re-engineering academic programmes using ects and learning outcomes
DESCRIPTION
Re-engineering Academic Programmes Using ECTS and Learning Outcomes. Dr Philippos Pouyioutas University of Nicosia Research Foundation ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop 2 nd March 2012. Presentation Topics. Learning Outcomes – Background Information and Definitions - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 1
Dr Philippos PouyioutasUniversity of Nicosia Research Foundation
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop2nd March 2012
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 2
1. Learning Outcomes – Background Information and Definitions
2. Intended Learning Outcomes of the Presentation
3. Re-engineering Academic Programmes Using ECTS and Learning Outcomes
4. A Case Study – A 2-year Project at the University of Nicosia
5. Conclusions
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 3
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 4
“Learning outcomes describe what a learner is expected to know, understand and be able to do after successful completion of a process of learning.”
“Learning outcomes statements are typically characterised by the use of active verbs expressing knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation, etc.”
http://ec.europa.eu/education/lifelong-learning-policy/doc/ects/guide_en.pdf
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 5
To be Used◦ create, plan, revise, analyze, design, select,
utilize, apply, demonstrate, prepare, use, compute, discuss, explain, predict, assess, compare, rate, calculate, etc
Not to be used◦ know, become aware of, appreciate, learn,
understand, become familiar with, etc.
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 6
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 7
make students aware of the various database models (emphasis on post-relational models) and database systems
provide students with deep knowledge for developing database applications and fundamental knowledge for developing web-based database applications
cover in detail all aspects of the SQL language (including security, authorization, optimization, embedded SQL)
thoroughly discuss the object-oriented database model, standards and languages and compare this model with the relational model
discuss Data Warehousing, OLAP, Data Mining, Web Technology and XML
introduce state-of-the art research in the area of databases.
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 8
critically compare and evaluate database models and database systems
design and develop database applications using commercially available database systems
enhance and fine-tune database applications with regards to security, authorization and optimization
develop web-based database applications at an intermediate level
critically assess post-relational database models and especially the object-relational database model, standards and languages
develop advanced queries using the SQL language research in state-of-the art areas in databases
systems.
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 9
Specific (clear and unambiguous, clearly communicated to and understood by students)
Measurable (objectively assessed) Achievable (at the right level and possible to
be achieved by students) Realistic Time Specific (possible to be achieved within
the timeframe of the programme/course)
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 10
Bologna Process European Qualifications Framework European Standards in Disciplines/Subject
Areas National Qualifications Framework Institutional Level – Programme Level Course Level Task Level
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 11
http://ec.europa.eu/education/policies/educ/eqf/rec08_en.pdf
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 12
Figure 1 : Mapping NQFs to EQF (adopted from EQF Newsletter April 2010 [email protected])
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 13
Provide a common platform for Transparency, Comparability, Transferability and Recognition of Programmes
Students become aware of what they will be able to do after completion of the courses and the programme
Faculty are forced to rethink of the curriculum and make sure that each LO is assessed
Employers know what graduates are able to do Careers Officers can match employers requirements to
graduates knowledge, skills and competences (L0s) Erasmus co-ordinators and Academic Departments are
facilitated when developing exchange agreements for students and faculty
Professional Associations can map Programmes to their requirements
Quality Assurance Agencies are facilitated when conducting audits of programmes and when evaluating European awards (through the EQF-NQF mapping)
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 14
QAA are in the process of modifying their accreditation/validation rules and procedures to incorporate L0s. Most probably QAA audits will be looking at evidence that◦ all stakeholders were involved in the formulation of a
programme’s LOs◦ there is consistency of LOs according to their level (e.g.
1st Cycle LOs match EQF and NQF corresponding level)◦ there is consistency of a programme’s LOs with the LOs
specified in European Standards/Sector frameworks, benchmarks, etc.)
◦ a programme’s LOs comply with technical qualifications frameworks at National Level
◦ there is consistency and comparability among LOs across the institution and its programmes
◦ the institution provides all resources so that LOs are SMART, are assessed and are met by students
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 15
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 16
Compare and contrast the LO approach in re-engineering academic programmes with the one currently used at your institution
Develop a plan (with scheduled actions and tasks) to re-engineer the programmes of your institution using the LO approach
Re-engineer your courses using LOs Work with colleagues in building a programme’s LOs and
ensuring that the supporting courses provide support for the LOs
Provide supporting arguments as to how your courses achieve the programme’s LOs
Defend your programmes and courses in front of evaluation/audit/accreditation teams
Develop reports that provide evidence for the correct implementation of the LO approach
Strengthen the link between employers and students
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 17
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 18
Rethinking of the Business Processes Not automating existing processes Redesigning Business Processes Restructuring the organization Automating the newly designed processes Sometimes creating a new type of
organization
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 19
Rethinking of the academic programmes Redesigning the academic programmes Restructuring the academic programmes Sometimes creating new academic
programmes
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 20
Programme Structure (thematic areas and clusters of courses, core, elective, etc. courses, pre-requisites, co-requisites, semester breakdown, etc.)
Programme and Course Content◦ Aims and Objectives usually expressed from the
programme/course point of view and referring to knowledge and skills to be given to /cultivated in students
◦ Topic areas and description of material to be covered Delivery Methods
◦ Teaching and Learning◦ Resources (Labs, Books, etc.)◦ Assessment
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 21
Empowering the student Learner (student) – centre learning Faculty members become educators and
facilitators of the learning process and not teachers
Learner feedback/input/active participation Industry feedback Professional Associations feedback/input
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 22
ECTS forces you to re-think carefully of the programme structure (plan yearly load to 60 ECTS, semester load to 30 ECTS)
ECTS forces you to re-think carefully the content of the programme from the point of view of the student (Learning Outcomes (LOs) vs. Aims and Objectives)
ECTS forces you to re-think carefully the delivery methods of the programme (Teaching and Learning and Assessment of Learning Outcomes)
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 23
A programme consists of many courses A Programme has a number of programme
LOs (PLOs) A Course has a number of course LOs
(CLOs) A PLO must be supported by at least one
course A course can support many PLOs
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 24
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 25
Cyprus Bologna Conference/Workshop, 13-14
September 2010
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 26
Proposal approved by the University of Nicosia Senate in September 2008
Project Stared in October 2008 and was completed in June 2010
Project was co-ordinated by the Vice Rector Project was audited by the University’s
Internal Quality Assurance Auditor
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 27
Item/Report/Form Produced Deadline Done
Report - Professional Association / Industry / Advisory Council
31/12/2008
Report – Student Feedback 31/12/2008
Report – Similar Programmes 31/12/2008
Report - Guidelines of Professional Associations 31/12/2008Report- Programme Learning Outcomes 31/12/2008
Degree Profile – Aims, Objectives, Learning Outcomes, Entry Criteria, Teaching and Learning Methods, Assessment Methods, Career Prospects
31/12/2008
Programme Pathway (240 ECTS for Bachelors, 90-120 ECTS for Masters)
31/12/2008
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 28
Semester Breakdown (30 ECTS per semester) 31/12/2008Courses LOs and estimation of ECTS 28/2/2009Matrix - Programme LOs vs. Courses 31/3/2009Calculation of Course ECTS by faculty using Tuning methodology/Form
30/4/2009
Course Syllabi in ECTS format 31/5/2009Report - Review of Programme (Profile, LOs, Courses, etc)
30/6/2009
Student Calculation of Course ECTS using Tuning methodology/form
31/1/2010
Fine-tuning of programme and courses –Audit, Reports for Programme, Senate Reports
28/2/2010
Item/Report/Form Produced Deadline Done
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 29
Resistance to change Initial questioning on the usefulness of the
project (was considered as a bureaucratic, administrative process not leading to any real academic benefits); this changed after some time and all were very thankful that the process helped them for the re-evaluation of the programmes by ECPU
Difficulty in writing Learning Outcomes and differentiating between knowledge, skills and competences
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 30
Confusing LOs at the programme and course level
Difficulty in monitoring the process for students filling the workload forms
A lot of paper work and manual processing Use of IT packages (e.g. Excel) but not in an
integrated support IT tool
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 31
Explain the need for using the ECTS system and Learning Outcomes and highlight the expected benefits for all stakeholders
Convince all stakeholders about the usefulness of such an exercise
Plan the process, specify who is responsible for what, set realistic deadlines, do not rush
Make sure that the project co-ordinator is somebody who understands the issues involved and will also have to do whatever the others will have to do
Expect resistance, mistakes and problems
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 32
Keep an open communication channel (through meetings, emails, etc.)
Provide training for writing ECTS Syllabi, for writing LOs, etc.
Hold regular meetings with Deans of Schools, Heads of Departments, Programme co-ordinators and faculty
Provide standard forms and templates Utilize IT packages to reduce manual work and
avoid errors Need for an integrated support tool -
ReProTool
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 33
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 34
There are some different definitions in the literature with regards to LOs
There is ignorance and confusion amongst the various stakeholders with regards to LOs
LOs at are still being implemented at various levels (NQF, Universities, QAA)
Educational models and University and QAA rules/regulations/procedures are being re-engineered using LOs
Re-engineering academic programmes using LOs provides a great opportunity to improve the programme, the delivery and assessment methods and the student learning process
LOs benefit all stakeholders and contribute to the mobility of students/graduates/faculty/employees within Europe
ReProTool and UNILO Information Day/Workshop March 2, 2012, Nicosia, Cyprus 35