origin and functioning of electoral authoritarianism

8/3/2019 Origin and Functioning of Electoral Authoritarianism

1/17

3/70,,88,3

!!49.,$9:/08$$!$

%0473,3/1:3.94334100.947,,:9479,7,382

,7,943,.4.0507850.9;0

-897,.9

%0 5,507 8 47,30/ ,8 1448 1907 90 945. -0 57080390/ 3 90 3974/:.943 9480.9438 0,. 430 8:-/;/0/ 3 945,7,7,58 /0;045 9 3 90 1789 94 5,7,7,58 ,

70;04190/0-,9043-7/70208574;/0890-,80147908:-806:03980.943..4;078

94 2470 850.1. 88:08 90 473 ,3/ 3899:943,,943 41 -7/ 70208 ,3/ 90 907

1:3.9433,3/.4384/,943

3974/:.943%05:7548041985,507894,//70888420419088:087803-4304190248970.039-7,3.08

4190/0-,9043/024.7,9,943,3/9839073,943,/11:84390020703.0/:739084.,0/97/,;0 41/024.7,9,943 41,30-7/.,904741549., 70208%097/,;041

/024.7,9,943894:9,3/4:-984304190248925479,395034203,9,9.,7,.9070/9039073,943, 88902 /:73 90 ,89 90391;0 0,78 41 90 9 .039:7 :3/70/8 2,-0

94:8,3/84189:/08,;0,70,/-0035:-80/4390945.4501:9847349-09039 70509943 41 842093 ,70,/ 89,90/ ,7:0/ /8.:880/ ,3/ 70;00/ 3/00/ 90 ;07

08903.0418:.,3,24:39415:-.,9438,4894850702:.419047.43.073390

3974/:.9439490945.,3/9414.:8/70.9439088:08,989,0

4709,3,/0.,/0,19079003/419084.,0/97/,;041/024.7,9,943990-0301941

,34034:/89,3.017429480/7,2,9.0;03989813,5488-0942,0,13,,880882039

4190.,3089,99097/,;0,8-74:9,-4:9%0.,308,239070890/3,7034943

9480 .43.0733 90 549., 2,5 41 90 39073,943, 88902 ,3/ 3 5,79.:,7 90 70,9;0

/897-:94341/024.7,.,3/,:94.7,.,,74:3/904-0$50.,,9903943-0,845,/94

90301472841549.,70209,9,;002070/39020,30,8,8479418/00110.94190

97/,;0

1907,339,5074/4170:.9,3.035,79/:09490-3/3088574/:.0/-9089:2308.039

2,041 90 03/41 90 8947,3/ 35,79.43806:03.0 41 90 90044., -,80/ 507850.9;0/07;0/174224709,3,/0.,/041/423,3.0-9084.,0/97,389435,7,/290907,9:70

,8 13, 70.430/ 90 1472,943 ,3/ 574107,943 41 8420 549., -7/8%080 70208800294.42-3030002039841/024.7,9.4;073,3.090020398419075,89,:9479,7,3

7:0%01789,3/80.43/5,7,7,5841985,507-0/0;490/94-70170.43897:.99070.039/0;04520398 4198 850.1.897,3/ 41 90 /0-,90%0 9,8 -0 .,770/ 4:9 -49 - 574;3

84200;/03.04190020703.0419830.,904741549.,7020,3/-;3,..4:394149,9.,9047,8-003/0130/,3/850.10/

39097/,3/14:795,7,7,58979414.:843,2470.7.:28.7-0/,850.94190/0-,90

43-7/70208 3,20 1,3/490 907,9:70 ,8 ,//70880/841,7 941:3/,2039, 88:08

.43.0733902%01789 890/3,2.41549.,0;4:9439,90/,3,:9479,7,3702094

-0.420,3-7/%080.43/890,.9:, 1:3.943341549., 10 38/0 908070208,3/9:8 90 , 90 2,3,0/ 94 .4384/,90 8 -49 88:08 3;4;0 572,7 90 3907,.9438

-09003 90 2489 700;,39 ,.9478 47 74:5 41 ,.9478 3 90 549 90 14.:8 -0 43 4 90

907,9:70 ,802540/ 7,943,.4.0904794 05,39480/3,2.8%8/0.843 8,70

.43889039990;0724895,79419089:/0843/024.7,9,9435:-80//:739088

7,943,.4.0574;0/94-08:.,54071:944 347/0794 8.,3 901:3.943341, 97,38943

1742 ,:94.7,. 94 /024.7,. ,3/ 90 80170574/:.3 20.,3828 9,9 2,0 , /024.7,.

.4384/,90 9 -0 39070893 94 800 1,3/ 4 9 ,8 -003 :80/ 3 47/07 94 05,3 -7/

70208


2/17

,9,70-7/70208

%0020703.041907,430

%01789,1419080;/039:3/079031:03.0419082-4.831.,3.0419003/41

904/,7,8 907,-3/0/ -90 :234:82,0 41,4-,,55,7039 :389455,-0

/024.7,9. 9703/ ,3 2,0 34:780/ - 90 0110.9;0 ,3/ 7,5/ 8:..088 41 2,3 574.08808 41/024.7,9,9433$4:9073:7450,93207.,,3/,89073:7450,3/8:554790/- .,9.

84,388:.,89003/4190894790;.94741-07,82/024.7,.,8,:3;078,;,:0,3/8443

$:.,3 039:8,82,8 3 0110.9 :891,-0 ;03, ,3.0 ,9 90 20,3;,:0 41 90 700/42

4:803/0,20,8:7041/024.7,.,8.79.0/,8:80/:3.'07:0384890/7,2,9.9703/1440//:73905074/9703/,84.431720/-90890053088

4190307057080393903.70,803507.039,0411700.4:3970839047/3908,205074/

:739080.43/,14190/0.,/040;07842093.,30/$0;07,30/024.7,.08070

1,.32,32:.24709,3050.90//11.:908343974:907549.,97,38943$420

8.4,7889,790/43/073,-4:99022303.041,97/0--,243/,5,3-:9907 .43.:8438 070 89 24/07,90459289. 3 147 389,3.0 ,243/ 702,70/ 903.70,83 8,4308841/024.7,9,943 89 0,8 70:.9,39 94.,2 90 03/ 41 9097/

,;0,3/57010770/94/0130/9,989:,943,5074/4189,88/:73.904;07,3:2-0741

/024.7,.08 39047/ 30907 3.70,808347 /0.70,808 831.,390307, 850,30,7

011479894,8808890,.9:,5747088419097/,;0,/-003700.90/,85702,9:70024.7,.

8 349 -:9 3, /,,8 90 :8:,09249;#,907 9,3, 847941 3;4:943 9480,2-:4:8

7020884:/-0.438/070/,843974:,840797,38943,5,8041549.,/0;0452039

0,7

:024.7,.::94.7,.

3/041024.7,.

0,7

417004:39708


3/17

1.4:78090.4:/39-0.438/070/,81:/024.7,9.-:91478:70904:/,;0-0.420

9

%,9;0,8.0,731:03.0/-,847941/024.7,9,9431,,.0;07,:9479,7,3.4:397

. 8:3/0743,549.,.788,3/ ,5,8041 549.,.,30 8, /024.7,93.4:397

$:., -,80/ 507850.9;0 /07;0/17429084.,0/ 97,38943 5,7,/2 ,749078 ,3/

.,3 -0 .438/070/ ,8 90 0,. 41 %7,38943 1742 :9479,7,3 #:0 90 8023, 47 414330,3/$.299070307, .438/070/,8902089430 4190 /0-,9043 90/11:843 41

/024.7,.5:-80/3039097/,;0,8,5574,.38039

%,9 90044., ,88:25943 250/8420 280,/3 904709., .43806:03.08%0 97,38943,

3,9:70419480 3899:943, 80993870/:.0/90 30.088941/0;493,.,/02.03070894 907.,881.,943 #,907 9,3 89:/3 902 ,8 , 30 503420343 ,3/ 9:8 473 43 90

/0;045203941,30,3,9.,17,20478.4,78.430/8420/2380/950841/024.7,.89480702080703.4250901472841/024.7,.90300/0/94-0/1107039,90/-491742

/024.7,.,3/17420,.4907-,574507,-0.,59:7390850.1.3,9:7041907/024.7,9./01.98%,957,.9.0 8443 708:90/ 3 ,574107,94341,/0.9;084070;98

-07,/00,9;04,7..,290/.439740/70897.9;05,79,8026:,8,3/2,32,349078,3/.43806:0393,.079,3/070041.,48,3/41$,79478.43.059:,89709.3 3

90 4907,3/,89 ,8-003.0,7 3901443 0,788:.,90044.,,88:25943 ,.0/0257.,14:3/,9438%014439,-02,059480090,.9:,9703/419080.43/5,8041

9097/,;0,3/4190,89/0.,/0

%0/110703.0-09003,1789,3/,80.43/5,80419097/,;086:900;/039085904190

1,.99,9,55,703990/11:84341/024.7,..4393:0/94:939077:5943:3990,1418

903909 30 00.947, /024.7,.08 -09003 ,3/ ,3/ , 949, 41 90

,8808820394:/.,30:89108190/90,99039439490700,3/!,79700.4:238":90

8:757830844370,09,93903:2-074170089,90880,.9908,20,83

08590 90 890,/ 749 3 90 3:2-07 41 00.947, /024.7,.08 90 3:2-07 41 -07,

/024.7,.08 . ,..47/3 94700/424:80 .47708543/ 94 90700.4:39708,3/ ,70 94 -0

.438/070/,8,8:-74:54100.947,/024.7,.08,889,3,90/,3/9075745479433904;07,

00.947,/024.7,..,9047,8831.,39/0.70,80/174294

%4-0 43089 8:.708:98,70 349 334;,9;0,9, 80 ,;08003 390 80.43/ ,141 90/0.,/08 80;07, 8.4,78 ,/ ,70,/ -00343/073 ,-4:9 90 03/ 41 90 97/,;09 9,9

2420399054908841,207089,02,90,850710.9,/288-094/,1190030,78,907088,3/0880985,,9903943949080.43/5,7941909,-0,3/35,79.:,79490,3/94

90 ,58084192043.073390 147207 945439884:/ -08970880/390430,3/ 90 700.4:397 74:5 70.47/0/ ,3 3.70,80 1742 94 .4:39708 9:8 574/:.3 ,

82,77803905745479434100.947,/024.7,.08.6:,10/,8-07,1742943904907,3/903:2-074100.947,/024.7,.081:.9:,90/890,/-:9349831.,3990

57454794341/024.7,.084390949,3:2-0741.4:39708-0374:.4389,3981479080;03

0,78-09003,3/39:730.,30,8349.09,9342,470;039,84..:770/8,20

3:2-07 41 00.947,/024.7,.088,20 3:2-07 411700 5,79 1700 ,3/ 349 1700 .4:39708 8,20

507.039,041-07,,3/414300.947,/024.7,.0843904;07,80941/024.7,.0898/40834970,440,902547,7843/433904-,/11:84341/024.7,.

,9903%0,-4;0702,788:089,90,8994.438/07,9438789905074/29

70,843,- 705708039, 8479 4180993/43 5,80 3. 90 4;07, 3:2-07 41/024.7,.08

89,3,90/ ,3/ , 10 .4:39708 41 90 4300.947, 8:-809 ,8 13, 430 974: 98 549.,

97,38943 0907 8:..0881: -0.423 , -07, /024.7,. 47 ;3 :5 94 907 39073,

,:9479,7,357088:708%0701470902088404100.947,/024.7,.5747088;0,.6:70/

,24709/39073,47,3,943,3:207.,30,907/893.943-09003,,7074:541-07,

,3/ , 82, 74:5 41 43 00.947,/024.7,.08$0.43/ 3 90 ,89 0,78 98 /897-:943 41


4/17

549.,70208,884204.4384/,90/478.4384/,93%074:541-07,/024.7,.08

,550,78902547,7.480,3/908,20.,3-089,90/147!,79700,3/49700.4:39708

#%%

$%%$

%#

#$#$%%$ !#%#$%%$

%#

$%%$

%% %%

%%

%%

&@nffffn

nfffff

98 ,84 8:0898 9,9 /:73 90 ,89 119003 0,78 , 7, 430 -09003 /024.7,. ,3/

,:94.7,.,749078,85747088;002070/,3/87,5/.4384/,93-4939072841

3:2-0741.4:397081,393,3/3907284150788903.0398.,9047%8894-094:941 ,8 , 8/00110.9 41 90 97/,;0 90 2489 41 9080 70208 ,;3 84204 :3/07430 ,

574.088 41 549., 97,381472,943 /:73 9,9 5074/ 574.088 40;07 9,9 ,55,7039 ,8

0,/3 9480 70208 94,7/8 /024.7,. -:9 9,9 :92,90 .430/ , -7,3/ 30 .,9047 41

-7/70208

0133,3-7/7020

:739088.4,78,85747088;070.430/9,990/0,41,90391;00,784-,/024.7,9.9703/,8,30.088;08251.,9430;03,34-89,.094,1:07:3/0789,3/34190


5/17

5708039.431:7,943419039073,943,88902#,9079097/,;084:/-0-09907390757090/

,8,5,80/:73.90.42509,3/090740309419039073,943,88902,83.70,80/

489 41 9480,2-:4:870208 9,9 390 80.43/5,79 41 90 880020/ 94-0 89:. 3 90

2//041,974:-08420-:9890;/0395,994/024.7,.574;0/94-0,-094147289,-038

949070.4342.,3/84.09,03;7432039,3/,708003-.438/07,-05,79841904.,0908,8

,3,/06:,903899:943,84:9439490850.1.574-028414;07330110.9;0070

&3/07 .079,3 .43/9438 3 4907 47/8 -7/8 70208 .,3 70,. , 8479 41 06:-7:2 ,3/

.4384/,90:990343.09030.,904741-7/70208,8-003/03910/494/0,99494

/0130-7/70208398248982589.1472:,943--7/70208.4,78:8:,20,3,

809 41 3899:9438 . .47708543/8 30907 94 , 1:10/0/ /024.7,. 347 94 ,3 4:979

,:94.7,.%8/013943/408349902:.,-4:98:.70208-:92,705708039,89,793543939,995354398901,.99,9:8:,-7/702081,3902//04190,3,9.,17,2047

,8,3390720/,90.,90473,.4393:4:820,8:7041/024.7,9.30888:.,890700/4239047/ 3/04790!49'1470,250-7/ 70208:8094 4.,908420070-09003 90

45548905408411:/024.7,.,3/1:,:94.7,.0,8:70203988:08349989,3/3,574507/013943 41 -7/ 7020 706:708 90 /0391.,943 41 907 850.1. 10,9:708 . 3 9:73

706:708 ,3 :3/0789,3/3 41 ,9 ,.9:, ,55030/ 3 9080 70208 /:73 907 574.088 41549., 97,38943 1742 ,:9479,7,3 7:0 8 ,3 3/059 2502039,943 41 98 9,8 4:/

/0807;0247085,.07084:7.08,3/0307080988004-7/70208,;0-003/0130/-90907,9:70,3/198/013943198900257.,0;/03.09,9.,3-0/7,3-90,;,,-02,.74

/,9,

8 147 90 /0-,90 43 4 94 /0130 -7/70208 , 80708 41 ,79.08- ,243/ $.0/07

0;98,3/,5:-80/33,850.,88:041904:73,41024.7,.89705708039

90 2089430 ,3/ 574-,- 90 2489 700;,39 .4397-:943 %0 :3/073 ,88:25943 41 90

904709., 17,20475745480/8 9,903/0,39 -7/7020890 025,88 43907

/024.7,9.8,7029-0280,/3,3/9,924894190284:/-0-09907:3/078944/,830

1472841,:9479,7,382

,243/ 574;/08 ,3 4;07, 30 .,881.,947 17,2047 - /893:83 -09003 -07,

/024.7,.08 43 00.947, /024.7,.08 ,2-:4:8 70208 ,3/ 9700 /1107039 9508 41

,:9479,7,382%080 ,70 549., .480/ ,:9479,7,382 , .,9047 .47708543/3 94 90

97,/943,1472841,:9479,7,3828:.,84305,79702084302,3/.9,9478588:9,389.7020800243. 00.947,,:9479,7,382,3/.425099;0,:9479,7,382%094,9907

84:/-094:941,8948:-.,90470841 90.43.0594100.947,,:9479,7,382.430/-$.0/07,3/90/110703.0-090039028-,8.,390/070041705708843,.9:,,550/

..47/309814.:84390.43.0594100.947,,:9479,7,38298 ;07 /03423,943 29 84:3/ ,8 90 50710.9 -7/3 90 430 ,3/ 90 025,88 43

,:9479,7,382/893:8089174290349434100.947,/024.7,.4390490790025,884300.9438 8098 9,5,79 1742 90349434197,/943,,:94.7,.%06:,13 10,9:70841 98

-7/ 1472 41 549., 7020 ,70 9414/ ,3/ 94 , .079,3 09039 .4397,/.947 789 90

3899:943,0/ 570803.0 41 2:95,79 ,3/ 1706:039 00.9438 147 90 .01 00.:9;0 ,3/ 90

3,943, 08,9;0,8802-%080 00.9438 ,70:8:,-74,/3.:8;0 39,9 90 ,700/

:3/07 :3;078, 8:117,0 232, 5:7,89. 3 9,9 45548943 5,7908 ,70 ,40/ 94 7:3232,.425099;039,9455489435,7908,70,40/943;4908,3/80,98,3/232,

4503 3 9,9 45548943 5,7908 ,70 349 .4389,39 8:-0.9 94 2,88;0 705708843 $0.43/ 90

570803.0 41 2,35:,9438 41 00.947, .439089 - 90 3.:2-0398 ,35:,943 41 1472,

.42509943 3 9080 70208 8 84 80;070 57414:3/ /08570,/ ,3/ 88902,9. ,8 94 703/07

00.9438 ,3 3897:2039 41 ,:9479,7,3 7:0 7,907 9,3 3897:20398 41 /024.7,. $.0/07

,35:,943 2, .420 :3/07 2,3 :808 , 807;3 90 5:75480 41 .439,33 90

:3.079,39 41 00.947, 4:9.4208 3974/:.94341/8.723,947 00.947,7:08 00.947,17,:/8

70897.9439445548943.,3//,908,..088942,8820/,,3/.,25,313,3.08;4,94341907


6/17

549., 798 ,3/ .; -07908 :80 41 .407.43 ,8 ,3 3897:2039 41 /88:,843 3 00.947,

,:9479,7,3 70202,08 :80 41 ,3 3899:943, 1,,/0 41 /024.7,. 3 47/07 94 .43.0, 90

70,9 41 ,3,:9479,7,3 4;073,3.0 9 90 8,20 920 3490 9,9 3 8:. 3899:943, 80993

00.9438 ,7024709,3, 2070 ,/473203980.943843 90 .4397,7 /4 2,9907,890 ,7090

.43.70903897:20399470574/:.090889029801430419814:3/,943,5,78%025479,3.041

98,8954398.431720/,84-90/01394341.425099;0,:9479,7,382;03-0;98

,3/,,70203..42509943870,-:9:31,7$:.,70208.425099;03

9,9 /024.7,9. 3899:9438 ,70 /0 8003,8 90 572,7 20,38 41,335407,3/,703492070 , 3/4 /70883 00.9438 4..:7 5074/., ,3/ 0-9 , 20,331: 0;0 41

.42509943455489438 0,089907,.9;9 9,085,.0,-4;074:3/,3/39047 90

.,33 9 8343/024.7,9. 39,9 8:. ;.94708,70 ;07 :30 -0.,:8000.947, 17,:/ 884

88902,9.90,7,8820394145548943.,3//,908,3/9078:55479078,770898.407.43;4,94341.;-0790809. 88409038;0,3/ 90,..088945:-.7084:7.08,3/20/,.4;07,0884

800/9,9905,310/8:30;038,39.5,90/9094/01394384100.947,,:9479,7,382,3/41.425099;0,:9479,7,382

903/944;07,5,3/9080029414.:843908,204-0.9849,9909490728.,3-0.438/070/,883432894:978841.431:8434931,.9/039190.47010,9:7041908030-7/

1472841,:9479,7,3823,847941507;078434184204190574.0/:708,3/3899:9438890/-, ,8 90 .470 41 /024.7,. 9801 ,3/ ,70 ,.340/0/ - 90 907,9:70 ,8 90

89,3/,7/232:2 $.29907,3/,7 00.94383.:843 .4250994300.:9;0 54071472, ;0890/ 3 00.90/ 411.,8 %07 507;07843 .438898 3 90 50788903.0 41 90 1472,

574.0/:70 38590 41 9888902,9. ;4,943%0 0110.9 41 2,35:,943 .,3 -02,30/ ,890

03,702039 41 90 ,5 -09003 90 /0, ,3/ 90 57,.9.0 41 /024.7,. ,5 9,9 43.0

.4384/,90/.,3,7/-010/849,99057,.9.0,8344307349394/4990/0,

347/0794,880880907,9$.0/070;98,3/,/08.7-07010.9890,.9:,10,9:70841

-7/70208, 1307,30/ .,881.,943,3/,3 3/059 89:/ 41 9071:3.94334:/ -0

300/0/9073,9;0,8,74:,55742,943985488-094;0711,9,2,.740;0,82,7

,5,85747088;002070/,3/03,70/4;07920003/:739080.43/5,79419097/

,;000.947,,:9479,7,3828,;002070/,3/.4384/,90/,74:3/9047/%0!49'

!740.9/8,70,90/5,30/,9,2,807;0905:75480

#!,3/$%,7094419014:7;,7,-08.42548390!49'3/041/024.7,.

#!20,8:7089045033088 4100.:9;0 70.7:92039 0 09039 94. , 90 549.,

,.9;0545:,943,8,3455479:393573.5094,99,3905489433 9000.:9;0974:,70:,70/574.088,78,09,$%20,8:708900;04100.:9;0.43897,398

09009039413899:943,0/.43897,3984390/0.8432,35407841.0100.:9;08

/024.7,. 8 , .4:397 9 ,3 4503 88902 41 00.:9;0 70.7:92039 #! 8.470 -

0,7

#! $%

441.4:3970891472,450300.:9;070.7:92039;8

441.4:3970890110.9;05,798:-47/3,943419000.:9;0

#!'$$%


7/17

20,38 41 .425099;0 00.9438 ,3/070 ,..4:39,-9 74:58 08,9:70,3/ ,3 3/0503/039

:/.,7 ,;0 ,3 0110.9;0 ,:9479 $% 8.470 47 9 90 8,20 920 #!

20,8:708901472,45033088419088902070,8$%14.:808900110.9;0.43897,39843

00.:9;0 /0.8432,3 5407 %0701470 ,..47/3 94 90 570;4:8 /013943 ,3 00.947,

,:9479,7,37020.4:/8.4703#!-:998:309,994:/8.4703$%

425,73 90 749 4;07 920 3 90 3:2-0741 .4:39708 8.473 3 #! ,3/ 3 90

3:2-0741.4:397088.4733$%9:82990:81/:739097/,;0903:2-07

41 .4:39708 9 , 1472, 4503 00.:9;0 70.7:92039 . .,3 -0 0907 /024.7,.08 4700.947,,:9479,7,3828,83.70,80/24709,3903:2-0741.4:397089,8:-89,39,

290/00.:9;05407/024.7,.0843

%0 1:70,-4;0 ,55,7039 .431728 90549088,3/ 90,557457,9030884190 /013943 41

00.947,,:9479,7,382,8,/08.7594341-7/70208%0020703.0,3/.4384/,943419080301472841,:9479,7,382.47708543/0/94,,707,5-09003903:2-0741.4:39708

/85,384201472,/024.7,9.574.0/:708,3/903:2-0741.4:39708,.9:,25020393902357,.9.0

$9:/300.947,,:9479,7,3828

%097,3894394,300.947,,:9479,7,37020490 ,9903943 84:/ -0 14.:80/43 ,2470 850.1.6:08943 4 /408,549 -0.420,3

00.947, ,:9479,7,382 $4 1,7 90 907,9:70 43 7020 .,30 ,8 14.:80/ 43 90 97,38943

1742,:9479,7,37:0 94/024.7,.,3/90.,8041, .,301742,950 41,:9479,7,38294

,34907,8702,30/,70300.90/%070,843,,38900,.4197,3894402070/,9

9003/41908:3/079031:03.041900,78:..0881:/024.7,9,94383$4:9073:7450

,3/ ,93 207., ,3/ .,7,.9070/ - , 90044., -,80/ 507850.9;0 ,..47/3 94 .

/024.7,.8903,9:7,03/543941,3574.08841549.,/0;04520393.0905488-99,9

,97,/943,,:94.7,.,4305,797020,29,7:39,,4302,3/.9,9478547842093

080:3/07408,549.,97,3894394,/11070393095041,:94.7,.,8-003,.340/0/

9 8 ,84 25479,39 94 -:/ , 904709., 17,2047 ,-0 94 05,3 ,3/ 4 , 574.088 41

549.,.,302,9,09,9/70.943

%0 ,2 41 98 5,7,7,5 8 94 44 394 5,79 41 90 0893 907,9:70 43 7020 .,30 14705,3,943 419,950342034382 10038 9,99070,703492,3850.1.89:/084390

945.9070;089,79174290907,9:70439097,3894394/024.7,.347/079480019480,3,808,90,899,0394,..4:39905488-941,/11070394:9.420

3 ;07 0307, 90728 89:/08 43 7020 .,30 903/ 94 1, 394 94 9508 $420 ,70 2,.74470390/ 903/ 94 025,80 4-0.9;0 .43/9438 ,3/ 800 549., 97,381472,943 ,8 /0907230/

%08089:/088974331:03.0/-24/073,943904795.,/0243897,909,9/024.7,.8, .43806:03.041 0.4342./0;045203997,381472,94341.,88897:.9:70 3.70,80/0/:.,943

,3/900$42049078,702.74470390/903/94.43.0397,9043549.,,.9478,3/1472:,90

574-028 3 90728 41 5488-908 ,3/ .4.08 %080 89:/08 95., 025,80 90 897,90.

-0,;4741549.,,.94783;4;0/390574.08841.,30

357,.9.,90728906:08943809079070874:3/94050.99,9702097,381472,9438,70/0907230/-842084.40.4342..43/94384734919890.,809,981,1:850.1.,943

41 8:. 1,.9478 4:/ :36:0 ,..4:39 147 7020 97,381472,9438 903 90 574507 7080,7.

897,904:/-094.43/:.9.425,7,9;089,989., 89:/08 415,990738 418947.,.4;,7,9438

,3/90435488-0549., 897,904:/-0 94,9 147 8:. 4-0.9;0 .43/9438 942,9:70

%8 ,8 90/423,93 ,5574,.83.0 905:-.,9434158098 8023,,79.0 $420 84.,

706:890841/024.7,.3%8,831,.9,8490.,80,8908,3/0,7874:

.47708543/ 94 ,9 :393943 /0130/ 90 80.43/ 74-,. 03 2,3 /024.7,9.

0507203983/0;0453.4:397080702807,-1,340;0790/7,2,9.0;03984..:770/


8/17

384:9073 :7450 ,3/ ,93207.,,;0 780 94, 30 45033088 94/0025,80 90 740 41

897:.9:7,.43897,398,3/949905488-941.4.0%0/0,9,9/024.7,.,3/90

50450 4 ;0 :3/074557088;0549., 70208 2:89 84204,9 147 90 .43/9438 94

574/:.09,8344307,..059,-0

%0 /0, 9,9 90 25479,3.0 41 897:.9:7, .43/9438 84:/ -0 70-,,3.0/ 3 1,;4741 504508

,03..4.0857010703.08,3/39070898,81789,/;,3.0/-#:8943,3,79.05:-80/3

#:894-0,38/8.:88433%7,38943894024.7,.990;078250,3/,.:90

4-807;,9439,92:.4190907,9:704390.,:808,3/706:890841/024.7,..431,90/909485439,89,9901,.94789,9005,/024.7,.89,-02,349-09043089,9-74:99394

08903.090390945034203,84:/-089:/0/805,7,9035,79.:,7.43.073390,9907

93.0/03910/,5705,7,947,/0.843,3/,,-9:,9435,8008970880/90740

5,0/-90700;,39,.947841,5498:.,8090202-078455489430,/078473074:58,3/ 90 05.9 /0-07,903088 41 907 ,.9438 ,3/ 3907,.9438 0907 90 9,0 90 1472 41

897:04741-,7,33#:8948 ,.947470390/ ,5574,. 209 , 70,9 1,;47 3 90 8:-806:039 0,78 3 5,79.:,7 9

7057080390/ 90 ,3,9., 17,2047 414330 $.29907 ,3/900,/8%7,38943 1742:9479,7,3 #:0 5740.9 , 7080,7. ,03/, /0;490/ 94 90 .4,580 41 ,:9479,7,382 3

$4:9073:7450,3/,93207.,742 908089:/0802070/ ,8070841.43.:8438,-4:9/024.7,9,9439,94:/ ,;0 897:.9:70/ 90/0-,90437020.,30390 1443/0.,/0

,3/ 4:/ ,;0 14720/ 90 .470 41 97,38944%7,38944 1:3/,2039, ,88:259438 .,3 -08:22,70/,81448,749078789,3.4:39724;3,,1742/.9,947,7:0.,3

-0.438/070/,.4:397397,3894394,7//024.7,.$0.43//024.7,9,943903/894:314/3

,809806:03.041 89,084503303 /;8438,550,7 3907:3090,43 90.0,;,0

-09003 ,7/3078 ,3/ 84193078 -70,974: 03 90 4/ 7020 .4,580 ,3/ 30

3899:9438,70389,0/.4384/,94303-49090,3/84.0909:80/9490307:0841

90,20%7/90:3/073.43/9438397,38943,.4:397089070.4342.0;0549.,

89473899:943,0,.08093..42548943.:9:7,97,/943809.349-02,471,.9478

3 0907 90 43809 47 90 4:9.420 41 90 97,38943 574.0884:79 90 572,7 .,:8, ;,7,-0

/:73 97,389438 8 090 -,7,33 0 90 897,90. 3907,.943 -09003 0,/078 41 90 147207

7020 ,3/ 705708039,9;08 41 90 45548943 19 14:3/3 00.9438 507 80 7057080398 , 0

0307,947 4;07 920 41 1:7907 /024.7,9. 7014728 $9 97/ ,;0 /024.7,9. 97,389438 ,70

-03-:943.4070391:3.943389,90898 349 .0,7 94,909039905,88,0 1742 90 850.1., 70,9;0 82,3:2-0741 .,808

93,70,9;04240304:8.:9:7,,70,$4:9073:7450,3/,93207.,94900307, 97,38943 94 /024.7,. ,9 ,70 47 0;03 /024.7,9,943 ,8 473, 3 90 ,:9478

39039438;03 ,7,5/70,/3 419079039,9;0.43.:843840;074://0243897,90900;0 41 ,55742,943 41 90 ,-4;0 :/0308 9 70850.9 94 4330 ,3/ $.299078

7010.943 ,70 /82880/ 35,79.:,7 ,550,7 907 702,78 ,-4:9 90 097,47/3,7 89,90 413/090723,.9,9.,7,.9070,574.0884197,389431742,.079,3,:9479,7,3702094,7/

,3 :3.079,3 842093 080 47 ,-4:9 90 1,.9 9,9 9480 1,.947 . 070 30.088,7 ,3/

8:11.039 147 574;43 90 .4,580 47 80197,381472,943 41 ,3 ,:9479,7,3 7020 2, -0

3090730.088,73478:11.03994038:7090389,:7,94341/024.7,.47,,3,-4:9908,75

/893.9430893-0900390 574.08808 41-07,,943,3//024.7,9,943 ,3/90/11070394:9.4208 03 , 574.088 4..:78 94:9 90 4907 8:. ,8 /.9,-,3/,8 ,3/

/024.7,/:7,84330 $.29907 8 ,70,/ 2039430/ 98 -,80/ 507850.9;0

574;086:90:317:91:03/0,39-7/70208

!704788024.7,.,3/90,709574-,-14790/70.95,79.5,9434190,:947

94 9,9 5740.9 41 7080,7. 7057080398 , 5,79, 0.05943 93 97,38944 907,9:70 3 9,9

;4:2090,:947/0;0450/,97,389431742,:9479,7,37:0,20.834.438/070/,

.,88.3/024.7,9,943907,9:70%024/0574.00/8,814488,.43806:03.04184208479

41 57088:70 0.4342. /0.30 29,7 /010,9 842093 ,55030/ 3 , 30-4744/ .4:397


9/17

09. 90 7:3 090 41 90 ,:9479,7,3 7020 8598 394 , 74:5 41 84193078 4 800 90

3974/:.943418420-07,37014728,8,20,3894-74,/039084.,-,8041907020,3/94

094:94190.788,3/,74:541,7/30784455480,345033701472;03904343

0,3088 41 90 7020 84193078 ,;0 .420 94 5742303.0 ,3/ ,70 34 3 90 548943 41

/0./3,994/409079489.99089,9:86:44794 2502039907.439740/45033

5,3 %07 /0.843 40;07 /0503/ 43 907 050.9,9438 ,-4:9 90 39039438 41 90

45548943 74:58 0 4 .; 84.09 708543/ 94,5,79,45033 41 90549.,88902

%04,41905,79,-07,,9435745480/-8419307831,.9894.445984204554894374:58394,-74,/030//.9,94785-:9984:9.420-05488-0431.;84.09,700894

0390714390.4397,7.;84.09/0./08949,0,/;,39,04190.7.:289,3.08 90 .788

90 0908 39073,/;8438 ,3/ 9030 85,.0 41,.943.43.0/0/ ,3/9424-0,,389 90

/.9,94785841930785,381,19890.,8084193078548943889743:3/07230/,3/,90;079,5503905, 1479071,:70 904393 90.,3/434 894

,990259 94,;4/904789 , .;,7%4.4.08,70,;,,-0%0 1789 45943 8 947057088545:,724-,943,3/947089470,3,77407/.9,947850/-90,7/3078%078398

.,8089,9705708843439-08:..0881:,3/9,9,338:703.2,09089,90.4,580%080.43/ 45943 8 94 ,..059 455489438 /02,3/8 ,3/ :92,90 5742490 90 97,38943 94

/024.7,.

!704788 24/0 41 97,38943 ,8 2,3 20798 789 9 98 90 897,90. 3907,.943

-09003202-07841901472077020,3/202-07841904554894374:58;3,..4:394190/3,28239738.39080574.08808$0.43/33094330,3/$.299078,/;.08

9 3.:/08 90 34943 41 :3.079,39 ,9 0,89 43 90 84193078 8/0 %7/ 9 2,39,38 9,9

-07,,943 ,3/ /024.7,9,943,70 349 834328 ,3/ 90147207 .,3 08994:990 ,9907

4:79,3/248925479,39,83.4397,8999085794190920903974/:.94341:3.079,39

2,08 , 97,38943 94/024.7,. , ;07 :30 4:9.420 41, 7020 .788 90 708:9 41 6:90

3,774.7.:289,3.08

03 84193078,;0 94/0./00907 94 2,39,3 90 89,9:86:4 47 94 5742490 -07,,943

701472890/439349070,89703941904554894374:58%0789703939:73843

9431:03.0-4990044/418:..08841705708843,3/:92,90908419307839,.4.0

%8-0.0,73,242039,1907,;3890/,.9478897:.9:7084157010703.08$4193078 74,/030/.9$9,9:8":4.9,774.9%7,3894338:703.

5548943 %7,3894374,/030/.9$9,9:8":4.938:703.,774.9

4098.438/079094.,8084189743,3/0,45548943805,7,90,3/7084;090,-4;0

,20--,.,7/ 3/:.943 184193078 1,.0,897434554894390 4591472,39,33

90 89,9:8 6:4 ;03 90 78 41 ,3 38:703. 3 .,80 41 705708843 ,3/ 90 45548943857010703.0 147 /024.7,. 3890,/ 41 , -74,/030/ /.9,94785 1 45548943 8 0, 43 90

.4397,7 84193078 .,3 4-9,3 907 2489 57010770/ 4:9.420 ;03 9,9 , /010,9 3 .,80 41


10/17

7057088438;07045548943,..05994 03907 3,5,79, -07,0/,:94.7,.7,907

9,3783941,3,3,77407702031,.940;0784193078.,3349-0.425090,,7041

90 89703941 9045548943,3/ 98250710.9 31472,943 ,5503894-09001472,3,

97,3894394 /024.7,. 5488-0%06:90:370,89. .,80 3. 84193078,70 31,.9 57494

/024.7,9078.280,/,7/3078349989,3/3,97,3894394/024.7,.2989,7943

1 841930782839075709 90 89:,943 ,3/ 93 90 ,70 1,.3 , 0, 45548943 070,8 90

,99078,.9:,,-09447,30

!70478824/041.4:780850710.9-0,3/9070,708420,990259894.4770.981,8,908,3/:208/090.9, 1,0/2,3,0203941:3.079,39%0 97,3814729024/0 3430

93.42509031472,9433974/:.33,9:70,84,990-0333-:990,843974/:.09700

5488-03/41-07,07857494/024.7,9078088.422990/0,89.422990/0,.4309

89/1107039897:.9:7084157010703.0890 708:9 8507,58 1472,.4770.9 -:9 8/013902470 2088 $,23,9,3 -:/8 , 82507 ,20 070 45548943 24;08 1789 -:9 8

390708989405,3;,7,943-0900350,.01:3049,90/,3/.431.9:,7020.,307,9079,39039,94341,97,38943

3 , !704788,20 9039 0,78 ,1907 98 5:-.,943 8 89 /0 ,..0590/ - 90907,9:70,3/98,7/9493,-4:9,3,9073,9;024/0,80307,,89,94309908,20920

-:9 988 ,2470 0307,574-02 411472,24/0841 702097,38943 0850., 1.425,70/970.039050703.089/024.7,9,943,3/-74,/850,37020.,309 419031,8

%,98,7-,7,0//08.4397-:94383245343844790( /1107039 3/8 41 ,:9479,7,382 /1107 1742 0,. 4907 ,8 2:. ,8 90 /1107 1742

/024.7,. 80 ,7:08 9080 /110703.08 .,:80 ,:9479,7,3 70208 94 -70, /43 3

88902,9.,/1107039,8,3/90,110.997,389434:9.4208,1907,;3/03910/

9700 /1107039 9508 41 ,:9479,7,3 70208 507843,89 29,7 830 5,79 5:8 , 14:79

-7/ 29:70 41 5:70 9508 0//08 57454808 ,3/ 90898 0//08 - 90 1443

549088 /1107039 9508 41 ,:9479,7,3 4;0732039 ,;0 /1107039 0110.98 43 90 3.039;08

.4317439370208:55479078031,.0/9.,0308949089,9:86:4$013/89,929,7

70208 03 .,030/ 903/ 94 859 0,8 ,3/ ,70 2470 57430 94 3049,90 50,.01: ,

97,38943 94 .425099;0 549., 889028 507843,89 70208 43 90 .4397,7 903/ 94 70,.9

/11.:908-.7.3 90 ,43 ,70 2470 0 9403/ 3 ;403.0,3/ ,84 94-0 1440/ -

84204907147241,:9479,7,3828305,797020813,84,,-9418:7;;,,8

90903/94.4459907.,03078,9073,9;090:80943049,90,50,.01:97,38943:99054398/4!70478824/04197,38943,4390//08850.1.,9438,..4:39147

90389,:7,94341,3-7/7020,3/35,79.:,741,300.947,,:9479,7,38208,3/3408-0.,:80903;8,08905488-941,-74,/030//.9,947858420936:9082,794,3

-7/ 7020 4 -0.,:80 90 .43.059 41 00.947, ,:9479,7,382 8 842093 2470 9,3 ,-74,/030//.9,94785,3/90/110703.0-090039094,5503894-06:,9,9;01:3/,2039,

..47/3 94 90 24/0 , -74,/030/ /.9,94785 8 90 708:9 41 84193078 05.9 4189,-3907020 ,3/41907 791:507.059434190 89:,943%8 8.438890399 90

389,:7,94341,300.947,,:9479,7,382. ,80,;08003 8349,3,../039,4390

5,994,7//024.7,.-:9,33899:943,,77,302039347/0794:,7,390070208:7;;,-

,/,593 94 90 8579 41 90 920%0 -49 708543/ 94 90 8,20 2507,9;0 $42093 2:89

.,301938,704394702,3908,203,250/:8,847/8:990/49/1107039:9479,7,37:0785742490-07,,94394:9,907390897:.9:7041,:94799,9894:9

-0.423,..4:39,-0 9490.9037,3/ 9:8 -0.420/.9,-,3/,80.947,,:9479,7,3828

82,7 3 90 8:-89,3.0 ,70 .,7,.9070/ - , 2470 1307,30/ 8:71,.0%0 3974/:.943 41

549.,70147288349,290/.43.0884330.,30418:55479#014728.,700;032470

7,/.,39071472-0.420,33897:203994/8:8070,9

0//08 389843907,3/ 8:089,3 39070893 54908894-090890/0329,7,3/

8305,79 70208 .7,. 90 903/ 94 ;0 90 , 94 , 50,.01: 97,38943 94 /024.7,.

507843,8970208033.788903/94-0.42000.947,,:9479,7,3828


11/17

%4.43.:/090389,:7,94341,300.947,,:9479,7,382890.43806:03.041,305.9

-:9982470090708:941,17,:/7,9079,341455489438:92,90,700203994039073/

17,:/08008,84,990-,8841981:3.9433

%0,2041#0/0.9438

4 /4 00.947, ,:9479,7,3 70208 1:3.943 ,9 20.,3828 8 907 3899:943,

.431:7,943,-0949707347/0794:,7,3900907438:7;;,,3/.4384/,943

3 90 570;4:8 5,7,7,58 9 ,8 ,70,/ -003 54390/ 4:9 9,9 90 2,3 10,9:70 /893:8300.947, ,:9479,7,382 1742 4907 97,/943, 14728 41 ,:94.7,. 8 90 570803.0 41 1472,

3.:8;0 ,3/ .425099;0 00.9438 9 90 8,20 920 90 2,3 10,9:70 /893:83 00.947,

,:9479,7,382 1742 /024.7,. 8 90 88902,9. 2,35:,943 41 9080 00.9438 0.947,

2,35:,943 020708 903 ,8 90 503420343 480 :3/0789,3/3 2, 05 94 05,3 90.,5,-94100.947,,:9479,7,382948:7;;0,3/70574/:.09801

8549.,7020824;01742,:9479,7,38294/024.7,.14:3/300.9438,708:55480/942,790 3899:943,-70,990,:9479,7,35,89%8 8,55742,90,9,55030/9

900,797/,;097,389438384:9073:7450,3/,93207.,3,90797,38943840;077,907 9,3 6:9 90 549., 8.030 ,3/ 3049,90 097,00.947, :,7,39008 ,:9479,7,3 7:078

4590/1470390739000.947,,703,;039,99074,,889,335407,8.,3//,908909794/89479,3/.439749000.947,574.088347/07942320907841/010,9 3/4384

90 ,;0/0;0450/80;07, /110703957,.9.08$9:/390805034203,$.0/07,8 ,-094.4250 , 203: 41 2,35:,943 %8 7,308 1742 90 00.947, 17,:/ 0 90

3974/:.94341/894794383,341902:950890584190;493574.08817429070897,94341

;490789490.4:3934190;490894549.,70570884317422,35:,9390549.,,703,-

0.:/3.425099478,3/ 17,203939045548943 1743994,9073907:0841705708039,943

1742 2,35:,93 90 88:0 85,.0 - 20,38 41 2,3:1,.9:70/ .0,;,08 39073,943, ,7

90774782 09. 94 90 8250 .43974 4;07 90 20/, 47 ,,3 90 ,7,882039 392/,943

/0897:.94341905:-.705:9,9434190,/;078,708

085904190-74,/,77,,3/90,55,70397:/0308841903897:20398,9907/8548,40;07

9020.,3828247017,0,3/.42509,3929-0 050.90/%01,.989,9 ,,3,3

00.947,,:9479,7,38283492070,-07,0/,:94.7,.3.:8;0,3/.425099;000.9438

,9 90 3,943, 0;0 ,705074/., 0/ ,3/ 00.94383;,7,-.,30 905,310/%0

.43;4.,943412:95,7900.943840;0770/30.088,72508904503341,-70,.41:3.079,39!70478%0897,9008412,35:,943,2,9.439,3398 :3.079,39

-:990.,3,7/023,909%03 30907 3.:2-039834741.4:780455430398507.0;02,35:,90/ 00.9438 ,8 ,3 06:-7:2 84:943 2489 - /013943 2,35:,90/ 00.9438

.,3349-03899:943,0/,890 ,70390.4397,790.,3-0 2,30/ 3902//041,7,,70,41 3899:943,,2-;,03.09,908-09003 905408411:,:9479,7,3.43974,3/

1:/024.7,9.:3.079,39$.0/07- %0,2-;,0393,9:704170/00.94388:0898$.0/0794/08.7-09,9503420343,8, 940;0,2041 /024.7,9,943-00.9438%0

3,20 29 -0 280,/3 -:9 9 8 825 /:0 94 90 1,.9 9,9 3 90 .,80 41 00.947,

,:9479,7,38289097,38943174297,/943,,:9479,7,37:0:8:,-0,3,8,3,55,7039

03:3097,3894394/024.7,.89.,7,.9070/-,3,248945548905,9970850.9944/

/024.7,.08,3/0,797/,;0/024.7,.08,80390,9907.,808090.425099434;0790307:084190,20,3/-,7,33570.0/0/3.:843,3/90.,4114:3/300.9438,

390147207.,8000.9438,;0-00390;0717898905

0983414.:890,99039434390940;03,9:7041$.0/078,20 %4/08.7-0990,:947

2,08 :80 41%80-088 34943 41 30890/,20 2,35:,90/ 00.9438 :314/ ,8 , 30890/ ,20

07090,20390573.5,,703, 830890/38/0,-07,20070907:084190,20

90280;08,70;,7,-0%0897:0-090033.:2-0398,3/45543039839000.947,,703,8,9

90 8,20 920 , 897:0 4;07 90 -,8. 7:08 8,53 90 00.947, ,703, 9801 %0 ,20 41

00.947, .42509943 93 570;,039 3899:943, 7:08 8 84204 30890/ 38/0 , ,707 ,3/


12/17

2470 1:3/,2039, 209,,20 41 00.947, 701472 90 ,9907 :314/3 82:9,304:8 ,3/

3907,.93990147207

8 3 , 897,90. ,208 ,9 0,. 89,0 90 94 ,.9478 90 ,:9479,7,3 4;0732039 ,3/ 90

45548943.43174399/1107039.4.08%089,79354398,4;0732039.,3,300.943

9045548943/034:3.08,81,0/3.4393:,943903.:2-039/0./08090794708543/

9490.79.82;4.0/-98,/;078,708-0907,9903/39447300.93907.425,398

90455489430;,:,908907085438090981742904;0732039,3//0./080907945,79.5,90

47-4.4999000.943903.:2-039.448080907947:3,70,9;0.0,300.9434794.422917,:/4300.943/,1907:35,798/0.,70/;.9474:89045548943/0./08

090794,..059 475749089 90 708:9,3/ 3.:2-0398 /0./094 7057088 0;039:, 45548943

5749089847708543/-45033:594701472

80.,38009024/0 ,/29843 430 5488-9 1472,39,33 9089,9:86:4 41 , 70/

00.947, 88902 9,9 8 455489438 ,.6:08.03.0 41 00.947, 708:98 472, 40;07

45548943,7/,..0591,0/00.9438,8,303/54399038:.,34:9.4208:30%0

248904:9.420,..47/394$.0/0780907, 1:7907890594,7//024.7,.47 34789

.,80 , 8905 -,. 94,7/ , 3,774 ,:94.7,. 0.947, ,:9479,7,382 ,,3 8 349 ,3

06:-7:2 $9 3 57,.9.0 70/ 00.9438903/ 94 9707 ..08 41 .431.9,74:3/ 00.947,

70147289,92,/080;07,97,58490178941,90,82209741907084:7.08,;,,-0940,.5,07,3/90 3907/0503/03.

4190,204;0732039,3/45548943.43974/11070399508417084:7.083,2000.947,7:08,3/00.947,092,.,3/9887010.90/39024/03.:2-0398.4.083,990209,

,20 0;0070,8455489438.4.08 3,990,200;0%,9 ,822097,8 25479,39.43806:03.080850.,10.438/0790897,90.3907/0503/03..,7,.907390,20 3

90 430 ,3/ ,:9479,7,3 7:078 .,70 ,-4:9 ,9 0,89 , 802-,3.0 41 092,. ,3/ 9:8 300/

45548943 .44507,943 3 90 4907 ,3/ 45548943 .,70 ,-4:9 90 .43/9438 41 00.947,

.42509943,.8/0.4397487084:7.08;,:,-094904907,3/,8943/:.090,/;078,794

.44507,90%0701470 90 3.:2-039 9708 94 09 ,9 0 ,398 ,9 90 ,20 0;0 455489435,79.5,943 94 00.9438 - /0543 90 7084:7.08 0 .422,3/8 ,9 90 209,,20 0;0

2,35:,9434100.947,.43/94385548943839:73979409,990,39,990209,

0;000.947,701472-:83900;07,090,;0,990,200;05,79.5,93701:8394

5,79.5,90949000.947,,20;03 907 .431.93 2507,9;08 ,3/ 90 3907/0503/03.0 .,7,.9073 90 ,20 ,.9478

.4317439980;070897,90./022,8390430,3/,33.:2-0391,.089097,/0411-09003-7334554894339490,20147 092,943,3/0053 9:3/07.43974,35:,93

00.9438 9:8 9:738 394 , /11.:9 -,,3.3 ,.9 /89479 90 00.947, 574.088 349 ,8 2:. ,8

5488-0 -:9 43 ,82:. ,8 30.088,73 90 4907 ,3/ 45548943 5,7908 1,.0 ,3 4554890

/022,%0 34 9,9 00.9438 -0 5,79, 70/ -:9 ,84 9,9 9070 -0 , .079,3


13/17

/07004145033088%089405499885,.0347/0794097,.9/024.7,9..43.088438-:9

9825085,79.5,9394,1,0/00.943,3/9:8092,939

%080 897,90. ,.943/022,8 ,70 ,84 09030/ - 90 :3.079,3908 ,884.,90/ 9 ,.9478

.4770,943 41 897039 ,3/ 9:8 549., .42509943 55,7039 3 1,.9 ,3 0;0 41

.425099;030882,.43899:90, 5,:8-0 70,843 147,3 3/ 41897,90. 70854380( 92,

249;,90701472,80,8.48:7043-0,1413.:2-0398,3/5749089,80,8,.6:08.03.043

-0,1 41 45548943 5,7908 $.0/07 742 90 507850.9;0 41 ,:9479,7,3 7:078 90

020703.041,89743455489432,09073.039;090,/45943412,35:,9;0897,90084790.43.08843418420/024.7,9.1700/428347/0794/01:80549.,574908983.,8041,0,

45548943 - .4397,89 3.:2-0398 2, 0907 :80 17,:/ 3/8.723,90 47 3974/:.0 450338

94:97874290507850.9;041455489435,790839:730,30882,-0,33.039;0-49

94-4.499,3/945,79.5,90,890,;099094480$2,7190,70897435,79.5,94329,,7/,80,85:389023.,804117,:/

494094:9418:.,/0,/4.%043,,3,.9472,/0,99097,584190,2041/024.7,9,943-00.94388-/0;8320/897,900855479:3908147.42-33897,9008

,70,;,,-0147-49903.:2-039,3/9045548943390430,3/,4;07320392,9,0,/;,39,0 41 98 ;,70,90 203: 41 2,35:,943 5.3 90 79 .42-3,943 41 9028 ,3

3.:2-0392,-0,-0941309:3000.9438,82:.,89830.088,794-:/.70/-9,3/9:8944-9,3092,.05:99335,.0,108:-90570.,:9438347/0794.439,3/024.7,9.

:3.079,393904907,3/,3455489435,792,84;098897,90./022,-,..05939489,3/ 147 00.9438 0 709,33 90 79 94 5749089 ,,389 708:98 1 00.9438 //39 8,981

232,706:8908411,73088

3 ,3 00.947, ,:9479,7,3 7020 7:078 ,3/ /024.7,9. 45548943 ,;0 10 94 , .4250

00.947, ,20 %0 -7/ 3,9:70 41 8:. ,3 3899:943, ,77,302039 90 5,7,/4 41

:3/024.7,9.00.943887010.90/39034306:-7:2548943,8830/949089,9:86:49

908,209209,9-7/3,9:7089070,843905,994,7/,5747088;0/024.7,9,943

84.480,9,3/ 39047 8088 57,.9.,-0 9,3050.90/%0.43;4.,9434170/00.9438

97078,30890/,203.90.42509943147;4908,3/90897:014700.947,7014724

,3/3,3/$.0/07-%8,8.43806:03.08

472,904:9.4202470/024.7,.29-0,.0;0/39700,809071904;0732039

39,/0./08 94,9903/455489438 .425,38 47 19 8:-806:0394598 147 7:33370,9;0

.0,3 00.9438471 9:92,90.43.0/0800.947,7014728;03 9,9905488-9089,9904;0732039 390,89/0.84354392,459 147 99033 908.70,7010893493:90

34306:-7:2 89,9:8 6:4 8 2,39,30/ 3 :89 94 .,808 0907 1 90 45548943 -4.499800.94389:8288390455479:39147,338970394719,..05989070/708:98%4

6:90 :30 459438 4:/ 8,%0701470903307 4.4190,2080028 945: 9,,1742,:9479,7,382

357,.9.040;07938,70349,8897,9147,7/,89029,550,739024/0,9,1789,3.0%0897,90.3907/0503/03.0419094,.94783;4;0/390,2098.43806:03.083

9072841.4.0841,.9439097,/04118,3//022,8,.94781,.0;0390770850.9;0.431.93

2507,9;08 90 :3.079,39 ,884.,90/ 9 5407 .4770,9438 ,3/ 3 5,79.:,7 90 34330,7

0110.9841 455489438970390,3088, 98 3.70,808 90.425094190,20 31,.9 ,

98,24898:-;079890044/41 0,.4:9.42070/:.0890.,3.041 099390/024.7,9.4:9.420,3/7,8089,941702,3389:.39034306:-7:24100.947,,:9479,7,382

42-33 897,9008 0 ,;08003 8430 90.36:0 147 70/:.3 90 .42509 41 90 ,20

4;073203930110.92,08:..00/3709,3354070.:9;,93842070802-,3.041

092,.-239,-9.42502039,7897,90084100.947,.43974554894339:73

.,3 5,79.5,90 ,3/8:-806:039574908994:9 0923 90 00.9438:9 8193 1742 90

1.943 41 90,20 -,. 94 70,9 :31479:3,90 .,898/4:-98 43 90 011.,.4:83088 41 8:. ,

897,9039073902,35:,90/ 00.947,,20944 41903 2508 98 092,943,3/ 9:8 98

507509:,943548907475749089803 2,35:,90/708:98,705:-.,70 41903 088 0110.9;0


14/17

9,3 , 5747 -,9908 4;07 90 7:08 41 90 ,2043089 4 2,3 .,808 41 8:..0881: 5489

00.947,57490898.,3070202-07370.0390,78:89,8,30./49,0;/03.009893,-4:990

/1107039923419070.0394;073203945548943897:083&7,30,3/7,3,3/90/1107039

4:9.420 41 9080 897:08%0 ,/;,39,0 0340/ - ,:9479,7,3 7:078 8 6:90 0;/039 ,3/

7,3081742/8.70/93.79.828-,997-:9345548943870;,3.08 94907:3545:,79,3/

:3/024.7,9.85799490:8041;403.0

43.:843

%0 ,241 985,507,8-,8., 94 , 9014:3/,9438 147,5574,.390 89:/41 -7/

7020892094/78970.43897:.90/90247070.0399703/841549.,.,3097070/-90 97/ ,;0 41 /024.7,9,943 3 /43 84 7,907 9,3 , 2070 907,9:70 70;0 970/ 94

574;/0 8420 0;/03.0 41,9 ,8 8,3- 20,38 418250 /08.759;0 89,989.8 41 0,8,;,,-0 /,9,;03 1 3.425090 7, ,3/ ,70 8:5071., 90 9,-08 ,3/ 7,58 574;/0/

8:554790/ 2,7:20398$0.43/ ,//70880/,9 3245343,70 90-,8. 88:08 147, 1::3/0789,3/34100.947,,:9479,7,38210;079-05488-0390430,3/90/3,2.

41 3899:943, .,30 9,99:730/ 80;07, 97,/943,,:9479,7,3 70208 3948:. , 5,79.:,7-7/390 4907 ,3/90/3,2. 9,92,08 90 8:7;;,,3/ 0;03.4384/,943 419080

702085488-0 ,;0 57479 94 89:/08 -,80/43 7,943, .4.0 9047 ,8 98,8 430 41 90 2489 .42243

,5574,.08 37020 97,38943 907,9:70/:73 90 803 2:.41 90 0893 89:/08 43

97,3894394/024.7,.,;0-0035:-80/81479014720788:090/0391.,9434100.947,

,:9479,7,382 ,8, -574/:.9 41 90 97/,;0,3/ ,8 ,3 ,2489-7,3/ 30 950 -03 43

70.0392,34190207034905.9,20/94/08.7-090/0;,3997,0.947,839070890/

3 40;07 94:9 94:/ ,;0-003 39070893 94 800 0907 948089:/08070,-0 94

,/29,9 0,89905488-941,82,7/0;,943814790,990788:04390.4397,77,943,

.4.0 574;08 5,79.:,7 011.,.4:8 3 ;3 ,..4:39 41 90 .4250 39073, /3,2.8 9,9

570;039,1:7907/0;04520393/024.7,9./70.943841948070208

%070;05745480/81,71742.425090-:94501:929705708039,89,7935439,898

843041909,888,.,774:939030924398


15/17

#010703.08

4,,7/8,998742 /0700 94 950 %0 /11.:9 ,79 41 /7,3 90 30 3 20,8:708 41

/024.7,.

4,,7/8 ,998 4 94 .,881 -7/ 70208 /010.9;0 /024.7,.08 ,3/ 00.947,

,:9479,7,382024.7,9,943;43

,749078%42,8024.7,.94:9:8438470311,78;43

,749078%42,8%03/4190%7,38943!,7,/2 4:73,41024.7,. ;4 3

,749078%42,8%0806:03.31,,.4:73,41024.7,.;43

,7 ,2 #4-0798 4/07 ,99 4/07 $43, !73.508 41 425,7,9;0 !49.8

,83943"!7088

407 ,;//.4.#4-079024.7,.08,3//.494208 ,57,2,9.,5574,. 94 .4.08,-4:9.43.059833:,#0;041!49.,$.03.03

407 ,;/ 0;98 $90;03 024.7,. 9 ,/0.9;08 43.059:, 334;,943 3

.425,7,9;07080,7.47/!49.83

, #4-079 !4,7., !,790.5,430 0 5548430 30 88902 549. 7,3.4 30

,349947!4,7.!,79.5,943,3/5548943

,243/ ,77 3 :,3 5809 $02:7 ,9 2,08 147 /024.7,. 3 !49.8 3

/0;0453.4:39708.425,73050703.089/024.7,.4:/07#03307

,243/,7789097/,;04;074:73,41024.7,.;43

,243/,77%33,-4:9-7/702084:73,41024.7,.;4357

03 , !,: %0 090723,398 41 024.7,9. %7,389438 %0 4:73, 41 431.9#084:943;43

::,2,7,3.8%003/41908947,943,3907089$:2207

,3F 0,37,348 ,389 90 %/0 70 -7/ #0208 2470 9,3 $,3/ ,8908 5,507

57080390/,990!$,33:,20093,83943$05902-079

,908 $.499 :208 7,3 ,208 31472,943 ,3/ !49.8 33 7-47 &3;0789 41

.,3!7088

0//08,7-,7,,9/4034,-4:9/024.7,9,943,190790390,7833:,#0;041

!49.,$.03.03,

0//08,7-,7,:9479,7,370,/430257.,908941, ,20904709.,7:2039473

!,50757080390/,990,33:,200934190207.,3!49.,$.03.0884.,943-


16/17

:393943 $,2:0 !, %07, 3/,9, :34 443, 99 47 %0 %7/ ,;0

024.7,9,943390,90%03909039:7

,5,3#4-079,8/024.7,.:89,242039%09,39.4390.02-07

:07 ,.0 03 5,33 ,3/ 4/03 024.7,9. %7,389438 %0 4:73, 41

431.9#084:943;4355

0;98$90;03,:.,3%0#8041425099;0:9479,7,382 4:73,41024.7,.

;43

0;98$90;03,:.,3425099;0:9479,7,38290020703.0,3//3,2.841-7/

702083905489.4/,707,.,5,3/1479.423

,78,439 :77%0/# ,07809 !49., #020,7,.90789.8 ,3/%7,389438!49'!740.903907147$8902.!0,.0

07041,370/.9,947858 709:733 #0;893 90 /024.7,9. 74-,. 549088

43902547,7!49.8;43,7.

4734 043,7/470 9070 -7/ 70208 7,70 90 :89 ,3 459., :843 :7450,3

!49.,$.03.0#0;0;43

:3. '07:03 43.059:,3 ,3/ 0,8:73 024.7,. ;,:,93 ,9073,9;0

3/.08425,7,9;0!49.,$9:/08;430-7:,7

!70478/,2024.7,.,3/90,709,2-7/0&3;0789!7088

#:894,3,79 %7,389438 94 /024.7,. 94,7/ , /3,2.24/0 425,7,9;0 !49.8

'45

4330 :0724 $.29907 !550 900,/,703.0 %7,38943 1742 :9479,7,3

#:0425,7,9;0!07850.9;0434538&3;0789!7088

4330 :0724 $.29907 !550 %7,38943 1742 :9479,7,3 #:0 %039,9;0.43.:8438,-4:9:3.079,3/024.7,.08434538&3;0789!7088

$,79474;,3341,7.,317004;073203997,;04:73,41024.7,.;4

$.0/073/70,8%0203:412,35:,9434:73,41024.7,.;43,

$.0/07 3/70,8 %0 0890/ ,20 41 024.7,9,943 - 0.9438 39073,943, !49.,$.03.0#0;0;43-

$.29907 !550,7%07733,9 /024.7,. 8,3/ 8349 4:73, 41024.7,.

$:2207

$42,3:034047,1,/0,/024.7,,:34443,


17/17

$,23,9,3 $//,79 %20 !407 ,3/ 024.7,9. %7,389438 %0 4:73, 41 431.9

#084:943;43

900,/,703.0024.7,9,943%047,3/50703.0147/&!

,,7,,700/%0#8041-07,024.7,.470311,7834;02-070.02-07

origin and functioning of electoral authoritarianism

Documents