sc12-2522 reply to response - supreme court of florida...ekctronicallv j,lal 10/15/2013 04:37:47 pm...
TRANSCRIPT
Ekctronicallv Jlal 10152013 043747 PM E[
REC l-]]middotI) lailS2H]3 lb384 Th0mus I) liall Clerk Supreme C0uri
GARY RICHARD WHITTON
Peti tioner
MICHAEL D CREWS Secretary Fla Dept of Corrections
Responder t
REPLY TO RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS
COUNSEL FOR APPELLANT
J
] J j
I I
S (_ - _ l S plusmnf I _
_r
C i 1 n C
he p o iuml n ce cons j ec b e
taacutete w I in a nut u I la i no cas S AcircIQUll( I t a OTDOy J t iplusmnses
Ore i1 1 DOel ir1 is Sliitch was L fleSS J1 tr 3_ a
s Reqta by middotlo SlaLui
o z ple v State 1 S 2d 9 196 E
e -1n anniImi L tre h ae a er s iuml-i ad1c
Statee So2 191 ( sinti
e cou V reumlegravel
bv I l 1 t]-_DV
e w i) i l re
1s therr 1cted
Or xiacuteena
t a t_
1
r i ue
I -]r) d ( - c C
cal_ t nswers 1 uuestic von corroc Liv -shy outsiae the
ecora e tr Ls mrmncat_1n w Lne
WS r F 1 flO ilTDr S i O-Z ci I) crfiVlac
c
c_ _Igrave
T a iuml i _ _ - J _ _ C Ol r i l auml ^_
-- _ - -1 - tshy - - - - q -shy -- -shy
J _ S ( | t i 8 l) _ l ) i
tG W i l i fiO -T GTO
Cl t t C I iuml | i lI 5 I i 1 W O 8
US 1 C T
H OW - O I 2 O i l l S W 1 040 Wfla
tshy l H w id h cJe q t thO t te W r1 h I
I l31OS W 1 I_O O r (V | 1idO ^ Llese
r - r -
n u 0 at 3959 r r reca
llO O J ll 1 I i W Flu eS d570 TIle OIgraveiumlHI
y
tOSpilG Lhe IacuteJt l l ) il L hO way Lhi l t and_Od
1 e
| | -
132 O a I L 4udges I n iumle
1
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
J
] J j
I I
S (_ - _ l S plusmnf I _
_r
C i 1 n C
he p o iuml n ce cons j ec b e
taacutete w I in a nut u I la i no cas S AcircIQUll( I t a OTDOy J t iplusmnses
Ore i1 1 DOel ir1 is Sliitch was L fleSS J1 tr 3_ a
s Reqta by middotlo SlaLui
o z ple v State 1 S 2d 9 196 E
e -1n anniImi L tre h ae a er s iuml-i ad1c
Statee So2 191 ( sinti
e cou V reumlegravel
bv I l 1 t]-_DV
e w i) i l re
1s therr 1cted
Or xiacuteena
t a t_
1
r i ue
I -]r) d ( - c C
cal_ t nswers 1 uuestic von corroc Liv -shy outsiae the
ecora e tr Ls mrmncat_1n w Lne
WS r F 1 flO ilTDr S i O-Z ci I) crfiVlac
c
c_ _Igrave
T a iuml i _ _ - J _ _ C Ol r i l auml ^_
-- _ - -1 - tshy - - - - q -shy -- -shy
J _ S ( | t i 8 l) _ l ) i
tG W i l i fiO -T GTO
Cl t t C I iuml | i lI 5 I i 1 W O 8
US 1 C T
H OW - O I 2 O i l l S W 1 040 Wfla
tshy l H w id h cJe q t thO t te W r1 h I
I l31OS W 1 I_O O r (V | 1idO ^ Llese
r - r -
n u 0 at 3959 r r reca
llO O J ll 1 I i W Flu eS d570 TIle OIgraveiumlHI
y
tOSpilG Lhe IacuteJt l l ) il L hO way Lhi l t and_Od
1 e
| | -
132 O a I L 4udges I n iumle
1
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
Ore i1 1 DOel ir1 is Sliitch was L fleSS J1 tr 3_ a
s Reqta by middotlo SlaLui
o z ple v State 1 S 2d 9 196 E
e -1n anniImi L tre h ae a er s iuml-i ad1c
Statee So2 191 ( sinti
e cou V reumlegravel
bv I l 1 t]-_DV
e w i) i l re
1s therr 1cted
Or xiacuteena
t a t_
1
r i ue
I -]r) d ( - c C
cal_ t nswers 1 uuestic von corroc Liv -shy outsiae the
ecora e tr Ls mrmncat_1n w Lne
WS r F 1 flO ilTDr S i O-Z ci I) crfiVlac
c
c_ _Igrave
T a iuml i _ _ - J _ _ C Ol r i l auml ^_
-- _ - -1 - tshy - - - - q -shy -- -shy
J _ S ( | t i 8 l) _ l ) i
tG W i l i fiO -T GTO
Cl t t C I iuml | i lI 5 I i 1 W O 8
US 1 C T
H OW - O I 2 O i l l S W 1 040 Wfla
tshy l H w id h cJe q t thO t te W r1 h I
I l31OS W 1 I_O O r (V | 1idO ^ Llese
r - r -
n u 0 at 3959 r r reca
llO O J ll 1 I i W Flu eS d570 TIle OIgraveiumlHI
y
tOSpilG Lhe IacuteJt l l ) il L hO way Lhi l t and_Od
1 e
| | -
132 O a I L 4udges I n iumle
1
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
Statee So2 191 ( sinti
e cou V reumlegravel
bv I l 1 t]-_DV
e w i) i l re
1s therr 1cted
Or xiacuteena
t a t_
1
r i ue
I -]r) d ( - c C
cal_ t nswers 1 uuestic von corroc Liv -shy outsiae the
ecora e tr Ls mrmncat_1n w Lne
WS r F 1 flO ilTDr S i O-Z ci I) crfiVlac
c
c_ _Igrave
T a iuml i _ _ - J _ _ C Ol r i l auml ^_
-- _ - -1 - tshy - - - - q -shy -- -shy
J _ S ( | t i 8 l) _ l ) i
tG W i l i fiO -T GTO
Cl t t C I iuml | i lI 5 I i 1 W O 8
US 1 C T
H OW - O I 2 O i l l S W 1 040 Wfla
tshy l H w id h cJe q t thO t te W r1 h I
I l31OS W 1 I_O O r (V | 1idO ^ Llese
r - r -
n u 0 at 3959 r r reca
llO O J ll 1 I i W Flu eS d570 TIle OIgraveiumlHI
y
tOSpilG Lhe IacuteJt l l ) il L hO way Lhi l t and_Od
1 e
| | -
132 O a I L 4udges I n iumle
1
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
c_ _Igrave
T a iuml i _ _ - J _ _ C Ol r i l auml ^_
-- _ - -1 - tshy - - - - q -shy -- -shy
J _ S ( | t i 8 l) _ l ) i
tG W i l i fiO -T GTO
Cl t t C I iuml | i lI 5 I i 1 W O 8
US 1 C T
H OW - O I 2 O i l l S W 1 040 Wfla
tshy l H w id h cJe q t thO t te W r1 h I
I l31OS W 1 I_O O r (V | 1idO ^ Llese
r - r -
n u 0 at 3959 r r reca
llO O J ll 1 I i W Flu eS d570 TIle OIgraveiumlHI
y
tOSpilG Lhe IacuteJt l l ) il L hO way Lhi l t and_Od
1 e
| | -
132 O a I L 4udges I n iumle
1
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
I l31OS W 1 I_O O r (V | 1idO ^ Llese
r - r -
n u 0 at 3959 r r reca
llO O J ll 1 I i W Flu eS d570 TIle OIgraveiumlHI
y
tOSpilG Lhe IacuteJt l l ) il L hO way Lhi l t and_Od
1 e
| | -
132 O a I L 4udges I n iumle
1
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
aw Le prwodra aspo e affe t q the su la]
C Appellant Counsel Acted Unreasonably and Prejudicially
i i 1-10 JI lSogravepoundJ l ( i ] I p t | JO _f lf
ea t t
OMTt
L li t i lIgraveiugravel 1 i l -1( OpoundUacute Tiacutemiddotl ( tlGd SS Tiilmiddotl1 uumlS D- Wriat
seal ld iquest_ave Lan gran m (or its u m appe ) and
I i-middot V 8 pound S - W middot i I ri ucirc O _i i i j j l G G u f L J
CONCLUSION AND RELIEF REQUESTE_D
1
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(
U COrISI1 ml Oliauml V ChiOrigrave ill G en tath r or
i Carol
ett
1
l
oev
a
heno
has acol
we
it
p
^ris
1er
Caro
i u
ci 12SSC(