pcebs from the sdss testing disrupted magnetic braking matthias schreiber tucson, march-2009 boris...

17
PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March- 2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick) A. Rebassa-Mansergas (Valparaiso) A. Rebassa-Mansergas (Valparaiso) M. Zorotovic-Fiebig, C. Tappert (PUC Santiago) L. Schmidtobreik (ESO) A. D. Schwope, A. Nebot Gomez-Moran (AIP)

Upload: deborah-preston

Post on 20-Jan-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

PCEBs from the SDSS

testing disrupted magnetic braking

Matthias Schreiber

Tucson, March-2009

Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

A. Rebassa-Mansergas (Valparaiso)A. Rebassa-Mansergas (Valparaiso)

M. Zorotovic-Fiebig, C. Tappert (PUC Santiago)

L. Schmidtobreik (ESO)

A. D. Schwope, A. Nebot Gomez-Moran (AIP)

Page 2: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

The orbital period distribution of CVs

Ritter & Kolb (2003)

Page 3: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

1983: Disrupted magnetic braking (DMB)

Paczynski & Sienkiewicz; Spruit & Ritter; Rappaport et al. (1983)

Two angular momentum loss mechanisms:

magnetic wind braking & gravitational radiation

MWB+GR GR

Page 4: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

DMB: believe it or not

Cons:- Spin down rates of low-mass

stars in open clusters (Sills et al. 2000)

- Large scale magnetic fields in fully convective stars(Donati et al. 2006)

Pros:- Mean mass transfer rates of CVs

(Townsley & Gaensicke 2008) - Donor star mass-radius relation

(e.g. Knigge 2006)

Page 5: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Predicted PCEB fractions

Politano & Weiler (2006)

Page 6: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

WDMS and PCEBs from the SDSS

- SEGUE and SDSS identified ~2000 WDMS - We followed-up 285

- 111 PCEBs identified (~39%)

- 54 orbital periods measured (see next talk)

Page 7: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

PCEB fraction versus secondary spectral

type

Page 8: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

PCEB fraction versus secondary mass

Page 9: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Comparing predictions and observations

Politano & Weiler (2006)

Page 10: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

- fast fully convective rotators in old field stars

- not a single early M fast rotator (Reiners et al. 2008)

- change in the magnetic field topology at ~M3.5(Donati et al. 2008)

Disrupted braking in single old field M dwarfs

Page 11: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Conclusion

Disrupted braking confirmed!

Page 12: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Remaining questions

Why does braking get disrupted?

How strong is AML below the gap?

Why is it different in young stars?

Page 13: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

For questions

Page 14: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Gemini PCEB identifications (2007B, 2008A)

Page 15: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

3 good reasons to believe in DMB

- Mean mass transfer rates of CVs (Townsley & Gaensicke 2008)

- Expanded secondaries above the gap(e.g. Knigge et al. 2006)

Page 16: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Selection effects

Bias towards short orbital periods

Bias towards low mass secondaries

Page 17: PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)

Disrupted braking in single field M dwarfs?