Berkeley City College Portfolio Assessment Reader 1 Initials Reader 2 Initials Final Scores                                                    Total  of  R1  and  R2,   no  discrepancy:  

Criterion

Score

Criterion

Score

Criterion

Score Reading   Comprehension       Reading   Comprehension       Reading   Comprehension    

Thesis/Main   Idea       Thesis/Main   Idea       Thesis/Main   Idea    

Organization       Organization       Organization    

Dev./Illustration       Dev./Illustration       Dev./Illustration    

Textual  Evidence       Textual  Evidence       Textual  Evidence    

Analysis       Analysis       Analysis    

Clarity/Style       Clarity/Style       Clarity/Style    

Mechanics/Usage       Mechanics/Usage       Mechanics/Usage    

Formatting       Formatting       Formatting    

#/Quality  of  Sources       #/Quality  of  Sources       #/Quality  of  Sources    

Significant  difference  between  proctored  in-­‐class  essay  and  other  writing  and/or  other  evidence  of  plagiarism:                  YES                                NO  

All  scores  4  and  above:                            YES                                NO        

 

FINAL SCORE: Total  of  final  scores                                          for  all  criteria  

� possible  plagiarism  in  in-­‐class  summary  

� possible  plagiarism  in  in-­‐class  essay  

� possible  plagiarism  in  research  paper  

� missing  or  inadequate  in-­‐text  citations  

� minimal  concession/refutation