President Richard M. Nixon and the Watergate Scandal

Adapted from a presentation by the University of Nebraska at Omaha

Michael Quiñones

Clarifying QuestionClarifying Question

How did the Watergate scandal affect Americans’ view and trust of government?

Richard Nixon only narrowly won the 1968 election, but the combined total of popular votes for Nixon and Wallace indicated a shift to the right in American politics. Nixon had earlier been vice-president from 1952-1960 under President Eisenhower.

Although the 1960s began with optimism and possibility it ended in disunity and distrust.

The Vietnam war and several assassinations and crises eroded public trust in government and produced a backlash against liberal movements and the Democratic party.

The Election of 1968

Nixon campaigned as a champion of the silent majority, the hardworking Americans who paid taxes, did not demonstrate, and desired a restoration of "law and order.”

The silent majority was a stark contrast to the many student protestors, civil rights activists and counterculture figures who had forced vast changes in U.S. society.

Nixon vowed to restore respect for the rule of law, improve the international prestige of America, end wasteful and costly social programs, and provide strong leadership to end the turmoil of the 1960s.

Daniel Ellsberg and the Pentagon Papers Daniel Ellsberg was an employee

of the U.S. Department of Defense who leaked a series classified intelligence assessments of the Vietnam War in 1971.

The 7,000 page document stream came to be known as the Pentagon Papers.

The documents cast doubt on the justification for the U.S. entrance into the war and revealed that senior government officials had serious doubts about continuing the Vietnam war.

When the New York Times and Washington Post began to publish the Pentagon Papers, the Nixon Administration sued them to stop.

The Supreme Court ruled that the papers could continue to publish the documents because they served a valuable public interest.

After the release of the Pentagon Papers, the White House established a covert special investigative unit to ensure internal security of matters related to the executive branch called the White House Plumbers or simply the Plumbers.

This secretive unit was called the Plumbers because they stopped leaks. A leak occurs when private information that only privileged few know if secretly shared or “leaked” to the press.

In 1971 the Plumbers secretly burglarized the office of Daniel Ellsberg’s psychiatrist, seeking information to discredit him and the validity of the Pentagon Papers.

Later it was learned that Nixon’s domestic advisor John Ehrlichman had approved the plan.

Howard Hunt G. Gordon LiddyJames McCord Chuck Colson

The Watergate Hotel Break-in

Early pre-election polls were unfavorable for Nixon in the upcoming Election of 1972.

The Plumbers allegedly turned their activities to political espionage in order to gain an advantage on the Democratic opposition.

On the night of 17 June 1972, 5 men were arrested attempting to install wiretaps inside the headquarters of the Democratic Party inside the Watergate building in Washington D.C. A security guard on rounds had discovered that tape was holding a hallway door open that had not been there during his previous round of security checks. Police were called to investigate.

One of the men arrested, James McCord, was the head of security for the Republican Party.

The Nixon re-election campaign denied any and all involvement with the Watergate Hotel break-in.

Reporters Bob Woodward Reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of the and Carl Bernstein of the

Washington PostWashington Post

Watergate came to public attention largely because of Watergate came to public attention largely because of Bob WoodwardBob Woodward and and Carl BernsteinCarl Bernstein’s investigative stories published in the ’s investigative stories published in the Washington PostWashington Post. .

Despite enormous political pressure to kill the story, Despite enormous political pressure to kill the story, PostPost editor Ben editor Ben Bradlee, publisher Katherine Graham, supported the stories which were Bradlee, publisher Katherine Graham, supported the stories which were fueled by leaks fed them by a secretive confidential source codenamed fueled by leaks fed them by a secretive confidential source codenamed “Deepthroat” [ironically named after a popular pornographic movie of the “Deepthroat” [ironically named after a popular pornographic movie of the same name].same name].

The identity of Bernstein and Woodward’s source remained secret until in The identity of Bernstein and Woodward’s source remained secret until in 2005 former associate F.B.I director 2005 former associate F.B.I director Mark FeltMark Felt revealed himself as revealed himself as DeepthroatDeepthroat..

Watergate effects Nixon’s re-election Watergate effects Nixon’s re-election CampaignCampaign

The break-in was eventually tied to the Nixon reelection The break-in was eventually tied to the Nixon reelection campaign through a $25,000 check from a Republican donor that campaign through a $25,000 check from a Republican donor that was laundered through a Mexican bank and deposited into the was laundered through a Mexican bank and deposited into the account of Watergate arrested burglary suspect Bernard Barker. account of Watergate arrested burglary suspect Bernard Barker.

Later it was discovered that Later it was discovered that Former Attorney General John Former Attorney General John MitchellMitchell, head of Nixon’s “Committee to Re-Elect the , head of Nixon’s “Committee to Re-Elect the President,” (CREEP) controlled a secret fund for political President,” (CREEP) controlled a secret fund for political espionage. espionage.

Mitchell would later go to prison for his role in the scandal. Mitchell would later go to prison for his role in the scandal.

The Election of 1972The Election of 1972

Although the weight of Watergate investigation was increasing, it had not Although the weight of Watergate investigation was increasing, it had not yet reached the President by the time of the election of 1972, Nixon yet reached the President by the time of the election of 1972, Nixon eventually won reelection by the largest margin in history to that date.eventually won reelection by the largest margin in history to that date.

The Watergate The Watergate Investigations: Federal Investigations: Federal Judge Judge

John SiricaJohn Sirica Watergate was eventually Watergate was eventually investigated by a Special Prosecutor, investigated by a Special Prosecutor, a Senate committee, and by the judge a Senate committee, and by the judge in the original break-in case.in the original break-in case.

Judge Sirica refused to believe that Judge Sirica refused to believe that the burglars had acted alone [he the burglars had acted alone [he suspected a conspiracy]. suspected a conspiracy].

In March of 1973, defendant James In March of 1973, defendant James W. McCord sent a letter to Judge W. McCord sent a letter to Judge Sirica confirming that there was Sirica confirming that there was indeed a conspiracy.indeed a conspiracy.

Sirica’s investigation transformed Sirica’s investigation transformed Watergate from the story of a “third-Watergate from the story of a “third-rate burglary” to a scandal reaching rate burglary” to a scandal reaching the highest levels of the federal the highest levels of the federal government.government.

Senate Investigation and Senate Investigation and the Oval Office Tapesthe Oval Office Tapes

The U.S. Senate began The U.S. Senate began hearings into Watergate in hearings into Watergate in May 1973. May 1973.

The hearings were televised in The hearings were televised in their entirety and focused on their entirety and focused on how, if and when the President how, if and when the President knew of the break-in. knew of the break-in.

In June 1973, former White In June 1973, former White House legal counsel John Dean House legal counsel John Dean delivered damning testimony delivered damning testimony that implicated Nixon from the that implicated Nixon from the earliest days of Watergate. earliest days of Watergate.

Senate Investigation and the Oval Senate Investigation and the Oval Office TapesOffice Tapes

The Administration was eager to discredit Dean and his testimony so it began The Administration was eager to discredit Dean and his testimony so it began to release factual challenges to his account. to release factual challenges to his account.

When former White House aide Alexander Butterfield was asked about the When former White House aide Alexander Butterfield was asked about the source of the White House information, he revealed the existence of an source of the White House information, he revealed the existence of an automatic taping system that Nixon had secretly installed in the Oval Office. automatic taping system that Nixon had secretly installed in the Oval Office.

These tapes would become the focus of the investigation and eventually These tapes would become the focus of the investigation and eventually become damning.become damning.

The Smoking Gun TapesThe Smoking Gun Tapes Eventually the Supreme Court ruled that Nixon had to surrender the tapes of White Eventually the Supreme Court ruled that Nixon had to surrender the tapes of White

House conversations although he had initially refused citing executive privilege. House conversations although he had initially refused citing executive privilege.

Nixon was implicated from the earliest days of the cover-up according to the tapes:Nixon was implicated from the earliest days of the cover-up according to the tapes: By authorizing the payment of hush moneyBy authorizing the payment of hush money By attempting to use the CIA to interfere with the FBI investigation. By attempting to use the CIA to interfere with the FBI investigation.

One tape has an 18 ½ minute gap. One tape has an 18 ½ minute gap. Nixon’s secretary Rosemary Woods demonstrated how she could have inadvertently Nixon’s secretary Rosemary Woods demonstrated how she could have inadvertently

erased the tape, but the judge and prosecutors were not convinced. erased the tape, but the judge and prosecutors were not convinced. ““The smoking gun tapes,” were released in August 1974, just after the House The smoking gun tapes,” were released in August 1974, just after the House

Judiciary Committee approved Articles of Impeachment against Nixon. Judiciary Committee approved Articles of Impeachment against Nixon.

The Saturday Night The Saturday Night Massacre Massacre The Nixon Administration The Nixon Administration

reached an agreement with reached an agreement with the Senate Watergate the Senate Watergate Committee that its Committee that its Chairman would be allowed Chairman would be allowed to listen to tapes and to listen to tapes and provide a transcript to the provide a transcript to the Committee and to Committee and to Special Special Prosecutor Archibald CoxProsecutor Archibald Cox. .

The agreement collapsed The agreement collapsed when Cox refused to accept when Cox refused to accept the transcripts in place of the transcripts in place of the tapes. the tapes.

Since the Special Prosecutor Since the Special Prosecutor is an employee of the Justice is an employee of the Justice Department, Nixon ordered Department, Nixon ordered Attorney General Elliot Attorney General Elliot Richardson to fire Cox. Richardson to fire Cox.

The Saturday Night The Saturday Night MassacreMassacre

When Richardson refused to When Richardson refused to fire Cox, he was fired. fire Cox, he was fired.

Nixon then ordered Deputy Nixon then ordered Deputy Attorney General William D. Attorney General William D. Ruckelshaus to fire Cox .Ruckelshaus to fire Cox .

When he also refused, he too When he also refused, he too was fired. was fired.

Nixon then ordered Solicitor Nixon then ordered Solicitor General General Robert BorkRobert Bork (who (who was later nominated for the was later nominated for the Supreme Court by Reagan Supreme Court by Reagan and rejected) to fire Cox and and rejected) to fire Cox and he complied.he complied.

The The Washington PostWashington Post reported on the “Saturday reported on the “Saturday Night Massacre.”Night Massacre.”

President Nixon Resigns the President Nixon Resigns the PresidencyPresidency

On 27 July 1974, the House On 27 July 1974, the House Judiciary Committee approved Judiciary Committee approved Articles of Impeachment against Articles of Impeachment against Nixon. Nixon.

The House was to vote on the The House was to vote on the matter soon. matter soon.

Nixon conceded that impeachment Nixon conceded that impeachment in the House was likely, but he in the House was likely, but he believed that the Senate vote to believed that the Senate vote to remove him would fail. remove him would fail.

On 5 August 1974, when the On 5 August 1974, when the “smoking gun tape” became “smoking gun tape” became public, a delegation from the public, a delegation from the Republican National Committee Republican National Committee told Nixon that he would not told Nixon that he would not survive the vote in the Senate. survive the vote in the Senate.

Nixon was visited by republican Nixon was visited by republican senator senator Barry GoldwaterBarry Goldwater from from Arizona as was told he two choices: Arizona as was told he two choices: [1] be the first president to be [1] be the first president to be removed by impeachment removed by impeachment oror [2] [2] the first to resignthe first to resign

On 9 August 1974, Richard Nixon On 9 August 1974, Richard Nixon became the first American became the first American president to resign. president to resign.

AftermathAftermath

More than 30 government officials went to prison for their role in More than 30 government officials went to prison for their role in Watergate. Watergate.

Richard Nixon, however, was not one of them. Richard Nixon, however, was not one of them. In September 1974, President Gerald Ford gave Nixon a full pardon. In September 1974, President Gerald Ford gave Nixon a full pardon. Reporters Woodward and Bernstein won the Pulitzer Prize for investigative Reporters Woodward and Bernstein won the Pulitzer Prize for investigative

journalism. journalism. They collaborated on 2 books, They collaborated on 2 books, All the President’s MenAll the President’s Men and and The Final DaysThe Final Days. . In 1976 In 1976 All the President’s MenAll the President’s Men a film about the scandal was won an Oscar. a film about the scandal was won an Oscar.

President Gerald Ford announcing the pardon of former president Richard Nixon

Reexamining the Reexamining the Clarifying QuestionClarifying Question

How did the Watergate How did the Watergate scandal affect scandal affect Americans’ view and Americans’ view and trust of government?trust of government?

Citations Slide 2: http://www.teachersparadise.com/ency/en/media/3/38/electoralcollege1968_large.pngSlide 3: http://www.fadedgiant.net/assets/images/nixon_richard_campaign_1968-550.jpgSlide 4: http://www.harvardsquarelibrary.org/stafford/images/danielellsberg.jpg Slide 5: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/images/wgate/wpics_tline/tlbig/hunt200.jpg, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/images/wgate/wpics_tline/tlbig/lid200.jpg , http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/JFKmccord2.jpg , http://www.newsbeacon.com/columns_files/colson.jpgSlide 6: http://www.historyplace.com/unitedstates/impeachments/watergate-complex.jpgSlide 7: http://my.brandeis.edu/news/images/bernstein_woodward_ap_bild.jpgSlide 8: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4678527 Slide 9: http://www.teachersparadise.com/ency/en/media/9/94/electoralcollege1972_large.png Slide 10: http://www.npr.org/politics/watergate/sirica.jpg Slide 11: http://img.timeinc.net/time/magazine/archive/covers/1973/1101730709_400.jpg Slide 12: http://www.gwu.edu/~elliott/news/briefing/pics/butterfield.jpg Slide 13: http://img.timeinc.net/time/magazine/archive/covers/1973/1101731210_400.jpg Slide 14: http://www.law.harvard.edu/alumni/bulletin/2004/summer/images/gallery.jpg Slide 15: http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/bork.jpg Slide 16: http://www.landmarkcases.org/nixon/images/nixon_resignation.jpg Slide 17: http://www.umich.edu/~urecord/0607/Jan08_07/img/070108_ford_pardon.jpgSlide 18: http://www.constitutioncenter.org/timeline/flash/assets/asset_upload_file761_12313.jpg

http://americanradioworks.publicradio.org/features/prestapes/images/rmn_jm.jpg