scss - e-sato.net · tomomi%sato tokai&gakuin&university kaoru%takahashi...

26
Proposal for a Computer System with Structured Chat and Social Stamp Functions to Support Social Reading for High School Students’ Essay-Writing Process SCSS(Structured Chat & Social Stamp ) Tomomi SATO Tokai Gakuin University Kaoru TAKAHASHI The University of Tokyo Toru FUJIMOTO The University of Tokyo Kiyoshi TAKAHASHI Benesse Corpora6on Masahiro YACHI Benesse Corpora6on Yuhei YAMAUCHI The University of Tokyo

Upload: others

Post on 09-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Proposal for a Computer System with Structured Chat and Social Stamp Functions

to Support Social Reading for High School Students’ Essay-Writing Process

SCSS(Structured Chat & Social Stamp )

Tomomi  SATO Tokai  Gakuin  University

Kaoru  TAKAHASHI The  University  of  Tokyo

Toru  FUJIMOTO The  University  of  Tokyo

Kiyoshi  TAKAHASHI Benesse  Corpora6on

Masahiro  YACHI Benesse  Corpora6on

Yuhei  YAMAUCHI The  University  of  Tokyo

Page 2: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Table Contents

ª  Background ª  Design Concept ª  Development of the System ª  Experiment and Evaluation ª  Summary

Page 3: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

~Examination Essays Test ~

1. Background

Question xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Comprehension xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Short Essays ********************** Students should write essay in response to a question **********************

Page 4: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

 Sono, M (2012) Social Reading Experiment: Stimulating reading behavior by sharing reading experience on electronic book,

 Graduate School of Media Design, Keio University: Master’s Thesis.

Social Reading Question xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Comprehension xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

important hard  to  understand

otherwise  notable

Page 5: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

The most popular social media applications for Japanese high school students.

LINE

Cite from LINE web. http://lineblog.naver.jp/archives/22378567.html

Page 6: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

SCSS The system with Structured Chat and Social Stamp

2.Purposes

Question xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Comprehension xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Social Reading Social Stamps

+

Structured chat +

Page 7: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

3.Social Stamps

The Characters of SCSS

MARK  Stamps

The  kind  of  comments

Changing  Appearance  of  Stamps  with  Increasing  

Number  of  Ideas “GOOD”  Stamp

Stamp    the  Good  comment

Gives  instrucJons

“Favorite”  Stamp

Selects  the  comment

Page 8: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Picking favorite ideas and comments

4.System Stage Question xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Comprehension xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Short Essays ********************** Students should write essay in response to a question **********************

Stage1

Stage3

Stage4

Stage2

Stage5 Understanding the questions

Achieving reading comprehension

Writing a short essay in the first person

Expressing ideas to answer the question

Page 9: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

4.System Stage

Stage1 Stage3 Stage4 Stage2 Stage5

Social Mode Personal Mode

Personal Mode But they can see other ideas

Personal Mode

Question xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Comprehension xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Short Essays ********************** Students should write essay in response to a question **********************

Page 10: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

System

Page 11: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage 1 Instructions from dad

Participant and Numbers of stumps

Comment

“GOOD” Stamp

Stumps Current Stages

Next Stage Button

Questions

Page 12: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage 2

Questions

Comprehension

Comment

Page 13: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage 3

Idea Pin Buttons

Idea Comments

Page 14: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage 4

Favorite Ideas

Participant tab

Page 15: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

The number of characters

Stage 5

Short essay

Questions Tab

Memo

Page 16: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Experiment

Page 17: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Time Schedule of the Experiment

PHASE STAGE MODE TIME (min)

Reading

1. Understanding the questions Personal mode 5 Social mode 5

2. Reading comprehension Personal mode 10 Social mode 5

3. Expressing Ideas Personal mode 15

4. Picking up and arranging content

Social mode 5

Personal mode 5

Writing 5. Writing a short essay Personal mode 50

Page 18: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Questionnaire about SCSS

Page 19: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

System

The  Number  of  ParJcipant  =  24

QuesJon Yes No  staJsJcal  difference  

1 Satisfied with SCSS 21 3 p<.01

2 Usability is good 20 4 p<.01

3 Stimulating and innovative 24 0 p<.01

4 System reaction is speedy 22 2 p<.01

Page 20: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Social Stamps

QuesJon Yes No  staJsJcal  difference  

1 Stamps feel friendly 17 7

2 Stamps are useful for learning 17 7

3 Stamps are useful for reading 14 10

4 Stamps are useful for comments 19 5 p<.05

5 Stamps are useful for ideas 13 11

The  Number  of  ParJcipant  =  24

Page 21: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage1 and Stage2

QuesJon Yes No staJsJcal  difference  

1 [Stage1] Function of Lines/comments is useful

21 3 p<.01

2 [Stage1] Others’comments are useful 21 3 p<.01

QuesJon Yes No staJsJcal  difference  

1 [Stage2] Function of Lines/comments are useful

22 2 p<.01

2 [Stage2] Others’ comments are useful 21 3 p<.01

The  Number  of  ParJcipant  =  24

Page 22: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage3 and Stage4

The  Number  of  ParJcipant  =  24

QuesJon Yes No 有意差

1 [Stage3] Function of Idea pins is useful 17 7

2 [Stage3] Others’ideas are useful 23 1 p<.01

QuesJon Yes No 有意差

1 [Stage4] Function of Retaining comments is useful

21 3 p<.01

2 [Stage4] Arranging comments is useful 18 6 p<.05

Page 23: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Stage5

The  Number  of  ParJcipant  =  24

QuesJon Yes No staJsJcal  difference  

1 [Stage5] Function of arranging thinking is useful for writing

18 6 p<.05

2 [Stage5] Character count is useful 23 1 p<.01

Page 24: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

•  We developed a system called SCSS to support the process of reading for essay writing.

• SCSS facilitates Social Reading, there are Structured Chat and Social Stamp functions.

5. Conclusion

Conclusion

Page 25: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

• SCSS was evaluated experimentally, and students found it useful for essay writing; furthermore, the structured chat and social stamp functions were useful for social reading.

•  Sharing ideas for writing essays make easier, and SCSS increased students’ enjoyment and concentration.

5. Conclusion

Conclusion

Page 26: SCSS - e-sato.net · Tomomi%SATO Tokai&Gakuin&University Kaoru%TAKAHASHI The&University&of&Tokyo Toru%FUJIMOTO The&University&of&Tokyo Kiyoshi%TAKAHASHI Benesse&Corporaon Masahiro%YACHI

Thank you for your kind attention!