perception of electronic cigarette use and effects on ... · 4/6/2017 · introduction •an...
TRANSCRIPT
PerceptionofElectronicCigaretteUseandEffectsonDivisionIIIAthletes
ByronCampbellDamianPulos
KimberlyPritchardPhD,LAT,ATCMichaelKotelnickiMS,ATC
Introduction
• Anelectroniccigaretteisahandheldnicotinedeliverysystem.2-4
• ECarefoundinavarietyofsettings– Nicotinereplacementtherapy4
– Recreational/social5
– Performanceenhancement6-7
11
DidYouKnow?
• 22.4%highschoolstudent-athletesusetobaccoproducts8– 8.8%aresmokelesstobaccoproducts
• 15%UScollegemaleathletesaresmokers9
• DivisionIvs DivisionIIIbaseball10– DI– 62.5%smokelesstobaccouse– DIII– 14.3%smokelesstobaccouse
Purpose
• Tounderstandtheperceptionathletesandnon-athleteshaveofelectroniccigaretteuseinDivisionIIIcollegeathletes.
Methods:Design
IndependentVariables:
• Group– Athletes– Non-Athletes
DependentVariables
• Likert-typeresponses– 10questionsrelatedtouse
andperceptionofEC
ObservationalSurvey
Methods:Subjects
InclusionCriteria• Allparticipants
– CurrentlyenrolledatSU– 18-25yearsold
• Athlete– Currentlyonavarsityteamroster
• Non-athlete– Hasnotcompetedforanyvarsityteamwithinthelastyear.
ExclusionCriteria• Allparticipants– Notenrolledasfull-timestudent
Methods:Instruments
• Survey– Likert-typequestions
NO YES
Survey
Methods:Procedures
Participantsnotifiedofsurvey
Participantsreadandsigninformedconsentform
Participantscompletesurvey
Resultsarereportedintheaggregate
Methods:StatisticalAnalysis
• Responsefrequenciesweresummarizedforeachquestion
• Chisquaretestsofindependencewereusedtodeterminegroupassociations– Cramer’sphiwasusedtoassessthestrengthofassociation
• Α settop<0.05
Areyoucurrentlyauserofelectroniccigarettes?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Yes No
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.018
Haveyouevertriedelectroniccigarettes?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Yes No
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.004
Iamawareofelectroniccigarettesandtheiruses.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.114
Athletesthatuseelectroniccigarettesfindtheirperformance-levelisenhanced.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.867
Electroniccigaretteshavethesamehealthrelatedrisksastraditionalcigarettes.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.138
Whichsportismostlikelytouseelectroniccigarettesthemost?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
La Bk Bb Vb Fb Fh So TF
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.001
Maleathletesaremorepronetoelectroniccigaretteusethanfemaleathletes.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.745
Electroniccigarettesarerecreationallyandsociallyacceptable.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.040
Thepresenceofelectroniccigarettesisrising?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.056
Thepresenceofelectroniccigarettesinathleticsisrising?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
ED MD SD Neither SA MA EA
Non-Athlete
Athlete
P=0.040
Discussion:BinaryResponses
• Therewasastatisticallysignificantassociation
• Majorityofbothgroupsare“currentlynotusers”.
• Non-Athleteswerefoundtobemorelikelytotryelectroniccigarettes.
Discussion:Likert-TypeResponses
• Resultsshowbothgroupshavesimilarviewpointsonmostofsurveyquestions.
• Athletesneitheragreednordisagreedthatelectroniccigarettesenhancedperformance
• Despitethenationtrend,bothAthletesandNon-Athletesneitheragreednordisagreedthatelectroniccigarettepresencewasrising.13
Discussion:MostLikelySport
• Collegiatebaseballathletesweremostperceivedtoengageinelectroniccigaretteuse.
• Lacrossewassecondmostperceived(moresoamongstathletes)
• Bothsportshavebeencommonlylinkedtosubstanceuse14
Limitations
• Samplesize• NeitherAgreenorDisagreeOption• Honesty/fearofpunishment• Subjectsknowledgeofelectroniccigarettes
FutureResearch
• ExamineperceptionofhookahuseandcigaretteusageinDivisionIIIathletes
• EliminateNA(Neitheragreeordisagree)optioninLikertscale.
ClinicalMeaningfulness
• HavinganunderstandingofthecorrelationbetweenvapingandathletesmayhelpATsfurtherenhancetheircounselingskillsonthisnewandsocialtrendtoathletesundertheircare
• HavinganunderstandingofpublicperceptiononECandhowtheyarethoughttoeffectathleticperformance.
ThankYou
Methods:StatisticalAnalysis
• Samplesize– Estimate350student-athletesatSU– Reachouttojustasmanynon-athletestudents• CI– 95%• Marginoferror– 5%• Samplesizeestimation– 120surveyscollected12
Survey(cont.)
Survey(cont.)
Survey(cont.)
References1. OlsenS.E-Cigvaporparticleshityourlungslikesmoke.MedicalDaily.PublishedMay8,2014.AccessedAugust8,2016.2. ZhuS-H,SunJY,Bonnevie E,etal.Fourhundredandsixtybrandsofe-cigarettesandcounting:implicationsforproductregulation.Tob
Control.2014;23(suppl 3):iii3-iii9.doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2014-051670.3. Vansickel AR,Eissenberg T.ElectronicCigarettes:EffectiveNicotineDeliveryAfterAcuteAdministration.NicotineTob Res.
2013;15(1):267-270.doi:10.1093/ntr/ntr316.4. Farsalinos KE,Polosa R.Safetyevaluationandriskassessmentofelectroniccigarettesastobaccocigarettesubstitutes:asystematic
review.Ther Adv DrugSaf.2014;5(2):67-86.doi:10.1177/2042098614524430.5. BlackAC,Hochman E,RosenMI.AcuteEffectsofCompetitiveExerciseonRisk-TakinginaSampleofAdolescentMaleAthletes.JAppl
SportPsychol.2013;25(2):175-179.doi:10.1080/10413200.2012.704621.6. Cadwallader AB,MurrayB.Performance-EnhancingDrugsI:UnderstandingtheBasicsofTestingforBannedSubstances.Int JSportNutr
Exerc Metab.2015;25(4):396-404.7. Veliz PT,BoydCJ,McCabeSE.CompetitiveSportInvolvementandSubstanceUseamongAdolescents:ANationwideStudy.Subst Use
Misuse.2015;50(2):156-165.doi:10.3109/10826084.2014.962049.8. Agaku IT,SinghT,JonesSE,etal.CombustibleandSmokelessTobaccoUseAmongHighSchoolAthletes-UnitedStates,2001-2013.
MMWRMorb MortalWkly Rep.2015;64(34):935.9. Primack BA,Fertman CI,RiceKR,Adachi-MejiaAM,FineMJ.Waterpipe andCigaretteSmokingAmongCollegeAthletesintheUnited
States.JAdolesc HealthOffPubl Soc Adolesc Med.2010;46(1):45-51.doi:10.1016/j.jadohealth.2009.05.004.10. Farrey A.AComparisonofSmokelessTobaccoUsageinTwoNCAABaseballPrograms.2014.
http://scholarworks.gsu.edu/iph_theses/334/.AccessedJuly16,2016.11. Halpert M.E-cigarettesmighthelpsmokingcessation.DukeResearchBlog.Sites.duke.edu.DukeUniversity.PublishedSeptember10,
2015.AccessedAugust8,2016.12. Surveymonkey.com/mp/sample-size-calculator/13. LittlefieldAK,GottliebJC,CohenLM,etal.ElectronicCigaretteUseAmongCollegeStudents:LinkstoGender,Race/Ethnicity,Smoking,
andHeavingDrinking.JAmColl Health.2015;63(8):523-9.doi:10.1080/07448481.2015.1043130.14. Farrey A.AComparisonofSmokelessTobaccoUsageinTwoNCAABaseballPrograms.2014.
http://scholarworks.gsu.edu/iph_theses/334/.AccessedJuly16,2016.