8/9/2019 Rafael Zulueta vs Pan Am

1/2

ALHAMBRA, RAYMOND PATRICK P.

RAFAEL ZULUETA, ET AL., plaintifs-app ll s, !s. PAN AMERICAN "ORLDAIR"AY#, INC., $ % n$ant-app llant.

&.R. N'. L-()*)+ an a / ), 0+12

CONCEPCION, C.J.:

E3 4pla / $a4a5 s 6& 'ss n 5li5 n7 8a ants t9 a8a $ '% 3 4pla /$a4a5 s, 8it9 4' as'n is its i4p'siti'n : sti; $ 89 n t9 a7t p %' 4 $is $ li< at , 4ali7i' s an$ taint $ 8it9 4in t s.Z l ta 8 nt t' t9 t'il t at t9 t 4inal < il$in5 < t ;n$in5 it it % ll 8al $(>> /a $s a8a/ in t9 < a79. As a s lt, 9 8as $ la/ $ in 4in t s. H t'l$ an 4pl'/ '% t9 Pan A4 Ai 8a/s t9 /al4'st 4a$ 9i4 4iss t9 i59t < 7a s '% a $ % 7ti! ann' n7in5 s/st 4.H 8as t'l$ t9at t9 / 8' l$ 'p n 9is

8/9/2019 Rafael Zulueta vs Pan Am

2/2

8' l$ < st an$ $ t9 %' a @4ini4 4 '% 'n 8 @ an$, in a$$iti'nt9 t', 79a 5 $ t9 %' 02.2> a $a/.

It is 5 $