�1396

u=DUtR�

'h}QWu

=Qta|U

Ovyt79

�71"X

'4/2|

xQ=tW'

33�2

|xQwO

Ori

gina

lArt

icle=@ xOW C}wkD |=yxR=U |Q}PBs}tQD |UQQ@

CFRP |D} RwBt=m |=yxkQw�|QDmO |wHWv=O� |DNO}@ |v=tR s}y=Q@=

OyWt |UwOQi x=oWv=O 'u=Qta |UOvyt xwQo�Q=}Wv=O� �Q=OtDa} QW sW=y

OyWt '|UwOQi x=oWv=O 'u=Qta |UOvyt |xOmWv=O

V}=tR; |}xNQJ |=yQ=@ QF= CLD |vD@ uwDU x@ Q}D |HQ=N Cq=YD= 'Q[=L Q=DWwv QOCq=YD= w s=Hv= FRP |=yxkQw =@ C} wkD '=yxvwtv QO x}rw= ?}U; O=H}= R= TB "Ov=xOW

Q=Ri=sQv R= xO=iDU= =@ xOW C} wkD Cq=YD= w =v@t p=YD= TBU "OvOW V}=tR; ,=OOHtl} TBU "CU= xOW xU}=kt =yv; |y=oW}=tR; Q=DiQ =@ G}=Dv w |R=UpOt Opensees

xHwD =@ w |UQQ@ uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD QF= CLD ?}U; O=H}= OvwQ w xOW |R=UpOt xk@] 3 ?=kp}rLD =y?=k '=yDv= QO "OvOW |R=Usw=kt V}=tR; OvwQ x@=Wt =y?=k '?}U; COW x@

x@ xHwD =@ "Ot; CUOx@ nv= w lQ=B CQ=UN T}Ov= w OvOW |v=tR |xJN} Q=D |]NQ}epO=at FRP |=yxkQw =@ xOW C} wkD |WtN ?=k sDU}U |Q}PBs}tQD K]U 'G}=Dv

|UQQ@ =@ "OvQ}o Q=Qk VR} QwQi |xv=DU; OQmrta K]U QO =yQ}D |t=tD xm CU= |L]UOQwt ?=k |=Q@ Q}PBs}tQD K]U 'lQ=B CQ=UN T}Ov= |x@U=Lt w =y?=k |m}t=v}O MU=B

"OwW|t O=H}= �1 03 |xk@] Ci} QO QO xar=]t

zamani.eb@shahroodut.ac.irshariatmadar@um.ac.ir

K]U 'FRP |=yxkQw '|R=Usw=kt '|vD@ |HQ=N Cq=YD= %|O}rm u=oS=w"|]NQ}e p}rLD 'OQmrta

xtOkt "1s}tQD xO}O?}U; Cq=YD= R}v [16�13]'|Qo}O C=ar=]t QO [12]"OvO=O u=Wv =Q |SQv=|WQ@ ha[ =@ Cq=YD= 'QwmPt C=ar=]t R= |Q=}U@ QO "Ov=xOW |R=Usw=kt wQO "OvOW xO=iDU= FRP |=yxkQw Q}F-=D QDy@ V}=tv CyH u}}=B Ctw=kt uD@ wu}= =Pr "CU= xOW xHwD QDtm xO}O ?}U; |=yxR=U |R=UpOt x@ u}W}B C=ar=]tV}=tR; G}=Dv =@ |vD@ Cq=YD= |R=UpOt G}=Dv O}}-=D R= TB Q[=L Q=DWwv QO Q=m|HQ=N Cq=YD= |y=oW}=tR; Q=DiQ =OD@= xm |Qw]x@ 'CU= xOW s=Hv= Cq=YD=Q=Ri=sQv =@ |R=UpOt R= pY=L G}=Dv =@ FRP |=yxkQw =@ xOW C} wkD |xtQ; uD@w ?}U; uwO@ Cr=L QO |Oa@ wO ?=k l} TBU "CU= xOW xU}=kt Opensees

|R=UpOt "CU= xOW |R=UpOt hrDNt |=yCOW x@ xO}O ?}U; Cr=L QO R}vK]U |wQ FRP ?Yv C} wkD sDU}U \UwD =Q Cq=YD= |}=v=wD u=R}t 'QwmPt

"OyO|t u=Wv xO}O ?}U; |=y?=k CQ=UN u=Q@H QO �EBR�

|vD@ uwDU x@ Q}D Cq=YD= V}=tR; "2x@=Wt uwDU x@ Q}D |HQ=N p=YD= OOa 4 'Q[=L VywSB |y=oW}=tR; VN@ QOCLD w OW xDN=U �hr=1� pmW QO xOW xO=O u=Wv |Q=PoQwD=tQ; w O=a@= =@?=k l} R= |WN@ u=wvax@ Q_vOQwt p=YD= [17]"CiQo Q=Qk x}rw= |}xNQJ |Q=PoQ=@

u=}t QO =Q|r}rLD w|y=oW}=tR;C=ar=]t R= |OwOLt syU 'xtQ;uD@ Cq=YD=C} wkDV}=tR; |=DU=Q QO u=QoWywSB VqD u} QDW}@ 'u=}t u}= QO "OQ}o|t Q@ QO xR=U <=RH=[8�1]"CU= xOW RmQtDt xtQ;uD@ |=yQ}D QO FRP |WtN C} wkD QF= |R=UpOt wK]U |wQ FRP C} wkD |=yx}q R= xO=iDU= |QDt=Q=B |UQQ@ QO '1998 p=U QOw wv xm Ot; CUOx@ xH}Dv u}= 'I}B QwO Q=yt R= xO=iDU= uwO@ =} =@ p=YD= Q}D |WWm[9]"OW=@ xDW=O |}xR=U OQmrta QO |O=} R Q}F-=D Ov=wD|t xO=iDU= OQwt h=}r= Vv}JCq=YD= |]NQ}e p}rLD CyH OwOLt <=RH= pOt l} '2006 p=U QO u}vJtyx@ xOW OQ=w QwD=tQ; |oO}Wm w VRer 'u; QO w OW xO=O xaUwD FRP =@ xOW C} wkD[10]"OW xOQw; ?=ULx@ p=YD= Qovr w |WQ@ C}iQ_ |x@U=Lt QO p=YD= |xDUy|vD@ Cq=YD= |Q}PBpmW QO |L]U |=yQ=}W |x}@aD QF= R}v '2015 p=U QO=yV}=tR; G}=Dv w OW |UQQ@ CFRP |D} RwBt=m |=yjQw =@ xOW C} wkD h}a[uO=Di= Q}N-=D x@ ?@U 'p=YD= |xtWJ QO |L]U |=yQ=}W R= xO=iDU= xm O=O u=Wv

[11]"OwW|t p=YD= |}xRQr |=yXN=W Ow@y@ w =yjQw |oOW=OH |xO}OBjQw xrtH R= hrDNt |=yxw}W =@ |HQ=N Cq=YD= '2003 p=U QO u}vJtyxO}O ?}U; Cq=YD= "OvOW xU}=kt w C} wkD 'u@ Qm w xW}W wv R= FRP |=yQ=wv wlqyDU= w Ctw=kt QO ?}DQD x@ |OYQO 15 w 40 Vy=m 'G}=Dv w OvOW C} wkD R}v

pw�Ut xOvU} wv �"1395 3 30 VQ}PB '1395 2 25 x}LqY= '1394 9 22 Ci=} QO %M} Q=D

"""=@xO

WC}wkD

|=xR=U

|Q}PBs}

tQD|U

QQ@"C}wkD sDU}U QO xDiQ Q=mx@ FRP |=yx}q O=OaD w x}rw= CQ=UN "1 pwOHFRP |=yx}q O=OaD x}rw= CQ=UN xvwtv s=v xvwtv wvuwDU QwLt |R=wt uwDU pmW U Q}D pmW L �mm� Q}D lwv u=mt Q}}eD ��� Ci} QO

� � � 0 0 NS5 |}xRQrQ}e �=v@t1 1 1 (�13); (+14) 1 NS1R xOW C} wkD1 1 1 (�20 2); (+20 8) 1 5 NS2R xOW C} wkD1 1 2 (�42); (+44) 3 NS3R xOW C} wkD1 1 2 (�71 3); (+71 2) 5 NS5R xOW C} wkD

"xvwtv |y=ox}mD \}=QW w V}=tR; |xwLv "2 pmW

"=yxvwtv |Q=PoQ=@ |xJN} Q=D "3 pmW

CQwYx@ TBU w Q=@ pQDvm CQwYx@ =OD@= 'xrLQt wO QO |Q=PoQ=@ "CU= xOWC@=F Qw]x@ uwDU |wQ 100kN |QwLt Q=@ u}vJty "OW s=Hv= u=mt Q}}eD pQDvmpmW "OwQ|t Q=tW x@ V}=tR; |=v@t |xvwtv u=wvax@ NS5 |xvwtv "OW OQ=wxOy=Wt xm Qw]u=ty "OyO|t u=Wv NS5 |xvwtv QO =Q =ylQD `} RwD �hr=4�Cwt=N u}vJty w p=YD= |xOvvmQwYLt |[Qa |=yQwD=tQ; Ow@v p}rOx@ 'OwW|tOWQ p=YD= |x}L=v QO |Q]k |=ylQD 'uwDU w Q}D |v=QL@ |x}L=v QO xS} w|oDN}Uo |wor= �?4� pmW "CU= xOW RmQtDt Q}D |v=QL@ |x}L=v QO w xOQmCi} QO =D CUv=wD |@ wNx@ NS1R |xvwtv "OyO|t u=Wv =Q xOW C} wkD |=yxvwtvu}ov=}t Qw]x@ =Q |Q@ Q=@ C}iQ_ FRP |=yx}q |oDN}Uo xvwoI}y uwO@ �5�3 u=R}t x@ NS2R |xvwtv QO w OyO V}=Ri= NS5 |xvwtv x@ C@Uv �5 =DQ}D |wQ pmW L |x}q '�3 Ci} QO QO NS2R |xvwtv QO "OW xOy=Wt V}=Ri=

"=yxvwtv |D}wkD |=yxkQw u=tO}J w =yOQor}t C=}�RH "1 pmW

?=NDv= 'Ov=xOW `]k xv=yO |xv=}t QO u; Q}D w xk@] `=iDQ= \Uw QO u; |=yuwDU xm|@v=H |Q=PoQ=@ CLD Qovr |vLvt h]a \=kv Ck}kL QO xOW `]k \=kv "OWxOWV}=tR; Cq=YD= 'OwW|t x_Lqt �hr=1� pmW QO xm Qw]u=ty "OvDUy ?=kQ}D |v=QL@ |L=wv w p=YD= |xOvvm QwYLt |=yOQor}t p}@k R= |}xRQr C=}�RH Ok=ix�=Q= xt=O= QO xm |LQW x@ 'Cq=YD= QO x}rw= CQ=UN O=H}= R= TB "OvDUy uwDU w1 pwOH KQW x@ w �?1� pmW j@=]t FRP |=yxkQw \UwD Cq=YD= 'CU= xOW"Ov=xDiQo Q=Qk |}xNQJ |Q=PoQ=@ CLD |}=yv OL x@ uO}UQ =D xQ=@ wO w xOW C} wkDACI440R�08 |xt=vu}}; T=U=Q@ p=YD= |WQ@ w |WtN C} wkD |L=Q]x@ Q}D |wQ |=ypmW L w uwDU |wQ |=yjQw \UwD Q=m u}= [18]"CU= xOW s=Hv=|=yI}B QwO u}vJty "OW=@ xDW=O =Q =QH= u=mt= u} QDW}@ xm CU= xOW s=Hv= |wLv"CU= xOW xO=iDU= uD@ K]U R= jQw |oOW=OH R= |Q}owrH CyH uwDU w Q}D |wQV}B R= OQmrta Kw]U xm CU= xOW s=Hv= |}xvwo x@ Cq=YD= QO x}rw= CQ=UNT=U=Q@ |@=NDv= OQmrta Kw]U "O}; OwHwx@ Cq=YD= QO C} wkD R= p@k xOW u}}aDOwHwt |=yu=tDN=U |}xRQr |R=Uy@ ptar=QwDUO w [19] FEMA�356 |xt=vu}};|v=H |vt}= '�IO� xikw|@ |xO=iDU= C}r@=k K]U u=wvax@ [20]'�360 |x} QWv�NS5 |xvwtv '1 pwOH T=U=Q@ "OvOW u}}aD �CP� VR} QwQi |xv=DU; w �LS�x}rw= CQ=UN "OW |Q=PoQ=@ xk@] Ci} QO �5 =D C} wkD uwO@ |=v@t |xvwtv u=wvax@x@ NS5R w NS3R 'NS2R 'NS1R |=yxvwtv QO |}xNQJ |Q=PoQ=@ CQwYx@,=OOHt w C} wkD QwmPt |=yxvwtv TBU "OW s=Hv= �5 w �3 '�1 5 '�1 =D ?}DQD

"OvOW |Q=PoQ=@ �5 Ci} QO =D|vDio "CU= xOW xO=O u=Wv 2 pmW QO xOW V}=tR; p=YD= |y=ox}mD \}=QW|Qw]x@ 'Ci=} VNQJ xHQO 90 p=YD= 'V}=tR; s=Hv= CrwyU CyH xm CU=h} QaD R= 'Q[=L Q=DWwv QO "OW s=Hv= |ki= CQwY x@ Q}D |=yDv= QO |Q=PoQ=@ xmxm Q}D |=yDv= u=mt Q}}eD C@Uv CQwYx@ �xk@] Ci} QO� xk@] |@Uv u=mt Q}}eD

"CU= xOW xO=iDU= uwDU Q+@ =D Q}D pw] x@ 'OwW|t s=Hv= x]kv u; QO |Q=PoQ=@xO=O u=Wv 3 pmW QO �5 Ci} QO =D =yxvwtv |}xNQJ |Q=PoQ=@ |xJN} Q=D

72

4/2|

xQ=tW'

33�2

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

u=Qta|

UOvyt

"=yxvwtv |y=oW}=tR; G}=Dv "5 pmW

u}vJty w OQ=O =Q |SQv= lqyDU= C}iQ_ w |Q}PBpmW Vy=m ?@U x@ CQ=UN"OQ}o|t Q_v QO =Q |Q=OQ@ Q=@ QO xDi=} Vy=m |DNU

CyH Beta u=wD "CU= Oqwi VvQm w VvD Qov=}@ 'Q=Owtv |wQ Q@ e w S \=kvpw] QO nv}Jv}B O=H}= CyH PinchY w PinchX w |Q=OQ@ Q=@ |DNU Vy=mx�=Q= 2 pwOH QO |R=UpOt QO xDiQ Q=mx@ |=yQDt=Q=B "OvwW|t xO=iDU= |Q=OQ@ Q=@|WWm OQ=Ov=DU= |=yxvwtv |wQ Q@ xOW s=Hv= |=yV}=tR; T=U=Q@ "CU= xOW|}=yv VvD w 530MPa Q@=Q@ |rw] |=yOQor}t s}rUD VvD '�18 wv R= OqwixO=O s}rUD VvD Q}O=kt QO 1 25 ?} Q[ xJv=vJ "Ot; CUOx@ 700MPa u;

"=yxvwtv |oDN}Uo |wor= "4 pmW

xO} Q@ CU=Q CtU pmW L C} wkD |x}q '�4 Ci} QO QO TBU w xOW xOt;Q@"OW

wQW OwR |r}N =ylQD 'NS3R |xvwtv QO x}rw= CQ=UN uOw@ q=@ p}rOx@QO Q}D |wQ pmW L |D} wkD |=yx}q '�3 Ci} QO QO xwqax@ "OvOQm uOW R=@ x@u}vJty "�?4 pmW� OvOW xOt;Q@ K]U |wQ R= w OvOQm Vv=tm |Q=Wi |=yQ=@CUv=wD NS3R |xvwtv "OvOW xO} Q@ ,qt=m �4 Ci} QO QO Q}D |wQ |=yI}B QwO|xvwtv "OyO V}=Ri= �2 'NS5 |xvwtv x@ C@Uv =Q p=YD= |xDiQ CUO R= C}iQ_j@=]t "CW=O =Q Ci} QO �5 OL =D CQ=UN K]U u} QDW}@ 'C} wkD R= p@k NS5R

|rw NS3R |xvwtv x@=Wt |oOQwNlQD ^=Lr R= NS5R |xvwtv '�?4� pmWR= I}B QwO CQw=Ht QO Q}D |=ypmW L '�1 5 Ci} QO QO "Ow@ QDW}@ COW =@"CW=O |B QO =Q xvwtv |DNU O}OW Vy=m w[wt u}= xm OvOW xOt;Q@ K]U |wQq=@ p}rOx@ "OvOW xQ=B |rw] O=ODt= QO Q}D |=ypmW L '�4 Ci} QO QO s=Hv=QUQ=DiQ QO FRP |=yxkQw Q}F-=D 'NS5R w NS3R |=yxvwtv QO x}rw= CQ=UN uOw@w[wt u}= "CW=O QDtm CQ=UN =@ Qo}O |xvwtv 2 x@ C@Uv |QDq=@ syU '=yxvwtv

"CU= xOy=Wt p@=k Kw[w x@ QwmPt |=yxvwtv R}UQDU}y |=y|vLvt QOV}=Ri= 'OW xOy=Wt OOHtV}=tR; R=TB xOWC} wkD |=yxvwtv |xty QO xJv;u}vJty "CU= |R=Usw=kt R= p@k xO}O ?}U; p=YD= x@ C@Uv |Q@ Q=@ C}iQ_=OH uD@ K]U |wQ R= I}B QwO uDW=Ov OwHw =@ uwDU w Q}D |wQ |=yjQw |=yDv=R= Q}D `=iDQ= pO=at |}xrY=i QO Q}D |wQ Q@ xi=[= I}B QwO l} xJv=vJ "OvOWv"Ovm |Q}owrH pmW L |=yjQw Vv=tm R= CUv=wD|t 'OW|t =QH= |r@k I}B QwO'xOW C} wkD |=yxvwtv R}UQDU}y |=y|vLvt VwB R= |QYDNt G}=Dv '5 pmW"OyO|t u=Wv =v@t |xvwtv Q=vm QO =Q =yxvwtv QO |SQv= lqyDU= w |DNU Vy=mC} wkD |=yxvwtv QO |SQv= lqyDU= w |Q@ Q=@ C}iQ_ xm CU= u}= Qov=}@ '5 pmW=@ xOW C} wkD |=yxvwtv Q}=U QO w =v@t |xvwtv R= V}@ NS2R w NS1R |xOW

"CU=v@t |xvwtv R= QDtm 'QDO=} R |x}rw= CQ=UN

Kr=Yt pOt |iQat "3xOW xO=iDU= Concrete02 pOt R= Q[=L VywSB QO uD@ |R=UpOt CyHw QOvt |O=yvW}B pOt T=U=Q@ =Q =yCwt=N OwHw ?@U x@ |oOWQwYLt xm CU=xiQ]l} |=y|Q=PoQ=@ QO uD@ VvQm � VvD |vLvt [21]"OQ}o|t Q_v QO 'u=Q=mtypOt R= =yQwD=tQ; |R=UpOt |=Q@ u}vJty "CU= xOW xO=O u=Wv �hr=6� pmW QOO=H}= C}r@=k xm CU= xOW xO=iDU= �?6� pmW j@=]t Hysteretic |]NOvJ

73

"""=@xO

WC}wkD

|=xR=U

|Q}PBs}

tQD|U

QQ@"uD@ w Oqwi Kr=Yt Q=DiQ |R=UpOt |=Q@ sRq |=yQDt=Q=B "2 pwOHBetta PinchY PinchX Fy(MPa) Et(Ec=10) ft(f 0c=10) Ec(4700pf 0c) |Q=Wi Ctw=kt

(f 0cMPa)

0 0 0 5 0 9 440 2916 27 3 85 29162 73 38 5 NS50 3 1 1 440 3194 62 4 62 31946 17 46 2 NS1R

0 4 0 7 1 440 3045 95 4 20 30459 48 42 NS2R

0 3 0 7 1 420 1937 86 1 70 19378 60 17 NS3R

"uwDU w Q}D <=[a= |=Q@ Beam with Hinges u=tr= "7 pmW

0 009 Q@=Q@ x}qwO w 0 0127 Q@=Q@ x}qlD |=yjQw QF-wt VvQm u}=Q@=v@ "OvDUyQwQt 'FRP |=yxkQw |oDUw}B Ctw=kt QDW}@ |UQQ@ CyH "CU= xOW Qw_vt

[24]"CU= xOW s=Hv= 2004 p=U QO |rt=m w xOQDUoQ=DiQ |R=UpOt CyH Elastic pOt R= FRP Kr=Yt u=UWm C}y=t p}rOx@Ct=N[ w 240GPa Q@=Q@ FRP |=yjQw |v=UWm pwOt "CU= xOW xO=iDU= =yv;Q}D <=[a= |R=UpOt CyH "CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QO 0 167mm u; |x}q Qyj@=]t 'OQ=O |}=yDv= |Q}tN |L=wv xm Beam with Hinges u=tr= R= uwDU wh} QaD u=mt= 'Beam with Hinges u=tr= R= xO=iDU= "CU= xOW xO=iDU= 7 pmWu} QDsyt "OR=U|t sy=Qi x=wNrO pw] =@ w x=wNrO C}akwt QO =Q |Q}tN pY=itQO |QwLt |wQ}v � Qovr Vvm QOv= |vLvt h} QaD x@ R=}v sOa 'QwmPt u=tr= C} Rt

"CU= |Q}tN pYitpw] QO Two |Q}op=QoDv= \=kv w |Q}tN Cr=L xm =yu=tr= Q}=U hqNQ@|L=wv QO Two \=kv Beam with Hinges u=tr= QO 'CU= xOW xOQDUo =yu;xm |}=yv; hqNQ@ Q=OH; |=yQwD=tQ; =@ |vD@ <=[a= QO "OQ=O Q=Qk |}=yDv= |Q}tN=@ "CU= xOW xOQDUo xHwD p@=k pw] l} QO |Q}tN pYit 'OvQ=O G; uwO@ QwD=tQ;|=yDv= wO |=Q@ |Q}tN pYit pw] '=]N w uwtR; R= xO=iDU= w Cq=YD= |R=UpOt=yQ}D |xv=yO |xv=}t |=Q@ w 400mm =yQ}D |=yDv= w =OD@= |=Q@ '100mm =yuwDU

"CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QO 200mm

|vD@ uwDU x@ Q}D Cq=YD= |R=UpOt "4T=U=Q@ |DWoQ@ w CiQ |=yQ=@ CLD OW V}=tR; Cq=YD= |]NQ}e p}rLD"OW s=Hv= p=YD= |xvwtv Qy |=Q@ V}=tR; QO xOW s=Hv= |Q=PoQ=@ |xJN} Q=DCQwY xOW xDio |=yu=tr= u}vJty w O=wt |=ypOt R= xO=iDU= =@ |R=UpOtCr=L w �?}U; uwO@� =v@t Cr=L QO uwDU x@ Q}D |HQ=N Cq=YD= w CiQ}PB?}U; Cq=YD= |R=UpOt |=y|oO}J}B R= |m} "OvOW |R=UpOt xO}O CQ=UN|xOW |Q}tN pY=it QO xOQwNlQD uD@ |R=UpOt |=yQDt=Q=B uOQw;CUOx@ 'xO}O

"|R=UpOt QO xDiQ Q=m x@ Kr=Yt |=ypOt `=wv= "6 pmW=@ u}vJty "Ow@ Oy=wN u=Um} jwi Q=Okt =@ pY=L 'OwW ?Q[ 2 pwOH QO xOW"OW pY=L 38 5 Q@=Q@ uD@ |xYNWt |Q=Wi Ctw=kt 'V}=tR; G}=Dv R= xO=iDU=NS2R w NS1R |=yxvwtv QO uD@ |oOWQwYLt p}rOx@ uD@ |Q=Wi Ctw=ktCtw=kt "CU= xDi=} Vy=m NS3R |xvwtv QO uD@ |oOQwNlQD Crax@ w V}=Ri=xOt; CUOx@ 'lQ=B w Cvm pOt |wQ R= xOW QwYLt uD@ w xOQwN lQD uD@ |Q=Wi

[22]"CU='OwOLt <=RH= p}rLD QO uD@ K]U R= FRP |oOW=OH |xO}OB p=ta= |=Q@[18]'ACI440 2�08 |xt=vu}}; |x}YwD x@ =v@ FRP |=yxkQw VvQm |xv}W}@u; QF-wt VvQm Q=Okt x@ 'CU= xOW O=yvW}B [23w7]'C=ar=]t |NQ@ QO xJv; x@=Wt

%CU= xOW OwOLt 1 |x]@=Q j@=]t

"fd = 0 41s

f 0cnEf tf

� 0 9"fu (1)

'|v=UWm pwOt ?}DQD x@ n w tf 'Ef 'FRP R=Ht VvQm |xv}W}@ 'u; QO xmFRP |}=yv VvQm "fu u}vJty w u; |=yx}q O=OaD w FRP |=yxkQw Ct=N[

74

4/2|

xQ=tW'

33�2

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

u=Qta|

UOvyt

"|R=UpOt w V}=tR; R= pY=L Q}D lwv u=mt Q}}eD � Q=@ |=y|vLvt |xU}=kt "8 pmW

"|R=UpOt QO xDiQ Q=mx@ `]=kt w ?=k |xUOvy "9 pmW

"?=k x@ |@v=H w �xOQt w xOvR� |rkF |=yQ=@ p=ta= |xwLv "10 pmW

|=Q@ =v@t ?=k |wQ Q@ uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD %CU= xOW xO=iDU= xOW C} wkD |=y?=k w?=DW CLD |v=tR |xJN} Q=D p}rLD w |Q}tN pY=it OQmrta Kw]U |UQQ@w xOW C} wkD |=y?=k CQ=UN R= TB Q=DiQ |UQQ@ |=Q@ wQDvUp= |xrRrR |x}=BuwDU w Q}D <=[a= `]kt "OvOW xO=iDU= nv= w lQ=B CQ=UN XN=W |x@U=LtxOW ?=NDv= xOW V}=tR; Cq=YD= QO uwDU w Q}D `]=kt x@=Wt 'QwmPt ?=k QO|xwLv '10 pmW "OQm xO=iDU= Cq=YD= |R=UpOt G}=Dv R= |@ wNx@ u=wD@ =D 'CU=11 77 KN=m COW x@ xOvR Q=@ "OyO|t u=Wv =Q |@v=H w |rkF |=yQ=@ p=ta=

Ctw=kt|x@U=LtCyH 'Q[=LVywSB QO "CU= x}rw= CQ=UN O=H}= R=TB|}=yDv=[21]"CU= xOW xO=iDU= 'lQ=B w Cvm |Q=DN=U pOt R= p=YD= |xDUy uD@ |Q=Wi

Cq=YD= |R=UpOt "1"4,q@k xm Kr=Yt C=YNWt T=U=Q@ xOW V}=tR; uwDU x@ Q}D Cq=YD= |R=UpOt=@ |R=UpOt G}=Dv QDy@ j}@]D CyH "OW s=Hv= 'CU= xOW x�=Q= 2 pwOH j@=]tu=ttVy=m?}=Q[ uwDU w Q}D <=[a= |oOQwNlQD QF= uDiQo Q_vQOCyH 'V}=tR;?}DQD x@ [25]'u=tDN=U |rt C=QQkt syv EL@t j@] Q@ uwDU w Q}D `]=kt |UQv}=QO |vD@ uwDU x@ Q}D |Oa@ wO Cq=YD= |R=UpOt G}=Dv "OW p=ta= 0 7 w 0 5 Q@=Q@|=yxkQw |xOvvm u}}aD syU p}rOx@ 'CU= QmP x@ sRq "OwW|t xOy=Wt 8 pmWx}@W Q=}U@ wO u; |r}rLD w |y=oW}=tR; Q=DiQ 'q=@ CQ=UN =@ |xvwtv wO QO FRP

"CU= xOW =iDm = NS3R |xvwtv G}=Dv u=}@ x@ \ki p}rO u}ty x@ "CU= xOw@ syG}=Dv =@ |@ wN Q=}U@ |v=wNsy Cq=YD= |R=UpOt G}=Dv '8 pmW j@=]t|DNU '|Q@ Q=@ C}iQ_ |v}@V}B |xv}tR QO VwQ CkO "OQ=O V}=tR; R= pY=Lu=wD|t =Pr "CU= XNWt ,qt=m =y|vLvt pN=O K]U R}v w |Q=OQ@ Q=@ w |Q=PoQ=@x@ \w@ Qt |=ypOt R= w lQD uwO@ |L=wv |=Q@ NS5 p=YD= x@ \w@ Qt pOt R=?}DQD x@ |Q}tN pY=it |R=UpOt CyH NS3R w NS2R ' NS1R Cq=YD=

"OQm xO=iDU= CP w IO' LS OQmrta Kw]U |xOwOLt QO

|Oa@wO ?=k l} OQmrta Kw]U |UQQ@ "5|Q=PoQ=@ |xwLv w pOt |xUOvy "1"5

pY=L G}=Dv =@ uwDU x@ Q}D |HQ=N p=YD= T=}kt QO xOW x�=Q= pOt xmv}= R= TB\}Lt QO =v@t |xR=U u=wvax@ xk@] 3 |Oa@ wO ?=k l} 'OW O}}-=D V}=tR; R='9 pmW QO xOW xO=O u=Wv ?=k "OW p}rLD w |R=UpOt Opensees Q=Ri=sQv?=k u}= "CU= QDt 3 6 `=iDQ= x@ s=Om Qy xk@] 3 w QDt 6 pw] x@ xv=yO 3 pt=WQO "CU= xOW x�=Q= |O=yvW}B CQ=UN T}Ov= p=ta= CyH [26]'=Q=@k C=ar=]t QOC} wkD uwO@ =v@t ?=k |xU}=kt |=Q@ |@v=H |Q=PoQ=@ wv wO R= 'Q[=L VywSB

75

"""=@xO

WC}wkD

|=xR=U

|Q}PBs}

tQD|U

QQ@

"uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD QO =v@t ?=k QO |Q}tN pY=it p}mWD OvwQ "11 pmW

xO=iDU= O=} R |R}NxRQr Q]N =@ |xk]vt QO 0 3g ?=DW |xv}W}@ =@ III wv l =N=@ R}v w 10 pmW QO xOW xO=O u=Wv |xOQt w xOvR |=yQ=@ uDiQo Q_vQO =@ "OWp@=k xv=yO Qy QO xk@] QF-wt sQH '0 2 Q@=Q@ xOvR Q=@ CmQ=Wt ?} Q[ ?=UDL=|=yDv= w \Uw '=OD@= |=yxQo QO RmQtDt CQwYx@ xk@] Qy sQH "CU= x@U=LtCW=OQ@ w |Oa@ wO ?=k x@ wQDvUp= |xrRrR |x}=B ?=DW p=ta= =@ "CiQo Q=Qk =yQ}D

"CU= �R =D hr=� 12 pmW j@=]t 's=@ |@v=H u=mtQ}}eD |HwQNw |DNU 'Ctw=kt Vy=m ?@U =yxR=U QO x}rw= CQ=UN O=H}= '|rm Qw]x@=yxR=U QO xO}O?}U; Cq=YD= C} wkD wQ u}= R= "OwW|t |SQv= lqyDU= C}iQ_xDW=O =Q xOQ=w |=yCQ=UN u=Q@H |}=v=wD |YNWt OL =D FRP sDU}U \UwDu}= R= "OvDU}v xR=U x@ CWoR=@ p@=k xOW O=} |=yQDt=Q=B 'QwmPt R=QD R= TB w CU=lqyDU= C}iQ_ w |DNU Vy=m p}rOx@ 'CU= xOW x�=Q= 5 pmW QO xmu=vJ wQVy=m u; p=@vOx@ w �1 5 Ci} QO R= QDq=@ |x}rw= CQ=UN =@ Cq=YD= QO |SQv=xm CU= Q=_Dv= p@=k xR=U R= |QDsQv Q=DiQ 'xR=U |SQv= lqyDU= w |DNU xHwD p@=k|=yxR=U MU=B '5 pmW x@ xHwD =@ =Pr "CU= xR=U ?w=vD |xQwO V}=Ri= u; |xH}Dv

"CU= C} wkD uwO@ |=v@t |xR=U R= V}@ xOW C} wkDMU=B |xv}W}@ '=y?=k MU=B �RMS� C=a@ Qt wtHt QPH u}ov=}t '3 pwOHOYQO x=Qty x@ CQ=UN hrDNt Kw]U QO =Q s=@ |xk@] pw= Owt ?w=vD |xQwO wOyO|t u=Wv QwmPt pwOH u}vJty "OyO|t u=Wv =v@t ?=k MU=B =@ u; hqDN=?w=vD |xQwO w MU=B |xv}W}@ '=yMU=B RMS u}@ hqDN= �10 R= QDtm xJv=vJ�Level4� 4?}U; R=QD 'OW=@ R=Ht =v@t ?=k x@C@Uv xOWC} wkD |=y?=k pw= OwtQO =Q =yu=mt Q}}eD CU= xDUv=wDv C} wkD sDU}U TB u; R= xm CU= |R=QD u} QN;pO=at 4 ?}U; R=QD xm CU= xDmv u}= |=} wo Qt= u}= "Ovm ^iL =v@t ?=k |xOwOLt"CU= C} wkD sDU}U \UwD Q}PBs}tQD ?}U; K]U u} QN; �1 03 |xk@] Ci} QO|=yxR=U QO Q}PBs}tQD K]U xm CiQo xH}Dv u=wD|t xOW x�=Q= ?r=]t x@ xHwD =@

|@v=H Q=@ u}vJty "OvOW OQ=w =yQ}D |wQ 28 83 KN=m COW x@ xOQt Q=@ w"OW OQ=w C=k@] x@ |FrFt |wor= j@] Q@ uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD QO

uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD \UwD |}xR=U OQmrta Kw]U |UQQ@ "2"5w =yQ}D |=yDv= QO |Q}tN u=QwO '=v@t ?=k |wQ Q@ �4Ci} QO =D uwRi=Q=@p}rLD s=Hv= =@FEMA-356 |xt=vu}}; x@ xHwD =@ |Q}tN pY=it w OvOt;CUOx@ ?=k |=yuwDU|wQ Q@ =yv; |Q}oQ=Qk C}a[w w |Q}tN pY=it p}mWD OvwQ [19]"OvOW XNWt

"CU= xOW xO=O u=Wv 11 pmW QO s=@ u=mt Q}}eD w x}=B VQ@ x=Qty x@ xR=U|=yxR=U '|Q}tN pY=it p}mWD OvwQ |}=U=vW R= TB '11 pmW j@=]t=D Level1� OvOW |Ov@xDUO |R=Usw=kt s=Hv= CyH hrDNt R=QD 7 QO xO}O ?}U;pY=it 'p@k R=QD x@ C@Uv s=Om Qy QO xm OvOW ?=NDv= |Qw] R=QD 7 u}= "�Leve77 Kw]U R= s=Om Qy "O}; OwHwx@ ?=k QO QDu}}=B OQmrta K]U =@ O}OH |Q}tN"CU= |R=Usw=kt R= p@k xO}O?}U; |xR=U |x}rw= C}a[w Qov=}@ 'QwmPt |xv=oxm |vat u}O@ "OW s=Hv= =yv; OQmrta K]U T=U=Q@ |Q}tN pY=it |R=Usw=ktQO �CP =} LS 'IO� OQmrta K]U Qy QO uwDU =} Q}D w[a Qy CQ=UN T=U=Q@QO FRP \UwD C} wkD '|y=oW}=tR; Cq=YD= x@ xHwD =@ '|Q=PoQ=@ R= xrLQt Qy"OvOW uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD ,=OOHt xOW C} wkD |=yxR=U w OW s=Hv= xv=o Ciy Kw]U|Q}tN pY=it 'xrRrR |=ywQ}v uOw@ xiQ]wO QF= uOQm OQ=wCyH xmCU= QmP x@ sRq

"Ov=xOW xO=O V}=tv xv} Qk CQwYx@ 11 pmW QO

|Oa@ wO ?=k |v=tR |xJN} Q=D |m}t=v}O p}rLD "6|=Q@ wQDvUp= |xrRrR |x}=B ?=DW R= |v=tR |xJN} Q=D |m}t=v}O p}rLD s=Hv= |=Q@

76

4/2|

xQ=tW'

33�2

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

u=Qta|

UOvyt

"wQDvUp= |xrRrR |x}=B ?=DW QF= CLD =y?=k MU=B |xJN} Q=D "12 pmW

"xv=oCiy CQ=UN hrDNt Kw]U QO =y?=k MU=B |xU}=kt "3 pwOH

�s� s=@ |xk@] pw= Owt ?w=vD |xQwO �mm� s=@ MU=B |xv}W}@ =yMU=B RMS

?=k |xU=vW=@ hqDN= OYQO =@ hqDN= OYQO =@ hqDN= OYQO=v@t |xR=U =v@t |xR=U =v@t |xR=U

� 1 49 � 104 � 0 5928 =v@t xR=U�4 1 43 0 36 104 38 3 78 0 6152 Level1

0 67 1 50 2 61 106 72 �1 40 0 5845 Level24 69 1 56 5 59 109 92 4 55 0 6198 Level36 71 1 59 1 71 105 78 8 59 0 6437 Level414 09 1 71 1 90 105 98 32 54 0 7857 Level515 43 1 72 2 96 107 08 33 60 0 7920 Level616 11 1 73 5 26 109 47 35 34 0 8023 Level7

77

"""=@xO

WC}wkD

|=xR=U

|Q}PBs}

tQD|U

QQ@"wQDvUp= |xrRrR |x}=B ?=DW CLD =v@t ?=k w xOW C}wkD |=y?=k CQ=UN XN=W |xU}=kt "4 pwOH[27]"nv= w lQ=B CQ=UN XN=W ?=k wv

Level7 Level6 Level5 Level4 Level3 Level2 Level1 =v@t ?=k0 75 0 75 0 77 0 58 0 56 0 6 0 61 0 75 pw= |xk@]0 94 0 96 0 96 0 71 0 61 0 52 0 64 0 71 swO |xk@]0 65 0 69 0 7 0 51 0 49 0 48 0 46 0 51 swU |xk@]0 81 0 83 0 83 0 61 0 56 0 54 0 58 0 68 CQ=UN XN=W

?=k pm

DIStory =PDIiEiPEi

(3)

w s)=i w[a CQ=UN XN=W DIi 'xk@] CQ=UN XN=W DIStory 'u; QO xm"CU= s)=i w[a QO xOW lryDUt |SQv= wtHt Ei

Ci} QO =@ j@]vt� 4 ?}U; R=QD =D xO}O?}U; Cq=YD= C} wkD '4 pwOH j@=]t'CU= xOW ?=k pm QO nv=w lQ=B CQ=UN T}Ov= Vy=m ?@U ��1 03 |xk@]R= V}@ xO}O ?}U; ?=k CQ=UN T}Ov= '�1 03 Ci} QO R= Qw@a R= TB xm =QJK]U R= TB ?=k uOw@ Q}PB=vs}tQD |=} wo |vWwQ x@ u}= xm 'CU=v@t Cr=L QO ?=k

"CU= QwmPt ?}U;

|Q}oxH}Dv "8|SQv= lqyDU= w |DNU '|Q@ Q=@ C}iQ_ Vy=m 'V}=tR; G}=Dv |x�=Q= VN@ QOQ_vQO =@ TBU "CU= xOW xO=O u=Wv �1 5 R= QDq=@ |=yCQ=UN QO Cq=YD=lryDUt |SQv= K]U Ci= w OOHt |Q=PoQ=@ |Q=OQ@ Q=@ |DNU Vy=m C=QF= uDiQoQO p=YD= |xO}O ?}U; uD@ |oOQwNlQD C=QF= R}v w |Oqwi |=yQwD=tQ; QO xOWpY=L G}=Dv x@ C@Uv |R=UpOt ?U=vt CkO 'xOW V}=tR; Cq=YD= |R=UpOtl} |v=tR |xJN} Q=D w uwRi=Q=@ p}rLD 'xt=O= QO "CU= xOW xO=O u=Wv V}=tR; R==yQ}D xm CU= |v=tR |@=k |=yxR=U QO Q}PBs}tQD K]U xm O=O u=Wv xk@] 3 ?=k|xrLQt R= |vwDU I}y w �CP |x}L=v wQW� OvQ}o Q=Qk VR} QwQi |xv=DU; QOR= TB =y?=k |m}t=v}O Q=DiQ |UQQ@ "OwQv QD=Qi �IO� xikw|@ |xO=iDU= C}r@=k|WtN ?=k QO xm OwW|t xH}Dv =y?=k CQ=UN XN=W |xU}=kt w |R=Usw=kt\UwD |HQ=N C} wkD VwQ R= xO=iDU= =@ |R=Usw=kt 'Q[=L Q=DWwv QO xOW |UQQ@Ci} QO =D =Q xO}O?}U; |xR=U |Q}PBpmW wC}iQ_ u=Q@H |}=v=wD FRP |=yxkQw|=yxR=U QO =Q Q}PBs}tQD K]U u=wD|t QwmPt VwQ R= xO=iDU= =@ "OQ=O �1 03

"OQm xar=]t hrDNt |=y`=iDQ= =@ |Oa@xU

I}y 'ut[ QO w OvQ}o Q=Qk �CP� VR} QwQi |xv=DU; QO =yQ}D xm CU= |v=tR |@=k'Oa@ x@ x_Lr u}= R= "OwQv QD=Qi �IO� xikw|@ |xO=iDU= C}r@=k |xrLQt R= |vwDU

"Ow@ Oy=wNv wo?=wH Qo}O FRP |=yxkQw \UwD |HQ=N C} wkD sDU}U

CQ=UN XN=W "7|iQat 2 |x]@=Q j@=]t [27]'nv= w lQ=B \UwD CQ=UN XN=W u} QDOQ@ Q=mQB|SQv= w u=UWmQ}e u=mt Q}}eD |@}mQD XN=W l} u=wvax@ u; QO xm CU= xOW

%OvwW|t ?}mQD sy =@ |]N CQwYx@ xOW lryDUt

DIPA = �m � �y�f � �y + �

RdE

Fy�f(2)

|Q=PoQ=@ QO xv}W}@ u=mt Q}}eD �f 'xNQJ Qy QO u=mt Q}}eD |xv}W}@ �m 'u; QO xmlryDUt |SQv= wtHt R dE 'uOW |Q=H |x_Lr QO u=mt Q}}eD �y 'xiQ]l}u=wvax@ � Oa@ uwO@ QDt=Q=B u}vJty "CU= xvwtv |oOW |Q=H C}iQ_ Fy w xOWDIPA XN=W "OwQ|t Q=mx@ �0 15 |w=Ut =Hv}= QO� pOt uw}U=Q@}r=m ?} Q[|xOvyOu=Wv 0 5 R= QDtmDIPA 'w[a pt=m ?} QND |xOvyO u=Wv '1 R= QDnQR@"CU= w[a QO R}J=v ?}U; u}@t 0 2 R= QDtm DIPA w w[a uOw@ Q}taD p@=k

pY=it s=tD QO nv= w lQ=B CQ=UN T}Ov= 'xrRrR |x}=B ?=DW CLD xJv=vJ|SQv= u=R}t T=U=Q@ xk@] Qy QO |vRw |Q}ou}ov=}t |wQ R= 'O}; CUOx@ |Q}tNR= w xk@] CQ=UN T}Ov= u=wD|t 3 |x]@=Q j@=]t w[a Qy QO xOW lryDUtCiy Cq=L s=tD |=Q@ Q=m u}= "OQw; CUOx@ =Q xR=U |rm CQ=UN T}Ov= u; |wQ|Q}tN pY=it C}akwt QO uQ=kD C}=aQ =@ 11 pmW QO xOWxO=O u=Wv |xv=o"CU= xOy=Wt p@=k 4 pwOH QO G}=Dv xm 'CU= xOW xU}=kt =v@t ?=k =@ w s=Hv=

�References� `@=vt1. Barbato, M. \E�cient �nite element modelling of rein-

forced concrete beams retro�tted with �bre reinforcedpolymers", Computers & Structures, 87(3), pp. 167-176(2009).

2. Karbhari, V.M. and Niu, H. \FE investigation of mate-rial and preload parameters on FRP strengthening per-formance of RC beams II: Results", Journal of Rein-forced Plastics and Composites, 27(12), pp. 1245-1267(2007).

3. Malek, A.M., Saadatmanesh, H. and Ehsani, M.R. \Pre-

78

4/2|

xQ=tW'

33�2

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

u=Qta|

UOvyt

diction of failure load of R/C beams strengthened withFRP plate due to stress concentration at the plate", ACIStructural Journal, 95(2) (1998).

4. Niu, H. and V.M. Karbhari, \FE investigation of mate-rial and preload parameters on FRP strengthening per-formance of RC beams, I: Model development", Journalof Reinforced Plastics and Composites, 27(5), pp. 507-522 (2008).

5. Pesic, N. and Pilakoutas, K. \Concrete beams with ex-ternally bonded exural FRP-reinforcement: Analyticalinvestigation of debonding failure", Composites Part B:Engineering, 34(4), pp. 327-33 (2003).

6. Rabinovich, O. and Frostig, Y. \Closed-form high-orderanalysis of RC beams strengthened with FRP strips",Journal of Composites for Construction, 4(2), pp. 65-74(2000).

7. Teng, J. and et al. \Intermediate crack-induced debond-ing in RC beams and slabs", Construction and BuildingMaterials, 17(6), pp. 447-462 (2003).

8. Yang, Z., Chen, J. and Proverbs, D. \Finite elementmodelling of concrete cover separation failure in FRPplated RC beams", Construction and Building Materi-als, 17(1), pp. 3-13 (2003).

9. Parvin, A. and Granata, P. \Numerical study of struc-tural joints reinforced with composite fabrics", Struc-tures and Materials, 21, pp. 411-421 (1998).

10. Mosto�nejad, D. and Talaeitaba, S. \Finite elementmodeling of RC connections strengthened with FRPlaminates", Iranian Journal of Science and Technology,Transaction B, Engineering, 30(B1), pp. 21-30 (2006).

11. Sattarifard, A. and Sharbatdar, M.K. \Experimentalstudy on strengthening of RC connections with FRPsheets by embedding surface grooves", Sharif Journal ofCivil Engineering, 31(2), pp. 41-50 (2015).

12. Antonopoulos, C.P. and Trianta�llou, T.C. \Experimen-tal investigation of FRP-strengthened RC beam-columnjoints", Journal of Composites for Construction, 7(1),pp. 39-49 (2003).

13. Garcia, R. and et al. \Seismic strengthening of severelydamaged beam-column RC joints using CFRP", Jour-nal of Composites for Construction, 18(2), pp. 04013048(2013).

14. Mahini, S.S. and Ronagh, H.R. \Web-bonded FRPs forrelocation of plastic hinges away from the column facein exterior RC joints", Composite Structures, 93(10), pp.2460-2472 (2011).

15. Realfonzo, R., Napoli, A. and Pinilla, J.G.R. \Cyclicbehavior of RC beam-column joints strengthened withFRP systems", Construction and Building Materials, 54,pp. 282-297 (2014).

16. Tsonos, A.G. \E�ectiveness of CFRP-jackets andRC-jackets in post-earthquake and pre-earthquakeretro�tting of beam-column subassemblages", Engineer-ing Structures, 30(3), pp. 777-793 (2008).

17. Zamani B.E. and Shariatmadar, H. \Strengthening andrehabilitation of exterior RC beam-column joints usingcarbon-FRP jacketing", Materials and Structures, 49(6),pp. (2016).

18. ACI440.2R-08, \Guide for the design and constructionof externally bonded FRP system for strengthening con-crete structures", Michigan (USA) (2008).

19. FEMA356, \Prestandard and commentary for the seis-mic rehabilitation of buildings: Rehabilitation require-ment S." American Society of Civil Engineers Washing-ton, DC (2000).

20. Instruction for Seismic Rehabilitation of Existing Build-ings, NO. 360, \Management and planning organization,o�ce of deputy for technical a�airs, technical citeria cod-i�cation & earthquake risk", Tehran, Iran (2007).

21. Mander, J.B., Priestley, M.J. and Park, R. \Theoreti-cal stress-strain model for con�ned concrete", Journalof Structural Engineering, 114(8), pp. 1804-1826 (1988).

22. Kent, D.C. and Park, R. \Flexural members with con-�ned concrete", Journal of the Structural Division,97(7), pp. 1969-1990 (1971).

23. Chen, J. and Teng, J. \Anchorage strength models forFRP and steel plates bonded to concrete", Journal ofStructural Engineering, 127(7), pp. 784-791 (2001).

24. Sayed-Ahmed, E., Bakay, R. and Shrive, N. \Bondstrength of FRP laminates to concrete: State-of-the-artreview", Electronic Journal of Structural Engineering, 9,pp. 45-61 (2009).

25. Design and Construction of Concrete Structures, IranianNational Building Code, Part 9 (2010).

26. Ghobarah, A., Abou-Elfath, H. and Biddah, A.\Response-based damage assessment of structures",Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 28(1),pp. 79-104 (1999).

27. Park, Y.-J. and Ang, A.H.-S. \Mechanistic seismic dam-age model for reinforced concrete", Journal of StructuralEngineering, 111(4), pp. 722-739 (1985).

79