oxford historic preservation...

1

Oxford Historic Preservation Commission

COA application: Case #301 Applicant: Pat and Patty Tatum Address: 605 North Lamar Boulevard COA Request: 1. Modifying the height and width of 2 windows on the north side of the house. 2. Creation of a bay window on the south side of the house. 3. Replacement of the siding on the south side of the house with brick to match the rest of the house. COA History: None Historic Preservation Ordinance References: Section 54-26 (2) New Construction (3) Exterior Alterations Design Guideline References: Section 6: New Construction – pages - 52-59 Section 10: Exterior Building Materials – pages 70-82 Comments: Property is a contributing element per Historic Survey.

1. Removal of Shutters a. The removal of the shutters is an improvement and returns the house back to more of a

true craftsman style.

2. Front Door Option ‘B’ is a preference; however, either is appropriate.

3. Modified windows along north elevation: a. This alteration does not negatively impact the building’s historic character and is an

appropriate solution to accommodate the proposed interior changes.

2

4. Bay window along south elevation:

a. The proposed location of this bay window creates an awkward relationship with the dormer above. The bay window should be shifted to align with the dormer. If the existing siding remains to the right of the bay window and brick veneer is utilized on the left of the bay window, the encroachment of the bay windows on the existing bedroom window is

b. somewhat mitigated. The applicant should consider the above or an alternative arrangement, and re-submit this item.

c. Consideration should be given to the detailing of the new bay window. The massing and proportions suit the historic nature of this residence; however, its detailing should not be an exact replication of historic elements. In lieu of the panels below the windows, consider horizontal siding or a simplified panel.

5. Siding along the south and east elevations: a. This existing siding condition provides evidence that the building has evolved over time

and should not be replaced. Cladding of this addition with brick creates too much homogeneity and suggest that the house was constructed in one building campaign. If the existing siding is not in good shape, a sympathetic material that can be clearly distinguished from the original masonry could be used. If the proposed painting is approved and the siding is painted the same color as the brick, the siding will not stand in stark contrast to the surrounding brick.

6. Railing: a. The replacement of an unsympathetic railing with a new wood railing appears to be an

appropriate alteration. The applicant should provide additional details about the new railing.

7. Painting: a. The applicant has made significant efforts to match the existing brick and avoid painting

this residence. Due to the incompatibility of the brick used in previous alterations, it appears that painting the entire house is the most appropriate solution if the other proposed alterations are approved. The applicant should consider leaving the water table unpainted to preserve some of the original brick.

b. The application states that the intent is to leave the garage unpainted. If the painted brick is approved, the garage should be painted as well which would include the south and east elevations. The west elevation (rear) could be left unpainted if not visible from West Washington.

OXFORD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATION

107 Courthouse Square, Oxford, MS 38655

IL FEE SCHEDULE: Fees shall be submitted with an application for Certificate of Appropriateness and are due 21 days before regularly scheduled Commission meetings.

Minor alterations ofless than $10,000.00 i~ total alterati~n costs ......................................................... ~ ~5.00 Major alterat10ns of more than $10,000.00 m total alteration costs....................................................... (t00.00 Demolition/removal of structure............................................................................................... $75.00 New Construction ..................................................... ,.......................................................... $200.00 Preliminary Conforence .................................................................................................... []No Charge

WORK PERFORMED IN THE ABSENCE OF A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS WILL RESULT IN THE DOUBLING OF FEES OUTLINED ABOVE.

III. PROPOSED WORK: (Please continue on a sepqrate sheet offjaper if necessary) . ~ Address of Property Subject to Application: (p{Y) '-f\ a1U QS:;:za o !t / /lluef_ Please provide a writren description and photographs of each existing condition and each proposed modification. Plans and/or drawings of proposed work MUST accompany this application when filed. If request is for a demolition permit, indicate if the site is to remain vacant.

ll~ 2.

It is warranted in good faith that the statements above and on attached page(s) are true and correct. I understand that, if this application is approved, it becomes a part of the Certificate of Appropriateness and that I have received approval ONLY for the work specified herein, subject to any conditions or modification imposed by the Commission. I acknowledge that if the owner, contractor, or any subcontractor(s) constructs, alters, relocates, or demolishes any resource in violation of the City of Oxford Preservation Ordinance, it shall be required to restore the resource to its appearance or setring prior to the violation and that the City of Oxford may bring forth civil and/or criminal prosecution and penalties for such violation.

I understand that no changes may be made to the approved dmwings/plans or Certificate of Appropriateness application without prior approval from the Oxford Historic Preservation Commission and if such violation is found civil and/or criminal penalties may be brought forth for such violations.

I understand that a CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS IS A PRE-REQUISITE TO OBTAINING A BUILDING PERMIT AND NO WORK MAY BEGIN UNTIL A BUILDING PERMIT IS OBTAINED.

Applicant ~~st sign: G~ d-ctu-nv Date: 5.ep±. :.zli) ;lo I Lj

State of Mississippi HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY Department of Archives and History P. 0. Box 571 Jackson, MS 39205

1 . a. Property Name, Historic

1 . b. Property Name, Common

2. Property Address

605 North Lamar Boulevard

3. Legal Description

86Q:2

19. Ownership 22. Condition private fair

4. Former/Historic Uses 5. Present Use residence residence

14.

15.

16.

20.

21 .

24.

6 & 7. Significant persons, events, themes, including

8. Date of Construction 9. Historic Changes 23. ca. 1925

10. Architect 11 . Builder/Contractor 25.

MDAH Inventory Code 185

County Lafayette

City

Oxford

USGS Quad Map

UTM Reference

Principal Materials brick veneer

dates of association

Post Historic Changes addn. 1999

Architectural Style Craftsman

13. Outbuildings or Secondary Features (use sep. form if important) Two outbuildings associated with this structure were demolished in 1999.

12. Brief Description: One and one-half story, four-bay, brick veneered bungalow with Craftsman influence, built ca. 1925. Hip roof covered with asphalt shingles, with box cornice and hip dormer with two, 3/1 double-hung sashes. Windows are Craftsman 4/1 double-hung sashes. Full-width, undercut porch supported by brick piers with added scrollsawn brackets. Entrance contains a Craftsman multi-light door set in an added, Colonial Revival surround with broken pedimant and fluted pilasters.

30. Historical Information: This structure was built between the 1925 and 1948 Sanborn map series.

31. Historical Contexts:

33. Sources of Information:

MISSISSIPPI HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY Page 2

32. Additional Remarks or Information:

35. Owner's Name and Address

36. Photographer/Source John Hopkins

37. Photo Roll/Frame 3555:35

39. Form by Hopkins & Associates, Memphis, TN

38. Photo Date January, 2000

40. Survey Project Oxford Date of Form January, 2000

Attach Photograph MDAH INFORMATION

Category

Functional Type

28. Registration Status/Dates NHL Listed NR In NR District Federal DOE State Landmark Local Landmark In Local District HASS/HAER

29. District Name

Rating C/N C Inventory #

42. Other HPD Information

43. Evaluation a. Al ready Listed NR

Individually Eligible Eligible if Restored Contribute to District Apparently Not Eligible Insufficient Information Not Extant

b. Area(s) of Significance

c. Evaluated by/date

t

' s

September 16, 2014 Dear Oxford Historic Preservation Commission Members, We will be making an application this fall for some minor exterior changes in our house, 605 North Lamar, to accommodate interior renovations of our kitchen, laundry room, bath, closets and bedroom. The needed exterior changes desired are: 1. Modifying the height and width of 2 windows on the north side of the house. 2. Creation of a bay window on the south side of the house. 3. Replacement of the siding on the south side of the house with brick to match the rest of the house. In 2001 we added on to the rear of the house. We carried the prairie/craftsman style through the whole addition, but found it impossible to match the original brick. We contacted The Brickyard in Harrison, Mo., Old Carolina Brick Co., Salisbury,N.C., Nawkan Corp., Athens, Ga. , Wittchen Lime and Cement in Memphis, Tn., Boral Brick, Anniston, Al. and Sonrise Enterprises in Indianola, Ms. The best option we had was to purchase old used bricks from Sonrise Enterprizes due to the thought that we had the best chance to match the brick with Mississippi clay bricks. They were almost twice as expensive to purchase than new bricks would have been; then we paid to have them cleaned and lost many bricks in the process. We also removed and cleaned the original bricks on the rear of the house and used them on the east side of the garage to help with the transition. There is an obvious mismatch in the two bricks which is most evident on the north side of the house. It is our hope that we can improve that situation and the modifications in the current renovation, by painting the brick on the north, east and south elevations; excluding the garage and the west elevation. Thank you for your consideration. Please feel free to come view our home so you may better understand the reasons for our request. If we can answer any questions please contact us at 234-3192, 816-4422 or 816-4433. Sincerely, Pat and Patty Tatum

TATUM RESIDENCE 605 NORTH LAMAR

PHOTO 1: Notice siding on left side of house under porch

PHOTO 2: Siding on south elevation facing Washington

PHOTO 3: First addition (owner salvaged original brick from back of existing house and re-purposed

brick on south side of house facing Washington)

PHOTO 4: First addition on north side (owner purchased reclaimed brick-notice vertical joint line)

PHOTO 5: Photo of rear elevation during first addition. Notice amount of unsalvageable brick in yard.

PHOTO 6: Proposed bay window (wood siding with brackets below)

PHOTO 7: Example of a Bungalow with painted brick

PHOTO 8: Example of Prairie style with painted brick (Bungalow Style, Treena Crochet)

...... rr~--,.. Arll n-..

Amil 1~ 1 ~ 1Ul:J ~ ~ VIJ w ,...,0 , ~ l u tJe ~u u IT IT 1h~ I~ IULlJ ]'I~ 6/

- ...... ~ :_'f:i: ...

llllUllllUlll ll ~ I I ;;i: '1-- I II TI Tl I I---.. ./I I I I 11 11 I I 11 I I 11 I I 11 "l • 1 I I I I I I ~"N.. II I I I I I I I 11 I 1-...,...,,,.

Al [IIJ [IIJ

I 1"1-.. I II ~_lJL I I ~ - I~ II 1-

; 11 ~ u1~u1tfi1Ul_~L ~ -

LJYU 1 rfi1U 1~L ~· 1 ~

I -

~ -~ - ,, ... ~ -

;;:;f'-1 I I I Ill 11 ~ -

I I 11 I I ~ rffi _ lJ ~ _ lJ l,lU lJ JU L ~J J LlJ lJ ~ ~ L UL,J LJ l,L.,J LJ UL,J ~ ~ L ~U lJ JU lJ ~ J L JL lJ Tf--J lJ it-.. .A" llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll 11111111111111111111111 llln-..

.All II 11111111111111 ,11,Lllll llllll l,,u_+,l,l,J 111111111111111,LJ,l,l,111111111 ,11,f,l,1,1111111 lllll lllll ll1r-r,..

EXPOSED RAFTER TAILS _j

(TO MATCH EXIST. GARAGE)

~I -~

~"'"· ~~~

NEW BAY WINDOW (WOOD ~~~~ PANELING)

~

REMOVE DECORATIVE --~ ~ ~-at

_.//;-........___ IRON RAILING AND

REPLACE WITH WOOD RAILING ///////

STRUCTURAL BRACKETS -•' ---BELOW

,

01

$ 1 O' -8" 2ND F.F. 6' -0" 2ND H.H.

I ~ ~ ~ = I ~

'2' I ~ = [IlJ ~ = I = = = = =

I ~

I I = I ~ I =

= I = = = I = = e----

~ I = = = [[]O[]][]][[ITIO[]] 11[]0[]]0[00[]] OO:III0[0[[]]0[]]0[00J00[]][0[]][]]J0[]]0

~ ~ ~ = = = == == =~

c'-6" I,' Lf-1 _P, 1:_ L :..:.; IL~ l\I <-~

1. WITI I GRIC f< 1. ,

EAST ELEVATION (N. LAMAR) SCALE: 1/8" = 1 '-0"

~ ~

~ - ~ = =

6

c-- ---- ---~

= [CJ}~ -- = =

11 []]0[00J0[]][]][]][]]0J0[]]0[

~ ~

= = -= ==

I

REP WITH

NEW

LACE GEORGIAN PEDIMENT SIMPLE CRAFTSMAN TRIM

DOD PRAIRIE STYLE FRONT

R WITH SINGLE PANEL

L_ B = =

D a

=

= = OJ]

"""i*"'ornl:,-,;orno'""'[]][]][]][]]~rn""""rno"""rno"""[]][]][]][]]~ DJ[]][]][]][]Jrnrnorno[]][]][]][]]rnornrno

6'-6" r~ C_ f-1 LA<-~ C_ s I Ll I r'J (;

WIT DRICI<

FRONT DOOR OPTION B SCALE: 1 /8" = 1 '-0"

=

~ = =

= = =

[IIJ D Li Li Li

~[[

$ 10'-8" 2ND F.F.

$ 10'-0" CEILING HEIGHT , "I I 11--+-++++ I

I =J lJ

$ 7'-9" HEAD HEIGHT

$ ~~po·~F FINISHED FLOOR --

$ -2'-o"

=

B --IEJJ IDI IDI 1111111 1111111 I

I 11 I I

=

1111111 1111111

I 11 !

11 '

Q 2 ;A~~~.~ ,.~.LEVATION (WASHINGTON)

= II II

[IlJ OJ]

= I

= = I II I II I II 1111111111111111111111111111111 1111111111111111111111111 1111 11111 11111111111111111 1111111111/111111111 1111

ITil I !/)'- I;-' / /II

EXPOSED RAFTER TAILS __j ;'

(TO MATCH EXIST. GARAGE)

NEW BAY WINDOW (WOOD __/ PANELING)

STRUCTURAL BRACKETS -BELOW

' / /

I , ,

II II II

= =

[] = =

c.5'

= ~

=

= =

II I 11 L_J = c=Jd 111111111111lllllllllllllll11111111111111111111111111111111111 Ill 11111111111111 I llllllllnrrmm~11~11~""""""""~~==t

LJ LJ

I --;

24'-::::::" r;cYLACC. SIUll\IG WI I H CJC\ICI<.

I I

I I

REMOVE DECORATIVE - 1

IRON RAILING AND REPLACE WITH WOOD

RAILING

I I

I I

I

I I

I

, 1.

This drawing is property of Wilson Residential Design and is not to be reproduced, copied, or altered in whole or in part without the approval of Amy Catherine Wilson & is to be returned upon request.

=

= =

[]

0[00]0[]]0[]][]][]][]][]]0]0[]]0

~

= =

=

= =

~

= ==

REVISIONS

w u z w 0 -(/) w ~

2 :=J ~ <( ~

w I l[)

l[)

~ ({) [()

~ n

0 (/)

2 LL

~

0

z O'.'.: 0

0 LL x - 0

~ <( ~

O'.'.: > <(

0 2 <(

z _J

w I

~ f-O'.'.: 0 z

•• l[)

~ 0

u ({)

w • •

z ~ 0 -0 f-

<(

~ u Q_ 0

_J

DESIGN BY: A.C.W.

DRAWINGS BY: A.C.W.

DATE: 10.01 .14

02

$ 10'-8" 2ND F.F. 6' -o· 2ND H.H.

$ 10'-8" 2ND F.F.

1 o· -o· CEILING HEIGHT

$ 7'-9" HEAD HEIGHT

$ Q"-Q" TOP OF FINISHED FLOOR

$ -2'-o" CARPORT FLOOR

I

Ai1-111L _Lilli- LI 1~ A"f I I 1-,.Y.-t--+c-c+-cf-UTYhf-L,,i:i;i.~ 1°-1

.A"'lll I II Ill I I I _JLJ -,-; ' :.µ 11 I

......-r:11 11

~.?iDf'Jf1"-Jftlu' I JI jl ~I U I ~I ~I ll I ~I J~ I lllllll__JI 111111111111 II

...-ii II II I JUJL 11111 II I 1Y1~1 rn 11~h1 u1m Yim Y /

ITO

omrrrrrrrnrnonrnmmoIIIJo 111 111 1111111111111111111111111

Q 3 ~A~~~~ ,.~.LEVATION

.-rr I I I I 11 I II I I I I I 111 I "-111111 11111111_JUJLJ111111 111111111 l 1r-,.,.. LJ LIU LJ LIU L LIU JI [...if'!: LJ I ~ I U_J LJ LIU LJ LIU l ...... I IT II I i..:+t"" -·. ~ ..... l~I II I IT II I I .~~I ~ll~l~~~~~~l~l~~~~l~~l~~~~l~,...,.,1

I n..... I I 1'." /II I N I I I I

_J LJ I 1 l [IIJ" I I [IIJ I • 1111~ 11Yn11111111n~ 11T1~ 11u1111rn 11Y11111T11111Yn111n~Y1Y1~11T11 rn ~ U_ I I I 11111111111111JUJLJ111111 lllll lllll llllll llllll lllll_l 11 I I

~J~l~~_l~lll I I 11 llllll llllll lllJUJLI 111111 lllll lllll llllll llllll lllll 11111111111111.~ Ul ULJU ULJ I LJU ULJl ULJU ULJU Ull LUU ULJU JJU ULJU ULJU ULJU ULJl ULJU ULJU U_LJ LU I 111 lllllUl llTI 111111 llllll lllll llllll lllllUl_JI llll I llllll llllll llllll llllll lllllLJlLJ_lJLI II

I 11 I _j__l 11 I I I I I I I I 1111 11 1111 11 11 _JUJLJ 1111 11 111 11 1111 l 1111 11 1111 11 1111 l_l Tl 11 Til I ~\ J Yin~ i1m Y1~ 1 ITT Yim LJ1m Yim Yim Yim Y1~ y m i1~h1 LJJ_Uhj Yim Yin~ Yim Yim Yin~ Yim Y1~ 11

[] PATCH

I

I

,----- I I '

I I I I I I I I I I

BRICK ~·~~~ I I I I • ~~ f.l~ I I I I ·~ I ~ ~~~ I 1 I

: : ~~~~~4 ii\\ L _______ .\ /.~---J :

\ \ I I

I 111111111111111111 II I 11111111111 Ill 11111111111111 II 111 I 11111111111111 111 111111! 11 I 1111111111111111111111111111111 II 11 I Ill 11111111111 11 11111 11111111111111 111111111111111 11111111111 llllt 11 1111111111111111

\\\ I i \,\\\

REMOVE SINGLE WINDOW & REPLACE WITH DOUBLE

WINDOWS (SILL TO REST ON NEW BACKSPLASH)

REMOVE DOUBLE WINDOWS & REPLACE WITH SINGLE

WINDOW (SILL TO REST ON NEW BACKSPLASH)

I i-.....

1 ~LJ ~ ..... ,,~--II 1111 II lllll'i-..

11111 1111 I 111111 111111 111 Ur-..... U ULJl UUU JLJU ULJl ULJU U

11lllllLJJLI11111111111 lllllUl_ I II 11 1111 TITI II I II 11 I II 111 JlilLlJJJ'l-.:-. l Yim Y1~h1 u1m Yim Yin~ i1m Y1~ 1 ....... n-,.,._

I II 111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111

EXISTING VERTICAL JOINT LINE OF NEW BRICK

(SEE PHOTO FOR COLOR)


REVISIONS

w u z w 0 -(/) w

I er

2 ::=) ~ <{ ~

w I LO

LO ~ c.o

lX)

er n

0 (})

2 LL

• 0

z er: 0

0 LL x - 0

~ <{ •

er: > <(

0 2 <(

z _J

w I

er f-er: 0 z

•• LO ~ 0

u c.o

w ••

z ~ 0 -0 f-

<( er u o_ 0

_J

DESIGN BY: A.C.W.

DRAWINGS BY: A.C.W.

DATE: 10.01 .14

03

,

SCREENED PORCH

STORAGE

I \ l

~·· t

~· \ t~~ .:\'<•><<<'·>>>>><<<'·>>>>>>->>>>> ·>>>>>>-:\'-

,

01 FLOOR PLAN SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"

FAMILY ROOM

DEMO PORTION OF WALL AND WIDEN

STAIRS

GARAGE

///

/

,/

/~ REMOVE SINGLE WINDOW ./ & REPLACE WITH DOUBLE

// WINDOWS (SILL TO REST ./ ON NEW BACKSPLASH)

r-- REMOVE DOUBLE WINDOWS j & REPLACE WITH SINGLE j WINDOW (SILL TO REST j ON NEW BACKSPLASH)

I I //////~EXISTING FENCE

1

~ 1

/r ~ 1

1/ /-- PATCH BRICK

... D ... z :;

I

\,aJ!l' KITCHEN ~--------------- "----

-----------------r--

F1

I I I !ii 111 [~ "'[] -/·"111 ~ :.!;

---------- I I r- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - __,-f- ------- - - 1-.9_ - - - - - - i==-==i - - - - - ~ -

bd

I ~UNDRY •

t

HALL

I ____ _J

••• WINE 1c---~

c::::::JI

(f I) v

[ ' .

GUEST BATH

-

GUEST BEDROOM

I II

NEW BAY WINDOW __ /

--r-

- -i---- -

"

SHELVES I '

'I I'

G'-- 1-/," ·~

: I '

-

-

I •

' I

--/

I I

MASTER BEDROOM

ADD (2) MED. CABINETS

·1 _, 53/" / - '/4

I

,, f',J E\,V B/\'/ \;\II r\j DC'vV ~ P/ffCH SIDll·JG WITH l•IEW BRICc< , , ,

' -- '' -, ----------------


I

'\

,

, . l]J

I

, '

I

' •

'1' I

FRONT PORCH

~----'I . ~ ~

' •

, (jJ

I ,

(jJ

' '

\

I )

\ , \ \ \

\ \

,

'\ \___NEW HANDRA L \ , ~ REMOVE SIDING &

PATCH WITH SRICK

S'-C1" ,, ,

0

"'

-C•I I -

0

-m

I

('j

Lil

' ' ' '

WALL LEGEND

NEW STUD WALL

EXIST. BRICK VENEER

NEW BRICK VENEER

REVISIONS

w u z w 0 -(/) w er

2 ::=) ~ <{ ~

w I LO

LO ~ CD

lX)

er n

0 (})

2 LL

• 0

z er: 0

0 LL x - 0

~ <{ •

er: > <(

0 2 <(

z _J

w I

er f--er: 0 z

•• LO ~ 0

u CD

w ••

z ~ 0 -0 f--

<( er u o_ 0

_J

DESIGN BY: A.C.W.

DRAWINGS BY: A.C.W.

DATE: 10.01.14

01

oxford historic preservation...

Documents