quality of life council committee - dallas...quality of life council committee meeting record...

88

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jun-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments
Page 2: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments
Page 3: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record

(DRAFT)

Meeting Date: 10-12-2009 Convened: 12:00 p.m. Adjourned: 1:58 p.m.

Pauline Medrano, Chair Vonciel Jones Hill, Vice-chair Sheffie Kadane

Briefing Presenters:

Steve Salazar Carolyn R. Davis David Neumann Angela Hunt Non-Committee Members: Dwaine Caraway Tennell Atkins Special Guests: Deborah Dennis, Rex Dennison & Mike Navarro with Oncor Electric

-David Cossum, Department of Sustainable Development & Construction -Elizabeth Ramirez, Public Works & Transportation Staff Present: Forest Turner, Kathleen Cervenka, Rick Galceran, Vernon Young, Gary Titlow, Patty Ramirez, Paul Currington, Chief Golbeck, Laura Foland, Daniel Soliz, Errick Thompson, Stephanie McHenry

AGENDA: 1. Approval of September 29, 2009 minutes

Presenter(s): Information Only: Action Taken/Committee Recommendation(s): Motion to approve the September 29, 2009 minutes with the correction of council member Hunt absent on “official City business”.

Motion made by: Vonciel Jones Hill Motion seconded by: Steve Salazar Item passed unanimously: __X__ Item passed on a divided vote: Item failed unanimously: Item failed on a divided vote:

2. Screening for Outdoor Storage

Presenter(s): David Cossum Information Only: __X__

Action Taken/Committee Recommendation(s):

The briefing discussed screening for outside storage and questions raised such as: are current screening requirements adequate, are current parking requirements appropriate, are all districts which currently allow an outside storage used appropriately, are metal fences appropriate to meet screening requirements. The City Planning Commission (CPC) made several recommendations: strike outside storage as a permitted main use in the CA district, require outside storage to be screened in an IM district, limit maximum stacking height, add a landscape buffer requirement when screening fence is visible and within 200 feet of right-of-way, and reduce parking requirements to one space per 5,000 square feet of outside storage area.

Page 4: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record

(DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments on November 9, 2009 and provide the Quality of Life Committee with a follow-up briefing on alternatives. Motion made by: Motion seconded by: Item passed unanimously: ____ Item passed on a divided vote:

Item failed unanimously:

Item failed on a divided vote:

3. Street Lighting – Process to Report & Repair Outages Presenter(s): Elizabeth Ramirez, Deborah Dennis, Rex Dennison & Mike Navarro

Information Only: __X__ Action Taken/Committee Recommendation(s): All lights are maintained by ONCOR, which creates a one stop shop. ONCOR maintains lights on public streets, repairs lights on failure, and keeps a database of outstanding and completed repairs. City Staff are responsible for resolving complaints on repeated calls or lack of service, enforces contract requirements, warrants and approves new installations, and patrols streets and freeways for outages. Property owners are responsible for lighting private properties for guard lights, alley lighting and security lighting. When reporting a street light outage it can be done either by calling 311 or online at www.oncorstreetlight.com. The new online system was launched on August 1, 2009 and allows customers the option to enter contact information and receive automated notification when repairs are completed. The intake screens also allow for history maintenance with each street light to be used to identify repeat failures. Future enhancements to the system will be made such as adding City-owned street light locations on maps and adding Tx-DOT owned street lights. Outage repairs are made by ONCOR contractors and are given required response times. Routine repairs are 5 days, circuit repairs are 15 days, and knockdowns are 30 days. ONCOR is not required to patrol for outages, yet the City of Dallas has signal maintenance technicians that are dedicated to patrolling during the night shifts. Only major streets and freeways are patrolled. Future actions include returning to the Quality of Life Committee with patrolling results, enhancements to ONCOR’s street light outage reporting system, and the status of new technologies related to energy savings and remote monitoring.

Motion made by: Motion seconded by: Item passed unanimously: _ ___ Item passed on a divided vote: ____ Item failed unanimously: Item failed on a divided vote:

_________________________ _________________________ Pauline Medrano Witness Chair

Page 5: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments
Page 6: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Urban Forest Inventory Using LiDAR & Hyperspectral Images

• Larger existing trees provide 60-70 times the benefit of newly planted trees

• Highest priority in managing any urban forest is a complete tree inventory

• Traditional method of inventory involves volunteers surveying only public trees

• These methods were very labor intensive, time consuming and often inaccurate

• Since public trees comprise only 15-20% of the entire urban forest, the traditional method only provides a small part of the picture

Page 7: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Project History

• Since a traditional survey was not ideal, extensive researched was completed which included hyperspectralimages (a new type of image)

• Dr. Fang Qiu was asked by the chair if the new images could be used for a complete tree inventory.

• “It may be possible…but it has never been done”• Chair works diligently to convince others of the value by

personally funding the field work portion of the project ($13K) and contributing almost a year of time

• Chair raises over $100K to complete the project• Chair authorized the project to move forward lacking

$30K of the required budget

Page 8: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Dallas on the “Cutting Edge”

• First complete tree inventory ever based on laser scanning and hyperspectral images using highly advanced computer algorithms

• New technology developed by Dr. Qiu and the chair which allows all tree inventory data to be easily accessed and utilized in makingcritical urban forest management decisions

• This is a first in the history of urban forestry in that someone can now effectively manage ALL trees (public & private) by simply sitting at their computer

• Hyperspectral images can also be used to manage water quality & quantity, street markings or light fixtures and many others relating to existing land cover management (grey & green infrastructure)

Page 9: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Cost and Next Steps

• The projected cost to complete all of the city is 1.25 million for collection and 1.25 million for processing

• When other city departments understand the potential use of the images in infrastructure management, the cost can be shared and become very economical

• As the use of hyperspectral images increases in the future, the cost will decrease

• Brief other departments on the potential uses

• Brief NCTCOG, EPA, Texas Forest Service and others to gain backing & financial support in completing a city & regional tree inventory & infrastructure mapping project

Page 10: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Urban Forestry Inventory using Urban Forestry Inventory using Concurrent Airborne Concurrent Airborne LiDARLiDAR and and HyperspectralHyperspectral Remote SensingRemote Sensing

Fang Fang QiuQiu

University of Texas as DallasUniversity of Texas as Dallas

Sponsored by Sponsored by

Dallas Urban Forest Advisory CommitteeDallas Urban Forest Advisory Committee

Page 11: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

OutlineOutline

Study areaStudy area

Remote Sensing Data CollectionRemote Sensing Data Collection LiDAR, HyperspectralLiDAR, Hyperspectral

Field Data Collection and AnalysisField Data Collection and Analysis In situ spectroradiometer data collection and analysisIn situ spectroradiometer data collection and analysis

Field tree specie, GPS location collectionField tree specie, GPS location collection

LiDAR Data Filtering LiDAR Data Filtering Segmentation and DTM generationSegmentation and DTM generation

Ground/nonGround/non--ground separationground separation

LiDAR Tree Mass Point Extraction LiDAR Tree Mass Point Extraction Hyperspectral NDVI Hyperspectral NDVI

0-2

Page 12: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

OutlineOutline

Urban Tree Top (UTT) IdentificationUrban Tree Top (UTT) Identification Tree Top ClimbingTree Top Climbing

Tree heightTree height

Urban Tree Canopy (UTC) DelineationUrban Tree Canopy (UTC) Delineation Donut Expanding and Sliding Donut Expanding and Sliding –– Canopy DiameterCanopy Diameter

Base height, crown depth Base height, crown depth

Urban Tree Species (UTS) IdentificationUrban Tree Species (UTS) Identification NeuroNeuro--fuzzy classificationfuzzy classification

Digital 3D Tree Canopy Model ConstructionDigital 3D Tree Canopy Model Construction Individual Tree Modeling Individual Tree Modeling

0-3

Page 13: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Study AreaStudy Area City of DallasCity of Dallas

Two pilot study sites, with a Two pilot study sites, with a total area of 20 square milestotal area of 20 square miles

0-4

Page 14: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Remote Sensing Data CollectionRemote Sensing Data Collection Terra Remote Sensing, Inc (TRSI)Terra Remote Sensing, Inc (TRSI)

Sydney, British Columbia, CanadaSydney, British Columbia, Canada

Mission partner at University of VictoriaMission partner at University of Victoria

Date: September, 23Date: September, 23--24, 200824, 2008

Aircraft Type: Piper NavajoAircraft Type: Piper Navajo Altitude: 960 m and 1260 mAltitude: 960 m and 1260 m

Flying air speed: 235km/hrFlying air speed: 235km/hr

Total Data VolumeTotal Data Volume HyperHyper--Spectral Imaging Data: 181 GBSpectral Imaging Data: 181 GB Radiance (60.6 GB) +Reflectance (121 GB)Radiance (60.6 GB) +Reflectance (121 GB)

LiDAR Data: 3.4 GBLiDAR Data: 3.4 GB 64 GB after uncompressed64 GB after uncompressed

0-5

Page 15: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

LiDAR DataLiDAR Data Terrain Scanning Laser SystemTerrain Scanning Laser System

LiDAR Point Cloud Density LiDAR Point Cloud Density (Average Spacing: 1/D(Average Spacing: 1/D1/21/2))

9/23/2008: 2 pts/m9/23/2008: 2 pts/m2 2 (0.7 m)(0.7 m) Due to overlap, 3.5 pts/mDue to overlap, 3.5 pts/m22 (0.53 m)(0.53 m)

9/24/2008: 1.25 pts/m9/24/2008: 1.25 pts/m22 (0.89 m)(0.89 m) Due to overlap, 2 pts/mDue to overlap, 2 pts/m22 (0.7 m)(0.7 m)

%Overlap: 80%Overlap: 80

Number of Returns: 2 Number of Returns: 2 First and Last ReturnsFirst and Last Returns

Bandwidth: 1064 nmBandwidth: 1064 nm

Beam divergence: 0.45 mradBeam divergence: 0.45 mrad

0-6

Page 16: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

LiDAR DataLiDAR Data

3D visualization of elevation of LiDAR points over the Reverchon park study area

Page 17: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

LiDAR DataLiDAR Data: Turtle Creek Corridor: Turtle Creek Corridor

3D visualization of elevation of LiDAR points over the Turtle Creek Corridor

Page 18: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

HyperHyper--spectral Imaging (HSI) Dataspectral Imaging (HSI) Data AISA DUAL HSI Sensor AISA DUAL HSI Sensor Spectral Spectral

Imaging Ltd. FinlandImaging Ltd. Finland

Simultaneous acquisition of Simultaneous acquisition of VNIR and SWIR dataVNIR and SWIR data

AisaEAGLE (VNIR)AisaEAGLE (VNIR)

AisaHawk (SWIR)AisaHawk (SWIR)

492 Band (400492 Band (400--2500 nm)2500 nm) VNIR (400VNIR (400--970nm, 2.44 nm)970nm, 2.44 nm)

SWIR (970SWIR (970--2500nm, 6.28 nm)2500nm, 6.28 nm)

Spatial Resolution Spatial Resolution 9/23/2008: 1.2 m 9/23/2008: 1.2 m

9/24/2008: 1.6 m 9/24/2008: 1.6 m

Sidelap: 22%Sidelap: 22%

0-9

AisaEAGLE(400-970 nm)

AisaHAWK(970-2500 nm)

AisaDUAL sensor assembly, side view(AisaEAGLE on the right, AisaHAWKon the left)

AisaDUAL sensor assembly, back view

Page 19: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Mosaic of HSIMosaic of HSI

0-10

Color Infrared Color Infrared Composite ImageComposite Image Red: 841.13 nmRed: 841.13 nm

Green: 677.11 nmGreen: 677.11 nm

Blue: 561.66 nmBlue: 561.66 nm

Typical ColorsTypical Colors Trees: RedTrees: Red

Buildings: CyanBuildings: Cyan

Water: Blue/blackWater: Blue/black

Page 20: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

In Situ Spectroradiometer Data CollectionIn Situ Spectroradiometer Data Collection FieldSpec Pro ASD SpectroradiometerFieldSpec Pro ASD Spectroradiometer

Spectral Range from 350 Spectral Range from 350 –– 2500 nm2500 nm

Spectral Sampling of 1.4 nm in 350Spectral Sampling of 1.4 nm in 350--1050 nm and 2nm in 10501050 nm and 2nm in 1050--2050 nm 2050 nm range resulting in 2151 bandsrange resulting in 2151 bands

Scan time of less than 3 secondsScan time of less than 3 seconds

Spectroradiometer High Intensity Contact Probe

Page 21: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

In Situ Spectroradiometer Data CollectionIn Situ Spectroradiometer Data Collection

Sampling areasSampling areas Reverchon parkReverchon park

Turtle Creek areaTurtle Creek area

Page 22: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Reflectance Spectral Signature for 50 speciesReflectance Spectral Signature for 50 species

Mean Spectral Profile for each species used as Reference Spectra

Page 23: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Species Spectral Seperability analysisSpecies Spectral Seperability analysis

Using GFLVQ approach (50 Testing Samples)Using GFLVQ approach (50 Testing Samples)

About 60About 60--72% of accuracy was achieved72% of accuracy was achieved

Double the % accuracy of the spectral angle mapping Double the % accuracy of the spectral angle mapping Trial Accuracy

1 64%

2 62%

3 62%

4 68%

5 64%

6 60%

7 70%

8 72%

9 68%

10 70%

Trial Accuracy

1 34%

2 30%

3 34%

4 42%

5 42%

6 36%

7 40%

8 42%

9 40%

10 42%

GFLVQ SAM

Page 24: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Urban Tree Field Survey Data by Halff Association

Turtle Creek CorridorTurtle Creek Corridor Total 2602 trees surveyed.Total 2602 trees surveyed. Total 46 species foundTotal 46 species found 10 most frequently occurring 10 most frequently occurring

species identified. species identified.

Page 25: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

LiDAR Data FilteringLiDAR Data Filtering

Segmentation using MNNSegmentation using MNN

Ground and nonGround and non--ground ground separationseparation

Digital Terrain Model Digital Terrain Model generationgeneration

Page 26: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Lidar FiltringLidar Filtring

Page 27: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Ground pointsGround points

Page 28: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

NonNon--ground pointsground points

Page 29: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Lidar filtering of ground and nonLidar filtering of ground and non--ground pointsground points

Page 30: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

LiDAR Data FilteringLiDAR Data Filtering: Ground points: Ground points

Page 31: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

LiDAR Data FilteringLiDAR Data Filtering: Non: Non--groundground

Ground Points

Page 32: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

0-23

LiDAR Tree Mass Point ExtractionLiDAR Tree Mass Point Extraction Normalized Difference Vegetation Normalized Difference Vegetation

Index (NDVI) Index (NDVI)

Red: 660nm (band 113)Red: 660nm (band 113)

NearNear--infrared: 860nm (band 198)infrared: 860nm (band 198)

nir red

nir red

NDVI

Page 33: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

0-24

Urban Tree Top Identification & Canopy DelineationUrban Tree Top Identification & Canopy Delineation

3.0

3.5

4.8

5.9

6.5

7.2

8.3 9.0

8.07.5

6.7

6.2

5.2

4.2

2.8

3.1

Crown Diameter

Page 34: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Urban Tree TopUrban Tree Top: Results: Results

Page 35: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Urban Tree Canopy (UTC) Delineation Urban Tree Canopy (UTC) Delineation : Results: Results

Page 36: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Urban Tree Species (UTS) IdentificationUrban Tree Species (UTS) Identification: Results: Results

Page 37: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Accuracy AssessmentAccuracy Assessment

0-28

Species Name Accuracy Species Name Accuracy

American Elm 39.39% Bois d'arc 91.67%

Hackberry 47.89% Sycamore 72.73%

Pecan 65.55% Black Locust 87.50%

E. Red Cedar 62.93% Redbud 100.00%

Shumard Red Oak 77.27% Persimmon 100.00%

Tree of Heaven 76.36% Slash pine 100.00%

Cedar Elm 83.54% Gingko 100.00%

Green Ash 87.23% Southern Magnolia 100.00%

Red Mulberry 84.62% Dogwood 100.00%

Chinaberry 78.79% White Ash 100.00%

Gum Bumelia 88.89% Pear 100.00%

Baldcypress 84.00% Chinese Pistache 100.00%

Cherry Laurel 95.00% Chinese Tallow 100.00%

Boxelder 90.00% Southern Catalpa 100.00%

Post Oak 100.00% Sweetgum 100.00%

Live Oak 89.47% Golden Raintree 100.00%

Bur Oak 94.12% Black Walnut 100.00%

94.12% Honey Locust 100.00%

Crepe Myrtle 100.00% Western Soapberry 100.00%

Black 93.75% Catalpa 66.67%

Kappa 64.4% Total Accuracy: 68.8%

40 Species which have field number >= 2

Page 38: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Digital 3D Tree Canopy Model ConstructionDigital 3D Tree Canopy Model Construction Tree top locations (xt,yt)

Tree heights (z)

Tree base heights(bh)

Tree crown depths (ch)

Tree crown radius (cr)

1:( ) ( )( )1

2 :

n nnt t

n n

n conical shapex x y yz bhn elliptical shapech cr

Page 39: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Tree model: Results

Page 40: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Individual Tree Extraction and Visualization

Page 41: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Individual Tree Structure Model Individual Tree Structure Model

0-32

Page 42: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments
Page 43: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Katy Trail Extensionfrom

McCommas Boulevard to White Rock Station

Presented to the Quality of Life Committee

By Public Works and Transportation

October 26, 2009

Page 44: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

2

Purpose of Briefing

Provide updates on Phase III, IV, and VI of the Katy Trail Extension from McCommas Boulevard to the White Rock Station

Page 45: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

3

Background Katy Trail Extension is being implemented in the

following phases: Katy Trail Phase III - from McCommas Boulevard to

Skillman Street Katy Trail Phase IV - from Skillman Street to the White Rock

Station Katy Trail Phase VI - from Ellsworth Avenue north to

Worcola Street (Mockingbird Pedestrian Bridge) Phase VI was separated from Phase III in 2006 due

to numerous issues related to the design of the grade separated crossing at Mockingbird Lane

Phases I, II, and V are complete

Page 46: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

4

Background (continued)

Page 47: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

5

Katy Trail Phase III –from McCommas to Skillman

Joint project between City of Dallas and the Texas Department ofTransportation (TxDOT)

Limits: McCommas Boulevard at North Central Expressway to Sandhurst Street just west of Skillman Street (Approximately 1.15 miles)

Scope: 12-ft wide concrete trail Current total estimated cost – $2.8 M, originally $2M Current funding sources

RTC – $2M Federal share $1.6 M (80%) Local share $400,000 (20%)

Additional local share - $800,000 $250,000 – 2006 bond program $550,000 - savings from two cancelled projects on Skillman

between Union Pacific Railroad and Lovers(authorized by Council on 10/26/2005)

Page 48: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

6

Katy Trail Phase III –from McCommas to Skillman (continued)

City is the lead agency to administer design and construction

Estimated Schedule Environmental clearance completed - April 2009 Design completed – August 2009 ROW acquisition complete - December 2009 Utility relocation complete - December 2009 Construction letting – January 2010 Construction begin – March 2010 Construction complete – March 2011

Page 49: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

7

Katy Trail Phase IV – from Skillman to White Rock StationJoint project between City of Dallas and TxDOT Limits: from Skillman Street to the White Rock Station

(Approximately 2.5 miles) Scope: 12-ft wide concrete trail with four 12-ft wide pedestrian

bridges (Skillman, Abrams, Ridgewood Park, UPRR at Fisher) and passing zones along the Northwest Highway segment for the shared trail and alley

Current funding sources - $4,812,000 Federal share $3,849,600 (80%) Local share $962,400 (20%)

– 2006 bond program has $962,400 towards local share Current total estimated cost – $5.4 M, originally $4,812,000 Additional $588,000 is needed. We anticipate using the

contingency funds to fund this additional cost. Bidding may reduce the construction cost.

Page 50: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

8

Katy Trail Phase IV – from Skillman to White Rock Station (continued)

City is the lead agency to administer design and construction

Estimated Schedule (if local share becomes fully funded) Environmental clearance complete - February

2010 Design complete – March 2010 ROW acquisition complete - February 2010 Utility relocation complete - March 2010 Construction letting – June 2010 Construction begin – September 2010 Construction complete – September 2011

Page 51: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

9

Katy Trail Phase IV – from Skillman to White Rock Station (continued)

Page 52: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

10

Katy Trail Phase IV – from Skillman to White Rock Station (continued)

Page 53: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

11

Katy Trail Phase VI –from Ellsworth to Worcola

Joint project between City of Dallas, TxDOT, and Dallas County

Limits: from Ellsworth Avenue to Worcola Street (Approximately 0.65 miles)

Scope: 12-ft wide concrete trail 841-ft long, 16-ft wide signature pedestrian bridge

over Mockingbird Lane 94-ft long, 14-ft wide pedestrian bridge over DART

track

Page 54: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

12

Katy Trail Phase VI –from Ellsworth to Worcola (continued)

Page 55: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

13

Katy Trail Phase VI –from Ellsworth to Worcola (continued)

Mockingbird Pedestrian Bridge

Page 56: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

14

Katy Trail Phase VI –from Ellsworth to Worcola (continued)

Mockingbird Pedestrian Bridge

Page 57: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

15

Katy Trail Phase VI –from Ellsworth to Worcola (continued)

Current total estimated cost – $8.1 M Current funding sources

Federal share $6.48 M (80%) Local share $1.62 M (20%)

Dallas County $810,000 2008 MCIP

City of Dallas $810,000. This amount could come from: Contingency funds Naming rights to the Mockingbird Bridge (J.C.

Williams Trust previously committed $250,000 if named after Mr. Williams)

Page 58: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

16

Katy Trail Phase VI –from Ellsworth to Worcola (continued)

City is the lead agency to administer design and construction

Estimated Schedule (if local share becomes fully funded) Environmental clearance completed - April 2009 Design complete – March 2010 ROW acquisition complete - January 2010 Utility relocation complete - January 2010 Construction letting – September 2010 Construction begin – December 2010 Construction complete – December 2011

Page 59: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Questions and Discussion

17

Page 60: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments
Page 61: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

OneDAY DallasCitywide Rollout in 2010

Presented to Neighborhood Quality of LifeOctober 26, 2009

Mary Nix, DirectorSanitation Services

Page 62: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

2

Purpose• Review plan for OneDAY Dallas transition

• Solicit Council input for outreach

Page 63: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

3

Background• January 16, 2009

– Provided a memo to Council– Advised on successful implementation of Phase 1

and plans to initiate Phase 2 in February 2009

• April 15, 2009– Council briefing on Too Good To Throw Away– Update status and look to future phases

• August 19, 2009– Briefed Council on SAN budget– Included cost savings projected with OneDAY

Page 64: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

4

What is OneDAY ?• Phase 1 of OneDAY started in Mar 2008 with

far north Dallas• Phase 2 followed in Feb 2009 in NW Dallas• Phase 3 intended to be NE Dallas

– Council approved citywide transition with FY10 budget

– Impacts approximately 180,000 households

• Cost Savings– FY10 $2.07M– FY11 $1.60M

• Transition to occur on March 1, 2010

Page 65: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

5

Transition Plan: Component 1 - Route Development

• Assess current routes and service styles– 55% curbside and 45% alley– Truck types and sizes– Manpower– Special needs

• Use software to re-route

• Field check each route

• Finalize routes

(April 2009 – November 2009)

Page 66: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

6

OneDAY Service Days

Page 67: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

7

Transition Plan: Component 1 - Route Development

• Met with individual Council members in early November– reviewed new days of service– identifed locations where service changes

are needed– planned community meetings schedule

(April 2009 – November 2009)

Page 68: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

8

PHASE 1 COMPLETED

PHASE 2 COMPLETED

PHASE 3 March, 2010

Page 69: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

9

Service Location Changes

Page 70: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

10

Transition Plan: Component 1 - Route Development

• Lessons learned about …– Carts set out on wrong day– Carts placed in wrong location– Missed calls spike..and then decrease… over a

6-week period

• Anticipate increase in recycling tonnage collected

(April 2009 – November 2009)

Page 71: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

11

The OneDAY Effect 2009 Household Recycling2007 Household Recycling

Page 72: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

12

• Increased budget for larger outreach $1M

• Two modes: Broad scope and Targeted• Broad strategies

• Radio/newspaper advertising

• Billboards, kiosks, bus advertising

• Web site with OneDAY look-ups by address

• Dedicated call center at 3-1-1

• Community meetings (scheduled and requested)

Transition Plan: Component 2 - Public Outreach

(August 2009 – March 2010)

Page 73: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

13

Proposed Community MeetingsCouncil Member District Day Date Time Location DAY OF SERVICE

Kadane/Davis 9 and 7 Monday 4-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Harry Stone Rec Center MONDAYNeumann/Jasso 3 and 1 Monday 4-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Mattie Nash/Myrtle Davis Rec Cente MONDAYJones Hill 5 Tuesday 5-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Janie C. Turner Rec Center TUESDAYCaraway 4 Tuesday 5-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Skyline Branch Library TUESDAYJasso 1 Tuesday 5-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. North Oak Cliff Branch Library TUESDAYAllen/Koop 10 and 11 Wednesday 6-Jan-10 7 p.m. Forest Green Branch Library TUESDAYHunt 14 Wednesday 6-Jan-10 7 p.m. Lakewood Branch Library CURBJones Hill 5 Thursday 7-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Polk Wisdom Branch Library THURSDAYNeumann 3 Thursday 7-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Mountain Creek Branch Library FRIDAYHunt/Kadane 14 and 9 Thursday 7-Jan 5:30 p.m. Central Library Auditorium CURBMedrano 2 Thursday 7-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Ignacio Zaragoza FRIDAYJasso 1 Saturday 9-Jan-10 North Oak Cliff Branch Library TUESDAYDavis 7 Saturday 9-Jan-10 Martin Luther King Rec Center TUESDAYSalazar 6 Saturday 9-Jan-10 Anita Martinez Rec Center TUESDAYJones Hill 5 Saturday 9-Jan-10 Thurgood Marshall Rec Center FRIDAYCaraway 4 Monday 11-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Beckley Saner Rec Center MONDAYSalazar 6 Monday 11-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Arcadia Park Branch Library MONDAYAtkins 8 Tuesday 12-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Singing Hills Rec. Center TUESDAYDavis 7 Tuesday 12-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Larry Johnson Rec Center TUESDAYNeumann 3 Thursday 14-Jan-10 7 p.m. Park in the Woods Rec Center FRIDAYAtkins 8 Thursday 14-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Fireside Rec. Center THURSDAYHunt 14 Thursday 14-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. K.B. Polk Rec. Center THURSDAYJones Hill 5 Saturday 16-Jan-10 Pleasant Grove Branch Library TUESDAYDavis 7 Saturday 16-Jan-10 Eloise Lundy Rec Center MONDAYMedrano 2 Saturday 16-Jan-10 Samuell Grand Rec Center FRIDAYAllen 10 Monday 18-Jan-10 7 p.m. Willie B. Johnson Rec Center MONDAYMargolin 13 Monday 18-Jan-10 7 p.m. Preston Royal Branch Library MONDAYMedrano 2 Thursday 21-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Samuell Grand Rec Center FRIDAYKadane 9 Thursday 21-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Harry Stone Rec Center FRIDAYHunt 14 Thursday 21-Jan-10 6:30 p.m. Lakewood Branch Library FRIDAYAtkins 8 Saturday 23-Jan-10 Tommie Allen Rec Center FRIDAYNeumann 3 Saturday 23-Jan-10 Hampton Illinois Branch Library THURSDAYSalazar 6 Saturday 23-Jan-10 Jaycee Zaragoza Rec Center MONDAYJasso 1 Saturday 23-Jan-10 North Oak Cliff Branch Library TUESDAYNeumann/Salazar 3 and 6 Saturday 30-Jan-10 Dallas West Branch Library TUESDAYCaraway 4 Saturday 30-Jan-10 Lancaster Kiest Branch Library FRIDAYAllen 10 Saturday 30-Jan-10 Audelia Road Branch Library TUESDAYKadane 9 TBD TBD 6 p.m. Lochwood Branch Library CURB

Page 74: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

14

Transition Plan: Component 2 - Public Outreach

• Targeted strategies• Direct calls to households

• Invitations to community meetings

• Letters to households

• Cart hangers

• Emails to community associations

• Special messaging on city utility bills

(August 2009 – March 2010)

Page 75: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

15

02468

10121416

Jul

Sept

Nov

Jan

Mar

May

Planning Operations Outreach Evaluation

Transition Plan: The TimelineDetails of Transition Plan in Appendix

Page 76: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

16

OneDAY: Follow-up Plans

After March 2010 implementation:

• Survey customers

• Share early findings with Council– 3-6 months after roll-out– customer adjustments (“missed” calls)– changes in recycling volumes

• Use early findings to adjust proposed FY11 budget for savings

(March 2010– Summer 2010)

Page 77: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

Request for Council Feedback

Page 78: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

AppendixTimeline Detail: Planning stageTimeline Detail: Operations Timeline Detail: Outreach activities Advertisements HOA email Invitation Post Card Cart hangers Notification Letter Web site in a snap-shot

Page 79: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

19

02468

10121416

AprilJu

ne

Aug Oct Dec

Feb AprJu

ne

Budget Dev Route Dev Council Mtgs Outreach Planning

Timeline detail: Planning

Page 80: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

20

05

1015202530

AprilJu

ne

Aug Oct Dec

Feb AprJu

ne

Routing Carts Ordered Carts InventoriedCarts Delivered Trucks Ordered Eval to Council

Timeline detail: Operations

Page 81: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

21

0

5

10

15

20

AugSep

tOctNovDecJa

nFeb Mar AprMayJu

ne

Planning WRR Dallas WeeklyUnivision Radio Bus Ads BillboardsKiosks HOA emails Press Event

Timeline detail: Outreach (Broad Scope)

Page 82: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

22

Ads

Bus Ad Sample

Print Ad Sample

Billboard Ad Sample

Kiosk Ad Sample

Click to hear Radio PSA (English Sample)

Page 83: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

23

0

5

10

15

20

AugSep

tOctNovDecJa

nFeb Mar AprMayJu

ne

Planning Council Input Community MtgsWeb site Ltrs Phone CallsCart Hangers HOA emails Survey

Timeline detail: Outreach (Personalized)

Page 84: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

24

Email Alert

Page 85: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

25

Post Card

Page 86: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

26

Cart Hangers

Page 87: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

27

Notification Letter

Page 88: Quality of Life Council Committee - Dallas...Quality of Life Council Committee Meeting Record (DRAFT) Next steps include having a City Council Public Hearing to consider the amendments

28

www.OneDAYDallas.com