sbd airport services llc -- order dismissing bk case
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
1/9
1OZDIZ OF I@IZMIFKW @OTGOF TO DG[@G[[ Gf zi [JD Agz~ozt [izsgki{% EEK% Dijto
1
:
;
4
9
3
=
2
7
1>
11
1:
1;
14
19
13
1=
12
17
:>
:1
::
:;
:4
:9
:3
:=
:2[AESATO EA]OCCGKI[
MZIMOZW @& [AESATO "[JF 1:3:29'LO[I^B JOYCADIE "[JF :3=;1:'[AESATO EA] OCCGKI[]iee{ Cazmo Kiftiz;99 [oytb Mzafd Asifyi% [ygti :49>Eo{ Afmiei{% Kaegcozfga 7>>=1-79>>
Tiei~bofi< ":1;' 424-24>>Cak{g`gei< ":1;' 4>:-;==2I-`age< M{aesatoN[aesatoea}occgki{&ko`
Attozfiw{ coz Kzidgtoz / Ei{{oz[AF JIZFAZDGFO GFTIZFATGOFAE AGZ^OZTAYTBOZGTW% a Kaegcozfga Logft ^o}iz{ Aytbozgtw
YFGTID [TATI[ JAFHZY^TKW KOYZT
KIFTZAE DG[TZGKT OC KAEGCOZFGA
ZGSIZ[GDI
Gf zi1:TG@I< 1> ~&`&^EAKI< Koyztzoo` ;>4
;4:> T}iectb [tziitZgsiz{gdi% KA 7:9>1
Of tbi I`izmifkw @otgof jw kzidgtoz /ei{{oz [af Jizfazdgfo Gftizfatgofae Agz~ozt
Aytbozgtw "[JGAA' coz af Ozdiz Dg{`g{{gfm oz Kofsiztgfm Ka{i afd Otbiz Ziegic "tbi
@otgof' {kbidyeid coz biazgfm of tbg{ dati% Mzimozw @& [aesato% I{q& a~~iazid of
jibaec oc [JGAA% @gkbaie L& Jyloed% I{q& a~~iazid of jibaec oc tbi Yfgtid [tati{ Tzy{tii
Dasgd J& Moeyjkbgh% I{q& a~~iazid a{ af ad`gfg{tzatgsi kzidgtoz ofew% afd tbizi }a{ fo
a~~iazafki coz tbi Dijtoz& Ja{id y~of tbi zi~zi{iftatgof{ oc koyf{ie afd tbi isgdifki
{yj`gttid gf tbi @otgof% gfkeydgfm "1' tbi Fotgki{ oc Kafkieatgof oc tbi Dijtoz{
CGEID # IFTIZID
OKT 17 :>1:
KEIZH Y&[& JAFHZY^TKW KOYZT
Kiftzae Dg{tzgkt oc Kaegcozfga
JW DI^YTW KEIZHdif{of
KBAFMI[ @ADI JW KOYZT
Ka{i 34-D[ Dok 1>= Cgeid 1>/17/1: Iftizid 1>/17/1: 14
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
2/9
:OZDIZ OF I@IZMIFKW @OTGOF TO DG[@G[[ Gf zi [JD Agz~ozt [izsgki{% EEK% Dijto
1
:
;
4
9
3
=
2
7
1>
11
1:
1;
14
19
13
1=
12
17
:>
:1
::
:;
:4
:9
:3
:=
:2[AESATO EA]OCCGKI[
gf{yzafki ~oegkgi{% ":' tbi cakt tbat tbi Dijtoz{ eimae koyf{ie ba{ }gtbdza}f a{ koyf{ie
coz tbi Dijtoz a{ a~~zosid jw Ozdiz iftizid of Oktojiz 11% :>1: XDht& Fo& 77P afd tbi
Dijtoz ba{ fot zitagfid otbiz koyf{ie% ";' tbi {yj`g{{gof oc isgdifki jw tbi Dijtoz{
Kbgic Zi{tzyktyzgfm Occgkiz% Az`if Asidg{{gaf% tbat tbi Dijtoz{ ziqygzid di~o{gt{ gfto a
{imzimatid Dijtoz gf ^o{{i{{gof Akkoyft coz zift of tbi CJO Eia{i coz tbi `oftb{ oc
Aymy{t afd [i~ti`jiz% :>1:% basi jiif zityzfid coz fof-{yccgkgift cyfd{ XDht& Fo& 1>>P%
afd "4' zi~zi{iftatgof{ tbat @z& Asidg{{gaf ba{ zi{gmfid czo` bg{ ~o{gtgof a{ tbi Dijtoz{
Kbgic Zi{tzyktyzgfm Occgkiz icciktgsi Oktojiz 1:% :>1:% afd% ja{id y~of tbi
ziko``ifdatgof oc tbi Yfgtid [tati{ Tzy{tii% afd coz otbiz mood kay{i% gfkeydgfm tbi
iftgzi zikozd oc tbi jafhzy~tkw ka{i%
GT G[ BIZIJW OZDIZID-daw
jaz to afw cytyzi jafhzy~tkw cgegfm{ jw tbi Dijtoz8~zosgdid% bo}isiz% tbat
:& Tbi coeeo}gfm amzii`ift{ jit}iif [JGAA afd tbi Dijtoz% oz ~yz~oztidew
a{{gmfid to afd a{{y`id ~zi-~itgtgof jw tbi Dijtoz "Amzii`ift{'% azi bizijw
dii`id ziliktid a{ oc Oktojiz 19% :>1:>=% gfkeydgfm aee a`ifd`ift{ afd
o~tgof{ zieatid tbizito "tbi CJO Eia{i'8
j& Mzoyfd Bafdegfm [izsgki{ Amzii`ift% datid Lyfi 1% :>>7% afd afw
a`ifd`ift{ tbizito "Mzoyfd Bafdegfm Amzii`ift'8
k& Eia{i Amzii`ift coz Jygedgfm 3=9% datid Lyfi 1% :>>7% afd afw
a`ifd`ift{ tbizio "Jygedgfm 3=9 Eia{i'8
d& Eia{i Amzii`ift coz Kiztagf Agz~ozt Mzoyfd Bafdegfm Cakgegtgi{% datid
Lyfi 1% :>>7% a{ a`ifdid "Mzoyfd Bafdegfm Cakgegtgi{ Eia{i'8 afd
i& Iqyg~`ift afd Sibgkei Eia{i Amzii`ift% datid Lyfi 1% :>>7% a{
a`ifdid "Iqyg~`ift Eia{i Amzii`ift'8
;& Tbi Y{i afd Egkif{i Amzii`ift coz [JGAA-o}fid Cyie Tzykh{% datid @aw 14
Ka{i 34-D[ Dok 1>= Cgeid 1>/17/1: Iftizid 1>/17/1: 14
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
3/9
;OZDIZ OF I@IZMIFKW @OTGOF TO DG[@G[[ Gf zi [JD Agz~ozt [izsgki{% EEK% Dijto
1
:
;
4
9
3
=
2
7
1>
11
1:
1;
14
19
13
1=
12
17
:>
:1
::
:;
:4
:9
:3
:=
:2[AESATO EA]OCCGKI[
:>1: "Egkif{i Amzii`ift'% a~~zosid jw Ozdiz oc tbi Jafhzy~tkw Koyzt of
@aw 14% :>1: XAds& Dht& Fo& ;=P afd koftgfyid gf iccikt jw [tg~yeatgof afd
Ozdiz{ iftizid of Lyfi 17% :>1:% afd [i~ti`jiz 11% :>1: XAds& Dht& Fo{& 41%
43P g{ ozdizid tiz`gfatid afd kafkieeid afd tbi Dijtoz g{ ozdizid to
g``idgatiew diegsiz ~o{{i{{gof to [JGAA oc aee oc tbi sibgkei{ afd iqyg~`ift
di{kzgjid gf tbat Egkif{i Amzii`ift8
4& Tbi Dijtoz g{ ozdizid g``idgatiew to diegsiz to [JGAA ~o{{i{{gof oc tbi
coeeo}gfm cakgegtgi{ tbat azi tbi {yjlikt oc tbi ziliktid Amzii`ift{% gfkeydgfm
diegsizw oc aee hiw{ bied jw tbi Dijtoz% coz tbi coeeo}gfm28
j& Koz~ozati Bafmaz% eokatid at :>:= I& ^izg`itiz Zoad% [af Jizfazdgfo%
Kaegcozfga 7:4>28
k& Bafmaz 3=4% eokatid at ::9 F& Eieafd Foztof ]aw% [af Jizfazdgfo%
Kaegcozfga 7:4>28
d& Jygedgfm 3=4 Occgki% eokatid at :9= Eieafd Foztof ]aw% [af
Jizfazdgfo% Kaegcozfga 7:4>28
i& Y&[& Ky{to`{ Jygedgfm% gfkeydgfm occgki {~aki of tbi tbgzd ceooz% eokatid
at :=9 F& Eieafd Foztof ]aw% [af Jizfazdgfo% Kaegcozfga 7:4>28
c& Jygedgfm 3=9% eokatid at 129 F& Eieafd Foztof ]aw% [af Jizfazdgfo%
Kaegcozfga 7:4>28
m& Bafmaz ;41% Bafmaz ;;;% Jygedgfm Fo& ;;7% eokatid at :279 Y [tziit%
[af Jizfazdgfo% Kaegcozfga 7:4>28 afd
b& Aee otbiz cakgegtgi{% ~zi`g{i{% sibgkei{ afd iqyg~`ift di{kzgjid gf tbi
Amzii`ift{ {it coztb ajosi oz otbiz}g{i o}fid jw [JGAA afd gf tbi
~o{{i{{gof oc tbi Dijtoz oz gt{ accgegati{&
9& Tbi cyfd{ bied gf tbi {imzimatid Dijtoz-gf-^o{{i{{gof akkoyft i{tajeg{bid coz
tbi di~o{gt{ oc ~o{t-~itgtgof zift ~awajei coz tbi CJO Eia{i ~yz{yaft to tbi
Ka{i 34-D[ Dok 1>= Cgeid 1>/17/1: Iftizid 1>/17/1: 14
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
4/9
4OZDIZ OF I@IZMIFKW @OTGOF TO DG[@G[[ Gf zi [JD Agz~ozt [izsgki{% EEK% Dijto
1
:
;
4
9
3
=
2
7
1>
11
1:
1;
14
19
13
1=
12
17
:>
:1
::
:;
:4
:9
:3
:=
:2[AESATO EA]OCCGKI[
tiz`{ oc jw Ozdiz iftizid Lyew :>% :>1: XDht& Fo& =7P "tbi [imzimatid DG^
Akkoyft' {baee ji g``idgatiew diegsizid to Mzimozw @& [aesato% I{q&% koyf{ie
coz [JGAA% to ji bied gf a Kegift Tzy{t Akkoyft ~ifdgfm cyztbiz Ozdiz oc tbi
Koyzt8
3& A biazgfm {baee ji bied gf tbg{ Koyzt of Diki`jiz 3% :>1:% at 1> ~&`& of tbi
a~~egkatgof coz cii{ jw ad`gfg{tzatgsi ~zoci{{gofae{ afd afw ad`gfg{tzatgsi
keag` jw [JGAA8 afd
a& Tbi 49 daw fotgki oc biazgfm ~yz{yaft to Eokae Zyei :>13-1":'coz
~zoci{{gofae{ {baee ji ~zosgdid jw Dasgd Moeyjkbgh% I{q&8 afd
j& Afw keag` coz ~aw`ift czo` tbi [imzimatid DG^ Akkoyft {baee ji cgeid
fot eatiz tbaf :1 daw{ gf adsafki oc tbi biazgfm of Diki`jiz 3% :>1:8
=& Tbi Adsiz{azw ^zokiidgfm iftgteid [JD Agz~ozt [izsgki{% EEK s& [af
Jizfazdgfo Gftizfatgofae Agz~ozt Aytbozgtw% it ae&% Ka{i Fo& 311;>-D[%
gfkeydgfm tbi Ko`~eagft afd tbi Koyftizkeag` cgeid jw [JGAA "tbi Adsiz{azw
^zokiidgfm' {baee zi`agf o~if yftge af ozdiz g{ iftizid dg{`g{{gfm oz
zi`afdgfm tbi Adsiz{azw ^zokiidgfm& Aee Ozdiz{ iftizid gf tbi Adsiz{azw
^zokiidgfm% gfkeydgfm tbi Ozdiz iftizid @aw 14% :>1: XAds& Dht& Fo& ;=P
kofcgz`gfm tbi tiz`gfatgof oc tbi Cyie [izsgki @afami`ift Amzii`ift datid
@azkb :;% :>>=% a{ a`ifdid% {baee zi`agf gf iccikt a{ cgfae Ozdiz{ oc tbi
Jafhzy~tkw Koyzt8
2& Lydm`ift g{ iftizid gf casoz oc tbi Yfgtid [tati{ Tzy{tii afd amagf{t tbi Dijtoz
gf tbi a`oyft oc $7=9&>> coz yf~agd qyaztizew cii{% zi~zi{iftgfm tbi {y` oc
$39>&>> coz tbi Tbgzd Qyaztiz oc :>1: afd $;:9&>> coz tbi Coyztb Qyaztiz oc
:>1:8
7& Tbg{ Ozdiz g{ icciktgsi g``idgatiew ~yz{yaft to Zyei 7>:1 oc tbi Cidizae Zyei
oc Jafhzy~tkw ^zokidyzi afd g{ fot {yjlikt to afw {taw a{ to gt{ icciktgsifi{{
yfdiz CZJ^ =>3: oz otbiz}g{i8
//
Ka{i 34-D[ Dok 1>= Cgeid 1>/17/1: Iftizid 1>/17/1: 14
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
5/9
9OZDIZ OF I@IZMIFKW @OTGOF TO DG[@G[[ Gf zi [JD Agz~ozt [izsgki{% EEK% Dijto
1
:
;
4
9
3
=
2
7
1>
11
1:
1;
14
19
13
1=
12
17
:>
:1
::
:;
:4
:9
:3
:=
:2[AESATO EA]OCCGKI[
1>&Tbg{ Jafhzy~tkw Koyzt {baee zitagf lyzg{dgktgof oc aee `attiz{ kofti`~eatid
bizigf a{ fiki{{azw to kazzw oyt tbi iccikt oc tbg{ Ozdiz&
+++
Yfgtid [tati{ Jafhzy~tkw LydmiDATID< Oktojiz 17% :>1:
Ka{i 34-D[ Dok 1>= Cgeid 1>/17/1: Iftizid 1>/17/1: 14
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
6/9
Gf zi4
Zgsiz{gdi% Kaegcozfga 7:9>1
Az`if Asidg{{gaf
Asidg{{gaf # A{{okgati{;19 Azdif Asifyi% [ygti :2Meifdaei% Kaegcozfga 71:>;-119>
A&L& ]ge{of[af Jizfazdgfo Gftizfatgofae Agz~ozt1>9 F& Eieafd Foztof ]aw[af Jizfazdgfo% KA 7:4>2
Zgkbazd A Mzafo}gt|;;> F *D* [t [ti ;>>[af Jizfazdgfo% KA 7:4>1
[izsgki gfcoz`atgof koftgfyid of attakbid ~ami
Ka{i 34-D[ Dok 1>= Cgeid 1>/17/1: Iftizid 1>/17/1: 14
-
7/31/2019 SBD Airport Services LLC -- Order dismissing BK case
7/9
Gf zi