8/11/2019 Promoting Human Rights in Context of Bioethics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/promoting-human-rights-in-context-of-bioethics 1/2

Introduction: The Future is Now—Promoting Human Rights in the Context of Bioethics

Vol !" No "

ByRobyn S. Shapiro

Robyn S. Shapiro is the Ursula von Der Ruhr Professor of bioethics and director of the Center

for the Study of Bioethics at the Medical College of Wisconsin. She is a partner in the Healtha! Practice "roup of Drin#er Biddle $ Reath P and regional partner in charge at the fir%&s

Mil!au#ee office. She currently serves as the chair of the 'B'&s Section of (ndividual Rights

and Responsibilities.

Since its e%ergence in the )*+,s- the field of bioethics has gro!n in ter%s of sie- scope- and

i%portance. (n addition to beco%ing a staple in ne!spaper headlines and tal# sho! topics- bioethics no! has a pro%inent place in acade%ia- at the bedside- and a%ong health policy

%a#ers.

Since its inception- bioethics and la! have been inti%ately connected. /or e0a%ple- the

establish%ent of regulations governing hu%an sub1ects research in the United States- as !ell as

 1udicial recognition of patients& rights to refuse un!anted %edical treat%ent- are land%ar# events

in the develop%ent of the bioethics field in this country.

Within the la!2bioethics relationship- over the past decade- an increased focus on global hu%anrights in bioethics has flourished. (n )**+- the Council of 3urope adopted the Convention on

Hu%an Rights and Bio%edicine- !hich covers %atters such as e4uitable access to health care-

consent- private infor%ation- the hu%an geno%e- scientific research- and transplantation. 5hisconvention see#s to establish a direct relationship bet!een bioethics and hu%an rights-

e%phasiing respect for hu%an dignity in scientific research- and also in the prohibition of the

co%%ercialiation of hu%an genes and hu%an reproductive cloning. 5he great si%ilarity bet!een portions of this 3uropean Convention and the U.S. Bel%ont Report- !hich sets forth

4uintessential re4uire%ents for the ethical conduct of research in this country- illustrates the

i%portance of transnational hu%an rights in guiding the evolution of conte%porary nor%s for global bioethics. 5he recent !or# of the United 6ations 3ducational- Scientific- and Cultural7rganiation 8U63SC79 also underscores the i%portance of global hu%an rights in the

develop%ent of bioethical guidance. (n :,,;- U63SC7 adopted an international declaration of 

universal nor%s for bioethics as a possible %odel for a future %ultinational treaty. 5hisDeclaration on Bioethics and Hu%an Rights see#s to pro%ote e4uitable access to %edical-

scientific- and technological develop%ents consistent !ith safeguarding respect for hu%an

dignity and protecting hu%an rights and funda%ental freedo%s.

Most recently- in the conte0t of gro!ing global health disparities- terroris%- and pande%ics- the

i%portance of hu%an rights issues in bioethics has beco%e particularly acute. We struggle toaddress 4uestions such as<

 = Do the hu%an rights of the very poor re4uire the affluent to help alleviate the global healthcrisis> (f so- ho! should such assistance be provided so as to create a socially enduring solution>

 = With respect to public health ethics- ho! do !e appropriately balance hu%an rights dutieso!ed to individuals as such against the duties o!ed to individuals as %e%bers of the population>

/or e0a%ple- in deciding ho! to distribute vaccines in the face of a flu pande%ic- should the

rationing sche%e be based on the priority of individual clai%s 8e.g.- the %ost vulnerable people-or the people %ost li#ely to survive9 or on the overarching ob1ective of %ini%iing trans%ission

Page 1 of 2

8/11/2019 Promoting Human Rights in Context of Bioethics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/promoting-human-rights-in-context-of-bioethics 2/2

throughout the population 8!hich !ould instead give priority to the people %ost li#ely to

trans%it the virus9>

5hese 4uestions illustrate the i%portant intersections bet!een bioethics and international hu%an

rights- and stress the need for bioethics to e%brace these intersections so as to addressconte%porary global challenges %ost effectively.

5he 'B' Section of (ndividual Rights and Responsibilities has a long and proud history of  pro%oting hu%an rights in the conte0t of bioethics issues. /or e0a%ple- the '(DS Coordinating

"roup- launched by the Section- has supported progra%s that recognie the inseparable

connection bet!een health- hu%an rights- and ethics in addressing the H(?@'(DS epide%ic. (n

addition- the Section has pro%oted hu%an rights issues through its 'B' policy initiatives-including a recent 'B' resolution sponsored by the Section that supports freedo% of scientific

in4uiry to pro%ote hu%an health. 5he Section&s national security and death penalty groups have

e%braced hu%an rights and bioethics concepts in their efforts to help define the roles andobligations of health care professionals in e0ecutions and in prisons. 5his special bioethics issue

of Hu%an Rights %againe- !hich ( have had the pleasure of coediting !ith %y talented

colleague- Steve Wer%iel- !ith invaluable assistance fro% 'ngela "!idala- is yet another contribution of the Section to pro%oting the lin# bet!een bioethics and hu%an rights.

 

Page 2 of 2