organizing for agile bi

Organizing for BI and Big Data in the 21st Century

Timo Elliott, SAP

SESSION CODE: 0903

© 2014 SAP SE or an SAP affiliate company. All rights reserved. 2

Agenda

BICC Overview

What Changed?

Learning From Others

Recommendations

Wrap-up

3

Business Intelligence Competency Centers


What is a BICC?

A Business Intelligence Competence Center (BICC) is a cross-functional organizational team that has

defined tasks, responsibilities, roles and skills for supporting and promoting the effective use of Business Intelligence across an organization

Note that Gartner says that “Competency Centers” have a bad reputation, and now recommends “Business Analytics Team”…


Basic Goal: Make BI More Strategic and Cost-Effective

Reactive

Maintenance

Strategic

Reactive

Maintenance

Strategic


BICCs Bring Big Benefits

Every winner of a BI Best Practice Award has a BICC

• (but beware of correlation and causation)

Organizations With A BICC see:

• Increased usage of Business Intelligence (74%)

• Increased business user satisfaction (48%)

• Better understanding of the value of BI (45%)

• Increased decision-making speed (45%)

• Decreased staff costs (26%)

• Decreased software costs (24%)

Survey conducted by BetterManagement.com, 2010

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=4&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CEIQFjAD&url=http://www.researchgate.net/publication/257036372_INTEGRATION_OF_KNOWLEDGE_MANAGEMENT_AND_BUSINESS_INTELLIGENCE_INNITIATIVES_IN_A_COLLABORATIVE_INTELLIGENCE_FRAMEWORK/links/0c960524405e2c55d4000000&ei=eVMZVKbRI5LeaJargfgK&usg=AFQjCNGVe13GiYTTCAmZ2M1fJIlFxzjxyA&sig2=Z1Qde6IY8CpZhm4e0m8jkg&bvm=bv.75558745,d.d2s


The Main Functions and Responsibilities of a BICC

Source: Capgemin BICC Study 2012i

http://www.slideshare.net/capgemini/business-intelligence-competency-centers-best-practices

http://www.slideshare.net/capgemini/business-intelligence-competency-centers-best-practices


BICC Key Skills

Source: Gartner

9

What Changed?


Analytics Is The New Heart of Business


Information Becomes a Profit Center

Products become

“experiences”

Experiences require real-

time, personalized information

Information becomes part

of product sale

Business owners

want/need more control

Faster, more iterative needs

Great news for analytics

The challenge for the future


Democracy and Empowerment Has Made Us Unhappy!

Consumerization of ITEmployee-driven technology

Business-led budgetsCustomer-facing needs

More external dataSpeed of change

Increased business frustrationIncreased IT frustration


Lots of New Techniques and Technologies

Businesses struggling to provide coherent approach

Source: Gartner


But BICCs Are Not Driving BI


The Majority of Data Users Need Isn’t In The System

“We found, on average, that 45% of the data business people use resides outside of the enterprise BI environments.

An astonishingly miniscule 2% of business decision-makers reported using solely enterprise BI applications.

This is undoubtedly connected to 76% of business respondents indicating they continue to resort to spreadsheets and other homegrown BI applications to analyze BI data. ”

Source: Forrester

45%

55%

In enterprise systemsNot in enterprise system


Enterprise Systems Are Too Slow


Enterprise BI: Too Little Data And Too Hard to Use


Business Users Do Not Fully Trust Enterprise Data


So Users Turn To Their Own Systems

40% are using an equal amount or more of homegrown applications


Basic Conflict

BI programs have struggled to clearly define roles and responsibilities between IT and business users in a self-service BI delivery model.

Few BI programs have been able to find a workable balance between business user empowerment and governance with self-service data discovery.

Top-downBICC

Bottom-upSelf-service

Trusted information

Efficient reuse

Too report-driven

Flexibility

Speed

Experimentation

21

Learning From Others


(1) Scandinavian Consumer Manufacturing Co.

22

The company deployed a first Global BI solution around 2000 together with the first SAP implementations

2000-2005 2005-2010 2011

No BI strategy

• No real BI strategy

• IT left to prioritize

• Multiple versions of the truth

One truth

• Company Performance model

• Standard reporting

• One truth

• Anchored in finance

Future vision

• Extend reporting to more users

• Redefine role

• More end user flexibility


A Change in User Profiles and Patterns

Over a period of 7 years the company saw several shifts in its BI user group

The shifts seem to happen with shorter and shorter intervals

23

• System Expert• Favored Excel as front end• Could live with poor

performance• Primarily used data from

SAP

2005

”The controller”

• General analyst• Wanted to use web reports

as well• Interested in data from

several sources• Demanded better

performance

2010

”The analyst”• Expecting BI self service• Want’s information on

mobile devices• Not scared of technology,

uses the right tool for the job

2012

”You and me”


Time to Find Out What Was Really Happening

With the help of external consultants the company ran a small three month project to determine current vs. desired• Did the team really understand the users and their needs? • Was the reporting in the central system a true picture of overall reporting activity?• Did management have an accurate overview of reporting activities? • How should the team involve management in prioritizing and setting strategic

directions? • Was the team perceived as a help or a bottleneck? • Where could the team really make a difference?• What were the new requirements in terms of speed, flexibility and simulation?

“I can recommend this exercise. I know a lot of departments who work with BI think they know their users, what they’re doing, and what they’re needs are – but unless you’ve done a real investigation of this, I would challenge you that you will find stuff you didn’t know existed.”

BI Manager, Scandinavian Manufacturing Company


Getting the Facts Straight

25

The project was an eye opener for the management team. The main findings were:

Tools

More user-friendly tools

Need a wider variety of tools

Data

Data is too hard to

understand

Need access to non ERP data

in reporting

Flexibility

Need to be able to create own reports

Standard reports have limited value

Ownership

Some had invested in own

systems

All preferred to be in a global

system


Acting On The Results

BI Self-Service Approach

More responsibility to end-users

More user-friendly tools

Visual discovery

Training required

Business and analytics skills

“Doing visualization is really cool… but if you apply the wrong graphs to the data you will not get a very good result…. Some of my employees have had to actually take a course in visualization, just to be able to challenge the business.”

BI Manager, Scandinavian Manufacturing Company


(2) European Consumer Goods Packaging Company

Had Created The “Perfect Giant” of Enterprise BI

Business Intelligence was:• Standardized• Repeatable• Clearly understood across the company

Regular, well-communicated releases• Jointly agreed between Business and IT• Facilitates the business areas planning and

scheduling of report requests

A steering group of senior management• Majority business leaders with strong

representation from IT

Clear measurements to follow up performance• Usage and user feedback


“Past Achievements Don’t Guarantee Future Success”

Time to information

Business case required to get new reports, and could take six months. Business movers ended up buying their own tools.

Multiple iterations

Multiple iterations required, communications degrading. Local BI teams able to be more consultative and collaborative.

Lack of accountability

Some things that should have been done locally were being delegated to central IT. Gut-based decision making was taking over.

Good: Agility, happier business users

Bad: Higher costs, no holistic view, no economy of scale, fragmented BI tool landscape, lost business opportunities from not having a global view


Making It Agile

How to make an Ocean liner perform as a speedboat?

Moving to an agile strategy

Learn from the business. BI is something that brings up emotions. Found a lot of good practice in the business as well as bad.

The unofficial BI was more agile and more cost-efficient: Creating the reports close to the action, leaner process, no handovers, more niche tools that met their requirements.

Had to find a new balance between control and autonomy/freedom.


Time for An Overhaul…

From Report Strategy

Single version of the truth

Standardized

Trusted

Secure

To BI Strategy

Single version of the truth

Standardized

Trusted

Secure

Agile development

Cost effective

Business driven


Decentralization of Reporting

Data warehouse centralized, but all report development local


Redefinition of Roles, Processes and Tools

Development close to the businessKnows Business/Analytics/IT

Report Developer

PrototypingBusiness-driven

Secure, strong BI governance

IntuitiveFast development

Cover all analytic needs

BI Expert

Agile BI

Up-to-date suite of tools + pragmatic

exceptions

New Role

New Process

New Tools

Need Solution


What Changed

Before: “The” BI process

Now three levels, self-serve, agile BI, IT/cross platform

Getting the BI experts: Looked for best fit, then trained

Some areas didn’t feel they had the competences

“Hypercare" handholding on first reports

First report more expensive, but now just a few days instead of four to five weeks —after six months, saving of 40% in the development time

New four-step process

Initiate, mock up, finalize, industrialize — two week cycles

Corporate “wikipedia” for documentation

Guide towards solutions rather than “tools”


Advice

• If your enterprise BI isn't agile, unofficial BI platforms will grow like mushrooms in the dark

• Learn from the business — There is a lot of good practice that should be adopted

• Report development is highly iterative — traditional IT dev processes didn’t work

• Build a broad BI competence — Turning business information into insight should be considered a core competence

• A fragmented BI tool strategy will add cost and jeopardize the holistic view of BI

• The business will always require new capability — stay current! Be two years ahead of the business, we were two years behind

• It will take time to build BI experts — Start now


(3) Large UK Retailer

Situation

Beloved UK institution but “beleaguered”

Top-to-bottom control of products

Lots of information silos, tools

Lots of “institutional knowledge”

Change Ahead

Needed omni-channel approach/“products”

Required new integrated, business-focused analytics approach

New executive team and “digital native” IT


Launched New Analytics Approach

Big kick-off meeting

Analysts, IT, execs, outside experts

All areas of the business

Tool independent

Launched new “service bureau” approach

Strong executive support

Analytics driven locally, best-practice shared centrally

“Own the problem, not the solution” (“Can we access this tool, please?”)

Collection of “agile services”

Community-driven, using internal social networking


Decision Pods

Fully interactive, data-based screens

Questions answered there and then, no leaving the meeting until a decision is made

Based on the experiences of a large US retailer

38

Recommendations


It’s All About the Relationship

Any CIO’s dream is to have a business partner that really embraces technology and wants to do really cool stuff with you. Someone who has a vision, but doesn’t come to you and say, ‘We want you to use this product to do this.’ They come to you with a problem and they want to work together to figure out how to solve it.

Instead of a scenario in which Business and IT play separate, traditional provider-versus-user roles everybody has to combine efforts to jointly explore and learn — and everybody has to compromise!


Build and Nurture a Community

Regular face-to-face meetings• Bring people together across silos: IT, Analysts, Business Leaders, Execs• Presentations of successes best practices• Invite external speakers

Virtual communities• Leverage internal social tools for people to share information• Community-driven BI content

Community self-policing• Act as BICC eyes and ears to discover projects,

opportunities• Social mechanisms to ensure the “right behaviors”

Ensure support at all levels• Not just executives — middle and users


Move to Agile BI

Forrester, 2014: Agile BI is an approach that combines processes, methodologies, organizational structure, tools, and technologies that enable strategic, tactical, and operational decision-makers to be more flexible and more responsive to the fast pace of customer, business, and regulatory requirements changes.

First and foremost, business-driven agile enterprise BI is about flexible organizational structures


Inspiration From The “Agile Manifesto”

The highest priority is to satisfy the customer through early and continuous delivery of analytics

Welcome changing requirements, even late in development. Agile processes harness change for competitive advantage.

Deliver working projects frequently, from a couple of weeks to a couple of months, with a preference to the shorter timescale.

Business people and analytics staff must work together daily throughout the project.

Build projects around motivated individuals. Give them the environment and support they need, and trust them to get the job done.

The most efficient and effective method of conveying information to and within a development team is face-to-face conversation.

Delivered, used analytics is the primary measure of progress.

Agile processes promote sustainable development. The sponsors, developers and users should be able to maintain a constant pace indefinitely.

Continuous attention to technical excellence and good design enhances agility.

Simplicity — the art of maximizing the amount of work not done — is essential.

The best architectures, requirements and designs emerge from self-organizing teams.

At regular intervals, the team reflects on how to become more effective, then tunes and adjusts its behavior accordingly.

Adapted from: http://agilemanifesto.org/


Reorganize and Refocus

Avoid “worst of both worlds” approach!

Move to federated approach

From “gatekeeper” to “air traffic controller”

Bring “shadow BI” under umbrella of BICC — but retaining local links

Co-locate “central” staff in business units whenever possible

Invest in appropriate tools and skills

Less reporting, more exploration

“Agency” philosophy

Business chooses you because you are the best option, not because they “have to”

Leverage unique knowledge of cross-functional opportunities


Offer Key Services

Data Bureau

One-stop shopping for data, internal, external, or “wrangled”

Tools Bureau

Expert recommendations of best technologies to use, when

Sandbox Environments

Environments that let business experiment on their own

Innovation Opportunities

Workshops (e.g., Design Thinking) to uncover new opportunities

Analysis Validation

Trust, but verify…


Data Driving Licenses?

Source: Gartner


Support The BI Lifecycle

Source: Gartner


Remember to Communicate!

Effective communication is the bedrock of a successful BICC

Involves skills that aren’t always part of the staff hiring process

Sell the sizzle

Use dashboards, scorecards, maps and other visual applications/tools

Analytics is “white hot,” so sell it

Celebrate success

Pick a first initiative and make it a business success

Identify evangelists from the initiative and have them sell the success

48

Wrap-up


Useful Resources

Barc Collective Insight white paperSAP BICC Playlist on YouTube: LinkSAP BI Self Assessment : www.sap.com/bistrategySAP BI Strategy Playlist on YouTube: Link

BI News: www.sap.com/BINews

Blogs on BI Strategyhttp://scn.sap.com/docs/DOC-30479http://scn.sap.com/docs/DOC-30480http://scn.sap.com/community/business-intelligence/blog/2012/12/07/bi-strategy-bicc-a-key-element-to-your-bi-programhttp://scn.sap.com/community/business-intelligence/blog/2012/11/07/bi-strategy-bi-competency-centers-take-center-stage-againhttp://blogs.sap.com/analytics/2013/03/27/driving-value-from-your-business-intelligence-program-define-track-and-measure-success/

http://www.sap.com/bin/sapcom/en_us/downloadasset.2014-05-may-07-17.information-culture--collective-intelligence-pdf.bypassReg.html

http://www.sap.com/bin/sapcom/en_us/downloadasset.2014-05-may-07-17.information-culture--collective-intelligence-pdf.bypassReg.html

http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPA5ZAeDvb1cPajM-cR8ar6Q8R_ihsE3i

http://www.sap.com/bistrategy

http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPA5ZAeDvb1dUMYIUChURAYcIhZy9etgD

http://www.sap.com/BINews

http://scn.sap.com/docs/DOC-30479




http://scn.sap.com/community/business-intelligence/blog/2012/12/07/bi-strategy-bicc-a-key-element-to-your-bi-program



http://scn.sap.com/community/business-intelligence/blog/2012/11/07/bi-strategy-bi-competency-centers-take-center-stage-again



http://blogs.sap.com/analytics/2013/03/27/driving-value-from-your-business-intelligence-program-define-track-and-measure-success/





7 Key Points To Take Home

1. Old approaches are no longer enough

2. Self-service BI is a wonderful business opportunityIf done right, can dramatically improve business agility and IT/Business alignment

3. But it requires new cultures and ways of workingYou’re no longer in charge — and everybody has to compromise

4. Provide what the business needs, not necessarily what they wantService-oriented approach, but the “customer is not always right”

5. Community is the essential pillarNo one person or team can do this alone —build momentum and listen to feedback

6. Look for opportunities to simplifyIt’s not about technology, but the right technology can help agility

7. Keep up momentum and successLook out for teaching opportunities, and market success widely and often

51

Thank you!

Timo Elliott, SAP

[email protected]

Twitter: @timoelliott

Blog: timoelliott.com

Please provide feedback on this session by completing a short survey via the event mobile application.

SESSION CODE: 0903

For ongoing education on this area of focus,visit www.ASUG.com

THANK YOU FOR PARTICIPATING

organizing for agile bi

Data & Analytics

sap affiliate company

2014 sap se

bi manager

agile bi

rights reserved

good practice

holistic view

enterprise systems