prince, j.d. and hordyk, a. (2013) implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
4.11 - Implementing the
Risk-Catch-Cost Framework for
Data Poor Fisheries
July 2013
Jeremy Prince & Adrian Hordyk Biospherics P/L & Murdoch University
Western Australia
Acknowledgements: The Nature Conservancy
David and Lucile Packard Foundation USAID
Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock Assessment Methods for Sustainable Fisheries (WCSAM 2013), 15 - 16 July, Boston, USA.
![Page 2: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Stock Assessment – per Stock
Aging 3 yrs $90k Tagging 3 yrs $150k
Stock Structure 3 yrs $100k
Catch & Effort 10-20 yrs $300k Biomass Surveys 10-20 yrs $1,000k
Size of Maturity 3 yrs $30k
Biology
Monitoring
Biomass Modeling 3yrs $150k
Total Cost / stock $500 – 1,000k
![Page 3: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Quantitative Stock Assessment Biomass Modeling
Risk Based Framework Expert Based
Catch Rate or Survey Time Series Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size & Other Data
Layers of Assessment
Data Requirements
Risk Management
High Risk Ranking Requires higher assessment
Quantitatively estimated BMSY, Bopt., SPRopt. targets & risk
![Page 4: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Quantitative Stock Assessment Biomass Modeling
Risk Based Framework Expert Based
Catch Rate or Survey Time Series Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size & Other Data
Layers of Assessment
Data Requirements
Risk Management
High Risk Ranking Requires higher assessment
Quantitatively estimated BMSY, Bopt., SPRopt. targets & risk
Gra
du
ated
Pro
gres
sio
n
Incr
easi
ng
Co
sts
& In
crea
sin
g P
reci
sio
n
![Page 5: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Quantitative Stock Assessment Biomass Modeling
Risk Based Framework Expert Based
Catch Rate or Survey Time Series Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size & Other Data
Layers of Assessment
Data Requirements
Risk Management
High Risk Ranking Requires higher assessment
Quantitatively estimated BMSY, Bopt., SPRopt. targets & risk
The Risk – Catch – Cost Framework G
rad
uat
ed P
rogr
essi
on
In
crea
sin
g C
ost
s &
Incr
easi
ng
Pre
cisi
on
![Page 6: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Meta-analysis
r-strategists High M/k
K-strategists Low M/k
Spawning Potential
Ratio (SPR)
![Page 7: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Meta-analysis Theoretical Development
+
r-strategists High M/k
K-strategists Low M/k
r-strategists High M/k
K-strategists Low M/k
![Page 8: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Meta-analysis Theoretical Development
Generic Knowledge from well Studied Species Predicts Size Composition in Unstudied Stocks
+
r-strategists High M/k
K-strategists Low M/k
r-strategists High M/k
K-strategists Low M/k
![Page 9: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Generic SPR @ Size curve
Size Data from Catch
SPR in Unfished Stock (SPR=100%) SPR
In Fished Stock (SPR=?)
Current SPR
Depletion (F/M)
Estimate of SPR
Size of Maturity SPR@Size
Assessment
![Page 10: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
SPR = 4.6% F/M = 1.96
Indonesian Blue Swimmer Crab
SPR = 45% F/M = 1.58
Spanish Razor Clam
Size-based Stock Assessmment
n=356
![Page 11: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
February 2013 Port Fairy, Victoria
Port Fairy blacklip
Distribution of estimated SPR
![Page 12: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
February 2013 Port Fairy, Victoria
Proportions of By-catch Species in size classes
SPR = 100% SPR = 50 % SPR = 30 %
![Page 13: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Quantitative Stock Assessment Biomass Modeling
Risk Based Framework
SPR @ Size Analysis –Triage Equilibrium Assessment
Expert Based
Generic SPR@ Size Curve & Categoric analysis of rudimentary size data
Catch Rate or Survey Time Series Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size & Other Data
Layers of Assessment
Data Requirements
Risk Management
High Risk Ranking Requires higher assessment
<SPR70% Requires higher assessment >SPR70% No action Required
Quantitatively estimated BMSY, Bopt., SPRopt. targets & risk
The Risk – Catch – Cost Framework G
rad
uat
ed P
rogr
essi
on
In
crea
sin
g C
ost
s &
Incr
easi
ng
Pre
cisi
on
![Page 14: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Recommend Biological Catch (RBC)
NewRBC = pastRBC * (1+V)
V = k1.A + k2.B A = SPRCUR – SPRCUR-5
B = SPRCUR – SPRTARG
k1 & k2 responsiveness parameters
Current Year
MSC Meeting, Fremantle, WA
11-14 September 2012
Harvest Control Rule
![Page 15: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
MSC Meeting, Fremantle, WA
11-14 September 2012
Iterative Catch Adjustments
Preliminarily MSEs
30 Iterations 40 years Low initial F High initial SPR k1 = 0.8 k2 = 0.7
![Page 16: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Quantitative Stock Assessment Biomass Modeling
Risk Based Framework
SPR @ Size Analysis –Triage Equilibrium Assessment
Expert Based
SPR @ Size Analysis – advanced Equilibrium Assessment
Generic SPR@ Size Curve & Categoric analysis of rudimentary size data
Generic SPR@ Size Curve & Better Quality Size Data
SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size Data
Catch Rate or Survey Time Series Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size & Other Data
SPR @ Size Analysis- basic Equilibrium Assessment
Layers of Assessment
Data Requirements
Risk Management
High Risk Ranking Requires higher assessment
<SPR70% Requires higher assessment >SPR70% No action Required
Incremental catch adjustment around SPR50% Size Target. Generic SPR @ Curve assumes worst-case productivity for species
Quantitatively estimated BMSY, Bopt., SPRopt. targets & risk
The Risk – Catch – Cost Framework G
rad
uat
ed P
rogr
essi
on
In
crea
sin
g C
ost
s &
Incr
easi
ng
Pre
cisi
on
![Page 17: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Scale-less Assessment Local Spawning Potential Ratio
CPUEprime CPUEold PropOld CPUErecruits Size based CPUE Indicators Target Level of SPR
Iteratively establish local catch levels
Froese, R. (2004). Keep it simple: three indicators to deal with overfishing. Fish Fish. 5, 86-89. Prince, J. D. et al. (2011). A simple cost-effective and scale-less empirical approach to harvest strategies. ICES
J. Mar. Sci. 68: 947-960.
![Page 18: Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013) Implementing the risk catch cost framework for data poor fisheries. In: ICES World Conference on Stock ... · Prince, J.D. and Hordyk, A. (2013)](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022050513/5f9dedee2d8e0f5d0113ed82/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Quantitative Stock Assessment Biomass Modeling
Risk Based Framework
SPR @ Size Analysis –Triage Equilibrium Assessment
Expert Based
SPR @ Size Analysis – advanced Equilibrium Assessment
SPR @ Size Decision Tree Dynamic Pool Assessment
Generic SPR@ Size Curve & Categoric analysis of rudimentary size data
Generic SPR@ Size Curve & Better Quality Size Data
SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size Data
Catch Rate Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size Data
Catch Rate or Survey Time Series Data with: SPR@ Size Curve curve estimated & High Quality Size & Other Data
SPR @ Size Analysis- basic Equilibrium Assessment
Layers of Assessment
Data Requirements
Risk Management
High Risk Ranking Requires higher assessment
<SPR70% Requires higher assessment >SPR70% No action Required
Incremental catch adjustment around SPR50% Size Target. Generic SPR @ Curve assumes worst-case productivity for species
Incremental catch adjustment around SPR50% Size & CPUE Targets
Dynamic assessment more accurate, less precautionary more catch
Quantitatively estimated BMSY, Bopt., SPRopt. targets & risk
The Risk – Catch – Cost Framework G
rad
uat
ed P
rogr
essi
on
In
crea
sin
g C
ost
s &
Incr
easi
ng
Pre
cisi
on