p wu - institute for research in fundamental sciences · p wu t q o r do qi o q m ... q b c nqo o v...

36

Upload: lekhuong

Post on 02-Apr-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q
Page 2: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q
Page 3: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

pw�Ut Q�Ot R� �D�OQit

�OQmv xOQw�Q� �Qt Q��Dv� �OW Q�RoQ� s��B�� ��Q� xm �tU�Qt xU��kt QOu�v�QvNU R� CwaO Qmi OW Ea�� OW xO�vW Q�vmwxWwo R� xm ���yCir�NtpN�O O�Qi� � ��tyOQo x � OW xYqN sU�Qt �s � Q�Po � Q� vm �Q �HQ�NTma l � w xtUHt l � uOQm � B Q � w CNQO OvJ TQe �x�oWywS BuwJ xm s�OQm CwaO �Q x�oWywSB R� uwQ�� O�Qi� sy RwQ l� ��atHxDUOQDUw�B OvJ w QwWwQ� l� �OWv wQx� wQ p��kDU� �� Ow� C���NDv� l�ORvxm OwW QWDvt x�oWywSB �xr�U �xt�vWywSB sDW�O wRQ� �OW x�yD

�OWv�u�WC�tON x� uO�yvGQ� w xDi��uU O�Qi� �� w C�UU�wt CW�OoQR��WN � sy u �� �OW� � xDW�O O ��� v w OQ�O v � D�e�r� D �x�vH xHwI�yx �w h � QW x�oW v�O QO uqOQ� QDmO ��Q � �CU� �Vvt w VwQ u�ty R��Ow� �vOv�tO��x� w xwmW�� Q��U� xm OW �B Q� �or�U O�Diy sU�Qt x�oWywSB�iwQat Q��U� u�v�O���� Q R� �OW Q�RoQ� �D����mQD Tv�Qivm x�tCWy��OQ� QOR� w OvDW�Po ut sU� x� �Q u� swW Q�OQ�N xmu�� uwO� w OvOw� xOQm CwaOR� �t� �sOW QNDit w p�LWwN Q��U� sDiQo Q�Qk �yv� s� QmD OQwt xmu��xm �OWQ� �U�vWQ�m �wHWv�O � ���� QkD w �QDmO �wHWv�O ��� u��OW Ea�� xm OQmv x��Q� ut �� ���DQ� QO ��xr�kt sy Qiv l� �DL �sDW�Ou�� QO �yQ�m u�� nvyQi �� OvOw� xO�O �Qyt�� ut R� ��� �swQ� wQi Qmi x���yQ�m sy q�L u�ty xJ OvW�� xO�O �O� xm svm�tv Qmi �CU�v �tp��kDU� w �w�wt u�� O��W s� wo� O��� �syO�t s�Hv� �yv� ��Q� �O�� RRwvy xm OW�� u�� R� ��xv�Wv x�oWywSB �or�UCU�� sU�Qt R� sQo u�OvJxvu�U�vN OvRo R� RmQt sQ�wO�t� �s��xO�UQv CU��� xm ��Wvt w VwQ u� x��OQ�o� uWH QDxwmW�� �Q OwN �or�U GvB wCU�� w Ov�t� u�t� QO Q�oRwQw xOvR Ow� s�y�wN xr�U�� �kwt u� xm sy xOv� w uqOQ� QDmO sQ�wO�t�VOwN X�N ��yVvt w �yVwQ �� VywSB nvyQi xm s�W�� u� Oy�W

�CU� xDiQo �B QDW�� u�tRQU u�� QO

�y�o R� Qy Qo � w OvDUy xOQBCWB ��ysO� �qwtat �C�� QWv pw�Ut u�Q�OtCWB QO nvQsm �tU� RH w OvwQ�t xv�NVwt�Qi x� �Ovvmv OwHw Q�y��u �� QO sDiQo s�tY D �yCOt R� Oa � �T B �O v�t�t v �y v� R� �Q F� OrH�xQ�� QO �R�J x�oWywSB T�U��D p�U u�tDU�� x� �w� Qt �xQ�tW u� QN�

�sU� wv� �x�oWywSB �or�UCU�� sU�Qt xm O�v�wN�t w� O�DU� pwk R� xQ�tW u�� QO uqOQ� QDmO �� x�L�Yt QOu�vJ ��y�oS� w R� �m� CU� u�� ut u�to ��CU� Vvt w VwQ uOtD �� x� RmQt ��Q� ��xt�vQ�N Q�WDv� Qmi �CU�v�UQQ�N �Wvt w VwQOQm �v���DWB Qmi u�� R� xm �Um �yvD u�tR u� QO w OOQo�tQ� V�B p�UR� �OW Q��O �v�UQ�q�� RmQt xm Ow� �v���DWB u�ty �� w Ow� s��B�� T��Q���H �yvD w CU� xOW QWDvt xQ�tW � R� V�� uwvm �D �Q��N� �xt�vQ�Nu� QO �� CWQO w R� Q �� x�oWywSB w RmQt ��yC�r�ai �x�rm xm CU�R�e� QO u� �R�Ov�x�Q Qmi xm R�v x�oWywSB x�o�w �CU� xOW C�F w ��GQ�N �xOvvmO�OR�� Q�Ry � OwOL uwvm �D OWv wQx� wQ u�OvJ p��kDU� ��

�CU� RwQx� ���� QkD w OvtwQ�� �y�o�w svm�t Qmi w xDW�O s��B�� R�O�yvW�B sy x�oWywSB T�U��D p�U u�tDU�� CW�OoQR� xm �t�ovyC� Qwt��t xD�r� w OQm p��kDU� u� R� �tQo �� xm Ow� T��Q ��k� R�� �OWsU�Qt u�� sOQm Qmi ���CW�Po ut �xOya Q� �Q u� C�tOkt uOQw�sy�Qil � u� QO x m OW� � xRwQl � � � xRwQwO �W �� ty w uWH R� pmWDtxwRH w QwWwQ� �Q�Okt �Ovvm �v�QvNU hwQat u�Om� R�i l� w u�O���� QQ�oO� � w OwW x�L�Yt �C�Qi v �a � � � �OwW QWDvt Qo �O �r��t wRm �Qt �re� �OvW��v Qo�O x�oWywSB �or�U� QO CU� umtt �Q� R Ov�t�syt w KQ�t ��ysO� R� w OvQ�o�t uWH p�U � Qy ��vO �D�k�kLD sytx � u�WsOQt �UQDUO xmu �� � � �Ovvm�t � B Q � T v�Qivm �Ovvm�t CwaO��yOQw�DUO �Ovvm�t QWDvt xt� vQ�N �CU�t R� QDW� � Q��U � C vQDv ���CU� uOtD xm CU� ��Wvt w VwQ sy u�� ���w Ovvm�t d�r�D �Q OwN

Page 4: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�V�xOv�� p�U CU�� w x�oWywSBsra O�rwD QwDwt �� sra �U�m

��QwYvt ��Q

�u�Q�� �RwQt� �u�Q�� xmu�� swO �Ov�t� u�Q��QO �O��v� ��yVv�O �rY� x�o��BVRwt� QO �vORp�Ft ���ys�o xm CU� �v�Q�� �CU�v V�B p�U CU��w ��Qw� vi �sra u� �t O vw� B ��Q � u�w�Qi ��yVq D �CU� xDW�OQ � swrax� sqU� u�yH R�v w swU u�yH ��yQwWm u��t QO �CU� xOQm O�YDk�QwWm OvJ wRH p�U �U R� TB xQ�� wO w xOQw�Q� QU �tra �DQOk u�wva�CU� xOW ��vO �O�YDk� CQOk CU�� wRH uwvm �sy R�v w swU u�yH QDQ�syORv�B uQk w �Oq�t �vwvm uQk xm OvQ�O u�� R� C��mL Oy�wW xmu�� swU�yv� OOHt uDU�N�Bx� w �tqU� ��yQwWm uOWKQ�t uQk �UtW �QHyx� xJ �xOvvmu��aD �Wkv u�Q�� OwQ�t Q��Dv� u��t u�� QO w �Ow� Oy�wNVkv u�� �t� �OQ�o� xOyaQ� �OQ�y�Q ��Lr x� xJ w ��Qw�vi w �tra ��LrR� QDOvr� ���yVyH u� wv �Qw�vi w sra QO u�Q�� xmu� Qot �OW Oy�wNv �i�� Q�aW Q� �vD�t w �P�m xv w Q�O��B w xDi��VyH �OWQ �OW�� xDW�O xDWPou�� �wJQ�J QO O��� x�oWywSB xm CU� u�� ��Q� �i�m ��yp�rO �yv���O�yv CQwY u�� Q�e QO �Ovm uWwQ �Q OwN R�Ov�sWJ �OQ�y�Q CqwLD�vwQO �nvD ��yQ�v w hQ� l� R� �vwQ�� �U��U ��yO�� xm OW Oy�wN

�Ov�Wm Oy�wN hQ� Qy x� �Q u� Qo�O hQ� R�

w �Ovm uWwQ �u� uQOt �vat x� �sra �� �Q OwN h�rmD O��� x�oWywSB��H�� sOQm QmP q�� QO xm ����QW �Ovm XNWt u�Q�� QO �Q OwN x�o��H R�vswra ��yx�vH �xty x� xm Ovm s�UQD OwN ��Q� ��xOv�� x�oWywSB Ovm�t�wJQ�J QO hkwD xm Ov�O� w OR�OQB� �C�v�mt� w ��QW �� �U�vDt ��O��v�xDW�O xHwD �Ow� Oy�wN u� �H� QOD nQt �� hO�QDt �Q�v �xYQa OvJ

��OQi se CU� xOw� Q�Qk �CU� xDW�Ov ��xk��U �t nvyQi QO �QovxOv�����vO ��t� �OOQo�tQ� �t ��yPt ��r�C�i�a x� xJv� OQwt QO RH �s� QwNvu�QovxOv�� �tH x� xm �OQm Oy�wN �� �CU� xOQm u�tQw�Ht �vwvm �xO�J�B

�s�Ovw�B��qt�m �� ��QW QO �V� B p�U CU� � ��O��v � ��yV v�O x�oWywS Bsra R� sy�t �QwYD �� �t� �xv�QovxOv�� ��xR�ov� �� �u�Q�� RwQt� �� Cw�iDt�CN�OQB �Q�v �x��B swra x� �yvDwxm� V���tm w �OW �Q�Pox��B �u� wvx� x�oWywSB p�eDW� �CU� u� wv �a��� swra R� �mJwm Q��U� VN� xmu�Q�� QO �Q u� u�wD�tv w CU� �v�vH �xrLQt QO Rwvy ��� QHD l� R�iu� O��� w CU� x�Q ��OD�� QO sy �DN�vW swra QO pwLD �CUv�O XN�W��tra p�wQ xm CU� �y�O� TB �O�O xr�UCU�� �xOv�� �wJQ�J QO �QQO x�oWywSB u�� QO xO�Di��H ��D� Q�Ot p�wQ R�v w ��Q�O� �v���DWB p�wQOQw�DUO xD�r� �OW�� xOW xO��B w OwW xO�O �Q�v swra nvD �wJQ�JOv�wD�tv xOv�� �t� �CU� �vORp�Ft sy nvD �wJQ�J u�ty QO RmQt �tra�sra QO uOw�u�WNQO pY� OW�� Q�Qk Qo � XwYNx� �OW�� xDWPo Ovv�t

�OW�� �tvy�Q xDWPo Ovv�txOv�� p�U CU�� w xDWPo p�U CU�� u��t Cw�iD ��Q� p�rO OvJCU� u�Q�� QO �O��v� swra x�oWywSB �yvD x�oWywSB u�� xmu�� sm� �CUyu� vJty OwQ�t Q��D v� u� R� w CU� xOW xQ�O� � � wNx � xDWPo QO xm

�O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB �u�Q�� �rt �xv�NOYQKQ� w swHv �xOmWywSB �

!

Page 5: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

QwYD R� xm CU� sRq �uOw�u�WNQO VHvU ��Q� �Qo�O ��yXN�WCUOx� �CU� u� ��Q�PB �t nvyQi xm xR�Ov� u� smCUO �u� wv sra R� �tQmi u�Q�� �x��B swra w u�Q�� ��Q� O��� xm OQ�PB� O��� x�oWywSB �Ot� Oy�wN�Ovm h� QaD u�Q�� ��Q� �Q sra OwN ��yC�r�ai �� �Ovm �QovxOv�� w Ovm�CU� V��tR� w x� QHD u� sHLQB w Q�PB�v���OH VN� xm ��Q sra C� Q�Ot�xaUwD QO u� s�a �vatx� xat�H w O�YDk� Vkv x� w �Ov�Rwt��� w ORwt���

�Ovm xHwD �O��v� swraOwN �wr�t �vyP �xmrt �Q sra �Um u��v�Q�� �t �r�e nvyQi�ovyQi ��Wvt Qy w OW�� xDW�O xm �Q�UiD Qy ��vyP �xmrt u�� �Ov�O�tQ�wNxQ�H xQ�wty �Q u��v�Q�� xm OQ�O �m �vOQO OU�i �r�D �OW�� xDW�O xmwQ�B �sra �xOvvmO�rwD xv sra �U�m "Ovm�t sra u�oOvvmO�rwD ��traC�kqN w OyO Q��eD �Q �vyP �xmrt u�� Ov�wD�t x�oWywSB jqN xvlQO ��Q� �u�DUQ�m CU� �Q�m u�� �Ov�Wv� u� ��Hx� �Q sra O�rwD QOx � x vwt v ZLt svm�t x�Yw D u� C�a� D w Vv� � VNQJ u �� R� QDy ���O�vm x�ov xOLDt Cq��� QO xDWPo uQk �Oq�t CYW �xyO CqwLD�OQ�y�Q �xt�vQ� �CU� s�Om x�oWywSB Vkv �CU�J Vv�� VNQJ u��Oy�wN �WywSB w �Q�O� �xv�RwQ Qwt� Q� �Q�F��D xJ x�oWywSB �xr�UCU��x�oWywSB ��i w �yu�tDN�U �Q�tat Q� �Q�F��D xJ xt�vQ� u�� �CW�Ox�oWywSB ��� �Ov� wo�t xJ �t u�QovxOv�� w u�OvtxR�ov� �CW�O Oy�wNs�UQD �Q xOv�� OwN �xDWPo p�U CU�� C�Q�NDi� Q� x�mD �� ki Ov�wD�t�D Ov�xOWv KQ� CUQO Rwvy OUQ�t Q�v x� xm CU� ���yVUQB �yv�� �Ovm

OvW�� xDW�O QwNQO �NU�B

CWwv�B

�xyO nvyQi O� C�yv xvwoJ �xOQB CWB ��QH�t �h�mQ�t u�H �

s�y�Q�� �xtHQD �O�t�Hv� �YNW ��yxv���Q CavY �Q�opmW x� CYW���#� Q�y� �u�Q�� l�D�tQwiv� C�Q�WDv� �M��Wt xO�R��kv

nQR� ���yx�oWRwt� ��QW u� QDy� QO xDWPo QO �t ��yx�oWv�O xm s�W��Q�N� �xyO QO xJQo sra �Um ��Q� �DL xv �swra VRwt� ��Q� Ov�xOw�Q��U� �v�tR �t� �CU� xOW �wQW �yx�oWv�O QO �sra jWt w �sra �UmR� �O�OH h� QaD Ov�wD� �y�oWv�O �x� Qi �xvO� u�� xm O�r��t �vqw�w QDCL�Q x�oWywSB QO �R�Ov�CUwB �OR�Ov��� CUwB s�Q� w OyO� VOwNxO�UQ sra O�rwD �xrLQt x� x�oWywSB Cio u�wD� �DNUx� �CU� QD�vOWsy x�oWRwt� xm Cio OwW�t ��a�k �t� �CU� xOW sra Orwt �O�yv wOQ�w u� Q� uwQ�� w uwQO R� xQ�wty �v�ovU ��yQ�Wi xJQo �CU� xOw�v�x��B swra x�oWv�O OQwt QO xm xvwou�ty �OwW p�O�D x�oWRwt� x� xm xOW

�O�Di� j�iD� u�HvRxm CU� xO�Wwm w �CU� xOQm sra �Um VywSB j� Q� R� x�oWywSBTB �CU�v jr�t ��xQ�Ro I�y xm s�v�O�t �OW�� u�WNQO CyH u�� QOsy w �yx�oWv�O sy �t� �svm�t ��iO sOwN ��y�aO� u�� R� xJQo xm s�v�O��Ov�xOQmv �jWt �yvD w �Ov�xOw� sra Orwt sy �OQ�wt QO x�oWywSB u���� xU��kt QO sy u� w CU�yC�r�ai �rY� CyH CU� xOvvmu��aD xJv�

�CU�J h�rmD �xDiQW�B ���vO QO sra ��yOrwt�xR�� QO �rt �xv�NOYQ �OQ�O Q��DN� QO �rt KQ� OvJ x�oWywSBswra ��yx�oW��tR� w C�R�yHD �xr�UxORv�B �xR�� QO �rt Qo��DW �xr�U�OvJ QO R�v xv���QQ�� w �O� Qo� u� QwD ��yKQ� �xOv�� p�U OvJ QO �DN�vWswra C�at�H R� �ta� w OQm Ovy�wN pwLDt �Q RmQt Q� wYD xOv�� p�U��yxr�kt O�OaD �� u�wD�tv �Q sa� u�� �Ov�WJ Ovy�wN QwWm x� �Q u� wvw OQm Oy�wN lQO �Q u� �rrtr�u�� �tra ��tDH� �t� O�WJ ��T���O��� x�oWywSB �OQm Oy�wN R�� �Qo�O ��UL u� sra w u�Q�� ��Q� x�ou�u� QDCNU xm �vyP ��Lrx� xJ �Ovm xO�t� �yKQ� u�� jkLD ��Q� �Q OwN�oO�t� u�� ��tra �v���DWB w �D� Q�Ot ��Lrx� xJ w �CU� u� VN��Ovm �pt��D OwN �xr�UCU�� �xOv�� ��Q� x�oWywSB CU� sRq xm �va�

OW�t �wQW V�B p�U OvJ CU����t pt��D u�� xJQo�O�HvU u� Cq�kt O�OaD �� u�wD�tv Qo�O �Q x�oWywSB uOw�u�WNQO

� ���� u�DUtR

Page 6: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

x�oWywSB QO �or�UO�Diy

�y�WwQUN ��Qtqe �� �QO�L QO�v �x�L�Yt

�Q sOwN Q��l� �DL �OvOQm�t u�Wvx�W�L �Qt xW�ty �yv�� �xty OwHw�rw sOQm K� QWD $RHx�$RH �Q s�xt�vQ� �t�tD �sOQm xwQo C� Q�Ot ORt�vx� xwQo u� QO xW�ty svm xYqN �OvO�O ���Q �y�� Qt R� �m� x� u�Q�mtysOw� s�oW�B VywSB w VRwt� Ow�y� ��Q� Qo�O ��y�r�N w sOwN �xO�ka�qFt sO�O Q�R� �r�N �LwQ Q�v R� �ut RH OW Q�Ot �Um �v w Tm Qy �rw�O�O Tma �xH�Dv xm sOQm OL R� V�� VqD Qiv wO �m� s�ONDU� ��Q�u�DU�O �OvO�O ut sWJ R� xty �Q �yv� ��y�O� �rw OvOW s�ONDU� �yv�

�svm Vwt�Qi O��� xm �CU� �R�ov�se u�DU�O u�QyD x�oWv�O QO ut

sOw� x�oWywSB u�� �Q�opmW u�mQ� R� �m� xm CU� u�� swO �xDmvx� ��xUU�wt u�vJ uDN�U ��Q� VqD �CU� ��xOvvm ��Q� �x� QHD xmx�oWywSB �� �Q x�oWywSB Qta p�U s�tD w OOQo�tR�� p�k p�U �R� �CU� syt ut ��Q� xDmv u�� w CU� xOW sra u�w�O �Hv�� q�L �s�xOw�

�sQ��t CPr svm�t QU x�oWywSB QO xm ��x�Lr Qy

p�U �� u QO xm �HvQ u R �Ow� u�ty sy �Oa� p wU �wN�OxDWO �Q�� QB �oOvR O�vm�t Qmi �O�DUy ��Q OO�Wm

w VRwt� Ow�y� ��Q� xOw� ��xRQ��t xW�ty ut �oOvR svm�t Qmi xr��Qmi �xeOeO Rwvy u�� sDUy �Hv�� Ckws�tD xm sy q�L u�ty �VywSBu� �� �u�QyD x�oWv�O QDw�Bt�m swra �� ���� Q �xOmWv�O �QJ xm CU� utOwN CU� xDUv�wDv Ckw I�y �Ot� V�B �oOvR�U CYQi xQwO u�OvJ xmOW ut �� �Hv� xm ���wQ�v Q�DiQ seQ�ra xm CU� ��Ha �Ovm �R�UR�� �Q��x��Bswra O��� QO�t x�oWv�O svm�t Qmi �Q� R sDUy �Hv� u�Qov xW�tyu�OvJ ��w p�U OvJ w O�Diy CWPo R� Oa� OQ�Ov w OW�� xDW�O QwNQO

u QDOWQ �vU ��Lr R uqOQ QDmO w �tW uwvm sy �� �QDmO ��k��O�DUy x�oWywSB ���a

u�� �x�t % �� � �xrY�i x� ���CU� uqOQ� QDmO VOa� sv� QDOWQ� ut �xr��OW�� VDUO Q�m ��UL uqOQ� QDmO xm O�vm C�F ��tDL �Q

u Q�W w MrD CQ��N �xty u��t R ���CU�RQO u�tR p�U O�Diy�R�J �OQm woR�� uwD�tv Q xty x�Dwm �x�L�Yt u QO ��DOa�k xm�OW�� �vDioR�� uQoO �Q� O�vm Qmi � OW�� QDxDUHQ� xm CUy

R� Oa � ut �sv m xQ�W� s�tra � oO vR QO OQwt wO x � O �� � sv m�t QmiQO xy�tVW �xQwO l � R� T B w p vQw �m x�oW v�O R� �r�YLD r�dQ�iQO w sOt� u�Q �� x � ��Oq�t ��� �va �� ���� p�U QO �u� DUro v�x� ��! p�U QO CQi�Ut R� p�k uwJ �sOW Q�m x� pweWt u�QyD x�oWv�OQ�yJ w pyJ ���� QkD �sOw� xOW s�ONDU� u�QyD x�oWv�O QO �� Qt CQwY�Ow� ���� Q xwQo QO u� p�U OvJ w �U xm sOQm Q�m u�QyD x�oWv�O QO p�UR� xty x�k� �sOw� xwQo u� QO �m� Qt� �xOQmp�YLD �yvD �kwt u� QO utQO sU�m&� Qw� Gw� ���� QkD �kwt u� �xUv�Qi R� sy QDW�� w OvOt��t �B wQ�u���UL T� QOD QO �DL �Ow� pmWt w lWN �UQO ��y��Dm �Ow� �Hv�w syO � Q��e D �Q �y��Dm sOQm Vq D �CW�O OwHw �O� � R Cq�mW� syl� ut� OW �O�B xr�Ut �H u�ty R� w svm QD�v�Uv� �Q VRwt� C�a�ww s�kDUt �OQm �O�B xt�O� sy QN� �D w � Qo�O hQ� sy u�Qo�O w hQ�C��y ��w $�k DQ� �VRwt� ��w Ow�y � ��Q � COt u �� QO s�kDUtQ�eQO �D�k�kLD KQ� u�rw� �sOQm u�w�Qi VqD �D�k�kLD ��yC�r�ai w ��tra�� �sOQm x��Q� �WywSB Cvw�at x� ut �Q x�oWv�O M� Q�D QO ���� Q �xDWQ

%

Page 7: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

xm ���yQDmO �wv u� �� ut �qw� �rw �O�� wo�t �tW xm ��xHQO u� x� xv�xOQwQB �� w Ov���t �Hv�� xm �v�Um uwJ s�xDW�Ov Q�mwQU O�� wo�t �tW�re� �� Ovv�wD�t w OvDUy �tra �xat�H XN�W ��ysO� OvDUy �Hv��OwHw p�PD�� xm sQ�PB�t �Ovvm C��kQ GQ�N ��yx�oWv�O ��yp�YLDr�dQ�iu�� OwHw CU� pwLD w OWQ p�L QO �tra Q�v R� xat�H �Dkw �t� OQ�Oxm CU� �D�k�iD� �wN �rw svm�tv O����D xD�r� �CU� �a��� �y�rkDw OvDU�v �wN �r�N xm OvyO�t �v�Um x� �QDmO �Q�vmwxWwo QO �ODi��tu�� u�tVqD w s�vm�t C�� QD l� xHQO ��ysO� �Hv�� �t� ��yhQL u�� R��tra �xat�H w ODi��� �H �wN ��yVRQ� s�v�wD�t xm �Hv� �D CU�QO �yOQw�CUO iL s��B�� ��yCr�UQ R� �m� svm�t Qmi R�� �OQ�o��B�OwW�t �QBU G� QODx� C�tm u�QwO �CU� Q�m C�i�m V��Ri� w q�� R�QDC����� Q �xOmWywSB QO ���conjecture� xQ�ov� OwQ�t Q��Dv� �qFtuOWxQ�J R� O�m ��D u�� s� Q�wO�t� w OwW xDWwv �wN ��yxr�kt w OwW pL�i�m Q�Okt x� xm ��xat�H OYQOOY �rw Ovm �Q�owrH UwDt ��ysO���tDL OQ�O sy wHWv�O Q�RyOYv�B w uw�r�t xU w OQ�Ov QL�Dt �v�Uv� �wQ�vu� QDsyt �O� wW�t xH�wt sy u���B C�i�m �� w ODi��t C�k�iD� u�� R� u� QO�yxOmWv�O �re� �CU� QL�Dt �v�Uv� �wQ�v uDW�Ov �t �tra �xat�H OQOQDW�� Qiv xORv�B xO u�W�tra C��y �rw OvQ�O wHWv�O � �D �OwW�tv C�a�w u�� �� �wN �OvQwN�tv OQOx� sy u�WhYv xm OvDU�v�xOmW v�O l � QO �m � Qt� lJwm ��yGr�m QO �CW�O C�i�m Q��D v��m� Qt� QO p�U Qy �OvDUy pweWt �QDmO lQOt �� Qiv � O�v���t ���� Q�wN w CU� R�ov�CQ�L OOa u�� �OvQ�o�t ���� Q �PhD Qiv ��HwQN QOku�� �t �Hv�� �Ovvm�t Q�m w �yx�oWv�O QO OvwW�t VNB �yv��OvwW�t �Q�O� ��yR�Ov�CUO u�� Q�JO sy u�t�wN ��y�HwQN �s� Q�Ov�CU� pwLD w wtv p�L QO xat�H �wN �OvwQ�t QwWm R� u�W�y�a� w���wt O��� w CU� �tra �� QU OWQ p�L QO C�tm Q�v R� sm CUOu�ty OQ�O �Q Cr�UQ u�� w Ov�wD�t xm ���yu�oQ� R� �m� w s�W�� C�i�mGvQCUO R� uDW�OC���Q �w�wt x� s�OQo�t Q� u��Q��v� �CU� s��B���WN� xm sr�LWwN w Ov�xOW �tH �Hv�� �yu� QDy� svm�t Qmi ut ��oOvRQHvt xUU�wt u�� �Q�opmW x� xm xOw� ���yVqD R� ��RH ut �oOvR R�

�sDUy TOkt w xwmW�� ��v� u�� R� ��RH xm sr�LWwN �CU� xOW

x�oWywSB QO Rwvy sy�or�UO�Diy QO uq xm xDmv u x�TB ��wNQQkQ� xm ��yCvU R Rwvy �� �� OQm x�ov Qw�xJ O�� O�DUyu R �D O�W�� �tW CU sRq xm u w �O�vm�t C��iL OxOQm

��ivt � CU �D�Ft �xDmv OwW C��iL �yCvUQO �ut �xO�kax � �CU� C�Ft �qt� m w s�v m�t C�� iL OYQOOYOQ�o ��a� xm u�� �m� �CU� u�� QH QO Ov��Qi wO �Hv�� �Q��L p�LCUO QO �Q �yQ�m �yp�Uu��t w OvwW�t GQ�N �D� Q�Ot �xvwOQo R� �t�OkQDmO w �aiQ� QDmO R� Q�e q�� x� p�U % �va� ��y�t�Ok R� �� OvQ�o�t�Hv�� �t uOw� u��Q��v� �Ovv�wH x�k� w CU�v C� Q�Ot s�kt QO �Um �QwYvt

u�� R� w CU� C�Ft Q��U� x�oWywSB R� ut ���� RQ� �rw �OQ�Ov �WwN�sr�LWwN w ���Q �r�N C�a�w

O�DWO Q�v QO x�oWywSB �Q� xm ��yhOy u� O�vm�t Qmi �vax�oWywSB u �tW uwO� �va xOW sy xvO�yv �� �CU xOW �rta

�OO OywN xtO Q xQ u�tyOWQx� wQ ��yQwWm QO �t�Ok OQ�o uwO� �va� ��y�t uwO� O�� wo� O���Q�O �� B ��yu�tR�U � � C�UU�wt x � p �O� D �O vwQ�t u� � R� OwR �yO� y v u�� �� xm �� wN ��yR�J u� CU� u�� u�tVqD �t �wN �OvwW�tv

�OvwQv u�� R� w OvwW C��FD CU� xOv�wO xW� Q �Hv��

���wN ��yR�J xJnvyQi uDN�Ov��H QO CU� xDUv�wD �CU� xOw� QwLtjkLt �Hv�� �qFt O�v���T�U��D R� Oa� xm s�xDio �Q u�� xW�ty �OW�� Q�PoQF� QwWm u�� QO j�kLDswra Q�v R� j�iD� u� QDsyt x�oWywSB u�� T�U��D u�Q�� QO �QDmO ��yxQwOOvU� wv�t xr�kt Vv�QoWywSB xm p�rO u�� x� �yvD xv �Hv�� w CU� x��B��xUU�wt �r�a �xvwtv xm p�rO u�� x� xmr� �OwW�t C�� QD jkLt wOvm�t QDQwQ�� �Q �D�k�kLD nvyQi uwJ OQ�O �v�w�Qi C�ty� �CU�D�k�kLD�yRwQ u�� "C�ty�QB �rw lJwm �r�Ft �Ovm�t XNWt �Q �yOQ�Ov�DU� w�y��NDv� w CUy Vv� Ro �CU� xOW pmWt �r�N �yx�oWv�O QO s�ONDU�xOW �DNU Q��U� Q�m uOWs�ONDU� w CU� xk�rU x� xDU� �r�N syOvwQ� uwQ�� QwWm R� Ovy�wN�tv xm �t ��yp�YLDr�dQ�i ��Q� �Hv�� �CU�CQwYx� �Q �r�YLDr�dQ�i R� TB CNU u�QwO u�� xm xOQm sy�Qi �DYQiu�� �OvyO� xt�O� �Q u�W�D�k�kLD ��yQ�m w Ovv�QPo� �QDmO�UB QoWywSB�Q C�mv u�� OwW�t Qw�J ���CU� x�oWywSB u�� lJwm O��wi R� �m�

�CU� QF�wt Q��U� �tra nvyQi OWQ sw�OD QO xty �yv�� �OQmv u�ULD

�Qy�� p�L u�a QO �rw Ovtyt �r�N O�Dio xm �yv QDmO ��k���yxQwO u�ty �qFt �OvwW xO�Wm pPD� x� xm CUy �yQ xW�ty�x DWQ QO smCUO w CU xOW O� R �r�N u�WOOa D �Q DmO�xQwO pw p�U �UQO ��Dm xm sxOQm OQwNQ� ��yQDmO �� l R�i�OvxDiQo �QDmO �QwHxJ CU�v swrat w Ovtyi�tv Q �U�vWQ�mu�WOwN Q Vxt�vQ� �DL xm xOw� �R�Ux��W �awv u�WQ�m �q�tDL�x r� kt w O vx D i� w O vxOQm wHwCUH xm�W QO �O vx DWw v vO� R sy �rkD ��yxQ copy � paste hrx� �OvxOQm QWDvtu Q�Q� QO Ctw�kt �xtRq �OvxDiQo O� smsm sOQt w CU xOWxvO�yvVywSB ��yQ��at xm OW�� u O�W �yuOWxO�WmpPD�x�� y v Dx v xm OQ �o � pmW �tra �xat�H xm �vat u x � OwWtH u R OQi uDiQ �� xmr� OW�� syt VQ� VywSB ��yQ��at�tW �OwW u�Wu Ro�H �yQ��at u�ty wnvyQi u�ty �� �QoO OQi

�CU xOO MQ �R�J u�vJ x�oWywSB QO O�vm�t Qmi

� ���� u�DUtR

Page 8: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

Q nwouw �wr��D �Hv QO �sUQB� u�DOwN R sy �tm QDmO ��k�O� R ��O ��y��Dm w �xOQm �W�kv VOwN R xm Q �QwYD �O QO

�OwW�tv QYLvt C���� Q x� �tW �oOvR �O QOM� Q�D x� �O�OW �xkqa sy �y�oR�D �sQ�Oxkqa �r�N C���O� x� ut�sQw��t sm Ckw xm�Qw� s�xOQm �O�B Q�N� p�U � M� Q�D w x�wQWtw Ov�t� xOv�wNv xOW xDW��v� xv�N QO xm ���y��Dm u�� w sQ�t� sUQD�t�a � �O � QN �qY� �QJ �CiQ w CW�Po �Q �y��Dm u �� O � wo � sQUtyxQwO l� s�xOQm �wQW �sv�wN� ��Dm xm swW�t Q�O�� �W �xt�v �y�Ww s�xOQm �wQW CwW�m uwO R� pw� �uOv�wN �Q ��vO l�Uqm ��yu�DU�Ox� �CU�oOvR hQ�atr�'xQ��O Q�ov� �sQ��t ��Dm u�� uOv�wN R� �Qi�w CPrxkqa �rw styi�t O�� R s� wo�tv �sQ�O �O�� R �xkqa QaW w C���O�

�O�O C��r�t O���v xm xkqa ��Q� �sQ�O

�OeH QJ �O��t u�DVwN �r�N OeH R OvxDiow CU� hwQat Qmi w pka x� �Qe QO �CU�QmiDt �xOvQB xmu�� ��Q� �xr��Ov�xDN�OQB OeH x� Qo�O u�oOvQB �xty R� V�� u�R�UxtUHt �Qe QO ���v�F

Tma O� R Q��N �xrHt OrH �wQ uwJ O QOCUwO �Qy�� sy dqm�O QPo�t dqm

sy CU� R �Lt uOQml �B QO w CU�Hv�� �tw� �xOvQB dqm uwJ �xr��r�t �� xm CU�Q��v�� QaW u�� Q��Nx� sy Q�Okt l� �CU� O�it �r�N

�OwW�t R�e� �seqm u� Qmi QO Rwvy

�CU xDWO C�Ft Q�F �D u�D�xiQL �oOvR QO �wW�vR �oOvR�svm �O�B Q�m ��Q� �i�m Ckw sDUv�wD �tv �qY� ut Ow�v ut QUty Qo ��yv�� x� u�WQO�t �s� Q�O OvRQi wO �t �OyO�t s�Hv� sQUty �Q �yQ�m s�tDK�Y �sDU�v Qw�u�� ut xm�r�L QO �CU�t �oOvR u�Qov ��t��O �OUQ�tu�W�� Qo � �sDUy �Hv�� sy �W # Ca�U �D C�kw� �a� w �Hv�� s���t

�sW�� xDW�O ��xt�vQ� u�vJ sDUv�wD�tv ut xm O�O�tv s�Hv� �Q �yQ�m

�xv � CUy ��QV�wW�vR �oOvR R xm O�UQB u�W R O��TBxmu�� ��Q� �CU�v ���Q sQ�Po�t Ckw �Hv�� �r�N xmu�� R� �qY� u�W��svm�t Qmi �sQ�Po� Q�vm xO�wv�N ��Q� sy �Dkw l� O��� xm CU� OkDat�a� w � Ca�U OwR K�Y �yRwQ �r�N �svm�t w s�xOQm xO�iDU�$wU�Lt �qw� �Hv�� �wN �swQ�t �Hv�� R� �W � w s���t # Ca�U sy �yRwQj�kLD w sra x� w uOQm�oOvR �yu�wH u�� sy Oa� w CU��r�H �r�NCi�� QO �Q s�oOvR p�U O�Diy V�O�B svm TL OwW�t Ea�� uDN�OQB

�sW�� xDW�O �oOvR R� �Q��Dv� sDUv�wD�tv u�� R� QDy� ��ak�w O��W �svm�t

q�L OW�t u Qr�� OW�tv uOtm Qo xm Ow� xDio u�rB�J �rQ�JQ�mxJ O OW�t v uO��� Q Qo �tW sUQB � �tW R sDUwN�t

w ut QDwolQ xty R� �tra ��y�QwW QO �CU� syt �yVRQ� u� iL ��Q�sQDLt T��Q �s�vR�t CL�QY x� �Q u�t�yhQL w s�DUy uqOQ� ��k�QO smsm uOw�CwUmV�B VRQ� w OQ�Po�t s�QDL� �t x� Q��U� x�oWywSB

�ODi��t �H �Hv��

��yuwH �qFt QJ OW�� �ivt sy �tm OvwD�t u xm O��t Q�vx��OwW xDWPo sQDL u�WQ�v x� � OvW�� wolQ OvvwD� O��v �t

u�WOwN C�a�w C��F D p�L QO �yu�wH �OQ�O ��xO�U �r�N ��wH�xOmWywS B ki w O vOQo�t � �� ��Rt p�� vO x � u�WOwN ��Q � �OvDUyOvv�wD�t �re� xm CU�Qw� �Hv�� Q�DN�U �OvQ�o�t Q�v QO �Q u�WOwN���yR�J �rw �Ovvm pL �Q u�WCqmWt w Ovvm C�LY T��Q �� ��t�kDUtw Ovv� ��t v OQm x�o v Q DCOtR�QO w Q DxOQDUo �R�O v�sWJ R� O �� � xm �Q�re� �y�QwW QO �qFt �OvvRv hQL O�� R xm Ovm�t ��H�� u�W�i�vt O��Wut �xHOw� �ut u�tDN�U �ut �wHWv�O xm CU� �wv u�� R� �yhQL�xDmv �s�DUy �t �re� Ovm�t Okv xm �Um u� �rw �OW u�vJ w u�vJO� wo �t w xDWoQ� w �m� Qt� CU� xDiQ uqOQ� QDmO �CUy sy �Qo�OuwO� O�vm Q�m O�v�wD�t sy p�U n �tW �Hv� QO �CU�v �Hv�� pFt �Hv�xO�UQ u�D�oDUWvR�� �xQwO uwJ uwQ�� O� wQ� O��� O� wo� �Um xmv��xm �QwWm QO sy u� �Ovvm�t xDUW vR� � �Q �yx r�UO� Diy �Hv �� �CU��xR��H xR�D xm�r�L QO �or�U %� QO �Qt �CUy �tra QO�m Qki QOku���OvOQm xDUWvR�� sOw� xOW �QwWm �xvwtv O�DU� w sOw� xDiQo �tRQ�wNu� xm �Q x v�N DQ�Rw OWQ� u�Q �Ot R� �m � � D�k�kL D KQ� uwJ OvDio�t��jr�Nr�pH� CU� xOQm �iqD w� w s��xOQm O&Q Ow� xOW �wYvt xR�D u�tR� � % �Dkw x�tra ��yxRwL QO Qot �Ovvm�t �Q Q�m u �� � � vO ��Hm�Qo vR� � x � R�� v �yCU��U u �� �O � wW�t xDUW vR� � O �OW xr�U O�Diy

�OQ�O��yxRwL �oS� w wO xW�ty ut O�v��� �CU� syt Q��U� �t�Ok OQ�o u��CU� Qo� R�� xm p�L u�a QO �Um Qy xmu�� �m� �svm�t V��DU �Q x�traCOwN ��Q� �wQ�t �OQi O�v�wN�t �Q C�tOkt �t�H �tW �CUy sy �� Qtu�� w OQ�o� O�� C�tOkt �t�H �tW R� O���� xm �vm�t �O�B �B wv �x�r�w O� Q�o�t GQ�N TQO O�DUy x�r� �yK�Y �CU� ��r�H VwQ �r�Nw OQ�O C�ty� �r�N C�OWQ� �Hv� xmu�� Qo�O �O�yO�t TQO �yQy�R�Oa���yO�DU� Qot �OvQ�o�tv �OH �Q C�OWQ� �yx�oWv�O QO �QJ styi�tv utsy O��� xm xRwL ��tra �OvwW�t xOwUQi xRwL ��tra R� QDW�� x�oWv�Os�vm iL �Q sra O��� ki �t xm�r�L QO �Q CQN� sy w Ovvm iL �Q u�OxDUWvR�� �yv� Qw�J TB CU� QDu�ovU u�WQ�m xm �yv� �s�vm VQDW�� whQ� u�� R� �s��DU�t �Q u� ut w CU� ��xvUL CvU u�� �OvwW�tv�wQ�v Ow�tm u�� �� �OQm xDUWvR�� O���v �Q xOa l� �k� xm svm�t O�kDv�p�U OvJ w CU�� R� CUv�wDv u�QyD x�oWv�O �CU��re Q�m u�� �v�Uv�sOw� xDNwt� x�oWywSB u�� QO xm �D�k�kLD C� Q�Ot w �D�k�kLD x� QHD

�OQ�Ov �OQ�O TwUi� OY w d� QO ��H u�� w Ovm xO�iDU�

� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 9: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

Qo � �Q�y� ��QOtLt ��k� �� �t��m lt��U ��k� O�vm ZQi �tW �qFt �xr�Ovtyiv sy Qo � �Ovtyi�tv �Q Vm� R�i �� VD����� Q Ovvm xtHQD Ovy�wN����yxRwL u�vJ CU����t QWv RmQt �OvUQB�t Qiv wO �m� R� Ov���tu�tHQDt sy xm OQm�t �O�B �Q �ar�t ��ysO� u�vJ w OQm�t CUQOOvDUv�wD�t w OvQ�O x��B swra R� ��xN�W QO �YYND sy w OvDUy �� wNw xOw� �� wN QH�D xv QWv RmQt svm�t Qmi xW�ty �Ovvm pL �Q pat u��

�wN QW�v xv

�OwW Q�m u �rwDt OvwD�t x�oWywSB O�vm�tv Qmiu�� w OvR� ut�O �Q C�k�kLD O��� �Hv�� �OQ�Ov ��xi��w u�vJ �qY� �Hv�� xvQ�mwQU ���� Q w l� R�i �� ki �Dkw �OD�� QO �DL �Hv�� �Ovm�t �Q Q�mq�L �rw s�Ow� hr�Nt �yR�J u�� w xiUri �wv Qy x� uDN�OQB �� CW�Oq�L ut xOW T�U��D x�oWywSB T��Q Cty x� �r�rLD �xiUri VN�py� xm Ovm�t C�� QD l� xHQO ��yhwUr�i xmu�� ��Q� sv�O�t �Q u� QOkx� sQ�wO�t� �r�N ut w OvyO�t G�wQ �Q �r�rLD �xiUri w OvDUy j�kLDu�vJ O��� �y�oWywSB u�vJ l� Q�vm QO svm�t Qmi ut �qY� �u�WxOv��

�sDUy p�LWwN �r�N Q�v u�� R� ut w Ovm �O�B xaUwD �iUri �Dmt

�OQm CUQO �Hv OwW�t sy sra M Q�D �xOmWywSB TB �wNutHv� �OQ�O h� QW x�oWv�O QO �vWro QDmO ��k� �Q sra M� Q�D �xOmWv�O

�Ovm�t �Q �yQ�m u�� �Q�Okt l� sy xiUri w CtmL

uOvtWvO OwW swrat xm u ���CU syt V�tra �x�vH QDW��OvDN�vW�t Q C���� Q �l R�i R��yCtUk xJ sOk QO�vQ���vO ��y�H �x�k� QO sra OWQ QO xDWPo �Q�F �D xJ u�W�yQ�m w�yC�akw CU �wN w OwW�t xDio O� R xYk sy xQ�� u QO uwJpmW x� �vQ uOvtWvO ��yQ�m QOk w xROv �va OwW swrat

�OwW XNWt �tra�yQ�m u�� TB R� �q�L �Qk�� QDmO� �Qk�� TOvyt ��k� pFt xOa l� kiu�� uOv�OQoQ� ��Q� �sra M� Q�D ��Q� OwW T�U��D O��� ��xUU�wt �� Ov���tQ��CU�v u�� VQ�m �Hv�� �rw �xQU�v R� xQU X�NWD ��Q� w �UQ�i x� Q�F�

�QDmO ��k� uwvtt �r�N

�CU�v �U�vt xr�� �Q� u�DsOv xD�r �OOQm�t�Ovm sO� �sQ�O v �Q s vO � ��a� uOQm nvy�ty O�OaDU� �qY� ut x v��t��O �sOW�t xOvU� wv O��W �sQ�O xkqa �r�N C���O� x� �wN �sDUyxm sOv�wN RwQt� ut �CWwv u�DU�O OwW�t Qw�J xm svm�t Qmi u�� x�Ov� Qi��t u�DU�O QO xm ���yC�YNW QO xOvU� wv CU� xDio w�mw�� wDQ�tw�sUHD OQ�O uyP QO xm �Q ���yOkv �Ovm�t Tmavt �Q VOwN �k�w QO

�CU� �r�H �r�N xm OyO�t

�OOW�t xOvUwv OOW�tv uO��� Q Qo TB��ak�w nQR� ��yxOvU� wv Q�F� �va� �CU� �tyt R�J �r�N �oOvU� wv �xr�

�Ovv�Uv� �oOvR �xQ�Ya

xm TO�rk pwY ��Dm sOW xHwDt �Q�N �OW uDWwv��DmC�LY�CU xOW A�J �QoO ��Dm Qy R V�� p�Hv R Oa� Ovwo�t�t �CU Qw�u QJ O�vm�t Qmi �OQOv OwHw �UQ�i x� VxtHQDCU�� Qa x� QDW�� u�W�yQ�m xm sxDWO sy �oQR� ��yuO��� Q�y��Dm u xmCU�v Qmi x� �Um QJ �OvxOQm Q�mxJ s�vO�tv �t w

�OvOQoQ� RwQt �UQ�i x� QV��D ��L� QDmO ��k� �Ot� OwHw x� �WR�N u�vJ �qkv� R� Oa� xD�r�u� �OQm xtHQD sy �Q VrYi wO �m� �h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O O�DU��l� R� C�aq�� p�kDv� w xtHQD w M� Q�D w xiUri x� uDN�OQB �qkv� p��w����� Q j�vt ��Dm sy ut �Ow� xOQm �O�B G�wQ �r�N Qo�O ��H x� �H�OW A�J O�OHD sy x�DQt CWy Ciy ut Q��Dv� hqNQ� w sOQm xtHQDVwt�Qi Qo�O w u�WOwN l�Dv�twQQ�e ��y�oOvR p��vO OvDiQ xty smsm �t�CU����t Ow� QWv RmQt Qo � QWv RmQt �svm O�kDv� QWv RmQt R� �Hv�� O��� �OW

�OQm�t p��vO �Q �yQ�m u��

TB xr�U OY OvJ w QRy M Q�D �� svm�t Qmi ut O�v��� �rwpt�m Q TO�rk pwY xm xO�Di��v u Qmi x� RoQy �Um sqU R

�Ovm xtHQD��kwt u� OvOQm xtHQD xm �� Qa x� xD�r�

sRq �CU�v u�� R �N Q�D pmW � w u�� R CN�vW �xr�Ut �ki�OQmVv��� �RwQt u�� R x� w O�tyi sy QVD���� Q CU

� ���� u�DUtR

Page 10: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

x�oWywSB QO �or�U O�Diy

uqOQ� O�yQi �� �QO�L QO�v �x�L�Yt

x�oWywSB QO ut ��Q� xm �or�UO�Diy sU�Qt u�ty QO �yv� R� �m� x� ��QJ�kwt u� xm T�O &y T�Rwt s�v x� s�DW�O �D���O� O�DU� �sOQm xQ�W� OW Q�RoQ�C���O� w OR�t uw�B�B xm CUy sO�� �OQ�t sy Oa� p�U OvJ w Ow� Q�B �r�N�O�O�t K��wD �wN �r�N �Q �yu�DU�O u�� xty w �Q�BUmW �Qtwy "uymu�� sU�Qt u� QO ��CU� Vvt w l

��U uOtD xm xOv�t sO�� x� w� R� �iQL

�CU� Vvt �xOv��tv xm sU�Qt u�� x� sOQm V�w� Qt w sOQm Q�QmD �Q hQLhQ� wO QO �v�H� Qq QDmO w ut xm sDio sy Oa� w �CU� l�U �xv�Wv�wrNt sy �� �Q u�tsra w CU��U p�L u�� �� s� Q�O Q�Qk �U��U h��

�CU� Vvt u�� �s�vm�t �Q�mty w s�k�iQ sy �� �s�vm�tv

�OxDWO �Q�� QB �oOvR O�vm�t Qmi �QDmO ��k�ut �OwW�t �U��U x�k sy R�� O�v��� ���xOw� Q�� QB svm�t Qmi �xr�Q�v QO �Q u�Q�� s�oOvR ��yxt�vQ� s�tD QO w s�xOQm Qmi u�Q�� x� Qta s�tDx� �sOw� xr�U�# �sDiQ �m� Qt� x� Tv�U�r �xQwO ��Q� xm �v�tR �s�xDiQoxiUri w Ow� l� R�i s�xkqaOQwt ��y�w�wt �sDW�O xkqa �r�N l� R�iC�LY �l� R�i CtUx� Ow� ut QO �D�P �WWm �rw ��U�vWxat�H w��DOwm �xaH�i u�� ��DOwm R� Oa� p�U � CUQO �va� CU� ���� p�UQO xW�ty �CU� xDW�Po QF� �r�N ut C� wy w C�YNW QO O�OQt #�U��U ��yx�Q �svm CtON u�Q�� x� �D svm Q�mxJ O��� xm sOw� Qmi u��sDU�wN�t �Ow� p�rO u�� x� �O�� R Q�Okt sy l� R�i ��NDv� w Ow� xDU�xm �m� Qt� �p�U � q�L w sDW�O p�U �# u�tR u� �OwQ� V�B u�Q�� srau�� wHWv�O utHv� QO sOQm�t C�r�ai �U��U ��yQ�m QO Q�Okt l� sOw�

C�LY w sOQm x�L�Yt �y�WwQUN QDmO �� �tW RV�B �QDmO ��k�O�m �D u�W �O�DUy x�oWywSB ���a u QDOWQ �tW xm OW u Rxi��w xYqN �OvDUy QDOWQ x�t OvJ �tW R xm xDmv u Q� OvOQm

�swo� �tW x� Q u sQOu�� CU� CUQO �qt�m �OvQ�O uU QDW�� x�t % �� ut R� s� wo� O��� �xr�

�O� Q�ov smCUO �Q u�W�� �qY� w OvDUy �tyt OQi u�W�� �hQL

�CU O� R �r�N �oOvR p�U O�Diy QO u Q�W w MrD CQ��N�OUQ� p�U O�Diy x� sQta sDW�Ov Q��Dv� �qY� �CU� O�� R �r�N xr�

��w �N Q CQ��N u �xty �OwW � sy QDW� � �r�N s QwO�tR QDxDUHQ� �tW �Q� xm CUy �R�J �Ov�Hvo xLiY � QO OwW�tv

�OW�� xOw� C�k�iD Q�U�xi��k �CU� ��� O�OQt # RwQ �m� ��U��U syt ��yj�iD� QDW���s�xO�O O�� R ���kw QwH u�� R� ��yuDWm w �yuOR �CU� sO�� Mt�� u��aWu����N QO xm CUy sO�� �Q uty� �CUy sO�� CiQ x�W xm �Q �RwQ�sQ�Ov �Qo�O �xQ��N �CU�yv�� ut �rY� C�Q��N ���OvOw� KrUt sOQt�Y�N �xr�Ut s�YNW �oOvR QO �sDUy uq� xm �Qmi wH QO pk�q

�sQwWm �xOv�� u�Qov �rw sQ�Ov

O� x� �Y�N R�J �Hv� R �OOvwNl R�i ���trm x�oWvO QO �tW�O�DWO TQO �yv� �� xm ��yO�DU R �qFt �O QOv

Page 11: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

��R�UR�� u�� Q�Ut �xQ�� QO CUy hqDN� xQ�� wO q�L �s�Ow� �R�UR��xQUl� s��xOQw� CUOx� COt u�� QO xm �Q �D��� QHD u�� Ovy�wN�t ��xOaQ� �v�wt �DQt sy ��vO �tra �t�wH �x�k� �� u�t���DQ� x�Q QO w �Ovvm �iv�� �OvDiQo pmW C��F uQk s�v QDU� Q� �D�D �� �w�Ovq pFt �D�UU�wt �OwW�t �B�Ow� u� R� V�B xm CU�v �R�J Qo�O sy �w�Ovq �xUU�wt �wQwW �W�B wQi

�Ow� Ovy ��y�UQ�B R �D�D�xr�

RQD QO �D�k�kLD �xUU wt OvvwD�t Ovy ��y�UQ�B �CU �r�HQO �or�U O�Diy QO O�vm�t Qmi �s QO pmWt �Hv w OvR�U� �r�ax�oWywSB QO xmu w �O�W�� xDWO O�vwD�t �Wkv xJ x�oWywSBOwHw O�vm�t Qmi ��ivt � CU C�Ft �xDmv �tW Q�v x� O�DUy

�CU sRq Rwvy �WywSB � �QO ��Lr R �tWV�B p�U GvB �O� Q�Po�t CWov� V� wQ �tW xm CU� �i� Q� �r�N �xDmvQw�Wt s�kt QO ki O��� sOQm�t Qmi �sO�Wm Q�vm �Q�O� ��yCUB s�tD R�u�WC� Q�Ot QO �t� �sDUy �yxD�tm �NQ� w �tra ��QwW QO �qFt �svm Q�mO�Ui �CQOk O� wo�t xm CUy �Q�aW �sOQm �Q Q�m u�� �QJ q�L �sDU�vR� w CU� xOw� svyP QO xW�ty u�� ��jr�t O�Ui �jr�t CQOk w OQw��tsOWv Q��L Ckw I�y �qkv� R� p�k w �s�xOQm R�yQB �yR�J QwHu�� w s�ktxty sOw� xDWoR�� u�Q�� x� xm p�U wO R� Oa� �qFt xmu�� �� svm pw�k �Q �D�rw�Ut�sOWv ut �t� OvOW T��Q xty �Q�o� xOya Q� �Q xOmWv�O CU�� Q w ��� OvDio

�OOW xmh QW�DavYx�oWvOl R�i�xOmWvOT��Q xQNq�� �t �va � sOw � xr�U � sDWoQ � xm �m � Qt� R� ��or�U � QO �t� �xr �QO ��or�U � QO xQNq�� �sQ�PB� �Q �Q�O� C&tU I�y sOWv Q��L p�UR� �m� RwQ l� �Ow� �O� p�L QO l� R�i �xOmWv�O �%� �� ��%# p�Uw Ovvm�t xO�iDU� C�v�mt� R� ki uqOQ� pFt �y�a� Cio u�Q�mty���H u�vJ x� Q�m �OvQ�Po� x��t u�WOwN R� OvDU�v Q��L xHwI�yx�QDmO pFt �v�Um Oa� �t� sOQmv pw�k ut R�� �Ow� w� �� jL w Ow� xO�Wm��i�L�ON xOmWv�O �� O��� svmv pw�k �Q Q�m u�� Qo � OvDio ut x� �t�tYu�Q�mty lt m � � �Ow � CNU Q� �U � ��QW �sOQ m pw � k xQNq� � �OQ m�Q l� R�i �xOmWv�O w sOw� xOmWv�O T��Q p�U �aiQ� XwYNx�Q�m QO ��Oa � xm s �OQm CUQO �Q s�� B�� sy u�tR u�ty �s �OQm �R�UR� �sOw� x�o � xW�ty �va� �CU� T� C� Q�Ot p�U �� �rw �sOw� VD� Q�Otw �m� Qt� sOw� xDiQ p�Ut� �rw �CU� C�v�Uv� h�iND pmW Qy x� CQOksO�O w �RQoD�Q �OQwivDU� �uDovW�w ��yx�oWv�O �sOQm �v�QvNU �H OvJ� OL QO uUt ��ysO� xty PivDt ��ysO� w �u�Wuqw�Ut ��yv� u�Q�Ot�OvW�� u�wH u�Q�Ot O��� xm hQL u�� O�UQ svyP x� �OvDUy p�U # w��yx�oWv�O sDU�U pFt xO�Di��H �r�N �tDU�U �CU�v �DUQO hQLw �k�kLD Q�m x� �yu�wH �OQ�to�t �yQ�m u�� x� �Q uUt ��ysO� �m� Qt�

utHv� u�� QO lQw� w�v QO ��xrLQt l� QO �DL w sOw� �m� Qt� QO u�Q��sOQoQ� w swW� l� QJ sDU�wN�t sy ��xrLQt l� QO �sOw� �QF�wt sO�sOwN l� R�i x� xQ�� wO sDWoQ� �sDU�v xQ�mu�� ut �k� sO�O Oa� u�Q�� x�

�sOQm �DUQO Q�m xm sv���t svm�t x�ov xm q�L w sDN�OQB

w CU xOQm CiQW�B �r�N kwt u� x� C�Uv uQ sra �tW u�tox��O�DWOVkv CiQW�B u QO sy �tW

R� ��RH ��w �N �sy l� R�i w sDW�O Vkv u�Q�� l� R�i QO svm�t Qmi�DavY x�oWv�O QO sy w Ow� s��B�� QO sy Vkv u�� w �CU� u�Q�� sra�or�UO�Diy sU�Qt QO �qFt u ��Q ��v � �VOwN p�wQ x � s�Om Qy �h � QWs�Hv� �sDU�wN�t xm �Q �Q�m xm O�O CUO ut x� T�UL� u�� �awvx��D� Qwt��t xm sOt� TL u�� �� sDWoR�� u�Q�� x� xm �akwt O�v��� �s�xO�OsvOt� �lQw� w�v QO sOw� �m� Qt� QO �or�U � �D �or�U �# R� ut �sQ�Oxm �CU� �r�H �r�N �sU�Qt u�� QO w �Ow� C� Qwt��t QwHl� Ovv�t u�Q�� x��wtHt QO s�oOvR Q�m pY�L �va� s�xO�O s�Hv� �Q sD� Qwt��t sOQm T�UL��r�k �oOvR u�ty Qo�O ut �oOvR Oa� x� u�� R� q�L �CU� VN�C���Q

�CU�Qo�O R�J �CU�v

QO �� �OxOw� x�oWywSB �� �tW Q x�oWywSB Qta p�U �� s�tD�� �OW�� �vOv�tO�x� xm CUy �Y�N R�J x�oWywSB �Q�opmW� �CU xOW �rta O�DWO Q�v QO x�oWywSB �Q� xm ��yhOy�va xOW xvO�yv �� w xOW �rta VQOkxJ xOWv �rta �qt�m Qo

�OO OywN xtO Q xQ u�ty x�oWywSB sy �tW uwO� ���rrtr�u�� RmQt xm Ow� u�� u�t�rY� hOy s�OQm �wQW �Q x�oWywSB �Dkww l � R�i VywS B u� QO xm s � Qw� � � OwHwx � u�Q �� QO � vQOt � D�k�kL Duq� xm ���yR�J R� �r�N w Ow� u�� �rY� hOy �OwW� s�Hv� ���� Qsy x� �r�N ���� Q w l� R�i s�DU�wN �t �wN �CW�Ov OwHw O�v���tOv���� jkLt ��xOa xm OW�� ���H s�DU�wN�t �rw �OWv xm OW�� l�ORvxm sOQm�t Qmi G� QODx� �OW u�� xm OW�� q�� ��D�Uv sy u� C�i�m w OvwQ� w�uwDUv� QB ��D�D �xUU�wt R�QD x� w s� Q�� QDq�� �Q �Hv�� K�U s�v�wD� O���x��W �R�J s�v�wD�t �s��xO�UQv pL�Qt u� x� Rwvy �wN xm s�v�UQ� �w�OvquwJ ODi��� j�iD� u�� COtx�Dwm QO svm�tv Qmi �t� s� wW� �D�D �xUU�wtQO xm OQ�O �U��U w �O�YDk� w �a�tDH� ��yxv�tR �NQ� x� G��DL���Q� �wtHt QO xm �y�oO�J�B w �a�tDH� dwr� w �oDNB �sv���tv u�Q���tm CUy uwvm � xJu� R� �OQ�Ov OwHw CU� sRq ��xUU�wt u�vJ l�w �y�y�W�ra pFt ���yxJ� ���OvDUy uq� xm �rUv uwJ OW Oy�wN QDy�Ovy�wN �QDy� ��yQoWv�O ��DOa�k �OvwW�t QDoQR� ���u�Qo�O w �Q��HM�W�t� �OvwW�t QDy� w Ow� Ovy�wN K�U u�� QO xm Ov���t �Qo�O u�v�wH �OWx� sy u� �CU� p�U � �! C�LY �OW Oy�wNv �w�Ovq �xUU�wt �Hv���OQ�Ov C��F w CU� Xk�v Qt� u�� ��Q� �t �a�tDH� Q�DN�U xm Q��N u��pweWt Oa� �s�Ow� nvH Q�oQO �Q Vr�U � �s�OQm �qkv� V�B p�U �

�� ���� u�DUtR

Page 12: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�yv�� �swQ� u�Q�� R� sOw�v Q��L �qY� w sDW�O �Q u�Q�� �qkv� ��wywp�L utw O�vm�t ��NDv� �O� Q�O ��NDv� �oOvR QO �tW �va� �O���t QO QwH sy ���O� �� �wN sOQm �Q s�qkv� ut Cio OwW�tv �O�DU��� u�D��NDv� ��B O���

�sOQm �R�� �Q sOwN Vkv ut �O�DU�� VQN� �D O��� � i�L�ON

�xOQmv �mtm �tW x� �r�N �wW�vR �oOvRTB�y�Qty �r�N ��ak�w sQUty �Ow� �wN stwO G�wOR� �rw �xv srw� G�wOR�

�sQ�O �� wN �x���Q s��yxwv w QDNO �� �s�DW�O �t�Q� �oOvR �r�N w OQm

xD�r �OOQm�t p��vO Q �yQ xJ OOvwN�tvl R�i Qo QDmO ��k��OOQm �U�vWxat�H w xiUri x� �xQ�W u R V�B

Rwvy w sDW�O xkqa �r�N C���O� x� sy �DOt �sOv�wN�t xiUri �q�tDL��sv�wN�t u�tQ �swQ�t QD��D �sQ�O sy

�O�yO�t Vwo sy T�ro A�r�i �k�Uwt xmu pFtw sQ�O CUwO �r�N �Q �k�Uwt �t� sQ�Ov �O�OaDU� �k�Uwt QO �xr� �xr��sDiQo O�� �Hm R� O�v�O�t sy �Q u�� �sQ�O CUwO �Q uQOt ��yu�O�k�UwtsHvB Tqm QO �s�Ow� �v�DU�O Q�� ��v�Q�� u�O�k�Uwt �N��Wt ��Q�ra R�V�B sDiQ�t ��k�Uwt d�QU CiQ �kwt u�ty R� �s�Ow� Tqmsy u�DU�O

�sDiQo w� R� �Q uQOt �k�Uwt x� xkqa �sO�O�t Vwo �k�Uwt w�

�OOO �t x� Q wowCiouCkw xm �tW R s QRoU�BU�r�N QDmO��k�

���ysO� svm�t Qmi q�L �OvDU�v C� Q�Ot Q�m QO �qY� �OvrweWt T� QODQO CU����t �aiQ� pFt �yQDu�wH �DL w �y�WwQUN w ut p�UwuU QO

�OvOv�t�t �k�� �D� Q�Ot C�akwtw O���� Tm Qy ����DQwWt Vkv �sQ�O CUwO �Q s�rai Vkv u�tyQ�m �syO�t s�Hv� �Q sOwN Q�m Oa� w syO�t �Q VNU�B �OUQB� ut R�O�� R T� QOD R� xv �sQ�Ov CUwO O�� R sy �Q T� QOD �qwY� ����D�k�kLDxm s� wo� O��� �VUQB u�� �xQ�� QO �rw �C� Q�Ot R� xv Ot��t sWwNu�Q�Ot �s�xOQm �O�B �O�OH O�O xOvr�� w xO�Di��H �D�k�kLD RmQt x� C�UvQ� B sO� xmu �� ��Q � �OvW� � q� � �vU ��yxOQ QO O �� � ��xUU�wt u�vJQy x� Ov�wD�t w OwW�t QDsm s�kt � �L w �D�UvH ��yQ�Wi w OwW�t

�CiQo smCUO O���v �Q xQ�ta Tiv �Ovm x�ov �QDW�� pt��D �� ��xr�Ut

�CU xDWO u�D�yQ�m QO �Q�F �D xJ u�D�oOwv�N �oOvR QDmO ��k��or�U! QO sDW�O �rw� G�wOR� �va� �xOw�v jiwt O�� R s��oO�wv�N �oOvRxO�wv�N ��Q� �qY� w sOw� �q���� w Ow� OwR �r�N ��ak�w �Ow� OwR �r�N xmQmi �swW� l� QJ sDU�wN�t u�tR u� uwJ sOQmv G�wOR� uO�Op�mWDQywW Oy�wN�t uR xm�r�LQO swW�t Q�OxJ� w svm�t G�wOR� sOQm�tvQwHO� �r�N w OQwN syx� sH�wOR� �Ovm nQR� �Q xJ� w OwW Q�OxJ� �Ovmx� �OvR� hQL ut �� CU�v Q��L q�L s�xJ� xm�Qw� OQwN syx� sysQUB xmu�� �Cra l� �OvOQm ��k ut �� �Q u�W���DQ� �rmx� w OvDiQ �m� Qt��m� Qt� x� �yv� �� xm Ow� u�ty Ov��� �Qt CU�v Q��L w sO�O CUO R� �Q�rw �Ow� Vr�U �! �sW�� V�k�Qt w swQ� sy ut xm CW�O Q��Dv� �sDiQv

� �

� ����� p�U u���B QO x�oWywSB �xv�N��Dm R� �WQ�Ro

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 13: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�ywQo �xar��t �p�tDL� �xiUri��OQwHq xw�m

Qy x� xm �a��D QO ��R�UQ�Hvy�� ��xO�U �C�Q��eD �� "s�� wo� �p�tDL� xDi�� Q��eD ����D xm OQm �Q�m u�wD�t OyO C�Uv �Q VtQH �(O�t ��W�Q �a��D u�vJ s�y�wN�tv ��trUt �t� �Ovm jOY hwQwowtrwm �pwY� QO

s�v�wN� p�tDL� ����D l��Q �D�tOkt ��yuDt �hQ�aDt ��yp�Ft �CUy sy �Qo�O �CqmWt�p�tDL� CU� �wr�t s�vm�t ��DQB �Q �tr�U �xmU "O� Q�o� Q�v QO��Q � sRq ��QW �CU� ��xmU x vwoJ �s r�U �xmU �t� � ��� x mu ��Qy QO uOt�N �p�tDL� w uOt�Q�W �p�tDL� xm CU� u�� xmU �uOw�sr�U��Q� �y�Q xm OUQ�t Q�vx� �pw� �Q�v QO smCUO ��t� �OW�� �w�Ut ��DQBQO �yO�O� wQ R� �y�vDt �xawtHt Qy "OQ�Ov OwHw xmU �uOw�sr�U �j�kLDpUwD �CU� )� uOt�Q�W �p�tDL� xm CU� Q�oR�U Qt� u�� �� xmU ���DQBu�� "Ovm�tv pL �Q �t �xr�Ut sy nQR� �O�Oa� ��yuwv�k Kq�Y�x� x��p�tDL� ����D �Q�O�kt R� ��xr��vO �OL xmu�� R� �m �L Ov����yx�k �yuwv�k�OwN �CU� � �� ��iO�YD ��yQ�eDt R� ���y���D ���q�� �OL �p�tDL� ��xm OW�� u�� ut �pmWt Qo � u��Q��v� �Ov��Dq�tDL� �t�mL� �yx��k u��u�� CU� QOkJ X�N �xmU l� �uOt�Q�W �p�tDL� xm svm j�kLD Qw�JQy �Q �W��tR� �� QHD �CQwY x� sv�wD� Qo � �DL �O���tv sQ�m x� �yx�k�uOw�sr�U xm O�vm Ctw�kt xUwUw u�� �Q��Q� QO ��i�r� �svm Q�QmD sy�wN� QOk

��O�vm h� QaD �m� R�i �uQ�kD ��ULQ� �qY� �Q xmU�Q��aD �CU� p�tDL� R� ��U�vt �p�rLD �� Q��aD uOQm �O�B �t �xr�Ut"CW�O Q�v �yv�� x� O��� xm OUQ�t Q�v x� �CU� �Q��aD xvwoJ ��U�vt

�VN� smCUO �� xty O��� s�yO�t CUO x� p�tDL� R� xm �Q��aD �I��xty ��twRr xv �QJ� �Ovm jO�Y �Q p�tDL� ����� Q ����k R��y��vDat�Dw�iDt ��aw�wtpY� ��yx�oDUO xm CU� u�� xDmv ��Q ���kR� "��YNWt �OQ�O OwHw p�tDL� ��Q� �� Cw�iDt ���yx�k �� ���C��im �OQwt QO CUy ���yEL� hwQwowtrwm OwN Q�F� QO xrtH���yv �p�rLD O��W ���Q�tW ��Q�PB�tH ��H x�� �y�vDt ��Q�PB�tH��OW�� Q�PB�tH �Q�tW �Qw�x� CU�v sRq p�tDL� xm OyO� u�Wv �t x�

�yO�O� wQ �p�tDL� OwW� �pwYq��ra smCUO �xm OW�� u�vJ O��� �II��OQm x�U�Lt �Q

CU� Q�Okt uqi Vr�tDL� xm s�� wo� �O�O� wQ �xQ�� QO xm O���t V�B O�� Ru�Q�� R� Q�v QO )� �p�tDL�x� xOv�� �p�U �u��� �sHvB �RwQ xm s�� wo� O��W�qFt ���� �OwW�t swU ����U� ��y�R�� QO u�Q�� )% R� QDtm �p�tDL�x� �� �OQ���tQ�Ry VW R� QDtm R� Oa� )� �p�tDL� x� �! u� Qm �xOwD u�� R� �y�wNrO �sD��s�� wo�t xJ s� Q�O �s�� wo�t ���yxrtH u�vJ �Dkw �OwW�t �WqDt p�Uu�O���� Q xm �U� �OwW�t �w� Qt ���� Q �Xr�N �Q�m x� xm ���H �DR� �xm O� wo� �t x� O��W �awv �u�O���� Q �OW�� xDW�Ov p��wU u�� x� �Q�m��i �h� QaD Q� �v� �xm OQ�O Q�mwQU p�tDL� ��i �� w� ����� Q �Q�vt�h� QaD u�� �� �CU� � �i �xR�Ov� xm C�Y�N u�� �� CU� ��xR�Ov�smCUO �� �� Ovm C��F� �Q p�tDL� �x� Q�v ����k Ov�wD�t u�O���� Qp�tDL� �x� Q�v �xDiQW�B ��y��Dm QO xm Qw�u�� �yC��F� �uOQmp��vO ��Q�QO �CU�v p�tDL� �OQwt QO u�� R� V�� �R�J �uDUv�O x� �R��v �CUyCU� swrat Oa� w �O�vm XNWt �Q p�tDL� �xR�Ov� �pw� �Ov� ��yxrtH �OQwt�xQ�Ro� ��R�x� p�tDL� ����D �Q�Okt s�� wo�t s� Q�O "s�� wo�t xJ s� Q�O xm

O���tQi� �Q �Oa� �pmWt �CU� Q�Okt uqi �Y�N �O�O� wQ ��xOvvmu���l� �Q � �x�wNrO �xawtHt ��yxawtHtQ� R R� ��xawtHt �Qw�O������tDH� w �Q�optmt �CLD w OW�� � ��w�L Qo � s�v�wN�t � �wQ Q�H���xR�� QO �Q�O�kt �� � ����D �OW�� � �wQ �Q�H�� A Qo � �OW�� xDU� �Q�tWs�v�wN�t ��� A� �wQ xROv l� �Q C�Ft �C��yv�� �D QiY �xDU���wtHt ��w�Ut A ��RHt ��a� ��Q�tW ���tDH� Qy �wQ VQ�Okt Qo �QPBtH Q�tW Qw�x� � Qo � "��Lq�Y�� OW�� �yxawtHt u� QO � �Q�O�kt�Q�H�� A Qo � CU� xROv ���i l� ��� A� �� ����DxU ��OW�����i l� ��� A� �� Qo � ���� A� �wQ ��xR�Ov� � w OW�� � �wQx� u�O���� Q ������ � � w OW�� xR�Ov� ��i l� �va�� OW�� p�tDLxm �yv�� ��U�vWKq�Y� QO ���yCw�iD �� �O� wo�t OO wQ A ��a�

��CU� xOQm QWDvt ���� QO hwQwowtrwm xm CU� �rwY� �u��� sDio�syi ��Q� smCUO �� �� p�tDL� �� u�txQtRwQ ��Q�oQO �syi ��Q� �t�R� � v u �� R� V� � �R �Jx � �� � Dq�t DL� �u�t Di o � � u�txQtRwQ ��Q � oQOOvm jOY hwQwowtrwm �pwY� QO xm �a��D Qy x� xm CU�v Qw�u�� �s� Q�O

�O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB ��r�rLD �xiUri �xOmWywSB �

��

Page 14: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�Q�R�� "OQ�O �O�� R �C�ty� �vyP �Ci��yQ �u�Q�OiQ� ��Q� uwv�k u�� �CU��CU� �yQw�� �KqY� �swyit ��R�UpOt ��Q� u�W�rY�

�OyO� K��wD �Q Ot�U� x� p�tDL� �� Q Ov�wD�t �RtQ �x� Q�v ��� �t���Q� Cw�iDt �sHUvt ��vyP �Cq�tDL� �� OwW�t xmu�� �� xm CU� xvwoJ wV���tm �Cq�tDL� sOQt ��D��yv xm OUQ�t Q�v x� �OQm �wQW �Q Q�m �yO�O� wQx� �Ovmu���D �Q Qt�u��Ov�wD�t R��� �uwv�k ��� �OvyO�tC�Uv �yO�O� wQ x��v�Um���iO ��Q� ��� ���Dm w ��CU��ivt swU w pw� ��yp��wU ���wH xm OUQ�t Q�v�t� �OQ�O��r�H Q��U� ����� Q w�iUri ��ypqODU��ivt ��y��wH u�� R�� ��� s� wQ�t QD�Qi Q��N���Q�CUOu�� R��WQ�Ro �pw� �pwtat �OL R� s� Q�O smsmp�tDL� �Q��aD �xeOeO xm �v�Um R� �ywQo CWywO�DWy �u�DU��D QOOvOQm�tEL� w OvOW�t �tH sy �QwO x�oWywSB �u�Qw��v �u�tDN�U QO OvDW�O���DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O ���� Q swra �xOmWv�O� �QeY� u�ULQ�t� ���QUm ���O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB �C����� Q �xOmWywSB��v�mQUwD x� RwQ�OQwHq xw�m ��h� QW�DavY x�oWv�O���� Q swra �xOmWv�O��y�W�rasOkt OtLt ���O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB �r�rLD �xiUri �xOmWywSB��QH�yt �i�Yt ���O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB �C����� Q �xOmWywSB�x�oWywSB �r�rLD �xiUri �xOmWywSB QO �QDmO �xQwO �wHWv�O��pYi u�oOvvmCmQW xm Ow� u�� Q� ZQi xUrH Qy QO ���O��v� ��yVv�OOwOLt u� x� �t� �s�OQm�t EL� pYi �xQ�� QO �Ov�xOv�wN �Q ��� R� ��w� Qt�CU� xOQm Okv w xO�O K��wD �Q hwQat ��yCi��yQ �xty ��Dm �s�Ov�t�tv�K�kvD w uOv�QwQB ��Q� ���ysOk u�oOvvmCmQW �a� �xQwO u�� �u���B QOOvOW Oa�kDt p�k R� QDW�� �a� �OvDW�OQ� u�WOwN �X�N �Ci��yQR� �rwkat �Q��aD I�y xm OvO�UQ u�k� x� �a� �CU� QB wB �� xD�r� jL xm�q�tDL� xm OvDiQ�PB �Q �RtQ �hQL �a� w �O�O CUO x� OwW�tv p�tDL�

��Ot�U� �Qo�O w �vyP �m� "OQ�O �vat wO smCUO �p�tDL� �xS�w

HQt

��� Donald Gillies� Philosophical Theories of Probability�

Routledge� �����

��� Alan H�ajek� Interpretations of probability� Stanford

Encyclopedia of Philosophy� �����

http���plato�stanford�edu�entries�probability�interpret�

��� Ian Hacking� The Emergence of Probability� A Philosophical

Study of Early Ideas about Probability� Induction and Statistical

Inference� �nd� ed� Cambridge University Press� ��� �

��� Frank P� Ramsey� Truth and probability� ��� �

http���fitelson�org�probability�ramsey�pdf

QWDvt ��Dm u�� R� ���UQ�i �xtHQD �Ow� C�UrH �wDmt QwLt xm CU� �vDt ���x�oWv�O ��v�mWt �QOtLt �xtHQD �p�tDL� �iUri ��yx� Q�v �R�r�o Orv�O �CU� xOW���� QkD� �CU� p�tDL� ��yQ��aD Q� �at�H u�wNWwN QwQt ��� � ��� �h� QW �DavY�xvwtv ��� ��CU� ��� R� xDiQoQ� O�DUy VQN�w� QO xm �WQ�Ro u�� CUQO hQL QyptDWt xm �CU� �RtQ QwyWt �xr�kt ��� �CU� wmwi l�U x� �Q�ovM� Q�D R� �iwQat

�O�v�wN� �� CUy sy Rv�m �k�vt Ci��yQ Q� �Qov�Q� w Okv Q�

��a��� �Q��Dv� �� OyO u�Wv �Q Ot�U� x� p�tDL� �� Q O��� Q��aD �III��OW�� QDW�� QDOt�U� QB ��yO�O� wQ �p�tDL� ��awv xm CU� u�� �t

�vqka �Qw�� �u�R�t w �vqka ��Q�os�tYD x� p�tDL� �� Q O��� Q��aD �IV����QW �x�k� �uOw�u�Um� �� �xm OUQ�t Q�v x� �� OyO� u�Wv �Qhr� ��wkw x� O��� s�v�O� � �p�tDL� R� QDW�� �Q hr� �p�tDL� Qo �

�� ��wkw x� �D s�W�� xDW�O �QDW�� �u�v�t��

�Ovm u���D �Q sra QO Cq�tDL� �Vkv Ov�wD� O��� Q��aD �V���Q� ��U�vt �Q��aD uDi�� �pmWt R� �tyt VN� xm Cio OwW� O��W���yQ��aD ��D(vU �CU� �IV� w �III� �uOQw� sy �Q�vm ��Q�wWO R� �W�v p�tDL�Q� xm �Q���yQ��aD w ��v�a ��� QoOt�U� Ovvm�t x�mD Ot�U� Q� xm �Q p�tDL� R��Q�Okt �� �Ovv�wN�t ��R��� �� ��YNW ����vyP Ovvm�t x�mD�vqka �Qw��QO u���Qo�vyP w �IV� �uOQw�Q� QO u���QoOt�U� xm Cio OwW�t �DkOsmOOaDt ��yxNUv�Dmt wOu�� R� s�Om Qy �OvQwN�tQ�pmWt x� �III� �uOQw�Q��TR�tuwi �TqBq "hwQat �u���QoOt�U� �a� �OvQ�O �� ZQ�aDt ��a� w ��

��RtQ ��hwQat �u�OO�YDk�� Rv��m OQ�v�t u�H "u���Qo�vyP �a� �QB wBOW��v �(vi ��r��t R� �r�N �qt�m u�oOvv�wN �xty ��Q� VQ�Ro u�� �D�Qw� � �xHQO �RtQ �svm�t C�LY �� �RtQ �Ci� �yQ �xQ� � QO �tm�Ov ��QW R� �Y�N ��w v QO CmQW ��Q � w� ��oO�t� � � �Q hr� �XNW"CUy �D��Lqt �Ov��QW �xQ�� QO �Hv�� QO xm CU� �y�O�� �OHvU�txmv�� ���xO��i � �Qo�O �R�J �� OW�� pwB ��UL Q� u�� R w OwU O��� ��� xmu����D�Uv �RtQ �p��k u�� R� w �OW�� �atH w Q�PBxR�Ov� hr� �C�L�HQD O����wv u�� �Qo�O u�Q�OiQ� �a� �� �OQ�wt QO w �OR�OQB�t �yv�� x� p�YiD x�s�y�wN�t O�vm ZQi ��OQ�O hqDN� �� �(Dv�iO wvwQ� xrtH R� �� Ci��yQ�OOa hr� �s�HvU� OyO�t C�Uv E �O�O� wQ x� hr� xm �Q ���vyP �p�tDL�sy�wN u��aD ��S ut xm Ov�O�t w �Ovm�t ��NDv� �� �� �xR�� QO �Q pS �dr�t hr� x� ut OyO� MQ E Qo � CU� u�� Q� Q�Qk xm Ov�O�t hr� �OQmR� hr� w �OW�� �ivt �� C�Ft Ov�wD�t S �OyO� ut x� pS �dr�t w� w syO�sy �Q V�uOw��ivt �� C�Ft� Ow� Oy�wN xJ ut ���NDv� xm Ov�O�tv p�k�CU� E ��Q� hr� ��vyP p�tDL p xm s�� wo�t ��QW u�� QO ��Ov�O�tvx� �s�U�vW�t C����� Q R� xm �r�tDL� x� OQ�O ��� Q xJ u�� q�L��Q� �Dutch book� �Ovry ��Ov��QW l� �y�Ov��QW R� ��xr��vOhr� Qo � xm svm u��a D � ��yS s v�wD � ut xm � DQwY QO s� � wo�t hr���awtHt CQwY Qy QO OOv� � �QW ut � � xr�� vO u �� ��a� �OQwt QOQo � s�� wo�t sHUvt �Q �yO�O� wQ x� �yp�tDL� ��� RwD �OyO� CUO R� �er�t��Dv�iO��RtQ �x��k �OW�� xDW�Ov OwHw ���Ovry ��Ov��QW V��Q�j�ta �Tiv �� Qo � ki w Qo � CU� sHUvt �yp�tDL� ��� RwD xm O� wo�t�C��F� �Ovm jOY ��y�vDt ��Q�PB�tH ��� hwQwowtrwm �pwY� QO �� O�Wm��Q�WDv� R� V�B �r�U OvJ �RtQ xm O�vm xHwD� �CU�v CNU x�k u��

��CU� xOQt hwQwowtrwm �Q�mCUQO sy Cq�tDL� �sHUvt ��y�� RwD ��Q� R��� �uwv�k �XNq�� �TB

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 15: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�Ret OQmrta �xwLv QO VywSB R� �WQ�Ro��v�LwQ u�y�W

l� R�i �xOmWywSB wO �t� �CU� ��xDWQu��t ��xrwkt�DN�vW swra ��CU����tO�OH �xOmWywSB ��a� �Ov�Xr�N �x��B swra���� Q w�oR�D x�oWywSB QO Qt� u�� w OvOW�t ��NDv� hrDNt ��yxDWQ R��DN�vWCU� R Cqwkt �VD� Q��DUO QwO R� xmv��p�rO x� ut �CW�OXYND �sOW �wYvt xOmWywSB �tra ��QwW C� wa x� sDW�O�C����� Q w ��U�vWv�wQ �xiUri �jQ��UOvyt R� Ow� CQ��a �a� Q��U

�Ow� u� ��yxSwQB uOw� �OQ� Q�m O�OH �xOmWywSB Qo�O R��tD xHw �jQ� �UOvyt XYND �Tmwr wQ�m� xOmWywSB T��Q xmv�� p�rO x�CQ�Rw w �rt lv�� �� �Q�mty QO �OQ� Q�m ��yxSwQB �O�OaD �CW�OR� �t�v R� V�� xm C�r�ai u�� �OW h� QaD Qo�O u�tR�U OvJ w ���vYO�D QO x�oWywSB �x�k� �� OW�t pt�W �Q xOmWywSB �tra C�r�aixm CU� �Y�N s�v sRrDUt �tQiQ�m ��Q� �OQ� Q�m �xSwQB ��QH� �Ow����� RQ� �xrwkt xmv�� Q� ��i�t �CW�Ov OwHw Qo�O �xOmWywSB wO QOQO �OW�t s�Hv� xOWA�J Cq�kt T�U�Q��t�Ok �xOmWywSB wO QO�Ot��tv QO u� R� R�v xr�kt w OW�tv���� RQ� �OQ� Q�mC�r�ai xm�r�L

�xOmWywSB �OQm�t ��H�� �Q x�oW��tR� OwHw xOmWywSB Q�m C�y�t ��l� R�i�xOmWywSB wCW�Ov�y�oW��tR� Q�m ���D�U�vtI�y���� Q�CW�O xrY�i�y�oW��tR� Q�m �� w Ow� �Q�vl� R�i VQ�m �k�w QO syu��Q��v� w Ow�Zk�vD QOCkw ��yx�oO�O ���qt�m�y�oW��tR� Q�m �k�w QO�OvOW Q��O x�oWywSB uLY R� GQ�N QO xOmWywSB ��yx�oW��tR�

�Q�Oyov x� R��v �DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O QO �mDU� QDmO x�oW��tR�C��QH x�oJ�y xOv� �L�QH w uwN R� CWLw �r�rO x� w CW�O C�v�w�L�sDi��v �Q �OyW u�DUQ�t�� QO �k�w �Um �Dw� QDU� x�oW��tR� QO QwLlJwm x�oW��tR� l� sDiQo xOya x� �Q xOmWywSB C� Q�Ot xm �t�ovy�r�N u�tR CWPo p�L Qy x� �OW Q��O u�Qw��v u�tDN�U QO l� R�iwm��U��yx�oW ��tR� x�oWywS B Q��L p�L QO w Ovm�t Zwa �Q �yQw� � R�

�CU� xO�O �H OwN QO �Q �OOaDt

pt�m Qw� x� u� OQmrta �xwLv Rwvy xm CU� u�Uv� uO� wa �yvD Ret��yp��wU �t� s�v�O�t Ret x� �H�Q �O�� R �r��t xD�r� �CU� xOWv xDN�vWCN�vW Ov��Qi xm s�v�O�tv xHw I�y x� �qFt �OvQ�O OwHw R�v �O�� R sy�tR�v C�v�w�L �xQ�� QO p��wU u�� xD�r� �O����t jkLD xvwoJ u�Uv� Ret QOwHwCUH �xy�H u� QN� u�wva x� Vr�J u�� �CU�v xOW xO�O MU�BQO � vOQm vQw� � w � r�H Q� �U � ��yji� O � w v u�U v� uO � CN� vW ��Q �

�OyO�t �Q h�Q�� ���vO R� u�Uv� uyP �wJQ�J"OQ�O C�ty� p�rO OvJ x� Ret OQmrta xwLv R� �y�o �

�� w Ret �� �DQt ��y�Q�t�� R� �Q��U� u�tQO "�m�v�rm p�qO ��Ovm O�H�� �Q xt�r pk�OL xm �Qw� x� Ret �wQ �L�QH pta s�Hv�

�CU� Ret R� �QDy� CN�vW sRrDUtw C� wy X�NWD Ovv�t �D��rta �t Ret xmv�� "�iUri ��yx�vH �

�Ovm�t O�H�� �wLv xJ x� �Q �y�o �OwN�wk Q��U� ��yxv���Q CN�U x� jiwt u�Uv� OvJQy "�awvYt Vwy ���R�Ux��W �Q u�Uv� �xv�OvtWwy ��y���v�wD R� �Q��U� xm xOWu� �rai C�a�w QO u�W�t Vwy xm OQ�Ov lW �Um �t� �Ovvm�t�xv�OvtWwy ��y���v�wD �DL �CU�v u�Uv� Vwy �� xU��kt p��kVwy C�v�mt� R� QDq�� Q��U� �R�wQB u�L QO ����CyH �qFt �C�v�w�LC�v�mt� Ov�wD�t Ret OQmrta �xwLv �hWm TB �CU� �awvYt

�Ovm sy�Qi u�W�t Vwy �xar��t ��Q� �t��a

u�yH nQR� �D�k�kLD Rm �Qt R� �Q��U� xm CU� C�ty� u�ty p�rO x�w �Ovvm�t �DN�vW swra �xYQa QO j�kLD hQY �O�� R pwB w VqDswra x� sy �O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB �xOmWywSB u�twU xm Ow� u�vJ

�OW xO�O X�YDN� �DN�vWs� v � � ��xOmWywS B T mw r wQ� m Q D mO C � Q �O t � � Q t� ��O D �� QOwO � � xHw OvJ QO xOmWywS B u �� �OW T�U�� D OvtWwy ��ysDU�U

"CW�O R��tD ���� Q w l� R�i QD�t�Ok �xOmWywSB

��Q�y� �QOtLt V��Q� w �s��B�� nv �H R� xDiQoQ� �h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w �O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB �

��

Page 16: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

� �

� ��mDU� u�UL QDmO x�oW��tR�

QwWm �tra �xr�kt u�rw� A�J xrtH R� ��tra �xDUHQ� G��Dv x� �DN�vWx� jiwt Nature �xrHt QO u��v�Q�� �q�k� �OW p��v �Nature �xrHt QO��OW�� xOW s�Hv� u�Q�� QO ��t�tD xm �Q�m ��Q� xv �t� OvOw� xOW xr�kt �x��Q��xk��U p�U � ��Q�O �DN�vW swra �xOmWywSB Q��L p�L QOu�� R� QwWm �DN�vW swra u�QoWywSB R� �O�OaD �CU� �tra u�WNQOxOmWywSB u�� u�QoWywSB R� �O�OaD �Ov�xOW p�YLDr�dQ�i xOmWywSBOQ�wQ�y w �lDrm �� D��s� Ov v�t u�yH syt ��yx�oW v�O QO uwvm �sy

�Ov�C�r�ai x� pweWtRmQt T�U��D �� XwYN x� ��DN�vW swra �xOmWywSB R�Ov�sWJQO xk�vt QO �Q u� u�w D�t C��QH x � �CU� VN � O�t� Q��U � �fMRI

�O�O Q�Qk pw� �x�DQt

u�Q�� QO �� �yv� uQOt h� QaD �� �� ���� Q w l� R�i �N� Q�D �xk��U �!��xk��U u�vJ R� �DN�vW swra xm �r�L QO OUQ�t p�U OY x���Q� �v�Uv� �wQ�v Ow�tm �Hwt �ok��Usm u�� w CU�v Q�OQwNQ��xQwO �R�Ov�x�Q u��Q��v� �OW�t �D�k�kLD ��yxSwQB QO �Q�oQ�mx�sw�Ot Qw� x� xQwO u�� w xDW�O C�ty� Q��U� �DN�vW �swra �QDmO

�CU� xOw� Q�QkQ� uwvm �D xOmWywSB u�� QO C�kiwt �� w

��yC�r�ai�DN�vW swra x� OvtWwy ��ysDU�U R� xOmWywSB s�v Q��eD ��Vvm �w QO �OW QDW���WywSBG��Dv x� u� ��mD� w QDtm R�v xOmWywSB �OQ� Q�mQO �WRwt� �xk��U xm u�wH u�QoWywSB R� �O�OaD ��v�Uv� �wQ�v Ow�tm x�wQ xOmWywSB u�� x� OvOw� �DN�vW swra x� Ovtxkqa �rw OvDW�O �mWRBswra �xOmWywSB �CiQo �Y�N jvwQ xOmWywSB �tra C�r�ai w OvOQw�

� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 17: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�s��B�� QO ���Hx��H�v �xUOvy

��r�NrN OwaUt

�xUOvy u��Q��v� �CU� xDiQo Q�Qk �twDv�wm l� R�i �pO QO ��k�ta ���Hx��H�vsRrDUt u� CUQO lQO xm CU� �OQHt Q��U� swyit ��Qy�� ���Hx��H�vp�U Q�Ry GvB �va� �CU� l� R�i w C����� Q R� �a�Uw ��yxv�tRV�B�UOvy QwYD xm CU� xOv�UQ �i R� �twyit x� �Q �t QN� CUO C����� Q���Hx��H�v �xUOvy R� �QDpYit KQW ��Q� OUQ�t Q�v x�pmWt Q��U� u��O�vm �wHQ ��#! u�DU��D ��� �B��B �xQ�tW �Q��N� �xrHt x� O�v�wD�t

C���� Q �xOmWywSB QO ��Hx��H�v �xUOvy ��

QO � p�U jiwt w nQR� Q��U� �rrtr�u�� Tv�Qivm �t �wQW �x�kv��vO QO xDWQ u�� l� �xHQO u�kkLt R� �Q�tW u� QO xm Ow� x�oWywSBu�� �OvDW�O QwL �� CU� xN�W u�� Q�Pov��v� xm �u�m ur&� xrtH R� ���Ow� ���Hx��H�v �xUOvy QO ��xFO�L �Cio OwW�t C��QH x� �Tv�QivmCmQW w u�Q�� QO Tv�Qivm u�� uDiQo pmW R� ut �HQ�N u�Q�mty R� �Q��U�

�� Alain Connes

u�tR Q� w u�tU� QOw�W�Qwy CU�yR�J Q��U�

�v�Hvo� C�xr�Nt QO �v�wD� xm �v� R� QDW���sHvB �xvLY �pw� �xOQB �Crty�

��Hx��H�v �xUOvy ��

x�o v QO C���� � Q R� ��xN�W ��Q � � ��Hx ��H� v �xUOvy u�wva O ��W�VH��Q w l�Uqm swyit x� �xUOvy �OUQ� Q�v x� ��Ha �tm CUNvVv�O w xar��t �� Cr�L u� QD�rm QO �� w �ysQi w �ypmW �UQQ� s��v�x���Q xm CU� �Q�H �qt�m �D�a�w �t� uOw� Q�PB���Hx��H�v �CU�y�i�OW QmP xm �twyit x� �xUOvy QO �R�J xJ �Ovm�t u��� �Q ab �� ba

�k�w QO R�J I�y xm CU� u �� ��wH �OW� � Q �P B� ��Hx ��H� v O v�w D�tswyit �yvD u�v�O���� Q �re� Q�v QO sy RwQt� �DL xm �l�Uqm �xUOvy�x���Q u� QO xm ���Hx��H Q�H �� �Ovm�t u��� �Q xUOvy R� xOWxDiQ�PBQO Qw�� u�� �xW� Q �CU� pO�at w u�Uty Ovm�t jOY xQ�wty ab � ba

�wQ R� �Q �i l� u�tDN�U s�v�wD�t �yv� �Hwt x� xm CU� xDiyv �����k�m� ViwQat �xvwtv wO �s�vm ���� R�� �i u� �wQ ���Hx��H ���wD Q�Hu��Q��v� �CU� lQ�t��v�Ov�iro �x�k �Qo�O w CQ�r�y x�oQiY �x�k��vat uO�tyi x� s�v�wD�t xm CU�i swyit x� u�ty�ov VQDUo �� �yvD�xar��t �wN �wQW �x�kv l� �s� wW l�ORv ���Hx��H�v �xUOvyCra ���Hx��H�v �xUOvy �CU� �UOvy x�oO�O R� ���Hx��H�v ��yQ�Hp��Ut pL x� xm CU� u�� u� w OQ�O ZLt C����� Q QO �� wN �OwHw��yxv�tN ��Q� hwUm� wwv TOL Ovv�t ��Q�H �SwrwB wD QO �rmWt�Ovm�t ltm u�mD ��y�i ��Q� T�Ov� �x�k �� w �xO�U Ov�ty�v��i xm OW swrat �twDv�wm l�v�mt hWm �� �ZLt C����� Q R� GQ�N�xUOvy �va� �CU� ���Hx��H�v ��i l� �twDv�wm ��ysDU�U R�i

��Q�y� �QOtLt V��Q� w �s��B�� nv �H R� xDiQoQ� ��O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB w ��O�v�m� w� Q�Dvw� uQDUw x�oWv�O �

��

Page 18: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

umtt �Q Tv�Qivm u�� �Q�RoQ� w O�O sy CUOx�CUO �xOmWywSB Ckw�xrHt ��#! u�DU��D �xQ�tW QO Tv�Qivm u� R� �LwQWt VQ�Ro� �OQmTv�Qivm u�twO xm s�r�LWwN uwvm � �p�U Q�yJ R� TB ��CU� xOt� Q��N��OwW�t Q�RoQ� � Q�y� QO s��B�� QO ���Hx��H�v �xUOvy �xUQOt w��yTv�Qivm xm Ow� u�� pw� Tv�Qivm u�oOvvmQ�RoQ� �� �tUQQ�e xJQo ��� �Q�QkQO Q�Qk u�� x� �Ov���B xv�iU��Dt xm s�W�� xDW�O s��B�� QO ��xvq�UwO�xUOvy ��Q� s��B�� xm ���yxt�vQ� �� sQ�wO�t� �OWv umtt � p�Uu�� QO �D�k�kLD �wk �xDUy l� O�H�� x�Q QO s�v�wD� OQ�O ���Hx��H�vQO �Q �yTv�Qivm u�� w s� Q�OQ� sOk u� �QDmO �xQwO p�mWD w u�Q�� QO xDWQ�s�vm Q�RoQ� s��B�� QO xvq�U Qw� x� �jkLt �C�� QD �nQR� �xSwQB l� u��

uQ QO ��Hx��H�v �xUOvy OWQ ��yxv�tR ��

ut Q�v x� �Ov�OQo�t Q�wO�t� u�Q�� QO xDWQ u�� �xaUwD x� �Q �t R�J xJx� w CU� OwHwt u�Q�� QO xDWQ u�� uOR xv�wH �Qmi w �O�t ��yxv�tRRm �Qt R� �m� x� �y�Dwm ��D�Uv COt QO s�v�wD�t �t xm Cio OwW�t C��QHQO Q�N� ��yp�U QO �s� wW p�O�D ��vO QO xDWQ u�� QO �D�k�kLD syt�xQwO TwQO �CU� xOW u�Q�� QO �� wN �Q�Pox��tQU �r�a VRwt� Qt������ Q ��yxN�W QFm � QO �u�Q�� QO ���� Q OWQ� �U�vWQ�m w �U�vWQ�m�xUOvy x� xkqa Q�N� u��r�U QO �OwW�t x��Q� �� wN K�U QO ��twtax� �u� R� GQ�N xJ w s��B�� QO xJ ��v�Q�� u�v�Om� R�i u��t QO ���Hx��H�vj�DWt w OaDUt u�� wHWv�O Q�vm QO �yv�� �xty �OQwN�t sWJ x� Kw�w��U�vt �xv�tRV�B �D OvyO�t sy CUOx�CUO j�kLD w uDNwt� ��Q�

�Ovm sy�Qi u�Q�� QO xDWQ u�� �� QU VQDUo ��Q�

��y�WwQUN ��Qtqe w �u�m u�r�� ��r�NrN OwaUt ��rwmQ�t xOr�D�t CU�Q R�

�D�Q�WDv� �xUU�wt �OvOQm�t�HaD Q�y�� Kw�w x� u� QO xN�W u�� u�Qw�s�v�xUOvy nQR� Tv�Qivm u�DUNv u�� ��y�v�QvNU World Scientic

�CU� xOQm A�J xLiY � R� V�� �� ���Dm QO �Q u�Q�� QO ���Hx��H�v�xOvQ�� u�m ur� ��y�v�QvNU xrUrU Tv�Qivm u�� syt ���kw R� �m��� xm Ow� u�� wHWv�O ��Q� w� �Y�YDN� �xUrH w ���# ROr�i p�Ots�xOw� �OOaDt ��yTv�Qivm u�oOvvmQ�RoQ� wRH ut �OW wQx� wQ ��Uw p��kDU�R� l� I�y xm sQ�Ov O�OQD �rw Ov�xOw� �r�H �awv x� �yv� R� l� Qy xms� wo� sv�wD�t �yvD �Ov�xO�UQ�tv x�oWywSB QO � Tv�Qivm ��B x� �yv�Qiv OvJ �xv�OHt VqD w �VwN CN� �Oa�Ut ��yO�O� wQ xDWQ l� xmT��Q w �y�WwQUN ��Qtqe �xv�t�tY C��tL XwYN� w u�Q�mty R�

� �

� ��� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 19: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

uwDw�v l �R�� ���� Q swra �xUU�wt

�xD�tm CUWv u�rw� �OvOW �wYvt T��Q���v CtU x� �xUU�wt OWQx�YwD xUU�wt T��Q x� xD�tm �OW Q�RoQ� ��� QO xUU�wt �tra C��Oyw Q�tWsm O�a�� QO �SwrwB wD ��yxv�tR QO xUU�wt ��yxt�vQ� u�rw� OQm�OvwW R�e� ��� �x��wS QO w OvW�� wt�v�O �x� Q�v w u�O�t �x� Q�vCWy s�ovy u�� QO w OQm Q�mx� R�e� ��� �x��wS swU QO ��tUQ xUU�wtxDiQW� B pL�Qt QO O vOW xUU�wt pw� p�U wO �Q�m �w�wt xm ��xt� vQ �R� �Q��U� w pw� p�U u�oOvvmCmQW s�tD ���� QkD ��Q� �yxt�vCwaO w OvOw�xUU�wt u�tDN�U �tUQ V��Wo �Ow� xOW xO�DUQi swO p�U u�oOvvmCmQWu�QoWywSB �� wO u�� C�kqt w wQ�v�O� lwO w x�oWv�O T��Q QwL ��

�OW s�Hv� ��� Q�Dm � � RwQ QO u�ty�t

"Ov�xOw� Q� R KQW x� uwvm �D R�e� R� xUU�wt ��U�wQ���������% x�D&� pm��t

����%�� C&iwt C�m���% u&tnv�m u�H

�uwvm �D � Tq�w O� w�O�tQi QN� �x��k

�y��D�L u�wva �� ��xt�vQ� QO QN� �v�QvNU xU ���� u�wS � QOswrat Oa� �tm �OQm sqa� �Q �tQi QN� �x�k C��F� Rr��w wQOv� ���UL wQO u�tR u� QO xm Qwr�D OQ�J� Q �OQ�O OwHw ���yh�mW C��F� QO xm OWx� �wQW �yh�mW uOQmQB ��Q� CW�O CmQW �y�v�QvNU QO w Ow� G� Q�tm

�OW pt�m C��F� lQDWt �xr�kt wO Q�WDv� �� w OQm Rr��w �� �Q�mty

xJN� Q�D

C����� Q ��Q� �rt ��xUU�wt x� u�DUrov� OW�t T�UL� xm Ow� �yp�U��yGr�m xm OW Q�PBu�mt� �v�tR xW�Ov� u�� jkLD �OQ�O R��v l� R�i wl �R�� CU�QD j� Q� R�* �D�v� QD Gr�m w u�HCvU Gr�m xS� wx� �G� Q�tmO�yvW�B u�HCvU Gr�m �OvOQm u�tD Q�m �wQW ��Q� �Q �er��t �+uwDw�vx � � v� t DN�U � � Qe G � Q �t m QO G r� m x � jra Dt ��yu�tR �wQ OQ mu�tR �xQ�H� ��Q� OvwB Q�Ry�� p�U � �D O�O pwk w OR�U� Qw�vt u��p�U Qy QO �OvwB Q�Ry �mtm O�yvW�B R�v �D�v� QD Gr�m �Ovm ltm��� Q utHv C��tL p��vOx� �OQm pw� p�U � �Q�H ��yxv� Ry ��Q�sw ra w �UOvyt ��yVywS B �QwW � � C�Q m �Pt w �LMS� uOv rx m �SERC� Science and Engineering Research Council�

EPSRC�� �m R�i sw ra w �UOvyt ��yVywS B �QwW lv ���Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council

T�U�� D x � p ��t xm �irDNt ��yx�oW v�O R� �QwW u �� �CU� xDiQo s� v��yO�yvW�B �UQQ� R� TB �OQm O�yvW�B CU�wNQO OvOw� ���� Q �xUU�wtxDiQ�PB G� Q�tm O�yvW�B OQm x�YwD �QwW �l� wQ�w w �OQwiUm � �wQ�v�O� �G� Q�tm�rolling grant� O�OtD p��k �xvq�U �xv�ywSB OvwB �%% pwk w OwWpB�� CmQW �Or��JD�Q�s��u� �� Qo �O � �� vt �O�O pw� p�U Q�yJ ��Q � �Q�uw DUv � Q B x�oW v�O C�Q�WD v� �G � Q �t m x�oW v�O C�Q�WD v� �u� DUro v���yG r� m �Q o �O u�QW� v w �Springer�Verlag� nqQ i Qo v � Q BW���Gonville and Caius College� Tw �� m w p �w v� o �CU ��Q mO� � v � ��Emmanuel and Jesus College� � U � a w p �w v� t�u�U ��ys DU �UwQ m � t C mQW ��Nu�eld Foundation� O r � i� vu�tD �Q �Qo�O dr��t �� G� Q�tm x�oWv�O w ��Sun Microsystems�

�OvOQm

w OW G� Q�tm x�oWv�O R� �WN� ��tUQ xUU�wt ��� Q�t�wv swO RwQ�tra COy w �Management Committee� C QOt ��yxD�tmC &tU x � x� D&� pm ��t QU �O vOW u�at u� �Steering Committee�

w �Q�opmW QO syt ��yC�YNW R� �m� �OQ�O�o QD�B w xUU�wt CU�� Q

��

Page 20: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

R� �Q xUU�wt �y ��Q �CU�y v� �xOya Q � C���� � Q �xOmW v�O R� Q�e��yxt�vQ� QO xm �v�Um �xty �Ovvm�t x�o � OvwW�t R�Q�� xm ���yQ�vC�UU�wt Qo�O QO xm OvwW�t j� wWD Ovvm�t CmQW xUU�wt COtR�QO��Q� �OvW�� C�UU�wt u�� u�ty�t �y�Dwm COt �� OvyO� Q�v�tU u�DUrov�pLt u�t��D C�rw�Ut w OR�OQB�t �Q QiU �xv� Ry xUU�wt ���yQiU u�vJu�� p�yUD Qw�vt x� �CU� u�� R�t �xUU�wt �� Qo�O ��yxv� Ry w Ct�k�xDiy wO R� V�� xm xUU�wt ��yxt�vQ� QO u�oOvvmCmQW R� �DUQyi Q�mu�WCt�k� �� � v�QvNU � � T � QO D x � p ��t w Ov v�t�t u� DUro v� QO�xwLv w �VywSB �w�wt �Ct�k� u�tR x� �w� Qt C�aq�� �� x�Qty OvDUy�� u�Qw�Wt �rt C��y �OwW�t RwQx� w �Q�Oxov xUU�wt QO ��yv� �� T�tDu�� �CU� xOQm Q�QkQ� R�v �Ovw�B wQ�v�O� QO ���� Q swra �rrtr�u�� RmQtCiQW�B ��Q� w OvQo�Om� ptmt xm OvQ�O R��tDt ���yhOy xUU�wt wOCw�a �xt�vQ� �Ovvm�t �Q�mty Qo�Om� �� u�DUrov� QO C����� Qx � x v�ywS B CN�OQ B � � �Junior Membership� uwH uQoWywS B

�Ovvm CmQW xUU�wt ��yxt�vQ� QO OyO�t u�mt� �yv� x� u�wH u�QoWv�OQ�RoQ� G� Q�tm R� uwQ�� ���yx�oQ�m V��yxt�vQ� �� ���DQ� QO xUU�wt� � xOvyOu�tR�U u �� �OQ�O �rLt ��xOvyOu�tR�U �qwtat x m Ov m�t��yxt�vQ� �CU� ���DQ� QO xUU�wt OwN w xt�vQ� �tra �xOvyOu�tR�U��� � Q u tH v� O� � x � �Spitalelds� RO r � ip� D � BU� �xRwQl �utHv� �Q�mty �� x�ox�x�o �Ow� uOvr ���� Q utHv� ���v xm ROr�ip�D�BU�xS� wx� ���� Q �xat�H uOQmx�o � ViOy w OwW�t Q�RoQ� uOvr ���� QCU� �Y�N �xt�vQ� �xv�tR QO �yCiQW�B u� QDxR�D R� �QDmO u�� wHWv�O�� xUU�wt ��yQ�v�tU �xty �OwW�t Q�RoQ� u�tRsy xUU�wt QO xm�OQ�o�t Q�Qk xty TQDUO QO xm�W QO xUU�wt x�o��B QO w OwW�t �� w�O� w�xOvQ� �� �p� wv �xR��H �xOvQ� � �ROr�i p�Ot �xOvQ� �# uwvm �DCmQW xUU�wt ��yxt� vQ � QO p �� �xR ��H �xO vQ � � w �h rww �xR ��H

�Ov�xOQm

��� Q swra RmQtQ� vm ��yu�tR QO ��� � Q swra ��Q � �O �OH RmQt ��Q � x� rw� Q�m�O�UQ u���B x� Q�t�UO QO w OW �wQW ���% QO uwDw�v �xUU�wt

RwQt�

VywSB ��Q� u�DUrov� �rt �xUU�wt x��Ft x� RwQt� uwDw�v l �R�� �xUU�wt�t� CU� Q�OQwNQ � �awvDt �r�t � ��vt R� xUU�wt �CU� C���� � Q QOxm CU� EPSRC O �Ot Dp ��k �x v�ywS B Rwvy u� Ot�QO ��vt u � Q Dsyt�v�� R�� pwtWt p�U xU Qy w xDWPo p�U QO OvwB uw�r�t�)% RQt R� uwvm �

�CU� u���Dty

w C��F D Qw�vt x � �ESPRC R� �D��y O �OR� � R� T B ���� p�U QOu�wva CLD �D��y ����� Q ��yVywSB QO xUU�wt ��rt Vkv VQDUo�CiQo pmW �National Advisory Board� uQw�Wt �rt C��yQO �Correspondents� u��Q �xm�W p�mWD u� C�Q�mD�� R� �m�CU� ���yVywSB �xa�W� ��Q� u�DUrov� C�UU�wt Q��U w �yx�oWv�Ox�o � xUU�wt ��yC�r�ai R� ���DQt �y��Q �OQ�o�t s�Hv� xUU�wt QO xm��yxOmWv�O xS� wx� u�Wx�oWv�O ��yxOmWv�O x� �v�UQ�q�� w OvwW�t

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 21: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

xUU�wt �CU��Uu� QDxOQDUo QO ���� Q swra x� xUU�wt xm xOw� u�� Q� OYk CUNv RwQ R�QOku� OQ�O Vkv �yv� QO C����� Q xm �twra �xQDUo �OR�OQB� VQ��aD�Q xty Ov�wD�tv pwtat ��yxR�Ov�wOL QO ��xUU�wt I�y xm CU� Qw�vyBpY� u�� xW�ty �WywSB ��y�w�wt Vv� Ro QO xH�Dv QO OyO VWwBxOvvmu��aD �Q��at w CU�v OwOQt V�B R� �w�wt I�y xm OwW�t C��aQ

�CU� �w�wt �tra C� Rtxm CU�av�wt Q� x�re uwDw�v �xUU�wt �xOta ��yhOy R� �m�wQ u�� R� �OvQw��t OwHwx� �yx�oWv�O QO �yxOmWv�O �Q�O� ��yQ�DN�U���xDWQu�� �x�vH xUU�wt ��yxt�vQ� u� wOD QO syt ��yxHw R� �m���yxv�tR w �yCQ�yt �� u�QoWywSB uOQw�syOQo ��vat x� �re� xm CU�yv�T�U� Q� �tra C��Oy �xD�tm ��DQD u��x� �CU� Cw�iDt Q��U� ��Q�m

"Ovm�t Q�m Q� R ��tvy�Q ��yQ��at

OwN�OwNx� �WywSB hrDNt ��yxv�tR R� u�QoWv�O uOQm�wrNt �hr��Ovv�wD� xty xm OW�� �mQDWt �xv�tR O��� xmr� CU�v R�t�C�kiwt

�Ovvm RmQtDt u� Q� �Q OwN Q�m

�OW�� xDW�O �U�U� w syt ���� Q ��wDLt O��� xt�vQ� Qy ���

�OW�� xDW�O C����� Q QO ��xOQDUo �xOwr�W O��� xt�vQ� Qy �G�

p t�W V ywS B �Q o �O �� yV v�O �Q� � U � O v v� t �C� ��� � Q QO�vqw� ��yxQwO xm CU� u� wv ��yxW�Ov� R� pY�L xOta ��y���WoxQuwDw�v �xUU�wt xmu�� ��Q� �OQ�O p��vOx� �Q �yOQw�CUO s�mLD w C��FDQO � ��WoxQ Q�oQO xm CU� sRq O v�t � �k� � Qw�w v w syt �RmQt O v�wD �xm �Hv� R� �OQ�Po �w u�Qo�O x� �Q s�mLD w C��FD Q�m w OW�� Vv�O ��yRQtQO �v�tR xJu� OvwW�t ��NDv� p�k p�U xU �D wO R� xUU�wt ��yxt�vQ�u��Q��v� �Ow� Oy�wNv u�vJ xt�vQ� �wQW s�ovy QO ��twRr CU� xOw� Vv�O RQtQ�O��B �q�tDL� u�W�wvD w C�ty� xm CU���yxv�tR ���NDv� �VwQ u� QDy�xm O� RoQ� O��� �Q �v�Q�yQ �WywSB ��y�w�wt ��Q� u�vJsy Ov�t Oy�wN��yx�vH w �oR�D �t� �OvyO jiw u� wv ��yxW�Ov� �� �Q OwN �OvDx� Ovv�wD���w�wt �OvW�� C�i�m QDsyt Q��U� Q��at ���D O��� �w�wt ��xDWQu��QU�QU R� �Q u�QoWv�O w �yu�O���� Q u� QDy� �PH ���v�wD O��� ���NDv�

�OW�� xDW�O u�yHCi�� QO �Q u� O��� �t� Ovm�t pta �v�yH T��kt QO xUU�wt xJQo�xty xm CU� u�� xUU�wt R� �a��� Q��Dv� w CiQo Q�v QO u�DUrov�xDW�O Q� QO R�v u�DUrov� ���� Q �xat�H ��Q� ��xO�iDU� u� ��yxt�vQ�OwQ�t Q��Dv� OvW�� �wk X�N ��xv�tR QO u�DUrov� u�QoWv�O Qo � "OW��OvW�� h�a� Qo � w �Ovvm �R�� xOta Vkv xv�tR u� x� �w� Qt ��yxt�vQ� QO�WRwt� ��yxQwO w Ovm ltm xv�tR u� QO �yv� R�QD uOQ�q�� x� O��� xt�vQ�

�CW�O Ovy�wN �U�U� �Wkv u�� wHWv�O w u�wH u�QoWywSB ��Q�

��Q�v l� R�i w �OQ� Q�m C����� Q ��yxOmWv�O �xv�N uwvm � �tDHt u��Qwt uwOQwo w �D� �xv�N��Dm w ����� Q Q�t� w ZLt C����� Q �xOmWv�OptDWt uw�r� w�B Ciy QO �Q ���� Q xwQo � w CU� G� Q�tm x�oWv�O QO�RmQt �v�tDN�U ��yx�Q R� �yQDiO u�� �CU� xO�O ��H Q�m QDiO �! Q�

�Ov��DQt sy x� OQ�O Q�Qk u�tR K�U Q� R u� R� �WN� xmuOvr �wQDt ��yQDUwB

�xUU�wt QO ���yQDUwB �� C����� Q �v�yH p�U �� p�U ��xDW�Po V��tv x� uOvr �wQDt ��yQ��k QO x�t x� x�t xm OW �L�Q� uwDw�vOQ� Q�m w Ow� �oOvR �� C����� Q ���DQ� uO�Ou�Wv �yQDUwB R� hOy �OW�r�t w ��vi ��DU� R ��m� R�i swra ��yxN�W R� �Q��U� QO �Q C����� Qx� �yQDUwB u�� ��yxawtHt �D ��yp�U �� �OQm�t u���tv

QO �yQDUwB uwvm �D u�tR u� R� w CiQo Q�Qk �yu�DUQ��O Q��DN� QO u�o��Q�Ov�xOW Qy�� ���tv�U w �vw� R� wrD ��ysr�i R� �Q�tW R� ���yxvLYQO �yQDUwB OwN w xJ��Dm u�� w xOW xDWwv �yQDUwB KQW QO ��xJ��Dm

�Ov�xDiQo Q�Qk VwQi ZQatxUU wt OQor�U u�tyO

w CiQo uWH �Q OwN T�U��D OQor�U u�tyO xUU�wt p�U QO�� x��wS QO u��y�oWv�O uWH �OQm Q�RoQ� Qw�vt u�� x� �Y�N sU�QtO�OH T��Q s�kt QO s�yov�m u�H Q �U �v�QvNU u�rw� w �v�QvNU Q�yJQO �vU xwQo xU ��Q� �twta ���Nt ��Q� sU�Qt �OW Q�RoQ� uwDw�v RmQtw u�wH u�mOwm xrtH R� Qiv OY OwOL s�Om Qy QO w Ow� xOW xDiQo Q�v

�OvOQm CmQW u�v�wHwv

�� ���� u�DUtR

Page 22: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

xUU�wt �D�aq�� x�o��B�v�Wv QO uwDw�v l �R�� �xUU�wt �D�aq�� x�o��B R� ��DOta q�� �r��t

http���www�newton�ac�uk

�� ve w C kO x� o �� B u �� � r�H C� m v R� �m � �CU� xOW x DW�OQ ��xLiY p�Ft ��Q� �OyO�t Q�Qk xOvvmO�OR�� Q��DN� QO xm CU�D�aq��http���www�newton�ac�uk�generalinfo�html

CUQyi x� �OvQ�O R��v xUU�wt u�v�ty�t xm CU�D�aq�� �xty �xOvQ�OQ� QO"��U�rov� ���ir� ��DQDx�� O�vm xHwD CU� xOt� B VN� QO xm ��r��t

�Q�Oxov �wQOwN uOQmx��Qm �xNQJwO �xUU�wt QO �vqw� QwL sOa�xUU�wt QO Ct�k� M� Q�D Q��eD ��QDw�Bt�m C�v�mt� ���J w xwyk �u�mOwm��y�v�wD�v x� �w� Qt Qwt� �OwW s�Hv� O��� xUU�wt lQD s�ovy xm �Qwt���RwUVD� ��r�t C��tL �Q��tv �OwQw CQ�m w O�rm �u�rwrat w �tUH�u�wH u�QoWywS B �xt � � �xUU�wt C�aq�� �u� t r �t �x � rw� ��ylt m��yxt� vQ � ��Q�Oy � �Q�y� v ��yQ�v�tU w � v�QvNU �A� DAr ��yQ Dw�Bt�m��BmwDwi �nv�mQ�B �Q�m QDiO �u�ty�t u�OvtWv�O w �yOQ�wxR�D XwYNt��Q� TQ�Ot �u�� wHWv�O �Ci�� R�� �C�Q�WDv� w Cq�kt �xvwtvV�B �CUBp��Uw w Q� QLD sR�wr ��WRQw C�v�mt� �Q�o�U �C�vt� �u�v�ty�t u�OvRQi�G� Q�tm x�oWv�O ��yQ�v�tU w �v�QvNU ��virD C�tr�mt MQv �uirD ��QDiO

�u�DUrov� Qo�O ��yx�oWv�O R� O�OR�� ��R� w ��Dt�k sR�wr

Qy QO �CU� Q�eDt x�t % � D xDiy ! u� � xUU�wt ��yxt� vQ � pw�O v�w D�t s�Om Qy xm CU� �Q�RoQ � p�L QO xUU�wt QO xt� vQ � wO u�tR�yV ��ty �Q Dx� Dw m ��yx� oQ� m �OW� � x DW�O xOv v mC mQW Qi v CU� � � DxO�O u�tR�U xt� vQ � R� �WN � CQwYx � R � v ��xQ�wy�t ��yCUW v w

�OvwW�tCUWv wO sra C��Oy �xD�tm ��O�yvW�B ��yxt�vQ� �UQQ� ��Q�OvwW �UQQ� CUWv wO u�� R� �m� QO �yO�yvW�B xmu�� ��Q� �OQ�O xvq�UCQwY QO �yxt�vQ� �OvW�� xOW x��Q� x��wS �� �� x� wv�S �� R� p�k �D O���jiwt ��yO�yvW�B �OW Ovy�wN Q�RoQ� Oa� p�U xU �D wO u�� �� wYDpmW xUU�wt T��Q w u�oOvvmO�yvW�B u�� wowCio Ov��Qi �� �qwtatCUWv l� R� V�� QO ���yv �� wYD R� V�B CU� umtt w OvQ�o�tOQm x��Q� xUU�wt x� �D�tOkt �O�yvW�B u�wD�t xH�Dv QO �OvwW �UQQ��Q O�yvW�B ���yv pmW �tra C��Oy �xD�tm C�Q�v Ci�� QO R� TB w

�OQm XNWtpmWDt �t�D �xOya Q� xt�vQ� Qy �yOu�tR�U w �tra �R� Qxt�vQ�Q�OQwNQ � R� v � DQwWt ��xD�tm ltm R� �y�o xm� CU� Qi v ! � � � R�QFm �OL� �O�Qi� xJ Ovvm�t x�YwD xm OvDUy u�oOvyOu�tR�U ��CU�w COtx�Dwm ��yx�oQ�m �R� Qxt�vQ� w Ovvm CmQW xt�vQ� QO �Qiv CU���xOya Q� R�v �QDW�� O�Qi� CwaO u�mt� ��� xt�vQ� �� �DQt ��yV��ty

�CU�yv�

� �

� �

uwDw�v �xQ�� QOxv G� Q�tm QO w OQm�t Vwt�Qi �Q R�J xty OW�t jQe �tra Q�mi� QO xm �t�ovy �CU� O�� R u�DU�O uwDw�v �DQBT�wL �xQ�� QO�OvQ�Qk u�� R� �yu�DU�O �NQ� �OQm�t �Q xO�iDU� p�tm C�a�w u�� R� w O�� R ��yC�rw�Ut xv w Ovw�W� wN xv w CW�O �vW� w CUwO

jQe x�Q u��t QO �t� �OvWwv� �D OQw��� �R�J u�W��Q� xv�N ���OQU R� �D Cio lQD �Q s�W R�t �O�O�t s�W Vv�DUwO �NQ� x� uwDw�vu����N x� xOQmv uD x� pt�m �Q �yT��r �y�o �CiQ �U�rm x� w OQm uD x� �Q V��OQ �OQm Vwt�Qi �Q Vv�v�ty�t w Q�m w OW OwN Q�mi�u�yo �v OR�t sOk d�� QO xm �t�ovy �re� �CWo�tR�� xv�N x� u�otQW w ��DW �� OW�t x�o � OwN ��w R� �Dkw w CiQ�tl� �OQm�t uDWwv x� �wQW xO�DU�� Ot��t VDUO sO xm �Pe�m u�rw� �wQ w CiQ�t Vk�D� x� u���DW TBU �O�DU���tQ�wU xQ�� wO xm OOQo�tQ� ZQ�wa CN�OQB ��Q� w OUQ�t xBD �q�� x� �Dkw �OwQ� q�� ��xBD R� �D Ow� xOW xO��B V�U� R� Q���OW�� xOW xHwDt uwDw�v xmu���CU� xOQm �yQ Q�Ui� R� �Q OwNuDiQq�� s�ovy�U� �OQ�OCUO QO �Q Q�Ui�ki xm Ov���t w OwWV�U�

!�vtSteven G� Krantz� Mathematical Apocrypha� MAA� Washington� DC ������� ��

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 23: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

VtU� Ovm�t Qwy u�Qw��v d� QO xm �D�vk u�� O�v�O�t �tW��Ov�xDWwv �J V�q� O��xO�O �CU�Hm �Vy�JQO�t w CU�J

�wDwxD O��� ��tDL q�L �D �y�y�oWywSB xm s�OQm QmiTB �Ov��w�mHvm py� sra py� xm s�Ow� xO�vW sy �t�MU�B QO u���k� �s�OQm C�LY u�W��DOvJ �� �OvW�� xOQw� QO CU� u�Qw��v ��L QO VQy�t xm �Q �D�vkCU�wN u�WrO xJQy �OH w �NwW w OvDi�� u�tU� Q x� �Q u�tU� �t �xO�U w K� QY p�wU �D wO �m�C�aq�� O�y�wN� �D �rw �OWv u�tQ�oDUO C�vk u�� �xQ�� QO ��xR�D R�J I�y xD�r� QN� CUO �OvDioh�kw� �xQ�O� �x�W u�Or�QY�vlH�rt �wv�i �xLiY �wU�m�B�W�kv p��k R� ���yxO�OB �xQ�� QO�� Q��

s� Qw��t �ywoDio M� Q�D ��DQD x� �Q �y��wH �s�OQm �Qw�tH �twDv�wm l�v�mt w �C�v�Q�tW

�QwYvt ��QV�q�� �xDWwv x� �xDW�O OwHw s�Ok �r�N R� xm xOw� �D�vk u�� xm s�xO�vW

�O���t xwm hQ� R� p�L Qy x� �xv�iU��Dt s�xOw� xHwD�� sy

V��vat �tW Q�v x� u�� �CU� �� u�tU� xm xOW xOvm Q�w�O �wQ�CU�J

�Q u�tU� w u�tR �� �qFt �va� �CU� �v�� R �s�y�� QwHm� O��W u���p��k u�� R� w CU� ��� u�tU� �nvQ �qFt �� �xOQmQB

�va� �OQ�O nvQ Qot �CU� x� �UDvt u�tU nvQ �va��CU� �ovQ H�O O���tQi�t

�Qo�O OUQ�t Q�v x� ��� �� QO �wD �qFt OwW�t �tH xm ��� �rw �xv

�xm CU� R�U Ov�wo�t l�D�� QO ��� QO �rw

�CU� ��� �� �CU� R�U �� xm Ov�xDiov Ckw I�y �t �C���O� �wD

�Ov�O� �Q C�vk u�� �xJN� Q�D xm OW�� �Um �yQ� wQwO u�� O�vm�t Qmi

�Ovv�O� u�W�y�a�CU�umtt�t�Ok ��y�v�Q�tW�q�tDL� �svmv u�to

�uwvtt �r�N

!uqOQ O�yQiR� �t��a sDU�U ��yC�vk R� �m� �O���t xwm R� q�� u� R� xOa�kr��ra��CU���� u�tU� xOW xDWwv �� wo sy Vq�� �xOw� u�Q�tW QO xmCU�yC�vk

�CU� C�vk OwN �CtOk x� xDWwv u�� O�vm�t Qmi�OvW�� xOQm T��Dk� �QyBU ��QyU ��yQaW R� ��Oa� svm�t Qmi �xv

�CU� �� u�tU xm �J �va� �CU�J VD�U�vtu�WOwYkt O�q �OvU� wv� �ovWk R�J l� Ov�xDU�wN �Qw� u�ty

�OwW�t xO�O �� QO u�tU� xm CU� u���u�tU �� CU� V��DU �tW Q�v x� u�� � �N

pmW x� Qvy py� xm xOw� �Da�tH �CUO �qkv� R� p�k �Hv�� �sv�O�tvu�WOwN �Q�m �yxtUHt u� pFt sy �yxDWwv u�� O��W �Ov�xOw� VvQOtxm CU� �QyBU QaW u�ty R� �DW�OQ � sy xDWw v u �� xm sDio �OW� �

s�vRv CUO �Q �� O� wo�tR� p�L Qy QO �s�vmv p �o� �Q xm Ow� xOQm O�yvW�B Qa�W ��Qy��

�sQmWDt �r�N �tW

��Q�y� �QOtLt V��Q� w �s��B�� nv �H R� xDiQoQ� �

Page 24: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

Qa�W xmv�� q�L �OvQ�O sy R� OvQ�O �J Qy� �k�w QO u�tU w TB�qFt �� �� ��J �va� �� u�� �CU�v �O�B C��� �xQyJ� O�wo�t

�CU� Vt�Q�

�xrwkt u�� CU� ���Ha R�J �Ha �k� �CU� Vt�Q� xmv�� pFt xr�sHL �� Ow� xO�Wm �R�J l� V�B Ckw �r�N �CU� V�kv svR ut �nvQ

�sDiQo Q�Qk Q�F��D CLD �r�N ut w ���xtQU nvQ R� �t��al� x� sDW�O ut V�B Ckw OvJ �nvQ CU� ��r�H �xrwkt ��ak�wCkO �� �Q �wiY QYa V�kv O�Ry� O�DU� �t�Ok ��yQwD��v�t �D�U�vtq�� xQPl� xm O�O OwW�t �Hv �CU� ���ewe xJ xm sO�O w sOQm�t x�ov�qFt �Ovm Zwa �Q VD�y�t Ov�wD�t QOkJ �ovQ l� COW QO u���B w�xO�Wm �r�v �xv�tR QO �qFt O�DU� xm �WN� Vt�Q w l�W �R�U l�OwW�t �v�DUm �B ��yuw�t�m �wQ xm �rPD�t ��vtJ �R�U l� �� VDw�iD

�CU� ur�UB� l� �ki O�O

x� C�Uv w Ca��� x� C�Uv �Q sO� w OyO�t Vt�Q� �qwY� �W�kv�yV�kv xm �a�RDv� u�� XwYN� �Ovm�t j�kO ��W� x� C�Uv �qm w nvQl� O� QO�t sOw� xDiQ ut �CU� Q�PoQ�F��D Q��U� �y�o Ovvm�t C�ak�w R��CU� xDiQo �Q �U� l� �xvyO ��xJ� QUB u� QO xm sO�O wU�m�B R� �� wr��D�yCr�L w �ynvQ xm T� �svR� wv�R wr��D u�� �wrH Ow� l�ORv O�vm Qw��xm nvWk QOkv� �sO�O �DNQO CWOQqm QO sy �Dkw l� �Ow� Q�PoQ�F��DCNQO u�� �RmQtDt w pt�m ������ R �Ovvm VW��DU xm Ow� xOW xO� Qi� Q�ov�

�sDio�t �y�o s��yTqmQU �Q u�� ut �xDU� Vkv ut uyP QO u�vJtyq�L �CU� �ak�w CUy Ov�wo�t sra QO xm ���y����� R u�� ���CU� xOW xDio xm u�vJ �Q�PoQ�F��D �r�N ��y����� R ��ak�w�va� �s�v�tOwN

�OQ�O OwHw sy C����� Q QO �qm w �yuQ�kD w CqO�at QO �qFt�va � C� � � �mQ D �s�DUy � D� � � �mQ D �tC����mQD QO ��y�vDt ��yxawtHt C����� QR �J xty �OQ�O v OwHw �qY� �C ��y v� � ut xm �rmW u�� QO �O�v��� �CU� Twtrtx� �CU� N l� �yv�� R� s�Om Qy �sWm�t�D Ciy �Hv�� �xawtHtQ� R s�� wo�t �yv��QO N �D xU Qy�x�kv �D Ciy w CUy N

u�� �Ov�N l� �wQ x�kv �D xU Qy w Ovvm�t ��k �Q Qo�Oty x�kv l�VtU� �xOW hWm p�L x� �D xm CU� ���� Q s�UH� u� QD��� R R� �m�X�wN QOk v� u �� �xOW hWm V� B p�U OY w CU� �w v�i �xLiY Cm�iQ�B Qwv�H u�� QO R�J xty �OQw��t QO M�W sO� xm OQ�O ����� R w OOaDt

�OW�� Ov�wD�t �Qo�O R�J xJ QD��� R u�� R� ��N �CU��O�vm�t V��DU CWOQqm CNQO u�ty pFt ��ak�w sy �Q �yv��

�Q �yv �� Tqm QO Ckw Qy ut �CU� Q D�H�w VW ��DU �qY� u ��xty u�� xm OwW�tv u�WQw�� �y�a� xm s���t OHw x� u�vJ s� wo�tx� �qY� pt�mD R� xHQO u�� x� �R�J �CU� pmW u�ty ��Q� haW w QwW

!�y�WwQUN ��Qtqesy �D�aw��t w �D�e�r�D �xO�iDU� �DL �t �CU� ��� u�tU� u�� R� xr�

�sv�O�tv �Q C�vk �Uv w pY� �rw �s��xOQm�CU� �� u�tU Ov�xDWwv �J ��Q�

��� OW��v �oOwr� Qo � �va� �CU� ��� ��tDL l �B �u�tU� �va��xv Qo�O CU� C�vk Qy�t �Hv��

�CUy �N� Q�D C�vk �D wO �Hv�� CU� xwm �q�� xm C�vk Qy�t ���� xv�yhQ� u� w �Da� QW u����N R� sy Qo�O �m� w CU� u�ty V��m�q�L x m Ow � xO �O ��U� �QOk wQ Dt uOv m �kwt s�xO� vW x m �OQP o�tQ��m� w xOWv ��k xm CU� p�U CU�� �t C�vk u�� �rw �Ov�xOQm VDUQO

�s��xOQm sy V��� wQq�CU� Q �W p��k hwQat pwk x� V�

xO�iDU� Ov�xDio �t x� �Ovvm�t Pwiv u� x� �v�tR wQ ��y�� �� wo �xv�s�vmv

�CU�J xDWwv u C�U�vt xm O�Diov�CU� �QyBU ��QyU R� �D�� l� sOQm Qmi Vrw� ut �s� wo� �J

O��� �QyBU �Q C�U�vt�� �rw nvWk R�J Qy Ovvm�t Qmi xty �QJ�Q�� s�xv�N� ��H x� �qFt uwJ ��iQL l� O��wo� �t�v R�� �OW�� xDio

�CU� �� u�tU O�wo� �r�k u�ty �wD xDUv�wD�t CU�x� �ut Q�v x� CU� ��rwUwU �tm l� uwJ OQwN�tv �t�v x� �xv

�CU� �� QO u�tU� T�mav� VQw�vt sy O��W �OQ�O s�y�� p�L Qy�CU� C�Uv ��� V���� �� �Ov�wo�t xm ��� �nvQ u�� �qY��CU�nvQ�� xm Ov�xDio �QJTB ��tW Q�v x�CU� x� wUvt�va�

�CU�v nvQ�� xm �y�� QO �wD OwW�t xDW��v� xm ��� �rwOvJ O�vm�t Qmi �tW �qY� �CU� �v�tU � �k�w QO Ovmv TBQmi V�q�� �xDWwv w C�vk u�� x� �q�k CU� umtt u�Dv�Q�mty pm R� Qiv

�OvW�� xOQmI�y w s��xOW OQ u�� �wrH R� �t p�U xty u�� xm CU� �r�H �r�N"sDio xv�kO�Y sDUv�O�t xJ Qy ut p�L Qy QO �s��xOQmv Qmi Vy� Ckw

�OW�� ��� xm OQ�Po�tv �oOwr� �CU�v �rw OW�� ��� O��� u�tU��CU� �ovQ xJ V� xQNq�� �O��xO�O Twv��k� xty u�� xm �tW

�Q �� �Qo�O hQ� R� �rw �CU� �Ow�m Cio OwW� O��W �CU�v sO��u�tU� Tma u�� �tW pwk x� O��W TB CU� nvQ�� �R� Q� xm u�w�r �wD

�Ovm�t V���� w ODi��t �� �wD xm CU��Ovvm uWwQ u�OvtWv�O �Q u�tU w �u�DU��xO� u�� CU� wN

xm sy u�tU� �CU� �� u�tR sQ�yJxU �O�v��� �CU� l�Dv�tQ �r�N�� ��� �wD OwW�t Tmavt VovQ w xOQDUo u�tR �wQ �Q VD��tL �QDJ�CU� �r�H �r�N u�DU�xO� u�� w �u�tU� x� ODUQi�t O�wt �y xm sy

�Ovvm xQ�W� l�v�oQ� �x���Q u�� x� xm s�xO�Ov sy C���O� �wD ut

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 25: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�va� xYqN �CU� �Qo�O pLt QO xD�r� �qai xm CUQB QU�� u�QDNO ��Q��CU� h�kw� �xQ�O� �p�t u�tR u�� xm

V��Otm xHw �� QDW�� �t xm �mH�rt u�� xm CU� �r�H �r�N�OW�� xOw� sy �yhQL u�� w p�YLD x� ltm w hkw py� �s���vW

xOw� �v�DUQ�t�� s�Ok QO ���yp�U l� QO u�tR u�� QO p�L Qy QOw Ovvm�t � � QN D �qk v� R� p�k � r�U OvJ �Q u� DUQ�t� � u �� �CU�

�OwW� xmrt QDiO xOw� Q�Qk xm OvR�U�t u� QO �Q �rai u�tDN�U�xOw� �v�Q�� VQ�tat

xOQm �L�Q� sy �Q QY�at ��yQvy �xRwt xm CU���O VQ�tat �xr��Dkw �xOw� �wryB O��v� VQ�m�L�Y xD�r� �CU� xUv�Qi QO �� wo uq� w�qkv� R� Oa� �Ow� xOW s�tD u�tDN�U Q�m R� OYQO �� OwOL OW �qkv��xUU�wt x� OW Q�Po �w �wryB O��v� �p�wt� �x�k� �� x�Qty u�tDN�U u���rt �x v�N �� Dm Q� � DN� QO �Q u� sy xUU�wt u �� w �ovyQi �C�a r��tC�ar��t �xUU�wt Oa� �CiQo �Q �Hv�� R� �WN� sy x�oWywSB �CW�Po�Q�OxQ�H� �k�w QO x�oWywSB u�� w �v�Uv� swra x�oWywSB x� OW p�O�D

�Ow� u�kDt �xUU�wt�CU�Hm O�Dio xm V�xUQOt u w xUU�wt u�� uq�

u�DUQvy w ��QwytH u����N OwOL �CU� u�QyD RmQt QO ���H l�uq� �s�DW�O �yv� �� �D�UrH w �Hv� s�xDiQ Q��m� ut �OQ�O sy ��xv�QDNOQO s� Q�O u�kDt �� �t xm ��xQ�H� O�OQ�Qk j�� �k�w QO u�Qw��v u�tDN�U u��

�CU� x�oWywSB Q��DN�xJ C�vk �q�� �xrtH u xm O��wo� Ow� Q�Qk �CiQ u�DO�� xmv�� pFt

�OQ�O �vat�rw sOv�wN�t sOW�t OQ �Hv� R� Ckw Qy ut xm CU� �ovWk �xrtH�CU� xDWwv �Q u� ��xv�Qa�W O�O �� xm Ov�O�t �Um u�ty O�q �Q VD�U�vtV��DU u�� �OW�� xDW�O �Qw�vt l� O��� xQNq�� sy xv�Qa�W O�O q�L

�u�tU �� CU� u�tU� QO CU� �� T�mav� �va� �Qo�O CU� �� R� u�tU� nvQ �Nu�tU� �� CU� �� py� u�tU� �va� �OQ�O s�y�� �qY� �Ovm�t ��� �Q u� xm

�OQm Q��aD OwW�t VwO Qy x� �CU� ����O��xO�O u�QyD QO �� u�tU ��ak�w �tW q�L�Ow� ��� �qt�m �RwQwv Cq��aD u�ty QO xr�

�y xm OwW� wN QOkv u�Wa�w u�QyD sOQt hYv svm�t wRQ ut�Ovv��� �� �Q u�tU �s�Ok pFt �Ovv�wD� Qo�O hYv �D OvwQ� QiU x� OvDOvDOw� �� xW�ty u�QyD u�vm �U �u�tU �Dkw l� �rw �O���v u�DO�� O��W �tW

�RwQwv u�WRwQ Qy w

!�aiQ uOrs�ULQmi xm �v�Q�mty R� C�vk u�� �xQ�� QO ���yR�J l� pw� ��yp�U u� ut

�ON xm OW�� �DWy� R�J l� O��� u�� �CU�v ��v�tR u�� xm O���t Q�vw Ovvm�t CUQO u�� R� O�m Ov���t �k� �CU� xDW�Po R�Q w RtQ u� QO QOkv��xJ x�kv �D Ciy w N �D Ciy u�� �wD QN� �OwW�t pt�m Om Ovv���tu� QO R�J xty �rw �CU� xO�U �UOvy pmW l� u�� �CUy �RtQ�DL �CU�v ����� R R�J OQ�O xm �vQ�kD xty u�� �� xQ�m �qFt �� �CU� �tH��yR�J l� xm CU� �DtmL xJ u�� �CU� Qw�CQ�L sy xQ��O ����� RsDio xm wU�m�B �wr��D u�ty �qFt �Ovvm �kr� sy �Q �y�vDt�v Ovv�wD�t �y�vDtw nvQ u�vJ �� ��� R O�iU �U� l� Q�vm QO dwr� uU QO ��xJ� QUB ��Ca��� �xOy�Wt �wv u�� �CU� Q��v�� ��ak�w xm OQ�O �vw�U� RwBtm u�vJ�yv�� �CUwU�m�B pFt ���ysO� XDNt xwmW�� �p(�ND u�� w u� R� ��RDv� wEr�F u�wN� xm �v�ty �C�kqN �u� �OyO�t CUO u�Uv� x� xm CU� �D�v��� OW�� QaW QO xm Ovm�tv jQi q�L ���D(w�v ��yx�Lr CU� xDio Vy�

�C����� Q QO �� �W�kv QO�CU� �ywmW�� R�J QW� O��wo� O�y�wN�t sy �tW Ovmv

�ut Q�v x� CU� Q��v��p��k �y�o uOw� Q��v�� w uOw� xwmW�� u�a QO xm CUy umtt ��

��OW�� sy sLQD CUy umtt p�L Qy QO �rw �VtO� x� OQ�O �oDU�

QOkv xm sQmWDt �r�N �rw �sW�� �OH sDUv�wDv xm O�WN�� �r�Nu�Qw��v C�vk R� �QwH xJ sOWv xHwDt �qY� xOv� xm O�Dio �r�H ��yR�J

�s�O�UQ O�R�tO xwmW x�

!Ck�kL ��QOtLC�vk u �� � � �t xm � ��QH� CqmWt p�rO x � �t� �s v�O�t v �Q V�xk ��UOQ x�oWywSB R� C�vk xN�W �D wO �O�v��� �sDiQo O�� ���yR�J l� s�DW�O�t Q�� wO �m� �CUy �� nQR� ��vt l� sy u�Qw��v nv�mQ�B Q� R �OwW�t��yu�mD sv�O�tv QF� Q� �yC�vk u�� �Dkw xm s�OW wQ� wQ pmWt u�� ���oQR� ��yxQiL Q� R u� �OwW� OwOUt u�W�yQ�Ut Qo�O R�J Qy �� u�tRxD�r� xm �OW sy VR� Q x� QHvt w OvOQm ��ak�w Q�� wO �m� xm Ovvm�t O�rwD

�s�OQm u�WDUQO�OvQ�O xQ�e w xWkv w xt�vU�vW �OvQ�O sy sUQ w sU� �yC�vk u��

�r�UmWN u� R� Oa� �OvW�� xDW�O O��� �rw sv�O�tv �Q u�WtU� utw j��vt u�� QO uOR x�J x� OQm �wQW wQ�v CQ�Rw Ot� V�B u�QyD QO xm�yv�� R� OvQ�O ��Qy�� w Ovvm xO�iDU� sy �yC�vk u�� R� xm �t d�QU OvOt�w xt�vU�vW �Ovvm�t sy xO�iDU� u�QyD ��Q� �� xQ�e w x�iYD R� Oa� xD�r� ��

�sv�O�tv �Q u�WxJN� Q�Dw x�oWywSB R� p�k �QwJ h�Q�� u ��yu�tR w u�Qw��v d�� �xQ�� QO

��v�Um xJ p�t w xOw� �J �y�Hv�� �xQ�e w �rt �xv�N��Dmu�Or�QY�v �lH�rt �CU� �ikw u�tR l� u�Qw��v QO x�oWywSB �u�tRu�QyD QO ��xUQOt �� u�kDt �xv�QDNO �xUQOt ��Q� �xOQm hkw �Q u� x�W

�� ���� u�DUtR

Page 26: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

xty xm ���vat w CU� u�at�v �r�N TB �OwW�t xDU�m wQi �J x� Tm�Dkw xm CU� �twDv�wm l�v�mt pFt �OQ�Ov O�� R p�tDL� x� Ovvm ji�wD

�O� Q�o�t �Qo�O ��wH O�vm�t Q�QmD �Q V��tR�Qmi �tW �OW�� xDW�O �QDW��C�ak xm sUQB� �R�J l� O���TB

�CU� �� �va� �CU� C�Uv ��� ��� �QN ��� O�vm�t�qFt Vy� xty �t �xv�N �wD xm CUy ���ynvQ l� uq� �sv�O�tvVQ�iU R�U �Q Tv�Qivm h�m u�ty ���xwyk s� wo�t ut �rw R�U Ov� wo�t�QDuQOt �swyit �qm �ovQ�� swyit �sv���t ��xwyk �Q u� ut �rw Ov�xO�Ou�w�r ��� �rw CU� ��� Ov� wo�t �Q �� QO �� �O�UQB� sOQt R� Qo � �CU�

�CU� nvQ�� u�W��Q�u�tU w uOw� �� O�q TB �CU� �Qm�B wQO�� �xO�OB �Ha �tW Q�v x� q�L �CU� �� ��yGwt pw� �oOvm �QB Q�YkD V��oty�va� �OvwW� �� ��t�Rr� O��� �Di Q� R �yRwQ xm OvQ�O Q�N u�WOwN u�tU w�� Ovvm �wQ�B Ca��� C�QQkt R� xm OvQ�o�t s�tYD xv�y�o u�WOwN ��

�OwW�t p�tLD u�Wy���xQ�J �Ovvm�t Q�DiQ CUQO �q�tDL� �rw �m �va� sv�O�tv u�WOwN��wH sv�wD�tv ��Qy�� ut xm CU� CNU QOkv� �tW ��yp��wU u�� �OvQ�Ov

�syO�OQo �W s��xO�UQB u�WR� xm ���yv�� �wD q�L �D �tW �O�W��v u�Qov

�Q�Oyov�ON �O��pw�

u�W�y�a� �q�tDL� �sO�UQB OvW�� xDW�O �D�aq�� CU� umtt sOQm�t�s� wo� �tW x� xm CU�v �R�J svyP QO uq� �rw OvO�O sy ���y��wH

x�J w j�ta x�J sv�O�tv w C�vk w xtWJ jQi �qY� �tW �uwvtt �r�N�O�v�O�t �Q xQ�e w p�Uv�DB

�rw �CU�J xm sv�O�t sy �Q u� RDQ� x�J �sv�O�t ���yR�J l��s�xO�tyiv CUQO �Q R� Q�m w C�vk jQi O�y�wN� �Q VDU�Q

�OvW�� R�J l� u�W���DwO svm QmisU� �D wO �� �QJ TB sDio ��Oa� �rw sOQm�t Qmi Qw� u�ty sy utOR� OrwDt ut pFt Qo � sO� p�L Qy QO �sOW lwmWt w Ovvm�t V��OY

�CU�J C�vk xm Ov�O� O��� ��tDL OW���O�W�� xDW�O Q�N V�q�� �xDWwv R� xm sDU�v Q�wO�t� u�OvJ

��CU� ��� u�tU� �sQ�O Q�N�CU� �Q�N �xQ�Ro l� ��iQY �tW Q�v x� xrtH u�� ��

O��W �CU� xOw� �J u�WQw�vt xm O�UQB �Hv�� u�L�Q� R� O��� �Q u���j�ta ��wDLt xYqN �CU�� � R �oO vR xm Ov � wo � O v�xDU�wN�t sy

OQ�O �iUri��Q u�tU �� Ovm V��DU �Q CU� xDU�wN K�Q� �tW Q�v x� q�L

sy x�k u �� x � sDUy �DU � wD � Rw B sO� Q� �U � xm � ��H v� R� utQy uyP QO xO�OB u�� Gwt ���D xm O�O O��� �va� �svm�t x�ov �DU� wD� RwB

� �

� �

� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 27: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�yVQ�Ro w �yQ�N����� u�DUtR�

�uQ�U w x�oWywSB �s�yi �ra

Update on the progress of the object selection�

Trigger report�

�uQ�U w x�oWywSB �u��WN� Ot�L

Charge improvement and conversion rejection�

A progress report on electron charge mis�

identi�cation studies�

�uQU w x�oWywSB ��QiaH xO��a

The �� method to select the hadronic top in a t�t

event�

Electron e�ciency from tag � probe method in Z

events to semi�electronict � TeV t�t study�

Electrons in Trigger week�

�uQU w x�oWywSB ��rv R s Qt

Top mass reconstruction in semi electronic t�t events�

�uQUw x�oWywSB �xORQiY pwD�

Two methods of background estimation for hadronic

search with top �nal states�

�uQU �AB lwr

Scenario for startup�

�yQo�DW w C�QP �xOmWywSB�oDiy �vQvNU w Q�v�tU �

�x�oWywSB �sU�k u�UL

Bunch lengthening e�ects by utilizing a third harmonic

cavity in conjunction with deecting cavities in TPS�

��m� Qt� ��ww��� �Dr��� x�oWv�O �utDB�y u�H

New ideas for big detectors in high energy physics�

�u�QyD �C�k�kLD swra x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �xORQiY pwD�

Hadronic search for SUSY in top �nal states at CMS�

�x�oWywSB ��wkD xt��i

Do we really say goodbye to the large gluon

polarization in the nucleon

�x�oWywSB ��OtLt ��DHt

Status of CMS experiment�

CMS xwQo �oDiy Q�v�tU �

�uQ�U w x�oWywSB ��OtLt xrrO�a

Particle ow algorithm�

Tau identi�cation and isolation�

Trigger report�

Page 28: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

QDw�Bt�m ��v�� �oDiy Q�v�tU �

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �Kr�Y l���

Monocular �D human�body shape estimation�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O ���v u�at

Learning actions from the web�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��DQHy uULt

Probabilistic latent semantic analysis �PLSA in the

context of text processing�

��O�v�m �wDvQwD x�oWv�O ��RwQwv OtLt

Max�margin output prediction and two vision

applications�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��kO�Y u�t

Parallel processing using MATLAB�

��tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O ��Q�oDUQ OtLt

Fast object detection in large�scale object database�

������ �ra s�UL w h � QW �DavY x�oW v�O �QwB��m �O�y OtLt��tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O

Boosting method for transfer learning�

x�U�Lt w C����mQD �oDiy Q�v�tU �

�TQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��O�it ��Q�ra

Combinatorics and mathematical logic� Some remarks�

�u�W�m x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��iQW ��Q�ra

Distance�based topological indices under graph

operations�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��vOvmU R�vO O�U

Harmonious coloring of graphs�

C����� Q �xOmWywSB�vQvNUlD �

�uB�S ��o �U x�oWv�O ��QD �mw��v

Locally complete intersection Stanley�Reisner ideals�

��O�v�m �p�QDvwt x�oWv�O ��QYv �iYt

Solving variational inequality problems by a projection

approach�

�u�QyD x�oWv�O �OQi�Qk��ToQv

Deformations of Lagrangian singularities�

�u�tr� �nQw� Q�t QO TB�r�i x�oWv�O �Q �mr�w Q�tmrwi

Problems in the theory of f�vectors of simplicial

complexes�

The Betti polynomial of powers of an ideal�

Random to random shu�es and commuting fami�

lies of matrices�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �OSvuUL �tU

On a conjecture of Yau in spectral geometry�

�xUv�Qi �RwrwD x�oWv�O �wrm�t uQw�r

On eigenfucions of Markov processes on trees�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w lvqB Tm �t �xUU�wt ��R�H u�OOL O�Ht

The motivic fundamental group and a theorem of

Siegel�

�WRwt� COtx�Dwm ��yxQwO �

�u�et�O x��B swra x�oWv�O ��Q�ov�yH s Qt

Graded local cohomology modules�

�x�oWywSB w �DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O �xORQeY uULt

Perfect algebra�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w lvqB Tm �t �xUU�wt ��R�H u�OOL O�Ht

Crystalline cohomology�

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 29: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

�u�Q�� CavY w sra x�oWv�O �xQ�W QwBOyt �ra�HQ�N p�Uv�Qi�O ��ysDU�U

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O ��w�Q xrOU O�UuQ�kDt ��y��i �wQ �J� Q �xQ�W

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��UOkt ��Q O�Un�r �xR�Ov� �UOvy �x� RHD OvJ

��DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O �OQi�a�HW �ra�Q�H �xUOvy x�oO�O R� �WOQw �twDv�wm ��yu�O�t �x� Q�v

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �OSvuUL "�tU�i�� �xUOvy QO w��� R� �UOL �xQ�� QO

�x�oWywSB w u�HvR �x��B swra �r�tmD Cq�YLD RmQt �u��r�iD O�aUTw�QDW�Q��w ��kv �x� Q�v

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �u�t Qv s�Uhwm� wv TOL �xQ�� QO

u� ��yOQ� Q�m w �iO�YD ��yOvQi �oDiy Q�v�tU �

�u�yiY� x�oWv�O �xOQwQB u�WiQ�O��B �iO�YD ��yOv��Qi Q�DN�U

�u�Q�� CavY w sra x�oWv�O �VwvQi u�tLQMCMC VwQ R� ���yOQ� Q�m

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O ��UQOt xOwvx��WtOwN ��yOv��Qi �i�� p�rLD

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O �xOR�rav�UL u�U�U��Ya ��yxm�W UwD ��NQ�e �v�tR ��y�QU �Ov�pOt

�x�oWywSB w u�QyD x�oWv�O �lWRB O�tLuS �� woW�B ��Q� �r�tDL� ��ypOt

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O �xORR Ra xt��i�v�tR ��y�QU QO �Q�DN�U C�Q��eD X�NWD

�u�QyD x�oWv�O �sOk RQu�yvB hmQ�t ��ypOt p��iwQB

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��v�� Qk s�yQ�

On square roots of Laplacian and signless Laplacian

eigenvalues of the graphs�

��Uw� u�Or�Q�Yv xH�wN �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��Q�vk s Qt

On the coloring of Steiner triple systems�

�T��wU �EPFL ��t�yQ� OwH

Algebraic framework for network coding�

�x�oWywSB ����Q xi�� RwQy�

Graphs with few eigenvalues�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��QiaH Q�t

Connes�Kriemer combinatorial Hopf algebra of trees�

�C��F xkv �x Q�v� �NQ�e R�r�v� �oDiywO Q�v�tU �

��Uw� u�Or�Q�Yv xH�wN �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��RwQwv VwQwm

Fixed point theorems in ultrametric spaces�

�x�oWywSB w u�DUOQm x�oWv�O ��O�aU sQyW

Nonlinear ergodic theorems for amenable semigroups�

�x�oWywSB w GwU�� x�oWv�O �OQ�kQv QOvmU

Some results on best proximity points and �xed points

in cone metric spaces�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O ��HQ QwOv�B

Fixed point theorems in a new notion of metric spaces

and their applications�

�u� wRk ��v�tN s�t� �rrtr�u�� x�oWv�O �OQi �LqY wQ�y

Some results in CAT�� spaces�

xUOvy �oDiy Q�v�tU �

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �OSv�r�tm �ral�OvDwQo �xJ� �W�kv� �x� Q�v

�� ���� u�DUtR

Page 30: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

u � QN� R� �q�� w Qo �Ol � � � QwW m QU�QU u� v�Oj�vt Q�O �O ���u�v� �WywSB ��yOQw�DUO

�u�Q�� QO j�vt �WywSB ��yxv�tR u� QN� �� u�� wHWv�O ���vW� �

xR�D xwQo �D� ��yC�r�ai �xQ�� QO u�v�Oj�vt Q�v pO��D w EL� ���C����� Q �xOmWywSB QO j�vt T�U��D

�r�k �xRwQwO ��yQ�v�tU �� xU��kt QO �Q�v�tU u�� QO xv�DN�WwNQO wHWv�O � ��OwOL ��k�w QO �s�DW�O u�� wHWv�O R� �QDy� Q��U� p��kDU����tyOQo u�� xHwD �r�H C�mv Qo�O R� �OvOQm CmQW xRwQwO Q�v�tU u����y�v�QvNU �j�vt �xRwL QO �YYND ��yEL� Q� xwqa xm Ow� u��swra xrtH R� �yxRwL Q��U �� ���� Q j�vt ���DQ� �xQ�� QO �Q �H�yt

�s�DW�O �a�tDH� ��ysDU�U w QDw�Bt�m �Q�v

!u�oOvvmQRoQ�

Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �u�OytQwB OwaUt �

x�oWywSB �QwB�vULt sQyW �

�DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��Q�vt ��DQt �

�y�vQvNU u w�va w u�vQvNU�TQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��Qk�� OtLt O�U

Linear fragment of metric model theory�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �u�OytQwB OwaUt

K�compactness in fuzzy logics�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �QwxOO ORQi

Relation between the usual order and the enumeration

orders of elements of r�e� sets�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �u��v��tQ pwUQ

Logical models of social systems�

�u�et�O x��B swra x�oWv�O �#QR �iYt

Preservation theorems for Kripke models�

�R� Q�D x�oWv�O �QytQwB �Lr�Y O�aU

Logarithmic witnesses in bounded induction�

�R� Q�D x�oWv�O �wr�w�a jO�Y QiaH

Valuational and non�valuational de�nable gaps in some

ordered structures�

��� Q jvt �oDiywO Q�v�tU �

�u�QyD x�oWv�O ��vOHw x�tUxDUw�B j�vt QO ���yx� Q�v �xQ�� QO

�TQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��O�it ��Q�raxDUw�B ��yQ�DN�U QO pqDN� �x� Q�v

�u�et�O �x��B swra x�oWv�O �#QR �iYt�mB� Qm ��ypOt ��yQ�HvR

�x�oWywSB ��Qwt�D �OytwDQOwD ��y� RwD ��Q� Qo�ri�y �x��k R� Q�PBh� QaD ��xNUv �xQ�� QO

�x�oWywSB �sOkt OtLt�Q�H �xUOvy w Q�H QO �y�Q��Qi ��yOQ� Q�m R� Qo�O �NQ�

�DU R C���� Q �oDiywO Q�v�tU �

�x�oWywSB ��v�mQUwD x� RwQh�Qo �x� Q�v w �Swrw�tO�B�

�x�oWywSB w �DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O ��JLqY R�ovJu��DwQB�u��DwQB �WvmsyQ� ��yxm�W

�x�oWywSB �u��U��a u�ULrO�aGvWD �D xv�mD R�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �uwRQ ��QOtLt�Swrw�tO�B� QO ���� Q ��ypOt

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��LwDi ��DQtwor� �Q�opmW w �Wvm �w Q�WDv� CqO�at

w �Qw�vi CU � R w l�D vS �UOvyt �rt x�oWywS B ��kO�Y �Oyt�x�oWywSB

�rt�mD Q�O��B �SD�QDU�

Q�v�tU w x�oQ�m �

����� x�t �O ��w �� ��� Q jvt �xRwQwO Q�v�tUQO ��## x�t �O � w � ��yRwQ QO ���� Q j�vt �xRwQ wO Q�v�tUu�wD�t �Q ���tyOQo u�� �rY� h�Oy� �OW Q�RoQ� C����� Q �xOmWywSB

"OQtWQ� Q� R KQW x�

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 31: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

u�QyD x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��tU�lt��U �

�y�vQvNU u w�va w u�vQvNU

�uB�S ��o �U x�oWv�O ��QD �mw��v

Cohen�Macaulayness for ordinary and symbolic powers

of edge ideals�

�x�oWywSB w u�DUOQm x�oWv�O �u�yH u�t�rU �ra

Stanley depth of Zn�graded modules�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O ��vOt �O�aU Q�U

Algebraic properties of the path ideal of a graph�

��Uw� u�Or�Q�Yv xH�wN x�oWv�O ��k�kL uUL

The Hilbert function of a set of ��fat points in

multi�projective space�

�u�QyD x�oWv�O ��Ovyv #QR s�LQ

Some generalizations of Cohen�Macaulay complexes�

�u�QyD x�oWv�O ��RQOwo u�Wi

Shellable quasi�forests and their h�triangles�

�OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O ��OtLt xt��i

Shellable cactus graphs�

��tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O ��OwtLt OtLt

The complements of a connected bipartite graph is

vertex decomposable�

��tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O �Ovw�Uwt Q�t

Castelnuovo�Mumford regularity of edge ideals�

�DN�vW swra �xOmWywSB�rrtru��TvQivm �

Tv�QivmWhat makes us di�erent from one another�

Low�budget neuroimaging of individual di�erences�

Q�v�tU u�� u�QvNU �OW Q�RoQ� x�oWywSB QO ��## x�t �O # M� Q�D QO�OvOw� u�DUrov� uOvr Gr�m �D�UQw�vw� x�oWv�O R� �t�Qy� QO�y� QDmO ��k�

��DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��Q�vt ��DQt

A new hierarchy of subsystems of Heyting arithmetic�

� ���� x�t uty� ��� �D����mQD ��Hx��H Q�H Q�v�tU u�rwAMS ��� � Q C�aw�wt �Ov �xDUO QO ��E CtUk ���� p�U R�C����mQD Q�N� �xyO pw� QO xJQo � �OW �iQat �Q�H C����mQD u�wva ��Q�H w C����mQD �� x���Q QO �D�aw�wt ��xDi��VQDUo CQwY x� �Q�Hu�� �rY� C�aw�wt xm Cio u�wD�t C�QH x� �t� �CU� xOQm p��vO �Qw �y�vDt �xUOvy �� w �DQt ���RH ��yxawtHt ��yO��wQD�t pt�W xN�Wxm�W �x� Q�v �V��tv �x� Q�v ��yxwQo �x� Q�v pt�W R�v �Q�H CtUk QOQO �QDW�� CaQU �� xm ���yxN�WQ� R R� �m� �CU� xOw� ���Hx��H Q�H wu�ty �xN�W u�� QO �CU� �D����mQD ���Hx��H Q�H u�ty CU� OWQ p�LC����mQD w ���Hx��H Q�H QO lQDWt p��Ut �CU�O�B u� s�v R� xm Qw��OOQo�tQ� ���� p�U x� xN�W u�� �xJN� Q�D �OQ�o�t Q�Qk EL� OQwtC��F� CyH �r�mt�uywm ��yxkrL �x� Q�v R� �rvDU� OQ�J� Q xm �v�tRxO�iDU� �y�i ��Q� �Upper Bound Conjecture� q�� u�Qm TOL��yAwD�rB xrtH R� �D����mQD s�y�it �Q�H �xar��t �TB u� R� �OQm�m� xN�W u�� Q�N� �xyO QO �O�OQo R�e� �mO�U ��y�tDHt w �OLt

�OwW�t �wULt ���Hx��H Q�H ��yxN�W u� QDp�ai R�xN�W u�� QO C�r�ai QwWm u�kkLt R� �atH Cty�� �� p�U R��� w xOW VQ�ov xv�tR u�� QO �QDmO �xr�UQ u�OvJ uwvm �D w O�OQo R�e�u�� QO QwWm u�kkLt UwD R�v Cq�kt �xwqa x� �OW���t VQ�ov p�L QOu�wva �� �i�YwD �xr�kt x� u�wD�t xrtH R� �CU� xO�UQ A�J x� xv�tRQ�Dm � QO xm �What is Stanely depth�� ��CU�J �rvDU� jta �CU� xO�UQ A�J x� Notices of the AMS �xrHt QO � p�Uu�kkLt R� �yHwD p��k O�OaD C�r�ai x� xHwD �� w T�U� u�� Q� �OQm xQ�W��OW T�UL� xN�W u�� �xvq�U ��yQ�v�tU �wQW swRr xv�tR u�� QO QwWmx�t uty� � M� Q�D QO �D����mQD ���Hx��H Q�H Q�v�tU u�rw� x���Q u�� QOxN�W u�� u�oDUHQ� R� �m� xm ���QD �mw��v QwUiwQB QwL �� w ��##xOWs�Hv� ��y�v�QvNU R� ��QD QwUiwQB �Q�v�tU u���B QO �OW Q�RoQ� CU�QwWm u�kkLt R� �yHwD p��k O�OaD xmv�� R� w OQm R�Q�� �Q OwN pt�m C���Q

�OQm �DioW R�Q�� �OvDUy j�kLD x� pweWt �v�yH p�ai �xN�W u�� QO�U�rov� u�� R x� u�QvNU � w xOvvmCmQW !� QwL �� Q�v�tU u��QtFQB ��yQ�v�tU R� �m� Q�v�tU u�� xm Cio u�wD�t C�QH x� �OW Q�RoQ��Q�v�tU u�� G��Dv R� �m� �s� Q�O �q�� xm �Hv� �D �Q� R OwW�t �wULt RmQt�CU� xOw� �HQ�N w �v�Q�� u�QoWywSB u�� lQDWt �xr�kt u�OvJ �x�yD

!u�oOvvmQRoQ�

h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��mvQwB ��QOtLt �

Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��v��m Vw QO �

�� ���� u�DUtR

Page 32: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

OwOL �OW Q�RoQ� �yu��DwQB �D��U�Lt p��Ut �xv�tR QO �yC�r�ai u� QN�swra hrDNt ��yxDWQ OWQ� �U�vWQ�m w �QDmO u�� wHWv�O R� Qiv pyJsra �Q��mQ�t� �h� QW �u�QyD ��yx�oWv�O R� ���� Q w Q�t� �QDw�Bt�m ��DU� RC�aw�wt xUrH xOR�wO �� xm OvDW�O CmQW u�yiY� �DavY w CavY w�CiQo Q�Qk EL� OQwt �yu��DwQB u�tDN�U w �r�wD R�r�v� �xv�tR QO hrDNt

�r�rLD �xiUri �xOmWywSB!�vQvNU w Q�v�tU �

�u�Q�� �xiUri w CtmL �WywSB �xUU�wt �xOR�U�� Qm Q�t��RHD�q �RH �xr�Ut w �v�Uu��

�x�oWywSB ��v�mQUwD x� RwQ�s�tYD �x� Q�v

�sk x�oWv�O ��w�v CO�Uxt��i����� Q j�vt x�oO�O R� xki pwY�

OR� TQO Tqm �QRoQ� �

u�wva �� O�R� TQO Tqm �Q�RoQ� x� s�Ok� �r�rLD �xiUri �xOmWywSBQO �OQwHq xw�m UwD �yTqm R� xQwO u�� �CU� xOQm �jqN� �xiUri

�OwW�t Q�RoQ� �u��t QO xDiy l�� x�vWwO ��yRwQ

�QH w �WywSB syt ��yC�r�ai �

!�yv� u� QHt w QH p�L QO ��yxSwQB w �yKQ��x�oWywSB �O�Lw O�tL

��m�D�to �QB x�HwD Q��Q� QO �DiQat x�HwD�u�Q�� �xiUri w CtmL utHv� �u QUv �Oyt

p��t� Q��U w CU�wN �� Qw�� �x���Q�x�oWywSB ��OQwHq xw�m

sra �xiUri w xa���r�Oa��t ��a��� ��y�wv OQwt QO ���QoC�P

l� R�i �xOmWywSBu�tU Q xwQo Q�v�tU �

�x�oWywSB ��Q��HM�W �OytOtLt

What is a chiral �d CFT And what does it have to do

with extremal black holes

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��iYt p�a�tUQ�t

On geodesic motion in Horava�Lifshitz gravity�

�oDiy Q�v�tU �

�x�oWywSB �u��r�i Ov

Temporal tagging of attended object�

�u�tr� �u�rQ� x�oWv�O �OSvut wt O�

Decoding the what and when of prospective intentions�

�x�oWywSB w ���HQ O�yW x�oWv�O �QwBs�yQ� ��Q

View�invariant face recognition�

��m� Qt� �uDUw� x�oWv�O �VN�uOR VQ�

Spatio�temporal dynamics of V� receptive �elds

provides a range of surface representation�

��Uw� u�Or�Q�Yv xH�wN x�oWv�O w u�o�W�t x�oWv�O �Qo OwU Q�t

Implantable neural recording microsystems�

�x�oWywSB w TQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O �Q��m xrru�UL

Handwriting analysis�

�CavY w sra x�oWv�O ��Q�rO OtLt

The e�ect of attention on coherence response functions

in area MT of macaque monkeys�

��m� Qt� �OQwivDU� x�oWv�O �CUwOawv OQy�

Attention� working memory� and the link between

them�

�DN�vW��Ya swra �QDmO �wHWvO VQPB �xQwO u�tDWy �

swra �xOmWywQB �DN�vW��Ya� swra ��QDmO �wHWv�O VQ�PB �yo �wHWv�O VQ�PB xQwO u�� QO �OW QWDvt ��## p�U x�t OviU� QO �DN�vWw CiQ �P B Oy�wN CQwY x�L�Yt w xOWp�UQ� ��tra lQ�Ot T�U�Q ���#� p�U x�t Qyt R� uOW xDiQ�PB w R��Dt� �Um CQwY QO u��r�w�O

�OQm Ovy�wN p�YLD x� �wQW

QDw�Bt�m swra �xOmWywSB�D��U�Lt �U�vWCU R x�oQ�m VQRo �

�Q�mty �� ��## uty� sDWy w sDiy QO �D��U�Lt �U�vWCU� R x�oQ�mx�oWywSB pLt QO �Qw�vi w sra OQ�W�B O��v� w �O��v� ��yVv�O x�oWywSB�� �r�tmD Cq�YLD u�� wHWv�O ���vW� hOy �� xm x�oQ�m u�� QO �OW Q�RoQ�

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 33: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

CQP �U�vWxOOB Q�v�tU �

�x�oWywSB ��r�a�tU u�tQ�

Flavor conversion of cosmic neutrinos from hidden jets�

��DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O ��kRQ Ov

Review of the paper by R� Friedberg � T�D� Lee� �A

possible relation between the neutrino mass matrix

and the neutrino mapping matrix�� hep�ph���������

HEP � NP �� ����� � ����

�u�tr� �M�vwt x�oWv�O �VD Qi OrQ�y

Flavor mixing� neutrino masses and neutrino

oscillations�

�VQiD x�oWv�O ��Q�Hv xQa�U

Extracting the CP�violating phases of trilinear

R�parity violating couplings from � decay�

�U�vWu�y�m Q�v�tU �

�u�yiY� �DavY x�oWv�O ��aQR srUt

Generation of circular polarization of the CMB�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��vULrw� Q�m �ra

Non�gaussianity�

��QyRr� x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �OSvlrt xOR�

Ination from non�abelian gauge �elds�

�Twr�J O�R� x�oWv�O ��r�mwl���

Quadratic cosmology and its quantum picture�

�x�oWywSB ��U�vWu�y�m xwQo

Open discussion of the WMAP data and their

cosmological implications�

�x�oWywSB ��tU�k �t�U

A��� cluster� Weak lensing analysis and the

distribution of dark matter�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��OwO �ra

Weyl anomaly in nonrelativistic CFTs�

�x�oWywSB �p��dQ�i ��Q

Aspects of the BMS�CFT correspondence�

p�oJ xO�t Q�v�tU �

����HQ O�yW x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �QwBp�a�tU �w

E�ect of gap opening on the conductance of graphene

superlattices�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��Qovr xrO�a

Exact ground state for a general class of ferrimagnets

in a magnetic �eld�

���r�D�� �pB�v x�oWv�O ��t Qm s�yQ�

Generation and control of laser beams carrying orbital

angular momentum for classical and quantum

information applications�

��m� Qt� ��QwU�t x�oWv�O �QwBuO��a O�aU

Drude weight and optical conductivity in doped

graphene� e�ects of electron�electron interaction�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �QwUQ�W ��Q

Liquid �lm motor�

�x�oWywSB ��yrTOk x���

Optical� electrical and magnetic properties of metallic

nano�particles�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��kQa �t�kt u�t�UT�Oty ��yu�O�t �x� Q�v w �vW ��yxBD

�u�yiY� �DavY x�oWv�O ��aQR �v�t

Detecting community structures in complex networks�

�x�oWywSB �QwBO��a �t�v

Conductance of a bilayer graphene� E�ect of disorder

and magnetic �eld�

�� ���� u�DUtR

Page 34: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q

O�D�U� R� uD % QwL �� ��## x�t OviU� �� M� Q�D QO �y�iW uwtR�xwQo xU QO Qiv % w OW Q�RoQ� Qy�R�Oa� w K�Y xUrH wO �� l� R�i

�OvOW xO� RoQ� �U�vWu�y�m w p�oJ xO�t l� R�i �u�tU� Q"R� CU� CQ��a u�oOWxDiQ�PB �t�U�

�Qi�t �OtLt ��QOtLt w �W��qt �ra �u�tU� Q xwQo�Q�oR�yQB RQ�� Qi w �tDUQ ���L �p�oJ xO�t l� R�i xwQo�wHt�v uULt w �O��t �t�t� x���Q ��U�vWu�y�m xwQo

�Ow� Oy�wN ��#� R���B R� �QDmO �xQwO ��yTqm �wQW

l� R�iQDN� w swHv �xOmWywSB

�y�vQvNUlD �

�u�DUrov� �Q��WOQwiDQy x�oWv�O �u� Qwt�D �i�vL

The discovery of a typical radio galaxy at z������

�OvrQ�� �u�r� wO �xDiQW�B C�k�kLD �xUU�wt ���Qwv �U�mv

X�ray transients and their counterparts in optical band�

�x�oWywSB ��y�WwQUN ���L

Luminosity functions of XMM�LSS�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �u��tQe�� Cv�W

Distinguishing modi�ed gravity�MG from smooth

dark energy �sDE models by reconstructed

gravitational slip parameter in palatini formalism�

�x�oWywSB w h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O ��vULrw� Q�m �ra

Tachyonic resonance preheating in expanding universe�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O � u�O�HU xkOY

Detection of exoplanets by gravitational microlensing�

�u�HvR �r�tmD Cq�YLD ��kL u�UL

The modi�ed gravity models in galactic and

subgalactic scales�

�T��wU �wvS x�oWv�O �uDvqvw lQ�t

Model�independent cosmological constraints from the

CMB�

��DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O ��t�t x��Q

The nature of primordial uctuations from anisotropic

ination�

�srat C�� QD x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB �sOkt �v��wN xtwr�U

Cosmic strings collision in cosmological background�

�twta Q�v�tU �

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O �QwB�t Qm O�Lw

Some common problems between quantum information

and condensed matter physics�

�u�HvR �x��B swra �r�tmD Cq�YLD x�oWv�O ��Dw�F hUw

Climate change and global warming�

�h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O w x�oWywSB ��mDU u�UL

How does our brain recognize faces

�u�tr� �M�vwt x�oWv�O �VD Qi OrQ�y

Fundamental constants in physics and their time

dependence�

�QDmO uwtR� �QRoQ� VQRo �

��## x�t uty� � x�vWGvB RwQ �QDmO �xQwO �wHWv�O �PH uwtR�uwtR� u�� QO �OW Q�RoQ� �yQo��DW�C�QP w l� R�i ��yxOmWywSB UwD���kDt Qiv ��� O�OaD w l� R�i �xOmWywSB x� OwQw ���kDt Qiv ���

�OvOw� �yQo��DW�C�QP �xOmWywSB x� OwQwOviU� � M� Q�D QO �Q �v�LDt� j�Qw� K�LYD �l� R�i �xOmWywSB�Um x� jiwt Qiv �� �u�oOvvmCmQW u��t R� �Ov�UQ s�tD� x� ��## x�t�t�U� �OvOW ��y�iW uwtR�� Oa� �xrLQt x� ����y�Q w xQtv ��Yv OL

�OW sqa� xOmWywSB C��U�w j� Q� R� pw� �xrLQt u�oOWxDiQ�PB

�� �� �B��B �xQ�tW

Page 35: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q
Page 36: p wU - Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences · p wU t Q O R DO Qi O Q m ... Q B C NQO O v JT ex o W yw S u w J x m s O Q mC aO Qx o W yw S BR uw i ... s U x Qus w W QO Q