responsive document - crew: department of homeland security: regarding interference with foia...

8/2/2019 Responsive Document - CREW: Department of Homeland Security: Regarding Interference with FOIA Review: 4/10/

1/15

ARE/^V K akvk|ehq n`r reqw`hqkbkikv{K _j h f evdkaq kh jqdkhov`hNebrujr{ :7) 27::

B{ Njaqkmkie $?712157662+jhf emjki $`kjiZ+dz(fdq(K@Y/+FkraAihr( Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJ NEB k j 27:7Wrk~ja{ @nnkaeU(Q) Fewjrvmehv `n D`meijhf Qeaurkv{265 Murrj{ FrkY/e Q_) Bukifkho 6: 7 KK-*+ :7-L3QV@W>55_jqdkhov`h( n+)A( 27524$+>55

Re(< Etwefkvef Nreef`m `n Khn`rmjvk`h Jav RezueqvFejr QkrkMjf)im A)W(R( Adjwver :jhf Wjrv 5(Qweaknkajii{) ARE_ qeecq jh{ jhf jii rea`rfq `n a`mmuhkajvk`hq jm`ho jhf beveehRew( Fjrreii E( Kqq** jhf`n jh{`he javkho `h bedjin`n Rew( Kqqj `r vde D@iiqe `n R a w r e 5 e h v j v k ~ e x A`mmkvvee `h @~erqkodv jhf O`~erhmehv Revk+rm $"@~erqkodv A`mmkvvee"+) Rew( Kqqj/q

werq`hji qvjnn( jh{ qvjnV `n( ikhf jh{ kh~eqvkojv`rq khverhji `r etiem(v: v` vde @~erqkodv A`mrhk**eekhaiufkho dUK h`v ikmkvef :7 R`berv B`rfeh) Ijrr{ Brjf{) Qve~e Ajqv`r) Jqd`c Wkhv`) MjvvdeVjD7:ar) jhf`r Wever _jrreh jhf< $K + jh{ emwi`{ee `n vde FBQ Wrk~ja{ @nnkae khaiufkho( buvh`v ikmkvef v`) _kKik(khi D( Ki`i|arijhf) Ajvderkhe M( Wjw`k) jhf`r ^)mkj V( I`acevv(ARE_ jiq` qeecq jh+/ jhf jii rea`rfq `n a`mmuhkajvk`hq )vi:i`ho jhf beveeh FDQ/@nnkae `n Khqweav`r Oeherji jhf Rew) Kq


2/15

Fkreav`r) Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJNebrujr{ :7) 27 KKWjo9(71 N(2f ;65) ;6; $F(A( Akr( :;?;+( M`ra`~ev(vde ^juodh khfet muqv "feqarkbe ejad fàumehv `r w$irvk h vdere`n kvddeif) jhf n`r eiiadkvddìfkho kv muqv fkqauqq vde a`hqezuehaeq `n quwwi{kho vde Q @ U x d i - j h e r khn`rmjvk`h(" Ckho YK(U(Q( F s x w /K `nLuqr*a(( N(2f 262) 25: $F(A( ekr( :;??(

Kh vde e~ehv q`me w`rvk`hq `n vde rezueqvef rea`rfq jra wr`weri{ etemwv nr`m fkqai`qure( wiejqe fkqai`qe jh{ rejq`hjbi{ qeoraojbie h`h-etemwi w`rvk`hq `n vde rezueqvef rea`rfq( Qee 5 U(q(A( 552$b+( Knkv kq {ùr w`qkvk9m vdjv j fàumehv a`hvjkhq h`h-etemwvqaomehvq) buv vdjvvd`qe h`h-etemwv qeomehvq jre q` fkqwerqef vdrùodùv Kde fàumehv jq v` mjce qeoreojvk`hkmw`qqkbie) wiejqe qvjve djv w`rvk$m `n vde fàumehv kq h`h-etemwv) jhf d` vde mjverkji kqfkqwerqef vdrùodùv vde fàumehv( Mejf Fjvj Aehivjk) 5>> N 2f jv 2>:( Aijkmq `nh`hqeoreojbkikv{ muqv be mu$c- kid vde qjme feoree `n fevjki jq rezukref n`r aijkmq `netemwvk`hq kh j ^juodh khfet( Kn j rezueqv kq fehkef ki: dìe) wiejqe qvjie qweakvkajii{ vdjK ki kqh`v rejq`hjbie v` qeoreojve w`rvk`hq `nida rea`rf n$ir reiejqe(Nee _iik~er Rezueqv

Kh jaa`rfjhae kvd 5 U(Q(A( 552$j+$6+$J+$ikk+ jhf > A(N(R( 5(+ L) ARE_ :/A9iueqvq jjk~er `n ieeq jqqàkjvef kvd wràeqqkho vdkq rezueqv n`r rea`rfq( Vde qubleav `n vdkq rezueqva`haerhq vde `wehiik`hq `nvhe neferji o`~erhmehv jhf vde fkqai`qureq ikcei{ kii a`mrkbuie v` jbevver uhferqvjhfkho `r reie~jhv o`~erhmehv wràefureq b{ ARE_ jhf vde oeherji wubika kh jqkohkikejhv j{( M`re`~er) vde rezueqv :5 wrimjiki{ jhf nvihfjmehvjii{ n`r h`h-aummarakjiK x u r w ` q a q ( 5 U(Q(a( 552$j+$6+$vY+$kkk+( Qee( e(o) J:aAneidm Eaìòkaji ~( Ajriuaa


3/15

Fkreav`r) Fk:sa:`qure ikhf r@iJNedrujr{ :7)27: KK+joe VdreeAdjrieq Orjqqie{ beojh kh kh~eqvkojvk`h `n vdkq kqque ijq* Juouqv deh vde v` qahv ievverq v` 2;o`~erhmehv joeha{ khqweav`rq oaherjL( khaiufkho mKQ/q khqweav`r oeherjI Rew`rvefi{ FDQfehkef jh{ khjwwr`wrkjve meffikho b{ wìkvkaji ie~ei `nnkakjiq( {ev Rew) K q x j kq a`hvkhukho v` wreqqvde kqque bjqef @ki uhfkqai`qef khn`rmjvk`h nr`m j q`-ajiief dkqviabièr(" Qdehhjh( Wìkvka`)Wab( 2) 27: I

Vde rezueqvef fàumehvq ùif qdef ikodv 7:: vdkq kqque jhf vde vruv(dnuiheqq `n kiejiieojvk`h Kdhv aervjkii FDQ `makjiq dj~e wìkvkak|ef r@LJ wràeqqkho jv vde ki*


4/15

Fkreav`r( Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJNebrujr{ :7)27::Wjoe Nùr

AREY^ rùvkhei{ jhf q{qvemjvkajii{ fkqqemkhjveq khn`rmjvk`h v` vde niYibika kii qe~erji j{q) Nkrqv) ARE_ mjkhvjkhq j nd7?)?;; ~kqkvq v` ARE_/q fàumehvq qkhae Jwrki :6)27:7)

Qea`hf) qkhae Mj{ 277? ARE_ djq wubikqdef jh `hikhe heqievver) ARE_AUKQ) vdjv aurrehvi{ djq :>);>7 qubqarkberq( ARE_Ai/nQ wr`~kfeq qubqarkberq "kvd reouijr uwfjveq reojrfkho ARE_/q javk~kvkeq jhf khn`rmjvk`h vde `rojhk?(:iik`h djq reaek~ef nr`m o`~erhmehv ehvkvkeq( J a`mwieve jradk~e `n wjq* ARE_euiq kq j~jkijbie jv i m w < i * " / ~ " / ~ ( a k v k | a h x n $ + r A i d k a q ( ` r o < h e q i e i i / ) i < )

Vdkrf) ARE_ wubikqdeq j biò) Akik|ehq biuookhol3)r H*qw`hqkbkiki{ jhf endkaq ki i_jqdkhov`h) vdjv rew`rvq `h jhf jhji[?((eq heq`rvd{ fe~ei`wmehvq reojrfkho o`~erhmehv evdkaqjhf a`rruwvk`h( Vde biò) iàjvef 4v dviw3i~ (()akik|heqn`:"Aidcq(`rZibiìi( jiq` wr`~kfeq ikhcqvdjv fkreav rejferq v` `vder heq jrvkaieq jhf a`mmehvjr{ `h vdeqe kqqueq( ARE_/q biò djf6)765 wjoe ~keq kh Ljhujr{ 27::(

Nkhjii{( ARE_ djq wubikqdef humerùq rew`rvq v` efuajve vde wubika jbùv o`~erhmehvevdkaq jhf a`rruwvk`h( Qee /VKiv0 Re~ì~kho F`jr( j a`mwredehqk~e i``c khv` vde w ` q v x o ` ~ e i / i i m e h v javk~kvkeq `n 26 n`rmer memberq `n Wh


5/15

Fkreav`r) Fkqai`qure jhf N@LJNebrujr{ :7(27::w(voe Nk~ewìk:kaji jww`khveeq( Vde wubika jiq` haefq vdkq khik(:m:jik`h :7 lufoe vde ieokvkmja{ `n vde`ho`kho a`horeqqk`hji kh~eqvkojvk`h khv` vdkq mjiver) feqwkve mKQ/q fehkjdk( Vde ijac `n nuiifkqai`qure /iiif vrjhqwjreha{ qurrùhfkho vdkq a`hvr`~erq{ uhfermkheq wubika a`hnkfehae kh b`vdFDQ jhf A`horeqq) jhf fkqvrjavq FDQ sduh jvvehfkho v` vde jirejf{ wreqqkho femjhf v` wràeqqN@KJ rezueqvq jhf refuae kvq bjaciò( Reiejqe `nide rezueqvef fàumehvq Y x k i i jhqer zueqik@*:qjq v` devder FiKQ/q N@VJ wràeqqkho djq beeh qubleav :7 wìkvkaji khvernerehae(

Uhfer vdeqe akraumqvjhaeq) ARE_ a:ehri{ meevq vde rezukremehv) n`r etwefkvk`h qev ùvkh vde N@KJ jhf FDQ reouijvk`hq(WurQKL(:hv :7 A(N(R( 5(5$f+$1+) vde uhferqkohef dereb{ aervknkeq vdjv vde bjqkq i`r vdkq

rezueqv n`r etwefkvk`h kq vrue jhf a`m(-av v` vde beqv `n der chìefoe jhf beiken(

Kn {ù dj~e jh{ zueqvk`hq jbùv vdkq rezueqv `r l x + L / e < 3 K ( ( / A jh{ wr`biemq kh reiejqkho nuii{ vderezueqvef rea`hiq K+Sejqe a`hvjav me jv $272+ 67455>5( Jiq`) kn ekvder ARE_/q rezueqv n`r j neejk~er @n kvq rezueqv n`r etwefkvk`h kq hm orjhvef kh nuii) wiejqe a`hvjav ùr `nnkae kmmefkjvei{uw`h mjckho Qvkad h fevermkhjvk`h( Wiejqe qehf vde rezueqvef rea`rfq v` Jm:e I( _ekqmjhh)Akvk|ehq *v+r Reqw`hqkbkikv{ jhf Evdkaq kh _jqdkhov`h) :677 Ere Qvreev) H(_() Qukve 657(_jqdkiiovìi) F(A( 27775(Qkàerei{) (

hhe I( _ekqmjhhAdken AùhqeiEhai`qure


6/15

akvk|ehq n`r reqw`hqkbkikv{ARE_ Kjhf evdkaq kh jqdkhov`h:677 E{e QU5 Njt< 272-544-5727

NJAQKMKIE VRJHQMKVVJI QDEBV

V@< NR@M< @vveav`r) Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJ (J(hh(e _ekqmjhh

A@MWJH[< FJVE A(N(R( Adjwver : jhf Wjrv 5(Qweaknkajii{) ARE_ qeecq jh{ jhf jii rea`rfq `n a`mmuhkajvk`hq jm`ho jhf beveeh

Rew( Fjrreii E( Kqqj jhf`r jh{`he javkho `h bedjin`nRew( Kqqj `r vde Dùqe `nRewreqehvjvk~eqA`mmkvvee `h @~erqkodv jhf @`~erhmehv Ren`rm $//@~erqkodv A`mmkvvee"+) Rew( Kqqj/qwerq`hji qvjnn) jh{ qvjnn n) jhf jh{ kh~eqvkojv`rq khverhji `r etverhji v` vde @~erqkodv A`mmkvveekhaiufkho buv h`v ikmkvef v` R`berv B`rfeh)( Ijrr{Brjf{) Qve~e Ajqv`r) Jqd`c Wkhv`) MjvvdeVjiimer) jhf`r Wever _jrreh jhf< $:+ jh{ emwi`{ee `n vde FDQ Wrk~ja{ @nnkae khaiufkho( buvh`v ikmkvef v`( _kiikjm D( Dì|erijhf) Ajvderkhe M( Wjw`k) jhf`r jhkj V( Iàcevv(ARE_ jiq` qeecq jh{ jhf jii rea`rfq `n a`mmuhkajvk`hq jm`ho jhf beveeh FRQ/@nnkae `n Khqweav`r Oeherji jhf Rew( Kqqj) Rew( Eikljd E( Aummkhoq( jhf`r jh{`he javkho `hbedjin`nRew( Kqqj jhf`r Rew( Aummkhoq(Wiejqe qejrad n`r reqw`hqk~e rea`rfq reojrfieqq `n n`rmjv) mefkh) r wd{qkajiadjrjaverkqvkaq( _dere w`qqkbie) wiejqe wr`fuae rea`rfq eieavr`hkajii{) kh WFN `r VKW n@imjv `h jAF-R@M( _e qeec rea`rfq `n jh{ ckhf) khaiufkho eieavr`hka rea`rfq) jufk`vjweq) ~kfe`vjweq)jhf wd`vòrjwdq( @ur rezueqv khaiufeq jh{ ievverq) emjkiq) njaqkmkieq) veiewd`he meqqjoeq) ~`kaemjki meqqjoeq) jhf vrjhqarkwvq) h`veq) `r mkhuveq `n jh{ meevkhoq( veiewd`he a`h~erqjvk`hq) `rfkqauqqk`hq( @ur rezueqv jiq` khaiufeq jh{ jvvjadmehvq v` vdeqe rea`rfq(

:677 E{e Qvreev) H(_() Qukve 657) _jqdkhov`h) F(A( 27775 K 272(674(55>5 wd`he K 272(544(5727 njt K (akvk|ehqn`revdkaq(`ro((
mailto:[email protected]:///reader/full/www.citizensforethics.orgmailto:[email protected]:///reader/full/www.citizensforethics.org


8/15

Fkreav`r) Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJNebrujr{ :7)27::Wjoe V`Kn kv kq {ùr w`qkvk`h vdjv jh{ w`rvk`h `n vde rezueqvef rea`rfq kq etemwv nr`m

fkqai`qure) ARE_ rezueqvq vdjv {ù wr`~kfe kv kvd jh khfet `n vd`qe fàumehvq jq rezukrefuhfer ^juodh ::( R`qeh) 646 N(2f 427 $F(A( Akr( :;?1+) aerv( fehkef) 6:5 U(Q( ;?? $:;?2+( Jq{ù jre jjre) j ^juodh khfet muqv feqarkbe ejad fàhehv aijkmef jq etemwv wkvd qunnkakehvqweaknkakv{ "v` wermkv j rejq`hef lufomehv jq v` devder vde mjverkji kq javujii{ etemwv uhferN@KJ(" Nùhfkho Adurad `Qakehvìò{ ~( Beii) >71 N(2f ;65);6; $F(A( Akr( :;?;+( M`re`~er)vde ^juodh khfet muqv kkfeqarkbe ejad fàumehv r w`rvk`h vdere`n kvddeif) jhf n`r ejadkvddìfkho kv muqv fkqauqq vde a`hqezuehaeq n quwwi{kho vde qùodv-jnver khn`rmjvk`h(" Ckho ::(u(q( Few/v `nLuqvkae) 417 N(2f 2:7)221-26 $F(A( Akr( :;4?+ $emwdjqkq jffef+( Nurvder) a/vdekvddìfkho joeha{ muqv quwwi{/ j reijvk~ei{ fevjkief luqvknkajvk`h) qweaknkajii{ kfehvkn{kho vderejq`hq d{ j wjrvkauijr etemwvk`h kq reie~jhv jhf a`vveijvkho vd`qe aijkmq kvd vde wjrvkauijrwjrv `nj kvddeif fàumehv v` dkad vde{ jwwi{(/" Kf jv 226 $akvkho Mejf Fjvj Aehvrji ::( U(Q(Few/v vde Jkr N`rae) 5>> N(2f 262)25: $F(A( Arr( :;??(

Kh vde e~ehv q`me w`rvk`hq `n vde rezueqvef rea`rfq jre wr`weri{ etemwv nr`m fkqai`qure)wiejqe fkqai`qe jh{ rejq`hjbi{ qeoreojbie h`h-etemwv w`rvk`hq `n vde rezueqvef rea`rfq( Qee 5U(Q(A( 552$b+( Knkv kq {ùr w`qkvk`h vdjv j fàumehv a`hvjkhq h`h-etemwv qeomehvq) buv vdjv vd`qe h`h-etemwv qeomehvq jre q` fkqwerqef vdrùodùv vde fàumehv jq v` mjce qeoreojvk`h kmw`qqkbie) wiejqe qvjve djv w`rvk`h `n vde fàumehv kq h ` h - e t e m w v x jhf d` vde mjverkji kq fkqwerqef vdrùodùv vde fàumehv( MejfFjvj Aehvrji) 5>> N(2f jv 2>:( Aijkmq `n ( h`hqeoreojbkikv{ muqv be mjfe kvd vde qjme feoree `n fevjki jq rezukref n`r aijkmq `netemwvk`hq kh j ^juodh khfet( K n j rezueqv kq fehkef kh dìe) wiejqe qvjve qweaknkajii{ vdjv kv kqh`v rejq`hjbie v` qeoreojve w`rvk`hq `n vde rea`rf n`r reiejqe(Nee _jk~er Rezueqv

Kh jaa`rfjhae kvd 5 U(Q(A( 552$j+$6+$J+$kkk+ jhf > A(N(R( 5(::) ARE_ rezueqvq jjk~er `nneeq jqqàkjvef kvd wràeqqkho vdkq rezueqv n`r rea`rfq( Vde qubleav `n vdkq rezueqva`haerhq vde `werjvk`hq `n vde neferji o`~erhmehv jhf vde fkqai`qureq ikcei{ kii a`hvrkbuve v` jbevver uhferqvjhfkho `n reie~jhv o`~erhmehv wràefureq b{ ARE_ jhf vde oeherji wubika kh jqkohknkajhv j{( M`re`~er) vde rezueqv kq wrkmjrki{ jhf nuhfjmehvjii{ n`r h`h-a`mmerakjiwurw`qeq( 5 U(Q(A( 552$j+$6+$J+$kkk+( Qee) e(o() MaAieiijh Eaìòkaji ::( Ajriuaak) 415 N(2f:242) :245 $;vd Akr( :;4?+(Vdeqe rea`rfq jre ikcei{ v` a`hvrkbuve v` orejver wubika jjreheqq `n FDQ/5 N@KJ re~ke

wìkakeq jhf wrjavkaeq jhf vde vruvdnuiheqq `n vde jiieojvk`h vdjv wìkvkaji jww`khveeq jv FDQ dj~ekhverneref kvd vde N@KJ re~ke wràeqq jv FRQ( Vdkq kqque aurrehvi{ kq vde qubleav `n jhkh~eqvkojvk`h b{ Rew( Kqqj jq adjkrmjh `n vde Dùqe @~erqkodv A`mmkvvee bjqef `h dkq aijkm vdjvjh uhhjmef khfk~kfuji djq wr`~kfef dkm wkvd khn`KiKijvk`h /"vdjv v`w FDQ `nnkakjiq ere kh~ì~efkh reqvrkavkho khn`rmjvk`h reiejqef uhfer N@KJ rezueqvq(" Ljce Qdermjh) Kqqj Bjvvieq FDQ @~erN@KJ Rezueqvq) Wìkvka`) Nebrujr{ 2)27:: $ehai`qef jq Etdkbkv J+( Rew( Kqqj vòevder wkvd Qeh(


9/15

Fkreav`r( Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJNebrujr{ :7) 27::Wjoe VdreeAdjrieq Orjqqie{ beojh kh kh~eqvkojvk`h `nvdkq kqque ijqv Juouqv deh vde vw` qehv ievverq v` 2;o`~erhmehv joeha{ khqweav`rq oehevj:) khaiufkho FDQ/q khqweav`r oeherji( Rew`rvefi{ FDQfehkef jh{ khjwwr`wrkjve meffikho b{ wìkvkaji-ie~ei nnkakjiq) {ev Rew( Kqqj kq a`hvkhukho v` wreqqvde kqque bjqef `h uhfkqai`qef khn`rmjvk`h nr`m j q`-ajiief //dkqviebièr(// Qdermjh) Wìkvka`)Neb( 2) 27::(

Vde rezueqvef fàumehvq ùif qdef ikodv `h vdkq kqque jhf vde vruvdnuiheqq `n vdejiieojvk`h vdjv aervjkh FRQ `nnkakjiq dj~e wìkvkak|ef N@KJ wràeqqkho jv vde joeha{ b{kmwr`weri{ khvernerkho wkvd jhf feij{kho joeha{ reqw`hqeq v` N@KJ rezueqverq( Kh jffkvk`h) vderezueqvef fàumehvq ùif brkho vrjhqwjreha{ v` j wràeqq vdjv v` fjve djq beeh qdrùfef khqearea{ bjqef `h uhkfehvknkef khn`rmjvk`h nv`m uhhjmef khfk~kfujiq vdjv) jaa`rfkhoi{) vdrejvehqv` uhferm(khe wubika a`hnkfehae kh FDQ/q jfmkhkqvrjvk`h nk vq fuvkeq uhfer vde N@KJ(

ARE_ kq j h`h-wr`nkv a`rw`rjvk`h) rojhk|ef uhfer qeavk`h 57:$a+$1+ `n vde KhvemjiRe~ehue A`fe( ARE_ kq a`mmkvvef v` wr`veavkho vde wubika/q rkodv v` be jjre `n vde javk~kvkeq`n o`~erhmehv nnkakjiq jhf v` ehqurkho vde khveorkv{ `n vd`qe nnkakjiq( ARE_ uqeq ja`mbkhjvk`h `n reqejrad) ikvkojvk`h) jhf jf~àja{ v` jf~jhae kvq mkqqk`h( Vde reiejqe `nkhn`rmjvk`h ojrheref vdrùod vdkq rezueqv kq h`v kh ARE_/q nkhjhakji khvereqv( ARE_ kiijhji{|e vde khn`rmjvk`h reqw`hqk~e v` vdkq rezueqv) jhf kii qdjre kvq jhji{qkq kvd vde wubika)ekvder vdrùod m e m ` r j h f j x rew`rvq) `r wreqq reiejqeq( Kh jffkvk`h) ARE_ kii fkqqemkhjve jh{fàumehvq kv jazukreq nr`m vdkq rezueqv v` vde wubika vdrùod kvq ebqkve)(akvk| A(N(R 5(::( KhHjv/S Qea( Jradk~e ~( Uq( Few/v `KFeehqe( 447 N(2f :14:) :14>$F(A( Akv( :;4;+( vde Aùrv `nJwwejiq n`r vde Fkqvrkav `n Aìhbkj Akraukv nùhf vde Hjvk`hjiQeaurkv{ Jradk~e jq j rewreqehvjvk~e `n vde heq mefkj uhfer vde N@KJ) rei{kho h vde N@KJ/qieokqijvk~e dkqv`r{) dkad khfkajveq vde wdrjqe 6/rewreqehvjvk~e `nkike heq mefkj" kq v` bekhverwrevef br`jfi{3 "kv kq arkvkaji vdjv vde wdrjqe /rewreqehvjvk~e `nvde heq mefkj/ be br`jfi{khverwrevef k n vde jav kq v` `rc jq etweavef( ( ( ( Kh njav) jh{werq`h `r `rojhk|jvk`h dkadreouijri{ wubikqdeq `r fkqqemkhjveq khn`rmjvk`h v` vde wubika ( (( qdùif zujikn{ n`r jk~erq jq j/rewreqehvjvk~e j/vM heq mefkj( /" :12 A`ho` Rea( Q:62;4 $fjki{ef( Qewv( (17(:;4>+ $emwdjqkqjffef+) akvef kh kf(
http:///reader/full/www.citiz:ensiorethics.orghttp://www.scribd.kqm/http://www.scribd.kqm/http:///reader/full/www.citiz:ensiorethics.orghttp://www.scribd.kqm/


10/15

Fkreav`r) Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJNebrujr{ :7)27::Wjoe NùrARE_ rùvkhei{ jhf q{qvemjvkajii{ fkqqemkhjveq khn`rmjvk`h v` vde wubika kh qe~erji

j{q( Nkrqv) ARE_ mjkhvjkhq j nrezuehvi{ ~kqkvef ebqkve) (akvk|eZqn`revdkaq(`ro) vdjvreaek~ef 51):65 wjoe ~keq kh Ljhujr{ 27::( Kh jffkvk`h) ARE_ w`qvq jii `n vde fàumehvq kvreaek~eq uhfer vde N@KJ `h (mbf(a`m( jhf vdjv qkve djq 7?)?;; ~kqkvq vÀRE_/q fàumehvq qkhae Jwrki :6) 27:7(Qea`hf) qkhAe Mj{ 277? ARE_ djq wubikqdef jh `hikhe heqievver) ARE_Auvq) vdjv

AUiVeKivi{djq :>);>7 qubqarkbeh( ARE_Auvq wr`~kfeq qubqarkberq kvd reouijr uwfjveqreojrfkho ARE_/q javk~kvkeq jhf khn`rmjvk`h vde rojhk|jvk`h djq r e a e k ~ x nr`m o`~erhmehvehvkvkeq( J a`mwieve jradk~e `nwjqv ARE_Auvq kq j~jkijbie jvdvv)w


11/15

Fkreav`r3Fkqai`qure jhf N@KJNebrujr{ :7)27::Wjoe Nk~ewìkvkaji jww`khveeq( Vde wubika jiq` heefq vdkq khn`rmjvk`h v` lufoe vde ieokvkmja{ `n vde`ho`kiLo a`horeqqk`hji kh~eqvkojvk`h khv` vdkq mjvver) feqwkve FDQ/q fehkjiq( Vde ijac `nnuiifkqai`qure jhf vrjhqwjreha{ qurrùhfkho vdkq a`hvr ~erq{ uhf(ermkheq wubika aamvkfehae kh b`vdFDQ jhf A`horeqq) jhf fkqvrjavq FDQ nr`m jvvehfkho v` vde jirejf{ fimj v` w ` e Z q v x 3 3 3 < ) ) < x * ) ((N@KJ rezueqvq jhf refuae kvq bjaciò( Reiejqe `nvde KAzUeqvef f`juFeFvqkii x < k / < < k" (jq v` devder FRQ/q N@iJ wràeqqkho djq beeh qubleav v` wìkvkaji khve5( Jiq`( k nekvder ARE_/q rezueqv n`r j neewjk~er `r kvq rezueqv n`r etwefkvk`h kq h`v oi/4Kivef kh nuii) wiejqe a`hvjav ur nnkae km


12/15

ETDKBKV J


13/15

Kqqj bjvvieq FDQ `~er N@KJ rezueqvq - W@IKVKA@(a`mWrkhv ^ke Wjoe :`n1

W@IKVKA@ Kqqj bjvvieq FDQ `~er N@KJrezueqvqB { < L v c ( Q x NebH/"[ 2( 27:: 76


14/15

Kqqj bjvvieq FDQ `~er N@KJ rezueqvq - W@IKVKA@(a`mWrkhv ^ke Wjoe2`n1

W@IKV(KA@ vde qearevjr{ `n jh @bjmj zu`ve kh jmem`rjhfum jbùv vde Nreef`m `nKhn`rmjvk`h Jav) dere vde wreqkfehv ijufqvde ij jq ehaùrjokho "jaaùhvjbkikv{vdrùod vrjhqwjreha{(" ajiikho kv vde "m`qvwr`mkhehv etwreqqk`h `n j wr`nùhfhjvk`hji a`mmkvmehv v` ehqurkho jh `weho`~erhmehv"FDQ jkfeq feaikhef( e~eh `h bjacorùhf)v` fkqauqq kn vde{ vdùodv vdere erewìkvkaji m`vk~jvk`hq n`r vde kh~eqvkojvk`h(Mjvvde Adjhfier) j qw`ceqmjh n`r FDQ)qjkf vde joeha{ ùif a``werjve kvd Kqqj/q kh~eqvkojvk`h(-_e kii a`hvkhue v` a``werjve kvdAdjkrmjh Kqqj jhf wr`~kfe khn`rmjvk`hreqw`hqk~e v` dkq rezueqvq)" Adjhfier qjkf("@ur rea`rf kq aiejr( uhfer vdkqjfmkhkqvrjvk`h) vde Fewjrvmehv djqrefuaef vde N@KJ bjaciò b{ 46 weraehv(reiejqef `~er :14)777 N@rJ rezueqvq khvde wjqv {ejr) vde m`qv `n jh{ neferjijoeha{) jhf qubqvjhvkjii{ refuaef vdejmùhv `n vkme kv vjceq v` wràeqq N@KJrezueqvq("A`mmkvvee Femàrjvq qjkf Kqqj/q jkfeqdj~e h`v kh~kvef vdem v` be j wjrv n vdkqKh~eqvkojvk`h(Kqqj) kh dkq rezueqv n`r fàumehvq) renerq v`j ij vdjv qj{q vdjv khfk~kfujiq mj{ h viKjrbnvrjrki{ `r ajwrkakùqi{" kvddìfKhn`rmjvk`h vdrùod N@LJ( FDQ jkfeq qj{vdjv/q h`v djwwehkho(Vde N@KJ fkqwuve djq kvq r``vq kh jhJqqàkjvef Wreqq qv`r{ nr`m 27:7) deh

vde kre rew`rvef vdjv vde fewjrvmehv jqqehfkho N@KJ rezueqvq vdrùod wìkvkajijww`Khveeq `h j kfe rjhoe `n qqueq( VdeJW qv`r{ qjkf vdjv ijmjcerq wd` nkiefN@KJ rezueqvq ere bekho kfehvknkef b{wjrv{) jhf vde wK/@ZeQQ `nckaLfhorezujQnj /3/*v` m`re qehk`r `nnLan4Kq a


15/15

:Q&j bjvvieq FDQ `~er N@iJ rezueqvq - W@ImA@(a`mWrkhv^kew Wjoe 1`n1

W@IKVKA@ Rewubikajhq qj{ vdjv Mjr{ Eiieh Ajiijdjh)vde fewjrvmehnq adken wrk~ja{ `nnkaer) v`LfKqqj/q qvjnn vdjv vdere jq h` khjwwr`wrkjvemeffikho b{ wìkvkaji joehvq - buv jdkqviebièr ijver oj~e Rewubikajha`mmkvvee qvjnn khn`rmjvk`h vdjvuhfermkhef vdjv aijkm) j a`mmkvvee jkfeqjkf(Buv khqvejf `n jqckho Hjwìkvjh` v` veqvkn{ j vjav vdjv ùif aervjkhi{ wr`~kfe vde O@Wkvd vde Kqqj ~erquq @bjmj frjmj vdjvmjh{ kh F(A( arj~e -iqqj kq o`kho jnverqmjiier nkqd( De djq jqcef Hjwìkvjh /qadken n qvjnn) fewuv{ adken `n qvjnn) vde adken`n qvjnn v` vde oeherji aùhqei) Ajiijdjhjhf v`w N@KJ `nnkaKjiq v` qwejc v` vdea`mmkvvee bedkhf ai`qef f``rq `h AjwkvìDkii( FDQ jkfeq ùif h`v a`mmehv `hdevder vd`qe jkfeq ùif be mjfej~jkijbie n`r khver~keq(Jq FDQ qùodv v` bruqd bjac `h Kqqj/qaijkm) vde{/~e vjceh v` j vrkef-jhf-vrueFemàrjvka vjavka< bijmkho vde Buqdjfmkhkqvrjvk`h("Rejii{ djv vdkq br`ce f`h v` kq vde N@iJ`nnkae dere djf vde bkooeqv bjaciò kho`~emmehv" j FDQ jkfe qjkf(Qd`rvauvq V` Uhcq Kh Jrvkaie

n`r m a lhn`rmjvk7:: o` vÀQ^(H.qvieUQJaa

responsive document - crew: department of homeland security: regarding interference with foia...

Documents