pptransient nhance public

8/19/2019 PPTransient NHance Public

1/48

Analysis of Captive Cogeneration Power PlantUpset Scenarios using Dynamic SimulationSoftware

!" $

%&'()* +,-./(0 1 2/34(5,6 7)8()33&

2 9,83.:,&, ;,< 1 =35/,)(5,6 7)8()33&

>


2/48

!"#$% '()*+, - .#$")#

• .$),#/+) 0 12 3 4456 ", 789 44

:4;<

• =>?@#A++*0 BCDCCC

• EF,+)*GH?0 I(J#)H%A FH%G K$"@HL

- 8H,(,LH(@ M,*N%$N#,*

• 8#$,O+O H, 4PQR "A %F# S(,H*G

=,TH,++)*5

• .+LG,#@#TAD +,TH,++)H,TD L#,*%)$LN#,

(,O >(,$U(L%$)H,T L#>?(,A

• V(,W* !>#,T .#? B X#>?(,H+* H,

M,OH(Y* K)H/(%+ 2+L%#)5

•

K)#U+**H#,(@@A I(,(T+O *H,L+

M,L+?N#,5

• 2$LL+**U$@ .)(LW V+L#)O H, EH@ - Z(*D

V+[,+)AD K#F+)D K+%)#LG+>HL(@*D

X+>+,% - M,U)(*%)$L%$)+5

•

\+%F#)W #U E]L+* ^#)@OFHO+5

• 2%(%+:#U:%G+:()% I(,$U(L%$)H,T

8(LH@HN+* H, M,OH( (,O E>(, 5

;


3/48

S27%9

79@@R

;3T-J3&

2&(U5,6 !HS9

>E&3..

%),6".(.

>E&-5E-&,6

%),6".(.

K(J()8%),6".(.

7YJ3&(G

43)E,6

C35/)(Z-3.

=,5/()3&"

B >".E34

I3.(8)

=,5/()3&" W

>E&-5E-&,6

I(,8)


4/48

_

45 2%$OA %G+ +`+L%* #U @#(O OH*%$)"(,L+* #, %G+ *A*%+>5

;5 2%$OA %G+ +`+L%* #U (,A #,+ +a$H?>+,% %)H? #) >$@N?@+ +a$H?>+,% %)H? 5.G+ %)H?* L#$@O "+ H*#@(%+O +/+,%* #) L(*L(O+5

Q5 .# O+[,+D O+*HT, (,O )+[,+ %G+ #?+)(N#,* b L#,%)#@ ?GH@#*#?GAD *A*%+>(,O >+LG(,H*> #U ( TH/+, ?#F+) ?@(,% b *A*%+>5

_5 .# %+*% %G+ ?@(,% #?+)(N#, $,O+) /()H#$* >#O+* #U #?+)(N#,5

B5 .$,H,T (,O (OJ$*%>+,% #U L#,%)#@@+) ?()(>+%+)*5

c5 E`:@H,+ %)(H,H,T #U ?@(,% #?+)(%#)*5


5/48

B

45 I#O$@() (??)#(LG %# >(%G+>(NL(@ >#O+@H,T #U ?#F+) ?@(,%*5

;5 E,+ #) >#)+ >#O$@+* )+?)+*+,%* #,+ +a$H?>+,% 7+5T5 "#H@+)D %$)"H,+D/(@/+D ?H?+D ?$>?D O$L% D U(,D >#%#)D %)(,*U#)>+)D T+,+)(%#)D +%L5D <

Q5 .G+ ?@(,%b*A*%+> >#O+@ H* L)+(%+O "A H,%+)L#,,+LN,T >#O$@+* %G)#$TG?#)%*5

_5 !, II2 >#O+@ H* ?)#L+**+O %G)#$TG ($%#>(%+O *%+?* %G(% ?)#O$L+ (*H>$@(N#, +d+L$%("@+5

B5 K)#T)(>>H,T @(,T$(T+* e !X2'D 8#)%)(, (,O fH*$(@ Xgg5

c5 'H")()A #U /()H#$* >#O$@+* e =@+L%)HL(@D I+LG(,HL(@D h#K (,O X#,%)#@*5

8+(%$)+* #U I#O$@() I#O+@H,T 2A*%+> 7II2< 2#iF()+


6/48

c

45 XG#HL+ #U H,%+T)(N#, (@T#)H%G>* *$LG (* =$@+)D V$,T+eW$j(D Z+()D !O(>:2>H%G +%L5D

;5 !$%#>(NL *#)N,T (,O *+a$+,LH,T #U OH`+)+,N(@ +a$(N#,* U#) *#@$N#,5

Q5 1*+) ,++O* %# G(/+ $,O+)*%(,OH,T #U !X2'D %# "$H@O (,O +d+L$%+ >#O+@*5

_5 k,#F@+OT+ #U fH*$(@ Xgg )+a$H)+O HU #,+ ,++O* %# O+/+@#? ,+F >#O$@+*5

B5M,:"$H@% *H>?@H[+O ?)#?+)%A )#$N,+* U#) F(%+)D (H)D (,O U$+@* +%LD

c5 f+,O#) e ,l(,L+ .+LG,#@#TH+* D 125

8+(%$)+* #U II2 *#iF()+ e X#,%O5


7/48

6

45 2%+(OA *%(%+ G+(% "(@(,L+ OH(T)(>5

;5 K-M OH(T)(>5

Q5 Z5!5 O)(FH,T*5

_5 =a$H?>+,% *?+LH[L(N#, *G++%* 7K$>?*D X#,%)#@ /(@/+*D lmD +%L @#THL OH(T)(>* (,O O+*L)H?N#,5

c5 E?+)(N#, (,O L#,%)#@ ?GH@#*#?GA5

65 2%()%:$? *+a$+,L+5

R5 2G$% O#F, *+a$+,L+5

SA,(>HL I#O+@ K)+?()(N#, e S(%( V+a$H)+O5


8/48

R

I#O+@H,T 2+a$+,L+

Define theSystem

Boundariesand gatherequipment

data

Generatemodel of

eachequipment

and test

Link theequipmentmodules

Executionand

achievingthe steady

state

operation

Controllertunings

Generateupset

conditionsGet resultsand analyze

Tie to a

trainingsimulator,if desired


9/48

P

B ,#*5 h#H@+)* e .G+)>(d5

_ ,#*5 2%+(> %$)"H,+*n .)H/+,H e 445R I^+ "(*+ @#(On X#,O+,*H,T

_ ,#*5 Z+,+)(%#)* e 44 Wf! 5

B ,#*5 O+(+)(%#)*5

B ,#5 "#H@+) U++O F(%+) ?$>?* (@#,T FH%G O)H/+ %$)"H,+*

Q ,#*5 ?#F+) o$HO ?$>?* (,O Q ,#*5 H,J+LN#, F(%+) ?$>?*

hEK 7KVS2n S+:(+)(%#)*D KH?+*D K$>?*D f(@/+*D L#,O+,*+)D 8S U(,*D +%L<

.)(,*U#)>+)*D =@+L%)HL(@ ,+%F#)W "$*D =@+L%)HL(@ >#%#)*D +%L5

I(J#) =a$H?>+,% I#O+@+O


10/48

'X

'X

KX

KX

KX KX

h#H@+) 4 h#H@+) ; h#H@+) Q h#H@+) _ h#H@+) B

2.Z ; 2.Z _

KX

KX

KX

lK 2.=!I l=!S=V

IK 2.=!I l=!S=V

IK XE\S=\2!.= l=!S=V

2.Z 4

K)#O$LN#,l+(%+)* M,J+LN#,l+(%+)* E`*?+L EH@b 2WH> EH@

l+(%+)* .(,W bf+**+@

l+(%+)*

IK XE\S=\2!.=

8'!2l SV1I

'K XE\S=\2!.=

8'!2l SV1I

H)?35U2F7=%CH2 IH%@;%=$ >C7%= %9I KSL7; @797;%CHS9 >[>C7=

!LN/(%+OX()"#, 8H@%+)

K(LW(T+.)+(%+O X#,O+,*(%+ 2%#)(T+.(,W

\; h@(,W+%

'K 2.=!Il=!S=V

'K XE\S=\2!.=

!XX

!XX

A7@79I

2.Z 2%+(> .$)"H,+ Z+ ,+)(%#)

'K ' #F K)+**$)+

IK I+OH$> K)+**$)+

lK lHTG K)+**$)+

!XX !H) X##@+O X#,O+,*+)

!.I !%>#*?G+)HL

KX K)+ **$)+ X#,%)#@

'X '+/+ @ X#,%)#@

8X 8@#F X#,%)#@

S

2S+*$?+)G+(%+)

2H@+,L+)

!XX

'X

'X

!XX !XX !XX

!.I !.I !.I

!.I 'X 'X 'X


11/48

Z4 Z; ZQ Z_

2h4

2h;

2hQ

2h_

2hB

2hc

^+@@ K(O* ^+@@ K(O* E?+)(N#,* h(*+

I4 I;

IQ I_

IB Ic

I6 IR

IP I4C

I44 I4Q

I4; I4_ c5c Wf I#%#)*

=IR =I4

c5c Wf =>+)T+,LA I#%#)*b'#(O*

2h6 2hR 2hP 2h4C 2h44 2h4; 2h4Q 2h4_

=I; =IQ

=I_

=IB =Ic

=I6 =IP =I4C

=I44 =I4;

=I4Q =I4_

=I4B

QRQ 0b !-.

^^ 0b !-.

]] 0b !-. !

QRQ 0b 743&83)5" !-.

44 bC5_QQ Wf 44 bc5P Wf

22 22

44 bc5P Wf

44 bc5P Wf 44 bc5P Wf

44 bQB Wf 44 bQB Wf

c5c bC5_QQ Wf

N]c b >J6(E !-.

N]c b >J6(E !-.

@797;%CS;>d ]c =b%M

]e =LM ]] 0bM ^ M cO Ff ]] 0b !-. % ]] 0b !-. 2

Plant Configuration (Electrical System)

C;%9>XS;=7;>

=Z4 =Z; =ZQ

7=7;@792[ IH7>7A @797;%CS;>

44


12/48

4;

Control Systems Implemented

• gU6(E" !+,% b *H,T@+ +@+>+,% O)$> @+/+@ L#,%)#@ "(*+O

#, *%+(> O)$> @+/+@D 2%+(> o#F )(%+ (,O %G+ 8++O F(%+)

o#F )(%+5

–

8H)H,T )(%+ L#,%)#@ "(*+O #, lK G+(O+) ?)+**$)+5

–

!H) U$+@ )(N# L#,%)#@ "A 8S U(,*

–

.+>?+)(%$)+ L#,%)#@ #U *%+(> "A O+*$?+)G+(N,T


13/48

4Q

Control Systems implemented (Contd.)

• >E3,4 C-&D()3.

– .$)"H,+ Z#/+),#) I#O+@ 7/+,O#)Y* X#,%)#@@+) h@#LW

SH(T)(> (,O .)(,*U+) 8$,LN#, SH(T)(><

– I+LG(,HL(@ K#F+) #$%?$%D I^5

• @3)3&,E(NL f#@%(T+ V+T$@(%#) 7!fV< /+,O#)Y* .)(,*U+)

8$,LN#, SH(T)(>


14/48

4_

Control System implemented (contd..)

•

I3G,3&,E H* L#,%)#@@+O "(*+O #, *%+(> o#F

• SH*LG()T+ ?)+**$)+ #U ?#F+) o$HO ?$>? H* >(H,%(H,+O q

;CQ5P4 "()< "A L#,%)#@@H,T *%+(> o#F %# %G+ K8 ?$>? O)H/+

%$)"H,+5

•

M,J+LN#, F(%+) ?$>? OH*LG()T+ ?)+**$)+ H* >(H,%(H,+O (%

4;45C; "()T

• >? >#%#)


15/48

Work Procedure

>E3J ] G I,E, @,E/3&()8• K)#L+** o#F OH(T)(>*D l+(% h(@(,L+ OH(T)(> (,O K-M OH(T)(>5

• =a$H?>+,% *?+LH[L(N#,*D ?GA*HL(@ (,O Z+#>+%)HL S+%(H@* O(%(

• E?+)(N,T ?()(>+%+)* O(%(D (@@#F("@+ >+%(@ %+>?+)(%$)+*5

• X#,%)#@ f(@/+*D L#,%)#@@+)* *?+LH[L(N#,*D (,O

•

X#,%)#@ *A*%+> @#THL O+*L)H?N#,5>E3J e G I,E, H)J-E E< =


16/48

Work Procedure (Contd.)

>E3J ^ 1 H)E3&5(%LGH,TFH%G G+(% "(@(,L+ OH(T)(>5

>E3J N 1 = %$)"H,+ %)H?*5

• E,+ *%+(> %$)"H,+ O)H/+, ?#F+) o$HO ?$>? %)H?*5

• E,+ +@+L%)HL >#%#) ?#F+) o$HO ?$>? %)H?*5

• E,+ "#H@+) U++O F(%+) ?$>? %)H?*5

•

8$+@ LG(,T+:#/+) U)#> 8$+@ T(* %# SH+*+@5

• K@(,% 2%()%:1?5

>E3J c 1 >-883.E &343*(,6 ,5U


17/48

!"##$%$&' )*+$, *# -.$%/'"*& *# 0'$/1 23%4"&$,

)*+$5$+ "& '6$ 7%*8$9':

! IES= : ! 0 4 2. H, M*#LG)#,#$* I#O+ (,O Q 2.* H, S)##? I#O+

FH%G V+>#%+ !$%#>(NL 2+% K#H,% XG(,T+5

!

IES= : h 0 4 2. H, M*#LG)#,#$* I#O+ (,O Q 2.* H, S)##? I#O+5

! IES= : X 0 !@@ U#$) 2.* H, S)##? I#O+5

46

9


18/48

;$/'3%$, 55 ?.,$'

l+(O+) K)+**$)+

L#,%)#@ #, U$+@ [)H,T H, *%+(OA *%(%+5

" !@@ U#$) *%+(> %$)"H,+* #?+)(N,T H, SVEEK I#O+5

" 2%+(> .$)"H,+ Z#/+),#) I#O+@ H>?@+>+,%+O (* TH/+, "A

%G+ f+,O#) 7.)H/+,H


19/48

-.$%/'"&= 7/%/1$'$% 2%$&+,

@6$& -&$ -3' -# ;"A$ B*"5$%, 2%".,


20/48

?.,$' +% "A )+>(H,H,T U#$) h#H@+)*

)(>?H,T $? q tQC %?Gb>H,5

" 2%+(> *$??@A %# #,+ M,J+LN#, ^(%+) K$>? .$)"H,+ H*

*%#??+O 5

"

IK *%+(> G+(O+) ?)+**$)+ O)#?*5

" 8@#F %G)#$TG %G+ lK %# IK *%+(> KVS2 FH@@ H,L)+(*+ %#

>(H,%(H, IK *%+(> G+(O+) ?)+**$)+5

;C1 Boiler Trip Case Results


21/48

C",' *# @H,+ U)#> lK *%+(> l+(O+)5

" 2FH%LGH,T #` 8$+@ *$??@A %# %G+ %)H??+O h#H@+)5

" X@#*H,T %G+ h#H@+) 8++O F(%+) /(@/+5

"

X#,N,$+ 4 h8^ K$>? #U %)H??+O "#H@+) H, ( >H,H>$> )+LAL@+ >#O+5

"

8S 8(, #U %G+ %)H??+O "#H@+) L#,N,$+* %# #?+)(%+ (% ( )+O$L+O @#(O5

"

M*#@(N,T "#H@+) "@#F:O#F, /(@/+5

" M*#@(N,T h#H@+) U)#> h8^ OH*%)H"$N#, l+(O+)5

" .# >(H,%(H, ?@(,% U)+a$+,LAD *%+(> @#(O *G+OOH,T H* O#,+ "A *%#??H,T #,+

M,J+LN#, F(%+) ?$>? %$)"H,+ O)H/+ (,O L#))+*?#,OH,T ?$>? FH%GH, ( O$)(N#,#U ; *+L#,O* #U %)H? #U %G+ "#H@+)5

"

X@#*H,T %G+ m2f* #, *$LN#, @H,+ %# %G+ %$)"H,+ O)H/+, M,J+LN#, ^(%+) ?$>? 5

" \# =@+L%)HL(@ @#(O *G+OOH,T H* )+a$H)+O %# "+ L#,*HO+)+O H, %GH* L(*+

;41 Boiler Trip Case Results


22/48

G##$9' *& *'6$% *.$%/'"&= 4*"5$%, ./%/1$'$%,H

;5*I JHHHHHHHK L=M,N 7%$,,3%$ JHHHHHHHK 7/N 2$1.$%/'3%$ JHHHHHHHK *


23/48

G##$9' *& )7 ,'$/1 6$/+$% .%$,,3%$ O

,'$/1 P5*I '6%*3=6 '6$ 7Q!0:

1 Boiler Trip Case Results

# 8@#F %G)#$TG lK %# IK KVS2 H,L)+(*+* %# >(H,%(H, %G+ IK

2%+(> l+(O+) K)+**$)+5;Q


24/48


G##$9' *& ,'$/1 P5*I JHHHK L=M, /&+ 7*I$% JHHHHK )@ *# *&$

4*"5$% '%".:

;_


25/48


G##$9' *& 75/&' ;%$D3$&9EN RS

# K@(,% U)+a$+,LA

H* >(H,%(H,+O

FH%GH, (LL+?%("@+

@H>H%* 7u _P K)+**$)+

;B


26/48

-4,$%A/'"*&, F -&$ B*"5$% 2%".

#

S$+ %# ( *$OO+, *G#)v(@@ #U 44C %?G *%+(> %G+ lK G+(O+)?)+**$)+ U(@@* *G()?@A U)#> _Q "()T %# QQ:Q_ "()T5

# M% %(W+* ()#$,O 4C >H,$%+* U#) %G+ lK G+(O+) ?)+**$)+ %#

*%("H@Hr+ (% ( ,+F /(@$+ #U Q_ "()T5

# .# *%("H@Hr+ %G+ lK *%+(> G+(O+) ?)+**$)+0

! V+>(H,H,T _ "#H@+)* ()+ )(>?+O:$? %# %G+H) >(dH>$> L(?(LH%A

! M,J+LN#, ^(%+) .$)"H,+ O)H/+, K$>? H* %)H??+O (i+) ; *+L#,O*5

#

lK 2%+(> G+(O+) ?)+**$)+ *%("H@Hr+* (% Q_ "()5

# K@(,% 8)+a$+,LA H* >(H,%(H,+O FH%GH, (LL+?%("@+ @H>H%* *# %G(%

%G+)+ H* ,# ,++O U#) %G+ @#(O *G+OOH,T5;c1 Boiler Trip Case Results


27/48

1 Steam Turbine Trip Results

-.$%/'"&= 7/%/1$'$% 2%$&+,

@6$& -&$ -3' -# ;*3% 0'$/1 23%4"&$, 2%".,


28/48

?.,$'


29/48

C",' *# .$)"H,+ U)#> %G+ lK *%+(>

l+(O+)5

:

M*#@(N,T %G+ Z+,+)(%#) L#,,+L%+O %# %G+ %)H??+O .$)"H,+

U)#> %G+ L#,,+L%+O 44 Wf h$*5

:

.#%(@ +@+L%)HL(@ @#(O *G+OOH,T #U B5464 I^ H* L#,*HO+)+O %#

W++? U)+a$+,LA FH%GH, ( )(,T+ #U _R5B %# B45B lr "A %)H??H,T

#,+ >#%#) O)H/+, M^ ?$>? (,O #,+ +d?#)% #H@ ?$>?5

;P1 Steam Turbine Trip Results


30/48

G##$9' *& TT LU B3, U*5'/=$N LU


# 44 Wf h$* /#@%(T+

OH?* %# ( >H,H>$>

R5PR Wf5

#

S$)(N#, #U/#@%(T+ OH? "+@#F

P5P Wf H* C5R *5

# .G+)+(i+) %G+ 44

Wf h$* f#@%(T+

*%("H@Hr+* FH%GH, _C*+L#,O*5

QC


31/48

"#$%& '()*+ ,+*-) ,(./0 12

G##$9' *& 75/&' ;%$D3$&9EN RS

# .G+ ?@(,% *%("H@H%A H*

(LGH+/+O "A )(>?H,T

)+>(H,H,T 2.* %# 445;;

I^ - *G+OOH,T B546

I^ @#(O (i+) ( N>+

H,%+)/(@ #U C5B *5

# MU %G+ +@+L%)HL(@ @#(O

*G+OOH,T #U Q5R I^ H*

O#,+ "A %)H??H,T #,@A #,+

I#%#) S)H/+, M^ K$>?

%G+, %G+ U)+a$+,LA O)#?*%# _R lr5

IH,5 8)+a$+,LA H*

N`RcN FfR

Q41 Steam Turbine Trip Results


32/48


G##$9' *& *.$%/'"&= 4*"5$%, ./%/1$'$%,H

0'$/1 ;5*I JHHHHHHHK L=M,N 7%$,,3%$ JHHHHHHHK 7/N 2$1.$%/'3%$ JHHHHHHHK*


33/48

B*"5$% T !%31 5$A$5 JHHHHK 1N ;$$+I/'$% P5*I JHHHHK L=M, O

0'$/1 =$&$%/'"*& JHHHHHK L=M,

1 Steam Turbine Trip Results QQ


34/48


#

.)H??H,T #U 2. )+*$@%* H, *G#)%:U(@@ #U R5c6 I^ #U ?#F+)5 .G+ ?@(,% *%("H@H%AH* (LGH+/+O "A )(>?H,T )+>(H,H,T 2.* %# 445;; I^ - *G+OOH,T B546 I^

#U +@+L%)HL(@ @#(O FH%GH, ( N>+ H,%+)/(@ #U C5B *5

# .G+ >(dH>$> O)#? H, U)+a$+,LA H* $? %# _R5B_ lr5

# MU =@+L%)HL(@ '#(O 2G+OOH,T #U Q5R I^ H* O#,+ "A %)H??H,T #,@A #,+ I#%#)

S)H/+, M,J+LN#, ^(%+) K$>? %G+, %G+ >(dH>$> O)#? H, U)+a$+,LA H* $?%#

_R lr5

# M>>+OH(%+@A (i+) %G+ %)H? O$+ %# *$OO+, @#** #U ?#F+) T+,+)(N#, %G+ 44

Wf h$* /#@%(T+ OH?* %# ( >H,H>$> /(@$+ #U R5PR Wf (,O %G+ /#@%(T+ OH? H*

U#) ( %#%(@ O$)(N#, #U C5R *5

# .G+)+(i+) %G+ 44 Wf h$* f#@%(T+ )+L#/+)* "(LW %# 44 Wf (,O *%("H@Hr+*

FH%GH, _C *+L#,O*5

-4,$%A/'"*&, F -&$ 02 2%".

Q_


35/48

-.$%/'"&= 7/%/1$'$% 2%$&+,

@6$& 0'$/1 !%"A$& 7; 731. 2%".,

++"'"*&/5 *# G5$9'%"9/5 C*/+

1 Boiler Trip Case Results QB


36/48

?.,$'


37/48

C",' *# ? .$)"H,+ S)H/+ U)#> lK 2%+(> l+(O+)5

:

X@#*H,T m2f #, *$LN#, @H,+ #U K8K5

: E?+,H,T m2f #, *$LN#, @H,+ %# >#%#) O)H/+, K8K5

:

2FH%LGH,T #, %G+ >#%#) U#) %G+ K8K "A L@#*H,T %G+ h)+(W+)L#,,+LN,T H% %# %G+ c5c Wf h$*5

: \# =@+L%)HL(@ '#(O 2G+OOH,T H* L#,*HO+)+O H, %GH* L(*+5

Q61 Steam Turbine Trip Results


38/48

"#$%3 && 45 678 5(+)*$/9 45

"#$%& ,+*-) "0/:7/-;

Results for 1 PFP Changeover from Turbine Drive to Motor Drive

# 44 Wf h$* f#@%(T+ O)#?* %# ( >H,H>$>

#U ]OReN 0bD 4456 * (i+) %G+ LG(,T+#/+)5

# !% %G+ H,*%(,% %G+ >#%#) (LGH+/+* H%* U$@@

*?++OD 44 Wf h$* f#@%(T+ T#+* $? %# ]cRP0b5

# f#@%(T+ *%("H@Hr+* FH%GH, PC *5

# .G+ >H,H>$> K@(,% U)+a$+,LA H* _R5QR lr5

#

.G+ OH? H, ?@(,% U)+a$+,LA "+@#F _R5B lr H*U#) _ *5

# K@(,% 8)+a$+,LA *%("H@Hr+* (% ( @#F+) /(@$+

#U _P56P lr5


39/48

"#$%? =, @)/*A =/*B/0 ,0/8870/9 ,*

"#$%C 1, @)/*A =/*B/0 ,0/8870/ D ,EF@ "+(.


# S$+ %# ( *$OO+, )+O$LN#, H, lK *%+(>

L#,*$>?N#, lK *%+(> G+(O+) ?)+**$)+

)H*+* %# _Q5c "()5

# 2$OO+, '#** #U c4 .Kl #U lK 2%+(> )+*$@%*

H, IK 2%+(> l+(O+) ?)+**$)+ O)#?5

# B65c .Kl #U lK 2%+(> H* OH/+)%+O %G)#$TG

%G+ lK %# IK l+(O+) KVS2 %# >(H,%(H, IK

2%+(> l+(O+) K)+**$)+5


40/48


"#$%G '()*+ H+/;)0#;*+ I(*B9 12

# X#))+*?#,OH,T %# 44 Wf "$* /#@%(T+

)+(LGH,T ( ?+(W #U 4B56 Wf %G+ %#%(@

+@+L%)HL(@ @#(O (@*# )+(LG+* ( ?+(W #U cc =L

)+*$@N,T H, %G+ ?@(,% U)+a$+,LA OH??H,T %# (>H,H>$> #U _R5QR lr5

# M,L)+(*+ H, =@+L%)HL(@ '#(O L#))+*?#,OH,T

%# %G+ (OOHN#, #U K8 K$>? I#%#) #U _5BRQ

I^5

# .G+ >#%#) (LGH+/+* U$@@ *?++O FH%GH, ;R

*+L#,O*5

#

!% %G+ *(>+ H,*%(,% %G+ >#%#) %#)a$+(,O %G+ >#%#) L$))+,% O)#?* )(?HO@AD

G+,L+D %G+ /#@%(T+ T#+* $? %# ( >(dH>$>

#U 4B56 Wf5

"#$%J ,", 1()(0 ,*0*A/)/08


41/48

#

44 Wf h$* f#@%(T+ O)#?* %# (,O )+(LG+* ( >H,H>$> #U 4C5;_ Wf 4456 * (i+) %G+ LG(,T+#/+)5

# !% %G+ H,*%(,% %G+ >#%#) (LGH+/+* H%* U$@@ *?++OD 44 Wf h$* f#@%(T+ T#H,T $? %# ( >(dH>$> #U

4B56 Wf5

# .G+ 44 Wf "$* /#@%(T+ +dL++O* 4;54 Wf H, ( *H,T@+ ?+(W U#) ( %#%(@ O$)(N#, #U Q5B *5 .G+)+(i+)

%G+ 44 Wf "$* /#@%(T+ H* *%("@+5

#

.#%(@ +@+L%)HL(@ @#(O (@*# )+(LG+* ( ?+(W #U BB I^ )+*$@N,T H, %G+ ?@(,% U)+a$+,LA OH??H,T %#( >H,H>$> #U _R5QR lr5

# .G+ OH? H, ?@(,% U)+a$+,LA "+@#F _R5B lr H* U#) _ *+L#,O*5

# lK *%+(> G+(O+) ?)+**$)+ ?+(W* %# ( >(dH>$> #U _Q5c "() (,O %GH* )+*$@%* H, H>>+OH(%+

)+O$LN#, H, *%+(> #$%?$% U)#> %G+ "#H@+)* %# ")H,T %G+ lK G+(O+) ?)+**$)+ "(LW %# _;5B "()5

#

!i+) %G+ K8K LG(,T+#/+) H* L#>?@+%+ %G+ ?@(,% U)+a$+,LA *%("H@Hr+* (% ( @#F+) /(@$+ #U _P56P5

# .GH* ?G+,#>+,#, H* (* ?+) )+O$LN#, H, %$)"H,+ *?++O FH%G H,L)+(*+ H, @#(O (* ?+) S)##?

L$)/+5

-4,$%A/'"*&, H 0'$/1 !%"A$& 7; 731. 2%".,



42/48

#

M% H* *HT,H[L(,% %# ,#%+ %G(% *%+(> @#(O *G+OOH,T H* )+a$H)+O O$)H,T #,+"#H@+) %)H?D FG+)+(* +@+L%)HL(@ @#(O *G+OOH,T H* ,+L+**H%(%+O "A %G+ 2%+(>

.$)"H,+ %)H?5

# II2 *#iF()+ U)#> ,l(,L+ .+LG,#@#TH+* M,L5D H* ( )#"$*%D L#,/+,H+,% (,O

?#F+)U$@ %##@ (/(H@("@+ %# %G+ K#F+) K@(,% +a$H?>+,% (,O L#,%)#@ *A*%+>*

O+*HT,+)* (,O (,(@A*%* %# ?)+OHL% ?+)U#)>(,L+ #U ( TH/+, ?#F+) ?@(,% %#

>++% ( TH/+, O$%A5

# .G+ ?#F+) ?@(,% %G+)>(@ (,O +@+L%)HL(@ *A*%+>* (,O %G+ (**#LH(%+O

O#F,*%)+(> ?@(,%* L(, "+ O+*HT,+O U#) (@@ L#,N,T+,LH+* FH%G %G+

?+)U#)>(,L+ ?)+OHLN#,* (/(H@("@+ "A $*H,T %G+ II2 2#iF()+5


43/48

#

! L#>?@+%+ %G+)>(@ (,O +@+L%)HL(@ *A*%+>* >#O+@H,T F(* O#,+ $*H,T II22#iF()+ U)#> ,l(,L+ .+LG,#@#TH+* M,L5 U#) %G+ _R I^+ %G+)>(@ ?#F+)

?@(,%5

# 2HT,H[L(,% H,*HTG%* F+)+ T(H,+O ("#$% %G+ ?#F+) ?@(,% #?+)(N#, H, H*@(,O

>#O+ (,O %G+ +`+L% #U /()H#$* OH*%$)"(,L+* 7H5+5 +a$H?>+,% %)H?*<

# !@%G#$TG %G+ *%$OA F(* L())H+O #$% U#) ( @()T+ ,$>"+) #U L(*+* *$LG

OH`+)+,% #?+)(N,T @#(O* O$)H,T A+()* ;D _ (,O c #U #?+)(N#,D *%()%:$? #U

%G+ ?@(,% (,O %G+ U$+@ LG(,T+ #/+) +%L5 (,O FH%G /()H#$* %$)"H,+ T#/+),#)

#?+)(N,T >#O+*D %GH* ?)+*+,%(N#, H* U#) %F# %)H?* L(*+* U#) A+() c 7U$@@

@#(O< #?+)(N#,5

X#,%O5


44/48

>3'6*% 7%*P"5$,

I)5 !)/H,O k($*GHW H* ( ?#*% T)(O$(%+ 7I5.+LG< XG+>HL(@ =,TH,++) U)#> M,OH(,

M,*N%$%+ #U .+LG,#@#TA 7MM.< k(,?$)D M,OH(D *H,L+ 4PPC5 l+ G(* FHO+ +d?+)H+,L+

#U #/+) ;Q A+()* H, %G+ O+*HT, #U %G+)>(@ +a$H?>+,%D ?)#L+** #?N>Hr(N#,D+,+)TA L#,*+)/(N#, H, ?)#L+** ?@(,%*D OA,(>HL *H>$@(N#, #U ?)#L+** (,O

?#F+) ?@(,%*D L#>>H**H#,H,T (,O %)#$"@+:*G##N,T H, M,OH( (,O #/+)*+(*5 !%

?)+*+,%D (* 2)5 SA5 Z+,+)(@ I(,(T+) 7V-S< (% '()*+, - .#$")# 'H>H%+OD

I$>"(HD M,OH(D G+ H* @+(OH,T ( %+(> #U I+LG(,HL(@ (,O XG+>HL(@ =,TH,++)* H,

%G+ .G+)>(@ =,TH,++)H,T Z)#$? #U V+*+()LG - S+/+@#?>+,% U#) H,,#/(N#,* H,

O+*HT, #U F(*%+ G+(% )+L#/+)A +a$H?>+,%5 lH* ()+(* #U H,%+)+*% H,L@$O+ *#@()%G+)>(@ +,+)TAD @#F %+>?+)(%$)+ %G+)>(@ O+*(@H,(N#,D %G+)>(@ +,+)TA *%#)(T+

*A*%+>*D OA,(>HL *H>$@(N#, #U ?#F+) ?@(,%*D +,+)TA #?N>Hr(N#, #U H,O$*%)H(@

?)#L+**+* (,O L#>>H**H#,H,T (,O %)#$"@+:*G##N,T #U ?)#L+** +a$H?>+,%5

=:>(H@0 ()/H,OwW($*GHWq'\.=\X5L#>

__


45/48

>3'6*% 7%*P"5$, J


46/48

>3'6*% 7%*P"5$, JO() G(* F#)W+O H, %G+ ()+(* )+@(%+O %# %G+ %G+)>(@

O+*HT,D (,(@A*H* (,O %)#$"@+*G##N,T #U G+(% %)(,*U+) +a$H?>+,% *$LG (* 2G+@@

- .$"+ l+(% =dLG(,T+)*D !H) X##@+O l+(% =dLG(,T+)*D ^(*%+ l+(% V+L#/+)A

X#H@* (,O ^(*%+ l+(% V+L#/+)A h#H@+)* U#) /()H#$* lAO)#L()"#, ?)#J+L%*5 l+

G(* (@*# F#)W+O H, %G+ ()+( #U %G+)>#:GAO)($@HL O+*HT, #U )+T+,+)(N/+ %A?+

?+""@+:"+O (,O L#)+O:")HLW "+O G+(%+)*5 lH* /()H+O F#)W +d?+)H+,L+ (,O [+@O

#U H,%+)+*% (@*# H,L@$O+* SA,(>HL 2H>$@(N#, #U K#F+) K@(,%* (,O K)#L+** Z(*

X#>?)+**H#, >#O$@+*5

=:>(H@0 2#$>A(wI(J$>O()q'\.=\X5L#>_c


47/48

>3'6*% 7%*P"5$, J+,% S+?()%>+,% 7KVSl< #U '()*+, - .#$")# 'H>H%+OD I$>"(H

7M,OH(HL *H>$@(N#, #U ?#F+) ?@(,%*D

%G+)>(@ O+*HT, b (,(@A*H* b %)#$"@+ *G##N,T #U G+(% %)(,*U+) +a$H?>+,% *$LG

(* 2-.D !Xl=D K8l=D ^lV L#H@* +%L (,O #%G+) *?+LH(@ G+(% %)(,*U+) (,O o$HO

o#F *%$OH+*5

=:>(H@0 V(>+*GW$>()wZq'\.=\X5L#>

_6


48/48

pptransient nhance public

Documents