sabrina winston - same-sex marriage thesis presentation
TRANSCRIPT
GAY MARRIAGE BANS
By: Sabrina Winston
SECTION 1
Background Section
GAY MARRIAGE BANS
A gay marriage ban is a ban
against same-sex marriage.
OTHER STATE LEVEL GAY MARRIAGE
POLICIESLegalized gay marriage
Gay marriage recognition laws
Civil unions/ domestic partnerships
IMPACTS OF GAY MARRIAGE BANS
No end-of-life decision making
No family leaveNo Social Security benefitsNo work place marriage benefits like
health insurance
Don’t benefit from1,100 laws legal & financial benefits and responsibilities for married couples
CITY & STATES WHERE GAY
MARRIAGE IS LEGAL
(California)
Connecticut
Iowa
Massachusetts
(Maryland)-pending
New Hampshire
New York
Vermont
Washington DC
RECOGNITION LAWS
There are currently no gay marriage
recognition laws
New York and Washington DC used
to have recognition laws before they
legalized gay marriage
STATES WITH CIVIL UNIONS
Delaware
Hawaii
Illinois
New Jersey
Rhode Island
STATES WITH DOMESTIC
PARTNERSHIPS
California
Colorado
Maine
Maryland
Nevada
Oregon
Washington DC
Washington State
Wisconsin
DEFENSE OF MARRIAGE ACT
(DOMA) Federal law
passed In 1996
Signed by President Clinton
Section 2: States don’t have to
recognize gay marriages from
states where they are legal
Section 3: For federal purposes,
marriage is defined as between a
man & a woman
SECTION 2
Policy Analysis
CONTROVERSY 1
Are Gay
Rights CIVIL
RIGHTS?
LOVING V. VIRGINIA (1967)
EQUAL PROTECTION CLAUSE
OF THE 14TH AMENDMENT
WITHOUT CIVIL RIGHTS,
HOMOSEXUALS ARE:
COUNTER POSITION:
ESTABLISHMENT CLAUSE OF THE 1ST
AMENDMENT
“Congress shall
make no law
respecting an
establishment of
religion”
CONTROVERSY 2
Is it more important
to honor majority
rule or minority
rights?
IS IT MORE IMPORTANT TO HONOR
MAJORITY RULE OR MINORITY
RIGHTS?
Marriage is one of the
"basic civil rights of
man," fundamental to our
very existence and
survival....
IS IT MORE IMPORTANT TO HONOR
MAJORITY RULE OR MINORITY
RIGHTS?
Should we have cared
that it bothered some
whites for blacks to be
equal or have civil
rights?
IS IT MORE IMPORTANT TO HONOR
MAJORITY RULE OR MINORITY
RIGHTS?
CONTROVERSY 3
Should states or federal
governments make gay
marriage laws?
DEFENSE OF MARRIAGE ACT
(DOMA)
Section 3: For federal
purposes, marriage is
defined as between a
man & a woman
SHOULD STATES OR FEDERAL
GOVERNMENTS MAKE GAY MARRIAGE
LAWS?
Massachusetts v.
United States
Dept. of Health
and Human
Services
(D. Mass 2010)
Supreme Court Justice Louis D.
BrandeisOne of the principal
values of American
federalism is that a
“single courageous
state may, if its citizens
choose, serve as a
laboratory; and try
novel social and
economic
experiments without
risk to the rest of the
country.”
COUNTER-POSITION
The Full Faith and Credit
Clause of the U.S Constitution
says that states must
recognize “public acts, records
and judicial proceedings of
other states.”
CONTROVERSY 4
Do people have a
right to marry whom
they want?
DUE PROCESS CLAUSE
OF THE 14TH AMENDMENT
- “Nor shall any state
deprive any person of
life, liberty, or property,
without due process of
law”
DO PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO MARRY
WHOM THEY WANT?
Goodridge v. Department
of Public Health
--Due Process Clause
--Equal Protection
Clause
DO PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO MARRY
WHOM THEY WANT?
Perry v. Schwarzenegger
(2010) (Perry v. Brown on
appeal)
--Due Process
Clause
COUNTER-POSITION
.
SECTION 3
Alternative policy
ALTERNATIVE POLICY
The outcome
SPECIAL THANKS TO
Mr. Rick Rosendall,
DC Gay Marriage Bill advocate.
WORK CITEDHRC Foundation Answers to Questions About
Marriage Equality
Merriam Webster defines domestic violence and civil
unions
Gallup poll First Time Majority Americans Favor Legal
Gay Marriage