rbrp presentation for fiu abc - curt b v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · microsoft powerpoint - rbrp...

25
Existing Structure SR 4013 Over Strodes Run ADT = 836 Vehicles / Day Existing Span Length = 30’ Existing Curb to Curb Width = 27’ Structurally Deficient Deficient Approach Geometry Deficient Guiderail Conditions 1 Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Upload: others

Post on 14-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Existing Structure• SR 4013 Over Strodes Run

• ADT = 836 Vehicles / Day

• Existing Span Length = 30’

• Existing Curb to Curb Width = 27’

• Structurally Deficient

• Deficient Approach Geometry

• Deficient Guiderail Conditions

1

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 2: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Traffic Detour• Limited to 35 Days

• 14.80 Miles

• Rural Area With Farm Equipment Regularly Utilizing the Bridge

2

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 3: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Folded Steel Plate Girder Fabrication• Fabrication Starts in Cleveland Ohio at American Tank & Fabricating Company

• ½” Plates Folded Into Shape• Shear Studs, Stiffeners, Lifting   Eyes Attached

• Galvanized at AZZ Inc. – Canton, Ohio

• Then Shipped to Precast Facility

3

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Photo courtesy of ABC‐UTC (2009 Maico‐Kansas fabrication of a test specimen)

Page 4: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Folded Steel Plate Girder Fabrication

4

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Photo courtesy of ABC‐UTC (2009 Maico‐Kansas fabrication of a test specimen)

Page 5: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Folded Steel Plate Girder Fabrication• Precast Work Done at AC Miller Concrete Products, Blairsville, PA

• Deck Placement First then Subsequent Placement of Parapet

• Match Casting NOT Required• Minimal Camber Formed Into Deck

5

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 6: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Folded Steel Plate Girder Fabrication

6

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 7: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Folded Steel Plate Girder Fabrication

Aesthetic Panels on Exterior Parapet Face Incorporated in Precast Process 

7

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 8: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Delivery of FSPG• Shipping Weight of Interior Pieces = 

41,000 lb

• Shipping Weight of Exterior Pieces (With Parapets) = 61,000 lb

• Common Flatbed Trailers Used

• Wood Cribbing Used to Stabilize Pieces During Transport

8

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 9: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionPre‐Detour Work to Reduce Detour Days

• Sandbag Stream Diversion Installation

• Predrilled Into Limestone Bedrock at Abutment 1, to Attain 15’ Minimum Pile Length for the 7 Piles

• Daytime Flagging Operation Utilized to Maintain Traffic Across the Bridge

• Holes Backfilled and Topped With Cold Patch to Reopen to Traffic at End of Shift

9

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 10: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionDemolition

• Deck Sawcut into Sections and Lifted Out With an Excavator

• Beams Lifted Out with an Excavator

• Abutments Demolished Using Traditional Methods with a Hydraulic Impact Hammer Mounted on an Excavator

• Entire Demolition Operation Took 2 Days

10

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 11: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionSubstructure Construction

• 7 End Bearing Piles Driven at Each Abutment

• Piles Were Driven Using Traditional Diesel Impact Hammer in Leads Suspended from a Crane

• Cast In Place Integral Abutments

• Both Abutments Placed on the Same Day Utilizing a Pump Truck

• 4000 PSI Concrete Used for Substructure.  Minimum Required Strength to Set Substructure is 2500 PSI, Achieved 5 Days After Placement

11

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 12: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionBearings

• Standard Neoprene Bearing Pad Design

12

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 13: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionFolded Steel Plate Girder Installation

• Pieces Set With a Grove 240 Ton Hydraulic Truck Crane

• Folded Steel Plate Girders Offer Advantage of Reduced Weight vs. Similar Beam/Precast Deck Options

• The 4 Pieces Were Erected in a Half Shift

• Alignment, Bearing, Cross Slope, and Match Up All Checked by Surveyors and Inspectors Prior To Crane Leaving the Site

13

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 14: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionFolded Steel Plate Girder Installation

14

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 15: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionBird Screen

15

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 16: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionLongitudinal Closure Forming

• Inserts Provided in the Precast on Each Side of the Longitudinal Closure Joints

• Inserts Facilitated All‐Thread Coil Rods Supported By the Deck 

• All‐Thread Coil Rods Supported Common Wood Soffit Forms

16

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 17: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionEnd Diaphragm Forming

• End Diaphragms Formed Similar to Normal Integral Abutment Application

• Hand Formed Bulkheads Inside the FSPG Steel For Diaphragms 

17

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 18: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionAccelerated Concrete

• Special Class AAA Accelerated Concrete Designed for  2500 PSI in 6 Hours, 3500 PSI in 24 Hours. Supplied by Centre Concrete of State College, PA

• The Mix Design Was Developed by Centre Concrete in Close Coordination with PennDOT Materials Engineers

• Due to Rapid Set Nature of the Concrete, Concrete was Made Onsite Using Mobile Mixer Trucks

• Test Batches Using the Mobile Mixers Were Run Well in Advance to Ensure the Mobile Mixing Operation Could Produce Material Within Specifications

18

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 19: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionAccelerated Concrete Specification Highlights

• Limited to end diaphragms and deck/barrier closure pours of bridges containing precast decks

• 28 day minimum compressive strength of 5000 psi for acceptance

• Accelerating admixtures that do not contain chlorides allowable

• Maximum cement factor 690 lb/cy

• Point of placement temperature range 65 F – 90 F

• Target Slump 10”

• Target Air = 6.0%

• No backfilling diaphragms until 3500 psi achieved

19

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 20: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionLongitudinal Closure and Diaphragm Pour

• Mobile Mixers Placed Concrete into a Telebelt to Move Concrete Quickly to Point of Placement

• Longitudinal Closures Placed First (4 CY)

• End Diaphragms (30 CY) Placed Immediately After Longitudinal Closure Pours Utilizing Same Setup of Mobile Mixers and Telebelt

• The AAA accelerated lost workability quickly and required several cement finishers to keep up with finishing

20

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 21: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionWing Parapets, Backfill, and Roadwork

• Waterproofing and Abutment Backfilling Took Place Upon Reaching Strength on Abutments and Diaphragms

• Wing Parapets Formed and Poured the Day After

• Wing Parapets Utilized Normal 4000 PSI Concrete

• Wing Parapets Cured and Attained Bridge Opening Strength While the Roadwork Was Completed

• Roadwork Was All Standard for a PennDOT Bridge Project

21

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 22: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Bridge ConstructionPPC Overlay

• Polyester Polymer Concrete (PPC) Was Approved By PennDOT as a Bridge Overlay Application for Use on The PA Rapid Bridge Replacement

• Due to the Bridge Finishing in Late October and Temperature Restrictions on the PPC Overlay, the Bridge Was Opened with a Temp. Wedge to Maintain Traffic Through the Winter

• PPC to Be Placed in May 2017 to Finalize the Bridge

22

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Completed PPC  Overlay at Another Bridge

Page 23: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Schedule 

• The detour was utilized for 33 days, finishing 2 days ahead of schedule

• 12 hour shifts, 7 days a week were utilized during the 33 day detour.

• No night shifts were needed, but were part of our schedule contingency plan

• A similar bridge in our program utilizing all cast in place elements and less overtime takes 70‐75 days 

• A similar bridge in our program utilizing all cast in place elements with staged construction to maintain a lane of traffic takes approximately 150 days

Accelerated Construction Time Savings• Stream diversion installation and predrilling prior to the detour saved 4 detour days

• Working overtime for the duration of the detour saved 2 weeks of detour time

• Utilizing the Folded Steel Plate Girder with precast deck system saved 3 weeks of detour time

• Utilizing precast abutments at a significant cost increase could have saved another 3‐5 additional days of detour time

23

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 24: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Economics vs. Other Design OptionsWalsh/Granite Construction Cost – Ranked Lowest to Highest

1. Detour traffic with spread box beam and cast in place deck superstructure

2. Detour traffic with Folded Steel Plate Girder superstructure system

3. Detour traffic with spread box beams and precast deck panel superstructure

4. Staged traffic with spread box beams and cast in place deck superstructure

5. Temporary road “runaround” traffic with spread box beams and cast in place superstructure

24

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA

Page 25: RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B v3 · 2017. 4. 20. · Microsoft PowerPoint - RBRP Presentation for FIU ABC - Curt B_v3 Author: Mary Lou Created Date: 5/13/2017 4:58:01 PM

Finished Structure (Rainy Day Photo)

25

Bridge JV-078 - Mifflin County, PA