� DG"kH-K IO % e ������������ ��� ����� �� "$UNNeG I , � $/���E u� �,/.E,/f�C ,"� G"kH-

K I O ������������ ��� ����� �� G"k"H$&bNG"k#3N50KD$FN

\7$rbO * 0D"�0 5 Zg� � Z>8/9 *hS) _�,/ �CD� ��5��/�:9 JIr2H5l?$#

33GO33GOY+$jAKO(l:" * $ .���A'_��E� Khk!N?jrRp

7?$#

?j ;=<�� <4?�* $ .���A`_a�E�d5 Z"�:9^@sDN

�!5N1N*#N I � H I�� ,&K � $����! u! ,/.d,/f1C ,"� G"j"5iK

I � V I � , � YjZ !5G � $����! u! �,:.d,/f�C3,"� G"kJi" I� k I ��� I � O � $����! u �,/.d,:f�C ,"� G"k#

3N@@O=.D=-NjAHsoKw?Ar7F$k#B]"1NO

� $����E u! .E,/f�C ,"� G"kNG"k,"3NvBH=.D=-NjA Z�� � Khj"

=.D=J1N*#NO9YF � $����E u! .E,/f�C ,"� G"k3Hr(93H,G-

k#D^j"!NX8,.j)CF$kNG"k#

=.D= k�� � $��1�E u� �,/.d,:f�C ,����3NFGO � $����! u! �,:.d,/f�C3,"� H$&-AKD$FO\7/RYJ$,"

& �!03A� 1�E�g5��/\:9 KhCF[bm8<2N@UGC’E1,?(ilF$k3H"

5iK f1 � #���EAd5 Z".:9 KhCF � $/���E u� �,/.E,/f�C ,"� -,1N*#NNv?X*B

=NH]m8<KhCFhj5lkH$&3H,(5lF$kH$&3HKD

$FO(lF*-?$#3liNkL+i"?H(P?MNN0QA,dNl

gKO[bm8<eLN0QA,dG"k3HH � $����! u! ,/.d,/f1C ,"� G"k3

H,yAG"k3HKJk#

l}"1N*L?LN,7’iVkG"k3HH\FG(9=.D=GJ

$eLN0QA,dN8_+i,+kh&K=.D=-d7’iSjF#<O

H]m8<N_KhCFOhj5lJ$-AG"k#

#%$"!<?MNH #%$ eL

Z��DZ aG1N*L?LNN-&,J91N*#NKD$F/7(l?,"3l

O1N*#NNfGOsoKBil?/i9K09kbNG"k#c(P!N

h&Jro,~?5lF$k3H,J1KN+ailk#NcG"k#L?LNN!5r

�'& Z H9kHU!;CHO9YF�!5

G"k#NIN

� Y�Z !5NLbAg&IsDNU!;CHK^^lF$k#N/"kG"k#D^j"INsDNU!;CH ; S�( KP7Fb>TrD

J0h&JU!;CHNs ; k ;�� S ; � S"= ="=ES ;*) k (r ;�+ H ;�+-,H� ,IN

Z�.0/2143 KD$Fb&LN� Y�Z !5NLr}Dh&KHlk#

8

Page 5: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

3N � DNror~?9h&J1N*#NOD<?MN ?>.!C3$�A'�Ec�B1A��Ef1c�$�2W,/ �0 ues$�C3cw@ HFPlF$k#lLK<?MN ?>B�A'�Ef�c1$�2t,: �0Des$�CDcw@ HO"eNsD\N

rorVIN� Y Z !5Lbb9 � DNU!;CHK^^lkWH7?bNN

3HG"k#

c(P ? "kJ @ ?MNN0QA,dO<?MNNcG"k#<?MNN� Y�Z !5NLGAg&I Z D@1NU!;CHK09kbN9YF,8.9

kt,#NO-& ?>" $�f� 1c=,/� �1@ HFPlk#3lO-&N"k?MNN0QA

,dNlgOAg&I-&Nt,KP~9k#D^j"D<?MNH$&NO

-&NJ$<?MNN3HG"k#

L?LNd=lK‘7?bNN-Ar4Y?$HWC?lg" ? D @ <?M

NrM!NP]H9kNOKaF+3J3HG"m&#33GP]r<?MN

K7\CF_k#

5F"=.D=J<?MNKOIsJbN,"j@kN@m&+"H$&

3HrM(F_?$NG"k,"BO=.D=-H$&NOsoK/$H]m

8<*)sr&1F$k3H,!N?j+i,+k#

?j ;=<��%<4?>���8&�� ��(32"*$��' ��E�d58��9 � ���!�E2W,/ F5�����9 @ =.D=J�!5N<?MNO

�!

5N ��� eN^?O ��� eLG"k#

33G � � eNHOv?X*B=,1NHNVKh,*~AJ1jL|r

bDbN" ��� eLHOv?X*B=,1NN-&HNVKh,*~AJ1j

L|rbDbNN3HG"k# ? ?jfG � � eNG"k+ ��� eLG"k+

O<?MN,DG"k+]+"D^j-&r}D+]+Khk# @3N?jO ��� H]m8<NpCj}G"k!N?jr’alPF"*K

J1KZ@9k3H,Phk#

?j ;=<�� <4?>���8&�� � ���E�!2t,/ 5 ���q9^@NsDN

�!5 ��� eNr=N-&eN

� Y Z !5 ��� eNG%jgo;k

H�!5 ��� eN,@ilk#N

sDN�!5 ��� eNr=N4-&G%jgo;kH

�!5 ��� eL,

@ilk#

? ?j Z���� NZ@ @+@K1NO ��� eNG"k#^?" \ !5NlgK?j,.)9kNb+@

G"k#J<"!5*hSU!;CHNtKX9k"<!rQ$k#

^:" I ,�!5N=.D=J<?MNG"1NGJ$H9k#9kH"

=.D=-NjA ? jA Z�� ��@ Khj"sDN=.D=J1N*#N I � H I �K,d5l" I7� V I � , � Y�Z !5N=.D=J1N*#NHJCF$k#

?`Zq@I � H I � ,<?MNG"k3HOJ1KN+ailk#J<Ji=.D=-K

hCFcG"k3HH/"kG"k3HO]Z5l" I Nt,#NG"k3

H+i� Y Z !5L,b9 � DNU!;CHK7+U/^lJ$3H,,+k

Page 6: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

+iG"k#7?,CF"U!;CHNtKhk"<!G I � H I � O �!5

� � eN^?O ��� eLG"k#

? ��@I � V I � NU!;CHG"k

� Y Z !5LO I�� *hS I � K07F$kNG"

I NfGb9 � DN�!5LK7+^^lF$J+C?3HrM(kH=l

>lNfGAg&I Z DN�!5LK^^lF$k3HKJk#3lO I � V

I � , I � *hS I � N-&K"k3HrU#9k# ? >CF I� H I � O ��� e

LGOJ/ ��� eNG"C?3HKJk# @ 9kH I � V I � O �!5 ��� eN

N-&"D^j� Y Z !5 ��� eLNt,#NG"j"3NvBH I � V I � ,

=.D=G"k3H+i I�� V I � O<?MNG"k3H,o+k#>CF!5

KX9k"<!rQ$k3HKhj I� V I � O � Y Z !5N ��� eN^?O ���eLG"k#

?��)@?`Zq@ H ?5��@ KhCF" I OsDN

�!5 ��� eNr-&eN

� Y Z !5 ��� eN

^?O � � eL ? D^j4-& @ G%jgo;FPhF$k3HKJkNG"

?j Z�� . KhCF�!5 ��� eN^?O � � eLG"k3HKJk#

3Nh&KU!;CHNtH!5NsDN"<!rQ$kD@O=.D=

-NjAKhCF$kNG"=.D=-KD$FD@9k~Np\*Jj!G

"kH$(k#5iK3NvB+i"!Nh&JXxJ-A,Q!5lk#

?j ;=<�� < =.D=J ��� eN^?OeLG"k I ,jA Z�� � Nh&K I � HI � K,d5l?H9k#9kH" I� H I�� OHbK ��� eNG"k#

D^j"<?MNr>j7F$kH"=.D=-KD$FND@NfGe

-Nh&K"<*KD@9klgKF9FCWGP], ��� eNG"kH$&

UCpsrxQ9k3HbG-kNG"k#

#%$��D<?MNN,X

kI"D<?MNO!Nh&J,X=$KJCF$k#

1N*L?LNN-&�

7’iVkJD<?MN�

=.D=JD<?MN�

��� eL�

eLN0QA,d�

� $����E u! �,/.E,/f�C3,�� JD<?MN

Page 7: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

3NF,XO � !5NlgKO9YFyAKJk3H,NilF$k#J

<Ji") _a�!03 �0 _av Nj} ?>�-� & ��� ��0D�E&�CD�E�g5����:9 @ KhCF � !5eLN0QA,d

O9YF � !5L?LNN-&H7FB=G-"^?"DJLN,‘j}H

& �!03A� 1�E�g5��/\:9 N � $����! u! �,:.d,/f�C3,"� -NC’E1+i � $����! u! ,/.d,/f1C ,�� J � !5

DJLOeLN_G"k3H,o+k+iG"k#

7+7" � !5JeKJkHF,XVKO=l>l.cCW,88k3H

KJk#c(P"N (J,/�� 1�!_�_�� NeL ?>�-� & ���-��03�!&�C3�!�g5����:9 @ OL?LNN-&H7FOB=5lJ

$ � !5eLG"k,"7’iVkG"k#N]"s+lN � !5[bm8<eL ?>�-� &�� � D< 5��-8/9 @ OeLGOJ$,e

LH18[bm8<2r}CF*j"CK � $����! u! ,/.d,/f1C ,"� G"kNK

eLGOJ$cHJk#N � !5JeNlg" ��� GJ$eL,8_9k3H,NilF$k ?s���8&�� ��c��J,:��c�Ad5�.:95� �J,/ � �$� 5 ��9 @ #?@7" � !5J<GO9YFNeL, ���G"k# ? 8 !5O$rh# @N7’iVkGJ/F=.D=G"kh&JD<?MNNcO^@N

ilF$J$#7+7"DGJ$cG"lP ��03�!&�C3�!� N � !5eN"� �-*f� "=,/f�2 N � !5eN" & f�c�0D N � !5eNJI,7’iVkGJ

$,=.D=G"kcHJCF$k ?s���8&�� �w*-,/.���0D2W$/��0 5 Z�ZE9 @ #\FN\*O=.D=GJ$h&J ��� eLrI&dCF=[9k+G"

k#D^j"V=.D=JD<?MNWN/i9HV ��� eLWN/i9N

.cCWN8_r(93HG"k# ? DGJ$lg"D^j � � eNG=.D

=GJ$bNKD$FO9GK * ,/.���0324$��'0 5 Z�ZE9 G � o‘Nc,Cj5lF$

k# @\FGO^: � OG � !5NeLN0QA,d ?�� !5NeLO9YF ���

G"k @ G=.D=GJ$bNN8_r(7"5iK � OGb!5NlgKb

� � eLG=.D=GJ$bN,nlk3Hr(93HKJk#

#%$��=N>NHg;,d

\ONA,G=.D=-rVHg;,dWNlD@HRY?,"7’iVkH

$&50bHg;,dN Z oG"k#3N>Kb$/DbNHg;,d,Ni

lF$k#\FHO>\X8OJ$,"=NfGbCK=.D=-*hS7’

iSjF#<HX"N"kbNKD$FJ1KRp7F*-?$#

jA ;=<>;��F<4? :@,rD=- @cJ1N*#N I ,:@,rD= ?s]��!�'_��bG c��E.!$�2WB $�A�,/"�C3�d@ G"kHO"J<N

IAi+Nror~?9~G"k#

?s0^@UI O1NG"k#

Page 8: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

?>030 @ "k:@ � KD$F" c�C r ?��%@ H C r ?��%@ ,HbK:@,rD=G"k#

?@7"

c�C r ? O @ k � TUQ I� T OOr^^J$ �

C� r ? O @ k � TUQ I� T V O k X +DT��JO Q I �

G"k# ? T�� OHO"

TH

ONLq"D^j

TH

ON:@?Ar:@H9k

1NN3H# @3N:@,rD=-H$&50O ���$g]:,/ =( ( 03CDC3�!�a,=5 Zg7:9 G3~5l?#:@

,rD=J1N*#NO7’iVkG"k3H,NilF$k#

jA ;=<>;w;w<4? ,dD=- @ 1N*#N I NU!;CH ; KP7F=NLNlD� ?5; @ rP~5;kXt�rM(F" I r � ( Q I � � ?B; @�� ( � ; � H$&

8gG,dG-kH-" I O,dD= ?>B=,/�`_a0 _a03$/ =,/"�CD�g@ G"kH$&#

7’iVkJ1N*#NO9YF,dD=G"k ?>�-� &�� � ��03�!&�C3�!�g5����:9 @ #� $����E u! �,/.E,/f�C3,�� J1N*#NO,dD=G"m&H=[5lF$k ?>�-� &�� �) _�,/ 1C3� ��5��/�:9 @ ,"^@$rhG"k#=.D=J1N*#N,,dD=G"k

+]+b^@,+CF$J$#

kS\N6XtH?s0kN6Xt

5F"\FGO Z�� 8 aGRY?h&K ��� eLG=.D=GJ$bNr=[9

kN,\*G"k,"CK � !5eLN0QA,d ?�� !5eLO9YF ���G"k @ G=.D=GJ$bNrnCF$/#=Nj!H7FO #(J � kS\r .5/ �)� !5eLNfKda~‘H$&3HrTJ&#>CF"kS

\N#(5r,k?i+NX8,,WG"k#kS\N#(5r,kNKH(

kTQLO$m$m"k,"33GO6XtH$&bNrM(k#

jA � <>;=<4? kS\N6Xt @kS\ � r �� ?LKMF7F" 4}~Nb5,KgKJk@NDtrt(

k#9YFND=JMFKD$FN=NG.Mr6Xt ?>"��'03c�&�� 03 �c1�bG�@ H7"� ?��R@ H=-9k#

y

.

Page 9: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

6XtKD$FN$/D+NJ1JvBr+F*-?$#NkS\KX7FO"+@G"k3HH6Xt, Z G"k3HOyAG"

k#3lOJ1KN+ailk#

? +@JkS\HOkPCF$J$kS\N3HG"k," � !5eNN

-& ? D^j � !5eL @ K^^lk3HNG-kkS\N3HG"kH

b@(k# @N0UkS\O<^Nh&KKg@, � DG"kMFr}CF*j"7+

b+@GOJ$NG6XtO � G"k#

y

NsDNkS\ � � H � � KP7F"kB �F��� � � N6XtO

� ? � ��� � �H@ k � ? � ��@ & � ? � �b@ Y�ZG?(ilk#?@7""kBHO!Nh&JbNN3HG"k#

� � � �

� ��� � �3NvBO6XtriaKjA7?

) .�� f1"%�!�'_ +HKhCF(5lF$

k ? ) .�� f1" �!�'_g5 � Z!9^@ #3liN3H+i!N?jOJ1KN’G-k#

7

Page 10: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

?j � <�� < $UN� A Z KP7F"6Xt,

�G"kh&JkS\,,:8_

9k#

? Z@ @ B]"� Y�Z DN0UkS\N"kBN6Xt,

�KJCF$k#

!NOG3NkS\N6XtrpK7F=.D=GJ$ � !5eLN0Q

A,drnkNG"k,"I&$&3Hr9k+H$&H" � !5eLN0Q

A,d I ,=.D=G"kH7F"=NUH:@rHCFkS\rnk3H

rM(k#=7F=NkS\N6XtNeBrkS\KHC?UNtKhCF

>A9kNG"k#9kH"b7=NeBr[(kh&J#(JkS\,da

~^lF$?i+0*K=N0QA,dO=.D=GJ$3HKJkNG"

k#

I ,=.D=G"kH9kH?j Z�� 7 GRYilF$kh&K" I � H I �K,d5lkH-K=N>TO&K=.D=J ��� eNG"j"=li,^?

sDN � � eNK,d5lFD"H$&qgKJj"G**K1NK^G,d

5lk3HKJk#

>CF I NfGUH:@rHCFnil?kS\N6Xtr>A9k?aK

O"3Nh&JF"*J,dNfGF9FCWK=lk.5$ ��� eNK^^

lkkS\NGR,INh&JbNG"k+rQ!7F$/3HKJk#3&

$C?3Hr9k?aKO3N kS\NGR � *hS=N6XtH$C?b

NrjA7F"2J1lP$1J$#,$"kS\NGRH$&bNO?s0

kH7Fh/NilF$kbNG"k#

jA � <�: <4? ?s0k @� !5eNK^^lk1cJ~G=N><,eNN-&KhCF$kbNr%

9 ?>A'B=,/ � 103 �&[,/�'.g@ H$&# � !5eN^?OeLK^^lk$/D+N_$K

roiJ$kS\*hS%9N8gr?s0k ?^_�,/ �&/C3�g@ H$&#

Zd\

Page 11: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

? aL"kS\d?s0kO?s0kN<@J0OeNNbtK^^lF$

kH7FD@9k,"33GOJ~t,,-&eK"CFbh$3HK7F$

k3HKmU7F*/#=&7Fb-&eNJ~ry/KeNNbtK\05

;FM(lPLoNlgH4/18h&KD@rJak3H,G-k# @l}"6XtOkS\K7+jA5lF$J$NG"?s0kN6XtJ

kbNr!Nh&KjA9k3HK9k#

jA � <��F<4? ?s0kN6Xt" � �1�E���! #"%$��'&)(+*-,/.��10324$���06587:9 @?s0k � r9}ANfK"%9N<@O<UK/kh&KMF9k#=7

FkS\N6XtN~H1MKKg@rt("9YFND=JMFKD$FG

.MrHC?Mr?s0kN6XtHjA7"� ?��-@ H=-9k#

y

?s0kNlgN6XtGO"4N,eLN-&eK^^lkh&J%9

O6XtKAg&I Z Ns?r9k#D^j"+@JkS\NlgH183

HKJCF$kHM(ilk#7?,CF"4N,eLN-&eKNkh&J

JD^j=l>lkPCF$:"_$Km^CF$J$h&JK?s0kN6

XtO.,NtKy7$3HKJk#

hKRY?h&J3N50rQ$?=.D=-ND@O!OGTJ&,"

33GO3N?s0kN6XtKX9k!N?jrRp7F*/#3l,!N

OND@N0KJk?jG"k#

?j � <�� <4?�������! #"%$��'&)(+*-,/.��10324$���0 5 7:9^@� !5eN I ,?s0k � r^sG$kH9k#3N I ,"k_WKhCF

sDN � !5eN I�� H I � KZj,1il"=l>l, � �-k�� V I � " � �[k��Y�� � H$& � rZj,1??s0kr^sG$kH9k#3NH-"3l

iN?s0kN6XtNVK

� ?��-@ . � ?��<��@ & � ?�� �b@H$&X80,.j)D#

Z/Z

Page 12: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

3N?jNZ@O ����'�E " $/��&)(+*-,:.b�10324$���06587:9 NfG6XtNLNjA!K

pE$F?(F"k,"33GO!K(9^KhCFJ<3N?j,.)9k

N+rb@9k3HK9k#

D^j"Zj,1il? � � H �H� N=l>lKP7FL9KKg@NtNG.

=rTJCF� ?�� ��@ H � ?�� �b@ rB=9kMFrD/j"=NsD+i^Nh&

Jj!G � NMFGKg@Nt,� ?�� ��@ & � ?�� �b@ rB=9kMFrnk3H,

G-kNG"k#B]KO � NMFO>KbM(ilkNG5iK� ?�� @ O3

&7FD/C?MFNKg@Nthjb/J/JkD=-,"kNG� ?�� @ .� ?�� ��@ & � ?��H�b@ H$&3HKJko1G"k#

� �!5eN&eLN=.D=-HkS\N6Xt

5F"3NOGO$h$h=.D=GJ$h&J � !5eLN0QA,dN8

_r(9#(9j}O!NbNG"k#

j} : <>;=<4?�������! #"%$��'&)(+*-,/.��10324$���06587:9 @� !5eN^?OeLN0QA,d I NfKUH:@rHCFkS\ � rn

k#3N � NUNtr �#?��R@ \"6Xtr� ?��R@ H9k#3NH-"b7 I

,=.D=G"lP � ? �R@ .��#? �R@G"k#>CF"b7

� ? �R@����#?��R@ G"lP I O=.D=GJ$#

Z��

Page 13: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

3Nj}+i"6XtNsoKg-$kS\r/J$UtG � !5eLN

0QA,dNfKda~‘3H,G-lP=.D=GJ$h&J0QA,dr

nlk3HKJj"CK � !5eLO ��� G"k3H,,+CF$kNG ���eLG=.D=GJ$bN,nlk3HKJko1G"k#7+7"j}Nr

or~?9h&J � !5eLN0QA,d,nlJ/FOj}r(7FbU#

,J/JCF7^&#>CFj}NZ@rRp9k0K=Nh&J0QA,d

,nlk3Hr+F*3&#

?j : <�� < $UKkS\ % H �A � ,?(il?i" % r � UGda~sG$

k � !5eL^?OeNN0QA,drnk3H,G-k#

? Z@ @3NvBO � 03.� /$���0DA��F5 Z ��9 KhCF(5lF$k,"B]ObCHE/+iN

ilF$kbNG"ki7$#

33GOkS\ % r � UGda~sG$k � !5eLN0QA,drnk

}!r^(9k#

��������� ���� ����������������� ������! �"#"

$%$�$

&'

^:"e&N^OeLNpKJk � !5eN ( Nnj}r(7F$k#3l

O^:.5$)}NrQ_EMFg-$)}NrnC?bNrM("3Ng-

$)}NN<NL+ilD:D.5$)}Nrhj|/3HKhCFjr"1

F$/#3NH-K"^K"kh&KkS\NAKj,"/h&K9k#=7

FG**KeNL+ij,41kh&K9kNG"k,"GeNlD"D^j

HsMk,0.9k>0Gdak#9kHHsMkOSL7J$NG4NO �!5eNN^^G"k#3&7FG-?.5$)}NN8gNr=l>lN)

}Nr � DNMLNK,1k3HKhCF7?J:@r3~9k3HJ/0Q

Zd�

Page 14: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

A,dK9k3H,G-k#3lGhlJ,N0.G"33G@il? � !5

eNN0QA,dr ( H>U1F*/3HK9k#

3N ( NC’*J@O^K@$~G(7?h&JUN8_G"k#8eK

(7?^NfN Z UO ( r&eNh&K8‘*J � !5eNK1jL|G\

93HrM(kH^Nh&KkPk3HKJk#D^j"kPC?%9, Z UGPhF$kH$&bNKJko1G"k#

? 3Nh&J Z UGPh?%9r}D � !5eNN0QA,dO3l+N7’

iVkGJ$3H, ��f���.H�F5 Zg\:9 KhCF(5l"5iK=.D=GbJ$3H

, *-,:.���0324$���065 Z/ZE9 KhCF(5lF$k# @5F"3N ( rQ$F � !5eLN0QA,drnkNG"k,"=N

=.!,<&N^G"k#3lO?r7F$k+H$&H" ( N0&K7

7$:@ � r3~7" ( N-&K"k0QA9YF+i � K~1F3<sr

nCF$kNG"k#D^j" ( N-&eK ���H� S �-� S ��� � r:@H9k0QA

,"C?i � � ��� � S � � S ��� � N 8 @r:@H9kMLNrC(kNG"k#3N

‘nrTJ&H � !5eL,@ilk3HOh/Nil?vBG"k#

?�( N0&K7?KU1C(il?MLNN4NO � rf4K ( N-&G"k

� !5eLK~1F3<srnC?bN� ( � � G"k+i � !5eNKJCF

*j">CF4NO ( H� ( � � H$&sDN � !5eNr4-&G%jgo

;F@ilkbNG"j"3lO � !5eLG"k# @3NH-K ( GC’*G"kHX&7? Z U+iJk%9H=N><@H

� rksG$k � Urgo;? � \NUr+F_kH"33KkS\,PhF

$k3H,Q!5lk#5iK"3NkS\NAOI&dCFh^CF$k+

rM(kH"BO ( fN%9NAGh^CF$kNG"j"5iK3lOi

aK"1?jNA=NbNKJCF$k3H,,+k#D^j"iaKQU9

kg-$)}Nr=,Kg-$bNH7F*-"jr+1k~K_7$kS\

% NANLjKjr+1F$1PG**K % H18kS\r � UG � !5eL

N0QA,dNfKda~‘3H,Phko1G"k#

3&7FkS\ % r � UGda~s@ � !5eLN0QA,d,@il?

Ji"3lr,vKY,9k3HKhCF � ? A �)@ U+iJkkS\rda~

s@bNOJ1Knlk#

eNNlgO"3N"HGkS\KX87J$U!;CHrlDhj|$

F"2lPh$#

5F"?j � � ��? H?j � � ��@ KhCFsoKg-$6XtNkS\,/J$

UtGda~^l? � !5eLN0QA,drnk3H,G-k3H,o+C

?NG"$h$hj} � �DZ NZ@rRp7?$#3lO?j � � � rQ$Fso

KJiK(93H,G-k#

? j} � �DZ NZ@ @� !5eN^?OeLN=.D=J0QA,dG"k I NU!;CHNtKh

k"<!G(9#Z@OkS\GJ/lLK?s0kNlgGZ@9k#

Z>8

Page 15: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

?`Zq@^:U!;CH, Z DN~O" I O � !5eNG"j"UO9YF3N � !5eNN-&eK"k#7?,CFUH:@rHC??s0k � N6Xt� ?��-@ O3N?s0kfN"k.,NtKy7$ ? jA � ��8 NeN3asH2

H @ #3N3H+i � NUt �#?�� @ KX7F� ?��-@ . �#?�� @ ,.j)D3HOF

WK,+k#

? ��@U!;CHNt, � JeNH-" I O=.D=-NjA Z�� � KhCFsDN=

.D=J1N*#N I � H I � K,d5lk,"3liO?j Z�� 7 KhCF>T

Hb � !5eNG"k3H,o+k#

I K^^lk?s0k � KP7F ���Jk � V I7� " � � k ��Y�� � HV/H"

3N � N � � H � � XN,dOAg&I?j � � � Nu7H18KJCF$k3H

,,+k#>CF" � ?��-@ . � ?��<��@ & � ?�� �b@G"k#l}" I7� H I � O I hjU!;CHNt,/J$NG"<!N>j

rH&3H,Ph"� ?��3��@ . �#?��<��@ S � ?�� �b@ .��#?����H@

G"k#3liH �#?�� @k �#?�� ��@ & �#?��H�b@ H$&+@JX80rQ$lP"� ?��-@ .��#?�� @

H$&k@,@ilk#

O : <�: <+� !5eL ? ^?OeN @ N0QA,dG=.D=GJ$bN,8_9

k#

? Z@ @6Xt, 8 JeNkS\r?j � � � N}!G � UGda~s@ � !5eL ? tOeN @ N0QA,drnlPh$#

U- < 3NOGOj} � �DZ +ik@r@k?aK6Xt, 8 JeNkS\rQ

$J1lPJi:"c(P0UkS\Nh&J6XtN.5$bNGOk@r

@kNK=,GJ$3HKJCF$k#7+7"BO *-,/.��10324$���03(��0D�E&�CD�E�d5 Z1�q9KhCF+@GJ$kS\, � UGda~^lF$kH=.D=GJ/JkH

$&3H,(5lF$kNG"3Nh&K � UGda~‘lgKO0UkS\

Gb=,G"k#>CFj} � �DZ Ol+e$j}Nh&K+(kNG"k,"

7+7!NOG+kh&J/$-Ar3/3H,G-kNOj} � �DZ N}G"

k#

U- < 3Nj}NZ@O=N^^?LN*,dd5’;k,dKD$FbQ$

k3H,G-k#

Z��

Page 16: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

�E4,d

5F"0OGO � !5eLN0QA,dG=.D=GJ$bN,8_9k3H

r(7?,"BOj} � � Z O!Nh&KbCH/$3Hr(93H,G-k#

O �F<>;=< IsJ+3t � r*sGb" � sE4Y,7Fb=.D=GJ$h&

J � !5eL^?OeNN0QA,d IW?�� @ rnk3H,G-k#

=N0K"E4Y,H$&50KD$FJ1JRpr7?$#

jA �F<�� < 1N*#N I KP7F" I N X J0NFLOKP~9k:@ � n

N8gr:@8gH9k1N*#N A'cF?�I @ rA�cF?>I @ k������ n�� S"=>="=!S � n�� � r:@H9k1N �)Xk O ��� D"D�D � O ? Q I�� � ��X��

HjA7"3lr I NE4Y, ?>"=,/�!� .E�E )_���03.+A'f�"%c10D] 03A'03$� w@ H$&#

3lO(K9kH!Nh&KJCF$k#

I A�cF?>I @

D^j3NE4Y,rhkH$&‘nOv?X*B=OQ(:K"F1N

r Z !5NbNOsDK" � !5NbNO � DK"D"�!5NbNO ? � &

Zq@�� DKY,9k‘nG"k#

5F"O 8��DZ NZ@O!Nh&KJk#

? O 8 �DZ NZ@ @E4Y,O Z sKD$F Z Ur � DK,d9kNG" � sE4Y,9kHO

aK Z U@C?bNO ��� UK,d5lk#>CF"6Xt, �7D"��� & Z JeG

"kh&JkS\, � UGda~^lF$k � !5eL^?OeN IW?�� @ rM

(kH"3NkS\NUtO � sNE4Y,NeK � DK��� JNG"j} � �DZ KhCF=.D=GJ$3H,(5lk#

3NE4Y,KD$FO"b7 I ,=.D=Ji A�c ?�I @ b=.D=G"

k"H$&-A,"k3HO[\+@KN+ak3H,G-k#GO" I ,

=.D=GJ$lgKE4Y,r+jV93HKhCF$D+=.D=K9

k3H,G-kNG"m&+) H$&NOK+3J?dG"k#6PH7F

O"E4Y,r9k3HKhCF I r,d9k}!Nt,}(kNG"=.

D=G"jd9/Jkh&KWolk# ? B]"E4Y,H$&NO=$rJ

ai+K9k?aKHolkj!G"k# @

Z"�

Page 17: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

7+7"c(Pv?X*B=,H<i9KJCF$?j ��� GJ$eLG

"C?j9klg"?j Z�� � +i?sE4Y,7Fb=.D=KOJj@J$

3Hb,+k#>CF"v?X*B=,=.D=JY,r}A@klgKCr

Bk,WO"k#CK<?MNNlgrM(kJiP" ��� eN^?O ��� e

LKBCF!Nh&JdjrM(k3HKJm&#

=[ �F<�: < � � eL^?O ��� eNO-BsNE4Y,NeK=.D= ? 5iK

O7’iVk @ KJk@m&#

7+7"O 8 �DZ ,3NdjNq75r(7F$F"D^j" � !5H$&

Gj5l?!5KBC?lgGb"b7=[,57$H7Fb=.D=G"

kuVK?Ije/?aK,WJE4Y,NtrjtG?(k3HOG-:"

V-BsWH7+@&3HOG-J$NG"k#

�b!5Nlg

09OH0OGO � !5NeL*hSeNNlgrM(F-?,"=liNk

Lr=N^^ 8 !5JeN � � eL*hS ��� eNN9F<HasHKV-9

(k3H,G-k#=N?aKOFLNjs/KX9k!Nh&J-AKm\

9k,W,"k# ? js/HO Z�� � ONjA Z�� Zg\ NfG?(F"k C� N3HG

"k# @?j � <>;=<4?>���8&�� � (32"*$��' ��E�d58�:95�=* ,/.H��0324$���03(���03�E&/C3�E�d5 Z���9^@=.D=J1N*#N I N$UNL

O Q I KP7FONjs/ C r ? O @ O=

.D=G"k#

Z@OsoKJ1G" I , I � H I � K,d5l?uVrM("O,IA

i+l}N_K^^lk~KO C� r ? O @4k C r�� ? O @j? / k Z $/� ��@ G"j"O,

I � H I � N>TK^^lk~KO

C r�� ? O @ � C r�� ? O @ k C r�����r�� ? O @ ?�k C r ? O @�@C r�� ? O @ V C r�� ? O @ k C r�����r�� ? O @

H$&X8,.j)DH$&3HrQ$FU!;CHNtH!5N"<!rQ

$lPh$@1G"k#

5F" � !5eNd � !5eLrbHKb!5NeNdeLrnkNKO

!NTi_CIH59Zs7gsH$&‘nrQ$k#

jA � <�� < 1N*#N I KP7F77$:@ � rU1C(FnC?1N*#

N

� � �d?�I @ k ��� � O � O Q I � ��I � ��X��

Z �

Page 18: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

r I eNTi_CI ?>B/� �a,/2403cw@ H$$" � :@ � S�� rU1C(FnC?1N

*#N �?�I @ k ��� �JO � O Q I ��� � � � O � ORQ I � � I � ��X��

r I N59Zs7gs ?>A�f1A�B �E �A'03$� w@ H$&#?@7" � �=O O � HON:@8

gN%k1NN3HG"k#

33GJ1G"k,EWJ-A,!N?jG"k#

?j � <�: <4?>���8&�� � ���E�!2t,/ 5 ���q9^@N I ,�!5 ��� eNG"lP � � �g?>I @ O � & Z !5 ��� eNG"k#N I ,

�!5 ��� eLG"lP

�?>I @ O � & Z !5 ��� eLG"k#

CK � !5J<NeNdeLO9YF ��� G"kNG" � !5J<NeN

deL+iO8aFTi_CItO59Zs7gsr+jV7F$1Pb!5

N ��� eNd ��� eLNs,@ilk3HKJk#

5F"33Gm\7?$NO � � �g?>I @ d�?>I @ K*$F77/U1C(i

lk:@ �%? ^?O� @ K*1kjs/O I =NbNKJCF$kH$&@G

"k#3N3HH?j � � Z +i!NO,(5lk#

O � <��F< $UN� A � KP7F=.D=GJ$

�!5N � � eN*hS ��� e

L,8_9k#

? Z@ @O � � � GD/C?=.D=GJ$ � !5eL^?OeNN0QA,dr I � H7"eLNlgO59Zs7gs"eNNlgOTi_CIrnk#9kH Z!5b$ I�� ,@ilk,"3N~K C r�� ? � @ k I � G"k3H+i C r�� ? �1@ O=.D=GJ/">CF?j � � Z +i I�� b=.D=GJ$#3lr

� Y � s+

jV;P=.D=GJ$�!5 ��� eN^?O ��� eL,@ilk#

0ONh&K5iK//E4Y,KX9k9F<HasH^Gb!5Nl

gK^ak?aKO!NX80r+lPh$#

A'cF?>C� r ? O @�@k C ���� r� ? O @ =?@7"

OO:@G"^?"33GNyfO1?H$&U#NyfG"k#

A'cF?>C� r ? O @'@

O O

C� r ? O @ C� ����� r� ? O @

Z".

Page 19: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

D^j"E4Y,rHk‘nHjs/rHk‘nOD9JNG"k#

O � <�� < $UN� A � H � A Z KP7F � sE4Y,7Fb=.D=GJ$

�!5N ��� eN*hS � � eL,8_9k#

? Z@ @O 8�� Z G?(? � sE4Y,7Fb=.D=GJ$h&J � !5eN^?Oe

Lr I ��? � @ H7"3lNTi_CItO59Zs7gsr I ��?�� @ H9k#9

kH � sNE4Y,KX7F

C� � � � r�� � � ? �1@k A�c � ?>C� r�� � � ? �1@'@k A�c � ?�I �g?�� @'@H$&X8,.j)DNG" I ��? � @ , � sE4Y,7Fb=.D=GJ+C

?3H+i C � � � r�� � � � ? � @ O=.D=GJ$3HKJk#7?,CF?j � � Z KhCF I �:?�� @ O=.D=GJ$#3lr

� Y � s+jV;P � sE4Y,eb

=.D=GJ$�!5 ��� eN^?O ��� eL I � ?�� @ ,@ilk#

����������� ���

������������������! !"$#&%('*),+.-0/1)32546-7%.8$469!)�40%./:%(;<%. .=>%.8@?BAC'*+.�D��8E%(;�FG-IH6)3;�+J40)3FK40%L469!)M %(�N�D2O+JH!P)�QR%(�TS0)32546U!HV)."����XW0YZ)32546UDH6)3-R%(�\[]%&FD)OH^�_[]+J469!)3'$+J46��2O-a`^`cb�"edgf��&Ya�!#!+.+J4C=)3Fh�jik"!lm�N;<)O=7dn�3o.pTqrik"Go.?BA^�3s.t&�

�usB�vw�x�yS{z%.H^�!)OH3" M %(-6)O46-O"rH^)O (UD;�+JH�Q�l|25%('*/G;<)5}�)3-V+.�DF\�RH^UD9D+J4V%.H^F!)OH3"&~aU!H6%./y�r�!�!QR%('�A� ���D+J40%.H^�N2O-O"1��dn�3o.tTqrik"1�{A^�3p&�

�u?B�vw���ZS{z%.H^�!)OH3"!f�%./e%(;<%. (��2O+.;e')O469!%�FD-O"����XW0��+.�GF � %x%.�$%.8�QR%(' � ���D+J40%.H^��2O-^b�"hdg���!��H^+TA9D+.'�"D[��:��HBz%.46-62�9!)3;Z+.�DF�Y��GYy%{��P+.-0��)3FD-O�jik"D��%.H6469�AC��%(;�;�+.�DF�dn�3o.o.�(ik"y�3t��3oBA^�3t(�Js&�

� qJ�vw�Z�yS3z%.Hk�!)OHw��[��hl�+.2^9G-O"�#�9D)3;�;�+ � ;<)*�D%(�!/GU!H6)*25%('*/G;<)5}�)3-�+.�DF7/:%(-0)O46-O�h`�"yf�H^+.�D-O�v�')OH{�D[]+J469h�e#&%r2J�<"G�G�1��dn�3o.o.p(ik"Z�3s.o.oBA^�3?.s(�r�

�u�B�vw�1�yS{z%.H^�!)OH���[��Gl7+.2�9D-O"h#�9!)3;�;N+ � ;<)w�D%(�!/GU!H6)�25%('/G;<)5}�)3-�+.�DF�/1%(-0)O46-3�G`6`�"1f�H^+.�D-O�v�')OH{�D[]+J469h�e#&%r2J�<"G�G�1��dn�3o.o(�.ik"G?.oTqx�BA�?.o(�J�&�

�upB��w�B�RH^UD . .)3-6-0)OH�� M �B[�+.�D��"x#�9D)3;�;�+ � ;<)RF!)325%('/:%(-6�<46�<%(�G-y%.8D25)3;�;N-�+.�DF�-0/G9D)OH6)3-O".[]+J469Z�#�2O+.�DFh�<"1 G��dn�3o(�&�{ik"Z�3o(�{A�sJ¡(�&�

�¢�{�*�D�Dl>�1Q�+.�D�!%(�h"e#�9!H^���D�&���D $25)3;�;�AC;����.)�F!)325%('/e%(-6�<46��%(�D-�%.8�'*+.�D�<8£%(;�FD-3�:QR%rFG��')3�D-6��%(�469!H6)O)."Dv��D�h�G[�+J469h�<"Z¤G¤&¥�dn�3o(�Jo(ik"1t.?BA^�.�3s&�

�utB����D¦��D~aF!§�+JH^FD-O"1f¨9!)�F!%(U � ;<)�-6UD-0/:)3�D-6��%(��%.8�+25)OH646+.���©9!%('*%(;<%. .=_?BAC-6/G9!)OH6)���-�ª � "�«%.46��25)3-«v�')OH{�G[]+J469Z�1#&%r2J�<": 1 7dn�3o(�J�(ik"Dv¬?.?Tq!�Dv � -040H^+.254�­*�J�*f�Ac�¬?.?&��uoB����:~V9!H6)3� � %.H6 _�®[��:��+.2^9G��'%.H^��"h��%(��AC25%(�D-040HkUD2546� � ;<)�25%('/G;�)5}&)3-�+.�DF�469!) � H^��FD .)

���DF!)5}e"!/DH6)O/DHk���&4O�Z�3o.o.o

Zd7

Page 20: $sHm@/7gs - infoshako.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp

���O¡T�*�����GU!Hk2^9h"��eU!HV .H^UD�DFD;�)O (UD�! wFD)OHa�(%(' � ���D+J40%.Hk��-62�9!)3�*40%./e%(;<%. (�<)."&v � 9h�x[�+J469h��#&)3'©���+.' � �����D�<�:�<"G��dn�3o.sTqrik"1p.oBA�t.t&�

���.���*[��a��+.2k9D�N'%.H^��"���%(�D25%(�D-040H^UG2546� � ;<)�-6��'/G;N��2O��+.; � +.;�;�-@+.�DF +7§�+{=�%.8�40)3-046���! �25%(��A-040H^UD2546� � ��;��<4�=("D¦���-625H6)O40)�Q�%('/GU!4O�1��)O%('©�<"1 G 7dn�3o.o.o(ik":s.s.?BA�s.?J¡��

���3sB�*[��V��+.2k9G��'%.H^��� ���R[����e��)O (;<)OH3"«¦�)325%('/:%(-6�<46�<%(�G-$%.8 � +.;�;�-@+.�DF -0/G9!)OH6)3-\§«�<469�&�!%.46-«25%(�D-6��-046�N�! *%.8 8E)O§ )3FD .)3-O"D40%*+J/D/:)3+JH�����[]+J469h�����

���3?B�*f +J�T+B=�U!�&����� � ��"\W0v�;< .) � H^+.��2IQR%(' � ���D+J40%.H^��2O-@%(� QR%(�r�()5} M %(;<=&40%./e)3-6b�"�Q�+JH^;N-6;�+3§M U � ;N��2O+J46�<%(�D-O"Z�3o.o.s&�

���5qJ�|f’7VD9etHHg;@W7eWjs,<&U’"i</l~

dn�3o.o.p(ik����3�B� M ��[�2O[�UD;�;<)3��f¨9!)\'$+T}���'�UD' �rUG' � )OH^-w%.8�8£+.25)3-�%.8¨+©25%(�&�.)5}7/1%(;<=&40%./e)$[�+J469!)5A

'*+J46�<�J+��{�_�3o(�T¡��{�JoBA^�3tTq���3pB�*[��D�«%&2k9G-040)OH3"D�«�N�! (-�%.8����&�B+JH^��+.�&46-�%.8 40%.H^��"1Q�%(9!)3��AC[�+.2O+.UD;�+B=\H^�N�! (-� .)3�!)OH^+J40)3F � =

'%(�!%('*��+.;N-O"D+.�DF©/�%(;<=r40%./:)3-O"Gv��D�h�D[�+J469h�<"G����dn�3o(�Js(ik"G?��3tBA�?.?(�r����{�{�l>�:���h���eYy�N2^�.%.H^�N-69h"���G-69!)3;�;�+ � ;<)�40H^��+.�! (UD;N+J46�<%(�D-�%.8a-0/G9D)OH6)3-O"Z~aUDH6%./Z�h�!�yQR%(' � ��A

�D+J40%.H^��2O-O"Z¤� �dn�3o.o��{ik"G�.s(�{A��.?J¡�����3tB�$�D�e���h[]UD�D�rH6)3-3"yfy%./e%(;<%. (�N2O+.;�H6)3-6UD;<46-��N�I25%(' � ���D+J40%.H^��2O-3"Z[]��2�9D�< (+.�I[�+J469h�Z�!�<"y�y¤

dn�3o.tTqrik"Z�.�3?BA^�3s.t&����3oB�$�D�h#:� M H^%{�J+.� �®Ya�e�D�:����;�;�)OH^+�":¦�)325%('/e%(-6��46�<%(�D-�%.8a-6��'*/G;���2O��+.;�25%('/1;<)5}&)3-�H6)3;N+J40)3F

40%�FD�N+.')O40)OH^-@%.8�25%(�r�()5} /:%(;<=&9D)3F!H^+ "«[]+J469Z���/e)OH^+J46��%(�D-_�¨)3-0)3+JH^2k9h"��Kdn�3o.tJ¡xik"�(�JpBA��.oTq!�

�usJ¡T�\����v��y�«)3��-6�!)OH{"�QR%(9D)3��AC[]+.2O+.UG;�+3= �&U!%.46�<)3�&46-�%.8�/e%(;<=��!%('*��+.;aH^���! (-O"�v�F!�T+.�G25)3-����[]+J469h�<"1 Z¤�dn�3o(�Jp(ik"G?J¡TA qxo&�

�us����*�w��#!2^9�U � )OH64O" z� � )OH�)3���!)_��UD')OH^�N-62^9!)����!%.40)3�G���x�J+JH^��+.�&40)."�[�+J469h�����<"��Z¤,dn�3o.�Tqrik"sTqx�BA�s.t.t&�

�us.sB�*��� M �T#&46+.�D;�)O=("Tf«9!)���/D/:)OH �R%(UD�DF�QR%(�TS0)32546U!H6)R+.�DF�Q�%(9!)3��AC[�+.2O+.UD;�+3=�Hk���! (-O"(#&46UDF�A�<)3-¨���]v«/D/1;��<)3F©[�+J469h�<"1�!�Xdn�3o(�J�(ik"Z�3?.�BA^�5qxs&�

�us.?B�*��� M ��#�46+.�D;<)O=."«W^QR%(' � ���G+J40%.H^��2O-�+.�DF�QR%('*'�U!46+J46�<�()*v�;< .) � H^+�"�#&)325%(�DFI~aFG�<46�<%(�Db�"�R��H6�&9�z+.UD-0)OH3"Z�3o.o.p&�

�usTqJ�D<l:VH]m8<WdH4q

dn�3o(�Js(ik��us.�B�*~«�hQ���:)O)3'*+.�h"�W^#&)3'$���D+JH�%(�7QR%(' � ���D+J40%.H^��+.;�f�%./e%(;<%. .=."�D+.-62O��2OUD;�)@�_dg~�}�/1%(-�P)3-�`

�+��>���G2O;�UD-kicb�"!`n�D-046�<46UD4«F!)3-¨��+.U!40)3-¨~a46UDF!)3-�#!2O�<)3�x46�����rUD)3-O"Z�3o.p.?&��us.pB�\���J[����e�<)O (;�)OH3"hW0YZ)32546U!H6)3- %(� M %(;<=&40%./:)3-^b�"(#�/DH^���! .)OH6A���)OH^;�+J !"!�3o.oTq!"x#&)325%(�DF�H6)O����-0)3F

/DH^���r46���! ��3o.o.t&�

�:\