period luminosity relations for rr lyrae stars horace smith (michigan state university) marcio...

14
PERIOD LUMINOSITY PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS LYRAE STARS Horace Smith Horace Smith (Michigan State University) (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) de Chile) Barton Pritzl Barton Pritzl (Macalester College) (Macalester College)

Post on 22-Dec-2015

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

PERIOD LUMINOSITY PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE

STARSSTARSHorace SmithHorace Smith

(Michigan State University)(Michigan State University)Marcio CatelanMarcio Catelan

(Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile)(Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile)Barton PritzlBarton Pritzl

(Macalester College)(Macalester College)

Page 2: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

RR Lyrae starsRR Lyrae stars

Traditional population II distance Traditional population II distance indicatorsindicators

They are on the “horizontal branch” They are on the “horizontal branch” so all RR Lyrae should have the same so all RR Lyrae should have the same absolute magnitude, shouldn’t they?absolute magnitude, shouldn’t they?

Page 3: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

RR Lyrae luminositiesRR Lyrae luminosities

What do theoretical period-luminosity What do theoretical period-luminosity relations look like for RR Lyrae stars? relations look like for RR Lyrae stars?

How do the relations depend upon How do the relations depend upon the filter used?the filter used?

How do the theoretical relations How do the theoretical relations compare with observed period-compare with observed period-luminosity relations?luminosity relations?

Page 4: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton
Page 5: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

Why the difference?

• Period increases with increasing luminosity or decreasing temperature

• At B, the effects of the HB slope in Teff and L are nearly orthogonal

• At I, the effects of the HB slope in Teff and L are in the same sense

Page 6: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

Results in more filters

Page 7: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

How do the P-L relations depend How do the P-L relations depend upon HB morphology?upon HB morphology?

Use the parameter Use the parameter L L to characterizeto characterize

HB morphologyHB morphology

L L = (B – R)/(B + V + R)= (B – R)/(B + V + R)

Page 8: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

HB morphology and the B band

Page 9: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

V band

Page 10: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

I band

Page 11: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

K band

Page 12: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

Comparison with observations (I band)

Page 13: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

Two more clustersTwo more clusters

Page 14: PERIOD LUMINOSITY RELATIONS FOR RR LYRAE STARS Horace Smith (Michigan State University) Marcio Catelan (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile) Barton

Still to doStill to do

• Quantitative comparison of observed P-L relations with theory

• Extension to systems beyond our own Galaxy