private equity and emerging domestic markets
TRANSCRIPT
Private Equity and Emerging Domestic Private Equity and Emerging Domestic MarketsMarkets
Marcellus TaylorMarcellus TaylorAldus EquityAldus Equity
April 25, 2006April 25, 2006
2
Aldus Equity is a private equity consulting and fund-of-fund firm with a specialty practice focused on Emerging Private Equity Funds
The firm has invested over $350 million into 14 different emerging private equity funds
Aldus manages a $375 million emerging manager program on behalf of New York Common Retirement
The firm has over $2 billion of total assets under management
Key clients include: CalPERS, New York City Retirement, New Mexico, Louisiana State Employees, San Antonio Fire & Police
Aldus EquityAldus Equity
3
Emerging Private Equity Market Reaching a Emerging Private Equity Market Reaching a Critical MassCritical Mass
Critical Mass of Assets Large Sub-Sectors
Significant Players
Emerging Private Equity Sub-Sectors($ Billions)
$1.7
$4.5
$3.0
$0.0
$2.0
$4.0
$6.0
Hispanic AfricanAmerican
Fund-of-Funds
EDM Firm Assets Under Management ($ Billions)
$1.2
$8.0
$0.0$2.0$4.0$6.0$8.0
$10.0
1994 2006
Source: Council of Urban Investors Institute
EDM Firm Assets ($M)Palladium Equity $750
Aldus Equity $500Pharos Capital $500Parish Capital $425ICV Capital $410
Bastion Capital $400Nogales Investors $275
Syncom Communications $250
4
Pension Funds Investing in Emerging Private Pension Funds Investing in Emerging Private
Equity FundsEquity Funds
CalPERSCalSTRS
New York CommonTexas Teachers
Illinois State RetirementChicago Police
New York City RetirementChicago Teachers
Illinois Municipal RetirementLos Angeles County Employees
Philadelphia RetirementMassachusettes Bay Transit
New Mexico State Investment CouncilLACERSLACERA
Teachers Retirement of LouisianaChicago Teachers
Shelby County of TennesseeChurch Pension Fund
Connecticut RetirementIllinois Teachers
New York PresbyterianRennesseleyer Polytechnic Institute
Prince Georges CountyWashington DC Retirement
Chicago TransitNew Jersey RetirementMassachusettes PRIM
Los Angeles Fire and Police
Wells FargoNokia
RaytheonVerizon
John DeereDisneyCitibankAXA
Deutsche BankMerrill LynchNew York Life
PrudentialGeneral ElectricGeneral MotorsLockheed Martin
SunAmericaArcher Daniels Midland
ExelonBoeing
Formal Emerging Programs Public Pensions Corporate Pensions
5
Access to differentiated deal flow which enhances diversification and reduces total portfolio risk
Emerging funds have proven ability to generate proprietary deal flow
Emerging funds have a stronger sense of alignment with LP’s– Can’t generate wealth through excessive management fees– Typically more motivated and hungry than established firms
Provides opportunity to cultivate long-term relationships with tomorrow’s private equity stars– Ensures strong access to best performing future funds
Benefits of Investing In Emerging Private Benefits of Investing In Emerging Private
Equity FundsEquity Funds
6
Historically, many of the most successful private equity firms achieved strongest performance investing first or second funds
A recent Kaufman Foundation study revealed that minority private equity firms generated an average IRR of 23.9%
Why Invest in Emerging Why Invest in Emerging Managers?Managers?
Sources: Kauffman Foundation: “Minorities and Venture Capital: A New Wave in American Business”. Kaufman survey of 24 minority-focused firms making investments during the 1989-1995 period. Private Equity Intelligence, Ltd., Fund private placement memos.
Firm Fund I Fund IIKKR 22.5% 39.7%Blackstone 41.7% 87.5%Thomas H Lee 55.1% 23.7%Welsh Carson 49.0% 24.0%Clayton Dubilier 116.8% 84.1%Carlyle Group N/ A 19.0%Hicks Muse N/ A 18.6%
Emerging Managers Have Demonstrated an Ability to Generate Strong Returns
7
Individual Track Record Analysis– Investment performance at prior firms– Attribution Letters– Extensive reference checks
Team Cohesion and Team Stability– Previous working relationships and shared experiences – Broad ownership across the partnership
Access to Quality Deal Flow– Successful deal sourcing at prior firms– Preliminary deal pipeline report
Comprehensive Investment and Due Diligence Process– Systematic approach to evaluating deals– Sufficient documentation and analysis throughout the
process
How to Evaluate Emerging Private Equity How to Evaluate Emerging Private Equity
FundsFunds Critical Due Diligence Items
8
Emphasis on generating strong returns should never be compromised
Thorough due diligence is critical
Requires a specialized advisor who has experience investing in a diversified pool of Emerging Funds
Investors should maintain a “portfolio” driven approach to investing in Emerging Funds– Diversified across key sub-strategies– Sufficient vintage year diversification
Keys to Investing in Emerging Private Keys to Investing in Emerging Private Equity Funds Equity Funds