political violence at the inca empire based in skeletal alfredo j. altamirano-enciso research of...

25
POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL Instituto de Pesquisa Clínica Evandro Chagas IPEC - FIOCRUZ FIOCRUZ ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro

Upload: samuel-cable

Post on 01-Apr-2015

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN

SKELETAL

ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO

Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro

POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL

Instituto de Pesquisa Clínica Evandro ChagasIPEC - FIOCRUZFIOCRUZ

ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISOResearch of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro

Page 2: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

INTRODUCTIONTh inca empire or Tawantinsuyo was the most great civilization of New World that expanded for more six andean countries: Argentina, Chile, Bolivia, Perú, Ecuador and Colombia during 1460-1532 d.C.. They spoke the quíchua, aymara, quignam, muchik and others languages. Beginning in Cusco place with the Ayarmaca and Killke, between XII-XIII centuries, across a political of competence and fight by the control of new lands for agriculture.

Their experience in wars was complemented by reciprocity and redistribution. Peoples conquered were anexed at inca empire like mitmaq (prisioners) to build cities, roads, bridge, and disturb several populations to diferent parts of andean world. The ritual of sacrifice camelids and guinea pig was due frequently in those works. In the Rimac valley lived the Ichmas or Ichimay people.

Paleopatological studies in human skulls of Makat-Tampu, Zapán, Limatambo and Ancón sites revel that had a political violence (VP) in central coast. It was incremented by introduction of mitmaq Huarochiri and Canta.

The control of Rimac valley was always appreciated by highlanders since Early Intermiddle period (100-700 d.C.). Conflicts between yungas and highlanders occurred frequently in the valley by control of good lands a abundant water.

Page 3: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

THE INCA EMPIRE OR TAWANTINSUYO, XIV-

XVI centuries a.C.

Page 4: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

TRADITIONAL HIPOTHESIS

Según los documentos históricos hispanos revela que la costa central, especificamente el valle del Rímac, fue ocupado por los Ichmas o Ichimay, habitantes de los valles Lurin y Rimac, y subjugados em forma pacifica por Tupac Yupanqui em 1470 proque el dios Pachacamac era similar al dios Wiracocha (Espinoza 1990; Rostworowski 1978, 1992). Además, el valle era fertil, tenía muchos canales de riego y vivian mas de 150 mil habitantes (Rowe 1956, Shady 1984).

La conquista del valle del Rímac fue dificil y se libraron constantes conflictos entre los ichmas y mitmaq-Huarochiri. Tensión que crecia por el control de los canales de irrigación del valle. Este stress y la fundación de tambos como Makat-tampu, Limatambo, Armatambo e Ichmatampu (en Pachacamac) era parte de la violencia politica (VP) practicado por los incas en el valle bajo del Rimac y Lurin.

MODERN PALEOPATOLOGICAL HIPOTHESIS

Page 5: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

INCA MUMMY FROM ARMATAMBO, RIMAC

VALLEY, LIMA, MUSEUM OF ARCHEOLOGY OF UNMSM

LOCALIZATION OF MAKAT-TAMPU ON THE CENTRAL COAST, RIMAC VALLEY, PERU, before Incas arrived

Page 6: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

THE MATERIAL

Between 1999-2000, were analyzed 241 skulls from Makat-Tampu, site (Lima). It is deposited in the Museo Nacional de Arqueologia, Antropologia and Historia (MNHAA) of Lima, Peru. The material was excavated by Toribio Mexia Xesspe in 1945.

In 1951, it was studied by Mary F. Ericksen. Actually, this material is in

Physical Anthropological Laboratory of MNHAA. The preservation is good.

Page 7: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

METHODOLOGY:

Age determination of the skull

-Dental eruption

-Skull sutures

-Fusion of fontanelas

-Fusion of basilar suture

-Osteons

Gener determination of the skull

Lateral eminences of frontal

-Superciliar Arch

-Malar bone constitution

-Canine form

-Zigomatic arch constitution

-Petross portion os temporal

-Elevation of nasal bone

Page 8: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

DIRECT METHOD: Paleopatological study

Sífilis e modelação tabular ereta, cráneo de Paracas, Ica (Peru)

Hiperostose porótica (Anemia) e modelação fronto-ocipital, Costa Central, Peru

Page 9: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

RESEARCHING MUMMIES AND SKULLS WITH TRAUMATIC BONE LESIONS (MNAAH, Perú)

Page 10: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

Results

The skeletal material was well preserved and 9 men and 2 women, aged up to 30 years (4.56% of the skulls), had peri and pre-mortem nasal, frontal, and parietal fractures.

Page 11: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

Results

-11 cases (4,56%): 9 men and 2 women adults with nasal and frontal lesions with trrauma skulls. N= 142, n = 11 cases.-The deformation os skull indicates that they were people procedent of the Lima highland perhaps Huarochiri or Canta people.

Page 12: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE
Page 13: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

ARMAS LITICAS INCAS QUE IMPACTARON LOS

CRANEOS ICHIMAY, MAKAT-TAMPU, PERU,

1470-1532 d.C.

Page 14: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

CIRURGICAL OPERATION OF SKULL AT PARACAS SOCIETY (1.000-800 B.C.)

Page 15: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

COMPARISON WITH THE ICONOGRAPHY OF

NORTH COAST, MOCHICA POTTERY

Page 16: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

EVOLUTION OF LITIC PROJECTIL POINT, RIMAC VALLEY (Between 10.000 - 1.000 a.C.)

Page 17: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

PARALELOS: PACATNAMÚ, PERU, MASACRE DE GUERREROS CHIMU, 1.100-1.300 d.C. (Verano 1995)

Page 18: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

VIOLENCE AT MOCHE SOCIETY Centuries I-VII a.C., Beginning of

Mitmaq

Page 19: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

RECONSTRUCTION OF TRAUMA SKULL FROM MAKAT-TAMPU USING MOCHE ART AND STONE CIRCULAR LITIC

Page 20: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

PRISIONERS: MOCHE CULTURE I-VII Centuries A.C., ORIGIN OF MITMAQ

Page 21: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

INCA POLITICAL VIOLENCE BY HUAMAN POMA (1616)

Page 22: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

LA LLEGADA DE LOS ESPAÑOLES, 1532 d.C., MUERTE DE

ATAHUALPA Y LA CAIDA DEL IMPERIO INCA

Page 23: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

CONCLUSIONS

-The skeletal material was well preserved and 9 men and 2 women, aged up to 30 years (4.56% of the skulls), had peri and pre-mortem nasal, frontal, and parietal fractures. Its were fractured by violence causa during inca installation at central coast of Rimac valley.

-The deformation os skull indicates that they were people procedent of the highland perhaps Huarochiri or Canta people. They were mitmaq.

-The depression of frontal is an indicator that it was did by litic instrument like porra or macana.

-Others village like Makat-tampu, Limatampu, Zapan, Macas and Huarochiri are indicators of the political violence during the inca administration.

-Mitmaq were the people with most stress (strangers) introduced in new regions to inca occupation.

Page 24: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

THE COLLAPSE OF INCA EMPIREEXTERNAL FACTORS : INTRODUCTION F

VIRAL DISEASES OF OLD WORLD: Smallpox, measless, syphilis, cold, typhoid fever, pneumoy, peste. Great mortality of population and dead about 95%.

CATEQUIZATION AND SANTA INQUISITION

THE DEAD OF ATAHUALPA INCA (23/11/1532)

ANDEAN PEOPLE WERE BURNED

INTERNAL FATORS : terrorisms, rebelions, treasons, economic crises, sacks, etc.

Page 25: POLITICAL VIOLENCE AT THE INCA EMPIRE BASED IN SKELETAL ALFREDO J. ALTAMIRANO-ENCISO Research of OSWALDO CRUZ FOUNDATION, Rio de Janeiro POLITICAL VIOLENCE

ACKNOWLEDMENTS

To Dr. Mauro Célio de A. Marzochi, physician, especialist in leishmaniasis (assessor teacher).

to Dr. João Soares Moreira, otorrinolaringologist, especialist in leishmaniasis of faringe (co-orientador).

to Dra. Keyla Feldman Marzochi, directora do IPEC/Fiocruz, by his constant help during of developing of research.

At ENSP, to Dra. Sheila Mendonça de Souza, physician and the first specialist in brazilian paleopathology.

To all members of the National Reference Center in Leishmaniases of Evandro Chagas Clinical Institute at FIOCRUZ.

Part of this estudy was realized between 1999-2000, to prepare my doctoral thesis.