play analysis cardullo

7/25/2019 Play Analysis Cardullo

1/316

"#$%&' ()&*+,,#

!"#$ &'#"$()(* & +,#-,.


2/316


3/316

"#$%&' ()&*+,,#

"#$% &'$#%()(* & +,$-,.

!"!#$%-.%&,)/0'+''/)&'


4/316

/)0#)12.$3)(45, 6'31.7$8)1' -,. 9,:8(45,' ;$8)1'$#0)0#)185,?7'%&7%' @$%& 5''ABCC*7$D*-7$D*% )$&+G #& '&)73>2''%*G 27 )7] G #& $] )7] >%)73 %,%4'),G >%45)724),G A5#'#4#A]27/G &%4#&*27/ #'5%&W23%_ W2'5#+' '5% A&2#& W&2''%7 A%&>2332#7 #< '5% A+$,235%&D R7] A%&3#7 W5# *#%3 )7] +7)+'5#&2:%* )4'27 &%,)'2#7 '# '523 A+$,24)'2#7 >)] $% ,2)$,% '# 4&2>27), A%4+'2#7 )7* 4292, 4,)2>3 )/%3D

;&27'%* 27 E%&>)7]


5/316

!

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+, ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .

/*+0'123+4'* -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5

6 7+%89#:97+%8 6880'"3; +'

!" $%&'()*) +, -'+. &%/ $0.*+% """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 12

!!" $%&'()*) +, 34&5&0.65 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 11

!!!" $%&'()*) +, 7&%89&86 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 1:

!;" '/?@' #6' .+A+(,


6/316

E

?@ABC B776D7E )K6H6)!BH 6FA H@CB ------------------------------- LM

>6( $%&'(.*0&' ?96).*+%@ AB4&. *) .46 /5&H&.*0 ,9%0.*+% +, &C&5.*09'&5 04&5&0.65@ F4( *) .4*) 04&5&0.65 *% .46 C'&(E &%/ F4&. /+6)46 +5 )46 0+%.5*Z9.6 .+ .46 /6D6'+CH6%. +, *.) .46H6JK

AN46 34+59) *% @%1E $ T+'/*65I) -5+Z'6H)@S+.6) +% .46 W9''65 -'&("""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 21:

AV&H6.I) N);/()&%/


7/316

O

?@ABC B776D7E

C6FNJ6NBG 7D?O@CG 7@JFAG 6FA 6CCJ7/@F ------------------- >MP

>6( $%&'(.*0&' ?96).*+%@ Aa+F F+9'/ (+9 /*).*%89*)4 .46 9)6 +,'&%89&86 &%/ *H&865( *% & C&5.*09'&5 C'&( ,5+H .4&. +, +.465 C'&()JK

AV9)*0 *% T4&[6)C6&56I) F79'@@/K """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 2:]

AN46 L%/*%8 +, Md04%65I) .'/(:' %() .'(%""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 2:P

A.+'P'37/)E \+H&%.*0*)HE &%/ -+6.5( *% B*''*&H)I)@'(71"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 2]_

A7*.65&5( $''9)*+%) *% T46C&5/I) D56+') M9+@)"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 2]:

AN*.'6 &%/ $)*/6 *% M56%.+%I) */6'


8/316

"

!"#$% $''()'*

+"!,(-.'"/0 +"/1-('10 (/# ./2%3$/+$ 44444444444444444444444 567

!"# %&'(#)*+'( ,-".)*/&0 123 )4/ 5('#. .*6*('7 *& .)#("8 .)7-+)-7"8 /7

6"'&*&98 4:') '7" ):" ;*33"7"&+". *& ./+*/."&I. 8$')&) '&; P/5:/+(".I 9%:6(-) ;3.2++')KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LLQ

1F:" R&;*&9. /3 O>."&I. %.'&; 8$')&)KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LSM

1P*6/& T'73/7; *& 2IJ"*((I. ? ;'-@$ 'A &$% B'%&'&; C'.% #&2&%>3

C2+)6'+)

KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LSS

1F:/6'.I. D+:%. C6>E F'':*& U*9:) /3 V*(;"7I. 9-. ;'G+KKKKKK LSQ

1V'(+/))I. ;$% #%2 2& 12-($6+'&; P#&9"I.

H6:%.) &' &$% #%20 % G/65'7*./&KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LWX

127)/&I. /''&'&; P:'Y".5"'7"I. %&KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LWW

1Z'6")I. 8>%+02..3 8>%+ H'))'&; P"((*&9 *& %6"7*+'& D7'6'LW[

8.8%."9-(,:.+(% -$'"3-+$' 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 5;;

9%"''(-) "2 #-(!(1.+ 1$-!' 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 5

OK F'>(" /3 G/&)7'.).0 F:"')"7 '&; \*(6 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK L]S

OOK F'>(" /3 G/&)7'.).0 F7'9";#8 G/6";#8 '&; \'7+" KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK L][

OOOK F'>(" /3 G/&)7'.).0 ^"'(*.6 '&; J')-7'(*.6 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LNX

O_K F#5". /3 F:"')"7 G7*)*+*.6 /7 C7/;-+)*/& G7*)*+*.6 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK LNL

1",.+' 2"- ?-.1./9 (/# #.'+3''."/ 4444444444444444444444444444444 57@

./#$A 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 >B>


9/316

!

!"#$%&'(#)%"

#$%& '() *(%$' )**+,* -./012)2 -. '(-* 3%%45 %.) 6-00 71-/40, 2-*/%8)$'(+' &, 9$)%//19+'-%.* +* + /$-'-/ +$) .%' '()%$)'-/+0: ; +&5 $+'()$5 +

+&-.+'-%. %? '()

*'$1/'1$)5 *',0)5 -&+@)$,5 /(+$+/')$-A+'-%.5 +.2 0+.@1+@) %? + 90+,: B*

*%&)%.) 6(% %./) $)@10+$0, 6%$4)2 -. '() '()+')$ +* + 2$+&+'1$@5 &%$)C

%8)$5 ; +& /%./)$.)2 /(-)?0, 6-'( 2$+&+'-/ +.+0,*-* '(+' /+. 3) %? 3).)?-'

.%' %.0, '% 90+,$)+2)$* +.2 '()+')$@%)$*5 31' +0*% '% 2-$)/'%$*5 2)*-@.)$*5

+.2 )8). +/'%$*D'(+' -*5 6-'( +.+0,*-* %? /(+$+/')$5 +/'-%.5 2-+0%@1)5 +.2

*)''-.@ '(+' /+. 3) '$+.*0+')2 -.'% /%./)9'* ?%$ '()+'$-/+0 9$%21/'-%.5 %$

'(+' /+. +' 0)+*' 9$%8-2) '() 4-.2 %? 1.2)$*'+.2-.@ %? + 90+, 6-'( 6(-/( +

'()+')$ 9$+/'-'-%.)$ /%102 ?$1-'?100, 71+$$)0: E+., %? '() 90+,* /%.*-2)$)2

-. '(-* 8%01&) +$) $)@10+$0, 9$%21/)25 )*9)/-+00, 3, 1.-8)$*-', '()+')$*5

+.2 -' &, (%9) '(+' '()*) )>90-/+'%$, )**+,* +.2 .%')* 6-00 -. *%&) *&+00

6+, &+4) + /%.'$-31'-%. '% ?1'1$) *'+@-.@*: B .1&3)$ %? '()*) 2$+&+*!

0-4) "#$%&'( *+,-../(0 1-23#40 5%.6 7#-,0 *-,4'88#0 1#$$- 9-:3#,0

;-#-4? /8 - @-3#(2-. +$) +0*% $%1'-.)0, '$)+')2 -.

(-@( */(%%0 +.2 /%00)@) /%1$*)* %. 2$+&+'-/ 0-')$+'1$)5 *% -' -* +0*% &,

(%9) '(+' '() $)0+'-8)0, *(%$' F+.2 '()$)?%$) 0)** -.'-&-2+'-.@5 &%$) +/C

/)**-30)G 9-)/)* /%.'+-.)2 -.A3-+ B.-3+(%(C B D#-$#, 6-00 *)$8) *'12).'*

+* &%2)0* ?%$ '() 6$-'-.@ %? 90+, +.+0,*)*:

H(+' ?%00%6* -* '() )>90-/+'-%. %? + &)'(%2 ?%$ 90+,$)+2-.@ +.2

+.+0,*-*5 .%' -. '() /%.8-/'-%. '(+' *1/( + &)'(%2 6-00 )>(+1*' )8)$,

8+01) -. + 90+,5 31' -. '() (%9) '(+' -' 6-00 1./%8)$ '() &+=%$ +$)+* '()$)+2)$ %? 90+,* *(%102 /%.*-2)$: I)' .% %.) +**1&) '(+' ?$1-'?10 +.+0,*-*

%? 90+,* -* + &+'')$ %? *-&90) ).1&)$+'-%. %$ %? ?-00-.@ -. 30+.4* %. +

/%&9$)().*-8) 71)*'-%..+-$): B.+0,*-* +0*% -.8%08)* =12@&).': J()$) -*

.% *(%$'/1' '% /10'-8+'-.@ +. )+$ ?%$ @%%2 2-+0%@1)5 +. ),) ?%$ )??)/'-8)

*'+@-.@5 %$ + ?))0-.@ ?%$ 9$%9)$ 3+0+./) +.2 *'$1/'1$) -. '() 6%$4 +* +

6(%0): K1*' +* '() $)+2)$ 6-00 3)'')$ 1.2)$*'+.2 6(+' + 90+, -* 3, $)+2-.@

+.2 *))-.@ +* &+., 90+,* +* 9%**-30)5 *% 6-00 () %$ *() 3)'')$ +.+0,A) +.2

-.')$9$)' 90+,* 3, (+8-.@ $)+25 *)).5 -.$)>').*-8)0, '(%1@(' +3%1' '()&:


10/316

VW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

#@@ U :%( )/ 9'6' +3 7/ :+7' 3/;' /H 79' %??6/%:9'3 79%7 9%A' ?6/A') 53'Y

H5@ 7/ 6'%)'63 +( 79' ?%37T

#@79/5,9 3/;' P',+((+(, 6'%)'63 %335;' % 9/37+@+71 P'7$''(

6'%)+(, %() %(%@13+3Z U ;537 376'33 79%7 79' 7$/ %:7+A+7+'3 %6' 79/6/5,9@1:/;?%7+P@'T U()'')Z P',+((+(, 375)'(73 3/;'7+;'3 'A+)'(:' % ;+376537 /H

%(1 &+() /H @+7'6%61 %(%@13+3T U7 ,%+(3 'L?6'33+/( +( 79' H/6; /H 35:9

37%7';'(73 %3 [U '(S/1') 79' $/6& H/6 +73'@HT J91 3?/+@ +7 P1 7%&+(, +7

%?%67K#(%@13+3Z @+7'6%61 :6+7+:+3;Z %() 79' :/(3+)'6%7+/( %() )+3:533+/(

/H +)'%3 %6' (/7 )'3+,(')Z 9/$'A'6Z 7/ 3?/+@ @+7'6%61 $/6&3\ 79'1 %6' +(Y

7'()') 7/ $+)'( %() )''?'( /56 %??6':+%7+/( /H 79/3' $/6&3T J' ;%1

'A'( 3%1 79%7 :/(3+)'6%7+/( %() )+3:533+/( %6' )+HH'6'(7 37%,'3 +( 79'

3%;' ?6/:'33X 79%7 /H '(S/1+(, %() 5()'637%()+(, % ?@%1T Q//) %(%@13+3

,6/$3 /57 /H % 79/6/5,9 %() +(H/6;') 6'%)+(, %() /(@1 /57 /H 35:9 %

6'%)+(,T

H%"14*Q +;%


11/316

U(76/)5:7+/( VV

39/5@) :/(:'(76%7' /( :/(7+(5+71Z ;//)Z %() +;?%:7T #H7'6 6'%)+(, 79'

?@%1Z 6'A+'$ 79' ?@/7 %() 37/61 +( 1/56 ;+()T *''& 7/ %??6'9'() $9%7 79'

7/7%@ %:7+/( /H 79' ?@%1 +3T ='6'Z %+)3 35:9 %3 ?@/7 35;;%6+'3 %6' (/7 P%)

/6 $6/(,Z ?6/A+)') 79'1 %6' 53') %3 %+)3 %() (/7 35P37+757'3T 8/ 6'@+%(:'39/5@) P' ?@%:') /( ?@/7 35;;%6+'3 P1 79';3'@A'3\ 9/$'A'6Z %3 % ;'%(3

/H :@%6+H1+(, 79' ?@%1 %() 6';+()+(, 79' 6'%)'6 /H 79' ;%S/6 'A'(73 %()

79'+6 3']5'(:'Z ?@/7 35;;%6+'3 :%( 3'6A' % 53'H5@ ?56?/3'T

U7 +3 %@$%13 %)A+3%P@'Z +( 6'%)+(, % ?@%1 H/6 79' H+637 /6 3':/()

7+;'Z 7/ ;%&' P6+'H (/7'3 %P/57 ?6/P@'; ?%33%,'3 P1 %(1 ;'79/) 79'

6'%)'6 H+() :/(A'(+'(7T


12/316

Va >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

$' :%( 3%1X J9'( +( )/5P7 6'6'%) 79' $/6&Z $9'79'6 79+3 ;'%(3 % 3:'('Z

%( %:7Z /6 'A'( 79' $9/@' ?@%1T M%6'H5@ 6'%)+(, %() A'6+H+:%7+/( 796/5,9

6'H'6'(:' 7/ 79' ?@%1 %6' 79' /(@1 $%13 7/ ,5%6) %,%+(37 %( %(%@13+3 79%7 +3

3?5( /57 /( % 3@'()'6 796'%) %() 9%3 P':/;' +66'@'A%(7 7/ 79' $/6& +(]5'37+/(T # ,//) %(%@13+3 $+@@ 7/5:9 /( 79' @+7'6%61 7'L7 ?/+(7 %H7'6 ?/+(7T

@%13 6%6'@1 :/(7%+( 35:9

'L?@+:+7 )':@%6%7+/(3 /H 79';'T C/6'/A'6Z 79' 37%7';'(7 /H % 3+(,@' 79';'

;%1 (/7 (':'33%6+@1 :%?756' %@@ /H $/6&\ 79'6' ;%1 P' 3'A'6%@ 79';'3 /6

3'A'6%@ $%13 /H 'L?6'33+(, % ,'('6%@ 79';'T


13/316

U(76/)5:7+/( Ve

7'6;+(/@/,1Z $9%7 +3 79' [79/5,97/H 79' ?@%1 %3 % $9/@'K *+(:' ?@%13

53' $/6)3 %() %:7+/(3 P%3') /(Z /6 6'@%7') +( % ;'%(+(,H5@ $%1 7/Z 95Y

;%( @+H'Z 79'1 ;537 +('A+7%P@1 :/(A'1 3/;' 79/5,97 %P/57 @+H'T U )+3:533Y

+(, 79' ;'%(+(, /H % ?@%1Z /(' '()'%A/63 7/ ;%&' :@'%6 $9%7 79%7 79/5,97+3T

=/$'A'6 $' 7'6; /56 ?5635+7f79';'Z %77+75)'Z 79/5,97f$' ;537

(/7 H/6,'7 79%7 +7 @+'3 ';P'))') +( 79' $/6& %3 % $9/@' %() 79%7 $' ?'6Y

:'+A' +7 H6/; 79' 'L?'6+'(:' /H 6'%)+(, /6 3''+(, 79' ?@%1 %() %(%@1^+(,

79%7 ?@%1 %3 79/6/5,9@1 %3 ?/33+P@'T D57 $' ;537 ,5%6) %,%+(37 ;%&+(, %

)6%;% % 76%:7 %() %,%+(37 /A'6';?9%3+^+(, 79' 3?':+H+: A'6P%@ 'L?6'3Y

3+/(3 /H :9%6%:7'63 +( 79' )6%;%T U(37'%)Z $' ;537 %77';?7 7/ ;%&' /56

%??6'9'(3+/( /H ;'%(+(, :/(3+37'(7 $+79 79' 7/7%@ %:7+/( 79' ?@%1 )'?+:73T


14/316

Vg >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

/HH+:+%@ 3?/&'3?'63/( H/6 79' )6%;%7+37Z P57 /H H+()+(, 79' :'(7'6 /H ,6%A+Y

71 /H 79' $/6& +73'@HT

U7 +3 +( )'7'6;+(+(, 79' ;'%(+(, /H % ?@%1 79%7 $' 39/5@) :%@@ 5?/(

/56 79/6/5,9 &(/$@'),' /H 79' $/6& /P7%+(') 796/5,9 /56 %(%@13+3T F(':/5@) $'@@ 3%1 79%7 79' H+(%@ ?56?/3' /H %(%@13+3 +3 31(79'3+3T J' 'L%;+('

79' ?%673 /H % ?@%1 +( )'7%+@ +( /6)'6 7/ %77%+( % P'77'6 5()'637%()+(, /H 79'

$9/@'\ $' %(%@1^' +( /6)'6 7/ &(/$Z +( 79' )''?'37 3'(3'Z $9%7 79' ?@%1

+3 %P/57T #(%@13+3 %335;'3 79%7 79'6' 9%3 P''( % ?%77'6( /H %:7+/( ?6'Y

3'(7') 796/5,9 ?@/7Z 3765:756'Z :9%6%:7'6Z @%(,5%,'Z ;53+: /6 69179;Z %()

b+;%,+(')c 3?':7%:@'Z % ?%77'6( 79%7 9%3 % ;'%(+(, /H +73 /$( $9+:9

';'6,'3 /(@1 796/5,9 79' :/(,65'(7 +(7'6%:7+/( /H 79' ?%673 /H % ?@%1T


15/316

U(76/)5:7+/( V!

%;/(, /79'6 79+(,3Z 6';%+(3 @/1%@ $9+@' /79'63 %6' 39'))+(, /@) @/1%@Y

7+'3Z %() $9/ @'%)3 9+3 H%79'6 7/ 3'@HY5()'637%()+(, )'3?+7' 9+3 H%79'623

6'S':7+/( /H 9+;T D':%53' /H N),%623 :9%6%:7'6 %() :/()5:7Z $9%7 9' 3%13

+3 @+&'@1 7/ P' /H :/(3']5'(:' +( 79' ?@%1T 8'A'679'@'33Z 79' 765' 7'37 +337+@@ $9'79'6 9+3 $/6)3 %6' P/6(' /57 P1 79' 7/7%@ %:7+/( /H 79' ?@%1T


16/316

VE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

#@P%(123 37%7';'(7 :@/3' 7/ 79' '() /H 79' ?@%1X [#@@ H6+'()3 39%@@ 7%37' d

@%13Z @+&' 'A'61 /79'6 $/6& /H %67Z /::56 +( )'H+(+7' 7+;'3 %() ?@%:'3 %()

P'%6 5?/( 79'; 79' ;%6&3 /H % 3?':+H+: :5@756' %() 3'7 /H :+6:5;37%(:'3T

Q6'%7 +(7'6'37 %77%:9'3 7/ 35:9 ;%77'63 /H :/(7'L7 P':%53' 79'1 /H7'(:/(76+P57' 7/ /56 5()'637%()+(, /H $/6&3 H6/; 79' ?%37T D57 P',+((+(,

375)'(73 %6' 3/;'7+;'3 )+376537H5@ /H 79+3 +(7'6'37T #3 79'1 )+376537 %(%@1Y

3+3 %() %P376%:7+/( H/6 79'+6 ?6'35;') )'%)'(+(, 'HH':7 /( 79' $/6& /H

%67Z 3/ 7// )/ 79'1 )+376537 ['L7'6(%@:/(3+)'6%7+/(3 H/6 79'+6 ?6'35;')

+66'@'A%(:'T D/79 353?+:+/(3 %6' ;+3?@%:')Z %7 @'%37 %3 H%6 %3 79' 3+(:'6'

%() ;'%356') @/A'6 /H @+7'6%756' +3 :/(:'6(')T J' )/ (/7 $%(7 [79' 7%+@ 7/

$%, 79' )/,+( 79+3 +(37%(:'Z P57 ('+79'6 )/ $' $%(7 7/ :9/? 79' 7%+@ /HT

$' ;537 &''? +( ;+() 79%7 79' 6'%3/( $' )/ (/7 %@$%13 9%A' 7/ 6'%)

3/:+%@ 9+37/61 /6 @+7'6%61 P+/,6%?91 /6 :/;?%6%7+A' 6'@+,+/( 7/ 5()'637%()

79' @%7'37 (/A'@ +3 3+;?@1 79%7 +7 +3 /H /56 /$( 7+;'T =/$'A'6Z /(:' 79'

:/(:'6(3 /H % ?'6+/) 76%(3H/6; 79';3'@A'3 +(7/ /79'6 :/(:'6(3f79%7 +3Z

/(:' :566'(7 'A'(73 P':/;' 9+37/61f79' 3%;' ?6/P@';3 79%7 P'3'7 53 +(

6'%)+(, /@)'6 @+7'6%61 $/6&3 $+@@ ?6'3'(7 79';3'@A'3 7/ /56 )'3:'()%(73

$9'( 79'1 6'%) 79' $/6&3 /H /56 )%1T


17/316

U(76/)5:7+/( VO


18/316

Vh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

?@%:' % ?%67+:5@%6 ?@%1 /::5?+'3 +( 79%7 )'A'@/?;'(7Z %3 $'@@ %3 +( 79'

:5@756' %7 @%6,'T


19/316

U(76/)5:7+/( Vi

)/'3 (/7 P':/;' % ;'6' 'L:53' H/6 /56 )+3:/A'61 /H % H%A/6') 79'/61 /6

)/:76+('fC%6L+37Z H';+(+37Z ?/37Y:/@/(+%@Z %() 79' @+&'T

6 F'+% '* @0Q"*4R"+4'*

*+(:' 375)'(73 71?+:%@@1 ,'7 '33%1 %33+,(;'(73 /H 79' H/@@/$+(, &+()Z

-'&( $%&'()*)@ $ \6&/65+3 )'3+,(') 7/ 39/$ 79'; 9/$Z 796/5,9 :%6'H5@Y

@1 ,6/5?')Z :/(:6'7' 'L%;?@'3Z 79'1 ;+,97 3'7 %P/57 :/;?@'7+(, 35:9

%33+,(;'(73X

VT [M9//3' %( +;?/67%(7 :9%6%:7'6 +( 35:9Y%()Y35:9 % ?@%1 %() %(Y

%@1^' 9+3 /6 9'6 )6%;%7+: H5(:7+/(T @/7 %()

#:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756'Z[M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@'Z[*71@' %() Q'(Y

6'Z [.%(,5%,'Z *1;P/@Z */5()Z %() #@@53+/(Z [


20/316

aW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

:6+7+:%@ %??%6%753 :/(3+37+(, /H % *7'?YP1Y*7'? #??6/%:9 7/ >@%1 #(%@1Y

3+3Z % Q@/33%61 /H 06%;%7+: 6/3?'6/ 3%13 +( *9%&'Y

3?'%6'23 N6HC6).Z ?6/A' 7/ P' [%@@ 3?+6+73Z %() %6' ;'@7') +(7/ %+6Z +(7/ 79+(

%+6TB/6 79' 6'%)'6Z 79'1 ;%1 :/;' P%:& 7/ @+H' %,%+(Z %() %,%+(Z /( 79'

?6+(7') ?%,'T


21/316

aV

6 7+%89#:97+%8 6880'"3; +' 31Y

:9/@/,+:%@K N79+:%@K ='6/+:K G'@+,+/53K >/@+7+:%@K N7:T

eT J9%7 9%3 79' )6%;%7+37 3'@':7') /H 79' ?/33+P@' 'A'(73 /H 79' 37/Y

61 7/ ?57 +(7/ %:75%@ 3:'('3K J9+:9 'A'(73 %6' 3+;?@1 6'?/67')

/6 6'A'%@') 796/5,9 'L?/3+7+/(K

gT 06%;% +3 %:7+/( %() 79' '33'(:' /H %:7+/( +3 :/(H@+:7T U(3/H%6 %3

% 3+75%7+/( :/(7%+(3 :/(H@+:7Z +7 +3 )6%;%7+:X (/ :/(H@+:7Z (/ )6%Y

;%T 06%;% +3 79' ?6/:'33 /H 56)+'D*%8:/(H@+:7Z %() $9%7 +3 ;/37

+;?/67%(7 +( )6%;%7+: %(%@13+3 +3 7/ ?'6:'+A' 79' :/(H@+:7 +(9'6Y

'(7 +( 79' ?@%1T M/(H@+:7 :6'%7'3 :9%6%:7'63Z /6 :9%6%:7'63f79'+6

/??/3+(, )'3+6'3 /6 ('')3f:6'%7' :/(H@+:7T


22/316

aa >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

bB/6 +(37%(:'Z 79' @%7' ?/+(7 /H %77%:& +( O6/*C9) N(5&%%+)Z

$9/3' ?@/7 9%3 % :/(3+)'6%P@' ?%37Z A'6353 79' '%6@1 ?/+(7 /H %7Y

7%:& +(>*%8 76&5Z +( $9+:9 79' ?%37 +3 A+675%@@1 (/('L+37'(7Tc

ET =/$ ;%(1 %:73 %() 3:'('3 %6' 79'6'K 0+) 79' ?@%123 %579/6 (/7'

79'; /6 $'6' 79'3' )+A+3+/(3 %))') @%7'6K J9%7 ;/7+A%7'3 79'

)+A+3+/(3 /H 79' ?@%1 %() 9/$ %6' 79'1 ;%6&') b:567%+(3Z P@%:&Y

/573Z '7:TcK

OT #6' 79'6' 35P?@/73K UH 3/Z 9/$ +3 '%:9 6'@%7') 7/ 79' ;%+( %:Y

7+/(K

hT J9%7 %@+,(;'(73Z ?%6%@@'@3Z /6 6'?'7+7+/(3 )/ 1/5 (/7+:'K bB/6

'L%;?@'Z 79' 76+?@' 6'A'(,' ?@/7 +( a&H'6.\ 79' P@+()


23/316

# *7'?YP1Y*7'? #??6/%:9 7/ >@%1 #(%@13+3 ae

gT J9%7 ]5%@+7+'3 /6 %3?':73 /H :9%6%:7'6 %6' 376'33')X 79' ?913+:%@Z

79' 3/:+%@Z 79' ?31:9/@/,+:%@Z /6 79' ;/6%@ /6 '79+:%@K bB/6 +(Y

37%(:'Z UP3'(23 ['79+:%@:9%6%:7'6 A'6353 M9'&9/A23 :9%6%:7'6 /H

[;//)

/6 H65376%7') 3'(3+P+@+71X #'3:91@5323 [,6%()Z

3:5@?756%@:9%6%:7'6 A'6353 N56+?+)'32 [?31:9/?%79+::9%6%:7'6Tc

!T =/$ +3 :9%6%:7'6 6'A'%@')K D1 31;P/@3 %() +;%,'61 bC%:P'7923

?6'/::5?%7+/( $+79 P@//) %() 7+;'cK D1 +(7'6%:7+/( $+79 A%6+/53

/79'6 :9%6%:7'63 b=%;@'7 $+79 =/6%7+/ %() F?9'@+%cK D1 $9%7

79' :9%6%:7'6 3%13K D1 $9%7 /79'63 3%1 %P/57 79' :9%6%:7'6K D1

$9%7 79' :9%6%:7'6 )/'3K b79' ;/37 +;?/67%(7cT D1 )'3:6+?7+/(3

/H 79' :9%6%:7'6 +( 79' 37%,' )+6':7+/(3K

ET =/$ )/ :9%6%:7'6 76%+73 %:7+A%7' 79' )6%;%K b8/7' 9/$ % :9%6%:Y

7'623 76%+73 %6' +(A%6+%P@1 +(A/@A') +( 9+3 /6 9'6 %:73 %3 ;/7+A'3

H/6Z /6 :%53'3 /HZ 79/3' %:73Tc

OT M/(3+)'6 '%:9 :9%6%:7'6 %3 % [A/+:'+( 79' ?@%123 /A'6%@@ )+%@':Y

7+:Z :/(76+P57+(, 7/ 79';'Z +)'%Z /6 ;'%(+(,T

hT J9%7 'A+)'(:' /H :9%(,' :%( 1/5 )'7':7K J9%7 3'';3 7/ 9%A'

P''( 79' 3/56:' /H 79+3 :9%(,'Z %() $9%7 )/'3 +7 3+,(+H1 H/6 79'

?@%123 79';' /6 79' H+(%@ (%756' /H 79' :9%6%:7'623 +)'(7+71K

iT =/$ +3 79' :9%6%:7'623 :9%(,' 'L?6'33') )6%;%7+:%@@1K bB/6 'LY

%;?@'Z +( % [6':/,(+7+/( 3?'':9Z +( % ('$H/5() %77+75)'Z +( %

P'9%A+/6%@ ,'3756'Z '7:Tc

///- 6*"$:,4, '( C"*Q2"Q%

VT


24/316

ag >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

%T J9%7 9%??'(3 )56+(, 79+3 )+%@/,5' %() %3 % 6'35@7 /H 79+3 )+Y

%@/,5'K

PT J9%7 )/'3 79+3 ?%33%,' 6'A'%@ %P/57 79' +(('6 @+H' %() ;/Y

7+A'3 /H '%:9 :9%6%:7'6K

:T J9%7 )/'3 79+3 3:'(' 6'A'%@ %P/57 79' 6'@%7+/(39+?3 /H 79'

:9%6%:7'63 7/ '%:9 /79'6K

)T J9%7 )/'3 79+3 3':7+/( 6'A'%@ %P/57 79' ?@/7 /6 %P/57 %(1 /H

79' :+6:5;37%(:'3 :/(76+P57+(, 7/ 79' :/;?@+:%7+/( /6 6'3/Y

@57+/( /H 79' ?@/7K

'T J9%7 %6' 79' ;/37 (/7%P@' ;/;'(73 /6 37%7';'(73 +( 79+3

)+%@/,5'K

HT #6' 79'6' %(1 +;?@+:+7 /6 5(3?/&'( ;%77'63 +( 79+3 3:'(' 79%7

)'3'6A' %77'(7+/(K

,T

J9%7 H%:+%@ 'L?6'33+/(3Z ?913+:%@ ,'3756'3Z /6 P/)+@1;/A';'(73 %6' +;?@+') P1 79' )+%@/,5'K

9T J9%7 ?6/?3 /6 3'7 ?+':'3 %6' 'L?@+:+7@1 /6 +;?@+:+7@1 :%@@')

H/6 +( 79' )+%@/,5' /6 79' 37%,' )+6':7+/(3K

+T J9%7 A/:%@ +(H@':7+/(3 /6 7/(' /H A/+:' )/'3 % @+(' 35,,'37K

ST

J9'6' ;+,97 79' :9%6%:7'63 +(:6'%3' /6 )':6'%3' 79' A/@5;'

/6 3?'') /H 79'+6 )'@+A'61K

&T J9'6' ;+,97 79' :9%6%:7'63 ?%53' +( )'@+A'6+(, 79'+6 @+('3K

@T J9'6' ;+,97 79' :9%6%:7'63 37%() /( 37%,' %() +( 6'@%7+/( 7/

'%:9 /79'6 %7 79' P',+((+(, /H 79' 3:'(' %() %7 @%7'6 ?/+(73

+( 79' 3%;' 3:'('K


25/316

# *7'?YP1Y*7'? #??6/%:9 7/ >@%1 #(%@13+3 a!

aT 0/ %@@ 79' :9%6%:7'63 53' @%(,5%,' +( ;5:9 79' 3%;' $%1Z /6

)/'3 '%:9 9%A' 9+3 /6 9'6 /$( A'6P%@ :9%6%:7'6+37+:3K

eT J9%7 %6' 79' )/;+(%(7 +;%,' ?%77'6(3K bB/6 +(37%(:'Z )+3'%3'Y

)':%1Y)'%79 +;%,'61 +(a&H'6.Tc 0/ :9%6%:7'63 3''; 7/ 39%6' %

?%67+:5@%6 ?%77'6(Z /6 +7 'L:@53+A' 7/ /(' :9%6%:7'6K bB/6 'L%;Y

?@'Z F79'@@/ ,6%)5%@@1 P',+(3 7/ ?+:& 5? U%,/23 3'L5%@YP'37+%@

+;%,'61 %3 9' P':/;'3 ;/6' :/(A+(:') /H 0'3)';/(%23 ,5+@7Tc

gT J9%7 :/;P+(%7+/(3 /6 :/(H@%7+/(3 /H +;%,' ?%77'6(3 :%( 1/5 )'Y

7':7K bB/6 +(37%(:'Z +(a&H'6.Z +( 79' @+('3 [D1 79' /2'6,6/$79 /H

3/;' :/;?@'L+/(Z d FH7 P6'%&+(, )/$( 79' ?%@'3 %() H/673 /H6'%3/(Z79' +;%,'61 /H :%(:'6Z /6 ?/@@57+/( P1 [/A'6,6/$79Z+3

:/(H@%7') $+79 ;+@+7%61 +;%,'61Tc

!T NL?@%+( 79' ?6'3'(:' /H 35:9 69'7/6+:%@ )'A+:'3 %3X 35))'( 39+H73

H6/; A'63' 7/ ?6/3'\ 691;') :/5?@'73\ [3'73?'':9'3 79%7 ,+A'

79' %??'%6%(:' /H P'+(, 37%()%6) /6 :/(A'(7+/(%@ b>/@/(+5323

%)A+:' 7/ .%'67'3 +(a&H'6.c\ :9/6%@ 3?'':9'3\ H/6;%@ [)'P%7'3\

'7:T


26/316

aE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

%??6/?6+%7' 7/ 79+3 ?@%1 %() (/ /79'6K bB/6 +(37%(:'Z V&0Z6.423

)%6&Z [;'7%?913+:%@ 3?%:' A'6353 a&H'6.23 )'(3' %() A%6+/53

$/6@) /H /PS':73Z ?'/?@'Z %(+;%@3Z %() ?6/:'33'3Tc

/S- N%*%0"$

VT J9%7 +3 79' )6%;%7+3723 %77+75)' 7/$%6) 79' ;%7'6+%@3 /H 9+3 /6 9'6

?@%1K b*&'?7+:%@K M6+7+:%@K U6/(+:K *1;?%79'7+:K 8'576%@ /6 /PY

S':7+A'K N7:Tc

aT J9%7 H'%756'3 /6 '@';'(73 /H 79' ?@%1 3''; 7/ P' 79' 3/56:' /H

79' )6%;%7+3723 %77+75)'K b# 6'%3/(%P@' /6 6'%3/(+(, :9%6%:7'61/5 :%( 76537K # :9/6%@ '@';'(7K # )+)%:7+: A/+:' )'7':7%P@' +(

79' :/(7'(7 %3 % $9/@'K #( %@@',/6+:%@ ]5%@+71K


27/316

# *7'?YP1Y*7'? #??6/%:9 7/ >@%1 #(%@13+3 aO

OT B/6 $9%7 &+() /H 79'%76+:%@ 3?%:' $%3 79' ?@%1 +(7'()') P1 +73

%579/6K #6' 3/;' /H 79' ?@%123 :9%6%:7'6+37+:3 79' 6'35@7 /H )6%Y

;%7+: :/(A'(7+/(3 +( 53' %7 79' 7+;' 79' $/6& $%3 $6+77'(K

hT =/$ 'L7'(3+A' %6' 79' 37%,' )+6':7+/(3K J'6' 79'1 $6+77'( P1

79' %579/6 /6 +(7'6?/@%7') P1 3/;'/(' '@3'K J9%7 71?' /H +(H/6Y

;%7+/( )/ 79'1 :/(A'1K #6' 79'1 +;?/67%(7 7/ 79' )6%;%7+: %:Y

7+/(K

iT U3 79' ?@%1 % 76%(3@%7+/(K M%( 1/5 :/;?%6' +7 7/ 79' /6+,+(%@K

M%( 1/5 :/;?%6' +7 $+79 /79'6 76%(3@%7+/(3K #6' 79'6' 3+,(+H+Y

:%(7 )+HH'6'(:'3 P'7$''( 79' 3/56:' %() % 76%(3@%7+/(Z 35:9 %379' 6'()'6+(, /H 79' %579/623 /6+,+(%@ B6'(:9 A'63' +( N(,@+39

?6/3'K

VWT U3 79'6' %(1 )+HH'6'(:' P'7$''( ?@%1+(, 7+;' b79' 7+;' +7 7%&'3 7/

?'6H/6; 79' ?@%1c %() +@@53/61 7+;' b79' 7+;' 79' %:7+/( +3 35?Y

?/3') 7/ 7%&'cK J9%7 +3 79' 6'@%7+/(39+? P'7$''( 79' 7$/Z +H %(1K

VVT

U3 79'6' %(179+(, 3?':+%@ %P/57 79' 7+7@'K 0/'3 +7 H/:53 /( % :9%6Y

%:7'6Z 79' 3'77+(,Z /6 % 79';'K U3 +7 7%&'( H6/; % ]5/7%7+/( /6 +3 +7

%( %@@53+/(K 0/'3 79' 7+7@' :/(7%+( % ?/+(7 /H A+'$Z 35,,'37 %

;//)Z /6 /79'6$+3' [/6,%(+^'79' %:7+/( /H 79' ?@%1K

VaT 0/'3 79' ?@%1 :@'%6@1 H%@@ +(7/ /(' /H 79' ;%S/6 )6%;%7+: :%7',/Y

6+'3 b76%,')1Z :/;')1Z '7:TcK J9%7 :/(A'(7+/(%@ H'%756'3 /H +73

71?' )/'3 79' ?@%1 'L9+P+7 b35PS':7 ;%77'6Z 3+75%7+/(3Z :9%6%:7'671?'3cK 0/'3 &(/$@'),' /H 79' ,'(6' :/(76+P57' 7/ %( 5()'6Y

37%()+(, /H 79+3 ?@%1K


28/316


29/316

ai

?@ABC B776D7E


30/316

eW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

%3 D'33+'23 +3Z P1 :/(A'(7+/(%@ P/56,'/+3 ?@%7+75)'3T C/'Z H/6 9+3 ?%67Z +3

% ,%(,37'6T bF))@1Z /(@1 +( 79' @+37 /H 79' ?@%123 :9%6%:7'63 )/ $' @'%6(

H6/; F)'73 79%7 [9' 9%3 &+@@') 7$/ ;'( +( 'L76%Y;%67+%@ %:7+A+71jaa!k\

%() ='((+' 9'63'@H +;?@+'3 +( #:7 UUZ *:'(' +Z 79%7 C/' 9%3 P''( +( ?6+3/(P1 :%@@+(, 9+; [R+) 4%+@P+6) jaghkTc D57Z +6/(+:%@@1Z +7 +3 (/7 79%7 H%:7

$9+:9 :/()';(3 9+; 3/ ;5:9 %3 79' +)'% H/6 $9+:9 9+3 6%:&'7''6+(,

bP//7@',,+(, )56+(, >6/9+P+7+/(Z $9+:9 '()') +( VieeZ %() P//&;%&+(,

)56+(, 79' ?@%1c 37%()3T B/6 C/' +3 % P53+('33;%( H+637 %() % &+@@'6 /(@1

3':/()Z %() 9' 9+;3'@H ?%6%@@'@3 ,%(,37'6+3; %() :%?+7%@+3; +( % 3?'':9

7/ D'33+'23 P6/79'6Z C/671 b% $'%@791 )6'33 ;%(5H%:756'6cZ %@3/ +( #:7 UUZ

*:'(' +X [U723 %@@ % 6%:&'7fH6/; 9/63' 6%:+(, )/$(T C%66+%,'Z ?/@+7+:3Z

P+, P53+('33f'A'61P/)1 ?@%13 :/?3 %() 6/PP'63T _/5Z 1/526' % 6%:&'7''6

1/563'@H ba!WcT

_'7Z +H +723 %@@ % :%?+7%@+37+: 6%:&'7Z $9'( C/' )'?%673 $+79 ='((+'

%7 79' '() /H $F&[6 &%/ T*%8hE5(;%66+') %() :9+@)@'33Z 9' +3 +()+6':7@1

:/(H/6;+(, 7/ 9'6 ,6%()H%79'6 4%:/P23 S5),;'(7 /( 79' D'6,'6 H%;+@1f

%() /( ?'7+7 P/56,'/+3 ;%66+%,' %() H%;+@1 +( ,'('6%@f)'@+A'6') +( #:7

UX [C%6L 3%+) +7f%P/@+39 35:9 H%;+@+'3baehcT b


31/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' eV

H6/; 4%:/P23 )'%79 7/ 9+3 ,6%3?+(, ;/79'6fP57 9' ;%1 5@7+;%7'@1 %@3/

761 7/ H/;'(7 79' 6'A/@57+/( H/6 $9+:9 4%:/P 9%) :%@@')T U( 79+3 3'(3' 9'Z

7//Z +3 % 6'P'@ b5(;%66+') %() :9+@)@'33Z @+&' C/'cZ 9/?+(, 7/ 6';%+(

$+79+( 79' 3137'; %3 % @%P/6 /6,%(+^'6 /(@1 +( 79' '() 7/ 3;%39 79%7 313Y7'; H6/; $+79/57Z +H (':'33%61Z %3 % C%6L+37 6'A/@57+/(%61T #7 79%7 ?/+(7Z

G%@?9 %() C/' $/5@) P' $/6&+(, %7 :6/33Y?56?/3'3Z 7/ P' 356'T D57

$9/23 7/ 3%1 79%7 C/'f9+;3'@H % A+:7+; /H 79' ;/('1Y;'( %() 79'+6

+(7'6'373 )56+(, 9+3 3'6A+:' +( J/6@) J%6 UZ $9/ &(/$3 (/$ 79%7 $%6

[%+(27 3/ )%;( (':'33%61bagecf:/5@) (/7 P' 6'H/6;') /6 '(@+,97'(')

%3 $'@@K =' :/;'3 H6/; 79' @/$'6 ;+))@' :@%33Z 9' :%( 7%&' % 9+7 b%3 9'

39/$') $9'( 9' @/37 9+3 @', +( 79' 76'(:9'3cZ %() 9' 9%3 ?6/A'(Z +( 79'

:%3'3 /H 4%:/P %() G%@?9Z 79%7 9' +3 %@$%13 /( 79' 3+)' /H 79' 5()'6)/,

b%3 9' %@3/ 3'@H@'33@1 $%3 $9'( 9' 35??/67') 9+3 ;/79'6 %() H+A' 3+P@+(,3

%H7'6 9+3 H%79'6 %P%()/(') 79'+6 H%;+@1cT 4537 79' 3/67 /H ;%( 79' 6'A/@5Y

7+/( :/5@) 53'T

#() 6';';P'6X C/' +3 9'%)') 7/ % ?@%:'Z M5P%Z $9+:9 $+@@ 9%A'

+73 /$( ?/@+7+:%@ 6'A/@57+/( +( 79' (/7Y7//Y)+37%(7 H5756' b79' @%7' Vi!W3cT

J+@@ C/' P' &+:&') /57 /H =%A%(%Z @+&' /79'6 #;'6+:%( ,%(,37'63 %()

P53+('33;'( %7 79' 7+;'Z /6 $+@@ 9' P' )6%$( 7/ 79' :%53' /H 79' M5P%(?'/?@'K J+@@ 9' P' 3'@H@'33 /6 3'@H+39K


32/316

ea >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

(+'23 3/(Z .'/(Z :/5@) ,6/$ 5? 7/ P' S537 @+&' 9+3 5(:@' G%@?9f+( C/'23

'L7/@@+(, $/6)3Z [% H+,97'6-baOVcT

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

F)'73Z M@+HH/6)T $F&[6 &%/ T*%8h"U( M/9(Z G5P1Z %() D'6(%6) 05&/6'Z

')3T NF6%.*6.4e36%.95( Q5&H&@ L%8'&%/E !56'&%/E .46 ^%*.6/

T.&.6)T 8'$ _/6&X G%()/; =/53'Z ViEET #@@ ]5/7%7+/(3 %6'

H6/; 79+3 @%7'6Z %() H+(%@Z A'63+/( /H 79' ?@%1f(/7 H6/;79' '%6Y

@+'6 )6%H7 &(/$( %3!


33/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' ee

TA0%"V, '( W'20*%:E @UF%4$$U,-.'+ /#012 3.45'%0 *'6. 7*+86

N5,'(' F28'+@@23 (%756%@+37+:7+%8 Q&(I) R+95%6( *%.+ S*84.bVigVc +3 (/7

(/6;%@@1 79/5,97 /H %3 % )6'%; ?@%1Z P57 +73 %:7+/(f?6/:'')+(, H6/;

hXeW +( 79' ;/6(+(, 5(7+@ 3/;' 7+;' %H7'6 ;+)(+,97 /H 79' 3%;' )%1f:%(

P' 3''( %3 % &+() /H (+,97;%6' /H )65,3Z %@:/9/@ %() 6':6+;+(%7+/( H6/;

$9+:9 79' :9%6%:7'63 $+39 79'1 :/5@) '%3'H5@@1 %$%&'(T U7 +3 $9+@' 79'

796'' ;'( )'66C 79' (+,97 P'H/6' 79%7 ;/79'6 C%61Z ?%:+(, +( 79' 3?%6'

6//;Z $/66+'3 %P/57 9'6 3/( N);5()23 +@@('33 %() :/(3+)'63 6'756(+(, 7/

;/6?9+(' H/6 :/;H/67T C/6'/A'6Z %7 @'%37 7$/ ?%33%,'3 +( 79' ?@%1 ;%&'

'L?@+:+7 79' +)'% 79%7 @+H' +3 % P%) )6'%; H6/; $9+:9 ;%( $+@@ :/;?@'7'@1

%$%&'( /(@1 $9'( 9' )+'3Z +H 79'(T


34/316

eg >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

%6+37/:6%7TV*)) R9'*67%&'3 ?@%:' /( C+)35;;'6 NA' b45(' ae6)Z :@/3' 7/

79' @/(,'37 )%1 /H 79' 1'%6cZ $9'( )%1@+,97 ?'63+373 796/5,9/57 79' (+,97

%() 79' :/5(761 H/@& '(S/1 %( %((5%@ P%::9%(%@+%Z $9+:9 ;%&'3 79' ?@%1

% 3/67 /H 76%,+:V*/)9HH65 S*84.I) Q56&HT7+%8 Q&(I) R+95%6( *%.+ S*84.Z $6+77'( P1 79' ;%( $9/ 9%) @/(,

3+(:' P':/;' *76+()P'6,23 ;/37 ?%33+/(%7' %() 3'@HY:/(3:+/53 #;'6+:%(

)+3:+?@'Z 7%&'3 ?@%:' +( #5,537 ViVaf79' H+637 $''& /H #5,537Z P1 ;1

6':&/(+(,Z 3+(:' 79%7 $/5@) @+7'6%@@1 ?@%:' +7 %7 ;+)35;;'6 %() 7953

:/((':7 +7 $+79 *76+()P'6,23 ;+)35;;'6 76%,')1 %3 $'@@ %3 *9%&'3?'%6'23

;+)35;;'6 :/;')1T b


35/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' e!

P'H/6' 39' ;'7 %() H'@@ +( @/A' $+79 4%;'3


36/316

eE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

T73%*% >> '( X4$$4"V,U,! )65%%69#5 7#:%( /%2*5%

*:'(' VVZ 79' @%37 3:'(' /H 56,%7/61Z $9'6' 3/5@3 )'37+(')

H/6 9'%A'( %6' ?56+H+') /H %@@ 3+( %() +;?'6H':7+/(T


37/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' eO

b$' &(/$ H6/; 79' H/@@/$+(, 37%7';'(7 P1 D@%(:9' 79%7 *:'('3 !mE /H

T.566.0&5 7%&' ?@%:' +( #5,537X [F9Z ;1 P+679)%123 ('L7 ;/(79Z 79' H+HY

7''(79 /H *'?7';P'6 jOOkc\ %() H/5679Z %3 3/;'/(' :/(:'+A') $+79/57

/6+,+(%@ 3+(Z C%61Z 79' A+6,+( ;/79'6 /H 4'353 M96+37Z +3 P'@+'A') 7/ P''3?':+%@@1 'HH+:%:+/53 %7 ?'7+7+/(+(, Q/) /( P'9%@H /H 35??@+:%(73 %()

3+(('63f'3?':+%@@1 79/3' 3+(('63 :/(3+,(') 7/ >56,%7/61 P57 %$%+7+(,

'@'A%7+/( 7/ >%6%)+3'T


38/316

eh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

$9+:9 39' H@+67') $+79 *7%(@'1 )56+(, *:'(' a beOc %() $+79 C+7:9 )56+(,

*:'(' e b!ecf+(7/ % P@5' /57H+7T [U723 0'@@% G/PP+% P@5'Z )':@%6'3

D@%(:9'Z [79' P@5' /H 79' 6/P' +( 79' /@) C%)/((% ?+:756'3bVe!cZ %()

7953 % P@5' 79%7 %33/:+%7'3 9'6 $+79 P/79 79' I+6,+( C%61 +( G'(%+33%(:'%67 %() 79' R/$%@3&+32 P%P1 P/1Z $9/; N5(+:' P6+(,3 /(37%,' [$6%??')

+( % ?%@' P@5' P@%(&'7 bVgac %() $9/ 9%) P''( [3@''?+(, @+&' % @+77@'

%(,'@bVeacT bNA'( 79' 3&1 ://?'6%7'3X +7 +3 ;/6' /6 @'33 79' 3%;' :/@/6

79%7 J+@@+%;3 )'3:6+P') %7 79' 37%67 /H 79' ?@%1 %3 [% ?':5@+%6@1 7'()'6

P@5'Z %@;/37 % 756]5/+3'jVeZ VeVkTc

D@%(:9'23 %(7+:+?%7') 76%(3:'()'(:' /6 6'3566':7+/( +3 H5679'6

%5,;'(7') P1 79' :%79')6%@ P'@@3 79%7 :9+;' H/6 79' /(@1 7+;' +( T.566.e

0&5)56+(, *:'(' VV bVeEc %() @'() +(:6'%3') 35??/67 7/ 79' +)'% 79%7 79+3

3:'(' /::563 /( #@@ */5@32 0%1\ P1 9'6 H%(7%31 79%7 '%7+(, %( 5($%39')

/6 +;?56' ,6%?'Z @'7 53 3%1 /(' 79%7 9%3 (/7 P''( 76%(35P37%(7+%7') +(7/

79' $+(' d P@//) /H M96+37Z 9%3 (/('79'@'33 76%(3?/67') 9'6 3/5@ 7/ 9'%A'(

%() 9'6 P/)1 +(7/ % )''? P@5' /:'%( bVeEc\ %() P1 79' 0/:7/623 6%+3+(,

D@%(:9' 5? H6/; 79' H@//6 /H 79' R/$%@3&+ %?%67;'(7Z 7/ $+(:9 39'

)6/??') %H7'6 79' C%76/( 9%) ?+(+/(') 9'6 %6;3 :65:+H+L+/(Y371@' bVgVcZ

7/,'79'6 $+79 D@%(:9'23 3?+6+7')@1 @'%)+(, 79' $%1 /57 /H 79' 9'@@ /H 9'63+37'623 9/;' b$+79/57 @//&+(, P%:&cZ H/@@/$') P1 79' 0/:7/6 %() C%76/(

+(37'%) /H P'+(, '3:/67') P1 79'; bVgacT

D@%(:9' +3 P'+(, 3'(7 7/ % ?56,%7/61 /H 3/673Z % ?31:9+%76+: 9/3?+Y

7%@Z % &+() /H 9%@H$%1 9/53' P'7$''( 79' 9'%A'( /H @5:+)+71 %() 79' 9'@@

/H +(3%(+71Z 79' 6'('$') @+H' /H 79' ;+() %() 79' H+(%@ )'%79 /H 79' 3?+6+7T

#() +7 +3 $9+@' D@%(:9' +3 +( [?56,%7/6179%7 39' $+@@ P' :@'%(3') /H 9'6

3+(3Z ?%67+:5@%6@1 79' 3+(f$9+:9 39' 9'63'@H %);+73 %() @%;'(73 bi!miEcf/H )'(1+(, 9'6 9/;/3'L5%@ 953P%()Z #@@%( Q6'1Z 79' :/;?%33+/(

79%7 $/5@) 9%A' 3%A') 9+; H6/; 35+:+)'T >'69%?3 79+3 :@'%(3+(, $+@@

:/;' 796/5,9 79' +(7'6:'33+/( /H 79' I+6,+( C%61 9'63'@HZ $9/3' /$(

3/66/$ %() 35HH'6+(, ;%)' 9'6 :/;?%33+/(%7'T D@%(:9'23 6'@+,+/53 /6+Y

,+(3 %6' >6/7'37%(7Z (/7 G/;%( M%79/@+:f39' 7'@@3 C+7:9 79%7 9'6 H+637

#;'6+:%( %(:'37/63 $'6' B6'(:9 =5,5'(/73 b!!cf%() ;%(1 >6/7'37%(7

)'(/;+(%7+/(3 /PS':7 7/ 79' A'('6%7+/( /H C%61Z P57 79%7 $/5@) (/7 ?6'Y

A'(7 3/ +()'?'()'(7 /6 $+@@H5@ % 3?+6+7 %3 D@%(:9' 05D/+3 H6/; '+79'6


39/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' ei

%??'%@+(, 7/ C%61 H/6 9'@? /6 6':'+A+(, 79' D@'33') I+6,+(23 ;+(+376%Y

7+/(3T U()'')Z D@%(:9' 9%3 @/(, 3+(:' 376%1') H6/; 9'6 6'@+,+/53 /6+,+(3Z

%() 9'6 '66%(7 $%13 7/,'79'6 $+79 9'6 @%?3' +(7/ ;%)('33 ?57 9'6 +( 3?'Y

:+%@ ('') /H Q/)23 ,6%:'f% ,6%:'Z 79' M%79/@+: M956:9 7'%:9'3Z H/6$9+:9 C%61 +3 79' :9+'H ;')+%76+LT

# (5;P'6 /H :/;;'(7%7/63 9%A' ?/+(7') /57 79' +6/(1 /H

D@%(:9'23 3?'()+(, 3'A'6%@ ;/(793 /( % 376''7 +( 8'$ F6@'%(3 (%;')

N@13+%( B+'@)3f+( Q6''& ;179/@/,1 79' )$'@@+(, ?@%:' /H A+675/53 ?'/Y

?@' %H7'6 )'%79f%() 79' H5679'6 +6/(1 /H 9'6 9%A+(, ?6'A+/53@1 @+A') +(

.%56'@Z C+33+33+??+ b@%56'@ $6'%793Z /H :/563'Z $'6' 53') P1 79' %(:+'(7

Q6''&3 7/ :6/$( 79' A+:7/63 +( %79@'7+: :/(7'373Z ;+@+7%61 P%77@'3Z %()

%67+37+: :/;?'7+7+/(3cT /@+39 H/6 [3;+79c\ %()Z 79'3' :6+7+:3 %6,5'Z 79+3 :/(H@+:7 $+@@

/PA+/53@1 (/7 3'() 9'6 7/ %( '7'6(%@ @+H' /H P@+33 +( %(1 N@13+%( B+'@)3Z P57

6%79'6 7/ 79' ;+3'61 /H % @+A+(, )'%79 $+79/57 :9%(:' /H 6')';?7+/( +( 79'

;%)9/53'T

U7 3'';3 ?/33+P@'Z 9/$'A'6Z 79%7 79'3' :'@'37+%@ /6 $+((+(, (%;'3%6' (/7 +6/(+:Z P57 +(37'%) 35,,'37 $9%7 79'1 %??'%6 7/ 35,,'37X 79%7

D@%(:9'Z P657%@@1 )'H'%7') +( 9'6 :65:+P@' $+79 *7%(@'1 +( 8'$ F6@'%(3Z

$+@@ 5@7+;%7'@1 76+5;?9 /( 45),;'(7 0%1 +( 79' &+(,)/; /H Q/) +H (/7

/( 76'%7;'(7 )%1 +( 79' 6'%@; /H 3':5@%6 ;+(+3761f;/)'6( b?31:9+%76+:c

;')+:+('T D@%(:9'23 /$( (%;'Z $9+:9 %??'%63 7/ P' +6/(+: +( 79%7 +7 35,Y

,'373 % A+6,+(+71 $9+:9 39' (/ @/(,'6 ?/33'33'3 +( )'')Z %77'373 7/ 9'6

A+6,+(+71 /H 3?+6+7f9'6 [P'%571 /H 79' ;+() %() T T T 7'()'6('33 /H 79'

9'%67bVaEcZ %3 39' ?573 +7T


40/316

gW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

/H 79' I+6,+( C%61Z P57 %@3/ 7/ 79' 6':@%+;') +((/:'(:' /H C%61 C%,)%Y

@'('Z $9/ $%3 :56') /H 9'6 3'L5%@ $%1$%6)('33 P1 4'353 bS537 %3 D@%(:9'

$%3 35))'(@1 :56') /H 9'63 $9'( 39' 6';%6&') 7/ C+7:9Z [*/;'7+;'3f

79'6'23 Q/)f3/ ]5+:&@1-

jiEkc %() @%7'6 3%$ M96+37 %H7'6 9' 9%) 6+3'(H6/; 79' )'%)T

*:'(' VV /H T.566.0&5:%( P' 6',%6)')Z 79'(Z %3 % 3:'(' /H :'@'P6%Y

7+/( %3 $'@@ %3 ;/56(+(,Z /H '7'6(%@ @+H' %3 $'@@ %3 76%(3+7/61 )'%79f@+&'

79' C'L+:%( 0%1 /H 79' 0'%) +73'@HT ='(:' J+@@+%;3 (/7 /(@1 +(76/)5:'3

79' R/$%@3&+32 ('$P/6( :9+@) +(7/ 79' %:7+/( ?6':+3'@1 %7 79' ;/;'(7 /H

D@%(:9'23 [?%33+(,Z% :9+@) /H $9/; D@%(:9' 3%+) +( *:'(' hZ [U 9/?'

79%7 9+3 '1'3 %6' ,/+(, 7/ P' @+&' :%()@'3Z @+&' 7$/ P@5' :%()@'3 @+,97') +(

% $9+7' :%&'- bVWicT J+@@+%;3 %@3/ :6'%7'3 % :/;P+(%7+/( H'37+A'Y

;%:%P6' %7;/3?9'6'X *7%(@'1Z *7'A'Z %() 79' C'L+:%(Z >%P@/Z 3+7 %6/5()

79' 7%P@' ?@%1+(, :%6)3Z '%7+(,Z %() )6+(&+(,Z $9+@' C+7:9 35@&3Z 3@5;?3Z

%() 3/P3 %7 79' 3%;' 7%P@' /A'6 79' @/33 /H D@%(:9' b79' 3%;' C+7:9 $9/

:/(76+P57') 7/ 79' H'37+A'Y;%:%P6' %7;/3?9'6' /H *:'(' i P1 )';%()+(,

3'L H6/; % )65(&'(Z )+376%5,97 D@%(:9' 05D/+3c\ %() $' 9'%6Z $/A'(

+(7/ 79' %:7+/(Z 79' ;53+: /H 79' [I%63/5A+%(% f79' ?/@&% 75(' 7/ $9+:9

D@%(:9' %() #@@%( $'6' )%(:+(, 79' (+,97 9' :/;;+77') 35+:+)' bVeOZ

Veicf79' 3+;5@7%('/53@1 ;'@%(:9/@+: %() +(3?+6+7+(, 3/5()3 /H 79'

[D@5' >+%(/ZbVgacZ %() 79' 9%639 :6+'3 %3 $'@@ %3 @56+) 39%)/$3 /H 79'

S5(,@' bVeiZ VgVcT

C/6'/A'6Z J+@@+%;3 :/(:@5)'3 79' H+(%@ 3:'(' /H T.566.0&5 /( %

3'L5%@ (/7'X %H7'6 D@%(:9' 9%3 )'?%67')Z *7%(@'1 [A/@5?75/53@1 &(''@3

P'3+)' 79' $''?+(, *7'@@% %() ?@%:'3 9+3 9%() +(3+)' 9'6 P@/53'Z %3 *7'A'

/?'(3 % ('$ 6/5() /H :%6)3 $+79 79' $/6)3 [


41/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' gV

F'+%,

VT J+@@+%;3 9+;3'@H $%3 7/ P' ?6'/::5?+') $+79 9+3 /$( )'%79 H/6

;5:9 /H 9+3 @+H'T C/6'/A'6Z 9' 9%) P',5( $6+7+(, T.566.0&5 +(

M9%?%@%Z C'L+:/ b('%6 Q5%)%@%S%6%cZ :/(A+(:') 79%7 9' $%3 )1Y

+(,Z 79%7 79+3 $/5@) P' 9+3 @%37 ?@%1Z %() 79%7 79'6'H/6' 9' 39/5@)

?57 9+3 %@@ +(7/ +7T bJ+@@+%;3 79/5,97 79%7 79' %,/(+^+(, %PY

)/;+(%@ ?%+(3 9' 9%) P''( 'L?'6+'(:+(, $'6' 79' 6'35@7 /H @'79%@

37/;%:9 :%(:'6Z P57 +( H%:7 79'1 $'6' :%53') P1 % 65?756') %?Y

?'()+LTc *'' /&'6 8+,97X >+:7/6+%@ N@';'(73 +( 6'33Z ViEVT

J+@@+%;3Z


42/316

ga >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

T!;% B*14*Q '( O%;"*U, ;8%


43/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' ge

.'3@+' %() %7 +3 ;+37%&'( %7 79' '() /H N46 a+)e

.&86$9'( 9' 6'3?/()3 7/ %7 3%13 79%7 +7 +3 :@/3'6 7/ V #TCT bVOOcT N+79'6 $%1Z +7 +3

(/7 h #TC /6 @%7'6f37%,' 7+;' +3 (/7 .4&.H@'L+P@'f%() .'3@+'

9%3 )+') P'H/6' 9+3 7+;'T


44/316

gg >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

D'9%(Z D6'()%(T N46 ?9&56 W6''+F%() N46 a+).&86T 8'$ _/6&X Q6/A'

>6'33Z ViEgT


45/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' g!

T!4V% "*1 ?:,+%0: 4* I2Q"01U,=%.>?% !5% -*@*'+ ;8%5%

U( #:7 U /H #79/@ B5,%6)23-6+C'6 $56 7*D*%8 N4656bViEhcZ 79' H/@@/$+(,

'L:9%(,' 7%&'3 ?@%:' P'7$''( 79' @%()@%)1 C+@@1 %() 9'6 1/5(, P/%6)'6

0/(X

V*''(T M%(27 P'T

Q+%T J9%7K

V*''(T


46/316

gE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

P56,Z 9' 6%( % 3;%@@ P53+('33Z #9@'632 #67+H+:+%@ B@/$'63Z %() 7//& 9'6 /57

['A'61 *%756)%1 (+,97T G',5@%6 %3 6'(7T D''6 %() 3%53%,'3 H/6 7$/ %7 79'

>9/'(+LT l(7+@ 7/(+,97 bVWEmVWOcT C+@@1 :/5@) S537 %3 $'@@ 9%A' 3%+)

[6',5@%6 %3 :@/:&$/6&T

D57Z @+&' 79' :@/:&23Z #9@'632 [;':9%(+3;

9%33?65(,X 9' 9%3 35))'(@1 )':+)') 79%7 9' $%(73 7/ 3'' $/;'( 1/5(,'6

79%( 79' H+H71Y1'%6Y/@) C+@@1Z +( 79' 9/?' /H ;%661+(,Z 37%67+(, % H%;+@1Z

%() &''?+(, 9+3 H%;+@1 (%;' %@+A'T

4537 %3 %(/79'6 /H C+@@123 P/%6)'63Z 79' P/L'6 *9/671Z $%(73 7/ )+3Y

:%6) 79' ;/793 79%7 %6' @'H7 /A'6 %H7'6 9+3 3+@&$/6;3 9%A' ?6/)5:') 3+@&Z

#9@'63 $%(73 7/ )+3:%6) 79' 95;%( P'+(, 79%7 6';%+(3 +( C+@@1 (/$ 79%7

9'6 ?6/:6'%7+A' $/;%(9//)Z 9'6 [3+@&Z+3 ?%37T =+3 P'9%A+/6 +3 % ;137'61

7/ 9'6Z S537 %3 79' 6'%@ 7+;' +3T NA'( %3 39' %3&3 *9/671 7/ 9+7 79' :@/:& 3/

79%7 +7 $+@@ :9+;' 79' :/66':7 9/56Z 39' %3&3 0/( 7/ 9+7 #9@'63 3/ 79%7 9'

$+@@ &(/$ 9' 9%3 P'9%A') +;?6/?'6@1 7/$%6) 9'6T J9'( C+@@1 1'@@3 +(7/

79' 9%@@$%1 %7 9'6 'LYP/1H6+'() P/79 /( 9+3 )'?%6756' H/6 %() 6'756( H6/;

% )%7'Z 9' ('+79'6 37/?3 (/6 3%13 %(179+(,T *9' ;+,97 %3 $'@@ P' 1'@@+(, %7

% :@/:&T

U7 +3 (/7 P1 %::+)'(7 79%7 B5,%6) ,+A'3 #9@'63 /(@1 % @%37 (%;' %()

)/'3 (/7 9%A' 9+; %??'%6 /(37%,'Z $9+@' 9' ,+A'3 79' H+637 %() @%37 (%;'3/H C+@@1Z 0/(Z %() *9/671Z $9/ ?%67+:+?%7' )+6':7@1 +( 79' %:7+/( %() ?%33

/A'6 H+A' 9/563 /H 79'+6 @+A'3 )56+(, 79' ?@%1T U( 9%A+(, /(@1 % 356(%;'

%() 6';%+(+(, /HH37%,'Z #9@'63 %:9+'A'3 % &+() /H +;;/67%@+71T J+79/57 %

H+637 (%;'Z 9' P':/;'3 @'33 % 3?':+H+: #9@'63 79%( 79' '7'6(%@ ';P/)+Y

;'(7 /H 79' #9@'63 H%;+@1 @+('T D1 (/7 %??'%6+(, /(37%,'Z 9' 3'';3 7/

76%(3:'() 3?%:' %() 7+;'Z 7/ P' %P/A' 79' %,+(, ?6/:'33 79%7 )/,3 79'

/79'6 :9%6%:7'63 %() 79%7 +3 :%@@') %77'(7+/( 7/ P1 79' 9/56@1 :9+;+(, /H79' ,6%()H%79'6 :@/:& b+73'@H H%+@+(, $+79 %,'cT U( 79' 3%;' $%1 79%7 9'

(/$ 3''&3 % ('$ @+H' %$%1 H6/; C+@@1Z $+79 % 1/5(,'6 $/;%(Z #9@'63

3/5,97 % ('$ @+H' %$%1 H6/; 9+3 (%7+A'Z )'A%37%7') Q'6;%(1 %H7'6 J/6@)

J%6 UU +( 79' 1/5(,'6Z ;/6' ?6/;+3+(, :/5(761 /H #5376%@+%T

C/6'/A'6Z 5(@+&' C+@@1Z #9@'632 %67+H+:+%@ H@/$'63f:6'%7') ?6+Y

;%6+@1 H/6 H5('6%@ 9/;'3f$+@@ (/7 $+@7T


47/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' gO

P56,Z $9'6' %;P5@%(:' 3+6'(3 :%( P' 9'%6) /HH37%,' 796/5,9/57 79' (+,97T

-6+C'6 $56 7*D*%8 N46567%&'3 ?@%:' +( $+(7'6Z P1 $9+:9 7+;' %@@ (%756%@

H@/$'63 9%A' )+')T #() $9'( $' H+637 :/;' 5?/( C+@@1Z +7 +3 %3 +H 39' 9%3

6+3'( H6/; 79' )'%)X 39' 9%3 3@'?7 %$%1 79' )%1 %() 6+3'3 +( 79' )%6& %7 O>TCTZ $%+7+(, H/6 % @/(, 7+;' P'H/6' 39' 756(3 /( 79' @+,97T U6/(+:%@@1Z +7 +3

9'6 P+679)%1f3/;'79+(, 79%7 $' )/ (/7 @'%6( 5(7+@ %@;/37 79' '() /H #:7

UZ P':%53' 79' )%1 /H 9'6 P+679 396+(&3 +( +;?/67%(:' ('L7 7/ 79' )%1

;%6&+(, 9'6 6'S':7+/( P1 #9@'63 %() 9'6 [)'%79%3 % $/;%(T

>/()'6+(, 9'6 5(9%??+('33 +( ,'('6%@ %() 79' :9%(,' +( #9@'632

H''@+(,3 H/6 9'6 +( ?%67+:5@%6Z C+@@1 3%13X

U 761 7/ 6';';P'6 $9'(T 6'33Z ViOhT iim

VEiT


48/316

gh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

T688%"0"*3% "*1 B,,%*3% 4* Y"4,%0U,

A5.: B.5' 6. B*('*+86

D1 ViVaZ $9'( Q'/6, R%+3'6 $6/7' W5+H V+5% .+ V*/%*84.Z 9' %@6'%)1

9%) ;/6' 79%( 7$'(71 ?@%13 7/ 9+3 :6')+7Z P57 (/(' 9%) P''( ?'6H/6;')

?5P@+:@1T J+79 W5+H V+5% .+ V*/%*84.Z R%+3'6 P',%( 9+3 'L?6'33+/(+37

?'6+/)Z $9+:9 :%7%?5@7') 9+; 7/ H%;' %() 756(') 9+; +(7/ Q'6;%(123

;/37 35::'33H5@ %() $+)'@1 ?'6H/6;') )6%;%7+37 5(7+@ VieeT


49/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' gi

':37%31T B+(%@@1Z %H7'6 % 3'6+'3 /H )+3%??/+(7+(, 'L?'6+'(:'3 +( D'6@+(Z 9'

:/;'3 7/ 6':/,(+^'f%7 % *%@A%7+/( #6;1 ;''7+(,f79%7 79' 6/%) 7/

H5@H+@@;'(7 @+'3 796/5,9 79' 3/5@T D57 $9'( 79' M%39+'6 H@+(,3 %$%1 9+3

37/@'( ;/('1Z 79' 35??/3')@1 6'?'(7%(7 3+(('63 H+,97 @+&' %(+;%@3 /A'6 +7Z%() 79' *%@A%7+/( .%33Z +( $9/; 9' 9%) ?'6:'+A') 9+3 3/5@ ;%7'Z P'76%13

9+; 7/ :@%+; 79' 6'$%6) /HH'6') H/6 9+3 %66'37T


50/316

!W >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

%() %(/79'6 :/;+(, S537 &,.65 79' M%39+'6 9%3 )'?%67') 79' 3:'('\ 79'

P%(& ;%(%,'623 A+3+7 7/ 79' M%39+'623 9/;' +( 79' 9/?' /H H+()+(, 9+;

79'6' %() 7%@&+(, 9+; +(7/ 6'756(+(, 79' EWZWWW ;%6&3 7/ 79' P%(&Z $+79

+;?5(+71Z S537 &,.65 79' M%39+'6 9%3 @'H7 9+3 H%;+@1 H/6 ,//)T


51/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' !V

A'%@3 9'63'@H +( 79' '() 7/ P' (/79+(, ;/6' 79%( % ,6'')1 91?/:6+7'T b*9'

9'63'@H :/+(:+)'(7%@@1 +H H%7'H5@@1 %??'%63 %7 79' A'@/)6/;' +( 37%7+/( H+A'Z

761+(, 7/ 3'@@ 79' *%@A%7+/( #6;1 ('$3?%?'6Z N46 B&5 35(Z 7/ 79' M%39Y

+'6Z P'H/6' 79' @%77'623 /$( A+3+7 7/ 79' *%@A%7+/( #6;1 =%@@ +( 37%7+/(3'A'(Tc /(7+53 >+Y

@%7' +( 79' D+P@'Z +( 4/9( ViX!Z +;;')+%7'@1 P'H/6' 4'35323 :65:+H+L+/(X

79'1 ;'%( [D'9/@) 79' ;%(T


52/316

!a >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6


53/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' !e

T!;% F4Q;+V"04,; Z2"$4+: '( +(7'623 )6%;% %() %6'

A+3+7+(, 9+3 H%;+@1 +( 8/679 ./()/(T D1 79' '()Z 39' 9%3 :%6'H5@@1 )':+)Y

') 7/ 6';%+( $+79 9+3 H%79'6 %() 7$/ P6/79'63 %3 79'+6 ;/79'6Y$9/6'Z

$9+@'


54/316

!g >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

3%+)Z @+&' 3@''?$%@&'63 /79'6$+3' +( 79' ';P6%:' /H % (+,97;%6'T *+;+@%6Y

@1Z F37'(3+P@1 +( P')Z .'((1 +( N46 a+H60+H*%8 @'%A'3 9+3 6//; +( #:7

UZ %H7'6 79' (+,977+;' %66+A%@ /H


55/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' !!

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

#@P''Z N)$%6)T$ Q6'*0&.6 M&'&%06T 8'$ _/6&X #79'('5;Z ViEOT

D'(7@'1Z N6+:T N46 7*,6 +, .46 Q5&H&T 8'$ _/6&X #79'('5;Z ViEgT

>+(7'6Z =%6/@)T N46 a+H60+H*%8T 8'$ _/6&X Q6/A' >6'33Z ViEOT


56/316

!" $%&' ()&%'*+*, ( -.&/.0

!"#$%&'() !"#$%&%'+ ",-. -$/ 0#,1

(%1)2 3+45 6&01%/ $+)4.07* 8%&'* !" $%&'( )%&*9:;

9:; 1023%4%, 9:;


57/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' !O

;/A'3 P%:&$%6) 7/ +73 P',+((+(,Z +( ViEhT D57 >+(7'6 )/'3(27 53' 79'

6'A'63'Y:96/(/@/,+:%@ ;'79/) 3@%A+39@1Z H/6 796'' /H 79' ?@%123 b%() 79'

H+@;23c (+(' 3:'('3 /::56 7';?/6%@@1 &,.65 79' 3:'(' +;;')+%7'@1 ?6':')Y

+(,TM6.5&(&'/?'(3 $9'( 4'661 %() N;;% ;''7 H/6 % )6+(&f%,%+(Z +(

ViOO\ 79+3 +3 79' H+637 7+;' 79'1 9%A' 3''( '%:9 /79'6 +( 79' 7$/ 1'%63

3+(:' 79'+6 %HH%+6 '()') b%( %HH%+6 79%7 +(:@5)') % 6'(7') H@%7 H/6 79' :/5Y

?@'23 %H7'6(//( ;''7+(,3cT N;;% 7'@@3 4'661 79%7 39' %() G/P'67 %6' 3'?%Y

6%7+(,Z 79%7 79'1 9%) % @/(, 7%@& 79' (+,97 P'H/6'Z 79%7 G/P'67 :/(H'33') 7/

% (5;P'6 /H %HH%+63 %() 39' 7/@) 9+; %P/57 79' @/(,YH+(+39') %HH%+6 $+79

4'661T b


58/316

!h >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

'7'6 =%@@ %() )'3+,(') b3:'('61Z @+,97+(,Z &%/:/3Y

75;'3c P1 4/9( D561Z 'A'61 3:'(' P',%( $+79 79' %:7/63 +;;/P+@' +( )+;

3+@9/5'77'Z $+79 :+71 3/5()3 P'9+() 79';Z %() 79'1 $'6' P6/5,97 7/ ;/Y

7+/( P1 79' :/;+(, /H @+,97T N%:9 /H 79' ./()/( 3'77+(,3 $%3 )/(' +(

3?%6' @+(' %() :/@/6\ 79' /(' I'(+:' 3:'(' $%3 'L':57') +( :56A'3T +(7'6 P57

?'6H':7@1 H5@H+@@') P1 4/('3f$9+:9 7%&'3 ?@%:' /573+)' G/P'67 %() N;Y


59/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' !i

;%23 9/53' +( ViOO %3 79'1 P+) ,//)Y(+,97 7/ )'?%67+(, ,5'373T


60/316

EW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

U(:6'%3+(,@1 796/5,9 79' 7$'(7+'79 :'(7561 %() P'1/()Z %3 79/3'

5??'6 :@%33'3 )$+()@') ?6/?/67+/(%7'@1 %,%+(37 %( ')5:%7')Z 6'%3/(%P@1

%HH@5'(7 ;+))@' :@%33Z 79' 7%@'(7 H/6 9+,9 :/;')1 +( @+H' 9%3 P''( %:]5+6')

P1 79' ;+))@' :@%33T FH :/563'Z 79' %:7+/( (/$ 9%3 7/ P' $/6&') %6/5()/HH+:' 9/563 %() :%6'H5@@1 ?@%((') A%:%7+/(3 %() (%((+'3 H/6 79' :9+@)6'(Z

P57 ;%(1 ;';P'63 /H 79' N(,@+39 ;+))@' :@%33 7/)%1 :/()5:7 79'+6 @+A'3

%() :/(A'63%7+/(3 +( % 371@' %3 3;//79@1 :65'@ %() 7%:+7@1 %HH':7+/(%7' %3

79'1 :%( ;%&' +7Z P%3') /( 5??'6Y:@%33 ?%6%)+,;3f79';3'@A'3 ?'69%?3

+;?'@@') P1 % ]5+7' N(,@+39 +;?'6%7+A' 7/ ;%+(7%+( ?/+3'Z 7/ &''? 79'

3/:+%@ P%:&P/(' %6:9')T

=%6/@) >+(7'6Z ?6'';+('(7 %;/(, 9+3 :/(7';?/6%6+'3Z ?'6:'+A')

79+3 3/:+%@ 39+H7 %() 9'6' $6+7'3 % &+() /H 9+,9 :/;')1 %P/57 79'3' ;+)Y

)@'Y:@%33 ?'/?@' $9/Z %3 H%6 %3 79' )%+@+('33 /H 79'+6 @+A'3 $+@@ ?'6;+7Z 761

7/ @+A' 79/3' @+A'3 $+79 9+,9Y:/;')+: ?%(%:9'T #() 79' 7/(%@ :9%(,' +(

M6.5&(&' H6/; 37%,' 7/ 3:6''( 9%3 %3 ;5:9 7/ )/ $+79 79' [/?'(+(, 5?/H

79' ?@%1 %3 +7 )/'3 $+79 79' +(7'(3+H+:%7+/( /H 79+3 9+,9Y:/;+: 371@' +(

;+))@'Y:@%33 ./()/( @+H'f?%67@1 P':%53' 35:9 [/?'(+(, 5?Z/6 [P6'%&Y

+(, /57Z ?'6;+73 79' 371@+37+: +(7'(3+H+:%7+/( 796/5,9 79' 3+75%7+(, /H

4&9.6P/56,'/+3 'L+37'(:' +( %3 6'%@+37+:Z 'A'( ;5()%('Z % )%+@1 :/(7'L7%3 ?/33+P@'T

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

Q%@'Z *7'?9'( =T T4&5C 39.@ a&5+'/ -*%.65I) T0566%C'&() &%/ .46 $5.*).*0

-5+06))T .'L+(,7/(X l(+A'63+71 >6'33 /H R'(75:&1Z aWWeT

Q%@'Z *7'A'( =TZ ')T N46 W*'H) +, a&5+'/ -*%.65" #@P%(1X *7%7' l(+A'63+Y

71 /H 8'$ _/6& >6'33Z aWWVT

R%('Z .'3@+'Z ')T N46 $5. +, 35*H6@ N46 -'&() &%/ W*'H) +, a&5+'/ -*%e

.65 &%/ Q&D*/ V&H6.T 8'$ _/6&X G/57@'),'Z aWWg

R@'+(Z 4/%(('T V&[*%8 -*0.956)@ N46 -*%.65 T0566%C'&()T M/@5;P53X

F9+/ *7%7' l(+A'63+71 >6'33Z Vih!T


61/316

C/)'@ N33%13X >@/7 %() #:7+/(Z /6 B/6; %() *765:756' EV

>+(7'6Z =%6/@)TM6.5&(&'T ./()/(X N16' C'795'(Z ViOhT

G'(7/(Z .+()%T -*%.65 &%/ .46 OZi60. +, Q6)*56@$% $CC5+&04 .45+984

.46 T0566%C'&()T FLH/6)Z lTRTX .','()% d N56/?'%( =5;%(+Y

7+'3 G'3'%6:9 M'(76'Z FLH/6) l(+A'63+71Z aWWaT


62/316


63/316

Ee

?@ABC B776D7E )K6H6)!BH 6FA H@CB

T!;% );'02, 4* N0%%[ !0"Q%1: - - - "*1 O%:'*1G\4+; 78%34"$ H%(%0%*3% +' 7'8;'3$%,U D%(*>42 ;05#''.2

#6+37/7@' 3?'%&3 /H 76%,')1 %3 '(,'()'6+(, ?+71 %() H'%6 +( 79' 9'%673 /H

3?':7%7/63 %() 3/;'9/$ 79'6'P1 ?56,+(, 79'; /H 79'3' ?6'35;%P@1 'LY

:'33+A' ';/7+/(3T D'+(, 79' 3/( /H % ?913+:+%(Z #6+37/7@' '%3+@1 756(') 7/

;')+:%@ 7'6;+(/@/,1\ P'+(, % 375)'(7 /H >@%7/Z 9' 39%6') 9+3 7'%:9'623

?'(:9%(7 H/6 :%37+(, +)'%3 +( ;'7%?9/6T D57 79' :'@'P6%7') ?56,%7+/( /H

?+71 %() H'%6 ;%1 P' (/79+(, ;/6' 79%( 79' )';137+H+:%7+/( /6 'A'( )+3Y

'(H6%(:9+3';'(7 /H (%756' 796/5,9 79' H/6;%@ )'(+%@ /H +335' 7/ %(1 76%,+:

)+%@/,5' P1 ;'%(3 /H 79' +(7'6A'(7+/( /H 79' :9/653T

#3 'A+)'(:'Z :/(3+)'6 79' 3765:756' /H Q6''& 76%,')1f% 3765:756'

79%7 :9%(,') 6';%6&%P@1 @+77@' /A'6 % ?'6+/) /H ('%6@1 VWW 1'%63T


64/316

Eg >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

;'7/?' 3/ %3 7/ :/(37+757' % A+35%@ $9/@' +(:/6?/6%7+(, % 76+,@1?9T b>'6Y

9%?3 /(@1 +( 79' *+:1/(+%(


65/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' E!

3?':+%@('33 /6 5(+]5'('33Z 3$%@@/$+(, +7 5? +(7/ % 3/:+%@+^') 6'3?/(3' /(

79' ?%67 /H 79' :/;;5(+71T

G'@%7') 7/ 79+3Z +7 9%3 P''( 3%+) 79%7 $9'( 76%,')1 H@/56+39')Z +(

79' H+H79 :'(7561 DTMTZ 79' P6'%&)/$( /H 79' +*[+)H%;+@1 3765:756' :%53')'A'61 ?'63/( 7/ 6'%@+^' 79%7 9' )+'3 %@/('T U7 9%3 %@3/ /H7'( P''( 6';%6&')

79%7 ?6/;+('(7 +( 79' )'H+(+7+/( /H 79' 76%,+: 9'6/ +3 9+3 +3/@%7+/(T


66/316

EE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

;/6' :'67%+( 79%7 9' ;%1 9%A' P''( .%+5323 ;56)'6'6Z 4/:%37% )'3?'6%7'@1

+(3+373 5?/( 79' ?@56%@+71 /H 79' 9+,9$%1;'(Z ,/+(, 3/ H%6 +( 9'6 +(3+37Y

'(:' %3 7/ )'(1 /6%:@'3 +( 79'+6 '(7+6'71T D57Z %,%+(Z 79+3 +3 69'7/6+:Z H/6

79' $/;%( H''@3 :/6('6')Z %() 5()'637%()%P@1 3/T*9' %() F')+?53 9%A' '),') H%6 /57 /( 79+( +:'Z $9'6' 79' :6%:&3

%6' 3/5()+(, @/5)'6 %() @/5)'6\ 1'7Z :/56%,'/53@1Z 79'1 P/79 9/@) /(T

[Q'7 ;' 79%7 ?'%3%(7 $+7('33Z)';%()3 F')+?53T #() 4/:%37% 6539'3 /57

%3 39' 3%13Z [U2@@ )/ %(179+(, 7/ ;%&' 1/5 9%??1T


67/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' EO

;5:9Z +( 79' @+A'3 /H 9+3 3+37'6 %() ;/79'6T C/6'/A'6Z 9+3 +6/(+: 7/('

3/;'7+;'3 ?6/A/&'3 79' %5)+'(:' 7/ @%5,97'6Z 7/ $9+:9 79'1 H+() 79';Y

3'@A'3 6'%:7+(, $+79 ';P%66%33;'(7T #() 79' %;P+A%@'(:'Z 'A'( :/(H5Y

3+/(Z /H 79'+6 6'3?/(3' :/;'3 H6/;


68/316

Eh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

TI04"0 C"20%*3% 4* 7;"[%,8%"0%U,E.:%. #'( 34?*%6

G/;'/23 %() M%?5@'723 +;?5@3+A'('33 /6 6%39('33 +( *9%&'3?'%6'23 \+e

H6+ &%/ R9'*6.bV!i!c 9%3 %@$%13 P''( 'A+)'(7T M%?5@'723 /HH'6 /H 45@+'7

+( ;%66+%,' 7/ >%6+3 $+79/57 H+637 :/(35@7+(, 9+3 )%5,97'6 +3 H/@@/$') P1

79' ']5%@@1 +;?5@3+A'Z %() 5@7+;%7'@1 )+3%376/53Z %:7+/( /H %)A%(:+(, 79'

$'))+(, H6/;


69/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' Ei

+(H':7+/(Z (/6 9%3 B6+%6 .%56'(:'X 79'1 %6' A+:7+;3 /H 79' )C*5*.9&'

?@%,5'f79' H'5)f79%7 P'3+','3 79' C/(7%,5' %() M%?5@'7 H%;+@+'3Tc U(

/79'6 $/6)3Z .%56'(:'23 9%37' :%53') 9+; 6%39@1 7/ 3'() 4/9( Z( 4*H)6',

7/ G/;'/ +( C%(75%Z $9'( 9' 39/5@) 9%A' 6';';P'6') 79' 65@' /H 79'B6%(:+3:%( /6)'6 79%7 H/6P%)' /(' H6+%6 7/ 76%A'@ %(1$9'6' $+79/57 79'

:/;?%(1 /H %(/79'6 B6%(:+3:%( baaVZ (/7'cT

NA'( +H +7 +3 %6,5') 79%7 +7 $%3 B6+%6 4/9(23 6'3?/(3+P+@+71 7/ H+()

9+3 /$( 76%A'@+(, :/;?%(+/(Z (/7 B6+%6 .%56'(:'23 7/ H+() /(' H/6 9+;Z

79' @%77'6 39/5@) 37+@@ 9%A' H/6'3''( 79' +;?6/P%P+@+71 /H 9+3 :/(H6'6'23

:9//3+(, % [3%H'B6%(:+3:%( :/;?%(+/( +( % :+71 P'3'7 P1 79' ?@%,5'T

b%6+3 3/ 79%7 39' :%( P' 6'5(+7') $+79 G/Y

;'/T =%) 9' 3'(7 M&'.4&)&5 +(37'%) /H B6+%6 4/9( 7/ C%(75% $+79 79'

@'77'6 7/ G/;'/Z 79' )'%793 /H 45@+'7 %() G/;'/ $/5@) 9%A' P''( ?6'Y

A'(7')T >6'35;%P@1Z G/;'/ $/5@) 9%A' 6'756(') 7/ I'6/(% %7 79' %?Y

?/+(7') 7+;' 7/ 7%&' 45@+'7 %$%1T 4537 %3Z +( 9+3 9%37' 7/ %+) G/;'/ %()

45@+'7Z B6+%6 .%56'(:' H/6,'73 %P/57 79' +(H':7+/53 )+3'%3' 79%7 %HH@+:73

I'6/(% %() 79%7 $+@@ 5@7+;%7'@1 )'7%+( B6+%6 4/9(Z 9' H/6,'73 7/ 3'() D%@Y


70/316

OW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

79%3%6 +( 4/9(23 ?@%:' b%3 9' 9%) 7/@) G/;'/ 9' $/5@)c %() 'A'( 7/ +(Y

H/6; D%@79%3%6 /H 79' ?@%( 7/ 6'5(+7' 79' @/A'63T

U( 35;Z B6+%6 .%56'(:' %() D%@79%3%6 %6' %:7+(, +()'?'()'(7@1 7/

3'6A' G/;'/Z $9'6'%3 79'1 39/5@) P' %:7+(, +( :/(:'67T *+;+@%6@1Z B6+%64/9( +3 %:7+(, [+()'?'()'(7@1 $9'( 9' @'%A'3 B6+%6 .%56'(:'23 :'@@

$+79/57 % B6%(:+3:%( :/;?%(+/( H6'' /H +(H':7+/(T 6+(:'Z %() 79'6'H/6'

%P@' 7/ S/+( +( 79' 5@7+;%7' 6':/(:+@+%7+/( /H 79' M%?5@'7 %() C/(7%,5'

H%;+@+'3T

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

*9%&'3?'%6'Z J+@@+%;T \+H6+ &%/ R9'*6.T N)T D6+%( Q+PP/(3T ./()/(X

#6)'( d C'795'(Z VihWT


71/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' OV

T!;% I"+% '( W%,,43" 4* 7;"[%,8%"0%U,

;8% B%598#'6 .F G%'*9%

bC53+:Tc

R6))*0&" U %; ('A'6 ;'661 $9'( U 9'%6 3/;' 3$''7 ;53+:T

7+56%j+"


72/316

Oa >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

7/ )'@+A'6 7/ ./6'(^/ % @'77'6 )'7%+@+(, 9'6 ?@%( H/6 '3:%?'T .+&' % $%(7/(

?@5()'6'6Z 39' $+@@ 3//( 3]5%()'6 [H/563:/6' )5:%73/H *91@/:&23 ;/('1

+( /(' (+,97 +( Q'(/% %() 76%)' 9+3 6+(, H/6 % ;/(&'1T

4'33+:% 3+,(+H+'3 3?1 /6 @//&'6Y/57 +( ='P6'$ bD6/$(Z eZ (/7'cZ%() 79' )%5,97'6 9%3 +()'') P''( % &+() /H 3?1 +( 9'6 H%79'623 9/53'9/@)T

*9' :/;;+73 76'%3/(Z +( % ;%(('6 /H 3?'%&+(,Z P1 ;%661+(, 79' '(';1Z

79' M96+37+%( ./6'(^/Z %() 39' :/;?/5()3 9'6 76'%3/( P1 6'A'%@+(,

P'H/6' 79' 76+%@ 3:'(' 79%7 *91@/:& 9%3 3%+) [9' $/5@) 6%79'6 9%A'

#(7/(+/23 H@'39 d /67+%

79%7 *91@/:& $%(73 #(7/(+/23 @+H' ;/6' 79%( %(1 35; /H ;/('1T U7 +3 %H7'6

#:7 UUUZ 3:'(' ++Z U $/5@) %6,5'Z $9'( 39' 6':%@@3 4'33+:%23 $/6)3Z 79%7

>/67+% )':+)'3 7/ ,/ +( )+3,5+3' 7/ I'(+:' %3 79' @%$1'6 D'@@%6+/23

6'?6'3'(7%7+A' $+79 % ?@%( 7/ )'H'%7 *91@/:&T

.+&' 79/3' /H [79' ;%( 79%7 9%79 (/ ;53+: +( 9+;3'@HZ 79'

;/7+/(3 /H 4'33+:%23 3?+6+7 %6' %3 )5@@ %3 (+,97T


73/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' Oe

Q/PP/ 9%3 3%+) 79%7 9' 79+(&3 39' +3 )%;(')Z %() 9'6 )%;(%7+/( +3

35,,'37') +( ./6'(^/23 @+&'(+(, /H 79' )%6&('33 /H %HH':7+/(3 7/ 79'

)%6&('33 /H N6'P53T N6'P53Z %::/6)+(, 7/ =T .T J+79'63Z +3 [79' :/A'6')

?@%:'Z 79' 5()'6Y$/6@)Z q)+; 6',+/( /H )'%) :/6?3'3r

bVghZ (/7' hOc /(79' $%1 7/ =%)'3T

U( #:7 IZ 3:'(' +Z 4'33+:% %() ./6'(^/ 3+7 /573+)' >/67+%23 9/53' %7

(+,97Z +( 79' ;//(@+,97Z %() 3?'%& /H @/A' b79'+6 :/(A'63%7+/( @'%)3 7/ 79'

'L:9%(,' ]5/7') %7 79' 37%67 /H 79+3 '33%1cT N%:9 )'3:6+P'3 % ;/;'(7 +(

7$/ @','()%61 @/A' %HH%+63 79%7 /::566') /( % (+,97 35:9 %3 79' /(' 79'1

%6' 'L?'6+'(:+(,T ./6'(^/ 6':%@@3 79' @/A'3 /H


74/316

Og >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

$%3 :5((+(, %() )':'+7H5@ P1 ?6/H'33+/(bL@+AcT _'7Z S537 %3 *9%&'3?'%6'

9%3 (/7 :6'%7') % 3+;?@' A+@@%+( +( *91@/:&Z P57 % :/;?@'L ;%( $9/ :%(

'@+:+7 %@7'6(%7'@1 /56 :/()';(%7+/( %() /56 31;?%791Z 3/ 7// 9%3 9' (/7

:6'%7') +( 4'33+:% 3/@'@1 [79' 5(H+@+%@ )%5,97'6 /H % ?'63':57') 4'$

/6Z +(4/9( C+))@'7/( C566123 $/6)3Z [% j:9%6;+(,k ?6+(:'33 9'@) :%?7+A' P1

%( /,6'bVigcZ P57 +(37'%) % :/;P+(%7+/( /H 79' 7$/T

*91@/:& $/5@) :'67%+(@1 3%1 79%7 4'33+:% :%((/7 P' 76537')\ %()

./6'(^/ ?@%1H5@@1 :/;?%6'3 9'6Z +( 79'+6 @/A' [)5'7%7 79' 37%67 /H #:7 IZ

7/ [% @+77@' 396'$ $9/ )+) [3@%()'6 9'6 @/A' bIT+TaVmaacT D'H/6' 79'

'(76%(:' /H >/67+% %() 8'6+33% b6'756(+(, H6/; I'(+:'c +( 79+3 3:'('Z

./6'(^/ +(7+;%7'3 79%7 5(7+@ 4'33+:% :%( P' ;/A') /6 ;%)' ;'661 P1

[3$''7 ;53+:Z9' $+@@ (/7 P' %P@' 7/ 76537 9'6T =+3 @%37 $/6)3 7/ 9'6 %6'

[;%6& 79' ;53+:Z $9+:9 39' )/'3 H/6 79' 6'37 /H 79' ?@%1T ./6'(^/

3?'%&3 /( H+A' ;/6' /::%3+/(3 %H7'6 79+3 @+('\ 4'33+:% )/'3 (/7 3?'%&

%,%+(T J9'( #(7/(+/ %() D%33%(+/ 6'756( H6/; I'(+:'Z 39' )/'3 (/7

/(:' +(]5+6' %H7'6 9'6 H%79'623 H%7'T *9' @'%6(3 /(@1 79%7 39' %() ./6'(^/

$+@@ 6':'+A' [B6/; 79' 6+:9 4'$Z % 3?':+%@ )'') /H ,+H7 d #H7'6 9+3 )'%79Z

/H %@@ 9' )+'3 ?/33'332) /H bIT+TaiamaiecT 4'33+:%Z +7 3'';3Z +3 3+@'(7@1

:/;+(, 7/ 7'6;3 $+79 9'6 P'76%1%@ /H *91@/:&X 6',6'77+(, +7Z P573+;5@7%('/53@1 5()'637%()+(, +73 (':'33+71T

[C53+:Z $6+7'3 8'A+@@ M/,9+@@Z +3 [*9%&'3?'%6'23 6':566'(7

31;P/@ /H 9%6;/(1 bVOcT U( H+(%@@1 6'3?/()+(, 7/ ;53+:Z 4'33+:% $+@@

9%A' 6'3/@A') 79' ?%6%)/L /H 9'6 P'76%1%@ /H d 3%@A%7+/( H6/; 9'6 H%79'6Z

%() $+@@ 9%A' %:9+'A') 9%6;/(1 $+79 9'63'@HZ $+79 (%756' b%3 6'?6'3'(7')

P1 79' [ $+@) %() $%(7/( 9'6) d F6 6%:' /H 1/579H5@ %() 5(9%()@')

:/@73Z/( 79' /(' 9%()Z %() 79' [76''3Z 37/('3Z %() H@//)3Z

/( 79' /79'6cZ

%() $+79 9'6 ('$Z M96+37+%(Z (/(Y5356+/53 $/6@) +( D'@;/(7T

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

D6/$(Z 4/9( G533'@@Z ')T N46 V6504&%. +, ;6%*06Z P1 J+@@+%;

*9%&'3?'%6'T ./()/(X C'795'(Z Vi!!T

M/,9+@@Z 8'A+@@T [


75/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' O!

C5661Z 4/9( C+))@'7/(T T4&[6)C6&56T VieET ./()/(X 4/(%79%( M%?'Z

Vi!iT

J+79'63Z =T .TZ ')T N46 V6504&%. +, ;6%*06Z P1 J+@@+%; *9%&'3?'%6'T

D/37/(X 0T MT ='%79Z ViVET


76/316

OE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

T!;% %)5%Z %3 $'@@ %3 7/ 79' I+6,+( C%61Z H/6


77/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' OO

79' ;+6%:@' /H @+7'6%@ 3%@A%7+/(Z 3+(:' 79+3 #(79/(123 H%A/6 +3 3/5,97 P1

76%A'@'63 +( ('')T #() 4/9((1 9%3 P':/;' % 76%A'@'6 /H 3/673 +( 9+3 %7Y

7';?7 7/ 3%A' 9+;3'@H H6/; :%?756' P1 79' U6+39 G'?5P@+:%( #6;1Z %3 79'

H/@@/$+(, )+%@/,5' 6'A'%@3X

V5)" M+('6T T T T 3@''?+(2 $%( (+,97 +( ;' 3+379'623Z %(2 79' ('L2 +( 1/56 H%79'623

P6/79'623f1/52@@ ,'7 (/ 6'37 ,/+(2 /( 79%7 $%1T

R+4%%(T U :%( 6'37 (/$9'6'Z (/$9'6'Z (/$9'6'T

V5)" M+('6T *56'Z 1/526' (/7 7961+(2 7/ 6'37 %(1$9'6'T

R+4%%(T .'7 ;' %@/('Z @'7 ;' %@/('Z H/6 Q/)23 3%&'T bVWec

%)5%T U( 9+3 %77';?7 7/

'@5)' /6 9+)' H6/; 79' U6+39 G'?5P@+:%( #6;1Z %3 $'@@ %3 /( %::/5(7 /H

9+3 )+HH+:5@71 +( $%@&+(,Z 4/9((1 9%3 P':/;' % &+() /H 9'6;+7 $9'6'A'6

9' 9%3 P''( 37%1+(, +( 05P@+(f%7 %( 5(:@'23 %?%67;'(7Z %( %5(723Z /6 9+3

H%;+@123 /$( ?@%:'T 056+(, 79' ?@%1Z 9' ('A'6 ,/'3 /573+)' 5(7+@ 79' '()Z

$9'( 9' +3 )6%,,') /HH P1 7$/ [U66',5@%63\ H5679'6;/6'Z 9' 6';%+(3

5(3''(Z +(3+)' 79' P')6//; /H 79' 7$/Y6//; D/1@' %?%67;'(7Z H/6 ;5:9

/H 79' %:7+/(T U7 +3 79'6' 79%7 9' ?6%13 7/ 9+3 H'@@/$ 6':@53'Z *%+(7 #(79/(1

/H N,1?7Z 79' ?%76/( 3%+(7 /H 3/@+7%61 9'6)3;'( %()Z P1 'L7'(3+/(Z 79'+6

;+@+7%61 :/5(7'6?%673Z ]5%67'6;%37'63 b$9/ 35??@1 76//?3 $+79 H//)Z

:@/79+(,Z 39'@7'6Z %() ']5+?;'(7cT

l(H/675(%7'@1Z 4/9((123 ?6%1'63 7/ 79' '6';+7+: *%+(7 #(79/(1Z

@+&' 9+3 ?6%1'63 7/ 79' I+6,+( C%61Z )/ 9+; (/ ,//)T U()'')Z +7 +3 ?6':+3'Y

@1 $9'( 9' +3 %@@ %@/(' +( 79' D/1@' %?%67;'(7Z %() 79'6'H/6' A5@('6%P@'Z

79%7 9' +3 ]5'37+/(') P1 79' UTGT#T b%7 79' '() /H #:7 UUZ %H7'6 9+3 H%;+@1

9%3 ,/(' )/$( 7/ 79' 376''7f+6/(+:%@@1Z 7/ /P3'6A' 79' ?%33+(, /H G/PP+'


78/316

Oh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6


79/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' Oi

(/$9'6'Z (/$9'6'Z (/$9'6'Z4/9((1 D/1@' 9%) )':@%6') 7/ 9+3 ;/79'6

+( #:7 UU /H R9%+ &%/ .46 -&(0+0[Z %()Z H6/; % M%79/@+: ?/+(7 /H A+'$Z

79/3' $/6)3 $+@@ :/;' P%:& 7/ 9%5(7 9+; +( 79' '()f+( 79' %H7'6@+H'T

F'+%,

VT 6/7'37%(7 )'(/;+Y

(%7+/(T J+79+( 79' :956:9 +73'@HZ )+HH'6'(:'3 'L+37 P'7$''( 79/3'

;';P'63 $9/3' 35P:5@756' +3 ;/6' M%79/@+:Y@'%(+(, %() 79/3'

;';P'63 $9/3' 35P:5@756' +3 ;/6' >6/7'37%(7Y@'%(+(,T

aT F2M%3'1 9+;3'@H $%3 % ;';P'6 /H 79' U6+39 G'?5P@+:%( D6/79'6Y

9//) bUTGTDTcZ % 3':6'7Z /%79YP/5() H6%7'6(%@ /6,%(+^%7+/( )')+Y

:%7')Z P'7$''( Vh!h %() ViagZ 7/ 79' '37%P@+39;'(7 /H %( +()'Y

?'()'(7 )';/:6%7+: 6'?5P@+: +( U6'@%()T B6/; ViVg 7/ ViVEZ 9'

$%3 %@3/ % ;';P'6 /H 79' U6+39 M+7+^'( #6;1 bUTMT#TcZ % 3;%@@,6/5? /H 76%+(') 76%)' 5(+/( A/@5(7''63 '37%P@+39') +( 05P@+( H/6

79' )'H'(3' /H $/6&'623 )';/(376%7+/(3 H6/; 79' ?/@+:'\ +( ViVEZ

79' UTMT#T 7//& ?%67 +( 79' N%37'6 G+3+(,f%( %6;') +(3566':7+/(

%+;') %7 '()+(, D6+7+39 65@' +( U6'@%()T


80/316

hW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

eT */;' 9+37/6+:%@ %() ?/@+7+:%@ P%:&,6/5() 3'';3 :%@@') H/6 9'6'T


81/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' hV

T!;% W%\ !;"+ ?4$$%0 A0%\E H%$4Q4'*G B+;*434+:G

"*1 ?4$$%0U,/%#68 .F # )#?%2:#'

Q6&.4 +, & T&'6)H&% bVigic +3 3'7 +( 79' @%7' VigW3 %() 6'%:9'3 P%:&

3/;' H+H7''( 1'%63 7/ 79' '%6@1 VieW3T U $/5@) (/7 +;?@1Z 9/$'A'6f%3

3/;' :6+7+:3 9%A' )/('f79%7 P1 A+675' /H +73 H@%39P%:& 3765:756'Z T&'6)e

H&% $/5@) 9%A' ;%)' % P'77'6 H+@; b$+79 +73 )+33/@A'3Z :6/33YH%)+(,Z %()

;+(57'@1 )'7%+@') 6'%@+3; %3 /??/3') 7/ 6'%@+3; /H 79' ;/)+H+')Z 3+;?@+Y

H+')Z /6 79'%76+:%@+^') &+()c 79%( % ?@%1T U( H%:7Z +( 79' :%3' /H #67956

C+@@'623 )6%;%Z 79' 79'%7'6 9%3 % 35?'6+/6 %P+@+71 7/ 35,,'37 P/79 79' :9+@)Y

+39('33 /H J+@@123 3/(3 bP1 9%A+(, 79' %)5@7 %:7/63 /H D+HH %() =%??1

[5(6'%@+37+:%@@1?@%1 79'+6 P/19//) 3'@A'3 /(37%,'c %() 79' ;/;'(7/53Y

('33 /H J+@@123 %)5@7'61 bP1 9%A+(, +7 /::56Z (/7 [/( @/:%7+/(+( D/37/(Z

P57 /( 79' H/6'37%,'f6+,97 +( 79' ./;%(32 @+A+(, 6//;Z %3 +7 $'6'cT #()

3/;' /H 79' ?@%1Z %3 ?@%1Z +3 7/5:9+(, /6 ?/+,(%(7 37+@@X J+@@1 $9'( 9' +3

%7 9+3 ;/37 3%@'3;%(Y@+&'Z 79' G']5+'; /A'6 9+3 :/HH+(Z %() 'A'( 79' A'61

H@%39P%:& 3765:756' /H T&'6)H&%T B/6 +7 35,,'373 79%7Z $+79/57 79' H@%39Y

P%:&3 /6+,+(%7+(, +( J+@@123 ;+()Z 79' +(H/6;%7+/( :/(A'1') P1 79';f

%P/57 35:9 35PS':73 %3 %)5@7'61Z @1+(,Z :9'%7+(,Z %() H%+@56'f$/5@) (/7P' 6'A'%@') +( 79' ?6'3'(7 +( )+%@/,5' %;/(, 79' ./;%(3Z $9/Z 5(@+&'

79'


82/316

ha >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

+(7'623 O'/ N*H6)jViOVkTc

B5679'6Z ;+,97 J+@@123 H@%39P%:&3 79'6'H/6' (/7 /(@1 P' 9+3 %77';?7

7/ 6';';P'6 % ?+A/7%@ 1'%6 +( 9+3 %() 9+3 H%;+@123 ?%37Z VieV /6 Viea

bH//7P%@@ 37%6 D+HH23 3'(+/6 1'%6 /H 9+,9 3:9//@Z )56+(, $9+:9 9' )+3:/A'63

9+3 H%79'623 %)5@7'6/53 6'@%7+/(39+? $+79 79' J/;%( +( D/37/(Z %() $9'(

J+@@1 ?56?/67')@1 756(3 )/$( % S/P +( #@%3&% $/6&+(, H/6 9+3 P6/79'6D'(c\ ;+,97 79'3' H@%39P%:&3 %@3/ P' J+@@123 %77';?7 7/ H+:7+/(%@+^' ?%67

/H 9+3 ?%37 %3 $'@@ %3 7/ ?/676%1 3/;' /H +7 76579H5@@1K #H7'6 %@@Z (/ :9%6%:Y

7'6 +( 79' ?@%1Z 'L:'?7 J+@@1Z 53'3 D'(23 (%;' /6 6'H'63 7/ 79' '@)'6 P6/79Y

'623 */579 #H6+:%( P53+('33 A'(756'3Z (/6 )/'3 %(1 :9%6%:7'6 P'3+)'3

J+@@1 6'H'6 7/ 9+3 $%,/(Y76%A'@3 J'37Z %3 % P/1Z $+79 9+3 H@57'Y:%6A+(,

H%79'6T #() ;/37 /H 79'3' 6'H'6'(:'3Z P1 J+@@1Z /::56 +( 9+3 H@%39P%:&3

79';3'@A'3Z )56+(, :/(A'63%7+/(3 $+79 D'(T


83/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' he

M/5@) D'( %() 79' $%,/(Y76%A'@3Z 79'(Z P' J+@@123 +(A'(7+/(Z 9+3

%77';?7Z +H 1/5 $+@@Z %3 % ?6/L1 H/6 C+@@'6 b% 4'$ $9/3' 796'' ;%66+%,'3

$'6' %@@ 7/ M96+37+%( $/;'(Z %() $9/ ('A'6 7//& 79' 37%(:' /H % ?5P@+:

R6F*)4+(7'@@':75%@ )56+(, 9+3 @/(, :%6''6cZ 7/ M96+37+%(+^' /6 5(+A'63%@+^'9+3 ?%37K C+,97 79+3 (/7 P' 35,,'37') 3/;'9/$ +( ?6/)5:7+/(Z A+35%@@1 %3

$'@@ %3 A/:%@@1Z 796/5,9 79' 53' /H )+HH'6'(7 %:7/63 +( 79' H@%39P%:&3 +(

79' 6/@'3 /H .+()%Z D+HHZ %() =%??1f$9/3' %??'%6%(:' %() ;%(('6 /H

3?'%&+(, $/5@) ;%&' :@'%6 79%7 79'1 $'6' J+@@123 +)'%@+^') M96+37+%(

A'63+/(3 /H 9+3 6'%@ $+H' %() 3/(3K J/5@) 35:9 %( +(7'6?6'7%7+/( /H 79'

:/(7'L7 /HQ6&.4 +, &T&'6)H&%23 H@%39P%:&3 (/7 P' 765'6 7/ 79' ?@%1 %3 +7

37%()3Z ?%67+:5@%6@1 +H 79+3 6'Y+;%,+(+(, $'6' %( 'L:5@?%7/61 ;/A' /(

J+@@123 ?%67Z 7/ P@%;' 9+3 H%+@+(,3 /( %(7+Y*';+7+3; %() 79'6'P1 35,,'37

79%7 9+3 @+H' $/5@) 9%A' P''( P'77'6f;%7'6+%@@1Z )/;'37+:%@@1Z ?31:9/Y

@/,+:%@@1f9%) 9' /(@1 P''( % >6/7'37%(7K #() $/5@)(27 35:9 %( +(7'6?6'Y

7%7+/( P' 765' %3 $'@@ 7/ C+@@'623 %:&(/$@'),;'(7 +( 79'V*04*8&% ?9&5e

.65'(\6D*6F+(7'6A+'$Z +( 6'3?/(3' 7/ 0%A+) C%;'723 6';%6&3Z 79%7 J+@@1

$%3 +( H%:7 % 4'$ %() 9+3 37/61 % 4'$+39 /('K

U()'')Z ;5:9 /H 79' ?/$'6 Q6&.4 +, &T&'6)H&%37+@@ 9%3 )'6+A'3

H6/; 79' 356'YH+6' :/(A'(7+/(3 /H _+))+39 )/;'37+: 79'%7'6T bQ6&.4 +, &T&'6)H&%$%3 +( H%:7 ?'6H/6;') +( _+))+39Z +( D6//&@1( +( Vi!VZ +( %

76%(3@%7+/( P1 4/3'?9 D5@/HHZ $+79 D5@/HH %() 9+3 $+H'Z .15P% R%)+3/(f

,+H7') %:7/63 H6/; 8'$ _/6&23 _+))+39 79'%7'6f+( 79' 6/@'3 /H J+@@1 %()

.+()%Tc #3 +H +7 $'6' +( % )+6':7 @+(' H6/; 35:9 4'$+39Y+;;+,6%(7 )6%;%

796/5,9 M@+HH/6) F)'73Z C+@@'623 ?@%1 :@+;%L'3 $+79 % 6'P'@@+/53 3/( P'Y

+(, 6':/(:+@') $+79 9+3 '376%(,') H%79'6T M/;?%6' #@ 4/@3/(Z +( 79' H+@;

N46 R&jj T*%865 bViaOcZ P'+(, H/6,+A'( P1 9+3 37'6( F679/)/L H%79'6 H/69%A+(, P':/;' % .6&.65j*%8656%79'6 79%( % :%(7/6T #() :/;?%6' T&'6)e

H&% $+79 C+@@'623 /$( N46 356&.*+% +, .46 B+5'/ &%/ O.465 M9)*%6))

bViOacZ $9+:9 $%3 ;'%(7 7/ P' % 4'$+39 )/;'37+: :/;')1 /( 79' ,*5).

H%79'6Y3/( 37/61Z 79%7 /H Q/) %() #)%;Z P57 $9'6'Z '79(+:%@@1 3?'%&+(,Z

79' ?@%1$6+,97 H+))@')Z H%@7'6')Z %() H5;P@') /(:' %,%+(T

G'@%7') 7/ 79+3 ;%77'6 /H 4'$+39 '79(+:+71Z :/(3+)'6 79' )+:7+/( /H

79' ?@%1Z P':%53' % ?@%1 +3 +73 @%(,5%,'Z H+637 %() H+(%@@1T #() Q6&.4 +, &

T&'6)H&%H%@7'63 P%)@1 +( 79+3 6',%6)Z ?/33+P@1 %@3/ /( %::/5(7 /H C+@@'623


84/316

hg >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

)+A+)') +;?5@3' P'7$''( $6+7+(, % 4'$+39 H%;+@1 ?@%1 %() :/;?/3+(, %

5(+A'63%@ )6%;% %P/57 #;'6+:%( @+H'T #7 +73 P'37Z +73 765' %() 7'@@+(, P'37Z

79' )+:7+/( +3 H+637Y,'('6%7+/( D6//&@1( 4'$+39f79' &+() /H N(,@+39 79%7

(/7 /(@1 +3 3?/&'( $+79 % ;53:5@%6Z ,57756%@Z 3+(,Y3/(,1 D6//&@1( %:Y:'(7Z P57 79%7 %@3/ 6'7%+(3 79' ?/'7+: +;%,'61Z H/6:'H5@ 'L?6'33+/(Z %()

6+75%@+37+: 6'?'7+7+/( /H _+))+39 $9+@' )+3:%6)+(, Q'6;%( 31(7%LZ ,6%;Y

;%6Z %() /H :/563' $/6)3T ='6' %6' 3/;' 'L%;?@'3 H6/; 79' ?@%1X [.+H'

+3 % :%37+(, /HH jV!k\ [# ;%( +3 (/7 % P+6)Z 7/ :/;' %() ,/ $+79 79'

3?6+(,7+;' b!gc\ [#77'(7+/(Z %77'(7+/( ;537 P' H+(%@@1 ?%+) 7/ 35:9 %

?'63/( b!Ec\ [C/('1 +3 7/ ?%33 bEgc\ [U 3@'?7 @+&' % )'%) /(' bOVc\

[='23 /(@1 % @+77@' P/%7 @//&+(, H/6 % 9%6P/6 bOEc\ [*?+7'Z 3?+7'Z +3 79'

$/6) /H 1/56 5()/+(,bVeWcT

FH7'(Z 9/$'A'6Z 79' )+%@/,5' 3@+?3 +(7/ % ,'('6%@+^') H%(:+('33

79%7 +3 3@+,97@1 @5)+:6/53T


85/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' h!

;'%(+(,H5@ 7/ 9+3 H'@@/$ :+7+^'(3 %() :/(3765:7+A' /H 3/:+'71 %3 % $9/@'T

U(37'%)Z C+@@'6 H/5() 9+;3'@H +( % $/6@) $+79 % $+3?1 '79/3 %() % )+;

:/3;/@/,1Z $9'6' 79'6' $%3 (/ :/;;/( 3/5()+(, P/%6) /H %3?+6%7+/(

%6/5() 9+; 7/ ':9/ 9+3 $/6)3Z (/ ,6%()Z %537'6' )'3+,( %,%+(37 $9+:9 9+3:9%6%:7'63 :/5@) ;'%356' 79';3'@A'3T


86/316

hE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

TF43[ 4* 6$#%%U, H8.12 !F5#*( .F G*5+*'*# H..?FI

MT JT NT D+,3P1 79+(&3 79%7 N)$%6) #@P'' (%;') 9+3 :9%6%:7'6 8+:&Z

H6/; B4+I) $,5&*/ +, ;*58*%*& B++',J bViEacZ %H7'6 8+&+7% R96539:9'A

bVhigmViOVc P':%53' 8+:& [+3 % 7/7%@+7%6+%( +(7'6'37') +( ?/$'6 baEOcT

D57 +7 +3 ;/6' @+&'@1 79%7 8+:&23 (%;' )'6+A'3 H6/; 9+3 ?6/H'33+/( /H

P+/@/,+37Z S537 %3 Q'/6,'23 (%;' )'6+A'3 H6/; 9+3 ?6/H'33+/( /H 9+37/6+%(Z

7953 ;%&+(, 9+; % &+() /H Q'/6,' J%39+(,7/( $9/Z %@/(, $+79 9+3 $+H'Z

C%679%Z ';P/)+'3 79' %6:9'71?%@ #;'6+:%( :/5?@'T


87/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' hO

9+;3'@HZ /6 %7 @'%37 %( +(35P37%(7+%@ :6'%756'Z 3+(:' 9+3 (%;' +3 53') +( 79'

37%,' )+6':7+/(3 P57 ('A'6 ;'(7+/(') /6 3?/&'( +( 79' ?@%123 )+%@/,5'T

'(,5+(Z

ViE!T

D+,3P1Z MT JT NT$ 35*.*0&' !%.5+/90.*+% .+ NF6%.*6.4e36%.95( $H65*0&%

Q5&H&T I/@T aT M%;P6+),'Z lTRTX M%;P6+),' l(+A'63+71 >6'33Z

VihgT

B6Z).65I) S*%.4 S6F 3+''68*&.6 Q*0.*+%&5(T *?6+(,H+'@)Z C%33%:953'773X

C'66+%;YJ'P37'6Z VihET


88/316

hh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

TJ*3$% 7"V 4*


89/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' hi

#H7'6


90/316

iW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

T!;% N;',+ 4* O'*1U,-%#5


91/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' iV

C/6'/A'6Z 79' D/1 $%3 3'@H@'33\ 79' Q9/37 +3 3'@HY3'6A+(,T J9'(

79' +;?6+3/(') .'%6 :%@@3 H/6 9+3 )%5,97'63 +( #:7 UUUZ *:'(' ++Z 79' Q9/37

:%( P6+(, 9+; /(@1 79' ,9/373 /H 9+3 )%5,97'63Z 79' @+77@' ,+6@3 D/)+:' %()

B/(7%('@@'Z $9/ :%( )/ @+77@' H/6 79'+6 H%79'6T UH 79' Q9/37 +3 79' [,9/37

/6 )+;+(57+/( /H 79' D/123 H/6;'6 3'@HZ 79' @/A+(, ,+6@3 %6' 79' [,9/373Z

79' @/37 /6 35??6'33') %3?':73Z /H D/)+:'23 %() B/(7%('@@'23 ?6'3'(7Z P657%@

3'@A'3T


92/316

ia >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

)'@+% b$9/ $%3 79' D/123 J+H'cZ +(3+37+(, 79%7 .'%6 7'@@ 9'6 79%7 9'6 @%7'

953P%() +3 ?6'3'(7f$9+:9 79' H/6;'6 65@'6 )/'3 (/7 )/T

J9'( M/6)'@+% @'%A'3Z 79' Q9/37 %3&3 .'%6Z [J91 )+)(27 1/5 7'@@

9'6 U $%3 9'6'K *9' $%(7') 7/ 7%@& 7/ ;'T *9' :/5@)(27 H/6,'7 ;'T U ;%)'@/A' 7/ 9'6 +( 79%7 9/53' (+,97 %H7'6 (+,97Z %() /( 79+3 ,6%33T .//& %7 ;'

(/$- U2A' 756(') +(7/ .4*)f%() U :%(27 'A'( 7/5:9 9'6-bh!\ UUUT+++TcT


93/316

C/)'@ N33%13X M9%6%:7'6 %() G/@' ie

=' +3 (/$ P',+((+(, 3+(,@'Y9%()')@1 7/ 7'%6 )/$( 79' $%@@ 79%7 M/6)'@+%

9'63'@H 9%3 P5+@7T

D/() :/(76%373 79' Q9/37 /H 79' Q6%A')+,,'623 D/1 $+79 .'%6 +(

3?+6+7 %3 $'@@ %3 P/)1T F(:' .'%6 +3 @+7'6%@@1 P@+()Z H/6 'L%;?@'Z 9' P',+(37/ %:9+'A' +(3+,97T =' 3''3 79' '66/6 /H 9+3 $%13 %3 &+(, %()Z %3 ?6'A+/53Y

@1 ;'(7+/(')Z $%(73 7/ 9'@? M/6)'@+% 7/ %A/+) 9+3 ;+37%&'3Z %3 79' H/@@/$Y

+(, @+('3 6'A'%@X [C'( )'376/1 79';3'@A'3 %() 3%1 +723 79'+6 )571K U723 (/7

?/33+P@'- =/$ :%( 79'1 P' 3/ %P53')K M/6)'@+% )/'3(27 &(/$ $9%7 39'23

)/+(,- U ;537 7'@@ 9'6f$6+7' 7/ 9'6-bEO\ UUTA++TcT l(@+&' 79' 3'@HY3'6A+(,

Q9/37Z .'%6 79'(Z P':/;'3 3'@H@'33f%3 $9'(


94/316

ig >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

$9'( .'%6Z @+A+(, /( 79' H%6;Z 9%3 H+(%@@1 7%&'( /( 79' D/123 /57@//&

:/;?@'7'@1f9%3 9+;3'@H P':/;' 79' D/1Z +( % ;%(('6 /H 3?'%&+(,T


95/316

i!

?@ABC B776D7E 7!DCB 6FA NBFHB

TI2+204,V "*1 @UF%4$$U, ;8% %

G/P'67 [_%(& *;+79 /H N46 a&*5( $C6 bViaac +3 ;'%(7f+H /(@1 P1

N5,'(' F28'+@@23 :9/+:' /H 9+3 (+:&(%;'Z 7/,'79'6 $+79 9+3 ;'@7+(, ?/7 /H

% [@%(,5%,'ZD6//&@1('3'f7/ P' 79' %6:9'71?%@ #;'6+:%(Z %(%@/,/53 7/

79' %6:9'71?%@ U7%@+%( /H H5756+37 )6%;%T bB5756+37 )6%;% $%3 37+@@ P'+(,

?6/)5:') +( U7%@1 %7 79' 3%;' 7+;' %3 N46 a&*5( $C6f$9+:9 +3 /79'6$+3'

% ]5%3+Y'L?6'33+/(+37Z Q'6;%(Y+(H@5'(:') $/6&f$%3 P'+(, 37%,') +(

8'$ _/6&Tc %))1 69%?3/)+^'3 +( *:'(' V /H F28'+@@23 ?@%1T #3 79'3'

U7%@+%(3 6'%@+^')f+( 35:9 ?@%13 %3


96/316

iE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

U( '33'(:'Z 79'(Z 79' @+;+73 /H 7+;' %() 3?%:' 9%) P''( 76%(3:'()Y

')f%3 79'1 %6'Z +( % 3'(3'Z +( %(1 ?6/)5:7+/( /H N46 a&*5( $C6Z $9+:9

;/A'3 H6/; % 76%(3%7@%(7+: /:'%( @+('6 P/5() H/6 */579%;?7/(Z N(,@%()Z

7/ 3'A'6%@ @/:%7+/(3 /( 79' 376''73 /H 8'$ _/6&Z %() $9+:9 7%&'3 ?@%:'/A'6 % ?'6+/) /H 7$/ ;/(793T 8/$ +7 $%3 ?/33+P@' 7/ @+A' 796/5,9 'A'(73

P/79 )+37%(7 %() ('%6 %7 9%()X +( H%:7Z 7/ P' 'A'61$9'6' %7 79' 3%;' 7+;'T

#::/6)+(,@1Z C%6+('77+ %() 9+3 H/@@/$'63 9'@) 79%7 79' 3?'') /H ;/)'6(

@+H' :%@@') H/6 % :/66'3?/()+(, 3?'') /H :/;;5(+:%7+/( +( :/(7';?/6%61

%67Z $9+:9 39/5@)f5(@+&' 79' :/(A'(7+/(%@ 79'%7'6fP' H%6 P6+'H'6 %()

;/6' :/;?6'33') /6 31(79'3+^') 79%( 'A'( N46 a&*5( $C6Z 1'7 %7 79'

3%;' 7+;' +(:/6?/6%7' 3+;5@7%('/53 %:7+/( /::566+(, +( )+HH'6'(7 ?@%:'3

/6 %7 )+HH'6'(7 7+;'3T

B5756+3; 7//& 9/@) +( U7%@1f%()Z +( 3/;'$9%7 )+HH'6'(7Z ;/6'

;'7%?9/6+:%@Z %3 $'@@ %3 ;/6' 39/67Y@+A')Z 79'%76+:%@ H/6;Z +( 79' H/6;'6

lT*T*TGT b$9+:9Z 5(@+&' 3//(Y7/YP' B%3:+37 U7%@1Z 6'376+:7') /6 :/;?@'7'@1

35??6'33') 79' H6'')/; 'A'( /H 79/3' %67+373Z @+&' 79' G533+%( H5756+373Z

$9/ 35??/67') 79' M/;;5(+37 6'A/@57+/(cf%3 +( (/ /79'6 J'37'6( (%Y

7+/( ?%67@1 P':%53' 79+3 :/5(761Z @+&' 79' */A+'7 l(+/(Z 5()'6$'(7 +()53Y

76+%@+^%7+/( b%3 $'@@ %3 (%7+/(%@+^%7+/( /6 :/(3/@+)%7+/(c ;5:9 @%7'6 79%(Z3%1Z 79' l(+7') *7%7'3T B/6 79+3 6'%3/(Z U7%@+%( H5756+373 ';P6%:') 79'

;%:9+(' %,' %() %@@ 79%7 +7 ;%)' ?/33+P@'f+(:@5)+(, $%6Z $9+:9 79'1

@%P'@') 79' 35?6';'Z 9'%@79YP'37/$+(, %:7+A+71f7/ %( 'L7'(7 5(&(/$( +(

#;'6+:%( %67+37+: :+6:@'3T U()'')Z _%(&23 (+:&(%;'f:/;;/(@1 53') %7

79' 7+;' 7/ 6'H'6 7/ %( #;'6+:%( 3/@)+'6 +( J/6@) J%6 U b$9+:9 '()')

/(@1 796'' 1'%63 P'H/6' 79' $6+7+(, /H N46 a&*5( $C6cf;%1 9%A' P''(

P'37/$') /( 9+; P1 9+3 39+?23 @%6,'@1 +;;+,6%(7 /6 N56/?'%( :6'$Z +(Y:@5)+(, U7%@+%(3 b3'' 79' [I/+:'3/( VEhmVEicZ P':%53' 9' $%3 % 6':'(7Y

@1 6'756(') $%6 A'7'6%(T


97/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' iO

J+7('33 F28'+@@23 /A'6%@@ 76'%7;'(7 /H 9+3 ?6/7%,/(+37 +( N46 a&*5(

$C6Z $9'6' _%(& *;+79 P':/;'3 6'?6'3'(7%7+A' /H 79' )+3?@%:';'(7 /H

;/)'6( 95;%(+71 +( ,'('6%@X /H ?'/?@' $9/Z +( 79' C%6L+37 3'(3'Z P'Y

:/;' %@+'(%7') H6/; 79';3'@A'3 P':%53' 79'+6 $/6& +3 (/7 ?%67 /H 79'+6@+H'\ P':%53' 79'+6 $/6& b?%67+:5@%6@1 79' %@@Y:/(35;+(, [$/6& /H $%6c

7%&'3 /A'6 79'+6 @+H' '(7+6'@1Z %3 +( 79' :%3' /H _%(&\ /6Z +( 79' :%3' /H 79'

+)@'Z 5??'6Y:@%33 C+@)6')Z %3 /??/3') 7/ %( 5(';?@/1') ;';P'6 /H 79'

5()'6:@%33Z P':%53' $/6& +3 3/;'79+(, 79%7 79'1 )/ (/7 'A'( $%(7T #3 %

6'35@7Z 79'3' ?'/?@' H+() 79';3'@A'3 %@+'(%7') H6/; /79'6 95;%( P'+(,3

%3 $'@@Z $+79 $9/; 79'1 (/ @/(,'6 39%6' % 3/:+%@ '33'(:' /6 7/ $9/3'

3/:+'71 79'1 (/ @/(,'6 H''@ 79'1 P'@/(,T

U( _%(&23 :%3'Z 79%7 %@+'(%7+/( 76%(3@%7'3 +(7/ % &+() /H ?'6;%('(7Z

H%7%@ 'L+37'(7+%@+3;f% ?%6%@1^+(, :@%39Z +H 1/5 $+@@Z P'7$''( 0%(7'23

;')+'A%@Y:5;YG'(%+33%(:' M96+37+%(+71 %() C%6+('77+23 7$'(7+'79Y

:'(7561Z 7/7%@+7%6+%( ,/)@'33('33 b/6 '@'A%7+/( /H 3:+'(:' %() 7':9(/@/,1

7/ ,/)@+&' 37%753cT #() 79' A'61 3765:756' /H N46a&*5( $C66'A'%@3 79+3

:@%39Z $9+:9 +73'@HZ +( % 3'(3'Z ?6'A'(73 _%(& H6/; ;/A+(, '+79'6 P%:&Y

$%6) /6 H/6$%6)Z /( 7/ 79' ?%37 /6 P%:& 7/ 79' H5756'T B/6Z /( 79' /('

9%()Z 79' '?+3/)+: H/6; /H 79' ?@%1 ;%1 P' :/()5:+A' 7/ 79' +@@5376%7+/(/H % ?6/,6'33+A' +H +(:6';'(7%@ S/56('1 7/$%6) 3?+6+75%@ $9/@'('33 /6

/6,%(+:+71\ /( 79' /79'6 9%()Z 9/$'A'6Z 79%7 3%;' '?+3/)+: H/6;Z +( 79'

6%?+)+71 $+79 $9+:9 +7 :%( 76%(3:'() /6 :/()'(3' 7+;' %() ?@%:'Z 35,,'373

79' C%:9+(' #,' /H $9+:9 _%(& +3 % ?%67Z $+79 +73 '%3' /H 76%(3?/67Z %7Y

/;+^%7+/( /H 95;%( 'L+37'(:'Z 3?'') /H 7';?/Z %() 'A'( 3+;5@7%('+71 /H

'L?'6+'(:'T

.//&') %7 %(/79'6 $%1Z 79' '+,97 3:'('3 /H 79' ?@%1 P6'%& )/$(9%@H %() 9%@H P'7$''( ;/)'6(+3; +( 79' H/6; /H H5756+3; %() ;')+'A%@Y

+3; +( 79' H/6; /H 79' 37%7+/(3Y/HY79'Y:6/33 )6%;%T


98/316

ih >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

3'' /( 37%,'c $/6& P'@/$ +( 79' 37/&'9/@' 'A'( %3 C+@)6') %() 9'6 %5(7

%6' A+3+P@' /( 7/? /( 79' /:'%( @+('623 ?6/;'(%)' )':&T

#H7'6 C+@)6') ;''73 79' [H+@791 P'%37Z/H :/563'Z 79' ?@%1 :/;Y

?@'7'@1 :9%(,'3T B/@@/$+(, /(' ;/6' 3:'(' %P/%6) 39+?Z *:'(' gZ 79'5()'6@1+(, 3765:756' /H N46 a&*5($C6 3$+7:9'3 7/ 79%7 /H % ;')+'A%@

37%7+/( )6%;%Z 6'@1+(, (/$ 5?/( 3']5'(:' 6%79'6 79%( 3+;5@7%('+71T


99/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' ii

TO0%3;+U,! B#'12 # B#'"*1 +;% N0'+%,]2%


100/316

VWW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

,6/7'3]5' 79%( $+79 79' 76%,+:/;+: b3'' (/7' acT [


101/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' VWV

Q%@1 Q%1Z D6':97 9%3 39/$( 53Z +3 ';+('(7@1 :9%(,'%P@'Z 3/ 79'6'

+3 (/ 6'%3/( 7/ P'@+'A' 79%7 9' $+@@ 6';%+( % ;56)'6/53 3/@)+'6X 79' A'61

(%756' /H 79' )6%;%Z %3 $'@@ %3 9+3 /$( :9%6%:7'6Z :/(76%)+:73 79+3 +)'%T #

;%(23 % ;%(Z +()'')T

F'+%,

VT D'(S%;+( $6+7'3 79%7 [(/$ >@%7/ %@6'%)1 6':/,(+^') A'61 $'@@

79' 5()6%;%7+: ]5%@+71 /H 79' 9+,9'37 H/6; /H P'+(,Z 79' $+3'

;%( bag /H D'(S%;+(23 ;65)9046 dZ65 M5604. jL))&() +%

M5604.\ B6%(&H567 %; C%+(X *596&%;? I'6@%,Z ViEEk\ ;1 76%(3Y

@%7+/(cT

aT C%6+%((' R'37+(,23 [0+' Q6/7'3&' A/; I'6@537 )'6 U)'(7+7t7

b+( =%(3 *7'HH'(Z ')TZ Q&) /69.)046 79).)C*6' 1 jQu77+(,'(X

I%()'(9/':& %() G5?6':97Z ViEikZ VhWmViic +3 79' /(@1 375)1 U

&(/$ /H 79%7 P6+(,3 5? 79' ,6/7'3]5' +( 6'@%7+/( 7/ $ V&%I) &

V&%T D57 R'37+(,23 %67+:@' +3 ?6+;%6+@1 % )+3:533+/( /H 79' )+HY

H'6'(:'3 P'7$''( 79' H+637 ?5P@+39') A'63+/( %() 35P3']5'(7 ')+Y

7+/(3Z (/7 %( 'L%;+(%7+/( /H 79' ,6/7'3]5' '@';'(7 +( 79' ?@%1T

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

D6':97Z D'67/@7T $ V&%I) & V&%T 6'33Z ViOVT


102/316

VWa >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

TK%3;+ "*1 ?"360+;20U, ;8% A5.'6 =#+%"*1 I"03%


103/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' VWe

95;%( @+H'f?%67+:5@%6@1 %3 +7 +3 @+A') %7 35:9 H%37 ?%:' P1 79'3' /??/6Y

75(+373T

J9%7 %@3/ 7%&'3 79' ?@%1 P'1/() ?56' H%6:' +3 79' )'?79 /H +73 3/Y

:+'7%@ %() :9%6%:7'6/@/,+:%@ ?/676%+756'Z %3 79' :9%6%:7'632 :%?%:+71 H/6:9+@)+39('33Z :%@@/53('33Z %() 'A'( 3%)+3; ?6/A+)'3 % 35P7'L7 7/ 'A'61

@%5,9T


104/316

VWg >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

79' ?@%1 ?6/A+)'3 % ,@+;?3' /H 79' 3'%;1 3+)' /H #;'6+:%( ?/@+7+:3 %()

?6'33 ?6%:7+:'3T

U()'')Z +( 79' $%1 79%7 +7 7%&'3 % P'%)1 @//& %7 95;%( :/665?7+/(Z

N46 W5+%. -&8635,,'373 9/$ 3/H7 $' 9%A' 3+(:' P':/;' %3 % )';/:6%7+:6'?5P@+: %() %( %67+37+: :5@756'T F(' ;+,97 'A'( 3%1 79%7 79' ?@%1 )6%;%Y

7+^'3 0%6$+(23 356A+A%@+37 79'/61 $+79 % P6''^1 3%(,H6/+) ']5%@') P'H/6'

/(@1 P1 D'( 4/(3/( %() 4/9( Q%1Z %() /(@1 P1 D'67/@7 D6':97 %() 0%A+)

C%;'7 +( /56 /$( 7+;'T

O4#$4'Q0"8;:

=':97Z D'(Z %() M9%6@'3 C%:#67956T N46 W5+%. -&86T 8'$ _/6&X *%;5Y

'@ B6'(:9Z Vi!WT


105/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' VW!

T!0"Q%1: 4* 7+%4*#%3[U, DF B*9% #'( B%'

M6+7+:32 H%+@56' 7/ %??6':+%7' 79' 765' ?/3+7+/( /H 79' :9%6%:7'6 /H M%()1 +(

O, V*06 &%/V6% 9%3 @') 7/ %( 5()'6Y%??6':+%7+/( /H 79' 76%,+: )+;'(Y

3+/(3 /H 4/9( *7'+(P':&23 ?@%1Z H6/; 79+3 $/6&23 H+637 %??'%6%(:' +( VieO

%@@ 79' $%1 5? 7/ aWWiZ $+79 79' ?5P@+:%7+/( /H C+:9%'@ C'1'623 N46

L))6%.*&' 35*.*0*)H +, R+4% T.6*%Z60[I) FH C+:' %() C'(T

U( % 6'A+'$ /H 79' ViO! 8'$ _/6& ?6/)5:7+/( /H O, V*06 &%/

V6%Z H/6 'L%;?@'Z *7%(@'1 R%5HH;%(( $6/7' 79%7

79' 76%,+: +('A+7%P+@+71 %7 $9+:9 *7'+(P':& %+;') +3 )+;;') P1 79' :6'%&+('33 /H

79' %66%(,';'(73T J' &(/$ $+79 3/;'$9%7 ?@'%3%(7 +6/(+:%@ H/6'&(/$@'),' +( 79'

H+637 3:'('Z $9'( 79' 7$/ H6+'()3 )+3:533 79'+6 ?@%(3 7/ 9%A' % ?@%:' /H 79'+6 /$(Z

79%7 79'1 $+@@ ('A'6 ,'7 +7\ P57 *7'+(P':& '(356'3 79' ,6+; '()+(, $+79 79' ('6A/53

1/5(, 953P%() %7 79' 6%(:9 %() 9+3 %6P+76%6+@1 6'37@'33 $+H'T D'3+)'3Z .'((+'23 H''Y

P@'Y;+()')('33 ;+7+,%7'3 79' 76%,')1T =' +3 % [:%3'/( 79' @//3'Z (/7 % ;%( 353Y

:'?7+P@' 7/ 76/5P@'T UH 9' $'6' /(@1 3@/$Y$+77')Z +(37'%) /H )'H':7+A'Z 79'6' $/5@)

P' 3/;' 9+(7 /H $9%7 9+3 @+H' ;+,97 9%A' P''(T J+79 79' +)+/7 .'((+' 79'6' %6' (/

%@7'6(%7+A'3T bV!hc

D57 O, V*06 &%/ V6%+3 (/7 .'((+'23 76%,')1\ R%5HH;%(( 3'';3 7/ H/6,'779%7 79'6' +3 % :9%6%:7'6 (%;') Q'/6,' C+@7/( +( 79' ?@%1T #()Z 79/5,9

R%5HH;%(( )/'3 (/7 3%1 3/Z O, V*06 &%/ V6% +3 9%6)@1 %( #6+37/7'@+%(

76%,')1T G%79'6Z +7 +3 % 76%,')1 /H 79' ;/)'6( &+()Z /H #67956 C+@@'623

:/;;/( ;%( @+A+(, +( % $/6@) $9'6' ?31:9/@/,1Z 3/:+/@/,1Z 9'6')+71Z

%() '(A+6/(;'(7 9%A' 6'?@%:') 79' %(:+'(7 :/(:'6( $+79 ,/)3Z /6%:@'3Z

?6/?9':1Z %() H%7' %3 79'1 %HH':7 79' @+A'3 /H (/P@' /6 %6+37/:6%7+: :9%6%:Y

7'63T

_'7 $+79 ?31:9/@/,1Z 3/:+/@/,1Z %() P+/@/,1 :/;'3 ;/)'6( /?Y

7+;+3;f/56 3756)1Z 3:+'(7+H+:Z %() 5(]5'(:9%P@' P'@+'H 79%7 %@@ ?6/P@';3

:%( 5@7+;%7'@1 P' H+L')Z 79%7 ;%( :%( :9%(,' %(1 5()'3+6%P@' %3?':7 /H

9+3 :/()+7+/(f%() 35:9 %;'@+/6%7+A' /?7+;+3; 3'';3 7/ P' %7 /))3 $+79

79' ;'7%?913+:%@ ?'33+;+3; /H 76%)+7+/(%@ 76%,')1T M@%33+:%@ 76%,')1Z P'

+7 %(:+'(7 Q6''&Z *9%&'3?'%6'%(Z /6 B6'(:9 8'/:@%33+:%@Z )'?+:73 ;%( %3

%( 5($'@:/;' ,5'37 +( 79' $/6@) %() 7'%:9'3 53 79%7 +7 +3 P'77'6 ('A'6 7/

9%A' P''( P/6(T 8/56+39') P1 % 3%:6') %3 $'@@ %3 9+'6%6:9+:%@ :/3;/@/Y

,1Z 79+3 ?%67+:5@%6 76%,+: H@%;' 5()'637%()%P@1 3?@577'63 %() )+'3 +( 79'


106/316

VWE >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

+(9/3?+7%P@' %+6 /H /56 3':5@%6Z )';/:6%7+: 7+;'3Z $9'6' 76%,')1 +3 ?'6Y

:'+A') %3 79' +)'/@/,+:%@ '(';1 /H ?/@+7+:3 P':%53' +7 ?6/;/7'3 % 3'(3' /H

9/?'@'33('33Z )'H'%7+3;Z %() 6'3+,(%7+/(T

8/('79'@'33Z H%7%@+3; /6 (',%7+A+3; /H 79+3 &+()Z %@P'+7 %79'+37+:Z:@'%6@1 :/(7+(5'3 7/ 'L+37 +( 79' ;/)'6( %() ?/37;/)'6( ?'6+/)3T [C/6'

?@+%(7 )+A/6:' @%$3 :/5@) (/7 %@7'6 79' H%7' /H #,%;';(/(Z $6+7'3

Q'/6,' *7'+('6 +( N46 Q6&.4 +, N5&86/(\ [3/:+%@ ?31:9+%761 +3 (/ %(3$'6

7/O6/*C9)bhcT


107/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' VWO

P6%A'@1Z H'@+:+7/53@1Z 'A'( H'6/:+/53@1Z O, V*06 &%/ V6%7%&'3 Q'/6,'23

@/A+(, 3/@+:+7/53('33 /H .'((+' H/6 ,6%(7') %() +(A+7'3 53 7/ )/ 79' 3%;'T

#() 79'6'+( @+'3 79' 65P /H +73 76%,+: %??'%@T B/6Z %3 G+7% B'@3&+ ;%+(7%+(3

+( 9'6 +(76/)5:7+/( 7/ \6.4*%[*%8 N5&86/(Z [J9%7 6'()'63 79' 76%,+: 3/6'3/(%(7 7/ ;/)'6( 79'/61 +3 +73 ,'3756+(, 7/$%6) $9%7 @+'3 P'1/() 79'

@+;+73 /H 95;%( 5()'637%()+(,Z +73 %P+@+71 7/ ?@%1 j+( 79' $/6)3 /H

I%33+@+3 .%;P6/?/5@/3k %( q'79+:%@ 6/@' $+79/57 %:]5+6+(, % H+L') ;/6%@

A%@5'r jVWkbecT

8/('79'@'33Z 3:9/@%63 %6' /H7'( +(%77'(7+A' 7/ 79' 76%,+: ]5%@+7+'3

+(9'6'(7 +( ;/)'6( )6%;%Z +( ,'('6%@Z %() +( *7'+(P':&23 ?@%1Z +( ?%67+:5Y

@%6T =%661


108/316

VWh >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

#() 79' +)'%@ /H 79' H%6; A%(+39'3 $+79 .'((+'23 )'%79Z $9'( Q'/6,' 7'@@3 M%()1

79' ?@%( +3 /HHT bVgec

J%66'( B6'(:9Z H/6 9+3 ?%67Z (/7 /(@1 )'(+'3 76%,+: 37%753 7/ O,

V*06 &%/ V6%Z P57 9' %:75%@@1 ,/'3 /( 7/ :%@@ 79+3 $/6& % :/;')1X

0'3?+7' 79' ,6+; 'A'(73 +7 :96/(+:@'3Z O, V*06 &%/ V6% +3 (/7 % 76%,')1Z P57 %

:/;')1f$9+:9Z +H +7 $'6' *9%&'3?'%6'%(Z $' $/5@) :%@@ % [)%6& :/;')1 f

%P/57 79' 76+5;?9 /H 79' +()/;+7%P@' $+@@ 7/ 356A+A'T


109/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' VWi

+3 $91 M%()1 +3 +( 79' ?@%1X 9' %() 9+3 )/, %6' A'61 +;?/67%(7 7/ 79'

%:7+/(T '7'6 .+3:% $6+7'3X

.'33 35P7@'Z ?'69%?3 7// /PA+/53Z +3 79' 6'@%7+/(39+? /H M%()1 %() 9+3 )/,Z $9+:9 +3

;%)' ?%6%@@'@ 7/ 79%7 /H Q'/6,' %() .'((+' T T T


110/316

VVW >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

79' 6%(:9 H/6 % @/(, 7+;'Z 9' 3'';3 9/('37@1 (/7 7/ 6'%@+^' 79%7 79' 6'%3/(

9' 9%3 ('A'6 P'H/6' '(7'6') M6//&323 6//; +3 79%7Z %3 79' @%77'6 9+;3'@H

)':@%6'3Z [Q513 )/(27 :/;' +( % :/@/6') ;%(23 6//;bVahcT

.+&' .'((+'Z M%()1 ('')3 3/;'/(' 7/ 65( 9+3 %HH%+63Z 7/ ;%&' 79'6'37 /H 9+3 @+H' '%3+'6 %() ;/6' :/(,'(+%@T =' ('')3 Q'/6,'T *@+; ?6/;Y

+3'3 M%()1 % ?5??1 H6/; 9+3 P+7:9 .5@523 @+77'6 7/ :/;?'(3%7' H/6 79'

39//7+(, /H 9+3 39''? )/,Z P57 M%()1 ('A'6 ,'73 79%7 ?5??1Z %() 9' ('A'6

%3&3 H/6 +7T .'((+' :%( %77';?7 7/ @//& %H7'6 % ?5?Z P':%53' 9' 9%3 Q'/6,'

7/ @//& %H7'6 9+;T M%()1 +3 +( 3'%6:9 /H % 9/;' H/6 4*H)6',\ 9' :%((/7

%HH/6)Z %7 79+3 ?/+(7Z 7/ ,+A' /(' 7/ % )/,T D57 M%()1Z H+(%@@1Z +3 (/7 .'(Y

(+'Z %() Q'/6,' $+@@ (/7 7'%; 5? $+79 9+; %H7'6 .'((+' +3 ,/('T M%()1

)/'3 (/7 %::/;?%(1 79' ;'( +( 79'+6 95(7 H/6 .'((+'Z %H7'6 M56@'123 J+H'

+3 H/5() )'%) +( 79' P%6(T =' 37%13 %@@ %@/(' /( 79' 6%(:9Z )'3'67')Z %3 +7

$'6'Z P1 'A'61/('Z 'A'( %3 9' $+@@ P' P1 Q'/6,' %H7'6 .'((+' 9%3 P''(

39/7T


111/316

C/)'@ N33%13X *71@' %() Q'(6' VVV

9%A' % P'77'6 @+H'Z 1'7 9' 756(3 +7 )/$(T l(]5'37+/(%P@1Z 9' $+@@ 35HH'6

;/6' /( 79' 6/%)Z $+79/57 .'((+'Z 79%( /( 79' H%6;Z $+79/57 .'((+'T ='

('A'6 ,+A'3 9+;3'@H % :9%(:' 7/Z +( 9+3 $/6)3Z [,'7 53') 7/M%()1T


112/316

VVa >@%1 #(%@13+3X # G'%)'6

%3 M%()123 @+(' [>//6 P%37%6)bVEVcZ 3?/&'( 7/ M56@'123 )'%) $+H' @1+(,

+( 79' 9%1Z :/5@) S537 %3 $'@@ P' %??@+') 7/ 9+;3'@H %3 7/ .'((+' /6

M56@'123 J+H'Z [>//6 P%37%6) 79+3 7+;' %??@+'3 7/ Q'/6,'Z $9/; $'

@'%A' %@/('Z $+79 79' )'%) .'((+'Z %7 79' '() /H 7

play analysis cardullo

Documents