refinerd.com - make proper decisions - bill hills, cmps®

3
 ! #$%& '()) *())+, -./01 2 345467 .869:;:< ';=><6 2 '())*())+?@8A !"#$%" '$( )"*+, %"-.+,*/ 0 1-,2 2$ 32%"33 24" #-52 24-2 0 -6 - )+2 $# -, -,-7'2+5-7 ,"%.8 94+3 +3 - *$$. 24+,* #$% 6' 57+",23 )(2 +2 6-' ,$2 )" $:"%7' ";5+2+,* #$% 24" %"32 $# '$(8 94" ";2%"6" -55(%-5' $# 6' !"# %&'#( )*+,-./. 0&' 1"0/*+*2/*3 6-' ,$2 )" ,"5"33-%' 14", ."2"%6+,+,* 14"24"% $% ,$2 '$( 34$(7. %"#+,-,5"8 <$1":"%/ 24+3 6"24$. 1+77 4"7= '$( (,."%32-,. 24" 2%(" 6-*,+2(." $# 24" )","#+2 $# '$(% %"#+,-,5" >0 .$ -77 24" 4"-:' 7+#2+,*?8 )'" -&4 '"+,,- .+5/ *3 6778999 &5"' #(" *":# ; -"+'.< &' /. /# =&'" ,/>" 6?@8999 @ 0 24+,A 24-2B3 +6=$%2-,2 2$ A,$1C %"*-%.7"33 $# '$(% D"%. E":"78 "#$%&$'% %'(")*)+' *)*,-.". .8+9 B<8B)< 4+< 9C< $/01234 ./56378 #249:; DC<= ;++<++(=: 9C< E(=;=@(;) F<=<E(9 8E ; 6<E(=;=@<? GC(+ A<9C8H D()) )<;H 98 I<67 (AB68B<6 H<@(+(8=+ (= A;=7 @;+<+? JC7K '<@;4+< 0:<= 1:=47/72 >/01234 68 3:4 / ?:84? L=)7 9C< (=9<6<+9 @8AB8=<=9 8E 7846 /6(=@(B;) M N=9<6<+9 B;7A<=9 (+ ; @8+9 O;=H 98 9;>< (9 <I<= E469C<6, 8=)7 9C< P;E9<6Q9;5R (=9<6<+9 @8AB8=<=9 (+ 9C< 964< @8+9S? GC< B;7A<=9 8E 9C< B6(=@(B;) @8AB8=<=9 (= 7846 B;7A<=9 (+ 8=)7 ;= ;++<9 6<B8+(9(8=(=: T E68A @;+C 98 C8A< <U4(97? GC(+ B6(=@(B;) B;7A<=9 H8<+ =89 (AB;@9 7846 =<9 D869C? -8=96;67 98 B8B4);6 F<)(<E, 98 A;>< ; E(=;=@(;))7 B68B<6 6<E(=;=@< H<@(+(8=, ;:3@4 252= A:?<8 :3 0:<= 1:349B0 >/01234 C8/56378DE  F968 1249:; ?/3 ?=2/42 / ;2?686:3 G/82; :3 /3 63/??<=/42 ?:84 G=2/HI2523 >:634J  NE 784 ;6< 6<E(=;=@(=: ;= ;:<H A869:;:<, 784 D()) F< )<H 98 F<)(<I< 9C;9 7846 P@8+9 +;I(=:+R (+ E;6 :6<;9<6 9C;= DC;9 (+ 964<? V=H I(@< I<6+;W (E 784 ;6< 6<E(=;=@(=: ; 6<);9(I<)7 =<D )8;=, 784 D()) F< )<H 98 F<)(<I< 9C;9 784 ;6< +;I(=: )<++ A8=<7 9C;= DC;9 (+ 964<? A)BCD E F 1DGH )!)CIJHJ +K%%')F ,&*) L&M) #*%- LXNYNZV3 3LVZ V.L[ZG \]^],$$$ \_%$,$$$ VY` La 3LVZ %$ b`VX0 % b`VX -[XX`ZG 'V3VZ-` \cdd,d^] \_$$,^&c NZG`X`0G XVG` e?e$$f e?e$$f G`X. &$ &$ /MN /Vb.`ZG \^,]%e \^,$&% NZG`X`0G -L0G Z`gG %# .LZG*0 \&],$$^ \&],#_# /XNZ-N/V3 /VNh Z`gG %# .LZG*0 \%d,__e \%$,%$^ )'N ,&*) L&M) #*%- 3LVZ V.L[ZG \_$$,$$$ \_$$,$$$ NZG`X`0G XVG` ^?$$$f ^?$$$f G`X. &$ &$ /MN /Vb.`ZG \&,&^# \&,&^# NZG`X`0G -L0G Z`gG %# .LZG*0 \#_,__c \#_,__c -3L0NZY -L0G0 \#,$$$ \#,$$$ GVg 'XV-i`G &&f &&f +&#$*%".&). L&M) #*%- XVG` hNaa`X`ZGNV3 %?e$$f %?e$$f /Vb.`ZG hNaa`X`ZGNV3 \%,^_& \c]d $*-#')F O.*P")Q.O I -'*% R S61>=:>2=T URVWXVY UZW[V\ *+FK*, ")F'%'.F .*P")Q. I -'*% R S$=2I4/]T UR^W[[Z UR^W_`X $%'IF*a bK"+c #'FM&d I -'*% R UR^WY^^ UR^WY^^ *(F'%IF*a bK"+c #'FM&d I -'*% R UVW^\Y UVW^\Y )'F N&%FM *)*,-.". I -'*% R S822 G2B:eT UXW`\X UVW^YR N= )88>(=: ;9 F/GB2 R ;F8I<, 9C< /;7A<=9 0;I(=:+ A<9C8H D84)H (=H(@;9< 9C;9 j8C= D()) +;I< \%,^_& <;@C A8=9C F7 6<E(=;=@(=:??? F49 .;67 D()) 8=)7 +;I< \c]d <;@C A8=9C??? <I<= 9C84:C 9C<7 ;6< F89C 6<E(=;=@(=: 9C< +;A< )8;= ;A84=9 849 8E ; e?$$f (=9<6<+9 6;9< )8;= ;=H (=98 ; =<D )8;= D(9C ; &?e$f (=9<6<+9 6;9<? N= 6<;)(97, 9C<+< =4AF<6+ 8=)7 6<B6<+<=9 ; B;7A<=9 H(EE<6<=9(;), =89 ;= ;@94;) k+;I(=:+k? V F<99<6 (=H(@;986 (+ 9C< ;==4;) (=9<6<+9 +;I(=:+ 8E \%$,##] ;=H \%$,^dc 6<+B<@9(I<)7? *8D<I<6, 98 @;)@4);9< 9C;9, 784 D84)H =<<H ; E(=;=@(;) @;)@4);986 86 ;= ;A869(l;9(8= +@C<H4)<? (:= 492 f<6?H284 I /3; 1:84 /??<=/42 I 1249:;8 A:= 25/B</4637 / =2A63/3?2W >B2/82 822 492 O$=:>2= *3/B0868O 82?46:3 4: 492 =6794J  $%&$'% %'(")*)+' *)*,-.". m<67 E<D B<8B)< 4+< 9C< F=<2 +:84 ./56378 #249:; DC<= ;++<++(=: 9C< E(=;=@(;) F<=<E(9 8E ; 6<E(=;=@<? N F<)(<I< 9C(+ (+ +(AB)7 F<@;4+< I<67 E<D B<8B)< 4=H<6+9;=H )8;= ;A869(l;9(8= ;=H 9C< 964< H7=;A(@+ 8E ; A869:;:<? GC(+ A<9C8H D()) )<;H 98 I<67 B68B<6 H<@(+(8=+ (= A8+9 @;+<+? JC7K '<@;4+< 64 238<=28 49/4 0:< /=2 :3B0 ?:1>/=637 4=<2 ?:84 ?:1>:32348 :A / 1:=47/72J $%'IF*a bK"+c #'FM&d !"K C&+* )=&4*# : H*#"'".# 1+#" L/00"'"*#/+,  \_$$,$$$ 5 %?e$f n UR^WY^^ 28461/42; /33</B 6342=284 8/56378 S>=2I4/]T OGC(+ A<9C8H D()) (=H(@;9< ;= (=E);9<H ;==4;) (=9<6<+9 +;I(=:+ F<@;4+< (9 H8<+ =89 ;@@84=9 E86 9C< 8=:8(=: 6<H4@9(8= 8E 9C< B6(=@(B;) F;);=@< 86 ;=7 9;5 H<H4@9(F()(97S *(F'%IF*a bK"+c #'FM&d !"K C&+* )=&4*# : H*#"'".# 1+#" L/00"'"*#/+, : ME F /*2&=" #+: N'+2>"#O  \_$$,$$$ 5 %?e$f 5 c_fo n UVW^\Y 28461/42; /33</B 6342=284 8/56378 S/A42=I 4/]T OGC(+ A<9C8H D()) (=H(@;9< ; +)(:C9)7 (=E);9<H ;==4;) (=9<6<+9 +;I(=:+ F<@;4+< (9 H8<+ =89 ;@@84=9 E86 9C< 8=:8(=: 6<H4@9(8= 8E 9C< B6(=@(B;) F;);=@<S  o;++4A<+ <)(:(F()(97 E86 %$$f 9;5 H<H4@9(F()(97 8E A869:;:< (=9<6<+9 ;=H ; &&f (=@8A< 9;5 F6;@><9 )'F N&%FM *)*,-.". #'FM&d O+<< +@6<<=+C89+ F<)8DS N @;)) 9C(+ A<9C8H 9C< )24 N:=49 *3/B0868 A:= %2A63/3?637 ;=H (9 (+ +8A<9C(=: N H<I<)8B<H F;@> (= #$$] ;+ 9C< E84=H<6 8E .869:4(H;=@<1 Q ; A869:;:< @8=+4A<6 @8=+4)9(=: E(6A? N =8D 4+< (9 A7+<)E E86 B68B<6 6<E(=;=@< ;=;)7+(+ E86 A7 8D= A869:;:< @)(<=9+? N9 9;><+ (=98 ;@@84=9 9C< E8))8D(=:??? p $=63?6>/B g/B/3?2 ;9 ; +B<@(E(@ ;=;)7+(+ B8(=9 (= 9(A< p +/89 ./56378 g/B/3?2 ;9 ; +B<@(E(@ ;=;)7+(+ B8(=9 (= 9(A< p F/] ./56378 ;9 ; +B<@(E(@ ;=;)7+(+ B8(=9 (= 9(A< p F/] +:848 ;9 ; +B<@(E(@ ;=;)7+(+ B8(=9 (= 9(A< 94" !"# %&'#( )*+,-./. 0&' 1"0/*+*2/*3 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 =7-5" -,. =-+. .$1, 6' =%+,5+=-7 6$%" -**%"33+:"7'@ N4-2":"% '$(% %"#+,-,5" $)P"52+:" 6-' )"/ 24" Q$%2*(+.-,5"R D"2 N$%24 F,-7'3+3 1+77 ",-)7" '$( 2$ 6-A" - 6$32 1"77S+,#$%6". -,. -==%$=%+-2" %"#+,-,5" ."5+3+$, SS 14+54 6-' ":", )" 2$ -:$+. - %"#+,-,5" -72$*"24"%8 GC< ZJV A<9C8H+ F<)8D D()) +C8D 784 9C;9 9C< ;@94;) +;I(=:+ (= 7<;6 % E86 L:93 (+ \^,d&c O9C< =<9 (AB;@9 8= =<9 D869C (E 784 +;I< 9C< B;7A<=9 H(EE<6<=9(;)S q 9C< \#,$$$ 9C;9 D;+ B;(H (= @)8+(=: @8+9+??? A:= / 4:4/B 8/56378 :A UXW`\XJ V=H 9C< ;@94;) +;I(=:+ (= 7<;6 % E86 #/=0 (+ \e,$e% O9C< =<9 (AB;@9 8= =<9 D869C (E 784 +;I< 9C< B;7A<=9 H(EE<6<=9(;)S q 9C< \#,$$$ 9C;9 D;+ B;(H (= @)8+(=: @8+9+??? A:= / 4:4/B 8/56378 :A UVW^YRJ g6BB M6BB8W +#$.h i ,<]<=0 #:=47/72 g/3H2= i +96?/7: i [[_IZ_ZI_\Z_ i g6BBM6BB8J?:1 0 4-:" )"", =%$:+.+,* 6$%2*-*" 3$7(2+$,3 #$% 6' 57+",23 3+,5" TUUV8 F3 - TUS'"-% 6$%2*-*" +,.(32%' :"2"%-,/ -,. H"%2+#+". Q$%2*-*" G7-,,+,* J="5+-7+32R/ 0 -6 =%"=-%". 2$ =%$:+." '$( 1+24 :-7(-)7" 6$%2*-*" 3"%:+5"38 H$,2-52 6" #$% - #%"" )(2 24$%$(*4 -,-7'3+3 $# '$(% %"#+,-,5" $% =(%54-3" 2%-,3-52+$,8 

Upload: bill-hills

Post on 14-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RefiNerd.com - Make Proper Decisions - Bill Hills, CMPS®

7/27/2019 RefiNerd.com - Make Proper Decisions - Bill Hills, CMPS®

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/refinerdcom-make-proper-decisions-bill-hills-cmps 1/3 ©2013BillHills,CMPS®|LuxuryMortgageBanker|BillHills.com

Beforeyoubeginreading,IwanttostressthefactthatIamabitofananalyticalnerd.Thisisagoodthingformyclientsbutitmaynot

beoverlyexcitingfortherestofyou.Theextremeaccuracyofmy NetWorthAnalysisforRefinancing maynotbenecessarywhen

determiningwhetherornotyoushouldrefinance.However,thismethodwillhelpyouunderstandthetruemagnitudeofthebenefitof

yourrefinance(Idoalltheheavylifting). Areyoureallysaving$88,000overthenext5years…orisit morelike$34,000 ?Ithinkthat’s

importanttoknow…regardlessofyourNerdLevel.

IMPROPERREFINANCEANALYSISMostpeopleusethePaymentSavingsMethodwhenassessingthefinancial

benefitofarefinance.Thismethodwillleadtoveryimproperdecisionsin

manycases.Why?Because yourmortgagepaymentisnotacost .Onlythe

interestcomponentofyourPrincipal&Interestpaymentisacost(andto

takeitevenfurther,onlythe“after-tax”interestcomponentisthetruecost).

Thepaymentoftheprincipalcomponentinyourpaymentisonlyanasset

repositioning–fromcashtohomeequity.Thisprincipalpaymentdoesnot

impactyournetworth.

Contrarytopopularbelief,tomakeafinancially

properrefinancedecision,don’teverfocuson

yourmonthlypayment“savings”!

Thismethodcancreateadecisionbasedonaninaccuratecostbreak-even

point.Ifyouarerefinancinganagedmortgage,youwillbeledtobelievethat

your“costsavings”isfargreaterthanwhatistrue.Andviceversa…ifyouare

refinancingarelativelynewloan,youwillbeledtobelievethatyouare

savinglessmoneythanwhatistrue.

TABLE1-REFIANALYSIS CURRENTLOAN JOHN MARY

ORIGINALLOANAMOUNT $848,000 $710,000

AGEOFLOAN 10YEARS 1YEAR

CURRENTBALANCE $699,948 $700,436INTERESTRATE 5.500% 5.500%

TERM 30 30

P&IPAYMENT $4,815 $4,031

INTERESTCOSTNEXT12MONTHS $38,004 $38,272

PRINCIPALPAIDNEXT12MONTHS $19,775 $10,104

NEWLOAN JOHN MARY

LOANAMOUNT $700,000 $700,000

INTERESTRATE 4.000% 4.000%

TERM 30 30

P&IPAYMENT $3,342 $3,342

INTERESTCOSTNEXT12MONTHS $27,776 $27,776

CLOSINGCOSTS $2,000 $2,000

TAXBRACKET 33% 33%

COMPARISONS JOHN MARY

RATEDIFFERENTIAL 1.500% 1.500%

PAYMENTDIFFERENTIAL $1,473 $689

PAYMENT"SAVINGS"-YEAR1(improper) $17,675 $8,273

ACTUALINTERESTSAVINGS-YEAR1(Pre-tax) $10,228 $10,496

PRE-TAXQUICKMETHOD-YEAR1 $10,500 $10,500

AFTER-TAXQUICKMETHOD-YEAR1 $7,035 $7,035

NETWORTHANALYSIS-YEAR1(seebelow) $6,936 $7,051

InlookingatTable1above,thePaymentSavingsmethodwouldindicatethatJohnwill

save$1,473eachmonthbyrefinancing...butMarywillonlysave$689eachmonth...

eventhoughtheyarebothrefinancingthesameloanamountoutofa5.00%interest

rateloanandintoanewloanwitha3.50%interestrate.Inreality,thesenumbersonly

represent a payment differential, notan actual "savings". A better indicatoris the

annualinterestsavingsof$10,228and$10,496respectively.However,tocalculatethat,

youwouldneedafinancialcalculatororanamortizationschedule.Forthequickest-

andmost accurate - methods for evaluatinga refinance,please see the

"ProperAnalysis"sectiontotheright.

PROPERREFINANCEANALYSISVeryfewpeopleusetheTrueCostSavingsMethodwhenassessingthe

financialbenefitofarefinance.Ibelievethisissimplybecauseveryfew

peopleunderstandloanamortizationandthetruedynamicsofamortgage.

Thismethodwillleadtoveryproperdecisionsinmostcases.Why?

Becauseitensuresthatyouareonlycomparingtruecostcomponentsofa

mortgage.

PRE-TAXQUICKMETHOD

NewLoanAmountxInterestRateDifferential $700,000x1.50%=$10,500estimatedannualinterestsavings(pre-tax)

(Thismethodwillindicateaninflatedannualinterestsavingsbecauseitdoes

notaccountfortheongoingreductionoftheprincipalbalanceoranytax

deductibility)

AFTER-TAXQUICKMETHOD

NewLoanAmountxInterestRateDifferentialx(1-incometaxbracket)

$700,000x1.50%x67%*=$7,035estimatedannualinterestsavings(after-

tax)

(Thismethodwillindicateaslightlyinflatedannualinterestsavingsbecause

itdoesnotaccountfortheongoingreductionoftheprincipalbalance)

*assumeseligibilityfor100%taxdeductibilityofmortgageinterestanda

33%incometaxbracket

NETWORTHANALYSISMETHOD(seescreenshotsbelow)

IcallthismethodtheNetWorthAnalysisforRefinancing anditissomethingIdevelopedbackin2008asthefounderofMortguidance®-amortgage

consumerconsultingfirm.Inowuseitmyselfforproperrefinanceanalysis

formyownmortgageclients. Ittakesintoaccountthefollowing...

•  PrincipalBalance ataspecificanalysispointintime

•  CashSavingsBalance ataspecificanalysispointintime

•  TaxSavingsataspecificanalysispointintime

•  TaxCostsataspecificanalysispointintime

TheNetWorthAnalysisforRefinancingisaveryaccuratewayofcalculatin

the truebenefit,or the lack thereof,of arefinanceasit comparesto you

currentmortgageataspecifiedperiodintime(AnalysisPoint).Ittakesint

accountalloftheCOSTcomponents,aswellastheSAVINGScomponentso

each ofthemortgage scenariospresentedandcan help illustrate howth

variousloan structureswill impactyour networth relative tokeeping you

current loan in place. It will help you answer questions such as...Whic

scenariooffersthegreatestvalueovertime?ShouldIpaypointstobuydown

myinterestrate?HowmanypointsshouldIpay?ShouldIputmypaymen

"savings"inthebank,orshouldIapplyittowardsmynewmortgageandpa

downtheprincipalmorequickly?Or...whatifIjustkeptmycurrentloanin

 place and paid down my principal more aggressively? Whatever you

refinance objective may be, the Mortguidance® Net Worth Analysis wi

enableyoutomakeamostwell-informedandappropriaterefinancedecisio

--whichmayevenbetoavoidarefinancealtogether.

TheNWAmethodsbelowwillshowyouthattheactualsavingsinyear1for

Johnis$4,936(thenetimpactonnetworthifyousavethepayment

differential)+the$2,000thatwaspaidinclosingcosts... foratotalsavings

of$6,936.Andtheactualsavingsinyear1forMaryis$5,051(thenetimpact

onnetworthifyousavethepaymentdifferential)+the$2,000thatwaspaid

inclosingcosts...foratotalsavingsof$7,051.

BillHills,CMPS®|LuxuryMortgageBanker|Chicago|224-848-4384|BillHills.com

Ihavebeenprovidingmortgagesolutionsformyclientssince1994.Asa19-year

mortgageindustryveteran,andCertifiedMortgagePlanningSpecialist®,Iamprepare

toprovideyouwithvaluablemortgageservices.Contactmeforafreebutthorough

analysisofyourrefinanceorpurchasetransaction.

Page 2: RefiNerd.com - Make Proper Decisions - Bill Hills, CMPS®

7/27/2019 RefiNerd.com - Make Proper Decisions - Bill Hills, CMPS®

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/refinerdcom-make-proper-decisions-bill-hills-cmps 2/3 ©2013BillHills,CMPS®|LuxuryMortgageBanker|BillHills.com

ScreenshotoftheNetWorthAnalysisforRefinancing (John)

MakeWell-InformedFinancialDecisions.

Page 3: RefiNerd.com - Make Proper Decisions - Bill Hills, CMPS®

7/27/2019 RefiNerd.com - Make Proper Decisions - Bill Hills, CMPS®

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/refinerdcom-make-proper-decisions-bill-hills-cmps 3/3 ©2013BillHills,CMPS®|LuxuryMortgageBanker|BillHills.com

ScreenshotoftheNetWorthAnalysisforRefinancing (Mary)

MakeWell-InformedFinancialDecisions.