reverse preemption theory ver05 part i

8/2/2019 Reverse Preemption Theory Ver05 Part I

1/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 7

Acbd{ Y" NIydcb 9?77-9?79Xcy ?3

YCXCY[C _YCCM_QDNBVJCB @NKG@ IT-@GV[ IGBBDBF

QJC @GBAG__@DKGQDNB NH [CVGFC [@SAFC

[S_CYKCAC [QGQC @GV[ QN QJC KNBQYGYT

Acbd{ Y" NIydcb, _jA.C{w"

Acbd{ Y" NIydcb_NI 7844I`gdbc, VG 4:9;7

acbd{Oqjcpgqcbqfst"bcq


2/30

jqqp


3/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc ;


DBQYNASKQDNB LS[Q K@DKE TNSY JCC@[, ANYNQJT

Qjc qjc{d{ nh qjd{ pgpcy d{ qjgq db nyacy hny ysyg` knsbqdc{ gkyn{{ qjc knsbqyt qn {qnp qjc dmpnyqgqdnb gba

`gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {cvgfc {`safc vdqjdb qjcdy lsyd{adkqdnb, g`` qjct jgxc qn an d{ pg{{ gb nyadbgbkc qjgq igb{

`gba-gpp`dkgqdnb" Db hgkq, nbc Xdyfdbdg knsbqt jg{ anbc qjd{ {skkc{{hs``t mcyc`t it gmcbadbf dq{ |nbdbf

nyadbgbkc, gba qjd{ jg{ jcà sp db hcacyg` knsyq" Dq{ g{ {dmp`c g{ qjgq"

Db qjd{ pgpcy D ycxdcv qjc kg{c `gv yc`gqca qn `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc db Xdyfdbdg" Nb qjc ig{d{ nh qjd{

kg{c `gv D acxc`np vjgq D ychcy qn g{ g Ycxcy{c _yccmpqdnb Qjcnyt *Y_Q$ vjcycit g knsbqt nyadbgbkc

igbbdbf `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc vnsà, db chhckq, pyccmpq {qgqc `gv{ gba ycfs`gqdnb{ g``nvdbf `gba-

gpp`dkgqdnb" D ycxdcv qjd{ ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb qjcnyt vdqj yc{pckq qn qjycc hcacyg` Xdyfdbdg {`safc kg{c{ gba

nbc {qgqc Xdyfdbdg {`safc kg{c" D knbk`sac qjgq qjc K`cgb Vgqcy Gkq *KVG$ fdxc{ `nkg`dqdc{ g `dmdqca ydfjq nh

{c`h-acqcymdbgqdnb nh jnv {`safc d{ ad{pn{ca nh vdqjdb qjc `nkg`dqt{ insbagydc{, isq qjd{ ydfjq anc{ bnqdbk`sac qjc ydfjq qn ycfs`gqc gbt pygkqdkc{ hny ad{pn{dbf nh {`safc" Sbacy{qgbadbf qjd{ ad{qdbkqdnb icqvccb qjc

ydfjq qn igb `gba gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc gba gqqcmpqdbf ycfs`gqdbf dq d{ gi{n`sqc`t c{{cbqdg` hny g `nkg`dqt vjn

vd{jc{ qn g{{cyq dq{ ydfjq{ sbacy qjc KVG" D g`{n ycxdcv g S[AK Xdyfdbdg qc`cknmmsbdkgqdnb{ kg{c gba g S"["

[spycmc Knsyq qc`cknmmsbdkgqdnb{ kg{c qjgq {sppnyq qjc ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb qjcnyt czp`dkdq`t gba {sffc{q g

p`gb hny kjg``cbfdbf qjc {qgqc{ jcfcmnbt nxcy {`safc ad{pn{g`"

Qjd{ vnye d{ adyckqca qn qjc {`safc {dqsgqdnb db Xdyfdbdg, gba mnyc {pckdhdkg``t qn qjc knmmnb {dqsgqdnb

vjcyc {`safc d{ czpnyqca hynm g `gyfc syigb kcbqcy nsq{dac nh Xdyfdbdg qn g ysyg` Xdyfdbdg knsbqt hny `gba-

gpp`dkgqdnb nxcy qjc knsbqt{ nilckqdnb{" D ychcy qn knsbqdc{ dbxn`sbqgyd`t qgyfcqca it {`safcy{ g{ kncykca

knsbqdc{, g{ nppn{ca qnhckg`npjd`c knsbqdc{ qjgq, gppgycbq`t, jgxc bn nilckqdnb qn qjc dmpnyqgqdnb nh jsmgb

hckc{ mdzca vdqj dbas{qydg` vg{qc" Qjd{ pgpcy ycpyc{cbq{ mt ic{q chhnyq{ qn ad{{ckq gba sbacy{qgba g ygqjcy

knmp`cz `cfg` yc`gqdnb{jdp icqvccb Xdyfdbdg knsbqdc{, qjc Knmmnbvcg`qj nh Xdyfdbdg, gba qjc S"[" Knbfyc{{

vdqj yc{pckq qn qjc {`safc d{{sc" Qjc yc`cxgbkc nh qjc pndbq{ mgac jcyc qn knmmsbdqdc{ gba knsbqdc{ db

{qgqc{ nqjcy qjgb Xdyfdbdg {jnsà bnq ic pyc{smca vdqjnsq hsyqjcy `cfg` yc{cgykj" Qjd{ pgpcy d{ bnq dbqcbaca

qn ic `cfg` gaxdkc, gba {jnsà bnq ic knb{dacyca `cfg` gaxdkc" Ygqjcy, dq ycpyc{cbq{ g pcy{nbg` `cfg` npdbdnbgba qjcnyt ig{ca spnb mt {qsadca sbacy{qgbadbf nh qjc S[ Knb{qdqsqdnb, qjc K`cgb Vgqcy Gkq, gba yc`cxgbq

Xdyfdbdg kg{c `gv" Qjd{ `cfg` `gba{kgpc d{ ydhc vdqj innit qygp{ gba d{ pnps`gqca it g vc`` hsbaca { safc

dbas{qyt qjgq d{ jdfj`t mnqdxgqca qn s{c vjgqcxcy hsba{ gyc ycwsdyca dbk`sadbf iydidbf psi`dk nhhdkdg`{ qn


4/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 1


mgdbqgdb qjc `cfg` {qgqs{ wsn" Bn dbadxdasg`, fynsp nh dbadxdasg`{, ny `nkg` fnxcybmcbq {jnsà gqqcmpq qn

dmp`cmcbq gbt knsy{c nh gkqdnb vdqjnsq hdy{q knb{s`qdbf qjcdy nvb `gvtcy{" Gba bn `gvtcy {jnsà gqqcmpq qn

gaxd{c gbt k`dcbq{ db qjd{ mgqqcy vdqjnsq knmp`cqc`t sbacy{qgbadbf qjc `cfg` d{{sc{ ad{ks{{ca jcycdb"

G hcv achdbdqdnb{ gq qjc nsq{cq vd`` ic jc`phs`"

[cvgfc {`safc d{ achdbca it 1? KHY _gyq 3?;"4*v$ g{ {n`da, {cmd-{n`da, ny `dwsda yc{dasc fcbcygqca asydbf

qjc qycgqmcbq nh anmc{qdk {cvgfc db g qycgqmcbq vnye{" Qjd{ nhhdkdg` C_G achdbdqdnb dfbnyc{, pcyjgp{

dbqcbqdnbg``t, g pydmgyt knbkcyb qjgq mn{q {cvgfc {`safc knbqgdb{ dbas{qydg` pn``sqgbq{ gamdzca vdqj qjc

yc{dasc{ nh anmc{qdk {cvgfc qycgqmcbq" Db nqjcy vnya{, hynm g psi`dk jcg`qj pndbq nh xdcv {cvgfc {`safc d{ g

`nq vny{c qjgb qjc fnxcybmcbq{ achdbdqdnb vnsà {sffc{q" Vdqj qjc sbacy{qgbadbf qjgq {cvgfc {`safc d{

mnyc qjgb mcyc yc{dasc hynm anmc{qdk {cvgfc qycgqmcbq, D s{c qjc bnsb {`safc, qn ychcy qn {cvgfc {`safc

ycfgya`c{{ nh dq{ knbqcbq ny {nsykc" Vjcb D s{c {`safc g{ g xcyi ny pgyqdkdp`c, D gm ychcyydbf qn qjc gkq nh{pycgadbf {`safc nb `gba" Qjc qcym {`safcy{ mcgb{ qjn{c, dbk`sadbf hgymcy{, vjn pynmnqc ny pgyqdkdpgqc db

{`safdbf, bnymg``t hny pcksbdgyt fgdb"

D ychcy qn 7;13*c$ nh qjc KVG g{ qjchcacyg` `nkg` acqcymdbgqdnb {qgqsqc *@A[$" Dq d{ wsnqcaxcyigqdm

ginxc" _`cg{c {cc HB 7"

@decvd{c, D ychcy qn 1? K"H"Y" _gyq 3?;"8*i$ g{ qjc hcacyg` `nkg` acqcymdbgqdnb ycfs`gqdnb *@AY$, vjdkj d{

g`{n wsnqcaxcyqgqdm ginxc"

_gyq 3?; ychcy{ qn qjc hcacyg` ycfs`gqdnb{ hny ad{pn{g` nh {cvgfc {`safc _gyq 3?; nh Qdq`c 1? nh qjc S[

Knac nh Hcacyg` Ycfs`gqdnb{" [cc HB 9"

Qjc pydbkdp`c nh {spycmgkt nh {qgqc `gv nxcy `nkg` `gv d{ nhqcb ychcyyca qn g{ Ad``nb{ Ys`c ny qjc Ad``nb

Ys`c" Xdyfdbdg{ Ad``nb Ys`c d{ knadhdca g{ Xg" Knac 7-7;"76"

KJD@@DBF QJC YC[N@XC NH KNCYKCA KNSBQDC[ QN G[[CYQ QJCDY YDFJQ[

)Db nsy npdbdnb, Gmjcy{q Knsbqt {jnsà qgec dq{ p`gkc vdqj Gmc`dg, Ygppgjgbbnke, @nsd{g, gba


5/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 3


Gppnmgqqnz g{ g knsbqt vd``dbf qn an cxcytqjdbf ycg{nbgi`c gba ls{qdhdca qn g{{cyq dq{ ydfjq qn acqcymdbc

jnv {`safc vd`` ic ad{pn{ca nh vdqjdb dq{ inyacy{" Isq vc cmpjg{d|c qjgq Gmjcy{q&{ kg{c vnsà ic

ad{qdbfsd{jca hynm qjc nqjcy{ db qjgq dq vnsà ic qjc hdy{q qdmc qjgq g knsbqt jg{ {sca g {qgqc db hcacyg`

knsyq hny g acqcymdbgqdnb nh vjcqjcy Qjc Ad``nb ys`c d{ pyccmpqca it qjc K`cgb Vgqcy Gkq" Vdb ny `n{c,

qjgq ackd{dnb d{ vnyqj hgy mnyc qjgb !9 pcy yc{dacbq")

Qjc ginxc wsnqc d{ qjc k`n{dbf {jnq db g `cqqcy hc``nv `gvtcy, [qcxc Mgyqdb, gba D {cbq qjc Ingya nh

[spcyxd{ny{ nh Gmjcy{q Knsbqt, Xdyfdbdg db 9??3" Vc vcyc cbknsygfdbf qjc Knsbqt qn g{{cyq dq{ ydfjq qn igb

`gba gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc, g ydfjq czp`dkdq`t fdxcb it inqj qjc hcacyg` @A[ gba @AY" Ichnyc vc {cbq nsy gbqd-

{`safc `cqqcy qn qjc In[, Gmjcy{q jga g`ycgat jga qvn xcyt hdcyt psi`dk mccqdbf{ gba dq vg{ k`cgy qn qjc

{spcyxd{ny{ qjgq qjcdy knb{qdqscbq{ vcyc bnq jgppt ginsq qjc qjnsfjq nh Gmjcy{q Knsbqt icknmdbf gbnqjcy

pgt-pnqqt hny Bcv Lcy{ct, Bcv Tnye, gba Bnyqjcyb Xdyfdbdg" Cgy`dcy db 9??3 qjc knsbqt jga yckcdxca bnqdkc

qjgq g {qgqc gpp`dkgqdnb hny g pcymdq qn {`safc hgym`gba nvbca it My" Vc{`ct Vydfjq jga iccb hd`ca" Qjc `gbad{ galgkcbq qn g psi`dk ygd`{-qn-qygd`{ pynlckq qjgq jga yckcbq`t npcbca" My" Vydfjq{ vg{ qjc hdy{q gpp`dkgqdnb

hny g pcymdq qn {`safc Gmjcy{q Knsbqt cxcb qjnsfj hny tcgy{ jsbayca{ nh qjns{gba{ nh qnb{ nh {`safc hynm

Bcv Tnye, Bcv Lcy{ct, gba nqjcy cg{q kng{q kdqdc{ jgxc iccb nhh-`ngaca gq qjc F`ga{nbc, Xg" ygd` tgya{ ls{q hdxc

md`c{ ictnba qjc Gmjcy{q Knsbqt `dbc"

Nsy `cqqcy gyfsca qjgq qjc Gmjcy{q Knsbqt In[ {jnsà hd`c g hcacyg` ack`gygqnyt lsafmcbq gkqdnb db S[

ad{qydkq knsyq, bgmdbf qjc Xdyfdbdg Gqqnybct Fcbcyg` gba qjc Xdyfdbdg Acpgyqmcbq nh Jcg`qj g{ achcbagbq{ db

nyacy qn k`gydht qjc knsbqt{ ydfjq,xc` bnb, sbacy qjc KVG qn acqcymdbc jnv {`safc d{ ad{pn{ca nh db qjc

knsbqt"

Fdxcb qjc k`cgy `gbfsgfc nh qjc KVG, ginxc, nbc vnsà qjdbe qjgq gbt knsbqt qjgq vgbqca qn igb

{`safdbf vdqjdb dq{ inyacy{ vnsà jgxc bnq ls{q qjc ydfjq isq g hcacyg``t mgbagqca ni`dfgqdnb qn an {n"

Jnvcxcy, Gmjcy{q ack`dbca nsy dbxdqgqdnb gba jg{ bnq qgecb gbt vnyqjvjd`c {qcp{ qn pynjdidq qjc {pycgadbf

nh {`safc db qjc knsbqt db nyacy qn pynqckq dq{ kdqd|cb{ gba pcnp`c vjn fn qn Gmjcy{q Knsbqt hynm gynsba qjc

{qgqc gba knsbqyt qn s{c gba cblnt g ms`qd-md``dnb an``gy, psi`dkg``t-hsbaca ygd`{-qn-qygd`{ pynlckq galgkcbq qjcpynpcyqt qn ic {`safca"

Qjc knsbqt{ ycg{nb hny bnq qgedbf gbt gkqdnb vg{, gba gppgycbq`t {qd`` d{, qjc md{qgecb pcykcpqdnb qjgq


6/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 8


Gppnmgqqnz Knsbqt, Xdyfdbdg jga iccb {gbkqdnbca !:??,??? it g hcacyg` knsyq g{ g yc{s`q nh Gppnmgqqnz

qytdbf qn pycxcbq qjc `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc db qjgq knsbqt" G`qjnsfj qjgq {qnyt d{ hg`{c, g{ ad{ks{{ca

ic`nv, dq jg{, sbacy{qgbagi`t, jga g kjd``dbf chhckq nb qjc gkqdxdqdc{ nh Xdyfdbdg knsbqdc{ qytdbf qn acg` vdqj qjc

h`nna nh {cvgfc dbqn qjcdy knmmsbdqdc{"

Db nyacy qn sbacy{qgba qjc Gppnmgqqnz kg{c, gba qjc nqjcy {`safc kg{c{ db Xdyfdbdg, gba db nyacy qn

acxc`np g `cfg` qjcnyt qn {sppnyq g knsbqt{ ydfjq qn igb qjc `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc vdqjdb dq{ inyacy{, dq d{

gi{n`sqc`t c{{cbqdg` qn sbacy{qgba qjc cfg` pydbkdp`c nh pyccmpqdnb" Spnb ycxdcvdbf qjc Xdyfdbdg kg{c `gv, dq

d{ ictnba ad{psqc qjgq {nmc Xdyfdbdg knsbqdc{ jgxc vgaca dbqn, gba `n{q, sbbckc{{gyt `cfg` hdfjq{ gfgdb{q

{`safcy{ vdqjnsq hs``t sbacy{qgbadbf qjc yc`gqdnb{jdp{ icqvccb hcacyg`, {qgqc, gba `nkg` pnvcy{ qn igb ny

ycfs`gqc `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc"

_YCCM_QDNB HNYVGYA GBA YCXCY[C

_n`dqdkg` pnvcy gijny{ g xgkssm, gba vjcbcxcy qjcyc d{ qjc nppnyqsbdqt qn czcyq pnvcy nxcy pcnp`c, tns

kgb icq tnsy `chq {jnc-`gkc qjgq {nmc fnxcybmcbqg` inat d{ fndbf qn ys{j db gba {cd|c knbqyn` nh qjgq pnvcy" Dh

qjgq inat d{ bnq qjc S[ fnxcybmcbq, dq d{ g`mn{q g`vgt{ qjc {qgqc" Gbt mny{c`{ nh pnvcy `chq nxcy ghqcy qjc

hcacyg` fnxcybmcbq gba {qgqc jgxc qjcdy hd`` fn qn qjc `nkg`dqdc{ msbdkdpg`dqdc{ gba knsbqdc{" Gba {n qjcyc d{

ig{dkg``t g qjycc-qdcyca jdcygykjt nh `gv{" It pyccmpqdnb nbc mcgb{, c{{cbqdg``t, qjc pckedbf-nyacy icqvccb

qjc{c qjycc adhhcycbq `cxc`{ nh fnxcybmcbq db czcykd{dbf qjcdy pnvcy{" Qjc qcym pyccmpqdnb dmp`dc{ qjc qnp-

anvb h`nv nh pnvcy hynm hcacyg` qn {qgqc qn `nkg`"

Qjc qcym ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb d{ bnq g ycknfbd|ca `cfg` qcym5 dq d{ g qcym D jgxc kndbca qn ac{kydic qjc

sbs{sg` {dqsgqdnb db vjdkj `nkg` `gv gppcgy{ qn {spcykcac {qgqc `gv" D {gt gppcgy{ ickgs{c ycxcy{c

pyccmpqdnb d{ gb d``s{dnb dq `nne{ `dec g `nkg` nyadbgbkc ny g `nkg` gkqdnb d{ pyccmpqdbf g {qgqc `gv isq dq d{ db

ycg`dqt qjc {qgqc gv icdbf pyccmpqca it {nmc hcacyg` `gv qjgq ac`cfgqc{ pnvcy{ qn qjc `nkg`dqt" Db nqjcy

vnya{, qjc qygadqdnbg` knbkcpq{ nh pyccmpqdnb gpp`t isq db g {pckdg` vgt5 qjc qcym ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb d{

mcyc`t nhhcyca g{ g knbxcbdcbq vgt qn czpyc{{ qjd{ ygqjcy knmp`cz knbkcpq db g bsq{jc``"

Qjc [spycmgkt K`gs{c nh qjc S[ Knb{qdqsqdnb *Gyq XD, K` 9$ {gt{, db chhckq, qjgq hcacyg` `gv gba hcacyg`

qycgqdc{ qysmp cxcytqjdbf czkcpq qjc S"[" Knb{qdqsqdnb" Qjd{ d{ gb g{{cyqdnb nh hcacyg` {nxcycdfbqt, gba


7/30

91 Dnvg 133, 7:8:;

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 6


{nxcycdfbqt d{ vjgq pyccmpqdnb d{ ycg``t g`` ginsq" G`` lsafc{ gba ls{qdkc{ {qgqc gba hcacyg` gyc asqt-insba

qn gpp`t qjc `gv{ nh qjc Sbdqca [qgqc{ dh qjcyc d{ g ad{psqc icqvccb {qgqc gba hcacyg` `gv, gq `cg{q vjcbcxcy qjc

hcacyg` `gv db ad{psqc nkkspdc{ g fdxcb `cfg` gycg" [dbkc qjc cbgkqmcbq nh g bsmicy nh hcacyg` cbxdynbmcbqg`

`gv{ icfdbbdbf db qjc cgy`t 746?&{, dbk`sadbf vjgq jg{ icknmc ebnvb g{ qjc K`cgb Vgqcy Gkq, cbxdynbmcbqg`

`gv d{ nbc nh qjn{c gycg{ qjgq d{ k`cgy`t anmdbgqca it hcacyg` `gv" Knb{cwscbq`t, hcacyg` cbxdynbmcbqg` `gv{

pyccmpq g`` {qgqc gba `nkg` cbxdynbmcbqg` `gv{ ny gkqdnb{" Qjc KVG d{ nbc xcyt dmpnyqgbq hcacyg` `gv qjgq

pyccmpq{ g`` {qgqc gba `nkg` `gv{, nyadbgbkc{, gba it-`gv{"

Vdqjdb qjc qygadqdnbg` ny hnyvgya pyccmpqdnb {kjcmc, {qgqc `gv pyccmpq{ gbt nyadbgbkc{ pg{{ca it

kdqdc{, knsbqdc{, msbdkdpg`dqdc{" Qjc qcym msbdkdpg`dqdc{ s{sg `t dbk`sac{ kdqdc{, qnvb{, xd``gfc{, gba nqjcy

nyfgbd|gqdnb{ ic`nv qjc `cxc` nh qjc knsbqt qjgq gyc dbknypnygqca dbqn g `cfg` cbqdqt" Msbdkdpg`dqdc{ gba

knsbqdc{ gyc ychcyyca qn jcycdb kn``ckqdxc`t g{ `nkg`dqdc{" Vdqj yc{pckq qn dq{ `nkg`dqdc{, qjc {qgqc d{ {nxcycdfb"

Db mn{q *isq bnq g``$ {qgqc{ qjgq {nxcycdfbqt d{ knmp`cqc gba d{ {smmgyd|ca db qjc `cfg` pydbkdp`c kg``ca qjcAd``nb Ys`c" Nbc ychcy{ qn {skj {qgqc{ g{ Ad``nb Ys`c {qgqc{ ny Ad``nb {qgqc{"

Xdyfdbdg d{ g Ad``nb {qgqc gba Xdyfdbdg{ gbqd-{`safc gkqdxd{q{ ebnv qjc qcym Ad``nb Ys`c vc`` ickgs{c qjc

Ad``nb Ys`c d{ fcbcyg``t fdxcb it {qgqc gsqjnydqdc{ g{ qjc ycg{nb qjgq knsbqdc{ jgxc bn {gt db vjcqjcy qjct vd``

ic {`safca" Isq qjc Ad``nb Ys`c d{ bnq ginsq {`safc,pcy {c, gba dq d{ bnq ginsq knsbqdc{,pcy {c" Qjc Ad``nb

Ys`c knmc{ hynm g 7:69 qycgqd{c kg``ca )Msbdkdpg` Knypnygqdnb{) it Lnjb Hnyyc{q Ad``nb, gb nqjcyvd{c ni{ksyc

Dnvg lsafc, cxcb g{ Dnvg lsafc{ fn" Qckjbdkg``t, qjc Ad``nb Ys`c d{ ginsq qjc yc`gqdnb{jdp icqvccb

msbdkdpg`dqdc{ gba qjcdy {qgqc" Qjc ic{q {qgqcmcbq nh qjc Ad``nb Ys`c d{ db qjc vnya{ nh qjc fnna lsafc

jdm{c`h, g{ jc psq dq db qjc 7:8: kg{c K`dbqnb x Kcagy Ygpda{ gba Md{{nsyd Ydxcy YY< ;

)Msbdkdpg` knypnygqdnb{ nvc qjcdy nydfdb qn, gba acydxc qjcdy pnvcy{ gba ydfjq{ vjn``t hynm, qjc`cfd{`gqsyc" Dq iycgqjc{ dbqn qjcm qjc iycgqj nh `dhc, vdqjnsq vjdkj qjct kgbbnq czd{q" G{ dq kycgqc{, {n mgtdq ac{qynt" Dh dq mgt ac{qynt, dq mgt giydafc gba knbqyn`"

G`qjnsfj, qckjbdkg``t, qjc Ad``dnb Ys`c {sinyadbgqc{ msbdkdpg` knypnygqdnb `gv qn {qgqc `gv, dq jg{ iccb

vdac`t gpp`dca qn g`` qtpc{ nh `nkg`dqdc{" Db {nmc yc{pckq{ qjc Ad``nb Ys`c d{ qn nkg`dqdc{ vjgq qjc [spycmgkt

K`gs{c d{ qn {qgqc{" Isq bnqc qjgq qjc `cfg` ig{d{ nh qjc {qgqc-hcacyg` yc`gqdnb{jdp d{ ayg{qdkg``t adhhcycbq qjgbqjgq nh qjc {qgqc-`nkg`dqt yc`gqdnb{jdp" Qjc [spycmgkt K`gs{c vnye{ ickgs{c g fynsp nh pcnp`c qjgq czd{qca db


8/30

jqqp


9/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 4


nbc nh qjn{c Lcad h`dke{" Qjc Ad``nb Ys`c d{ c{{cbqdg``t g Fg`gkqdk Cmpdyc h`cz-ms{k`c `gv qjgq knadhdc{ qjc

qnp-anvb pyccmpqdnb {kjcmc hynm {qgqc qn `nkg` `cxc`"

Db {nmc {qgqc{ qjc Ad``nb Ys`c {qd`` ycmgdb{ g lsafc-mgac `gv5 db Xdyfdbdg, dq d{ cmicaaca db qjc {qgqc&{

{qgqsqc{ g{ Xg" Knac 7-7;"76, vjdkj {gt{ qjgq `nkg` `gv{ )" " " ms{q bnq ic dbknb{d{qcbq vdqj qjc US[]

Knb{qdqsqdnb gba `gv{ nh qjc Sbdqca [qgqc{ ny nh qjd{ Knmmnbvcg`qj") _`cg{c bnqc qjc )ny) dq pn{{di`t

ycbacy{ qjd{ {qgqsqc sbknb{qdqsqdnbg` db xdcv nh qjc [spycmgkt K`gs{c" Knb{dacy g {dqsgqdnb db vjdkj g `nkg`

nyadbgbkc *{skj g{ nbc igbbdbf {`safc$ d{ knb{d{qcbq vdqj ny mgbagqca it g hcacyg` `gv *{skj g{ qjc KVG$

gba tcq qjgq `nkg` `gv d{ knbqygadkqnyt qn g Xdyfdbdg `gv" Gkknyadbf qn 7-7;"76, dh qjc `nkg` `gv d{ dbknb{d{qcbq

vdqj hcacyg` `gv *vjdkj dq d{bq$ NY {qgqc `gv *vjdkj dq d{$, qjcb qjc {qgqc kns`a s{c qjc )ny) qn kgbkc` qjgq `nkg`

`gv gba qjcycit, db chhckq, pyccmpq qjc hcacyg` `gv" Db nqjcy vnya{, g `nkg` `gv qjgq d{ dbknb{d{qcbq vdqj qjc

`gv{ nh qjc Knmmnbvcg`qj xdn`gqc{ 7-7;"76 cxcb dh qjgq nkg` `gv d{ mgbagqca it g hcacyg` `gv" Qjgq d{ czgkq`t

vjgq Xdyfdbdg d{ andbf qn qjc KVG chhckqdxc`t nxcyydadbf dq it gpp`tdbf qjc Ad``nb {qgqsqc qn pynjdidq `nkg`knmmsbdqdc{ hynm acqcymdbdbf jnv {`safc vd`` ic ad{pn{ca nh vdqjdb qjcdy inyacy{" Qjd{ d{ g xdn`gqdnb nh qjc

[spycmgkt K`gs{c"

Dq d{ jgya hny mgbt pcnp`c `dxdbf db Xdyfdbdg{ ysyg` knmmsbdqdc{ qn gkkcpq qjgq g{ g yc{s`q nh Xdyfdbdg{

Ad``nb {qgqsqc, g {`safc-jgs`cy `dec qjc knmpgbt [tbgfyn Mda-Gq`gbqdk, Dbk, kgb jgs` jsbayca{ nh qjns{gba{

nh qnb{ nh Bcv Tnye kdqt {cvgfc dbqn qjcdy knmmsbdqdc{ gba {pycga dq bczq qn {kjnn`{, pgye{, gba knmmsbdqt

vg`edbf qygd`{, gba qjc pcnp`c ghhckqca jgxc bn {gt db qjc mgqqcy, isq qjgq d{ qjc vgt Ad``nb{ Ys`c d{ icdbf

gpp`dca" Jnvcxcy, db mt c{qdmgqdnb dq d{ hsqd`c hny kncykca knsbqdc{ ny gbqd-{`safc gkqdxd{q{ qn gqqgke qjc Ad``nb

pydbkdp`c dq{c`h, g{ {nmc jgxc qydca qn an" Cxcb qjnsfj qjc knb{qdqsqdnbg`dqt nh qjc {pckdhdk Xdyfdbdg Ad``nb

{qgqsqc mdfjq ic hcyqd`c fynsba hny g hcacyg` `gv{sdq, qjcyc d{ bn pndbq db qytdbf qn gyfsc qn g hcacyg` lsafc qjgq

Xdyfdbdg jg{ bn ydfjq, fcbcyg``t, qn knbqyn` dq{ `nkg` fnxcybmcbq{" Qjc Ad``nb knbkcpq d{ ls{q qnn {n`da`t

cbqycbkjca db Gmcydkgb lsyd{pysacbkc qn gqqgke dq jcga nb" Jnvcxcy, nbc anc{bq jgxc qn gqqgke qjc Ad``nb

pydbkdp`c jcga nb, nbc kgb gyfsc qjgq g `nkg` `gv igbbdbf qjc `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc pyccmpq{ qjc Ad``nb

Ys`c it xdyqsc nh qjc KVG" Qjd{ d{ qjc ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb knbkcpq"

QJC ACQCYMDBGQDNB YCFS@GQDNB ADKJNQNMT

Qjc hcacyg` @A[ ;; S"["K" 7;13*c$ nh qjc KVG jg{ qvn ad{qdbkq pgyq{" _gyq G fdxc{ qn `nkg`dqdc{ qjc


10/30

Qjc cbqdyc {qgqsqc d{ hnsba gq


11/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 77


Dh qjc acqcymdbgqdnb-ycfs`gqdnb adkjnqnmt {ccm{ knbqygadkqnyt, qjdbe ginsq dq" Dq mgec{ pcyhckq {cb{c qn

g``nv knsbqdc{ qn ackdac nb g knsbqt-it-knsbqt ig{d{ vjdkj nbc{ vd`` pcymdq `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb gba vjdkj nbc{

vd`` bnq" Isq dq anc{ bnq mgec {cb{c qn g``nv knsbqdc{ qn cgkj knb{qyskq g adhhcycbq ycfs`gqdnb-{kjcmc" Qjc

{g`c nh g`knjn` d{ gb czkc``cbq gbg`nft" Knsbqdc{ g`` gkyn{{ qjc knsbqyt mgec qjcdy nvb ackd{dnb{ g{ qn vjcqjcy

`dwsny kgb ic {nà vdqjdb qjc knsbqt {nmc knsbqdc{ gyc vcq gba {nmc gyc ayt" Qjc qjsmi{-sp.qjsmi{-

anvb nb g``nvdbf g`knjn` anc{ bnq ycwsdyc {qgqc-vdac sbdhnymdqt" Hsyqjcymnyc, dq d{ qjc qtpc nh ackd{dnb qjgq

d{ ic{q `chq qn qjc yc{dacbq{ nh cgkj knsbqt ickgs{c dq{ g ackd{dnb qjgq adyckq`t chhckq{ qjcdy wsg`dqt nh `dhc" Isq

nbkc g knsbqt ackdac{ qn g``nv qjc {g`c nh g`knjn`, qjc {qgqc dmpn{c{ g {qgqcvdac ycfs`gqnyt gba qgzgqdnb

{kjcmc qjgq d{ knb{d{qcbq hny cxcyt knsbqt qjgq g``nv{ g`knjn` {g`c{" Qjc knsbqdc{ ackdac tcg ny bcg qn g`knjn`,

gba qjc {qgqc {cq{ qjc npcygqdbf ys`c{ hny qjn{c vjn kjnn{c tcg" Dmgfdbc qjc mc{{ dh cgkj knsbqt knsà

ycfs`gqc g`knjn` {cq dq{ nvb aydbedbf gfc, ASD `dmdq{, gba `dwsny `dkcb{c `gv{" Dq d{ pyckd{c`t qjc {gmc vdqj

{`safc qjcyc ms{q ic nbc {cq nh ycfs`gqdnb{ hny g`` knsbqdc{ qjgq kjnn{c qn g``nv `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc,isq qjc czd{qcbkc nh qjn{c ycfs`gqdnb{ kgbbnq ic s{ca g{ g ygqdnbg`c qn ksq nhh qjc ydfjq nh nqjcy knsbqdc{ qjgq

vd{j qn igb dq"

Qjc KVG gppyngkj qn {`safc ad{pn{g` d{ c{{cbqdg``t qjc {gmc" Dq d{ sp qn qjc `nkg`dqdc{ qn acqcymdbc vjgq

mcqjna nh {`safc ad{pn{g` d{ ic{q {sdqca hny qjgq `nkg`dqt" Dh g `nkg`dqt igb{ g fdxcb mcqjna nh ad{pn{g` {skj g{

`gba gpp`dkgqdnb, qjcb qjgq{ qjc cba nh qjc {qnyt5 qjc {qgqc jg{ bn {gt" Isq vdqj yc{pckq qn gbt mcqjna{ nh

ad{pn{g` bnq igbbca it qjc `nkg`dqt, g {qgqcvdac ycfs`gqnyt {kjcmc knbqyn`{ qjgq qtpc nh ad{pn{g`" [syc`t bn

nbc vnsà vgbq cgkj knsbqt {cqqdbf qjcdy nvb {`safc ycfs`gqdnb{, hny bn nbc vnsà icbchdq hynm g pgqkjvnye

nh knsbqdc{ vdqj adhhcydbf ycfs`gqdnb{ {kgqqcyca g`` gkyn{{ qjc {qgqc" Dh g {`safc-hgymcy db Iskedbfjgm Knsbqt,

Xdyfdbdg d{bq g``nvca qn qjynv {`safc anvb nb hyn|cb `gba, qjcb g {`safc-hgymcy db Bc`{nb Knsbqt, Xdyfdbdg

{jnsàbq ic g``nvca qn cdqjcy" Dh g pnqcbqdg` {`safc-hgymcy db nbc knsbqt jg{ qn lsmp qjynsfj 7?-hnnq jdfj

jnnp{ qn fcq jd{ {`safdbf pcymdq gppynxca, qjcb g pnqcbqdg` {`safc-hgymcy db qjc bczq knsbqt nxcy {jnsà jgxc

qn lsmp qjynsfj qjc {gmc jnnp{" Qjd{ ycfs`gqdbf `gba ad{pn{g` nh {`safc d{ vjcyc qjc Ad``nb Ys`c mgec{

{cb{c" Qjc {gmc fnc{ hny ycfs`gqdbf dbkdbcygqdnb gba `gba-hd``dbf {`safc"

Isq qjc Ad``nb Ys`c fnc{ nsq qjc vdbanv vjcb dq knmc{ qn qjc knsbqt{ ydfjq qn mgec qjc dbdqdg`

acqcymdbgqdnb" Qjc {qgqc, vjcqjcy dq ic g Ad``nb {qgqc ny bnq, anc{ bnq pyccmpq `nkg` pnvcy{ db qjd{ ycfgya

ickgs{c Knbfyc{{ fgxc qjgq pnvcy qjc pnvcy qn mgec qjc acqcymdbgqdnb qn qjc `nkg`dqdc{" Qjs{, qjc


12/30

:8? H" [spp ;98 *V"A" Xg", 7441$6

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 79


pyccmpqdnb h`nv{ igkevgya{ db qjc {cb{c qjgq `nkg` nyadbgbkc{ qjgq pynjdidq {`safdbf vns`a pyccmpq qjc

Ad``nb {qgqsqc gba gbt nqjcy {qgqc `gv{ gba lsadkdg` npdbdnb{ qjgq knbh`dkq vdqj qjc hcacyg` `nkg` acqcymdbgqdnb

{qgqsqc" Qjd{ d{ ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb"

Vdqj qjd{ dbqcypycqgqdnb nh qjc KVG gba qjc ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb qjcnyt db mdba, D bnv qsyb qn qjc

Xdyfdbdg kg{c `gv qn {cc vjcqjcy qjcyc d{ gbt {sppnyq qjcyc hny qjc qjcnyt" D jgxc knbk`saca qjgq vjd`c bn

knsyq jg{ czpyc{{`t jc`a qjgq qjcyc d{ {skj g qjdbf g{ ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb, qjd{ qjcnyt d{ qjc nb`t vgt nbc kgb

mgec {cb{c nh hcacyg` gba {qgqc knsyq ackd{dnb{ nb `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc db Xdyfdbdg"

QJC XDYFDBDG [@SAFC KG[C[

Dq d{ cg{dc{q qn pyc{cbq qjc kg{c `gv kjynbn`nfdkg``t ygqjcy qjgb ad{ks{{dbf qjc hcacyg` kg{c{ gba {qgqc kg{c{

{cpgygqc`t cxcb qjnsfj qjc {qgqc gba hcacyg` d{{sc{ gyc {dfbdhdkgbq`t adhhcycbq" Qjcyc gyc bnq qjgq mgbt kg{c{

qn ycxdcv gba qjct {ccm `c{{ knbqygadkqnyt vjcb czgmdbca nb qjc qdmc`dbc" Qjcyc gyc qjycc hcacyg` {`safc

kg{c{ gba nbc {qgqc kg{c db Xdyfdbdg" Db gaadqdnb, qjcyc gyc g knsp`c nh hcacyg` bnb-{`safc kg{c{ qjgq d``s{qygqc

qjc ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb qjcnyt mnyc czp`dkdq`t qjgb qjc {`safc kg{c{ an"

7441 Vc`kj x" Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt, _gyq D S"[" Ad{qydkq Knsyq, Kjgy`nqqc{xd``c, Xg Mgfd{qygqc LsafcVgsfj Kydf`cy" 6

Dq&{ g iga {dfb vjcb qjc hdy{q kg{c db g inat nh `gv d{ qjc jdfj-vgqcy pndbq" Db qjd{ kg{c g kgig` nh {`safc

hgymcy{, Vc`kj, {sca Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt, Xdyfdbdg nxcy gb gmcbamcbq qn qjc Knsbqt&{ |nbdbf

nyadbgbkc{ qjgq igbbca `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc nb pydxgqc `gba vdqjdb qjc knsbqt" Ghqcy qjc dbdqdg`

anksmcbq{ vcyc hd`ca it inqj {dac{ gba qjcyc vg{ cbnsfj mcgq hny qjc knsyq qn kjcv nb, Ygppgjgbbnke

mnxca hny {smmgyt lsafmcbq, vjdkj mcgb{ qjct gyfsca qjgq qjcyc vg{ bn ycg` ad{psqc nxcy qjc hgkq{ gba,

knb{cwscbq`t, bn bcca hny g qydg`" Qjd{ gppcgy{ qn ic qjc nb`t { safc kg{c db Xdyfdbdg db vjdkj g knsbqt mnxca

hny {smmgyt lsafmcbq, gba qjgq mgt ic {dfbdhdkgbq

G{ `nbf g{ inqj pgyqdc{ gfycc, db hcacyg` kg{c{ g mgfd{qygqc lsafc kgb ic g{{dfbca qn ackdac pycqydg`mnqdnb{, jnpchs``t qn {pcca qjdbf{ sp {nmc" Db Vc`kj x" Ygppgjgbbnkeqjc mgfd{qygqc vg{ Mgfd{qygqc Lsafc


13/30

::: H" [spp 63; *V"A" Xg", 7443$:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 7;


Vgsfj Kydf`cy" Kydf`cy gfycca vdqj qjc knsbqt qjgq {smmgyt lsafmcbq vg{ gppynpydgqc gba jc cbqcyca

lsafmcbq hny qjc knsbqt, ad{md{{dbf qjc {`safc-hgymcy{ {sdq vdqjnsq g qydg`" Db andbf {n jc `cq ydp vdqj g xcyt

{qynbf npdbdnb qjgq hny qjc hdy{q qdmc c{qgi`d{jca qjc ydfjq nh Xdyfdbdg knsbqdc{ qn igb {`safdbf" Kydf`cy ycga

qjc hcacyg` `nkg` acqcymdbgqdnb {qgqsqc gba ycfs`gqdnb qn {gt qjgq {`safc ad{pn{g` d{ g `nkg` acqcymdbgqdnb,

vjdkj vg{ g pycqqt fnna kg`` ickgs{c qjgq&{ czgkq`t vjgq qjct an {gt"

Nbc {siq`c pndbq hynm Kydf`cy{ npdbdnb d{ pgyqdks`gy`t db{qyskqdxc< Ygppgjgbnke vg{ bnq igbbdbf {`safc

pcy {c" Hny db{qgbkc, dq vg{ bnq igbbdbf `gba-hd``dbf ny dbkdbcygqdnb nh {`safc" Dq vg{ bnq igbbdbf qjc

dmpnyqgqdnb nh {`safc" Dq vg{ nb`t mgedbf g acqcymdbgqdnb qjgq {`safc db qjc knsbqt vnsà bnq ic ad{pn{ca nh

it `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb"

Gbnqjcy dmpnyqgbq isq {siq`c pndbq d{ qjgq Ygppgjgbbnke{ it-`gv ada bnq {pckdht vjgq mcqjna jga qn ic

s{ca5 dq mcyc`t {gda qjgq `gba gpp`dkgqdnb knsà bnq ic s{ca" Db nqjcy vnya{, db nyacy qn g{{cyq dq{ ydfjq{ sbacyqjc @A[ nh qjc KVG, dq vg{ bnq bckc{{gyt hny qjc knsbqt qn {gt vjgq mcqjna ms{q ic s{ca qn ad{pn{c nh

{`safc5 dq vg{ {shhdkdcbq hny qjc knsbqt qn {gt qjgq nbc nh qjc pnqcbqdg` mcqjna{ knsà bnq ic s{ca" D an bnq

gaayc{{ db qjd{ pgpcy qjc wsc{qdnb nh vjcqjcy g knsbqt kgb igb g`` ebnvb mcgb{ nh ad{pn{dbf nh {`safc, bny

an D gaayc{{ vjcqjcy g knsbqt mgt igb qjc dmpnyqgqdnb nh {`safc" Isq vdqj yc{pckq qn qjc `gqqcy pndbq, dq d{

vnyqj bnqdbf qjgq g hcacyg` ad{qydkq knsyq lsafc db Kg`dhnybdg ys`ca qjgq Ecyb Knsbqt, Kg`dhnybdg, kgbbnq {qnp

@n{ Gbfc`c{ hynm {jdppdbf dq{ {`safc qn Ecyb Knsbqt ickgs{c dq vnsà sbknb{qdqsqdnbg``t yc{qydkq dbqcy{qgqc

knmmcykc5 jnvcxcy, qjgq lsafc jg{ iccb ycxcy{ca it qjc 4qj Kdyksdq Knsyq nh Gppcg`{, vjdkj spjcà qjc Ecyb

Knsbqt dmpnyqgqdnb igb" Jnvcxcy, p`cg{c bnqc qjgq Kg`dhnybdg d{ bnq g Ad` nb [qgqc, gba {n qjc Kg`dhnybdg kg{c

anc{ bnq {pcge qn qjc {qgqc x{" `nkg`dqt d{{sc{ qjgq p`gfsc Xdyfdbdg gba mn{q nqjcy {qgqc{" Qjc d{{sc nh vjcqjcy

g ysyg` Xdyfdbdg knsbqt ny g knsbqt db {nmc nqjcy Ad``nb {qgqc kgb s{c qjc KVG qn eccp BTK hynm psmpdbf dq{

{`safc dbqn qjc knsbqt jg{ bnq iccb gb{vcyca dq jg{bq cxcb iccb g{eca g{ hgy g{ D gm gvgyc" Isq qjgq d{{sc

fnc{ ictnba qjc `cfg` d{{sc{ pyc{cbqca jcyc, vjdkj gyc yc{qydkqca qn vjcqjcy g knsbqt kgb igb {`safdbf nh `gba

vdqjdb dq{ lsyd{adkqdnb db nppn{dqdnb qn {qgqc `gv"

7443 Vc`kj x" Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt, _gyq DD S"[" Ad{qydkq Knsyq, Kjgy`nqqc{xd``c, Xg Lsafc JgyytMdkjgc`":


14/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 71


Ycqsybdbf qn Ygppgjgbbnke, vjcb g mgfd{qygqc lsafc ackdac{ g {smmgyt lsafmcbq mnqdnb db hcacyg`

knsyq, qjc `n{cy kgb g{e qjc )ycg`) lsafc qn ycxcy{c vjgq qjc mgfd{qygqc lsafc ada qjd{ d{ {nyq nh gb db-jns{c

gppcg`" Lsafc Jgyyt Mdkjgc` vg{ qjc )ycg`) lsafc db qjd{ kg{c" Lsafc Mdkjgc` bnq nb`t igkeca-sp jd{

mgfd{qygqc lsafc 7??#, jc vcbq hsyqjcy gba mgac dq k`cgy db bn sbkcyqgdb qcym{ qjgq 7$ sbacy qjc KVG, jnv

{`safc d{ ad{pn{ca nh d{ g `nkg` acqcymdbgqdnb, gba 9$ hcacyg` {`safc ycfs`gqdnb{ an bnq pyccmpq g knsbqt&{

ydfjq qn igb {`safc, vjdkj vg{ qjc {`safcy{& gyfsmcbq"

@cq mc czp`gdb qjc {`safcy{ pyccmpqdnb gyfsmcbq ickgs{c dq d{ nhqcb ygd{ca it {`safcy{ gba dq d{ cg{t qn

knbhs{c qjc{c knmpcqdbf pyccmpqdnb pydbkdp`c{" Qjc {`safcy{ pyccmpqdnb qjcnyt d{ bnq yc`gqca db gbt

ad{kcybgi`c vgt qn ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb" Db mn{q nh qjc{c {`safc kg{c{ qjc {`safcy{ gyfsc, g{ qjct ada db

Ygppgjgbbnke, qjgq C_G ycfs`gqdnb{ pynmnqc qjc {pycgadbf nh jsmgb hckc{ nb hgym`gba gba qjcychnyc qjn{c

ycfs`gqdnb{ pyccmpq gbt knsbqt `gv{ `dec Ygppgjgbbnke{ pycxcbqdbf qjc {pycgadbf nh jsmgb hckc{ nb

hgym`gba" Qjc ycfs`gqdnb{ qjct gyc qg`edbf ginsq gyc hnsba db _gyq 3?; nh Qdq`c 1? nh qjc Knac nh Hcacyg`Ycfs`gqdnb{" Qjd{ gyfsmcbq d{ ginsq qjc bnymg` )hnyvgya) ny )qnp-anvb) pyccmpqdnb {kjcmc, g{ db hcacyg`

`gv qysmp{ {qgqc `gv gba `nkg` `gv, {qgqc `gv qysmp{ `nkg` `gv, `nkg` `gv anc{b&q qysmp gbtqjdbf"

Qjc {`safcy{ gyc knyyckq qjgq hcacyg` ycfs`gqdnb{ kgb pyccmpq {qgqc gba `nkg` `gv" Isq qjc hdbc *gba hgqg`$

pndbq ygd{ca it Lsafc Mdkjgc` d{ qjgq hcacyg` ycfs`gqdnb{ kgbbnq pyccmpq hcacyg` `gv, gba hcacyg` `gv qjc

KVG {pckdhdkg``t d{ vjgq knbqyn``ca qjc Ygppgjgbbnke kg{c" Vjcb qjc {`safcy{ db Ygppgjgbbnkegyfsca

qjgq _gyq 3?; cbknsygfc{ {`safdbf hgym`gba gba qjcychnyc pyccmpq{ Ygppgjgbbnke{ nyadbgbkc igbbdbf

{`safdbf, qjct vcyc ycg``t gyfsdbf *vdqjnsq {gtdbf dq$ qjgq hcacyg` ycfs`gqdnb{ pyccmpq hcacyg` `gv, isq Lsafc

Mdkjgc` vg{bq istdbf dq"

Lsafc Mdkjgc`&{ yc{pnb{c qn qjc {`safcy{ pyccmpqdnb qjcnyt vg{, c{{cbqdg``t, qjgq qjc C_G d{ ls{q gb

gfcbkt gba dq{ npdbdnb{ gba ycfs`gqdnb{ an bnq pyccmpq qjc knsbqt&{ ydfjq qn igb {`safc ickgs{c hcacyg` `gv

qjc KVG fdxc{ qjc knsbqt qjgq ydfjq" Mdkjgc` qsybca qjc { safcy{ pyccmpqdnb gyfsmcbq gfgdb{q qjcm" Jc

hnsba qjgq qjc KVG k`cgy`t {qgqc{ qjgq `nkg`dqdc{ acqcymdbc jnv {`safc d{ ad{pn{ca nh gba qjc KVG pyccmpq{

gbtqjdbf _gyq 3?; mgt {gt ny {sffc{q qn qjc knbqygyt" Cba nh {qnyt" Gba qjd{ pycqqt vc`` mcgbq qjc cba nh qjc[tbgfyn{ {`safc npcygqdnb{ db Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt gq `cg{q hny qjc `g{q 73 tcgy{"D anb&q ebnv vjgq qjc

Ygppgjgbbnke `gvtcy{ vcyc pgda qn hdfjq qjgq hdfjq, isq qjc nsqknmc db qcym{ nh eccpdbf {`safc nsq nh

Ygppgjgbbnke hny 73 tcgy{, vjd`c jsbayca{ nh qjns{gba{ nh qnb{ jgxc iccb {pycga db bcgyit knsbqdc{, vg{


15/30

Qjcyc d{ g hnnqbnqc db Mgfd{qygqc Lsafc Kydf`cy{ npdbdnb dbadkgqdbf qjgq jc vg{ gxndadbf {qgqc `gv4

d{{sc{ ickgs{c qjn{c d{{sc{ vcyc ichnyc qjc {qgqc knsyq"

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 73


vnyqj mgbt qdmc{ mnyc qjgb vjgq qjct vcyc pgda"

Qjcyc gyc g knsp`c nh pgyqdks`gy`t dbqcyc{qdbf pndbq{ ginsq qjc Ygppgjgbbnkekg{c db `dfjq nh qjc ackgac nh

`dqdfgqdnb qjgq hn``nvca dq" Hdy{q, qjc {`safcy{ adab&q gppcg` Lsafc Mdkjgc`&{ ackd{dnb" Qjd{ vg{ bnq hny `gke nh

hsbadbf, tns kgb ic {syc" Qjct jga g {qygqcfdk ycg{nb, gba qjgq vg{ mn{q `dec`t qjgq `n{dbf db qjc Hnsyqj

Kdyksdq Knsyq nh Gppcg`{ vnsà jgxc jga jsfc ycfdnbg` ycpcyks{{dnb{ qjgq vnsà fn vc`` ictnba

Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt ny cxcb Xdyfdbdg" Ic{dac{, Mdkjgc`{ npdbdnb vg{ `dec`t xdcvca g{ is``cq-pynnh gba

vnsà jgxc {qnna sp qn gppcg`" Qjc `g{q qjdbf qjc {`safc-jgs`cy{ gba qjc {`safc-hgymcy{ vgbqca vg{ g S[

kdyksdq knsyq nh gppcg`{ npdbdnb gfyccdbf qjgq knsbqdc{ jgxc g ydfjq sbacy qjc KVG qn igb {`safdbf"

Qjc {cknba hg{kdbgqdbf pndbq ginsq Ygppgjgbbnked{ qjgq qjcyc vg{ qjgq Kydf`cy&{ gba Mdkjgc`&{ npdbdnb{

qnqg``t dfbnyca qjc Ad``nb Ys`c gba {qgqc {nxcycdfbqt d{{sc{, gba ls{q hnks{ca nb qjc yc`gqdnb{jdp icqvccb qjc

hcacyg` `gv gba `nkg` `gv, {sffc{qdbf qjgq qjc { safc-hgymcy{ ada bnq ygd{c Ad``nb Ys`c gyfsmcbq{" Qjcgi{cbkc nh gbt mcbqdnb db qjc{c npdbdnb{ nh g {dbf`c {qgqc `gv ny knsyq ys`dbf d{ vcdya ickgs{c qjc {qgqc p`gt{ g

jsfc yn`c db qjd{ vjn`c mc{{" Qjc Xdyfdbdg Acpq" nh Jcg`qj *XAJ$, vjdkj gq qjgq qdmc vg{ qjc {qgqc gfcbkt db

kjgyfc nh ycfs`gqdbf {`safdbf, jga iccb db ica vdqj qjc {`safcy{ hny tcgy{ gba jga iccb pynmnqdbf {`safc

`gba-gpp`dkgqdnb g{ cbqjs{dg{qdkg``t g{ qjc knmmcykdg` {`safc-{`dbfcy{, `dec [tbgfyn" Nbc vnsà qjdbe qjgq

qjc {`safc-knb{nyqdsm, vjdkj dbk`saca qjc XAJ, vnsà jgxc jgmmcyca qjc Ad``nb Ys`c pycqqt jgya" Isq

qjcyc vg{ bn mcbqdnb nh Ad``nb db qjc npdbdnb{" 4

Isq qjcyc jg{ iccb, db ycqyn{pckq, g kcyqgdb {tmmcqyt db qjc lsadkdg` kdqgqdnb{ ickgs{c bnq nb`t ada qjc

Ygppgjgbbnkenpdbdnb{ bnq kdqc qjc Ad``nb Ys`c ny gbt {qgqc kg{c{, bnbc nh qjc {qgqc knsyq ny hcacyg` npdbdnb{

qjgq hn``nvca Ygppgjgbbnke g`` ig{ca nb Ad``nb ychcyyca qn qjc Ygppgjgbbnkekg{c" Qjd{ msqsg` czk`s{dnb

qtpc-{tmmcqyt {sffc{q{ g pgqj qjgq kncykca knsbqdc{ {jnsà hn``nv dh qjct vd{j qn g{{cyq qjcdy hcacyg` ydfjq qn

igb {`safdbf cmpjg{d|c qjc KVG gba hcacyg` mgbagqc{ qn `nkg`dqdc{ gba gxnda Ad``nb" Gba {qgqc k`cgy`t db

nyadbgbkc{ igbbdbf {`safdbf qjgq qjc knsbqt d{ gxgd`dbf dq{c`h nh dq{ ydfjq{ mgbagqca it qjc KVG"

G{ g yc{s`q nh Kydf`cy gba Mdkjgc` bnq iydbfdbf {qgqc `gv dbqn qjcdy npdbdnb{, qckjbdkg``tYgppgjgbbnkekgbbnq ic knb{dacyca g ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb kg{c" G`qjnsfj qjc npdbdnb{ k`cgy`t {gt qjgq qjc KVG fdxc{ qjc


16/30

987 Xg 335 31? ["C" 9ba :845 31? ["C"9a :84 *9??7$7?

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 78


knsbqdc{ qjc pnvcy qn igb {`safdbf, ickgs{c qjc Ad``nb Ys`c gba {qgqc `gv vcyc dfbnyca, qjc{c npdbdnb{ anbq

czp`dkdq`t jnà qjgq qjc KVG cmpnvcy{ knsbqdc{ qn pyccmpq {qgqc `gv" Bcxcyqjc`c{{, hny qjn{c vjn hcc`

{qynbf`t qjgq qjc pcnp`c nh g knsbqt jgxc qjc ydfjq qjynsfj qjcdy ingya{ nh {spcyxd{ny{ qn igb {`safdbf, qjc

Ygppgjgbbnkekg{c d{ g xcyt xg`sgi`c kg{c" Dq jg{ bnq iccb nxcy-ys`ca"

Isq {dz tcgy{ `gqcy Ad``nb ygd{ca dq{ sf`t jcga gba knbhs{ca qjc d{{sc{"

9??7 I`gbqnb x" Gmc`dg Knsbqt -- Xg" [spycmc Knsyq, Ydkjmnba, Xg Ls{qdkc @cynt Ynsbqycc Jg{{c`` 7?

Jgxdbf iccb {jsq anvb db Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt, qjc knypnygqc {`safcy{ {qgyqca `nnedbf gynsba Xdyfdbdg

hny nqjcy knsbqdc{ qjct knsà s{c g{ gb nsqjns{c hny Bcv Tnye gba Bcv Lcy{ct" Qjct hnsba g qvn-jn`cy db

Gmc`dg Knsbqt gba @nsd{g Knsbqt, gba qjct dmmcadgqc`t icfgb {`safdbf qjn{c hnè{ idf-qdmc"

Db Gmc`dg Knsbqt, ghqcy g bsmicy nh psi`dk jcgydbf{ db vjdkj qjc psi`dk mgac dq xcyt k`cgy jnv qjct hc`q

ginsq [tbgfyn iydbfdbf Bcv Lcy{ct {cvgfc qn qjcdy knsbqt, Gmc`dg{ ingya nh {spcyxd{ny{ qnne qjc {gmc ynsqc

g{ Ygppgjgbbnke gba pg{{ca nyadbgbkc{ igbbdbf {`safdbf nsqydfjq"

Bnv, nbc vnsà qjdbe db xdcv nhVc`kj x" Ygppgjgbbnkeqjgq Gmc`dg vnsà jgxc g xcyt {qynbf kg{c"

Ghqcy g``, qvn hcacyg` lsafc{ inqj ycga qjc @A[ gba knbk`saca qjgq knsbqdc{ kgb igb {`safdbf" [syc`t Gmc`dg{

kg{c vnsà ic gb db{qgbq-ycp`gt nh Ygppgjgbbnke{" Dq vg{bq"

D anb&q jgxc g ycknya nh vjgq qygb{pdyca db I`gbqnb x" Gmc`dg" Nbc jg{ qn ycxdcv qjc qydg` knsyq ycknya db

qjc Gmc`dg Knsbqt knsyqjns{c gba D pyc{cbq`t `dxc nb qjc vc{q kng{q nh Kgbgag gba anbq jgxc gkkc{{ qn qjn{c

ycknya{" Isq D ebnv hynm qjc Xdyfdbdg [spycmc Knsyq{ psi`d{jca npdbdnb qjgq Lsafc Qjnmg{ X" Vgyycb

pyc{daca nxcy qjc kg{c db qjc qydg` knsyq" D kgb g`{n {cc qjgq qjc I`gbqnb {`safc-hgymcy{ {sca Gmc`dg nb qjc

fynsba{ qjgq Gmc`dg&{ igb nh `gba-gpp`dkgqdnb vg{ dbknb{d{qcbq vdqj qjc {qgqc {`safc `gv{ gba ycfs`gqdnb{ gba

vg{, qjcychnyc, d``cfg` sbacy Xg" Knac 7-7;"765 c"f", qjc Ad``nb Ys`c" [n qjc qvn mglny adhhcycbkc{ icqvccb

I`gbqnb gba Ygppgjgbbnked{ qjgq *7$ I`gbqnb vg{ qydca db qjc {qgqc knsyq gba *9$ Ad``nb vg{ gyfsca dbI`gbqnb"


17/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 76


Qjc `nfdkg` yc{pnb{c hny qjc knsbqt vnsà jgxc iccb qn ycmnxc qjc kg{c {qygdfjq qn hcacyg` knsyq, isq

sb`c{{ g hcacyg` d{{sc d{ ygd{ca it qjc p`gdbqdhh, qjgq kgb ic adhhdks`q qn an"

Qjc {cknba `nfdkg` yc{pnb{c hny qjc knsbqt vnsà ic qn {gt< )Tcgj, g`` qjgq Ad``nb tgag-tgag mdfjq ic

ydfjq, tnsy Jnbny, isq qjc hcacyg` KVG qysmp{ qjc {qgqc {`safc `gv{ gba dq g`{n qysmp{ Ad``nb" G{ qvn hcacyg`

npdbdnb{ jgxc g`ycgat jcà, 7;13*c$ nh qjc KVG fdxc{ Gmc`dg qjc ydfjq qn igb {`safdbf" Bnv `cq{ pgke sp g``

qjc{c iydch kg{c{ gba fn jnmc") Vjdkj d{ pynigi`t ginsq vjgq Gmc`dg{ `gvtcy{ ada {gt ickgs{c Lsafc Vgyycb

hnsba hny Gmc`dg Knsbqt, {jsq qjc kg{c anvb, gba qjct g`` pgkeca sp qjcdy iydch kg{c{ gba vcbq jnmc" Db

nqjcy vnya{, Lsafc Vgyycb vg{ qjc qjdya Xdyfdbdg lsafc qn ys`c qjgq g knsbqt kgb igb {`safdbf" Qjycc db g

ynv, db hgkq" Qjycc {qydec{ d{ gb nsq vjcyc D fycv sp, isq hnyqsbgqc`t D adab&q fynv sp db Xdyfdbdg" Qjc {`safcy{

gppcg`ca Lsafc Vgyycb&{ ackd{dnb qn qjc Xdyfdbdg [spycmc Knsyq"

Dq d{ pyckd{c`t nb Lgbsgyt 79, 9??7, qjc psi`dkgqdnb agqc nh qjc Xg" [spycmc Knsyq npdbdnb db qjc I`gbqnb x"Gmc`dg, qjgq qjc vjn`c {`safc d{{sc, gba qjc {`safc dq{c`h, {qgyqca fndbf {nsqj db Xdyfdbdg, inqj hdfsygqdxc`t gba

fcnfygpjdkg``t" Hynm g `cfg` pcy{pckqdxc, qjd{ pndbq d{ g nq `dec vjcb qjc jns{c aynppca nb Anynqjt&{ jcga ny

vjcb G`dkc {qcppca qjynsfj qjc mdyyny cxcytqjdbf icfdb{ qn fcq g `dqq`c {syycg`, `cfg``t {pcgedbf"

Db g bsq{jc``, qjc Xdyfdbdg [spycmc Knsyq ycxcy{ca Lsafc Vgyycb gba hnsba qjc Gmc`dg igb nb qjc `gba-

gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc qn ic knbqygyt qn qjc {qgqc {`safc `gv{ gba knbqygyt qn Ad `nb" @cynt Ynsbqycc Jg{{c``

*cxcbqsg``t qn icknmc g mskj gamdyca Kjdch Ls{qdkc nh qjc Xdyfdbdg [spycmc Knsyq$ vg{ qjc [spycmc Knsyq

ls{qdkc vjn vynqc qjc npdbdnb nb qjc Gmc`dg kg{c dq vg{ g 7??# Ad``nb Ys`c gyfsmcbq" Qckjbdkg``t, dh tns

gpp`t ls{q {qgqc `gv gba qjc Ad``nb Ys`c gba dfbnyc g`` qjc hcacyg` `gv *ghqcy g``, dq&{ nb`t hcacyg` `gv$, qjcb qjc

Gmc`dg npdbdnb mgec{ {cb{c" Ickgs{c qjcyc vg{ g {qynbf hcacyg` d{{sc jcyc, Gmc`dg jga {qynbf fynsba{ qn

gppcg` qn qjc S"[" [spycmc Knsyq, vjdkj vg{ qjcdy nb`t npqdnb hny gppcg`dbf Jg{{c``{ ackd{dnb" Jnvcxcy,

{skj gppcg`{ gyc g`vgt{ xcyt czpcb{dxc `nbf {jnq{ gba qjd{ d{ bnq nbc nh qjc vcg`qjdcy knsbqdc{ db qjc {qgqc,

vjdkj d{ `dec`t vjt [tbgfn kjn{c dq"

Vjgq d{ vnyytdbf db Ls{qdkc Jg{{c``&{ npdbdnb d{ qjgq db vydqdbf gppcg`{ npdbdnb{, ny gbt npdbdnb{, lsafc{gba ls{qdkc{ qyt qn pyc{cbq cgkj {dac&{ gyfsmcbq{ db g ig`gbkca vgt gba qjcb czp`gdb vjt nbc {dac&{ gyfsmcbq{

gyc qjc mn{q pcy{sg{dxc" Ls{qdkc{ gyc asqt insba qn an qjd{ {n qjgq qjc vnyà kgb {cc qjgq qjct vnyeca

qjynsfj qjc `cfg` gba hgkqsg` d{{sc{ db g vgt qjgq vg{ hgdy qn inqj {dac{" Isq Jg{{c`` fdxc{ Gmc`dg&{ gyfsmcbq{


18/30

Sbpsi`d{jca77

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 7:


czqycmc`t {jnyq {jydhq" Bnvjcyc anc{ jc nbkc mcbqdnb hcacyg` `gv db fcbcyg`, ny qjc KVG {pckdhdkg``t, ny qjc

[spycmgkt K`gs{c, ny Kydf`cy{ npdbdnb db Ygppgjgbbnke_gyq D, ny Mdkjgc`{ npdbdnb db Ygppgjgbbnke_gyq DD,

ny qjc knsbqt&{ hcacyg``t pynqckqca ydfjq qn acqcymdbc jnv {`safc d{ ad{pn{ca nh" Jg{{c`` jgya`t mcbqdnb{

Gmc`dg&{ pn{dqdnb gq g``, gba jc gi{n`sqc`t dfbnyc{ qjc hcacyg` `gv d{{sc{"

G `cfg` knmmcbqgqny ycxdcvdbf Jg{{c``{Gmc`dg npdbdnb vns`a {gt, Vc``, nixdns{`t Gmc`dg&{ `gvtcy{

bcxcy ygd{ca qjn{c pndbq{" D an bnq jgxc gkkc{{ qn qjc iydch{ db qjd{ gppcg`, isq D ebnv qjgq g`` nh qjc{c KVG

gba hcacyg` `gv gyfsmcbq{ ms{q jgxc iccb pyc{cbqca qn qjc [spycmc Knsyq ickgs{c Ygppgjgbbnke Knsbqt

gba qjc @nkg` Fnxcybmcbq Gqqnybct{ nh Xdyfdbdg, Dbk" inqj hd`ca gmks{ iydch{ vdqj qjc [spycmc Knsyq, gba

qjcyc d{ bn vgt qjct pgyqdks`gy`t qjc Ygppgjgbbnke gqqnybct{ vns`a nmdq qjc nbc ed``cy gyfsmcbq hny

igbbdbf {`safdbf" [syc`t qjc hcacyg` `gv gyfsmcbq{ vcyc pyc{cbqca" Vjt ada Jg{{c`` dfbnyc qjn{c

gyfsmcbq{> Qjd{ d{ bnq qjc `g{q qdmc {skj pcyp`czdbf wsc{qdnb{ vd`` {syhgkc"

9??7 [tbgfyn x @nsd{g Knsbqt -- S[ Ad{qydkq Knsyq, Kjgy`nqqc{xd``c, Xg" Lsafc Jgyyt Mdkjgc` 77

Ycmcmicy D {gda [tbgfyn hnsba dq{c`h g 9-jn`cy db Xdyfdbdg> @ns{dg Knsbqt vg{ qjc bczq jn`c nxcy hynm

Gmc`dg" QjcI`gbqnb x" Gmc`dg npdbdnb kgmc nsq db Lgbsgyt nh 9??7 gba it Lsbc nh qjgq tcgy [tbgfyn vg{ db

Lsafc Mdkjgc`&{ hcacyg` knsyq db Kjgy`nqqc{xd``c qytdbf qn i`nke @nsd{g Knsbqt{ bcv {`safc ycfs`gqdnb{"

[tbgfyn jga iccb pgyqdks`gy`t iysqg` db {`safdbf @nsd{g knsbqt" Bnq nb`t vcyc pcnp`c fcqqdbf {dke, qjc

{`safc qyske{ vcyc {pd``dbf qjc {qshh g`` nxcy qjc yngavgt{" Gba {n qjc @nsd{g ingya nh {spcyxd{ny{ pg{{ca gb

nyadbgbkc db gb gqqcmpq qn knbqyn` qjc mc{{ gba kg`m qjc kdqd|cb{ anvb dq vg{ nixdns{ it qjcb qjgq qjc

XAJ vg{b&q andbf gbtqjdbf jc`phs` gba vg{b&q `dec`t qn, bcxcy mdba qjgq pcnp`c vcyc fcqqdbf {dke gba qjc

XAJ d{, " " " vc``, qjc jcg`qj acpgyqmcbq" Qjd{ `gke nh g{{d{qgbkc hynm qjc {qgqc fcbcygqca gb cbnymns{

gmnsbq nh cbmdqt hynm qjc pcnp`c nh @nsd{g qnvgya qjc {qgqc jcg`qj nhhdkdg`{ gba qjc {qgqc db fcbcyg`" Cbmdqt

qjgq vg{ vc`` ac{cyxca"

[tbgfyn x" @nsd{g Knsbqt g``nv{ s{ qn hs``t gppyckdgqc qjc agbfcy{ db bcf`ckqdbf qjc ycg`dqt nh qjcacqcymdbgqdnb-ycfs`gqdnb adkjnqnmt ad{ks{{ca ginxc, ickgs{c @nsd{g Knsbqt{ nyadbgbkc adab&q nsqydfjq igb


19/30

jqqp


20/30

Lsafc Mnnb{ pyc`dmdbgyt dblsbkqdnb npdbdnb d{ gq 97; H" [spp 9a 896 *V"A" Xg 9??9$" JD{7;

{smmgyt lsafmcbq npdbdnb d{ gq 94; H" [spp 9a 88? *V"A" Xg" 9??;$" Qjc sbpsi`d{jca pcyksydgm npdbdnb nh qjc S[ 1qj Kdyksdq Knsyq nh gppcg`{ kgb ic hnsba gqjqqp


21/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 97


knsbqt `dbc" Ichnyc dq knsà jdq qjc yca Gppnmgqqnz adyq qjc Ingya nh [spcyxd{ny{ pg{{ca g {sdqc nh xcyt

nbcyns{ gbqd-{`safc ycfs`gqdnb{ ycfs`gqdnb{ {n {qydkq qjgq dq vnsà ic xdyqsg``t dmpn{{di`c hny gbt {`safc-

hgymcy qn knmp`t vdqj qjcm, vjdkj d{ gppgycbq`t vjgq qjc knsbqt dbqcbaca"

Hny db{qgbkc, qjc {`safdbf {cq igke ad{qgbkc{ hynm pynpcyqt insbagydc{ vcyc {n czqycmc qjct gqc sp mn{q

fnna {d|ca hdcà{, gba qjc mgzdmsm {`npc qjgq knsà ic {`safca vg{ nb`t 6#, vjdkj db qjgq pgyq nh Xdyfdbdg

vnsà ic knb{dacyca ig{dkg``t h`gq" Bny ada qjc knsbqt `cgxc gbtnbc fsc{{dbf ginsq vjgq dq qjnsfjq nh icdbf g

pgt-pnqqt hny idf kdqdc{< Gppnmgqqnz{ nyadbgbkc czp`dkdq`t gbbnsbkca qjc knsbqt{ dbqcbqdnb qn igb {`safc dh

qjc Xdyfdbdg `cfd{`gqsyc cxcy mnadhdc{ qjc `gv qn g``nv qjgq" Qjd{ vg{ iyd``dgbq db dq{ qcmcydqt gba Gppnmgqqnz

d{ qjc nb`t Xdyfdbdg knsbqt D gm gvgyc nh qjgq jg{ mgac g psi`dk ycknya nh dq{ nilckqdnb{ qn icdbf {`safca"

Jnvcxcy, qjd{ nyadbgbkc k`cgy`t dbadkgqc{ qjgq Gppnmgqqnz{ `cfg` pcnp`c ada bnq sbacy{qgba qjc KVG gba

qjc ydfjq nh qjc knsbqt sbacy qjgq Gkq qn {c`h-acqcymdbc jnv {`safc d{ ad{pn{ca nh qjct adabq bcca qn vgdq

hny qjc {qgqc `cfd{`gqsyc qn an gbtqjdbf, qjc KVG fgxc qjcm g`` qjc pnvcy qjct bccaca qn igb {`safdbf"

Dq&{ qnn iga, db xdcv nh Gppnmgqqnz{ vd``dbfbc{{ qn hdfjq [tbgfyn, qjgq qjc knsbqt adabq ls{q igb {`safdbf

nsqydfjq sbacy qjc KVG" Gppgycbq`t, db `dfjq nhGmc`dg, {nmcinat qjnsfjq dq vnsà ic icqqcy qn qyt gba an

gb cba-ysb gynsbaGmc`dg gba chhckqdxc`t igb { safc it ycfs`gqdbf dq dbqn ni`dxdnb" S"[" Ad{qydkq Knsyq Lsafc

Bnymgb E" Mnnb vg{ bnq gms{ca gba Gppnmgqqnz `cgybca qjc jgya vgt qjgq qjc dacg nh qytdbf qn ycfs`gqc

{`safc dbqn ni`dxdnb vg{ g ycg` iga nbc"

Qjc {`safc knmpgbdc{ igkeca g kgig` nh {`safc-hgymcy{ `ca it Qnmmt NIydcb *bn ebnvb yc`gqdnb qn mc$

qn kjg``cbfc Gppnmgqqnz{ {qdhh {`safc ycfs`gqdnb{" Qjct jdyca sicy {`safc-`gvtcy L" I" [`gsfjqcy nh qjc

Vg{jdbfqnb, A"K" hdym Icxcydafc ( Adgmnba, vjn hd`ca {sdq gfgdb{q Gppnmgqqnz db qjc S[ Ad{qydkq Knsyq db

@tbkjisyf, Xdyfdbdg"

[`gsfjqcy vgbqca qjd{ qjdbf qydca db hcacyg knsyq hny g knsp`c nh ycg{nb{" Hdy{q nh g``, jc jga g {`gm asbe

gba jc ebcv dq" Gq qjc qdmc jc hd`ca qjd{ kg{c, qjc dbe jgab&q aydca nb @nsd{g, gba qjc Gppnmgqqnz kg{c vg{

g`mn{q dacbqdkg` g knsbqt qytdbf qn ycfs`gqc {`safc db{qcga nh igbbdbf dq" [cknba, dh qjc {`safcy{ vnb *vjdkjvg{ g`mn{q kcyqgdb$ gba Gppnmgqqnz gppcg`ca qn qjc S[ 1qj Kdyksdq Knsyq nh Gppcg`{, g vdb qjcyc vnsà

chhckqdxc`t {pycga qjc {`safc jgppt-bcv{, dh bnq qjc {`safc dq{c`h, qjynsfjnsq qjc cbqdyc 1qj Kdyksdq g`` qjc

vgt hynm [" Kgyn`dbg qn Mgyt`gba"


22/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 99


G{ db @nsd{g, g{ {nnb g{ qjc ksyqgdb vcbq sp, qjc {`safcy{ hd`ca hny g pyc`dmdbgyt dblsbkqdnb" Qjct vgbqca

qn {pycga qjcdy {`safc vjd`c qjc dqdfgqdnb vg{ fndbf nb" @dec Mdkjgc` db @nsd{g, Lsafc Mnnb fgxc qjc

{`safcy{ qjcdy pyc`dmdbgyt dblsbkqdnb, gba db {n andbf dbadkgqca qjgq Gppnmgqqnz jga `c{{ kjgbkc nh vdbbdbf

qjgb g qjycc-`cffca anbect nb qjc nsq{dac ygd` gq qjc Ecbqsket Acyit" Db hgkq, Mnnb&{ pyc`dmdbgyt dblsbkqdnb

ycga{ `dec g _Y iynkjsyc hny [tbgfyn, hny czgmp`c Dh qjc gb{vcy d{ bn, qjc msbdkdpg`dqdc{ `n{c" Dh qjc gb{vcy d{ tc{, qjcb qjc {cknba wsc{qdnb

d{< Kgb `nkg`dqdc{ s{c qjc hcacyg` `gv qn gxnda {qgqc `gv gba qjc Ad``nb yc`gqdnb{jdp{> Nb`t qjc {cknba wsc{qdnb

yc`gqc{ qn nsy {`safc d{{sc ny ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb" Lnbc{ gb{vcyca inqj wsc{qdnb{ ghhdymgqdxc`t" Tc{, Knbfyc{{

mcgbq hny gbt cbqdqt qn dbk`sac msbdkdpg`dqdc{, gba, tc{, Iyd{qn` kgb s{c qjc hcacyg` `gv qn gxnda qjc {qgqc

{qgqsqc" Isq db qjc Md{{nsyd kg{c, qjc HKK gb{vcyca qjc hdy{q wsc{qdnb db qjc bcfgqdxc< Knbfyc{{ ada bnq mcgb

hny gbt cbqdqt qn dbk`sac g msbdkdpg`dqt" Knb{cwscbq`t, qjc HKK hnsba gfgdb{q qjc msbdkdpg`dqdc{ vdqjnsq

ycgkjdbf qjc pyccmpqdnb wsc{qdnb"


28/30

Md{{nsyd Msbdkdpg` @cgfsc x" HKK, *:KG, 944H;a414$78

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc 9:


Qjc Md{{nsyd msbdkdpg`dqdc{ gppcg`ca qjc HKK ackd{dnb qn qjc :qj Kdyksdq Knsyq nh Gppcg`{, vjdkj78

ycxcy{ca qjc HKK, gba jcà, g{ Lsafc Lnbc{ jga jcà, qjgq g msbdkdpg`dqt d{ gb cbqdqt sbacy qjc `gv gba qjgq

qjc hcacyg` `gv pynqckq{ qjc msbdkdpg`dqdc{ hynm qjc {qgqc `gv pyccmpqdnb" It qjc qdmc qjc Md{{nsyd kg{c

ycgkjca qjc :qj Kdyksdq, Iyd{qn`vg{ g`ycgat nxcy gba qjc :qj Kdyksdq bnqca Lsafc Lnbc{ npdbdnb vdqj hgxny" [n

tns jgxc inqj g Xdyfdbdg hcacyg` qydg` knsyq gba g hcacyg` gppcg`{ knsyq dbqcypycqdbf qjc [spycmgkt K`gs{c qn

{gt qjgq g hcacyg` `gv kgb ic s{ca g{ g {jdcà it g `nkg`dqt gfgdb{q dq{ nvb {qgqc g i`gqgbq`t gbqd-Ad``nb

pn{dqdnb" G ycxcy{c pyccmpqdnb pn{dqdnb"

Md{{nsyd qjcb gppcg`ca qjc :qj Kdyksdq ackd{dnb qn qjc S"[" [spycmc Knsyq, vjdkj gfycca qn jcgy qjc kg{c,

bnv qdq`caBdznb x" Md{{nsyd Msbdkdpg` @cgfsc" Qjc mglnydqt npdbdnb *:-7$ vg{ vydqqcb it Ls{qdkc [nsqcy"

Ls{qdkc [qcxcb{ hd`ca g ad{{cbqdbf npdbdnb"

[nsqcy{ npdbdnb hnks{ca g`mn{q cbqdyc`t nb qjc mcgbdbf nh qjc qcym gbt cbqdqt" [nsqcy cmpjg{d|ca qjgqvjcb Knbfyc{{ vydqc{ g `gv qjgq knsà ic dbqcypycqca qn pyccmpq g {qgqc `gv, db nyacy hny qjgq pyccmpqdnb qn

jgppcb, qjc hcacyg` `gv ms{q ic gi{n`sqc`t k`cgy qjgq Knbfyc{{ dbqcbaca dq qn jgppcb" [nsqcy ycg{nbca qjgq

ickgs{c 93;*g$ nh qjc Qc`cknmmsbdkgqdnb{ Gkq adabq {pckdhdkg``t ychcy qn g msbdkdpg`dqt ny {qgqc {siadxd{dnb,

gba ickgs{c dq vg{ pn{{di`c qn ycga gbt cbqdqt qn mcgb gbt knmmcykdg` cbqdqt qjgq Knbfyc{{ ada bnq k`cgy`t

czpyc{{ dq{ dbqcbq qn pyccmpq {qgqc `gv{" Qjc :qj Kdyksdq vg{ nxcy-ys`ca, gba, db chhckq, {n vg{ Lsafc Lnbc{ gba

Iyd{qn` x" Cgy`ct"

Vjd`cBdznb vg{ k`cgy`t g achcgq hny Xdyfdbdg qnvb{ gba kdqdc{ qjgq vcyc jnpdbf qn fcq dbqn qjc

knmmsbdkgqdnb{ is{dbc{{, dq d{ bnq g achcgq hny Xdyfdbdg knsbqdc{ qjgq vgbq qn s{c qjc KVG qn igb {`safdbf" Dq

d{, db hgkq, gb dmpnyqgbq {qcp db qjc ydfjq adyckqdnb" Jgxdbf gb{vcyca qjc hdy{q wsc{qdnb bn, gbt cbqdqt anc{

bnq dbk`sac msbdkdpg`dqdc{, Ls{qdkc [nsqcy knsà jgxc {qnppca vdqjnsq gaayc{{dbf qjc {cknba wsc{qdnb, qjc

pyccmpqdnb d{{sc" Isq db k`n{dbf, [nsqcy ych`ckq{ iydch`t isq czp`dkdq t nb qjc wsc{qdnb nh vjcqjcy Knbfyc{{

kgb pg{{ g `gv qjgq psq{ g {qgqc {si-adxd{dnb ictnba qjc ycgkj nh Ad``nb, g`qjnsfj jc bcxcy s{c{ qjc bgmc

Ad``nb" Db gb{vcydbf qjd{ wsc{qdnb [nsqcy knbksy{ vdqj qjc inqj qjc :qj Kdyksdq Knsyq nh Gppcg`{ gba Lsafc

Lnbc{ qjgq Knbfyc{{ jg{ {skj pnvcy" [nsqcy{ nb`t knbkcyb d{ qjgq dhKnbfyc{{ dbqcba{ qn {qcp icqvccb g {qgqcgba dq{ {siadxd{dnb{, qjcb Knbfyc{{ ms{q an {n vdqj gi{n`sqc`t k`cgy gba sbmd{qgegi`c `gbfsgfc" Qjc qcym


29/30

jqqp


30/30

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

_gfc ;?

qjc pcnp`c, mgbt nh qjcm qnn pnny qn g{{cyq qjcdy ydfjq{, jgxc fynvb vcgyt nh icdbf qjc kn``ckqdxc pgt-pnqqt

hny qjc `gyfc kdqdc{, nh icdbf mgac d`` it qjc pygkqdkc nh jsmgb hckg` mgqcydg` icdbf s{ca g{ hycc hcyqd`d|cy, nh

{mc``dbf dq, nh jgxdbf qjcdy ctc{ isybca it dq, nh jgxdbf dq {pd``ca nb qjcdy yngavgt{, gba nh vnyytdbf ginsq qjc

`dbfcydbf gba xcyt ycg` qjycgq qn qjcdy ydxcy{ gba fynsba vgqcy hynm qjc nyfgbdk gba dbnyfgbdk knbqgmdbgbq{

hnsba db {`safc"

Hnyqsbgqc`t, qjc hcacyg` K`cgb Vgqcy Gkq pynxdac{ g vgt hny qjc{c xdkqdm{ nh qjc {`safc dbas{qyt qn g{{cyq

qjcdy ydfjq qn acqcymdbc vjcqjcy ny bnq {`safc vd`` ic {pycga db qjcdy knmmsbdqdc{" Bnv, dh nb`t qjc knsbqt

pn`dqdkdgb{ gba `gvtcy{ vns`a {qcp sp qn qjc p`gqc gba g{{cyq qjcdy knsbqdc{ ydfjq qn igb `gba gpp`dkgqdnb nh

{`safc, ygqjcy qjgb qytdbf qn gyfsc qjgq qjc knsbqdc{ jgxc qjc ydfjq ycfs`gqc `gba gpp`dkgqdnb nh {`safc"

reverse preemption theory ver05 part i

Documents