pp 5.1 standohyd competition comparison incl drf
TRANSCRIPT
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
STANDOHYD BASECOAT
Standohyd CompetitionComparison
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
Competition Comparison
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
Competition Comparison
The results presented are based on factual data taken from Technical Data Sheets, and the practical findings of Standox Technicians and customers in evaluation of these products in six different countries.
Spain, Germany, Netherlands, Germany, UK and Standox International Training.
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
Standox Glasurit Nexa PPGSikkens RM DuPontStandohy
dSeries
90Autowav
eAquabas
eEnvirobas
e Onyx HD CromaxName
64 58 59 63 66 53 67No of
Toners
Binder Urethane Disp Urethane ResinWB Acryl Resin Microgel Urethane ResinUrethane ResinUrethane Acrylate
VOC g/l 250 - 410 420110 - 130 ? 480 420
100 - 420
Shelf Life 24 months -
18 months No limit
36 months
24 months
Mixed life 6 months
6 months
24 - 36 h
3 months - 7 days
24 months
Mix ratio
100 - 10% 2:1
100-10/20 10:1:1 100:30 100:60 RFU
Competitors - System Overview
No of Coats
0.5 + 1 + 0.25 2 + 0.5 2 + 1 to 2
1 + 0.5 + 0.25 2 to 4
1 to 3 + 0.5 2 + 0.25
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
1.0 0.5 0.25
STA
ND
OX
0.51.0 0.25NEX
A
1.01.0 0.25
Du
Pon
t
1.0 1.0 0.50.5
SIK
KEN
S
1.0 1.0 0.5
GLA
SU
RIT
1.01.0 1.0 0.5
PP
G-R
MApplication – Number of Spray Passes
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
STA
ND
OX
0.51.0 0.25NEX
A
1.01.0 0.25
Du
Pon
t
1.0 1.0 0.50.5
SIK
KEN
S
1.0 1.0 0.5
GLA
SU
RIT
1.01.0 1.0
PP
G-R
M
Number of Spray Passes “Work & Wait” Time (Front end, no dryers.
From TDS)
11 min
19 min
0 min
22 min
24 min
26 min
1.0 0.5 0.25
STA
ND
OX
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Activity compared
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Ease of application (full panel) Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Overspray absorption Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Sand-ability / de-nib Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Mottling - clouding Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Aluminium appearance Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Opacity covering power Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Material consumption (Ford Mondeo Bonnet and wing) Green Pearl
460g
635g676g
510g524g
486g
Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd SikkensNexaPPGGlasuritDuPont
Competitive System Characteristics
Total rating for all compared properties
54
45
3740
35
53
Best Worst
Full panel
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
Competitive System Characteristics
Part IIFade out area
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Ease of application fade out (gold metallic) Fade out
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Cloudiness of fade out area Fade out
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Silver halo / band Fade out
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Aluminium structure Fade out
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd DuPontSikkensPPGNexaGlasurit
Competitive System Characteristics
Flop tone of the blend area Fade out
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd Sikkens PPGGlasuritDuPont Nexa
Competitive System Characteristics
Total rating for all compared properties
40
35
40
3027
35
Best Worst
Fade out
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
High
Low
Standohyd Sikkens PPGNexaGlasurit DuPont
Competitive System Characteristics
Total rating for all compared properties full panel and fade out
9480 77 70
62
88
Best Worst
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
Strengths and Weaknesses
StrengthsBright clean silver colour tonesApplication is near fool-proofSilver colours sand-able wet or dryNot difficult to blend on small repairs
WeaknessesVery poor overspray absorptionSilver colours settle in the canAll non-Silver colours are poor performingOpacity not consistentSensitive to spray gun choice (WSB too small)High material consumptionMixing accuracy when using concentrated toners
90 Line
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
StrengthsBasecoat can be sandedBright Silvers have a good-fine effectUse of coagulant
WeaknessesMultiple coats requiredHigh material consumptionDry control coat can shift the final colour tonePoor opacity for many coloursClouding/mottling possible with light colours
Wave 21
Strengths and Weaknesses
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
StrengthsOpacity goodBlending not difficultGood metallic appearance
WeaknessesBasecoat remains very sticky can not tak-wipeNo chance to de-nibMixing very complicatedShort mixed pot lifeOpacity not as good as Standox
Aquabase
Strengths and Weaknesses
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
StrengthsGood to sprayFast inter coat flash off until multiple coats usedGood to dry de-nibGood overspray absorption
WeaknessesVery poor opacity on some colours (reds)Large colour change wet to dry (reds are pink then red)Metallic colours can appear to sparkle/glitter
Envirobase
Strengths and Weaknesses
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
StrengthsColour documentation
WeaknessesLong process timesMultiple coatsDifficult for blend-in/fade outColour accuracy to the vehicle
Strengths and Weaknesses
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
StrengthsColour documentationBasecoat can be masked for two-tone coloursReady to use (no-mixing)One visit application
WeaknessesMaterial consumptionEnd flash off can be long without blow-dryers
Cromax
Strengths and Weaknesses
04/12/23 Technical Training- Setting new Standards
StandohydStrengthsEasy to applyVery good opacityOne visit applicationCan be de-nibbed and tak wipedGood to fade outLow material consumption
WeaknessesSome Silver colours can appear glittery Dirty colour tonesBits in the filter can be seen after straining
Strengths and Weaknesses