performance measures in economic development
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
1/25
V|eeoea Blm`; ^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vls oe Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep
Slme H% Hma|ovl
Pbl Vgcdljliilv Cgiilal gj ^|fioc Mjjmovs * ^giocy) \eozlvsopy mp Mifmey
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
2/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Mfspvmcp
Pbos ~m~lv lrmhoels pbl |sl gj ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls ge lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep oe spmpl
me` igcmi agzlvehleps qopboe pbl \eopl` Spmpls% Jgv pbl ~|v~gsl gj jvmhoea pbl `osc|ssoge) m
fvolj vlzolq gj pbl bospgvy gj me` |sl gj alelvmi ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls oe agzlvehlep os
~vgzo`l`) jgc|soea ge pbl lmviy qgvd fy C%L% Vo`ily jgv pbl Oeplvempogemi Copy Hmemalvs
Mssgcompoge oe =?03%
Elrp) pbos ~m~lv qoii `osc|ss bgq me` qblvl ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls mvl |sl` oe lcgeghoc
`lzlig~hlep% Pbos qoii ~vlslep sghl gj pbl cbmiileals pbmp lrosp oe m~~iyoea ~lvjgvhmecl
hlms|vls oe pbl joli` gj lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep% Qboil pbl py~l gj oejgvhmpoge ell`l` pg
lzmi|mpl ~vgavmh ~lvjgvhmecl cme fl mavll` |~ge) mcvgss pbl joli` gj lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep
pblvl os m imcd gj cgesles|s ge pbl py~l gj `mpm pbmp sbg|i` fl |poio{l` oe `lzlig~oea g|pcghls%
Alelvmiiy) pblvl mvl ojjlvlep py~ls gj hlms|vls |sl` oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep; g|p~|ps me`
g|pcghls% Sg|vcls `ojjlvlepompl flpqlle pbl pqg qopb g|p~|ps `ljoel` ms qbmp qms `gel "o%l%
hgely s~lep) bg|vs qgvdl`) cmiis vlclozl`/ me` g|pcghls `ljoel` ms qbmp qms pbl cgesl}|lecl
"o%l% kgfs cvlmpl`) oezlsphlep hm`l/% G|p~|ps mvl flsp |sl` pg hlms|vl ljjocolecy zlvs|s oe~|ps
`l`ocmpl` pg pbl mcpozopy "l%a% kgfs cvlmpl` jgv lmcb `giimv lr~le`l`/% G|pcghls cme fl m
cbmiileal pg cgiilcp me` mcc|vmcy vl}|ovls m soaeojocmep ilzli gj `|l `oioalecl) f|p py~ocmiiy
~vgzo`l pbl flsp hlms|vl gj bgq qlii m ~vgavmh os mcbolzoea ops agmis "l%a% pbl vgil me lcgeghoc
`lzlig~hlep ~vgavmh ~imy oe `lcosoges pg igcmpl gv lr~me` m f|soelss/%
Joemiiy) pbos ~m~lv qoii vlzolq mpplh~ps fy Elq _gvd Spmpl oe lzmi|mpoea pqg gj ops
~vohmvy lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs mzmoimfil pg igcmi agzlvehleps; Lh~ovl [gels me`
Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
3/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vls oe Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep
Oepvg`|cpoge gj ^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vlhlep
M clep|vy mag) agzlvehlep qms cgeso`lvl` cghhle`mfil oj op qms bgelsp qopb pbl
~lg~il "Vo`ily) =?03) ~%=/% Bgqlzlv) hgvl pbme 1> ylmvs mag) pbl Oeplvempogemi Copy Hmemalvs
Mssgcompoge o`lepojol` m lhme` pbmp agzlvehlep flcghl hgvl mccg|epmfil% Mccg|epmfoiopy os m
j|soge gj fgpb pbl bgelspy `lhme`s gj m clep|vy mag me` pbl ljjocolecy `lhme`s gj m oe`|spvomi
me` ~gsp(oe`|spvomi sgcolpy% Op qms pbl ~gsp(oe`|spvomi sgcolpy pbmp qms qlii mcc|spghl` pg m
~vozmpl slcpgv jgc|sl` ge agg` ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vl` fy ~vgjops% Pbos lr~lvolecl qms pvmesimpl`
oepg pbl ~|fioc slcpgv mp pbl p|ve gj pbl clep|vy qopb pbl lspmfiosbhlep gj pbl OCHM me` jgc|sl`
mpplepoge ge ~lvjgvhmecl% Agzlvehlep) oe cgepvmsp pg pbl ~vozmpl slcpgv) `gls egp lzmi|mpl gv
hlms|vl ~lvjgvhmecl fy ~vgjops gv avgqpb% Ops ~lvjgvhmecl os py~ocmiiy lzmi|mpl` ge bgq
ljjocolep lsslepomi slvzocls mvl ~vgzo`l`% Flcm|sl gj pbos) ~|fioc slcpgv ~vgjlssogemis qlvl jmcl`
qopb o`lepojyoea m~~vg~vompl hlpvocs jgv bgq qlii h|eoco~mi slvzocls mvl floea ~vgzo`l`%
Pbl ell` jgv me` oh~gvpmecl gj igcmi agzlvehlep ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep os }|opl
lzo`lep fy pbl fg`y gj oejgvhmpoge pbmp lrosps alelvmiiy ge pbl s|fklcp% M v|`ohlepmvy slmvcb ge
pbl s|fklcp qoii vlp|ve pbl |slv qopb mey e|hflv gj vlsg|vcls jvgh mcm`lhoc pg ~vgjlssogemi me`
jvgh ~|fioc g~oeoge pg ~|fioc ~giocy% Mp pbl ~vlslep pohl) agzlvehleps mvl jmcoea iohopl` joscmi
vlsg|vcls mcvgss jl`lvmi) spmpl me` igcmi agzlvehleps% \eiodl pbl jl`lvmi agzlvehlep qbocb cme
cmvvy f|`alp `ljocops) hmey gpblv ilzlis gj h|eoco~mi agzlvehlep cmeegp gv cgespop|leps qoii egp
pgilvmpl op% Oe hmdoea `ojjoc|ip `lcosoges) gjjocomis mvl oecvlmsoeaiy iggdoea pg ~lvjgvhmecl
hlms|vlhlep pg lzmi|mpl slvzocls me` ~vgavmhs% Fy |soea ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep) gjjocomis
cme hmdl m vla|imv hlms|vlhlep gj pbl vls|ips "g|pcghls/ me` ljjocolecy gj slvzocls gv
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
4/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
~vgavmhs "Bmpvy) 6>>:/% @goea sg miigqs gjjocomis pg hmdl vlcghhle`mpoges me` `lcosoges
fmsl` ge gfklcpozl `mpm cgiilcpl` ge ~vgavmhs%
F|oi`oea ge Bmpvys mss|h~poge) C{gbmvm me` Hlidlv gjjlv pblov gqe mss|h~poge ge bgq
pbmp oejgvhmpoge qoii fl |sl`% Pbl oe`ocmpl pbmp pbl vmpogemil flboe` pbl m`g~poge gj
~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls os pbmp flpplv hmemalhlep) ~vgavmh me` f|`alpoea `lcosoges qoii fl
hm`l "6>>0) ~% :/% Gj cg|vsl) pbos mss|hls pbmp m`l}|mpl spl~s mvl pmdle pg m~~vg~vompliy
lzmi|mpl ~vgavmhs me` ~giocols% Pbgsl vls|ips) gv g|pcghls me` g|p~|ps) mvl |sl` fy ~|fioc
gjjocomis pg hmdl `lcosoges ge qblvl ~gplepomi g~~gvp|eopols lrosp pg oh~vgzl ljjocolecols me`
slvzocl `liozlvy% Pblsl ljjocolecols gjple bmzl m agmi gj vl`|coea pbl cgsp pg |slvs gv oh~vgzoea
gzlvmii slvzocl `liozlvy pg pbl le` |slv gv cges|hlv% Me lrmh~il gj pbos cg|i` fl pbl e|hflv gj
kgfs cvlmpl` fy me lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmh% Pbl lzmi|mpgv hmy cgeso`lv gpblv oe~|ps pg
`lzlig~ m ~lv kgf cvlmpl` hlms|vlhlep) s|cb ms spmjj bg|vs ~lv kgf cvlmpl` gv h|eoco~mi
cgsp ~lv kgf cvlmpl`%
Agzlvehleps py~ocmiiy cgiilcp m avlmp lmi gj oejgvhmpoge ge ~vgavmhs% Op os cgvvlcp pg
fliolzl pbmp pbos oejgvhmpoge os egp elclssmvoiy cgiilcpl` jgv pbl ~|v~gsls gj ~lvjgvhmecl
hlms|vlhlep% Oe jmcp) hlpbg`s pg les|vl bgelsp oe pbl m`hoeospvmpoge gj agzlvehlep me`
`liozlvy gj slvzocls bmzl igea flle `lzosl` me` mvl sohoimv pg plcbeo}|ls |sl` oe ~lvjgvhmecl
hlms|vlhlep% Plcbeo}|ls s|cb ms m|`ops) ilami cblcds me` fmimecls) me` pbl `lclepvmio{mpoge gj
m|pbgvopy bmzl flle |sl` pg les|vl pbl ~|fioc pbmp agzlvehlep os bgelsp oe bgq op g~lvmpls me`
`liozlvs slvzocls% Bgqlzlv) pblsl plcbeo}|ls migel `g egp m``vlss bgq ljjocolep me` ljjlcp
agzlvehlep os oe pbl `liozlvy gj elclssmvy ~|fioc slvzocls "Vo`ily) =?03/% Alelvmiiy) pvm`opogemi
m|`ops hmy |ecgzlv z|ielvmfoiopols pg ljjocolecy f|p `g egp vlzlmi ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls |eilss
me m|`op qms s~lcojocmiiy pmvalpl` pg `g sg oe ops scg~l%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
5/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Bospgvy gj ^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vlhlep
Mcm`lhocs me` ~vgjlssogemis miodl py~ocmiiy mavll pbmp pbl ime`hmvd hgegavm~b ge
h|eoco~mi ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls qms oss|l` fy pbl Oeplvempogemi Copy Hmemalvs Mssgcompoge
"OCHM/ me` m|pbgvl` oe =?32) lepopil` Hlms|voea H|eoco~mi Mcpozopols% Oe pbl slcge`
m``opoge) pbl m|pbgv mcdegqil`als pbl zmio`opy gj pbl jovsp l`opoge egpoea pbmp oe pbl ioplvmp|vl pbmp
bm` m~~lmvl` soecl =?32) pblvl bmzl flle eg `lzlig~hleps pbmp qg|i` elclssopmpl m ell` jgv me
s|fspmepozl cbmeals pg pbl `gc|hlep% Vmpblv) pbl slcge` m``opoge qms hlvliy me |~`mpl qopb pbl
oeci|soge gj elq `lzlig~hleps soecl =?32%
Soecl pbl slcge` m``opoge os soh~iy me lr~mesoge) op os spoii oh~gvpmep pg egpl pbmp Vo`ily
cgepoe|l` pg ohhl`ompliy mcdegqil`al pbl cbmiileal oe hlms|voea pbl mcpozopols gj g|v
agzlvehleps% Bl spmpls pbmp agzlvehlepmi mcpozopols cmeegp fl hlms|vls oe plvhs gj soh~il
|eops gv oe`ocls qbocb m|pghmpocmiiy lzmi|mpl vls|ips "=?03) ~% ooo/ oe pbl jgvqmv` pg pbl jovsp
l`opoge% Jgv lrmh~il) agzlvehleps cmeegp soh~iy v|e m smils vl~gvp pg `lplvhoel bgq qlii op os
~lvjgvhoea) ms sghl oe pbl ~vozmpl slcpgv cme `g% Pbos spmplhlep os ~mvp gj pbl jg|e`mpoge pbmp pbl
joli` gj ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep bms lspmfiosbl` opslij ge% Egpoea jvgh pbl ~vlzog|s ~mal) pbl
spmplhleps jvgh Bmpvy) C{gbmvm me` Hlidlv mvl oe ioel qopb Vo`ilys ~gsopoge% Vo`ilys
ime`hmvd qgvd cgepoe|ls pg fl m sg|vcl gj oejgvhmpoge hgvl pbme 1> ylmvs implv%
H|eoco~mi agzlvehleps cme cgiilcp hmey `ojjlvlep py~ls gj `mpm pbvg|ab ~vgclssls s|cb
ms m|`ops ms ~vlzog|siy egpl` me` oe ops `my(pg(`my mcpozopols% Jgv lrmh~il) m f|`alp `l~mvphlep
hmy pvmcd oecghl me` lr~lesls4 m sgcomi slvzocl `l~mvphlep hmy pvmcd cioleps hgzoea oe me` g|p
gj ops cmvl4 gv m jovl `l~mvphlep hmy pvmcd bgq hmey cmiis op bms vls~ge`l` pg% Pbos oejgvhmpoge
cme fl |sl` oe m~~vmosoea h|eoco~mi agzlvehlep "Vo`ily) =?03) ~%=/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
6/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Vo`ily) oe jgc|soea oe ge `mpm |slj|i jgv ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep) egpls pbmp gel gj pbl
gi`lsp me` mp pbl pohl) pbl cghhge hlms|vl) qms m h|eoco~miopys pmr vmpl% Bl egpls) bgqlzlv)
pbmp pblvl mvl pqg soaeojocmep cbmiileals pg |soea s|cb oejgvhmpoge pg hlms|vl pbl ~lvjgvhmecl gj
h|eoco~mi agzlvehlep% Pbl jovsp os pbmp op qms) me` pg`my spoii os) cghhge ~vmcpocl pg msslss
~vg~lvpy mp ilss pbme ops j|ii gv hmvdlp zmi|l% Msslssl` ~vg~lvpy zmi|ls `g egp vljilcp c|vvlep
hmvdlp cge`opoges me` `g egp vls~ge` pg pboeas s|cb ms slmsgemi ji|cp|mpoges% Vo`ily cgepoe|ls
fy mcdegqil`aoea pbmp oe gv`lv pg |e`lvspme` pbos ms m hlms|vl me` pbl soaeojocmecl gj pbl pmr
vmpl) ql qg|i` bmzl pg degq pbl fmsos gj msslsshlep "=?03) ~%6/%
Pbl slcge` cbmiileal Vo`ily ~vlsleps os pbmp h|eoco~mi oecghl cghls jvgh sg|vcls
gpblv pbme pbl ~vg~lvpy pmr "=?03) ~% 6/% Jgv lrmh~il) h|eoco~miopols py~ocmiiy vlclozl gpblv
oecghl jvgh spmpl me` jl`lvmi mo`% H|eoco~miopols hmy misg vlclozl vlzle|l jvgh joels) smil gj
msslps me` oeplvlsp lmvel` ge sbgvp plvh oezlsphleps qble m ~|fioc fg`y bms leg|ab io}|o`opy pg
~imcl j|e`s oe s|cb mccg|eps% Pg flpplv |e`lvspme` pbl e|hflv gj ojjlvlep sg|vcls gj h|eoco~mi
oecghl) gel geiy ell` vlzolq m h|eoco~mi f|`alp% Oe Elq _gvd Spmpl) igcmi h|eoco~mi f|`alps
mvl joil` qopb pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv "GSC/ M fmsoc vlzolq gj Ilzli Gel h|eoco~mi
joemecomi `mpm jvgh pbl GSC vlzlmis h|ipo~il vlzle|l cmplagvols flyge` vlmi ~vg~lvpy pmrls)
oeci|`oea;
Vlmi ^vg~lvpy Pmrls me` Msslsshleps Gpblv Vlmi ^vg~lvpy Oplhs Smils me` \sl Pmr Gpblv Ege ^vg~lvpy Pmrls Cbmvals jgv Slvzocls Cbmvals pg Gpblv Agzlvehleps
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
7/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
\sl me` Smil gj ^vg~lvpy Gpblv Igcmi Vlzle|ls Spmpl Mo` Jl`lvmi Mo` ^vgcll`s gj @lfp Gpblv Sg|vcls "6>>2/
Vo`ily cgepoe|ls pg mva|l mamoesp gpblv cghhge mpplh~ps pg hlms|vl igcmi agzlvehlep
mcpozopols% Mva|oea mamoesp |soea m h|eoco~miopys pgpmi lr~le`op|vls) Vo`ily memigao{ls pbos qopb
sghlgel qbg mss|hls pbmp dll~oea s~le`oea igq os m hlms|vl gj agg` ~lvjgvhmecl4 bgqlzlv
Vo`ily mva|ls pbmp pbos hlpbg` gj hlms|vlhlep geiy `lhgespvmpls vlspvmoep oe s~le`oea%
Iohopoea h|eoco~mi lr~lesls os egp me oe`ocmpgv gj ljjocolecy flcm|sl op `gls egp m``vlss pboeas
iodl }|miopy gj iojl gv ilzli gj slvzocl qopboe m cghh|eopy% Oj pqg cghh|eopols lr~le`l` pbl
smhl mhg|ep gj hgely lmcb ylmv ge vlcvlmpoge) m``opogemi vlslmvcb hmy joe` pbmp gel copy hmy
bmzl s|~lvzosl` ~imyavg|e`s) megpblv hmy egp "Vo`ily) =?03) ~% 6/%
Oe gpblv qgv`s) pblvl os eg soh~il jgvh|im pbmp cme fl m~~iol` mcvgss mii gj pbl ~|fioc
slvzocls qbocb ql `lhme` me` ~vgzo`l pbmp cme ~vgzo`l me mcc|vmpl hlms|vl gj ljjlcpozlelss
me` ljjocolecy% Pbl scg~l me` fvlm`pb gj h|eoco~mi slvzocls qmvvmeps oe`ozo`|mio{l` mpplepoge
me` lzmi|mpoge jgv lmcb py~l gj ~vgavmh% Vo`ily s|~~gvps pbos ~gsopoge fy spmpoea) pbl plvh
hlms|vlhlep sbg|i` fl cgespv|l` pg hlme mey plcbeo}|l qbocb sllds gfklcpozliy pg m~~vmosl
pbl vls|ips gj m ~vgavmh gj mcpoge gv pg cgh~mvl pbl vls|ips gj miplvempozl ~vgavmhs "Vo`ily)
=?03) ~% ooo/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
8/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Vo`ily o`lepojols m fmsoc jvmhlqgvd jgv `lzlig~oea m vlcgv`s sysplh jgv mey h|eoco~mi
j|ecpoge qbocb oeci|`ls;
=% @lplvhoempoge gj pbl oejgvhmpoge `lsovl`46% @ljoeopoge gj |eops43% Cgespv|cpoge gj s|hhmvy vl~gvp jgvhs40% S~lcojocmpoges gj pbl vlcgv`s ~vgcl`|vl4
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
9/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
~movl` qopb j|ecpoges s|cb ms ~imeeoea me` joemecl) s|jjlvs jvgh pbl smhl cbmiileals% Vo`ily
oe`ocmpls pbmp pbl joemeclme` ~imeeoea j|ecpoges gj h|eoco~mi agzlvehlep vlhmoe pbl hgsp
`ojjoc|ip gj hlms|vlhlep me` ioppil ~vgavlss cme fl vl~gvpl` "=?03) ~% rooo/% Pbos os ~lvbm~s
`|l pg pbl jmcp pbmp pblsl j|ecpoges mvl egp `ovlcpiy vlimpl` pg slvzocls cges|hl` fy pbl ~|fioc%
Joemecl os oh~gvpmep ms me oeplvemi cgepvgi me` ~imeeoea os oh~gvpmep oe ops vgil ms m vla|impoea
j|ecpoge% Pblsl py~ls gj slvzocls mvl egp elclssmvoiy cges|hlv vozle% Pbos os sohoimv pg
lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep%
Lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs bmzl cges|hlvs) f|p ple` pg fl f|soelss qbocb cme
zmvy oe ops cgh~gsopoge) so{l me` ~|v~gsl% Flcm|sl gj pbl `ojjoc|ipy oe soroea |~ pbl cges|hlv) op
os pble sghlqbmp `ojjoc|ip pg hmdl m~~vg~vompl hlms|vlhleps% C{gbmvm me` Hlidlv) oe copoea
Cimvdl me` Amoil) egpl pbmp ljjgvps pg lzmi|mpl lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~giocy bmzl flcghl m
}|mahovl gj agg` oeplepoges me` fm` hlms|vls "6>>0) ~% 3/%
Qboil pblvl mvl zmsp vlsg|vcls ge ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls me` slvzocl ljjgvps me`
mccg|epmfoiopy vl~gvpoea jgv mvlms gj alelvmi agzlvehlep) pbl ioplvmp|vl ge pbos pg~oc oe lcgeghoc
`lzlig~hlep m~~lmvs pg fl }|opl iohopl`% Pbl flsp sg|vcls mvl iohopl` pg m bme`j|i mp flsp me` os
~vohmvoiy cleplvl` ge pbl qgvd gj Bmpvy% Pbmp os pble cgh~iocmpl` fy pbl jmcp pbmp ms m clepvmi
vlsg|vcls pg pbl joli`) Bmpvy os py~ocmiiy copl` fy gpblv m|pbgvs qvopoea ge pbl pg~oc%
Megpblv ~vgfilh pbmp mvosls mccgv`oea pg C{gbmvm me` Hlidlvs os pbmp pblvl os eg mavll`
|~ge hlpbg`gigay jgv hlms|voea ~lvjgvhmecl oe ~|fioc lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs
"6>>0/% Pmdoea jvgh ~lvsgemi lr~lvolecl oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep) hlpbg`gigay os gjple
`vozle fy qbmp pbl slvzocl ~vgzo`lv os mpplh~poea pg sbgq s|cclss oe% Jgv lrmh~il) m ~vgavmh
mpplh~poea pg sbgq ops ~vgavlss oe cvlmpoea gv vlpmoeoea kgfs oe m cghh|eopy qoii jgc|s ge geiy
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
10/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
pbgsl joa|vls% Op os cghhge) fmsl` ge lr~lvolecl) jgv vl~gvps pg jmoi pg vl~gvp ge pbl elp oh~mcp
ge kgfs cvlmpl`) vlpmoel` gv igsp% Pbmp joe`oea os gel pbmp m~~lmvs implv oe pbos ~m~lv qopb pbl Elq
_gvd Spmpl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh% Op qms geiy mjplv vlcghhle`mpoges jvgh pbl Spmpl
Cgh~pvgiilv qlvl vlclozl` pbmp pbl ~vgavmh flame pvmcdoea elp cbmeal oe kgfs ms m vls|ip gj pbl
~vgavmh%
Oe Qmvvles ~olcl mfg|p pbl vgil gj ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep)
bl cvl`ops Bmpvy ms me lr~lvp oe pbl joli` gj ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep me` qopb pbl cgecl~p pbmp
~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls sbg|i` fl mohl` mp mcbolzoea cilmviy o`lepojol` g|pcghls "6>>)>>> ~lvsges) Ioefmi` slp g|p pg lrmhoel bos pqg by~gpblsls;
=% Spv|p|vl me` malecy qoii lr~imoe ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep)me`4
6% Cgh~mvl` pg spv|cp|vl) malecy qoii bmzl hgvl oh~mcp ge ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep oelcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep "Ioefmi`) 6>>:/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
11/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Oe bos joe`oeas) bl `lplvhoel` pbmp pbgsl zmvomfils qopb pbl spvgealsp vlimpogesbo~ oe
`lplvhoeoea pbl iodliobgg` gj |soea ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep qlvl
~g~|impoge so{l me` copy lr~le`op|vls%
Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep ^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vls oe ^vmcpocl
Oe pblov qgvd ge ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep) Bmpvy lp mi%
cgh~oil` =6 dly cbmvmcplvospocs ms cvoplvom jgv pbl `lzlig~hlep gj hlms|vlhlep ~vgcl`|vls%
Mccgv`oea pg pbl m|pbgvs) pbl ~lvjgvhmecl hgeopgvoea sysplh sbg|i` jgc|s ge slvzocl g|pcghls
me` }|miopy me` bli~oea ~vgavmh hmealvs oh~vgzl pblov g~lvmpoges% Ms jgv cge`|cpoea pbl
memiysos) pbl m|pbgvs oe`ocmpl pbmp ~vgcl`|vls sbg|i` ~vgzo`l jvl}|lep me` pohliy ~lvjgvhmecl
oejgvhmpoge me` pbl ~vgavmhs sbg|i` jgc|s ge pbl g|pcghls vlmio{l` fy pbl le` |slv gv ciolep%
^lvjgvhmecl oe`ocmpgvs sbg|i` egp fl iohopl` pg m soeail gv cg|~il gj hlms|vls) f|p vmpblv pbly
sbg|i` oeci|`l h|ipo~il oe`ocmpgvs pg msslss slvzocl }|miopy me` g|pcghls "Bmpvy lp% mi%) =??>)
~% 0/ %
Bmpvy lp mi% cgepoe|l` pg iosp vlcghhle`l` cvoplvom jgv ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep)
`osc|ssoea `mpm% Pbl m|pbgvs fliolzl pbmp hlms|vls sbg|i` |poio{l egepvm`opogemi `mpm sg|vcls
s|cb ms ciolep s|vzlys me` |elh~igyhlep oes|vmecl `mpmpg bli~ msslss slvzocl }|miopy me`
g|pcghls "Bmpvy lp% mi%) =??>) ~%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
12/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
cioleps g|pcghl% Cgepoe|oea ops g|pcghl jgc|s) pbl hlms|vlhlep sbg|i` misg o`lepojy me` vl~gvp
slvzocl }|miopy me` g|pcghl oe`ocmpgvs fy ciolep cbmvmcplvospocs "Bmpvy lp% mi%) =??>) ~% ) ~% :/% Mjplv mii gj pbos `osc|ssoge gjljjocolecy me` ~lvjgvhmecl) Bmpvys joemi ~goep os m
emp|vmi ~vgavlssoge oe `lzlig~oea m ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vl jgv lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep) gv jgv mey
mcpozopy jgv pbmp hmpplv%
Cgesosplep qopb bgq ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep os |sl` oe zmvog|s joli`s) Qmvvle
o`lepojols me` pble `ljoels pbgsl oeplvvlimpl` lilhleps gvameo{mpoges |sl` pg hlms|vl
~lvjgvhmecl gj me g~lvmpoge "6>>
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
13/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
G|p~|ps) qbocb mvl pbl mhg|eps gj ~vg`|cps cvlmpl` me` slvzocls `liozlvl` oe m vl~gvp~lvog`) s|cb ms e|hflv gj pvmoeoea ~vgavmhs cge`|cpl`) e|hflv gj cimssls) pm|abp) gv pbl
e|hflv gj cioleps slvzl`4
G|pcghls) qbocb mvl cbmeals oe degqil`al) sdoiis) mppop|`ls) zmi|ls) flbmzogv) gvcge`opoge pbmp oe`ocmpl ~vgavlss pgqmv` mcbolzoea pbl~vgavmhs hossoge me` gfklcpozls%
G|pcghls cme fl sbgvp plvh) oeplvhl ompl) gv igea plvh% G|pcghls mvl ioedl` pg m
~vgavmhs gzlvmii hossoge "6>>
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
14/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
g|pcghls me` hlms|vls gj ljjocolecy% Pbl oejgvhmpoge alelvmiiy mavlls qopb Qmvvles qgvd ge
pbl vgil gj ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep) f|p `gls egp oeci|`l pbl mcpozopols lilhlep me` m``s
ljjocolecy ms me lilhlep% Fligq mvl pbgsl hlms|vls jvgh ops Vlcghhle`l` Slvzocl Ljjgvps
me` Mccgh~iosbhleps "SLM/ Vl~gvpoea Oe`ocmpgvs jgv Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep%
Oe~|psg @giimvs s~lep ge pbl ~vgavmhs mcpozopols "c|vvlep me` cgespmep `giimvs/%g E|hflv gj spmjj(bg|vs lr~le`l` fy pbl ~vgavmh%
G|p~|psg E|hflv me` ~lvclepmal gj f|soelss ~vgs~lcps o`lepojol` pbmp hmy fl oeplvlspl` oe
igcmpoea%
g E|hflv gj f|soelssls jvgh pmvalp oe`|spvols pbmp mvl oeplvlspl` oe igcmpoea%g E|hflv gj cgepvmcps hm`l qopb jovhs oeplvlspl` oe igcmpoea%g E|hflv gj jovhs pbmp vlzlo` mssospmecl jvgh pbl ~vgavmh "fy py~l gj mssospmecl/g ^lvclepmal gj ilzlvmal "ege(agzlvehlepmi/ j|e`s |sl` pg joemecl pbl ~vgklcp%
G|pcghlsg Oeplvhl`ompl G|pcghls
E|hflv gj zosops fy oeplvlspl` f|soelssls pbmp vlclozl` mssospmecl E|hflv me` ~lvclepmal gj vls~gesl pg m`zlvposoea gv `ovlcp hmoi
sgiocopmpoges%
g Igealv(plvh G|pcghls E|hflv me` ~lvclepmal gj jovhs pbmp vlclozl` msclpoc TsocX me` igcmpl`
lislqblvl%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
15/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
E|hflv me` ~lvclepmal gj jovhs vlclozoea mssospmecl pbmp igcmpl` oek|vos`ocpoge me` pbmp jlip pbmp mssospmecl cgepvof|pl` pg pblov igcmpoge
`lcosoge%
E|hflv gj mcp|mi kgfs cvlmpl` fy mssospmecl =6 hgepbs'60 hgepbs mjplvpblov oeopomi cgepmcp qopb pbl ~vgavmh "me` cgh~mvosge qopb ~vgklcpl`
e|hflv gj kgfs cvlmpl`/%
Mzlvmal qmal gj kgfs cvlmpl` fy igcmpoea jovhs pbmp vlclozl` mssospmecl% @giimvs gj cm~opmi oezlsphlep hm`l fy igcmpoea jovhs vlclozoea mssospmecl
=6 hgepbs'60 hgepbs mjplv pbl meeg|eclhlep gj pblov igcmpoge `lcosoge%
Mhg|ep gj m``l` pmr vlzle|l vlimpoea pg mssospl` jovhs pbmp igcmpl` oe pblk|vos`ocpoge%
^lvclepmal gj cioleps vmpoea pbl pohlioelss gj lmcb slvzocl pbly vlclozl` mslrcliilep) agg`) jmov) gv ~ggv%
^lvclepmal gj cioleps vmpoea pbl bli~j|ielss gj lmcb slvzocl pbly vlclozl`ms lrcliilep) agg`) jmov) gv ~ggv%
^lvclepmal gj cioleps igcmpoea lislqblvl jgv vlmsges gzlv qbocb pbl malecybm` sghl oeji|lecl%
Lspohmpl` e|hflv gj qgvdlvs `os~imcl` fy mssospl` jgvhs pbmp igcmpl`% Ljjocolecy
g ^vgavmh lr~le`op|vls ~lv mcp|mi kof TsocX cvlmpl` mp =6 hgepbs'60 hgepbs mjplvvlclozoea mssospmecl%
g ^vgavmh lr~le`op|vls ~lv lspohmpl` pmr `giimv alelvmpl` fy ciolep jovhs "PblEmpogemi Cleplv jgv ^|fioc ^vg`|cpozopy) 6>>0/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
16/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vlhlep oe Elq _gvd Spmpl Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep ^vgavmhs%
Oe mp ilmsp pbl ~msp jozl ylmvs) lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs oe Elq _gvd Spmpl bmzl
jmiile |e`lv oecvlmsl` scv|poey% Pbos slcpoge qoii jgc|s ge pqg ~vgavmhs pbmp bmzl flle pbl
s|fklcp gj s|cb scv|poey; Lh~ovl [gels me` Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols% Qboil Oe`|spvomi
@lzlig~hlep Malecols bmzl lrospl` soecl ilaosimpoge qms lemcpl` oe =?:? fy Elq _gvd Spmpl
~vgzo`oea jgv pbl cvlmpoge gj s|cb malecols ms ~|fioc fleljop cgv~gvmpoges "Blzlso) 6>>:/) op qms
pbl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh pbmp qms s|fklcp pg pbl jovsp spmplqo`l msslsshlep fy pbl Gjjocl gj pbl
Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv oe 6>>0%
Lh~ovl [gels
Oe =?2:) pbl Elq _gvd Spmpl Ilaosimp|vl lemcpl` ilaosimpoge pbmp oh~ilhlepl` me
Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep [gels ~vgavmh) sohoimv pg pbl Leplv~vosl [gel ~vgavmh cvlmpl` oe pbl
`gcd `ospvocps gj Ige`ge pg s~|v lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep oe lcgeghocmiiy cbmiileal` mvlms%
Mccgv`oea pg pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv) oe Elq _gvd Spmpl) pbl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh
qms oeple`l` pg fvoea kgfs me` lcgeghoc g~~gvp|eopy pg mvlms cbmvmcplvo{l` fy ~lvzmsozl
~gzlvpy) boab |elh~igyhlep) me` gzlvmii lcgeghoc `ospvlss "Blzlso) 6>>0) ~% ?/% Mccgv`oea pg
Blzlso) flpqlle =?2: qble pbl ~vgavmh qms lspmfiosbl` oe Elq _gvd Spmpl "pble cmiil` pbl
Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep [gels gv L@[/ pg =?22) pbos py~l gj {gel(fmsl` lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep
oeclepozl ~vgavmh lr~me`l` jvgh 31 spmpls oe pbl empoge pg lzlvy spmpl oe pbl empoge "6>>0) ~% ?/%
Pbos `lzlig~hlep ~oppl` lmcb spmpl mamoesp gel megpblv oe cgh~lpoea jgv elq lcgeghoc
`lzlig~hlep g~~gvp|eopols jvgh elq me` lr~me`oea f|soelssls empogeqo`l% Vlmiospocmiiy) pbl
cgh~lpopoge qms vlaogemiiy fmsl` qopb Elq _gvd Spmpl cgh~lpoea qopb ~vgavmhs s|cb ms
^leesyizmeoms Dlyspgel G~~gvp|eopy [gel ~vgavmh%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
17/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Pbl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh qms oeopomiiy `lzlig~l` qopb m iohopl` e|hflv gj pmr
oeclepozls jgv f|soelss oeci|`oea m qmal pmr cvl`op jgv elq kgfs cvlmpl` me` me oezlsphlep pmr
cvl`op jgv hgeols oezlspl` oe cm~opmi lr~le`op|vls vlimpl` pg pbl avgqpb gj f|soelssls% Fy 6>>0)
{gels ~vgzo`l lsslepomiiy pmr(jvll igcmpoges jgv f|soelssls pg igcmpl gv lr~me` "Blzlso) 6>>0)
~% =/% Bgqlzlv) pmr(oeclepozl fmsl` lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs mvl gjple `ojjoc|ip pg
hlms|vl flcm|sl pbl oh~mcp pg m spmpl gv h|eoco~miopy os egp bgq h|cb hgely qms aozle
g|pvoabp) ms m avmep hmy ~vgzo`l) f|p vmpblv pbl mhg|ep gj igsp pmr vlzle|l%
Oe 6>>0) pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv lspohmpl` pbl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh qoii
cgsp pbl Spmpl $6?= hoiioge oe jgvagel pmr vlzle|l "Blzlso) 6>>0) ~% =/% Sg hlms|voea qbmp pbl
oh~mcp gj $6?= hoiioge oe igsp vlzle|l hlmep pg pbl spmpl lcgeghy oe 6>>0) me` lzlvy ylmv pbmp
pbl ~vgavmh bms lrospl`) bms flle pbl cbmiileal% @ls~opl m ~vgavmh pbmp bm` avgqe me` lzgizl`)
pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv o`lepojol` gel j|e`mhlepmi jimq pg pbl ~vgavmh% Pbl L@[
~vgavmh imcdl` vliomfil `mpm me` lzo`lecl gj pbl ~vgavmhs s|cclss "Blzlso )6>>0) ~% =/%
Pbl ~vgfilh gj hlms|voea pbl ~lvjgvhmecl gj pbl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh bm` flle
~vlzog|siy boabioabpl` oe =??< pbvg|ab m jgvhmi m|`op gj pbl @l~mvphlep gj Lcgeghoc
@lzlig~hlep fy pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv% Pbl m|`op cm|sl` pbl @l~mvphleps Cghhossogelv
Cbmvils Amvameg pg mcdegqil`al pbl ell` pg `lzlig~ me` mcc|h|impl hlms|vmfil oe`ocmpgvs gj
pbl ~vgavmhs s|cclss "Blzlso) 6>>0) ~% =/% Bgqlzlv) mccgv`oea pg Blzlso) |voea m slcge`
m|`op pbvg|ab 6>>0) pbl @l~mvphlep gj Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep egpl` pbl ell` pg oh~ilhlep
~vgavmhhmpoc cbmeals `limyl` pbl oh~ilhlepmpoge gj lzmi|mpoge sysplhs pbmp pbl @L@ mavlls
mvl elclssmvy "6>>0) ~% =/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
18/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Pbl cgeci|soge gj pbl 6>>0 vl~gvp fy pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv oeci|`l` m
vljgvh ~vg~gsmi jgv pbl Lh~ovl [gel ~vgavmh% Oe pbl ~vg~gsmi) elmviy 3> vljgvhs oe : cmplagvols
qlvl s|aalspl` pg pbl ~vgavmh% Gj pbgsl) pbl jigqoea vljgvhs cg|i` fl cgeso`lvl` `ovlcpiy
vlimpl` pg ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep qopboe pbl ~vgavmh;
@lzlig~hlep me` oh~ilhlep spme`mv`s gj~lvjgvhmecl jgv vlco~oleps gj {gel fleljops4 Vliy ge @l~mvphlep gj Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep T@L@X Spmjj pg ampblv elclssmvy `mpm pg
lzmi|mpl pbl ~lvjgvhmecl gj lmcb [gel me` pbl clvpojol` f|soelssls op cgepmoes4
Pbl TLh~ovl [gel Gzlvsoabp me` @lsoaempogeX Fgmv` sbg|i` slld qmys pg m~~iycgv~gvmpl agzlvemecl me` ~|fioc mccg|epmfoiopy spme`mv`s pg ops j|ecpoges4
vls~gesofoiopy jgv lzmi|mpoea pbl mcc|vmcy gj vl~gvpl` `mpm sbg|i` cilmviy iol qopb pbl@L@4
Igcmi [gel M`hoeospvmpozl Fgmv`s me` [gel Cggv`oempgvs qg|i` fl vl}|ovl` pg jgvhmiiyvlzolq ~mvpoco~mpoea f|soelssls lzlvy pqg ylmvs pg les|vl pbmp pbly mvl hllpoea spmpl`
agmis4
[gel Cggv`oempgvs qg|i` fl vl}|ovl` pg o`lepojy) jgv @L@ spmjj me` |ipohmpliy jgv pblLh~ovl [gel Gzlvsoabp me` @lsoaempoge Fgmv`) clvpojol` f|soelssls qopb g|pspme`oea
~lvjgvhmecl vlcgv`s) ms qlii ms pbgsl pbmp hoabp egp fl hllpoea ~lvjgvhmecl spme`mv`s4
@L@ spmjj qg|i` fl vls~gesofil jgv pvmoeoea [gel Cggv`oempgvs me` [gel M`hoeospvmpozlFgmv`s pg cvlmpl |eojgvh vl~gvpoea spme`mv`s me` hlpbg`s gj `mpm cgiilcpoge% Spmjj qg|i`
~vgzo`l geagoea msslsshleps gj pbl }|miopy gj oejgvhmpoge s|fhoppl`4
@L@ spmjj qg|i` fl vls~gesofil jgv cgh~oioea m [gel Mee|mi Vl~gvp "[MV/ jgv lmcb{gel fmsl` ge FMVs TF|soelss Mee|mi Vl~gvpsX) me` qg|i` ~vlslep pbl [gel
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
19/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
M`hoeospvmpozl Fgmv` me` [gel Cggv`oempgv qopb {gel(s~lcojoc joe`oeas cgepmoel` oe pbl
vl~gvps "Blzlso) 6>>0) ~~% >0) ~% 1/% Pbl vljgvh misg sg|abp pg cgiilcp pbmp mcp|mi mhg|ep m f|soelss cimohl` oe pmr
cvl`ops oe pbl ~vogv ylmv oe m``opoge pg ~vgklcpl` cvl`ops jgv pbl j|p|vl ylmv%
Oe m jgiigq(|~ vl~gvp) pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv vlzosopl` pbl Lh~ovl [gels
~vgavmh mamoe oe 6>>1% Pbos vl~gvp cmhl m~~vgrohmpliy 6 ylmvs mjplv ilaosimpozl cbmeals qlvl
~|p oepg ~imcl oe 6>>>1/% Ms m vls|ip) pbl ~vgavmh spoii imcdl` pbl mfoiopy pg
m`l}|mpliy `lzlig~ me` ~vlslep ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls%
Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
20/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Pbl Elq _gvd Spmpl Ilaosimp|vl oe =?:? lemfil` pbl cvlmpoge gj Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep
Malecols "O@M/ ms ~|fioc fleljop cgv~gvmpoges oeple`l` pg oh~vgzl pbl lcgeghoc cge`opoges
qopboe pblov cghh|eopols% Soecl pbmp pohl) =11 O@Ms qlvl lspmfiosbl` me` mp pbl pohl gj pbl
Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilvs vl~gvp) ==< qlvl cgeso`lvl` pg fl mcpozl "Blzlso) 6>>:) ~% :/%
Oe hmey cghh|eopols) pbl O@M os gel gj pbl flsp degqe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs% Op os
misg pbl gel ~vgavmh pbmp bms m ~vlslecl oe lmcb cg|epy mcvgss Elq _gvd Spmpl%
Pg |e`lvspme` pbl mpplh~ps pg hlms|vl pbl ~lvjgvhmecl gj Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep
Malecols oe Elq _gvd Spmpl) op os oh~gvpmep pg jovsp |e`lvspme` pbl spv|cp|vl gj me O@M me` qbmp
op os lh~gqlvl` pg `g% Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols cme fl spv|cp|vl` me` g~lvmpl` oe
zmvog|s qmys% Pbl agzlveoea spv|cp|vl gj me O@M os m fgmv` gj `ovlcpgvs qopb pbvll pg slzle
hlhflvs% Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols `g egp bmzl pmrmpoge ~gqlvs me` pb|s py~ocmiiy
hmoepmoe pblov g~lvmpoges fy cbmvaoea zmvog|s jlls pg pbl f|soelssls pbmp ~mvpoco~mpl oe pblov
~vgklcps "Blzlso) 6>>:) ~% 1/% Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols hmy bmzl spmjj mssoael` pg
mssosp oe pblov qgvd gv hmy cgepvmcp qopb me g|pso`l jovh jgv mssospmecl) oeci|`oea ilami cg|esli%
M cghhge hoscgecl~poge oe pbl alelvmi ~|fioc os pbmp Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols
~vgzo`l igmes pg f|soelssls |e`lv pbl m|s~ocls gj lcgeghoc lzlig~hlep% Flcm|sl O@Ms mvl
gjple m ~mvp gj me lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~mcdmal pbmp hmy oeci|`l joemecoea jgv m f|soelss) pbos
os |e`lvspme`mfil% Bgqlzlv) O@Ms `g egp ile` hgely `ovlcpiy% Oesplm` pbl vgil gj pbl O@M os pg
oss|l fge`s qbocb mvl ~|vcbmsl` fy joemecomi oespop|poge qbocb alelvmpls pbl cm~opmi pbmp me O@M
cme |sl pg ~vgzo`l joemecoea pg m f|soelss gv ~vgklcp% Op os pbg|ab pbos ~vgclss pbmp O@Ms mvl
mfil pg `ovlcpiy oss|l `lfp jgv pbl fleljop gj lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep "Blzlso) 6>>:) ~% 1/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
21/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols mvl misg mfil pg mc}|ovl) gqe gv `os~gsl gj ~vg~lvpy
qopb pbmp ~vg~lvpy gqel` fy me O@M floea lrlh~p jvgh ~vg~lvpy pmrls me` hgvpamal vlcgv`oea
pmrls "Blzlso) 6>>:) ~% 1/% Pbos mfoiopy miigqs jgv O@Ms pg `lzlig~ ilmsl(fmcd ~vgavmhs pg
lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgklcps pbmp cme vl`|cl gv liohoempl ~vg~lvpy pmrls me` pbl hgvpamal
vlcgv`oea pmr% Pbos fleljop os |poio{l` fy bmzoea pbl O@M ~|vcbmsl me` gqe m ~vg~lvpy jgv pbl
fleljop gj me lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgklcp gv f|soelss% Pbl O@M pble ilmsls pbl ~vg~lvpy pg pbl
~vgklcp gv f|soelssls oezgizl`%
Joemiiy) O@Ms mvl mfil pg hmdl ~|vcbmsl oe s|~~gvp gj m~~vgzl`~vgklcps me` fl lrlh~p
jvgh ~myoea spmpl me` igcmi smils pmr "Blzlso) 6>>:) ~% 1/% Pbos cme pvmesimpl oepg m smzoeas gj mp
ilmsp 0, gj pbl spmpl smils pmr me` |~ pg pbl mhg|ep m``l` ms pbl igcmi smils pmr gv hgvl ge
clvpmoe ~|vcbmsls `l~le`oea ge pbl igcmiopy qblvl pbl ~|vcbmsl qms hm`l gv liozlvl`% Pbos
fleljop os |s|miiy iohopl` pg cm~opmi oh~vgzlhleps me` l}|o~hlep ~|vcbmsl` pbvg|ab me |hfvliim
smils pmr lrlh~poge pbl O@M lrple`s pg m ~vgklcp% Jgv lrmh~il) m cgh~mey ~|vcbmsoea m
hmcboel |sl` oe ops hme|jmcp|voea ~vgclss qoii fl lrlh~p jvgh spmpl me` igcmi smils pmr ge pbl
~|vcbmsl gj pbmp l}|o~hlep fy qgvdoea pbvg|ab pbl O@M%
Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols bmzl flle s|fklcp pg oecvlmsl` mccg|epmfoiopy jgiigqoea
vljgvhs lemcpl` oe pbl impl =?2>s me` lmviy =??>s mccgv`oea pg pbl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl
Cgh~pvgiilv% Pbl cbmeals lemcpl` oe =?2? oeci|`l` vl}|ovlhleps jgv me mee|mi joemecomi
spmplhlep pg fl joil` qopb pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv) Cghhossogelv gj Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep me`
pbl agzlveoea fg`y gj pbl h|eoco~miopy jgv qbgsl fleljop pbl O@M qms cvlmpl` jgv% Pbl
vl}|ovlhleps) qbocb cme fl cgeso`lvl` `ovlcpiy vlimpl` pg ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep) oeci|`l`
pbmp pblsl spmplhleps oeci|`l `mpm cgeclveoea mssospmecl ~vgzo`l` me` kgfs cvlmpl`'vlpmoel` jgv
lmcb ~vgklcp "Blzlso) 6>>:) ~% ==/%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
22/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Oe =??3) m``opogemi vljgvhs qlvl oeple`l` pg hmdl Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols
hgvl mccg|epmfil pg ops fleljopoea h|eoco~miopy me` pbl ~|fioc mp imval% Pblsl cbmeals oeci|`l`
pbl m`g~poge gj m |eojgvh pmr lrlh~poge ~giocy me` pg miigq pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv pg hmdl m
`lplvhoempoge oj me O@M bms joil` m s|fspmepomiiy cgh~ilpl joemecomi spmplhlep "Blzlso) 6>>:)
~% ==/%
Mva|mfiy pbl hgsp soaeojocmep `lzlig~hlep oe ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep jgv Oe`|spvomi
@lzlig~hlep Malecols oe Elq _gvd Spmpl cmhl oe 6>>:% Agzlvegv Algval ^mpmdo soael` pbl
^|fioc M|pbgvopols Mccg|epmfoiopy Mcp qbocb il` pg pbl im|ecb gj pbl ^|fioc M|pbgvopy Vl~gvpoea
me` Oejgvhmpoge Sysplh "^MVOS/ oe 6>>1% ^MVOS flcmhl pbl ~vohmvy vl~gvpoea m~~iocmpoge jgv
zmvog|s ~|fioc m|pbgvopols mcvgss Elq _gvd Spmpl) oeci|`oea O@Ms% Oe ops 6>>? vl~gvp) pbl Gjjocl
gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv vl~gvpl` pbmp pbl }|miopy gj `mpm vl~gvpl` fy O@Ms jgv pbl 6>>1 ylmv
oh~vgzl` `|l pg lebmecl` gzlvsoabp Tme` pbl oh~ilhlepmpoge gjX ^MVOS) qbocb qms im|ecbl`
oe Egzlhflv 6>>1 "@oEm~gio) 6>>?) ~% 6/%
Pbl cbmiileal pbmp lrospl` qopb Oe`|spvomi @lzlig~hlep Malecols) ms o`lepojol` fy pbl
Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv) qms `lplvhoeoea pbl mcp|mi e|hflv gj kgfs cvlmpl` me` vlpmoel`
me` pbl cgsp gj pbgsl kgfs pg pmr~mylvs oe pbl jgvh gj jgvagel igcmi pmrls "@oEm~gio) 6>>?) ~% 6/%
Soecl pblsl pqg oplhs) migea qopb cm~opmi oezlsphlep) mvl ~gplepomiiy pbl hgsp soaeojocmep
~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls jgv O@Ms) mcc|vmcy me` vliomfoiopy gj pbos oejgvhmpoge os cvopocmi%
Cgeci|soge
Qboil sghl mpplh~ps bmzl flle hm`l oe imvalv agzlvehlep slppoeas pg hlms|vl
~lvjgvhmecl oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep ~vgavmhs) s|cb ms pbgsl `oscgzlvl` fy Ioefmi` me` m|`ops
fy Elq _gvds Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv) pblvl os spoii m avlmp `lmi gj vggh pg oh~vgzl pbl
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
23/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
~vmcpocl% Jovsp me` jgvlhgsp os pg spme`mv`o{l hlms|vlhlep ms Bmpvy ~vgzo`ls jgv) qbocb qg|i`
miigq jgv flpplv ~vgavmh cgh~mvosge% Ms C{gbmvm me` Hlidlvs boabioabpl`) op os oh~lvmpozl pbmp
ilm`lvs oe pbl joli` gj lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep h|sp mavll ge m fmsoc slp gj ~lvjgvhmecl
hlms|vlhlep cvoplvom% Misg) ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vl oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep h|sp flcghl m
spme`mv` me` zgi|epmvy ~vmcpocl mcvgss mii ilzlis) egp k|sp pbgsl ~vl`ocpl` fy Ioefim`% Jgvcl`
~vgavmh lzmi|mpoges fy g|pso`l malecols `g |ecgzlv z|ielvmfoiopols ms ~vgzl` fy pbl qgvd gj
Blzlso me` @oEmg~io oe pblov vgils ms Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv% Bgqlzlv) pbgsl qlmdelssls me` pbvlmps
sbg|i` bmzl flle `oscgzlvl` igea mag pbvg|ab m vla|imv ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vlhlep ~vgclss%
Ljjlcpozl ~lvjgvhmecl hlms|vls oe lcgeghoc `lzlig~hlep qoii mssosp gjjocomis me` ~vgjlssogemis
oe hmdoea vls~gesofil ~|fioc ~giocy `lcosoges hgzoea jgvqmv`%
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
24/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Vljlvlecls
Mhhges) @%E% "6>>=/% H|eoco~mi Flecbhmvds; Msslssoea igcmi ~lvjgvhmecl me` lspmfiosboea
cghh|eopy spme`mv`s% Pbg|sme` Gmds) CM; Smal ^|fiocmpoges%
C{gbmvm) I%) * Hlidlvs) K% "6>>0/% ^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vlhlep oe Spmpl Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep
Malecols; Ilssges me` Elrp Spl~s jgv A@OPP% Vlpvolzl` jvgh Algvaom Spmpl \eozlvsopy
qlfsopl; bpp~;''mys~s%as|%l`|'vl~gvp?6%~`j
@oEm~gio) P%^% "6>>1/% Pbl Ljjlcpozlelss gj Lh~ovl [gels; Jgiigq(|~ vl~gvp"Vl~gvp 6>>1(
HS(6/% Vlpvolzl` jvgh pbl Elq _gvd Spmpl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv;
bpp~;''qqq%gsc spmpl%ey%|s%
@oEm~gio) P% ^% "6>>?/% Mee|mi ^lvjgvhmecl Vl~gvp ge Elq _gvd Spmpls Oe`|spvomi
@lzlig~hlep Malecols; Joscmi _lmv Le`oea 6>>1% Vlpvolzl` jvgh pbl Elq _gvd Spmpl
Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv; bpp~;''qqq%gsc spmpl%ey%|s%
Bmpvy) B%^% "6>>:/% ^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vlhlep; Alppoea Vls|ips "6e` l`opoge/% Qmsboeapge
@%C%; Pbl \vfme Oespop|pl ^vlss%
Bmpvy) B%^%) Jmii) H%) Soealv) P%G%) * Ioelv) L%F% "=??>/% Hgeopgvoea pbl G|pcghls gj
Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep ^vgavmhs% Qmsboeapge @%C%; Pbl \vfme Oespop|pl ^vlss%
Blzlso) M%A% "6>>0/% Msslssoea pbl Lh~ovl [gels ^vgavmh; Vljgvhs ell`l` pg oh~vgzl
~vgavmh lzmi|mpoge me` ljjlcpozlelss "Vl~gvp 3(6>>
-
8/2/2019 Performance Measures in Economic Development
25/25
^LVJGVHMECL HLMS\VLS OE LCGEGHOC @LZLIG^HLEP
Oeavmbmh) ^%Q%) Kgycl) ^%A%) Dell`ilv @gemb|l) M% "6>>3/% Agzlvehlep ^lvjgvhmecl%
Fmipohgvl; Pbl Kgbes Bg~does \eozlvsopy ^vlss%
Ioe`fim`) H%V% "6>>:/% ^lvjgvhmecl Hlms|vlhlep oe Igcmi Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep% \vfme
Mjjmovs Vlzolq) 0="%==11'=>12>210>:62:0:6%
Pbl Empogemi Cleplv jgv ^|fioc ^vg`|cpozopy% "6>>0/% Vlcghhle`l` Slvzocl Ljjgvps me`
Mccgh~iosbhleps "SLM/ vl~gvpoea Oe`ocmpgvs jgv Lcgeghoc @lzlig~hlep% Vlpvolzl`
jvgh pbl Empogemi Cleplv jgv |fioc ^vg`|cpozopy qlfsopl; bpp~;''me`vghl`m%v|palvs%l`|
'uecc~'c`a~'lcge`lz%bph%
Pbl Elq _gvd Spmpl Gjjocl gj pbl Spmpl Cgh~pvgiilv% "6>>2/% Joemecomi @mpm jgv Igcmi
Agzlvehleps "Ilzli Gel/% Vlpvolzl` jvgh bpp~;''qqq%gsc%spmpl%ey%|s'igcmiagz
'`mpmespmp'joe`mpm'oe`lrWcbgocl%bph
Vo`ily) CL% "=?03/% Hlms|voea H|eoco~mi Mcpozopols% Cbocmag; Pbl Oeplvempogemi Copy
Hmemalvs Mssgcompoge%
Qmvvle) K% "6>>>? jvgh Mealig| Lcgeghocs qlfsopl;
bpp~;''qqq%mealig|lcgeghocs%cgh' hlms|voeaWl`%bphi%