scientist-local community interactions relations for aic… · willie goodwin alaska beluga whale...
TRANSCRIPT
Scientist-LocalCommunityInteractions
ReportforAICCMeetingNovember9-10,2016
Seattle
ChesapeakeBiologicalLaboratoryUniversityofMarylandCenterforEnvironmentalScience
ArcticWaterwaysSafetyCommittee(http://www.arcticwaterways.org/)
AreaofresponsibilityinmauveThemissionoftheArcticWaterwaysSafetyCommitteeistoimplementlawfulbestpracticestoensureasafe,efficient,andpredictableoperatingenvironmentforallArcticwaterwayusers.
Organizational Structure
Subsistence HuntersWillie Goodwin
Alaska Beluga Whale Committee
Harry Brower*George Noongwook
Alaska Eskimo Whaling Commission
John GoodwinAlaska Ice Seal Committee
Jack Omelak*Charles Brower
Alaska Nanuuq Commission
Vera Metcalf*Charles Brower
Eskimo Walrus Commission
IndustryDavid George, Shell
Oil and Gas
Greg Pavellas, CrowleyJim Dwight, Bowhead
Tug & Barge
TBDRegional Economic Development
TBDCommercial Fishing
TBDTourism
OtherMayor Denise Michels
City of Nome
Wendie SchaefferNorthwest Arctic Borough
Paul FuhsNorth Slope Borough
Austin Ahmasuk, KawerakRegional Tribal Organization
James BoyerAlaska Marine Pilots
Executive SecretaryJenny Evans
Ex-Officio ObserversDavid Pikul, State of Alaska; Capt. Ed Page, Marine Exchange of Alaska; CDR Hector Cintron, U.S. Coast Guard, Sector Anchorage;
Dr. Martin Robards, Science/NGO; Bob Poe, University of Alaska; OSRO/Marine Salvage
Willie GoodwinChairman
OfficersJames BoyerVice Chair
Jack OmelakTreasurer
Wendie SchaefferSecretary
* Alternates
Sub-Committees & ChairmanshipSubsistence: Harry Brower, Jr.
Standards of Lightering and Barge Operations: Jim Dwight & Greg PavellasScience: Dr. Martin Robards Infrastructure: Paul Fuhs & Denise Michels
ArcticWaterwaysSafetyCommittee
WorkshoponStrategiesandCommunicationProtocolstoMitigateImpactsofResearchVesselsonAlaskaNativeSubsistenceHuntsintheHighArctic
Anchorage,December10-11,2015
Follow-upMeeting,Juneau,March2-3,2016Informalmeetingwithscientistinvolvement
ArcticScienceSummitWeek,Fairbanks,March13andMarch16,2016
http://arcticwaterways.org
WhatisaStandardofCare?Intortlaw,thestandardofcareistheonlydegreeofprudenceandcautionrequiredofanindividualwhoisunderadutyofcare.Therequirementsofthestandardarecloselydependentoncircumstances.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_of_care“Whatseparatesacommonaccidentfromanactofnegligence,however,isthe"standardofcare"requiredinagivensituation.Byneglectingtheproperstandardofcareforagivensituation,anindividualmaybefoundliableforanyresultinginjuries.”Source:http://injury.findlaw.com/accident-injury-law/standards-of-care-and-the-reasonable-person.html
AICCcommentsonStandardofCareDocument
AICCcommentsondraftStandardofCaredocumentsubmittedbyBobCampbell,February25,2016
Revisedversioncommentssubmitted,October20,2016
Someofthemajorcriticismsrevolvedaroundunrealistictimelinesforcruiseplanningandthepotentialforsignificanttraveltomeetreportingrequirements,andotherfactorsthatscientistsmaynothavemuchcontrolover.NorthPacificResearchBoardhasalsocontributedcriticalsuggestions(perDanielleDickson)
MyconclusionisthatweneedaBestPracticesdocument,notaStandardofCare
Briefing Provided at PAG meetings 2016 meetings in Fairbanks, March 2016 (primarily about the Arctic Waterways Safety Committee and
need to communicate cruise plans to local communities)
Cruise information sharing for 2017, October 27, 2016
Sophia International Hotel Qingdao, China
Pacific Arctic Group (PAG): Informing our International Colleagues
h"p://pag.arc+cportal.org
Scienceaccessduringsubsistencewhaling:April-MayandSept-Octperiods-needtointerfacewithcoastalcommuni+es,contactAlaskaEskimoWhalingCommission,
EskimoWalrusCommission,andnewArc+cWaterwaysSafetyCommi"ee
[modifiedfromS.Danielsenmap2015]
NorthernBeringandSEChukchiSea
NEChukchiandBeaufortSea
Examples of one page summaries provided to Alaska Eskimo Whaling Commission, February
2016
Pacific Arctic Group (PAG):
h"p://pag.arc+cportal.org
Canada’sThreeOceans(C30)andtheDistributedBiologicalObservatory(DBO)Program
CCGSSirWilfridLaurier,July10-22,2016Ports:Victoria,BC,CanadatoBarrow,Alaska,USA
USDBOContact:JackieM.Grebmeier,ChesapeakeBiologicalLaboratory,UniversityofMarylandCenter
for Environmental Science, Solomons, MD 20688, USA; ph. 410-326-7334, fax 410-326-7302; email:
[email protected];CanadianChiefScientist:[email protected]
During the annual cruise of the Canadian Coast Guard icebreaker Sir Wilfrid Laurier from US into
Canadianwaters,weplantore-samplefiveregions(Figure1)extendingfromthenorthernBeringSeato
the northern Chukchi Sea as part of the Distributed Biological Observatory (DBO) program
www.arctic.noaa.gov/dbo/. We are tracking the seasonal and year to year changes in the marine
ecosystem, returning to the same “hotspots” of biological productivity each year. TheDBO has been
developedinthePacificArcticasa“changedetectionarray”sowecandocumentecosystemchangesas
seaicedisappearsearlier,returnslater,andtheoceanwarms.Thesefiveregionsareimportantfeeding
areasforPacificwalrus,beardedseals,bowheadwhales,anddivingseaducksatdifferenttimesofthe
year. Duringour cruise,wewill studywater column temperature and salinity, currents, nutrient and
chlorophyllcontent,phytoplankton,zooplanktonandbenthicspeciescomposition.Thedatawecollect
includes abundance and biomass, surface sediment characteristics, andmarinemammal and seabird
observations.Themapbelow (Figure1) shows theproposedsamplingduring July2016.Thesampling
withineachofthefiveregionstakes12-24hours,althoughsamplingforthehandfulofstations inthe
coastalzonebetween5-12milesfromshorearenormallycompletedwithin2hours.Wehopetohearof
anyconcernsorquestionsaboutourresearchplanfromlocalcommunities.Dataandotherinformation
on the research we have already completed as part of DBO effort are available at
http://www.arctic.noaa.gov/dbo/,butofcoursewewouldwelcometheopportunitytocomeinperson
tolocalcommunitiesasfundsandtimepermit.DBOstudiesarefundedbytheUSNationalOceanicand
AtmosphericAdministration,NationalScienceFoundationandothernationalgovernmentagencies.We
dothiswork incooperationwith internationalpartners includingscientistsonotherships fromChina,
Korea, Japan andRussia, in addition to theCanadian scientistswehaveworkedwith each year since
1998aboardtheSirWilfridLaurier.
Figure1.Mapandtimingofplanned
samplingsitesinJuly2016
• July14-southSt.LawrenceIsland
(DBO1)
• July15-ChirikovBasin(DBO2)
• July17:SEChukchiSea(DBO3)-
closeststation5milesfromcoast,
estimatetimewithin12milestobe
2hours
• July19:NEChukchiSeaoff
Wainwright(DBO4)-closeststation
30milesoffshore
• July20:offBarrow(DBO5)-closest
station5milesfromcoast,estimate
timewithin12milestobe2hours
Multidisciplinary.ocean.survey.in.the.western.Arctic.Ocean..
ARAON,&Aug&3&*&Aug&20,&2016:&Nome&to&Barrow,&Alaska&
&
&
Chief&Scientist:&Eun&Jin&Yang,&Department&of&Polar&Ocean&Environment,&Korea&Polar&Research& Institute,&
26,& Songdomirae*ro,& Yeonsu*gu,& Incheon,& 21990,& Republic& of& Korea;& ph.& 82*32*760*5334;& Email:&
&
The& icebreaker&ARAON&will&be& sampling&north&of& the&Bering&Sea,&Chukchi&Sea&and&East&Siberian&Sea&
from& Aug& 3& to& Aug& 20& during& the& summer& of& 2016.& The& objective& of& this& cruise& is& to& investigate& the&
structure&and&processes&in&the&water&column&and&subsurface&sediment&around&the&Pacific&Arctic&Ocean&in&
rapid& transition.& Another& objective& is& to& understand& sea& ice& dynamics& and& sea& ice& ecosystem& in& the&
Chukchi&Sea.&These&studies,& funded&by& the&Ministry&of&Oceans&and&Fisheries&and&Korea&Polar&Research&
Institute,&will&be&undertaken&by&a&team&of&scientists&from&the&Korea&Institute&of&Science&and&Technology&
Busan&National&University,&Inha&University,&Incheon&National&University,&Hanyang&university,&SAMS,&BAS,&
University&of&Seattle,&Ocean&University&of&China&and&Tokyo&University&of&Marine&Science&and&Technology.&
We&will& study& the&plankton& (bacteria,& phytoplankton&and& zooplankton),& phytoplankton&physiology& and&
pigments,&primary&production,&nutrients,&DOC,&POC,&PON,&DON,&pCO2,&DIC,&Amino&acid,& &N2O&gas,&black&
carbon,& interaction&between&water&column&and&atmosphere,&as&well&as&physical&oceanographic&studies&
of& the& currents& and& ice& conditions.& The& map& below& (Figure& 1)& shows& about& 40& stations& that& we& will&
sample& during& summer& 2016& that& are& similar& to& our& 2015& effort.& & Particularly,& & we& are& going& to& take&
samples&at&6&stations&in&DBO&line&3&between&4&and&6&August.&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
.
.Figure.1.&Map&of&our&proposed&sampling&sites&(2016&Arctic&Cruise)&&
!!
R/V Mirai Arctic Ocean cruise
22 Aug – 23 Sep, 2016: Shimizu (Japan) to Nome (Alaska) Chief Scientist: Shigeto Nishino Japan Agency for Marine-Earth Science and Technology (JAMSTEC) 2-15 Natsushima, Yokosuka, Kanagawa 237-0061, Japan Tel. +81-46-867-9487; Email: [email protected]
The Research Vessel Mirai (R/V Mirai) belonging to Japan Agency for Marine-Earth Science and Technology (JAMSTEC) will conduct hydrographic, marine biogeochemical, and meteorological surveys in the Arctic Ocean during September, 2016. The objective of this cruise is to quantify on-going changes in the ocean, atmosphere, and ecosystem, which are related to the recent Arctic warming and sea ice reduction.
The observational activities consist of CTD/XCTD/UCTD, drifting buoy deployments, mobile float observation with camera and sensors, optical measurements, water samplings, plankton net samplings, sediment samplings, visual observation of marine animals, wave and sea spray observations, ship-board ocean current and surface water monitorings, meteorological measurements and samplings, radiosondes, Doppler radar, sea bottom topography, gravity, and magnetic field measurements, and mooring and sediment trap recoveries and deployments.
Planned schedule is as follows. 22 Aug: Depart from Shimizu, Japan 2 Sep: Northern Bering Sea 3 Sep: Bering Strait 6 Sep: Northern Chukchi Sea 7 -16 Sep: Canada and Makarov Basins 17-20 Sep: Barrow Canyon 22 Sep: Bering Strait 23 Sep: Nome 4 Oct: Hachinohe, Japan 5 Oct: Sekinehama, Japan
Geographical areas of the intended work, locations of sampling stations, and cruise tracks of survey lines in the Arctic Ocean. Planned points of stationary observations are represented by blue dots. Locations of moorings and sediment traps are represented by red circles and yellow triangles, respectively. The stations and cruise tracks are subject to change due to weather, sea ice, and other conditions. Enlarged view near the Barrow.
Canada Korea Japan
2017PAGandDBOFieldPlan-DRAFTv1
2017PAGandDBOFieldSeason(10_27_16):SamplingContributors.ProjectsKey:AON=USArcticObservingNetwork(NationalScienceFoundation);ArCS=ArcticChallengeforSustainability;C30=Canada’sThreeOceans;CHINARE=ChineseArcticResearchExpedition;DBO=DistributedBiologicalObservatory,JAMSTEC=JapanAgencyforMarine-EarthScienceandTechnology;KOPRI=KoreaPolarResearchInstitute;NOAA=NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministration;OfficeofNavalResearch(ONR)MarginalIceZone(MIZ)project;PMEL=PacificMarineEnvironmentalLaboratory;RUSALCA=Russian-AmericanLong-termCensusoftheArctic.DBORegionKey:DBO1=So.St.LawrenceIs.,DBO2=ChirikovBasin,DBO3=SoChukchiSea,DBO4=NEChukchiSea,DBO5=BarrowCanyon,DBO6=EastBeaufortSea,DBO7-BeaufortSeaCentral,DBO8=Bathurstpolynyaregion.Dates(Portcalls) Ship DBORegion Projects PAGcontact ChiefScientistMay-June Sikuliaq 2,3 ASGARD SethDanielson SethDanielsonJuly(Nome-Nome) NorsemanII 3 BeringStraitMooring
Project/[email protected]
July1-22(Victoria,BC-Barrow)
SirWilfridLaurier
1,2,3,4,5 C30/DBO(AON) [email protected]
August TBD 3,4 ArcticEIS2 [email protected]
Aug5-25Aug27-Sept10
Araon
3+ChukchiBorderland+EastSiberianSeaChukchiBorderland
KoreanExpedition(KOPRI)oceanandSea-iceresearchesGeophysical/paleoceano-graphicresearches
[email protected]@kopri.re.kr
Sept1-14 Healy 3,4,5 ARPDBOandSBE [email protected]
Sept16-Oct15 Healy - Navy -NA Navy
Aug22-Oct5 Mirai 3,5+ArcticBasin
JapaneseArCS [email protected]
August TBD 3,4,5 NOAA/PMEL [email protected] [email protected] Sikuliaq 3,4,5,6 ArcticNFixation
ArcticProductivity/[email protected].
[email protected];RachelSipler
Aug24-Oct4 OscarDysonF/VCapeFlattery
12
NOAA/AFSC/EMA/FOCI [email protected] [email protected]
Oct3-11 SirWilfridLaurier
4,8 C30 [email protected] [email protected]
Oct-Nov Sikuliaq ArcticBasin ONRAcoustics M.Badley/ArcticShelf-Basin/SonarPerformance
Navy/ONR
ArcticShelfGrowth,Advection,RespirationandDepositionRateExperiment(ASGARD):UAF(Lead:SethDanielson):June2017and2018(NPRB)
DBO2
DBO3
Canada’sThreeOceans(C30)andtheDistributedBiologicalObservatory(DBO):CCGSSirWilfridLaurier,July10-22,2017
• Seawatertemperatureandsalinity;velocitymeasurements• Nutrients,chlorophyll,carbonproducts,CDOM• Phytoplankton,zooplanktonandmacrobenthicabundance,
biomass,communitystructure• Marinemammalandseabirdsurveys
DBOdatacollecQons Contact:Dr.SveinVagle,CanadianChiefScienQst,JackieGrebmeier,UMCESandPAG,[email protected]
DBO1
DBO2
DBO3
DBO4
Focus:samplingalonglaQtudinaltransectlinesdevelopedasa“changedetecQonarray”forconsistentmonitoringofbiophysicalresponsestochangingenvironmentalcondiQons
EsQmatedTimeline:• July14-southSt.LawrenceIsland
(DBO1)(5process,4CTDonlY)• July15-ChirikovBasin(DBO2)-add7
sta+ons(4CTDonly)• July17:SEChukchiSea(DBO3)-closest
sta+on5nmfromcoast,es+mate+mewithin12nmtobe2hrs
• July19:NEChukchiSeaoffWainwright(DBO4)-closeststa+on30nmoffshore
• July20:offBarrow(DBO5)-closeststa+on5nmfromcoast,es+mate+mewithin12nmtobe2hrs
DBO5
ArcQcMarineBiodiversityObservingNetwork(AMBON);NOAA/BOEM/ShellAugust2017(eitherSikuliaqorNorsemanII)-occupyDBO3and4
[fromS.Danielsenmap2015]
• LeadKatrinIken(UAF);Co-PIs:SethDanielson,EricCollins,RussHopcroft,FranzMueter
• co-PIS:JackieGrebmeier,LeeCooper(CBL/UMCES
• SueMoore(NOAA),KathyKuletz(USFWS)
• T/S• Chlorophyll,nutrients• Phytoplanktonand
zooplanktoncomposition
• Macrofaunaandepifauna
• Fishes• Marinemammaland
seabirdsurvers
Sipler/Juranek(OSU)2016(?2017)Augustcruise(DBO3,4,5,6)
DBO3
DBO4DBO6
DBO5
ArcticEcosystemIntegratedSurvey:ArcticEIS2(NOAA)-August/Sept2017and2019August
DBO3
[NOAAandNPRB]
2017DRAFTPlansDBOandNorthernChukchiSeaShelf-BasinExchangeStudy-NOAAArcQcResearchProgram(WHOI,UMCESandNOAAPMEL)-Aug/Sept(BClinepriorto
Sept15) FieldMeasurements:StandardDBO
measurementsandprocessstudies(DBOandBarrowCanyonregion):• Physical:CTDandloweredADCP• Chemical:nutrients,oxygen-18,
chlorophyll-a(Chla),carboncomponents
• Biological:zooplankton(abundanceandbiomass,growthrates)
• Benthos:macrobenthosabundance,biomassandpopula+onstructure,
• Sediment:organiccarbon/nitrogencontent,chlacontent,grainsize,Cs-137andPb-210content;benthicoxygenuptakeandnutrientexchange
• Uppertrophiclevels:marinemammalshipboardsurveys
NSFAward#1637688toSitkaSoundScienceCenter
AlaskaScienceCommunicationWorkshop,October31-November2,2016
LisaBusch,leadPI“goalofimprovingthecommunicationskillsofArcticresearcherssothattheycaneffectivelyconveythegoalsandresultsoftheirresearchtoruralandAlaskaNativeaudiences.”
AlaskaScienceCommunicationWorkshop,October31-November2,2016
Participant“Inspire”talksatMt.EdgecumbeHighSchoolVisittoPublicradiostationKCAWinSitkaDiscussionswithSitkaNativeTribeoninitiatingresearchprojects