report to the collaboration india-cms collaboration meeting delhi univ, 27-28 march 2009

52
Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009 A. Gurtu Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai

Upload: eadoin

Post on 15-Jan-2016

32 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009. A. Gurtu Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai. LHC Schedule. All the damaged magnets replaced - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Report to the Collaboration

India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

A. Gurtu

Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai

Page 2: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

LHC Schedule

• All the damaged magnets replaced• In order to prevent any further similar incident

precautionary hardware being installed at all magnets• This is a big job, in particular many thousand control

cards have to be fabricated, prototypes will be available in May

• Discussed in Chamonix meeting in February. Recommendations made to CERN council

• CERN council: First collisions in October 09, followed by extended run at 8-10 TeV, till 200 – 300 pb-1 per experiment is collected (~ 1 year).

Page 3: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

LHC schedule …

• Note that above scenario is still a compromise between safety and need for quick physics

• Only half the machine will be FULLY protected during the first run starting October 2009

• Remaining half will be done during the long shutdown starting in end-2010

• This schedule also has implications for experiments: NO SHUTDOWN in end-2009. So, all hardware will remain as it is, no repair, no additional installation possible.

• Consequences for HO (Si-PM), RPC

Page 4: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Beam Conditions for Physics

• Conclusion 5 TeV/beam for Physics• Machine Protection will be Tested with beam (at 0.5TeV

energy levels)• 4 TeV “on the way” to 5TeV (limited in 2010)• Estimated integrated luminosity

• during first 100 days of operation.. ≈100pb-1» Peak L of 5.1031 η (overall) = 10% gives 0.5pb-1/day

» Peak L of 2.1032 η (overall) = 10% gives 2.0pb-1/day

• During next 100 days of operation.. ≈ 200pb-1?• Then towards end of year ions (to be planned in detail

soon)

Page 5: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

• Gains 20 weeks of LHC physics (independent of “slip”)

Schedule with running in winter months

Page 6: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Statement on LHC Safety (1)Statement on LHC Safety (1)• Following the incident on 19 September the most crucial

improvement foreseen was a more precise system to monitor (and protect) anomalously high resistance in a joint (splice) near the magnets.

• The development of this new enhanced ohmic resistance measurement is well under way and the new system will be installed and tested before beam operation. This will allow effective protection against thermal runaway in the magnet and interconnect splices. There is still no way to protect against an “instantaneous” rupture of a bus bar splice.

• It has been shown by simulations that the new system with a threshold trigger of 0.3mV (compared with the 1V of the system in place on 19 September) will protect the joints form thermal runaway “in all imaginable conditions”. Note if this system had been in operation the September incident would not have taken place.

• In the Risk analysis, we have mitigated against the re-occurrence of a thermal runaway of a splice. The risk-score is the product of the probability of the event and the level of the resulting impact.

Page 7: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Statement on LHC Safety (2)Statement on LHC Safety (2)• For the September 19 incident, the high impact was caused by collateral

damage by:1. High pressure build up damaged the magnet interconnects and the super-insulation

2. Perforation of the beam tubes resulted in pollution of the vacuum system with soot from the vaporization and with debris from the super insulation.

• Until now and even after discussions in Chamonix there have not emerged any new ideas which would significantly reduce the pollution of the vacuum system in the event of a similar incident.

• However, measures will be taken to vent the Helium more rapidly and therefore reduce the pressure increase and consequently minimize (eliminate?) the damage done to interconnects and super-insulation.

• The already existing flanges in the Short straight sections (SSS) will be fitted with additional relief valves. Calculations have shown that this gives a factor of more than 9 with respect to the system existing on 19 September. These calculations show that the collateral damage (to the interconnects and super-insulation) which would be produced in a repeat incident of 19 September would be minor (significantly reduced). Such a repeat incident would not have a major impact on the spares situation for magnets . Whereas the collateral damage due to vacuum pollution would remain very similar to the September 19 incident.

Page 8: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Strawman Luminosity Profile

We (CMS) need to consider the impact of the long length of this run

(and prepare appropriate plans).

http://lhc-commissioning.web.cern.ch/lhc-commissioning/luminosity/09-10-lumi-estimate.htm

• *Switching to 50 ns bunch spacing could be attempted at this stage. With 5.1010 protons/bunch the integrated L could be as high as 110 pb-1/month.• Implies impeccable performance of the machine.

Page 9: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Status of India-CMS tasks

Page 10: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009T. VirdeeCERN/Imperial College

Details in Talks by Coordinators

Page 11: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Summary of HO commissioning (details from KS/SRD)

• HO is installed and commissioned • Known that HPDs have problems: for HO cross talk

(misalignment of electric and magnetic fields) as well as discharge.

• Overall plan to replace HPDs with Si-PM readout, for all HCAL. As problems for HO moving wheels (rings +-1,

+-2) are more severe, proposal to change soon.• As noted, no shutdown in end-2009, so earliest

replacement can take place in end-2010 shutdown.• This year placing two RBXs with Si-PM readout, one

each in ring 1 and 2, to study performance in real-life conditions.

• Also test beam in July 09 with Si-PM RMs

Page 12: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Brief Status of Interventions(report from TSV)

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 12

HCAL HB & HE : 19 out of 288 HPDs changed and tested. 11 due to high rate of discharges at B=0T and B=3.8T 5 due to gain loss or very low gain

3 Readout Modules (f.e. electronics) exchanged. Operating voltage for HB/HE lowered to <7kV>.

HCAL HO (W±1, W±2) replacement programme completed Operating voltage lowered to <6.5kV>. Aim to install 2 RBX’s with SiPMs (no discharging at all field values)

Page 13: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Si-PSD (BARC report)

• All sensors fabricated and module mounting done and shipped to CERN

• Installation of PSD within CMS detector was scheduled in February/March 2009

• Going on successfully

Page 14: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Some Photos:Installation of the Preshower

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 14

Page 15: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

PreshowerMuch progress since Dec CMS WeekAll 4 Dees are ready for installation

System tests done at +15C and -15C, 0.015‰ channels dead!

Installation platforms delivered on time

Infrastructure for ES+ ready, for ES- in March. Final off-detector readout cards (ES-DCC) expected in May.

ES+ moved on 26 Feb, installed underground and attached to support cone. Finish ES+ commissioning by end March

ES- moved on 12 Mar, installation starts this week, aim to finish commissioning by Easter

Well Done to All InvolvedWell Done to All Involved

One Crate/plane: 4 FEC-CCSs, 10 ES-DCCs

Page 16: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Preshower: Photos

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 16

The two separate ES+ DeesThe two separate ES+ Dees

Transporting the ES+ towards EE+Transporting the ES+ towards EE+

ES+ attached to support coneES+ attached to support cone

Page 17: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

GRID Tier-2 Centre(details by KM)

• All hardware purchased and most is commissioned• All technical tests passed successfully.

• Recall that we have TIFR-CERN point-to-point link and in CMS computing model Taiwan is our Tier-1, NOT CERN.

• (Also working towards connecting this 1 Gbps link to the European GEANT network which will allow general internet access and not exclusively to CERN)

• After much delay (11 months) European Commission (via Dante) agreed to peering of our line to GEANT.

• Thus, we now have high speed connectivity to many Tier-1 centers and the requisite number of up- and down-links have been established to qualify as a regular CMS Tier-2.

Page 18: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

RPC affairs• OLD:• Not only low η, but also high η RPCs have to be built as part of the

“endcap-RPC restoration” program for CMS. For high η the deadline is end-2010.

• It is now confirmed that India can expect to participate in the overall program and the real deadline for us is end-2010.

• DU withdrew from the India-CMS RPC project, leaving BARC and PU.

• NOW• Effect of delay in LHC: forwards RPCs expected to

be installed during 2012-13 long shutdown (not in 2010-11 shutdown). So time is very comfortable.

• Next slide: some (minor) problems to be sorted out.

Page 19: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Areas of Concern

T. Virdee LHCC Feb09 19

Not Major

Endcap RPCs: Some chambers, especially in RE-2, showed increasing leakage current – progress being made. Still collecting data. Soon determine strategy to follow.

AG later discussion with Archana, Jim Virdee: problem occurred inside CMS detector environment (temp? humidity?). Once outside (ISR hall) some seemed OK again. Being investigated. But new chamber production will starts only after this is understood.

Magnetic Field: fringe field, modeling and flux in return yoke

Forward Region: TOTEM, ZDC, CASTOR etc.

ECAL: Work ongoing to recover other Trigger Towers, Off-detector Electronics: EE_TCC48, ES_ DCC

Others: manpower, sustained operation, SLHC upgrades and the required facilities …- being dealt with – but more to do.

Page 20: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

< 0.5 A/day

< 1.0 A/day

< 2.0 A/day

> 2.0 A/day

RE+ chambers were switched on in the cavern for the first time beginning of September. HV was applied after about 100 gas volumes exchange. The gas flow was set to (1 volume)/ (2 hour). In a few days a significant increase of current was reported on several channels.

RE+ chambers were switched on in the cavern for the first time beginning of September. HV was applied after about 100 gas volumes exchange. The gas flow was set to (1 volume)/ (2 hour). In a few days a significant increase of current was reported on several channels.

Situation for gaps RE+2 down (about 40% of HV channels reported an

increase)

Situation for gaps RE+2 down (about 40% of HV channels reported an

increase)

Endcap RPCs Current Increase

Page 21: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Endcap RPC’s Preliminary Conclusions

RE chambers show larger than expected sensitivity to temperature. Similar measurements on the way for barrel chambers.

Stability of cavern humidity and temperature should be achieved for a safe RPC running. An installation campaign of T and RH sensors (both environmental and gas) has been launched

Increase of current at P5 partially reproduced at ISR. Careful investigation to spot other causes

Final brainstorming expected middle March to revise the results and take action. A possible parallelization of the gas circuit will be discussed.

RPCs Noise Susceptibility

Spikes observed during CRAFT data taking. The chambers are susceptible to noise generated by the flickering of fluorescent and projector lamps in the cavern (with magnetic field on). Star washers on the chamber front panels and additional shielding appear to help. More work needed.

Endcap RPC’s Preliminary Conclusions

RE chambers show larger than expected sensitivity to temperature. Similar measurements on the way for barrel chambers.

Stability of cavern humidity and temperature should be achieved for a safe RPC running. An installation campaign of T and RH sensors (both environmental and gas) has been launched

Increase of current at P5 partially reproduced at ISR. Careful investigation to spot other causes

Final brainstorming expected middle March to revise the results and take action. A possible parallelization of the gas circuit will be discussed.

RPCs Noise Susceptibility

Spikes observed during CRAFT data taking. The chambers are susceptible to noise generated by the flickering of fluorescent and projector lamps in the cavern (with magnetic field on). Star washers on the chamber front panels and additional shielding appear to help. More work needed.

RPC’s

Page 22: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

General, CMS-week related

Page 23: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009T. Virdee LHCC Feb09 23

Reminder from Dec Week: InterventionsNB: the CMS detector was/is in good shape to have taken high quality collision data.

Maintenance is an ongoing process.

Areas of Intervention Under Discussion Tracker: Cooling system, Fpix. Review soon before proceeding. HCAL: a few HPDs in HB and HE. Several in HO (W±1, W±2). Muon DT/RB: ~ 10 chambers to be repaired, start & gain experience with YB0 +side and then proceed, the one that is most difficult. CSCs - repair ~10 chambers previously known to have faults but were inaccessible due to logistics of disks in 2008. Alignment Components: protect sensors/MABs, repair DCOPs,...

Endcap RPCs: Some chambers show increased leakage current - under investigation.

Work is going reasonably well. We are within a few days of the schedule defined in mid-Nov. Vigilance is paramount.

Work is going reasonably well. We are within a few days of the schedule defined in mid-Nov. Vigilance is paramount.

Page 24: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Brief Status of Interventions

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 24

Muon CSCs Repaired 7/8 chambers on +end. Minus-end chambers (6) will be repaired during closing sequence.Other Items:

HV resistors  -replacing ~15,000 HV resistors (unstable). +endcap done, -endcap by early April.Install 5 ME4/2 chambers (upscope)

Muon AlignmentDone Repair & test of MABs (16 in total) Repair of readout boards for barrel (MAB boards) and endcap DCOPS on central wheels

To Be DoneRe-install 8 (external) MABs & z-bar extensions on YB2 wheelsFinal check out of components in YE1 disks & Photogrammetry of re-installed components

Page 25: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Some Photos: Fpix, ECAL

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 25

Page 26: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Tracker P5 activities status and plan1. Revise & re-commission cooling plants. Reminder: assure the long-term reliability: complete

replacement of the tanks, distribution lines, valves and manifolds on the SS1 and SS2 strip tracker (182 circuits) and pixels (36 circuits) cooling plants Work is progressing well. Aim to have 1st SS cooling plant connected by second half April. 2nd SS plant by mid May. Pixel plant available by early April.

2. Remove, fix and reinstall the Fpix system. Reminder: replace internal cooling pipes to provide

greater safety margin, recover the 6% of ‘bad’ ch. Fpix+ : removed and transported to TIF on 5th March,

Fpix- : extract Mar 18Re-install + Z side end-March, – Z side 2nd Week Apr.

3. Commissioning environmental system (thermal screen, heating wires)Dry-air seal (bulkhead) & between barrel-endcap, Recover & repair services at PP1

Manifolds

Page 27: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Magnetic Field

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 27

Measured by Field Mapper (at 2, 3, 3.5, 3.8, 4 T) in 2006 MTCC

TOSCA field map agrees < 0.1%

NMR probes inside solenoid confirm agreement scale < 0.1% between 2006 and 2008

In the Tracker RegionIn the Tracker Region

Compare tracker vs stand-alone muon momentum scale:

Dec. CMS Week: for stand-alone muons, momentum is over-estimated by 20%

Confirmed by other analyses

In the Return YokeIn the Return Yoke

material effects

Page 28: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Magnetic Field

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 28

B field picture confirmed by several CRAFT analyses: deficit of up to ~30% in outer layers of the yoke

Comparison with Hall probe measurements in progress – appear compatible with track-based results

The origin of the discrepancy has been uncovered → boundary conditions in 3.8T TOSCA model

Two technical solutions available in CMSSWNew TOSCA map – better agreement with data (in yoke)Per-volume rescaling of the field map (more freedom to 'calibrate the field')

Further WorkFurther Work

Where is the Flux going?Where is the Flux going?

Old TOSCA

Hall Probes

Flux LoopsTracks CRAFT

To be Updated

Page 29: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Newmodel

LESS

MORE

MORE

Results from track angle in YBResults from track angle in YB

Data MC (old)B12 ~1.6T 1.7TB23 ~1.2T 1.55TB34 ~1.2T 1.5TpT 20 GeV/c

New TOSCA Map

Much larger box

1.2

1.6

B34

Old TOSCA

New TOSCA

Rescaled

Validate, refine, extend tracking studies from CRAFT (later data)

Monitor better B field (more probes, 32 Hall probes ordered)

Improve TOSCA (and/or equivalent e.g. ANSYS) model of the field.

Work is continuingWork is continuing

Page 30: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009T. Virdee CMS Week Mar09 30

CMSSW Release Plan & Main Goals Working on improving cycle time & aimingto have one working

and one development release at a time – aspire for stability CMSSW_2_2_0 – End Nov. 2008

Improvements in Reconstruction, Particle Flow, AlCa algorithms,.New Features in Fast simulation and Analysis Toolkit (PAT)Used for Fast simulation production and Full simulation re-processing (RECO/AOD/PAT) and for cosmic data 2008 re-processingTo be used for second Middle Week Global Runs (MWGR) in 2009

CMSSW_3_0_0 - close new features mid-DecFullSim: geometry fixes, geometry DB, integration of forward detectors, Data Mixer, performance improvementsReconstruction: tracking and muon algorithms, e/ identification, Particle Flow, better handling of dead/hot channels in calorimeterIntegration and validation of new Geant4 release, new ROOT releasePreparation of migration to SLC5 and new compilers

CMSSW_3_1_0 - close new features end-MarInputs from analyses of re-processed CRAFT data Improvements in PAT resulting from analyses made with 2_2_xInputs from Trig/Phys Reviews held in Dec/Feb (new trigger table for startup)To be used for CRAFT09, MC production, collision data taking in 2009.

Need full validation to become production-ready and be widely deployed.

Page 31: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009T. Virdee CMS Week Mar09 31

ComputingData collected in the CMS Global Runs, CRAFT were re-reconstructed twice with latest software and calibrations.

Large MC productions were completed(~500M FullSim/5 months + 350M FastSim, several CMSSW versions) Lessons learned: address the following - latencies of tails, request tracking, reporting, develop metrics, production tools, close holes in validation chain, QA

MC production continues (full- and fast simulation)

Improve and (make persistent) the CAF/Tier-0/Tier-1/Tier2 infrastructure

Better monitoring tools, commissioning policies, computing shifts…

ECoM (Evolution of the Computing Model) with Physics/Trigger/DPG reviewed case for higher trigger rate to mass storage – recommended to stay with the current 300 Hz

Resource requirements for 2009/10 are being re-evaluated based on new LHC schedule in CMS Computing Resources Board and WLCG-RRB.

Page 32: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Trigger Reviews• Starting point: CSA08 HLT Menu had over 160 paths

– Proof of principle that we can run with this many triggers• Established a set of core triggers & thresholds at 8E29,1E31:

– 8E29: collision menu for Day 1– 1E31: aimed for longer-term MC studies

• Reviewed justification of all other triggers wrt. this set of core triggers at 2 luminosities.– Individual reviews of JetMET, μ’s, eγ, cross-triggers, b-tag/tau/p-

flow, AlCa-MinBias-Commissioning triggers• Collaborative work between Physics & Trigger

Result: a new set of leaner menus with HLT, express stream & physics datasets defined.– Optimized thresholds & other cuts, rates, efficiency calculations,

backup triggers, monitoring samples, plans for evolution– Clear definition of maintenance and responsibilities

• Triggers will be deployed online for CRUZET/CRAFT

32T. Virdee CMS Week Mar09

Page 33: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 200933

Preparation for Physics Since December, the large data samples from CMSSW_2_1 were

completed. Arrival of 2_2 meant that the latest particle-flow code and objects were available for analysis.

Two Events of note Input to Chamonix meeting: CERN management requested expected

physics reach at different collision energies and integrated luminosities. Scaling the CMS results from 14 TeV to 10 and 6 TeV. Discussed in a Special CMS MB, Wed. Plenary and given to LHC Coordinator. Approved results available in Performance Note DP-09/001 for use in talks/seminars.

Chamonix deliberations quickly converged on a run at 10 TeV, through the winter of 2009-10 until we accumulate ~300pb-1

Mini-Review of Physics by the LHCC (see later)

A neologism: PAT-uple a selection of events made persistent at PAT-layer1 level - bridge between

the reconstruction-software domain and physics analysis the quality of our physics analyses will benefit from this concept - increase

of synergy and the possibility of independent cross checks a new tool in the hands of PAGs, to be used for the forthcoming LHC data!

T. Virdee CMS Week Mar09

Page 34: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

First Few Hundred pb-1 @ 10 TeV

AAAS Feb09 tsv

SUSYSUSY

34

Signals and backgrounds are scaled from 14 TeV Plots are indicative of CMS reach

HiggsHiggs

With 200 pb-1, reach current Tevatron

sensitivity for Higgs

Z’Z’

Page 35: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

CRAFT Results

T. Virdee LHCC Feb09 35

AAAS Feb09 tsv

rms=24umrms=24um

BarrelPixelsBarrelPixels

Si Tracker

TOB

Si Tracker

TOB

rms=47umrms=47um

Energy deposited by muons

Energy deposited by muons

HCALHCAL

ECALECAL

radiativeradiativeionisationionisation

Points- dataPoints- data

totaltotal

35

~250um~250um

MB4MB4

MB3MB3

MB2MB2

MB1MB1

Muon Chambers Point Resolution

Muon Chambers Point Resolution

Alignment in Inner TrackerAlignment in Inner Tracker

Page 36: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Electronics and Electrical Systems Review

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08

Goal (w/s 19 Jan) Go through the operational experience with the electronics and electrical systems, Identify any problems, including sensitivity to noise,The reliability of the systems, the availability of spares, plans for Upgrades.Conducted by M. Hansen and P. Sharp (with other experts).

Main ConclusionsMain Conclusions

Over All CMS Electronics Operated well during the CRAFT Global Run.Over All CMS Electronics Operated well during the CRAFT Global Run.

However there are some Issues:However there are some Issues:There is a Serious Shortage of Firmware Experts and the Development & There is a Serious Shortage of Firmware Experts and the Development & Maintenance of Firmware will remain an Issue for the Life of CMSMaintenance of Firmware will remain an Issue for the Life of CMSAll Sub-Detectors need to have access to a well Maintained Integration All Sub-Detectors need to have access to a well Maintained Integration Centre in B 904. Centre in B 904.

This Centre should Continue to be used to ‘Sign-Off’ all Changes to Hardware, Firmware and Software before they are deployed in CMSThe Facilities at B 904 should involve ‘End to End’ Systems including the Trigger and DAQ

Page 37: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Electronics and Electrical Systems Review

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08

Other ConclusionsOther Conclusions

Emphasis should be given to ensure that all systems have both the People Emphasis should be given to ensure that all systems have both the People and Documentation to and Documentation to maintain the systems throughout the life of CMSmaintain the systems throughout the life of CMS

Institutional Commitment

New Systems must be Reviewed to ensure that they are Safe and have no New Systems must be Reviewed to ensure that they are Safe and have no impact on existing Systemsimpact on existing Systems

Pre-Shower, Totem, Castor, ZDC

All All ChangesChanges to Existing Systems Must be thoroughly Reviewed to ensure that to Existing Systems Must be thoroughly Reviewed to ensure that they are Functionally Correct and Well Engineeredthey are Functionally Correct and Well Engineered

Vigilance in Controlling System Noise is EssentialVigilance in Controlling System Noise is EssentialRPC & New Systems

System Problems and ‘Down Time’ must be logged and ReviewedSystem Problems and ‘Down Time’ must be logged and Reviewed

ES DCC production issues and EETCC production and commissioning will ES DCC production issues and EETCC production and commissioning will require close monitoringrequire close monitoring

Page 38: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Upscopes and Upgrades - SLHC

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08

Topical EB+PMs meeting on SLHC, Lyn Evans invited.

Phase 1 (2-3 1034, foresee long shutdown 13/14 ?)RE and ME4/2 are ‘shovel ready’, Pixels TDR in about 1 year ! Plan a presentation on pixels in Mon Plenary of the next CMS Week Whoever is interested has an opportunity to participate.

Phase II A few areas where big decisions have to be taken which have serious implications for CMS as a whole: e.g. Tracking/L1 TriggerECAL/HCAL/Trigger – also End-cap calorimetry in general. Cross-subdetector work. Whoever is interested has an opportunity to participate.

Engineering Issues (New TAS/FIN, cooling, Forward Region, BCM/BLM, YE4)Radiation Issues

Funding: In addition to R&D and construction costs need to fund the TC Project Office, Engineering Centre (System Engineers – Mechanical and Electronics), Facilities such as 904,…Cost Book + Cost Reviews

Page 39: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Report from LHCC Referees (17 Feb Meeting)

Detector Construction, Maintenance and Repairs The referees congratulate CMS for their careful planning and impressive progress …. to produce a complete, reliable detector for the upcoming long 2009-10 run. Once again taking the long-term view has paid off for CMS, and should put the experiment in good stead for the unusually long and important 2009-10 run.….. the puzzling loss of flux in the return yoke - look forward to the answer at a future meeting.

PreshowerThe preshower detector was completed and comprehensively tested on the schedule presented in November. Bravo! TOTEM Issues (combined session with TOTEM and its LHCC referees) The referees identified several issues of concern that are now being worked out among CERN management, CMS, and TOTEM. The guiding principle established is that TOTEM elements must be subjected to the same standards and reviews as were CMS subsystems before they are allowed to be installed in CMS.

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08

Page 40: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Report from LHCC on 17 Feb.Detector Performance, Computing and Physics CMS physics organization has provided outstanding leadership and planning, which has helped advance CMS to an unusually mature level of preparedness for physics. … efforts underway to improve reliability of T1 and T2 sites ……. great progress toward achieving TDR performance specifications……We support the approach of developing the PAT tools and a standard framework for CMS analyses. Experience at the TeVatron and the B Factories has shown that a common “language” like this has been of great benefit in producing physics results that can be easily understood, and rigorously evaluated within the collaboration. … We were impressed by the several analyses presented of simulated data, including measurements of top, searches for Higgs, exotics, SUSY, and the other “standard candles” …In this as in the other areas of preparation for beam and physics, CMS is in excellent shape.

Very encouraging report BUT we (CMS) should not get too carried away. These nice words will not mean much if we cannot rapidly produce good physics results when the real moment comes. We must maintain our focus and continue striving to do better.

Very encouraging report BUT we (CMS) should not get too carried away. These nice words will not mean much if we cannot rapidly produce good physics results when the real moment comes. We must maintain our focus and continue striving to do better.

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08

Page 41: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

CMS Schedule

41

2) Software, Computing &

Physics Analysis1) Maintenance & Operation

Install ES1

Install ES2

Tracker Cooling Plant Revised

Close CMS

Magnet Tests

CRAFT

Full validation of 3_1 (incl. production and physics)

Deadline for Input for 3_1 CRAFT, Trigger Review (menu), Phys etc.

Use 3_1 widely CMS gets familiar with 3_1

CMS READY for Beam CMS READY for Beam

Release CMSSW3_0 (limited validation, step towards 3_1)

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Start Fullsim production 3_1

Release CMSSW3_1 (LHC Startup)

Start Fastsim production 3_1CRAFT Contingency & pre-beam maintenance

Page 42: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

New CollaboratorsNew Collaborators - Singapore Profs. K K Phua, Belal Baaquie, Phil Chan, L N Chang, N P Chang, Low Hwee Boon, C H Oh• Started HEP in the 1970's. Have trained at least 20 PhD students • Organised HEP conferences and workshops in Singapore,• Currently working in phenomenology, theory.• Developing interests in Grid Computing, software?• 2 Institutes: Institute of Advanced Studies (Nanyang Technological Univ) and Department of Physics  (National Univ. of Singapore).

Note: Princess Sirindhorn of Thailand visiting CMS later this aftrnoonPoses the question- can we do something regional?

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08

Page 43: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 200943

CMS Centres Worldwide II• What is it?

– Information and communications focal point in institute with LHC / CMS displays, Web GUIs, video links, and outreach.

– Facilitates remote participation and harnesses global CMS expertise.

– Acts as a local focal point for their CMS work and outreach, and to improve communications with all CMS collaborators.

• How is it used?– Sub-detector DQM, calibration, analysis, computing ops, outreach (maybe

some remote shifts if running is stable – DQM, computingNB: shift credit only if CMS Coordinators/PMs authorize.

Page 44: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

CMS Centres Worldwide II

T. Virdee CMS Week Dec08 44

“How to create a CMS Centre @ My Institute”* Paper attached to this agenda addresses the questions:What is a CMS Centre and how is it used?

What hardware is needed?

What software is needed?

How much does it cost?

Build on the ~ dozen CMS centres so far.

Encourage CMS institutes to create CMS Centres

Cost: General costs + 2 consoles – about 15 kCHF

* L Taylor will give more details to the CB

Page 45: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Lucas: CMS Centres Worldwide

• CMS institutes are encouraged to establish CMS Centres– For their own benefit (and CMS)– 15 CMS Centres so far and

steadily rising

• Frequently Asked Questions1. What is a CMS Centre and how

is it used ?2. What hardware is needed?3. What software is needed?4. How much does it cost?5. How can I get more information?

Page 46: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Education and Outreach

MB Mar 09 tsv

Current core activities : continued production of the CMS Times and the evolution of the Outreach web site (11k distinct visitors/mo).

Recent Activities• Several new "virtual reality" movies of CMS underground,• Archiving thousands of superb images of CMS (please send your most interesting photos to Lizzie ([email protected]) • New online version of the CMS Bulletin, hope to release during June CMS Week. •Release of the Hollywood movie ‘Angels and Demons’, based partly at CERN. Much activity in the US, CERN e.g. public lectures. CMS planning to hold one such evening at Point 5 with a guided visit to UX.

•Setting up CMS alumni group (with CERN) to keep over 1000 CMS ex-members in touch with CMS news, events, developments and each other. Possible to upload articles, receive e-newsletters on latest developments and network.

Looking Ahead•Create two new exhibition centres: one at Point 5 and one next to the CMS Centre (Meyrin). Use spare parts of the detector incorporated with modern technologies, such as large touch-screens and "virtual reality" movies.Education: sharing data/simple analyses in schools and undergraduates in Uni

Page 47: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Miscellaneous

Publishing CRAFT ResultsMany people across the whole Collaboration contributed to the successes of last year, including the CRAFT run and its data handling and analysis.Results are very encouraging. The whole Collaboration should sign this. Should publish before LHC startup. Discuss whether to publish as a single paper or several, suitably linked, in one volume ? Choose whichever path is most efficient. To discuss.

MB Mar 09 tsv

Page 48: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Issues for this India-CMS meeting

1. Decision on new groups2. Organizational matters: soon going into M&O (data taking + physics mode) (good idea to rotate, but same one can continue)

HO M&O, calibration etc of current detector, future towards Si-PM Si-PSD M&O, calibration etc of current detector RPC detector fabrication by end-2012

GRID, Tier-2/3 connectivity from T2 to T3 soon, integration in CMS-GRID network: Vipin, Kajari, Sudeshna, Raman, Satyaki, Manas. All these be in Task Force.

Physics activity increasing rapidly

Coordination, coordinators.(Current: HO-Sudhakar, Si-PSD-??, RPC-LMP/JBS)

Page 49: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Issues…

• Discussions underway in CMS on detector upgrades for SLHC, timescale 4-5 years from now.

• Keep in mind we have already 2 hardware projects on our hands/consideration: Si-PM in HO, and RPCs…. Still….

• Budget: spoke with Mr Vijayraghavan (26 feb, 25 mar, also rks and kailas spoke to him). Both CMS and GRID are with DAE-Finance, he expected 7-10 days from 26 feb…. Says he will push again.

• Next meeting… 31 July, 1 Aug, BARC, Mumbai…• Mailing list… WEB page…

Page 50: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Lines of Communication

MB Mar 09 tsv

CMS Week Dec08CMS Week Dec08

5050

Collaboration Board

CMS Weeks5 per Year

Management Board~ Monthly

SP

Executive Board +PMs

Topical, SP

Finance BoardMonthly

RM

All-CMS Meeting~ 6 /year

SP

TechnicalCoordination

Commissioning &RunCoordination

TriggerCoordination

ComputingCoordination

OfflineCoordination

PhysicsCoordination

JOC - Joint Offline Computing, (weekly)CRB ~ every 2 months

MP3 - Monitoring Progress in Preparation for PhysicsWeekly, SP : DSP, Data Ops, Online, Dan

Run Meeting Daily, Weekly CRC

CDPG Monthly DCRC

MTP - Monitoring Technical Progress

Weekly,SP: DSP,RM EC, CTL, PE, Pt5, AH

Joint Physics Offline, (~monthly)

Pt 5 Site Meeting 2/wk TCTCM/TIG Weekly TCESSC Fortnightly EC

In Dec’08 noted that we should review structures in Q109 and adapt ~ Mar’09.So far have convened weekly - MTP (Monitoring Technical Progress) and MP3 (Monitoring Progress in Preparation for Physics). I believe they have served CMS well.Since beg’09 summary of MP3 meetings sent to all the Conveners

Page 51: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

+PMs Extended*Topical

WeeklySP

Lines of Communication from Mar09

MB Mar 09 tsv 5151

Collaboration Board

CMS Weeks5 per Year

Management Board~ Monthly

SP

Executive Board

Finance BoardMonthly

RM

All-CMS Meeting~ 6 /year

SP

TechnicalCoordination

Commissioning &RunCoordination

TriggerCoordination

ComputingCoordination

OfflineCoordination

PhysicsCoordination

JOC - Joint Offline Computing, (weekly)CRB ~ every 2 months

Run Meeting Daily, Weekly CRC

CDPG Monthly DCRC

MTP - Monitoring Technical Progress

Weekly,SP: DSP,RM EC, CTL, PE, Pt5, AH

Joint Physics Offline, (~monthly)

Pt 5 Site Meeting 2/wk TCTCM/TIG Weekly TCESSC Fortnightly EC

* Composition of XEB: SP, DSPs, CMS Coordinators and their Deputies, CB Chairperson, 3 – 4 invitees.Meet Weekly and distribute summaries to the whole Collaboration within a few days.

Wed. PlenaryDCRC,PC

Page 52: Report to the Collaboration India-CMS Collaboration Meeting Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

AG: Report to the Collaboration, India-CMS meeting, Delhi Univ, 27-28 March 2009

Issues in this meeting

• To consider report of the committee’s recommendations regarding induction of new groups into India-CMS (and CMS).

• To consider the participation of India-CMS in the HO upgrade.• From July 08, expected that instead of India-Fund, India-CMS will

have to support per diems at CERN from budgets requested. It was agreed in an earlier Steering Committee meeting that an India-CMS committee be in place to consider all the requested deputations. Check with funding agencies also.

• Have been some suggestions again regarding written constitution for India-CMS. Can have a short discussion later and, if necessary, can constitute a committee to draw up a draft.

• Finally we are in 2008. And hope that beam-beam collisions will take place in LHC at full energy.