CSFGAR ;LB CWACJJCLAC DMPXMTLE

;RRMAG;SCRGLGLRSGSTSGML;JJ;v DGPKR·

Gmvjcv ecug- vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtv fkuekrnkpgf c ncy{gt hqt jwtnkpiKnqecpq kpxgevkxgucv c Ncf{ Engtmqh Eqwtv eqpegtpkpi vjg xcikpc qh jgtoqvjgt/ Cu uqog qh {qw mpqy- vjg Knqecpq kpxgevkxg-cu rjtcugf d{ vjgUwrtgog Eqwtv kvugnh-ku "Qmkppco"/ Jg jwtngf vjku ewtug cv vjg jcrnguuncf{ vjtkeg/

Vjg Cogtkecpu cnuq jcxg vjgkt qyp xgtukqp qh vjcv kpxgevkxg;"Spopk b cjudi"-

Vjqug yjq jcxg yqtmgf ykvj og mpqy vjcv K nkdgtcnn{wug vjgVcicnqi xgtukqp; "Pvuboh Ioe'- O{ fghgpug ku vjcv K fq pqv wvvgt vjcvkpxgevkxg-qt cp{ qvjgt kpxgevkxg-cv c ncf{ qt igpvngocp gmc eqwtv tsqo qtgmcp{ cflwfkecvqt{ rtqeggfkpiu /

| Cfcrvgf htqo ocvgtkcn qtkikpcnn{rtgrctgf hqt vjg Cpictc CdgnnqEqpegrekqp Tgicnc ' Etw}Ncy Qhhkeg)CEETCNC Y, Tgvckpgt Oqpkvqtkpi Fgrctvogpv )TOF,/ Vjg cwvjit cempqyngfigu vjgkpxcnwcdngcuukuvcpegqh TOF Jgcf Ou/ CpcvguuCtpcnfq.Qtcekqp- TOF Oqpkvqt Ou/ Dtkikfc U/Cnfgiwgt- Ou/ Gxcpignkpg V/ Dctiq- Ou/ NwekngI/ Ictekc- cpf Ou/ Pwgxc I/ Cdcpvq/ Vjg cwvjqt cnuqcempqyngfigu vjg cuukuvcpegqh Ot/ Quect HtcpmnkpD/ Vcp- yjq itcfwcvgf htqo vjg Wpkxgtukv{qh vjgRjknkrrkpguNcy Uejqqn kp 3117/ Jg kurtgugpvn{ cp Cuuqekcvgqh vjg CEETCNC Y Qhhkegcpf kuqp ngcxgrwtuwkpi jku itcfwcvg uvwfkgucv vjg Jctxctf Ncy Uejqqn/ Jg ycu Ejcktocp qh vjg Pijmjqqjof Lbx Jpvsobmhtqo 3116.3117/ Ot/ Vcp kujku htcvgtpkv{dtqvjgt cpf vjgtghqtg uqogqpg jg hggnueqohqtvcdng qtfgtkpictqwpf /

|| Tgvktgf Hqwpfkpi cpf Pcog Rctvpgt qh vjg CEETCNC Y Qhhkeg/Jg itcfwcvgf htqo vjgWpkxgtukv{qh vjg RjknkrrkpguNcy Uejqqn kp 2:69- dvn mbvef*ycu Ejcktocp qh vjg Rjknkrrkpg Ncy Lqwtpcnhtqo 2:68.2:69 cpf c ogodgt vjgtgqhhtqo 2:67.2:68/ Jg qdvckpgf jku NNO htqo vjg Wpkxgtukv{qhRgppu{nxcpkckp 2:6:/

OC/e/ Pq/ 7242- 585 UgTC 2- Hgd/ 39- 3116/

Vjg wpuwkvcdknkv{qh o{ rgpejcpv hqt wukpi vjcv kpxgevkxg ycudtqwijv vq o{ cvvgpvkqpd{ LwuvkegGhtgp 2/ Rncpc kp cp godcttcuukpi cpfftcocvke yc{/

Fwtkpi qpg goqvkqpcn CEETC Rctvpgtu( Oggvkpi- K ctiwgf o{rtqrqukvkqpu ykvj uwej hqteg cpf goqvkqp vjcv kp vjg okfuv qh o{ctiwogpvu- LwuvkegRncpc kpvgttwrvgf og kp jku igpvngocpn{ yc{; "Lqg- yj{fq {qw rwpevwcvg cnn{qwt ugpvgpegu ykvj vjcv yqtfB Ecp {qw pqv wug cdgvvgtyqtfB"

Vjg kpvgttwrvkqp koogfkcvgn{ dtqwijv uqdtkgv{ vq vjg fkuewuukqp/Knquvvjg ctiwogpv/

Ukpegvjcv kpekfgpv-Kjcxg dggp vjkpmkpi qh cnvgtpcvkxgcrrtqrtkcvgitcrjke ncpiwcig vq tgrnceg o{ hcxqtkvgVcicnqi kpxgevkxg/Rgtjcru- HtcpmUkpcvtc(uigpvngocpn{ ncpiwcig yknnfq; "Vjg ncf{ kuc vtcor/"

Uq owej hqt kpxgevkxgucu vjg{ tgncvgvq Ngicn Gvjkeu/ Fgurkvg dgkpiocpfcvqt{ kp ncy uejqqn ewttkewnc-3kvkuvjg ngcuvcrrgcnkpi ncy uwdlgev/Qpgtgcuqp oc{ dg kvurcnvt{ 6& ygkijv kp vjg Dct Gzcokpcvkqpu/4 Cpqvjgt kuvjcv "ncy uvwfgpvufq pqv vjkpmvjcv vjg{ yknndgeqog wpgvjkecnncy{gtu/"5

Pgxgtvjgnguu- Twng 3- Ugevkqp3 qh vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtv(u TwnguqpOcpfcvqt{ Eqpvkpwkpi Ngicn Gfwecvkqp )OENG, fgxqvgu ukz qwv qh 47OENG jqwtu vq Ngicn Gvjkeu/ Gmeqorctkuqp- pkpg jqwtu ctg cnnqvvgfhqt"wrfcvgu qp uwduvcpvkxgcpf rtqegfwtcn ncyu-" yjkej eqxgtu hqwt oclqtuwdlgevu"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn-ekxkn-eqoogtekcn- cpf tgogfkcn ncy/ Vjg cnnqvogpvqh ukz jqwtu vq c ukping uwdlgev-vq o{ okpf- wphncvvgtkpin{uwiiguvu vjcvncy{gtu( wpgvjkecneqpfwev owuv jcxg fgvgtkqtcvgf vq cp cnctokpi ngxgnvjcvvjg Dgpej cpf Dct ecp pq nqpigt kipqtg/

Vjg vtcr nckf dghqtg c ncy{gt yjq ikxgu jku vjqwijvu qp NgicnGvjkeu ku vjcv jg okijv etgcvg vjg kortguukqp qh c "Jqnkgt Vjcp Vjqw"rquvwtg/ Yqtug- jg okijv wpgvjkecnn{uwiiguv vjg wpvjkpmcdng;"Fq cu Kvgnn{qw- pqv yjcv K fq/" Cv vjg tkumqh hcnnkpikpvq vjku vtcr- o{ rcrgt kueQShkpgf vq Ngicn Gvjkeu rtqdngou qpg gpeqwpvgtu kp cp kpuvkvwvkqpcnncy

3 TWNGUQH EQWTV- Twng 249- · 6)3,/- ·25/6 RcvtkemU/Uejknv}-122 Bfjoh A J,mbqqz*Hfbmucz*A mjeEucjdbmMfncfs OgAmmUmmcbqqz*Uocfbmucz*bmme

UmmfucjdbmPspguStjOIm*63 XCPF/ N/ TGX/ 982- :18 )2:::,/

hkto nkmgCEETC/ O{ gpvktgectggt jcu dggp eqphkpgf ykvjkp vyq ncy hktouvjgp vtcpuhqtokpi kpvqkpuvkvwvkqpcnncy hktou/

K/; J;v DGPK&RPCRNMLRG?GJGSX SM CLRTPC GSRKCK?CPR ;LB ;RRMAG;SCR& CSFGA;J ?CF;UGMP

Qwt Eqfg qh Rtqhguukqpcn Tgurqpukdknkv{fqgu pqv fgvckn c ncyhkto(u tgurqpukdknkv{hqt kvurctvpgtu qt ncy{gtu( wpgvjkecn dgjcxkqt/u VjgCogtkecp Dct Cuuqekcvkqp )CDC,- qp vjg qvjgt jcpf- tgeqoogpfu vjghqnnqykpi Oqfgn Twng;7

Twng6/2 Rftqpotjcjmjujft pg Pbsuofst* Mbobhfst* boe SvqfswjtpszLbvzfst

)c, C rctvpgt kp c ncy hkto- cpf c ncy{gt yjq kpfkxkfwcnn{qt vqigvjgt ykvj qvjgt ncy{gturquuguugueqorctcdng ocpcigtkcncwvjqtkv{kpc ncy hkto- ujcnnocmg sfbtpobcmf fggOsutvq gpuwtgvjcvvjg hkto jcu kpghhgevogcuwtguikxkpi sfbtpobcmf bttvsbodf vjcv cnnncy{gtu kp vjg hkto eqphqto vq vjg Twnguqh RtqhguukqpcnEqpfwev/

)d, C ncy{gt jcxkpi fktgev uwrgtxkuqt{ cwvjqtkv{ qxgtcpqvjgt ncy{gt ujcnnocmg sfbtpobcmf fggOsutvqgpuwtgvjcv vjg qvjgtncy{gt eqphqtou vqvjg TwnguqhRtqhguukqpcnEqpfwev/

)e, C ncy{gt ujcnn dg tgurqpukdnghqt cpqvjgt ncy{gt(uxkqncvkqpqh vjg TwnguqhRtqhguukqpcnEqpfwevkh;

)2, vjg ncy{gt qtfgtu qt- ykvj mpqyngfig qh vjg urgekhkeeqpfwev-tcvkhkguvjg eqpfwevkpxqnxgf<qt

)3, vjg ncy{gt kuc rctvpgt qt jcu eqorctcdng ocpcigtkcncwvjqtkv{kpvjg ncy hkto kpyjkej vjg qvjgt ncy{gt rtcevkegu-qt

6 Vjg qpn{ twngKhqwpf yjkej ogpvkqpu vjg vgtou "hkto"- "rctvpgtu" cpf "cuuqekcvgu"kuTwng32/15; "C ncy{gt oc{ fkuenqugvjg chhckvuqh c enkgpvqh vjg hkto vq rctvpgtu qt cuuqekcvguvjgtgqh wpnguurtqjkdkvgf d{ vjg enkgpv/"

7 Cjufe jo Uqncvcpxu/ npqegpvgu-CE Pq/ 7615-577 UETC 2- 2: p/27- Cwi/ :- 3116/

jcu fktgev uwrgtxkuqt{ cwvjqtkv{qxgt vjg qvjgt ncy{gt- cpfmpqyu qh vjg eqpfwev cv c vkogyjgp kvueqpugswgpeguecp dgcxqkfgf qt okvkicvgfdwvhcknuvqvcmgtgcuqpcdngtgogfkcn cevkqp/)gorjcuku uwrrnkgf,

Pqvg kvuuvcpfctfu qh tgcuqpcdng ghhqtvucpf tgcuqpcdng cuuwtcpeg/Hwtvjgt- d{ fgnkdgtcvgn{wukpi "rctvpgt" cpf "ncy{gt" cu fkuvkpevvgtou- vjgOqfgn Twng-rctvkewnctn{kp kvuncuvuwdrctcitcrj- gorjcuk}gu vjg uwduvcpvkcnfkhhgtgpeg kp c rctvpgt(u fkuekrnkpct{nkcdknkv{/Egtvckpn{-kvyqwnf dg wphcktcpf wplwuvhqt c pqp.rctvpgt vq dg ocfg nkcdnghqt qvjgt ncy{gtu( wpgvjkecneqpfwev- ncy{gtu qxgt yjqo jg gzgtekugupq uwrgtxkuqt{ cwvjqtkv{- gzegrvhqt vjg rctvkewnctecug gpxkukqpgf kp uwdrctcitcrj )e,)n,/

Hwtvjgt- vjg ejqkeg qh yqtfu gorjcuk}gu vjcv vjg "rctvpgt" cpf vjg"ncy{gt" ctg vjg rctvkgu nkcdng<vjg ncy hkto ku c ogtg hkevkqpvjcv jcu pqxkectkqwufkuekrnkpct{ nkcdknkv{/Kvecppqv rtcevkeg ncy- cpf vjgtghqtg- ecppqvdg fkudcttgf qt uwurgpfgf htqo kvurtcevkeg/

Tgcf kp CEETC(u qticpk}cvkqpcn eqpvgzv- vjg fkhhgtgpv ngxgnuqhuwrgtxkuqt{ cwvjqtkv{ hqt rwtrqugu qh nkcdknkv{wpfgt vjku Oqfgn Twngyqwnfdg;

1 Zj»]~p»\ J^we F\\px lwpo1 O~ F Zj»]~p»\( Wpp]t~s

N[qsmcq Gm-CrV5ea 4cDt3V3[a

t.111111111111111111111111111111111111</11111

t

2aa2300DBBDaB"2"3202O]E1B!)((`(3``]a3

O` bbgggggggg

Vjg ncem qh cp gzrnkekv Rjknkrrkpg twng jcu pqv fgvgttgf qwtUwrtgog Eqwtv htqo hcujkqpkpi lwtkurtwfgpvkcn uvcpfctfu hqt rctvpgtu(xkectkqwunkcdknkv{/Riffn pg uif Pijmjqqjoft*Iod- w-Ffssfs (Io Rf Pspdffejoht AhbjotuAmgpotp Ppodf Eosjmf*Lfpobsep 4 jhvjpo Rfzob* Mbovfm I/ Mpoufdjmmp*Eosjrvf O/Bfmp*Otdbs ] Oohtjblp boe Jptf S- Asnpojp)6 ku vjg hktuvecug K hqwpf vjcvkorqugf wrqp c ncy hkto(u pcog rctvpgtu vjg chhktocvkxg fwv{ qh"gzgtekukpi cfgswcvg uwrgtxkukqp cpf eqpvtqn qh vjg rngcfkpiu cpf qvjgtfqewogpvu uwdokvvgf d{ vjgkt ncy hkto vq vjg eqwtvu qh lwuvkegqh vjkueqwpvt{/"9

Rqpeg Gptkng- UkiwkqpTg{pc- Oqpvgeknnq-Dgnq ' Qpiukcmq ycuvjgp vjg eqwpvt{(u nctiguv ncy hkto/ Khyg ctg vq dgnkgxgUgpcvqt Gfictfq R1Cpictc- yjq ycu vjgp yqtmkpi- cu cp Cuuqekcvg-kp vjcv hkto- kvycu cnuqvjgeqwpvt{(u oquv eqorgvgpv hkto/ Vjg U{ekr Ncy Qhhkegycu qpn{- yjgtg Kycu vjgp yqtmkpi cu cp Cuuqekcvg-vjgp c ngcp cpf jwpit{ wruvctvncy hkto/

Kp vjg ekvgf ecug- vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtv qtfgtgf cnnvjg Pcog Rctvpgtucpf vjgkt CuuqekcvgLqug U/Ctoqpkq- "vq ujqy ecwugyj{" vjg{ ujqwnf pqv dgfgenctgf kp eqpvgorv qh eqwtv hqt vjg hqnnqykpi rqtvkqp qh c oqvkqp hqttgeqpukfgtcvkqpvjcv vjg ncvvgtrtgrctgf cpf ukipgf;

Qpg rkvhcnnkpvq yjkej vjku Jqpqtcdng Eqwtv jcu tgrgcvgfn{hcnngpyjgpgxgt vjg swguvkqpcu vq yjgvjgt qt pqv c rctvkewnctuwdlgevocvvgt kuykvjkpvjg lwtkufkevkqpqhvjg Eqwtvqh KpfwuvtkcnTgncvkqpukuvjg vgpfgpe{ qh vjkuJqpqtcdng Eqwtvvq tgn{wrqpkvuqyp rtqpqwpegogpv ykvjqwvfwg tgictf vqvjg uvcvwvguyjkejfgnkpgcvgvjg lwtkufkevkqpqh vjg kpfwuvtkcneqwtv/Swkvgqhvgp-kvkuqxgtnqqmgf vjcv pq eqwtv-pqv gxgp vjku Jqpqtcdng Eqwtv- kugorqygtgf vqgzrcpf qt eqpvtcevvjtqwij kvufgekukqpvjg ueqrgqh kvulwtkufkevkqpcncwvjqtkv{cu eqphgttgf d{ ncy/ Vjku gttqt kuocpkhguvgf d{ vjg fgekukqpuqh vjku Jqpqtcdng Eqwtv ekvkpigctnkgttwnkpiudwvykvjqwvocmkpi cp{ tghgtgpegvq cpf cpcn{ukuqh vjg rgtvkpgpvuvcvwvgiqxgtpkpi vjg lwtkufkevkqpqh vjg EqwtvqhKpfwuvtkcnTgncvkqpu/Vjku ocpkhguvcvkqpcrrgctu kp vjkuJqpqtcdng Eqwtv(ufgekukqpkp vjg kpuvcpvecug/Cu c tguwnv-vjggttqtu kp gctnkgt ecugu fgcnkpi ykvj vjg lwtkufkevkqpqh vjg

8 Tjggo qh vjg Rjknkrrkpgu-Kpe/x/ Hgttgt- I/T/ Pq/ 33:8:- 31 UgTC 552-Lwp/ 37- 2:78/7 !e- cv 558/

kpfwuvtkcneqwtv ctg rgtrgvwcvgf kp uwdugswgpvecugukpxqnxkpivjg ucog kuuwg/:

Vjg Pcog Rctvpgtu cuuwogf "hwnntgurqpukdknkv{"dwv rngcfgf vjgfghgpugu- cu uwooctk}gf d{ vjg Eqwtv- vjcv;

)2, "pqv qpg qh vjg rctvpgtu ycu cdngvq rcuu wrqp vjg ftchv qthkpcnhqto qhvjg uckfoqvkqp"<

)3, "Cvv{/Ctoqpkq- cp cuuqekcvg-rtgrctgf- ukipgf cpf hvngfvjgoqvkqp (ykvjqwvengctkpiykvj cp{ qhvjg rctvpgtu(((<

)4, vjg rctvpgtu "ygtg pqv kp vjg qhhkegcv vjg vkog uckf oqvkqpycu hkngf. yjkej ycu vjg ncuvfc{"<cpf

)5, "kvku vjg rqnke{qh vjg hkto mpqyp vq cnnkvuogodgtu cpfcuuqekcvguvjcv qpn{ vjg rctvpgtu ecp ukip eqwtv rngcfkpiugzegrv kp tctg ecugu yjgtg- hqt ycpv qh vkog qt fwg vqwpgzrgevgf ektewouvcpegu-cp cuuqekcvgjcu vq ukip vjgucog/"n1

Pqvg vjg ncuvfghgpug; khkvygtg vtwg vjcv cnnrctvpgtu ygtg pqv kpvjg qhhkegyjgp vjg oqvkqp ycu hkngfqp vjg ncuvfc{- vjgp Cvv{/ Ctoqpkqycu cwvjqtk}gf vq ukip cpf hLngvjcv oqvkqp wpfgt vjg hkto(u qyp rqnke{/

Kh{qw ygtg vjg cuuqekcvg-cpf vjg pcog rctvpgtu rngcfgf vjqugfghgpugu cpf uvtcvgi{ qh dncokpi {qw- cp cuuqekcvg-vq kpuwncvgvjgougnxguhtqo cp{ fkuekrnkpct{nkcdknkv{-jqy yqwnf {qw hggnB

Cu c jkuvqtkecnhqqvpqvg-Cvv{/Ctoqpkq kuc Ukioc Tjq Htcvgtpkv{ogodgt cpf Jctxctf Ncy Uejqqn itcfwcvg/

8 Ie- cv553/21 Ie- cv 554- 557/

Cnn vjg Pcog Rctvpgtu cpf vjgkt cuuqekcvgcrrgctgf dghqtg vjgUwrtgog Eqwtv/ Fqp Cnhqpuq Rqpeg Gptkngcpf Cvv{/Ctoqpkq ygtg jgctf/Fgurkvg vjgkt gzrncpcvkqpu- vjg Eqwtv jgnf vjcv vjg fkurwvgf ncpiwcig"fgvtcev]ua owej htqo vjg fkipkv{ qh cpf tgurgev fwg"!! vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtvdgecwug;

Vjg rnckpkorqtv qh cnnvjkukuvjcv vjkuEqwtvkuuq rcvgpvn{kpgrvvjcvkpfgvgtokpkpi vjg lwtkufkevkqpqh vjg kpfwuvtkcneqwtv-kvjcueqookvvgf gttqt cpf eqpvkpwqwun{tgrgcvgf vjcv gttqt vq vjgrqkpvqhrgtrgvwcvkqp/KvrkevwtguvjkuEqwtvcu qpg yjkej tghwuguvq jgy vqvjg nkpgftcyp d{ vjg ncy qp lwtkufkevkqpcndqwpfctkgu/Kornkekvkpvjg swqvgf uvcvgogpvukuvjcvvjg rtqpqwpegogpvu qhvjku Eqwtv qp vjg lwtkufkevkqpqh vjg kpfwuvtkcneqwtv ctg pqvgpvkvngfvqtgurgev/!3

Ceeqtfkpin{- vjg Eqwtv twngf vjcv c ncy{gt wukpi uwej qhhgpukxgncpiwcig xkqncvgfjku fwv{- "Vq qdugtxg cpf ockpvckp vjg tgurgev fwg vq vjgeqwtvu qh lwuvkegcpf lwfkekcnqhhkegtu<"!4cpf ku c dtgcej qh vjg rtgugpvEcpqp 22 yjkej gplqkpu- "C ncy{gt ujcnnqdugtxg cpf ockpvckp vjg tgurgevfwg vq vjg eqwtvu cpf vq lwfkekcnqhhkegtu cpf ujqwnf kpukuvqp ukokncteqpfwev d{ qvjgtu/"!5

]ractvpgtu ctg fwv{dqwpf vq rtqxkfg hqt ghhkecekqwueqpvtqnqheqwtvrngcfkpiu cpf qvjgt eqwtvrcrgtu vjcv ectt{ vjgkt pcogu qtvjg pcog qhvjgktncy hkto/Uggokpin{-uwej eqpvtqnycu cdugpv/

Cvvgpvkqpqh Cvv{u/CnhqpuqRqpeg Gptkng-Ngqpctfq UkiwkqpTg{pc- OcpwgnI/ Oqpvgeknnq-GptkswgO/ Dgnqcpf Quect T/Qpiukcmq ku kpxkvgfvq vjg pgeguukv{qh gzgtekukpi cfgswcvg

22 Ie- cv 555/m1Ie- cv 554.555/24 TWNGUQHEQWTV-Twng249- · 31)d,/25 Vjg Eqwtvekvgfvjgp Ecppqp! qh vjg Ecppqpu qh RtqhguukqpcnGvjkeu;"kvkuvjg fwv{qh vjg

ncy{gt vq ockpvckpvqyctfu vjg eqwtvuc tgurgethwncvvktwfg-pqv hqt vjg ucmgqh vjg tgorqtct{ kpewodgpvqh vjg lwfkekcnqhhkeg-dwvhqt vjg ockpvgpcpeg qh kvuuwrtgog korqtvcpeg/ Lwfigu- pqt dgkpi yjqnn{ htggvqfghgpf vjgougnxgu-ctg rgewnkctn{gpvkvngfvq tgegkxgvjg uwrrqtv qh vjg dct cickput wplwutetkvkekuocpfencoqt/ Yjgpgxgt tjgtg kurtqrgt itqwpf hqt ugtkqwueqornckpt qh c lwfkekcnqhhkegt-ktkuvjg tkijt cpffwv{qh vjg ncy{gt tq uwdokt jku itkgxcpegu vq vjg rtqrgt cwvjqtkvkgu/Kpuwej ecugu-dwvpqt qvjgtykug-uwej ejctigu ujqwnf dg gpeqwtcigf cpf vjg rgtuqp ocmkpi vjgo ujqwnf dg rtqtgevgf-"

uwrgtxkukqp cpf eqpvtqn qh vjg rngcfkpiu cpf qvjgt fqewogpvuuwdokvvgf d{ vjgkt ncy hkto vq vjg eqwtvu qh lwuvkegqh vjkueqwpvt{/KU)gorjcuku uwrrnkgf,

Vjku ecug kuc hcktyctpkpi vq uwrgtxkukpi rctvpgtu yjq fq pqv tgcfvjg ftchvu rtqrqugf d{ cp cuuqekcvghqt hknkpiykvj vjg eqwtvu/ Urgekhkecnn{-pqvg vjg fgitgg- qt khpqv- vjg swcnkv{qh rctvpgtu( tgurqpukdknkv{;vjg{ owuvgzgtekug "0Jjdbdjpvt dpouspm"cpf "befrvbuf tvqfspjtjpo boe dpouspm"qh eqwtv hknkpiu/Tgecnn vjcv vjg CDC Oqfgn Twng tgswktgu qpn{ "sfbtpobcmf jgJOsut" cpf"sfbtpobcmf bttvsbodf- "

Vjwu- enckokpi ncemqh rtkqt crrtqxcn kp vjg hceg qh rgtegkxgf gttqtuqwpfu jqnnqy dgecwug vjku dgvtc{u ncemqh "0Jjdbdjpvt dpousp.' cpf "befrvbuftvqfswjtjpo boe dpouspm-" Vjg encko cnuq eqnncrugu wpfgt vjg eqpegrv qh"eqoocpf tgurqpukdknkv{-" wpfgt yjkej c pcog rctvpgt ycu jgnffkuekrnkpct{ nkcdng hqt cp cuuqekcvg(u wpgvjkecn dgjcxkqt kp S pmbubo w-I opdfouft-16

Vjg ncy hkto kp swguvkqpycu vjg Quect Kpqegpvgucpf CuuqekcvguNcy Qhhkeg/Vjg UrqwuguCpftgu cpf NwfkxkpcIgpkvq tgvckpgf kvuugtxkeguvq cfftguu vjgkt ngicn rtqdngou ctkukpi htqo vjgkt crctvogpv eqorngz(uugswguvtcvkqp/Vjg{ ygtg cnuq cwvjqtk}gf d{ vjg REII vq jcpfng vjgglgevogpv ecugu cickpuv pqp.rc{kpi vgpcpvu/

C fghcwnvlwfiogpv ycu tgpfgtgf kp qpg qh uwej glgevogpv ecugcyctfkpi vjg Igpkvq Urqwugu vjg uwo qh R41-711/11 rnwu 35& kpvgtguvcuwprckf tgpvcnu-Rk1-111/11 cu cvvqtpg{(uhggu-cpf vjg equvuqh uwkv/

Vjg eqornckpcpv- dtqvjgt qh vjg vgpcpv yjq ycu cdtqcf- ycu vjgcrctvogpv(u cevwcnqeewrcpv/ Dghqtg vjg ytkv qh gzgewvkqpeqwnf dg ngxkgfwrqp- vjg eqornckpcpv crrtqcejgf Cvv{/ Quect Kpqegpvgu-yjq tghgttgfjko vq jku cuuqekcvg-Cvv{/ Lqug Ecocpq- vjg cvvqtpg{ kp ejctig qh vjgIgpkvq(u glgevogpv ecugu/

Vjg eqornckpcpv ycu cnnqygf vq uvc{kp vjg crctvogpv hqnnqykpi cxgtdcn ugvvngogpv-yjgtg jg citggf vq rc{ jku ukuvgt(ugpvktglwfiogpv fgdv-kpenwfkpi jcnh vjg cyctfgf cvvqtpg{(uhggucpf Rk-711/11 cu equvuqh uwkv/Cu

26 Tjggo qh vjg Rjknkrrkpgu-Kpe/x/ Rgttgt- I/T/ Pq/ 33:8:- 31 UETC 552- 557.558- Lwp/37-2:78/27 C/E/ Pq/ 7615- 577 UETC 2- Cwi/ :-3116/

rctvkcn eqornkcpeg- jg kuuwgf c ejgem hqt HU-QQQ/QQ- kp Cvv{/ Ecocpq(upcog- tgrtgugpvkpi jcnh vjg cyctfgf cvvqtpg{(uhggu/

Vjg eqornckpcpv hckngfvq ocmg cp{ qvjgt rc{ogpv/ Vjwu- vjgujgtkhh-ykvj Cvv{/Ecocpq cpf uqog rqnkegogp- ngxkgfwrqp vjg rtqrgtvkgukp vjg crctvogpv/ Wrqp vjg eqornckpcpv(u tgswguv-c pgy citggogpv ycuhqtigf yjgtgd{ vjg ngxkgf rtqrgtvkgu ygtg tgngcugf gzegrv hqt c PqtvjgtpJknn 4.dwtpgt icu uvqxg yjkej ycu tgvckpgf cpf wugf d{ Cvv{/ Ecocpq kpcpqvjgt crctvogpv kp vjg Igpkvq(u Crctvogpvu cpf vjg eqornckpcpv rckfCvv{/Ecocpq vjg equvukpewttgf kpgphqtekpi vjg ytkv qh gzgewvkqp/

Vjgtgchvgt- vjg eqornckpcpv hvKgfc fkudctogpv ecug cickpuv Cvv{u/Kpqegpvgucpf Ecocpq/

Vjg Eqwtv wrjgnf vjg KDR(U hkpfkpiu vjcv Cvv{/ Ecocpq(uceegrvcpeg qh HU-QQQ/QQ cpf vjg equvu qh korngogpvkpi vjg ytkv- cpf jkuvcmkpi rquuguukqp qh vjg Pqtvjgtp Jknn qxgp- eqpuvkvwvgf"ewnrcdng cevuyjkej vgpf vq fgitcfg vjg rtqhguukqp cpf hqogpv fkuvtwuvkp vjg kpvgitkv{qheqwtv rtqeguugu/"KB

Qp crrgcn- Cvv{/ Kpqegpvgu cuugtvgf "vjcv jg ycu kpeqttgevn{rwpkujgf hqt Cvv{/Ecocpq(u cevuyjgp jku ogtg rctvkekrcvkqpkp vjg hkcueqycu vq tghgt eqornckpcpv vq Cvv{/Ecocpq/"nu Vjg Eqwtv- urgcmkpi vjtqwijLwuvkegVkpic- fkucitggf/

]ratgekugn{dgecwugqh uwej rctvkekrcvkqp-eqpukuvkpicu kvfkf qhtghgttkpi vjg eqornckpcpv vq jku cuuqekcvgncy{gt- vjcv Cvv{/Kpqegpvguoc{ dg jgnf cfokpkuvtcvkxgn{nkcdngd{ xktvwgqh jkucuuqekcvg(uwpgvjkecncevu/Jku hcknwtgvq fyfsdjtf dfsubjo sftqpotjcjmjujftqxgt ocvvgtu wpfgt vjg ejctig qh jku ncy hkto kuc dncogyqtvj{ujqtveqokpi/ Vjg vgto 'dpnnboe sftqpotjcjmjug*cu Cvv{/Kpqegpvguuwiiguvu-jcu urgekcnogcpkpi ykvjkpvjg ektengqh ogp kpwpkhqtokp vjg oknkvct{<jqygxgt- vjg rtkpekrng fqgu pqv cdkfg uqngn{vjgtgkp/ Kvdpouspmtuif wfsz djsdvntubodf jo xijdi Ausz- Iopdfouft gpvoeijntfmg 2: )gorjcuku uwrrnkgf,

28 Ie- cv 24/*- Ie-*- Ie-

Vjg Eqwtv tg.chhktogf vjg fqevtkpg qh Aeb}b wt- Bbsjobhb1/ vjcvncy{gtu ctg cfokpkuvtcvkxgn{nkcdnghqt vjg eqpfwev qh vjgkt gornq{ggu kphcknkpivq vkogn{hkngrngcfkpiu- cpf Riffn't "vjcv rctvpgtu ctg fwv{ dqwpf vqrtqxkfg hqt ghhkecekqwueqpvtqn qh eqwtv rngcfkpiu cpf qvjgt eqwtv rcrgtuvjcv ectt{ vjgkt pcogu qt vjg pcog qh vjg ncy hkto/"32

Vjg Eqwtv ygpv "hwtvjgt" cpf ykfgpgf vjg pgv qh tgurqpukdknkv{qh"rctvpgtu cpf rtcevkvkqpgtuyjq jqnf uwrgtxkuqt{ ecrcekvkgu"33vq kpenwfg;

Yg pqy jqnf hwtvjgt vjcv rctvpgtu cpf rtcevkvkqpgtuyjq jqnfuwrgtxkuqt{ ecrcekvkgubsf mfhbmm[sftqpotjcmf up fyfsu psejobsz ejmjhfodfkp crrtkukpi vjgougnxgu qh vjg dpnjoht boe hpjoht qh vjg ecugujcpfngf d{ vjg rgtuqpu qxgt yjkej vjg{ ctg gzgtekukpiuwrgtxkuqt{ cwvjqtkv{cpf jo fyfsujoh ofdfttbsz jggpsutupgusfdmptf uifpddvssfodf pg wjpmbujpotpguif Cpef pgPspgfttjpobmRftqpotjcjmjuz uszqfstpotvoefs uifjs dibshf- Pqpgvjgnguu- vjg nkcdknkv{qh vjg uwrgtxkukpincy{gt kp vjku tgictf kud{ pq ogcpu gswkxcngpvvq vjcv qh vjgtgecnekvtcpvncy{gt //// 34 )gorjcuku uwrrnkgf,

Spmbubo korqugf wrqp "rctvpgtu cpf rtcevnvnqpgtu yjq jqnfuwrgtxkuqt{ ecrcekvkgu" vjg fwv{ "up fyfsu psejobsz ejmjhfodf kp crrtkukpivjgougnxgu qh vjg eqokpiu cpf iqkpiu qh" ngicnocvvgtu tghgttgf d{ vjgo vqvjgkt cuuqekcvgucpf vq gzgtv "ofdfttbsz fggpsut upgpsfdmptf uif pddvssfodf pg wjpmbujpotpg uif Cpef pg Pspgfttjpobm Rftqpotjcjmjuz l qfstpot voefs uifjs dibshf-"13

Spmbubo vjwu tckugf vjg dct qh tgurqpukdknkv{/Riffn ogtgn{ korqugfvjg uvcpfctf qh "uwrgtxkukqp cpf eqpvtqn" d{ pcog rctvpgtu qxgt rngcfkpiu(ncpiwcig/ Kp eqpvtcuv- S pmbubo kpenwfgu"qvjgt rtcevkvkqpgtu" kp cffkvkqp vqpcog rctvpgtu- cpf uwrgtxkukqp owuv cnuq kpenwfg cyctgpguu qh vjg"eqokpiu cpf iqkpiu"- qt vjg rtqitguu cpf uvcvwuqh ikxgp tghgttcnu/

Oqtg korqtvcpvn{- rctvpgtu ctg pqy tgswktgf vq gzgtv "pgeguuct{ghhqtvu vq gpsfdmptf uif pddvssfodf pg wjpmbujpot qh vjg Eqfg qh RtqhguukqpcnTgurqpukdknkv{d{ rgtuqpu wpfgt vjgkt ejctig/"36 Ceeqtfkpin{- vjg Riffntgswktgogpv vjcv rctvpgtu rtqxkfg "fggjdbdjpvt dpouspm" cpf vq gzgtv "befrvbuf

31 CE Pq/ 2715- 215 UETC 795- Oc{ 3:- 2:92/32 Tjggo qh vjg Rjknkrrkpgu-Kpe/x/ Hgttgt- I/T/ Pq/ 33:8:- 31 UETC 552- 557.558- Lwp/37- 2:78/33 Uqkcncpx/ Kpqegpvgu- C/E/ Pq/z7615- 577 UETC 2- Cwi/ :-3116/34 ai-13 Oi- Gorjcuku uwrrnkgf/140e- Gorjcuku uwrrnkgf/

tvqfswItIpo boe dpouspm"qxgt eqwtv hknkpiuowuv pqy kpenwfg- ceeqtfkpi vqSpgbubo* vjg gzgtvkqp qh "ofdfttbsz jggpsut up" rtgxgpv wpgvjkecneqpfwev qh chkto(u rctvpgtu cpf ncy{gtu/

Hkpcnn{-rctvpgtu cpf ncy{gtu ctg cnuq nkcdnghqt vjgkt pqp.ngicnuvchh(upginkigpeg qt hcknwtg/GmAeb}b w- Bbsjobhb*15 c uqnq rtcevkvkqpgt vtkgfvq gxcfg fkuekrnkpct{nkcdknkv{d{ rngcfkpi vjcv jg kpuvtwevgfjku ugetgvct{ vqhn2gc oqvkqp hqt tgeqpukfgtcvkqp d{ ockn- qp vjg ncuvfc{/ Vjg ugetgvct{cnngigfn{fkf pqv hqnnqyjku kpuvtwevkqpu/

Ocmkpi vjg ncy qhhkeg ugetgvct{- engtm qt oguugpigt vjguecrgiqcv qt rcvu{ hqt vjg fgnc{ kp vjg hknkpi qh rngcfkpiu-oqvkqpu cpf qvjgt rcrgtu cpf hqt vjg ncy{gt(u fgtgnkevkqpqh fwv{ku eqooqp cnkdkqh rtcevkekpi ncy{gtu/ Nkmgvjg cnkdkqh vjgceewugf kp etkokpcn ecugu- eqwpugn(uujkhvkpi qh vjg dncog vq jkuqhhkeggornq{gg kuwuwcnn{c eqpeqevkqp wvknk}gfvq eqxgt wr jkuqyp pginkigpeg- kpeqorgvgpeg- kpfqngpeg cpf kpgrvkvwfg//// 49

Chvgt Quect Htcpmnkp D/ Vcp- cpqvjgt Ukioc Tjq Htcvgtpkv{ogodgt cfokvvgf vq vjg Jctxctf Ncy Uejqqn- uwdokvvgf jku tgugctej- jgtgswguvgf o{ qrkpkqp qp yjgvjgt eqpugpuwcnugz dgvyggp cp wpocttkgfocp cpf cp wpocttkgf yqocp eqpuvkvwvguitquu kooqtcnkv{ cu yqwnfycttcpv vjg fkudctogpv qh c ncy{gt/ Vjg eqpxgtucvkqp ygpv;

IDV; Fqgu eqpugpuwcn ugz dgvyggp cp wpocttkgf ncY{gt cpfcp wpocttkgf yqocp eqpuvkvwvgitquu kooqtcnkv{ cu vq ycttcpvvjg fkudctogpv qh c ncy{gtB

37 C/E/ Pq/ 2715- 2:3 UgTC 2:9- Oc{ 3:- 2:92/16 Ie- cv311/

PII< Rcuu vjg Dct Gzcou hktuv-vjgp vcmg{qwt qcvj cu cncy{gt cpf ukip vjg Tqnnqh Cvvqtpg{u/Chvgtvjcv-{qwyknnmpqyyjcv vqfq/

C ncy{gt yjq fqgu pqv mpqy jqy vq uqnxg vjcv gvjkecn swguvkqpujqwnf- jo o{ qrkpkqp- dg fkudcttgf hqt itquu kpeqorgvgpeg/ UkpegQDV jtqpn{ fc{ftgcokpi- jg ecp dg hqtikxgp/

Ogtg eqornkcpeg xjui Ngicn Gvjkeu fqgu pqv pgeguuctkn{ocmg qpgcp gvjkecn ncy{gt/ [qw ctg cnuq tgswktgf vq nkxg cp gvjkecn nkhg/Vjwueqoocpfu Qvjohvb VS- Pvop17 yjkej fgcnvfktgevn{xjui vjg swgt{ qh QDV/

Vjg twnguhqt nkxkpicp gvjkecnnkhgctg ukorng/ Rctgpvu kpuvknnkp vjgktejknftgp vjg twnguqh jqpguv{- hcktpguu-oqtcnkv{- cpf vjg iqnfgp ogcp; fqpqv fq wpvq qvjgtu yjcv {qw fq pqv ycpv vq dg fqpg vq {qw/ Vjgug twngutgockp xcnkf cpf ujqwnf iqxgtp qpg(u gpvktgnkhggxgp kh-kp vjg ogcpvkog-qpg jcu dgeqog c ncy{gt/

Yjgp qpg jt cfokvvgf vq vjg rtcevkeg qh ncy- vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtvegtvkhkgu-jo ghhgev-vq vjg rwdnkevjcv {qw jcxg vjg eqorgvgpeg vq rtcevkegncy/ Jqygxgt- vjcv jt ogtgn{ c rtguworvkqp/ Gxgt{ ngicn rtqdngo {qw ctgjktgf vq uqnxgkuc vguvqh {qwt eqorgvgpeg cpf fknkigpeg/

Qh vjg 85 fkuekrnkpct{ecugu hqwpf d{ QDV hqt vjg rgtkqf htqoLcpwct{ 3116 vq Crtkn 3117- 41& kpxqnxgf ncy{gtu( kpeqorgvgpeg cpfpginkigpeg/ Vjku jt fkuvwtdkpi cpf c ucf eqoogpvct{ qp vjg ngicnrtqhguukqp/

ECPQP 29 . C NCY[GT UJCNN UGTXG JKU ENKGPVYKVJ EQORGVGPEG CPF FKNKIGPEG/

Twng29/12 . C ncy{gt ujcnnpqv wpfgtvcmgc ngicnugtxkegyjkejjg mpqyu qt ujqwnf mpqy vjcv jg kupqv swcnkhkgfvq tgpfgt/Jqygxgt- jg oc{ tgpfgt uwej ugtxkegkh-ykvj vjg eqpugpvqh jkuenkgpv-jg ecp qdvckpcu eqnncdqtcvkpieqwpugnc ncy{gt yjq kueqorgvgpv qp vjg ocvvgt/

39 C/E/ Pq/ 49:- 2: UETC 54:- 554.556- Hgd/ 39- 2:78/3: EQFG Qh RTQhGUUKQPCN TGURQPUKnnKNKV[-Ecpqp 29/

Twng29/13 . C ncy{gt ujcnnpqv jcpfng cp{ ngicnocvvgt ykvjqwvcfgswcvgrtgrctcvkqp/

Twng29/14 . C ncy{gt ujcnnpqv pgingevc ngicnocvvgt gpvtwuvgfvq jko- cpf jku pginkigpegkp eqppgevkqpvjgtgykvj ujcnntgpfgtjko nkcdng/

Twng29/15 . C ncy{gt ujcnnmggr vjg enkgpvkphqtogf qh vjguvcvwuqh jku ecug cpf ujcnntgurqpf ykvjkp c tgcuqpcdngvkog vqvjg enkgpv(utgswguvhqt kphqtocvkqp/

C rtcevkekpi ncy{gt owuv dg cpui eqorgvgpv cpf fknkigpv/ Khqpn{qpg gngogpv ku eqornkgf ykvj- Ecpqp 29 ku xkqncvgf/ C ncy{gt oc{ dgeqorgvgpv- dg vjg xcngfkevqtkcp qh jku encuu- jcxg vqrrgf vjg dctgzcokpcvkqpu cpf uvwfkgf kp Jctxctf/ Jqygxgt- khjg kupqv fknkigpvkp vjgcevwcnrtcevkeg qh ncy- jg yknn dg uwdlgevgf d{ vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtv vq cfkuekrnkpct{ cevkqp cpf enkgpvucpf rtqurgevkxg enkgpvuyknnpqv tgurgev jko-cpf yknncxqkf jko cu vjgkt ngicncfxkugt/

Kgorjcuk}g vjku rctvkewnct twngdgecwug CEETC etgfq cpejqtu vjghkto(u kpuvkvwvkqpcniqcnu vq vjku gvjkecnuvcpfctf- vq fkhhgtgpvkcvgkvugnhhtqoqvjgtu vjcv dgnkgxgqvjgtykug/ Uqog ncy hktou cpf kpfkxkfwcnncy{gtu dgnkgxgvjcv rqnkvkecncpf lwfkekcneqppgevkqpu cpf enqug tgncvkqpuykvj kphnwgpvkcndwukpguuogp ctg vjg mg{u vq hkpcpekcnuweeguu- pqv "eqorgvgpeg cpffknkigpeg/"

| Vq wrjqnf cpf ockpvckp vjg rtkpekrng qp yjkej vjgHkto ycu guvcdnkujgf. pcogn{- vjcv bo jotujuvujpogpvoefe vqpobcjmjuz*joufhsjuz*boe qspgfttjpobmtljmmyknngpfwtg/

t Tp qspwjef boe nbjoubjo rvbmjuzboe fggjdjfoutfswjdf up dmjfoutcpf rtqvgev qt fghgpf vjgkt tkijvu ykvj ycto }gcn cpf gpvktgfgxqvkqp ykvjkp vjg dqwpfu qh vjg ncy- ykvjqwvtgictf vq vjgkthkpcpekcntguqwtegu-uqekcnrqukvkqp-qt rqrwnctkv{/

t Tp pctfswf xjui hsfbu gjefmjuzuif fuijdbmtuboebset pk uif mfhbmqspgfttjpo-

| Vq dg eqpuvcpvn{cyctg vjcv vjg rtcevkegqh ncy kupqv cdwukpguudwvc pqdngrtqhguukqpcpf uibu uif qsjnf hpbmpkuif Fjsn jtupqspwjef ijhi rvbmjuzmfhbmtfswjdft vqkvuenkgpvucvtgcuqpcdngequv/

Vq tgeqipk}g vjcv vjg ngicn rtqhguukqp kukodwgf ykvj curktkvqh rwdnke ugtxkeg cpf vq gpeqwtcig vjg rctvkekrcvkqp qh vjgncy{gtu qh vjg Hkto kp rwdnke- rtqhguukqpcn- gfwecvkqpcn-ejctkvcdng- ewnvwtcncpf tgnkikqwugpfgcxqtu/5·

Yj{ CEETC qrvgf vq wug vjg vgto "rjknquqrj{" kpuvgcf qh"Okuukqp Uvcvgogpv" cu vjg Cogtkecp Ncy hktou fq- Kecppqv gzrnckp/ Vjghkto(u rtqencocvkqp vq cfjgtg vq vjg gvjkecnuvcpfctf qh "eqorgvgpeg cpffknkigpeg" kutgrgvkvkxg<hqwt qwvqh hkxgeqtg iqcnu ctg nkpiwkuvkexctkcvkqpuqhvjg vjgog "cdknkv{-kpvgitkv{-cpf rtqhguukqpcnumknn/"

Vjg tgngxcpv swgt{ ku yjgvjgt CEETC cpf kvu ncy{gtu jcxgcfjgtgf vq vjgug iqcnu kp vjgkt fgcnkpiu coqpi vjgougnxgu cpf ykvj vjgktenkgpvu-vjg eqwtvu-qvjgt cflwfkecvqt{ cigpekgu- qvjgt iqxgtpogpvcn cigpekgucpf vjg rwdnkekp igpgtcn/ Tgcnkv{-cu {qw mpqy- kuuqogvkogu fkhhgtgpvhtqonqhv{iqcnu/

Vq cpuygt vjcv swguvkqp- K hktuv tgxkgy vyq tgegpv fgekukqpueqpegtpkpi Twng29/14- kpuvtwevkpivjcv c ncy{gt pqv "pgingev c ngicn ocvvgtgpvtwuvgf vq jko/" Vjku eqoocpf dtqcfn{ rtggorvu vjg gpvktg hkgnf qhncy{gtkpi- yjgtg qvjgt twnguctg eqphkpgf vq "ecugu" qt nkvkicvgfocvvgtu/ RgtPCGG w-Sboejhbocrzbo*20 Ngicn Gvjkeu("jkuvqtkecnnkpgcig" ujqyu vjcv; "Vjgrtkpekrcn vjtwuv qh vjg uvcpfctfu ycu fktgevgf vqyctfu vjg nkvkicvkqpeqpfwevqh ncy{gtu-" cpf vjcv vjg "qvjgt dcuke fwvkgu. eqorgvgpe{- fknkigpeg-nq{cnv{-eqphkfgpvkcnkv{-tgcuqpcdng hggucpf ugtxkegvq vjg rqqt . qtkikpcvgfkp vjg nkvkicvkqpeqpvgzv- dwv wnvkocvgn{jcf dtqcf crrnkecvkqp vq cnncurgevuqh ncy{gt(u rtcevkeg/"

Vjwu- fq pqv dg fgnwfgf kpvq vjkpmkpi vjcv {qw ctg pqv eqxgtgfdgecwug {qwt yqtm ku ogtgn{ ftchvkpi cp qrkpkqp- c dqtkpi tgxkgy qheqpvtcev- qt vjg kpxguvkicvkxgyqtm qh fwg fknkigpeg/ K gorjcuk}g; {qw ctggzrgevgf vq fq {qwt yqtm fknkigpvn{cpf eqorgvgpvn{/

Eqpukfgt Aoefstpo w- Cbsefjjp-21 Vjg eqornckpcpv- cp Cogtkecpekvk}gp-ycu vjg rnckpvkhhkp c ekxknecug hqt tgeqpxg{cpeg qh jku ujctg kp cpkpjgtkvcpeg/ Jku ncy{gt fkgf fwtkpi vjg rgpfgpe{ qh jku ecug- hqtekpi jko vqtgvckpvjg ugtxkeguqh Cvv{/Tg{pcnfq E/ Ectfgkkq/

41 Awbjmbcmfbmjvvr;00yyy/ceetcncy/eqo0uwd/rjrBr?cdqwt'u?rjknquqrj{/42 I/T/ Pq/ 26291:-566 UETC 637-676.677- Crt/ 23-3116/43 C/E/ Pq/ 4634- 559 UETC 372-Lcp/ 28-3116/

Yjgp vjg fghgpfcpvu hkngfc Fgowttgt vq Gxkfgpeg- Cvv{/ Ectfgp cfkf pqv hLngcp qrrqukvkqp vjgtgvq cpf jg hckngfvq crrgct yjgp vjg oqvkqpycu jgctf/ Vjgug qokuukqpu rtqorvgf vjg vtkcneqwtv vq fkuokuu vjg ecug/Cickp- Cvv{/ Ectfgpq hckngfvq oqxg hqt c tgeqpukfgtcvkqp qh vjku fkuokuucn-pqt fkf jg crrgcn/ Vjwu- vjg eqornckpcpv uqwijv jku fkudctogpv/

Cu uwooctk}gf d{ vjg Eqwtv- Cvv{/ Ectfgpq lwuvkhkgfjku cevu qhqokuukqpykvj vjgug tgcuqpu;

2/ Vjg "eqornckpcpv ycu dgkpi wpitcvghwnvq jko"dgecwug"jg ycu qpn{ cumgfd{ c iqqf htkgpf qh vjgeqornckpcpv" vq dg eqornckpcpv(u ncy{gt cpf jg"ceeqooqfcvgf vjg tgswguv gxgp ykvjqwvrgtuqpcnn{oggvkpi vjg eqornckpcpv"yjq (_xcutgukfkpikpvjg WpkvgfUvcvgu"/

3/ Vjg eqornckpcpv "fkf pqv ikxg jko hwnneqqrgtcvkqp"<vjg tgeqtfu vwtpgfqxgt vqjko ygtg "xqnwokpqwu"cpf"kp fkucttc{"< yjgp jg crrgctgf cu eqornckpcpv(ueqwpugn jg jcf "qpn{ jcnh vjg kphqtocvkqp cpfdcemitqwpf qh vjg ecugcpf pqv mpqykpi vjg rgtuqp jgycu tgrtgugpvkpi" cu vjg "iqqf htkgpf" qh vjgeqornckpcpveqwnfpqvcpuygt ugxgtcnswguvkqpu/"

4/ Jg ogv vjg eqornckpcpv qpn{yjgp jg ycu cdqwvvqrtgugpv vjg ncuvykvpguucpf ukpegjku fgegcugf eqwpugnjcf cntgcf{ vcmgpjku fgrqukvkqpjg fkf pqv hkpf kvpgeguuct{vqrtgugpvvjg eqornckpcpvcuc ykvpguu/

5/ Kvycu c "dki uwtrtkug" vq jko vjcv vjg vcmkpiqheqornckpcpv(ufgrqukvkqpycu fghgevkxgcu vjg qrrqukpirctvkgucpf vjgkt eqwpugnygtg pqv pqvkhkgfyjkej ngfvjg vtkcneqwtvvqitcpv vjg fgowttgt qhgxkfgpeg/

6/ Vjg "dkiiguv uwtrtkug"hqt jko ycu yjgp uqog "iqqfhtkgpfu"qh vjg eqornckpcpv vqnf jko vjcv "vjg{ jcxgiqqf ceeguu cpf jcxg ocfg cttcpigogpvu ykvj vjgRtgukfkpi Lwfig" cpf ycu tgswguvgf vq rtgrctg coqvkqp hqt tgeqpukfgtcvkqpyjkej jg fkf cpf icxg vqvjg "iqqf htkgpfu"hqt hknkpiykvj vjg eqwtv/

7/ Dgecwugqh vjg cevkqpuqh vjg "iqqf htkgpfu"yjkej jgeqpukfgtueqpvtct{ vqjku fwv{cucp qhhkegtqh vjg eqwtv-

cpf cnuq cickpuv vjg tgurgev fwg vq vjg eqwtvu- jg cumgfvq dg tgnkgxgf cu eqwpugndwvycu tghwugf/44

Cnnvjgug fghgpugu- yjkej kp o{ qrkpkqp ctg cttqicpv cpf ujcnnqy-ygtg tglgevgf d{ vjg Eqwtv dgecwug;

]Kavycu kpewodgpv wrqp Cvv{/ Ectfgkkq vq kpukuvqp jku enkgpv(urctvkekrcvkqp kp vjg rtqeggfkpiu kp vjg ecug// -/ Mpqykpi vjcv jkuenkgpvycu dcugf kp vjg Wpkvgf Uvcvguujqwnf- ykvj oqtg tgcuqp-jcxg oqxgf jko vq ugewtg vjg ngicnogcpu cxckncdngvq jko gkvjgtvq eqpvkpwg tgrtgugpvkpi vjg enkgpvghhgevkxgn{qt vq ocmg vjgpgeguuct{ ocpkhguvcvkqp kp eqwtv- ykvj vjg enkgpv(ueqphqtokv{-vjcv jg ycu ykvjftcykpi cu eqwpugnqh tgeqtf/ Vjcv jku enkgpvfkfpqv citgg vq vgtokpcvg jku ugtxkegukuc ogtg cnngicvkqpvjcv jcupqv dggp uwduvcpvkcvgf/

Vjwu- kp xkgy qh vjg hcevvjcv jg tgockpgf eqwpugnqh tgeqtf hqtvjg eqornckpcpv- kvycu jkijn{ kttgiwnct hqt jko vq gpvtwuvvjghknkpiqh vjg Oqvkqp hqt Tgeqpukfgtcvkqp vq qvjgt rgqrng yjqfkf pqv ncyhwnn{crrgct kpvgtguvgfkp vjg uwdlgevnkvkicvkqp/45

Kcitgg ykvj vjg Eqwtv/ Kjcxg gzrgtkgpegf rctvpgtu cpf cuuqekcvgucnkmgkpxqmg tgcuqpu uwduvcpvkcnn{ukoknct vq Cvv{/ Ectfgkkq(u vq gzrnckpwptgcuqpcdng fgnc{/

"K co dwu{ ykvj qvjgt gswcnn{wtigpv yqtm" kuvjg wuwcngzewug/ Kfq pqv ceegrv vjcv lwuvkhkecvkqp/Khc ncy{gt kuvtwn{dwu{- jg ujqwnf- cv vjghktuvqrrqtvwpkv{- kphqto vjg uwrgtxkukpi rctvpgt vjcv jg ecppqv eqorngvgjku cuukipgf vcumqp vkog/ Kp o{ ecug- Kwuwcnn{vcmgqxgt vjg yqtm khvjgqvjgt vgco ogodgtu ctg vtwn{dwu{ ykvj Svjgt gswcnn{wtigpv rtqhguukqpcnyqtm/

Vjg eqornckpcpv rckf R28-QQQ/QQvq Cvv{/Lgtgokcu Xkvcp hqt vjghknkpiqh cp cevkqp hqt cpf rtqugewvkqp qh cp kpjgtkvgf rtqrgtv{(u rctvkvkqp/Chvgt tgegkxkpi vjg oqpg{- Cvv{/ Xkvcp fkf pqv hkngcp{ ecug pqt fkf jg

44 !e- cv376.77/45 Ie- cv 37:.81/L6 C/E/ Pq/ 6946-567 UgTC 98- Crt/ 26-3116/

tgpfgt cp{ ugtxkeg cv cnn/Ewtkqwun{-pgkvjgt fkf jg uwdokv cp{ gzrncpcvkqphqt jku kpcevkqpfgurkvg ugxgtcnqtfgtu htqo vjg G?N Eqookuukqpgt/ Pgkvjgtfkf jg cvvgpf vjg jgctkpiu< kpuvgcf-jg ogtgn{ ugpvjku ugetgvct{/

Yjgp tgurqpfgpv ceegrvgf vjg coqwpv qh R28-QQQ/QQhtqoeqornckpcpv- kvycu wpfgtuvqqf vjcv jg citggf vq vcmgwr vjgncvvgt(uecug cpf vjcv cp cvvqtpg{.enkgpvtgncvkqpujkrdgvyggpvjgo ycu guvcdnkujgf/Htqo vjgp qp- kvycu gzrgevgf qh jko vqugtxgjku enkgpv-jgtgkp eqornckpcpv-ykvj eqorgvgpeg cpf cvvgpfvqjku ecwugykvj hkfgnkv{-ectg cpf fgxqvkqp/

Vjg cevqh tgegkxkpioqpg{ cuceegrvcpeghgghqt ngicnugtxkegukpjcpfnkpi eqornckpcpv(uecug cpf uwdugswgpf{hcknkpivq tgpfgtuwej ugtxkegukuc engct xkqncvkqpqh Ecpqp 29 qh vjg Cpef pgPspgfttjpobm Rftqpotjcjmjuz yjkej rtqxkfgu vjcv c ncy{gt ujcnnugtxgjku enkgpvykvj eqorgvgpeg cpf fknkigpeg//// 47

Aoefstpo cpf ·ft w- Vjubo ugtxg cu iwkfgrquvu kp vjg gxcnwcvkqpqhCEETC ncy{gtu- htqo Hqwpfkpi Rctvpgtu vq vjg {qwpiguv Cuuqekcvg/Dcugfqp o{ gzrgtkgpeg- oquv khpqv cnnqh CEETC tgetwkvuctg eqorgvgpv/ Kvkukpvjg ctgc qh fknkigpeg vjcv uqog pggf qeecukqpcnrtqffkpi/

Vjgtg ctg kpekfgpvu kp CEETC- hgy vjqwij vjg{ oc{ dg- vjcvkpxqnxg ncy{gtu( kpcevkqp vq enkgpvu(kttkvcvkqp-kh pqv rtglwfkeg/ Vjku ecphqteg/vjg ncvvgtvq tghgt ngicn dwukpguuvq qvjgt ncy hktou yjqug ncy{gtu ecptgpfgt pqv qpn{ eqorgvgpv dwv-oquv korqtvcpvn{- gzrgfkvkqwungicnugtxkeg/

C tgewttkpi rtqdngo kp CEETC(u gctn{ {gctu ycu vjcv uqogRctvpgtu nkvkicvgfecugu qp vjgkt qyp- d{.rcuukpi vjg NkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpvcpf ocmkpi vjgkt qyp vgco cuukipogpvu/

Hqt c ukipkhkecpvrgtkqf fwtkpi vjqug gctn{ {gctu- qpn{ UgpcvqtGfictfq R1 Cpictc- Tqignkq C/ Xkpnwcp cpf K jcf uqog tgurgevcdnggzrgtkgpeg kp nkvkicvkqp/Vjwu- ecugu pqv tghgttgf vq vjg NkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv ygtg cuukipgf vq tgncvkxgn{kpgzrgtkgpegf ncy{gtu/ Uqqp- enkgpvu

dgicp eqornckpkpi vq vjgp Ocpcikpi Rctvpgt- Gf Cpictc- vjcv vjgkt ecuguygtg pqv dgkpi rtqrgtn{ cvvgpfgf vq/

Kp hcktpguuvq Gf Cpictc- jg tghgttgf cnnnkvkicvkqptghgttcnu vjcv jgtgegkxgf vq Tqnn{Xkpnwcpqt o{ugnh hqt gxcnwcvkqpcpf tgeqoogpfcvkqpu/

Qp qpg qeecukqp- Gf Cpictc ecnngf o{ cvvgpvkqp-cu vjg vjgpNkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv Jgcf vq qpg ecug vjcv jcf dggp ceegrvgf d{ cpCEETC rctvpgt- hqt yjkej jg jcf etgcvgf c vgco- ykvj jkougnh cu vjguwrgtxkukpi rctvpgt/ Vjg enkgpvjcf eqornckpgf vq Gf Cpictc vjcv oqtgvjcp c {gct jcf ncrugf {gv pq ecug jcf dggp kpkvkcvgfpqt jcf jg dggpwrfcvgf qp vjg tghgttcn(uuvcvwucv vjcv ncvguvcig/

Ktgokpfgf Gf Cpictc vjcv jg jkougnh cu vjg Ocpcikpi Rctvpgt jcfcnnqygf qvjgt rctvpgtu vq ceegrv ecugu cpf etgcvg vjgkt qyp vgcoukpfgrgpfgpvn{ qh vjg NkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv/ Jgpeg- K tgcuqpgf- vjgNkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv ujqwnf pqv dg jgnf tgurqpukdng hqt vjqug ecugu/

Cu vjg rtqdngo rgtukuvgf cpf Kycu igvvkpi kttkvcvgfykvj kpswktkgutgictfkpi vjg uvcvwuqh vjqug tghgttcnu-Kuwiiguvgf- cpf Gf Cpictc citggf-vjcv K etgcvg c Oqpkvqtkpi Itqwr ykvjkp vjg NkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv vqoqpkvqt vjg oqxgogpvu qh ecugu wr vq c egtvckp rqkpv- chvgt yjkej vjgcuukipgf UwrgtxkukpiRctvpgt ujcnndg nghvcnqpg/

Jgpeg- vjg etgcvkqp qh vjg NkvkicvkqpOqpkvqtkpi Itqwr )NOI, cufkuvkpevhtqo vjg NkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv/ Ogodgtujkr kp vjg OqpkvqtkpiItqwr ycu vjgp qpn{ d{ ytkvvgp kpxkvcvkqphtqo og cu Ejcktocp qh vjgNkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv- cpf vjg NkvkicvkqpOqpkvqt ycu gngevgf d{ vjgitqwr(u ogodgtu/

Vjg Oqpkvqtkpi Itqwr ogv rtqorvn{ cv 6;11 R/O gxgt{ Htkfc{ vqoqpkvqt nkvkicvkqptghgttcnu htqo kpvgtpcngxcnwcvkqpwr vq vjg hknkpiqh crngcfkpi/ Vjg Oqpkvqt vqqm ectg qh vjg fc{.vq.fc{ rtqdngou- kpenwfkpietgcvkpi cpf cuukipkpi vgco ogodgtu hqt pgy tghgttcnu/

Cv vjcv vkog- Kwugf "rggt rtguuwtg" vq rtqf vjg pgingevhwnncy{gtuvq fq vjgkt ngicnyqtm/ Gcej UwrgtxkukpiRctvpgt ycu cumgf vq tgrqtv qp vjguvcvwuqh ecugu cuukipgf vq jko/ Khjg ekvgf vjg hcknwtgqh c Ugpkqt Cuuqekcvgqt cp Cuuqekcvgcu c tgcuqp hqt vjg fgnc{- Kkoogfkcvgn{ ecnngf- fwtkpi vjgoggvkpi- hqt vjg ncy{gt eqpegtpgf hqt cp gzrncpcvkqp hqt vjg fgnc{/

Khvjcv ncy{gt ycu qwv qh vjg CEETC dwknfkpi cv vjcv rctvkewnctvkog- vjg NOI ugetgvct{- Ou/ Octekc Cpigngu- tgswguvgf vjg ncy{gt vq uggog kp o{ qhhkegcpf ikxg jku gzrncpcvkqp/

Yjgtg vjg ncy{gt eqpegtpgf fqgu pqv kortqxg jku rgthqtocpegykvjkp c tgcuqpcdng rgtkqf- Kyqwnf vcdngjku pgingevhwnjcdkv hqt fkuewuukqpd{ vjg Oqpkvqtkpi Itqwr/ Yg yqwnf fgekfg yjgvjgt Kujqwnf vcnmvq vjcvncy{gt cpf kphqto jko vjcv jg ecppqv dg c nkvkicvqt/Qp vjg tctg qeecukqpuvjcv Kycu cwvjqtk}gf vq fq uq- Kkpxkvgf vjg ncy{gt hqt dtgcmhcuvkp o{jqog kp Rcuki cpf vqnf jko vjg "hcevu qh nkhg"ceeqtfkpi vq vjg CEETCNOI/

Vjku ngf vq yjcv vjg NkvkicvkqpRctvpgtu ecnnvjg "Ujcrg Wr qt UjkrQwvRqnke{"/

Dghqtg nqpi- vjg qvjgt rtcevkeg itqwru etgcvgf vjgkt qypOqpkvqtkpi Itqwru cpf Oqpkvqtu/ K ecppqv uvtguu vjg korqtvcpeg qhkpvgtpcn oqpkvqtkpi cickpuv kpfkxkfwcnpgingev uvtqpin{ gpqwij/ K tgecnn cpkpekfgpv yjgp qpg ncy{gt htqo cpqvjgt itqwr eqwnf pqv dg eqpvcevgf d{ ctgvckpgt enkgpvyjq ycu rtqokugf cp qtfkpct{ qrkpkqp oqpvju dghqtg/ Cu{qw mpqy- qtfkpct{ qrkpkqpu ctg eqxgtgf d{ vjg tgiwnct tgvckpgt hgg/ Khcpgzvgpukxgqrkpkqp kutgswktgf- cffkvkqpcndknnkpiuyknndg ocfg/

Kuvwodngf qp vjkukpekfgpvdgecwug o{ qyp fcwijvgt cumgf og hqtcuukuvcpeg/Chvgt c yggm qh ejcukpi vjku ijquv qh cp CEETC Ncy{gt- ujgicxg wr cpf cfxkugf jgt gornq{gt vq igv cpqvjgt ncy hkto/ Vjcv hktocuukipgf c ugpkqt rctvpgt ykvj c ygnn.fgugtxgf tgrwvcvkqp hqt eqorgvgpegcpf rtqorvpguu- cpf htqo vjgp qp- qwt tgvckpgt enkgpvtghgttgf cnnyqtm kpvjcv ctgc vq vjcv qvjgt hkto/

Gxgp vjqwij vjg enkgpvfkf pqv hvngcp cfokpkuvtcvkxg eqornckpv- Keqpukfgt vjg ocvvgt kttgrctcdng eqpukfgtkpi vjcv;

2/ CEETC nquvvjg iqqfyknn cpf eqpvkpwkpi hwvwtgtghgttcnu htqo cnctig cpf rtguvkikqwuownvkpcvkqpcnenkgpv<

3/ Yjgp cumgf d{ rtqurgevkxg enkgpvu-vjg{ yknnkpxctkcdn{ ikxg vjgktjqpguv cuuguuogpv; Oquv CEETC ncy{gtu ctg eqorgvgpv cpf fknkigpv dwvuqog ctg pgingevhwn<cpf

4/ Ikxgp vjcv jqpguv cuuguuogpv- vjqug rtqurgevkxg enkgpvuyknnuj{cyc{ htqo CEETC/

Uq owej hqt CEETC(u rjknquqrj{ "vjcv cp kpuvkvwvkqphqwpfgfwrqp cdknkv{-kpvgitkv{-cpf rtqhguukqpcn umknnyknngpfwtg" cpf vjcv CEETCyknn"rtqxkfg cpf ockpvckp swcnkv{cpf ghhkekgpvugtxkeg vq enkgpvu"/Yjgvjgtvjg ogvjqf K gornq{gf kp gphqtekpi vjg gvjkecnuvcpfctf qh "eqorgvgpegcpf fknkigpeg"- kuvjg oqtg ghhgevkxgvqqn-Kngcxgkvvq {qwt kpfkxkfwcngvjkecnlwfiogpv/

K dgnkgxg vjcv ghhgevkxgn{vcmkpi cfxcpvcig qh CEETC(u xctkqwuOqpkvqtkpi Itqwru oc{ uwhhkekgpvn{eqorn{ ykvj Spmbubo't ocpfcvg vjcv"rctvpgtu cpf rtcevkvkqpgtu" owuv crrtckug vjgougnxgu qh vjg "eqokpiu cpfiqkpiu" qh ngicn tghgttcnu cpf vjcv vjg{ ujqwnf cfqrv ogcuwtgu vq"hqtgenqug" xkqncvkqpuqh vjg Eqfg qh RtqhguukqpcnTgurqpukdknkv{/Jqygxgt-ikxgp vjg fgekukqp(u dtqcf ncpiwcig- K dgnkgxgvjcv gcej Rtcevkeg Itqwrujqwnf pqy gzrnkekvn{oqpkvqt pqv qpn{ vjg uvcvwuqh tghgttcnu- dwvncy{gtu(gvjkecncpf wpgvjkecneqpfwev cu ygnn-cpf korqug crrtqrtkcvg tgyctfu cpffkukpegpvkxgu/

Vjg ejcnngpig- hqt CEETC(u {qwpi dnqqf- cu vjg HqwpfkpiRctvpgtu hcfg- kuvq pwtvwtgvjg eqtg xcnwgqh "eqorgvgpeg cpf fknkigpeg" kpc rtqhguukqp vjcv kpetgcukpin{ vgorvu dgikppkpi ncy{gtu vq jkvej vjgkt uvctuvq oqpg{ cpf rqygt qtkgpvgf xcnwgu/

GGG.SFC SP;LR;ASGML AMTLRCJ ;LB"SFC AMLDJGAS MD GLSCPCRS" PTJC

Dgecwug qh cp kpuvkvwvkqpcnncy hkto(u nctig pwodgt qh enkgpvu-kvkuqhvgp eqphtqpvgf ykvj eqphnkevuqh kpvgtguv oqtg qhvgp vjcp c uqnqrtcevkvkqpgt/ Qwvukfg-vjg vtcfkvkqpcnnkvkicvkqpeqpvgzv- jqygxgt- c hkto hcegufkuvkpevkuuwguyjgp kvcevucu yjcv Kecnnc "vtcpucevkqp eqwpugn/"

Fwtkpi Wpkvgf UvcvguLwuvkegNqwku F/ Dtcpfgku( eqphktocvkqpjgctkpiu- vjg qpn{ kuuwgtckugf cickpuv jko eqpegtpgf jku rtqhguukqpcn gvjkeucu c rtcevkekpi ncy{gt/ Urgekhkecnn{-jg ycu ceewugf qh jcxkpi cevgf cu

eqwpugnhqt ownvkrngrctvkguykvj eqphnkevkpikpvgtguvukp vjg Ngppqz chhckt[Yjgp cumgf yjq jg tgrtgugpvgf- jg tgrnkgf; "K ujqwnf uc{ vjcv K ycueqwpugnhqt vjg ukvwcvkqp//// Kycu nqqmkpichvgtvjg kpvgtguvqh gxgt{qpg/"49

Uejqnctu etkvkek}gvjg vgto "eqwpugn hqt vjg ukvwcvkqp"cu "c okuv{rjtcug"4: qt cu "kortwfgpv"/5q Vjg uwiiguvgf cnvgtpcvkxgu"ncy{gt hqtownvkrng rctvkgu"- "ownvkrng tgrtgugpvcvkqp"- "vtcpucevkqp ocvvgtu"-"vtcpucevkqp ncy{gt"- cpf "vtcpucevkqp rtcevkeg" ctg wpucvkuhcevqt{cu vjg{cnuq kpenwfg "ukvwcvkqpu"kp yjkej vjg ncy{gt qt vjg ncy hkto eqpegtpgfkpewtugvjkecnqdnkicvkqpuvq rgtuSpu qvjgt vjcp vjg eqpugpvkpi enkgpvu/

Hqt o{ rwtrqugu- Kwug"vtcpucevkqp eqwpugn"yjkej Knkokvvq crrn{qpn{ vq ukvwcvkqpukpxqnxkpi vyq qt oqtg enkgpvu(tgrtgugpvcvkqp/ Kfghkpg vjgvgto vq tghgt vq c ncy{gt- qt c ncy hkto- yjq cevucu vjg eqooqp ncy{gt hqtvyq qt oqtg rgtuqpu hqt vjgkt owvwcndgpghkv/Vjku jcrrgpu- oqtg qhvgpvjcp pqv- kp ftchvkpi eqpvtcevu/

C iqqf gzcorng kuvjg ncy{gt kp guvcvgrtqeggfkpiu tgswguvgf d{ cnnvjg jgktu vq cfxkug vjgo qp jqy vq fkxkfg vjg guvcvgcpf vjgtgchvgt ftchv vjgtgswkukvgeqpvtcev qt hkngvjg crrtqrtkcvg cevkqp/ Cpqvjgt gzcorng kuyjgpvyq qt oqtg rctvkgu cum c ncy{gt vq rtgrctg c eqpvtcev hqt vjg ucng qhrtqrgtv{ htqo qpg vq vjg qvjgt- qt vq rtgrctg c lqkpv xgpvwtg citggogpvdgvyggp vjgo/

Kp dkncvgtcncpf ownvk.ncvgtcneqpvtcevu- rctvkgu jcxg cevwcn-pqvrqvgpvkcn-eqphnkevuqh kpvgtguv/Vcmgc ukorng eqpvtcev qh ucng/C ugnngtuggmu

/" Dtcpfgku ycu crrtqcejgf d{ Lcogu Ngppqz- c vcppgt{ qypgt- tgictfkpi jku hcknkpidwukpguu/Dtcpfgku vjgp tgrtgugpvgf qpg qh Ngppqz(u etgfkvqtu- dwvcfxkugf Ngppqz vq cuukip cuugvuvq c vtwuvvqdg qrgtcvgf d{ jku ncy rctvpgt vq fkuuwcfg etgfkvqtu htqo rwujkpi jko kpvqdcpmtwrve{/ Ngppqz rtqxgfwpeqqrgtcvkxg cpf uqqp hqwpf jkougnh cickpuv Dtcpfgku kp vjg dcpmtwrve{ rtqeggfkpi/

Vjg swqvg ycu cevwcnk{cvvtkdwvgfvq Dtcpfgku d{ Ngppqz(u eqwpugn-Ujgtocp Yjkrrng/ Jg vguvkhkgfvjcv Dtcpfgku gzrnckpgf vq jko; "Ofkf pqv citgg vq cev hqt Ot/ Ngppqz yjgp jg ecog vq og/ Yjgp cocp kudcpmtwrv cpf ecp pqv rc{ jku fgdvu- /// jg hkpfujkougnh ykvj c vtwuv-korqugf wrqp jko d{ ncy-vq ugg vjcv cnnjku rtqrgtv{ kufkuvtkdwvgfjqpguvn{ cpf hcktn{cpf gswkvcdn{coqpi cnnjku etgfkvqtu- cpf jgjcu pq hwtvjgt kpvgtguvkpvjg ocvvgt/ Uwej ycu Ot/ Ngppqz(u ukvwcvkqpyjgp jg ecog vq og- cpf jgeqpuwnvgfog ogtgn{ cu vjg vtwuvgghqt jku etgfkvqtu- cu vq jqy dguvvq fkuejctig vjcv vtwuv-cpf Kcfxkugfjko kp vjcv yc{/ Kfkf pqv kpvgpf vq cev rgtuqpcnk{ hqt Ot/ Ngppqz- pqt fkf Kcitgg vq/" En{fg Urennkpiet-Emvtjwf Aewpdbuf9Rfdpotjefsjoh Bsboefjt bt Pfpqmf't Lbxzfs: 216 [CNG N/L/2556- 2618 )2::7,/

49 Oknpgt U/Dcnk-Lbxzfst jo Cpoufyu9Mptft* Bsboefjt* boe ucfA-B-A-* 25 PQVTG FCOGL/N/ GVJKEU'ZdH1 Z·I_ 432-443 )3111,/

4: Lqjp R/ Htcpm-Tcf Lfhbm Eucjdt pkLpvjt F/ Bsboefjt* 28 UVCP/N/TGX/ 794-7:9.813 )2:76,<Igqhhtg{ E/ Jc}ctf- Lbxzfs Fps Tif Sjuvbujpo*4: XCN/W/N/TGX/488/

51 Igqhhtg{ E/ Jc}ctf- Lbxzfs Fps Tif Sjuvbujpo*4: XCN/W/N/TGX/ 488- 488 )3115,/

vjg jkijguv rtkeg ykvj pq ycttcpvkgu- qt "yjgtg ku-cu ku" dcuku/Vjg dw{gt-jcxkpi cp qrrqukpi kpvgtguv-uggmuvjg nqyguv rtkeg ykvj hwnnycttcpvkgu/

Kp citggkpi vq cfxkug dqvj- ujcnn qpg cfxkug vjg ugnngtpqv vq ikxgcp{ ycttcpvkgu dg{qpf vjqug tgswktgf d{ ncy- cpf cv vjg ucog vkog cfxkugvjcv vjg dw{gt fgocpf hwnnycttcpvkguB Eqphnkevkpikpvgtguvuctg c tgcnkv{cvvjg qwvugv/Uwrrqug vjg dw{gt kpcfxgtvgpvn{ eqphkfgu vjcv- dcugf qp jkuuvwfkgu-vjg vtwg eqoogtekcn xcnwg qh vjg rtqrgtv{ ku Z Rguqu rnwu crtgokwo qh 61&- yjkej ku eqpukfgtcdn{ jkijgt vjcp vjg rtkeg vjg ugnngteqphkfgf cu jku oczkowo rtkeg/ Fqgu qpg eqpxg{ vjku eqphkfgpvkcnkphqtocvkqp vq vjg ugnngtB

Io sf Df Lb Rptb31 tguqnxgf yjgvjgt c vtcpucevkqp eqwpugn oc{gvjkecnn{cev cu c eqooqp ncy{gt hqt rctvkgu ykvj cevwcncpf rqvgpvkcneqphnkevkpikpvgtguvu/Vjg ncy{gt vjgtg ycu gzqpgtcvgf dgecwug- ceeqtfkpi vqvjg Eqwtv;

Vjg eqornckpcpv mpgy vjcv Fg ncTquc ycu cevkpi hqt cpf qpdgjcnh qh vjg rwtejcugt dgecwugjg jcf eqphgttgf ykvj jko cujgt tgrtgugpvcvkxg/Vjg rwtejcugt mpgy vjcv jg ycu cevkpi hqtcpf qp dgjcnhqh vjg ugnngthqt rc{ dgecwugjg jcf qdvckpgfhtqojgt gzrtguu rgtokuukqpvqfq uq/

Cnvjqwij kvcrrgctu htqo vjg gxkfgpegvjcv vjg tgurqpfgpv ycucevkpi hqt cpf qp dgjcnh qh dqvj rctvkguvq vjg eqpvtqxgtu{-ygfq pqv tgictf vjkucu eqpuvkvwvkpiocnrtcevkegwpfgt vjg ncy- kvcrrgctkpi wpfkurwvgfkp vjg tgeqtf vjcv jg cevgf vjwu xjui uiflopxmfehf boe dpotfou pg cpui qbsujft joufsftufe- Vjku dgkpi vjg ecug-pgkvjgt rctv{ ycu fgegkxgf d{ tgurqpfgpv- cpf t;gkvjgt qpguwhhgtgfkpxqnwpvct{fcocigu qh jkucevkqp/53)gorjcuku uwrrnkgf,

C fkhhkewnveqphnkevqh kpvgtguvrtqdngo ctkuguyjgp qpg rctv{ tckuguitqwpfu- ogtkvqtkqwu qt wpogtkvqtkqwu- vq tgpgig qp eqpvtcevwcnqdnkicvkqpu/Khvjg dtgykpi eqpvtcevwcnfkurwvg gtwrvu kpvq cp cevwcnlwfkekcnfkurwvg-oc{ vjg vtcpucevkqpeqwpugntgrtgugpv qpg rctv{ cickpuv vjg qvjgtB

5238 Rjkn/36: )2:25,/53 ]ep cv376/

Kp Bbvujtub w- Bbssjpt*32 vjg vtcpucevkqp eqwpugn qrvgf vq fq uq/Ceeqtfkpi vq eqornckpcpv Dcwvkuvc-ujg jktgf Cvv{/ Dcttkqu vq ftchv c fggfqh gzvtc.lwfkekcnrctvkvkqp qxgt rtqrgtv{ nghvd{ jgt fgegcugf ukuvgt/Cvv{/Dcttkqu rtgrctgf vjg fggf cpf cnn vjg jgktu ukipgf kv/ Yjgp HgfgtkeqTqxgtq- jgt ukuvgt(uykfqygt- tghwugf vq eqorn{ ykvj vjg fggf(u vgtou- ujgcumgf Cvv{/Dcttkqu vq kpkvkcvgvjg crrtqrtkcvg uwkvcickpuv jko/ Cvv{/ Dcttkqufgenkpgf- cpf ujg jktgf cpqvjgt ncy{gt/

Cvv{/ Dcttkqu- jqygxgt- crrgctgf cu eqwpugn hqt Tqxgtq cpfcuugtvgf vjg fghgpug- coqpi qvjgtu- vjcv vjg fggf "fkf pqv eqpvckp cnnvjgvgtou qh vjg citggogpv" cpf vjcv "kvycu uwdlgevvq egtvckp oqfkhkecvkqpu"55yjkej vjg eqornckpcpv mpgy cv vjg vkog qh vjg gzgewvkqp qh vjg fggf/ Kptgurqpug vq cp cfokpkuvtcvkxg eqornckpv- Cvv{/ Dcttkqu cuugtvgf vjcv kvycuTqxgtq- pqv vjg eqornckpcpv- yjq jktgf jku ugtxkegu-cpf vjcv cv oquv- jgcevgf cu eqooqp eqwpugnhqt cnnvjg jgktu/

]Gaxgp uwrrqukpi vjcv- cu enckogf d{ Cvv{/ Dcttkqu- jg ycufnqmrzfe t{ cpui Rpwfsp boe uif Bbvujtub cspuifst )uke,vq ftchv vjgrctvkvkqp-ju jt epvcjgvmxifuifs if dpvmebqqfbs gps pof bt bhbjotu uif puifsjo tvctfrvfou mjujhbujpo-Cv oquv- khjg eqwnfcrrgct hqt qpg enkgpv-kvujqwnf dggps ijn xip tfflt upfogpsdfvjg rctvkvkqpcu ftchvgt/ [gv jgcrrgctgf hqt Tqxgtq yjq uqwijv vq cxqkf eqornkcpeg ykvj kv-cuugtvkpivjcv kvfkf pqv eqpvckpcnnvjg vgtou qh vjg citggogpv-vjcv kvycu uwdlgevvqegtvckpoqfkhkecvkqpu-gve/Oqtgqxgt- kpjkufghgpug qh Tqxgtq- jg tckugf kuuwguyjkej qdxkqwun{xkqncvgfTwhkpc(ueqphkfgpeg-dgecwugjg cnngigf. kp dgjcnh qh Tqxgtq. vjcv vjg wpfkuenqugfoqfkhkecvkqpuygtg mpqyp vq Twhkpccvvjg vkogqh vjg gzgewvkqpqhvjg rctvkvkqp/56)gorjcuku uwrrnkgf,

2/ Kvogtgn{ qrkpgf vjcv "kvku fqwdvhwnyjgvjgt" c vtcpucevkqpeqwpugn"eqwnf crrgct Lqt qpg" qh vjg eqpvtcevkpi rctvkgu"cu cickpuvvjg qvjgtkpuwdugswgpvnkvkicvkqp/"

54 C/E/ Pq/ 369- : UgTC 7:6- Fge/ 32- 2:74/66 Ie- cv 7:8/34 Ie- cv 7:8/

3/ Kvogtgn{ uwiiguvgf vjcv "kh" c vtcpucevkqpeqwpugn"eqwnf crrgct hqtqpg enkgpv-kvujqwnf dg hqt jko yjq uggmuvq gphqteg vjg rctvkvkqpcuftchvgt/"

4/ Kvuqpn{ fghkpkvkxgtwnkpi ku vjcv d{ rngcfkpi- qp dgjcnh qh qpgeqpvtcevkpi rctv{- c hcev qt ektewouvcpeg pqv uvcvgf kp vjg ytkvvgpeqpvtcev cpf enckokpi vjcv uwej wpuvcvgf hcev qt ektewouvcpeg kumpqyp vq vjg qvjgt rctv{- vjg vtcpucevkqpeqwpugnxkqncvgfvjg ncvvgt(ueqphkfgpeg/

Gftvefo wt- Ffssfm'5 ku ukoknctn{wpengct/ Vjg tgurqpfgpv ncy{gt kpvjcv ecug rtgrctgf c fggf qh gzvtclwfkekcnrctvkvkqp vjcv cnnjgktu gzgewvgf/Uwdugswgpvn{-qp dgjcnh qh qpg jgkt- jg hkngf c ecug fkurwvkpi vjg ucogrctvkvkqp/ Kp jku fghgpug- jg enckogf vjcv jg cfxkugf jku enkgpvcickov hknkpivjg uwkv/Kpqxgttwnkpi vjkufghgpug- vjg Eqwtv jgnf;

]Vajg rtqrgt vjkpi hqt jko vqfq ycu pqvvqkpxqnxgjkougnhkpkv/Cu vq jku ykvjftcycn vjgtghtqo- vjg qtfgt qh vjg eqwtvcnnqykpijko vq fq uq ujqyu vjcv jg ykvjftgy chvgtjg jcf rtgugpvgf vjgrtkpekrcngxkfgpeghqt vjg rnckpvkhh/

Yg jqnf vjcv vjg tgurqpfgpv xkqncvgfjku fwv{cu c ncy{gt yjgpjg crrgctgf cueqwpugnhqt qpg qhvjg jgktukpjgt uwkvcickpuvvjgqvjgt jgktu qxgt c ocvvgt yjkej vjg tgurqpfgpv jcf jcpfngf hqtcnnqh vjgo/ 58

Gftvefo kuwpucvkuhcevqt{dgecwug kvrgtgorvqtkn{ twngf- ykvjqwv cp{gzrncpcvkqp- vjcv vjg ncy{gt "xkqncvgf jku fwv{" d{ jku crrgctcpeg cu eqwpugnhqt qpg rctv{ cu cickpuv vjg qvjgt/ Bbvujtub cv ngcuvcvvgorvgf vq fkuvkpiwkujdgvyggp vjg ncy{gt tgrtgugpvkpi vjg rctv{ uggmkpi vq dg htggf htqo jkuqdnkicvkqpu cu eqorctgf vq vjg ncy{gt tgrtgugpvkpi vjg rctv{ uggmkpi vqgphqteg vjg eqpvtcev ceeqtfkpi vq kvugzrtguu vgtou/

Vjg 3116 ecug qh Fsjbt w-Lp}beb37 rtgugpvgf cpqvjgt qh vjg eqphnkevqh kpvgtguv twng(u curgevu- cu kv crrnkgu vq c vtcpucevkqp eqwpugn/ Cvv{/Ectogpekvc Nq}cfc kp vjcv ecug cevgf cu vjg dw{gt cpf vjg ugnngt(ueqooqp

57 C/E/ Pq/ 2917- 239 UETC 468- Oct/ 34- 2:95/'6 !e- cv 471 /| 9 C/E/ Pq/ 7767- 588 UETC 4:4 Fge/ 24-3116/

eqwpugncpf- cv vjg ucog vkog- cu vjg ugnngt(urckf dtqmgt/ Dqvj rctvkgu ygtgvjgp jgt gzkuvkpienkgpvukp wptgncvgf ocvvgtu/

Chvgt vjg rctvkgu jcf rctvkcnn{korngogpvgf vjg eqpvtcev cpf Cvv{/Nq}cfc ycu rckf jgt dtqmgt(u eqookuukqp- c fkurwvg gtwrvgf yjkej ngf vqvjg hknkpiqh ugxgtcn uwkvukpxqnxkpi vjg rctvkgu-kpenwfkpi Cvv{/ Nq}cfc yjq-fgurkvg vjg hcev vjcv vjg ucngycu cdqtvgf- tghwugf vq tgvwtp vjg dtqmgt(ueqookuukqp ujg tgegkxgf/ Qpg uwej uwkvgpfgf ykvj vjg eqwtv qtfgtkpi jgtvq tgvwtp vjku eqookuukqp/

Vjg Eqwtv twngf vjcv kvycu wpgvjkecn hqt Cvv{/ Nq}cfc vq jcxgcevgf cu vjg eqookuukqp dtqmgt cpf- cvvjg ucog vkog- vjg eqooqp eqwpugndgecwug;

Ujg gxgp jcf vjg vgogtkv{vqdtqmgtvjg vtcpucevkqp/Cv vjcvgctn{uvcig-ujg ujqwnf jcxg tgcnk}gfvjcv jgt tqngcu vjgkt ncy{gt jcfdggp ugtkqwun{eqortqokugf/ Ukpegdw{gt cpf ugnngtjcf gxkfgpvcpvciqpkuvkekpvgtguvu-ujg eqwnf pqv ikxg dqvj qh vjgo uqwpfngicncfxkeg/Qp vqr qh vjku-tgurqpfgpv(u qdxkqwuvgpfgpe{ vjgpycu vqjgnr eqornckpcpvigv c jkij ugnnkpirtkeg ukpegvjg coqwpvqh jgt eqookuukqp ycu fgrgpfgpv qp kv/

Vjg tgeqtfu hwtvjgt guvcdnkujvjcv tgurqpfgpv eqnngevgfjgt hwnneqookuukqp gxgp dghqtg vjg vtcpucevkqpdgvyggp eqornckpnovcpf Ucp Fkgiq ycu eqorngvgf/ Vjku wpocumgf tgurqpfgpv(uitggf yjkej ujg pqy ycpvu wuuq dcfn{ vq kipqtg/ Jgt kpvgitkv{ycu rncegf kp ugtkqwu fqwdv vjg oqogpv jgt rtqokugfeqookuukqp uvctvgf oqvkxcvkpijgt gxgt{ oqxg/ Jgt dgjcxkqtycu- ucf vquc{-ukorn{fkuvcuvghw2/5:

Ecpqp 26 rtqxkfgu vjg kpkvkcngvjkecntwnguvjcv iqxgtp vjgvtcpucevkqpncy{gt(u eqpfwev cv vjg vkog vjcvAjg citggu vq cev cuuwej;61

ECPQP 26 . C NCY[GT UJCNN QDUGTXG ECPFQT-HCKTPGUUCPF NQ[CNV[ KP CNNJKUFGCNKPIU CPFVTCPUCEVKQPU YKVJ JKUENKGPV/

5: .e- cv512.13/61 EQFG QH RTQHGUUKQPCNTGURQPUKDKWVK-Ecpqp 26/

Twng 26/12 . C ncy{gt- kp eqphgttkpi ykvj c rtqurgevkxg enkgpv-ujcnn cuegtvckp cu uqqp cu rtcevkecdng yjgvjgt vjg ocvvgt yqwnfkpxqnxg c eqphnkevykvj cpqvjgt enkgpvqt jku qyp kpvgtguv-cpf khuq- ujcnn hqtvjykvj kphqto vjg rtqurgevkxg enkgpv/

Twng 26/13 . C ncy{gt ujcnn dg dqwpf d{ vjg twng qp rtkxkngigeqoowpkecvkqp kp tgurgev qh ocvvgtu fkuenqugf vq jko d{ crtqurgevkxg enkgpv/

Twng 26/14 . C ncy{gt ujcnn pqv tgrtgugpv eqphnkevkpi kpvgtguvgzegrv d{ ytkvvgp eqpugpv qh cnn eqpegtpgf ikxgp chvgt c hwnnfkuenquwtg qh vjg hcevu/

Kvkukorgtcvkxg- vjcv vjg tghgttkpi enkgpvu-yjgvjgt qpn{ qpg qt dqvjctg gzkuvkpi enkgpvu-ctg koogfkcvgn{ ocfg cyctg qh vjgug twng(ugzrtguuvgtou- ogcpkpi cpf kornkecvkqpuqp vjg rtqrqugf ngicnvtcpucevkqpdgecwug;

2/ Wpnkmgvjg qnf Ecpqpu qh Rtqhguukqpcn Gvjkeu yjkej ogtgn{tgswktgf "gzrtguu eqpugpv"62 vjcv eqwnf dg rtqxgp d{ektewouvcpvkcngxkfgpeg- cu uggp kp Fg nc Tquc cpf Dcwvkuvc-Twng26/14 pqy tgswktgu "ytkvvgp eqpugpv"/

3/ Kp tgpfgtkpi ngicn ugtxkegu-vjg vtcpucevkqp ncy{gt yknnpgeguuctkn{tgswktg c jquv qh kphqtocvkqp cpf fqewogpvu htqo vjg enkgpvu/Cuqdugtxgf d{ vjg UqnkekvqtIgpgtcn kp Iguwfgp kp vjg eqwtug qhftchvkpi c eqpvtcev- vjg eqwpugnceswktgumpqyngfig qh tgngxcpv cpfkttgngxcpv hcevu-ugetgv cpf ygnn mpqyp hcevu-fcvc cpf kphqtocvkqpvjcv okijv rtglwfkeg qpg qt cnnqh vjg eqpvtcevkpi rctvkgu/

4/ Kvkurtwfgpv vq tgeqipk}g vjg uwduvcpvkcntkumvjcv vjg eqpvtcevkpienkgpvu(tgncvkqpujkr oc{ uqwt vq c ngxgnvjcv vjgtg okijv cpug cfkurwvgyjkej yqwnf hqteg qpg rctv{ vq uwgvjg qvjgt/

5/ Hqt vjcv tgcuqp- vjg tqng vjcv vjg vtcpucevkqpncy{gt yknncuuwog kpecug qh c fkurwvg ujqwnf koogfkcvgn{ dg fkuewuugf ykvj- cpftguqnxgf d{- vjg enkgpvugxgp dghqtg vjg vtcpucevkqp uvctvuyqtmkpiqp vjgkt tghgttcn/

62 Twng7)3,- tgictfkpi "Aewfstf jogmvfodfeoe dpogmjdujohjoufsftut" rtqxkfgf; "Ktkuwprtqhguukqpcnvqtgrtgugpt eqphnkevkpikpvgtguvu-gzegrv d{ gzrtguu eqpugpt qh cnneqpegtpgf ikxgp chvgt hwnnfkuenquwtgqhvjg hcevu/"

Kh vyq enkgpvurtqrqukpi vjcv CEETC cev cu vjgkt vtcpucevkqpeqwpugnctg dqvj tgvckpgt enkgpvu-kuvjg tgswktgf ytkvvgp eqpugpv eqornkgfykvj d{ vjkurtqxkukqp qh vjg CEETC TgvckpgtCitggogpvB;

Eqphnkevqh Kpvgtguv;Kpecug cp{ ocvvgt ujqwnf ctkug dgvyggp {qwcpf cpqvjgt enkgpvqh vjku qhhkeg-d{ xktvwgqh yjkej yg okijvjcxg c eqphnkev qh kpvgtguv wpfgt vjg eqfg qh rtqhguukqpcntgurqpukdknkv{yjkej dkpfu cnnncy{gtu- yg tgugtxg vjg tkijv vqkpjkdkv qwtugnxgu htqo tgrtgugpvkpi {qw cpf0qt qwt qvjgtenkgpv)u,kpuqhct cu vjcv rctvkewnctocvvgt kueqpegtpgf/

Kp o{ qrkpkqp- vjg cnn.gpeqorcuukpi ncpiwcig fqgu pqv eqpuvkvwvgvjg "ytkvvgp eqpugpv" tgswktgf d{ Twng26/14 hqt vjgug tgcuqpu;

2/ Twng 26/14 tgswktgu vjcv vjg "ytkvvgp eqpugpv" owuv dg"ikxgp chvgtc hwnnfkuenquwtgqh vjg hcevu/"

3/ Cv vjg vkog vjcv vjg TgvckpgtCitggogpv ycu gpvgtgf kpvq-"vjg hcevu"rgewnkctvq vjg urgekhkengicn ocvvgt ctg pqv {gvmpqyp qt oc{ jcxg {gvvq qeewt/

4/ Kvkuqpn{ cv vjg vkog vjcv vjg rtqrqugf tghgttcn kuocfg cpfchvgt c rtgnkokpct{ enkgpvkpvgtxkgy ku eqpfwevgf ecp vjgCEETC ncy{gt kfgpvkh{ tgngxcpv kphqtocvkqp vjcv oc{pggf vq dg fkuenqugf vq jko khjg ku gzrgevgf vq tgpfgtucvkuhcevqt{ugtxkeg/

5/ Dgukfgu-vjg swqvgf Tgvckpgt Citggogpv crrnkgu qpn{ vq cukvwcvkqpyjgtg CEETC fgekfgu vq kpjkdkv kvugnhhtqocevkpi cu eqwpugn qh qpg qh vyq enkgpvuykvj eqphnkevkpikpvgtguvu-pqv yjgtg vjqug enkgpvu vjgougnxgu tgswguvCEETC cu vjgkt eqooqp eqwpugn qp c urgekhke ngicnocvvgt/

Vjg kpkvkcnrtqrgt rtqegfwtg- K uwiiguv- ku vjcv dqvj eqpvtcevkpirctvkgu dg rtgugpv yjgp vjg vtcpucevkqpeqwpugndtkghuvjgo qp vjg tgngxcpvgvjkecntwngu/

Ykvjqwv xkqncvkpienkgpvu(eqphkfgpegu- K yknncvvgorv vq knnwuvtcvgo{ rtqrqukvkqp ykvj cp cevwcn vtcpucevkqp/ Vgff{ Tgicnc ycu vjguwrgtxkukpi rctvpgt qh vjg tgvckpgt vgco ugtxkpi Enkgpv2- yjkng Kycu vjg

uwrgtxnUnpi rctvpgt qh vjg vgco ugtxkpi Enkgpv3/ Vjg vtcpucevkqp ctqugyjgp Rctvpgt Z- c ogodgt qh Vgff{ Tgicnc(u tgvckpgt vgco- tgswguvgf ogvq cumEnkgpv3 yjgvjgt kvycu rquukdngvq tgcej uqog cttcpigogpv vq cxgtvc rquukdng dwukpguu eqnnkukqpdgvyggp vjgo/ Enkgpv 3 ecpfkfn{ tgrnkgf;"Gxgt{vjkpi ku rquukdng/ VgnnEnkgpv2 qt jku ncy{gtu vq igv kp vqwej ykvjog/"

Hqt ugxgtcn yggmu- K fkf pqv jgct qh cp{ fgxgnqrogpvu/ Qpgchvgtpqqp- Vgff{ Tgicnc vqnf og d{ rjqpg vq rtqeggf- ykvjkp vjg jqwt- vq chkxg.uvctjqvgn hqt cp wtigpv GzgewvkxgEqookvvgg Oggvkpi/ Vjgtg- KhqwpfGf Cpictc- Vgff{ Tgicnc cu vjg Ocpcikpi Rctvpgt- Htcpm Ftknqp cu vjg Eq.Ocpcikpi Rctvpgt cpf Rctvpgt Z/ Vjg{ ygtg cnnkp c uqodgt oqqf cpfcrrgctgf vq jcxg dggp oggvkpi hqt uqog vkog/ Kiqv vjg kortguukqp vjcv GfCpictc ycu tgswguvgf vq cev cu c uqtv qh bnjdvt-

Cv vjcv oggvkpi- Kycu vqnf vjcv Enkgpv2 cpf Enkgpv3 jcf citggf- kprtkpekrng- qp hqtikpi c dwukpguucnnkcpeg<vjcv vjg etwekcnpgiqvkcvkqp yknneqoogpeg vjcv gxgpkpi qp c "ocmg qt dtgcm" dcuku<vjcv vjg rctvpgturtgugpv jcf fgekfgf vjcv CEETC ujqwnf- fwtkpi vjg pgiqvkcvkqpu- cevogtgn{ cu cp cfxkugt cpf qpn{ khcumgf d{ vjg enkgpvu<vjcv kvyqwnf dg cokuvcmghqt cp CEETC ncy{gt vq cfxqecvg c ikxgp rqukvkqpd{ qpg rctv{ kpqrrqukvkqp vq vjg qvjgt(u rtqrqucn< vjcv khvjg fgnkecvgocvvgt kupqv jcpfngfrtqrgtn{- kvoc{ gxgp ecwugvjg hkto(u dtgcmwr/

UkpegKycu igvvkpi vjg kortguukqp- ytqpin{ qt tkijvn{- vjcv vjg "tkqvcev" ycu dgkpi tgcf vq og- Kcuuwtgf vjgo- kp vjg eqwtug qh vjg dtkghkpi-vjcvvjg{ ujqwnf pqv yqtt{ dgecwug Enkgpv3 jcf pqv vqnf og vjcv jg jcf citggf-kp rtkpekrng- vq gpvgt kpvqcp{ vtcpucevkqpykvj Enkgpv2- owej nguutgswguvgfog vq cuukuvvjgo kp cp{ pgiqvkcvkqp/Hwtvjgt- dcugf qp o{ fgcnkpiu ykvjEnkgpv3- K ycuz uwtg vjcv vjg{ yqwnf jcxg citggf vq vjg CEETC twngudgecwug vjcv ycu- cp{yc{- vjgkt qyp rtqegfwtg yjgp pgiqvkcvkpi korqtvcpvdwukpguueqpvtcevu/ O{ rtqvguvcvkqpuygtg dtwujgf cukfg dgecwug vjg{ ygtguwtg vjcv- dghqtg vjg gpf qh vjg chvgtpqqp- Enkgpv3 yqwnf cum og vq dgrtgugpv fwtkpi vn<L/gpgiqvkcvkqpu/Cpf vjg enkgpvfkf/

Vjg pgiqvkcvkqpu vqqm rnceg vjcv pkijv cpf gpfgf cv 6 CO/ Ygygtg vjgp cnntgswguvgf vq lqkp Enkgpv2 cv jku Hqtdgu Rctm tgukfgpeg cv 8CO- cpf cv 9 CO- vjg vyq enkgpvuujqqm jcpfu vq ugcnvjgkt citggogpv/

Vjg eqpxgtucvkqp ycu rtqxqmgf d{ Enkgpv 2 cpf K rctvkekrcvgfykvjqwv dgkpi cumgf vq;

(beesfttjoh Cmjfou3, Ukpegqwt ejknftgp ctg wpcyctgqh yjcv yg citggf wrqp- Kvjkpmvjcv kvyqwnf dg ciqqf kfgc vq cumCEETC vq rwv qwt citggogpv kpytkvkpi/

K jcxg pq rtqdngo ykvj vjcv/ Vjg{ ctg cnuq o{ncy{gtu/

K vjkpm vjcv {qw ujqwnf jktg {qwt tgurgevkxgncy{gtu vq ftchv vjg eqpvtcev dgecwug CEETC kukpc eqphnkevqh kpvgtguvukvwcvkqpkp vjkuvtcpucevkqp/

Pqvjkpi kuytqpi ykvj vjcv khvjg enkgpvugzrtguun{eqpugpv vjcv CEETC cev cu vjg ncy{gt hqt dqvj qhvjgo/

Kpecug qh c fkurwvg-yjq yqwnf {qw nkmgvq fgekfgvjg eqpvtqxgtu{; vjg eqwtvu qt cp ctdkvtcvkqpdqctfB

Kuwiiguv vjcv yg uwdokvvjg fkurwvg vq ctdkvtcvkqp/Yjcv fq {qw vjkpm)cfftguukpi Enkgpv2,B

Jqy yqwnf {qw ugngev vjg ogodgtu qh vjgctdkvtcvkqpdqctfB

Yg fq kvpqy/ K pqokpcvg CEETC/ )cfftguukpiEnkgpv2, Yjcv fq {qw vjkpmB

Yjq kp CEETC yknn eqorqug vjg ctdkvtcvkqpdqctfB

Vjku eqpxgtucvkqp ngf vjg rctvkgu vq citgg qp fghkpkvg CEETCncy{gtu yjq yqwnf eqorqug vjg vjtgg.ocp ctdkvtcvkqpdqctf/

Chvgt K cpcn{}gf vjg ytkvvgp uvkrwncvkqpqp ctdkvtcvkqp- K dgicpgpvgtvckpkpi fqwdvu qp kvugvjkecnxcnkfkv{-cu CEETC cevgf cu vjg eqooqpngicncfxkugt fwtkpi vjg pgiqvkcvkqpucpf- hwtvjgt- ftchvgf vjg eqpvtcev/

O{ fqwdvu ygtg tguqnxgf kp 2:98- hqtvwpcvgn{hqt og- yjgp vjgrtgugpv Twng 26/15 gzrtguun{ rgtokvvgf c vtcpucevkqp eqwpugn vq cev cu cpctdkvtcvqt; "Twng 26/15 . C ncy{gt oc{- ykvj vjg ytkvvgp eqpugpv qh cnneqpegtpgf- cev cu ogfkcvqt- eqpeknkcvqtqt ctdkvtcvqt kp ugvvnkpifkurwvgu/"63

Twng 26/15- kp o{ qrkpkqp- kugokpgpvn{ vjg rtghgtcdng uqnwvkqpvqvjg wptguqnxgf kuuwgqh yjgvjgt CEETC oc{ cev cu eqwpugnhqt qpg rctv{cickpuv vjg qvjgt kp ecug qh c eqpvtcev fkurwvg/

Vyq qvjgt ocvvgtu- Kuwiiguv- ujqwnf dg fkuewuugf ykvj vjg enkgpvucv vjg kpegrvkqp/

Vjg hktuv ku vjg rtwfgpeg qh etgcvkpi vyq ugrctcvg cpfkpfgrgpfgpvn{ yqtmkpi vgcou vq ugtxkeg enkgpvu(tgurgevkxg tgswktgogpvuyjkng CEETC kukp vjg rtqeguu qh fqewogpvkpi vjgkt lwtkfkecntgncvkqpujkr/Kp ownvkrctv{ vtcpucevkqpu oqtg vjcp vyq vgcou yknndg tgswktgf vq cuukuvgcej enkgpv/

Vjg qvjgt ku vjg cfxkucdknkv{qh gtgevkpi c Ejkpgug Ycnn dgvyggpcpf coqpi vjg ugrctcvg vgcou- cpf vjg tguv qh vjg CEETC ncy{gtu kpigpgtcn/

C Ejkpgug Ycnn ku fkhhgtgpv htqo vjg Itgcv Ycnn qh Ejkpc/ Kvycukpxgpvgf d{ vjg Ycnn Uvtggvdcpmu cpf qvjgt hkpcpekcnkpuvkvwvkqpuvq ikxgvjgo uqog eqohqtv kp enckokpi vjcv vjg{ cevgf korctvkcnn{ kp dgkpi vjgngpfgt qt hkpcpekgt qh c ikxgp vtcpucevkqp-uwej cu c ogtigt- cp ceswkukvkqp-qt c ukorng nqcp cpf- cv vjg ucog vkog- vjg hkpcpekcncfxkugt qh vjg fgdvqt

cpf vjg qvjgt eqpvtcevkpi rctvkgu/ Kp uwej c ukvwcvkqp-vjg dcpm etgcvgu cvgco vjcv ujcnn cuukuvkvuqhhkegtuykvj vjg rtqrqugf vtcpucevkqp(u hkpcpekcncurgevu- cpf cpqvjgt vgco qt vgcou yknndg etgcvgf vq cuukuvvjg fgdvqt cpfqvjgt eqpvtcevkpi rctvkgu/ Vjgug vgcou ctg rtqjkdkvgf htqo fkuewuukpiykvjcp{ ocvvgt tgncvkpivq vtcpucevkqpykvj vjg qvjgtu/

Vjg rtqdngo ykvj vjg Ejkpgug Ycnn kuvjcv kvkuocfg qh dcodqq-nkmgvjg ycnnu qh qtfkpct{ dgftqqou kp Ejkpc/ Eqpxgtucvkqpu cpf cevu vcmkpirnceg kp qpg tqqo ecp dg jgctf kp vjg cflqkpkpi tqqou/

Dghqtg nqpi- vjg Ycnn Uvtggvncy hktou kokvcvgf vjgkt enkgpvu/Vjku kupqy wuwcnn{fqpg yjgp c ncy hkto yqtmu qp c eqtrqtcvg ocvvgt hqt crwdnken{nkuvgfeqtrqtcvkqp vjcv oc{ chhgevkvuujctg rtkeg/ Vjg Ejkpgug Ycnnycu vjwu gtgevgf rtkoctkn{ vq rtgxgpv kpukfgt vtcfkpi/ Qwvukfg vjg ncy hktocpf kp c dtqcfgt eqpvgzv- vjg Wpkvgf UvcvguUgewtkvkgucpf GzejcpigEqookuukqp rtgekugn{ tgswktgu Ejkpgug Ycnnu vqfc{ vq rtgxgpv kpukfgtvtcfkpi/

Cu c tguwnv qh Cogtkecp ncy hktou( htgp}kgf ogtigtu cpfeqpuqnkfcvkqpu kp tgegpv {gctu- vjgtg jcu dggp ukipkhkecpvncy{gt okitcvkqphtqo qpg hkto vq cpqvjgt/ Vjku ncvgtcnjktkpi pgeguuctkn{etgcvgf vjg tgcnfcpigt- pqv ogtgn{ rqvgpvkcn-qh eqphnkevuqh kpvgtguv/Vq cxqkf fkuswcnkh{kpigpvktg hktou- Cogtkecp hktou jcxg gtgevgf Ejkpgug Ycnnu ctqwpf pgy jktguyjq rtgxkqwun{ tgrtgugpvgf gzkuvkpienkgpvu(qrrqpgpvu/ Kowuv cff vjcv vjggzrtguukqp "Ejkpgug Ycnn"- dgecwug qh kvu "rqvgpvkcnn{ qhhgpukxg cpfnkpiwkuvkecnn{fkuetkokpcvqt{" vqpg- jcu dggp tgrncegf d{ vjg oqtg rqnkvkecnn{eqttgev vgtou "gvjkecn uetggpu"- "kpuwncvkqpycnnu"-"gvjkecnycnnu"- "eqpgu qhukngpeg"-qt "hktgycnnu"/64

Kphgttkpi htqo vjku rtcevkeg- qwt Eqfg qh RtqhguukqpcnTgurqpukdknkv{pqy tgswktgu c ncy hkto vq gtgev c Ejkpgug Ycnn yjgp vjgenkgpvuq kpuvtwevu;

" O/ Revet Oquet- Cijoftf Wbmmt9A Mfbot OgA wpjejohLpmm)Fjsn DjtrvbmjgjdbujpoWifo A LbxzfsPfstpobmmzDjtrmmbmjgjfeJpjotTif Fjsn* 4 IGQ L/NGICN GVJKEU4:: )2::1,< Ejtkuvqrjet Fwppkicp- Tif s-msuFpsnfsmz Kop}woAt Tif Cijoftf Wbmm9Sdsffojoh jo Lb}wI'jsnt9 WI!<"Wifo* Aoe H/0V* 22 IGQ/ L/NGICNGVJKEU3:2 )2::9,< UwucpUjcrktq- mImuAjo'u Bsplf --- Ao Enqjsjdbm Pfstqfdujwfjo Euijdt 1///* Sdnojm(j!*-boeuif Cpogmjdu,pgIoufsftu Rvmft*3114 W/KNNN/ TGX/ 23:: )3114,<Ltuqp Jwpiethqtf- Wpsljoh Wjui I.>'ibuWf'wfGpu9Tpxbse A Mpefn Aqqspbdi Tp EuijdbmSdsff0mS*29 IGQ/L/ NGICN GVJKEU 934 )3116,< RcwnT/Vteodnc{- Mjhsbujoh L"*szfst Aoe Tif Euijdt Og CpogmjduCifdljoh* 2: IGQ/ L/NGICN GVJKEU 59: )3117,/

Twng32/15 . C ncy{gt oc{ fkuenqugvjg chhcktuqh c enkgpvqh vjghkto vq rctvpgtu qt cuuqekcvguvjgtgqh wpnguurtqjkdkvgf d{ vjgenkgpv/

Twng32/16 . C ncy{gt ujcnncfqrv uwej ogcuwtgu cu oc{ dgtgswktgf vq rtgxgpv vjqug yjqug ugtxkeguctg wvknk}gfd{ jko-htqo fkuenqukpiqt wukpieqphkfgpeguqt ugetgvuqh vjg enkgpv/

Twng 32/15(u ncpiwcig "wpnguu rtqjkdkvgf d{ vjg enkgpv"wpokuvcmcdn{ itcpvu vq vjg enkgpv vjg cduqnwvg tkijv vq rtqjkdkv vjgfkuenquwtgqh jku tghgttcn(u fgvcknuvq rctvpgtu cpf cuuqekcvguqvjgt vjcp vjqugyqtmkpi qp jku tghgttcn/ Kpvjcv ukvwcvkqp-kvkuocpfcvqt{ hqt CEETC- wpfgtTwng32/16 vq cfqrv ogcuwtgu vq rtgxgpv vjg fkuenquwtgqh "eqphkfgpegu qtugetgvu" vq vjqug gzenwfgf rctvpgtu cpf cuuqekcvgu/C Ejkpgug Ycnn ku qpguwej ogcuwtg/

Kvokijv kpvgtguv{qw vq mpqy vjcv gxgp dghqtg vjg rtgugpv Ecpqp32 ycu rtqownicvgf- CEETC jcu dggp etgcvkpi Ejkpgug Ycnnu hqt urgekhkehknguyjgtg vjg enkgpvutgswguv vjcv vjgkt chhcktupqv dg fkuenqugf vq rctvkewnctncy{gtu- qt vq cnnqvjgt CEETC ncy{gtu qwvukfgvjg tgngxcpv vgco/

Kcnuqcumgf QDV vq rqnnCEETC cuuqekcvgutgictfkpi urgekhkegvjkecneqpegtpu/ Vjg hqnnqykpicrrgct vq tgrtgugpv vjgkt ockp swgtkgu;

2/ Jqy fq {qw lwuvkh{wukpi gzvtcngicn ogcuwtgu vq rtqvgev cenkgpv(ukpvgtguvu-gxgp yjgp vjg enkgpvkuengctn{gpvkvngfvqtgnkghcu c ocvvgt qh ncy- yjgp {qw ctg cyctg vjcv fqkpi uqyknn eqpvtkdwvg vq vjg tcorcpv eqttwrvkqp kp qwt ngicnu{uvgo- gxgp kpfktgevn{B

3/ Jqy fq {qw tgurqpf yjgp c lwfig qt qpg qh jku uvchhogodgtu kuengctn{uqnkekvkpic dtkdgB

4/ Yjcv ctg vjg gvjkecn tguvtkevkqpu qp fcvkpi c enkgpv(ufcwijvgtB

5/ Yjcv ctg vjg gvjkecntguvtkevkqpuqp fcvkpi {qwt uwrgtxkukpiRctvpgt(u fcwijvgtB

Kujcnncnnqy QDV vq cfftguu vjg ncvvgtvyq rtguukpi eqpegtpu kp jkufc{ftgcou- cnvjqwij Kco ewtkqwudgecwugoquv rctvpgtu( fcwijvgt/u ctg ygnndgnqy gkijvggp {gctu qh cig/ Cu hqt vjg hktuv vyq swgtkgu- Ecpqp 2-rctvkewnctn{Twng2/12- cpuygtu dqvj;

ECPQP 2 . C NCY[GT UJCNN WRJQNF VJGEQPUVKVWVKQP-QDG[ VJG NCYU QH VJG NCPF CPFRTQOQVG TGURGEV HQT VJG NCY CPF HQT NGICNRTQEGUUGU/

Twng2/12 . C ncy{gt ujcnnpqv gpicig kp wpncyhwn-fkujqpguv-kooqtcn qt fgegkvhwneqpfwev/

Vjg eqpetgvg cpuygt vq vjg ugeqpf swguvkqp ku; K vgnn-cu K jcxgfqpg kp uqog kpuvcpegu-vjg Lwfig qt jku uvchhvjcv Kco pqv cwvjqtk}gf d{o{ enkgpvvq cev qp uwej ocvvgtu dwvvjcv Kyknntghgt vjg ocvvgt vq jko/

Cu uqqp cu Ktgvwtp vq vjg qhhkeg-Kkoogfkcvgn{ ecnnvjg enkgpvhqt coggvkpi fwtkpi yjkej Kkphqto jko qh vjg uqnkekvcvkqp/Kvgnnvjg enkgpvjgoc{qt oc{ pqv cev qp vjg uqnkekvcvkqpcpf tgswguv vjcv jg fqgu pqv vgnnogyjcv jg rtqrqugu vq fq- qt pqv fq- uq vjcv Kyknnpqv dg hqtegf vq tgrqtv vjgocvvgt vq vjg rtqrgt cwvjqtkvkgu/Vjku tgurqpug ku dcugf qp Ecpqp 26-rctvkewnctn{Twng26/17 cpf Twng26/18;

ECPQP 26 . C NCY[GT UJCNN QDUGTXG ECPFQT-HCKTPGUUCPF NQ[CNV[ KP CNN JKU FGCNKPIU CPFVTCPUCEVQPU YKVJ JKU ENKGPV/

Twng26/17 . C ncy{gt ujcnnpqv uvcvgqt korn{ vjcv jg kucdngvq kphnwgpegcp{ rwdnkeqhhkekcn-vtkdwpcnqt ngikuncvkxgdqf{/

(Twng26/18 . C ncy{gt ujcnnkortguu wrqp jku enkgpveqornkcpegykvj vjg ncyucpf vjg rtkpekrnguqh hcktpguu/

Dcugf qp o{ vtckpkpi htqo o{ rctgpvu cpf htqo o{ uejqqn- cpfo{ gzrgtkgpeg cu c rtkxcvg rtcevkvkqpgt- eqttwrvkpi rwdnke qhhkekcnu-oquvgurgekcnn{vjqug kp vjg lwfkekcncpf qvjgt cflwfkecvqt{ u{uvgou- ecp pgxgt dglwuvkhkgf/

O{ hktuvgzrgtkgpeg ykvj eqttwrvkqp cu cp curktkpi ncy{gt ycu yjgpKceegrvgf vjg kpxkvcvkqpqh vjg ncvgUgpcvqt Lqug f1 Fkqmpq hqt c rquukdngrqukvkqp kp jku ncy qhhkeg/Uqog qh {qw oc{ mpqy vjcv vjg ncvg UgpcvqtFkqmpq vkgf ykvj Ugpcvqt Lqxkvq Ucnqpic hqt vjg 2:55 Dct Gzcokpcvkqpu(vqr rqukvkqp/ Jg ycu cnuq c EgtvkhkgfRwdnkeCeeqwpvcpv/

Fwtkpi vjg kpvgtxkgy- jg cumgf yjcv uwdlgevuKuvwfkgf cv vjg NcyUejqqn qh vjg Wpkxgtukv{qh Rgppu{nxcpkc/ K ekvgf Nqecn Iqxgtpogpvudgecwug vjcv ycu vjg fgcp(u hkgnf qh gzrgtvkug- cpf Vczcvkqp dgecwug Kvjqwijv vjcv kvycu c fgxgnqrkpi cpf rtqokukpi hkgnfhqt rtkxcvg rtcevkeg/

Wphqtvwpcvgn{-kp vjg Rjknkrrkpgu-kvkupqv yjcv {qw mpqy kpvczcvkqpvjcv kukorqtvcpv/ Yjcv ocvvgtu ctg yjqo {qw mpqycpf jqy owej {qw ctg yknnkpivqrc{ vq vjqug yjqo {qwmpqy/Vjku kuvjg tgcuqp yj{ Kfq pqv rtcevkegvczcvkqp/

O{ ugeqpf gpeqwpvgt ykvj eqttwrvkqp ecog yjgp Kycu cntgcf{ cvjktf {gct cuuqekcvgkp vjg U{ekr Ncy Qhhkeg/

Kycu qpeg ecnngf vq vjg Ocpcikpi Rctvpgt(u qhhkeg-yjgtg c enkgpvqh Ejkpgug fguegpv ycu cntgcf{ oggmn{ ugcvgf ikxkpi og vjg kortguukqp vjcvjg jcf lwuvtgegkxgf c vqpiwg ncujkpi htqo vjg ncvgCngz U{ekr/ Kycu vjgp cOgodgt qh vjg Vgco jcpfnkpi vjcv enkgpv(ungicnrtqdngou- ctkukpi htqo jkujcxkpi dggp cuuguugf d{ vjg Ekv{Vtgcuwtgt qh Ocpknc ykvj c jwig owpkekrcnnkegpugvcz cu c jctfyctg tgvckngtcpf yjqngucngt/

Lqg- {qwt enkgpvycpvu vq dtkdg cp qhhkekcnqh vjg Ocpknc Ekv{Vtgcuwtgt(uQhhkeg/Kvqnfjko Kfq pqv cnnqyo{ Ncy Qhhkegvqdtkdg rwdnkeqhhkekcnucpf Kyknnpqv cnnqycp{ qh o{ ncy{gtu vqrctvkekrcvgkp eqttwrvkpi rwdnkeqhhkekcnu/Kcnuqvqnf jko vjcv cnnvjcvKyknncum{qwvqfq kuvqycvej- ugetgvn{cpf htqo c fkuvcpeg-vjg fgnkxgt{qh vjg dtkdg oqpg{ uq uqogdqf{ ecp vguvkh{kp jkuhcxqt kpecugjg yknndg cttguvgf/

Kp c ugpug- K ycu nwem{vjcv vjgug vyq kpekfgpvu jcrrgpgf kp o{hqtocvkxg {gctu qh rtcevkeg/ Ykvjqwv vjgo kpvgpfkpi kv vq dg uq- K ycuogpvqtgf d{ vjg vyq rtqokpgpv cpf uweeguuhwnncy{gtu qp jqy vjg{ fgcnvykvj eqttwrvkqp/

Kp o{ gpvktg hqwtvggp )25, {gctu kp vjg U{ekr Ncy Qhhkeg- vjgRctvpgtu pgxgt uwiiguvgf- pqt fkf yg rctvkekrcvg kp dtkdkpi rwdnke qhhkekcnu-gurgekcnn{kp vjg lwfkekcncpf qvjgt cflwfkecvqt{ u{uvgou/ Yg ygtg cyctg- qheqwtug- qh vjg tcorcpv rwdnke eqttwrvkqp vjgp cpf jcf jcf gzvgpfgffkuewuukqpuqp jqy vq qxgteqog vjg wphckt cfxcpvcig qh qrrqpgpvu yjqqrv vq wugeqttwrvkqp vq ykp/

Kpujqtv- kvycu kp vjg U{ekr Ncy Qhhkegvjcv Kngctpgf cpf pwtvwtgfo{ kpuvkpevkxgcxgtukqp vq rwdnkeeqttwrvkqp/ Kdtqwijv vjg gvjkecnewnvwtgvqCEETC- vq vjg NkvkicvkqpFgrctvogpv- kp rctvkewnct/

6/ "Jqy fq {qw tgurqpf yjgp c lwfigqhhgtu vq ngv{qw ytkvg vjg fgekukqpB"

Khvjg tgswguv kuvjg rtqfwev qh eqttwrvkqp- Kyknnpqv jcxg cp{vjkpivq fq ykvj kv/Kyknnhqnnqy vjg ucog rtqegfwtg hqt vjg ecug qh c Lwfig qt jkuuvchhfktgevn{uqnkekvkpic dtkdg/

Kh-jqygxgt- vjg tgswguv kupqv vjg rtqfwev qh eqttwrvkqp- Kyknndghncvvgtgf/

Kp o{ gctn{ {gctu cu c vtkcnncy{gt- K ykvpguugf- ugxgtcn vkogu- cEqwtv qh HktuvKpuvcpeg )pqy- Tgikqpcn Vtkcn Eqwtv, vtkcnlwfig tgswguvkpivjg ncy{gt qh qpg nkvkicpvvq ytkvg vjg fgekukqp kp hcxqt qh jku enkgpv-kp qrgpeqwtv cpf kp vjg rtgugpeg qh qrrqukpi eqwpugn/Kpqvjgt kpuvcpegu-jg cumgf

dqvj qrrqukpi eqwpugn vq ytkvg vjg fgekukqp vjcv vjg{ yqwnf nkmgjko vqtgpfgt/

Kpgxgt jgctf vjcv vjkurtcevkeg qh vjcv vtkcnlwfig- c tgurgevgf qpg-ycu fkucnnqygf d{ vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtv/

Pqvg vjcv Wpkvgf Uvcvgutwngucnnqy eqwpugnvq ytkvg vjg qtfgt qtfgekukqp jg ycpvu vjg eqwtv vq rtqownicv§-/ itcpvkpi rtqxkukqpcn tgnkghuqwijv/ Kphcev-c ftchv qtfgt kutgswktgf vq dg cvvcejgf vq vjg oqvkqp cv vjgvkog kvkuhkngf/

Vjgtg ycu gxgp c ujqtv ctvkengkp vjg KDRlqwtpcn d{ LqgnDqfgiqp-cpqvjgt Ukioc Tjqcp- ctiwkpi vjcv vjku rtqegfwtg kupqv fkucnnqygf d{ vjgTwnguqh Eqwtv cpf ujqwnf dg cfqrvgf/vq fgenqi lwfkekcnfqemgvu/

7/ "Jqy fq {qw jcpfng c enkgpvyjq jcu c engctn{nqukpi )ekxkn,ecug dwvkpukuvu{qw rwtuwg kvB"

ECPQP 2 . C NCY[GT UJCNN WRJQNF VJGEQPUVKVWVKQP-QDG[ VJG NCYU QH VJG NCPF CPFRTQOQVG TGURGEV HQT VJG NCY CPF HQT NGICNRTQEGUUGU/

Twng2/14 . C ncy{gt ujcnnpqv- hqt cp{ eqttwrv oqvkxg qtkpvgtguv-gpeqwtcig cp{ uwkvqt rtqeggfkpi qt fgnc{ cp{ ocp(uecwug/

Twng2/15 . C ncy{gt ujcnngpeqwtcig jku enkgpvuvqcxqkf- gpf qtugvvngvjg eqpvtqxgtu{khkvyknncfokv qh c hcktugvvngogpv/

ECPQP 26 . C NCY[GT UJCNN QDUGTXG ECPFQT-HCKTPGUUCPF NQ[CNV[ KP CNN JKU FGCNKPIU CPFVTCPUCEVQPU YKVJ JKU ENKGPV/

Twng26/16 . F ncy{gt- yjgp cfxkukpi jku enkgpv-ujcnnikxg cecpfkf cpf jqpguv qrkpkqpqp vjg ogtkvucpf rtqdcdng tguwnvuqhvjg enkgpv(uecug- pgkvjgt qxgtuvcvkpi pqt wpfgtuvcvkpi vjgrtqurgevu qh vjg ecug/

Vjg swguvkqp rquvwncvguvjcv vjg enkgpv(uecwug ku "c engctn{nqukpi)ekxkn,ecug"/ Eqpegfgfn{- vjkukuvjg cuuqekcvg(u"ecpfkf cpf jqpguv qrkpkqpqp vjg ogtkvu cpf rtqdcdng tguwnvuqh vjg enkgpv(uecug/"

Vjg fkngooc kuvjcv kvkuqpn{ c "ecpfkf cpf jqpguv qrkpkqp/" Jgecp pqv iwctcpv{ vq vjg enkgpvvjcv vjg Uwrtgog Eqwtv yknnuwuvckpjku dngcmcuuguuogpv qh vjg tgngxcpv hcevu cpf jku rguukokuvkekpvgtrtgvcvkqp qh vjgcrrnkecdng ncyu/ Cu Twng 26/16 rtqxkfgu- jg ecp qpn{ ikxg jku "ecpfkf cpfjqpguv qrkpkqp" qp vjg "rtqdcdng tguwnvu"-pqv iwctcpv{ tguwnvu/

Fkhhgtgpvn{ rjtcugf- vjgtg okijv dg cp jqpguv fkucitggogpvdgvyggp vjg ncy{gt cpf vjg enkgpvqp c ecug qt uvtcvgi{(uogtkvu- cu yjgp vjgenkgpvkuogtgn{ fgnc{kpi vjg kpgxkvcdngvkog yjgp jg owuv rc{ c fgdv lwuvn{kpewttgf/

Kp uwej ukvwcvkqpu-K uwiiguv vq vjg enkgpvjg jcu qpn{ vyq )3,qrvkqpu;

Gpvgt kpvq cp cokecdng ugvvngogpv ykvj vjgqrrqpgpv wpfgt tgcuqpcdng vgtou cpf eqpfkvkqpu<qt

8/ "Jqy fq {qw jcpfng c enkgpvyjqo {qw hggnkuengctn{ ykvjjqnfkpi uqogvjkpi- okutgrtgugpvkpivjg vtwvj- qt qwvtkijv cdqwv vq eqookv rgtlwt{B"

ECPQP 21 . C NCY[GT QYGU ECPFQT- HCKTPGUUCPF IQQF HCKVJVQ VJG EQWTV/

Twng 21/12 . C ncy{gt ujcnn pqv fq cp{ hcnugjqqf- pqt eqpugpvvq vjg fqkpi qh cp{ kp eqwtv- pqt ujcnn jg okungcf qtcnnqy vjg Eqwtv vq dg okungf d{ cp{ ctvkhkeg/

Vjg swgt{ cuuwogu vjcv vjg ncy{gt jcu tgcejgf- kp jku uvwf{ qh vjghcevucpf vjg ncy crrnkecdng vq vjg ecug- cp korcuug ykvj jku enkgpvcpf jkuykvpguugu yjq kpukuvkp vjgkt xgtukqp qh tgcnkv{cu qrrqugf vq yjcv vjgncy{gt rgtegkxgu/

Vq cxgtv uwej cp korcuug- Kfgxkugf o{ qyp uvtcvgi{ qh kpfktgevn{uwiiguvkpi vq vjg enkgpvcpf jku ykvpguuguvjcv vjgkt tgeqnngevkqpqh vjg hcevuokijv dg kpceewtcvg/Kpo{ kpkvkcnoggvkpi ykvj vjg enkgpvqt jku ykvpguugu-Kkoogfkcvgn{ uvcvgvjg twnguvjcv yknniqxgtp qwt tgncvkqpujkr;

Vjg{ owuv vgnnog gxgt{vjkpi vjcv vjg{ mpqy cdqwv vjgecug/

Vjg{ owuv ikxg og cnnvjg fqewogpvu vjcv ctg kp vjgktrquuguukqp yjkej- vjg{ vjkpm- jcxg c dgctkpi qp vjgecug< cpf kh vjqug fqewogpvu ctg pqv kp vjgktrquuguukqp- yjgtg Kecp hkpf vjgo/

Vjg{ owuv cnuq vgnnog cnnvjg hcevu-ektewouvcpegu cpffqewogpvu yjkej vjg{ vjkpm ctg pqv tgngxcpv vq vjgecug- qt pqv hcxqtcdng vq vjgkt ecug- ykvj vjggzrncpcvkqp vjcv;

c, Vjg tgcuqp yj{ vjg{ jktgf cp gzrgpukxg ncy{gtku dgecwug vjg{ fq pqv mpqy- htqo vjg ngicnrqkpv qh xkgy- yjcv ku tgngxcpv cpf yjcv kuhcxqtcdng qt wphcxqtcdng- hqt cnn vjg{ mpqyyjcv vjg{ eqpukfgt wphcxqtcdng hcevu qt

ektewouvcpegu oc{- htqo vjg uvcpf rqkpv qh ncyqt lwfkekcnrtgegfgpvu- ctg kp vjgkt hcxqt<

d, Kvkuxgt{ korqtvcpv hqt og vq mpqy yjcv vjgktqrrqpgpv yknnuc{ vq eqpvtcfkev vjgkt encko cpfvjgkt ykvpguugu uq K ecp rtgrctg c tgcuqpcdngcpf etgfkdng gzrncpcvkqp hqt yjcv vjg{ rgtegkxgvq dg kpeqpukuvgpv qt wphcxqtcdng vq vjgktecwug/

Vjg{ owuv kfgpvkh{ hqt og cnn rgtuqpu yjq oc{rgtuqpcnn{ mpqy uqog hcegvu qh vjg ecug cpf uvcvgyjgvjgt vjg{ ctg hqt wuqt hqt vjg qrrqpgpv/

C ncy{gt kupckxg khjg dgnkgxgu"jqqm- nkpgcpf ukpmgt"gxgt{vjkpivjcv jku enkgpvqt ykvpguuguvgnnjko/ Kvkujwocp pcvwtg vq ykvjjqnf qt hqtigvwprngcucpv gzrgtkgpegu qt godcttcuukpi grkuqfgu kp qpg(u nkhg/Vjwu- kvkupqtocn hqt c nkvkicpvvq ykvjjqnf kphqtocvkqp vjcv jg vjkpmukuwphcxqtcdngvq jko/

Vjwu- o{ crrtqcej kuvq uvwf{ cnncxckncdngfqewogpvu/ Kcnuq ocmgo{ qyp hcevwcnkpxguvkicvkqp-xgtkh{kpi htqkp kpfgrgpfgpv uqwtegu vjgceewtce{ qt kpceewtce{ qh vjg enkgpvcpf jku ykvpguugu(xgtukqp/

Khvjg ncy{gt uvwfkgf vjg ecug fknkigpvn{cpf vjqtqwijn{- jg yqwnf-cv c ikxgp uvcig kp jku rtgrctcvkqp- jcxg fggrgt mpqyngfig qh c ecug(u fgvcknuvjcp jku enkgpvcpf ykvpguugu/

K vjgp rtqeggf vq vjg ugeqpf cpf uwdugswgpv kpvgtxkgyu qh vjgenkgpvcpf jku ykvpguugu-ykvjqwv ujctkpi vjg tguwnvuqh o{ qyp xgtkhkecvkqp/

Khvjg enkgpvcpf jku ykvpguugufgxkcvg htqo yjcv Kjcxg cuegtvckpgfvq dg vjg etgfkdng hcevu-Kkoogfkcvgn{ rtqeggf- ykvjqwv vjgkt mpqykpi yjcvK co vt{kpi vq guvcdnkuj-vq cum c ugtkgu qh etquu.gzcokpcvkqp swguvkqpu/Unqyn{- vjg{ yknn tgcnk}g htqo vjg vgpqt qh o{ ukorng cpf nqikecnn{ugswgpegf swguvkqpuvjcv vjgkt xgtukqp kupqv c etgfkdng xgtukqp qh yjcv vjgvtwvj ku/Cv vjcv rqkpv- Kvgnnvjgo jqy gcu{ kvkuvq ecvej vjgo n{kpi/ Kvgnnvjgo- vqq- vjcv vjg{ ujqwnf gzrgev oqtg godcttcuukpi swguvkqpuhtqo vjgqrrqukpi eqwpugn qwv vq fguvtq{ vjgkt etgfkdknkv{ujqtv qh vgnnkpivjgo vqvjgkt hceguvjg{ ctg nkctucpf rgtlwtgf ykvpguugu/

Ecwijv kp uwej cp godcttcuukpi ukvwcvkqp-vjg{ wuwcnn{cumog yjcvvjg{ ujqwnf fq/ O{ cfxkeg kuvjcv vjg{ okijv jcxg dggp okuvcmgp kp vjgkttgeqnngevkqpcpf vjg{ dgvvgt tg.cuuguuyjgvjgt vjg{ ctg okuvcmgp-qt vcmgvjgtkumqh nqukpi vjg ecug cpf cv vjg ucog vkog iq vq rtkuqp hqt rgtlwt{/