practical religion: living through the ages - mcgill university

CANONSUndergraduate Journal of Religious Studies

McGill UniversityVol. VIII

!"#$#%

Undergraduate Journal of Religious StudiesMcGill University

!"#$%&'()*+*!"#$#%,*-./0%'%1/21)0*3"2%.14*"5*604&'&"27*8)2/&079*:;<&44*-.&=0%7&)$9*:".)%0149*!1.1/19*>?@>A

B/&)"%&14*7040;)&".9*;"C#&41)&".9*1./*C1)0%&14*+*D$*)(0*>?@>*B/&)"%&14*E"1%/*"5*!"#$#%&1./*&)7*;".)%&D2)"%7A

!"#$#%*&7*1.*1;1/0C&;*F"2%.14*"5*:;<&44*-.&=0%7&)$*G&)(*72DC&77&".7*D$*2./0%'%1/21)0*7)2/0.)7A*

H%&.)0/*1./*D"2./*&.*!1.1/1*D$*!"#&0*BI#%077*:".)%014A*

J44*%&'()7*%070%=0/A*BI;0#)*5"%*D%&05*#1771'07*K2")0/*1./*;&)0/*5%"C*0I)0%.14*12)("%79*."*#1%)*"5*)(&7*D""L*C1$*D0*%0#%&.)0/*"%*%0#%"/2;0/*"%*2)&4&M0/*&.*1.$*5"%C*"%*D$*1.$*040;)%".&;9*C0;(1.&;149*"%*")(0%*C01.79*."G*L."G.*"%*(0%015)0%* &.=0.)0/9* &.;42/&.'*#(")";"#$&.'*1./*%0;"%/&.'9*"%*&.*1.$*&.5"%C1)&".*7)"%1'0*"%*%0)%&0=14*7$7)0C9*G&)("2)*#0%C&77&".*&.*G%&)&.'*5%"C*)(0*#2D4&7(0%A

8#0;&14*N(1.L7*)"*)(0*J%)7*-./0%'%1/21)0*8";&0)$9*)(0*O1;24)$*"5*604&'&"27*8)2/&079*)(0*8)2/0.)7P*8";&0)$*"5*:;<&44*-.&=0%7&)$9*1./*)(0*604&'&"27*8)2/&07*-./0%'%1/21)0*8";&0)$*5"%*0.1D4&.'*)(0*#2D4&;1)&".*"5*)(&7*F"2%.14A

Q1$"2)*1./*/07&'.*D$*6$1.*R0140$A*

!"#$#%FEATURING ESSAYS BY

!"#$%&%'#(')$*+,(%"'-*,.*/$-0&0,(1*2)(#0$1

Mallory Hennigar Maxwell Lanocha

Kaitlin D’Avella

Laura Moncion Rachel RosenbluthJulia Yudelman

EDITOR-IN-CHIEFNatalie Gershtein

ASSOCIATE EDITORSAbbie Buckman

James Farr Ryan Healey

Mallory Hennigar Jasmine Lefresne Avian Tang

DESIGN EDITORRyan Healey

Table of Contents

!"#$%&'()!"#$%$"*)+#,-./.-,&#0)"#)+#$&"#)1",&2#"3&(,'()423&,&5"3)6(-)27),%-)8"9":"#")!"##$%&'()**+,"% 9

;2#5-&<&#0),%-)=2$:)27);%&#-(-)=>$$%&(9)!"-.)##'/"*$01"' 27

8-3&0&2>()?.--$292"+3#+*'4567)##"

41

!-#$-.3-(()@>9"#&,:*);%.&(,)"()A2,%-.)&#)B>3&"#)27)12.C&5%)/"8%"'!$*0+$* 51

43"#,&#0),%-)D--$()27);%"#0-*)E%-)B-C&(%)?."9-C2.F)72.)")D>(,"&#"G3-)?22$)D:(,-99"01)#'9$:)*;#831 59

/)33)%'<%$='31)'>?+3$% vi

About the Editors and Contributors 86

E%-2.:)&#)4."5,&5-*);29/".&#0)H((-#,&"3&(,)H527-9&#&(9)"#$)I$<"&,")J-$"#,")"()D2>.5-()27)I&$)72.)+#$&"'()?2.-(,()@8#+"'A8?)#="* 77

vi

Letter from the Editor

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

T*(1=0*D00.*1*#1%)*"5*!"#$#%*5"%*)(0*#17)*)(%00*$01%7*1./*&.*)(1)*)&C0*(1=0*G&).0770/*

)(0*#2D4&7(&.'*7)1'0A*U"G9*5"2%*$01%7*41)0%9*.")*".4$*(17*&)*%0C1&.0/*;".7&7)0.)*&.* &)7*$01%4$*#2D4&;1)&".9*D2)* )(0*K214&)$*"5*1;1/0C&;*G"%L*(17* 7#&%140/*(&'(0%*1./*(&'(0%*01;(*$01%A*N(&7*&7*&.*#1%)*/20*)"*)(0*#%07)&'0*1./*(&'(*7)1./1%/*70)*D$*01;(*#%0;0/&.'*0/&)"%V&.V;(&05*1./*0/&)"%&14*D"1%/9*;"2#40/*G&)(*)(0*1CD&)&".*1./*

Q17)* $01%*G0*G0%0* 5"%;0/* )"* )2%.* 1G1$*C1.$*G"./0%524* #1#0%79* #2D4&7(&.'* 1*!"#$#%*1&C0/*)"*#2D4&7(*

".0*0I)%1*#1#0%*)(&7*$01%9*#244&.'*)"'0)(0%*52./&.'*5%"C*=1%&"27*"2)40)7*1=1&41D40*1)*:;<&44A*S0*%0;0&=0/* )(0*'%01)07)*.2CD0%*"5*72DC&77&".7* )"*/1)09* )")14&.'*1)*

)"*)2%.*/"G.*7"C0*)%24$*G044*G%&))0.*1./*2.&K20*G"%L7A

)(%&440/*)"*D0*1D40*)"*7040;)*#1#0%7*1C".'*72;(*1*G&/0*1%%1$*"5*0I;0#)&".14*)"#&;7A**

)"'0)(0%*C1.$*&C#"%)1.)*;".)0C#"%1%$*&77207A*

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

vii

!"#$ %#&'$ '()$ *+*#,-$ '+.#$ +$ /)).$ +'$ '()$ (#-'#,%$ ,#/010)%-2$ 3",0-'0+%0'4$ +%5$

675+0-89$ ,#-*#:'0;#/4<$ =>#%5#,/#--$?78+%0'4@$ A4$ B+7,+$C)%:0)%$ 5,+(-$ 7*)%$

+$:,#+'0;#$#&+80%+'0)%$)D$3",0-'$ +-$C)'"#,$ 0%$ 67/0+%$)D$E),(0:"F-$!"#"$%&'()*+(,+-'#')"+.(#"9$#&*/),0%1$'"#$:)%:#*'$)D$>)5$("0/-'$',+%-:#%50%1$:+'#1),0#-$)D$1#%5#,<$$G)7,'"$0%$)7,$/0%#H7*$'"0-$4#+,$0-$I+:"#/$I)-#%A/7'"F-$=J/+%'0%1$'"#$K##5-$

)D$3"+%1#<@$!"0-$*+*#,$'"),)71"/4$5#/;#-$0%')$'"#$#'"0:+/$+%5$/#1+/$08*/0:+'0)%-$

)D$8)5#,%H5+4$D))5$-4-'#8-$'",)71"$'"#$/#%-$)D$6#(0-"$/+(<$G0%+//49$(#$:/)-#$)7,$

L)7,%+/$(0'"$+$:)8*+,0-)%$)D$M--#%'0+/0-'$M:)D#80%0-8$+%5$'"#$?0%57$-:"))/$)D$

'")71"'$)D$N5;+0'+$O#5+%'+<$67/0+$P75#/8+%F-$=!"#),4$0%$J,+:'0:#@$*,);05#-$+%$

);#,;0#($)D$'"#$5#-',7:'0)%$)D$Q%50+F-$D),#-'-$+%5$"4*)'"#-0R#-$N5;+0'+$O#5+%'+$

+-$+$8),#$;0+A/#$)*'0)%$D),$+55,#--0%1$'"#$:7,,#%'$8+L),$#:)H:,0-0-$0%$Q%50+<$

I+%10%1$0%$'"#8#-$D,)8$'"#$#%;0,)%8#%'9$-#&7+/0'49$"78+%$,01"'-$+%5$D,##5)8$')$

/%)()*$

'+.#$'"0-$)**),'7%0'4$')$'"+%.$'"#$#50'),0+/$A)+,5$+%5$#+:"$+7'"),$D),$:)%',0A7'0%1$

'"#0,$#DD),'-$')$8+.0%1$'"0-$L)7,%+/$'"#$"01"#-'$S7+/0'4$Q$"+;#$-##%$4#'<$Q'$"+-$A##%$

84$")%)7,$+%5$*,0;0/#1#$')$(),.$(0'"$-7:"$'+/#%'#59$"+,5$(),.0%1$+%5$:"+,0-8+'0:$

0%50;057+/-<$

G0%+//49$ Q$(0-"$ ')$ '+.#$ +$8)8#%'$ ')$ :)88#%5$ '"#$ D+:7/'4$ +%5$ -'+DD$(0'"0%$ '"#$

I#/010)7-$K'750#-$ 5#*+,'8#%'<$!"#$8+1%#'0-8$ +%5$ *+--0)%$ '"+'$ )7,$ 0%-',7:'),-$

+%5$*,)D#--),-$ A,0%1$ ')$ '"#0,$(),.$ 0-$ ',7/4$ 0%-*0,0%1<$!"#$GIK$:)887%0'4$"+-$

"#/*#5$')$8+.#$'"#$A#+7'0D7/$T0,.-$T70/50%1$+$")8#$D),$8+%4$-'75#%'-9$+%5$Q$"+;#$

%)$5)7A'$'"+'$C:>0//F-$I#/010)7-$K'750#-$*,)1,+8$(0//$:)%'0%7#$')$:)8*#/$%#($

-'75#%'-$')$#&*/),#$'"#$/080'/#--$0%;#-'01+'0)%-$'"+'$:+%$A#$D)7%5$'"#,#0%<$

U0'"$(+,8$(0-"#-9

E+'+/0#$>#,-"'#0%

M50'),H0%H3"0#D$

/%)()*9$V'"$M50'0)%

9

!"#$%&'()!"#$%$")&*+,-.-,+/*0)1*)&*2/1*)#1+/3*14/5+'5)634/+/714)85,)39)

+:,);1<1=1*1

!"##$%&'()**+,"%

10

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

J7* 8(04/".* H"441;L* &4427)%1)07* &.* (&7* 70C&.14* 0771$* W61C1$1.1* 1./*H"4&)&;14* TC1'&.1)&".* &.* T./&19X* )(0* 61C1$1.1* .1%%1)&=0* (17* D00.* /00#4$*;"..0;)0/*G&)(*T./&1.*#"4&)&;7*7&.;0*)(0*)G045)(*;0.)2%$*]H"441;L*@_`^A*J)*&)7*C"7)*D17&;9* )(0*61C1$1.1* &7* 1* ;4177&;* )140* "5* '""/* )%&2C#(&.'* "=0%* 0=&49*C1L&.'* &)*;"./2;&=0* )"*/&=&7&=0*#"4&)&;14*1'0./17A*J*;".)0C#"%1%$*0I1C#40*"5* )(&7* &7* )(0*R&./2* 6&'()P7* 1##%"#%&1)&".* "5* &C1'0%$* 1./* %(0)"%&;* 5%"C* )(0* 61C1$1.1* )"*&.;&)0*=&"40.;0*1./*0I;427&".1%$*#"4&)&;7*1'1&.7)*:274&C7A*R"G0=0%9* )(0*R&./2*6&'()*G0%0*.")*)(0*".4$*T./&1.*.1)&".14&7)7*G("*270/*)(0*61C1$1.1*)"*5"%G1%/*1* #"4&)&;14* 1'0./1a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

N(0*&C#"%)1.;0*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1*)"*)(0*5"%C1)&".*1./*/&770C&.1)&".*"5*

<1./(&P7*(")*+*",*T.)0%#%0)&.'*1.*T./&1.*U1)&".14&7)P7H"4&)&;14*-70*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1

11

<1./(&P7*#"4&)&;7*&7*2./0.&1D40A*H(&44&#*Q2)'0./"%5*D0'&.7*(&7*0771$*WT.)0%#%0)&.'*(")0"1X*G&)(*1*/&7;277&".*"5*<1./(&P7*#"4&)&;14*270*"5*)(0*61C1$1.19*%0;"'.&M&.'*)(1)*<1./(&*G"24/*"5)0.*K2")0*N247&/17P*(")2,"0+-)"#"%*&.*7#00;(07*1./*40))0%7A**Q2)'0./"%5*.")07*)(1)*".*1)*4017)*".0*";;17&".*<1./(&*71&/*)(1)*)(0*U".V!""#0%1)&".*:"=0C0.)*G17*&.7#&%0/*D$*8&)1P7*%07&7)1.;0*)"*61=1.1*]Q2)'0./"%5*>_bÂ*T./00/*<1./(&*#%";41&C0/*(&C7045*W1*/0=")00*"5*N247&/17*5%"C*c(&7d*;(&4/(""/*e*cG("*(1/d9*)(0%05"%09*14G1$7*G"%7(&##0/*<"/*17*61C1X*]!345*fb,>b_Â@*Q2)'0./"%5*1%'207* )(1)* ".0* "5* )(0*C"7)* &C#"%)1.)* 17#0;)7* "5*<1./(&P7*61C1$1.1V&.7#&%0/*%(0)"%&;*G17*(&7*270*"5*)(0*)0%C*(")"0"1."*])(0*%240*"5*61C^*W)"*1%)&;241)0*(&7*/%01C*"5*1.*&./0#0./0.)*T./&19*"5)0.*0K21)&.'*&)*G&)(*"%*#%050%%&.'*&)*)"*)(0*)0%C*%6"0"1*]7045V%240^X*]Q2)'0./"%5*>_bÂ*<1./(&P7*270*"5*61C1%1F$1*&.*#41;0*"5*)(0*C"%0*70;241%* )0%C*%6"0"1* &7* %&50*G&)(*;".)%1/&;)&".9*1./*G17*"##"70/*D$*")(0%*401/0%7* "5* )(0* T./&1.* %0="42)&".* ]Q2)'0./"%5* >_gÂ*<1./(&P7* ;%&)&;7* K207)&".0/*)(0*#%"/2;)&=&)$*"5*27&.'*1.*1.;&0.)*%04&'&"27*7)"%$*17*1*G1$*)"*&C1'&.0*)(0*52)2%0*&./0#0./0.)* T./&19* 1%'2&.'* )(1)* &)*G"24/*D0*C"%0*1##%"#%&1)0* )"* 401=0* )(0*#17)*D0(&./*1./*0CD%1;0*1*.0G*70;241%*52)2%0A***

Q2)'0./"%5* )%&07* )"* %0;".;&40* )(070* ;".)%1/&;)"%$* =&0G7* D$* 1%'2&.'*)(1)* )("2'(* ")(0%* T./&1.* .1)&".14&7)7* 5"2./* &)* #%"D40C1)&;9* <1./(&* &/014&M0/*(")"0"1."&D0;1270*(0* %0;"'.&M0/* )(0*1D&4&)$*"5* )(0*61C1$1.1* )"* 7#01L* )"* )(0*=17)*C1F"%&)$*"5*T./&1.7*]Q2)'0./"%5*>_gÂ*S(&40*)(&7*&7*1.*&C#"%)1.)*17#0;)*"5*G($*<1./(&*270/*)(0*61C1$1.19*&)*".4$*#1%)&144$*0I#41&.7*G($*(0*5"2./*&)*)"*D0*72;(*1*#"G0%524*=0(&;40*5"%*;"CC2.&;1)&.'*(&7*#"4&)&;14*=&7&".A*Z.0*"5*)(0*C"7)*0550;)&=0*1./*;".7&7)0.)*C0)("/7*)(1)*<1./(&*270/*)"*;"CC2.&;1)0*(&7*#"4&)&;14*#(&4"7"#($*G17*D$*#($7&;144$*0CD"/$&.'*(&7*&/014&7)&;*#%&.;&#407A*N(&7*G17*.")*1*

)"*G"%LA*T.*(&7*D""L*5"#7,+8%&9$7.9*3"70#(*J4)0%*/0C".7)%1)07*("G*/0=04"#&.'*".0P7*C"%14&)$*1./*C1&.)1&.&.'*".0P7*(014)(*G0%0*&.)%&.7&;144$*4&.L0/*&.*<1./(&P7*#(&4"7"#($9* )(27* 0I#41&.&.'* )(0* &C#"%)1.;0* "5* <1./(&P7* #%0";;2#1)&".* G&)(*(&7*/&0)9*0I0%;&709*1./*D"/&4$* 52.;)&".7*]J4)0%*hV`Â*:1&.)1&.&.'*:0",)"2,"0."*];04&D1;$a*7045V;".)%"4^*1./*0.;"2%1'&.'*)(0*$"2)(*)"*401/*1*4&50*"5*7045V%07)%1&.)*

(014&.'*".07045X*]J4)0%*>bÂ*N(0%05"%09*(&7*;".;0%.*5"%*(&7*"G.*D"/&4$*52.;)&".7*1./*1;)&".79*17*G044*"5*)("70*"5*")(0%79*G17*7$.".$C"27*G&)(*(&7*#"4&)&;14*1;)&=&)$*1./*;".;0%.*5"%*)(0*52)2%0*"5*)(0*.1)&".A*

Q&71*N%&=0/&*/07;%&D07*1.")(0%*G1$*)(1)*<1./(&*7"2'()*)"*#2%&5$*1./*5%00*)(0*.1)&".*D$*;".)%"44&.'*(&7*D"/$9*14".'*G&)(*)(0*D"/&07*"5*)(0*.1)&".A*<1./(&*0.;"2%1'0/*)(0*;&)&M0.7*"5*T./&1*)"*#1%)&;&#1)0*&.*D2&4/&.'*1./*%0;41&C&.'*)(0*.1)&".*)(%"2'(*)(0*#%"/2;)&".*1./*270*"5*;,"7+*;4")(*]N%&=0/&*>@V>Â*O"%*<1./(&9*G(1)*

1*T**.*)(&7*#1#0%9*<,=&!$**=2-=7&3$0;%&$>&4","-)"&5"#7,+*G&44*D0*;&)0/*27&.'*)(0*&.&)&147*!345*5"44"G0/*D$*)(0*="42C0*.2CD0%*1./*)(0*#1'0*.2CD0%*70#1%1)0/*D$*1*;"4".A*N(&7*7$7)0C*&7*C"/040/*15)0%*)(0*7$7)0C*270/*&.*J4)0%P7*5"#7,+8%&9$7.A*

12

C1/0*;,"7+*72;(*1*#"G0%524*.1)&".14*7$CD"4*G17*)(1)*&)*G17*W1*)1.'&D40*"DF0;)*)(1)*;"24/*D&./*#0"#40*)"'0)(0%*)(%"2'(*)(0*;"CC".*0I#0%&0.;0*"5*41D"%*#0%5"%C0/*".*D0(145*"5*)(0*.1)&".X*]N%&=0/&*ihÂ*N(279*4&L0*:0",)"2,"0."9*;,"7+*;4")(*D0;1C0*1*#($7&;14*C1.&507)1)&".*"5*C"%14&)$*)(1)*#0"#40*;"24/*&.;"%#"%1)0*&.)"*)(0&%*D"/&07*17*1*G1$*"5*#1%)&;&#1)&.'*&.*.1)&".VD2&4/&.'*1./*%07&7)1.;0A*<1./(&*;"CC2.&;1)0/*1./*2./0%7)""/*(&7*#"4&)&;14*;".;0#)7*D$*#($7&;144$*0.1;)&.'*)(0C9*/0C".7)%1)&.'*)(0*&.70#1%1D&4&)$*"5*C&./*1./*C1))0%*&.*(&7*#(&4"7"#($A*

T.*"%/0%* )"* '%17#* )(0* 5244* 5"%;0*"5*<1./(&P7* 270*"5* 41.'21'0* 5%"C* )(0*61C1$1.19*&)*C27)*D0*2./0%7)""/*&.*)0%C7*"5*(&7*#1))0%.*"5*C1.&507)&.'*#"4&)&;14*&/0147* &.*C1)0%&14* %014&)&07A*S(0.* 17L0/* )"* /07;%&D0*G(1)* T./&1.* &./0#0./0.;0*G"24/*4""L*4&L09*<1./(&*71&/*W)(0*&./0#0./0.;0*"5*c(&7d*/%01C7*C01.7*(")"0"1."X*]!345* fg,f?Â* E$* 0K21)&.'* %6"0"1* G&)(* (")"0"1."9* <1./(&* )%1.75"%C0/*1.*1D7)%1;)*;".;0#)* &.)"*1*;".;%0)0* &C1'0*"5* )(0* 52)2%0* )(1)*;"24/*D0*7(1%0/* )"*;%01)09*&.*)(0*G"%/7*"5*E0.0/&;)*J./0%7".9*)(0*&C1'&.0/*;"CC2.&)$*"5*)(0*.1)&".A*R"G0=0%9* 2./0%7)1./&.'* (&7* %050%0.;07* )"* )(0* 61C1$1.1* 17* C0%0* &4427)%1)&=0*0I1C#407*/"07*.")* ;1#)2%0* )(0*G1$7* &.*G(&;(*(0* ;"C#40)04$* %0;".7)%2;)0/* )(0*7)"%$*)"*(&'(4&'()*("G*)(0*70))&.'9*0=0.)79*1./*;(1%1;)0%7*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1*G0%0*

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

)*$$+,-. $/*. )'*,*(. 0*1-%&2/34. 5+#$1%34. 6. 7+$*%&8. 9,$*%2%*$&$+1,. 1:. $/*.;&<&3&,&.. J* ;0.)%14* ;".;0%.* 5"%* ;".)0C#"%1%$* R&./2* .1)&".14&7)7* &7* )(0*07)1D4&7(C0.)* "5* 1* 71;%0/* '0"'%1#($* &.* T./&1* 1./* &)7* #%")0;)&".* 5%"C* 5"%0&'.*

D&%)(#41;0* "5*61C1* 1./* )(0%05"%0* W1.* &440'&)&C1)0* 7#1;09* c1./d* 17* 1* 7$CD"4* "5*R&./2* /"C&.1)&".* 1./* )(27* R&./2* C140* (2C&4&1)&".9X* )(0* R&./2* .1)&".14&7)7*G0%0*1D40*)"*;(1%'0*)(0*7&)0*G&)(*#"4&)&;14*1./*%04&'&"27*C01.&.'*]E1;;(0))1*>ìÂ*

13

S(&40*&)*&7*41%'04$*1;;0#)0/*D$*7;("41%7*)(1)*1*(&7)"%&;14*61C1*G17*#%"D1D4$*.")*D"%.*&.*)(0*#%070.)*/1$*J$"/($19*7"C0*1%;(10"4"'&7)7*(1=0*.0=0%)(04077*)%&0/*)"*07)1D4&7(*#%""5*)(1)*1*(")1"#)":,?)+&)0C#40*0I&7)0/*D05"%0*)(0*C"7K20*]N(1#1%*+@V@+AÂ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a*b@,*@_iÂ*R"G0=0%9*&.*7"C0*&.7)1.;07*<1./(&*G17*(07&)1.)*)"*"2)%&'()*/0.$*)(0*#"77&D&4&)$*"5*61C1P7*0I&7)0.;09*17*;1.*D0*700.*&.*)(&7*40))0%*)"*1*/&7;&#40,*

O&;)&".*C01.7* 1.* &C1'&.0/* 7)"%$A* T)* &7* D0$"./*/"2D)* )(1)* )(0*(")"."#"*1./*)(0*4",":,"0"-"*(1=0*4077*"5*(&7)"%$*1./*C"%0*"5* &C1'&.1)&".A*N(0$* 1%0*D")(* 71;%0/*D""L7a* )0.7*"5*C&44&".7*"5* #0"#40* 4""L* 2#".* )(0C*"%&)$0=& -,"#& ,+%-$0.9* 1./* %&'()4$A*:1$D0*)(0%0*G17*."*D%")(0%*"5*61C1*0I1;)4$*4&L0*E(1%1)19*D2)*)(0%0*(1=0*D00.*72;(*E(1%1)17*1)*1.$*%1)0*&.*T./&1*1./*)(1)*&7*G($*N247&/17*;"24/*;".;0&=0*".0A*T)*&7*)"*)(0*E(1%1)1*/0#&;)0/*&.* )(0*(")"."#"* )(1)*E(1%1=1%7(1*#1$7*("C1'0*]!345*@b,*gba*0C#(17&7*C&.0Â

T.* )(&7* K2")1)&".*<1./(&* /&/* .")* /&%0;)4$* K207)&".* )(0* 0I&7)0.;0* "5*61C19* D2)*G(0)(0%* E(1%1)1* G17* 1;)2144$* (&7* D%")(0%A*J//&)&".144$9* (&7* 1770%)&".* )(1)* )(0*)0I)7* 1%0* WC"%0* )(1.* (&7)"%$X* ;1.* D0* %01/* &.* 70=0%14* G1$7a* )0I)7* ;1.* &.;42/0*0CD044&7(C0.)7* ".* %014* (&7)"%$9* "%* )(0$* ;1.* D0* ;".7&/0%0/* C"%0* &C#"%)1.)* "%*%040=1.)* D0;1270* )(0$* 1%0* .")* #2%0* (&7)"%$A* R0* #%070.)0/* )(0* &/01* )(1)* G(&40*#0%(1#7*E(1%1)1* /&/* .")* 0I&7)* 17*61C1P7* D%")(0%9*C0.* 4&L0*E(1%1)1*C27)* (1=0*0I&7)0/*0470*N247&/17*G"24/*.")*(1=0*L."G.*)"*G%&)0*(&C*)(1)*G1$A*N(279*&.*)(&7*

%0&)0%1)0/*)(070*)(0C07*41)0%*G(0.*(0*71&/9**

T*1C*.")*1*4&)0%14&7)A*N(0%05"%09*T*)%$*)"*2./0%7)1./*)(0*%D+0+-*"5*)(0* =1%&"27* 7;%&#)2%07* "5* )(0*G"%4/e*eT*G"%7(&#*61C19* )(0*#0%50;)*D0&.'*"5*C$*;".;0#)&".9*.")*1*(&7)"%&;14*#0%7".9* 51;)7*1D"2)*G("70*4&50*C1$*=1%$*G&)(*)(0*#%"'%077*"5*.0G*(&7)"%&;14*/&7;"=0%&07*1./*%0701%;(07A*N247&/17*(1/*.")(&.'*)"*/"*G&)(*)(0*61C1*"5*(&7)"%$A*32/'0/*D$*(&7)"%&;14*)07)9*(&7*61C1$1.1*G"24/*

!345*>f,*@@@Â*

14

O%"C*)(&7*0I;0%#)*&)*G"24/*700C*)(1)*<1./(&*7+7*D04&0=0*)(1)*61C1*0I&7)0/*17*1*(&7)"%&;14*#0%7".9*D2)9*&.*7"C0*G1$79*)(1)*)(&7*#0%7".*G17*&%%040=1.)A*R0*/&/*.")*G&7(*)"*;41&C*)(1)*)(0*(")2,"0+-)"#"%&)*&C#"%)1.)*)"*/"*7",*WN(0*4",":,"0"-"*1./*)(0*(")"."#"e*1%0*2./"2D)0/4$*1440'"%&07* 17* )(0* &.)0%.14* 0=&/0.;0* 7("G7A* N(1)* )(0$* C"7)* #%"D1D4$* /014* G&)(*

!345*hb,*bbiÂ*<1./(&*/&/*

(&7)"%$*(17*."*0550;)*".*)(0*#"G0%*"5*)(0*7)"%$A

5"#7,+&B&5=$/0"D,.A*S(&40*<1./(&*;41&C0/*)"*D0*/&7&.)0%07)0/*&.*)(0*(&7)"%&;14*61C19*(0*/&/*.")*;"C#40)04$*%0F0;)*)(0*&/01*)(1)*)(0*C$)(&;*L&.'*1;)2144$*0I&7)0/*

/0(&7)"%&;&M0* )(0* 61C1$1.1* &.* "%/0%* )"*C1L0* &)* 1##4&;1D40* )"* 1* D%"1/0%* %1.'0*

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

S(&40*<1./(&*G17*C2;(* 4077* &.)0%07)0/* &.*J$"/($1* )(1.* )(0*C"/0%.*R&./2* 6&'()9* (0* /&/* %050%* )"*J$"/($1* 17* )(0* #41;0* "5* 61C1P7* D&%)(* ".* 1* 50G*";;17&".7A*J)*1*7#00;(*".*8G1/07(&*)(1)*<1./(&*'1=0*&.*U1/&1/9*<2F1%1)9*(0*71&/*)(1)*(0*(1/*W7)1$0/*&.*)(0*#41;0*G(0%0*61C1;(1./%1*G17*D"%.9*1./*&.*)(1)*#41;09*&.*E&(1%9*1./*&)7*.0&'(D"%(""/9*G(0%0*8&)1*'%0G*2#*1./*#41$0/A*N(0%0*1%0*C1.$*)(0%0*G("*G&44*.")*01)* &.*1* )%1&.9*D2)* 517)A*N"*D0*72%09* &)* &7*1*=1421D40* %04&'&"27*70.)&C0.)*G(&;(*G&44* .")* #0%C&)* 1*C1.* )"* 01)* &.* 1* )%1&.9* .")* )"* 7#01L*"5* ")(0%*#41;07X*]!345*@_,*gbiÂ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i,*g__Â*R0*/&/*.")*700C*)"*)1L0*1.$*%014*&.)0%07)*&.*G(0)(0%*"%*.")*)(&7*G17*)(0*%014*#41;0*G(0%0*61C1*G17*D"%.9*D2)*&.7)01/*G17*2))0%4$*;".72C0/*G&)(*)(0*)17L*"5*)%$&.'*)"*;".=&.;0*)(0*)0C#40*#%&07)*)"*/%077*61C1*1./*8&)1P7*&C1'07*&.*;,"7+A*R0*5"2./*J$"/($1*&C#"%)1.)*".4$*&.17C2;(*17*")(0%*R&./27*D04&0=0/*&)*G17*1.*&C#"%)1.)*4";1)&".A*N(0%05"%09*G(&40*(0*/&/*.")*/0.$*)(1)*J$"/($1*;"24/*D0*61C1P7*D&%)(#41;09*(0*".4$*0=0%*C0.)&".0/*&)*17*1*G1$*)"*/&7;277*")(0%*C"%14*&77207A*

15

* <1./(&* 4";1)0/* E&(1%* 17* )(0* #%"=&.;0* G(0%0* 8&)1* '%0G* 2#* G&)(* (0%*51)(0%*31.1L19*147"*C0.)&".&.'*)(1)*61C1*1./*Q1L7C1.1*7#0.)*)&C0*)(0%0*17*G044*]!345*@b,*bh_a*@_,*gbia*>>,*ìa*_`,*@??9*@@@9*@>b9*@>f9*@``9*>?h9*>@?a*f`,*`_Â*<1./(&*G17*#1%)&;241%4$* 5"./*"5*E&(1%9* 7)1)&.',* WE&(1%9* )(0* 41./*"5* 31.1L1*1./*

&7*1*#%"=&.;0*G(&;(*(17*L0#)*C"7)*.".V=&"40.)A*T)*(17*7("G.*7#40./&/*%0724)7*&.*C"7)*&)0C7*"5*.".V;"V"#0%1)&".X*]!345*>>,*ìÂ*N(0*4&.L*(0*C1/0*D0)G00.*)(0*#%"=&.;0*17*D0&.'*#1%)&;241%4$*%0;0#)&=0*)"*(&7*#"4&)&;14*1'0./17*1./*17*)(0*("C0*"5*61C1$1.1*;(1%1;)0%7*(&'(4&'()7*(&7*D04&05*)(1)*&5*#0"#40*270/*(&7*C0)("/7*)(0$*G"24/*D0* ;4"70%* )"* 1;(&0=&.'*(")"0"1."A*<1./(&*C1/0* )(0*C"7)* %050%0.;07* )"*8&)1P7* ;"..0;)&".* )"*E&(1%*G(0.*(0* 7"2'()* /".1)&".7* )"* 1&/* )(0* =&;)&C7*"5* )(0*@ibg*01%)(K21L0* )(1)*/0=17)1)0/* )(0*#%"=&.;0* ]!345*_`,*@??9*@@@9*@>b9*@>f9*@``9*>?h9*>@?a*E%"G.*>`gÂ*B1;(*)&C0*(0*C1/0*72;(*1*%050%0.;0*&)*G17*1*=0%$*7("%)*1//0./2C*)"*1* 41%'0%*7#00;(*)(1)*;"=0%0/*")(0%*=1%&"27* )"#&;7A*R0*D0'1.*)(070*17&/07*D$*71$&.'9*WU"G9*1*G"%/*1D"2)*)(0*41./*"5*8&)19X*)(0.*'"&.'*".*)"*/07;%&D0* )(0*/1C1'0* )(1)* )(0*01%)(K21L0*;1270/9* 7"C0)&C07*.0=0%*".;0*;144&.'*)(0*#%"=&.;0*D$* &)7* #%"#0%* .1C0* ]!345* _`,* @@@9* @>bÂ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

T.*1*7#00;(*<1./(&*'1=0*)"*)(0*N1C&4*-.&".*&.*!"4"CD"*(0*C0.)&".0/*)(0*D04&05*)(1)*8&)1P7*&C#%&7".C0.)*)""L*#41;0*&.*8%&*Q1.L1*]!345*b_,*b>_Â*<1./(&P7*%050%0.;0*)"*8&)1P7*&C#%&7".C0.)*&.*jQ1.L1P*G(&40*&.*8%&*Q1.L1*G17*C2;(*C"%0*#"4&)&;144$*;".)%"=0%7&14*)(1.*(&7*#401*5"%*.1)&".14*2.&)$*&.*)(0*.1C0*"5*;(1%&)1D40*/".1)&".A*N(&7*7#00;(*G17*#1%)*"5*(&7*;,"7+*#%"C")&".14*)"2%*&.*G(&;(*(0*)%&0/*)"*0.;"2%1'0*#0"#40*)"*)1L0*2#*7#&..&.'A*R0*)"4/*)(0*G"C0.*"5*!"4"CD"*)(1)*&5*)(0$*D0'1.*G01%&.'*1./*C1L&.'*;,"7+*)(0$*G"24/*WD0*7"C0G(1)*%0#%070.)1)&=0*"5*8&)1*G("70*71;%0/*500)*(144"G0/*)(&7*41./*17*40'0./*(17*&)X*]!345*b_,b>_Â*T5*)(&7*;("&;0*)"*;144*2#".*8&)1*&7*2./0%7)""/*)"*7)0C*5%"C*)(0*71C0*4"'&;*"5*.1)&".14*2.&)$*)(1)*&.7#&%0/*)(0*E&(1%*%050%0.;079*)(0.*&)*;1.*D0*&.50%%0/*)(1)*<1./(&*147"*G&7(0/*)"*&.;42/0*8%&*Q1.L1.7*&.*)(0*52)2%0*.1)&".*D$*1##014&.'*)"*)(0*7(1%0/*(0%&)1'0*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1A*!401%4$9*)(&7*G"24/*(1=0*D00.*#%"D40C1)&;*)"*7"C09*&5*.")*C"7)9*"5*)(0*4&7)0.0%7A*T.)0%07)&.'4$9*("G0=0%9*<1./(&*/&/*.")*%050%*)"*8%&*Q1.L1*17*)(0*41./*"5*61=1.19*."%*17*)(0*#41;0*G(0%0*61C1*5"2'()*61=1.1A*T.7)01/9*<1./(&*;("70*)"*%050%0.;0*8&)19*)(0*C"7)*#177&=0*;(1%1;)0%*&.*)(0*G("40*"%/014A*N(0%05"%09*G(&40*0=0.*)(&7*7C144*'07)2%0*(1/*)(0*#")0.)&14*)"*;%01)0*)0.7&".9*<1./(&*;".)%"440/*)(0*0I)0.)*)"*G(&;(*(0*;"..0;)0/*;(1%1;)0%7*5%"C*)(0*61C1$1.1*)"*'0"'%1#($*&.*"%/0%*)"*;%01)0*&.)%1.1)&".14*D"./7A*

16

T)*&7*)044&.'*)(1)*<1./(&*4&.L0/*'0"'%1#(&;*7&)07*)"*8&)1*C"%0*"5)0.*)(1.*(0*/&/*)"*C140*;(1%1;)0%7A*S(&40*31.1L1*1./*61C1*G0%0*";;17&".144$*C0.)&".0/*17*D0&.'*#%070.)*G&)(*8&)19*5"%*)(0*C"7)*#1%)*7(0*&7*)(0*".4$*;(1%1;)0%*)(1)*<1./(&*

!345* @b,* bh_a* f`,* `_Â*N(&7* ;"24/* D0* 0I#41&.0/*D$*)(0*51;)*)(1)9*G(&40*<1./(&*(1/*)%"2D40*)(&.L&.'*"5*61C1*17*1*(&7)"%&;14*C1.*/20* )"*(&7*/0=")&".* )"*61C1*17*1*'"/9*#0%(1#7*(0* &C1'&.0/*8&)1* )"*D0*1*C"%0*(2C1.*;(1%1;)0%9*C1L&.'*&)*017&0%*5"%*(&C*)"*)&0*(0%*)"*)(0*41./A*N(&7*/&7;277&".*

E0'&..&.'* &.*@i?`* 1./* 07#0;&144$*#%0=140.)* 15)0%* )(0*@ib?P79* )(0*C1#*"5* T./&1*

]61C17G1C$*@hgÂ*N(0*8G1/07(&*C"=0C0.)*&.*#1%)&;241%9*&.*G(&;(*<1./(&*G17*(01=&4$*&.="4=0/9*#%"C")0/*)(0*&C1'0*"5*)(0*41./*"5*T./&1*17*)1L&.'*1*50C140*5"%C*]61C17G1C$*@`bÂ*N(0%05"%09*4&.L&.'*8&)1*)"*)(0*41./*G"24/*4&L04$*(1=0*&.="L0/*)(0*&C1'0*"5*E(1%1)*:1)1*)"*)("70*4&7)0.&.'*)"*<1./(&P7*7#00;(07A*J7*C"7)*"5*)(0*&.7)1.;07*"5*<1./(&*4&.L&.'*8&)1*)"*)(0*41./*";;2%%0/*&.*@ibg9*/2%&.'*)(0*(0&'()*"5*)(0*#%"/2;)&".*"5*E(1%1)*:1)1*&C1'0%$9*&)*700C7*4"'&;14*)"*#%072C0*)(1)*<1./(&*C&'()*(1=0*D00.*;1#&)14&M&.'*".*)(&7*;"..0;)&".A*S(&40*E(1%1)*:1)1*;1440/* )(0*7".7*"5*T./&1*)"*5%00*(0%*5%"C*)(0*D"./1'0*"5*&C#0%&14&7C9*8&)1*;1440/*)(0*;&)&M0.7*"5*T./&1*)"*(04#*(0%*41./*"5*E&(1%*G(0.*&)*G17*&.*/&%0*.00/A*

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

=81$$+,-.$/*.;*>18?$+1,(.@/*.;&<&3&,&4.=18&%+A&$+1,4.&,B.$/*.C?*#$+1,.1:.D+18*,'*

H"441;L* 1%'207* )(1)* )(0* 61C1$1.1* 7)"%$* &7* 72;(* 1.* 0550;)&=0* =0(&;40*5"%*#"4&)&;14* %(0)"%&;*D0;1270*W".* )(0*".0*(1./9* 1*/&=&.0*#"4&)&;14*"%/0%*;1.*D0*;".;0#)214&M0/9*.1%%1)0/9*1./*(&7)"%&;144$*'%"2./c0/d9*1./9*".* )(0*")(0%9*1* 5244$*/0C".&M0/*Z)(0%* ;1.* D0* ;1)0'"%&M0/9* ;"2.)0%#"70/9* 1./* ;"./0C.0/X* ]H"441;L*@_iÂ*N(&7*/&;(")"C&M1)&".*&7*&./00/*1.*&C#"%)1.)*#1%)*"5*("G*<1./(&*270/*)(0*61C1$1.1*5"%*(&7*#"4&)&;14*1'0./1A*T.*01%4$*T./&1.*#"4&)&;14*%(0)"%&;9*)(0*jZ)(0%P9*

17

0";%"%"%9* G17* C"7)* ;"CC".4$* ;17)* 17* :274&C*]H"441;L*@i@Â*<1./(&9*("G0=0%9*/&/*.")*$-,=0*)(0*:274&C*#"#241)&".*)(%"2'(*(&7*%050%0.;07*)"*)(0*61C1$1.19*D2)*&.7)01/*;("70*)"*/0C".&M0*)(0*E%&)&7(*;"4".&M0%7*D$*0K21)&.'*)(0C*G&)(*61=1.1A*

("A"#"0"1."& "%&90+-+%,&("1=0%727*61=1.1P* )"*C01.* jT./&1*=0%727* )(0*BC#&%0P* &.* )(0* 41)0%*C".)(7*"5*@i>?*]!345*@f,*bfgÂ*T.*(&7*7#00;(*1)*1*#2D4&;*C00)&.'*&.*\1L"%*&.*Z;)"D0%*@i>?9*

("A"#"0"1."P*)"*/07;%&D0*)(0*%240*"5*)(0*E%&)&7(*BC#&%0,*

R"G*1%0*G0*)"*D0*%&/*"5*)(&7*("A"#"0"1."k*E$*D0;"C&.'*0=&4*C0.*&.*/014&.'*G&)(*0=&4*C0.k*e*R"G*;1.*)(0*C0.*"5*#"4&;$*1C".'* 27* 72;;00/* 1'1&.7)* )(&7* BC#&%0* G(&;(9* D$* &)7* 7L&44524*/0;0#)&".79*(17*;".K20%0/*0=0.*B2%"#0*G&)(*(0%*;2..&.'*G1$7k*B=0.*&5*G09*R&./27*1./*:274&C79*G"24/*0C#4"$*;2..&.'9*G0*7&C#4$* /"* .")* (1=0* &)A* T5*G0*G1.)* )"* L&44* 61=1.1*G&)(* D%2)0*5"%;09*G0*7("24/*(1=0*)0.*(01/7*1./*)G0.)$*1%C7*4&L0*(&CA*O%"C*G(0%0*1%0*G0*)"*'0)*)(070k*T)*&7*".4$*1*C1.*"5*61C1P7*7)%0.')(*G("*;1.*/"*7"A*S(1)*G17*)(1)*7)%0.')(*"5*(&7k*R0*(1/*"D70%=0/*:0",)"2,"0."*1./*(0*G17*'"/V501%&.'A*R&7*1%C$*;".7&7)0/*"5*C".L0$7A*R1=0*C".L0$7*0=0%*270/*G01#".7k*\2%&.'*\&G14&*G0*;040D%1)0*0=0.*)"/1$*)(0*=&;)"%$*"5*61C1*"=0%*61=1.1A*E2)*G0*;1.*)%24$*;040D%1)0*)(&7*=&;)"%$*".4$*G(0.*G0*/07)%"$*)(&7*C".7)0%*G&)(*.")*)0.*D2)*1*)("271./*(01/7*]!345*@f,*bfhV`Â

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

S(0.9*("G0=0%9* )(0*<"=0%.C0.)* 7)%2;L*1)* )(0*7045V%07#0;)*"5*C$*;"2.)%$9*T*G"L0*2#*1./*%014&M0/*)(1)*&)*G17*1.*&.;1%.1)&".*"5* 61=1.1* 1./* C27)* D0* /07)%"$0/A* T)* /"07* .")* C01.* )(1)* T*;41&C* )"* D0* )(0* &.;1%.1)&".* "5*61C1A*S0* %0'1%/*61C1* )"* D0*

18

1.*&.;1%.1)&".*"5*<"/*R&C7045A*T*1C*.")*<"/a*.0&)(0%*1%0*$"2A*E2)* 144* "5* 27* 1%0* (0&%7* "5*61C1A* T)* &7* "2%* /(1%C1* )"* #%1;)&;0*-"D"%,2,"0."*1./*2./0%'"*72550%&.'7*4&L0*(&7A*S0*7("24/*.".V;"V"#0%1)0* &.* )(0* 71C0*C1..0%* &.*G(&;(* (0* .".V;"V"#0%1)0/*G&)(*61=1.1A*8&.;0*G0*1%0*.")*61C19*G0*;1.*700*.")(&.'*D$*L&44&.'*61=1.1*#($7&;144$A*S0*D04&0=0*)(1)*)(&7*61=1.19*)(1.L7*)"*(&7*0=&4*/07&%079*1772C07*0=0%*.0G*D"/&07A*S0*7("24/9*("G0=0%9*1;)* 2#".* )(0* ;"2.704* "5*l14C&L&* 1./*N247&/17* 1./* /&77";&1)0*"2%704=07* 5%"C* c)(0* C"/0%.d* 61=1.1* 1./* )%$* )"* /07)%"$* (&7*G&;L0/.077*]!345*@i,*>_>VbÂ

N(279* D$* /0.$&.'* )(0* T./&1.* #0"#40* )(0* %"40* "5* 61C1* &.* )(0* /&;(")"C$9* (0*/007;141)0/*)(0*#")0.)&14*5"%*=&"40.;0A*J44*)(1)*(2C1.7*;1.*/"*&7*#%1;)&;0*127)0%&)&07*1./*.".V;""#0%1)&".*Y*L&44&.'*&7*1.*"#)&".*$#*.*5"%*)(0*'"/7A**

("A"#"0"1."/0501)*)(0*/0C".&;*%0'&C0,*WT5*$"2*1%0*C0.*G("*G"24/*.0=0%*;17)*427)524*'41.;07*1)*;(17)0*1./*/0=")0/*G"C0.*4&L0*8&)19*)(0.*14".0*G&44*$"2*D0*1D40*)"*C"D&4&M0*

81)1.9*&)*&7*<"/P7A*R0*&)*G17*S("*;%01)0/*81)1.*1./*R0*&)*&7*S("*;1.*L&44*(&CX*]!345* @f,*bf`Â*R0*1%'20/* )(1)*C"%14*#2%&)$* 1./* )%27)* &.*<"/*G"24/*D0* )(0*".4$*G1$*)"*/0501)*1*/0C".&;*%0'&C0A*U0&)(0%*D1))4&.'*G&)(*D%2)0*5"%;0*."%*)%$&.'*)"*;""#0%1)0*G&)(* )(0*0.0C$*G"24/*G"%La*;(1.'&.'* )(0*C"%14*;(1%1;)0%*"5* )(0*#0"#40*"5*T./&1*&7*)(0*".4$*G1$*)"*/0501)*)(0*0.0C$A*<1./(&P7*;("&;0*)"*7G&);(*)"*!(%&7)&1.*41.'21'0*&.*)(&7*&.7)1.;0*&7*&.)%&'2&.'9*07#0;&144$*'&=0.*)(1)*(0*G17*1%'2&.'*5"%*)(0*C"%14*72#0%&"%&)$*"5*R&./2*1./*:274&C*T./&1.7*"=0%*)(0*!(%&7)&1.*E%&)&7(A*J7*<1./(&*G17*1*#%"#".0.)*"5*.0"Vl0/1.)&;*;".;0#)&".7*"5*)(0*2.&=0%714*<"/9*)(&7*%(0)"%&;14*;("&;0*;"24/*D0*&.)0%#%0)0/*17*1*G1$*"5*&.7&.21)&.'*)(1)*R&./27*0I0C#4&5$*!(%&7)&1.*=&%)207*D0))0%*)(1.*)(0*TC#0%&14*C17)0%7*]!345*>`,*gbgVà*

C"%14*#2%&)$*Y*".4$* )("70*C0.*G("*/"*.")* 427)*15)0%*;(17)0*G"C0.*;1.*/0501)*)(0* &CC"%14&)$*"5* )(0*BC#&%0A*R0%0*(0* &7* 1442/&.'* )"*61=1.1P7*/07&%0* 5"%*8&)19*G(&;(*401/*(&C*)"*L&/.1#*(0%A*N(1)*)(&7*&7*)(0*".4$*;%&)0%&".*.0;0771%$*)"*F2/'0*

&/014&M1)&".*"5* )(0*;(17)0*G"C1.9*1./*(&7*#%0";;2#1)&".*G&)(*;".)%"44&.'*".0P7*

* <1./(&P7*270*"5*)(0*)0%C*j("A"#"0"1."P*G17*K2&)0*7("%)*4&=0/A*E0)G00.*Z;)"D0%*@i>?*1./*80#)0CD0%*@i>@*(0*270/*)(0*)0%C*K2&)0*(01=&4$A*N(070*/1)07*;"&.;&/0*G&)(*)(0*D0'&..&.'*"5*(&7*.".V;""#0%1)&".*C"=0C0.)*1'1&.7)*)(0*E%&)&7(*%1F*1./*C1%L*1*)&C0*#0%&"/*G(0%0*(0*WD0;1C0*70=0%04$*;%&)&;14*"5*)(0*%1F*1./*14C"7)*/0="&/* "5* 1.$* ("#0* )(1)* 1* ;"..0;)&".* D0)G00.* T./&1* 1./*E%&)1&.*G"24/* 144"G*T./&1.*0K214&)$*1./*'%"G)(*)"*5244*.1)&".(""/X*]E%"G.*@biVg?Â*N(&7*70.)&C0.)*

("A"#"0"1."A*E$* )(0*D0'&..&.'*

19

"5*@i>>9*<1./(&*(1/*D0'2.*)"*7"4&/&5$*(&7*&/017*1D"2)*%6"0"19*.".V=&"40.;0*1./*.".V;""#0%1)&".9*;"&.;&/&.'*G&)(*)(0*/%"#V"55*&.*)(0*)0%C*("A"#"0"1."*]E%"G.*@`bÂ* T)* &7*#"77&D40* )"* &.)0%#%0)* )(&7*;(1.'0*17*1*;".;0%)0/*055"%)* )"*C"=0*1G1$*5%"C*27&.'*=&"40.)* 41.'21'0*1./* )1L&.'*1.*1;;271)"%$* )".0* )"G1%/7* )(0*E%&)&7(*61F9*)"*D0&.'*;".;0%.0/*G&)(*("G*)"*D2&4/*(")"0"1."*5%"C*)(0*&.7&/0*"2)A*O%"C*)(&7*#"&.)*".G1%/79*&.7)01/*"5*27&.'*41.'21'0*"5*/0501)&.'*("A"#"0"1."9*(0*270/*41.'21'0*"5*D2&4/&.'*(")"0"1."A*

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

T)* .0=0%* ";;2%7* )"* cC&44&".7* "5* %01/0%7deG(0)(0%* )(0$*C&'()*.")*L&44*)(0&%*0.0C&07*17*61C1*L&440/*61=1.1A*B=0.*G(0.*51;0*)"*51;0*G&)(*0.0C&079*)(0$*#%1$*5"%*61C1;(1./%1P7*#%")0;)&".*1./* %0C1&.* 2.15%1&/A* N247&/179* )(0* 12)("%* "5* )(0* 61C1$1.19*(1/*.")(&.'*D2)*;"C#177&".*D$*G1$*"5*1*G01#".A*R0*/07&%0/*)"*L&44*.".0A*R0*G("*;%01)079*/07)%"$7A*61C1*G17*<"/a*R0*(1/*;%01)0/*61=1.1*1./*7"*(1/*)(0*%&'()*)"*L&44*(&CA*S(0.*1.$*"5*27*

#"G0%*)"*/07)%"$*]!345*@g,*@b`Â

<1./(&*1%'20/*)(1)*G(0)(0%*"%*.")*".0*7007*7"C0".0*17*(&7*"%*(0%*0.0C$9*&)* &7*.0=0%*&.*".0P7*#"G0%*)"*)1L0*7"C0".0P7*4&50A*B;("07*"5*)(070*71C0*)(0C07*;1.*D0*5"2./*&.*(&7*/0;41C1)&".7*1'1&.7)*)(0*E%&)&7(*("A"#"0"1."9*D2)*(&7*1%'2C0.)*5"%*.".V=&"40.;0*D0;1C0*C"%0* ;".=&.;&.'*G(0.*(0* ;0170/* )"* 0C#4"$*/0C".&M&.'*41.'21'0A* T.7)01/9* (0* ;("70* )"* 5";27* ".* ("G*".0* 7("24/* D0* /0=")0/* )"*61C19*#0%5"%C*127)0%&)&079*1./*%04$*".*)(0*'"/7*)"*/0501)*)(0*E%&)&7(*5"%*)(0CA*<1./(&*1%'207*)(1)*)(0*".4$*%0;"2%70*1=1&41D40*)"*(2C1.7*&7*/0=04"#&.'*1./*#%"C")&.'*C"%14&)$A*

<1./(&*&.)0%#%0)0/*)(0*D1))40*D0)G00.*61C1*1./*61=1.1*17*1.*1440'"%$*5"%*)(0*D1))40*D0)G00.*'""/*1./*0=&4*)(1)*&7*#41$0/*"2)*/1&4$*G&)(&.*)(0*C&./*"5*0=0%$*#0%7".,*W61=1.1*17*)"."* ;".)&.207* )"*0I&7)* )"/1$*1./*61C1P7*/0=")0079* )("70*G("70*(01%)*&7*R&7*1D"/09*1%0*0=0%$*/1$*/07)%"$&.'*61=1.1X*]!345*>h,*b?iÂ*R&7*#%""5*5"%*)(&7*1440'"%&;14*&.)0%#%0)1)&".*G17*D170/*".*)(0*51;)*)(1)*(0*5"2./*&)*&C#"77&D40*)"*&.)0%#%0)*C1.$*#1%)7*"5*)(0*7)"%$*4&)0%144$,*WS(1)*&7*)(0*C01.&.'*"5*61C19*1*C0%0*(2C1.*D0&.'9*G&)(*(&7*("7)*"5*C".L0$79*#&))&.'*(&C7045*1'1&.7)*

20

)(0*&.7"40.)*7)%0.')(*"5*)0.V(01/0/*61=1.1*72%%"2./0/*&.*72##"70/*7150)$*D$*)(0*%1'&.'*G1)0%7*".*144*7&/07*"5*Q1.L1k*\"07*&)*.")*C01.*)(0*;".K207)*"5*#($7&;14*C&'()* D$* 7#&%&)214* 7)%0.')(kX* ]!345* @f,* @bbVgÂ*R0%0*<1./(&*7+7* ;(""70* )"*14&'.*(2C1.*D0&.'7*G&)(*61C1P7*;(1%1;)0%*&.*)(0*7)"%$A*S(0.*(0*/&/*)(&79*(0*G17*72%0*)"*/&=07)*61C1*"5*144*"5*(&7*/&=&.0*#($7&;14*7)%0.')(*&.*"%/0%*)"*0C#(17&M0*(&7*C"%14*#2%&)$*17*)(0*".4$*1/=1.)1'0*)(1)*(0*(1/*1'1&.7)*61=1.1A*T.*1*#0%7".14*40))0%9*

5"2./*.")(&.'*)"*7("G*)(1)*(0*'1&.0/*=&;)"%$*)(%"2'(*#($7&;14*7)%0.')(X*]!345*>_,*b>hÂ*E$*C1L&.'*)(0*/&;(")"C$*D0)G00.*61=1.1*1./*61C1*1*D1))40*D0)G00.*#($7&;14*=0%727*C"%14*7)%0.')(9*(0*G17*1D40*)"*270*)(0*7)"%$*)"*1%'20*&.*51="2%*"5*(&7*"G.*#"7&)&".*%0'1%/&.'*("G*T./&1.7*7("24/*"=0%)(%"G*TC#0%&14*#"G0%A**

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

1%'2&.'*)(1)*)(0*".4$*G1$*)"*5%00*T./&1*5%"C*E%&)&7(*%240*G17*)(%"2'(*)(0*C"%14*

D$*"=0%41$&.'*)(0*#4")*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1*".)"*(&7*;".)0C#"%1%$*;&%;2C7)1.;07A*

E&#$+,-.&,B.E1#$?<+,-(.F<"1B3+,-.;&<.6.)+$&* J*C1F"%*17#0;)*"5*;".)0C#"%1%$*R&./2*.1)&".14&7)*&C1'0%$*1./*%(0)"%&;*

61C1P7*G01#".7*]\1=&7*g`Â*J*#1%)&;241%4$*1#)*0I1C#40*"5*)(&7*G17*)(0*61)(*m1)%1*#%";077&".*"5*@ii?*G(0%0*QA[A*J/=1.&*"5*)(0*E3H9*/%0770/*17*61C1*V*;"C#40)0*G&)(*D"G*V*#%";0770/*1%"2./*T./&1*&.*1*N"$")1*)%2;L*C1/0*)"*4""L*4&L0*1*;(1%&")*&.*"%/0%*)"*%144$*5"%*(&7*#1%)$*1./*)(0*/07)%2;)&".*"5*)(0*E1D%&*:17F&/*]\1=&7*>`ViÂ*<1./(&P7*&.)0%#%0)1)&".*G17*7)%&L&.'4$*/&550%0.)*5%"C*)(1)*"5*)(0*R&./2*6&'()A*

51;)*1))%&D2)&.'*;(1%&")7*)"*61=1.1,*WS(0.*l&D(&7(1.1*17L0/*8(%&*61C1;(1./%1*("G*2.1%C0/9*2.7("/9*G&)("2)*1.$*1%C"2%9*(0*G17*'"&.'*)"*/0501)*)(0*(01=&4$V1%C0/*1./*C&'()$*61=1.1*G&)(*(&7*;(1%&")79*61C1P7*%0#4$*G17*)(1)*&)*G17*51&)(*1./*#2%&)$* )(1)*G"24/*G&.*)(0*D1))40A*R&7*D"G*G17*(&7*7045V;".)%"4A*R&7*=&;)"%$*G17*)(0*=&;)"%$*"5*'""/*"=0%*0=&4X*]!345*f_,*g@gV_Â*<1./(&*(1/*1D7"42)04$*."*&.)0%07)*&.*'4"%&5$&.'*G01#".7a*)(0*".4$*G01#".7*(0*0=0%*1))%&D2)0/*)"*61C1*G0%0*

21

7"V;1440/*W7#&%&)214*G01#".7X*]!345*>@,*_@_a*h>,*ifÂ*J7*#%0=&"274$*/&7;2770/9*<1./(&*/&/*.")*D04&0=0*#($7&;14*7)%0.')(*1&/0/*61C1*1)*144* &.*(&7*/0501)*"5* )(0*/0C".*L&.'A*N(070*)G"*;".;0#)&".7*"5*)(0*&/014*61C1*17*#2)*5"%)(*D$*J/=1.&*1./*<1./(&* 1%0* ;401%4$* K2&)0* /&7)&.;)* V* )(0* 5"%C0%* &/014&M&.'* 1.* 1%C"%0/9*C27;241%*D"/$*1./*)(0*41))0%*1*7&C#409*2.1/"%.0/*".0A** J7*3"70#(*J4)0%*&4427)%1)079*<1./(&*D04&0=0/*)(1)*)(0*&..0%*D"/$*1./*)(0*

1##01%1.;07*"5*D")(*61C1*1./*8&)1*G17*1.*&C#"%)1.)*#1%)*"5*(&7*C&77&".*)"*#2%&5$*)(0*D"/&07*"5*)(0*.1)&".A*<1./(&*G17*K2&)0*&.7&7)0.)*)(1)*61C1*1./*8&)1*/&/*.")*G01%*51.;$*D%";1/0*7&4L*;4")(&.'9*D2)*&.7)01/*G"%0*;,"7+*;4")(*]!345*@f,*biba*@i,*g__a*>?,*@@g9*@iia*>f,@ì9*bg?a*b_,@@9*@gfa*bi,*gg`Â*T.)0%07)&.'4$9*<1./(&*1##0140/*)"*(&7)"%&;14*j51;)P*)"*1%'20*)(1)*61C1*1./*8&)1*G"24/*(1=0*G"%.*;,"7+,*Wm"2* 7("24/* D01%* &.*C&./* )(1)9* &.* )(0* /1$7* "5* 8(%&*61C1;(1./%19* .0&)(0%* %&;(*."%*#""%*270/*1.$* 5"%0&'.*;4")(*1./* )(0*;,"7+*#%"/2;0/* &.* )(0*;"2.)%$*G17* &.*)(0*'0.0%14*270*"5*144X*]!345*>f,*@ìÂ*S(&40* &)* &7*2.;401%*G(0%0*(0*'")* )(&7*&.5"%C1)&".*1D"2)*W)(0*/1$7*"5*8(%&*61C1;(1./%19X*;401%4$*<1./(&*G17*#%"F0;)&.'*(&7*=&7&".*"5*G(1)*)(0*T./&1.*.1)&".*7("24/*4""L*4&L0*D1;L*".)"*61C1P7*L&.'/"CA*N%&=0/&* #"&.)7* )"* )(&7* L&./* "5* %0&C1'&.&.'* "5* )(0* #17)* 17* 1*C"/27* "#0%1./&* "5*)(0* 8G1/07(&* C"=0C0.)* 17* 1* G("409* 1%'2&.'* )(1)* #1%)* "5* )(0* 0550;)&=0.077* "5*)(0*C"=0C0.)*G17*&)7*;144* )"*%0)2%.*)"* )%1/&)&".*]N%&=0/&*gbÂ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

G"C0.*&.*)(0*.1)&".14&7)*7)%2''40X*][1)%1L*bi`Â*J.*0I1C#40*"5*)(&7*;1.*D0*5"2./*&.*1.*0I;0%#)*5%"C*1*@i>`*7#00;(*1)*1*G"C0.P7*C00)&.'*&.*!"&CD1)"%09*N1C&4*U1/2,*

8&)1*G17*#2%0* &.*(01%)*1./*#2%0* &.*D"/$A* T* )(&.L*1./* &)* &7*C$*

D"/$*G&)(*5"%0&'.*;4")(A*U")*7"*/&/*8&)1*\0=&A*\".P)*72##"70*5"%*".0*C"C0.)*)(1)*8&)1*\0=&*G0.)*&.*5"%*"%*70.)*"2)*5"%*5"%0&'.*

8&)1* \0=&P7* )&C09* 8&)1* \0=&* 1./* 144* )(0* G"C0.* "5* T./&1* 71)*7#&..&.'*1./*G"%0*;4")(*G"=0.*D$*)(0*C0.*"5*T./&1A*J./*)(1)*G17*D012)&524*]!345*b_,*@gfÂ

22

<1./(&P7* /&7)&.;)&".* D0)G00.* &C#2%0* 5"%0&'.* ;4")(* 1./* #2%0* (1./7#2.* ;4")(*;"%%07#"./7*G&)(*(&7*1770%)&".*)(1)*)(0*G"C0.*"5*(&7*/1$*G0%0*&C#2%09*G(0%017*8&)1*%0#%070.)0/*1*j#2%0%*G"C1.(""/P*"5*)(0*#17)A*<1./(&*1770%)0/*)(1)*7&C#4$*D$*;(1.'&.'*)(0*G1$*)(0$*/%077*)(0C704=079*G"C0.*G"24/*D0*#2%&5$&.'*)(0&%*D"/&079*

)"* ;".=&.;0* )(0*G"C0.* )"*G01%*;,"7+* ;4")(A*S(&40*(0* &C#4&;&)4$* 1/C&))0/* )(1)*#0%(1#7*(1./7#2.*;4")(*&7*.")*)(0*C"7)*0$0V;1);(&.'*#%"/2;)9*)(0*C01.&.'*D0(&./*)(0*;4")(*&7*G(1)*0./"G7*&)*G&)(*D012)$A*N(0*&C#4&;1)&".*)(1)*T./&1.*G"C0.*G"%0*)(0*;4")(*)(1)*T./&1.*C0.*C1/0*5"%*)(0C9*7("G&.'*)(0&%*/0#0./0.;0*1./*72##"%)*".*j)(0&%P*C0.*%1)(0%*)(1.*j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bi`Â*R0*)%&0/*)"*;".=&.;0*G"C0.*)"*)1L0*)"*)(0*2,"0;,"*D$*1%'2&.'*)(1)*0=0.*1*K200.*4&L0*8&)1*270/*)"*7&)*1)*".0A*T.*1*.0G7#1#0%*%0#"%)*"5*1*G"C0.P7*C00)&.'*1)*G(&;(*(0*7#"L09*(0*&7*K2")0/*17*71$&.'*)(1)*W8&)1*147"*7#2.*".*(0%*"G.*2,"0;,"*G(&;(*C&'()*(1=0*D00.*D0/0;L0/*G&)(*F0G047*1./*#%"D1D4$*"%.1C0.)0/*G&)(*'"4/9*D2)*144*)(0*71C0*&)*G17*7)&44*1*2,"0;,"X*]!345*>f,*>i_Â*:"%0*)(1.*F27)*C1L&.'*)(0*2,"0;,"*1##014&.'*)"*G"C0.9*<1./(&*G17*147"*72%0*)"*0C#(17&M0*)(1)*&5*G"C0.*G1.)0/*4&D0%1)&".*5%"C*)(0*E%&)&7(*%1F*&)*G17*1D7"42)04$*.0;0771%$*5"%*)(0C*)"*7#&.,*

cTd5*$"2*G1.)*%6"0"1*"%*(")"0"1."*&.*T./&1*$"2*(1=0*)"*D0;"C0*#2%0*17*8&)1A*8&)1*G17*#2%0*&.*D"/$*1./*C&./A*S(0.*7(0*G17*#2)*

0=0.*)"2;(*(0%A*S($k*E0;1270*7(0*G17*#2%0*.")*".4$*&.*D"/$*D2)*147"*&.*C&./A*U"*;4")(*G17*&C#"%)0/*5%"C*B.'41./*1)*)(0*)&C09*B.'4&7(*;4")(*G17*.")*G"%.A*J44*G"C0.*#4&0/*)(0*2,"0;,"*1./*G"%0*;,"7+eA*Z.4$*1*G"C1.*G("*L00#7*D"/$*1./*C&./*#2%0*;1.*D0*G"%)($*"5*"2%*%0=0%0.;0*]!345*b>,*_bfÂ*

\&7;277&.'*)(0*(&'(4$*;".)07)0/*C"C0.)*"5*8&)1P7*"/#+&D"0+;%,"*17*1*50C140*&/014*&7*;401%4$*#%"D40C1)&;A*<1./(&*72''07)0/*)(1)*)(0*50C140*D"/$*G14L&.'*)(%"2'(*

("C07#2.* G"24/* .")A* T)* &7* &.)0%07)&.'* )(1)* (&7* 1##014* )"* 4"'&;* 1./* .".V4&)0%14*%01/&.'7*"5*)(0*7)"%$*/&/*.")*;"C0*&.)"*#41$*G(0.*)(0*50C140*D"/$*G17*1)*7)1L0A*E$*27&.'*)(&7*0I1C#40*(0*&/014&M0/*)(0*G&44524*72550%&.'*"5*G"C0.*".*D0(145*"5*1*.1)&".14*;1270A*R0*#41;0/*)(0*".27*".*T./&1.*G"C0.*)"*0.72%0*)(1)*0=0%$*("C0*(1/*1*2,"0;,"* &.* &)*7"* )(1)*(")"0"1."*;"24/*D0*1;(&0=0/*)(%"2'(*)(0*#2%&)$*"5*

23

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c)(0$*G%")0dA*Z)(0%G&70*T*;1..")* &C1'&.0*)(0*D0.0="40.)*61C1;(1./%1F&* "%* )(0* /00#4$*/0="2)*8&)1F&* ;1%%$&.'* 0=0.* 1* #1%)&;40* "5* '"4/* ".*)(0&%* D"/&07X* ]!345* @?,* bi`VfÂ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

N(&.L*"5*8&)1A*\"*$"2*&C1'&.0*7(0*G0.)*1D"2)*G&)(*61C1*&.*(&7*@g*$01%7P*5"%07)*G1./0%&.'7*G&)(*(01=$*"%.1C0.)7*4&L0*$"2k*\"*$"2*)(&.L*)(0$*1//*)"*$"2%*D012)$k*8&)1*;1%0/*5"%*)(0*D012)$*"5*(0%*(01%)*1./*;"=0%0/*(0%*D"/$*G&)(*#2%0*L(1//1%A*N(0*(01=$*"%.1C0.)7*$"2*G01%*1%0*.")*".4$*2'4$*D2)*(1%C524*&.17C2;(*17*)(0$*1%0*)(0*#0%C1.0.)*%0;0#)1;407*"5*/&%)A*O%00*$"2%704=07*"5*)(070*7(1;L407*1./*%04&0=0*)(0*#"=0%)$*"5*#0"#40*G("*(1=0*."*;4")(079*C2;(*4077*"%.1C0.)79*)"*G01%*]!345*b>,*_`?Â*

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g??Â*R0*#%1&70/*8&)1*5"%*(0%*/0=")&".*)"*(0%*(27D1./*1./*5"%*)(0*D%1=0%$*"5*(0%*/0;&7&".*)"*5"44"G*(&C*&.)"*&7"41)&".9*1./* 0.;"2%1'07* G"C0.* )"* /"* )(0* 71C0* D$* 5"44"G&.'* )(0&%* (27D1./7* &.)"* )(0*4&D0%1)&".*C"=0C0.)*]!345*b_,*biÂ*R0*/&/*144"G*G"C0.*)"*F"&.*(&7*C"=0C0.)*5"%*.1)&".14*4&D0%1)&".*G&)("2)*)(0*0I#%077*#0%C&77&".*"5*)(0&%*(27D1./79*D2)*".4$*D0;1270*(0*;41&C0/*)(1)*8&)1*G"24/*(1=0*/".0*)(0*71C0*17*7(0*G17*7045V%04&1.)*1./*

24

.")*1*W741=0*"5*61C1X*]!345*b@,*_@@^A*<1./(&*71G*8&)19*1./*G"C0.*&.*'0.0%149*17*7$CD"4&;144$*(04#524*)"*(&7*#"4&)&;14*1'0./19*17*(0*D04&0=0/*)(1)*G"C0.*G0%0*

]K2")0/*&.*[1)%1L*bif^A*S(&40*#0%(1#7*)(070*/1.'0%"27*7)0%0")$#07*)(1)*#%"C")0/*G"C0.P7*72550%&.'*17*1.*&/014*144"G0/*G"C0.*)"*1;;077*)(0*#2D4&;*7#(0%09*)(0*5244*7;"#0*"5*<1./(&P7*4&D0%1)&".*"5*T./&1.*G"C0.*&7*.")*2.#%"D40C1)&;*1./*%0K2&%07*;%&)&;14*0I1C&.1)&".A** N(%"2'(*<1./(&P7*%(0)"%&;*)(0*D"/&07*"5*61C1*1./*8&)1*D0;1C0*)(0*&/014*D"/&07*"5*)(0*C0.*1./*G"C0.*"5*)(0*.1)&".*"5*T./&1A*E$*&.7&7)&.'*)(1)*)(070*)G"*

;,"7+*;4")(9*(0*1))0C#)0/* )"*'1%.0%*72##"%)*5"%*(&7*"G.*=&7&".*"5*)(0*;,"7+V;41/*.1)&".A*R0*270/*)(0*61C1$1.1*7)"%$*)"*1##014* )"*1*70.70*"5* )%1/&)&".*1./*(&7)"%$* )(1)*(0*(&C7045*;%01)0/* &.*"%/0%* )"*(04#*)(0*.1)&".*%0)2%.*)"*1*C"%0*jT./&1.P*G1$*"5*4&50A*E$*)01;(&.'*#0"#40*)"*G01%*;,"7+9*7#&.*".*)(0*2,"0;,")(0*C&./7*1./*7#&%&)7*"5*)(0*.1)&".*1./*)(0%0D$*;%01)0*)(0*&./0#0./0.)*T./&1*)(1)*G"24/*D%&.'*(&7*=0%7&".*"5*(")"0"1."&)"*4&50A*

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

S(&40* )(0%0* &7* 7)&44* 7"*C2;(*C"%0* )(1)* ;"24/* D0* 71&/* 1D"2)* <1./(&P7*&.)0%#%0)1)&".*"5*)(0*61C1$1.19*)(&7*#1#0%*(17*)%&0/*)"*#%070.)*".0*5%1C0G"%L*5"%*2./0%7)1./&.'*(&7*#"4&)&;14*/0#4"$C0.)*"5* )(0*7)"%$A*J7*7(1%0/*'%"2./*D0)G00.*)(0*j.".=&"40.)P*<1./(&1.*.1)&".14&7C*1./*C"/0%.*R&./2)=19*1.14$M&.'*)(0*#41;0*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1*7)"%$*&.*01;(*"5*)(0&%*#"4&)&;14*1'0./17*(04#7*)"*&442C&.1)0*G($*T./&1.P7*504)*1./*;".)&.20*)"*5004*72;(*7)%".'*;"..0;)&".7*)"*D")(*&/0"4"'&07A*N(0*1D&4&)$*"5*)(0*7)"%$*)"*D0*270/*D$*D")(*<1./(&*1./*)(0*R&./2*6&'()*/0C".7)%1)07*)(1)*)(0*61C1$1.1*&7*1.$)(&.'*D2)*1*7)1'.1.)*)0I)214*)%1/&)&".*)(1)*7&C#4$*%0;1447*

1550;)*%014*;(1.'0*&.*#0"#40P7*4&=0/*0I#0%&0.;07*)(%"2'(*;".7)1.)*%0&.)0%#%0)1)&".7*1./* %0)044&.'79* G(0)(0%* )(1)* D0* 5%"C* #"4&)&;144$* /%&=0.* 7"2%;07* "%* ")(0%G&70A*<1./(&P7*=0%7&".*"5*)(0*7)"%$*&7*$0)*".0*C"%0*1//&)&".*)"*)(0*;".7)1.)4$*0="4=&.'*)%1/&)&".*"5*)(0*61C1$1.1A*

25

S"%L7*!&)0/*

J4)0%9*3"70#(*8A* A*H(&41/04#(&1,*-.&=0%7&)$*"5*H0..7$4=1.&1*H%0779*>???A*H%&.)A

J./0%7".9*E0.0/&;)A*A*Q"./".,*l0%7"9*>??hA*H%&.)A

50$6-,&"#7&!,"#/=*b@A>*]>???^,*>__V>fgA*H%&.)A

E%"G.9*32/&)(*:A*5"#7,+E&F0+%$#=0&$>&C$D=A*U0G*R1=0.,*m140*-H9*@ifiA*H%&.)A

\1=&79*6&;(1%/A*WN(0*T;"."'%1#($*"5*61C1P7*!(1%&")AX*:1L&.'*T./&1*R&./2,*604&'&".9*!"CC2.&)$9* 1./* )(0* H"4&)&;7* "5* \0C";%1;$* &.* T./&1A* B/A* \1=&/* Q2//0.A*H(&41/04#(&1,*-.&=0%7&)$*"5*H0..7$4=1.&1*H%0779*@iihA*>`V_gA*H%&.)A

<1./(&9* :"(1./17* [1%1C;(1./A* <,=& !$**=2-=7& 3$0;%& $>& 4","-)"& 5"#7,+A* l"4A*g9*`9*iVi?A*\04(&,*N(0*H2D4&;1)&".7*\&=&7&".9*:&.&7)%$*"5* T.5"%C1)&".*1./*E%"1/;17)&.'*<"=0%.C0.)*"5*T./&19*@i_fA*H%&.)A

[1)%1L9*[0)2*RA*WT./&1.*U1)&".14&7C9*<1./(&1.*j81)$1'%1(19P*1./*60#%070.)1)&".7*"5*O0C140*80I214&)$AX* A*B/A*J./%0G*H1%L0%9*:1%$*6277"9*\"%&7*8"CC0%9*n*H1)%&;&1*m10'0%A*U0G*m"%L,*6"2)40/'09*@ii>A*bi_Vg?hA*H%&.)A

Q2)'0./"%59*H(&44&#A*WT.)0%#%0)&.'*(")0"1R&./2*U1)&".14&7CAX*"#7&F$*+-+2"*&G2-+$#A*B/A*\1=&/*UA*Q"%0.M0.A*J4D1.$,*8-Um*H%0779*@ii_A*>_bV>f`A*H%&.)A

H"44";L9* 8(04/".A* W61C1$1.1* 1./* H"4&)&;14* TC1'&.1)&".* &.* T./&1AX* (=*+/+$?%&A*B/A*\1=&/*UA*Q"%0.M0.A*U0G*m"%L,*

ZI5"%/*-H9*>??gA*@_bV>?fA*H%&.)A

61C17G1C$9*82C1)(&A*Wl&7214&7&.'*T./&1P7*<0"VE"/$,*<4"D079*:1#79*E"/$7;1#07AX*!$#-0+:?-+$#%&-$&H#7+"#&I$2+$*$/.*bh*]>??>^,*@_@V@fiA*H%&.)A

N(1#1%9*6"C&41A*WB/&)"%&14*H%051;0AX*G.$7,."E&G02,"=$*$/.&">-=0&J=)$*+-+$#A*U0G*\04(&,*Z%&0.)*Q".'C1.9*>??bA*+@V@+AA*H%&.)A

N%&=0/&9*Q&71A* A*E4""C&.')".,*T./&1.1*-H9*>??`A*H%&.)A

27

!"#!$%&%#'()*$(+",-(".(!*%#$/$(+0,,*%/1

!"#$%&&'&"()*+"'

28

*

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

%,=*+*1./*0$?%,=#&D?%"*&.*E2//(&7)*#%1;)&;0*("4/7*1*/&7)&.;)&=0*#41;0*&.*)(0*#%1;)&;0*"5*E2//(&7C*&.*!(&.1A*

JC".'* <12)1C1* E2//(1P7* C"7)* 0770.)&14* )01;(&.'7* 1%0* )(0* %041)0/*/";)%&.07*"5*."V7045*]"#"-)"#^*1./*;"/0#0./0.)V"%&'&.1)&".*]D0"-+-."%")?-D"7"Â*N(070* #(&4"7"#(&;14* .")&".7* 5%1C0* E2//(&7)* ;"7C"4"'$* 17* 1* C177* G0D* "5*;".7)&)20.)* #1%)7* K7,"0)"ô)(0C704=07* ;"C#"70/* "5* 0=0%* 7C1440%* 7,"0)"o

&/0.)&)$* &.*1*C24)&V41$0%0/*2.&=0%70*2.&)0/*D$*0C#)&.077* ]%?#."-"Â*N0I)7* 72;(*17* )(0* W:&//40V40.')(* \&7;"2%7079X* L."G.* 17* )(0* &.* H14&9*4"7,.")"/")"&&.*81.7L%&)*1./*)(0*L,$#/&","#1+#/*&.*!(&.0709&0C#(17&M0*)(0*&C#4&;1)&".7*"5*72;(*;"7C&;*#%&.;&#407*".*".0P7*"G.*4&50*1./*0.;"2%1'0*C".L7*)"*;".)0C#41)0* )(0&%*#($7&;14*;"C#"7&)&".*1./*;"%#"%14*0I&7)0.;0A*S(0.* )(070*T./&;* #(&4"7"#(&07* %01;(0/*!(&.070* )0%%&)"%&079* )(0$* &.)0'%1)0/*G&)(* )(0*N1"&7)*.")&".* "5* /"#/.+#/* ]W7)&C2427V%07#".70X* "%* W7$C#1)(0)&;* %07".1.;0X^* 1./*

M"-";"*)1407*"5*)(0*E2//(1P7*#%&"%*4&=079*1./*7)"%&07*"5*1/=1.;0/*:$7,+%"--A"%*D0;1C0*&/0147*)"*D0*C1);(0/*&.*".0P7*"G.*#%1;)&;0A*N(0*#%"4&50%1)&".*"5*7045V&CC"41)&".*1./*5244VD"/$*%04&;7*&.*!(&.070*E2//(&7C9*)("2'(*)(0$*;1.*

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j=&7214&M&.'* )(0* &C#2%0*D"/$Pe*cG(&;(d* &7* 72##"70/* )"*C1L0*".0*$01%.* 5"%*1*D"/&4077*7)1)0*"5*#2%&)$*1./*)%1.7;0./0.;0X*]fbÂ*82;(*C0/&)1)&".*'2&/07*#%"=&/0*

!".;0&=&.'*)(0*E"/$*"5*!(&.070*E2//(&7C*

29

)(0*%01/0%*G&)(*D&"4"'&;14*/07;%&#)&".7*"5*)(0*(2C1.*D"/$*&.*&)7*C1.$*#1%)79*W7"*/0)1&40/*)(1)*7"C0*7;("41%7*;%0/&)*C0CD0%7*"5*)(0*01%4$*E2//(&7)*C".17)&;*"%/0%*]%"#/,"^*G&)(*1*/0;&7&=0* %"40* &.* )(0*/0=04"#C0.)*"5*1.;&0.)* T./&1.*1.1)"C&;14*)(0"%$X*]S&47".*hgÂ*\&%0;)&.'*)(0*%01/0%VC".L*)"*;".)0C#41)0*(&7*;"%#"%14*7045*5%"C*)(0*7"407*"5*(&7*500)*)"*)(0*;%"G.*"5*)(0*(01/9*)(0* */07;%&D07*)(0*(2C1.*5"%C*17,*

e72%%"2./0/* D$* 7L&.* 1./* 5244* "5* =1%&"27* L&./7* "5* 2.;401.*)(&.'7,* jT.* )(&7* D"/$* )(0%0* 1%0* (01/* (1&%79* D"/$* (1&%79* .1&479*

4&=0%9* #402%19* 7#400.9* 42.'79* 41%'0* &.)07)&.079* 7C144* &.)07)&.079*'"%'09* 50;079*D&409*#(40'C9*#279*D4""/9* 7G01)9* 51)9* )01%79* 7L&.V

&5*(0*G0%0*)"*700*1*;"%#70*;17)*1G1$*&.*1*;(1%.04*'%"2./o".0*/1$9*)G"*/1$79*)(%00*/1$7*/01/oD4"1)0/9*4&=&/9*n*507)0%&.'9*(0*1##4&07*&)*)"*)(&7*=0%$*D"/$9*jN(&7*D"/$9*)"",*82;(*&7*&)7*.1)2%09*72;(*&7*&)7*52)2%09*72;(*&)7*2.1="&/1D40*51)0P*]E(&LL(2*@Â

R"G0=0%9*1.1)"C&;144$*/0)1&40/*/07;%&#)&".7*"5*)(0*#($7&;14*7045*1./*/0;"C#"7&)&".*#%";07707*.00/*.")*D0*C0)*G&)(*)(0*W("%%"%X*)(1)*S1.'*72''07)79*1./*72;(*%01;)&".7*1%0*&.*51;)*;".)%1%$*)"*)(0*#2%#"70*"5*D"/$VC&./524.077*;".)0C#41)&".A***

HX*&.*%0;"'.&)&".*"5*".0P7*#($7&;14*70#1%1)&".*5%"C*)(0*G"%4/*1)*41%'0*][%&7)0=1*@_hÂ*8"C0)(&.'*&.)0./0/*)"*%0=014*)(0*0770.)&14*)%2)(*)(1)*".0P7*D"/$*&7*;"C#"70/*"5*&.)0%/0#0./0.)*#1%)&;407*G&)(&.*1*41%'0%*0.=&%".C0.)*1./*2.&=0%70*&7*C0)*G&)(*%0=247&".*%"")0/*&.*1*D17&;*(2C1.* &.7)&.;)* )"* #2%'0* )(0*$-,=0A*J7* ".0P7* D".079* (01%)9* (1&%79* 0);A* 1%0* .")* 1*

)(0$*1%0*%0'1%/0/*G&)(*)(0*71C0*%0#2'.1.;0*17*W%05270*1./*;"%#707*c)(1)d*%,$6&)=

#1%)*"5*/01)(X*][%&7)0=1*@_`Â**N(&7*52./1C0.)14*;"C#".0.)*"5*(2C1.*52.;)&".&.'*&7* 7&C#4$*C1##0/* ".)"* )(0* P7* 01%.07)* 1))0C#)* )"* 0I#4&;1)0* )(0*&C#0%C1.0.;0* ]"#+-."^* 1./* %?#."-"&.7)&44&.'*1*%0#2470/*1=0%7&".*)"*)(0*D"/$*&.*)(0*C".17)&;A*T./00/9*72;(*/07;%&#)&".7*7("24/*&.7#&%0*W.0&)(0%*1))%1;)&".*."%*%0=247&".*D2)*&./&550%0.;0X*)"G1%/*)(0*)%209*

/&7'27)*5"%*)(0*D"/$*7("24/*&/0144$*'&=0*G1$*)"*1*C"%0*.02)%14*1))&)2/0X*]S&47".*hgÂ*Z.;0*)(&7*;".;0#)&".*"5*)(0*D"/$*&7*5244$*%014&M0/9*1./*/042/0/*1))1;(C0.)*)"*1.*W1DF0;)X*&.)0%#%0)1)&".*51/079*1;;0#)1.;0*"5*"#"-)"#*&7*72%0*)"*5"44"GA*N(&7*&7*)(0*24)&C1)0*'"14*"5*D"/$VC&./524.077*C0/&)1)&".A

J4".'*G&)(*")(0%*)0I)7*1./*#%1;)&;079*D"/$*;".)0C#41)&".*'2&/07*C1/0*)(0&%*

30

G1$*5%"C*)(0*E2//(&7)*WS07)0%.*60'&".7X*&.)"*!(&.1*17*)(0*)G"*;24)2%07*;"44&/0/*)(%"2'(*)%1=04&.'*C0%;(1.)7*14".'*)(0*8&4L*6"1/*1./*G1./0%&.'*C".17)&;7A*S&)(*=1%&"27* W)0I)7X* "5* )(0* 71C0*D17&;* 7)"%$*C0C"%&M0/* &.* )(0*l0/&;* "%14* )%1/&)&".9*;"2.)4077* )1407* "5* )(0* E2//(1* G0%0* )%1.741)0/* &.* /&7#1%1)0* 7)$407* 1./* 5"%C1)7*

1+#/* ]7;%&#)2%0Â* 60#"%)0/4$* )%1.741)0/* D$* <12)1C1* 81.'(1/0=1* 1)* \".')&.'*:".17)0%$*&.*1##%"I&C1)04$*bif*!B9*)(0*L,$#/&","#1+#/&&7*1*)%1.7C&77&".*"5*)(0*4"7,.")"/")"9* 1* 81.7L%&)* =0%7&".* "5* )(0* 9* 14)("2'(* &)*C27)*D0*1;L."G40/'0/*)(1)*)(0*)G"*1%0*.")*&/0.)&;14*]61/&;(*W:&//40*Q0.')(*J'1C1*82)%17X*@Â*O"%*(&7*)%1.741)&".*055"%)7*1./*40;)2%07*".*G:,+7,"0)"9*81.'(1/0=1*D0;1C0*1*G044*L."G.*C".L*/2%&.'*(&7*)&C0*&.*3&1.L1.'*]U1.F&.'^*1./*(&7*40'1;$*

7045* &.)"* )(0*#(&4"7"#(&;14* /&14"'20*"5*!(&.1* ]61/&;(9* W<12)1C1*81.'(1/0=1X*@Â*N(%"2'(* )(&7*#%";077*"5* ;24)2%14*/&5527&".9*E2//(&7)* &/0"4"'$*;1C0* 51;0* )"*51;0*G&)(*)(0*;".;0#)&".*"5*/"#.+#/9*2./0%7)""/*D$*N1"&7)7*17*W)(0*C0;(1.&7C*)(%"2'(* G(&;(* ;1)0'"%&;144$* %041)0/* D2)* 7#1)&144$* /&7)1.)* #(0."C0.1* &.)0%1;)X*

&.* )(0*C"%0* 0I#41.1)"%$* 5"%C* "5* W7$C#1)(0)&;* %07".1.;09X* /"#.+#/* &7* /&7)&.;)*5%"C*)(0*51C&4&1%*;1270V1./V0550;)*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5*;"0)"*]fbÂ*N(0*;".;0#)*"5*/"#.+#/*#"7&)7* )(1)9* 17*144*"DF0;)7*1./*D0&.'7*1%0*=1%&"27*C1.&507)1)&".7*"5* )(0*2.&=0%714* 72D7)1.;0*L."G.*17*O+'& )(1)* ;".7)%2;)7* 144* %014&)$* ]&C#4&;&)4$* 0="L&.'*D0"-+-."%")?-D"7"&1./*%?#."-"^9*)(0%0*&7*1*;"..0;)&".*D0)G00.*7&C&41%*#($7&;14*&.7)1.)&1)&".7*"5*O+P& T.* )(&7*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5* )(0*;"7C"79*W"DF0;)7*D04".'&.'* )"*)(0*71C0*;1)0'"%$*"%*;4177*7#".)1.0"274$*%07".1)0*G&)(*01;(*")(0%*F27)*17*/"*)G"*&/0.)&;144$*)2.0/*7)%&.'7*".*1*#1&%*"5*M&)(0%7X*]8(1%5*fb^*72;(*)(1)*1.$*)G"*(2C1.7*G&44*(1=0*1*7)%".'0%*W%07".1.;0X*)(1.9*71$9*1*(2C1.*1./*1*)%009*G(&40*)G"*(2C1.7*5%"C*)(0*71C0*'0.0)&;*D1;L'%"2./*G&44*4&L0G&70*D0*0=0.*C"%0*727;0#)&D40*)"*)(0*0550;)7*"5*".0*1.")(0%P7*1;)&".7A** * * * *

5"#.+#/9*17*)(0*2./0%4$&.'*#%&.;&#40*)"*0I#41&.*)(0*&.)0%1;)&".*D0)G00.*)(0* 1##1%0.)4$* /&7;%0)0* 0.)&)&07* )(1)* ;"C#"70* %014&)$9* (1/* 1* #41;0* &.* .01%4$*144* 51;0)7* "5* !(&.070* ;24)2%09* 1;;"%/&.'* )"* 8(1%5A*J7* /"#.+#/* &7* 2)&4&M0/* 17* 1*C01.7* )"* 0I#41&.* W1./*17)%"."C&;14*;$;4079*#"4&)&;14*2#(01=14X*1./*C"%09*&)* &7*2.72%#%&7&.'*)(1)*&)*

#(&4"7"#($9*1./*C".17)&;*#%1;)&;0X9*72;(*)(1)*!(&.070*#%1;)&)&".0%7*C"%0*%01/&4$*C"=0*D0$"./*1))1;(C0.)*)"*)(0*1DF0;)*040C0.)7*"5*E2//(&7)*7;%&#)2%0*]8(1%5*@?@Â*N(0*.")&".9*17*5"2./*&.*)(0*L,$#/&","#1+#/'*"5*)(0*(2C1.*D"/$*17*1*;".7)%2;)0/*C1)%&I*"5*;"C#"7&)&".14*040C0.)7*5"%C&.'*1.*1##1%0.)*G("409*70%=0/*)"*%0&.5"%;0*)(0* &./&'0."27*!(&.070* ;".;0#)&".* "5*/"#.+#/9* &.* 1* 4";14&M0/* 1##4&;1)&".* "5* 1*

/07;%&#)&".* "5* )(0* &/019* )(0%0* &7* ."* 2./0%7)1./&.'* "5* )(0* &C#4&;1)&".7* "5* )(070*

31

&.0551D40*.")&".7*".* )(0*/1&4$* 4&50*"5* )(0*!(&.070*#0"#40A*J7*G&)(*.01%4$*0=0%$*;"C#".0.)*"5*!(&.070*;24)2%09*/"#.+#/*G17*&.07;1#1D4$*G"%L0/*&.)"*)%1/&)&".14*

D"/&07*1./*1;)&".7*"5*%041)&=07*1%0*700.*)"*%07".1)0*7"*0550;)&=04$*17*".0P7*#($7&;14*D"/$*&7*'&5)0/*D$*".0P7*#1%0.)7*1./*&7*;"C#"70/*"5*)(0*71C0*;".7)&)20.)*040C0.)79*G(&;(*)(27*0.;"2%1'07*".0*)"*C1&.)1&.*1./*#%"#1'1)0*".0P7*#($7&;14*D0&.'*17*1*7&'.*"5*%07#0;)*1./*'%1)&)2/0*)"G1%/*".0P7*#1%0.)7A*T./00/9*)(0*;".;0#)*"5*/"#.+#/*

/=/?9*)(&7*#%1;)&;0*

#"G0%7* "5* %07".1.;0*G&)(* )(0* #1%0.)7P* "G.*D"/$A* T.* )(&7*G1$9*/"#.+#/* ;1.* D0*

7"C0)(&.'* )%1.7;0./0.)*"5*".0P7*"G.* &/0.)&)$*G&)(* )(0*;1#1;&)$* 5"%*C&%1;24"27*1./*)1.'&D40*&.)0%1;)&".*G&)(*)(0*%07)*"5*%014&)$A** * *

Q&L0G&709* /"#.+#/* &7* =0%$* C2;(* %07#".7&D40* 5"%* )(0* ;".7&7)0.)*#(0."C0.1*"5* 7045V&CC"41)&".* &.*!(&.070*E2//(&7CA*B=0.* &.* 1.* 0.=&%".C0.)*G&)(*)G"V5"4/*7";&14*%07)%&;)&".7*".*)(0*(1%C&.'*"5*".0P7*"G.*D"/$*]!".52;&1.*

/07)%"$0/9*1./*)(0*E2//(1P7*O&%7)*H%0;0#)*)"*1D7)1&.*5%"C*=&"40.)*1;)&".7^9*)(0*&/01*"5*1*2.&=0%714*2.&)$*0I#%0770/*)(%"2'(*/"#.+#/*G17*1D40*)"*)1L0*#%0;0/0.;0*1./*

";;2%%0.;0A*J4)("2'(*)(0*&/01*"5*=&"40.;0*)"*".0P7*W7045X*C1$*1##01%*;".)%1/&;)"%$*

7,"0)";"."'*1.$*&.7)1.)&1)&".*"5*%014&)$*]&.;42/&.'*".0P7*;".=0.)&".14*D"/$^* &7*24)&C1)04$*1*;"C#".0.)*"5*1* 41%'0%*72#%1VC2./1.0*7045* 1./* )(27* /070%=&.'*"5* .".V=&"40.;0A*O2%)(0%C"%09* )(0*:1(1$1.1*E2//(&7)*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5*7L&44524*C01.79*"%* 9*144"G7*5"%*#%1;)&)&".0%7*1./*

J,"0)"&&5*)(0&%*#2%#"70*&.*/"&.'*7"*&7*5"%*1*(&'(0%*;12709*72;(*17*)(0*G&/0%*#%"4&50%1)&".*"5*E2//(&7)*)("2'()*"%*;"C#177&".1)0*177&7)1.;0*)"*70.)&0.)*D0&.'7A*T)*&7*)(&7*;".;0#)&".*"5*?D"."&)(1)*144"G7*)(0*E2//(1*)"*%0#01)0/4$*72%%0./0%*(&7*D"/$*&.*=1%&"27*0I;00/&.'4$*=&"40.)*1./*'%1#(&;*0#&7"/07*&.*)(0*M"-";"&)1407*&.*G(&;(9*1;;"%/&.'*)"*31C07*E0..9*)(0*

N(0* E2//("V!(&.070* 41./7;1#0* )(1)* /0=04"#0/* 5%"C* )(&7* ;24)2%14*&.)0%1;)&".*G17*%&#0*5"%*)(0*#%"/2;)&".*"5*7045V&CC"41)"%7A*N(0*E2//(&7)*#%0;0/0.)*

4&=07*(1/*;"CD&.0/*G&)(*)(0*!(&.070*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5*)(0*%07".1.)*;1#1;&)$*"5*144*7,"0)"'*/20*)"*)(0&%*C2)214*&C#0%C1.0.;0A*J7*72;(9*&)*D0;1C0*1.*07)1D4&7(0/*%&)214*)"*%04&.K2&7(9*1)*4017)*&.*#1%)9*".0P7*#($7&;14*D"/$*17*)(0*24)&C1)0*/0=")&".14*1;)* 7045V&CC"41)&".* )(27* #%"4&50%1)0/* 1C".'* !(&.070* E2//(&7)* #%1;)&)&".0%7A*J4)("2'(*)(0*)0%C*&7*C"7)*"5)0.*2./0%7)""/*)"*%050%*)"*12)";%0C1)&".9*E0..*#"&.)7*

32

"2)* )(1)* #%1;)&;07* 72;(* 17* %&)214* 7)1%=1)&".9*/%"G.&.'9* 500/&.'*".07045* )"* 5"%07)*1.&C147* "%* &.70;)79* "%* )(%"G&.'*".07045* 5%"C*1*#%0;&#&;0* ;1.*D0*2./0%7)""/* 17*5"%C7*"5* /0=")&".14* 7045V&CC"41)&".A*B=0.* &5* )(070* #%1;)&;07* /"*.")* 24)&C1)04$*

D"/$PX*]>??g9*`_fÂ*O2%)(0%C"%09*&.7)1.;07*"5*1;)214*;%0C1)&".*.00/*.")*;".7&7)*

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fViÂ* * ** *N(0*&C#0)27*5"%*C&C&;%$*"5*72;(*%04&'&"27*51.1)&;&7C*0I)0./7*5%"C*1*

7#&%&)214*;24)&=1)&".*1./*)(0*#%"/2;)&".*"5*C0%&)*)"*;(1%&)1D40*1;)7*"5*;"C#177&".A*R"G0=0%9* %0'1%/4077* "5* )(0* #2%#"709* 5%"C* )(0* #0%7#0;)&=0* "5* 1* 7)%&;)* 7;%&#)2%14*&.)0%#%0)1)&".9*1*=&"40.)*1;)*".*)(0*#($7&;14*D"/$*7("24/*%07)%&;)*&CC"41)&".*%&)2147*5%"C*&.;427&".*&.*WE2//(&7)X*#%1;)&;0A*\%1G&.'*".*J4D0%)*S04)0%P7*&.=07)&'1)&".*"5*m1.7("2P7* <$#//?+& 1+9* E0..* 1%'207* )(1)* W5"%*m1.7("2* 7045V&CC"41)&".* G17*#%&C1%&4$*1*C1.&507)1)&".*"5*7"#"*];(1%&)$^9*1./*)(1)*17*)(0*24)&C1)0*0I#%077&".*"5*)(&7*D"0")+-"*]#0%50;)&".^*)(0*'&5)*"5*".0P7*D"/$*&7*1.*1;)*"5**+&17*"##"70/*)"*%,+9*G(&;(*&7*)"*71$*)(1)*&)*)1L07*#41;0*1)*)(0*40=04*"5*)(0*24)&C1)0*)%2)(*%1)(0%*)(1.*)(0*40=04*"5*;".=0.)&".14*#(0."C0.1X*]@@>Â*-./0%*)(&7*;".;0#)&".9*7045V&CC"41)&".9*G(&40*;".=0.)&".144$*1*W=&"40.)X*1;)9*/"07*.")*D%01L*)(0*O&%7)*H%0;0#)*17*)("70*G("*2./0%)1L0*72;(*1.*1;)&".*W(1/*1G1L0.0/*)"*)(0*51;)*)(1)*4&50*&7*)0C#"%1%$X*]E0..*ii^*1./9*24)&C1)04$9*W)(0%0*&7*."*7045*)"*&CC"41)0X*]E0..*fiÂ*8&C&41%4$9*&.*)(0*I$#/&/"$%=#/& R,?"#* ]N?0-,=0&9+$/0"D,+=%&$>&S)+#=#-&4$#;%^9* Wp1..&.'* %0;"'.&M07*)(1)* 72&;&/0* &7* )0;(.&;144$* 1.* "550.;09* D2)* 71$7* )(1)* )(&7* %0144$* ".4$* 1##4&07* )"*)("70*G("*;"CC&)*72&;&/0*G&)(*)(0*G%".'*&.)0.)&".*"5*07;1#&.'*I")%"0"X*]E0..*@@gÂ*E0$"./*72;(*1D7)%270*/";)%&.14*4""#("4079*/"#.+#/*#41$7*1.*&C#"%)1.)*%"40*&.* 07)1D4&7(&.'* 7045V&CC"41)&".* 17* 1*E2//(&7)* #%1;)&;0A*J;;"%/&.'* )"* 8(1%59* 17*01%4$* 17* )(0*!("2* 1./*R1.*\$.17)&079* )(0* 72;;077* "5* %1&.C1L&.'* %&)2147* WG17*2./0%7)""/* &.* )0%C7*"5* %07".1.;0* D0)G00.* )(&.'7* "5* 4&L0* L&./9X*G(&;(* &C#4&07*

&)* %07&/07*G&)(&.* ]8(1%5*f`Â*8&C&41%4$9*W)(0* 4&.L*D0)G00.* %&)214* 7045V;24)&=1)&".9*".*)(0*".0*(1./9*1./*)(0*#"G0%*)"*)%1.75"%C*")(0%7*1./*1550;)*;"7C&;*(1%C".$9*".*)(0*")(0%9*&7*#%0;&704$*)(0*#%&.;&#40*"5*%07".1.;0X*]8(1%5*i>Â*N(&7*&./&;1)07*1*7(1%0/*K214&)$*&.*144*)(&.'7*)(1)*;1.*D0*)2.0/*&.)"*1./*1550;)0/A*N(279*)(0*!(&.070*#%&.;&#40*"5*/"#.+#/*(04#7*0I#41&.*)(0*)0.7&".*)(1)*0I&7)7*G&)(&.*)(0*E"/(&71))=1*

)"*%014&M0*".0P7*;"C#177&".1)0*'"14A*-./0%*)(&7*;".;0#)&".9*)(0*)G"*1%0*".0*&.*)(0*

33

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`fÂ*J;;"%/&.'* )"* 7"C0*=0%7&".7*"5* )(0* )1409* W)(0*E40770/*Z.0P7*

)(1)* ]&.*G(1)*D%&.'7* )"*C&./*1*D"/$V;".)0C#41)&".*'2&/0^*W."*;&./0%*"%*17(*"5*

Z.4$*)(0*%04&;7*%0C1&.0/X*]8&4L*@?Â*N(&7*&7*1.*&C#"%)1.)*501)2%0*)"*(&'(4&'()*17*7#".)1.0"27*;"CD27)&".*;1C0*)"*D0*=&0G0/9*1)*4017)*/";)%&.144$9*17*)(0*%0724)*"5*(&'(4$* ;24)&=1)0/* #%1;)&)&".0%7* &.* 1.* 1/=1.;0/* 7)1)0* "5*C0/&)1)&".9* 17* "##"70/*

;".72C&.'*C0/&)1)"%7*5%"C*G&)(&.*;1.*D0*700.*17*1.*&4427)%1)&".*"5*)(0*0C#)&.077*"5*144*7,"0)"A*N(0*D"/$P7*1D&4&)$*)"*/07)%"$*&)7045*%0724)7*7&C#4$*5%"C*&)7*7)1)27*17*1.*&C#0%C1.0.)*0.)&)$A*E0..*;".)0./7*)(1)*)(&7*L&./*7#".)1.0"27*&CC"41)&".*G17*"5)0.*=&0G0/*17*)(0*.1)2%14*0./*5"%*)("70*G("*(1/*/0=04"#0/*1*WC17)0%$*"5*)(0*%")"7,+&!(&.070*)%1.741)&".*"5*)(0* 9*&.*G(&;(*)(0*E2//(1*&7*71&/*)"*(1=0*W0.)0%0/*&.)"*)(0*O&%0*!".)0C#41)&".*1./*1D1./".0/*(&7 )"*/&77&#1)&".X*]8&4L*ghÂ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g>Â*604&;7*1%0*0I)%1"%/&.1%&4$* &C#"%)1.)* &.* D")(* T./&1.* 1./*!(&.070* ;".)0I)7* 1./* *]%04&;*G"%7(&#^*1./*)(0*0%0;)&".*"5*%-?D"%*]C"2./V4&L0*7)%2;)2%07*)(1)*)%1/&)&".144$*("270*%04&;7*1./*70%=0*17*#41;07*"5*G"%7(&#^*%0C1&.*G044V07)1D4&7(0/*)%1/&)&".7A*J7* 8(1%5* 0I#41&.79* %04&;7* (1=0* W;".)%&D2)0/* )"* )(0* 72;;077* "5* E2//(&7C* 17* 1*C&77&".1%$* %04&'&".e1./* 40'&)&C&M0/* )(0*E2//(&7)*1##%"#%&1)&".*"5* &./&'0."27*%04&'&"27* ;0.)0%7* )(%"2'("2)* J7&19* )%1.75"%C&.'* )(0* 41./7;1#0* &.)"* 1* 71;%0/*E2//(&7)*/"C1&.X*]@h`Â*J4)("2'(*%04&;7*;"24/*&.;42/0*1.$*D"/&4$*%0C1&.79*%"0+0"*272144$*%050%%0/*)"*)("70*5"2./*&.*)(0*17(07*"5*52.0%14*#$%07A* * ** H%&"%* )"*E2//(&7CP7* &.)%"/2;)&".*"5*;%0C1)&".*1./*G1)0%*D2%&149*E0..*

34

;41&C7*)(1)*)(0*".4$*C01.7*)"*/&7#"70*"5*/01/*D"/&07*270/*D$*)(0*1.;&0.)*!(&.070*G0%0*01%)(*D2%&14*1./*W0I#"72%0*"5*)(0*;"%#70X*]E0..*@?@Â*S&)("2)*;%0C1)&".9*

)"*)(0*!(&.070*#0"#40A*J7*)(0*#%1;)&;0*#%"4&50%1)0/*17*1*52.0%1%$*%&)09* )(0*%"2./*%"0+0"* 5"2./*&.*)(0*17(07*"5*#$%07*]1%'21D4$*C1'&;14*W#%""5X*"5* )(0*/0;0170/P7*

!(&.1*F27)*17*)(0$*G0%0*&.*)(0*S07)0%.*60'&".7A*R0%14/0/*17*#%""5*"5*)(0*E2//(1P7*

&C#"%)1.)*)""47*5"%*/&770C&.1)&.'*)(0*J,"0)"*1./*%0;%2&)&.'*.0G*;".=0%)7*)"*)(0*51&)(*1C".'*1*#0"#40*5"%*G("C*W)(0*.00/*)"*/&7#04*)(0&%*2.;0%)1&.)$*;".;0%.&.'*)(0*0I&7)0.;0*"5*1*'"/*"5*1*/&7)1.)*41./*1./*)&C0*(1/*1.*1//&)&".14*2%'0.;$X*]S1.'*f@Â*N(0%0*G17* 1.* &C#"%)1.)* /0D1)09* ("G0=0%9* )(1)* /0=04"#0/* "=0%* )&C0* 17* )"*G(0)(0%*E2//(&7)*%04&;7o)(0*N%20*E"/$*"5*)(0*E2//(1oG0%0*)"*D0*2./0%7)""/*17*5"%C4077*"DF0;)7*"5*Wj127#&;&"27P*42C&.1.;0X*]&.*%0#%070.)1)&".*"5*)(0*E2//(1P7*24)&C1)0**)%1.7;0./0.)14*K214&)&07^*"%*17*4&)0%14*D"/$*#1%)79*72;(*17*5%1'C0.)7*"5*D".0*"%*;%0C1)&".*%0C1&.79*&.*1;L."G40/'0C0.)*"5*(&7*W)%20X*0I&7)0.;0*17*1*(2C1.*D0&.'* ]S1.'* fhÂ* N"* )(0*S07)0%.* 7;("41%9* D")(* "#)&".7* #%070.)* 1* ;".2./%2CA*J*;".;0#)&".*"5*%,=*+* 17*0)(0%014* 4&'()*/0=&1)07* 5%"C*1*=&0G*"5*E2//(&7C*17*1*W%1)&".14X*#(&4"7"#($*/0="&/*"5*72#0%7)&)&".9*G(&40* )(0*G"%7(&#*"5* )(0*#($7&;14*%0C1&.7*"5*1*/01/*7#&%&)214*401/0%*&4427)%1)07*1*41;L*"5*;".=&;)&".*&.*)(0*E2//(&7)*&/0147*"5*.".V1))1;(C0.)*1./*)(0*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5*)%1.7&0.)*#(0."C0.1A*T.*"%/0%*)"*%07"4=0*)(&7*/&40CC19*)(0*&7720*"5*%04&;*G"%7(&#*C27)*D0*&.=07)&'1)0/*52%)(0%A*

N(0*#%"/2;)&".*1./*/&70CC&.1)&".*"5*%04&;7*D0;1C0*1.*&C#"%)1.)*51;0)*"5*!(&.070*E2//(&7C*1./9*17*&4427)%1)0/*D$*E0..9*7045V&CC"41)"%7*("#0/*)"*270*)(0&%*/01)(7*17*1*C01.7*"5*#%"#1'1)&.'*)(0*51&)(A*T.*)(&7*%07#0;)9*W)"*/&0*055"%)40774$*

14G1$7* 1##%0;&1)0/* 1./* )"* 270* ".0P7* "G.* /01)(* 17* 1* C01.7* "5* #%01;(&.'* )(0*J,"0)"&G17* ;401%4$* ;".7&/0%0/* &/014X* ]E0..*@fgÂ*J4)("2'(* )(0*(1'&"'%1#(&;*1;;"2.)7* "5* /&550%0.)* 7045V&CC"41)"%7P* /01)(7* =1%$* 5%"C* 714=1)&".* 1))0C#)7* 1)*%0D&%)(*&.*1*H2%0*Q1./9*WG(&;(*G17*.")*&.5%0K20.)4$*.1C0/*17*1*/07)&.1)&".*5"%*41)0* &C#0%&14* 12)"V;%0C1)"%7X* ]E0..* @`_^9* )"* ;"C#177&".1)0* W#2D4&;* 1;)c7d* "5*1)".0C0.)* 5"%* )(0* #0%;0&=0/* C&7/00/7* "5* )(0* %"#/,"X* ]E0..* @`g^* "%* #%1$0%7*

0=0%$*;170*)"*D0*)(0*52%)(0%0/*#%"4&50%1)&".*"5*J,"0)"A*N(&7*G17*C"7)*0550;)&=04$*;".=0$0/*)(%"2'(*)(0*0.7(%&.0C0.)*"5*%04&;79*C"7)*;"CC".4$*;%0C1)&".*%"0+0"*"%*)(0*C"%0*%1%0*0$?%,=#&D?%"*]5244VD"/$*%04&;^*)(1)*1%0*7"C0)&C07*#%"/2;0/A*N(070*2.&K20*E2//(&7)*1%)&51;)7*1%0*"5)0.*%050%%0/*)"*17*WC2CC&07X9*14)("2'(*)(0$*1%0*.")*#%0#1%0/*1./*#%070%=0/*&.*)(0*71C0*C1..0%*17*)(0&%*B'$#)&1.*;"2.)0%#1%)79*D2)*%1)(0%*1%0*700.*17*&4427)%&"27*D0&.'7*G("*(1=0*1;(&0=0/*)(0*&/014*"5*W1))1&.&.'*)(0*

H2%#"%)0/4$* ;%01)0/* 7&C#4$* D$* =&%)20* "5* )(0* #%1;)&)&".0%P7* 0I)%0C04$*

35

1/=1.;0/*7)1)0*"5*7#&%&)214*;24)&=1)&".9*0$?%,=#&D?%"*;1.*D0*5"2./*&.*!(&.1*1./*N1&G1.9* 1./* C1.$* G0%0* #%"/2;0/* &.* )(0* 41))0%* (145* "5* )(0* )G0.)&0)(* ;0.)2%$A*

0$?%,=#& D?%"* &.* )(0*!(&.070*C1&.41./* D0'1.* &.*)(0*41)0*)(&%/*;0.)2%$*1./*144*1%0*&.7)1.;07*"5*C"2.)1&.*17;0)&;7*G("70*/&7;&#407*/&/*.")*&.)0.)&".144$*;%01)0*%04&;7*5%"C*)(0&%*%07#0;)&=0*C17)0%P7*;"%#70A*R042"F&0*

%0#"%)0/4$*/&0/*&.*1*C0/&)1)&=0*#"7)2%09*&.*G(&;(*7)1.;0*W(&7*/&7;&#407*1))0C#)0/*)"* ;%0C1)0*(&CX* )"* 4&))40* 1=1&4* W15)0%* 70=0%14*/1$7*".* )(0*#$%0X* ]<&4/"G*ffViÂ*N(070* 127#&;&"27* ;&%;2C7)1.;07* G0%0* )1L0.* 17* 1* 7&'.* "5* R042"F&0P7* 7#&%&)214*1))1&.C0.)*1./*(&7*%0C1&.7*G0%0*#41;0/*&.*1*;1=0*5"%*=0.0%1)&".A*T.*)(0*41))0%*(145*"5*)(0*5"2%)(*;0.)2%$9*70=0%14*")(0%*C"2.)1&.*17;0)&;79*&.*1.*1%01*51%*%0C"=0/*5%"C*R042"F&09*405)*7&C&41%*5244VD"/$*%04&;7*]<&4/"G*fiÂ*N(070*%0;427&=0*C".L7*70)*)(0*#%0;0/0.)*5"%*41)0%*5244VD"/$*%04&;79*)("2'(*)(070*/&/*.")*1##01%*2.)&4*)(0*C&//40*"5*)(0*N1.'*\$.17)$*"=0%*)G"*(2./%0/*$01%7*41)0%A*R"G0=0%9*)(070*01%4$*0I1C#407*

)"*#%070%=0*)(0*D"/&079*14)("2'(*)(0*5%2'14*/&0)*"5*1.*17;0)&;*C1$*(1=0*51;&4&)1)0/*.1)2%14*#%070%=1)&".A*** * * *

E$*h>`*!B9*1;;"2.)7*&.*)(0*T?&/"$%=#/&R,?"#*]O2%)(0%*E&"'%1#(&07*"5*BC&.0.)*:".L7^*1##01%*)(1)*/&7;277*)(0*&.)0.)&".14*7)0#7*)1L0.*)"*;%01)0*5244VD"/$*%04&;7A*8)&44*1.*17;0)&;*C".L9*\1"I&2P7*;"%#70*G17*5"2./*)"*%07&7)*/0;1$*1./*G17*W;"=0%0/*G&)(*41;K20%V7"1L0/*;4")(X*&.*"%/0%*)"*D0*0.7(%&.0/*]<&4/"G*fiÂ*Q1)0%*&.* )(0*N1.'*\$.17)$9*C"%0*C".L7* %0#"%)0/4$* D0;1C0* 5244VD"/$* %04&;7A*N("2'(*=1%&"27*C0)("/7*G0%0*2./0%)1L0.*1./*)(0*/0)1&47*1%0*.")*14G1$7*#%070.)0/*&.*52449*

]<&4/"G*fiÂ*T)*&7*1*7)%&L&.'*51;)*)(1)*0I1C#407*"5*)(&7*#(0."C0.".*;1.*D0*700.*)(%"2'("2)*)(0*(&7)"%$*"5*!(&.070*E2//(&7C*2#*)"*)(0*#%070.)*/1$*1./*;".)&.20*)"*D0*G"%7(&#0/*17*4";14*/0&)&07*G&)(*.2C&."27*#"G0%A*($?%,=#&D?%"*&)70459*W)(0*C"7)* ;"CC".4$* 270/* !(&.070* )0%C* &.* N1&G1.X* 5"%* 1* 5244VD"/$* %04&;9* 4&)0%144$*

:$7,+%"--A"X* ]<&4/"G*i_Â*N(&7* &442C&.1)07* )(0*0I)0.)*)"*G(&;(*)(070*D0&.'7*G0%0*G"%7(&#0/9*17*&./&;1)0/*D$*)(0*51;)*)(1)*)(0&%*#%070.;0*

C".0)1%$*"550%&.'7*1./*#%07)&'0*D2&4)* 1%"2./* )0C#407* )(1)*("270/*C17)0%7*G("*D04&0=0/*)"*(1=0*)(0*#"G0%*)"*W'%1.)*51="%7*1./*&.)0%1;)*G&)(*#0"#40*D$*70./&.'*

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

0$?%,=#&

36

D?%"9*/&0/*&.*@i_g9*G(0%02#".*(&7*D"/$*G17*#41;0/*&.*)G"*70140/*01%)(0.G1%0*)2D7*

$01%79*17*#0%*(&7*&.7)%2;)&".7A*J)*72;(*)&C09*)(0$*"#0.0/*)(0*70140/*2%.*1./*5"2./*(&7*D"/$*&.)1;)*)"*D0*'&4/0/*1./*#41;0/*&.*)(0*)0C#40*14".'7&/0*7)1./1%/*7)1)207*"5*)(0*E2//(1*1./*;"7C&;*:$7,+%"--A"%A*N(&7*5"%C1)*5"%*D2%&14*1./*0.7(%&.0C0.)9*%0K207)0/*D$*!&(1.'9*70)*)(0*#%0;0/0.)*5"%*41)0%*N1&G1.070*C".L79*1./*".0*.2.*D04".'&.'*)"*1*N&D0)1.*)%1/&)&".9*G("*G"24/*4&L0G&70*D0*C1/0*&.)"*0$?%,=#&D?%"*]<&4/"G*i_Â*J4)("2'(*)(0%0*(1=0*".4$*D00.*7&I*%0;"'.&M0/*N1&G1.070*0$?%,=#&D?%"9* 144* G0%0* 0.7(%&.0/* D0)G00.* @i_g* 1./* >???9* &./&;1)&.'* 1* %0C1%L1D40*72;;077&".*15)0%*!&(1.'P7*/01)(A*Z5*)(070*7&I9*".4$*)(1)*"5*)(0*C"2.)1&.*17;0)&;*H2M(1"*]/A*@ifb^9*1D"2)*G("C*4&))40*&7*L."G.9*&7*.")*0.;170/*&.*D%".M0*"%*'"4/*4015*]<&4/"G*igÂ*N(070*D"/&07V;2CV7)1)207*70%=0*17*&/"47*1./*1%0*#0%;0&=0/*)"*7)&44* 1;)&=04$* )01;(*J,"0)"* 1./* '%1.)* D4077&.'7A*N("2'(* %0;"'.&M0/* 17* (2C1.*

W;"24/*017&4$*D0*C&7)1L0.*5"%*F27)*1.")(0%*E2//(1*7)1)20X*]<&4/"G*@?_Â*J##01%1.;07*;1.*D0*/0;0&=&.'*("G0=0%9*17*&)*&7*;401%*)(1)*)(070*&/"47*(1=0*

H2M(1"P7*0.7(%&.0C0.)*1./*)(0*5244VD"/$*%04&;*"5*1*:"'"4&1.*41C19*)(0*[1.F2%G1*[(2)2'()29*G(&;(*G17* %0#"%)0/4$* )(0* W1;;&/0.)14* #%"/2;)* "5* 1.* &.0#)4$* 7)1'0/*;%0C1)&".X*]<&4/"G*ib^9*144*"5*N1&G1.P7*5244VD"/$*%04&;7*(1=0*5"44"G0/*!&(1.'P7*

:$7,+%"--A"U%V*/20* )"* c)(0&%d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m0)9* 17* 0=&/0.;0/* D$*)(0*51;)*)(1)*0$?%,=#&D?%"*.00/*W)"*2./0%'"*jC1&.)0.1.;0*1./*%0#1&%7P*G(&;(e*&.="4=07*1##4$&.'*1//&)&".14*'"4/*4015X*0=0%$*/0;1/0*]<&4/"G*@@@^9*)(0*41G7*"5*.1)2%0*1./*)(0*J,"0)"& "#+-."&]&C#0%C1.0.;0Â* *

S(&40* )(070* 1))0C#)7* )"* ;&%;2C=0.)* .1)2%14* /0;1$* C1$* 1##01%* )"* D0*&.* ;".)0.)&".* G&)(* E2//(&7)* /";)%&.0* 1./* )%1/&)&".9* )(0* #%0;0/0.;0* 5"%* 72;(*1;)&=&)&07* 7)%0);(07* D1;L* )"* 81L$1C2.&* (&C7045o(&7)"%&;144$* 1.* &C#"%)1.)*;"C#".0.)*5"%*07)1D4&7(&.'*)(0*W40'&)&C1;$X*"5*1.$*%&)214*&.*!(&.070*E2//(&7CA*J;;"%/&.'*)"*70=0%14*"5*8&4LP7*)%1.741)&".7*"5*1;;"2.)7*"5*)(0*E2//(1P7*;%0C1)&".*;0%0C".$9*81L$1C2.&*G17*#41;0/*&.7&/0*1*'"4/0.*;17L0)*1./*)(0*G""/*#$%0*G17*0I)&.'2&7(0/*]D$*=1%&"27*C&%1;24"27*"%*;".=0.)&".14*C01.7^*D05"%0*&)*(1/*D2%.0/*

51;)*17*)"*G($*)(0*E2//(1P7*D"/$*405)*7"*C1.$*%04&;7*)"*D0*/&770C&.1)0/*&.*%-?D"%*

37

)(%"2'("2)*J7&1*1./*07)1D4&7(07*1*)%1/&)&".*"5*C1.&#241)&.'*)(0*D2%&14*#%";077*)"*0.72%0* )(0*#%"/2;)&".*"5*%04&;7A*J4)("2'(*:1(1L17$1#1*1./*)(0*%"#/,"&(1/*."*&.)0.)&".*"5*)2%.&.'*)(0*E2//(1P7*D"/$*&.)"*1*0$?%,=#&D?%"9*)(0$*144"G0/*5"%*72;(*

* T.*)%1;&.'*)(0*4&.01'0*"5*5244VD"/$*%04&;7*D1;L*)"*)(0*H14&*;1.".9*".0*&7*7)&44*."*;4"70%*)"*)(0*1.7G0%*"5*G($*%,=*+9*&.;42/&.'*5244VD"/&079*(1=0*;".)&.20/*)"*D0*G"%7(&#0/*)(%"2'("2)*)(0*(&7)"%$*"5*E2//(&7CA*H%&"%*)"*)(0*E2//(1P7*/01)(9*(0*%0#"%)0/4$*&.7)%2;)0/*J.1./1*])(0*E2//(1P7*;"27&.*1./*;4"707)*/&7;&#40^*)"*D0*2.;".;0%.0/*WG&)(* )(0*G"%7(&#*"5* )(0*N1)(1'1)1P7*D"/$X*1./* &.7)01/* )"*W7)%&=0*5"%*)(0*)%20*'"149*D0*;"CC&))0/*)"*)(0*)%20*'"149*4&=0*D0&.'*M014"279*1%/0.)9*1./*%07"42)0*)"G1%/*)(0*)%20*'"14eX*]8&4L*iÂ*604&;*G"%7(&#*G"24/*)(0.*1##01%*5%"C*)(0*"2)70)*)"*D0*/&7;"2%1'0/*D$*)(0*E2//(1*17*1*/042/0/*1))0C#)*)"*;4&.'*)"*)(0*#17)* 1./* ;".=0.)&".14* 0I&7)0.;0A*J./* $0)9* )(0* #($7&;14* %0C1&.7* "5* 1.$* (2C1.*D0&.'*1%0*&.;".)%"=0%)&D40*#%""5*"5*)(0*)%1.7&)"%$9*0C#)$*.1)2%0*"5*0I&7)0.;0*1./*

WN%20*E"/$X*&7*)(27*.")*(&7*;"%#"%14*;".7)%2;)&".*17*#%""5*"5*(&7*#17)*0I&7)0.;0*&.*)(&7*%014C9*D2)*%1)(0%*)(0*51;)*)(1)*(0*&7*0.)&%04$*)%1.7&0.)o&.*/01)(9*144*1%0*#2%0*1./*)%1.7;0./0.)*1./*)(279*1.$*1./*144*(2C1.*%0C1&.7*&4427)%1)0*)(0*WN%20*E"/$X*"5* )(0*E2//(1* 1./*(&7*G"%4/4$* )01;(&.'7A* T.="L&.'* )(0* 41.'21'0*"5*[%&7)0=1P7*

2))0%4$* #%"51.0* 1./* 4"1)(7"C0o)(0* ;"%#"%14* %0C1&.7* "5* )(0* /01/X* ]@h_Â* E2)*&.* )(0&%*#(7$&;14*#%070.;09* %04&;7* &4427)%1)0* )(1)*.")* 0=0.* )(0*E2//(1*(&C7045* &7*5%00*5%"C*)(0*;$;40*"5*&C#0%C1.0.)*0I&7)0.;09*1*#"&.)*%0&.5"%;0/*D$*)(0*51;)*)(1)*1.")(0%*;"CC".*81.7L%&)*)0%C*5"%*%04&;*&7*7,"-?,&1*)0%C*)(1)*W&7*147"*270/*)"*%050%*)"*)(0*52./1C0.)14*"%*;".7)&)20.)*040C0.)]7^*"5*)(0*2.&=0%70*&)7045X*]8(1%5*@`@Â*N(0*24)&C1)0*'"14*&7*)"*C"=0*#17)*".0P7*/0427&".7*"5*)(0*1DF0;)*1./*#0%;0&=0*)(0*72#%0C0*)01;(&.'*0CD"/&0/*G&)(&.*&)A*

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j)(&.'.077P*1./*1)*)(0*71C0*)&C0*G&)(*)(0*#2MM40*"5*4&50*&)7045X*]@f@Â*($?%,=#& D?%"* 1./* 7045V&CC"41)"%7* 52%)(0%* /0C".7)%1)0* )(0* #%"#0%* C1..0%* &.*G(&;(*".0* &7* )"*C00)* )(0* &.0=&)1D40* 0./* )(1)* &7* 0="L0/* 1./* 0CD"/&0/* &.* )(070*1%)&51;)7A* E0..* #"&.)7* "2)* )(1)* W1* .")1D40* )%"#0* )(1)* ;1C0* )"* /"C&.1)0* 41)0%*D&"'%1#(&07*c"5*7045V&CC"41)"%7d*G17*)(0*5";27*".*)(0*C"C0.)*"5*/01)(*1./*)(0*&C#"%)1.;0*"5*)(0*&/014*#"7)2%0*17*4&50*0./7X*]@_`Â*!"CD&.0/*G&)(*)(0*)%0./*"5*

38

C".L7*#%01;(&.'* 1./* 0=0.* ;"C#"7&.'* W/01)(* =0%707X*G(&40* D2%.&.'9* )"* /&0* &.*5244VC0/&)1)&".* 7)1.;0* G&)("2)* #1&.* &7* #%"C")0/* )(%"2'(* )(0* 1;;"2.)7* "5* 7045V&CC"41)"%7*17*)(0*#%050%%0/*1./*#%"#0%*G1$*)"*C00)*".0P7*0./A*N(0*C0771'0*&7*)(27*)(1)*E2//(&7)*#%1;)&;0*/0=04"#7*)(0*1;;0#)1.;0*1./*;"C5"%)*G&)(*)(0*;".;0#)*"5* ".0P7* )%1.7&0.;0* &.* )(&7* G"%4/A* N1&G1.070* 0$?%,=#& D?%"* 0I(&D&)* )(&7* 71C0*K214&)$*17*)(0$*(1=0*144*D00.*#%070%=0/*1./*/&7#41$0/*&.*1*C0/&)1)&=0*7)1.;0*)(1)*/0C".7)%1)07*)"*G"%7(&##0%7*)(1)*)(0$*C0)*)(0&%*/01)(*;14C4$*1./*&.*C0/&)1)&".A*T./00/9*&)* &7*1*;"CC".*";;2%%0.;0*5"%*)(0&%*(1'&"'%1#(&07*)"*#2%#"%)*)(1)*)(070*C17)0%7*#%0/&;)0/*)(0&%*"G.*/01)(7*]<&4/"G*if^A*N("2'(*700C&.'4$*"##"70/*)"*".0*1.")(0%9*C17)0%7*G("*7045V&CC"41)0*1./*401=0*%,=*+&"%*D0;"C0*0$?%,=#&D?%"*144*;".=0$*)(0*71C0*C0771'0*)"*#%1;)&)&".0%7,*D")(*&.7)&44*1.*1;;0#)1.;0*"5*/01)(*1./*24)&C1)04$*&4427)%1)0*)(1)*144*(2C1.79*0=0.*)("70*"5*1*(&'(4$*1/=1.;0/*7#&%&)214*7)1)09*1%0*72DF0;)*)"*)(0*41G7*"5*J,"0)"A* *

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f>^A*N(%"2'("2)*)(0* ;".)0.)&"27* /0D1)0* "=0%*G(1)* ;".7)&)2)07* 1.* W12)(0.)&;X*E2//(&7)* #%1;)&;09*?D"."V;"?%,"*."&#%1;)&;0*1./*%&)214*)(1)*;".7)&)2)0*)(0*G("40*"5*!(&.070*E2//(&7CA*N(0*;".)&.20/*#%070.;0* "5* D"/$V;0.)0%0/* #%1;)&;07* 72;(* 17* %04&;* G"%7(&#9* 7045V&CC"41)&".*1./* )(0*1;)&=0*#%"/2;)&".*"5* 5244VD"/$* %04&;7* &4427)%1)07* )(0*0I)0.)* )"*G(&;(* )(0*E2//(1P7*0I#4&;1)&".*"5*)(0*)%1.7&)"%$*D"/$*%07".1)0/*G&)(*)(0*!(&.070*#0"#40*17*

39

!"#$%&'()*+

,*--.&/01*%&23& 3&& & 4"-"56567&8-(9*#%():&";&40<0(=(&>#*%%.&?@@A3&>#(-)3

BBB&CD*5;BE11"50)("-3F&!"#!$%%$"&'($)*"*+',-.-*-&#-'/&#+#%01-2$"'0.'34225$673&& G"53&H3&I*<J"#$7&KL"1%"-BM05*.&?@@N3&AOPBQ3&>#(-)3

,L($$L6.&KL0-(%%0#"3&CR0:0S0)0B%0)(&D6))07&T(-+;65-*%%&E11*#%*+&(-&)L*&& ,"+:3F&8##-66'90':&6$;593&?@H@3&!*U3&@A&T0#3&?@HH3&VL))W7XX<<<3& 0YY*%%)"(-%(SL)3"#SX)(W()0$0X1-X1-3HHQ3)L0-3L)15Z3

& K0(<0-7&K<"&'0%*&D)6+(*%3F&86$"'!"<0*.&KL(#+&D*#(*%.&?@@O3&PABH?A3&& !*U'K3

R#(%)*90.&/65(03&C2WW#"0YL(-S&2U[*Y)("-3F&=6+#50"&"%+9$#'>*$9$#$67?'8',-"2-*3&& \+3&D6*&G(Y*3&'01U#(+S*.&T27&>"5():.&HQQ]3&HOOBOP3&>#(-)3

T0--.&D6%0-.&0-+&J6BJ(-&'L*-S3&@&2-*'>0&.4#$"&'/+-6?'A*$9$&;6'0&'B-&2-*'$&'' >5$&-6-'C$690*+3&,*#$*5*:7&8-(9*#%():&";&'05(;"#-(0.&?@@H3&>#(-)3

^0+(YL.&T(YL0*53&CM06)010&D0-SL0+*903F&D$;$9"%'D$#9$0&"*+'0.'34225$673&?O&& 26S3&?@@Q3!*U3&@A&2W#3&?@HH3&VL))W7XX<<<3U6++L(%1B+(Y)3-*)XYS(BU(-X& _W#B++U3W5`AA3_15a(+bcUAAU;]]YAO@*ABN;d+B]d+@BO0N]=eZ3

BBB3&CT(++5*&f*-S)L&2S010&D6)#0%3F&D$;$9"%'D$#9$0&"*+'0.'34225$673&@?&T0:&& ?@@Q3&!*U3&@A&2W#3&?@HH3&VL))W7XX<<<3U6++L(%1B+(Y)3-*)XYS(BU(-X& _W#++U3W5`N*3_15a(+bcUN*?+Q]d;BON?UBA+Qd=eZ3

DL0#;.&^"U*#)&43&C'L(-*%*&,6++L(%1&0-+&)L*&'"%1"5"S:&";&D:1W0)L*)(Y&& ^*%"-0-Y*3F&>07$&;'90'E-*76'F$95'>5$&-6-'34225$67?'"',-"2$&;'' 0.'95-'E*-"64*-'G90*-'E*-"9$6-3&4"-"56567&8-(9*#%():&";&40<0(=(.&& ?@@?3&>#(-)3

BBBB3&Cg-&)L*&2556#*&";&,6++L(%)&^*5(Y%3F&/7)02+$&;'95-'D5"*7"7'34225$69'3&\+3&h09(+&M*#10-"&0-+&R*9(-&K#0(-"#3&25U0-:7&

& D)0)*&8-(9*#%():&";&I*<&J"#$.&?@@N3&H]dBHQd3&>#(-)3

40

8&4L9*3".1)(1.*JA*9$7.&Q"#/?"/=E&H#7+2&I"0+0"&"#7&!,+#=%=&I,=*+&+#&-,=&A*N"L$",*T.)0%.1)&".14*

* T.7)&)2)0*5"%*E2//(&7)*8)2/&079*>??hA*H%&.)A*8)2/&1*H(&4"4"'&;1*E2//(&;19** :"."'%1#(*80%&07*qTqA

S1.'9*B2'0.0A*WZ5*)(0*N%20*E"/$,*N(0*O1C0.*:".17)0%$*604&;7*1./*!"%#"%014** N%1.75"%C1)&".*&.*N1.'*TC#0%&14*!24)2%09X&&.*9$7.&"#7&N"2=&+#&!,+#=%=&

9*0/7AS2*R2.'*1./*[1)(0%&.0*N7&1.'A*!1CD%&/'0*:177A,** R1%=1%/*-.&=0%7&)$*J7&19*>??_A*`iV@@fA*S0D!NA

S&47".9*Q&MA*WH0%7#0;)&=07*".*)(0*E"/$AX*4"24+**+"#&Q+:0"0.&(=>=0=#2=&& S#2.2*$D=7+"&$>&9?77,+%)P&l"4A*@A*U0G*m"%L,*N("C7".V<1409*>??gA** hbVhhA*H%&.)A

41

;F7909GH).I;FFJGK.[JTNQTU*\PJlBQQJ*

42

!"#$%&'$(. N(0* #0%)&.0.)9* ;".)%"=0%7&14* 1./* =24.0%1D40* .1)2%0* "5* %04&'&"27*5%00/"C*&.*)(0*G1L0*"5*70;241%&M1)&".*/0C1./7*1*;".;0#)214*%0V0I1C&.1)&".*"5*

"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*1./*&)7*#%1;)&;14*1##4&;1)&".7*&.*1.*&.)0%.1)&".14*1%0.19*)(&7*#1#0%*G&44* 1))0C#)* )"* 042;&/1)0* )(0* .00/* 5"%* 1* #1%1/&'C* 7(&5)* &.* /&7;"2%707* ".*%04&'&"27*5%00/"CA*!170*7)2/&07*"5*)(0*51&42%0*"5*)(0*-.&)0/*8)1)07*T.)0%.1)&".14*

O%00/"C*&.*!1.1/1*G&44*#"&.)*)"*)(0*#%077&.'*.00/*5"%*1*.0G*1##%"1;(*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*)(1)*#%")0;)7*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*5%"C*1*#42%14&7)&;*#0%7#0;)&=0A*

9L.M/&$.9#.;*8+-+1?#.I%**B1<N

* 31$*U0GC1.'&

* :1.$* #(&4"7"#(0%7* "5* )(0* B.4&'()0.C0.)* #%0/&;)0/* )(0* /0;4&.0* "5*%04&'&".* &.* )(0* #2D4&;* 7#(0%0A* 8"C0* "5* )(0* C&./7* C"7)* 5"2./1)&".14* )"* )(0*S07)0%.*1;1/0C&;*)%1/&)&".*Y*[1%4*:1%I9*rC&40*\2%L(0&C9*1./*8&'C2./*O%02/*Y*1.)&;&#1)0/*)(0*0=0.)214*/&71##01%1.;0*"5*)(0*#%1;)&;0*"5*%04&'&".*&.*1*#%";077*"5*70;241%&M1)&".A*R"G0=0%9*)(&7*W70;241%&M1)&".*($#")(07&7X*(17*51&40/A*N(0*%014&)$*%0C1&.7* )(1)* %04&'&".*(17*72%=&=0/*17*1.* &C#1;)524*1./*#0%7&7)0.)*/&C0.7&".*"5*D")(*&.)0%.1)&".14*1./*4";14*;"CC2.&)&07A*N(&7*#0%7&7)0.;0*"5*%04&'&".*&.*)(0*#2D4&;*

%04&'&"27*5%00/"CA** 604&'&"27* 5%00/"C* (17* '1%.0%0/* 1.* &./&7#0.71D40* #41;0* &.* /&7;"2%70*".* 4&D0%14&7C9* /0C";%1;$9* 5"%0&'.* 1551&%7* 1./* (2C1.* %&'()7A* NG"* &CC0/&1)0*0I1C#407*&.*;2%%0.)*1551&%7*&.*)(0*-.&)0/*8)1)07*40./*)(0C704=07*)"*)(&7*#%"#"714A*T.*(&7*51C"27*!1&%"*7#00;(*&.*>??i9*-A8A*H%07&/0.)*E1%1;L*ZD1C1*7)%0770/*)(0*;%2;&14*&C#"%)1.;0*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*&.*D")(*&.)0%.1)&".14*1551&%7*1./*(&7*"G.*1/C&.&7)%1)&".*17*)(0*G"%4/*D0;"C07*&.;%017&.'4$*&.)0%;"..0;)0/*]ZD1C1*>??iÂ*T.*32.0*"5*>?@@9*)(0*82D;"CC&))00*".*J5%&;19*<4"D14*R014)(*1./*R2C1.*6&'()7*&.*)(0*-A8A*R"270*"5*60#%070.)1)&=07*(04/*1*(01%&.'*#%&"%&)&M&.'*&.)0%.1)&".144$*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*17*1.*&.)0'%14*;"C#".0.)*"5*-A8A*5"%0&'.*#"4&;$*]8C&)(*>?@@Â*J7*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*)1L07*;0.)%0*7)1'0*&.*D")(*)(0"%0)&;14*1./*#"4&)&;14*/&7;"2%7079*&)*&7*0770.)&14*)"*)1L0*1*7)0#*D1;L*1./*0I#4"%0*G(1)*)(0*;".;0#)*"5*)(0*5%00/"C*"5*%04&'&".*%014&7)&;144$*0.)1&47A* :2;(*&.L*(17*D00.*7#&440/*&.*1.*1))0C#)*)"*%01;(*1*)("%"2'(*1./*("4&7)&;*

%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*0.)1&47*D")(*1*5%00/"C*]5%"C*)(0*7)1)0^*>$0*%04&'&"27*&.7)&)2)&".79*1./* 147"* 1* 5%00/"C* ]5"%* &./&=&/2147^* >0$)* %04&'&"27* &.7)&)2)&".7* ]!%1.7)".* @gÂ**

604&'&"27*O%00/"C

43

:1.$* 5"2./1)&".14* %&'()7* /";2C0.)7* "5* 4&D0%14* 7)1)07* 0.7(%&.0* )(0* ;".;0#)* "5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*17*)(0*D17&;*&./&=&/214*(2C1.*%&'()*5%"C*G(&;(*144*")(0%7*7)0CA*N(0*:1'.1*!1%)1*1./*)(0*!".7)&)2)&".7*"5*)(0*-.&)0/*8)1)07*1./*!1.1/1*0I#4&;&)4$*0.72%0*)(0*5%00/"C*"5*)(0*;(2%;(*17*1.*&.7)&)2)&".*/&7)&.;)*5%"C*)(0*7)1)0a*1*C"=0*G(&;(*1%'21D4$*41$7*)(0*5"2./1)&".*"5*4&D0%14&7CA*N(&7*(&7)"%&;14*0.)%0.;(C0.)*"5*70;241%&7C*17*1*;144*5"%*4&D0%)$*&C#4&07*)(1)*)(0*%&'()*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*&.7)&447*1* 2.&K20* %07#0;)* 5"%* )(0* &./&=&/214*G(&;(* #%0/&;1)07* )(0* ;".;0#)* "5* 1* D"/$* "5*(2C1.*%&'()7*&/0144$*'21%1.)00/*)"*144*&./&=&/2147A*\0.&14*"5*)(&7*/&'.&)$*%0/2;07*)(0*;1#1;&)$*"5*)(0*&./&=&/214a*1./*)(27*%0F0;)7*4&D0%)$A* N(&7*#%"#"714*&7*0;("0/*&.*#%070.)*/1$*&.*)(0*G"%L*"5*:1%)(1*U277D12CA*T.*Q+:=0-.&$>&!$#%2+=#2=9*7(0*1770%)7*)(1)*%07#0;)*5"%*&./&=&/2147*)"*;(""70*)(0&%*%04&'&"27*D04&057* &7* 1)* )(0* ;"%0* "5* /0C";%1;$* ]U277D12C*bÂ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Â*J;;"%/&.'4$9*/&550%0.)*L&./7*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*C1$*D0*/&7;0%.0/A* T.* %041)&".* )"* )(0*15"%0C0.)&".0/* )(0"%0)&;14*/&40CC19*J%=&./*8(1%C1*#%070.)7*=1%&"27*;".;0#)214*;(1440.'07*177";&1)0/*G&)(*2./0%7)1./&.'7*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C* &.* (&7* D""L9* F0$:*=)"-+R+#/& (=*+/+$?%& N0==7$)A* 604&'&"27* 5%00/"C*;0%)1&.4$*0.)1&47*)(0*5%00/"C*)"*#%1;)&;0*1.$*%04&'&".A*T)*147"*&.;42/07*)(0*5%00/"C*#$-&)"*#%1;)&;0*1*%04&'&".*]8(1%C1*`gÂ*N(&7*5%00/"C*)"*;(""70*".0P7*D04&05*"%*41;L*)(0%0"5*0I)0./7*D0$"./*)(0*&./&=&/214A*N(0*!1.1/&1.*!(1%)0%*"5*R2C1.*6&'()7*1./* O%00/"C7* 1./* )(0* !1.1/&1.* !".7)&)2)&".14*J;)* "5* @fh`* /0C".7)%1)0* )(1)*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*;1.*&.;42/0*)(0*5%00/"C*"5*)(0*&./&=&/214*17*G044*17*)(0*5%00/"C*"5* )(0* %04&'&"27* &.7)&)2)&".A* T1&.*E0.7".* .")07* )(1)* )(070* )0I)7* W/"* .")* 7("G* 1*#%&"%&)$*"5*&./&=&/214*%&'()7*"=0%*'%"2#*%&'()7A*E")(*1%0*%0;"'.&M0/*17*&C#"%)1.)9*1./*;1707*72##"%)*)(&7X*]E0.7".*@>bÂ*J;;"%/&.'4$9*C1.$*/&550%0.)*1##%"1;(07*)"*)(0*#%")0;)&".*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*0I&7)9*1./*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*C27)*52.;)&".*17*

* 8(1%C1* 1//&)&".144$* .")07* /&550%0.)* ;".7)%1&.)7* ".* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C*)(1)* 1%0* 0=&/0.)* G&)(&.* )(0* ;".)0I)* "5* '4"D14&M1)&".* 1./* 4&D0%14&7CA* H"4&)&;149*/0."C&.1)&".149* 1./* 1)* )&C07* #1%0.)14* 12)("%&)$* 144* #41;0* ;".7)%1&.)7* ".* )(0*")(0%G&70*1D7"42)0*%&'()*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*]8(1%C1*`gÂ**T.*)(&7*G1$9*)(0*%&'()*

44

G(&;(*(1=0*12)("%&)$*"=0%*)(0*&./&=&/214A*O"%*0I1C#409*1*$"2.'*;(&4/P7*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*C1$*D0*4&C&)0/*D$*)(0*/0;&7&".*"5*)(0*#1%0.)7A*S&..&5%0/*8244&=1.*1770%)7*)(1)*)(0*40'14*4&C&)7*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*1%0*W"5)0.*0I#%0770/*D$*%(0)"%&;144$*70)*D"2./1%&07*)(1)*1%0*7)%1.'04$*2.(04#524*G(0.*&)*;"C07*)"*1;)2144$*;1707X*]8244&=1.*@__Â* R0* 0.=&7&".7* 4&C&)1)&".* "5* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C* 17* 1* 7#0;)%2C9* &.* G(&;(* 1*%04&'&"27*'%"2#*&7*D"2./*D$*4";14*1./*#%1;)&;14*#"4&;0*7150)$*%0'241)&".7*".*".0*

D0)G00.*)(070*0I)%0C079*)(0*#"G0%*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*G&)(&.*)(0*'%01)0%*;".)0I)*"5*7";&0)$*&7*"5)0.*2.;401%*1./*%0K2&%07*1*;170VD$V;170*1.14$7&7A*J7*)(0*0I#4"%1)&".*"5*)(0*;".;0#)*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*/00#0.79*&)*D0;"C07*&.;%017&.'4$*0=&/0.)*)(1)*%04&'&"27* 5%00/"C* &79* 17* /0;41%0/* D$* 31$*U0GC1.9* 1* W=1421D40* D2)* 1CD&'2"27*0I#%077&".X*]U0GC1.*@>Â

99L.;*8+-+1?#.I%**B1<(.!.'1,$*,$+1?#.+##?*

* J%)&;40* @f* "5* )(0* -.&=0%714* \0;41%1)&".* "5* R2C1.* 6&'()7* ]-\R6^*1770%)7*)(0*5%00/"C*"5*%04&'&".*17*1*5"2./1)&".14*(2C1.*%&'()A*T)*7)1)07,

B=0%$".0*(17*)(0*%&'()*)"*5%00/"C*"5*)("2'()9*;".7;&0.;0*1./*%04&'&".a* )(&7*%&'()* &.;42/07*5%00/"C*)"*;(1.'0*(&7*%04&'&".*"%*D04&059*1./*5%00/"C9*0&)(0%*14".0*"%*&.*;"CC2.&)$*G&)(*")(0%7*1./*&.*#2D4&;*1./*#%&=1)09*)"*C1.&507)*(&7*%04&'&".*&.*)01;(&.'9*#%1;)&;09*G"%7(&#*1./*"D70%=1.;0*]-\R6Â

T.)0./&.'* )"* 0.7(%&.0* )(0* %&'()* )"* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C* 17* 1* '4"D14* &/0149*J%)&;40*@f* 70%=07* 17* 1.* 1##%"#%&1)0* 7$CD"4* "5* )(0* '%01)0%* ;".)%"=0%7$* "=0%* %04&'&"27*5%00/"CA*J%=&./*8(1%C1*04"K20.)4$*0I#41&.7*)(1)*J%)&;40*@f*&7*W5244$*;"'.&M1.)*"5*c)(0*5%00/"C*)"*;(1.'0*5%"C*".0*%04&'&".*)"*1.")(0%d9*1./*0K2144$*"D4&=&"27*"5*c2.%07)%&;)0/*1;;077*)"*)(0*")(0%*%04&'&".7*G&)("2)*)(0*.00/*5"%*2./0%'"&.'*72;(*;(1.'0dX* ]8(1%C1* `hÂ*J7* 72;(9* &)* &7* "5)0.* 1%'20/* )(1)* )(0* ;2%%0.)* W2.&=0%714X*;".;0#)&".*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*;".)1&.7*1*D&17*&.*51="2%*"5*S07)0%.*C&77&".1%$*%04&'&".7*1./*1'1&.7)*J7&1.*.".VC&77&".1%$*%04&'&".7A** N"*042;&/1)0*)(&7*#"&.)9*1*D%&05*1./*'0.0%14*0I#4"%1)&".*"5*S07)0%.*=0%727*J7&1.*%04&'&"27*&/0147*&7*&.*.00/A*J*7#00;(*/04&=0%0/*D$*OA*:1I*:s440%*&.*@f`b*

:s440%*#41;0/*32/1&7C9*R&./2&7C*1./*p"%"17)%&1.&7C*G&)(&.*)(0*.".VC&77&".1%$*;1)0'"%$9*17*)(0$*/"*.")*1;)&=04$*700L*;".=0%)7A*!(%&7)&1.&)$9*E2//(&7C*1./*T741C*G0%0*;1)0'"%&M0/*17*C&77&".1%$*)%1/&)&".7*G(&;(*G04;"C0*;".=0%7&".9*1*#%1;)&;0*0=&/0.)* &.* )(0* )%1.741)&".* "5* 71;%0/* )0I)7* &.)"* ")(0%* 41.'21'079* 17* G044* 17* )(0*

45

17*01;(*"5*)(0*15"%0C0.)&".0/*W.".VC&77&".1%$X*%04&'&".7*."G*1;;0#)7*;".=0%)7A*

* N$#&;144$*S07)0%.*JD%1(1C&;* %04&'&"27* )%1/&)&".7* 72;(* 17*!(%&7)&1.&)$*1./* T741C* 1%0* /00C0/* D$* 8(1%C1* 17* WC&77&".1%$X* )%1/&)&".7* D0;1270* )(0$*1;)&=04$* 700L* ;".=0%)7A* O2%)(0%C"%09*S07)0%.* %04&'&"27* )%1/&)&".7* 1%0* #%&C1%&4$*;(1%1;)0%&M0/*D$* W0I;427&=0* %04&'&"27* &/0.)&)$9* 1./* %0#%070.)* )(0* #0%7#0;)&=0* "5*)(0*#%"704$)&M&.'*%04&'&".7X*]8(1%C1*>__Â*!".=0%704$9*)(0*7#&%&)214*0.=&%".C0.)*"5*J7&1*(17*5"7)0%0/*1*C0/&2C*G(&;(*"5)0.*/"07*.")*/0C1./*)(1)*)(0*&./&=&/214*

&./&'0."27*J7&1.*41.'21'07*G(&;(*;"%%07#"./7*)"*)(1)*"5*W%04&'&".X*&.*6"C1.;0*41.'21'07A*J7*72;(9*&)*&7*#"77&D40*)"*D04".'*)"*C24)&#40*%04&'&"27*)%1/&)&".7*&.*J7&1*7&C24)1.0"274$A*N(279*&.*;".)%17)*)"*S07)0%.*%04&'&"27*)%1/&)&".79*)(0*J7&1.*%04&'&"27*0.=&%".C0.)*&7*;(1%1;)0%&M0/*D$*)(0*W#"77&D&4&)$*"5*C24)&#40*%04&'&"27*&/0.)&)&079*1./* #%070.)7* )(0* #0%7#0;)&=0* "5* .".V#%"704$)&M&.'* %04&'&".7X* ]8(1%C1* >__Â* 604&'&"27*5%00/"C*;1..")*D0*/&70.)1.'40/*5%"C*%04&'&"27*&/0.)&)$*1./*)(0*5%00/"C*)"*;(""70*".0P7*%04&'&".]7Â*T5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*&7*)%24$*1*2.&=0%714*%&'()*17*;41&C0/*&.*)(0*-\R69*&)*5"44"G7*)(1)*C24)&#40*%04&'&"27*&/0.)&)$*17*0=&/0.)*&.*J7&1.*;"CC2.&)&07*7("24/*D0*#%070%=0/*&.*1//&)&".*)"*2.&)1%$*%04&'&"27*&/0.)&)$A*N(&7*&.50%7*)(1)*W)(0*;".=0%7&".*)"*1*%04&'&".*7("24/*.")*&.="4=0*)(0*1D1./".C0.)*"5*)(0*")(0%X*]8(1%C1*@?@Â*R"G0=0%9*)(0*%(0)"%&;*0C#4"$0/*&.*J%)&;40*@f*"5*)(0*-\R6*)(%"2'(*)(0*270*"5*)(0*#(%170*W5%00/"C*)"*;(1.'0*(&7*%04&'&".*"%*D04&05X*&./&;1)07*1*;"CC&)C0.)*)"*)(0*S07)0%.V;0.)%&;*&/014*"5*7&.'241%*%04&'&"27*&/0.)&)$*1./*0.;"2%1'07*#%"704$)&7CA*T.*)(&7*G1$9*&)*;1.*D0*1%'20/*)(1)*)(0*;2%%0.)*40'14*/&7;"2%70*".*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*51="2%7*)("70*G("*72D7;%&D0*)"*S07)0%.*%04&'&"27*)%1/&)&".7A*

'%01)0%*S07)0%.V;0.)%&;* (2C1.* %&'()7* /0D1)0A* !(1%407*N1$4"%* (17* 7#&440/*C2;(*&.L* 1))0C#)&.'* )"* &442C&.1)0* )(0* ".0V7&/0/* .1)2%0* "5* (2C1.* %&'()7* /&7;"2%70A*T.* j!"./&)&".7* "5* 1.* -.5"%;0/* !".70.727* ".* R2C1.* 6&'()79P* N1$4"%* &7"41)07*

)(0*S07)0%.*#(&4"7"#(&;14* 7)%01CX* ]N1$4"%* bb`Â*-7&.'* )0%C&."4"'$*G(&;(*(17*1* /&7)&.;)4$*S07)0%.* ;"..")1)&".* &.(&D&)7* )(0* #%";077* "5* ;%01)&.'* 1* #42%14&7)&;9*&.)0%.1)&".14*/&7;277&".*"5*(2C1.*%&'()7A*N(0*;2%%0.)*7)1)0*"5*'4"D14*%&'()7*)14L9*(0*1770%)79*&7*W7"C0)(&.'*)(1)*(17*%"")7*&.*S07)0%.*;24)2%0X*]N1$4"%*bb`Â*N"*07)1D4&7(*1*C"%0*#"4$=140.)@*1./* )%24$*'4"D14*1##%"1;(* )"*(2C1.*%&'()79*N1$4"%*72''07)7*

/&14"'20*&7*)(0.*D2&4)A*

1*N(0*)0%C*j#"4$=140.)P*G&44*(0%0&.*D0*270/*)"*/07;%&D0*)(0*#1%)&;241%*1##%"1;(*)"*(2C1.*%&'()7*#%"#"70/*D$*!(1%407*N1$4"%*&.*jJ.*-.5"%;0/*!".70.727*".*R2C1.*6&'()7Pa*".0*G(&;(*)1L07*&.)"*1;;"2.)*1*=1%&0)$*"5*#0%7#0;)&=07*1./*G"%4/=&0G7A

46

)"*40'&741)&".*1//%077&.'*2.&=0%714*%04&'&"27*5%00/"CA*E$*&/0.)&5$&.'*1*;"CC".*'%"2./* D0)G00.*S07)0%.* 1./*J7&1.* %04&'&"27* )%1/&)&".7* &.* )(0* 7(1%0/* /07&%0* )"*#%1;)&;0* %04&'&".* 5%004$9* 1*.0G*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C*;1.*D0*D2&4)*G(&;(*%0;"'.&M07*)("70*G("*1/(0%0*)"*7&.'241%*1./t"%*C24)&#40*%04&'&"27*&/0.)&)&07a*)("70*G("*700L*)"*;".=0%)*1./*)("70*G("*700L*)"*1="&/*5"%;0/*;".=0%7&".A*8(1%C1*72''07)7*1*;".70.727*"5*)(&7*.1)2%0*&.*;(1.'&.'*J%)&;40*@f*"5*)(0*-\R6*)"*%01/*17*5"44"G7,*WB=0%$".0*(17*)(0*%&'()*)"*5%00/"C*"5*)("2'()9*;".7;&0.;0*1./*%04&'&".A*N(&7*%&'()*&.;42/07*)(0*5%00/"C*)"*2,$$%=*c.")*;(1.'0d*(&7*%04&'&".*"%*D04&05AAAX*]8(1%C1*>@?Â*T.*)(&7*G1$9*1*#"4$=140.)*1##%"1;(*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*&7*)1L0.9*1./*1*2.&=0%714*;".70.727*".*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*;1.*D0*1;(&0=0/A

999L.;*8+-+1?#.I%**B1<.O&'P8&#/(.!.'&#*.#$?B3.1:.$/*.H).9,$*%,&$+1,&8.;*8+-+1?#.I%**B1<.!'$

* T)* &7* 0=&/0.)* 5%"C* 1* )(0"%0)&;14* 7)1./#"&.)* )(1)* 1* 7&.'241%* 1##%"1;(* )"*)(0*#%070%=1)&".*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*#%"=07*'4"D144$*&.0550;)&=0A*J*;170*7)2/$*"5*)(0*!(%&7)&1.V;0.)%&;*&C#40C0.)1)&".*"5*)(0*T.)0%.1)&".14*604&'&"27*O%00/"C*J;)*]T6OJ^*&.*)(0*-.&)0/*8)1)07*G&44*(04#*)"*0I#"2./*)(0*)%24$*&.0550;)&=0*.1)2%0*"5*1*#2%04$*S07)0%.V;0.)%&;*/&7;"2%70*".*)(0*%&'()*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"CA*N(0*D41)1.)4$*!(%&7)&1.* D&17* )1L0.* &.* )(0*-.&)0/*8)1)07*G&)(* %0'1%/* )"* &.)0%.1)&".14* %04&'&"27*5%00/"C* (17* ;1270/* D1;L417(* "=0%70179* #0%#0)21)&.'* G(1)* N1$4"%* /00C7* W)(0*&.1D&4&)$*"5* cAAAd*S07)0%.0%7* )"*700* )(0&%*;24)2%0*17*".0*"5*C1.$9X* ]@gb^*1./* )(0*#0%;0&=0/*&C#"77&D&4&)$*"5*1*)%24$*#"4$=140.)*(2C1.*%&'()7*/&7;"2%70*]@gbÂ*** N(0* T.)0%.1)&".14* 604&'&"27* O%00/"C*J;)* "5* @iif* ]T6OJ^* G17* D"%.*W&.* %07#".70* )"* )(0* '%"G&.'* #%0772%0* 5%"C* %04&'&"27* 1./* ;&=&4* 7";&0)$* '%"2#7*%0'1%/&.'*)(0*#0%70;2)&".*"5*!(%&7)&1.7*&.*70=0%14*12)("%&)1%&1.*7)1)07X*]\1.;(&.*bfÂ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

"5*T.)0%.1)&".14*604&'&"27*O%00/"C*1)*)(0*-8*\0#1%)C0.)*"5*8)1)09*G("*G&7(07*)"*%0C1&.*.1C040779*41C0.)7*)(0*2.51="2%1D40*&C#%077&".*"5*S07)0%.*#%"C")&".*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*1D%"1/A*T.*1*#0%7".14*;"CC0.)1%$*".*)(0*&C#40C0.)1)&".*"5*T6OJ*&.*812/&*J%1D&19*)(0*1/=&7"%*7(1%0/*)(1),

47

T.*C$*C00)&.'7*G&)(* 812/&79* T* "5)0.* '")* )(0* 70.70* )(1)* )(0%0*G17* c1.d* 2.0I#%0770/* 70.)&C0.)* )(1)* 70%=0/* 17* )(0* D17&7* 5"%*)(0&%*;"C#41&.)7*1D"2)*"2%*G"%LA*S(1)*)(0$*G"24/*1;)2144$*71$9*

8)1)07* )"* )%$* )"* 5"%;0*JC0%&;1.*=14207*".* )(0CA* *N(0$* 5"2./*)(0* G("40* .")&".* "5* (1=&.'* )"* D0* 0=1421)0/* 1..2144$* D$* )(0*

)(0&%*;&)&M0.%$*)"*D0*/00#4$*"550.7&=09*1./*144*)(0*C"%0*7"*G(0.*)(0* 7)1./1%/* 1'1&.7)* G(&;(* )(0$* 1%0* D0&.'* C0172%0/* &7* ".0*;".;";)0/*D$*1.*&C#0%&14&7)*S07)0%.*;"2.)%$*)(1)*&7*%0144$*"2)*)"*2./0%C&.0*)(0&%*%04&'&".*1./*G1$*"5*4&50*]H0%7".14*T.)0%=&0G*>?@@Â

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

%04&'&"27*5%00/"CX*]8(1%C1*>>>Â*8(1%C1P7*;41&C*&7*72##"%)0/*D$*)(0*2))0%*41;L*"5*/&=0%7&)$*&.*)(0*D"/$*"5*;"CC&77&".0%7*;%01)0/*D$*T6OJ*)"*C".&)"%*%04&'&"27*5%00/"CA*N(0*D"/$*"5*-8!T6O*;"CC&77&".0%7*(17*D00.*;"C#"70/*14C"7)*0.)&%04$*"5*!(%&7)&1.79*G&)(*".4$*".0*R&./29*".0*:274&C9*1./*".0*30G&7(*;"CC&77&".0%*)"*/1)0*]8(2L1*@Â*82(1'*8(2L1*"5*)(0*R&./2*JC0%&;1.*O"2./1)&".*(17*&442C&.1)0/*-8!T6OP7*D41)1.)*/&7%0'1%/*5"%*)(0*%04&'&"27*#0%70;2)&".*"5*R&./27*&.*E1.'41/07(9*E(2)1.* 1./* :141$7&19* /07#&)0* &)7* )("%"2'(* %0#"%)&.'* ".* )(0* C&7)%01)C0.)* "5*!(%&7)&1.7*1%"2./*)(0*G"%4/*]8(2L1*@Â*J*#4127&D40*1%'2C0.)*;1.*)(27*D0*C1/0*5"%*)(0*51="2%&)&7C*"5*!(%&7)&1.7*&.*-.&)0/*8)1)07P*K207)*)"*#%070%=0*&.)0%.1)&".14*%04&'&"27*5%00/"CA*

604&'&"27*O%00/"C*J;)*(17*D0;"C0*&.;%017&.'4$*;"CC".#41;0*17*!1.1/1*/0D1)07*

#"4$=140.)*1##%"1;(*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C9*!1.1/1*(17*)(0*#")0.)&14*)"*0.;"2%1'0*1*.0G*0%1*&.*(2C1.*%&'()7*/&7;"2%709*G(&;(*0.;"2%1'07*#42%14&)$*1./*/&=0%7&)$A

O%00/"C*17*1*#1%)*"5*O"%0&'.*J551&%7*1./*T.)0%.1)&".14*N%1/0*!1.1/1A*8#01%(01/&.'*

48

80#)0CD0%*1//%077*)"*)(0*-.&)0/*U1)&".7*<0.0%14*J770CD4$9*E1&%/*#40/'0/,

"5*%04&'&".*1./*D04&059*;".7&7)0.)*G&)(*;"%0*!1.1/&1.*=14207*72;(*17*5%00/"C9*/0C";%1;$9*(2C1.*%&'()7*1./*)(0*%240*"5*41GA*:"7)*&C#"%)1.)4$9*&)*G&44*/0C".7)%1)0*)(1)*!1.1/1*)%24$*&7*1*5%00*7";&0)$*]E1&%/*>?@@^A

T.* "%/0%* )"* %0C1&.* ;".7&7)0.)* G&)(* !1.1/1P7* #%"50770/* ;"%0* =14207* "5*

#42%14&7C*D$*;24)&=1)&.'*1*.0G*S07)0%.*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*)(1)*/"07*.")*51="2%*!(%&7)&1.&)$9*D2)*%1)(0%9*1;)&=04$*#%")0;)7*)("70*G("*#%1;)&;0*1.$9*

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

%0#"%)*".*)(0*7)1)0*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*5%"C*1.*2.D&170/9*#"4$=140.)*1##%"1;(9*

604&'&"27*O%00/"C*G&44*)("%"2'(4$*1./*0550;)&=04$*2#("4/*&)7*=1420*"5*#42%14&7C*1./*72;;00/*&.*&)7*C&77&".*)"*#%")0;)*52./1C0.)14*(2C1.*%&'()7A* T.*1;;"%/1.;0*G&)(*)(0*&C#40C0.)1)&".*"5*1*#42%14&7)&;*%0#"%)9*!1.1/1P7*

C".&)"%*)(0*7)1)0*"5*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*1%"2./*)(0*G"%4/A*N(0*D"/$*"5*;"CC&77&".0%7*

"5*%04&'&"27*)%1/&)&".79*17*G044*17*.".VD04&0=0%79*C27)*D0*%0#%070.)0/*&.*"%/0%*)"*1;(&0=0* 1* .02)%14* #0%7#0;)&=0A*J7*8(1%C1* 0I#41&.79* )(&7*C01.7*C&77&".1%$* 1./*.".VC&77&".1%$* %04&'&".7* C27)* D0* %0#%070.)0/* )"* 1="&/* 1* #")0.)&14* 1%0.1* 5"%*)(0* 0.;"2%1'0C0.)* "5* #%"704$)&7C* 1./* )(0* 7#%01/* "5*S07)0%.* %04&'&"27* =14207A

5"%* 604&'&"27* O%00/"C* &.* !1.1/1* G&44* &./2;0* 1* #1%1/&'C* 7(&5)* &.* )(0* '%01)0%*(2C1.*%&'()7*/&7;"2%70*1G1$*5%"C*S07)0%.V;0.)%&;*=142079*1./*)"G1%/7*1*C"%0*#"4$=140.)*1##%"1;(*)"*%04&'&"27*5%00/"C*1./*(2C1.*/&'.&)$A*

49

E1,'8?#+1,

* N(&7* #1#0%* (17* 1))0C#)0/* )"* 042;&/1)0* )(0* 72#%0C0* &C#"%)1.;0* "5*%04&'&"27* 5%00/"C* 5%"C* 1* )(0"%0)&;14* 1./* )(0.* 1*C"%0* #%1;)&;14* 7)1./#"&.)A*J7*)(0* G"%4/* D0;"C07* &.;%017&.'4$* &.)0%;"..0;)0/* &.* 1* #%";077* "5* '4"D14&M1)&".9*)(0* #%")0;)&".* "5* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C* &7* #1%1C"2.)A* J4)("2'(* 1.* 1CD&'2"27*)0%C9* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C*(17*;0%)1&.4$*'1%.0%0/*1*.0'1)&=0* %0#2)1)&".* &.* %0'1%/7*)"* )(0*0.;"2%1'0C0.)*"5*S07)0%.*=14207*1D%"1/A*J*;170*7)2/$*"5* )(0*#0%;0&=0/*

T.* "%/0%* )"* )%24$* #%")0;)* )(0* %&'()* )"* %04&'&"27* 5%00/"C9* 1* 7(&5)* &.* /&7;"2%70* &7*.0;0771%$*)"*;%01)0*1*.02)%14*0.=&%".C0.)*5"%*"***D04&0=0%7A*N(0*;%01)&".*"5*1*.0G*

"##"%)2.&)$*)"*&./2;0*)(&7*7(&5)*1./*0CD"/$*1*.0G*/&7;"2%70*".*%04&'&"27*5%00/"Ca*#41.)&.'*)(0*700/7*"5*1*)%24$*#"4$=140.)*1##%"1;(*)"*(2C1.*%&'()7A

S"%L7*!&)0/

E1&%/9*3"(.A*-.&)0/*U1)&".7*<0.0%14*J770CD4$A*N$0=+/#&G>>"+0%A*W!1.1/1P7*U0G*

* 5%00/"CuA

E0.7".9*T1&.A*WO%00/"C*"5*!".7;&0.;0*1./*604&'&".*&.*!1.1/1,*!(1440.'07*1./*** Z##"%)2.&)&07AX*S)$0.&H#-=0#"-+$#"*&Q"6&(=A+=6&>@*]>??`^,*@@@A*H%&.)A

!%1.7)".9*:12%&;0A* A*>7)*0/A*Q"./".,*Q".'C1.7** <%00.9*@i_gA*H%&.)A

\1.;(&.9*H0)0%A*W-A8A*-.&41)0%14&7C*1./*)(0*T.)0%.1)&".14*H%")0;)&".*"5** 604&'&"27*O%00/"C,*N(0*:24)&41)0%14*J4)0%.1)&=0PW*!$*?):+"&M$?0#"*&& $>&<0"#%#"-+$#"*&Q"6*g@*]>??>Vb^A*S0DA*v())#,tt#1#0%7A77%.A;"Ct7"4bt* #1#0%7A;5Ck1D7)%1;)w&/x@?hbig@uA*

U277D12C9*:1%)(1A*Q+:=0-.&$>&!$#%2+=#2=E&+#&J=>=#%=&$>&G)=0+2"8%&<0"7+-+$#&$>&&& (=*+/+$?%&SO?"*+-.P*H(&41/04#(&1,*H0%7027*E""L7*<%"2#9*>??fA*H%&.)A

U0GC1.9*31$A* *Z))1G1,*-.&=0%7&)$*"5*Z))1G1*H%0779*@ii`A** H%&.)A*

:s440%9*OA*:1IA*!,+D%&>0$)&"&5=0)"#&3$0;%,$DA*Q"./".,*Q".'C1.79*<%00.** 1./*!"9*@f`_A*H%&.)A

50

ZD1C19*E1%1;LA*WN(0*H%07&/0.)P7*8#00;(*&.*!1&%",*U0G*E0'&..&.'7AX*N(0*S(&)0** R"270A*>??iA*S0DA*v())#,ttGGGAG(&)0("270A'"=tD4"'tU0GE0'&..&.'uA

H0%7".14*T.)0%=&0GA*>i*U"=A*>?@@A

8(1%C19*J%=&./P&F0$:*=)"-+R+#/&(=*+/+$?%&N0==7$)A*U0G*m"%L,*8#%&.'0%9*>?@@A** H%&.)A

8(2L419*82(1'A*WO&I*)(0*-A8A*T.)0%.1)&".14*604&'&"27*O%00/"C*!"CC&77&".** "%*O2''0/1D"2)&)PX* *?g*Z;)A*>?@@A*S0DA**

* 52''0/1DwDwifbgi_A()C4^uA

8C&)(9*!(%&7)"#(0%A*XR01%&.'*".*)(0*>?@@*T.)0%.1)&".14*604&'&"27*O%00/"C** 60#"%)AX*82D;"C&))00*".*J5%&;19*<4"D14*R014)(*1./*R2C1.*6&'()7A** S0DA*v())#,tt;(%&77C&)(A("270A'"=t-#4"1/0/O&407t>?@@V@@V@`w* 604&'&"27wO%00/"Cw>?@@w60#"%)A#/5uA

8C&)(9*8)0=0.A*N$0=$07"+#=7&N"+*?0=E&-,=&Y?=%-&>$0&"&!$#%-+-?-+$#"*&F0+#2+D*=&& $>&(=*+/+$?%&N0==7$)P*U0G*m"%L,*ZI5"%/*-.&=0%7&)$*H%0779*@ii_A*H%&.)A

8244&=1.9*S&..&5%0/*O1440%7A*<,=&H)D$%%+:+*+-.&$>&(=*+/+$?%&N0==7$)A*U0G** 30%70$,*H%&.;0)".*-.&=0%7&)$*H%0779*>??_A*H%&.)A

N1$4"%9*!(1%407A*W!"./&)&".7*"5*1.*-.5"%;0/*!".70.727*".*R2C1.*6&'()7AX*N(0** H"4&)&;7**"5*R2C1.*6&'()7A*U0G*m"%L,*l0%7"9*@iiiA*H%&.)A

WJ%)&;40*@fAX*-.&=0%714*\0;41%1)&".*"5*R2C1.*6&'()7A*UA#A9*.A/A*S0DA*v())#,tt* GGGA2.A"%'t0.t/";2C0.)7t2/(%t&./0IA7()C4uA

51

!"#$"%&"''()*+,#-./012345(64(+75182(39(:;<369(7=(#72>3?1

!"#$"%&'()*'(

52

!"#$%&'$(*N(&7*#1#0%*0I#4"%07*)(0*&C1'0*"5*!(%&7)*17*C")(0%*&.*324&1.*"5*U"%G&;(P7*(=A=*"-+$#%&$>&J+A+#=&Q$A='* 1./* &)7* &C#4&;1)&".7* 5"%* (0%* )(0"4"'$*"5* 714=1)&".A*O2%)(0%C"%09*)(&7*#1#0%*G&44*041D"%1)0*".*1*;".;0#)&".*"5*<"/9*G(&;(*52707*1./*)%1.7;0./7*'0./0%*;1)0'"%&07A

* S07)0%.*!(%&7)&1.&)$*(&.'07*".*)(0*0770.)&14*;".;0#)*"5*30727*!(%&7)*17*7&C24)1.0"274$*(2C1.*1./*/&=&.0A*J5)0%*)(0*;"2.;&47*"5*B#(0727*1./*!(14;0/".9*"%)("/"I* /";)%&.0* 1770%)0/* )(1)* !(%&7)* G17* W)%24$* <"/* 1./* )%24$* C1.e*;".72D7)1.)&14*G&)(*)(0*O1)(0%*1;;"%/&.'*)"*)(0*<"/(01/9*1./*;".72D7)1.)&14*G&)(*27*1;;"%/&.'*)"*)(0*:1.(""/X*]W!%00/*"5*!(14;0/".X^A*!(%&7)P7*(2C1.&)$*G17o1./*;".)&.207*)"*D0o1)*4017)*17*&C#"%)1.)*)"*!(%&7)&1.*51&)(*17*(&7*/&=&.&)$a*$0)*)(0%0*&7*1*)0.7&".*D0)G00.*)(0*)G"9*)(0*;4177&;*#(&4"7"#(&;14*)0.7&".*D0)G00.*)(0*D"/$*1./*7"24a*)(0*.00/*)"*%0;".;&40*#($7&;14*%0K2&%0C0.)7*G&)(*7#&%&)214*7)%&=&.'A*N(&7*)0.7&".*D0;"C07*07#0;&144$*&C#"%)1.)*5"%*C$7)&;*G%&)0%79*G("*0./01="2%*)"*040=1)0*)(0*7#&%&)*G(&40*0.;4"70/*G&)(&.*)(0*D"/$A*N(&7*055"%)*;"24/*401/*)"*%1/&;14*

#27* "5* 40#0%79* 1./* W("4$* 1."%0I&1X* ;1.* 1))07)o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bbV@@?i^9* S&44&1C* "5* 8)A* N(&0%%$* ];A@?`_V@@gf^9* 1./* 8)A* E0%.1%/* "5* !41&%=12I*]@?i?V@@_b^*270/*C1)0%.14*&C1'0%$*)"*7#01L*"5*)(0*.2%)2%&.'*K214&)&07*"5*!(%&7)9*07#0;&144$* &.* ;"..0;)&".* )"* D%017)7A*E0%.1%/P7* 51C"27* 70%C".7* ".* )(0*8".'*"5*8".'7*)%01)*)(0*=0%70*WO"%*$"2%*D%017)7*1%0*D0))0%*)(1.*G&.09*7C044&.'*7G00)*"5*)(0*

<0./0%4077*R2C1.&)$,*!(%&7)*17*:")(0%*&.*324&1.*"5*U"%G&;(

53

D07)*"&.)C0.)7X*]8".'*@,@V>^*17*1.*&C1'0*"5*7#&%&)214*72;L4&.',*

S(0.*7(0*c)(0*E%&/0d*71&/9*)(0.9*jm"2%*D%017)7*1%0*D0))0%*)(1.*

$"2%*D%017)7*;".)%&D2)07*51%*C"%0*)"*C$*7#&%&)214*#%"'%077*)(1.*)(0*D&)&.'*%0#%&C1./7*"5*C$*72#0%&"%7P* ]E0%.1%/*"5*!41&%=12I*K)/A*&.*E$.2C*@>fÂ

N(0*&/017*"5*'0.)40.077*1./*50C&.&.&)$*1##4&0/* )"*!(%&7)*'0.0%144$*7)"#*(0%0* &.*)0%C7*"5*!&7)0%;&1.* )(0"4"'$9*D2)*'"*".* )"*#41$*1.*1;)&=0*%"40* &.* )(0* 4&50*"5* )(0*!&7)0%;&1.*;"CC2.&)$A* T.)0%07)&.'4$9*C".L7o&.;42/&.'*E0%.1%/*(&C7045o%050%*)"*)(0C704=07*17*G"C0.*1./*G&=07*&.*"%/0%*)"*0I#%077*)(0&%*)")14*/0#0./0.;0*".*<"/9*1./*1DD")7*7#01L*"5*)(0C704=07*17*C")(0%7*&.*"%/0%*)"*4&.0*)(0*(1%7(.077*"5*C".17)0%$*/&7;&#4&.0*1./*WD&)&.'*%0#%&C1./7X*G&)(*)(0*'0.)40%* &/01*"5*C1)0%.14*4"=0*]E$.2C*@hhÂ* 324&1.* 0I)0./7* )(0* &/01* "5* 1* C")(0%P7* 2.;"./&)&".14* 4"=0* D0$"./* )(0*%041)&".7(&#* "5* 1DD")* )"*C".L9* 17;%&D&.'* &)* &.7)01/* )"* )(0* %041)&".7(&#* D0)G00.*<"/*1./*)(0*G"%4/A*8(0*7007*)(0*G"%4/*17*W1*4&))40*)(&.'9*)(0*7&M0*"5*1*(1M04.2)e*cG(&;(d* 417)7* 1./*G&44* 417)* 5"%0=0%* D0;1270*<"/* 4"=07* &)a* 1./* &.* )(0* 71C0*G1$*0=0%$)(&.'* 0I&7)7* )(%"2'(* )(0* 4"=0* "5* <"/X* ]324&1.* @ìÂ* 8&.;0* 0=0%$)(&.'* &7*/0#0./0.)*".*<"/P7*4"=09*&)*5"44"G7*)(1)*)(&7*4"=0*C27)*D0*0)0%.149*2.;"./&)&".149*144V0.;"C#177&.'o1./* 5"%* 324&1.9* &)* &7A* <"/P7* 4"=0* &7* )(0* =0%$* ;"%.0%7)".0* "5*(0%*)(0"4"'$9*1./*7(0*;"2;(07*&)*&.*C1)0%.14*41.'21'0,*WG0*1%0*%0/00C0/*D$*)(0*C")(0%(""/*"5*C0%;$*1./*'%1;0*1./*D%"2'()*D1;L*&.)"*"2%*.1)2%14*/G044&.'*G(0%0*G0*G0%0*C1/0*D$*.1)2%14*4"=0a*1*.1)2%14*4"=0*G(&;(*.0=0%*401=07*27X*]324&1.*>?@Â*N(0*".0*G("*C1L07*)(&7*4"=0*)1.'&D40*&7*307279*)"*G("C*7(0*17;%&D07,

cNd(&7*51&%9*4"=04$*G"%/*jC")(0%9P*7"*7G00)*1./*7"*)0./0%*&.*&)7045*)(1)*&)*;1..")*)%24$*D0*71&/*"5*1.$*D2)*"5*(&Ce*)"*)(0*.1)2%0*"5*C")(0%(""/*D04".'*)0./0%*4"=09*G&7/"C9*1./*L."G40/'09*1./*&)*&7*'""/9*5"%*14)("2'(*)(0*D&%)(*"5*"2%*D"/$*&7*".4$*4"G9*(2CD409*1./*C"/07)*;"C#1%0/*G&)(*)(0*D&%)(*"5*"2%*7"249*$0)*&)*&7*(0*G("*/"07*&)*&.*)(0*D0&.'7*D$*G("C*&)*&7*/".0*]324&1.*>?bÂ*

324&1.*'"07*G044*D0$"./*)(0*!&7)0%;&1.*;".;0#)*"5*!(%&7)P7*C")(0%(""/o%1)(0%*)(1.*7&C#4$*D%017)500/&.'9*!(%&7)*W;1.*51C&4&1%4$*401/*27*+#-$*(&7*D40770/*D%017)*)(%"2'(* (&7* 7G00)* "#0.* 7&/0X* ]324&1.* >?>Â* 8(0* %05%1C07* )(0* H177&".* &.* )0%C7*"5*;(&4/D&%)(9*#"%)%1$&.'*!(%&7)*W&.*41D"2%*5"%*)(0*5244*)&C0*2.)&4*(0*72550%0/*)(0*

(0* (1/* D"%.* 27* &.)"* D4&77X* ]324&1.* >?>Â*N(0* =&=&/* #($7&;14&)$* "5* )(070* &C1'07*7#01L7*)"*)(0*&C#"%)1.;0*"5*!(%&7)P7*(2C1.&)$a*$0)*!(%&7)P7*C")(0%(""/*&7*1D"=0*144* 7#&%&)214A* T.*"2%* 7#&%&)214*D&%)(9*!(%&7)* W'&=07*27* 7"C0*/0'%00*"5*L."G40/'0*

54

1./*4"=0*"5*(&7*D40770/*<"/(01/9*G&)(*1G1%0.077*)(%"2'(*'%1;0*"5*(&7*#%0;&"27*:1.(""/*1./*(&7*D40770/*H177&".9*1./*G&)(*;"2%)0"27*G"./0%*1)*(&7*'%01)*1./*72%#177&.'*'""/.077X*]324&1.*>?bÂ

N(&7*'""/.0779*1./* )(0*#"G0%524*;".;0#)*"5*<"/P7*2.;"./&)&".14* 4"=0*5"%*144*;%01)&".9*144"G7*324&1.*)"*7"C0G(1)*72D=0%7&=04$*7"4=0*;0%)1&.*)(0"4"'&;14*#%"D40C79*07#0;&144$*)(1)*"5*714=1)&".A*324&1.*(17*)%"2D40*G&)(*)(0*)0.7&".*D0)G00.*

)(0*!(2%;(P7*)01;(&.'7*)(1)*/0=&479*(01)(0.79*1./*(0%0)&;7*1%0*;"./0C.0/*)"*)(0*

)"*$"2*&7*.")*&C#"77&D40*)"*C0A*T*7(144*L00#*C$*G"%/*&.*144*)(&.'7*1./*144*)(&.'7*G&44*D0*G044X*]324&1.*@i?Â*VV*324&1.9*1*;".72CC1)0*)(0"4"'&1.9*;1..")*7)"#*(0%7045*5%"C*G"%L&.'*"2)*)(0*#%"D40C*"5*7&.*1./*714=1)&".9*1./*7(0*/"07*7"*&.*)0%C7*"5*1*C")(0%P7*4"=0A*<"/*144"G7*(2C1.L&./*)"*7&.*17*1*C")(0%*144"G7*(0%*;(&4/*W)"*D0*D01)0.* )"*D%01L*/"G.*=&;07*7"* )(1)* )(0*;(&4/*C1$*'1&.* &.*=&%)20*1./*'%1;0X*

%0#01)7*)(0*;"C5"%)&.'*C1.)%1*"5*W144*7(144*D0*G0449*1./*144*7(144*D0*G0449*1./*144*C1..0%*"5*)(&.'7*7(144*D0*G044X*]324&1.*@fhV`Â*N(&7*%01772%1.;09*72##"%)&.'*(0%*;".=&;)&".* &.* )(0* 2.;"./&)&".149* 0./40779*C")(0%4$* .1)2%0* "5*<"/P7* 4"=09* 401/7*324&1.*)"*;1%05244$*0./"%70*)(0*.")&".*"5*2.&=0%714*714=1)&".A*S(&40*7(0*/"07*.")*%0F0;)*!(2%;(*)01;(&.'79*7(09*)(%"2'(*/&%0;)*;"CC2.&;1)&".*G&)(*<"/9*41$7*;41&C*)"*1*C$7)&;*5%00/"C9*G(&;(*144"G7*(0%*)"*D$#177*)(0C*]E$.2C*>h_Â

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Â*E$*#"%)%1$&.'*!(%&7)*17*1*C")(0%*)(1)*&7*D")(*#($7&;14*1./*7#&%&)2149*17*G044*17*<"/P7*4"=0*5"%*)(0*G"%4/*17*C1)0%.149*324&1.*&C#4&;&)4$*%0=14207*)(0*C")(0%&.'*%"40*&.*!(%&7)&1.&)$*D0$"./*)(1)*"5*)(0*l&%'&.*:1%$A*J4)("2'(*)(0*;24)*"5*)(0*l&%'&.*:1%$*G17*&CC0.704$*#"#241%*&.*)(0*:&//40*J'079*)(&7*)%0./*/"07*.")*.0;0771%&4$*)%1.741)0*&.)"*1*7G044*"5*50C140*7#&%&)214&)$A*N(0*;24)*"5*:1%$9*4&L0*)(0*!&7)0%;&1.*#"%)%1$147*"5*!(%&7)*17*C")(0%9*7#"L0*41%'04$*)"*C0.*"5*1*50C&.&.0*&/0149*G(&;(*G17*.")*.0;0771%&4$* 4&.L0/* )"*"%*D170/*".*1;)214*G"C0.* ]E$.2C*h`Â*U"%*/&/*G"C0.*C$7)&;7*.0;0771%&4$*(1=0*1*7#0;&14*;"..0;)&".*)"*)(0*l&%'&.*:1%$*"%*700*)(0C704=07*17*0C241)&.'*(0%a*&)*&7*)044&.'*)(1)9*G(&40*(0%*D&"'%1#(0%7*7$7)0C1)&;144$*;"C#1%0*!41%0*"5*J77&7&*)"*)(0*l&%'&.*:1%$9*&.*!41%0P7*"G.*G%&)&.'7*7(0*;"C#1%07*(0%7045* )"* !(%&7)* ]E$.2C* @_bÂ* T.* (0%* )%01)C0.)* "5* !(%&7)* 17* C")(0%9* 324&1.*;"..0;)7*)(0*50C&.&.0*&/014*)"*G"C0.*)(0C704=079*WD$*&.7&7)&.'*".*)(0*%040=1.;0*

55

"5*(2C1.*C")(0%(""/*)"* )(0*7#&%&)214*C")(0%(""/*"5*!(%&7)9*1./*D$*0I#1./&.'*C")(0%(""/*)"*&.;42/0*0C")&".14*17*G044*17*#($7&;14*0I#0%&0.;07X*]S&44&1C7*@>hÂ

N(0%0* &7* 14G1$7* 1* /1.'0%* )(1)* 7"C0* &.)0%#%0)1)&".7* C1$* "=0%7)%077*WG"C1.*;".7;&"27.077X*1./*W'$.";0.)%&;*&C1'0%$X*)"*)(0*#"&.)*"5*1.1;(%".&7C9*".0* 72;(* &.7)1.;0* D0&.'* )(0* 14C"7)* L.00VF0%L* %01;)&".* "5* 0K21)&.'* )(0* D4""/*

@fiÂ*J4)("2'(*(0%*G%&)&.'7*;1.*D0*700.*&.*C1.$*G1$7*)"*#%"=&/0*1*G1$*)"*!(%&7)*)(%"2'(*50C140*0I#0%&0.;09*)(0*&C#4&;1)&".7*5"%*1.$*7"%)*"5*50C140*7#&%&)214&)$*1%0*41%'04$*&.;&/0.)14A*324&1.9*17*1*C$7)&;9*G17*.")*#%&C1%&4$*;".;0%.0/*G&)(*;%01)&.'*1*#1%)&;241%4$*50C140*%04&'&"27*#1)(9*D2)*G&)(*0C241)&.'*!(%&7)9*1*'"14*/0="&/*"5*'0./0%*/&7)&.;)&".*]E$.2C*@__Â

Z.*)(0*")(0%*(1./9*&)*G"24/*D0*0K2144$*G%".'*)"*&'."%0*144*50C&.&.&)$9*1./*&)7*1550;)&=09*#($7&;14*177";&1)&".79*1./*)"*"=0%0C#(17&M0*)(0*&.)0440;)2149*1D7)%1;)9*C17;24&.0*.1)2%0*"5*324&1.P7*)("2'()A*N"*.")&;0*)(1)*)(0*#($7&;14&)$*"5*)(0*D400/&.'*

1*G("44$*0C")&".149*j50C&.&.0P*%07#".709*&7*".0*)(&.'9*D2)*)"*;".;42/0*5%"C*)(&7*"D70%=1)&".*]J0%7*1./*8)140$*fi^*&7*K2&)0*1.")(0%A*O2%)(0%C"%09*)"*/00C*(0%*G%&)&.'7*0770.)&144$*C17;24&.0*D0;1270*"5*)(&7* )0./0.;$*)"G1%/7*1D7)%1;)&".9*1))0C#)&.'*)"*#42'*(0%*

1./*8)140$*i`^*&7*)"*.0'40;)*)(0*&.;427&=09*2.&=0%714*.1)2%0*"5*(0%*)("2'()A*N(0%0*&7*."*%017".*)"*D04&0=0*)(1)*324&1.*;".7&/0%0/*)(0*/&7)&.;)&".*D0)G00.*0C")&".14*1./*&.)0440;)2149*#($7&;14*1./*7#&%&)2149*]"%*5"%*)(1)*C1))0%9*C140*1./*50C140^*)"*D0*70)*

24)&C1)04$*"5*C1.L&./,

T* 72//0.4$* 71G* )(0* %0/* D4""/* )%&;L4&.'* /"G.* 5%"C*2./0%* )(0*;%"G.*"5*)("%.79*144*(")9*5%07(4$9*#40.)&5244$9*1./*=&=&/4$9*F27)*17*T*&C1'&.0/*&)*G17*1)*)(0*C"C0.)*G(0.*)(0*;%"G.*"5*)("%.7*G17*)(%27)*".)"*(&7*D40770/*(01/o(0*G("*G17*D")(*<"/*1./*C1.9*)(0*71C0*G("*72550%0/*5"%*C0e*G&)(*)(&7*7&'()*"5*)(0*D40770/*H177&".9*14".'*G&)(*)(0*<"/(01/*)(1)*T*71G*&.*C$*C&./9*T*71G*)(1)*T9*$079*1./*0=0%$*;%01)2%0*4&=&.'*)(1)*G"24/*D0*71=0/9*;"24/*

0.0C&07*]324&1.*@`fÂ

N(0*W7&'()*"5*)(0*D40770/*H177&".X*1./*)(0*/&=&.&)$*"5*)(0*<"/(01/*1%0*.")*/&7)&.;)*&.*324&1.P7*)(0"4"'$a*)(1)*)(0*1550;)&=0*1./*&.)0440;)214*0I#0%&0.;07*"5*<"/*'"*(1./*&.*(1./*&7*#0%50;)4$*.1)2%14A** N(0*7$.)(07&7*"5*C140*1./*50C140*&.*)(0*&C1'0*"5*!(%&7)*17*C")(0%*5"44"G7*

56

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Â* R"G0=0%9*

&.*!(%&7)a*(0.;0*)(0*1%'2C0.)7*1./*7;(&7C*"=0%*(&7*/&=&.&)$*=0%727*(&7*(2C1.&)$*&.*)(0*#1)%&7)&;*#0%&"/9*1./*)(0*0170*G&)(*G(&;(*324&1.*52707*C140*1./*50C140*&.*!(%&7)A*N(&7*527&".*&7*1##1%0.)*&.*)(0*G1$*7(0*/07;%&D07*!(%&7)*#1%0.)&.'*)(0*7"24,*

"2%*7"249X*]324&1.*>?b^*/0C".7)%1)&.'*1*C")(0%P7*'0.)40*;"C#177&".A*E0;1270*"5*

17*C")(0%*&7*.")*1*G("407140*50C&.&M1)&".9*D2)*1*D42%%&.'*"5*'0./0%*/&7)&.;)&".7A*E$*17;%&D&.'*C")(0%(""/*)"*!(%&7)9*324&1.*0I#1./7*)(0*C01.&.'*"5*(&7*(2C1.&)$9*

* !1%"4&.0* S14L0%* E$.2CP7* 7)2/$* "5* )(0* 270* "5* 50C140* &C1'0%$* &.*C0/&10=14* %04&'&"27* )0I)7* %0=0147* )(1)*WG"C0.* )0./0/* )"* 5270*C140*1./* 50C140*

G17*2.&C#"%)1.)*&.*G"C0.P7*G%&)&.'7*1./*=&7&".7X*]E$.2C*@hiÂ*S"C0.*C$7)&;7*/&/*.")*.0;0771%&4$*700*)(0C704=07*17*&.50%&"%*)"*)(0&%*C140*;"2.)0%#1%)79*#0%(1#7*D0;1270*)(0$*)("2'()*"5*)(0C704=07*#%&C1%&4$*17*(2C1.*D0&.'7*&.*%041)&".*)"*<"/A*N(&7*;1.*;0%)1&.4$*D0*71&/*"5*324&1.9*G("9*D$*27&.'*)(0*41.'21'0*"5*C")(0%(""/*)"*7#01L*"5*<"/P7*4"=0*5"%*;%01)&".9*1//%07707*144*(2C1.&)$*G&)(*)(0*G1%C*1770%)&".*)(1)* )(&7* 4"=0* &7*2.;"./&)&".14*1./*0)0%.149* )(1)*<"/*W&7*"2%*;4")(&.'9*G%1##&.'*1./*0.=04"#&.'*27*5"%*4"=09*0CD%1;&.'*27*1./*'2&/&.'*27X*]324&1.*@`fÂ*T.*)(0*%"40*"5*C")(0%9*!(%&7)P7*(&)(0%)"*C17;24&.0*(2C1.&)$*&7*D141.;0/*"2)*D$*)(0*1//&)&".*"5* )(0* 50C&.&.09* 1./9* ".;0* 5244$* &.(1D&)&.'*D")(*'0./0%79* D0;"C079* &.* 1* 70.709*'0./0%4077A*N(0*(2C1.&)$*"5*!(%&7)9*&.*)(0*51;0*"5*(&7*/&=&.&)$9*&7*%0#%070.)1)&=0*"5*

"5*C140*1./*50C140*14&L0*c1%0d*&.7&#&/*1./*2.&C#"%)1.)*&.*)(0*D4&./&.'*4&'()*"5*)(0*24)&C1)0*17$CC0)%$*D0)G00.*<"/*1./*;%01)&".X*]E$.2C*@ìÂ*N(&7*;%01)&".* &7*

N(&7*&7*)(0*(2C1.&)$*&.*G(&;(*324&1.*7&)21)07*(0%7045*G(0.*7(0*G%&)079

T5* T* 4""L* 7"404$* 1)*C$70459* T* 1C* %0144$*.")(&.'a*D2)* 17*".0*"5*C1.L&./*&.*'0.0%149*T*1C*&.*".0.077*"5*4"=0*G&)(*144*C$*5044"G*!(%&7)&1.79*5"%*2#".*)(&7*".0.077*"5*4"=0*/0#0./7*)(0*4&50*"5*144*G("*7(144*D0*71=0/a*5"%*<"/*&7*144*)(1)*&7*'""/9*1./*<"/*(17*C1/0*144*)(1)*&7*C1/09*1./*<"/*4"=07*144*)(1)*(0*(17*C1/0*]324&1.*@f@Â

57

S"%L7*!&)0/

J0%79*\1=&/*1./*8)140$9*Q$..A*<,=&F$6=0%&$>&-,=&C$*.E&(=*+/+$#'&F$*+-+2%'&"#7&& 5=#7=0&+#&Q"-=&4=7+"=A"*&S#/*+%,&!?*-?0=A*-.&=0%7&)$*H1%L9** H0..7$4=1.&1,*H0..*8)1)0*-.&=0%7&)$*H%0779*@iihA*H%&.)A

E$.2C9*!1%"4&.0*S14L0%A*WjJ./*S"C1.*&.*(&7*R2C1.&)$P,*O0C140*TC1'0%$*&.*)(0*604&'&"27*S%&)&.'* "5* )(0* Q1)0%*:&//40*J'07AX* T.*N0"/)=#-"-+$#& "#7&(=7=)D-+$#E& S%%".%& $#& 5=#7=0& "#7& -,=& C?)"#& 9$7.& +#& 4=7+"=A"*&(=*+/+$#9*@_@VìA*U0G*m"%L,*p".0*E""L79*@ii>A*H%&.)A

VVVA*M=%?%&"%&4$-,=0E&I-?7+=%&+#&-,=&ID+0+-?"*+-.&$>&-,=&C+/,&4+77*=&G/=%A*E0%L040$9** Q"7*J.'04079*Q"./".,*-.&=0%7&)$*"5*!14&5"%.&1*H%0779*@if>A*H%&.)A

!"2.;&4*"5*!(14;0/".A*W!%00/*"5*!(14;0/".*]g_@ÂX*N(0*:0/&10=14*8"2%;0D""L,*!"2.;&4*"5*!(14;0/".9*0/A*H124*R171449*O"%(1C*-.&=0%7&)$9*@iihA*S0DA*?_*J2'A>?@@A*v())#,ttGGGA5"%/(1CA0/2t(147144tD17&7t;(14;0/".A17#uA

R0&CC049*30..&50%*HA*& H)"/=&$>&!,0+%-+"#&N=)+#+#=&J+A+#+-.A*Q0G&7)".9*y200.7)".9*Q1C#0)0%,** )(0*B/G&.*:0440.*H%0779*@if>A*H%&.)A

324&1.*"5*U"%G&;(A*BI;0%#)7*5%"C*W60=041)&".7*"5*\&=&.0*Q"=0AX*T.*4=7+"=A"*&& 30+-+#/%&$#&N=)"*=&ID+0+-?"*+-.9*0/A*B4&M1D0)(*8#01%&.'A*U0G*m"%L9** Q"./".9*n;A,*H0.'2&.*E""L79*>??>A*H%&.)A

:;J="$9*Q&M*R0%D0%)A*WjN(0*:"/0%P7*80%=&;0P,*:")(0%(""/*17*:1)%&I*&.*324&1.*"5*U"%G&;(AX*T.*4.%-+2%&Y?"0-=0*.*]@iif^,*@f@V@iÀ*H%&.)A

8&4D0%C1.9*Q12%0.A*W:$)("'%1#(&;*N%1.75"%C1)&".7*"5*Z=&/P7*R0%C1#(%"/&)0XA&

& 5=#7=0P&H%070.)0/*1)*)(0*:1/&7".*!".50%0.;0*".*B.'4&7(*8)2/&07,*31C07** :1/&7".*-.&=0%7&)$,*f*:1%;(*@ii_A*S0DA*?>*J2'A*>?@@Av())#,tt* ;"CC2.&)$A).;;A0/2t51;24)$t4".')t#1#0%7t324&1.wq)w17w:")(0%A()C4uA

S&44&1C79*N1%1A*H#A=#-+#/&3$)"#,$$7E&5=#7=0&"#7&Q"#/?"/=&+#&Q"-=&4+77*=&& S#/*+%,&30+-+#/A*!"42CD279*Z(&",*Z(&"*8)1)0*-.&=0%7&)$*H%0779*>?@@A** H%&.)A

59

!"#$%&$'(%)*(+**,+(-.(/)#$'*%01(213450(.6781396:(;96(7(+<5=74>7?@1(.99A(+B5=18(

!"#$%&'!()%*+&,-$

60

!"#$%&$'(%)*(+**,-(./(0)#$'*1(2)*(3*4&-)(56#7*4.68(/.6(#(+9-%#&$#:"*(5..,(+;-%*7

!"#$%&'$((2)&-( <#<*6( *=<".6*-( *%)&>#"( #$,( "*'#"( -;-%*7-( 6..%*,( &$( 39,#&-7( %.(&""97&$#%*( %)*( 3*4&-)( /6#7*4.68( /.6( #( -9-%#&$#:"*( /..,( -;-%*7?( 2)*( <#<*6(

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

5..,( &-( #( :#-&>( $*>*--&%;A( ;*%( &%( &-( #7.$'( %)*(7.-%( <#6#,.=&>#"( #-<*>%-(./(%)*(>.$%*7<.6#6;('".:#"(-;-%*7?(5..,(-9-%#&$-()97#$(8&$,(#$,(&-(>*$%6#"(%.(&,*$%&%;(#$,(>9"%96*A(;*%(#(-).>8&$'(<6.<.6%&.$(./( %)*(4.6",G-(<.<9"#%&.$( "#>8-(

,*%*67&$#$%-( ./( '".:#"( /..,( &$-*>96&%;A( %)&-( <#<*6( &$B*-%&'#%*-( #$( #"%*6$#%&B*(/6#7*4.68(#-(#$(#'*$%(/.6(>)#$'*1(%)*(3*4&-)(/..,(-;-%*7?(H*-<.$-*-(%.(/..,(-*>96&%;( #6*(<#6#7.9$%A( #$,( 39,#&-7(<"#;-( #( 6."*( &$('#"B#$&I&$'(<*.<"*( &$( %)*(<6.7.%&.$(./(*%)&>#"(B#"9*-(#$,(#>%&.$-?(J7:*,,*,(4&%)&$(39,#&-7(#6*(#$>&*$%(#$,( >.$%*7<.6#6;( "#4-A( B#"9*-( #$,( *%)&>-A( 4)&>)( <6.B&,*( #( %)*.6*%&>#"( #$,(<6#>%&>#"(/6#7*4.68(/.6(<6.7.%&$'(#(-9-%#&$#:"*(#$,(*D9&%#:"*(/..,(-;-%*7?

K$(%)&-(<#<*6A(#$(#$#";-&-(./(39,#&-7G-(*%)&>#"(#$,("*'#"(-;-%*7-(6*B*#"-(%)#%( %)*( %4.( &$)*6*$%";(9<).",( C9-%&>*A( -9-%#&$#:"*( #'6&>9"%96#"( %*>)$&D9*-A( #$,(%)*(>.$->&.9-$*--(-)&/%($*>*--#6;(/.6(#$(*D9&%#:"*(#$,(-9-%#&$#:"*(/..,(-;-%*7A(

%)*(<#<*6(#$#";I*-(/.96(#-<*>%-(./(3*4&-)("#4(E!"#"$%"%F1(#'6&>9"%96*("#4-A(/..,(*%)&>-A( -.>&#"( #$,( *$B&6.$7*$%#"( 6*-<.$-&:&"&%;?( +9:-*D9*$%";A( &%( ,*7.$-%6#%*-().4(%)*(/.96(#-<*>%-(./(!"#"$%"%&>.""*>%&B*";(<6.7.%*(%)6**(>.7<.$*$%-(%)#%(#6*($*>*--#6;(/.6(*-%#:"&-)&$'(#(-9-%#&$#:"*(#$,(*D9&%#:"*( /..,(-;-%*71(-9-%#&$#:"*(#'6&>9"%96*(%*>)$&D9*-L(-.>&#"(C9-%&>*L(#$,(#(<#6#,&'7(-)&/%(E"&7&%&$'(*'.>*$%6&-7F?(

:;(/.>9-&$'(.$(%)*(9$-9-%#&$#:"*(&7<"&>#%&.$-(./(%)*(>.$B*$%&.$#"(/..,(-;-%*7L(EMF(,&->9--*-(#"%*6$#%&B*(/..,(-;-%*7-A(4)&>)(<6.7.%*(-.>&#"(6*-<.$-&:&"&%;(#$,(*$B&6.$7*$%#"( -9-%#&$#:&"&%;L( ENF( <6.B&,*-( #( ,*%#&"*,( #$#";-&-( ./( O&:"&>#"( #$,(H#::&$&>(3*4&-)(#'6&>9"%96#"("#4-(#$,(/..,(*%)&>-(#$,(#--*--*-(%)*(&7<"&>#%&.$-(/.6(<6.7.%&$'(-9-%#&$#:"*(#$,(*D9&%#:"*(/..,(-;-%*7-L(EPF(,&->9--*-(:6.#,*6(3*4&-)(

61

=14207*"5*7";&14*%07#".7&D&4&)$*1./*0.=&%".C0.)14*7)0G1%/7(&#9*G(&;(*07)1D4&7(*)(0*

30G&7(*5""/*7$7)0Ca*1./*]h^*#%"=&/07*1*D%&05*;%&)&K20*"5*)(0*5%1C0G"%LA

* T.*7("24/*D0*.")0/*)(1)*)(&7*#1#0%*2707*j727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D40*5""/*7$7)0CP* 17* 1* #%"I$* 5"%* 5""/* 70;2%&)$A* N(0* O""/* 1./*J'%&;24)2%0* Z%'1.&M1)&".*

0I&7)7*G(0.*144*#0"#409*1)*144* )&C079*(1=0*#($7&;149* 7";&14*1./*0;"."C&;*1;;077*

#%050%0.;07*5"%*1.*1;)&=0*1./*(014)($*4&50X*]OJZ^A*O""/*70;2%&)$*&.="4=07*)(%00*17#0;)7,* 1=1&41D&4&)$9* 1;;077* 1./* 2)&4&M1)&".A* J* 727)1&.1D40* 1./* 0K2&)1D40* 5""/*7$7)0C* &.(0%0.)4$* #%"C")07* 144* )(%00* 17#0;)7,* &.* D0&.'* j0K2&)1D409P* )(0* 5""/*7$7)0C*0.72%07*5""/*1;;0779*1./*147"*#%"C")07*0K2&)1D40*5""/*K214&)$A*T.*D0&.'*

.2)%&)&"27*]K214&)$^*5""/*)(%"2'(*C2)2144$*#%"C")&.'*0.=&%".C0.)14*1./*(2C1.*(014)(*1./*G044VD0&.'A*N(&7*;"%%07#"./7*G&)(*)(0*E%2./)41./*!"CC&77&".*%0#"%)*

179*W/0=04"#C0.)*)(1)*C00)7*)(0*.00/7*"5*)(0*#%070.)*G&)("2)*;"C#%"C&7&.'*)(0*1D&4&)$* "5* 52)2%0* '0.0%1)&".7* )"* C00)* )(0&%* "G.* .00/7X* ]W60#"%)* "5* )(0*S"%4/*!"CC&77&".*".*B.=&%".C0.)*1./*\0=04"#C0.),*Z2%*!"CC".*O2)2%0X^A*

62

QRS.081"&8.I11B.9,#*'?%+$3.&,B.9,B?#$%+&8.!-%+'?8$?%*

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a* &)* &7*D170/*2#".*.0"4&D0%14*0;"."C&;7*1./*&7*/07&'.0/*)"*#%"/2;0*17*C2;(*17*#"77&D40*5"%*)(0*4"G07)*;"7)*]R&.%&;(7*1./*Q$7".*>?^A**TC#%"=0C0.)7*&.*)0;(."4"'$*(1=0*40/*)"*'0.0)&;*

T.* 1//&)&".9* )(0* 5""/* 7$7)0C* &7*D170/*".*0;"."C&07*"5* 7;1409* 51="2%7*K21.)&)$9*

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p1%&P&C*QPp0C1.1.2*R1''1/1(9*@^*14)0%.1)&=0*7$7)0C7*1./*#1%1/&'C7*C27)*D0*#%"C")0/9*)"*144"G*5"%*4";14*1./*'4"D14*5""/*70;2%&)$9*1./*1*F27)*1./*727)1&.1D40*G"%4/A*

QTS*)?#$&+,&"8*.&-%+'?8$?%*.U.:11B.#3#$*<#.

J*.2CD0%*"5*14)0%.1)&=0*7$7)0C7*(1=0*0C0%'0/*&.*%0;0.)*$01%79*;(1440.'&.'*)(0*G&7/"C*"5*;".=0.)&".14*1'%&;24)2%14*#%"/2;)&".*&.*)(0*("#0*"5*%0C1L&.'*)(0*

727)1&.1D40*1'%&;24)2%09*&.="4=0*1*=1%&0)$*"5*)0;(.&;149*)(0"%0)&;14*1./*&/0"4"'&;14*7(&5)79* G(&;(* 1%09* ;"440;)&=04$9* ;%&)&;14* &.* )(0* #%"C")&".* "5* 727)1&.1D40* 1./*0K2&)1D40* 7$7)0C7A* * N(070* 7$7)0C7* 1772C0* ("4&7)&;* 1##%"1;(07* )(1)* =&0G* 5""/*#%"/2;)&".* 1./* ;".72C#)&".* 17* &.)0%/0#0./0.)* 7$7)0C79* =1420* (2C1.* %&'()7*1./* 7";&14* 0K2&)$9* 1./* #%"C")0* 0.=&%".C0.)14* (014)(A* 827)1&.1D40* 1'%&;24)2%09*&.;42/&.'* 1'%"0;"4"'$9* #0%C1;24)2%0* 1./* ;"CC2.&)$* 72##"%)0/* 1'%&;24)2%09*2.4&L0* &./27)%&14* 1'%&;24)2%09*C&C&;7* 0;"4"'&;14* #1))0%.7* 1./* ;$;407* )"* 72##"%)*

63

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

QV&S.W*X+#/.!-%+'?8$?%*.7&X#.

* 30G&7(*J'%&;24)2%0* Q1G7* ]b1^9* 1./* )(0* 5""/* 0)(&;7* ]bD^* G(&;(* G&44* D0*/&7;2770/* D04"G9* 1%0* %"")0/* &.* E&D4&;14* 41G* 1./* /0=04"#0/* )(%"2'(* 61DD&.&;*;"CC0.)1%$9* G(&;(* &442C&.1)07* ("G* 0CD0//0/* )(0* 5""/* 7$7)0C* 5%1C0G"%L*&7* )(%"2'("2)* 1* 4".'* (&7)"%$* "5* )%1/&)&".A*J'%&;24)2%14* 41G7* 1%0* /&7#0%70/* D")(*)(%"2'("2)*)(0*D""L7*"5*)(0*D&D409*17*G044*17*&.*I=7=0&L=0"+)9*1*:&7(.1&;*;(1#)0%*

N(&7*70;)&".*(&'(4&'()7*1*.2CD0%*"5* )(0* 41G7* )"*/0C".7)%1)0* )(0&%*C24)&51;0)0/*

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b,@?V@@Â$01%7*$"2*7(144*#%2.0*$"2%*=&.07*1./*$"2*7(144*'1)(0%*&.*)(0&%*#%"/2;0A*J./*&.*)(0*70=0.)(*$01%*)(0%0*7(144*D0*1*81DD1)(*"5*7"40C.*%07)*5"%*)(0*41./9*1*81DD1)(*5"%*)(0*Q"%/eX*]Q0=&)&;27*>_,*@V_Â**Q17)4$9*

e*0=0%$*;%0/&)"%*7(144*%0C&)*1.$*/0D)*"G0/*D$*(&7*.0&'(D"2%*1./* (&7* D%")(0%* G(0.* <"/P7* 8(C&))1(* $01%* ;"C07* 1%"2./e*T5* )(0%0* D0* 1C".'* $"2* 1* .00/$* C1.9* ".0* "5* $"2%* D%")(0%79*G&)(&.* 1.$* ".0* "5* $"2%* '1)079* &.* $"2%* 41./* G(&;(* )(0* 4"%/*$"2%* <"/* &7* '&=&.'* $"29* $"2* 7(144* .")* (1%/0.* $"2%* (01%)*1./* $"2* 7(144* .")* 7(2)* $"2%* (1./* 5%"C* $"2%* .00/$* D%")(0%A*

5"%* (&7* .00/* &.* )(1)* G(&;(* (0* 41;L7* ]\02)0%"."C$@_,@VfÂ*

N(0%0*1%0*)(%00*C1F"%*&C#4&;1)&".7*"5*)(0*;"CC1./C0.)*"5*I,)+--",A*O&%7)4$9*17*1.*1'%&;24)2%14*)0;(.&K209*144"G&.'*)(0*41./*)"*4&0*5144"G*&7*1.*"##"%)2.&)$*5"%*)(0*

64

41./*)"*%0F2=0.1)0*)(0*.2)%&0.)7*)(1)*(1=0*D00.*)1L0.*2#*)(%"2'(*51%C&.'*#%1;)&;07A*:1&C".&/079*"%*61CD1C*&.*R0D%0G9*)(0*%0."G.0/*N"%1(*7;("41%*1./*#(&4"7"#(0%*"5*@>)(*;0.)2%$*8#1&.*7)1)0/*&.*)(0*5?+7=&>$0&-,=&F=0D*=@=7*b,bi9*WN(0*41./*G&44*147"* &.;%0170* &)7* #%"/2;0* 1./* &C#%"=0*G(0.* &)* %0C1&.7* 5144"G* 5"%* 7"C0* )&C0X*]:1.041*>?@?9*hbÂ*N(&7*#%"C")07*)(0*727)1&.1D&4&)$*"5*)(0*41./9*D0;1270*/2%&.'*)(0*5144"G*$01%9*C&;%""%'1.&7C7*D%01L*/"G.*)(0*7"&49*#%"=&/&.'*1&%*1./*%07)";L&.'*&)7*.2)%&0.)7*5"%*;".)&.20/*#%"/2;)&=&)$A

80;"./4$9*I,)+--",*&.="4=07*1;)7*"5*7";&14*F27)&;09*&.;42/&.'*500/&.'*)(0*#""%* 1./* %04017&.'*/0D)7A*N(0* 41G7* W&C#4$* 7$C#1)($* )"G1%/7*"2%* 5044"G*C0.9*1./*#%"C")0*)(0*G044D0&.'*"5*C1.L&./e*c\0D)*%0401707d*70%=0*)"*70;2%0*#0"#40*1*#0%C1.0.)*7"2%;0*"5*C1&.)0.1.;0*1./*72##"%)X*]hbÂ*N(0$*147"*&.7#&%0*'0.0%"7&)$9*W7&.;0*.".0*&7*C"%0*)(1.*(0*G("*'&=07*G&)("2)*1.$*#%"7#0;)*"5*;"C#0.71)&".X*]hgÂ

*T.*1//&)&".9*)(0*61DD&*8(4"C"*B#(%1&C*Q2.7;(&)M*1770%)7*)(1)*)(%"2'(*)(0* 727#0.7&".* "5* #%&=1)0* "G.0%7(&#9* W)(&7* &7* 2./"2D)0/4$* 1* #%&C1%$* 51;)"%* &.*#%"C")&.'*#01;0*7&.;0*C"7)*/&770.7&".*"%&'&.1)07* 5%"C*)(0*1))&)2/0*"5* jC&.0* &7*C&.0PAAA*1./*j&)*&7*144*C&.0Pe*E2)*&.*)(0*70=0.)(*$01%*144*1%0*0K2149*1./*)(&7*&7*)(0*%014*0770.;0*"5*#01;0X*]hgÂ*N(0%05"%09*/2%&.'*)(0*I,)+--",*$01%*)(0%0*&7*0K214&)$*D0)G00.*%&;(*1./*#""%9*1./*1.*0C#(17&7*".*7";&14*F27)&;0A*

N(&%/4$9* )(0* &C#4&;1)&".7* "5* I,)+--",* ".* 1* ;"7C"4"'&;14* 40=04* 1%0*

)(1)*=14207* )(0* 4".'V)0%C*(014)(*"5*(2C1.7*1./* )(0*01%)(A*I,)+--",* 07)1D4&7(07*)(0* %041)&".7(&#* D0)G00.*<"/* 1./* (2C1.*D$* 2./0%C&.&.'* 0'";0.)%&7C* 1./*D$*70%=&.'*17*1*%0C&./0%*)(1)*(2C1.7*1%0*)0.1.)7*".*<"/P7*41./9*1./*)(1)*)(0$*;1..")*4&C&)40774$*270*)(0*41./*5"%*)(0&%*"G.*&./&=&/214*'""/9*17*&)*&7*71&/9*WI,)+--",*&7*

]h_Â*Z)(0%*61DD&7*7)%077*)(1)*I,)+--",* &7*1*.0;0771%$*4&D0%1)&".*5%"C*;"C#40)0*#%0";;2#1)&".*G&)(*C1)0%&14&7C9*1./*#%"=&/0*1*)&C0*5"%*7#&%&)214*1./*&.)0440;)214*'%"G)(*]7)2/$&.'*N"%1(^*]W30G&7(*O1%C*8;(""4X*@fÂ*61=*[""L9*!(&05*61DD&*"5*H1407)&.0*&.*)(0*01%4$*>?)(*;0.)2%$9*#"&'.1.)4$*/07;%&D0/*)(0*.00/*5"%*I,)+--",*&.*%0"%&0.)&.'*)(0*1.)(%"#";0.)%&;*G"%4/=&0G*17,*

J*$01%*"5*7"40C.*%07)* &7*0770.)&14* 5"%*D")(* )(0*.1)&".*1./* )(0*41./9*1*$01%*"5*#01;0*1./*K2&0)*G&)("2)*"##%077"%*1./*)$%1.)eT)*&7*1*$01%*"5*0K214&)$*1./*%07)9*&.*G(&;(*)(0*7"24*%01;(07*"2)*)"G1%/7* /&=&.0* F27)&;09* )"G1%/7* <"/* G("* 727)1&.7* )(0* 4&=&.'*;%01)2%07*G&)(*4"=&.'*L&./.077A*N(0%0*&7*."*#%&=1)0*#%"#0%)$*1./*."*#2.;)&4&"27*#%&=&40'0*D2)*)(0*#01;0*"5*<"/*%0&'.7*"=0%*144*&.*G(&;(*)(0%0*&7*)(0*D%01)(*"5*4&50A*81.;)&)$*&7*.")*#%"51.0/*D$*)(0*0I0%;&70*"5*#%&=1)0*1;K2&7&)&=0.077*"=0%*144*)(&7*$01%P7*#%"/2;09*1./* )(0* ;"=0)"27.077* "5* G014)(* 7)&%%0/* 2#* D$* ;"CC0%;0* &7*5"%'"))0.*]@iÂ

65

N(279* &)* &7* 0=&/0.)* )(1)* I,)+--",& #%"C")07* 727)1&.1D40* 1'%&;24)2%0* )0;(.&K2079*0)(&;14*=142079*1./*1*%0"%&0.)1)&".*"5*(2C1.*0'";0.)%&7C9*144*"5*G(&;(*;".)%&D2)0*'%01)4$* )"*1*C"%0*727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D40* 5""/*7$7)0C9*G(&;(*7)1./7* &.*7)1%L*;".)%17)*)"*)(0*;2%%0.)*7$7)0CA

F=8",* &7* 1.")(0%* 1'%&;24)2%14* 41G9* G(&;(* %050%7* )"* )(0* &.7)%2;)&".* 5"%*

)(0*#""%A*U")*".4$*&7*)(0*01%)(*0I#0%&0.;0/*17*1*4&=&.'*"%'1.&7C9*D2)*(2C1.7*1%0*1.*&.)%&.7&;*;"C#".0.)*"5*)(0*4&=&.'*01%)(*D&"7$7)0CA*T.*1//&)&".*)"*j500/&.'*)(0*7"&4P* )(%"2'(* )(0* 270* "5* ;"C#"7)9*C1.2%09* ;"=0%* ;%"##&.'9* %")1)&".* 1./* 5144"G*#%1;)&;079*j500/&.'*)(0*;"CC2.&)$P*G17*%0K2&%0/*5"%*)(0*41./*)"*D0*5%2&)524*]80/0%*p1%&P&C*QPp0C1.1.2*R1''1/1(*_Â*F=8",* &442C&.1)07* )(0* %"40* "5* 7";&14* F27)&;0*17*D0&.'*&.(0%0.)4$*4&.L0/*)"*5""/*7$7)0C79*17*F=8",*&7*1.*0I1C#40*"5*1*E&D4&;14*;"CC1./C0.)* )(1)*#%"C")07* 5""/* F27)&;09*G(&;(*;".)%&D2)07* )"* )(0*;%01)&".*"5*1.* 0K2&)1D40* 5""/* 7$7)0CA*J7* 7)1)0/* &.* )(0*E&D409* WS(0.*$"2* %01#* )(0* (1%=07)*

'"* )"* )(0* 7)%1.'0%9* )(0* "%#(1.9* 1./* )(0* G&/"Ge*J4G1$7* %0C0CD0%* )(1)* $"2*G0%0* 1* 741=0* &.* )(0* 41./*"5*B'$#)a* )(0%05"%0* T* ;"CC1./*$"2* )"* /"* )(&7* )(&.'X*]\02)"%"."C$*>g,@i9>>Â*J//&)&".144$9*WS(0.*$"2*%01#*)(0*(1%=07)*"5*$"2%*41./9*

"5*$"2%*(1%=07)A**m"2*7(144*.")*#&;L*$"2%*=&.0$1%/*D1%09*"%*'1)(0%*)(0*51440.*5%2&)*"5*$"2%*=&.0$1%/a*$"2*7(144*401=0*)(0C*5"%*)(0*#""%*1./*)(0*7)%1.'0%,*T*)(0*Q"%/*

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

".*D4077&.'79*1./*#%1;)&;07*)"*0.72%0*)(1)*144*"5*)(0*;"CC2.&)$*&7*#%"=&/0/*G&)(*5""/*1./*/&'.&)$*)(%"2'(*)&)(&.'*1./*'401.&.'A*N(0*1.;&0.)*T7%104&)0*L.0G*)(1)*D$*500/&.'*)(0*#0"#409*144* )(0*#0"#409* )(0*01%)(*G"24/*&.*%0)2%.*#%"=&/0*&)7*D"2.)$*)"*144X*]80/0%*p1%&P&C*QPp0C1.1.2*R1''1/1(*hÂ*8";&14*F27)&;0*&7*)(27*700.*17*1*%0K2&%0C0.)*7&.;0*&)*&7*0)(&;14*V*&)*&7*%"")0/*&.*)(0*;"CC2.&)$P7*;"440;)&=0*C0C"%$*"5*#17)*"##%077&".*V*1./*D0;1270*J.;&0.)*T7%104&)07*D04&0=0/*)(1)*7"&4*50%)&4&)$*G17*D170/*".*5""/*F27)&;0A*

&7*)(0*1'%&;24)2%14*;"CC1./C0.)*)(1)*1770%)7*)(1)*".0*7("24/*401=0*

G(0.*$0*7(144*;"C0*&.)"*)(0*41./9*1./*7(144*(1=0*#41.)0/*144*C1..0%*"5*)%007*5"%*5""/9* )(0.*$0* 7(144* ;"2.)* )(0* 5%2&)* )(0%0"5* 17* 5"%D&//0.a* )(%00* $01%7* 7(144* &)* D0*

)(&7*;"CC1./C0.)*&7*)(1)*&)*07)1D4&7(07*)(0*.00/*5"%*%07)%1&.)*"=0%*".0P7*#%"/2;)&".*

66

1./*G1.)79*G(&;(*C&%%"%7*)(0*)(0C0*)(1)*#0"#40*1%0*)0.1.)7*".*<"/P7*41./A*N(&7*;"CC1./C0.)*&7*;".7&/0%0/*W;$7=%,&,+*?*+)1770%)7* )(1)* 270* "%* #%"/2;)&".9* C27)* &.="4=0* )(0* %0;"'.&)&".* "5* 1./* '%1)&)2/0*)"G1%/7*<"/A*WN(0*30G*G1&)7*)(%00*$01%7*D05"%0*(0*0.F"$7*)(0*5%2&)e*(0*7)%&#7*(&C7045*"5*)(0*%&'()7*"5*#%"#0%)$*D05"%0*<"/e*#%1;)&;07*%07)%1&.)*1./*7045*;".)%"4X*]:1.041* >?@?9* ìÂ* N(&7* ;"CC1./C0.)* C&.&C&M07* 0I;077&=0* 0'";0.)%&7C9*1770%)&.'*'%01)0%*G"%)(* )"*<"/P7* ;"CC1./* )(1.*(2C1.*/07&%09* 1./* 07)1D4&7(07*1*4&C&)* )"*/"C&.&".*"=0%*<"/P7*;%01)&".7A*R2C1.*0.)&)40C0.)*1./*;".72C#)&".*(17* &)7* 4&C&)79* 1./* )(0* ;"CC1./C0.)* 07)1D4&7(07* %07)%1&.)9* #0%7#0;)&=09* 1./*C&./524.0779* )(27* #%"C")&.'* 1.* "%&0.)1)&".* "5* 0'"* )(1)* &7* 1* ;%&)&;14* 17#0;)* "5*;%01)&.'*1*727)1&.1D40*7$7)0CA*

Z)(0%* 1'%&;24)2%14V%041)0/* 41G7* &.;42/0* Z+*".+)* ]5"%D&//0.* C&I)2%07^9*G(&;(*1770%)7*)(1)*;"CD&.1)&".7*"5*/&=0%70*700/79*1.&C1479*1./*;0%)1&.*C1)0%&147*1%0*#%"(&D&)0/a*)(0*E&D40*7)1)079*W/"*.")*&.)0%D%00/*$"2%*;1))40a*/"*.")*7"G*$"2%*

C1)0%&14*C&I0/*)"'0)(0%X*]Q0=&)&;27*@i,@iÂ*N(&7*41G*0I#"707*;0%)1&.*/&7;%0#1.;&07*&.* 30G&7(* 1'%&;24)2%14* )0;(.&K207A* Z.* ".0* (1./9*Z+*".+)* 700C7* 1.)&)(0)&;14* )"*727)1&.1D40*1'%&;24)2%0* )0;(.&K207*"5*/&=0%7&)$*1./* &.)0%;%"##&.'A*U0=0%)(040779*

7#0;&07*&.*&.)0%;%"##&.'9*5"%*0I1C#409*G&)(*0."2'(*7#1;0*D0)G00.*)(0C*)"*#%0=0.)*401;(&.'9*G&)(*=&7&D40*D"2./1%&07*D0)G00.*#4")79* 0);* ][&41$&C*:&7(1*b,@Â* T)* &7*)(27*;401%*)(1)*)(0*61DD&7*/"*.")*#%"C")0*C".";24)2%07a*%1)(0%*)(0$*"550%*C1.$*)0;(.&K207*5"%*'%"G&.'*#41.)7*)"'0)(0%9*G&)("2)*;"C#%"C&7&.'*&./&=&/214*7#0;&079*)(27*#%"C")&.'*D")(*&.)0%;%"##&.'*1./*D&"/&=0%7&)$A

J//&)&".144$9* ;".)0C#"%1%$* )(&.L0%7* 2./0%7)1./* )(0* ;"CC1./C0.)* 17*#%"(&D&)&.'* ($D%&/* 700/79* 1./* )(27* <:Z79* G(&;(* &7* 1.* &C#"%)1.)* )"#&;* &.* )(0*

'41.;09* ;".)1&.7* 7"C0* /&7;%0#1.;&079* &)* &442C&.1)07* )(0* &.)0%07)&.'* ;".;0#)* "5*&.)0%#%0)&.'* ;"CC1./C0.)7* jG&)(&.* )(0* 7#&%&)* "5* )(0* 41GP9* %1)(0%* )(1.* G&)(&.*)(0*7)%&;)*40))0%*"5*)(0*41GA*N(&7*&7*1*#%&.;&#40*)(1)*1770%)7*)(1)*1CD&'2&)&07*7("24/*5"44"G*)(0*"=0%1%;(&.'*=14207*"5*)(0*41G9*72;(*17*71=&.'*1*4&509*7";&14*F27)&;09*1./*

9+;?0+)

)(0* '%"2./9*G(&;(* $"2* D%&.'* &.* 5%"C*$"2%* 41./* )(1)* )(0*Q"%/* $"2%*<"/* '&=07*$"2a*1./*$"2*G&44*#2)*&)*&.*1*D17L0)*1./*G&44*'"*)"*)(0*#41;0*G(&;(*)(0*Q"%/*$"2%*<"/*G&44*;(""70eX*]\02)0%"."C$*>h,@V@@Â*N(&7*07)1D4&7(07*".0P7*%041)&".7(&#*G&)(* )(0*01%)(*17* 1* )0.1.)* 1./* 7)0G1%/9*G(&;(*#%0=0.)7* )(0* 4&D0%)$* )"*C&7270* &)*1./*C&)&'1)07*1*70.70*"5*0.)&)40C0.)A**N(%00*("4&/1$7*)(1)*1%0*;0.)%14*)"*32/1&7C*1%0*F=%"2,9*I,=A?$-9* 1./*I?;;$-9*G(&;(*#%&"%* )"* )(0*/07)%2;)&".*"5* )(0*80;"./*N0C#409*G1%%1.)0/*=&7&)7*)"*)(0*N0C#409*1%0*(1%=07)*("4&/1$7*5"%*D1%40$9*G(01)*1./*72CC0%*;%"#7*%07#0;)&=04$A*N(279*D%&.'&.'*)(0*(1%=07)*17*1.*"550%&.'*&7*0I)%0C04$*

67

&C#"%)1.)A*S(&40*)(0*N0C#40*."*4".'0%*0I&7)79*1./*)(27*"550%&.'7*1%0*.")*C1/09*)(0* ("4&/1$7* 1%0* 7)&44* ;040D%1)0/* 17* (1%=07)* ("4&/1$7A* N(070* ("4&/1$7* #%"C")0*)(0* #1%1/&'C* 7(&5)* "5* 4&C&)&.'* 0'";0.)%&7C* D$* 7("G&.'* '%1)&)2/0* )"* <"/* 5"%*727)0.1.;09*G(&;(*&7*1*.0;0771%$*17#0;)*5"%*7(&5)&.'*)(0*5""/*7$7)0C*)"*&.;"%#"%1)0*727)1&.1D&4&)$*1./*0K2&)$A*

J//&)&".144$9* 61DD&.&;* #1%1D407* #%"C")0* D&"/&=0%7&)$* #%070%=1)&".*]=1%&"27* #41.)* 7#0;&07^9* G(&;(* &7* &.)0'%14* &.* 727)1&.1D40* 7$7)0C* 5"%* #%"C")&.'*7"&4*(014)(9*;"C#1.&".*#41.)&.'*]1;)&.'*17*.1)2%14*#07)&;&/079*50%)&4&M0%79*.&)%"'0.*

R0D%0G9*)(0*@b)(*;0.)2%$*E&D4&;14*;"CC0.)1)"%*&.*8#1&.9*7)1)0/9*WN(0*N"%1(*/"07*.")*#0%C&)*1*L&44&.'*)(1)*G"24/*2#%"")*1*7#0;&079*0=0.*&5*&)*#0%C&))0/*)(0*L&44&.'*"5*&./&=&/2147*&.*)(1)*7#0;&07*5"%*5""/A*J./*(0%09*)(0*".0*G("*L&447*)(0*C")(0%*1./*)(0*;(&4/*".*)(0*71C0*/1$9*&)* &7*17*&5* )(1)*#0%7".*(17*C1/0*)(1)*7#0;&07*0I)&.;)X*]60'1%/&.'*\02)0%"."C$*>>,h9*80/0%*p1%&P&C*QPp0C1.1.2*R1''1/1(Â*

#2%#"70*&7*;1%%&0/*)(%"2'(*0=0%$)(&.'9*0=0.*)(%"2'(*1*7.1L09*1*7;"%#&".9*1*'.1)*1./* 1* 5%"'X* ]<0.07&7*61DD1(* @?,`Â*N(279* )(0* #%"C")&".* "5* D&"/&=0%7&)$* &7* 1.*0770.)&14*=1420*1./*1*727)1&.1D40*1'%&;24)2%0*)0;(.&K209*G(&;(*&7*1.")(0%*E&D4&;14*;".)%&D2)&".*)"*)(0*#%"C")&".*"5*727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D40*5""/*#%"/2;)&".A*

Q17)4$9*)(0%0*&7*61DD&.&;*%050%0.;0*)"*)(0*=142&.'*"5*4";14*5""/9*G(&;(*&7*

%0/2;0/*5""/*C&4079*)(0*#%"C")&".*"5*4";14*0;"."C&079*1./*&.)&C1)0*;"..0;)&".7*)"9* 1./* )(27* 1G1%0.077* "5* 5""/* #%"/2;)&".A*!"CC0.)&.'* ".* )("70*G("*/"* .")*'%"G*)(0&%*"G.*#%"/2;09*61DD&*J(1&*D0.*3"7&1(*71&/9*

R0*G("*D2$7*'%1&.*&.*)(0*C1%L0)9*)"*G(1)*C1$*(0*D0*;"C#1%0/k*N"*1*;(&4/*G("* &7*;2)*"55* 5%"C*(&7*C")(0%9*1./*14)("2'(* &)* &7*

D2$7*D%01/* &.* )(0*C1%L0)9* )"*G(1)* &7*(0*;"C#1%0/k*N"*1*C1.*G("*/&'7*(&7*"G.*'%1=0*V*1*G%0);(0/9*#%0;1%&"27*0I&7)0.;0A*E2)*(0*G("* 01)7* "5* (&7* "G.* #%"/2;0* &7* 4&L0* 1* ;(&4/* %01%0/* 1)* (&7*C")(0%P7*D%017)*]N(0*O1)(0%7*J;;"%/&.'*)"*61DD&9*U1)(1.*b?,hÂ

J//&)&".144$9* &)* &7* 71&/9* WT)* &7* 5"%D&//0.* )"* 4&=0* &.* 1* )"G.* G(0%0* )(0%0* 1%0* ."*=0'0)1D40*'1%/0.7X*]61DD&*m"70*E0.*E2.9*N14C2/*[&//27(&.*g,@Â*Z.;0*1'1&.9*30G&7(*41G*72##"%)7*727)1&.1D40*1'%&;24)2%0*)0;(.&K2079*)(27*;".)%&D2)&.'*)"*)(0*#%"C")&".*"5*727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D40*5""/*7$7)0C7A*

)0;(.&K2079*7";&14*F27)&;09*"%*1*#1%1/&'C*7(&5)A*R"G0=0%9*2./0%7)""/*;"440;)&=04$9*)(0$*#%"C")0*)(0*14)0%.1)&=0*5""/*7$7)0C7*)(1)*;".)%&D2)0*)"*5""/*70;2%&)$A

68

QV"S.W*X+#/.I11B.F$/+'#

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

Z.0*"5*)(0*;0.)%14*17#0;)7*)"*5""/*&.*32/1&7C*&7*)(0*17#0;)*"5*71.;)&5$&.'*"%*D4077&.'*5""/A*T.*)(0*N14C2/*;(1#)0%*"5*:170;(0)*E%1;(")9*)(0*61DD&7*)12'()9*W&)*&7*5"%D&//0.*)"*1*C1.*)"*0.F"$*1.$)(&.'*"5*)(&7*G"%4/*G&)("2)*1*D4077&.'9*1./*&5*1.$".0*0.F"$7*1.$)(&.'*"5*)(&7*G"%4/*G&)("2)*1*D4077&.'9*(0*;"CC&)7*71;%&40'0X*]81=1'0* 0)* 14A* >Â*E4077&.'7* 1%0*C1/0* "=0%* 1.$* )$#0* "5* 5""/* #%&"%* )"* 01)&.'* &)*)(%"2'(*1*%0;&)1)&".*V*5"%*0I1C#409*WE40770/*1%0*m"29*J/".1&9*"2%*<"/9*7"=0%0&'.*"5*)(0*2.&=0%709*)(0*Z.0*G("*D%&.'7*D%01/*5"%)(*5%"C*)(0*01%)(X*]81=1'0*0)*14A*hÂ*N(0*D4077&.'7*#%"C")0*'%1)&)2/09*(2C&4&)$9*1##%0;&1)&".*1./*&.;%0170/*1G1%0.077*"5* 5""/9* G(&;(*C&.&C&M0* 1.* 1))&)2/0* "5* 0.)&)40C0.)A*J*C1F"%* ;(1440.'0* "5* )(0*;".)0C#"%1%$*5""/*7$7)0C*&7*)(0*&'."%1.;0*1D"2)*)(0*7$7)0C*1./*)(0*/&7;"..0;)*)(1)*(17*1%&70.*D0)G00.*#0"#40*1./*)(0&%*5""/A*N(0*0."%C"27*7;140*1./*1.".$C"27*.1)2%0* "5* )(0* 5""/* 7$7)0C* (17* ;".)%&D2)0/* )"* &%%07#".7&D40* D0(1=&"2%* 1)* )(0*0I#0.70*"5*(2C1.*1./*0.=&%".C0.)14*G044D0&.'A*T.*;".)%17)9*)1L&.'*)&C0*)"*D4077*5""/*#%"C")07*;".7;&"27*01)&.'*1./*1.*1G1%0.077*1./*C&./524.077*"5*)(0*"%&'&.7*"5*)(0*5""/**]0'A*W5%2&)*5%"C*)(0*)%00X^9*17*G044*17*#%";07707*&.="4=0/*&.*D%&.'&.'*)(0*5""/*)"*".0P7*)1D40*G(&;(*07)1D4&7(07*1*;"..0;)&".*D0)G00.*1*;".72C0%9*)(0*5""/*1./*)(0*7$7)0CA*1*D4077&.'*;1440/*jE&%L1)*R1C1M".P*G(&;(*1770%)7*)(1)*".0*01)7*D0;1270*"5*<"/P7*'""/.077*1./*'&=07*)(1.L7*)"*<"/9*G(&;(*52%)(0%*%0/2;07*0.)&)40C0.)*1./*#%"C")07*;".7;&"27*;".72C#)&".A*N(0*D4077&.'7*71.;)&5$*5""/9*07)1D4&7(&.'*)(0*"D4&'1)&".*)"*#%"/2;0*5""/*0)(&;144$*1./*)%01)*5""/*%07#0;)5244$9*17*&)*&7*("4$A*

T.*1//&)&".*)"*D4077&.'79*30G&7(*5""/*0)(&;7*1%0*0CD"/&0/*&.*Z"%,0?-9*)(0*

4&50VD4""/* &.* &)9* 1="&/1.;0* "5*C&I&.'*C&4L* 1./*C01)* 5"%* &)* &7* /&7%07#0;)524* 1./*

)("70*)(1)*;(0G*)(0&%*;2/*1./*(1=0*7#4&)*(""=07^9*1./*#0%5"%C1.;0*"5*1*#1%)&;241%*C0)("/*"5*7412'()0%&.'*1.&C1479*/07&'.0/*)"*%0/2;0*72550%&.'*1./*D0*17*(2C1.0*17*#"77&D40*]<0.07&7*i,g9*\02)0%"."C$*@>,>bV>gÂ*T.*)(0*5?+7=&>$0&-,=&F=0D*=@=7&

9*:1&C".&/07*71$79*W&)*&7*/&%0;)4$*#%"(&D&)0/*&.*)(0*Q1G*)"*;1270*#1&.*)"*1.*1.&C14e*G0*7("24/*.")*1772C0*;%204*(1D&)79*G0*7("24/*.")*27040774$*;1270*#1&.*)"*")(0%7a*)(1)9*".*)(0*;".)%1%$9*G0*7("24/*D0*#%0#1%0/*)"*7("G*#&)$*1./*C0%;$*)"*144* 4&=&.'*;%01)2%07AX*N(0*7)%&.'0.)* )%1/&)&".14* 41G7* &.;"%#"%1)0*(014)(*;".;0%.7*1./*)(0*0)(&;14*)%01)C0.)*"5*1.&C1479*17*G044*17*07)1D4&7(&.'*4&C&)7*)"*)(0*(2C1.*

69

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jB;"V[17(%2)AP*O""/7*)(1)*C00)*)(0*0;"VL"7(0%*7)1./1%/*5"44"G*)%1/&)&".14*L"7(0%*41G7*1./*1%0*#%"/2;0/*727)1&.1D4$9*17* C0172%0/* D$* %07"2%;07* 270/* /2%&.'* 5""/* #%"/2;)&".9* ;1%D".* 5"")#%&.)9* 1./*/&7)1.;0*)%1=0440/*5%"C*51%C*)"*5"%LX*]S17L"G*@@`Â**[17(%2)*(17*)(0%0D$*D0;"C0*1*#%1;)&;14*G1$*)"*&.)0'%1)0*=14207*72;(*17*5""/*0)(&;79*7#&%&)214&)$9*0.=&%".C0.)14*;".;0%.*1./*7";&14*0K2&)$*&.)"*/1&4$*/&0)1%$*#%1;)&;0A*

J//&)&".144$9* )(%"2'("2)* )(0*;0.)2%&07*"5*D&D4&;14*;"CC0.)1%$9* )(0%0*(17*D00.* /&7;277&".* 17* )"* )(0* #%"C")&".* "5* =0'0)1%&1.&7C* &.)"* 30G&7(* 5""/* 0)(&;7A*l0'0)1%&1.&7C*&7*"5)0.*;".7&/0%0/*&C#"%)1.)*5"%*500/&.'*)(0*G"%4/P7*#"#241)&".9*17*C2;(*"5*)(0*G1)0%*1./*0.0%'$*)(1)*;"24/*'"*/&%0;)4$*)"*500/&.'*#0"#409*&7*270/*)"*'%"G*1.&C147*5"%*C01)*#%"/2;)&".A*60;0.)4$9*1*50G*C"=0C0.)7*1%0*#%"C")&.'*=0'0)1%&1.&7C* 17* )(0* &/014* WB;"V["7(0%XA* N%1/&)&".144$9* )(0%0*G0%0* %1DD&7* )(1)*#%"C")0/*C01)*;".72C#)&".*".4$*5"%*7#0;&14*";;17&".7A*T.*)(0*D&D4&;14*/&0)9*C01)*G17*".4$*01)0.*".*("4&/1$7*]80/0%*p1%&P&C*QPp0C1.1.2*R1''1/1(*h^9*G(0%017*

G0.)*7"* 51%*17* )"*7)1)0* )(1)*G(0.* )(0*:077&1(*1%%&=079* )(0*G("40*G"%4/*G&44*D0*=0'0)1%&1.79* 040=1)&.'* =0'0)1%&1.&7C* 17* 1.* &/014A*R0* 71&/9* W)(0.* (2C1.*D0&.'7*G&44* %0;"'.&M0* )(0&%* ;"C#1.&".7* &.* !%01)&".,* 144* )(0* 1.&C147A* J./* )(0$* G&44*

.")*)"*%07"%)*)"*C"%14*;".;077&".79*)"*;"C#%"C&70*)(0*\&=&.0*1))%&D2)0*"5*F27)&;0*G&)(*)(1)*"5*C0%;$*cD$*#0%C&))&.'*C1.L&./P7*0I#4"&)1)&".*"5*1.&C147de*61)(0%*)(0$* G&44* G14L* )(0* #1)(* "5* 1D7"42)0* '""/X* ]81=1'0* 0)* 14A* >`Â* l0'0)1%&1.&7C9*("G0=0%9* &7* .")* #%"C")0/* 17* 1* %0K2&%0C0.)* "%* 1* ."%C* &.* 32/1&7CA* N(27* &)* &7*0=&/0.)* )(1)* ;"CD&.0/* G&)(* D4077&.'7* 1./* Z"%,0?-9* 4&L0* )(0* 1'%&;24)2%0* 41G79*30G&7(* 5""/* 0)(&;7* #%"C")0* 727)1&.1D40* #%"/2;)&".* )0;(.&K2079* F27)&;09* 1./*1* #1%1/&'C* 7(&5)* ;"./2;&=0* 5"%* 1.* 0K2&)1D40* 1./* 727)1&.1D40* 5""/* 7$7)0CA**

QY&S. )1'+&8. ;*#21,#+"+8+$3(. E/&%+$34. W?#$+'*4. @+PP?,. G8&<4. &,B.F,>+%1,<*,$&8+#<

N"*2./0%7)1./* )(0* 5244* 7;"#0*"5* )(0* 30G&7(* 5%1C0G"%L9*G(&;(*#%"C")07*0K2&)$* 1./* 727)1&.1D&4&)$9* )(0* "=0%1%;(&.'* =14207* "5* 7";&14* 1./* 0.=&%".C0.)14*%07#".7&D&4&)$9*C27)*D0*/&7;2770/A*T.)0%07)&.'4$9*U1;(C1.&/07*1770%)7*)(1)*".0*;1.*L00#*0=0%$*41G*"5*)(0*N"%1(9*D2)*7)&44*D0*1*7;"2./%04*G&)(*)(0*N"%1(P7*#0%C&77&".9*W#"A"*&:+0%,?-&,"-$0",W&][&%7;(0.D12C*@?_Â*8)%&;)*"D70%=1.;0*"5*)(0*j40))0%*"5*

70

&.)0.)&".9*"%*("4&.077*]WL0/27(&C*)&(&$2X^9*G(&;(*1;;"2.)7*5"%*)(0*7#&%&)*"5*)(0*41G*17*G044A*-./0%7)1./&.'*)(0*41G7*%0K2&%07*1.*&.;"%#"%1)&".*"5*)(0*41G9*17*G044*17*)(0*7#&%&)*"5*)(0*41GA*N(279*41G7*)(1)*C1$*700C*)"*(1=0*1CD&'2"27*0)(&;14*&C#4&;1)&".7*C27)*D0*1770770/*("4&7)&;144$9*D$*)1L&.'*&.)"*1;;"2.)*)(0*7#&%&)*"5*)(0*41GA*E0;1270*

'%01)0%*7#&%&)*"5*)(0*41G9*G(&;(*&.;42/07*=14207*5"%*("4&.0779*7";&14*F27)&;0*0);A*!0.)%14*)"*30G&7(*=14207*&7*)(0*.")&".*"5*7";&14*%07#".7&D&4&)$A*<R=7";",9*

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m"2*8(144*H2%720X* ]\02)0%"."C$*@h,>?Â* T.*B)(&;7* "5* )(0*O1)(0%7* &)* 7)1)079* W&)*&7*.")*$"2%*/2)$*)"*;"C#40)0*)(0*G"%L*D2)*.0&)(0%*1%0*$"2*5%00*)"*/07&7)*5%"C*&)X*]B)(&;7*"5*)(0*O1)(0%79*:&7(.19*>,>@Â.J//&)&".144$9* 9*"%*%0#1&%&.'*)(0*G"%4/9*&7*D")(*1.*1.;&0.)*1./*;".)0C#"%1%$*30G&7(*=14209*G(&;(*1##4&07*)"*0)(&;149*40'14*1./*7#&%&)214*5%1C0G"%L7A*Q17)4$9*)(0*=1420*"5*j P9*"%*71=&.'*1*4&509*&7*".0*"5*)(0*50G*;"CC1./C0.)7*)(1)*&7*040=1)0/*1D"=0*144*")(0%79*G(0%0*".0*&7*;"CC1./0/*)"*71=0*1*4&50*0=0.*&5*&)*0.)1&47*D%01L&.'*")(0%*;"CC1./C0.)7A*N(070*7";&14*=14207*1%0*&.)0'%14*)"*32/1&7C*1./*2./0.&1D4$*;"%%07#"./*G&)(*1*5""/*7$7)0C*)(1)*&7*727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D409*%1)(0%*)(1.*)(0*;".=0.)&".14*7$7)0CA

QY"S.F,>+%1,<*,$&8.D&8?*#

T.* 1//&)&".* )"* =14207* "5* 7";&14* %07#".7&D&4&)$* 1%0* 2./0%4$&.'* 30G&7(*0.=&%".C0.)14* =14207A*J7* 07)1D4&7(0/* &.* <0.07&79* (2C1.7* 1%0* )(0* 7)0G1%/7* "5*<"/P7*G"%4/A*N(0*&.7)%2;)&".*5"%*(2C1.*/"C&.&".*&7*4&C&)0/*D$*)(0*&.7)%2;)&".*)"*W)&44*1./*L00#*)(0*41./X*]<0.07&7*>,@_^9*G(&;(*72''07)7*)(1)*(2C1.7*;1.*2709*D2)*.")*C&7270*)(0*41./9*07)1D4&7(&.'*0.=&%".C0.)14*%07#".7&D&4&)$*1./*7)0G1%/7(&#9*17*W144*1%0*)0.1.)7*".*<"/P7*41./X*]:1.041*>?@?9*>_Â**N(%"2'("2)*;%01)&".9*)(0*#($7&;14*G"%4/*G17* ;%01)0/* 17* W'""/X9*G(&;(* %0=0147* 1.* &.(0%0.)*G"%)(* )"* )(0*0.=&%".C0.)* 1./* &)7* D0&.'7A* 30G&7(* )01;(&.'7* &.7)%2;)* #0"#40* )"* 270* )(0*G"%4/*G&)(*;1%09*1./* )"* 727)1&.* &)* 5"%* 52)2%0*'0.0%1)&".7A*WT.* )(0*("2%*G(0.* )(0*R"4$*

1./* 0I;0440.)* )(0$* 1%0z*U"G*144* )(1)* T* (1=0* ;%01)0/9* 5"%* $"2*(1=0* T* ;%01)0/* &)A*N(&.L*2#".*)(&7*1./*/"*.")*/07)%"$*1./*/07"41)0*:$*S"%4/9*O"%*&5*$"2*;"%%2#)*&)9*)(0%0*&7*."*".0*)"*70)*&)*%&'()*15)0%*$"2XP*]:&/%17(*".*B;;407&17)07*61DD1(*`,>fÂ*

71

)"* '0.0%1)&".9* 07)1D4&7(&.'* 727)1&.1D&4&)$* "5* )(0*.1)2%14*G"%4/* 5"%* 52)2%0* 270A*J*61DD&.&;*7)"%$*#%"=&/07*1.*0I1C#40,*

* Z.0*/1$*R".&*R1C11'14*G17* F"2%.0$&.'*".* )(0* %"1/* 1./*(0*71G*1*C1.*#41.)&.'*1*;1%"D*)%00A*R0*17L0/*(&C,*R"G*4".'*/"07*&)* )1L0* c5"%* )(&7* )%00d* )"*D01%* 5%2&)k*N(0*C1.* %0#4&0/,*80=0.)$*$01%7A*R0*)(0.*17L0/*)(0*C1.,*J%0*$"2*;0%)1&.*)(1)*$"2*G&44*4&=0*1.")(0%*70=0.)$*$01%7k*N(0*C1.*%0#4&0/,*T*5"2./*c%01/$*'%"G.d*;1%"D*)%007*&.*)(0*G"%4/a*17*C$*5"%051)(0%7*#41.)0/*)(070*5"%*C09*7"*T*)""*#41.)*)(070*5"%*C$*;(&4/%0.*]N14C2/*E1=4&9*:170L(0)*N1P1.&)*>b1Â*

N(0*30G&7(*0.=&%".C0.)14*0)(&;* &7*147"*700.* &.* )(0*;"CC1./C0.)*9"*&<"%2,+-9*WS(0.9* &.*$"2%*G1%*1'1&.7)*1*;&)$9*$"2*(1=0* )"*D07&0'0* &)*1* 4".'* )&C0* &.*"%/0%*)"*;1#)2%0*&)9*$"2*C27)*.")*/07)%"$*&)7*)%0079*G&04/&.'*)(0*1I0*1'1&.7)*)(0CA*m"2*

(2C1.*)"*G&)(/%1G*D05"%0*$"2*&.)"*)(0*D07&0'0/*;&)$kX*]\02)0%"."C$*>?,@iÂ*9"*&<"%2,+-&&.="4=07*7$C#1)($*5"%*)(0*.1)2%14*G"%4/A*T)*(17*D0;"C0*1*K2&.)0770.)&14*30G&7(*0.=&%".C0.)14*0)(&;9*&.)0%#%0)0/*17*1*#%"(&D&)&".*1'1&.7)*G17)0*"%*G1.)".*/07)%2;)&".A*

Q17)4$9* )(0* 81DD1)(9* 1* /1$* "5* %07)9* 1;)7* 17* 1.* 0.=&%".C0.)14* =1420A*N(0*30G&7(*81DD1)(*#%"(&D&)7*;%01)&".9*G"%L9*1./*)(0*270*"5*040;)%&;&)$9*1C".'*C1.$*")(0%* )(&.'7A* J7* JD%1(1C* 3"7(21* R07;(049* 1* 401/&.'* >?)(* ;0.)2%$* JC0%&;1.*)(0"4"'&1.9*#(&4"7"#(0%*1./*61DD&9*7)1)0/,*

* N"*70)*1#1%)*".0*/1$*1*G00L*5"%*5%00/"C9*1*/1$*".*G(&;(*G0*G"24/*.")*270*)(0*&.7)%2C0.)7*G(&;(*(1=0*D00.*7"*017&4$*)2%.0/*&.)"*G01#".7*"5*/07)%2;)&".9*1*/1$*5"%*D0&.'*G&)(*"2%704=079*1*/1$*"5*/0)1;(C0.)*5%"C*)(0*=24'1%9*"5*&./0#0./0.;0*"5*0I)0%.14*"D4&'1)&".79* 1* /1$* ".* G(&;(* G0* 7)"#* G"%7(&##&.'* )(0* &/"47*"5* )0;(.&;14*;&=&4&M1)&".9*1*/1$*".*G(&;(*G0*270*."*C".0$e&7*)(0%0*1.$*&.7)&)2)&".*)(1)*("4/7*"2)*1*'%01)0%*("#0*5"%*C1.P7*#%"'%077*)(1.*)(0*81DD1)(k*]W30G&7(*O1%C*8;(""4X*@>Â

*B.=&%".C0.)14* 0)(&;7* 1%0* )(27* &.)0'%14* =14207* &.* #%"C")&.'* 1.* 0K2&)1D40*1./* 727)1&.1D40* 5""/* 7$7)0C9* &.* #%"C")&.'* )(0* &.(0%0.)* G"%)(* "5* )(0* .1)2%14*0.=&%".C0.)9*1./*)(0*%"40*"5*(2C1.7*17*0.=&%".C0.)14*7)0G1%/7A*

N(0*30G&7(*5""/*7$7)0C*&7*;"C#%&70/*"5*1'%&;24)2%0*41G7*1./*5""/*0)(&;79*1./* &7* 7)%0.')(0.0/* D$* 7";&14* 1./* 0.=&%".C0.)14* =14207A* N(070* ;"C#".0.)7*72##"%)*7";&14*F27)&;09*727)1&.1D40*1'%&;24)2%09*1./*)(0*.0;0771%$*#1%1/&'C*7(&5)A**

7$7)0C9*;"440;)&=04$* )(0$*#%"C")0*1*727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D40* 5""/*7$7)0C*)(1)*

72

144"G7*5"%*5""/*70;2%&)$9*&.*7)1%L*;".)%17)*G&)(*;".=0.)&".14*5""/*7$7)0C7A*

QZS.9<28*<*,$&$+1,(.W*X+#/.:11BU&-%+'?8$?%*.<1>*<*,$#.$1B&3

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

/1$* #%"C&.0.)* U"%)(* JC0%&;1.* ]1./* T7%104&^* "%'1.&M1)&".7* &.;42/0,* C"R$#*]C01.&.'*=&7&".^9*%2.7*#%"'%1C7*]D&L0*%&/079*!8J79*5""/*;".50%0.;07*1./*)"2%79*;2%%&;242C7* 0);A^* )"* ;%01)0* (014)($9* 1G1%09* 1./* 727)1&.1D40* ;"CC2.&)&07* &.* )(0*30G&7(*G"%4/*1./*D0$"./*]Wl&7&".*1./*:&77&".Xâ*30G&7(*O1%C*8;(""4*1./* &)7*#1%).0%9*[1$1C*O1%C9*1.*0.=&%".C0.)14*0/2;1)&".*"%'1.&M1)&".*G("70*C&77&".*&7*)"*#%1;)&;0*1./*#%"C")0*727)1&.1D40*1'%&;24)2%0*1./*)"*72##"%)*5""/*7$7)0C7*%"")0/*&.* F27)&;0* 1./* 30G&7(* )%1/&)&".7* ]WS("*S0*J%0Xâ* 8("%07(9*G(&;(* %2.7* 30G&7(*0.=&%".C0.)14*#%"'%1C7*&.*N"%".)"9*14".'*G&)(*&)7*51%C*0/2;1)&".14*;0.)0%*1./*!8J9*)(%"2'(*[1=1..1(*<1%/0.*]W!1.1/&1.*8"&49*30G&7(*6"")7Xâ*H0%C1;24)2%0*.0)G"%L9*G(&;(*&.;42/07*C"%0*)(1.*b?*#0%C1;24)2%0*51%C7*&.*T7%104*)(1)*1%0*"#0.*)"*="42.)00%7*1./*70%=0*17*0/2;1)&".14*)%1&.&.'*;0.)0%7a*30G&7(*!8J79*G(&;(*1%0*51%C7*)(1)*#%"=&/0*"%'1.&;*1./*4";14*5""/*)"*.01%D$*;&)&07a*J/1C1(*]1./*-%D1.*J/1C1(^9* 1.* "%'1.&M1)&".* )(1)* ;"..0;)7* #0"#40* )"* )(0* 41./9* ;"CC2.&)$* 1./*32/1&7C*)"*D2&4/*1*C"%0*727)1&.1D40*G"%4/9*&.)0'%1)&.'*#($7&;149*7";&149*7#&%&)2149*30G&7(*1./*0;"4"'&;14*%014C7*)"*;%01)0*1*4&50*"5*70%=&;0*)"*)(0*;"CC2.&)$*1./*)(0*01%)(*)(%"2'(*0/2;1)&".14*#%"'%1C7*1./*51%C&.'*0I#0%&0.;07*]WJ/1C1(Xâ*N0=1*Q01%.&.'*!0.)0%9*1*51%C*1./*0/2;1)&".14*;0.)0%*)(1)*)%1.75"%C7*30G&7(*0/2;1)&".*)(%"2'(*0I#0%&0.)&14*401%.&.'9*5"7)0%&.'*30G&7(*1./*0.=&%".C0.)14*727)1&.1D&4&)$*]WN0=1*Q01%.&.'*J44&1.;0XÂ* T.* 1//&)&".* )"* )(070* %04&'&"27t7";&14* "%'1.&M1)&".79*)(0*30G&7(*604&'&"27*/0."C&.1)&".7* &.*U"%)(*JC0%&;1*0.;"2%1'0*B;"*[17(%2)9*)(%"2'(*72;(*&.7)&)2)&".7*72;(*17*:1'0.*NM0/0L*1./*-%&*QPNM0/0LA*

Q[S.E%+$+\?*

S(&40*)(0*30G&7(*5%1C0G"%L*(17*1./*;".)&.207*)"*#%"=&/0*1.*1##%"1;(*)"*1*30G&7(*727)1&.1D40*5""/*7$7)0C9*".0*"5*&)7*G01L.07707*&7*)(1)*&)*/"07*.")*"2)4&.0*1*;"C#40)0*1./*;"C#%0(0.7&=0*&.7)%2;)&".*5"%*1*727)1&.1D40*5""/*7$7)0CA*61)(0%9*

73

".0*(17* )"* 1;)&=04$*/%1G*2#".*/&550%0.)* 17#0;)7* "5* )(0* 41G* )"* ;%01)0* 1* 7$7)0C9*G(&;(* 401=07* %""C* 5"%* 1CD&'2&)$* 17*G044* 17* 1#1)($A*J7*G0449* 727)1&.1D40* 5""/*C"=0C0.)7*1%0*;%&)&;&M0/*5"%*)(0*41;L*"5*1;;077&D&4&)$A*S(&40*)(0%0*1%0*1*.2CD0%*"5*C"=0C0.)7* )(%"2'("2)*U"%)(*JC0%&;19* )(0$*1%0* 41%'04$*&.*C1F"%*;&)&079* )(27*401=&.'*50G*"#)&".7*5"%*C1.$*JC0%&;1.7*1./*!1.1/&1.7A*J//&)&".144$9*727)1&.1D40*5""/*7$7)0C7*1%0*"5)0.*;%&)&;&M0/*5"%*)(0*(&'(*;"7)*"5*5""/9*G(&;(*";;2%7*D0;1270*)(0%0* 1%0* ."* (&//0.* 0.=&%".C0.)14* 1./* 7";&14* ;"7)79* 2.4&L0* )(0* ;".=0.)&".14*7$7)0CA*Q17)4$9*G(&40*)(0*C"=0C0.)*&7*'%"G&.'*1./*0.)0%&.'*&.)"*30G&7(*5"%C14*1./* &.5"%C14* 0/2;1)&".14* ;2%%&;242C79* &)* %0C1&.7* 1* 5%&.'0* "%* .&;(0*C"=0C0.)9*1./*(17*1* 4".'*G1$*)"*'"*)"*D0* )("%"2'(4$*&C#40C0.)0/*&.*C1&.7)%01C*30G&7(*0/2;1)&".*)(%"2'("2)*30G&7(*;"CC2.&)&07*G"%4/G&/0A***

E1,'8?#+1,

* N(0* 30G&7(* 5%1C0G"%L9* 14".'* G&)(* ")(0%* 727)1&.1D40* 1'%&;24)2%0*C"=0C0.)79* 1%0* )"'0)(0%* )%1.75"%C&.'* )(0* ;".=0.)&".14* 5""/* 7$7)0C* 5%"C* )(0*

71&/9*WU"*4".'0%* )1L0.*5"%*'%1.)0/*"%*=&0G0/*&.* &7"41)&".9*5""/*;1.*1./*7("24/*D0* ;"..0;)0/* )"* ;"CC2.&)$* =&)14&)$9* ;24)2%14* 72%=&=149* 0;"."C&;* /0=04"#C0.)9*7";&14* F27)&;09* 0.=&%".C0.)14* K214&)$9* 0;"4"'&;14* &.)0'%&)$* 1./* (2C1.* (014)(X*]R&.%&;(7* 1./* Q$7".* `^A* N(279* D")(* %"")0/* &.* )(0* 1.;&0.)9* 1./* 7)&44* 0I)%0C04$*%040=1.)* 5"%*;".)0C#"%1%$*7";&0)$9*32/1&7C*#%"=&/07*1* )(0"%0)&;14*1./*#%1;)&;14*5%1C0G"%L*5"%*72##"%)&.'*727)1&.1D40*5""/*7$7)0C7*1./*)(27*5""/*70;2%&)$A**S(&40*)(0*;".=0.)&".14*7$7)0C*&7*.")*4&L04$*)"*2./0%'"*1*72//0.*%1/&;14*)%1.75"%C1)&".9*)("271./7*"5*#0"#40*1%0*#1%)&;&#1)&.'*&.*;".)0C#"%1%$*5""/*C"=0C0.)7a*)(0$*1%0*4&)0%144$*;(0G&.'*".*)(0*%"")7*"5*;(1.'0A*N(0%0*&7*%&;(*#")0.)&14*&.*)(0*1D&4&)$*"5*#0"#40*)"*"%'1.&M0*1./*%07(1#0*)(0*5""/*7$7)0C*5%"C*)(0*'%177%"")7*2#A*N(0*D""L*N$$7&N="0%*1%)&;241)07*)(0*&C#"%)1.;0*"5*5""/*1./*&)7*#41;0*G&)(&.*)(0*41%'0%*%014C*"5* 727)1&.1D&4&)$*G044,* W-4)&C1)04$9*G(1)* 727)1&.1D&4&)$* %0K2&%07*"5*27* &7*;(1.'0*&.*'4"D14*7";&0)$*17*1*G("40e*N"*7)1%)* )(0*'4"D14* )17L* )"*G(&;(*G0*1%0*;1440/9*

&.&)&1)0*)(0*7C1449*%05"%C&7)*;(1.'07*)(1)*G0*;1.*".4$*("#0*C1$*7"C0*/1$*D0;"C0*%1/&;144$*)%1.75"%C1)&=0A*S0*7)1%)*G&)(*5""/AX*]E41$VH14C0%*@^A*E&)1$P1=".@z*O"%*1*727)1&.1D40*1./*0K2&)1D40*5""/*7$7)0Cz**

G&%D=2+"*&-,"#;&.$?&-$&<,=&M=6+%,&N"0)&I2,$$*&>$0&D0$A+7+#/&+#A"*?":*=&0=%$?02=%&>$0&-,=&0=%="02,&"#7&2$)D*=-+$#&$>&-,+%&D"D=0P

1*R0D%0G*5"%*E".*J##0)&)0

74

S"%L7*!&)0/

WJ/1C1(AX*H%":=**"&N0==7)"#&M=6+%,&(=-0="-&!=#-=0A*>?@@A*S0DA*@_*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,tt&71D04415%00/C1.A"%'t1/1C1(uA

E0417;"9* 32/&)(9* 327)&.* <"4/7)0&.9* BC&4$* !"C&71%9* U&'04* 81=1'09* 1./* J..1*R1.12A* *R1M".*T.;A*]>?@@^A*H%&.)A

E41$VH14C0%9*J4&7".A*N$$7&N="0%E&>0$)&H#7?%-0+"*&-$&I?%-"+#":*=&N$$7&I.%-=)%A*J4/0%7(")9*B.'41./,*J7('1)0*H2DA9*>??fA*H%&.)A

W!1.1/&1.*8"&49*30G&7(*6"")7AX*I,$0=%,&M=6+%,&S#A+0$#)=#-"*&F0$/0")%A*>?@@A*S0DA*@_*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,tt7("%07(A;1tuA

OJZA* WO""/* 80;2%&)$* 8)1)&7)&;7AX*A*>?@@A*S0DA*@f*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,ttGGGA51"A"%'t0;"."C&;t

077t077V57t0.tuA

O"%/9* 31C07A* W827)1&.1D40* \0=04"#C0.)AX* <0"'%1#(&;14* H0%7#0;)&=07,* S"%4/*B.=&%".C0.)14*H%"D40C7A*!1.1/19*:".)%014A*80#)A*>??fA*Q0;)2%0A

W<4"D14* O""/* H%&;07* &.* >?@@,* y207)&".7* n* J.7G0%7AX* A*ZI51C9*>?@@A*S0DA*@b*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,ttGGGA"I51CA"%'t0.t;1C#1&'.7t1'%&;24)2%0t5""/V#%&;0V;%&7&7VK207)&".7V1.7G0%7uA

W<4"D14*R2.'0%*\0;4&.&.'9*D2)*8)&44*-.1;;0#)1D4$*R&'(AX*N$$7&"#7&G/0+2?*-?0=&A*B;"."C&;*1./*8";&14*\0=04"#C0.)*

\0#1%)C0.)9* 80#)A* >?@?A* S0DA* @b* U"=A* >?@@A* v())#,ttGGGA51"A"%'t/";%0#t?@>t14bi?0t14bi?0??A#/5uA

G/0+2?*-?0"*& Q+:0"0.A*J4)0%.1)&=0* O1%C&.'* 8$7)0C7* T.5"%C1)&".* !0.)0%9*>??`A* S0DA* @_* U"=A* >?@@A* v())#,ttGGGA.14A27/1A'"=t157&;t#2D7t)0%C7t7%Dii?>A7()C4uA

R07)0%C1.9*Z%1.*EA*N"+0&N$$7E&50$6+#/&"&C="*-,.'&I?%-"+#":*=&N$$7&I.%-=)&>$0&G**A*U0G*m"%L,*H2D4&;J551&%79*>?@@A*H%&.)A

R&.%&;(79* !A* !41%0A9* 1./* N("C17* JA* Q$7".A*N$$7&I.%-=)E&I-0"-=/+=%& >$0&I?%-"+#":+*+-.A*Q&.;"4.9*U0DA,*-.&=0%7&)$*"5*U0D%17L19*>??fA*H%&.)A

75

R"4C'%0.9* \1=&/A* WB770.;0* "5* H0%C1;24)2%0,* J* 82CC1%$* "5* H0%C1;24)2%0*!".;0#)7* 1./* H%&.;&#407AX* F=0)"2?*-?0=& F0+#2+D*=%& "#7& F"-,6".%&9=.$#7& I?%-"+#":+*+-.A* R"4C'%0.* \07&'.* 80%=&;079* >??À*S0DA* v())#,tt#0%C1;24)2%0#%&.;&#407A;"Ct5%00/"G.4"1/7w0770.;0A#(#uA

30G&7(*O1%C*8;(""4A* A*cJ./*J77";1&)0/* 7"2%;0,*80/0%*p1%&P&C*QPp0C1.1.2*R1''1/1(dA* 30G&7(*O1%C*8;(""4,*8)2/0.)*B/&)&"#*]>??iÂ*H%&.)A

MFI&<"#";,E&<,=&C$*.&I20+D-?0=%P*H(&41/04#(&19*HJ,*30G&7(*H2D4&;1)&".*8";&0)$9*>??fA*H%&.)A

[&%7;(0.D12C9* J1%".A* SO?+-.& +#& M=6+%,& Q"6E& :=.$#7& SO?+-.E& C"*";,+2&G%D+0"-+$#+%)& +#& M=6+%,& !+A+*& Q"6A* R"D"L0.9* U3,* [NJl* H2DA* R"2709*@ii@A*H%&.)A

:1.0419*31L&%9*;"C#A*<R=7=;&<R=7=;&<+07$>E&I$?02=:$$;&>$0&\07&G##?"*&Z".")&N"0)& 9=+-& 4+70"%,A* cJ./* [&41$&C* ;2%%&;242C* G"%L7(00)dA* :1%$41./,*[1$1C*O1%C9*>?@@A*H%&.)A

:1.0419* 31L&%9* ;"C#A*3=&3+**& (=-?0#& <$& ]$?E& G& M=6+%,& I$?02=:$$;& $#& Q"#7'&G/0+2?*-?0=&"#7&I?%-"+#":+*+-.A*:1%$41./,*[1$1C*O1%C9*>?@?A*H%&.)A

:1&C".&/079*:"707A*<,=&5?+7=&>$0&-,=&F=0D*=@=7A*N%1.7A*:A*O%&0/41./0%A*>./*0/A*@i?gA* S0DA* v())#,ttGGGA)01;(&))"C0A;"Ct705"%&C>t705"%&Ct)(0w'2&/0w5"%w)(0w#0%#40I0/A#/5uA

W60#"%)*"5*)(0*S"%4/*!"CC&77&".*".*B.=&%".C0.)*1./*\0=04"#C0.),*Z2%*!"CC".*O2)2%0AX* A*-.&)0/*U1)&".7A* S0DA* @_* U"=A* >?@@A* v())#,ttGGGA2.V/";2C0.)7A.0)tG;0/V";5A()CuA

H#+-+"-+A=&S7+-+$#E&G&M$+#-&F0$1=2-&:=-6==#&^(M&"#7&C"R$#*]>??iÂ*H%&.)A

N045"%/9* 6&;(1%/9* 1./* \1=&/* J%."4/A* WH0%C1;24)2%0* B)(&;7a* H%&.;&#407a*O4"G0%AX* H0%C1;24)2%0* H%&.;&#407A* S0DA* 324$* >?@@A* v())#,ttGGGA#0%C1;24)2%0#%&.;&#407A;"CuA

<=A"&Q="0#+#/&G**+"#2=E&50$6+#/&M=6+%,&Q="0#+#/& >0$)&-,=&50$?#7&^DA*>?@@A*S0DA*>?*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,tt)0=1401%.&.';0.)0%A"%'tuA

76

WN(0*<4"D14*O""/*!%&7&7AX* A*ZI51C9*>?@@A*S0DA* @h*U"=A* >?@@A*v())#,ttGGGA"I51CA;1t.0G7V1./V#2D4&;1)&".7t.0G7t)(0V'4"D14V5""/V;%&7&7uA

Wl&7&".*1./*:&7&".AX*C"R$#E&M=6+%,&H#%D+0"-+$#'&I?%-"+#":*=&!$))?#+-+=%A*>?@@A*S0DA*@_*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,ttGGGA(1M".A"%'tuA

S17L"G9*J%)(2%*Z;01.A* A*U0G*m"%L,*y2&449*@ii_A*H%&.)A

WS(1)* T7* 827)1&.1D40* \0=04"#C0.)kX* T.)0%.1)&".14* T.7)&)2)0* 5"%* 827)1&.1D40*\0=04"#C0.)* ]TT8\^A* S0DA* b* 324$* >?@@A* v())#,ttGGGA&&7/A"%'t7/uA*

WS("*S0*J%0AX* I?%-"+#":*=& G/0+2?*-?0=& ($$-=7& +#& M=6+%,& <0"7+-+$#%A* 30G&7(*O1%C*8;(""49*>?@@A*S0DA*>?*U"=A*>?@@A*v())#,ttGGGAF0G&7(51%C7;(""4A"%'tG("VG0V1%0tuA

S"4559*JL&=1A*W30G&7(*H0%7#0;)&=07*".*<0.0)&;*B.'&.00%&.'AX*H#%-+-?-=&>$0&5*$:"*&M=6+%,& G>>"+0%A* Z;)A* >??@A* S0DA* >?* U"=A* >?@@A* v())#,ttGGGAF;#1A"%'t3!HJtN0C#41)07t8("GH1'0A17#k\6TNx`uA

m15509*:1%)&.*\A*M?7"+%)&"#7&S#A+0$#)=#-"*&S-,+2%E&"&(="7=0A*Q1.(1C9*:\,*Q0I&.')".9*>??@A*H%&.)A

77

!"#$%&'()'*%+,!(,#,-./01234'#55637208257'#9-:6.2325.'03;'+;<0270'=6;0370'05'>-?1965'-:'+2;':-1'(3;20@5'A-16575'

!"#$%&'"()#*%+

78

N(0"%$*&.*H%1;)&;0,*!"C#1%&.'*B770.)&14&7)*B;"50C&.&7C*1./*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*17*8"2%;07*"5*J&/*5"%*T./&1P7*O"%07)7*

!"#$%&'$(*N(0* 7$7)0C1)&;*/07)%2;)&".*"5* T./&1P7* 5"%07)7* &7* 1.* &7720* )(1)* ;1.*."*

D&"/$.1C&;*0.)&)&079*)(&7*0771$*;".7)%2;)&=04$*;"C#1%07*)(0*R&./2*7;(""4*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*)"*)(0*0770.)&14&7)*D%1.;(*"5*0;"50C&.&7CA*\20*)"*&)7*C".&7)&;*#(&4"7"#($*1./* 7$C#1)($* )"G1%/7* /0=")&".14* L."G40/'09* J/=1&)1* l0/1.)1* &7* 24)&C1)04$*7("G.* )"* D0* 1*C"%0* =&1D40* "#)&".* 5"%* 1.7G0%&.'* )(&7*C177* 0;"V;%&7&7* )(1.* )(0*

N(0*5"%07)7*"5*T./&1*(1=0*D00.*(1&40/*1%"2./*)(0*G"%4/*17*)(0*C"7)*=&)14*.1)2%14*%07"2%;0*"5*)(0*;"2.)%$A*J7*7045V727)1&.&.'9*D&"/$.1C&;9*1./*(1%C".&"27*0.)&)&079*)(0*5"%07)7*1%0*%0'1%/0/*.")*".4$*17*71;%0/9*D2)*17*".0*"5*)(0*"%'1.&M1)&".14*

D00.*7$7)0C1)&;144$*0I#4"&)0/*1./*/07)%"$0/*7&.;0*)(0*/1$7*"5*E%&)&7(*;"4".&14&7)*)&CD0%*C&.&.'A*T.*I-".+#/&G*+A=E&3$)=#'&S2$*$/.&"#7&I?0A+A"*&+#&H#7+"'&l1./1.1*

&'."%&.'*)(0*;"C#40I*%041)&".7(&#*G&)(&.*)(0*5"%07)*;"CC2.&)$*1./*D0)G00.*#41.)*4&50*1./*")(0%*%07"2%;07*4&L0*7"&4*1./*G1)0%9*)(&7*#1))0%.*"5*%07"2%;0*270*'0.0%1)07*&.7)1D&4&)&07* &.* )(0*0;"7$7)0C*1./*401/7* )"*;"2.)0%#%"/2;)&=0*270*"5*.1)2%0*17*1*4&=&.'*1./*7045V%0#%"/2;&.'*%07"2%;0X*]8(&=1*hbÂ*82;(*/07)%2;)&".*147"*/0.&07*)(0*%&'()7*"5*)("70*#0"#407*Y*C1&.4$*G"C0.*1./*)%&D14*'%"2#7*Y*)(1)*/0#0./*".*)(0*/&=0%70*%07"2%;0*52.;)&".7*"5*)(0*5"%07)7*5"%*)(0&%*72%=&=14*]8(&=1*hbÂ*S&)(*7)&44*=0%$*4&))40*1;)&".*/&%0;)0/*)"G1%/*)(0*#%")0;)&".*"5*)(0*5"%07)7*)"/1$9*)&C0*&7*%2..&.'*"2)A*N(279*)(&7*0771$*G&44*4""L*)"*7"C0*#")0.)&14*7"2%;07*"5*1&/*5"%*)(&7*0;"V;%&7&7A*J7*1*%1/&;14*C"=0C0.)*)(1)*&7*;0.)%144$*;".;0%.0/*G&)(*1440=&1)&.'*)(0*7$7)0C1)&;*"##%077&".*1./*0I#4"&)1)&".*"5*G"C0.*1./*.1)2%09*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7C*G&44*D0*;"C#1%0/*;".7)%2;)&=04$*)"*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)19*1*72D70)*"5*)(0*l0/1.)1*7;(""4*"5*R&./2&7C*)(1)*&7*#%&C1%&4$*;".;0%.0/*G&)(*)(0*4&D0%1)&".*"5*D0&.'7A*N(%"2'(*1.*0I1C&.1)&".*"5*D")(*7$7)0C79*)(&7*0771$*G&44*7("G*)(1)*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1P7*C".&7)&;*#(&4"7"#($* 1./* 7$C#1)($* )"G1%/7* /0=")&".14* L."G40/'0* C1L07* )(0* )%1/&)&".*D0))0%*0K2&##0/*)"*/014*G&)(* )(0*T./&1.*0;"V;%&7&7*"5*5"%07)*/07)%2;)&".*)(1.*)(0*

O%"C* &)7* "%&'&.79* 0770.)&14&7)* 0;"50C&.&7C* (17* ("270/* 1* 7)%".'* 72DVC"=0C0.)*5"2./0/*".*C1)0%.14*#%&.;&#407A*T%0.0*\&1C"./*1./*<4"%&1*Z%0.7)0&.*7#01L* )"* )(&7*C"/04* &.*(=6="A+#/& -,=&3$0*7E& -,=& S)=0/=#2=& $>& S2$>=)+#+%)P&T.*)(0*D""LP7*&.)%"/2;)&".*)(0*12)("%7*G%&)09*WN(%"2'(*)(0*7";&14*0I#0%&0.;0*"5*;1%0)1L&.'*1./*.2%)2%&.'9*G"C0.*D0;"C0*1))0.)&=0*)"*)(0*7&'.7*"5*/&7)%077*&.*)(0&%*;"CC2.&)&07*)(1)*C&'()*)(%01)0.*)(0&%*("270("4/7X*]\&1C"./*1./*Z%0.7)0&.*@?Â**\&1C"./*1./*Z%0.7)0&.P7*&.)0%#%0)1)&".*"5*1.*&..1)0*;"..0;)&".*D0)G00.*G"C0.*

79

1./*.1)2%0*;401%4$*1##0147*)"*1*7)%".'*;".;0#)&".*"5*)(0*C1)0%.14A*N(0*7;("41%7*'"*".*)"*1%'20*)(1)*72;(*1*;"..0;)&".*0I&7)7*".*1*C1)0%&14*40=049*17*G044*17*1*7$CD"4&;*".0A*O"%*&.7)1.;09*\&1C"./*1./*Z%0.7)0&.*G%&)0*)(1)*WD0;1270*"5*G"C0.P7*2.&K20*%"407* &.* )(0* D&"4"'&;14* %0'0.0%1)&".* "5* )(0* 7#0;&079* "2%* D"/&07* 1%0* &C#"%)1.)*C1%L0%79* )(0* 7&)07*2#".*G(&;(* 4";149* %0'&".149*"%* 0=0.*#41.0)1%$* 7)%077* &7*"5)0.*#41$0/*"2)X*]\&1C"./*1./*Z%0.7)0&.*@?Â*!1%"4$.*:0%;(1.)*0I#1./7*".*)(&7*=0%$*#($7&;149*&..1)0*;"..0;)&".*&.*)(0*;(1#)0%*W<1&1,*B;"50C&.&7C*1./*)(0*B1%)(X*"5*(0%*D""L*S"0-,2"0=P&%1/&"1;)&=&)$*5%"C*.2;401%*#"G0%V#41.)*1;;&/0.)79*)"I&;*;(0C&;1479*1./*(1M1%/"27*G17)07* )(%01)0.* )(0* D&"4"'&;14* %0#%"/2;)&".* "5* )(0* (2C1.* 7#0;&079* G"C0.*0I#0%&0.;0*)(&7*;".)%1/&;)&".*17*177124)7*".*)(0&%*"G.*D"/&07*1./*".*)("70*"5*)(0&%*;(&4/%0.*1./*1;)* )"*(14)* )(0CX*]:0%;(1.)*`Â*Q&L0*\&1C"./*1./*Z%0.7)0&.9*7(0*1##0147*)"*)(0*G"C1.V17VC")(0%A*J7*700.*07#0;&144$*G&)(*:0%;(1.)P7*0I#41.1)&".9*)(&7*7)%1./*"5*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7)*)("2'()*5";2707*".*)(0*%0149*)1.'&D40*0550;)7*504)*5%"C*)(0*.1)2%0VG"C0.*;"..0;)&".A*O%"C*72;(*1*#0%7#0;)&=09*&)*&7*".4$*.1)2%14*5"%*1*C")(0%*)"*1/=";1)0*1'1&.7)*)(0*)"I&.7*)(1)*1%0*(1%C524*)"*(0%*;(&4/%0.9*1./*

N(0*&7720*4&07*&.*)(0*C1)0%.14*;(1%1;)0%&M1)&".7*)(1)*1%0*7"*52./1C0.)14*)"*)(070*1%'2C0.)7A*J4)("2'(*C1.$*"5*)(0*G"C0.*1550;)0/*D$*)(0*/07)%2;)&".*"5*T./&1P7* 5"%07)7*C1$* &./00/*D0*C")(0%79* )(0"%&7)7* (1=0* K207)&".0/* )(0* 0I)0.)* )"*G(&;(*)(&7*7)%1./*"5*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7C*1;)2144$*0C#"G0%7*G"C0.A*J./%01*!1C#D044*#%"=&/07*1*D%&05*72CC1)&".*"5*".0*;"CC".*"DF0;)&".*)"*)(&7*C"/04A*T.*

*7(0*G%&)079*WU1)2%0*&7*700.*&.*"##"7&)&".*)"*;24)2%09*1./*%0#%070.)7*50C1409*.".(2C1.*;(1%1;)0%&7)&;7*G(&40*;24)2%0*;".7&7)7*"5*C1409*(2C1.*%0#%070.)1)&".7A*J*;24)2%0t.1)2%0*/214&7C*&7*;4"704$*%041)0/*)"*)(0*(2C1.t.".(2C1.*/214&7C*G&)(*G"C0.9*1.&C147*1./*.1)2%0*5144&.'*".*)(0*71C0*7&/0*&.*01;(*;170X*]!1C#D044*@bÂ*J4)("2'(*)(0*1%'2C0.)7*#2)*5"%)(*D$*:0%;(1.)9*\&1C"./9*Z%0.7)0&.9* 1./*")(0%* 0;"50C&.&7)7* "5* )(0* 0770.)&14&7)*C"=0C0.)*C1$*7)%0.')(0.*)(0*D"./*D0)G00.*G"C0.*1./*.1)2%09*)(0$*/"*.")*7"4=0*)(0*#%"D40C*"5*("G*72;(*1*D"./*G&44*"=0%;"C0*)(0*"##%077&=0*5"%;07*"5*#1)%&1%;($A*J7*7("G.*D$* !1C#D0449* 2./0%* )(&7* 4"'&;* G"C0.* 1%0* '%"2#0/* )"'0)(0%* G&)(* 144* )(1)* &7*.".V(2C1.9*0770.)&144$* 4"G0%&.'* )(0&%*#41;0* &.* )(0*"=0%144*(&0%1%;($*"5*D0&.'7A*

#1)%&1%;(14* &/0"4"'&07*"##%077*D")(*G"C0.*1./*.1)2%0A*N(279* &5* )(0*0770.)&14&7)*C"=0C0.)*;1..")*/0D2.L*)(0*5"%;07*)(1)*"##%077*G"C0.9*&)*;1..")*0I)0./*C2;(*%04&05*)"*.1)2%0*0&)(0%A*82;(*0770.)&14&7)*4&.07*"5*)("2'()*)(0.*/"*.")*#%"=0*)"*D0*#1%)&;241%4$*270524*&.*1440=&1)&.'*)(0*"##%077&".*)(1)*#41'207*T./&1P7*5"%07)7A*

J.")(0%* 4&.0* "5* ;%&)&K20* )"G1%/7* 0770.)&14&7)* 0;"50C&.&7C* 7#01L7* )"*)(0* C"=0C0.)P7* /&7)&.;)4$* S07)0%.* %"")7A* Q12%1* S%&'()* 7007* )(0* #%0=&"274$*

G"%4/* #0%7#0;)&=0A* T.* WH%"#(0;$9* :")(0%4077.0779* 1./* )(0* Q1L0,* H"7);"4".&14*B;"50C&.&7C*1./*O4"%1*UG1#1P7*S>?0?'X*S%&'()*;".)0./7*)(1)*;".7)%2;)&".7*72;(*

80

17*:")(0%*B1%)(*&C#4$*W51C&4&14*2.&)$*5"%*144*4&=&.'*D0&.'7*)(1)*&.(1D&)*)(0*#41.0)9*1./* )(0* &.51.)&4&M&.'* %(0)"%&;* "5* j:")(0%*!"2.)%&07P* %07#".7&D40* 5"%* )(0"%0)&;14*;&=&4&M1)&".9*0.4&'()0.C0.)9*1./*C1&.)0.1.;0*"5*)(0*j;(&4/%0.P*)(1)*&.(1D&)0/*)(0&%*;"4".&07X*]S%&'()*igÂ*T./00/9*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7C*%2.7*)(0*%&7L*"5*1/"#)&.'*

4&D0%1)0/*.0&)(0%*G"C0.*."%*.1)2%0A*T/0"4"'&;14*&C#4&;1)&".7*17&/09*("G0=0%9*)(0*1##4&;1)&".*"5*1*S07)0%.*C"=0C0.)*)"*1*)(&%/*G"%4/*70))&.'*C1$*147"*D0*5%12'()*

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`>Â* O2%)(0%C"%09* )(0* 0;"50C&.&7)* #%&.;&#40* )(1)* G"C0.* (1=0* 1*7#0;&14* %041)&".7(&#* G&)(* .1)2%0*C01.7* )(1)* #"4&;$* 1/=";1)07* )0./* )"* '%1=&)1)0*)"G1%/*&/017*"5*G"C0.P7*.1)2%14&M0/*0$*=%9*%1)(0%*)(1.*0+/,-%*]J'1%G149*W!(1440.'0*5"%* B;"50C&.&7CX* @>Â* * J7* 14%01/$* 0I1C&.0/* &.* )(&7* 0771$9* 72;(* %0/2;)&=0*;1)0'"%&M1)&".*/"07*.")*)%1.741)0*&.)"*)(0*4&D0%1)&".*"5*G"C0.A*N(&7*&7*0=&/0.)*'&=0.*)(0*;2%%0.)*7)1)27*"5*=&441'0*;"CC2.&)$*5"%07)*'%"2#79*G(&;(*;"C#%&70*1*L0$*#1%)*"5*)(0*0.=&%".C0.)14*C"=0C0.)*&.*T./&1A*J'1%G14*.")07*)(1)*D")(*7)1)0V&.&)&1)0/*1./*7045V&.&)&1)0/*'%"2#7*1%0*;".7&7)0.)4$*C140VD&170/*1./*"5)0.*501)2%0*".4$*C140*C0CD0%7(&#*]J'1%G149*W!(1440.'0*5"%*B;"50C&.&7CX*@>V@bÂ*!401%4$9*)(0*/0.&14*"5*G"C0.P7*%&'()7*&7*7)&44*7"C0G(1)*&'."%0/*&.*D")(*)(0*50C&.&7)*1./*0.=&%".C0.)14*C"=0C0.)7*&.*T./&1A*B7#0;&144$*'&=0.*)(0*/0427&".*)(1)*G"C0.*1%0*5244$*0K2&##0/*17*1;)&=0*1'0.)7*"5*;(1.'09*&)*C1$*D0*41%'04$*2.5017&D40*5"%*T./&1.*G"C0.*)"*1##014*)"*1.*0;"50C&.&7)*5%1C0G"%LA*<1&.&.'*C"C0.)2C*1./*;%0/&D&4&)$*5%"C*72;(*1.*1##014*C1$*147"*#%"=0* )"*D0* &C#"77&D40* &.* T./&1* 5"%* %017".7* 72;(*17* 1* 41;L*"5*%07"2%;07A*S&/07#%01/*&44&)0%1;$*1./*#"=0%)$*&.*T./&1*/"*.")*;"&.;&/0*G044*G&)(*1*(01=&4$*)0I)2149*)(0"%$VD170/*C"=0C0.)9*07#0;&144$*G(0.*)(0*7)1L07*1%0*#%077&.'A*

N(&7*0771$*(17*14%01/$*0I1C&.0/*)(0*0770.)&14&7)*C"=0C0.)P7*)0./0.;$*)"*("4/*;24)2%0*1./*.1)2%0*&.*"##"7&)&".*)"*".0*1.")(0%*)(%"2'(*&)7*270*"5*/214&7C79*1./* ("G* )(&7* )0./0.;$* 70%=07* )"* 1;)2144$* %0&.5"%;0* #1)%&1%;(14* "##%077&".A*J7*!1C#D044* .")079* W)(0%0* &7* ."* %""C* 5"%* .0'")&1)&".* D0)G00.* ;24)2%0* 1./* .1)2%0*G(0.*#41;0/*&.*"##"7&)&".*)"*".0*1.")(0%X*]!1C#D044*fÂ*m0)*72;(*1.*"##"7&)&".*

T./&1.* 5"%07)7A* T.* WB;"50C&.&7C,* N(0* BI#4"&)1)&".* "5* U1)2%0* 1./* S"C0.9X*

)0%C7* "5* (&0%1%;($* 401/7* )"* 0I#4"&)1)&".* "5* D")(* .1)2%0* 1./*G"C0.* 1./* )(1)* 1*.0G* C"%14&)$* "5* &.)0%%041)0/.077* &7* .00/0/X* ][&.740$* >?hÂ* Z.;0* 1'1&.9* ".0*7007* )(0* "##"7&.'* ;24)2%0V.1)2%0* /214&)$* 1)* G"%L9* 1./* 4&L0* C1.$* 0770.)&14&7)*

81

"5*(&0%1%;(&;14*7";&0)14*7)%2;)2%079*G(&;(*&7*1*#1%)&;241%4$*)%"2D4&.'*1%'2C0.)*&.*1.*T./&1.*;".)0I)A*Z5*;"2%709*1.*"=0%G(04C&.'*1C"2.)*"5*)(0*T./&1.*#"#241)&".*

W(&0%1%;(&;144$X*)(%"2'(*;".;0#)7*72;(*17*L1%C1*)(0"%$*1./*%0&.;1%.1)&".A*N(279*G&)(* 72;(* 7$7)0C7* "5* W(&0%1%;(&07X* D=0%$#"**.& 1./* 0=*+/+$?%*.& &.5"%C&.'* )(0*4&=07*"5*7"*C1.$*T./&1.79*1*'0.0%14&M&.'*;%&)&K20*"5*;24)2%14*(&0%1%;(&07*7)%".'4$*

W1*.0G*C"%14&)$X*".4$*52%)(0%*72''07)7*)(1)*)(0*;2%%0.)*7$7)0C*"5*C"%14&)$*C27)*D0* /".0* 1G1$*G&)(9* )(&7* 7$7)0C* D0&.'*R&./2&7C* 5"%*C1.$* T./&1.7A* 8&.;0* )(&7*0771$*&7*;".;0%.0/*G&)(*;"CD1)&.'*)(0*5"%;07*)(1)*(1=0*0I#4"&)0/*)(0*5"%07)7*"#7&"##%0770/*)(0*T./&1.*#0"#409*1*=&0G*)(1)* &C#4&;&)4$*D2)* &.(0%0.)4$*;%&)&;&M07* )(0*;24)2%14V%04&'&"27*7$7)0C*"5*)("70*#0"#407*&7*.")*/07&%1D40A*

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a* &.*)(0*;170*"5*T./&1P7*%1#&/4$*#0%&7(&.'*5"%07)79* )&C0*&7*"5* )(0*0770.;0A*

N(0*)%1/&)&".*"5*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*(17*1/(0%0.)7*1;%"77*T./&1*1./*1%"2./*)(0* '4"D0A*N(0* %04&'&"27* )%1/&)&".* &7* ".0* "5* )(0* )G"*C1&.* /0=04"#C0.)7* "5* )(0*41%'0%*l0/1.)1*)%1/&)&".9*G(&;(*7;("41%*<1=&.*O4""/*(17*%050%%0/*)"*17*W)(0*C"7)*

D"0& =@2=**=#2=&7* (&'(4$* %0=0%0/* 1%"2./* )(0* G"%4/* $0)* 2.C&7)1L1D4$* T./&1.9*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*#%"=&/07*1*%&;(*70)*"5*/&=0%70*;24)2%14*#%&.;&#407*)(1)*1%0*;".7)%2;)&=04$*%040=1.)*)"*)(0*C1))0%*"5*#%")0;)&.'*T./&1P7*5"%07)7A

J7* 700.9*C1.$* "5* )(0* ;%&)&K207* 1'1&.7)* 0770.)&14&7)* 0;"50C&.&7C* 7)0C*5%"C* )(0*C"=0C0.)P7* #%"D40C1)&;* 72D7;%&#)&".* )"* /214&7CA*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1* &7*

"5* /214&7CA*N(0* )0%C*"7A"+-"& )%1.741)07* )"* W.".V/214X* 1./* &7* &./&;1)&=0* "5* )(0*1D7"42)0*C".&7)&;* #(&4"7"#($* )12'()*D$* )(0* )%1/&)&".P7* 5"2./0%9*8(1.L1%1A*N(&7*#(&4"7"#($*("4/7*)(1)9**

8#&%&)214*&'."%1.;0*]"A+7."^*"%*&4427&".*])"."^*&7*;1270/*D$*)(0*72#0%&C#"7&)&".*]"7,."%"^*"5*G(1)*&7*.")*)(0*7045*".)"*)(0*7045A*J44* L."G40/'0* &7* /&7)"%)0/* D$* 72#0%&C#"7&)&".* "%* #%"F0;)&".9*G(&;(* #%0=0.)7* 27* 5%"C* 700&.'* "2%* )%20* .1)2%0* 17* )(0* 7045P7*]"-)"#P7^* #2%0* 72DF0;)&=&)$9* ".)"4"'&;144$* &/0.)&;14* G&)(* )(0*1D7"42)0*]:0",)"#^*]O4""/*>g@^A

82

H2)*7&C#4$9*144*%014&)$*&7*".09*G&)(*."*/&7)&.;)&".7A*Q&D0%1)&".*&7*1;(&0=0/*)(%"2'(*)(0*%014&M1)&".*)(1)*)(0*70459*"%*"-)"#'*&7*".0*G&)(*)(0*1D7"42)0*90",)"#P&

)(0*1D7"42)0*#0%7#0;)&=0*"5*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)19*1.$*#0%;0&=0/*/&550%0.;0*D0)G00.*

l0/1.)1P7*C".&7C*147"*/"07*1G1$*G&)(*)(0*;24)2%0V.1)2%0*/214&7C*)(1)*#41'207*0770.)&14&7)* 0;"50C&.&7C9* )(27* ."* 4".'0%* ("4/&.'* )(0* )G"* &.* "##"7&)&".* )"* ".0*1.")(0%A* [&.740$* 041D"%1)07* ".* )(0* #"7&)&=0* 0.=&%".C0.)14* &C#4&;1)&".7* "5* )(&7*#(&4"7"#($*D$*.")&.'*)(1)*72;(*1.*2./0%7)1./&.'*W#2)7*".0*&.*)"2;(*G&)(*1*G&/0%*

;"..0;)0/*)"*.1)2%0*&.*)(&7*=&0G*#%0;&704$*D0;1270*."*/&550%0.;0*0I&7)7*D0)G00.*".07045*1./*.1)2%0A*N(&7*;"..0;)&".9*[&.740$*1770%)79*;%01)07*1*70.70*"5*;"CC2.&".*G&)(*)(0*0.=&%".C0.)9*7&.;0*W#%")0;)&".*"5*5%00*.1)2%0*&7*504)*1./*;".;0&=0/*"5*17*#%")0;)&".*"5*"2%*=0%$*704=07X*][&.740$*hbÂ*N"*/"*(1%C*".)"*.1)2%0*&7*)"*/"*(1%C*".)"*".070459*1./*=&;0*=0%719* )(27*#%"C")&.'*1*'0.0%14*0)(&;*"5*;1%0*5"%*.1)2%0A*N(279*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1* 72;;0775244$* "=0%;"C07* ;"C#4&;1)&".7* )(1)* 1%&70* "2)* "5*/214&7)&;*)(&.L&.'A*

R"G0=0%9*)(0*)%1/&)&".P7*C".&7)&;*#(&4"7"#($*/"07*.")*#%"=&/0*1*7"42)&".*)"* 144* "5* )(0* #%"D40C7* %1&70/* D$* 0770.)&14&7)* 0;"50C&.&7CA* Q&L0* 0;"50C&.&7C9*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*&7*1*(&'(4$*;"C#40I*1./*1D7)%1;)*7$7)0C*"5*)("2'()9*1*K214&)$*)(1)*'%01)4$*4&C&)7*)(0*1;;077&D&4&)$*"5*)(0*)%1/&)&".A*O2%)(0%C"%09*1;;077&D&4&)$*/"07*.")*.0;0771%&4$*51;&4&)1)0*;"C#%0(0.7&".9*7&.;0*2.0.4&'()0.0/*D0&.'79*G(&;(*&7*)"*71$9*C"7)*#0"#409*;1..")*700*%014&)$*5%"C*)(&7*1D7"42)0*C".&7)&;*#0%7#0;)&=0A*T./00/9*)(0*#1)(*"5*L."G40/'0*&7*1*4".'*1./*)2C24)2"27*".0*&.*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1A*T5* )(0*"DF0;)&=0*(0%0*&7*1*G&/07#%01/*;".7;&"27.077*"5*T./&1P7*5"%07)7*17*)%24$*;"..0;)0/*)"*)(0*70459*1*'0.0%14*2.1))1&.1D&4&)$*"5*)(&7*;".7;&"27.077*72''07)7*1*(2%/40*)(1)*C27)*D0*"=0%;"C0*D$*)(0*)%1/&)&".A*

m0)*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1* 1;;"2.)7* 5"%* 72;(* 1* ;"C#4&;1)&".* &.* 1* G1$* )(1)*0;"50C&.&7C* /"07* .")A*J4)("2'(* )(0* )%1/&)&".* &7* 2./"2D)0/4$* 7;("41%4$9*G(&;(*1'1&.*%1&707*)(0*&7720*"5*&.1;;077&D&4&)$9*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*0.;"C#17707*L."G40/'0*)(1)*&7*D0$"./*)(0*40=04*"5*)(0*)0I)A*N"*)(&7*0./9*O4""/*.")07*8(1.L1%1P7*;".;077&".*)"*)(0*&/01*"5*/0=")&".*)"*1*#0%7".14*Q"%/*17*1*5"%C*"5*L."G40/'0A*R0*G%&)07*)(1)*14)("2'(* &.* &)7*1D7"42)0* 5"%C*90",)"#* &7*D0$"./*144*K214&)&079*W&.* &)7* )0C#"%14*C"/0*17*)(0*Q"%/*&)*(17*1))%&D2)07*]%"/?#"^9*1./*7"*;1.*D0*1##%"1;(0/*)(%"2'(*/0=")&".*17*1.*"DF0;)*"5*;".7;&"27.077X*]O4""/*>g>Â*Z.0*C27)* %0C0CD0%* )(1)*&.*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)19*17*&.*R&./2&7C*1)*41%'09*90",)"#*&7*C1.&507)*&.*144*)(&.'79*%0'1%/4077*"5*)0C#"%14*1./*.".V)0C#"%14*C"/07A*

N("2'(* (0* %0'1%/0/* &)* 17* 1* 5"%C* "5* L."G40/'0* )(1)* &7* 4"G0%* )(1.*1D7"42)0*C".&7C9*8(1.L1%1*0=&/0.)4$*/&/*;".7&/0%*/0=")&".*)"*D0*1.*&C#"%)1.)*5"%C*"5*L."G40/'0* &.* &)7045A*O4""/* %1&707* )(0*#"&.)* )(1)* 1*.2CD0%*"5* )%1/&)&".7*1))%&D2)0* 8(1.L1%1*G&)(* )(0* 12)("%7(&#* "5* 1* 51C"27* ($C.* )"* )(0*<"//0779* )(0*I"?#7"0."*","0+&]O4""/*>g?Â*Z5*;"2%709*<"//077*G"%7(&#*;"C#%&707*1*;%&)&;14*

83

#1%)*"5*7"C0*R&./27P*#%1;)&;0*1./*%&)214A*[&.740$P7*/&7;277&".*"5*)(0*'"//077*81)&*&7*07#0;&144$*%040=1.)*&.*)(&7*%0'1%/A*N(0*7)"%$*"5*81)&*%0;"2.)7*)(0*'"//077P7*72&;&/09*G(&;(*G17* 5"44"G0/* D$* )(0* /&7C0CD0%C0.)* "5* (0%* ;"%#70* 1./* &)7* /&7)%&D2)&".*)(%"2'("2)* T./&1A* [&.740$* G%&)079* W144* "=0%* T./&19* 7(%&.07* 1./* )0C#407* 1%0*

&7* ;".;%0)04$* 177";&1)0/* G&)(* )(0* #($7&;14* D"/$* "5* 1* '"//077A* N(0* '"//077P7*D"/$*71;%14&M07*)(0*41./*2#".*G(&;(*#0"#40*4&=09*1./*)(0*41./*&7*)(0%05"%0*'&=0.*%0=0%0.;0*1./*%07#0;)X*][&.740$*_iÂ*N(279*1*7)%".'*4&.L*0I&7)7*D0)G00.*/0=")&".*)"*1*'"//077*1./*/0=")&".*)"*)(0*41./9*1*4&.L*;401%4$*%0;"'.&M0/*D$*)(0*5"2./0%*"5*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1A*N("2'(*7"C0*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7)7*/"*4"DD$*5"%*)(0*1/"#)&".*"5* 1* '"//077V"%&0.)0/* 2./0%7)1./&.'* "5* )(0* 0.=&%".C0.)9* 72;(* 1*C"/04* &7* 7)&44*/"C&.1)0/* D$* )(0*C"=0C0.)P7* ;"C#4&;1)&.'* /214&7)&;* /&7;"2%70A* !".)%17)&.'4$9*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*72;;0775244$*401=07*%""C*5"%*1.*14)0%.1)09*1;;077&D40*C"/04*)(1)*/"07*.")* ;"C#%"C&70* )(0* 7)%2;)2%0*"5* )(0* )%1/&)&".*1./* 7)&44*C1&.)1&.7* 1* 7)%".'*;"..0;)&".*)"*0;"V1G1%0.077*1./*#%")0;)&".A*

R"G0=0%9*."*/&7;277&".*"5*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*7("24/*'"*G&)("2)*C0.)&".*"5* )(0* ;"4".&14&7)* 5"%;07* )(1)* #"#241%&70/* )(0* 7;(""4A*J7*6&;(1%/*[&.'* 1770%)79*)(0%0*1%0*1*.2CD0%*"5*7";&"V(&7)"%&;14*%017".7*G($*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*(17*%0;0&=0/*#%1&70*5%"C*S07)0%.0%7A*O"%*&.7)1.;09*)(0*!(%&7)&1.*C&77&".1%&07*&.*T./&1*71G*)(0*#(&4"7"#(&;14*"%&0.)1)&".*"5*)(0*^D"#+%"7%&1./*)(0*5+-"&*17*1;)2144$*1/=1.)1'0"27*)"*)(0&%*055"%)7A*[&.'*.")07*)(1)*5"%*)("70*C&77&".1%&079

cNd(0*^D"#+%"7%&;"24/*147"*D0*270/*17*0=&/0.;0*"5*1.*&.;&#&0.)*C".")(0&7C* G&)(&.* )(0* R&./2* )%1/&)&".A* O"%* )(0* 4&D0%14*!(%&7)&1.* )(&7* #%"=&/0/* 1* #41)5"%C* 5"%* &.)0%V51&)(* /&14"'20*D0)G00.*!(%&7)&1.&)$*1./*R&./2&7C*1./*1*%0;"'.&)&".*"5*7"C0*;"CC".14&)$* D0)G00.* 51&)(7e* O"%* !(%&7)&1.7* G&)(* 1* C"%0*0=1.'04&;14* M0149* )(0* ^D"#+%"7%& %0#%070.)0/* 1* G1$* &.)"* )(0*jR&./2*C&./V70)P*G(&;(*"#0.0/*2#*)(0*#"77&D&4&)$*"5*;".=0%)&.'*R&./27*)"*!(%&7)&1.&)$*][&.'*@>>Â**

Z5* ;"2%709* 1*R&./2* 7;(""4* )(1)*S07)0%.0%7* ;"24/* 71504$* /00C* W#(&4"7"#(&;14X*G"24/*D0*)(0*4017)*4&L04$*)"*)(%01)0.*1*02%"V;0.)%&;*2./0%7)1./&.'*"5*L."G40/'0A*N(0* C&77&".1%&07* G0%0* C0%04$* ".0* '%"2#* )(1)* 7"2'()* )"* 0./"%709* 1./* &./00/*0I#4"&)9*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1* 5"%* ;"4".&14&7)* #2%#"707a* )(0%0*G0%0* 147"*C1.$9*C1.$*")(0%7A*J;;"%/&.'4$9* G0* 7("24/* %0;"'.&M0* )(1)*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1* (17* 4".'* D00.*#%&=&40'0/* "=0%* ")(0%* R&./2* 7;(""47* 1./* #%1;)&;079* 1./* )(1)* G0* C27)* .")* 5144*#%0$* )"* 50)&7(&M1)&".* D$*C&7)1L&.'* &)* 17* &4427)%1)&=0* "5* 144* R&./2&7C]7Â* T* (1=0*".4$* '&=0.* 1* D%&05* /&7;277&".* "5* 7"C0* "5* )(0* ")(0%9* 4077* #%&=&40'0/* D04&057* 1./*#%1;)&;07*177";&1)0/*G&)(*8(1.L1%1*(0%0*]72;(*17*'"//077*G"%7(&#^9*&.*)(0*("#07*"5*/0C".7)%1)&.'*)(0*/&=0%7&)$*"5*)(0*)%1/&)&".A*:"%0*&C#"%)1.)4$9*T*(1=0*4""L0/*)"*")(0%*G1$7*"5*2./0%7)1./&.'*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1* &.*1.*1))0C#)* )"* &'.&)0* 52%)(0%*

84

/&7;277&".*1D"2)*T./&1P7*0;"V;%&7&79*1./*)(0*D07)*G1$*)"*1.7G0%*&)A*N(279* &)* 7("24/* D0* .")0/* )(1)* )(0* 1&C* "5* )(&7* 0771$* G17* .0&)(0%* )"*

;"./0C.*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7C*."%*)"*'4"%&5$*J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1A*61)(0%9*&)*G17*)"*/0)0%C&.0*G(&;(* 7$7)0C* &7*D0))0%* 72&)0/* )"*;"#0*G&)(*".0*"5* )(0*C1F"%*0;"V;%&707* )(1)* ;2%%0.)4$* 51;07* T./&1,* )(0* 0I#4"&)1)&".*1./*/07)%2;)&".*"5* &)7* 5"%07)7A*

J/=1&)1*l0/1.)1*G"24/*D0*C"%0*72;;077524*)(1.*)(1)*"5*0770.)&14&7)*0;"50C&.&7CA*N(0*41))0%*G17*7("G.*)"*#0%#0)21)0*/214&7C79*G(&;(*2./0%C&.07*)(0*C"=0C0.)P7*

D")(*&/0"4"'&;144$*1./*#%1'C1)&;144$A*Z.*)(0*")(0%*(1./9*17*1.*14%01/$*%07#0;)0/*)%1/&)&".* &.* T./&19*J/=1&)1* l0/1.)1* #%070.)7* 1* C".&7)&;* #(&4"7"#($* G&)(* =0%$*#"7&)&=0* 0.=&%".C0.)14* &C#4&;1)&".79* G(&40* 7)&44* 401=&.'* %""C* 5"%* 1* C"%0*

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

85

S"%L7*!&)0/

J'1%G149*E&.1A*WJ*!(1440.'0*5"%*B;"50C&.&7C,*<0./0%9*<%00.&.'9*1./*!"CC2.&)$** O"%07)%$*&.*T./&1AX*3$)=#&"#7&S#A+0$#)=#-%&_>*]>??@^,*@>V@_A*H%&.)A*

VVVA*WB.=&%".C0.)14*:1.1'0C0.)9*BK2&)$*1./*B;"50C&.&7C,*\0D1)&.'*T./&1P7** BI#0%&0.;0AX*M$?0#"*&$>&F="%"#-&I-?7+=%A*>_Ag*]@iif^,*__Vi_A*H%&.)A

!1C#D0449*J./%01A*WT.)%"/2;)&".AX* A*B/A** J./%01*!1C#D044A*U0G*!17)40,*!1CD%&/'0*8;("41%7*H2D4&7(&.'9*>??fA** `V@@A*H%&.)A*

\&1C"./9*T%0.0*1./*<4"%&1*Z%0.7)0&.A*WT.)%"/2;)&".AX*(=6="A+#/&-,=&3$0*7E&& -,=&S)=0/=#2=&$>&S2$>=)+#+%)P&B/7A*T%0.0*\&1C"./*1./*<4"%&1** Z%0.7)0&.A*81.*O%1.;&7;",*8&0%%1*!42D*E""L79*@ii?A*iV@_A*H%&.)A

O4""/9*<1=&.A*G#&H#-0$7?2-+$#&-$&C+#7?+%)P&!1CD%&/'0,*!1CD%&/'0*-.&=0%7&)$** H%0779*@iihA*H%&.)A*&

[&.'9*6&;(1%/A*& 4.%-+2&S"%-P8&Q"./".,*6"2)40/'09*@iiiA*H%&.)A*

[&.740$9*\1=&/A*& F=0%D=2-+A=P&-##0%*81//40*6&=0%,*H%0.)&;0VR1449*T.;A9*@ii_A*H%&.)A*

:0%;(1.)9*!1%"4$.A*S"0-,2"0=E&3$)=#&"#7&-,=&S#A+0$#)=#-P&U0G*m"%L,** 6"2)40/'09*@ii_A*H%&.)A

8(&=19*l1./1.1A*I-".+#/&G*+A=E&3$)=#'&S2$*$/.&"#7&I?0A+A"*&+#&H#7+"P&U0G** \04(&,*[14&*O"%*S"C0.9*@iffA*H%&.)A

S%&'()9*Q12%1A*WH%"#(0;$9*:")(0%4077.0779*1./*)(0*Q1L0,*H"7);"4".&14** B;"50C&.&7C*1./*O4"%1*UG1#1P7*S>?0?PX*& Q+-=0"-?0=P&B/A*J./%01*!1C#D044A*U0G*!17)40,*!1CD%&/'0*8;("41%7** H2D4&7(&.'9*>??fA*i?V@?`A*H%&.)A

86

FJ9@G;)

UJNJQTB* <B68RNBTU* ]B/&)"%V&.V!(&05^* &7* 1* -b* 7)2/0.)9* G"%L&.'* )"G1%/7*;"C#40)&.'*1*3"&.)*R"."2%7*/0'%00*&.*604&'&"27*8)2/&07*1./*B.'4&7(*]\%1C1*1./*N(01)%0^A*8(0*(17*D00.*".*)(0*0/&)"%&14*D"1%/*"5*!"#$#%&5"%*)(%00*$01%79*1./*(17*(1/*".0*"5*(0%*#1#0%7*#2D4&7(0/*&.*)(0*7&I)(*0/&)&".*"5* )(0*F"2%.14A*R0%*7)2/&07*&.* %04&'&".* (1=0* #%&C1%&4$* 5";270/* ".* 017)0%.* %04&'&".79* #1%)&;241%4$*R&./2&7C*1./*E2//(&7CA*8(0*&7*147"*#%07&/0.)*"5*68-8*]604&'&"27*8)2/&07*-./0%'%1/21)0*8";&0)$^A*Z2)7&/0*"5*1;1/0C&19*7(0*(17*41%'04$*&.="4=0/*(0%7045*&.*)(01)%0*/&%0;)&".*1./*C1.1'0C0.)A* T.* )(0* $01%7* )"* ;"C0* 7(0* G&44* #2%720* 1.*:AOAJA* &.* N(01)%0*:1.1'0C0.)*1./*H%"/2;&.'*1)*!"42CD&1*-.&=0%7&)$A*

JEETB*E-![:JU* ]J77";&1)0*B/&)"%^* &7* &.* (0%* )(&%/* $01%* /"&.'* 1.*R"."2%7*/0'%00*&.*604&'&"27*8)2/&07*]J7&1.*%04&'&".7^*1./*1*/"2D40*C&."%*&.*B.=&%".C0.)*1./*T.)0%.1)&".14*\0=04"#C0.)A*N(&7*&7*(0%*)(&%/*$01%*&.="4=0/*&.*!1.".7,*&.*(0%*

)(0*R"4L1%*\$.17)$X* 1./* 7(0*(17* 0/&)0/* 5"%* )G"*$01%7A*R0%* 1;1/0C&;* &.)0%07)7*;0.)0%*1%"2./*)(0*&.)0%70;)&.'*K207)&".7*"5*%04&'&".9*C24)&;24)2%14&7C9*70;241%&7C9*%04&'&"27* =&"40.;09* 52./1C0.)14&7C9* #"7)V;"4".&14* 40'14* 7$7)0C79* 1./* (2C1.*%&'()79*07#0;&144$*&.*)(0*;".)0I)*"5*T./&1A*JDD&0*&7*147"*1;)&=0*&.*Z%'1.&;*!1C#27*1./*G"%L7*17*1*.1..$A*

6mJU* RBJQBm* ]J77";&1)0t\07&'.* B/&)"%^* &7* 1* -g* 3"&.)* R"."2%7* B.'4&7(*Q&)tH(&4"7"#($* '2$* G&)(* &/&"7$.;%17&07* D04"GA* R0* )%&07* .")* )"* D0* ;2)0*D2)* 0./7* 2#* 71;;(1%&.0A* 60K2&7&)0* .")0* "5* /&7;"C5"%)* &.* )(&%/* #0%7".A* T*'2077* C$* jG"%LP* (17* 147"* 1##01%0/* &.* C"0D=08%9* 9$$;>$0?)* 1./* T* (1=0*7"C0)(&.'* 5"%)(;"C&.'* &.* <+#& C$?%=9* G(&;(* T* .00/* )"* 7)1%)* 17* 7"".* 17* T*

G0//&.'V142C&.2CV;1.7V5%"CV)(0V50./0%* )%1&4&.'* ;4"70* D0(&./A* T* 4&L0* $"2A**

About

87

*:JQQZ6m*RBUUT<J6*]J77";&1)0*B/&)"%^*&7*1*-b*B.'4&7(*Q&)0%1)2%0*1./*S"%4/*604&'&".7*/"2D40*C1F"%* 5%"C*R1C&4)".9*:1771;(270))7A*8(0*#41.7* )"*D0'&.*(0%*'%1/21)0*/0'%00* &.* )(0*O144*G(0%0*7(0*("#07*;".)&.20*7)2/$&.'* )(0* &.)0%70;)&".*"5*#"4&)&;7*1./*%04&'&".*&.*T./&1*/2%&.'*)(0*41)0*;"4".&14t01%4$*#"7);"4".&14*#0%&"/A**3J:B8*OJ66* ]J77";&1)0*B/&)"%^* &7* 1*-g*604&'&"27*8)2/&07*R"."2%7*8)2/0.)A*J4".'* G&)(* (&7* )0.2%0* 1)* !1.".79* (0* (17* 70%=0/* 17* 1* !"#$* B/&)"%* 5"%* N(0*:;<&44* \1&4$* 1./* %2.7* 1* C27&;* D4"'* ;1440/* <4"77"414&1A* O1%%* ;"C#40C0.)7*(&7* 1;1/0C&;* #2%72&)7* G&)(* C27&;* 17* 1* '2&)1%&7)* &.* 70=0%14* :".)%014* D1./7A***3J8:TUB* QBO6B8UB* ]J77";&1)0* B/&)"%^* &7* 1* -b* 7)2/0.)* #2%72&.'* 1* /"2D40*C1F"%* &.*S"%4/*604&'&".7* 1./*J.)(%"#"4"'$A* * 8(0* &7* #1%)&;241%4$* &.)0%07)0/* &.*8"2)(*J7&1.*7)2/&07*G&)(*1*5";27*".*R&./2&7CA**Z)(0%*1%017*"5*&.)0%07)* &.;42/0*0)(."#"0)&;7* 1./* )(0* %"40* "5* .1%%1)&=0* )%1/&)&".7* &.* 5"%C&.'* ;24)2%14* &/0.)&)$A**JlTJU*NJU<* ]J77";&1)0* B/&)"%^* &7* 1* ->*R"."2%7* 604&'&"27* 8)2/&07* 7)2/0.)*

"5* C24)&;24)2%14&7C* 1./* '4"D14&71)&".9* 17* G044* 17* #(&4"7"#($* "5* %04&'&".A* 8(0*147"* 0.F"$7* (&7)"%$9* G(&;(* &7* (0%* C&."%9* G&)(* #1%)&;241%* 0C#(17&7* ".* %04&'&".*&.* :0/&0=14* B2%"#09* 1./* S"%4/* S1%* T* 1./* S"%4/* S1%* TT* (&7)"%$A* E07&/07*7#0./&.'* /1$7* %01/&.'* D""L79* 7(0* 0.F"$7* %2..&.'9* 1./* )%&07* )"* %2.* 1D"2)* b?*L&4"C0)%07* 0=0%$* ")(0%* /1$9* 07#0;&144$* G(0.* )(0* G01)(0%* &7* .&;0* "2)7&/0A*

88

!"#$%&'($"%)

!"#$%#&'()"*+%%"',-'.'/0'123245-'678,9,24-':;4<,7-'-;4<73;'=,;>'.'?2@4-'23'"-,.3' 578,9,23-A':>7' ,-' ,3;757-;7<' ,3' ;>7' -;4<B'2?' 578,9,23'.3<'>4C.3' 5,9>;-'.-'=788'.-'$,D7;.3'E4<<>,-CA':>7',-'23';>7'7F7@4;,G7'?25';>7'678,9,24-':;4<,7-'/3<7595.<4.;7':2@,7;BA'/H23'95.<4.;,39I'->7'>2H7-';2'H45-47'.'95.<4.;7'<79577',3'>4C.3'5,9>;-'8.=A

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

-;4<,7-I'.3<'C7<,.'-;4<,7-A'175'H75-23.8',3;757-;-',3@84<7'C.V,39'C4-,@I'C.V,39'C2G,7-I'.3<'C.V,39'O2V7-A

Contributors!"#$%#&'()*+,%%"-"%%./0'1,&&#2"/-"34,%%'5"&.67"'5"8/"'-.&6#.&9"67,%'9.:,&;%8$7'<8%#"'=8>,%?"&

practical religion: living through the ages - mcgill university

Documents