sail valuation

16
CIMP Steel authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED (SAIL) (Firm Analysis) Presented to Prof. Amit Parakh By: Ankita Sarni- PGDBA-01/06 Anurag-PGDBA-01/08 (Chandragupt Institute of Management, Patna)

Upload: anuragchoubey1

Post on 13-Nov-2014

945 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Firm Valuation of SAIL by DCF method, done by Ankita Sarni & Anurag Choubey as academic project on Valuation at Chandragupt Institute of Management Patna (CIMP). Extensive explanation of the steps is given in this.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

Steel authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED (SAIL)

(Firm Analysis)

Presented to

Prof. Amit Parakh

By:

Ankita Sarni- PGDBA-01/06

Anurag-PGDBA-01/08

(Chandragupt Institute of Management, Patna)

Page 2: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

2 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

INDIAN STEEL INDUSTRY:

Steel Industry in India is on an upswing because of the strong global and domestic demand in 2008, the

total amount of domestic steel consumption was 43.925 million tones. With the increased demand in the

national market, a huge part of the international market is also served by this industry.

India is the seventh largest steel producer in the world and, India's rapid economic growth and soaring

demand by sectors like infrastructure, real estate and automobiles, at home and abroad, has put Indian

steel industry on the global map. The outlook for Indian steel industry is very bright. India's lower

wages and favorable energy prices will continue to promise substantial cost advantages compared to

production facilities in (Western) Europe or the US.

OPPORTUNITIES FOR SAIL DUE TO MACROECONOMIC FACTORS:

The Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India (ASSOCHAM) has projected

that the domestic steel industry would grow by 10 to 12%

The scope for raising the total consumption of steel is huge in India as the per capita steel

consumption is only 35 kg (compared to 150 kg across the world and 250 kg in China) and is

estimated at 44 kg in 2008-09 and projected to reach 54 kg by the end of 2011-12.

The government has removed full exemption of customs duty on Iron and steel products like

pig iron, spiegeleisen from 15% to 5%.

In the Union Budget 2009-10, the government has made a 23 per cent hike in allocation for

highway development and US$ 1.034 billion increase in budgetary support to Railways which

will further promote the steel industry.

The reduction in railway freight has also benefitted the domestic iron ore miners.

SAIL - FUTURE GROWTH PLANS:

SAIL is going to own 65 warehouse and 2,500 strong dealership network to tap the rural

market which has very high growth perspective.

SAIL is putting huge capital expenditure of around Rs.50,000 crore to add 10 million tonnes of capacity and achieve operational effectiveness. The company plans to achieve entire production through BOF steel making (currently at 78% of production) and continuous casting route (currently at 64% of production).

Sail is gradually implementing alternative fuel injection methods like coal dust/tar injection in all the blast furnaces

SAIL has been pursuing cost saving methods like implementation of modern techniques of

processing. and thus, in2008-09 they were able to save Rs 725 crore which helped in increasing

the profit margin.

Page 3: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

3 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Projects worth around Rs 28,000 crore are in various stages of implementation. This includes

ongoing 28 numbers of projects worth more than Rs 2,800 crore spread over six production

units across the country.

SAIL is ready to own the 2,028-hectare block in the Rowghat iron ore mine deposits in

Chhattisgarh to feed its flagship unit, the Bhilai Steel Plant.

They are developing two major mechanised iron ore mines – at Rowghat in the western

region and Chiria in the east. Both the mines will be developed with latest technology to

ensure assured supply of required quantity of quality iron ore to SAIL plants.

They are also planning to set up a pellet plants (one at Bhilai and another near Manoharpur),

which would enable utilisation of huge iron ore fines generated during the mining operations,

apart from reducing cost of hot metal production which help in generation of revenue from the

waste materials.

SAIL is providing customized services to its clients.

TRENDS OF SALES AND GROSS PROFIT FOR PAST 5 YEARS:

32,569.53 33,220.7840,291.75

46,261.05 49,739.74

10,492.30 6,913.0410,634.10 12,390.96 10,672.55

Mar ' 05 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 09

Sales and gross profit

Sales Gross profit

Page 4: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

4 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SAIL WITH ITS COMPETITORS:

SAIL TATA JSW Ispat Bhushan steel Industry

P/E 10.99 6.04 28.27 -4.07 11.58 10.56

P/BV 9.13 1.45 1.75 1.53 2.94 3.36

ROE 22.06 21.10 5.59 5.13 26.07 15.99

P/Sales 7.62 5.98 3.27 2.06 4.25 4.64 Net Profit margin 13.40 21.09 3.23 0.41 10.09 9.64

COMPARISON OF SAIL’S STOCK GROWTH VIS -VIS SENSEX GROWTH:

Page 5: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

5 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

COMPARITIVE CHART SHOWING GROWTH TREND OF SAIL VS TATA STEEL:

MARKET SHARE OF SAIL AND ITS COMPETITORS IN DOMESTIC MARKET:

SAIL42%

TATA26%

JSW19%

Ispat7%

Bhushan steel6%

Market Share

Page 6: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

6 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Valuation of SAIL

CALCULATION OF BETA FROM HISTORICAL DATA:

We calculate the Beta by doing a regression of SAIL’s stock return with the market return.

X= SAIL’s average return/ month for ten years

Y=Sensex’s average return/ month for ten years

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics Multiple R 0.586972953 R Square 0.344537248 Adjusted R

Square 0.339787518 Standard Error 15.7375221

Observations 140

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 17965.52674 17965.53 72.538279 2.504E-14

Residual 138 34178.40504 247.6696

Total 139 52143.93177

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P-value Lower 95% Upper 95%

Lower 95.0%

Upper 95.0%

Intercept 1.557380799 1.341696967 1.160755 0.2477458 -1.0955613 4.21032292 -1.0955613 4.2103229

X Variable 1 1.409028907 0.165438384 8.516941 2.504E-14 1.081907 1.7361508 1.08190701 1.7361508

Page 7: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

7 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

CALCULATION OF BOTTOM-UP BETA:

The logic behind following this approach is as follows:

1) We wanted to use another method as well for calculation of Beta to compare the difference

between the valuations done by using beta from different methods.

2) This method is helpful in a way because, it helps us figuring out the operational leverages,

financial leverage and risk implicit in the business of the company.

3) The standard deviation of this method is very low compared to the one using Regression on

Historical data. This is because the sample size used is more than 5.

Company Name

Regression

Beta D/E Ratio

Effective Tax

Rate %

Fixed/Variable

Cost

Tata Steel 1.21 1.34 30 0.33

Jindal Steel 1.16 1.51 30 0.11

Kalyani Steel 1.14 0.44 30 0.22

Uttam Galva 1.23 1.48 30 0.06

National Steel 1.11 1.43 30 0.04

Bhushan Steel 0.76 3.52 30 0.05

Adhunik Metalik 0.9 2.87 30 0.16

Average (Simple) 1.072857143 1.798571429 30 0.138571429

SAIL 1.41 0.26 30 0.42

Page 8: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

8 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Step 1 Unlevered Industry beta

Average regression beta 1.07 Average debt-equity ratio 1.79 Average effective tax-rate 30.00%

Un-leveraged beta

Regression beta/ {1+ (1-tax-

rate)*debt-equity ratio}

Un-leveraged beta 0.474922326

(Financial Leverage is being

eliminated)

Business Beta

Unlevered beta/ {1+ (fixed

to variable-ratio)}

Business Beta 0.41712124 (Operational Leverage is being eliminated)

Step 2

Unlevered beta of SAIL (adjusted for

its operating leverage)

Business beta 0.41712124 Fixed/variable cost ratio 0.42

Unlevered Beta of SAIL 0.59231216 (If SAIL has no debt)

Step 3

Relevered beta of SAIL (adjusted for

its financial leverage)

Unlevered Beta of SAIL 0.59231216 Debt-equity ratio 0.26 Effective Tax rate 30.00%

Levered beta

Unlevered beta * {1+ (1

- effective tax rate) *

debt-equity ratio}

Levered beta 0.700112974 β = 0.7

Note: The regression beta is of a larger sample base (7 companies in this case) which reduces the

standard error in statistical estimation. Assuming the regression beta for SAIL has a standard error of

.16. The average industry regression beta would have a much lower error. Statistically, the standard

error for the sample would be - individual error / square root of number of samples i.e. 0.16/√7 = .06

Page 9: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

9 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

The Bottom Up beta by this method is 0.7 only which is less than the Regression beta by almost 0.7.

The difference is primarily due to the greater financial leverage (D/E ratio) of the company.

WACC Calculation using Historical Beta:

Return on Market, rM 15.67%

Return On Debt, rD 10%

Corporate Tax Rate, TC 30%

Beta of SAIL, β 1.42

Risk Free Rate, rF 6.50%

Return on Equity, rE 19.52%

D/E Ratio of SAIL 0.26

D/V Ratio of SAIL 0.206349

E/V Ratio of SAIL 0.793651

After Tax WACC 16.94%

WACC Calculation using Bottom - Up Beta:

Return on Market, rM 15.67%

Return On Debt, rD 10%

Corporate Tax Rate, TC 30%

Beta of SAIL, β 0.70

Risk Free Rate, rF 6.50%

Return on Equity, rE 12.92%

D/E Ratio of SAIL 0.26

D/V Ratio of SAIL 0.206349

E/V Ratio of SAIL 0.793651

After Tax WACC 11.70%

Page 10: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

10 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Page 11: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

11 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

PV Free cash flow, years 1-10 46214.8 (Horizon value in year 10)

PV Horizon value 37179.1 Buy

176658

PV of company 83393.8

Fair Price 201.9

Current Price 162.0

Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10 Year 11

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

1 Sales Turnover 32569.53 33221 40292 46261 49740 53719 58016 62658 67670 73084 78931 85245 92065 99430 107384 109532

2 Cost of goods sold 18224.93 21646 24684 28692 34857 44062 40612 43860 47369 51159 55252 55409 59842 64629 69799.8 71195.8

3 EBITDA (1-2) 14344.6 11575 15607 17570 14883 9656.8 17405 18797 20301 21925 23679 29836 32223 34800 37584.5 38336.2

4 Depreciation 1126.95 1207.3 1211.5 1235.5 1285.1 1692.1 1827.5 1973.7 2131.6 2302.1 2486.3 2685.2 2900 3132 3382.61 3450.26

5 Profit before tax (EBIT) (3 - 4) 13217.65 10368 14396 16334 13597 7964.6 15577 16824 18169 19623 21193 27151 29323 31668 34201.9 34886

6 Tax 2592.37 1694.4 3253.8 3934.7 3284.3 2389.4 4673.2 5047.1 5450.8 5886.9 6357.9 8145.2 8796.8 9500.5 10260.6 10465.8

7 Profit after tax (5 - 6) 10625.28 8673.4 11142 12399 10313 5575.2 10904 11777 12719 13736 14835 19005 20526 22168 23941.3 24420.2

8 Investment in fixed assets 12485.07 -

322.93 -564.43 -26.4 697.52 6532.8 1504.1 1624.5 1754.4 1894.8 2046.4 2210.1 2386.9 2577.8 2784.04 751.691

9 Investment in working capital 2323.25 1147.9 4545.9 3533.3 4506.9 5430.4 1719 1856.5 2005 2165.5 2338.7 2525.8 2727.8 2946.1 3181.76 859.075

10 Free cash flow (7 + 4 - 8 - 9) -3056.09 9055.8 8372.3 10128 6394

-

4695.9 9508.6 10269 11091 11978 12936 16955 18311 19776 21358.2 26259.7

Assumptions:

Sales growth (percent) Base Year 2.0 21.3 14.8 7.5 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 2.0

Costs (percent of sales) 67.8 80.3 76.1 75.6 82.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0

Working capital (percent of sales) 7.1 10.4 19.9 25.0 32.3 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0

Net fixed assets (percent of sales) 38.3 36.6 28.8 25.0 24.7 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0

Depreciation (percent of net fixed assets) 9.0 9.9 10.4 10.7 10.5 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0

Tax rate, percent 30.0%

Cost of debt, percent (rD) 10.0%

Cost of equity, percent (rE) 19.4%

Debt ratio (D/V) 0.2

WACC, percent 16.9%

Long-term growth forecast, percent 2.0%

FORCASTED CASH FLOW ON THE BASIS OF HISTORICAL BETA (1.42)

Page 12: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

12 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

PV Free cash flow, years 1-10 61204.4

(Horizon value in year 10)

PV Horizon value 89561.5 Buy

270763

PV of co mpany 150765.9

Fair Price 365.0

Current Price 162.0

Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10 Year 11

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

1 Sales Turnover 32569.53 33221 40292 46261 49740 53719 58016 62658 67670 73084 78931 85245 92065 99430 107384 109532

2 Cost of goods sold 18224.93 21646 24684 28692 34857 44062 40612 43860 47369 51159 55252 55409 59842 64629 69799.8 71195.8

3 EBITDA (1-2) 14344.6 11575 15607 17570 14883 9656.8 17405 18797 20301 21925 23679 29836 32223 34800 37584.5 38336.2

4 Depreciation 1126.95 1207.3 1211.5 1235.5 1285.1 1692.1 1827.5 1973.7 2131.6 2302.1 2486.3 2685.2 2900 3132 3382.61 3450.26

5 Profit before tax (EBIT) (3 - 4) 13217.65 10368 14396 16334 13597 7964.6 15577 16824 18169 19623 21193 27151 29323 31668 34201.9 34886

6 Tax 2592.37 1694.4 3253.8 3934.7 3284.3 2389.4 4673.2 5047.1 5450.8 5886.9 6357.9 8145.2 8796.8 9500.5 10260.6 10465.8

7 Profit after tax (5 - 6) 10625.28 8673.4 11142 12399 10313 5575.2 10904 11777 12719 13736 14835 19005 20526 22168 23941.3 24420.2

8 Investment in fixed assets 12485.07 -

322.93 -564.43 -26.4 697.52 6532.8 1504.1 1624.5 1754.4 1894.8 2046.4 2210.1 2386.9 2577.8 2784.04 751.691

9 Investment in working capital 2323.25 1147.9 4545.9 3533.3 4506.9 5430.4 1719 1856.5 2005 2165.5 2338.7 2525.8 2727.8 2946.1 3181.76 859.075

10 Free cash flow (7 + 4 - 8 - 9) -3056.09 9055.8 8372.3 10128 6394 -

4695.9 9508.6 10269 11091 11978 12936 16955 18311 19776 21358.2 26259.7

Assumptions:

Sales growth (percent) Base Year 2.0 21.3 14.8 7.5 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0 2.0

Costs (percent of sales) 67.8 80.3 76.1 75.6 82.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0

Working capital (percent of sales) 7.1 10.4 19.9 25.0 32.3 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0 40.0

Net fixed assets (percent of sales) 38.3 36.6 28.8 25.0 24.7 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0 35.0

Depreciation (percent of net fixed assets) 9.0 9.9 10.4 10.7 10.5 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0

Tax rate, percent 30.0%

Cost of debt, percent (rD) 10.0%

Cost of equity, percent (rE) 12.9%

Debt ratio (D/V) 0.2

WACC, percent 11.7%

Long-term growth forecast, percent 2.0%

FORCASTED CASH FLOW ON THE BASIS OF BOTTOM UP BETA (0.7)

Page 13: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

13 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Mar ' 09 Mar ' 10 Mar ' 11 Mar ' 12 Mar ' 13 Mar ' 14 Mar ' 15 Mar ' 16 Mar ' 17 Mar ' 18 Mar ' 19 Mar ' 20

Income

Operating income 13597.48 7964.609 15577.41 16823.61 18169.49 19623.05 21192.9 27150.59 29322.63 31668.45 34201.92 34885.96

Expenses

Material consumed 22,042.58 23805.99 25710.47 27767.3 29988.69 32387.78 34978.8 37777.11 40799.28 44063.22 47588.28 51395.34 Manufacturing expenses 3,762.77 4063.792 4388.895 4740.007 5119.207 5528.744 5971.043 6448.727 6964.625 7521.795 8123.538 8773.421

Personnel expenses 8,401.73 8821.817 9262.907 9726.053 10212.36 10722.97 11259.12 11822.08 12413.18 13033.84 13685.53 14369.81

Selling expenses 935.68 982.464 1031.587 1083.167 1137.325 1194.191 1253.901 1316.596 1382.426 1451.547 1524.124 1600.33

Adminstrative expenses 1,644.78 1694.123 1744.947 1797.296 1851.214 1906.751 1963.953 2022.872 2083.558 2146.065 2210.447 2276.76

Expenses capitalised -1,930.40 -2,026.92 -2,128.27 -2,234.68 -2,346.41 -2,463.73 -2,586.92 -2,716.27 -2,852.08 -2,994.68 -3,144.42 -3,301.64

Cost of sales 34,857.14 37645.71 40657.37 43909.96 47422.75 51216.57 55313.9 59739.01 64518.13 69679.58 75253.95 81274.27

Operating profit 8,941.44 9,656.76 10,429.30 11,263.64 12,164.73 13,137.91 14,188.94 15,324.06 16,549.98 17,873.98 19,303.90 20,848.21

Other recurring income 2,279.89 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000

Adjusted PBDIT 11,221.33 11,656.76 12,429.30 13,263.64 14,164.73 15,137.91 16,188.94 17,324.06 18,549.98 19,873.98 21,303.90 22,848.21

Financial expenses 253.24 258.3048 263.4709 268.7403 274.1151 279.5974 285.1894 290.8932 296.711 302.6452 308.6981 314.8721

Depreciation 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12 1,285.12

Other write offs 128.02 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100

Adjusted PBT 9,554.95 10,013.33 10,780.70 11,609.78 12,505.50 13,473.19 14,518.63 15,648.04 16,868.15 18,186.21 19,610.08 21,148.22

Tax charges 3,284.28 3003.999 3234.211 3482.934 3751.649 4041.957 4355.59 4694.413 5060.445 5455.864 5883.024 6344.465

Adjusted PAT 6,270.67 7,009.33 7,546.49 8,126.85 8,753.85 9,431.23 10,163.04 10,953.63 11,807.71 12,730.35 13,727.06 14,803.75

Non recurring items -277.12 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 Other non cash adjustments 181.26 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200

Reported net profit 6,174.81 6,759.33 7,296.49 7,876.85 8,503.85 9,181.23 9,913.04 10,703.63 11,557.71 12,480.35 13,477.06 14,553.75

Equity dividend 1,073.90 1175.558 1268.979 1369.912 1478.957 1596.766 1724.04 1861.536 2010.073 2170.536 2343.879 2531.135

Preference dividend -

Dividend tax 181.26 198.4185 214.1867 231.2228 249.6283 269.5128 290.9949 314.2024 339.2735 366.3576 395.6156 427.2218 Per share data (annualised)

Shares in issue (lakhs) 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01 41,304.01

Earning Per Share (Rs) 14.95 16.36 17.67 19.07 20.59 22.23 24.00 25.91 27.98 30.22 32.63 35.24

Consolidated Profit and Loss Account

Page 14: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

14 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Mar ' 09 Mar ' 10 Mar ' 11 Mar ' 12 Mar ' 13 Mar ' 14 Mar ' 15 Mar ' 16 Mar ' 17 Mar ' 18 Mar ' 19 Mar ' 20

Sources of funds

Owner's fund

Equity share capital 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 4,130.40 Share application money -

Preference share capital -

Reserves & surplus 23,853.70 28,954.61 34,538.38 40,565.90 47,072.83 54,097.72 61,682.19 69,871.19 78,713.29 88,260.92 98,570.73 109,703.91

Loan funds

Secured loans 1,473.60 1742.2061 2036.2391 2353.6388 2696.284 3066.204 3465.5905 3896.8109 4362.4221 4865.1858 5408.0849 5994.341

Unsecured loans 6,065.19 8,183.30 9,564.40 11,055.25 12,664.69 14,402.23 16,278.19 18,303.67 20,490.68 22,852.21 25,402.25 28,155.95

Total 35,522.89 43,010.51 50,269.42 58,105.19 66,564.20 75,696.56 85,556.37 96,202.07 107,696.79 120,108.71 133,511.47 147,984.60

Uses of funds

Fixed assets Gross block 32,728.69 40,561.48 43,365.61 46,290.07 49,344.49 52,539.26 55,885.61 59,395.67 63,082.54 66,960.35 71,044.39 73,096.08 Less : revaluation reserve - Less : accumulated depreciation 20,459.86 21,759.86 23,059.86 24,359.86 25,659.86 26,959.86 28,259.86 29,559.86 30,859.86 32,159.86 33,459.86 34,759.86

Net block 12,268.83 18,801.62 20,305.75 21,930.21 23,684.63 25,579.40 27,625.75 29,835.81 32,222.68 34,800.49 37,584.53 38,336.22

Capital work-in-progress 6,544.24 4,056.15 4,336.56 4,629.01 4,934.45 5,253.93 5,588.56 5,939.57 6,308.25 6,696.03 7,104.44 7,309.61

Investments 652.7 808.90739 864.82944 923.15121 984.06467 1047.7772 1114.5126 1184.5129 1258.0391 1335.3733 1416.8203 1457.7367

Net current assets

Current assets, loans & advances 35,666.84 41,097.29 42,816.29 44,672.82 46,677.87 48,843.32 51,182.01 53,707.79 56,435.63 59,381.71 62,563.47 63,422.54 Less : current liabilities & provisions 19,609.72 20,786.30 22,033.48 23,355.49 24,756.82 26,242.23 27,816.76 29,485.77 31,254.91 33,130.21 35,118.02 37,225.10

Total net current assets 16,057.12 21,487.57 23,206.57 25,063.10 27,068.15 29,233.60 31,572.29 34,098.07 36,825.91 39,771.99 42,953.75 43,812.82 Miscellaneous expenses not written -

Total 35,522.89 43,010.51 50,269.42 58,105.19 66,564.20 75,696.56 85,556.37 96,202.07 107,696.79 120,108.71 133,511.47 147,984.60

Consolidated Balance Sheet

Page 15: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

15 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

Forecasted Current ratio and ROI:

Mar'05 Mar'06 Mar'07 Mar'08

Mar' 09

Mar' 10

Mar ' 11

Mar ' 12

Mar ' 13

Mar ' 14

Mar ' 15

Mar ' 16

Mar ' 17

Mar ' 18

Mar ' 19

Mar ' 20

Current ratio 1.18 1.23 1.59 1.73 1.82 1.98 1.94 1.91 1.89 1.86 1.84 1.82 1.81 1.79 1.78 1.70

ROI 3.98 1.61 1.16 0.97 0.60 0.47 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.48

Some Facts & Assumptions:

1) While calculating the Bottom - Up Beta, we have assumed that a group of 7 steel companies is

a good sample for the reflection of Steel Industry in India.

2) Effective Corporate Tax rate has been taken as 30% for SAIL as it is an old company.

3) Return on Debt has been taken as 10%.

4) Risk Free rate has been taken as the return on G-Sec in the past Ten years which is 6.5%.

5) Stable Sales Growth rate for SAIL has been assumed as 8% because of the fact that there will

be high demand of Steel both in India and Overseas in the next 10 years.

6) Terminal growth of SAIL has been taken as 2%.

7) Working Capital has been taken as 40% of Sales because of the high capital requirements of the

industry.

8) Depreciation has been taken as 9%.

9) In the forecasted P & L account of the company, we have assumed the Variable Cost Growth

Rate of 8% because the Sales Turnover is growing 8% year on.

10) Fixed Cost Growth Rate has been assumed to be 5% and Admin Expenses to be 3% because of

the further scalability of operations.

Page 16: SAIL Valuation

CIMP

16 Steel Authority of India © Anurag and Ankita Sarni

References:

1. “Principles of Corporate Finance” by Brealy, Myers, Allen, Mohanty

2. “Security analysis for Investment and Corporate Finance” by Damodran 3. www.wikipedia.com

4. www.bseindia.com

5. www.nseindia.com

6. www.worldsteel.org

7. http://indiabudget.nic.in/

8. http://finmin.nic.in/

9. http://www.worldsteel.org/ 10. http://www.worldsteeldynamics.com/ 11. www.yahoofinance.com

12. www.rediffmail.com

13. www.moneycontrol.com

14. www.economictimes.com

15. www.buisnessstandard.com