run: april 26, 2012 department of justice page 1 of ......endangered species defensive cases active...

276
Page 1 of 276 Run: Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION WILDLIFE SECTION Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed Date Concluded Date Closed District Case Title Section: Wildlife 5/4/09 Civil Defensive 08-3542 7/24/08 9/10/10 California, North PESTICIDE ACTION NETWORK NORTH AMERICA, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY Party Name NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL ALASKA COMMUNITY ACTION ON TOXICS TEAMSTERS LOCAL 890 FARM LABOR ORGANIZING COMMITTEE BEYOND PESTICIDES AFL-CIO UNITED FARM WORKERS CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH PESTICIDE ACTION NORTH AMERICA PINEROS Y CAMPESINOS UNIDOS DEL NOROESTE Statutes ENDANGERED SPECIES FIFRA

Upload: others

Post on 05-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 1 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/4/09Civil Defensive

08-3542 7/24/08 9/10/10 California, North

PESTICIDE ACTION NETWORK NORTH AMERICA, ET AL. V.UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

Party NameNATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

ALASKA COMMUNITY ACTION ON TOXICS

TEAMSTERS LOCAL 890

FARM LABOR ORGANIZING COMMITTEE

BEYOND PESTICIDES

AFL-CIO

UNITED FARM WORKERS

CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH

PESTICIDE ACTION NORTH AMERICA

PINEROS Y CAMPESINOS UNIDOS DEL NOROESTE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FIFRA

Page 2: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 2 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/4/09Civil Defensive

08-3595 8/4/08 9/10/10 California, North

UNITED FARM WORKERS, ET AL. V. ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION AGENCY

Party NameFARM LABOR ORGANIZING COMMITTEE

PESTICIDE ACTION NETWORK NORTH AMERICA

TEAMSTERS LOCAL 890

AFL-CIO

LOPEZ, LUIS GARCIA

UNITED FARM WORKERS

PINEROS Y CAMPESINOS UNIDOS DEL NOROESTE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FIFRA

Page 3: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 3 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/21/10Civil Defensive

08-4 1/31/08 7/27/10 AlaskaNATIVE VILLAGE OF POINT HOPE, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameNORTHERN ALASKA ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER

INTERIOR, DEPT MMS

NATIVE VILLAGE OF POINT HOPE

CITY OF POINT HOPE

SIERRA CLUB

ALASKA WILDERNESS LEAGUE

RESISTING ENVIRONMENTAL DESTRUCTION

PACIFIC ENVIRONMENTAL

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

INUPIAT COMMUNITY OF THE ARETIC SLOPE

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

OCEANA

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

MINERALS LEASING-OFFSHORE

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 4: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 4 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

99-870 8/4/99 New MexicoMIDDLE RIO GRANDE CONSERVANCY V. BABBITT

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MIDDLE RIO GRANDE CONSERVANCY DISTRICT $149,693.00 10/25/01

Attorney Fees Hubert & Hernandez $5,867.90 11/27/01

Attorney Fees ARMIJO, JERRY $7,865.09 11/14/01

Attorney Fees ARMIJO, JERRY $1,150.00 5/8/03

Attorney Fees LAW AND RESOURCES PLANNING ASSOCIATES, $42,000.00 5/16/03

Attorney Fees Hubert & Hernandez $395.94 5/16/03

Party NameCLARK, RAPPAPORT JAMIE

BABBIT, BRUCE SECY DOI US

Kaufman, Nancy

FISH, AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

MIDDLE, RIO GRANDE CONSER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

8/7/09Civil Defensive

03-3013 2/6/03 2/7/11 OregonSISKIYOU REGIONAL EDUCATION PROJECT V. UNITEDSTATES FOREST SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 5: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 5 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/12/08Civil Defensive

03-1175 8/29/03 1/7/11 OregonWALDO MINING DISTRICT, ET AL. V. UNITED STATESFOREST SERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameFOREST, SERVICE

BARTON, LESA

BARTON, ROBERT

WALDO, MINING DISTRICT

Statutes

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FOREST MANAGEMENT

Civil Defensive

03-165 10/14/03 MontanaFOREST SERVICE EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTALETHICS V. UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Party NameFOREST, SERVICE US

FOREST, SERVICE EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 6: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 6 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/1/06Civil Defensive

03-621 11/3/03 9/23/09 HawaiiCENTER FOR FOOD SAFETY, ET AL. V. ANN VENEMAN, U.S.DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, ET AL.

Party NamePESTICIDE ACTION NETWORK NORTH AMERICA

KAHEA

CENTER, FOR FOOD SAFETY

FRIENDS, OF THE EARTH, BLUEWATER NETWORK DIVISION

ANIMAL & PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. FEDERAL PROGRAM

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

Page 7: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 7 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-3096 11/15/04 OregonOREGON NATURAL DESERT ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V. U.S.FOREST SERVICE, ET AL

Party NameFOREST, SERVICE US

OREGON, NATURAL RESOURCES COUN FUND

OREGON, NATURAL DESERT ASSOCIA

Statutes

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

1/21/10Civil Defensive

05-261 5/31/05 8/17/10 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBANDEVELOPMENT, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MCCRYSTIE ADAMS $36,429.95 10/13/06

Party NameHOUSING, AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT

VETERANS AFFAIRS, DEPARTMENT OF

CENTER, FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY INC

SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 8: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 8 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

05-107 6/20/05 MontanaROCK CREEK ALLIANCE, ET AL. V. U.S. FOREST SERVICE,ET AL.

Party NameCLARK FORK COALITION

ROCK CREEK ALLIANCE

EARTHWORKS

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

CABINET RESOURCE GROUP

MONTANA WILDERNESS ASSOCIATION

CASTANEDA, BOB

REVETT SILVER COMPANY

KIMBELL, ABIGAIL

ALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MINERAL EXTRACTION-LOCATABLE MINERALS

FED LAND POLICY MGM

FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

WILDERNESS ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 9: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 9 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/28/08Civil Defensive

05-297 7/21/05 9/30/09 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. JOE KRAAYENBRINK,ET AL

Party NameBUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

WESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FED LAND POLICY MGM

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

10/6/08Civil Defensive

05-273 7/11/05 3/5/10 IdahoNORTH IDAHO COMMUNITY ACTION NETWORK V. U.S.DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, ET AL.

Party NameNORTH IDAHO COMMUNITY ACTION NETWORK

FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM

DOT ACT 4(F)

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 10: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 10 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/6/07Civil Defensive

05-4038 10/14/05 1/7/11 California, North

WILDERNESS SOCIETY, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameSITKA CONSERVATION SOCIETY

OREGON NATURAL RESOURCES COUNCIL FUND

NORTHCOAST ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER

KLAMATH-SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

PACIFIC RIVERS COUNCIL

FORESTS FOREVER FOUNDATION

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY

CONSERVATION NW

CALIFORNIA WILDERNESS COALITION

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

SIERRA CLUB

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

SISKIYOU REGIONAL EDUCATION PROJECT

IDAHO CONSERVATION LEAGUE

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION INFORMATION CENTER

GREENPEACE

BIODERVISITY CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

GREATER YELLOWSTONE COALITION

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 11: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 11 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/1/10Civil Defensive

05-4038 10/6/05 3/9/10 California, North

THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BOYLES, KRISTEN L. $500,000.00 2/19/10

Party NameKLAMATH-SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

PACIFIC RIVERS COUNCIL

GREATER YELLOWSTONE COALITION

SISKIYOU REGIONAL EDUCATION PROJECT

IDAHO CONSERVATION LEAGUE

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION INFORMATION CENTER

GREENPEACE

CALIFORNIA WILDERNESS COALITION

FORESTS FOREVER FOUNDATION

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY

CONSERVATION NW

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

SIERRA CLUB

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

SITKA CONSERVATION SOCIETY

OREGON NATURAL RESOURCES COUNCIL FUND

NORTHCOAST ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER

BIODERVISITY CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 12: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 12 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/24/08Civil Defensive

05-7513 10/19/05 7/13/09 California, Central

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC., ET AL. V.GORDAN R. ENGLAND

Party NameINTERNATIONAL, FUND FOR ANIMAL WALFARE

CETACEAN SOCIETY INTERNATIONAL

NAVY, DEPARTMENT OF THE

COPUSTEAU, JEAN MICHEL

LEAGUE FOR COASTAL PROTECTION

OCEAN FUTURES SOCIETY

NATURAL, RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

DEFENSE DEPARTMENT PROGRAM

Page 13: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 13 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/5/09Civil Defensive

08-154 2/26/08 9/23/09 Texas, WestAQUIFER GUARDIANS IN URBAN AREAS, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION, ET AL.

Party NamePEOPLE FOR EFFICIENT TRANSPORTATION, INC.

FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION

TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

AQUIFER GUARDIAN IN URBAN AREAS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM

10/15/08Civil Defensive

06-1473 6/21/06 2/10/11 Georgia, NorthSTATE OF GEORGIA V. U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameGEORGIA, STATE OF

U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ARMY CORPS CONSTRUCTION & OPERATION STATUT

Page 14: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 14 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/23/10Civil Defensive

06-2418 1/15/07 4/7/11 ColoradoTHE ARK INITIATIVE, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameSMITH, PAUL

DUERR, DONALD

ARK INITIATIVE

FORSYTHE, ALEX

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

06-527 10/4/06 NevadaWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. BUREAU OF LANDMANAGEMENT, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

WESTERN, WATERSHEDS PROJECT

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

Page 15: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 15 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/10/09Civil Defensive

07-335 3/22/07 9/23/09 California, Central

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, ET AL. V.DONALD C. WINTER, ET AL.

Party NameNATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

NAVY, DEPARTMENT OF THE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

DEFENSE DEPARTMENT PROGRAM

COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT

Page 16: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 16 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/22/11Civil Defensive

07-114 6/20/07 8/24/11 Kentucky, EastHEARTWOOD, INC., ET AL. V. CHARLES L. MYERS, ET AL.

Party NameKENTUCKY HEARTWOOD INC

HEARTWOOD INC

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 17: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 17 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

1/14/09Civil Defensive

07-254 5/16/07 1/7/11 HawaiiOCEAN MAMMAL INSTITUTE, ET AL. V. ROBERT M. GATES,ET AL.

Party NameKAHEA

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

ANIMAL WELFARE INSTITUTE

OCEAN MAMMAL INSTITUTE

SURFRIDER FOUNDATION KAUA'I CHAPTER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Civil Defensive

07-8044 4/20/07 Florida, SouthCITIZENS FOR SMART GROWTH, ET AL. V. MARY E. PETERS,ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 18: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 18 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/19/08Civil Defensive

07-279 8/27/07 9/23/09 IdahoCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. U.S. SHEEPEXPERIMENT STATION, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY $12,224.00

Party NameFOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

CENTER, FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY INC

U.S. SHEEP EXPERIMENT STATION

WESTERN, WATERSHEDS PROJECT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FED LAND POLICY MGM

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

8/6/10Civil Defensive

07-3802 3/31/08 8/17/10 South CarolinaSOUTH CAROLINA COASTAL CONSERVATION LEAGUE V.UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, ET AL.

Party NameSOUTH CAROLINA COASTAL CONSERVATION LEAGUE

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 19: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 19 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-2332 08-237

12/21/07 Florida, MiddleDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL, PARKS AND CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE US

WILDLANDS CPR

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

SIERRA CLUB

SCHERF, BRIAN

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

FLORIDA BIODIVERSITY PROJECT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

10/16/08Civil Defensive

08-168 3/11/08 9/23/09 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DEPARTMENT OFENERGY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 20: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 20 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/3/11Civil Defensive

08-14 11/24/08 1/10/12 MontanaDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

ALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

JACKSON HOLE CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

FRIENDS OF THE CLEARWATER

WESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

HELLS CANYON PRESERVATION COUNCIL

MINETTE GLASER (NO LONGER A PARTY TO CASE)

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

SIERRA CLUB

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 21: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 21 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-91 1/14/08 Pennsylvania, Middle

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-93 1/14/08 Pennsylvania, Middle

PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL, ET AL. V.DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 22: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 22 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/31/10Civil Defensive

08-380 8/7/08 10/22/10 District of Columbia

APPALACHIAN VOICES, ET AL. V. SAMUEL W. BODMAN, ETAL.

Party NameCANARY COALITION

ENERGY, DEPARTMENT OF

TREASURY, DEPARTMENT OF

APPALACHIAN VOICES

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

Civil Defensive

08-43 4/2/08 MontanaFOREST SERVICE EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTALETHICS V. UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 23: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 23 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/27/08Civil Defensive

08-608 3/25/08 1/23/09 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. NATIONAL PARK SERVICE

Party NameWILDEARTH GUARDIANS

NATIONAL PARK SERVICE US

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 24: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 24 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/30/09Civil Defensive

08-1927 4/23/08 2/7/11 California, North

CITIZENS FOR BETTER FORESTRY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

THE LANDS COUNCIL

CITIZENS FOR BETTER FORESTRY

CASCADIA WILDLANDS PROJECT

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

WILD WEST INSTITUTE

WILD SOUTH

KLAMATH SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER

FOREST SERVICE EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS

FRIENDS OF THE CLEARWATER

IDAHO SPORTING CONGRESS

OREGON WILD

UTAH ENVIRONMENTAL CONGRESS

GIFFORD PINCHOT TASK FORCE

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION INFORMATION CENTER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 25: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 25 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-2326 6/26/08 California, North

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. ED SCHAFER, ET AL.

Party NameVERMONT NATURAL RESOURCES COUNCIL

THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

SIERRA CLUB

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 26: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 26 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/3/09Civil Defensive

08-280 5/1/08 3/1/11 ArizonaDEFENDEERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. BENJAMIN TUGGLE,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees KENNA AND HICKOX $80,487.62 1/8/10

Court Costs KENNA AND HICKOX $2,012.38 1/8/10

Party NameWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

NEW MEXICO WILDERNESS ALLIANCE

GRAND CANYON WILDLANDS COUNCIL

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

NEW MEXICO AUDUBON COUNCIL

SOUTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER

CENTER FOR BIOLOIGCAL DIVERSITY

WILDLANDS PROJECT

UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO WILDERNESS ALLIANCE

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

SIERRA CLUB

Statutes

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 27: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 27 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-1624 3/26/10 ColoradoCOLORADO ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION V. OFFICE OFLEGACY MANAGEMENT

Party NameINFORMATION NETWORK FOR RESPONSIBLE MINING

COLORADO ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION

CENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

08-1409 8/18/08 District of Columbia

CARPENTERS INDUSTRIAL COUNCIL, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 28: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 28 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-4240 9/9/08 California, North

SIERRA FOREST LEGACY, ET AL. V. UNITED STATESFOREST SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-5552 9/16/08 Washington, West

PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTALRESPONSIBILITY, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENTOF THE NAVY, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees DINERSTEIN, PAULA $20,000.00

Party NameU.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY

PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILITY

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF NAVY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 29: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 29 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/29/09Civil Defensive

08-162 11/17/08 6/15/10 MontanaHELENA HUNTERS & ANGLERS, ET AL. V. TOM TIDWELL, ETAL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/13/10Civil Defensive

08-168 1/14/09 8/18/10 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES V. TOM TIDWELL, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BECHTOLD, TIMOTHY M. $451.00 8/27/10

Attorney Fees BECHTOLD, TIMOTHY M. $29,549.00 8/27/10

Party NameALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 30: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 30 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-2631 12/18/08 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

SIERRA CLUB

CALIFORNIA WILDERNESS COALITION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FED LAND POLICY MGM

REFUGE MANAGEMENT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 31: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 31 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/30/09Civil Defensive

09-13 2/20/09 11/2/09 District of Columbia

NATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V.KENNETH SALAZAR

Party NameCOALITION OF NATIONAL PARK SERVICE RETIREES

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF NPS

NATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

09-15 1/16/09 IdahoGERALD JAYNE, ET AL. V. MARK REY, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 32: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 32 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/31/09Civil Defensive

09-60 3/17/09 3/9/10 OregonOREGON WILD, ET AL. V. EDWARD SHEPARD, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BOYLES, KRISTEN L. $11,832.77 11/2/09

Court Costs BOYLES, KRISTEN L. $667.23 11/2/09

Party NamePACIFIC COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'S ASSOCIATIONS

OREGON WILD

BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

KLAMATH-SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER

SIERRA CLUB

INSTITUTE FOR FISHERIES RESOURCES

COAST RANGE ASSOCIATION

THE CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY

UMPQUA WATERSHEDS

CASCADIA WILDLANDS PROJECT

GREENPEACE

AMERICAN LANDS ALLIANCE

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION INFORMATION CENTER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 33: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 33 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/1/09Civil Defensive

09-58 3/30/09 3/9/10 OregonPACIFIC RIVERS COUNCIL, ET AL. V. EDWARD W. SHEPARD,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BAHR, DAVID A $12,000.00 12/14/09

Court Costs BAHR, DAVID A $500.00 12/14/09

Party NamePACIFIC RIVERS COUNCIL

MCKENZIE FLYFISHERS

BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

9/21/09Civil Defensive

09-6019 3/13/09 3/9/10 OregonFOREST SERVICE EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTALETHICS V. UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BECHTOLD, TIMOTHY M. $467.53 12/30/09

Attorney Fees BECHTOLD, TIMOTHY M. $19,423.00 12/30/09

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

FOREST SERVICE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

MISC. NRS MATTER

Page 34: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 34 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

10/3/11Civil Defensive

09-8011 3/25/09 2/22/12 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V BUREAU LANDMANAGMENT, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

CULTURAL RESOURCE CLAIMS

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-302 2/13/09 NevadaWILDERNESS WATCH, INC. V BUREAU OF LANDMANAGEMENT, ET AL.

Party NameBUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

WILDERNESS WATCH, INC.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

WILDERNESS ACT

Page 35: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 35 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

1/13/12Civil Defensive

09-640 4/7/09 2/22/12 District of Columbia

BLUE GOOSE ALLIANCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Party NameBLUE GOOSE ALLIANCE

REDFEARN, EVELYN

ENRIGHT-REFFALT

UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

REFFALT, WILLIAM

REDFERN, DON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

Page 36: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 36 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-95 5/4/09 WyomingWYOMING STATE SNOWMOBILE ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V.UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GINSBERG, BETH $253,336.45 6/17/11

Court Costs GINSBERG, BETH $11,663.55 6/17/11

Party NameWASHINGTON STATE SNOWMOBILE ASSOCIATION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

WYOMING STATE SNOWMOBILE ASSOCIATION

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 37: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 37 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-3048 7/7/09 California, North

THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY V. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR

Party NameSOUTHERN UTAH WILDERNESS ALLIANCE

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

WESTERN RESOURCE ADVOCATES

NATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

OREGON NATURAL DESERT ASSOCIATION

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

GREAT OLD BROADS FOR WILDERNESS

COUNTY OF SAN MIGUEL COLORADO

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

BARK

WESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

KLAMATH-SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

SIERRA CLUB

NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FED LAND POLICY MGM

MISC. LAND MANAGEMENT

Page 38: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 38 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-8116 7/6/09 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-206 7/9/09 Washington, East

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY V. SALAZAR

Party NameBULLITT, HARRIET

INTERIOR, DEPT OF (FWS)

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY

Statutes

RECLAMATION LAW

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 39: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 39 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-107 6/27/11 MontanaALLIANCE FOR WILD ROCKIES V. JANE L. COTTRELL

Party NameNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL

ALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 40: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 40 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-2523 12/3/09 California, EastCENTER FOR SIERRA NEVADA CONSERVATION V. UNITEDSTATES FOREST SERVICE

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

FOREST SERVICE

FOREST ISSUES GROUP

CENTER FOR SIERRA NEVADA CONSERVATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 41: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 41 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/9/11Civil Defensive

09-127 8/26/09 7/11/11 MontanaSWAN VIEW COALITION V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE

Party NameALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

SWAN VIEW COALITION

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

FRIENDS OF THE WILD SWAN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

09-160 11/16/09 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES V. PAUL BRADFORD

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SMITH, REBECCA $56,000.00 7/1/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 42: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 42 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/31/10Civil Defensive

09-8207 11/16/09 3/31/10 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Party NameBUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

GRAND CANYON TRUST

SIERRA CLUB

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

Page 43: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 43 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-629 12/4/09 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. UNITED STATESFOREST SERVICE

Party NameWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

2/16/11Civil Defensive

09-8239 12/30/09 3/9/12 ArizonaGREER COALITION V. UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 44: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 44 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-14 1/28/10 Georgia, SouthDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE V. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENTOF THE NAVY

Party NameCETACEAN SOCIETY INTERNATIONAL

CENTER FOR A SUSTAINABLE COAST

ANIMAL WELFARE INSTITUTE

SOUTH CAROLINA COASTAL CONSERVATION LEAGUE

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

FLORIDA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC.

WHALE AND DOLPHIN CONSERVATION SOCIETY

NORTH CAROLINA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

CITIZENS OPPOSING ACTIVE SONAR THREATS

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY

OCEAN MAMMAL INSTITURE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

DEFENSE DEPARTMENT PROGRAM

Page 45: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 45 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-254 8/10/10 Alabama, SouthDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE V. MINERALS MANAGEMENTSERVICE

Party NameDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

INTERIOR, DEPT MMS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

Civil Defensive

10-816 7/26/10 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

INTERIOR, DEPT MMS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

Page 46: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 46 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-2178 7/14/10 MinnesotaMINNESOTA CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY, ETAL. V. UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Party NameMINNESOTA CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY

NORTHEASTERN MINNESOTANS FOR WILDERNESS

SIERRA CLUB

UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 47: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 47 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-330 6/4/10 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. HEATHERPROVENCIO, ET AL.

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

6/14/11Civil Defensive

10-567 6/21/10 3/8/12 UtahUTAH RIVERS COUNCIL V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPT BLM

UTAH RIVERS COUNCIL

COMMITTEE TO SAVE OUR CANYONS

ENVIRONMENTAL CONGRESS

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

Page 48: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 48 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-14175 8/10/10 Florida, SouthCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. ANIMALAND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

ANIMAL AND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE

GLOBAL JUSTICE ECOLOGY PROJECT

SIERRA CLUB

DOGWOOD ALLIANCE

INTERNATIONAL CENTER FOR TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT

CENTER FOR FOOD SAFETY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. FEDERAL PROGRAM

Page 49: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 49 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/22/11Civil Defensive

10-4098 7/13/10 10/13/11 Arkansas, WestHEMPSTEAD COUNTY HUNTING CLUB, ET AL. V.SOUTHWESTERN ELECTRIC POWER CO., ET AL.

Party NameHEMPSTEAD COUNTY HUNTING CLUB INC

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

10-1174 9/13/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Party NameWILDEARTH GUARDIANS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

SIERRA CLUB

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

Page 50: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 50 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-5527 7/29/10 Washington, West

WOODBROOK HUNT CLUB V. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENTOF TRANSPORTATION

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

WOODBROOK HUNT CLUB

FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION

TAHOMA AUDUBON SOCIETY

CONSERVATIONNORTHWEST

AMERICAN LAKE GARDEN EQUESTRIAN ALLAINCE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

HISTORIC PRESERVATION

DOT ACT 4(F)

Page 51: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 51 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-708 8/25/10 Texas, WestAQUIFER GUARDIANS IN URBAN AREAS V. FEDERALHIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

AQUIFER GUARDIANS IN URBAN AREAS

FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-521 8/23/10 NevadaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 52: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 52 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/13/10Civil Defensive

10-504 10/6/10 1/25/11 IdahoALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES V. RANOTTA MCNAIR,ET AL.

Party NameALLIANCE, FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-492 1/14/11 California, Central

WESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 53: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 53 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-93 1/14/11 California, South

THE PROJECT OUR COMMUNITIES FOUNDATION, ET AL. V.DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

PROTECT OUR COMMUNITIES FOUNDATION

BACKCOUNTRY AGAINST DUMPS

TISDALE , DONNA

EAST COUNTRY COMMUNITY ACTION COALITION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FED LAND POLICY MGM

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 54: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 54 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-246 1/31/11 ColoradoTHE WILDERNESS SOCIETY V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE

Party NameWILDLANDS, CPR

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

GREAT OLD BROADS FOR WILDERNESS

CENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS

QUIET USE COALLITION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

5/6/11Civil Defensive

11-27 2/21/11 6/9/11 MontanaNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL, ET AL. V. LESLIE WELDON,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SMITH, REBECCA $419.94

Attorney Fees SMITH, REBECCA $9,080.06

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 55: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 55 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1310 4/18/11 California, North

CENTER FOR FOOD SAFETY, ET AL. V. THOMAS J. VILSACK

Party NameBEYOND PESTICIDES

NORTHEAST ORGANIC DAIRY PROCEDURES ALLIANCE

DAKOTA RESOURCES COUNCIL

ANIMAL AND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE

CENTER FOR FOOD SAFETY

WESTERN ORGANIZATION OF RESOUCE COUNCILS

TRASK FAMILY SEEDS

CALIFORNIA FARMERS UNION

SIERRA CLUB

NATIONAL FAMILY FARM COALITION

GEERTSON SEEDS FARMS

CORNUCOPIA INSTITUTE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

Page 56: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 56 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-76 7/14/11 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES V. USDA, ET AL.

Party NameALLIANCE FOR WILD ROCKIES

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-212 5/11/11 IdahoNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL, ET AL. V. UNITED STATESFOREST SERVICE

Party NameNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL

ALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 57: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 57 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1174 10/31/11 District of Columbia

AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR,ET AL.

Party NameSTARFIRE LUMBER CO INC

ROUGH & READY LUMBER LLC

AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE COUNCIL

CARPENTERS INDUSTRIAL COUNCIL

DOUGLAS TIMBER OPERATORS, INC.

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

SWANSON GROUP MFG. LLC

C & D LUMBER CO.

SENECA JONES TIMBER COMPANY

FRERES, LUMBER CO

AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FED LAND POLICY MGM

MISC. NRS MATTER

Page 58: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 58 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1650 6/20/11 California, EastFRIENDS OF THE RIVER, ET AL. ARMY CORPS OFENGINEERS

Party NameDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

FRIENDS OF THE RIVER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

11-99 7/20/11 MontanaNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL, ET AL., V. WELDON, ET AL.

Party NameALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL

UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. NRS MATTER

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 59: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 59 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1031 1/10/12 Indiana, SouthCITIZENS FOR APPROPRIATE RURAL ROADS, INC V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, ET AL

Party NameUNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

BOYD, WILLIAM A.

JOCHIM, THOMAS

TOKARSKI, THOMAS

FLYNN, WILLIAM SCOTT

CITIZENS FOR APPROPRIATE RURAL ROADS, INC.

YOUNG, CORA E.

CITIZENS FOR APPROPRAITE RURAL ROADS, INC

FLYNN, RUTH ANN

KNOTT, MICHAEL

INDIANA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

TOKARSKI, SANDRA

WILLIAMS, MARY ANN

JOCHIM, KENDA

BERGH, LYNNE

JOCHIM, JERRY

BREEDEN, DARRELL

BOYD, JANICE ANN

SULLIVAN, WAYNE

I-69 ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT

KNOTT, ANDREW

BAAS, ANN M.

PAUL, CHARLOTTE ANN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

DOT ACT 4(F)

Page 60: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 60 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Civil Defensive

11-2250 8/24/11 California, EastCONSERVATION CONGRESS, ET AL. V. J. SHARONHEYWOOD

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-125 9/16/11 MontanaFRIENDS OF THE WILD SWAN, ET AL. V. DEBORAH L.R.AUSTIN, ET AL.

Party NameFRIENDS OF THE WILD SWAN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 61: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 61 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-578 10/12/11 Florida, MiddleNATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL PARKS CONSEVATIONS ASSOCIATION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF NPS

ADORNATO, JOHN III

NATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 62: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 62 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-647 11/3/11 Florida, MiddlePUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTALRESPONSIBILITY, ET AL. V. KENNETH SALAZAR, ET AL.

Party NameSOUTH FLORIDA WILDLANDS ASSOCIATION

SCHERF, BRIAN

SIERRA CLUB

FLORIDA BIODIVERSITY PROJECT

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF NPS

WILDERNESS WATCH

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

PEER

PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 63: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 63 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-2208 2/17/12 District of Columbia

OCEANA ET AL V. BUREAU OF OCEAN MANAGEMENT

Party NameDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

OCEANA, INC

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MINERALS LEASING-OFFSHORE

Civil Defensive

11-3294 12-34 1/5/12 ColoradoCITY OF GOLDEN, COLORADO V. UNITED STATES FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL

Party NameUNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

GOLDEN, COLORADO, CITY OF

GOLDEN, COLORADO, CITY OF

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

REFUGE MANAGEMENT

Page 64: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 64 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-388 2/14/12 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS ET AL V. UNITED STATES FISHAND WILDLIFE

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

ROCKY MOUNTAIN WILD

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

REFUGE MANAGEMENT

Page 65: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 65 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-29 2/28/12 MontanaFRIENDS OF THE WILD SWAN, ET AL. V. CHIP WEBER, ET AL

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

WESTERN ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CNTR

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

SWAN VIEW COALTION

FRIENDS OF THE WILD SWAN

SWAN VIEW COALITION INC

FRIENDS OF THE WILD SWAN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 66: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 66 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

90-1331 6/28/90 Alabama, NorthSTATE OF ALABAMA V. CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameMONTGOMERY, CITY OF WATER WORK

ATLANTA, GEORGIA CITY OF ET AL

State of Alabama

State of Florida

INDUSTRIAL, WATER BOARD ALABAM

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 67: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 67 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-4275 10/15/04 California, North

KARUK, TRIBE OF CALIFORNIA V. U.S. FOREST SERVICE, ETAL

Party NameKARUK, TRIBE OF CALIFORNIA

FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

MINERAL EXTRACTION-LOCATABLE MINERALS

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

10/13/09Civil Defensive

07-20027 1/26/07 3/30/11 Texas, SouthIN RE: SCOTIA DEVELOPMENT, LLC., ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 68: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 68 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-2409 11/19/04 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS, ET AL. V. U.S. FORESTSERVICES, ET AL.

Party NameBIODIVERSITY

CENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/29/08Civil Defensive

05-20663 3/8/05 2/9/09 Florida, SouthFRIENDS OF THE EVERGLADES V. UNITED STATES OFAMERICA, ET AL.

Party NameFRIENDS OF THE EVERGLADES

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

CLEAN WATER

Page 69: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 69 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/2/10Civil Defensive

06-479 4/7/06 8/6/10 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES V.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

Party NameNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/31/08Civil Defensive

08-120 2/4/08 8/12/10 Florida, MiddleFORIDA CLEAN WATER NETWORK, INC., ET AL. V. COLONELPAUL L. GROSSKRUGER, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPT OF (FWS)

CITIZENS FOR THE BAY INC

FLORIDA CLEAN WATER NETWORK INC

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 70: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 70 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-5591 09-5889

11/19/09 New JerseyDELAWARE RIVERKEEPER NETWORK V. UNITED STATESARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameDELAWARE RIVERKEEPER

DELAWARE NATURE SOCIETY

DELAWARE RIVERKEEPER NETWORK

CLEAN WATER ACTION

DELAWARE NATURE SOCIETY

DELAWARE RIVERKEEPER NETWORK

CLEAN WATER ACTION

DELAWARE RIVERKEEPER

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

NEW JERSEY ENVIRONMENTAL FEDERATION

NEW JERSEY ENVIRONMENTAL FOUNDATION

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ARMY CORPS CONSTRUCTION & OPERATION STATUT

Page 71: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 71 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-564 6/30/10 Florida, MiddleSIERRA CLUB, ET AL. V. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameMANASOTA-88, INC.

SIERRA CLUB

PEOPLE FOR PROTECTING PEACE RIVER, INC.

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

MANASOTA-88-INC

SIERRA CLUB INC

PEOPLE FOR PROTECTING PEACE RIVER INC

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 72: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 72 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/3/10Civil Defensive

10-1866 7/1/10 9/10/10 Louisiana, EastANIMAL WELFARE INSTITUTE, ET AL. V. BP AMERICA, INC.,ET AL.

Party NameBRITISH PETROLEUM PLC

TURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK

ANIMAL LEGAL DEFENSE FUND

BP AMERICA, INC.

ANIMAL WELFARE INSTITUTE

BP EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

CLEAN WATER

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/3/11Civil Defensive

09-4503 12/31/10 3/30/11 California, North

UNITED STATES V. PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

Party NamePACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC (PG&E)

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

CLEAN AIR

Page 73: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 73 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-10359 12/10/08 MassachusettsRICHARD MAX STRAHAN V. DANIEL HOLMES

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

5/24/04Civil Defensive

98-934 4/15/98 9/23/09 District of Columbia

SOUTHWEST CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL.V. BABBITT, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MEYER, KATHERINE A $85,000.00 2/2/05

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 74: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 74 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/15/06Civil Defensive

98-2234 12/10/98 9/20/11 California, South

SOUTHWEST CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL.V. BERG

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LEVINE, NEIL $9,469.69 11/7/07

Attorney Fees LEVINE, NEIL $537,462.50 11/7/07

Attorney Fees LEVINE, NEIL $120,000.00 3/4/10

Party NameCARMEL, MOUNTAIN CONSERVANCY

SOUTHWEST, CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

RAMONANS, FOR SENSIBLE GROWTH

WETLANDS, ACTION NETWORK

IRON, MOUNTAIN CONSERVANCY

SAVE, OUR FORESTS AND RANCHLANDS

PRESERVE, WILD SANTEE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

99-1320 11/15/99 New MexicoRIO GRANDE SILVERY MINNOW, ET AL. V. ELUID L.MARTINEZ

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LUCAS, LAURENCE (LAIRD) J. $790,985.00 5/23/11

Court Costs LUCAS, LAURENCE (LAIRD) J. $31,018.74 5/23/11

Statutes

INDIAN MISC. CLAIM

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 75: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 75 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

00-68 1/26/00 HawaiiGREENPEACE FOUNDATION V. DONALD EVANS

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ATCHITOFF, PAUL H. $125,000.00 12/30/01

Party NameDALEY, WILLIAM M

CENTER, FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

GREENPEACE, FOUNDATION

TURTLE, ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

00-927 3/16/00 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. BLM

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees CUMMINGS, BRENDAN R. $333,057.75 7/20/01

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 76: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 76 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/12/07Civil Defensive

00-903 5/15/00 9/23/09 ArizonaNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HOME BUILDERS, ET AL. V.BABBITT, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SHAPIRO, JAY $21,315.07 5/7/02

Attorney Fees JAMES, NORMAN D $21,315.07 5/7/02

Attorney Fees JAMES, NORMAN D $225,000.00 10/12/07

Attorney Fees WILMOTH, TOM $21,315.07 5/7/02

Court Costs JAMES, NORMAN D $6,106.89 5/7/02

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

01-79 1/22/01 2/9/09 New MexicoFOREST GUARDIANS, SOUTHWEST ENVIRONMENTALCENTER AND SIERRA CLUB V. FEDERAL EMERGENCYMANAGEMENT AGENCY

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs KENNA AND HICKOX $428.91 5/17/02

Attorney Fees KENNA AND HICKOX $8,450.00 5/17/02

Party NameENVIRONMENTAL, CENTER

FEDERAL, EMERGENCY MGMT AGENCY

FOREST, GUARDIANS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 77: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 77 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

01-0132 1/30/01 Washington, West

WASHINGTON TOXICS COALITION, ET AL. V. EPA

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GOLDMAN, PATTI $625,602.40 6/22/06

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

01-640 5/3/01 OregonNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. NATIONALMARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs STEVE MASHUDA $608.80 12/22/08

Attorney Fees TRUE, TODD $950,000.00 7/10/07

Attorney Fees STEVE MASHUDA $940,000.00 4/12/12

Court Costs TRUE, TODD $1,105.03 10/28/05

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 78: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 78 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/31/10Civil Defensive

01-259 6/7/01 9/22/10 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FOREST SERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameWESTERN, WATERSHEDS PROJECT ET AL

BUREAU, OF LAND MANAGEMENT

FOREST, SERVICE

Statutes

WATER RIGHTS

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

02-1580 4/2/02 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. CHRISTIEWHITMAN, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GRAF, MICHAEL $405,000.00 4/19/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 79: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 79 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/30/07Civil Defensive

02-6087 3/27/02 1/10/12 OregonAMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE COUNCIL, ET AL. V.SECRETARY OF INTERIOR

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

AMERICAN, FOREST RESOURCE COUNCIL ET AL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

02-6100 4/8/02 OregonWESTERN COUNCIL OF INDUSTRIAL WORKERS, ET AL. V.SECRETARY OF INTERIOR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees RUTZICK, MARK C. $0.00

Attorney Fees HAGLUND AND KIRTLEY $80,943.89

Party NameSWANSON, GROUP INC

AMERICAN, FOREST RESOURCE COUNCIL

WESTERN, COUNCIL OF INDUSTRIAL WORKERS

ROUGH, AND READY LUMBER CO

INTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 80: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 80 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/27/07Civil Defensive

02-2006 4/23/02 1/7/11 California, North

PACIFIC COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'SASSOCIATION, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES BUREAU OFRECLAMATION, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MICHAEL MAYER $192,000.00 9/6/06

Party NamePACIFIC, COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'S ASSOC ET AL

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

YUROK, TRIBE

Statutes

INDIAN MISC. CLAIM

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 81: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 81 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/23/10Civil Defensive

03-23427 02-1652

8/20/02 1/24/12 Florida, SouthSIERRA CLUB, ET AL. V. ROBERT B. FLOWERS, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $20,000.00 10/24/08

Attorney Fees GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $255,000.00 10/24/08

Party NameAPAC-FLORIDA, INC.

FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

RINKER MATERIALS OF FLORIDA, INC.

FLOWERS, ROBERT B

WILLIAMS, STEVE

ARMY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS

TARMAC AMERICA LLC

NATIONAL, PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION

KENDALL PROPERTIES

SAWGRASS ROCK QUARRY, INC.

FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

NATURAL, RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

FLORIDA ROCK INDUSTRIES, INC

SIERRA, CLUB

INTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

MIAMI-DADE LIMESTONE PRODUCTS ASSOCIATION, INC.

VECELLIO & GROGAN, INC.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 82: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 82 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/8/05Civil Defensive

02-2259 11/4/00 1/14/09 Washington, West

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. NATIONALMARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Party NameARMY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS

NATIONAL, MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

NATIONAL, WILDLIFE FEDERATION ET AL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

03-29 2/18/03 MontanaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HICKCOX, GEOFF $165,000.00 3/23/09

Attorney Fees HICKCOX, GEOFF $120,000.00 8/30/06

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 83: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 83 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/21/04Civil Defensive

03-142 4/10/03 1/14/09 NebraskaBLASKE MARINE, INC., ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL

Party NameMIDWEST, TERMINAL WAREHOUSE COMPANY INC

MIDWEST, AREA RIVER COALITION 2000

MISSOURI, RIVER KEEPERS

BLASKE, MARINE INC

MO-ARK, ASSOCIATION

INTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

COALITION, TO PROTECT THE MISSOURI RIVER

MAGNOLIA, MARINE TRANSPORT COMPANY

ARMY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS

ERGON, ASPHALT & EMULSIONS INC

CONOCOPHILLIPS COMPANY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

6/22/04Civil Defensive

03-1758 03-1376

8/22/03 9/30/09 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. NORTON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 84: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 84 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/14/07Civil Defensive

03-252 2/25/03 1/7/11 New MexicoCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. NORTON,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs ROBIN COOLEY $3,267.00 12/4/07

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $92,733.00 12/4/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/26/05Civil Defensive

03-888 7/1/03 9/22/10 OregonOREGON NATURAL RESOURCES COUNCIL, ET AL. V. DAVIDB. ALLEN, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 85: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 85 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/12/06Civil Defensive

03-112 7/15/03 2/25/09 MontanaSWAN VIEW COALITION, ET AL. V. CATHY BARBOULETOS,ET AL.

Party NameSWAN, VIEW COALITION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

FRIENDS, OF THE WILD SWAN

FOREST, SERVICE

ALLIANCE, FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

WILDLANDS, CENTER FOR PREVENTING ROADS

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

3/29/06Civil Defensive

03-2444 8/20/03 11/24/10 MarylandNATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL V. EPA

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees AARON COLANGELO $140,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 86: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 86 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

03-1607 8/22/03 ColoradoCITY OF GREELEY, COLORADO V. UNITED STATES FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Party NameGREELEY, CITY OF COLORADO

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

3/1/05Civil Defensive

03-2824 9/16/03 2/4/09 Washington, West

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. FEMA

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HASSELMAN, JAN $117,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 87: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 87 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/3/09Civil Defensive

04-75 03-547 10/30/03 1/7/11 ArizonaTUCSON HERPETOLOGICAL SOCIETY, ET AL. V. NORTON,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LEVINE, NEIL $123,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/10/11Civil Defensive

08-2775 12/23/08 4/7/11 ColoradoMOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION V. NORTON, ET AL.

Party NameMOUNTAIN, STATES LEGAL FOUNDAT

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 88: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 88 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-61 1/16/04 OregonAMERICAN RIVERS, ET AL. V. NATIONAL OCEANIC ANDATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/20/07Civil Defensive

04-299 04-60 1/16/04 4/28/11 IdahoNEZ PERCE TRIBE V. NATIONAL OCEANIC ANDATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION, ET AL.

Party NameNEZ, PERCE TRIBE

NATIONAL, OCEANIC AND ATMOSPERIC ADMIN

INTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 89: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 89 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/29/08Civil Defensive

04-242 2/3/04 1/7/11 California, EastSURF-OCEAN BEACH COMMISSION, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs R.S. RADFORD $265.33 7/24/09

Attorney Fees R.S. RADFORD $16,247.83 7/24/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/30/05Civil Defensive

04-63 1/14/04 9/30/09 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $30,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/1/05Civil Defensive

04-349 3/15/04 9/30/09 Florida, MiddleSAVE OUR BIG SCRUB, INC., ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MURPHY, JENNIFER $44,833.09

Attorney Fees PABEN, BRETT M. $12,106.35

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 90: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 90 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/19/07Civil Defensive

04-1299 5/27/04 Washington, West

PACIFIC COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'SASSOCIATIONS, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIESSERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameKLAMATH, FOREST ALLIANCE

NATIONAL, MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

SISKIYOU, REGIONAL EDUCATION PROJECT

UMPQUA, WATERSHEDS INC

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

FOREST, SERVICE

OREGON, NATURAL RESOURCES COUN FUND

WILDERNESS, SOCIETY

PACIFIC, RIVERS COUNCIL

KLAMATH, SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER

PACIFIC, COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'S

INSTITUTE, FOR FISHERIES RESOURCES

NORTHWEST, ECOSYSTEM ALLIANCE

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 91: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 91 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-779 8/31/05 1/7/11 District of Columbia

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. NORTON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/5/10Civil Defensive

04-384 6/14/04 3/5/10 IdahoFRIENDS OF THE CLEARWATER, ET AL. V. LOHN, ET AL.

Party NameECOLOGY, CENTER

FRIENDS, OF THE CLEARWATER

NATIONAL, OCEANIC AND ATMOSPERIC ADMIN

ALLIANCE, FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

IDAHO, SPORTING CONGRESS

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 92: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 92 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-1230 7/22/04 District of Columbia

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $17,316.00 7/9/08

Court Costs GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $273.00 7/9/08

Party NameDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE ET AL

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

12/21/04Civil Defensive

04-3240 8/10/04 9/30/09 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. NORTON

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HICKCOX, GEOFF $10,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 93: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 93 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/22/09Civil Defensive

04-1660 9/27/04 4/27/11 District of Columbia

FRIENDS OF ANIMALS V. GALE NORTON, ET AL.

Party NameFRIENDS OF ANIMALS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

11/29/11Civil Defensive

04-2026 11/18/04 2/28/12 District of Columbia

BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION ALLIANCE, ET AL. V.NORTON, ET AL

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $193,738.22 12/22/11

Attorney Fees LEVINE, NEIL $54,000.00

Court Costs GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $1,261.78 12/22/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 94: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 94 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

04-236 12/2/04 MontanaCABINET RESOURCE GROUP, ET AL. V. U.S. FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/17/08Civil Defensive

04-2091 12/2/04 1/7/11 District of Columbia

PACIFIC SHORES SUBDIVISION CALIFORNIA WATERDISTRICT, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OFENGINEERS, ET AL.

Party NamePLECHATY, RON

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

PACIFIC, SHORES SUBDIVISION CALIFORNIA WATER DIST

FERGUSON, HELEN

GOODGAME, LOUIS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ARMY CORPS CONSTRUCTION & OPERATION STATUT

Page 95: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 95 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/1/10Civil Defensive

04-1813 12/14/04 7/27/10 OregonALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES, INC., ET AL. V. ALLEN,ET AL

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees TUHOLSKE, JACK R $196,868.75 6/15/10

Attorney Fees TUHOLSKE, JACK R $42,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-10275 2/10/05 MassachusettsRICHARD MAX STRAHAN V. DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE, ETAL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-1207 05-690

2/15/05 California, EastNATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, ET AL. V.NORTON

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ORR, TRENT W ATTY $1,906,500.00 2/22/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 96: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 96 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/11/10Civil Defensive

05-189 2/11/05 4/27/11 Washington, West

FRIENDS OF THE EAST FORK AND FISH FIRST V. ROBERTLOHN, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SVEND A. BRANDT-ERICHSEN $30,000.00 12/22/10

Party NameNATIONAL, OCEANIC AND ATMOSPERIC ADMIN

FRIENDS OF THE EAST FORK

NATIONAL, MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

FISH FIRST

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

4/18/08Civil Defensive

05-165 2/3/05 6/19/09 OregonCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. U.S. FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs STEPHANIE PARENT $115,000.00 2/9/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 97: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 97 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

05-560 3/22/05 California, EastCALIFORNIA STATE GRANGE, ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees RIVETT, ROBIN L. $25,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/14/06Civil Defensive

05-1363 3/30/05 7/27/10 California, EastHOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERNCALIFORNIA, ET AL. V. MATTHEW J. HOGAN, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HOPPER, REED $60,000.00 2/23/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 98: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 98 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

05-2524 05-629

3/30/05 California, EastHOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERNCALIFORNIA, ET AL. V. U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BRIAN SEGEE $2,128.85 5/15/08

Attorney Fees BRIAN SEGEE $68,010.00 5/15/08

Party NameGREENHORN GRANGE

BUILDING INDUSTRY LEGAL DEFENSE FOUNDATION

CALIFORNIA STATE GRANGE

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION

HOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 99: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 99 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

10/15/09Civil Defensive

05-64 4/29/05 2/24/10 MontanaSWAN VIEW COALITION, ET AL. V. CATHY BARBOULETOS,ET AL.

Party NameSWAN, VIEW COALITION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/24/08Civil Defensive

05-623 4/4/05 4/8/09 District of Columbia

RESEARCH AIR INC., ET AL. V. GALE NORTON, ET AL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 100: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 100 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/24/07Civil Defensive

05-313 5/6/05 9/23/09 Ohio, SouthHEARTWOOD, ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-1043 5/23/05 1/14/09 District of Columbia

AMERICAN WILDLANDS, ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 101: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 101 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

05-181 6/16/05 Washington, East

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY V. GALE NORTON, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BRIAN A. KNUTSEN $151.46 10/13/11

Attorney Fees BRIAN A. KNUTSEN $82,848.54 10/13/11

Attorney Fees SMITH, RICHARD A. $55,000.00 7/31/07

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

WASHINGTON, TROUT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

MISC. FEDERAL PROGRAM

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/15/10Civil Defensive

05-346 6/20/05 2/24/10 Iowa, SouthIOWA ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL, ET AL. V. STEVENJOHNSON, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 102: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 102 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

10/6/08Civil Defensive

05-461 7/26/05 10/17/08 HawaiiAMERICAN BIRD CONSERVANCY, ET AL. V. FEDERALCOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/25/07Civil Defensive

06-14197 05-1671

8/22/05 8/12/10 Florida, SouthNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. FRANCIS J.HARVEY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 103: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 103 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/9/09Civil Defensive

06-245 8/9/05 11/29/10 California, EastPACIFIC COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'SASSOCIATION, ET AL. V. GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SHERWOOD, MICHAEL $76,281.00 3/3/11

Attorney Fees SHERWOOD, MICHAEL $2,117,219.00 3/3/11

Party NameNATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

FRIENDS OF THE RIVER

SACRAMENTO RIVER PRESERVATION TRUST

PACIFIC COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMEN'S ASSOCIATIONS

CALIFORNIA TROUT

WINNEMEM WINTU, TRIBE

BAYKEEPER

UNITED STATES BUREAU OF RECLAMATION

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

INSTITUTE FOR FISHERIES RESOURCES

THE BAY INSTITUTE

NORTHERN CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF FLY FISHERS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 104: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 104 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/5/07Civil Defensive

05-248 8/17/05 3/29/11 Washington, East

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. SUSAN MARTIN, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ADVOCATES FOR THE WEST $396,832.00

Party NameTHE LANDS COUNCIL

IDAHO CONSERVATION LEAGUE

DEFENDERS, OF WILDLIFE

CONSERVATION, NORTHWEST

SELKIRK CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-1279 8/17/05 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER V. DAVIDB. ALLEN, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 105: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 105 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/2/06Civil Defensive

05-1363 7/8/05 3/7/11 District of Columbia

MARILYN WALL, ET AL. V. NORTON

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees UKEILEY, ROBERT $13,107.50

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/20/09Civil Defensive

05-1278 9/8/05 4/23/09 Arkansas, EastNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. FRANCIS J.HARVEY, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SARGENT, RANDOLPH M. $3,656.99 5/11/09

Attorney Fees SARGENT, RANDOLPH M. $316,343.01 5/11/09

Party NameARKANSAS WILDLIFE FEDERATION

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

Statutes

ARMY CORPS CONSTRUCTION & OPERATION STATUT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 106: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 106 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/26/07Civil Defensive

05-1573 9/9/05 8/13/09 Louisiana, WestHAROLD SCHOEFFLER, ET AL. V. GALE NORTON

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs TUTCHTON, JAY $2,593.55

Attorney Fees TUTCHTON, JAY $72,406.45

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/29/06Civil Defensive

05-1063 10/5/05 3/7/11 New MexicoFOREST GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs ROBIN COOLEY $299.67 9/1/06

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $11,200.33 9/1/06

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-1835 11/4/05 Washington, West

SEATTLE AUDUBON SOCIETY, ET AL. V. NORTON, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees KAMPMERIER, PAUL $26,000.00 9/22/06

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 107: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 107 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/22/09Civil Defensive

06-2120 05-4363

10/26/05 4/27/11 California, North

REBECCA ANN CARY, ET AL. V. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Party NameSCHMIDT, MISTI MARIE

BOBAN, DEBRA JOAN

HUMANE SOCIETY OF UNITED STATES

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

KIMYA INSTITUTE

CARY, REBECCA ANN

BORN FREE USA

CLARK, BILL

SLACKMAN, MARCIA

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

5/11/09Civil Defensive

05-1877 11/14/05 10/27/09 Washington, West

SALMON SPAWNING & RECOVERY ALLIANCE, ET AL. V.CARLOS M. GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 108: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 108 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/9/10Civil Defensive

05-1878 11/14/05 6/3/10 Washington, West

SALMON SPAWNING & RECOVERY ALLIANCE, ET AL. V.GALE A. NORTON, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-23045 11/21/05 Florida, SouthMICCOSUKEE TRIBE OF INDIANS OF FLORIDA V. FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameMICCOSUKEE TRIBE OF INDIANS OF FLORIDA

U.S. FISH & WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 109: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 109 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/9/08Civil Defensive

05-2191 11/9/05 1/26/09 District of Columbia

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. CARLOS M.GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $6,833.00 1/6/09

Attorney Fees GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $313,167.00 1/6/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-1675 11/10/05 Florida, MiddleFLORIDA HOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION V. GALE A.NORTON, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees STEVEN GIESELER $20,000.00 9/20/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

05-1876 12/13/05 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES V. EPA, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 110: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 110 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

06-296 2/21/06 ColoradoTHE WILDERNESS SOCIETY, ET AL. V. SALLY WISELY, ETAL.

Party NameCOLORADO ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION

CNETER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS

SIERRA CLUB

THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY

U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

U.S. BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FED LAND POLICY MGM

MINERALS LEASING-ONSHORE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 111: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 111 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/1/06Civil Defensive

06-494 2/16/06 1/7/11 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. U.S.BUREAU OF RECLAMATION, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees KENNA AND HICKOX $20,500.00 2/1/07

Party NameSIERRA CLUB

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

U.S. BUREAU OF RECLAMATION

ARIZONA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

GLEN CANYON INSTITUTE

LIVING RIVERS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

9/8/08Civil Defensive

06-1075 2/16/06 10/17/08 California, North

GEERTSON FARMS INC., ET AL. V. MIKE JOHANNS, ET AL.

Party NameGEERTSON FARM, INC.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. FEDERAL PROGRAM

Page 112: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 112 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

06-73 2/21/06 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/26/06Civil Defensive

06-32 3/20/06 9/23/09 Texas, SouthTEXAS GENERAL LAND OFFICE V. GALE NORTON, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/23/10Civil Defensive

06-308 3/21/06 11/29/10 California, EastCALIFORNIA STATE GRANGE, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 113: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 113 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/2/08Civil Defensive

06-231 3/27/06 10/13/10 New MexicoFOREST GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFESERVICE

Party NameSIERRA CLUB

FOREST, GUARDIANS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

NEW MEXICO AUDUBON COUNCIL

PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL RES

SOUTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER

CHIHUAHUAN DERSERT CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

11/21/06Civil Defensive

06-24 2/15/06 9/23/09 MontanaTHE ECOLOGY CENTER, INC. V. BOB CASTANEDA, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 114: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 114 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/21/08Civil Defensive

06-561 4/20/06 9/22/10 Washington, West

ROZ GLASSER V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

GLASSER, ROZ

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

6/13/07Civil Defensive

06-483 4/6/06 9/23/09 Washington, West

TROUT UNLIMITED V. D. ROBERT LOHN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 115: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 115 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/14/07Civil Defensive

06-6093 5/1/06 9/30/09 OregonALSEA VALLEY ALLIANCE V. CONRAD C. LAUTENBACHER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/27/10Civil Defensive

06-73 5/11/06 3/5/10 MontanaSWAN VIEW COALITION V. CATHY BARBOULETOS

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ROHLF, DANIEL J. $17,193.00 4/7/09

Statutes

FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

8/15/08Civil Defensive

05-168 06-50 4/18/06 9/23/09 MaineNULANKEYUTMONEN NKIHTAHKOMIKUMON V. GALENORTON

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees $0.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 116: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 116 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

10/22/07Civil Defensive

07-572 06-932 5/17/06 9/23/09 District of Columbia

HOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERNCALIFORNIA, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFESERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

06-453 5/19/06 California, EastMODESTO IRRIGATION DISTRICT V. CARLOS GUTIERREZ

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/11/07Civil Defensive

06-80532 6/1/06 12/30/08 Florida, SouthNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION V. PAUL SOUZA

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees DAVIS, GARY $12,249.79 3/6/07

Attorney Fees SARGENT, RANDOLPH M. $37,758.21 4/17/07

Party NameNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 117: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 117 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

06-3604 6/7/06 California, North

CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY V. EPA

Party NameEPA

CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

3/11/09Civil Defensive

06-2641 6/13/06 6/2/09 New JerseyAMERICAN BIRD CONSERVANCY V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 118: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 118 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/14/08Civil Defensive

06-1493 6/26/06 2/12/09 OregonTROUT UNLIMITED V. D. ROBERT LOHN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/6/09Civil Defensive

06-946 7/7/06 3/17/09 OregonOREGON NATURAL DESERT ASS'N V. D. ROBERT LOHN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/4/08Civil Defensive

06-1744 7/13/06 9/23/09 ArizonaARIZONA CATTLE GROWERS ASSOCIATION V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 119: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 119 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

06-1279 7/19/06 District of Columbia

THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL. V.DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/4/07Civil Defensive

06-277 7/14/06 6/9/10 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. US FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LUCAS, LAURENCE (LAIRD) J. $135,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

06-11312 7/31/06 MassachusettsRICHARD STRAHAN V. MICHAEL MULLEN, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 120: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 120 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/28/11Civil Defensive

06-4884 8/14/06 3/8/12 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. BLM

Party NamePUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILTY

CALIFORNIA WILDRNESS COALITION

SIERRA CLUB

WILDERNESS SOCIETY

ALLIANCE FOR RESPONSIBLE RECREATION

DESERT SURVIVORS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY

FRIENDS OF JUNIPER FLATS

WESTERN SAN BERNIDINO COUNTY LAND OWNERS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FED LAND POLICY MGM

Page 121: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 121 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/13/09Civil Defensive

06-9 8/16/06 9/16/11 AlaskaSOUTHEAST ALASKA CONSERVATION COUNCIL, ET AL. V.FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. FEDERAL PROGRAM

FOREST MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Civil Defensive

06-1190 8/22/06 OregonBARK, ET AL. V. REN LOHOEFENER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 122: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 122 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

06-410 9/6/06 Florida, NorthSTATE OF FLORIDA V. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

11/5/07Civil Defensive

06-471 9/7/06 7/7/09 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs KENNA AND HICKOX $646.14 12/5/07

Attorney Fees KENNA AND HICKOX $24,853.86 12/5/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/14/09Civil Defensive

06-1462 10/10/06 1/20/10 Washington, West

SALMON SPAWNING & RECOVERY ALLIANCE, ET AL. V. D.ROBERT LOHN, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 123: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 123 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/21/08Civil Defensive

06-22557 10/17/06 10/28/08 Florida, SouthNATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION, INC., ETAL. V. U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, ET AL.

Party NameTROPICAL AUDUBON SOCIETY

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

NATIONAL PARKS CONSEVATIONS ASSOCIATION

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

06-1584 11/3/06 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER, ET AL.V. REN LOHOEFENER, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 124: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 124 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/4/10Civil Defensive

06-1946 11/14/06 9/29/10 District of Columbia

COUNTY OF SAN MIGUEL, ET AL. V. JULIE MACDONALD, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs HICKCOX, GEOFF $1,854.96 10/19/09

Attorney Fees HICKCOX, GEOFF $123,145.04 10/19/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/3/07Civil Defensive

06-226 12/15/06 9/30/09 MaineCONSERVATION LAW FOUNDATION, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees PARENTEAU, PATRICK A ESQ $11,650.00 10/26/07

Court Costs PARENTEAU, PATRICK A ESQ $350.00 10/26/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 125: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 125 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/28/09Civil Defensive

06-2560 11/29/06 5/12/11 California, South

FOREST GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs ROBIN COOLEY $1,271.87 12/19/08

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $23,563.54 5/15/08

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $23,728.13 12/19/08

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $65,000.00 9/11/09

Court Costs ROBIN COOLEY $436.46 5/15/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/5/07Civil Defensive

06-1186 12/6/06 10/29/10 New MexicoFOREST GUARDIANS V. UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 126: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 126 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/11/07Civil Defensive

06-2151 12/19/06 10/8/09 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs MIYOKO SAKASHITA $766.42 6/21/07

Attorney Fees MIYOKO SAKASHITA $17,233.58 6/21/07

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

06-2845 12/14/06 California, EastSOUTH YUBA RIVER CITIZENS LEAGUE, ET AL. V. NATIONALMARINE FISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/8/08Civil Defensive

06-1121 12/21/06 10/28/08 Texas, WestAQUIFER GUARDIANS IN URBAN AREAS, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 127: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 127 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-38 1/5/07 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/1/10Civil Defensive

07-60 1/10/07 7/29/10 California, EastSIERRA FOREST PRODUCTS, INC. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/31/08Civil Defensive

07-142 1/19/07 1/22/09 District of Columbia

OCEANA, INC. V. CARLOS M. GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 128: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 128 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/22/07Civil Defensive

07-25 1/24/07 9/23/09 WyomingSTATE OF WYOMING V. U.S. DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR, ETAL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

11/7/08Civil Defensive

07-358 3/9/07 3/16/10 OregonINSTITUTE FOR WILDLIFE PROTECTION V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees WEBB, DON R. $104,902.47 12/12/08

Court Costs WEBB, DON R. $2,451.04 12/12/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 129: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 129 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/9/09Civil Defensive

07-216 3/22/07 3/4/09 Alabama, SouthSIERRA CLUB, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameGULF RESTORATION NETWORK

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

SIERRA CLUB

U.S. DEPT. OF INTERIOR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 130: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 130 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/8/09Civil Defensive

07-484 3/12/07 2/24/10 District of Columbia

AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Party NameAMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE

U.S. DEPT. OF INTERIOR

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

1/16/08Civil Defensive

06-6685 10/23/06 3/24/09 California, North

NORTHERN CALIFORNIA RIVER WATCH, ET AL. V.CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 131: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 131 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/4/08Civil Defensive

07-161 4/6/07 2/24/10 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees TUCCI, TODD C. $110,000.00 6/25/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/15/08Civil Defensive

07-677 4/16/07 9/7/11 District of Columbia

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MICHAEL SOULES $280,000.00 1/13/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 132: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 132 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/1/10Civil Defensive

07-14114 4/23/07 8/12/10 Florida, SouthNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. PAUL SOUZA,ET AL.

Party NameCONSERVANCY OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

FLORIDA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

COLLIER COUNTY AUDUBON SOCIETY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

07-243 6/4/07 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT, ET AL. V.CHRISTOPHER SERVHEEN, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 133: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 133 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-2794 5/30/07 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION AGENCY, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JUSTIN AUGUSTINE $172,000.00 11/22/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-6228 5/30/07 OregonJACK MARINCOVICH, ET AL. V. CONRAD C.LAUTENBACHER, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/11/08Civil Defensive

07-247 6/5/07 6/22/10 IdahoNEZ PERCE TRIBE V. NOAA FISHERIES, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 134: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 134 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/25/09Civil Defensive

07-1220 7/6/07 9/29/09 District of Columbia

FISHERIES SURVIVAL FUND V. CARLOS GUTIERREZ

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/8/08Civil Defensive

07-582 7/12/07 12/5/08 Texas, WestAQUIFER GUARDIANS IN URBAN AREAS V. U.S. ARMYCORPS. OF ENGINEERS, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-24 8/2/07 IdahoROBERT H. ALAND V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 135: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 135 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/31/09Civil Defensive

07-372 8/2/07 5/25/10 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEMPTHORNE, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BUSE, JOHN T $1,133.45 8/13/09

Attorney Fees BUSE, JOHN T $51,866.55 8/13/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-1545 8/29/07 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/26/10Civil Defensive

07-4347 8/23/07 3/26/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SIVAS, DEBORAH A. $2,942.50 3/18/08

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $6,610.00 3/18/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 136: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 136 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-2216 07-876

9/6/07 New MexicoCOALITION OF ARIZONA/NEW MEXICO COUNTIES FORSTABLE ECONOMIC GROWTH, ET AL. V. KEMPTHORNE, ETAL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-1396 9/20/07 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER, ET AL.V.U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees DANIEL P. MENSHER $40,000.00 7/13/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 137: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 137 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-4771 9/17/07 California, North

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, ET AL. V.CARLOS GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

COUSTEAU, JEAN MICHEL

CETACEAN SOCIETY INTERNATIONAL

NAVY, DEPARTMENT OF THE

INTERNATIONAL FUND FOR ANIMALS WELFARE

LEAGUE FOR COASTAL PROTECTION

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

OCEAN FUTURES SOCIETY

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL INC

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

DEFENSE DEPARTMENT PROGRAM

Page 138: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 138 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-484 9/25/07 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs MELANIE KAY $3,285.96 2/9/12

Attorney Fees MELANIE KAY $159,044.00 2/9/12

Party NameMELANIE KAY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-1756 10/1/07 District of Columbia

SIERRA CLUB, ET AL. V. LT. GEN ROBERT L. VAN ANTWERP,ET AL.

Party NameSOMMERVILLE, RICHARD

CLEAN WATER ACTION

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

GULF RESTORATION NETWORK

SIERRA CLUB

LOY, CHRIS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 139: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 139 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

1/16/08Civil Defensive

07-5075 10/2/07 3/4/09 California, North

NORTHERN CALIFORNIA RIVER WATCH, ET AL. V.DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/31/09Civil Defensive

07-409 10/2/07 9/24/09 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JUDITH M. BRAWER $34,225.00 8/18/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 140: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 140 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/4/08Civil Defensive

07-837 10/30/07 UtahFOREST GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. FISH AND WILDLIFESERVICE

Party NameUTAH ENVIRONMENTAL CONGRESS

FOREST GUARDIANS

CENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICES

WILLIAMS, TERRY TEMPEST

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-134 11/13/07 MontanaGREATER YELLOWSTONE COALITION, INC. V.CHRISTOPHER SERVHEEN, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees DOUGLAS HONNOLD $291,262.00 3/23/12

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 141: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 141 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-2073 11/15/07 District of Columbia

FRIENDS OF MISSISSIPPI PUBLIC LANDS, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MISTY EWEGEN $9,986.75 7/3/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/19/08Civil Defensive

07-596 11/15/07 12/3/08 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. U.S. FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BRAWER, JUDITH $3,850.00 7/16/08

Court Costs BRAWER, JUDITH $450.00 7/16/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/5/09Civil Defensive

07-152 11/15/07 9/10/10 MontanaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. U.S. FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs PRESO, TIMOTHY J $176.06

Attorney Fees PRESO, TIMOTHY J $26,823.94

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 142: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 142 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-657 11/15/07 New MexicoCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/22/09Civil Defensive

08-4811 11/15/07 12/15/10 California, Central

CALIFORNIA TROUT, INC. ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $13,000.00 2/10/09

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $377.16 2/10/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-1791 11/5/07 Washington, West

NORTHWEST COALITION FOR ALTERNATIVES TOPESTICIDES, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIESSERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JOSHUA OSBORNE-KLEIN $41,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 143: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 143 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/25/08Civil Defensive

07-2464 11/27/07 7/29/10 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYTEMS, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $4,833.00 3/19/08

Court Costs JAMES J. TUTCHTON $367.00 3/19/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/25/08Civil Defensive

07-2928 11/27/07 12/7/10 Georgia, NorthCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. SAM HAMILTON, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LAWRENCE SANDERS $369.00 6/5/08

Attorney Fees LAWRENCE SANDERS $2,585.00 6/5/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 144: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 144 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-8164 12/7/07 ArizonaGRAND CANYON TRUST V. U.S. BUREAU OF RECLAMATION,ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

GRAND CANYON TRUST

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-150 12/5/07 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES V. U.S. FORESTSERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BECHTOLD, TIMOTHY M. $15,000.00 1/27/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 145: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 145 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

07-1871 12/21/07 OregonOREGON NATURAL DESERT ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V.ABIGAIL KIMBELL, ET AL.

Party NameWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

OREGON NATURAL DESERT ASSOCIATION

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

FOREST MANAGEMENT

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

4/11/08Civil Defensive

07-2378 12/19/07 2/22/12 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $428.50 5/12/08

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $3,494.00 5/12/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 146: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 146 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/2/08Civil Defensive

07-2261 12/17/07 6/12/09 District of Columbia

SIERRA CLUB, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JOSHUA STEBBINS $15,200.00 7/10/08

Court Costs JOSHUA STEBBINS $603.08 7/10/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-1277 12/19/07 New MexicoFOREST GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $20,000.00 2/4/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

07-8221 12/19/07 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $432.00 7/16/08

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $6,330.00 7/16/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 147: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 147 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/5/09Civil Defensive

07-6404 12/19/07 9/10/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEMPTHORNE, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs ERIN M. TOBIN $390.12

Attorney Fees ERIN M. TOBIN $20,000.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

11/19/10Civil Defensive

07-2379 12/19/07 2/8/11 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $432.00 8/12/08

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $6,568.00 8/12/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 148: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 148 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

1/21/11Civil Defensive

07-2380 12/19/07 4/27/11 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $8,561.00

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $738.88

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/14/08Civil Defensive

07-6406 12/19/07 6/12/09 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ANDREA TREECE $6,000.00 6/6/08

Court Costs ANDREA TREECE $410.18 6/6/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 149: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 149 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/15/09Civil Defensive

08-11 1/3/08 9/4/09 District of Columbia

FOREST GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees UKEILEY, ROBERT $4,805.00

Court Costs UKEILEY, ROBERT $373.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/6/10Civil Defensive

08-32 1/24/08 9/9/10 Washington, East

PALOUSE PRAIRIE FOUNDATION, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs $89.00 8/19/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/4/09Civil Defensive

07-530 12/18/07 3/9/10 Florida, NorthPAUL AND GAYLE FISHER, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ETAL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 150: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 150 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-151 2/5/08 OregonALLEN, HARLEY AND SHERRIE, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/18/08Civil Defensive

08-335 2/27/08 2/6/09 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. H. DALE HALL, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SENATORE, MICHAEL P. $400.00 10/16/08

Attorney Fees SENATORE, MICHAEL P. $8,100.00 10/16/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/28/08Civil Defensive

08-214 2/21/08 2/6/09 OregonWALT MODEN, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 151: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 151 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/21/09Civil Defensive

08-441 3/3/08 3/26/10 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LEVINE, NEIL $35,269.56 12/5/08

Court Costs LEVINE, NEIL $374.44 12/5/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-1278 3/5/08 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-28 2/29/08 MontanaROCK CREEK ALLIANCE, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 152: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 152 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-2113 3/10/08 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameNATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL INC

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

GREENPEACE, INC.

Statutes

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

2/12/09Civil Defensive

08-1407 3/10/08 4/28/10 Illinois, NorthNORTHWOODS WILDERNESS RECOVERY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees AARON BLOOM $29,650.00 3/9/09

Court Costs AARON BLOOM $350.00 3/9/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 153: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 153 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-383 3/3/08 District of Columbia

OTAY MESA PROPERTY, ET AL. V. DEPARTMENT OFINTERIOR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/9/09Civil Defensive

08-472 3/19/08 3/26/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees TUTCHTON, JAY $17,092.00 4/6/09

Court Costs TUTCHTON, JAY $400.00 4/6/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 154: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 154 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/23/10Civil Defensive

08-14115 4/2/08 8/12/10 Florida, SouthNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. PAUL SOUZA,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GOLDMAN, JAN $208,245.24 7/21/10

Court Costs GOLDMAN, JAN $5,754.76 7/21/10

Party NameCOLLIER COUNTY AUDUBON SOCIETY

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

FLORIDA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

CONSERVANCY OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

INTERIOR, DEPT OF (FWS)

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

5/4/10Civil Defensive

08-1814 4/4/08 3/1/11 California, North

PESTICIDE ACTION NETWORK NORTH AMERICA, ET AL. V.UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 155: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 155 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-443 3/13/08 1/29/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs UKEILEY, ROBERT $395.00

Attorney Fees UKEILEY, ROBERT $6,544.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-689 4/9/08 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs MELISSA A. HAILEY $450.00 5/26/09

Attorney Fees MELISSA A. HAILEY $44,550.00 5/26/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 156: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 156 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/17/09Civil Defensive

08-56 4/28/08 9/7/11 MontanaDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JENNY HARBINE $261,395.00 3/6/09

Court Costs JENNY HARBINE $1,704.66 3/6/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-676 4/17/08 1/29/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MATTHEW BISHOP $14,418.00 1/7/09

Court Costs MATTHEW BISHOP $1,134.26 1/7/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/12/09Civil Defensive

08-1488 3/18/08 4/21/09 California, North

MAN AGAINST EXTINCTION V. H. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 157: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 157 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/29/08Civil Defensive

08-146 5/12/08 9/23/09 MaineFRIENDS OF MERRYMEETING BAY, ET AL. V. CARLOSGUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/13/11Civil Defensive

08-820 5/1/08 1/10/12 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 158: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 158 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/27/09Civil Defensive

08-80553 5/23/08 8/12/10 Florida, SouthPALM BEACH COUNTY ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION, ET AL.V. THE STATE OF FLORIDA, ET AL.

Party NameSHULTZ, PETER

TSOLKAS, PETER PANAGIOTI

PALM BEACH COUNTY ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION

LARSON, ALEXANDRIA

WAITE, SHARON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

2/8/10Civil Defensive

08-1592 3/24/08 1/5/12 California, North

HOMER T. MCCRARY V. CARLOS M. GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 159: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 159 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-335 6/3/08 2/23/11 ArizonaDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE V. DALE HALL, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/1/10Civil Defensive

08-1316 6/11/08 10/22/10 California, EastBUTTE ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL V. UNITED STATESARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

BUTTE ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 160: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 160 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-159 7/8/08 AlaskaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NamePACIFIC ENVIRONMENT

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MARINE MAMMAL

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

3/30/10Civil Defensive

08-2999 6/18/08 7/27/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. MICHAELCHERTOFF, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 161: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 161 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/12/08Civil Defensive

08-1034 6/10/08 10/28/08 California, South

AMERICAN SAND ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HUBBARD, DAVID P. $8,000.00 10/28/08

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/23/09Civil Defensive

08-7679 7/2/08 9/23/09 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. BUREAU OFLAND MANAGEMENT

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

DESERT SURVIVORS

ARMY DEPARTMENT OF

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

DEFENSE DEPARTMENT PROGRAM

RANGELAND MANAGEMENT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 162: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 162 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

10/27/08Civil Defensive

08-1129 6/30/08 2/12/09 District of Columbia

COOK INLET BELUGA WHALE, ET AL. V. CARLOSGUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-1352 8/4/08 District of Columbia

STATE OF ALASKA V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

MARINE MAMMAL

Civil Defensive

08-1067 7/11/08 Washington, West

CONSERVATION NORTHWEST, ET AL. V. MARK E. REY, ETAL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 163: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 163 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-10919 5/30/08 MassachusettsRICHARD MAX STRAHAN V. GARY ROUGHEAD, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/12/09Civil Defensive

08-939 8/8/08 7/27/10 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER V.UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

NORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 164: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 164 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/9/11Civil Defensive

08-946 8/12/08 4/7/11 OregonCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. PAULHENSON, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

11/10/10Civil Defensive

08-1470 8/13/08 1/5/11 California, South

SAVE SAN ONOFRE COALITION, ET AL. V. CARLOSGUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/30/09Civil Defensive

08-1496 8/27/08 5/5/09 District of Columbia

AMERICAN PETROLEUM INSTITUTE, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 165: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 165 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/20/09Civil Defensive

08-1202 8/11/08 2/22/12 Washington, West

INSTITUTE FOR WILDLIFE PROTECTION, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees DON WEBB $20,000.00 3/11/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/17/08Civil Defensive

08-1107 6/26/08 4/8/09 District of Columbia

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. CARLOS GUTIERREZ,ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

MARINE MAMMAL

2/24/09Civil Defensive

08-1936 8/19/08 3/25/09 California, EastCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LOARIE, GREG $27,000.00 3/20/09

Court Costs LOARIE, GREG $534.28 3/20/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 166: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 166 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-1550 9/8/08 District of Columbia

SAFARI CLUB INTERNATIONAL, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

5/29/09Civil Defensive

08-1593 9/15/08 6/18/09 District of Columbia

THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL. V.CARLOS GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MARINE MAMMAL

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 167: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 167 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/27/10Civil Defensive

08-1353 9/9/08 10/29/10 Washington, West

PRESERVE OUR ISLANDS, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES ARMYCORPS OF ENGINEERS, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs MANN, DAVID S. $482.10 10/20/10

Attorney Fees MANN, DAVID S. $81,017.90 10/20/10

Party NameARMY CORP OF ENGINEERS

PEOPLE FOR PUGET SOUND

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

PRESERVE OUR ISLANDS

WASHINGTON ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MARINE MAMMAL

FISHERIES/MARINE RES

5/3/10Civil Defensive

08-156 9/5/08 11/24/10 Washington, West

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY V. ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION AGENCY

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BRIAN A. KNUTSEN $138,000.00 10/13/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 168: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 168 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/30/09Civil Defensive

08-1547 9/8/08 1/5/11 District of Columbia

DOUGLAS COUNTY, OREGON, ET AL. V. JAMES W.BALSINGER, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-535 10/2/08 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. U.S. FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HICKCOX, GEOFF $95,000.00 4/23/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-1689 10/2/08 District of Columbia

CALIFORNIA CATTLEMEN'S ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 169: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 169 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/24/09Civil Defensive

08-1679 10/1/08 4/9/10 District of Columbia

FISHERIES SURVIVAL FUND V. CARLOS GUTIERREZ

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/13/12Civil Defensive

08-2830 9/9/08 2/22/12 Georgia, NorthCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. SAM HAMILTON, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HARRIS, MIKE $51,098.00 9/11/09

Court Costs HARRIS, MIKE $372.16 9/11/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-1490 10/2/08 California, EastCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $406.92 8/14/09

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $4,929.00 8/14/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 170: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 170 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/10/09Civil Defensive

08-139 9/30/08 12/9/10 MontanaDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees PRESO, TIMOTHY J $12,247.50 6/23/09

Court Costs PRESO, TIMOTHY J $416.01 6/23/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-1596 9/16/08 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs UKEILEY, ROBERT $3,368.75 7/15/11

Attorney Fees TUTCHTON, JAY $60,000.00 12/8/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 171: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 171 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/5/09Civil Defensive

08-4595 10/2/08 1/10/12 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BILL EUBANKS $24,000.00 5/27/09

Court Costs BILL EUBANKS $1,000.00 5/27/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-4594 10/2/08 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BUSE, JOHN T $350.00 8/20/09

Attorney Fees BUSE, JOHN T $13,150.00 8/20/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 172: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 172 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-1348 10/2/08 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHONRE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $512.46 4/22/09

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $5,657.60 4/22/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

11/22/10Civil Defensive

08-22966 10/24/08 10/13/11 Florida, SouthMICCOSUKEE TRIBE OF INDIANS V. UNITED STATES OFAMERICA, et al.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

08-1881 10/31/08 District of Columbia

OCEANA, INC. V. CARLOS M. GUTIERREZ, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 173: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 173 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

3/29/11Civil Defensive

08-508 11/25/08 7/11/11 IdahoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/17/09Civil Defensive

08-2394 11/4/08 11/29/10 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LEVINE, NEIL $10,692.96 7/1/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 174: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 174 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/15/09Civil Defensive

08-5546 5/15/09 9/18/09 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

GREENPEACE, INC.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

5/18/09Civil Defensive

08-2173 12/11/08 9/18/09 District of Columbia

CHAMBER OF COMMERCE OF THE UNITED STATES OFAMERICA V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

CHAMBER OF COMMERCE OF THE UNITE STATES OF AMERICA

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 175: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 175 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/15/09Civil Defensive

08-5605 12/16/08 9/18/09 California, North

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, ET AL. V.UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR, ET AL.

Party NameCONSERVATION NORTHWEST

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

PACIFIC COAST FEDERATION OF FISHERMAN'S ASSOCIATIONS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

INSTITUTE FOR FISHERIES RESOURCES

SIERRA CLUB

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL

HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE US

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 176: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 176 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

7/7/10Civil Defensive

08-941 12/15/08 8/12/10 Florida, MiddleCONSERVANCY OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA V. COL. PAUL J.GROSSKRUGER, ET AL.

Party NameCONSERVANCY OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

ARMY CORP OF ENGRS US

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 177: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 177 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/15/09Civil Defensive

08-5654 12/18/08 9/18/09 California, North

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

FLORIDA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

ARIZONA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

WYOMING WILDLIFE FEDERATION

WISCONSIN WILDLIFE FEDERATION

INDIANA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

GOLDEN GATE AUDUBON SOCIETY

NEVADA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

PLANNING AND CONSERVATION LEAGUE

CONSERVATION COUNCIL FOR HAWAII

KANSAS WILDLIFE FEDERATION

NEBRASKA WILDLIFE FEDERATION

MINNESOTA CONSERVATION FEDERATION

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

IDAHO WILDLIFE FEDERATION

ASSOCIATION OF NORTHWEST STEELHEADERS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 178: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 178 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

08-2744 12/16/08 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ROBIN COOLEY $144,250.00 4/3/12

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

5/18/09Civil Defensive

08-265 12/3/08 4/22/10 AlaskaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees REBECCA NOBLIN $6,000.00 6/3/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/5/10Civil Defensive

08-2292 12/10/08 4/27/11 California, South

RICHARD MADDALENA, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 179: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 179 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-31 1/14/09 Texas, WestCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BUNCH, WILLIAM G. $374.28

Attorney Fees BUNCH, WILLIAM G. $3,675.00

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/5/10Civil Defensive

09-465 1/14/09 4/27/11 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

11/16/09Civil Defensive

09-50 1/14/09 4/22/10 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $706.81 12/2/09

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $6,142.50 12/2/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 180: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 180 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-15 1/15/09 Washington, East

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE,ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-103 1/20/09 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Party NamePRESERVE WILD SANTEE

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

SIERRA CLUB

CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

SAN DIEGO HERPETOLOGICAL SOCIETY

SAN DIEGO AUDUBON SOCIETY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 181: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 181 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/18/09Civil Defensive

09-91 1/15/09 11/30/10 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-90 1/14/09 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BUSE, JOHN T $642.36 5/6/11

Attorney Fees BUSE, JOHN T $36,405.00 5/6/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-51 1/14/09 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BUSE, JOHN T $5,351.50 12/2/09

Court Costs BUSE, JOHN T $430.00 12/2/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 182: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 182 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/19/09Civil Defensive

09-91 1/14/09 4/22/10 California, Central

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $726.20 12/3/09

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $6,072.50 12/3/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/14/09Civil Defensive

09-312 1/14/09 9/23/09 California, Central

CALIFORNIA TROUT V. BUREAU OF RECLAMATION, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-90 1/15/09 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 183: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 183 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-115 1/16/09 District of Columbia

NATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION V. DIRKKEMPTHORNE, ET AL.

Party NameNATIONAL PARKS CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION

INTERIOR, DEPT OF OSM

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

SURFACE COAL MINING

Civil Defensive

09-185 2/13/09 OregonOREGON WILD V. J. WILLIAM MCDONALD

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees CARPENTER, WILLIAM C. JR. $7,310.93 10/9/09

Court Costs CARPENTER, WILLIAM C. JR. $389.07 10/9/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 184: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 184 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/17/10Civil Defensive

09-236 2/9/09 10/22/10 District of Columbia

THE CAPE HATTERAS ACCESS PRESERVATION ALLIANCE,ET AL. V. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR

Party NameDARE COUNTY NORTH CAROLINA

HYDE COUNTY NORTH CAROLINA

CAPE HATTERAS ACCESS PRESERVATION ALLIANCE

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

1/12/10Civil Defensive

09-363 2/24/09 4/22/10 District of Columbia

ENDANGERED SPECIES RECOVERY COUNCIL V. KENNETHSALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 185: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 185 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-480 3/12/09 California, EastCOALITION FOR A SUSTAINABLE DELTA, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-422 3/4/09 California, EastSTATE WATER CONTRACTORS V. KENNETH SALAZAR, ETAL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

STATE WATER CONTRACTORS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 186: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 186 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-407 3/3/09 California, EastSAN LUIS & DELTA-MENDOTA WATER AUTHORITY, ET AL. V.KENNETH SALAZAR, ET AL.

Party NameWESTLANDS WATER DISTRICT

SAN LUIS & DELTA-MENDOTA WATER AUTHORITY

INTERIOR, DEPT OF (FWS)

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

9/30/10Civil Defensive

09-574 3/24/09 8/12/11 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs JAMES J. TUTCHTON $370.00 8/12/11

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $47,160.00 8/12/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 187: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 187 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

10/30/09Civil Defensive

09-112 3/17/09 HawaiiHUI MALAMA I. KOHOLA, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/23/09Civil Defensive

09-533 3/17/09 4/22/10 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs JOHNATHAN EVANS $437.00 10/29/09

Attorney Fees JOHNATHAN EVANS $14,289.00 10/29/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/9/09Civil Defensive

09-172 3/27/09 1/25/11 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. ANIMALAND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs KENNA AND HICKOX $506.61 8/10/09

Attorney Fees KENNA AND HICKOX $19,493.39 8/10/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 188: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 188 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-824 4/1/09 MarylandDOW AGROSCIENCES LLC, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-496 3/16/09 District of Columbia

CONSERVATION FORCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-495 3/16/09 District of Columbia

CONSERVATION FORCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 189: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 189 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/13/09Civil Defensive

09-100 4/15/09 7/27/10 Florida, NorthCARIBBEAN CONSERVATION CORP., ET AL. V. GARYLOCKE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-245 2/4/09 District of Columbia

CONSERVATION FORCE, ET AL. V. DIRK KEMPTHORNE, ETAL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 190: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 190 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-153 1/27/09 District of Columbia

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE V, UNITED STATES DEPARTMENTOF THE INTERIOR, ET AL.

Party NameDEFENDERS, OF WILDLIFE

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

09-1170 3/17/09 California, North

CONSERVATION FORCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 191: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 191 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-631 4/8/09 California, EastTHE METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF SOUTHERNCALIFORNIA V. UNTED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFESERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameMETROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

7/1/09Civil Defensive

09-1415 4/1/09 1/25/11 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR, ETAL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs CUMMINGS, BRENDAN R. $422.00 7/15/09

Attorney Fees CUMMINGS, BRENDAN R. $10,578.00 7/15/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 192: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 192 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-77 6/2/09 MontanaDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/10/09Civil Defensive

09-331 4/15/09 1/25/11 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $5,000.00 8/18/09

Court Costs SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $418.21 8/18/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-1658 4/15/09 California, North

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC. V. KENSALAZAR, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees RILEY, REBECCA $42,000.00 12/18/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 193: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 193 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/4/09Civil Defensive

09-866 5/11/09 4/22/10 District of Columbia

FRIENDS OF OCEANO DUNES, INC. V. KENNETH SALAZAR,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ROTH, THOMAS D. $6,232.00 8/10/09

Court Costs ROTH, THOMAS D. $693.00 8/10/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/24/10Civil Defensive

09-1098 5/12/09 1/25/11 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $21,000.00 4/7/10

Court Costs JAMES J. TUTCHTON $370.00 4/7/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 194: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 194 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/20/09Civil Defensive

09-707 4/16/09 3/31/10 District of Columbia

FRIENDS OF ANIMALS V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs MICHAEL RAY HARRIS $350.00 3/26/10

Attorney Fees MICHAEL RAY HARRIS $12,774.00 3/26/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-892 5/21/09 California, EastSTEWART & JASPER ORCHARDS, ET AL. V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-118 6/2/09 WyomingSTATE OF WYOMING V. DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 195: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 195 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/7/10Civil Defensive

09-1120 5/26/09 7/8/10 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $13,830.00 4/21/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-73 5/26/09 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES, ET AL. V. JANE LYDER,ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HUBER, ERIC $221,787.00 5/6/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

3/8/10Civil Defensive

09-2346 5/28/09 8/6/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. GARYLOCKE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs ANDREA TREECE $459.38 10/19/09

Attorney Fees ANDREA TREECE $17,540.62 10/19/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 196: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 196 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/24/09Civil Defensive

09-1166 6/1/09 4/22/10 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LORI COLT $2,100.00 9/2/09

Court Costs LORI COLT $419.00 9/2/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-942 5/21/09 District of Columbia

LAWRENCE FRANKS, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/15/09Civil Defensive

09-2578 6/10/09 1/5/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JACLYN LOPEZ $3,010.50 10/26/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 197: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 197 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-91 6/15/09 ColoradoCOLORADO ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION, ET AL. V. KENSALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-85 6/15/09 ColoradoCOLORADO ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-82 6/10/09 MontanaGREATER YELLOWSTONE COALITION V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 198: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 198 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/28/09Civil Defensive

09-1092 6/15/09 9/7/11 District of Columbia

THE HUMANE SOCIETY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-138 6/19/09 WyomingBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF THE COUNTY OFPARK V. DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 199: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 199 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-1053 6/16/09 California, EastSAN LUIS DELTA-MENDOTA WATER AUTHORITY V. GARY F.LOCKE

Party NameNATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

SAN LUIS AND DELTA MENDOTA WATER AUTHORITY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

WESTLANDS WATER DISTRICT

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

9/17/10Civil Defensive

09-1893 6/17/09 1/7/11 Texas, SouthWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MISTY EWEGEN $61,389.28 12/20/10

Court Costs MISTY EWEGEN $510.72 12/20/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 200: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 200 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

1/8/10Civil Defensive

09-2870 6/25/09 1/7/11 California, North

SIERRA CLUB V. CALIFORNIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-1090 6/19/09 California, EastSTOCKTON EAST WATER DISTRICT V. NATIONAL OCEANICAND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

STOCKTON, EAST WATER DIST

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 201: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 201 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-1201 7/10/09 California, EastFAMILY FARM ALLIANCE V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-1463 6/23/09 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees GLITZENSTEIN, ERIC $120,000.00 2/27/12

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-729 6/25/09 OregonAUDUBON SOCIETY OF PORTLAND V. FEDERALEMERGENCY MANAGMENT AGENCY

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees ROHLF, DANIEL J. $35,700.00 2/15/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 202: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 202 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-1378 8/6/09 California, EastSTATE WATER CONTRACTORS V. GARY LOCKE

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

STATE WATER CONTRACTORS

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

09-1520 8/26/09 California, EastKERN COUNTY WATER AGENCY V. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

KERN COUNTY WATER AGENCY

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

COALITION FOR A SUSTAINABLE DELTA

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 203: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 203 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-1580 8/31/09 California, EastOAKDALE IRRIGATION DISTRICT V. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

Party NameOAKDALE IRRUGATION DISTRICT

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

NATIONAL OCEANIC & ATMOSPHERIC ADMIN.

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BREC

SOUTH SAN JOAQUIN IRRIGATION DISTRICT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

3/16/11Civil Defensive

09-1684 9/3/09 11/29/11 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 204: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 204 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/2/10Civil Defensive

09-3711 8/13/09 5/25/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LISA T. BELENKY $8,619.96 2/19/10

Court Costs LISA T. BELENKY $380.04 2/19/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-368 7/29/09 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. WILLIAM WOOD

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs LAUREN M. RULE $422.77 11/8/10

Attorney Fees LAUREN M. RULE $45,000.00 11/8/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-4087 9/3/09 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. JANE LUBCHENCO

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 205: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 205 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-1864 8/27/09 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. JIM BARTEL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-1704 9/8/09 District of Columbia

DOUGLAS TIMBER OPERATORS V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/25/10Civil Defensive

09-1703 9/8/09 1/17/12 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. NATIONALOCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs CUMMINGS, BRENDAN R. $372.00 10/6/09

Attorney Fees CUMMINGS, BRENDAN R. $2,829.00 10/6/09

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 206: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 206 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-1625 9/14/09 California, EastTHE METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF SOUTHERNCALIFORNIA V. NATION MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

1/7/10Civil Defensive

09-1977 8/20/09 3/5/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 207: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 207 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

1/28/10Civil Defensive

09-2744 8/26/09 4/5/10 Texas, SouthWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs PETER THOMPSON $450.55 2/24/10

Attorney Fees PETER THOMPSON $9,549.45 2/24/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-882 9/14/09 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. FEDERAL EMERGENCYMANAGMENT AGENCY

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SUGARMAN, STEVEN $89,624.00 4/28/11

Court Costs SUGARMAN, STEVEN $376.00 4/28/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 208: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 208 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-863 8/26/09 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. FEDERAL EMERGENCYMANAGEMENT AGENCY

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SUGARMAN, STEVEN $117,404.25 4/11/12

Party NameFEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

09-1814 9/23/09 District of Columbia

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE V. THE HONORABLE LISAJACKSON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 209: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 209 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-4610 9/30/09 California, North

THE OTTER PROJECT V. SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-2216 10/7/09 California, South

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/21/10Civil Defensive

09-2091 10/15/09 10/28/10 California, EastCOUNCIL FOR ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT RELIABILITY V.KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BICK, ALAN N. $2,702.95 10/15/10

Attorney Fees BICK, ALAN N. $32,297.05 10/15/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 210: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 210 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-532 10/16/09 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. DAVIDROSENKRANCE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LAUREN M. RULE $64,512.69 3/8/11

Court Costs LAUREN M. RULE $487.31 3/8/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-1912 10/8/09 District of Columbia

RALPH MARCUM V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/21/10Civil Defensive

09-2092 11/13/09 4/22/10 California, EastCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 211: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 211 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-5239 11/10/09 California, North

TURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK V. DEPARTMENTOF STATE

Party NameSTATE, DEPARTMENT OF

TURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK

MAYPORT VILLAGE CIVIC ASSOCUATION INC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MISC. FEDERAL PROGRAM

Civil Defensive

09-5370 11/13/09 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs JACLYN LOPEZ $350.00 2/15/11

Attorney Fees JACLYN LOPEZ $17,530.00 2/15/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 212: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 212 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-2024 11/19/09 California, EastCOALITION FOR A SUSTAINABLE DELTA V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees PAUL WEILAND $200,000.00 4/2/12

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-2023 11/19/09 California, EastCOALITION FOR A SUSTAINABLE DELTA V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/21/10Civil Defensive

09-2022 11/19/09 7/27/10 California, EastCOALITION FOR A SUSTAINABLE DELTA V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 213: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 213 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-611 11/25/09 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. DAVIDROSENKRANCE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees LAUREN M. RULE $27,923.76 2/14/11

Court Costs LAUREN M. RULE $576.24 2/14/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-2122 11/12/09 District of Columbia

FRIENDS OF BLACKWATER V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-358 11/16/09 IdahoGOVERNER C.L. OTTER V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 214: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 214 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

5/25/10Civil Defensive

09-1719 12/3/09 6/15/10 Washington, West

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. MICHELLEPIRZADEH

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-2233 11/24/09 District of Columbia

COLORADO RIVER CUTTHROAT TROUT V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 215: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 215 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-259 12/18/09 Florida, NorthCARIBBEAN CONSERVATION CORPORATION V. GARYLOCKE

Party NameCARIBBEAN CONSERVATION CORPORATION

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

GULF RESTORATION NETWORK INC

TURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

SEA TURTLE CONSERVANCY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

7/13/10Civil Defensive

09-1204 12/28/09 10/29/10 New MexicoBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF OTERO COUNTYV. UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 216: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 216 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/20/10Civil Defensive

09-1212 12/30/09 10/28/10 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MELISSA A. HAILEY $4,750.00 5/18/10

Court Costs MELISSA A. HAILEY $425.00 5/18/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

09-598 12/16/09 HawaiiTURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

MIGRATORY BIRD

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 217: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 217 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

8/19/10Civil Defensive

09-9162 12/14/09 8/23/10 California, Central

RIVERSIDE COUNTY FARM BUREAU V. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SCHIFF, DAMIEN M. $609.00 5/26/10

Attorney Fees SCHIFF, DAMIEN M. $11,250.00 5/26/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/16/10Civil Defensive

10-44 1/22/10 1/10/12 HawaiiHAWAII LONGLINE ASSOCIATION V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

5/13/10Civil Defensive

10-102 1/19/10 9/10/10 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MCCAIN, KENNETH $2,655.50 6/3/10

Court Costs MCCAIN, KENNETH $367.64 6/3/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 218: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 218 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-57 1/12/10 7/12/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/29/10Civil Defensive

09-2990 12/23/09 7/12/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/29/10Civil Defensive

09-2997 12/28/09 7/12/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 219: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 219 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-48 1/8/10 7/12/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-169 1/26/10 7/12/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/14/11Civil Defensive

10-91 1/15/10 2/22/12 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 220: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 220 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/28/10Civil Defensive

10-31 1/7/10 10/29/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs ADMUNDSON, ALENA $378.27 7/16/10

Attorney Fees ADMUNDSON, ALENA $8,121.73 7/16/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/27/12Civil Defensive

10-11 1/5/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-36 1/8/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 221: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 221 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-02 1/5/10 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-176 2/17/10 OregonCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/12/10Civil Defensive

10-106 2/17/10 1/25/11 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 222: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 222 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-230 2/17/10 7/12/10 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-80 2/1/10 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $2,343.00 5/25/10

Court Costs SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $419.00 5/25/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-1051 10-122

2/11/10 7/12/10 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $418.46 8/18/10

Attorney Fees SAMANTHA RUSCAVAGE-BARZ $1,440.50 8/18/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 223: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 223 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-53 1/28/10 7/12/10 NevadaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/11/10Civil Defensive

10-263 2/9/10 6/22/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-149 1/27/10 7/12/10 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs BUSE, JOHN T $369.98 9/7/10

Attorney Fees BUSE, JOHN T $4,330.02 9/7/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 224: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 224 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/13/10Civil Defensive

10-401 2/17/10 6/22/10 California, EastCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KENNETHSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/30/11Civil Defensive

10-116 2/10/10 11/21/11 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/11/10Civil Defensive

10-256 2/8/10 6/22/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 225: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 225 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-74 2/5/10 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs JAMES J. TUTCHTON $369.47 12/22/10

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $10,050.00 12/22/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/19/10Civil Defensive

10-86 2/2/10 1/5/11 New MexicoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SUGARMAN, STEVEN $9,500.00 5/5/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-106 2/18/10 Florida, MiddleCONSERVANCY OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA V. UNITEDSTATES AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 226: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 226 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-394 2/16/10 California, EastBACKCOUNTRY AGAINST DUMPS V. JIM ABBOTT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/3/10Civil Defensive

10-54 2/3/10 10/29/10 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. UNITED STATES FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees TUCCI, TODD C. $5,000.00 10/18/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

4/29/10Civil Defensive

10-3 1/4/10 5/3/10 HawaiiWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 227: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 227 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/27/10Civil Defensive

10-153 10-1-0036

2/15/10 10/28/10 HawaiiSYDNEY ROSS SINGER V. MALAMA O PUNA

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/21/11Civil Defensive

10-992 3/9/10 2/23/11 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BUSE, JOHN T $7,563.74 6/28/10

Court Costs BUSE, JOHN T $436.26 6/28/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/18/10Civil Defensive

10-299 2/24/10 9/14/10 District of Columbia

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL. V. KENSALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs RILEY, REBECCA $350.00 7/8/10

Attorney Fees RILEY, REBECCA $4,450.00 7/8/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 228: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 228 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-283 2/22/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. GARY LOCKE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees KAY, MONA $7,250.00 7/8/10

Court Costs KAY, MONA $393.00 7/8/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

7/22/10Civil Defensive

10-8042 3/16/10 8/31/10 ArizonaCOUNCIL FOR ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT RELIABILITY V.LISA P. JACKSON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

5/26/10Civil Defensive

10-817 4/12/10 9/24/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $700.00 6/17/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 229: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 229 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

6/29/10Civil Defensive

10-421 3/15/10 7/12/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1193 3/23/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. GARY F. LOCKE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1161 4/7/10 MinnesotaGERALD M. TYLER AND DALE K. LUECK V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 230: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 230 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

09-152 2/18/10 OregonLOREN STOUT AND PIPER STOUT V. UNITED STATESFOREST SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/27/12Civil Defensive

10-1501 4/8/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-357 3/2/10 District of Columbia

FRIENDS OF ANIMALS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HARRIS, MICHAEL RAY $6,698.50 8/19/10

Court Costs HARRIS, MICHAEL RAY $350.00 8/19/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 231: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 231 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-229 4/30/10 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. UNITED STATES FISHAND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/3/10Civil Defensive

10-5381 5/6/10 3/8/11 Washington, West

ARTHUR WEST V. NORTHERN SPOTTED OWL POLICY WORKGROUP

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-286 6/8/10 IdahoNEZ PERCE TRIBE V. NATIONAL OCEANIC ANDATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 232: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 232 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/21/11Civil Defensive

10-927 6/4/10 1/26/12 District of Columbia

STATE OF ALASKA V. JANE LUBCHENCO

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

12/8/11Civil Defensive

10-832 5/19/10 2/14/12 District of Columbia

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HOME BUILDERS V. KENSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/30/10Civil Defensive

10-10887 5/28/10 11/1/10 MassachusettsDEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIESSERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SIERRA B. WEAVER $15,000.00 11/17/10

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 233: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 233 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

11/23/10Civil Defensive

10-10873 5/25/10 4/27/11 MassachusettsTHE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES V.NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SIERRA B. WEAVER $21,000.00 4/8/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

9/14/10Civil Defensive

10-43 5/3/10 3/9/12 MontanaNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL V. LESLIE WELDON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1057 6/23/10 District of Columbia

CONSERVATION FORCE V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 234: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 234 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-1063 6/23/10 District of Columbia

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL V. UNITEDSTATES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENCY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-377 6/29/10 District of Columbia

IN RE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT SECTION 4 DEADLINELITIGATION

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees WILDEARTH GUARDIANS $167,602.00 3/5/12

Court Costs CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY $5,287.00 3/2/12

Attorney Fees CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY $122,871.00 3/2/12

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 235: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 235 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-22300 7/13/10 Florida, SouthNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION V. W. CRAIG FUGATE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs KOSTYACK, JOHN $1,042.34 2/3/11

Attorney Fees KOSTYACK, JOHN $53,018.00 2/3/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-385 6/23/10 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 236: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 236 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-1477 6/15/10 California, EastCALIFORNIANS FOR ALTERNATIVES TO TOXICS V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Party NameAMES, LAUREL

FRIENDS OF SILVER KING CREEK

CALIFORNIANS, FOR ALTERNATIVES TO TIXICS

WILDERNESS WATCH

MCCAMPBELL, ANN

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

WILDERNESS ACT

Civil Defensive

10-431 7/20/10 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. FOREST SERVICEAND FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 237: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 237 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-907 8/2/10 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES V. NATIONALMARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1262 7/26/10 District of Columbia

CONSERVATON FORCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-420 7/15/10 ArizonaWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KENNETH SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MELISSA A. HAILEY $7,287.75 11/2/11

Party NameWILDEARTH GUARDIANS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 238: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 238 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-206 8/30/10 Texas, SouthWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. GARY LOCKE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1959 8/17/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. STEVE GUERTIN

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs HICKCOX, GEOFF $425.64 10/28/11

Attorney Fees HICKCOX, GEOFF $26,072.87 10/28/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 239: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 239 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-1129 9/20/10 OregonNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER V.UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameNORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE CENTER

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

11/10/10Civil Defensive

10-1536 9/13/10 1/24/11 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 240: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 240 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-2129 8/31/10 ColoradoWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs JAMES J. TUTCHTON $370.49 1/11/12

Attorney Fees JAMES J. TUTCHTON $6,534.00 1/11/12

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-3366 9/20/10 Texas, SouthWILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1642 9/29/10 District of Columbia

ILLINOIS COMMERCIAL FISHING ASS'N V. SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 241: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 241 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-2130 10/5/10 ArizonaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL V. KENSALAZAR, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-6427 10-1644

10/12/10 OregonHALCYN OLENEC, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIESSERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

OLENEC, HALCYN

JONES, JULIE

STARK, THOMAS

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

JONES, JOHN B III

OREGON COAST ALLAINCE

WHITE, LARRY

BRANDON WOODLANDS COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 242: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 242 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-1272 10/15/10 OregonHELLS CANYON PRESERVATION COUNCIL V. UNITEDSTATES FOREST SERVICE

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Court Costs SCHWARTZ, JENNIFER $629.00

Attorney Fees SCHWARTZ, JENNIFER $47,508.00

Party NameHELLS CANYON PRESERVATION COUNCIL

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

HELLS CANYON PRESERVATION COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

10-2232 10/25/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 243: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 243 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-2231 10/27/10 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1843 10/29/10 District of Columbia

SWANSON GROUP MANUFACTURING, LLC. V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/14/11Civil Defensive

10-3116 10/26/10 4/15/11 OregonKLAMATH-SISKIYOU WILDLANDS CENTER V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 244: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 244 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-4861 10/27/10 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-1919 11/29/10 Washington, West

NORTHWEST COALITION FOR ALTERNATIVES TOPESTICIDES V. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

10-8254 12/22/10 ArizonaCOUNCIL FOR ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT RELIABILITY V.LISA P. JACKSON

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 245: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 245 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

12/14/10Civil Defensive

10-1910 11/23/10 1/11/11 Washington, West

WASHINGTON FARM BUREAU V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

6/22/11Civil Defensive

10-193 12/23/10 8/24/11 Georgia, SouthJERRE BRUMBELOW V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-293 1/20/11 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION AGENCY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 246: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 246 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-181 1/25/11 District of Columbia

CARPENTERS INDUSTRIAL COUNCIL V. ROWAN GOULD

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/4/11Civil Defensive

11-3019 2/16/11 3/29/12 Washington, East

WASHINGTON CATTLEMEN'S ASSOCIATION V. KENSALAZAR, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees HIMEBAUGH, DANIEL A. $4,861.12 10/26/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

1/4/12Civil Defensive

11-444 2/23/11 2/22/12 ColoradoCENTER FOR NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS, ET AL. V. KENSALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees SANDLER, MATTHEW $14,612.60 2/7/12

Court Costs SANDLER, MATTHEW $387.40 2/7/12

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 247: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 247 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-25 3/1/11 AlaskaALASKA OIL & GAS ASSOCIATION V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-36 3/9/11 AlaskaSTATE OF ALASKA V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

8/10/11Civil Defensive

11-507 3/10/11 10/13/11 Florida, MiddleMIDNIGHT PASS SOCIETY, ET AL. V. FLORIDA DEPARTMENTOF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 248: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 248 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-461 10-1085

3/22/11 Louisiana, WestLOUISIANA CRAWFISH PRODUCERS ASSOCIATION-WEST,ET AL. V. VAN ANTWERP

Party NameATCHAFALAYA BASINKEEPER

ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS US

LOUISIANA CRAWFISH PRODUCERS ASSOCIATION-WEST

LOUISIANA ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION NETWORK

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ARMY CORPS CWA AND R&H PERMIT CHALLENGES

Civil Defensive

11-4118 3/10/11 California, North

BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION OF THE BAY AREA, ETAL. V. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 249: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 249 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

2/15/11Civil Defensive

10-2943 12/30/10 4/12/11 Ohio, NorthRONALD SAMPLE, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-442 4/8/11 OregonPACIFIC RIVERS COUNCIL, ET AL. V. EDWARD W. SHEPARD,ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/17/11Civil Defensive

11-943 4/8/11 3/29/12 California, EastNORTH SACRAMENTO LAND COMPANY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees MIDDLETON, BRANDON $12,000.00 11/2/11

Party NameNORTH SACRAMENTO LAND COMPANY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 250: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 250 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-494 4/22/11 OregonAUDUBON SOCIETY OF PORTLAND, ET AL. V. NATIOANLMARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-1870 4/19/11 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. GARYLOCKE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees KILDUFF, CATHERINE $6,500.00 7/28/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-71 5/5/11 MontanaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 251: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 251 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-70 5/5/11 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES, ET AL V. KEN SALAZAR,ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-106 5/13/11 AlaskaARTIC SLOPE REGIONAL CORPORATION, ET AL. V. KENSALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

10/18/11Civil Defensive

11-643 5/27/11 3/8/11 OregonDULCICH, INC., ET AL. V. UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OFENGINEERS, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 252: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 252 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

1984-104 6/7/11 Virgin IslandsUNITED STATES OF AMERICA V. GOVERNMENT OF THEVIRGIN ISLANDS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-993 5/27/11 District of Columbia

SIERRA CLUB V. UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFESERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-61 5/24/11 Texas, WestWILDEARTH GUADIANS V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 253: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 253 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

9/21/11Civil Defensive

11-2904 6/14/11 3/29/12 California, North

WILD EQUITY INSTITUTE V. KEN SALAZAR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees PLATER, BRENT $11,050.00 10/24/11

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-276 7/18/11 2/22/12 MaineFRIENDS OF MERRYMEETING BAY, ET AL. V. DEPARTMENTOF COMMERCE, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-809 8/3/11 Virginia, EastPEOPLE FOR THE ETHICAL TREATMENT OF ANIMALS, INC.V. UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 254: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 254 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1414 8/4/11 District of Columbia

THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES V.REBECCA BLANK, ET AL.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-1417 8/4/11 District of Columbia

WILDEARTH GUARDIANS V. REBECCA M. BLANK

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 255: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 255 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1263 8/23/11 California, Central

BEAR VALLEY MUTUAL WATER CO., ET AL. V. KENSALAZAR

Party NameBEAR VALLEY MUTUAL WATER COMPANY

WESTERN MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT

SAN BERNARDINO MUNICIPAL WATER DEPARTMENT

YUCAIPA VALLEY WATER DISTRICT

RIVERSIDE CITY OF

WEST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT

BIG BEAR MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT

EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

SAN BERNARDINO VALLEY MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT

RIVERSOIDE COUNTRY FLOOD CONTROL AND WATER CONSERVATI

REDLANDS CITY OF

SAN BERNARDINO VALLEY WATER CONSERVATION DISTRICT

Statutes

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 256: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 256 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1564 8/31/11 District of Columbia

SAFARI CLUB INTERNATIONAL V. KEN SALAZAR

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-2136 9/15/11 California, South

COALITION OF LABOR, AGRICULTURE, AND BUSINESS, ETAL.. V. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees COALITION OF LABOR, AGRICULTURE, AND BUS $6,100.00 3/2/12

Party NameCOALITION OF LABOR, AGRICULTURE, AND BUSINESS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-4779 9/27/11 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 257: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 257 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-2605 10/3/11 California, EastCONSERVATION CONGRESS V. UNITED STATES FORESTSERVICE

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

CONSERVATION CONGRESS

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

11-4752 9/23/11 California, North

CONSERVATION CONGRESS, ET AL. V. NANCY FINLEY, ETAL.

Party NameENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION INFORMATION CENTER

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

CONSERVATION CONGRESS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

Page 258: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 258 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-1232 10/12/11 OregonBARK V. FOREST SERVICE, ET AL.

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees BELL, BRENNA $9,424.00 3/20/12

Party NameBARK, ET AL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-462 10/5/11 IdahoWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT V. DANIEL ASHE

Party NameWESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 259: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 259 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-194 10/17/11 District of Columbia

EXOTIC WILDLIFE ASSOCIATION, ET AL. V. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR

Party NameEXOTIC WILDLIFE ASSOCIATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-5108 10/19/11 California, North

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. UNITED STATESFISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 260: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 260 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-345 10/25/11 NebraskaCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF STATE, ET AL.

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

WESTERN NEBRASKA RESOURCES

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH INC

ATWOOD, AMY R.

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-11927 10/31/11 MassachusettsTHE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL. V.NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameTHE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES (NON-GOV'T PARTY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 261: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 261 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

11-2008 11/10/11 District of Columbia

CONSERVATION FORCE, ET AL. V. KEN SALAZAR

Party NameCONSERVATION FORCE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

11-5955 11/17/11 Washington, West

SHELBY PROIE, ET AL. V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIESSERVICE, ET AL.

Party NamePROIE, SHELBY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 262: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 262 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-5109 2/9/12 Washington, West

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY ET AL V. NATIONAL PARKSERVICE ET AL.

Party NameWILD FISH CONSERVANCY

FEDERATION OF FLY FISHERS

WILD STEELHEAD COALITION

INTERIOR, DEPT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

WILD SALMON RIVERS

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF NPS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

11-2044 12/8/11 Washington, West

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION V. FEDERALEMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY

Party NameNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 263: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 263 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-5 1/5/12 Mississippi, North

MARGARET COPELAND, ET AL V KEN SALAZAR ET AL

Party NameCOPELAND, MARGARET

UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

WILD SOUTH

WILD SOUTH

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

REFUGE MANAGEMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

12-71 1/18/12 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY v. GARY LOCKE, ETAL

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 264: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 264 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-41 1/11/12 District of Columbia

OCEANA, INC V. JOHN E. BRYSON ET AL

Party NameOCEANA, INC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

12-111 1/24/12 District of Columbia

AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCES COUNCIL, ET AL V. KENSALAZAR, ET AL

Party NameAMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 265: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 265 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-420 1/26/12 California, North

INTERTRIBAL SINKYONE WILDERNESS COUNCIL, ET AL V.NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Party NameINTERTRIBAL SINKYONE WILDERNESS COUNCIL

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

MARINE MAMMAL

Civil Defensive

12-157 1/27/12 OregonLANDWATCH LANE COUNTY V. UNITED STATES FISH ANDWILDLIFE SERVICE

Party NameLANDWATCH LANE COUNTY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 266: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 266 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-151 1/31/12 District of Columbia

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY, ET AL. V. NATIONALMARINE FISHERIES SERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameCENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

12-275 2/21/12 District of Columbia

ROMAN-MAS FOUNDATION ET AL V. UNITED STATES ARMYCORPS OF ENGINEERS

Party NameROMAN-MAS FOUNDATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 267: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 267 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-27 2/21/12 MontanaNATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL, ET AL. V. VICKICHRISTIANSEN, ET AL.

Party NameALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC

NATIVE ECOSYSTEMS COUNCIL

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

ALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

NATIONAL FOREST MANAGEMENT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 268: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 268 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-340 3/2/12 District of Columbia

THE EXOTIC WILFLIFE ASSOCIATION, ET AL V. UNITEDSTATES DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR, ET AL

Party NameDOCKERY, RAY

LEIFESTER, ROY

VALICEK, ED

OATES, THOMAS

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

GREEN, NANCY

SEALE, CHARLY

GREEN, JOE

CAFFEY, TERRY

EXOTIC WILDLIFE ASSOCIATION

EXOTIC WILDLIFE ASSOCIATION

BLASSINGAME, EDDY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

FWS REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 269: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 269 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-618 3/12/12 California, EastNORTH SACRAMENTO LAND COMPANY, ET AL V. UNITEDSTATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, ET AL

Party NameNORTH SACRAMENTO LAND COMPANY

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

12-57 4/13/12 MontanaCOTTONWOOD ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER

Party NameBIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION ALLIANCE

FOOTLOOSE MONTANA

KEN SALAZAR

DANIEL ASHE

MEYER, JOHN

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 270: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 270 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-642 12-427 3/19/12 District of Columbia

THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL V.JOHN BRYSON, ET AL

Party NameHUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES

WILD FISH CONSERVANCY

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

KOZIL, ANDREA

THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES (NON-GOV'T PARTY

O'DRISCOLL, BETHANIE

Statutes

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

MARINE MAMMAL

ENDANGERED SPECIES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 271: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 271 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-55 4/10/12 MontanaALLIANCE FOR THE WILD ROCKIES ET AL., V. VICKICHRISTENSEN, ET AL.

Party NameVICKI CHRISTENSEN

FOREST SERVICE US AGRIC DEPT

FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Civil Defensive

12-431 3/9/12 OregonNATIVE FISH SOCIETY V. NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIESSERVICE, ET AL.

Party NameNATIVE FISH SOCIETY

NATIVE FISH SOCIETY

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 272: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 272 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

12-2586 3/26/12 California, Central

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL V. ROBERTABBY, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC.

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL INC

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Civil Defensive

12-2578 3/26/12 California, Central

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE ET AL. V. U.S. BUREAU OF LANDMANAGEMENT, ET AL.

Party NameINTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF BLM

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF FWS

DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE

SIERRA CLUB

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

Page 273: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 273 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

4/2/90 Florida, SouthFLORIDA KEY DEER, ET AL. V. GALE NORTON

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION $130,000.00

Attorney Fees SARGENT, RANDOLPH M. $1,909,725.28 12/10/08

Court Costs SARGENT, RANDOLPH M. $15,371.12 12/10/08

Party NameNATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/26/03Civil Defensive

97-3779 10/15/97 9/30/09 California, North

CALIFORNIA TROUT, ET AL. V. BABBITT

Amount Type Owed to Amount Date Paid

Attorney Fees and Court Costs

Attorney Fees EARTHJUSTICE LEGAL DEFENSE FUND $30,000.00 1/8/01

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 274: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 274 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-1067 6/25/10 District of Columbia

PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR ENVIRONMENTALRESPONSIBILITY V. MICHAEL R. BROMWICH

Statutes

MIGRATORY BIRD

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

2/4/11Civil Defensive

10-627 10/26/10 3/1/11 HawaiiHAWAII LONGLINE ASSOCIATION V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE

Party NameNATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

HAWAII LONGLINE ASSOCIATION

Statutes

FISHERIES/MARINE RES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Page 275: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 275 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

Civil Defensive

10-271 12/14/10 AlaskaSTATE OF ALASKA V. JANE LUBCHENCO, ET AL

Party NameState of Alaska

NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

FISHERIES/MARINE RES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NOAA REGULATORY CHALLENGE

Civil Defensive

11-230 4/8/11 HawaiiHAWAII LONGLINE ASSOCIATION V. NATIONAL MARINEFISHERIES SERVICE

Statutes

FISHERIES/MARINE RES

ENDANGERED SPECIES

Page 276: Run: April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Page 1 of ......Endangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012) Case Type Court # Date Filed

Page 276 of 276Run:Report Name: wl_esa_defensive_active_related_2009_gs

April 26, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICEENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION

WILDLIFE SECTIONEndangered Species Defensive Cases Active At Some Point During FY09-FY12 (through April 4, 2012)

Case Type Court #DateFiled

DateConcluded

DateClosed DistrictCase Title

Section: Wildlife

4/3/09Petition for Review

09-70972 4/2/09 3/25/10 Petition for Review

CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY V. NATIONALHIGHWAY TRAFFICE SAFETY ADMINISTRATION

Statutes

ENDANGERED SPECIES

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT

TOTAL CASES FOR SECTION: 573

GRAND TOTAL CASES: 573