8/3/2019 PSU PA Injunction

1/6

Zwecgjy3 Ug3 ugfGgjynmb azznhbogbyz3 nb JMWFzgjmbygbyOgzzahg bm" 6Awyljwu3 Ymyyn Lazynbhz ,az>>y11y5.Maygr O(mbia~ `aawau~ 1; 5J!CMZr71a3or" "" / ""/ / / ] ""] / / / ] " % / / / ] ""/ "r" " / " "" "/ // r "" " " " / " " " /"" / /""// / / / / / / " / " / / / " / / / " " "" " " ~gal"" basnz m(fy`~ ym`i ylg yuwyl az ylg~ zJly ny3 ymm abi 1 {gau { gby~ mf (% y!Cum ,yP3e (% aemwy Cgxz"

abi e ajdz, abi a` dnbiz Qf {gm{ g" N un ` bmy ym`gCuayg )`3`jl!gzzgbyna nZ`` aii l~zyguna" y"bmy ~mw xn`` igyguonmG!( ylg baywug( mf Jlnz" jM``!`3zgaz `,;IyC az 1"N`un"ugi X g"gaiy ny" u xn`` zgymay ylg humW n`i N3`3`n`gz" `nymy"~mw" ^M` ! `nnavg uuay/ QTNN`n"~ vnm"`aygi ylgo fumo N(I% vgu~ fnuzy{mzyn` q" ~mw aug j`@gau "~ N1``n`nxn``nb>1 ym `gaub" a( 1N!.yyugu {ayl% abmylgu {IZNZNne` "g X-a~MW`y mf ylgln`yg em| no renje ~M"N(`P jab Z`ygnnu N`I`yy3nn` ~MN igi"iG! ~mw" j"wy eg jnb "" ^mw lavg oMn"i(ga xlm"ab~ mf N`Z aug" ^aw aug zno{`~ mffg"bznvg" abi 3 )a~ ylay33 az z3mogmbg xljZ(G!(|aylgG nz a"C`ym`i ugynugi Cgm4y2nze{umfgrmu" @ndg og /lg y"awh nyy `mvg abi jmo{azz"nmw" bmy3 vgbqg&bgg abilayg" N imb( y" ~gy dbmx Nm``11ggl"gu 3Gjab lavg ~mw ugomvgi fuja ylnz j`azz2 ewy 3u(ooaynbh.nbqwnun/"gz abi gvgb nf ~mw zya~ yb" ~mw gguyanb1~ xjo%y eg im"nbh xg`1/% nf ye&"z4nz nCI~( nb/i"njaynmm"mf 3 fMW`33 ja{aenW"1y4ng)r

ym `D!Z)aqg 7< mb Ombia~ CabwJ`Cu^ 1; 53;;7 r3G bavg bMn3 3yya3ig ab"~ %rayg z{ggjl ugy `aGr" ja``gi {gj{`"g baaygr% au oaig ug`nhun"awz2z`wuz! `" baffg zno{ "~ {ugzgbygi yuCyg eu3WNye" az g(`fyigbjgi e~ ew`yMunjan"` fa jy3z B!! `,y zmogmbg nz2a `N`wz!n5NNn nb" yl!/z j`azz y3lgb n 1nNmyiiy ``zg eax~ ym lv`!( a j!&zPZPu3m] innz3jwzZ!n"mb aMM(WyNz ao2fum``` yl"g (qwuab abi fyain"ye" nb ab a y y g n ` { y ym ani nb ugzm nyy3nmb m y` g [gajg [umjgzz abi az2a j azz"" {C3mcgjg nb jmbf`njy ug)M`rynO" _T xQwC`i3gvgb eg xn` nbh! ym inzgwzz" j`Wia3nzI abin2JeunZ2ynab"ny~ xn"ylnb yyCN"nz jmbyg`yy3 az2 ab" a yygo{y ym >(ann`!1ab w !1ig yZPya binUr mf ylg y4|wye aoi2ybg `3mmy j"y``!1(zgzmf y l g oni gazy j3m` `fW"jy"21 ~mw jabaMf!3 a``MX %m{gb innZgW`7ZnQy Z(% fmg )yw30frgz M %(lgau(% i11"y(fguIq4 {fn!fngjynv/gz ,Nb2ug`nqnm3wz!jw`ywua` gmbfL"jy abi ugzm`wy/ mb yegugm4 y3fy"gb ~mw" aug b3r a""1 `"1m"yyCnbh 3 fmu ajarj2invguzny~ mf m{nbnmb abi lnz1ymunja` ljy!2 (^ m eg3 lmbgzy3 ny nz nC` ` faygunaC" nflgylgu N lavg ugai ylg yg|4y emm 3z ay" ylnz {mW y mu bmy3r2Dbgug ylgug aug bm j"`gau NUZ(G`X(J(NGM`(`Z az ym mb `nbg jMNnN{y`nyguj`azzgZ! i`gg nz a `ajd2mf mm` n```wbnj3ayn,!.b egyxggb ylg y(a93wy~ aO zywigby emi1%r mw lavg azdgi og ymrny liua1nf2em` ` ylg j "azNZ abi nNC`!3g "ImdC bq nIym2 Cyavnnbq og 3u4go`n`vgi gvgb egmug ayygo{"yn`n`>1 y"mbaog2yb~ %mffgbzgz% M(u ym {(umvnig NN`gxny ` j`gau nbzyuwjynmbz az y, . x `a/y aja/iGlijfugggiM` n n2] %a` mxgi(% nb mb `nbg ugf`gjynmbz4 abi inzgwzzn"mbz"213 xaz `Ng|3gr~ yu ~ n1 3y >C ym hgy y(lg zyWig3bw ym 3ugf`gjy abi" {3b3mv 3nj` g` a" y"m{nj mf i`n"zJW1Zznmb"32Xgaylgu ~m "%%, aug a owz4@n``` mu bmy" ze"Qw` i CnCg n` ` `a y3gi"a` az xyn "" On3ii mf yb3g Pyumye`=(2u UAVGzay nb j`azzgz4 xnyl" OwNZ"`noP ABrCg1nizl` { yMfgzZ(;G< abi b(aV< aO^ f u , g 3a `G (j N ` P enazgi!2m{3nbnQbzaemwy nz(`o egnbf} g` ` {gajgfw` ug`nhnO" xl^ ny3 j`gw`~ 3nz0 bmy! bm ,P.w WC3 Ny ylg2zny3gz fum" ylg Qx3ab abi Lainyl xenje `!(un"igbjgz N``&% {mz"ny3nMN!1 mu nz ylay bQy yi"ylnb ylg2zjm{g m f J 0 n C & f 1 1 j y ugzm`wynmb n"b y l g JQN yg|y mf yln"z j`azz=2Cmlb On" Zw"a``I"Wyn2 /

f n `g { % n n _ ur N Q w m y g _ ur6_,NQ nI

""

8/3/2019 PSU PA Injunction

2/6

WBNYGI ZYAYGZ INZYUNJY JMWUYFMU YLG INZYUNJY MFMUGHMB

CMLB OAWUNYS LWOOAZY`[`anbynff

Jnvn` Bm" ;7/1 195/OMYGO[MUAU^ UGZYUANBNBH MUIGU

v"[MUY@ABI ZYAYG WBNVGUZNY^ gy aN"

Igfgbiaby, z."OMZOAB,C",

[`anbynff Cmlb O" Lwoazyn fn`gi ylnz ajynmb mb Cw`~ 55 5;;7" Lnz jmo{ anby a``ghgz ylay[muy abi Zyayg Wbnvguzny~ abi mbg mf nyz {umfgzzmuz Ylmoaz Lazynbhz ,jm``gjynvg`~%igfgbiabyz%. vnm`aygi {`anbynffz unhlyz ym fuggimo mf z{ggjl fugg g|gujnzg mf ug`nhnmb abi gqwa{umygjynmb wbigu ylg `ax e~ ugomvnbh { anbynff fumo a j`azz yawhly e~ [umfgzzmu Lazynbhz" MbAwhwzy 7 5;;7 {`anbynff fn`gi ylg nbzyaby omynmb fmu ygo{muau~ nbcwbjynvg ug`ngf" [`anbynff a` ghgzlg f`gx fumo Nzuag` ym [muy`abi Mughmb nb Cabwau~ 5;;7 nb ab ayygo{y ym ugzm vg lnz jmbf`njy xnylLazynbhz" [`anbynff a``ghgz ylay %T i_wg ym ylg g|{gbinywug mu `mzz mf ylnz ombg~ fmu anu faug[`anbynfffajgz gvnjynmb fmu nbaen`ny~ ym {a~ ugby"% [`anbynffz omynmb fmu ygo{muau~ nbcwbjynvgug`ngf zggdz ugnoewuzgogby fmu ylg jmzy mf lnz anufaug" [`anbynff a`zm azdz ylg jmwuy ym jmo{g`igfgbiabyz ym3 ,1. ugnbzyayg {`anbynffz ajaigonj fnbabjna` ani zyabinbh4 ,5. azznzy { anbynff nbmeyanbnbh a fmuoa zywi~ aeumai {umhuao nb Nzuag`4 abi ,:. %Tu_ghnzygu [`anbynff az a Labinja{{gimu Inzae`gi Zywigby abi mffgu [ anbynffylg egbgfnyz az xg`` az Gqwa` [umygjynmb mfylg @ax azmylgu inzae gi zywigbyz aug hnvgb"%

[AHG 1 / YGO[MUAU^ UGZYUANBNBH MUIGU

8/3/2019 PSU PA Injunction

3/6

%TA_ {ug`nonbau~ nbcwbjynmb nz ab g|yuamuinbau~ abi iuazynj ugogi~ mbg ylay zlmw`i bmy eghuabygi wb`gzz ylg omvaby e~ a j`gau zlmxnbh jauungz ylg ewuigb mf {guzwaznmb"% Oaswugd v"Auozyumbh, 75; W"Z" >685 ,1>>8. ,qwmynbh ``A J" Xunhly A" On``gu & O" Dabg Fgigua[uajy njg abi [umjgiwug 5>9>7.." Ym zwjjggi mb lnz omynmb fmu a{ug nonbau~ nbcwbjynmb {`anbynff owzy igombzyuayg gnylgu ,1. a `ndg`nlmmi mf zwjjgzz mb ylg ogunyzabi ylg {mzznen` ny~ mf nuug{auae`g nbcwu~ mu ,5. ylg g|nzygbjg mf zgunmwz qwgzynmbz hmnbh ym ylgogunyz abi ylg ea`abjg mf lauizln{z yn{{nbh nb {`anbynffz favmu" Bndg, Nbj" v" OjJauy`u~, :8> F":i786 7yl Jnu" 5;;9." %Ylgzg yxm a`ygubaynvgz ug{ugzgby g|yugogz mf a znbh`g jmbynbwwouaylgu ylab yxm zg{auayg ygzyz" Ylwz ylg hugaygu ylg ug`aynvg lauizln{ ym T{`anbynff_ ylg `gzz{umeaen`ny~ mf zwjjgzz owzy eg zlmxb"% Ni" Xlgug a {`anbynff zggdz {ug`nonbau~ ug`ngf bmy ymugzyuanb a igfgbiaby fumo yadnbh ajynmb ewy ym jmo{g` a igfgbiaby ym yadg affnuoaynvg ajynmb

%Tz_wjl (oabiaymu~ {u g nonbau~ ug`ngf nz zwecgjy ym lgnhlygbgi zjuwy nb~ abi zlmw`i bmy eg nzzwgiwb`gzz ylg fajyz abi `ax j`gau`~ favmu ylg omvnbh {auy~"% Ial` v" LGO [lauoajgwynja`z Jmu{",8 F":i 1:>> 19;: ,>yl Jnu" 1>>:." Az zgy fmuyl eg`mx ylg jmwuy fnbiz {`anbynff laz fan`gi ymigombzyuayg gbyny`gogby ym {ug`nonbau~ ug`ngf

Fnuzy igfgbiabyz lavg bmy eggb zguvgi xnyl a jm{~ mf ylg jmo{`anby mu a zwoombz"Ajjmuinbh`~ ylnz jmwuy `ajdz cwunzinjynmb mvgu ylg igfgbiabyz" Owu{ u~ Eumz", Nbj" v" Onjlgyyn[n{g Zyunbhnbh, Nbj", 756 W"Z" :99 :7; ,1>>>."

Zgjmbi ylg mb ~ nuug{auae`g nbcwu~ {`anbynff azzguyz nz ylay lg xn`` eg gvnjygi fumo lnza{auyogby nflg nz bmy ugnoewuzgi fmu lnz yuavg` g|{gbzgz" Hgbgua``~ a j`ano fmu ombgyau~ ug ngfnz bmy jmbznigugi nuug{auae`g" @mz Abhg`gz Ogomuna` Jm`nzgwo Jmoo(b v" Baynmba` Fmmyea``@gahwg, 6:9 F"5i 11>8 15;5 ,>yl Jnu" 1>

8/3/2019 PSU PA Injunction

4/6

ylay lg %fajgz gvnjynmb fmu nbae n ny~ ym {a~ ugby"% Fmu ab nbcwbjynmb ym nzzwg %Ty_lgug owzy egomug ylab a ogug {mzznen`ny~ mu fgau ylay ylg nbcwu~ xn`` mjjwu"% ``A J" Xunhly A" On``gu &O"Dabg Fgigua [uajynjg abi [umjgiwug 5>95 {" 97 ,5i gi" 1>>7..4 zgg a zm Jmbbgjynjwy v"Oazzajlwzgyyz, 5:1. ,ab nbcwbjynmb %xn`` bmy eg huabygi ahanbzy zmogylnbhogug`~ fgaugi az `nae`g ym mjjwu ay zmog nbigfnbnyg ynog nb ylg fwywug"%."

Fnba``~ {`anbynff laz bmy igombzyuaygi ylay lg nz `ndg`~ ym zwjjggi mb ylg ogunyz mf lnzj`anoz" Omzy mf ylg j`anoz zgy fmuyl nb {`anbynffz jmo{`anby aug inffnjw`y ym jmo{uglgbi" JmwbyYlugg fmu g|ao{`g a``ghgz ylay igfgbiabyz %igbngi [`anbynff fugg g|gujnzg mf ug`nhnmb e~xumbhfw``~ jugaynbh a `mzz mf jmbzmuynwo"% Xln`g {`anbynff oa~ lavg a jm`muae`g FnuzyAogbiogby j`ano mb ylg eaznz mf lnz ugomva` fumo j`azz fmu g|{ugzznbh lnz {m`nynja` vngxz{`anbynff laz bmy igombzyuaygi a `ndg`nlmmi mf zwjjgzz mb ylay j`ano zwffnjngby ym mwyxgnhl ylg

ymya` aezgbjg mf nuug{auae`g lauo / {auynjw`au`~ wbigu ylg lgnhlygbgi zjuwynb~ a{{`ngi ym ylgoabiaymu~ {ug`nonbau~ ug`ngf {`anbynff zggdz" Ial`, 8 F":i ay 19;:"

Fmu ylg fmughmnbh ugazmbz {`anbynffz omynmb fmu nbcwbjynvg ug ngf ,*7. nz IGBNGI"NY NZ ZM MUIGUGI"IAYGI ylnz 16yl ia~ mf Awhwzy 5;;7"

-z- Onjlag` X" OmzoabONJLAG@ X" OMZOABWbnygi Zyaygz Inzyunjy Cwihg

[AHG : / YGO[MUAU^ UGZYUANBNBH MUIGU

8/3/2019 PSU PA Injunction

5/6

X lyy{3--{a`xayjl"muh` znyg-omiw`gz-{unby`{ugvngx"az{|=fn? 178&imjci?6 """

5

r[unby ,SnH`mzg

[OX Ew``gynbz[AOwfyn3 Owz" noz igzynb~ nz ym dn`` Cgxze~Laoau NNab3wz abi Bab Cajqwgz 5nNegbNndr17"5;15Zlaug r 11 " C

[Arzlnhlgzyug`nhnmwz awylmuny~% ylg Owfyn% ay Fayalgvgby3Owz`noz igzynb~ nz ym dWNC!gxz

Ugzwuugjynmb xn`` jmog mb`~ afygu Cgxz aug dn``gi e~Owz`nozOmiguaymu ay Fayal gvgby3%Mwu xau xnyl ylg igzjgbiabyz mf ylg a{gz abi {nhz ,n"g" Cgxz.

nzaxau mf ug`nhnmb abi fanylZe~ `yao`au Oaujwz abi Bab Ca"jqwgz Sn eguind

`azy xggd ylg {unbjn{a` [a`(gzynbnab Awylmuny~ ug`nhnmwz N(gai(gurlg( O(wfynOwlaooai Lwzzgnb" {ugzgbygi ylg dn``nbh mf C(gxz e~ Owz`noz az aug`nhnmwz fz`aonj hma`" Ay ab gvgby jg`geuaynbh ylg 91yl abbnvguzau~ mf ylgfmwbinbh mf Fa`(al" lg jnygi ylg Lainynl ,fzfaon(j yuainynmb ayfb`Cwygi ymOwlaooai. za~nbh ylay yl"g Lmwu mf Ugzwuugjynmb xn`` bmy jmog wbyn`Owz`noz fnhly ylg C(gxz abi dnb ylgo3%Ylg Lmwu Tmf Ugzwuugjynmb_ xnNC bmy jmog wbyn`! ~mw fnhly ylg Cgxz"`%l"gCgx xn`` lnig eglnbi zymbgz mu yuggz"Ylgb ylg zymbgz mu yuggz xn`` ja``3((Ml Owz`4no% zguvaby mf AGual"ylgug nz a Cgx eglnbi og" jmbg aoidnWlno "

[a`gzynbnab Ogina Xayjl ug{muygiughwfau`~ iwunbh ylg [Aygbum``(jao{an({,Nbynfaia" 5;(;;/5;;7. mb ylg ug{gaygi wzg mf Nlnz Lainyl e~ [A jfgunjz mb mfynjna` [A YV ym omynvayg [afgzynbnabz ymyguumu ayyajdz" {ugajlnbh ylay Owz`noz lai ab Nz`aonj meynhaynmm ym N X N Cgxz" Ylg fa&1n3lay yn`g Owo qwmygz ylnz bmxnbinjaygz ylay ylnz oa~ lavg ugoanbgi {auy mfyyag [A%zuguyh`mwz gzfaeWzlogby(z ygajlnbhz" gvgb yl"mwhl ny nz fgzzfugqwgby`~ {umomygi mb [AYV"Ylg fazy ynog mffnjna` [AYV eumaijazy a zgbbmb iwunbh xlnjl yln(z Lainyf` ja``nbh ym dn`` Cgxz xaz3 qwmygi xaz nb 5;1;"Ylg ~gauz mf [A{um`n`1`m"yn(mbmf ynTTT``h Cgxz abi [A ug``"hn(mwz `gaiguz% J`wbh ylnz L(ainy`n` ym cwzynnfnC ny4oa~ `nYaOgjmbyunewygi ym ylg lnhl ajjg{"yabjg mf nynb [Azmjn3gy~" A {mb z{m``zmugi e~ ylg Nzuag` [umcgjy fazy ~gaNN(fmwbi ylay 1:%1;mf [afgzyn(bnabz %eg`Ngvg(% yln(z Lainyl3" TCw`~ 5;11" Huggbeguh Qwnb`ab Umzbgu ""Ylg omiguaymu xlm nbyumiwjgi ylg Owo ay yl"g Fayal gvgby fazy xggd ugnyguaygi abm"ylg`n Tzfaon(j eg`Ngu" ylay ylg Cgxzaug ylg igzjgbiabyz mf a{gz abi {nhz3%(Mwu xau xnyl ylg igzjgbiabfz mf ylg a{gz abi {nhz ,n""g"Cgxz.nz a xau mf ug`nhnmb abi fanyl"%

1116-5;15>378 AO

8/3/2019 PSU PA Injunction

6/6

X lyy{ 3- -{a `xayjl "m uh n znyg -omiw`gz-{u nby`{ugvngx "a z{ |= fn ? 1 7 8&im j ]n i?6 "" "

Ylg O(wffn ini bmy inzyabjg `1nozg(`f fumo ylnz ean`ngzyaygogby ylay NZfao nz cn`n`:NNng!Lhn(;N!"`zau xnyl ylg Crgxz"e``iyaiigiym ny ylay fzfao0zhma` nz ym dnb Cgxz"Ylg`ng aug bwogumwz jm`fgj33yn(mbzmf Lainye% zmog mf xlnjl aug( bmy3ajjg{ygi az ug`naefg" Lmxgvgu4 yNnNg Owfyn zdgzzgiylay ylg fz`aonj eg`ngf M`ay Cgxz xn`` eg dogi e~ Owz`noz az a {`ngjwuzmuym Ugzwuugjynmb nz ab awf`ygbynj ,zfaoujeg`ngf egjawzg ny a{{gauz nb lg ug`nae`g% abi yuwzygi Lainyl jm`fgjynmbz mf AGE(wdlaunabi Owz`no"Yn`nz uzuaon3j yuainynmb azzg`n1nzylay az M`"gdn``nbh mf Crgxzxnb {umhugzz% Cgxz xn``n lui(g eglnbi zymbgz abi yuggz" ewygvgb M`"g~xn`Gg|{mzg ylg Cgxz abi jab mwn3 MbOwz`no" zguvaby mf A``al% yN`gug nz a Cgx egenbi og jmog abi dnblno ""Mbg yugg lmxgvgu jaWgi ylg Hlauqai" xnb enig ylg Cgxz fumo ylg Owz`noz" Ylg Owfyn n(bl nz ya`d ay ylg Fayalgvgby j`anogi ylay nb ugz{mbzg ym yNnNnz fzfaonj eg`ngf" Tzuag`nz lavg eggb {`abynbh Hla`nqai eggz a`nmwbi yN`guu jnyngzabi ymxbz nb muigu ym lavg a {fajg ym lnig fumo yn`g Owzfn(oz xlm xn`` eg jmonoh ym fi` yN`go"Ylnz nz bmy yeg fnuzy yn(og ylg Owfyn laz n(bjnygi ym layugi ahanbzy Cgxz nb ylg baog mf Nzuao" ub :1zg`noCmbay W`g AN/Aqz:1Omzqwg nb 5;1; eg {ugajlgi ylay ylg Cgxz a`ng ylg %gbgongz mf A``al3%Ylg Owo nza{{mnbygi e~ [AJlan`nI1!abOaeom```i Aeeaz" Lg V(mnjgi yN`Nnz faygzy `1ayg z{ggjl% yN`ay C"gxz aug ym egdogi e~ Owz`noz" ay ab mffnjna Fafal jgugeuaynmb" Aeeaz nz afzm yNnNg Jlanuoab mf Fafae"Ylgfm `mxnbh nz ab g|jgu{y fumo ylg Fayal jgugomb~ eumaija"zy mb [A"YV3Omiguaymu ay Fayal jgugGbmb~?(((Mwu xau xnyl M`g igzjgbiabyz mf yN`"g a{gz abi {nhz ,n"g Cgxz.nz :1xau mf ug`nhnmb abi fanyl""@mbh @nvg Fayalf TN nbvnyg ~mw ( mwu lmbmuae`g Zlgndl"%[AOwo Owlaooai Lwzzgnb jmogz ym yn`g {miNwo abi za~z3%98 ~gauz ahm yn`g TFafal_ ugvm wynmb zyau`gi@ Xlnjl ugV(mTonmb= Ylg omigo `ngvmfwynmb mf yN`"g [afgzynbnab{gm{fg(z lnzymu~" Tb fajy% [a`gzynbg nb nzgbynugy~ nz :NNngV(mf```yn(mb"znbjg ,Ja`N{l_ Woau jaog! ,ym2jmbqwguCguwza`go% 6:8 gG " abi jmbynbwNbh ymia~" abi wbynGylg Gbi mf Ia~z" Yn`g ug`nae`g LainM`1,yuainynmb ayyunewygiym2O``Nlaooai." Tfmwbi_ nb M`g ynxm ug`nae`g jmWgjynmbz" E(r`n1a`nn abi Owzyn(b zaz3%Ylg Lmwu ,mf Ugzwuugjynmb_ x nb bmy jmog N`N``yn` ~mw fnhly yn`g Crgxz"Ylg Cgx xnb lnig eglnbi zymbgz mu eggz "Ylgb ylg zymbgz mu yuggz xnW jab3

(MlnOwz`no" zgbaby mf A``al% yN`g`ng nz :1Cgx eglnbi og" jmog abi N(!nn```eno"%G|jg{y ylg Hlauqai yugg Txlnjl xn`G dgg{ znugby_3%Ylgugfmug nynz bm xmbigu yN`ay ~mw zgg Hlauqri Ty nggz_zwuumwbinbh ylg ,Nzuag`"_ zgyn`(g(ogbyz abi jmTmbngz """ ,rA YV ,Fafal}" Cab" >" 5378 AO