sep i 8 2015 r. · on iuoo 2~,.2015, svc.filgd its motion _lo d"mi.,~ omti,-rtul ca~e...
TRANSCRIPT
Sep 18 2815 11:31:38 2111-389-1388
Michael C. Creamer+ 1$8 # 4030 Mi~&acl .P . .Ll\wrcnee. lSB .. # 7.288 GIVENS PURSLEY LLP' 601. W; Bl\nnook.St. P.O. Box 2720
->
Bolac. Idaho 83 70 f 02720 Telephone: zog .. 3gg.J20o FeJt: 208•388· I 300
Alibri1t.p for Ciljl of fltlilay
Scott L Cempbcll. JSB # 22-5-1 Mfttthcw J. McOee; ISB # 7979 Mor:flATTt TuOMAS; BARRITT+ ROCK&. F'ml.OSt Ctt#\R.TURtiD · • t 61 S. t:apitol ,Blvd., l Q(h .P.l<tor Po,t .Offioo Box 829 Boise,.ldliho 83701 Teleph<sne: '(208}-343,.2000 fe:,t: (208)3~-j334
A.llwner,,/or S,111 ·1fa1tey CM,pa1tJt
Suaan e. Bu1tton. fSB.#f 40jfl Clieri5e ·o. MoLotn~.lSB # 191 l MOORE--SMITR BUXTQN.&. TURCK,5, CHTD: . . . 9S(1W. l3all~k St.) Sto •. S20 8Que;.'tdal1o· 83?02 · Telephone: (208}'331 • 1'800 Pax; .. (?08))31.,1202
Atuwn~ /r,,-1.he CltiJ!..¥- of Ke1c}1~n, mtd' Fajifielil . . . . . .·
2881362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 882
Candice M. Mc.Jiugn, lSB .fl S998 Clui11.M.·Bii.>rnley, lSB ti 65~0. MCHUGH BROM LE'?.; PLLC 380 $. 4th.St,, Ste. 1'03-Bol~ 'Idaho '8370.2 District c Tolephone: 208-2874>9~ 1 Pax;208-287-0864
Fifth J ~urt • SfiBA Co In Re: Adm:~~la/ /District
unty of Twin FaJf at ve ApPeals s • State of Idaho
Ai~tJl'l1<3)'$ fm· Clty.r,fBal(dllU«
JOSEVH r. JA:Ml!S, JSliti·S BROWN. & JAMES 130 Fourth Avenue West Ooodinltldaht) 83~30 T~ephone:. '208-'934~8 l SS f'ilx;· .2~·934'-410J ·
Att,>r1t'il:~'for Big ti Ltl.ilc .Wocxl Waio,. Us<!/'$ 11:YRO<:(utltm
LAWREN'C¥t.o. WASDEN ATI'ORNBY GENERAL
CLI.VE J. STRONO Deputy A'ttQmcy Ooncral Chlet, Nat6rat ~UTOCS·Divtaion.
QAtUUC.K L. BAXTE~ ISB #6301 EMMI L. BLADES, lSB #8612 ~puty .Attomoys.Oonerol. Idaho .Department <Sf Water Resourc:cs P.O. Uox. .83720 Boise • .Idalfo .83720..0098 Tc!q,h6ne:· (208)·U7.:4KOO Fncsim'ilc~ (20.a} 287~700 [email protected] e1nf1(i.'blades@ldwr:idabo.gov
A ti.a~ /of Gary Sf}(ld(,,,an (Ufd the .{tf rilio Dt1/>al'l>ntmt,of W~tor RttS()Ul'Cd..• .
SEP I 8 2015
IN ·TRE DISTRlCT COURT .OF THE FOURTH JUDlCJA:~ DISTRICT OF THE
STAJJ'E.OF IDAHO,JN·AND Ji'OR THE,COONTY OF ADA
crrv OF HAILEY, M ·Idaho m~nicipal corporation. and CITY bF BBl,LEVUBi an ldaho municipal corporation, ·
Sep 18 2815 11:31:43 288- 380-1388 ->
V9,
OARY SPACKMAN in bis<0ffiobd ~pa(.'ily,as the Dlrecl'Oroflhe·IDAHO DBPARTMBN'J' OF·WATER .RBSOLIRCBS; and the IDAHO DBPARTMEN1' OFWA TER RESOL!R~ES,
Rctpnndc.ttts.
S'UN VALLEY COMPANY, a Wyoming corpot11tion,
Peti tion~r.4~
v~.
OARY SPACJ:(MAN in hit<ifficial C'ftl>~City,asthe Plrdctor-00hc Idaho ,Dop4rtmoni .at W1tu Rcsourcca, 41nd .tho JDAUO D.sPARTMENT OP W AT13tl llBS0URCBS.
IN THE MA T'l'BR Of DIST.IUBtJrlON OF WATER TO WA'tSR .RlOtITS HSU> BY Ml!MBBRS OF·THE BIO .:WOOD. t..i"rrus· WOOD W ArElt· USERS A$'SOC1AT10N D1VERTINO PJ\QM.T,HB BIO-WOOD AND Lf.ITLBWOOD RIVEltS .
288?3&2121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 883
CORRECTED StlPtUATlON
Ca,e No. cv.w .A-2015-l4SOO
CORRECTED STlPLUATION . .• ..
The City Qf Hailey .(''Halloy"); thc:Cit)I ofl3eUcvuc (''Bell<:Vue~ S\lh VilUey-Company
("SVC"); the Ola & Utttc Wood Water Users Assocfatlon -~'WUA'j; the City.of'l(.ctehum
("Ketchum'!). the City ,0f}'aJrfleld {''Falrfle.ld'), and 1ho Idaho Dcpertmont o(Water Resources . . .
("Depllrtm~l~').-and Gaty 8paclman. Ditcctol"·or~ Ikpfll'tmont,by··mk1 lhrough.1~ir ~live·
attomcy~-of rceo.rd~ h'creby·.cntot into {hls S1tpulatio11 :in··ow ciDOViXaptti>ned mntlc,"nt.
Sep 18 2815 11:31:54 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 11K
BACKGROUND
1. The WUA, through tholr counsel .. ~ubmittcd.writtcn requests to lt,c O<,p11rlmt,nl
lhat the Wtttennaster of Wat.er Dlstriotg 37 ·nnd 37B udmlnister junior ground waler·rights tbat· .. . . the WUA ollcges·11rc causiflg,materlal injury.to:~e ~raco Wit~'flghlh>fthe WUA ·~-members..
2. The Departmont·<tcwed lh.c WUA •s·requestHto.1Je dcUvery call$ as defined in the
rJepQrtmenl'• Coajunctlve.Managcmoot Rulcs,.JDAP.A 37.03 . .1 J ('IC:;M.Rutes"), ftnd lnitiemd
conicsted-OIJ.86 Jl~hlQS for.the Big Wood·Dcllvcr1 CAii (IA'lekot No. CM~pt:.201~~J) lllld
~ Littlq Wood Delivery.Call {D()el(et No. CM-DC-201S.:oo2) ("Deli1,/cf)' Culls'~)·undQr C~ . . . . .. . . . .
Ruie·40.
J , Jrr a:toltcrtltt~Mareh 20,:201-s, the lJct1artlmmt.l\Otilioc1 holdm i;f Urtidn
around water.t.ig)rts.within-W1ttat .o1siric;itil 11 .and 3713 Qf the filina of tbe. WlJA 'a requellts for
administration. The Department also J)Ublumod notlcc of the Delivery Col~ in the fd;Jhc!
Mountain E~~ t1nd C\mas Comicr on M~rch 2s1h,.~ots & AptiJ 111\)01 s,:and tltoTjmoa
Nc:Ws<>t1Mffl'Ch26i\201'5 &April 2"'1,20JS.
~. Hailey, Bellm1e, l<.etclmm, Fai('fietd and SVC, among others, ntcd nodeC$-of
intent·«> partiotpR\e in th0 Dolivery. Call3.
,. On Iuoo 2~,.2015, SVC.filGd its Motion _lo D"mi.,~ Omti,-rtul Ca~e Proceo,llngf.
p~~U!f -i:-_~l(~Y~ MQ(Ullt'')Jtgufn·g. amona.othcr 1btns.1t. theWUA ft.ilcd to filQ.petitiansfor
dcHv.~n, ~aUa ciStiiptiilff witifth'.o r«jtiir(W'eo.(s of Ida1Jo:·Codc1 4Z-2371t,.the °*'rtmcnt~s-Jtutc:.,
of'P~re, artcl ·~ CM ~ulos;
6. On June 26; 20f S, RaUey end 'J30lluvue ,f'iJed their Joint MOl.ion 10 fMRlgnote . . . . .. .
ACCJ..WS by Jbd~m.a~tgand ~ Dimnfs., D<1livary·C11ll1 C'C/lie;'f' Ml)tft,1f'1-ftl'QU'iilg tblt :the
~etrt·~y tt,ot-adminijter an>'uhd \vatetrigh~ m wa·cefi Disb.'ici.·.37 and . .37B in.respotfic:to
a dc1ivef1~afl tindet'°tMRule40 unlesa-and until the,IJeparnncn.t, fhrougn rutemnkins,
Sl'IPUl,ATJ°ON• 3
Sep 18 2815 11:32:8(, 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 885
cstabli~s an a.rca of co1J1.mon grQ1~11cf w.atc1· surply ("At:GWS") that e11c.ompas.~is the WUA 's
m~fhm' ·war.er riahl'S fln<l pal~.ntfolly implicated ju(1'ior gfot111d water right,;:
7. On July 22r 201S lhcOcpartmcnt issued .itll Order Denying Sun Volley CIJmpant,
Motion fo ·DLwJ!l.•,1t ('.'.Sun Valley ~er'') denying Su,, Jl(,lley:., Molian, sn.d its.On!e.r l)enylng
Joh:ft Motion ti;, .Designale .i1CGJ!'.S·by Rulct1wki,:,g·µh'<J lo DIA·mia:t Dc1Jw,ry C.itll., {"ACGWS·
Ord.rr"') d6nYin&·1he Cltfar Morlt;n. N~ t110·..\)t1t '}ldli<!.y.Qt<d,et'rtc'h thcS . .AL'GWS Cnilef
contall\ed lnnguase or wa11 .G<1COtnpanlod by a.document cantitining l1111suaso indfoodng,thoy . . .
wete recommended ord~ pt'Olltnill4U)I urdcn or thud orders. Thu~ under the Dcpartm~'1lt1J
Rukrof Protcdlrft:·7.lO, the.-S&fn .Vall~y Order nnd ACGWS Order are. futet1ocutoty <>rdent·, • , • .. • 1' •
8.. 01t Aua~t fl and .1'1.~01 s. ruspeetivol)', SVC timely .filed Ha M~wnfor Reviliw:of
tnltfr!r.iciilo,Y'Ordar and.llailoy'amd 8ellevt1&.iifn~ly fil~ 'tnoir Jbilll Motim1/o,: RcriieW ot
l1'terlocu(ory Order in the DcUvery Calls {together thc .. "Ruhi 7.1 ·I M<11lom,', seddn11 review .of . .
the Sun JlalleJ> Order ond ·the ACGWS Order wl<fer .tho Ocpnttmcm's Rule of.J>tocodurc 71'1 ,
IDAPA'3?.-0I.Ol.71 l. As<>ftbia date. the Director has iaken no action 10 re9Cind, alter onn~end . , , .
the Sun Yti/ley Order or thcACGWS q,der in ·responsc . .to .lJte Rule 711 Motiona-.
9·,. On Auaust 18, 201 S, Hailey and Bellovue ftlcd their Petll/011 for Judicial 'RR.vl~w
of Ag6ttey At.:tlon (KC1Ji,.1 • l'~tilinn~') in Ada County Olstrlct Court, Gase 'NQ • .CV-OC-15144 J 9, . . .
seok(ngjudicial review of.the A COWS Ordt.r Pw,\IAftUQ :ldi\110 (;Qdi) §§··67«5270 Rnd :67-~211(2} . . ~ , . . . . . . . . . . .
en~ ~utc M-<>f th6. ld(tlfo: Rulcsli~f:C((liI P~tf~ ~ll\8Jti~iciel ~v~~ .c,fitn iutt1&1r(~~to
epn.ey irCtlon Oft ·tJUl ·lt,'Olirtdi 1nill ~view of f(Mt tgeooy AetiQj1 Will .llOf . .Pl'OV'l.dc, thm1· With ai,
adequate remcdr.
J 0, On Ausust .1.9, ZO ls,.svc {if ecf its .Porltl<>n /or ,l,ttlit:ial -Rcrvtew f'S,YC Perttlon"')
in Ada Counly:Disrric,. Court. Case- No; C,V.:OC-l.S l 4Spo,,oekina'jodici1'1 a'OV'ieW o,f ·tJfe Su'!f
Valley (?rder purs\fllnt to l<ltdl0 ;Cod~· §§ -6 7.527()' it'fd :67-5271 (2) nnd llt~l<!:'8a ofth'c ~fio Rides
Sep 18 2815 11:32:28 288-388-131.11 -> 2887362121 Givens Pu.rsely W Page 886
of Civil Proccdt1re1 ~ecking judic.i.al review of an inl.etmedittle ngoncy action on th~ gmundi. tlu,t
nNiCW 6f 'nJ\al fl jency-action•wtlJ ,iot pro'vide'.lhem Wi\h·im adequate remedy,
H . The Cltles' Petlifon nnd the SYC.Pet!Jlon (logcthl!r the .. Pafltinns'':) have been
reaa8lgnod from the Fourth.District to·tho Snnke Riv.er Ba~in Adjudication District Coll.rt of the . . . .
Fifth .Judioial _DistricL Tll&-Cl//u 'Potitilm waft rnnumbcn'!d l:iy the ~urt .. lroJi,: CV ~QC-15-14419
to,C.V~W~·i9tS.·144U>. Tho.SVC Pelt/lO!(wlls-rtnum~ercd by llKf~urt ftot11,CV-OC-1$14'S00
co cv .. w~./J.Or!-14300 •.
12: 1'ho D.epQ,-trnonJ.ttl~putos that1ho .ACO'WS·O,dcr-and flto $tm Va'1~-0rderrm.ey
be reviowed by the Diatrict C'.ourut.thi& tfme.
13; All -of tht(pm1fe&.fo·thls:Stlpu/at.foo agree thtitc"pedite<t Jt1~iciaJ .roview 'O'f.tlic
i81oos riiscct bs, ttao:Cilias ' Moµa;,. a'nd 81m .Y. alliiy. 's Motw,,n>ri ~ -ter.ms· set to'rili below j.~· in. tno
i~ of admitiistralive-And· judieiul econQmy.
STIPULATION
14. Desiggation ofthpA,CGWS.QrdOJ'pnd thaSu,, YqllevOrder H ,firn,I Orcleq._
Ame.ndmertt of PmiYons, andAugmcmtation 9f RC®nb on Appenl. The.partica to this
Slipt'ilalion agree to tak.o the following actiollll with re.. .. peot to tJ10ACGWS 01'(/e,· aud the $u11
l'alfey Ordar, lhe PoUti<m:r, and th~ records on appeol:
o. l{nUoy~ Bellevu~ K.$hum, f'afrtie!d ~nd SVC will ~I~~ motio~ J'_l?(l~ing th~
D~l'Cir ~migNi~ .~he·1CG'lf'$ OJ'dctr r11i~.t~e· $m,· 'l'al~ey 01.·<lilf' U fii'lnl-Qi'U~
punu11nt ttr (ho-~rtm~t":s R~1~-:~r.Prooodure 11 o· and ·150 ·with .~tie
isau• jjre!lented by 1he Citlu·' Mo{ion .and Sun Jlnlley ·.,. Motion (''Motion to
Designate"), If 1~ objcotio?, ia fled to t~o Motto~ to Daip\te, .tho Director wm , . . .
isaue:,;cpanrt~ ordors.t1osignat~g.tl\e AC(rWS o~r1•1'id d\'O·S'dn -Valltt; Orf!cf •
fi~l ·<>nters .sn'bjoot toj(idiclat tc".iewe~niJjglent..~th tno;J)epntfr11i:nt'i;-Rulo-<1f
Prwedure 740, ("'Designation O.rders~). If ill objection is timely fifed to the
s:r1P~LATION• 3
Sep 18 2815 11:32:33 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 881
Motiou to Dcs.ignatc, the Oit'OQtOr will con11ider the objt=ction 1md n1lc on the
merits of the motion and objection ,wcordingly.
b. Hailey! Sel1evt1o, Ketchum, Fairfield, SVC, and the WU~ agree not to seek
~o~iderntion-o;r~,or nte·e,tceptiQn.1110, ttrc Designation {)rdots.
c. Ptomptlyfunowing expil't\lkkt o'f Utourno allow~ fur other pordde to tho
Delivery cans who Ol'e nol Jwtieuo this Stlpulntlnn .to Jlc,tk t'C(.~lJideNltlon, liJc
cxcei>tlon11 or roq\lest a hearing on d10 Dosignalion Ord~1.,;, 11s11umh1,g.n() pa.l'tlcs . .. ~ , , . .. . . . .
h~vc, ,ione.ao,. H~il~Y .. ~mf 01)ltc;vt1c.at1<1 SVC w:iU lftke ft}>pro_p·ri~ M~ to'ann,~Jd
tlwlr ~peotlv~ ·J>l!d.J_ton} in.1h~ ~~tri¢t eouri tif rcn~ tbaf lft~y Ql'f(~ktnu
jml1Cinl rovfowur Jlnel 11i(cney t1cr.of\Y.. ·Within iwcnty-ono (2l) daYiJ·o.f'H\e ·min;
oflhe seitled n,cords, the partieR wUJ ta1'e approprlftto eteps to augment the
records beforo tho Db1trict Co1:1rt ~f th ~o M~on t~ ~g~c and Designation
Orders J11 accordance with -Rute-84(1)~ fc:teho:-Rulct 6fCjvil·Ptocedore. . . . .
d. ·me.patties i\gnic nol ·to·.opjio56 tbe,aOO\'~tibed.lll'rictKlmcnrs tQ tl'i'e· Pttlltfoh., ...
or to assert .that Hailey ar,d .Bcllcvuo.or SVC have. failed to exhausl-1\dminh,trntl\l.e
remedies, or lo take any other action to prevent rcv.iew by the District Court, on
lhe merits, ofthe.issuCA.pr~nled.
e. J.n uie ~~t. Ute Dir..ootor tak~ ;81\Y. aotitm io rc.;P<>* tQ thc:~ule 7 J J Moti<1ns
withitr(~onty..ot'lil'{21)"da·ya.of the nti«{j:~fUn, scttl.echveQl'dll(the patties a~
th•tHafloy·1md Bellevue.end ·SVC wllr tttke npnrupif«le t!top u,. mncnd.thcir
Ptuilion.,. if nOOCSS&ry, and the parties will tak" apJjropriate ~tops .lo n\,gmont tho . . . . . . . -,,
records ~ofore·the District Court with any record:or evideneo-of!luoh.letion· in
~ iioc wi{h:R~tc. 84{1), Jdaijo Ru1t>JJ.csfCivil .V~un,,
f. None-of '\he _pru1ies·ah1'11 be.decmc,d (6 .. have warivod.any olaiin or dotoneo,.
inc}ud1ug without limitntfoo claims Or d_of0rl$('8 COflcmllJlg sdequll~C reme<fi~
STIPlJ~.A TION- 6
Sep 18 2815 11:32:45 288-389-1388 -> 2887362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 88B
C)(hftUf;tiou of admioist~live remedies a,!d tho.se cluitnll, dtif~,~, araume11ti;,
findings of conclusiobs eontained in the, emu· M.ntJoft; Sttn Jlntley ~v M01lon. the
ACGWS Order, th6Sun Palley Ore/el', or the PetJt(ons in the event tho District
Court does not rocosnize u~ Designation Onlcn and/or Hailey and BeUcvue's.O\'
SVC's amendm""ts:of tho Pellti.01t1 .as.c:onferringjurisdiotion on lhoCo'ltrtto
~~~w-thO ilCGWS qrd,r ~r. '1\0 Su~ ·Yal/ey OYdor-a~.fu.tR1 agency ac6onlf.
15. Stit,ula]ism fg E,tPJXlito·JuctiejaLRQYiO:W, The parties agre(Ho.tiike au rcaadm1blo
11l'cps to expedite the OJ~rict111 Court judicial review ~f the l'ofilt<HJa,
16~ .w~~~~~,Qd Cmio Pnu;~ ..
a.. .H•ltey; _BaJlevue, I<-ctelrun,, falr1i~~d., svc~.atuf. tbeWUf\ will fit~ with'thc
OdJ)annmnt a Ji;ini Mi#ion for ~l.(fji o.fDo1lwr)i:C,i1lfSU'bsfantiA1ly'in lho' form
attaclied hrio n.s·Atuir,l;fneot A ("M<>tl()n for Slit/'}, v.lhicb is hereby.
incorpc:mrtod hy reference.
b. Conaistc:nt with~ OcpartmC!lt's Rule of Proccch1re 170, llllY J)tlrtyto:t)lc
.Dollvory Calls ~Y ~e· a rcspon~ive'}'.)leadin.g Jo ttie .Motloh for Sruy Within
ibur'totm (14) days ,~'tj1a filing ~t" thc·m.oUon.
c. Th~Departmcnc will cx.p«fite -ita doolsien,on tllo.Motum[or.Stay.
d.. Poll~wini_ issua_n~. o~l\~lo jf fl~I ~nd ~ppeaht~lo Judam~tf o~ ~th PetJllon.,
~y~he.~•f_t'lof~,.1we POJ':«rtmcfflt·~ilt~ptly·noti~~l{~Jing:O-fishitu..
couf~iit.·Whic1flhc:ptu1iei ·.to.1h1 Deliv.ety Cat111:and'llte-Ocpnrim1Snt \Vilt
oon&ult-conccmintt the procoduml'set,P8 required .H> .give-~ccl..to {bo.Oiktrlet
Co\111's decisions, .lncludina wlth0\11 timitallon, dlsmh,sa.l orthe c:ont'Cltcd caeca,
o~ oatabltshinf e hearina ~ule ..
1.7. SLill!Jlaii@ as m ttnon:a Scb«Me auo: Furtbet Procefflinp in t~.Qelixm
STIPULATIQN. 7
Sep 18 2815 11:32:57 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Giuens P11rsely LLP Page 1119
"· lfpmco~in~ 1•u1no on the Pollvory Coll~ followlna 100 11ttt)' onlcmxJ puncm1n1
10 mo M()/11111 fi>r Su11, tho pMiCI to aha OctlvorY Cadl• ahall be c,ntiOtd 10 o
lfCl,cdulo provJcU1114 t'tio t\lUowi~ dmo rmmgs at • minimum:
l. [)btcoycry, Tiki partica to lbu OoliY\.'1)' C.U11 nil be cntttlod W rotlUlttf
dltQOVCt')' n. authllrl~f by the l)lrcc1or'1t Ma)' 13, 201j, 01Yltl'
Aiuh1'1'/~IJtlf l>INco1>0ry: Nullr.tt ,t/ P~llar11'111g Cu,r/imm<*. lbr e minimum
periocl ofono hundnxt olghty (HIO) da~ ondlfttl ''° Cf\rtlor ,hnn thh1y (30)
WIYIJ pri<>r tho Heorlng.
ii. ~.X!..WiU~~. Th0 r,ertleA lo the Delivery Calla .i.tl
diaOJo.o o,qxm wilaclltllCt U"1>'1Cwd tu tOlltlfy at tho HOll'lna, lnch1dJ119
iJi(hm\ftttcn n,quirod by I.R.C.P. I 6(1)(1) 111d 24(b)(4)(A), "° lac... thlu1
alxty (60) •~ prklr 10 lho Homfag.
Iii. lhmjl>Jl. Any ovidcntiftt)' hearingit on (he Oollvary Calla ah,11 ho hql(I ff<'
oarllor than Cw(> hundrccl furty (240) duys t'ollc,wina tho C(lncfudcm nf tho
ttay ol'dcrod 1)\IQUlnl 10 1,/qtiou for Stn,,.
DAT~D thl• L£...t\.yor ~~15.
C!IVBNB P0t\SLB'V U.,P
~~~ A ttol'M)II Jbr Cir, 6/ I "'liq
MOFPATI', THOMAS, 8ARRE'rr, ROCJ<. &. FIUI.,l)S, CHt\R1'liRED
... ~~ By:~~4?_. Mat®w J. McOoe Afftll'lt«>"f./br Stttt Yu/lcJI Ca111pnny
STIPULATION• A
MCHUOH BROMLIW. PLLC
BROWN & JAMBS
Sep 18 2815 11:33:88 288-388-1388 ->
MOO!t.e SMl'l'H BUXTON & TURCK.I!. CH'l'O,
STtPULA1'10fol· 9
2887362121 Giur:ns Pursely LLP Page 818
Sep 18 2815 11:33:12 288-388-1388 -> 288?3&2121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 811
CF.RTlFICA'fK 01<' 81tRVIClt
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this lt!?aoy of.September 201 s.1 c11uscd a true and corrw( C<lpy of lho foregoing dooumen.t 10 be filed with the Court ai,d sorvcd 0 11 the lbllowins panics by the iodicated mothoos:
Or/gi1tnl 1a:
SRBA DISTRICT COURT
253 3RD A VE NORTH
f>O B0X2707
TWtN FALLS lD 83303·2707
Facsimile: (208) 736-2l21
CANDICE MCHUGH CHRIS M BROMLEY MCHUGH OROMLUY PLLC 380 S 4°"1 STRfiET $TE 103 BOJSfi 1D 83702 qmcbuaJ>@mcmalbbmmloy.com cbtomlev@molnt&hbromJgy.com
MICHAEL C CREAMBR MICHAEL P LAWRENCE OJVRNS PURSLEY LLP POBOX2720 BOISB ID 8370 I ~2720 ms:Piiai.uum1oloy,,com mpl@gjycnRQ\111lRY&S2W
SCOTT' L CAMPBELL NORMAN M SBMANKO MA T'fHSW J MCOf!! MOPFATf THOMAS PO B0X829 BOISE IDAHO 83701 aJc@moffatt,com nrne@mo!fgu,oom mim@moff11t,com
OARRJCK L BAXTER EMMl L BLADES ID DEPT OF WATER RESOURCES POQOX83720 BOISE 1D 83720-0098 prrick,buter@id»ir.tdaho,119y cmml,[email protected],aov
STlPlJLA'flON· 10.
( ) U.S. Mail, Postage Prepaid ( ) .Hand Delivery (x) ft1C$hnilo ( ) E•mnil
(x) U.S. MRil, Postage PrcJ>tlid ( ) Hand Dolivcry ( ) F11ct1imilo (x) n-m11II
(x) U.S. Mail, J>~t1gc Prcpeid ( ) Hind Delivery ( ) fltC8imUe (x) E-mRil
(,t) U.S. Mftil, POl'taao l~ld ( ) Hand Deliv«y ( ) r: IIC4lhrtlle (x) E•mnil
(x) U.S. Mail, Postajc Prepaid ( ) Hqnd D.clivery ( ) FOClllmile (JI) E-tnRil
Sep 18 2815 11:33:23 288-3lll-1388
SUSAN E BUXTON CHBRBSE D MCLAIN
->
MOORE SMITH BUXTON & TURKE 950 W BANNOCK STREET SUITE 520 BOISE ID 83702 Mb@msbllRW,O(lffl [email protected],wm
JOSEPH F JAMES BROWN & JAMES t 30 FOUR'J'H AVENUE WEST GOODING ID 83330 JQs;@brownfamcu1tnw.com
DYf.,AN lA WRENCE VARIN WARDWEU., THOMAS+
Kl)NKEL .Ll.c 242 N. 8TH ST., sun·e 220 BOlSB, ID 83702 dylaplomngQ((hadnwudweJl,wn
ALBBRT P. BARKBR BARKER ROSHOLT & SIMPSON Ll.P 1010 W. JeFF.BRSON ST., SUITE 102 P.O. B0X2139 BOTSB, tO 83701-2139 8Pb®idall<2D"'a,S<S>m
JAMBS P. SPECK SPBCK &AANESTAO 120.E.AVE. P.O. BOX987 KETCHUM, JD 83340 ji~QQMllUldlg,~
28873£,2121 Givens Pursely W Page 812
(x) U.S. Mnil, Posto;o Prepaid ( ) H11J1d DcUvQr)' ( ) r:ac11fmilc ( Jf) P. • IJ\ll II
(x) U.S. Mnll, Po.tago J>rot,ald ( ) H1md J>c:Uvory ( ) Pacaiii,Oe (x) E-inail
(x.) U.S. Mail, l'Ot1111g~ Pn,pcdd ( ) Hlmd Dolivory C ) 1-'oosin,ile (x) E-mitil
(x) U.S. Mail, Poataae Prop11ld ( ) Hand Delivery ( ) Fncehnile (x) E-moil
(x) U.S. Mail, P~e Prepaid ( ) H1md Delivery ( ) \1ocahnilo (lt) B-mnil
~tft2--
S'J'WUJ,ArlON· JI
Miclutel C. Creamer Attoma~ for City uf H11iley
Sep 18 2815 11:33:32 288-388-13111 -> 2881362121 Givens P11rSely LLP Page 813
Michael G. C1umer, tSB # 403,0 Michael P. Lawreno.e, ISB '# 7288.. ONE.NS-~URSU!Y LLP 60i W. Bannock St, P:O. Bo"x 2720 . Boise, ldabcS 8'3701-l720 T.elepb~ne: 208;. 3 88"-12.00 Fai,.; 208-3.88-1 lOO
Attorneys for Clty o.( Hailey
Scott L. ~pbell, ISB # 2251 Matthew. J. Mc:Oee, ISB· ff 7919 MOFFATTiTHOMAS1,l3AAArrr~ ROCK & f't6L.PS, CHARTBAAD . 101 S. Capitol _Blvd., 10th Floor Pott: Office 13<1x. ·s29 Boi°sc~ Ida'ho :Sj?OJ
Candice M. McHug~ !SB If 5908 Chris}vJ._Bromley • .ISB # 6S30 MCHUGH BROMLEY, PL'LC· 380 S. 4th St., Ste. 103 Boise, Id"aba 83702. · Telephone: 208-28.7-099.J Fax: 208-2&7-0864
Anorneys for City of Bel/evt.re
Joscph·F. Ja~. ISB# 5771 BR.OWN &.·JAMES tm·Fourth Avenue.West Oooding, tdllho 83330 Telephone: 208~934:-.8 l 8S Pax:. 208-934-4101
Telephone: (20S) 345-2000 Fax:· (208):J8S-S)84
Atwrn.eysfor Big & 1.iiula .Wood Watv Ute/'$ Aiiix:iaiiJn · · · ·
A tiorneysfor.Sun .Pal/ey·Cbtnpany
Su.,an E: BuxtoP, ISB # 404 t Cb.enme·D, McLam.JSB # 79ll MOO'RE SMrfli BOXTON. & 'rURCK:E, CHTD. 950 W. Bannock St., Ste. S20 &ie, Idaho 83702 . . reteph'one: (208) j~J -1.800 F:ax: {208) l~ 1-1202
Att_~ for the PtltU-0/ Ketc~um.and Fallfit!ld
llUORE THE DEPAl{TMENT O.F WATER.RES0URC2S
OF.THE ST ~'.fE OF IDAHO
IN THEMATTl:!R OF' DlSTRJBtmON·OF WATER··TO'WATER RIGHTS HELD BY . MEMBBlt$ OF THJHUG WOOD & U'M'LE WOOD .. WATER USERS ASSOCl'A TION l)IVERTINO FROM THE BIO WOOD RIVER . . . . . . '
IN'THB·MA. ER .OJt"DISTRlBUTION OF WATER TO W.A.TBR RIOHTS HELD' BY MEMBEAS OF·THE.BIO WOOD & LITI'LE
.Docket NO'. CM-DC-201 s..po J
Docket No. cM .. oc-201 s-002
JOINT MOTION FOR ST,. 'V OF D&UVERV CALLS • p. 1
.A.ttachment A.
Sep 10 2815 11:33:45 288-300-1388 ->
WOOD WATER US.ERS ASSOCIATION DIVERTING FROM THE.LITTLE WOOD RIVE1t
2807362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 814
JOINT MOTION FOR STA\' OF DEUVER:Y CALLS
Tho City oftimley-(~HaHey1'),:thc.City ofBcllcvue{"Bellevue"), Sun Valley Company . .
{0 SVC"), the. Big &.·Liff le Wood Water'Users.Association («WUA"), the-City of Ketclrum
("Ketchum it and the Ci(y of Fairfield C'~airt'ie1d")° {collectively,. the ·~ovants")~ by and
tf1rough· 'tneif respettive.altomeys of record. jointly file this Joirtt Motion far· Slay of Delivery
Call, (":loint·Motioni requesting the Dtrector ("Director") of the Idaho Department of Water . .
Resources C\Depnnment'') stay.alHurther proceedings fo_thc,.above--caption_ed matters (tlie
"Delivery Calls'') for the .reasons and upon the terms. set forlh .herein;
RECITALS
1. The WUA, through their attom~, initiated proceedings boforc lhe .. Oepartment
seeking administration of.juµjor ground water rights in ~atcr.Districts 3.7 ~d 3?8 alleging that·
diversions of water under . .such junior ground ·water rights oausc material injury. t.o the surface
water rights 0fthe WUA's.membe:fS.
2. On Ausust.1"8, 2015, Hailey and.-Bcllevue filed.their Peti.th>nforJudicial Review
of Age,rcy Action ecm~~· P1tlil,01''')·in Ada County District Court. Case No. CV-OC-1$14419,
seekingjudiejal review of the July ·22/ 2015,. Order Denying Joint Moliun to .Deslg,rale A.COWS
l!~ RulemtlkJng and m Dlf,,.J.fs De/lW!l')' Ca!.I, {'1A.CG~ .Order'') i~ ~y ~ ~rector.
3, On A~~Ll9; WfS; svc· filed itt P.t'tilionfor Judicial RtNiew {0 SYC 'Petltion")
i_n .A<la Co~nty Pisu:ict <;:au.rt, ~ · No. CV -<?C· 1 S ~ ~S~. ~~og j~iciaJ royiew ~f.the July 22,
2015, Orth,-Den.ybtg.Sun .Jlalley.tomporty.isMotion To Di3mi1s.C'Sun. Yallej.(niJe,~'!) issued by . . . lho D:(rcctor.
JOINT'NIOTION'FOR STAY Of' DELIVPY' CALLS·· p.,1
Sep 1B 2815 11:33:50 288-388-1388 -> 28873(,2121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 815
4. The. Cities ' Petition and the SVC PetitiQlf .. (together tl:te ''Petillons!J have been
rea89igned from the Fourth-District.to .the Snak~ River Basin Adjudication Disll'ict-Court of tho
~ Judicial Di.strict. Tho .. <:.Jti~.,.~ J>~ltion was renumbered by-the Court from CY-OC-Ul-4419
toCV .. WA-201S-.H419, TheSVC .Pa11Jion wastenmnbered by tho Court.from.CV~OC-1:S14'500
to CV-WA-2015-J4S00.
S-; Concutrent wjth the ~ecution of lhis Joint Motion, Che Movants and the
~~nt:.~tercd !nto.aStiBU,ati<m in \Ybich th~y a_~: (~)..that.Ha_ilef, ~e1Jev'1e, Ketcbum,
f'airfi~d Ibid SVC'Wo\tl<Ullc-a .motion·t'CQ\lesting the D~tor desi8fiate the.ACGWS Order .and
~n Jlqlley (?rde: Q fi~;1hmicrsP.Ursu1;nt to the; Oepartm?t.'·s.RuJ~ of.f~ure;?lQ~.7~
sutije<frto·jtidloial'rovf ew tiitdedh",ldaho A<l1111nitttaftve Prooedore Act.:ldaho· Code § .61·
S2~3)~ ~) ·thlt:thc,·~~ts wo~ file-thH Join~ MD/.iQn .req~ti~g that. ~ :D_iroc~qtay ~l
oilminiattet·{ve p~i~ on the Deliv~if Cail~, mclitdinifwithouf limitation all discovery -Md
m~tion-P.fflctiee, until tht,,-Diltrlct C<,urt jssues,Rulc 5'4 final and appoalab_lcjudgmen.ts c:-n the ... , . .. . ' , . . . ' .. . .
Cltli!.l"' P,liil6n·lfi.d tlie svc Petition;- &'Ui'(c)'th'ahha:ferini-ario eoftditioti• 6f tlie,siay wottld be
set fotih1it.thia JWJt,Molion . . . ,• . . . . . .
JOlNTMOTION
6. 1'he Movants hereby move tbo Director to;
a. qrdcr tho stay·of all <1dministrative proceedings-on the Delivery Calla~
including.without limitation all discoveey and inolion practice, until tbe:Disfrict Cour1.ha11 iS1Ued
Rule S4 final and .oppeal~ble.judgrricnts on both ~he Ci(lcs • P~rltion and the.SVC Petition (the
b. Order that, follU~il\l-iiisuancc of Rule .54 .final and .a~lable,judgmcmts
by the D'lstriot Court on both tho Cities' J'etilion and thc:SYC Pefifiorr, whichever ts later, tho
Dopartmcnt will prolJlptly )lOtice scheduling. of a .status.conferenc.e at which tho parties. tq.-the:
.IOIN'I' MOttON FOR STAY OF UELIVERY-CALLS • p.J
Sep 18 2815 11:34:12 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 81£,
Delivery Calls .and the Department wiJI consult concc11~ing the procedural steps required to .give
efTeet:to the District Court.ts decisions, including wlthout..limltation. dismissal of the contested
cases, or establishing a,hcaring:schedulc. Any ~i:thcr.procccwngs shall be consistent wit:h the
time,f'ralnes aetiorth in the Stipultltion..
7. Tlte.Movants further agree.a.~ follows:.
a. All ri~hts to further adrniniilrative.and judicial proceedings arc reserved to
tbc panics of such p~ings, and the S(ay.shall not affec.t S\JCh ri- including ~ithout . ' . . ' . . . . , . , . . .
limitation tho right of any party ot-lhe.Dcf,artmctit to seokrcconsideration,or·appellatereview of
the District Cwrt'J de.t:lsi<ms QJt ~c·CltlP:.f'' PetUlon fM. th~. src Pttitton, ~r.an:y 1>th.et ·T.C?Hef . ' .. .. . . . .. . . ' . . ..
ptOtlided :~tli·~;
b. Nothin$ h~n-prcctud~ any·.P,l~y·or pcr~-th,!Jl --~ng a ~11iY,·qruny
othet1eJi~f }Sffiviclcitf" by ·law :ii\ 1lntad'.mlnistroltvc and.judicial proec«ling: and
c. No_.party ~r pcirson.~ ~<? anl'·s~y~~proe~i~ c~~t,t\a..expre$sly
p.tmiided he'teln.
D~T,~D .thi, ....,,,.,.,.. day ~f~epte.mber 20 l S.
OJVENS:PURSLEY LLP- MCHUOB l3R.OMLEY~.PLt:.c.
By: ___________ By: ... Michael C.· Creamer Candice M . Mcffugh A1t<1rttaJ$/or Cil)I of Hailty Attontct)'t for Cit~ o/ .Bellev~
MOFF.AIT~ THOMAS, BARRETT~ ltOCl< & FIELDS;CH.AR1'EKED
BROWN.&JAM~
B.y: _____________ )3y: _____________ _
Matthew J. McGee Joseph F. James Attorney,Jo,.·Swt 'J'allty.Compa,iy AI/Qrtl~.ft/or JJlg &: Littlc. W-0tJd Water U.tcmt A,f,Tqe/ctth?n
JOJl'c'T MOTION FOR STAY .OF DEUVERY CALLS • p. 4
Sep 18 2815 11:34:24 288-388-13118 ->
MOORE SMITH BUXTON & TURCKE, CHTD.
2887362121 Giuens Pursely W Page 817
By: ___________ _
Susan B. Buxton All()rtHJysfor CJrl~ of KeJc//um a/Id Fai,tlild
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
J HEREBY CERTIFY that, on this _ day of 201 S, I served a true and ~orrect copy of the fore;oiog document to all parties listed on tbe Combined Certificate of Services List posted on the Department's website at http://jdwz.idah6.gov/legal•actions/delivezycaU-actioM'gis-wog4-river,html and hni,:l/idwr,i<kb2,sov/Jel&ll-a9tioJJs!delb~m-01Jlactions/littlc-wood-rlver1html updated th.e 19th day of August201,. by the following method:
0 Placing a copy of the docwnent in the United States mail. postage prepaid and properly addressed.
0 EmaUina only to parties who have consented to service by etnail as indicated on the above-described Certificate of Service List; placing a copy of the document in the United States mail, postage prepaid and properly addressed. to parties who have not consented to service by email; and emailing to parties wt,o provided email addresses to the Oepanment but have not consented to service by email.
Michael C .. Cresmer Attorneys for City of Hailey
JOINT MOTION FOR STAY OF DELIVERY CALLS • p. S