reportablein thefgf supreme court of indiaoriginal jurisdiction

Upload: nikita-sharma

Post on 08-Jul-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    1/26

    REPORTABLEIN THE

    SUPREMECOURT OF

    INDIAORIGINAL

    JURISDICTION

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    2/26

    WRITPETITION

    (CRL.) NO.120 OF 2012

    Manohar Lal Sharma …… Pet

    itioner!"The Prin#i$al Se#reta

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    3/26

    r% & Or!" ……Re!$on'ent!

    WITHWRITPETITION [C]

    NO. 463 OF2012WRIT

    PETITION [C]NO. 515 OF

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    4/26

    2012WRITPETITION [C]

    NO. 283 OF2013JUDGME

    NTR.M.LODH! CJI.

    Coal i! (in)an' $aramo*nt

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    5/26

    Lor' o+ in'*!tr%i! an ol'!a%in)

    in thein'*!trial ,orl'"

    In'*!trial)reatne!! ha!

    -een -*ilt *$on#oal -%

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    6/26

    man% #o*ntrie!" In In'ia. #oal

    i! themo!t im$ortant

    in'i)eno*!ener)%

    re!o*r#e an'remain! the

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    7/26

    'ominant +*el+or$o,er )ener 

    ationan' man% in'*

    !triala$$li#ation!" A

    n*m-ero+ma/or

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    8/26

    in'*!trial!e#tor!

    in#l*'in) ironan' !teel

    $ro'*#tion'e$en'

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    9/26

     

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    10/26

     2

    on #oal a! a!o*r#e o+ener)%" The#ementin'*!tr% i! al!o

    a ma/or#oal*!er" Coal0!

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    11/26

    $otential a! a+ee'!to#( +or

    $ro'*#in)li1*i'tran!$ort

    +*el! i! h*)e inIn'ia" Coal #an

    hel$ !i)ni+i#ante#onomi#)ro,t

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    12/26

    h" In'ia0!ener)% +*t*re

    an' $ro!$erit%are inte)rall%

    'e$en'ant*$onminin) an'

    *!in) it! mo!ta-*n'ant.

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    13/26

    a++or'a-le an''e$en'antener 

    )% !*$$l% 2,hi#h i! #oal"

    Coal i!e3tremel%

    im$ortantelementin the

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    14/26

    in'*!trial li+e o+'e4elo$in)

    In'ia" In $o,er.iron an' !teel.

    #oali! *!e' a!an in$*t an' in

    #ement. #oal i!*!e' -oth a!

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    15/26

    +*el an'anin$*t" It i! no

    e3a))erationthat #oal i!

    re)ar'e' -%man% a!

    the-la#('iamon'"5" Bei

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    16/26

    n) !*#h a !i)ni+i#ant. 4al*a-le

    an' im$ortantnat*ral re!o*r#e.

    the allo#ation o+ #oal -lo#(! +or

    the $erio' 6778to5969 i! the

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    17/26

    !*-/e#t mattero+ thi! )ro*$ o+

    ,rit $etition!+ile' in

    thenat*re o+P*-li# Intere!t

    Liti)ation.$rin#i$all% one

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    18/26

    -% ManoharLalSharma an'

    the other -% theCommon

    Ca*!e" Theallo#ation

    o+#oal -lo#(!ma'e '*rin)

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    19/26

    the a-o4e$erio' -% the

    CentralGo4ernment.

    a##or'in) to$etitioner!. i!

    ille)al an'*n#on!tit*tional

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    20/26

    inter alia on the

    +ollo,in))ro*n'!:;a<

    Non=#om$lian#e o+ t

    he man'ator% le)al $ro#e'*re

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    21/26

    *n'er theMine! an'

    Mineral!;De4elo$ment

    an'Re)*lation<

     A#t.67>? ;+or

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    22/26

    !hort. @67>? A#t0

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    23/26

    on< A#t. 67?8;+or !hort.

    @CMN A#t0

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    24/26

    a,a% $re#io*!re!o*r#e!

    a! lar)e!!e";'

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    25/26

    o+ min'an';e< Allotme

    nt tainte' ,ithmala +i'e!

     an' #orr*$tionan'ma'e in

    +a4o*r o+ineli)i-le

  • 8/19/2019 Reportablein thefgf Supreme Court of Indiaoriginal Jurisdiction

    26/26

    #om$anie!tainte' ,ith

    mala +i'e! an'