PhragmitesPhragmites

from Greek, from Greek, fencing in fencing in 

AgendaAgenda

• Background info Background info

• Some considerationsSome considerations

• Suggested test plotSuggested test plot

• DiscussionDiscussion

PhragmitesPhragmites

• The plant can tolerate standing water, low The plant can tolerate standing water, low oxygen levels and acidic sediments, which allow oxygen levels and acidic sediments, which allow it to thrive in disturbed habitats often unsuitable it to thrive in disturbed habitats often unsuitable for other plants (Marks et al. 1994; Bart and for other plants (Marks et al. 1994; Bart and Hartman 2000). http://www.mdsg.umd.edu/Hartman 2000). http://www.mdsg.umd.edu/

• At the scale of the entire Rhode River subestuary, P. australis coverage expanded from 7,294 m2 in 1971–72 to 183,369 m2 in 2007

Whigham et al, et al, Wetlands (2010) 30:67–74

Phragmites con’t.Phragmites con’t.

• Phragmites is often encouraged by, and a symptom of, underlying problems, such as siltation, nutrient loading, and hydrological alteration. Erik Kiviat

• The most common means of spread is The most common means of spread is from fragments of rhizomes that are from fragments of rhizomes that are carried on road maintenance equipment. carried on road maintenance equipment. http://www.invadingspecies.comhttp://www.invadingspecies.com

ProsPros

• Native species existNative species exist– Less aggressiveLess aggressive– Rare on Western shoreRare on Western shore– Can detect after sprayingCan detect after spraying

• GreenGreen– Some value in cover/erosionSome value in cover/erosion– Used by some animal speciesUsed by some animal species

ConsCons

• MonocultureMonoculture

• Less diverse habitatLess diverse habitat

• InvasiveInvasive

• Literally unsightlyLiterally unsightly

• Every area started as a patchEvery area started as a patch

• Prevents recovery, even as conditions Prevents recovery, even as conditions improveimprove

• Climate changeClimate change

• Event- fire, spill on 97 or 50Event- fire, spill on 97 or 50

Encourage byEncourage by

• Soil disturbanceSoil disturbance– DirectDirect– Indirect via storm water runoffIndirect via storm water runoff

• Nutrients in waterNutrients in water

Doing itDoing it

• Variety of approachesVariety of approaches

• ReportsReports

• SuggestionsSuggestions

EquipmentEquipment

• Large tank sprayersLarge tank sprayers– Plants up to 12 foot heightPlants up to 12 foot height– Road access. Possibly boat.Road access. Possibly boat.

• Backpack sprayersBackpack sprayers

• PlanesPlanes– Aerial control is restrictedAerial control is restricted

SprayingSpraying

• Still need to mow or cut or burnStill need to mow or cut or burn

• Must return the following yearMust return the following year

Bind, Cut and PaintBind, Cut and Paint

• Twine, shears, brushTwine, shears, brush

• GlovesGloves

• Body suit?Body suit?

www.ipaw.org/.../www.ipaw.org/.../phragmitesphragmites/...//.../PhragmitesPhragmites_workshop_meetin_workshop_meeting_minutes.doc g_minutes.doc • Bundle, cut and chemically treat – Ryan Magana, DNRBundle, cut and chemically treat – Ryan Magana, DNR• (handout)(handout)• Easy to do, cheap labor force, apply chemical to cut surface,Easy to do, cheap labor force, apply chemical to cut surface,• Tried Rodeo first but had to return for multi treatment then moved to Tried Rodeo first but had to return for multi treatment then moved to

Habitat which works better with impressive resultsHabitat which works better with impressive results• Track what you treat due to bundles marking where treatedTrack what you treat due to bundles marking where treated• Tops let lay, cut in August before seeds.Tops let lay, cut in August before seeds.• Does not work for large areas, largest area is size of room (6 people, with Does not work for large areas, largest area is size of room (6 people, with

thick areas, 4 hours) can pre bundle and leave for days for cutting and thick areas, 4 hours) can pre bundle and leave for days for cutting and herbicide laterherbicide later

• As long as you can see green when you cut the herbicide will be effective, As long as you can see green when you cut the herbicide will be effective, light frost is not a bad thing, above 28 degrees, denser the stand the better light frost is not a bad thing, above 28 degrees, denser the stand the better since roots are connected, seed viability is a concernsince roots are connected, seed viability is a concern

• Regrowth of native species – depends on “mulch” and density of phramitiesRegrowth of native species – depends on “mulch” and density of phramities• Shade provided aphides promoted wasps which can be an issue with Shade provided aphides promoted wasps which can be an issue with

humanshumans• Add dye to the bottle to make where you have been, use an herbicide dye Add dye to the bottle to make where you have been, use an herbicide dye

not a food dye, use a water soluble dye for habitat or rodeo, tablets work not a food dye, use a water soluble dye for habitat or rodeo, tablets work well for land owners but for large scale work use the liquid highlight bluewell for land owners but for large scale work use the liquid highlight blue

U. Of Wisconsin/ DNRU. Of Wisconsin/ DNR

• What is the optimal timing for cut stem treatment of phragmites? – late summer to early September (we focused our treatment work after Labor Day). For the bundle and cut method, the phragmites need to be tall enough to be bundled by volunteers at a comfortable height – usually around waist height. Other types of spraying can be done in June prior to it the phragmites growing taller.

• • What is the average rate you paid per hour for spot treatment by a contractor? We utilized around 30 hours of spot treatment by contractors, and depending on contractor (and travel costs) the average costs was $40 per hour.

– MDA quoted $150/hr for 2 people and truck, no herbicide.

• • How short do you cut the bundles using the bundle/cut method? We use a comfortable height for the person bundling and cutting or usually around waist high. The tops are laid down on the grown. We are not concerned about removing the seeds from the area.

Rodeo, Habitat, Clear castRodeo, Habitat, Clear cast

• Ridges Sanctuary - Work on the Native phragmites was started due to increase in spread of native variety since 1960’s. Observations show that native phragmites is spreading and affecting endangered species. Work also focused on controlling the non-native variety as it spread. Majority of the treatment was done by the cut and bundle treatment. The bundling was done by volunteers and herbicide applied by DNR crews. Used all three types of herbicide, Rodeo and Habitat but currently using Clear cast. Clear cast is a new herbicide being developed for aquatic work. First year treatment bundled 2000 stems, following year 30 stems were needed to be treated. Large number of volunteers were needed to bundle the stems. Follow up treatment is required after first major treatment. If not retreated can re-infest the area and spread rapidly. Herbicide damage seen the second year to native vegetation but can rebound with lack of Phragmites.

• Issue: Aphids were thick on the canes and volunteers’ hands turned green. Wasps were attracted to the aphids and stinging caused an allergic reaction in a volunteer.

• Moonlight Bay - Shoreline habitat work due to spread of phragmites in exposed lake bed. Seeds washed in along shoreline increasing the spread of phragmites. Used backpack sprayers to treat 1st and 2nd year clones which is more manageable than cut and bundle. 3rd year the clone will be thicker and more difficult to treat.

• North Bay

Clear Cast- from Univ. of Clear Cast- from Univ. of Wisconsin Workshop 2008 Wisconsin Workshop 2008 • Aquatic invasive Herbicide concentrations: 32 oz per acre – mentioned in

early presentation • 48 and 64 oz per acre historically control treatment • Need to factor in northern climate, residual effect, longer native rebound

time • Clear Cast – new herbicide in development, well suited for aquatic use,

hoping to hear in spring 2008. Wisconsin has assisted with testing sites. Activity on submerged weeds and surface weeds. Less broad spectrum and shorter soil half life. Can go over top of hardwoods with little effect. Use rates 32 – 64 oz, Hope to have product available by fall to customers.

• Herbicide is affected by weather, habitat, temperature, species types, species age, density,

• Surfactants – never skimp on them, MSO is recommended. • Hardwater – habitat is not affected by hardwater, glysophas does have

issues with hard water, talk with agricultural agent. • Cost of clear cast - $175 per gallon with use rates at 2 quart per acre. • Note – price movement on glysophas prices increasing

Suggested guidelinesSuggested guidelines

• AccessibilityAccessibility• Small patches, get it early in the Small patches, get it early in the

processprocess• Healthy surrounding habitatHealthy surrounding habitat

– ReplacementReplacement– Less likely to reoccurLess likely to reoccur– Edges of large patches? Edges of large patches?

• In conjunction with SW restorationIn conjunction with SW restoration

Discussion:Discussion:

• Consolidate info to add to web site. Consolidate info to add to web site. – Enable communities to access info, Enable communities to access info,

resources, permits, etc.resources, permits, etc.

• Determine the number and size of Determine the number and size of direct activities to remove phragmitesdirect activities to remove phragmites– Number of SW restorationsNumber of SW restorations– Other considerations (patch size, stage, ?)Other considerations (patch size, stage, ?)

• Encourage communities/scouts to Encourage communities/scouts to controlcontrol

A few links:A few links:

• Phragmites - Wikipedia, the free Phragmites - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia encyclopedia

• Invasive Species In The Chesapeake Invasive Species In The Chesapeake Bay Watershed Workshop - Bay Watershed Workshop - Phragmites Phragmites

• issg Database: Ecology of Phragmites issg Database: Ecology of Phragmites australis australis