presented by: cfm/vr-tesco, llc scott smith – svp & general manager

43
Presented By: CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager Roy Button – Welding Engineer & Specialty Welding (WDI) Division Manager

Upload: satin

Post on 01-Feb-2016

37 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

VALVE MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA TECHNICAL SEMINAR IN-LINE WELD REPAIRS OF VALVE DEFECTS (FAILURE CASES & WELD REPAIR ACTIVITIES PER ASME SECTION 1 AND B31.1 CODE REQUIREMENTS). Presented By: CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Presented By: CFM/VR-TESCO, LLCScott Smith – SVP & General ManagerRoy Button – Welding Engineer & Specialty Welding (WDI) Division Manager

Page 2: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Our Presentation FocusWHO ARE WE?Continental Field Machining (CFM) formed a valve

repair division in 1986 known as “VR-TESCO”.CFM/VR-TESCO is highly focused on disassembly,

inspection, repair, and reassembly of valves throughout the Power Generation Sector.

Specialized welding and machining equipment has been developed to effectively complete difficult in-line valve repairs.

Personnel are given extensive training to perform these activities.

2

Page 3: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Our Presentation Focus

Our presentation focus is on ASME Section 1 and B31.1 Code valve repairs performed within the past (2) two years.

In this timeframe, CFM/VR-TESCO has performed major welding and machining repairs on (46) forty-six plus ASME Code large bore valves.

The valve sizes have ranged between 12” to 24”.

Valves from all the major OEM’s have been included in these repairs.

3

Page 4: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Our Presentation Focus

(21) twenty-one of these valves are Code Boundary valves, hence repairs are performed following guidelines of ASME Section I and National Board Inspection Code and Jurisdictional requirements.

(25) twenty-five plus valves were part of the Boiler external piping, hence repairs are performed following guidelines of ASME B31.1.

4

Page 5: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Original Manufacture of Valves

Valves manufactured for use in Power Generation are produced under the American National Standards as outlined in ASME B16.34.

This standard applies to new construction and covers pressure-temperature ratings, dimensions, tolerances, materials, NDE requirements, testing, marking for cast, forged and fabricated valves with flanged, threaded or welding ends.

5

Page 6: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Original Manufacture of Valves

It is the manufacturer’s responsibility to provide the purchaser with documentation that details his program compliance in the manufacturing of the products.

Requirements for manufacturing may be less stringent than those required for repair of the product.

Listed are acceptance NDE criteria for new valves manufactured.

6

Page 7: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B16.34 Acceptance Criteria

B16.34 - 11-2 Acceptance Standards for Magnetic Particle Examination (MT) B16.34 - 11-2 Acceptance Standards for

Magnetic Particle Examination (MT) 11-2.1 Castings – Maximum acceptable indications are as follows :a. Linear indications

(1) 0.3” long for materials up to 0.5” thick.(2) 0.5” long for material 0.5” to 1.0” thick.(3) 0.7” long for material over 1.0” thick.

For linear indications, the indications must be separated by a distance greater than the length of an acceptable indication. A linear is one with length in excess of 3 times the width.

11-2.2 Forgings and Rolled or Wrought Material – Maximum acceptable indications are as follows:a. Linear indications

(1) 0.2” long for materials up to 0.5” thick.(2) 0.4” long for materials over 0.5” – 1.0”thick.(3) .06” long for materials over 1.0” thick.For linear indications, the indications must be separated by a distance greater than the length of an acceptable indication. A linear indication is one with length in excess of 3 times the width.

7

Page 8: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B16.34 Acceptance Criteria

B16.34 - 11-2 Acceptance Standards for Magnetic Particle Examination (MT)

B16.34 - 11-2 Acceptance Standards for Magnetic Particle Examination (MT)

11-2.1 Castings – Continuedb.Rounded Indications

(1) 0.3” diameter for materials up to0.5” thick.(2) 0.5” diameter for materials over 0.5” thick.

Four or more rounded indications in a line separated by 0.06” or less edge to edge are unacceptable. Rounded indications are those that are not defined as linear indications.

11-2.2 Forgings and Rolled or Wrought Material – Continuedb. Rounded Indications

(1) 0.2” diameter for materials up to 0.5” thick.(2) 0.3” diameter for materials over 0.5” thick.

Four or more rounded indications in a line Separated by a 0.06” or less edge to edge are Unacceptable. Rounded indications are thosethat are not defined as linear indications.

8

Page 9: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B16.34 Acceptance Criteria

B16.34 - 111-2 Acceptance Standards for Liquid Penetrant Examination (PT)

B16.34 - 111-2 Acceptance Standards for Liquid Penetrant Examination (PT)

111-2.1 Castings – Maximum acceptable indications are as follows:a. Linear Indications

(1) 0.3” long for materials up to0.5” thick.(2) 0.5” long for materials over 0.5” to 1.0” thick.(3) 0.7” long for materials 1.0” thick.

For linear indications, the indicationsmust be separated by a distance greater than the length of an acceptable indication. A linear indication is one withlength in excess of 3 times the width.

111-2.2 Forgings and Rolled or Wrought Material - Maximum acceptable indications are as follows:a. Linear Indications

(1) 0.2” long for materials up to 0.5” thick or less.(2) 0.4” long for materials over 0.5” to 1.0” thick.(3) 0.6” long for materials over 1.0” thick.

For linear indications, the indications must be separated by a distance greater than the Length of an acceptable indication. A linear indications is one with length in excess of 3 times the width.

9

Page 10: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B16.34 Acceptance Criteria

B16.34 - 111-2 Acceptance Standards for Liquid Penetrant Examination (PT)

B16.34 - 111-2 Acceptance Standards for Liquid Penetrant Examination (PT)

111-2.1 Castings – Continuedb.Rounded Indications

(1) 0.3” diameter for materials up to0.5” thick.(2) 0.5” diameter for materials over 0.5” thick.

Four or more rounded indications in line separated by 0.06” or less edge to edge are unacceptable. Rounded indications are those that are not defined as linear indications.

111-2.2 Forgings and Rolled or Wrought Material - Continued

b. Rounded Indications(1) 0.2” diameter for materials up to 0.5” thick.(2) 0.3” diameter for materials over 0.5” thick.

Four or more rounded indications in a line separated by 0.06” or less edge to edge are unacceptable. Rounded indications are those that are not defined as linear indications.

10

Page 11: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME Section I Repairs Repair requirements of a valve are usually confined to the

location of the valve in the boiler piping system of the power plant.

If the valve to be repaired is located in the piping system which is considered part of the boiler proper or part of the external boiler piping it is declared to be inside the Boiler Code Boundary.

Preamble to ASME Section I paragraphs 4, 5 & 7 provide the detailed information defining Code Boundary’s.

Repairs to piping and valves within the Code Boundary are repaired using the requirements provided in ASME Section I, National Board Inspection Code (NBIC) and the jurisdiction.

11

Page 12: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME Section I Repairs

To repair Section I Items a Quality Program & NBIC “R” Stamp certification is required.

12

Page 13: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve RepairsCFM/VR-TESCO, LLC performed (21) twenty-one

“R” Stamp repairs in 2010-2012.

Most of the repairs can be segregated in to 3 groups.1. Valves requiring a seat or seats replaced.2. Removal and rewelding of integral valve seats.3. Repairs of cracks in the valve body or on guide ribs

or disc guides.

Of the (21) twenty-one valves repaired (10) ten valves required replacement of seat rings.

13

Page 14: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve RepairsAll (10) valve bodies were SA217-C12A material.(10) Seats had cracks in partial penetration welds of

seat to body. Many of these welds had full 360o cracks.

(6) Seats had Hardface material missing from the seat face.

(1) Valve had 316 SS seats that were cracked 360o andwere replaced with A182-F91 material seats.(4) Valves had seats that were manufactured from A355-P22 (P5A) material and they were replaced like for like.

14

Page 15: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve RepairsSEAT RING REPLACEMENTAll seat ring replacements were completed utilizing

the following guidelines:Minimum preheat 400oF.Welding process machine GTAW.WPS – 15E MN/GTAW-HT..035” dia wire – ER90S-B9.Mn & Ni chemistry < 1.0.PWHT @ 1375oF – 2 hours soak time.

15

Page 16: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve RepairsThermocouples and ceramic pads on ID seat area.Final NDE (PT) & (VT).

16

Page 17: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve RepairsINTEGRAL SEAT REPAIR CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC repaired integral seats in (11) Eleven valves from 2010 – 2012.

Base metal of valve bodies were:(2) A217-WC6(9) A217-C12A

All (11) valves had cracks in the seat area Hardfacegoing in to the base metal.

17

Page 18: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve Repairs(4) Four valves had major cracks in the upper and

lower 6oclock rib @ rib to body interface.

(10) Ten valves had indications in the Stellite Hardfacing on the guide ribs. This required removal of the Stellite and undercutting of the base metal. The repair required rewelding of the base metal and Hardfacing.

18

Page 19: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve RepairsINTEGRAL SEAT REPAIRSCFM/VR-TESCO, LLC utilized the following guidelines for Integral Seat Repairs.1.All defects removed after removal of Stellite hard

facing material and approximately .080” of base metal.

2.NDE (PT) inspection of all repair areas.3.Sketch and dimensioning of all repair areas.

19

Page 20: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve Repairs4. Preheat valve to 400oF minimum.

NOTE: 300oF for P4 material.5. Weld excavated repair areas and Hardface under

cut areas with Er90S-B9.NOTE: Er80S-B2 for P4 material.

6. Base metal area profiled and NDE with dry (MT)on P15E material. Base material is kept at 100oF minimum. No moisture allowed on as welded P15E materials.NOTE: PT or wet (MT) allowed on all other low alloy materials.

20

Page 21: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve Repairs 7. Preheat back to 400oF.

NOTE: 300oF for P-4 base materials.8. Apply a minimum of (2) layers of Stellite 21.9. Cool valve to below 175oF and visually inspect

the welds.10. PWHT minimum hold 2 hours @ 1375oF per heat

treat traveler.NOTE: PWHT temp 1250oF for P-4 material.

21

Page 22: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Section I Valve Repairs11. Profile the seat and ribs to OEM specifications.12. Final NDE, PT to ASME Section 1, VT to ASME

B31.1 13. AI review of the weld data package and issuance of

R-1 Form and data plate as required.

22

Page 23: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B31.1 Valve Repairs CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC repaired (25) plus valves per

ASME B31.1 requirements in 2010-2012.The majority of the valves were parallel slide gate valves. (22) Valves required seat replacements.

ASME B31.1 covers the external boiler piping as defined for power boilers, high temperature, high pressure boilers in which steam or vapor is generated at a pressure of more than 15psig and high temperature water is generated at pressure exceeding 160psig and/or temperature of 250oF.

23

Page 24: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B31.1 Valve Repairs All welding or brazing of pipes or items shall be

performed by manufacturers or contractors who perform repairs holding stamps for symbols shown in Fig. PG-105.1 thru PG-105.3 of ASME Section I of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. (B31.1 Chapter 1 100.1.2).

The installer of external boiler piping joined by welding or brazing is required to have a Quality Control system meeting, requirements of Mandatory Appendix J of the ASME B31.1 Code.

24

Page 25: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B31.1 Valve Repairs For repairs of valves controlled by the

requirements of B31.1 the following are required to be documented.1. Removal of defect or reduce to acceptable

size as outlined in Chapter V 127.4.11.2. NDE of the defect area by Magnetic

Particle (MT) or Liquid Penetrant (PT) examination. NDE inspection acceptance criteria per Chapter V – 136.4.3 for (MT)

& 136.4.4 for (PT).

25

Page 26: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B31.1 Valve Repairs3. Preheat of the base material as required

in Chapter V-131 “Welding Preheat”.4. Welding shall be performed by use of

PQR’s, WPS’s & WPQ’s as outlined in Chapter V-127.5.

5. PWHT of the repair as required by Chapter V-132 “PWHT Requirements”.

6. Final NDE of the repair as required in Chapter V-136.4 “Examination methods

26

Page 27: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B31.1 Valve Repairs6. for Welds & Repairs”. ASME B31.1

Chapter V.

a. Visual Examination (VT) – 136.4.2 b. Magnetic Particle Examination

(MT) – 136.4.3 c. Liquid Penetrant Examination

(PT) – 136.4.4

27

Page 28: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

ASME B31.1 Valve Repairs All examinations to be performed by technicians certified to perform each non- destructive examination per ASME B31.1 Chapter V – 136.3.2 “Qualifications of NDE personnel”.

28

Page 29: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1

29

REPAIR REPAIR 360O CRACKED SEAL WELD 360o CRACKED SEAL WELD SEAT RING SEAT RING FIGURE - 1 FIGURE - 2

Page 30: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1

30

REPAIR REPAIR SEAL WELDING OF SEAT RING SEAL WELDED SEAT RING IN GATE VALVE IN GATE VALVE FIGURE - 3 FIGURE - 4

THERMOCOUPLE PLACEMENT FOR PRE-HEAT

Page 31: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1

31

REPAIR 6 O’CLOCK GUIDE RIB CRACKING @ INTREGAL SEAT INTERFACE AND CRACKING 360 DEG. AROUND RIB FIGURE - 5 FIGURE - 6

Page 32: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1 REPAIR

CRACKING IN INTREGAL SEAT AND GUIDE RIBS IN GLOBE VALVES FIGURE -7

FIGURE - 8

32

CRACKS IN INTERGAL SEAT

CRACKS IN GUIDE RIBS

CRACKS IN INTREGAL SEAT

CRACKS IN GUIDE RIB

Page 33: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1 REPAIR

LAMINATION IN GUIDE RIBS FIGURE - 9

FIGURE - 10

33

LAMINATION IN GUIDE RIB LAMINATION GUIDE RIB PIECES

Page 34: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1

34

REPAIR WELDING INTREGAL SEAT FIGURE - 11

GTAW MACHINE WELD OF INTREGAL SEAT

Page 35: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

REPAIRS – ASME SECTION 1 & B31.1

35

REPAIR COMPLETED SEAT RING PARTIAL PENETRATION WELD FIGURE - 12

Page 36: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

Successful repair of valves and valve components are a Hallmark of CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC’s years of service. It Takes a lot more than just welding and machining skills to repair today’s valve deficiencies.It starts with gathering all the information available about the valve to be repaired. All the valve component information from the OEM when the valve was 1st purchased.

36

Page 37: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

The customer must supply the following information toallow for the completion of work travelers and R-1 dataform if required.Unit NumberBoiler ManufacturerMfg Serial NumberNational Board NumberJurisdiction NumberYear Built

37

Page 38: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

Original Code of ConstructionSystem and location of valve being workedValve DrawingValve IdentificationValve Year of Manufacture

38

Page 39: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

Once all the pertinent information is gathered QA and The Welding Department start the planning process:

Initiate work traveler and weld data sheets.Identify WPS’s and Welder Performance

Qualifications.Create PWHT Traveler.Identify NDE requirements and notify NDE

subcontractor.

39

Page 40: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

Issue filler material and supporting documentation MTR/CMTR’s.

Notify Authorized Inspector (If required). Present Data Package to Project Manager for review.

40

Page 41: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC has specialized machining andWelding equipment that is required to repair the different types of valve repairs. Equipment is staged and inspected before shipping to each project.

Personnel training on specialized equipment and valve repairs.

41

Page 42: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

The recipe for success may seem simple, but care must be taken on each step to insure the “best possible” results for each valve repair.

CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC working with OEM’s and our Customers have been “Teaming Together for Success” for over 26 years.

42

Page 43: Presented By:  CFM/VR-TESCO, LLC Scott Smith – SVP & General Manager

Recipe for Success

43