ph 3: 21 - us epa › ... › menzelenterprisesiowainc.pdfmenzel enterpnses. iowa inc 605 s i 8th...

4
(),C o.... ,,cJ (_,;2.,-) Enclos ure UM) ED STATE S '! NVlhOHHENTAL PROTE CTIOH AGENC Y -RE GION 7 CLEAN A[R ACT VE HI CLE AND ENGlNf. 2019 OCT 31 EXPE DITE D SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT PH 3: 21 l>OC. KF. T NO. CAA-07- 2019-11207 Respondent. Menzel Enterpnses. Iowa Inc 605 S I 8 th 5trcet. Suite C West Des vfomc<, Iowa 50 26, The part1c-.. enter into th, .., Clean Atr Act Vehicle and Lngrne Expedited ~cttlement Agret:mcnt ( Aμ.1t:e111 enu 111 order tr, .:;cttlc the c1vrl, 1olat1on( s) discO\ ercd as a result of the inspectton(s) specified m I ahlc I attached. IIH.orporatcd mto tl11 s Al!reement b, rctercnce. I he c1v1I v1olat1on{ s) that are the subJect of tlw, .\g1 ce rn e nt drl dc .-, cnhccl rn l ahle 2. attached. rncorporatcd mto the .\grcement h~ reference. regarding th e Vl.:h1Llev, ) 1 eng111c( s) "PCl-lfied therem Kc-;pnndent ,1dm11 s to hctng °'llhJcct lo the Clean Air Act (( AA) and its as~ociated regulation.., dlld th at thl· I 1111cJ ',tatc, rm 1rn11111cntal Protection Agcnl-, (rPA) ha'i J1m<;d1ct10n over the Respondent and the Re~pondcnt .., conduu Jcscrrbcd 111 I able 2 Respondent neither adnuts nor denies the lmdmg,;; detailed therein. and wn1ves am oh1ect1ons Re-;pondcnt may have to the 1:- .PA ·., Jumdtction Rc!\pondent ccn1he.., that payment of the pcnalt) has been made 111 the amount of S I 1,800 and Re -, pomlcnt hii tnllowed the 111,;trucllon., 111 '"CAA Vehicle and f.ngme l:.xped1ted Settlement Agreement lnstntd101h . attached. tnLOrporated mto tht !-. Agreement b) reference Respondent certifies that the req111red remullatHtn , pec,tied 111 1 ahlc 1 and mcorporated mto thic; Agreement h) reference. has been carried 0u t R\. 1t:-. t1rc,t ~ 1gnaturc.: helcw.. the FPA approves the findings rc,;ultmg trom the mspectton( , } and alleged \ 1ola11on(s) ,ct forth 111 Table I and ·1 able: Respondent acknowledge, that this Agreement ,., hmdmg llfl thL par11e., '>l!!fllng helo\\ and become-; effective on the date of the FPA Delegated Official"s rat,tymg -., gnatu rc 5 The panie~ com,cnt 11, .. crvtcc ofth1c, Abrrecment b) electronic delivery at the Respondent·, e-matl noted helm, APPROVED BY EPA : \._J_ a u 1 l .e __ De Am.ire ~mgletal). Act mg I (;rector Date . T 11fon .. tm1c..:nt ,md Complra 11cc A,' mrance D1v1~ton. EPA Regmn 7 APPROV ED B\' RESPONDENT· \J ame J lt ,~iJ_~q_ _ f 1tk Co- v,v~ E ,4, la t Kc,.;.slr, (2 Ct x. ~j _ l'(J1"\ _ /_& - ;;; S-- I 1 RA Tl Fl ED B\' E ..\: Datt: ------- ---- D . ·. Ac tm g Director FnforL cmcnt and Cnmpliance As'iurance D, v1s10n . EPA Region -

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jan-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • (),C

    o....,,cJ (_,;2.,-)

    Enclosure

    UM) ED STATES '!NVlhOHHENTAL PROTECTIOH

    AGENCY-REGION 7

    CLEAN A[R ACT VEHICLE AND ENGlNf.2019 OCT 31 EXPEDITED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT

    PH 3: 21

    l>OC. KF.T NO . CAA-07-2019-11207 Respondent. Menzel Enterpnses. Iowa Inc 605 S I 8th 5trcet. Suite C West Des vfomc

  • Table 1 - Information Collection ---------------------- -~ -- --Jlnte(sJ Information Collected:

    5/16 20 IQ § 208 I nformatiun Request

    Respondent Location:

    Docket Number:

    --- -. - -,-------.,.. ~ ,- - -- r

    !-~'----'--' ----"----'-I __ .._I ___....i _._al_!....._~I -605 $ I Kth St.. Suite C City: lnspectorCs) Name(s): -------·-·--·--------------\Ve.st Des l\·loines I

    I

    State: Zip Code: EPA Appro\'ing Official: 1 -I!\ 1

    1

    502115 \ l DcAndre Singletary Actmg Division Director

    ~-_____________ __,I Enforcement and Compliance Assumnce Division

    Kespondent: EPA Enforcement Contact(s): I

    Lisa Hanlon. Air Branch Menzel Enterprises Ned Lewis Tim Menzel

    Enforcement and Compliance Division '

    Table 2 - Description of Violations and Vehic_les/Entrlnes EPA oht11ined evidence that Mcn7.el Enterprises. Iowa. Inc. (Respondent) tampered with the vchicle(s)/engineis) listec1 hclow. EPA obtained evidence that Respondent installed. defeal devices. producls listed below wh,ch render mopcrauve crn1ssin11 control .systems on EPA-certified motor vehicles and/or. EPA received a tip through an m1nnymou~ comrlamt that vehicle tampering and installation of defeat devices had occurred. EPA obtained a copy of a workers· compensa11on claim III which Menzel continned the allegations. EPA then issued an infonnation request letter pursuant 10 CAJ\ ~20R. Menze l's response con finned that it removed emissions control devices from six vehicles. II is a violation of Section 203(a >(J )I Al of the CA.'\. 42 U.S.C. § 752'.!(a)IJ )( t\) to tamper with EPA-certified vehicles and engines. It 1~ a v1nlat1011 of Section .!0J(a't(J)(B) of the CAA. 42 U.S.C. § 7522(a)(3XD) to sell. offer for sale. or install a defeat device mtendeJ for usl' with EPA-certified motor vehicles and engines. Based mi mfonnation summarized below. EPA finds that Rcsponde111 has committed 5 violations of Section 203(a)(3) of the CAA. 42 U.S.C. & 7522(a)(3).

    Tampered·Motor Vebicle/En1 jn~ Violanon(s,

    Model I•ivoiee/ Ta~per~',1 Emi.uion Tampering Date(J) Make M-0del/VIN License1 Year ·Plate Parts o~-Com.pon~nts

    Novcmhcr 20 ..,018 NA NA NA Inv. #000808 Ahsnlute Perfomiancc 20 I:--20 Io EGR Delete Kit

    .lamo Race Pipe Kit. Ab~olute

    IFD8WJB I\. Perfomiance EG R K 1t.

    Novcmhcr 15. 2018 NA NA FED70440

    Inv. #000820 J\hsnlutc l'erfnnnance 6.7 CCV. SCT x4 Programmer

    WiCustnm Tune Absolute Perfomiancc EGR

    F350 Kit, ,\bsolutc Pcrlimn:.111cc 6.i IJcccmbcr (, :.!0 18 201:i Ford IFD8W3R r?J lnv.#1002 CCV. SCT X4 Programmer W.

    ED70441 Sing.le Custom Tune. MHRP Race Pipe

    Janw Race Pipe Kit. \hsoh11t·

    Nov1;mbl·r '21 2018 IFD8W3BT9f l'erfumtancc EG R Kn.

    NA NA Inv.#9215 Absolute l'crfonnancc: (1.7 [D70445 CCV. SCT X4 Programmer W

    Custom Tune

    !-3.50 Absolute Performance EGR

    Kit. 1\usolult: Perfor111anu: h.7 I >ccembcr 12 2018 2015 h,rd luD8W313"15 Inv. #1003 cr v. SC'T X4 Programmer\\

    f[D7044, Smgle Tune, SBRP Race Pipe

    2

  • I Penally i Required Remedia1in11

    L

    Table 3 - Penalty and Required Remediation '

    SI 1.800 '

    In addition to paying the monetary penalty. Respondent must cease and refrain from I purchasing. offering for sale. selling, or installing any device that defeats. bypasses. or otherwise renders inoperative an emission component of any motor vehicle or cngme regulated by the EPA. Respondent must cease and refrain from rampering wi1h emission control S)Stcms on EPA-certified motor vehicles and engines. Respondent acknowledges receipt of the Compliance Plan attached as Appendix A.

  • Ggar,tad; Oct 18, 201911'43:39 AM

    Transaction oatan tor: 2§KP31CF Bu1io1u lofonnatJ.90 Source Bualneu Transaction ID Buelneaa Tnanaac~on Group ID Reporting Program/Subprogram

    Procealng Program/Subprogram

    ALC

    SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

    Collections Information Repository (CIR) Financial Transaction Detail Report

    1101.:i,20 OOA585

    26KP31CF

    Pay.gov:Hosted Form (web)

    68010727

    002585 215

    Bual11t1n Date

    BIil Data Initiation Date

    Chann.el Receipt D•!• Voucher Data Depoa1tD1te CahflowlD

    10/18/2019

    10/10/2019

    10/10/2019

    · 10/10/2019

    10/18/2019

    10/1812019

    6801072701 Voucher Number

    Voucher Type

    CAN 000367 Cnh Flow Name EPA Miscellaneous Payments

    Agency Account ~ Initial Location

    Office Loc:atlon Code

    Ag.ncy Transaction ID

    f lnanctal Jrao1,c;t1_on _O,,lll! Source Financial Tnanucuon ID

    Source Settlement Tranuctlon ID

    Transaction Type

    Transaction Statu■

    Payment Medium Type

    Tranaactlon Type Code

    Agent Trace ID

    lnetallment Number

    Total Installment Count

    1355

    01

    75859375583

    26KP31CF

    6NJBMM6MKR 1

    Collection

    .Settled

    Debit

    27

    Payerpetans Party Name PayerRTN

    Payer Type

    "ddreaa Line 1 City

    Menzel Enterprises Iowa, Inc.

    275979034

    Business

    I

    Pr_~~l!19 Sita ID RTN Reporter ldentlfl•~ Non Treaury Col!9ctlon Code

    -'Amount

    Credit Ind

    Settlement MKhanlsm

    ~•~lpt M~~hanlem __ Flnanclal Transaction Code Channel Bitch ID -Recurrl'!V lndl~~r

    ,R~urrl~-~ Frequency

    P•~ Identifier Account Number

    Bank Account Type

    AddrMSLlne2

    State

    4200

    C

    042000437

    Public

    y

    ACH

    ACH

    CCD

    N

    Postal Code Email Addrtl■ [email protected]

    ?ayae oatan, ~arty Name EPACFC

    ,ddress Une 1 ::tty >oatal Code

    tbec;k/ACH Data_lll :heck Type

    :heck Number tesearchlnd

    Procees Method Code

    ':'•rty_ (clentlfle! Addreallne2 State

    Settlement Status Code · 413

    teported CtaglficatJon{s) C, rl _ f\: C A A-:-- 0 , ... J . 0 I '3_ -. __ c,;). b r Ckey Name Ckey Value

    Pay.gov ALC+2 6801072701

    f\ p p_ R_, I O Cf 'f -r, ' '8 () f'-\ : Pi C)

    TAS Tu: SP ATA Agency

    Class ID BPOA EPOA

    apartment of the Treasury

    ,ni report contains Paraonally ldantlflable Information.

    l

    A M-r Jf I I) ·i O O • o C)

    Avail Type

    SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

    ACH Cate~o_ry !YP• Debit NOC Update Result

    Main Sub BETC Crd Ind y

    $11,800.00

    Clasalflcatlon Tolll Amount

    $11,800.00

    t< ~Al 10 /J 9 / 11